Domestic Violence Fatality Review Team

Presentation

For

Criminal Justice Advisory Group

February 16, 2010

2

Session Law 2009-52 An act establishing a domestic violence fatality prevention and protection review team—ratified 6/1/2009

Milestone for Domestic Violence Advocates Part of Mecklenburg BOCC legislative agenda Modeled after N.C. Child Fatality Prevention Team Mecklenburg model, if successful, may be replicated

state-wide Goal is to identify and review dv-related deaths and

facilitate communication among the various agencies involved in dv cases to prevent future fatalities.

3

Review Team: Community Support Services is lead agency with mandated representatives from:

DV victim’s service group An attorney from the local district attorney’s office Local law enforcement personnel Local medical examiner’s office Local department of social services Local health department Local area mental health authority Local public schools A health care system Local medic or emergency services personnel A survivor of domestic violence

4

Powers and Duties of the Review Team

Meet at least four times annually Study incidences and causes of death by dv-related behavior in

the community, including an analysis of all community, private and public agency involvement with decedent and family members prior to death

Develop a system for multidisciplinary review of dv-related deaths

Determine whether polices governing exchange of information impede information exchange necessary to protect victims; recommend changes

5

Powers and Duties…continued

Recommend system improvements and needed resources where gaps and deficiencies may exist.

Perform other studies needed to enable Team to carry out its mandate

Issue an interim report to BOCC, NC Domestic Violence Commission, and Governor’s Crime Commission by June 15, 2011

Issue final report with recommendations for action by June 15, 2014.

Terminate upon filing of final report or June 15, 2014.

Access to Records

SECTION 1.(e) Team shall have access to all medical records, hospital records, and records maintained by county or any local agency as necessary to carry out the purposes of this act, including police investigations data, medical examiner investigative data, health records, mental health records and social services records.

6

Limitation on Access

SECTION 1.(f)…no member shall be authorized to review a d.v. fatality case while the case is under investigation by any law enforcement agency, or if an action is pending in any criminal or civil court in the State…The District Attorney must give written approval for access.

7

Confidentiality and Immunity

SECTION 1.(g) All otherwise confidential information and records acquired or created in the exercise of the duties of the team are not subject to discovery or introduction into evidence….

No member or any one who attends a Review Team meeting may testify about what went on at any meeting

8

Confidentiality and Immunity

Persons disclosing or providing information or records pursuant to this act are not criminally or civilly liable for disclosing or providing the information. Except for possible civil or criminal liability for breach of confidentiality, Team members are immune from claims of liability, and confidential information gathered pursuant to this act is not subject to subpoena or discovery.

9

10

Goal: Review First Case by Spring 2010

– June 2009- Legislation Enacted– September 2009 – Planning Team Formed with

representation from: District Attorney Law Enforcement Medical Examiner Social Services County Manager’s Office United Family Services Mental Health Association Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools…and

More Planning Team Members:

Child Fatality Review Team Health Department Judiciary Magistrates Office Probation Area Mental Health Domestic Violence Survivors Central Piedmont Community College Domestic Violence Health Care Project Women’s Commission Division of Community Support Services

11

12

Accomplishments (Sept. – Feb. 2010)

Mission Statement, confidentiality agreements, memorandum of understanding, code of conduct, some case review protocols have been drafted

Ms. Jane Harper (retired/emergency district court judge) has been selected to serve as initial Chair.

More than half of the Review Team members have been named.

A mock review is scheduled for March 22, 2010, facilitated by the National Domestic Violence Fatality Review Initiative

13

Accomplishments (cont’d):

Visit scheduled March 4, 2010 to Lynchburg, Virginia to observe a DVFRT in action

Information about the DVFRT has been presented to staff of Latin American Coalition, Mi Casa Su Casa, International House, and Mecklenburg Ministries. Meeting is planned with Carolinas Asian - American Chamber of Commerce.

Website developed to provide information about the DVFRT to members and to the public.

HTTP://CHARMECK.ORG/DEPARTMENTS/COMMUNITY+SUPPORT+SERVICES/DV+FATALITY+REVIEW+TEAM.HTM.

To be Accomplished:

Compile a list of DV fatalities (closed cases from the District Attorney’s standpoint) for the Mecklenburg Review Team to consider

Determine training needs for Team members Complete initial Team member appointments Based on mock review and visit to Lynchburg, select

data collection tools and procedures to be used to conduct first review in spring 2010

Evaluate the process and modify as needed.

14

Questions??

Comments?? Thank you for your support.

15