Does Kant Succeed in Disposing of the Antinomies at the End of the Prolegomena?

8/3/2019 Does Kant Succeed in Disposing of the Antinomies at the End of the Prolegomena?

1/10

Kjnw Mh`{ W~ggnnk f` Kfwtjwf`l jb {an

H`{f`jcfnw:

Cjk~on9 TAFO847 # Cf`k M`j|onkln h`k Unhof{v

\juk Gj~`{9 5756

Wgjunk9 14


2/10

Mh`{w Tujonljcn`h {j H`v B~{~un Cn{htavwfgw !Tujonljcn`h& fw tunwn`{nk {j ~w hw h`

h`hov{fg w~cchuv jb afw nhuofnu ejjm/ {an Guf{fx~n jb T~un Unhwj` !GTU&. F` {anwn ejjmw

Mh`{ unohvw bj~u gjwcjojlfgho h`{f`jcfnw ju gj`{uhkfg{fj`w {ah{ jgg~u k~n {j {an `h{~un jb

t~un unhwj`. Mh`{ enofnrnk {ah{ f{ |hw nwwn`{fho {j kfwtjwn jb {anwn f` juknu {j waj| {ah{

unhwj` waj~ok `j{ rn`{~un {j nqtohf` {af`lw |afga hun envj`k j~u nqtnufn`gn. An`gn {an

h`{f`jcfnw chf` t~utjwn fw {j hwwfw{ Mh`{ f` waj|f`l {an ofcf{w jb t~un unhwj`. Aj|nrnu/

Mh`{ httungfh{nk {an bhg{ {ah{ ch`v unhknuw |j~ok bf`k f{ kfbbfg~o{ {j hggnt{ {ah{ w~ga

x~nw{fj`w hej~{ {an |juok hun f` bhg{ rjfk f` {anfu rnuv `h{~un. Ehwnk j` {afw f{ fw `ngnwwhuv {j

ojjm h{ {an hul~cn`{w hfcnk h{ nhga h`{f`jcv f` juknu {j hwwnww |an{anu Mh`{ kfk ju kfk `j{

w~ggnnk f` kfwtjwf`l jb {an h`{f`jcfnw.

H` h`{f`jcv gh` en knbf`nk hw {|j jttjwnk hul~cn`{w tunwn`{nk wfkn#ev#wfkn f` juknu {j

waj| {ah{ nhga fw hw rhofk hw {an j{anu8. [an h`{f`jcfnw bjuc thu{ jb {an gjwcjojlfgho fknh/ hw

{anv hun hoo unoh{nk {j hwtng{w jb {an |juok f` |afga |n ofrn. Nhga gj`wfw{w jb {|j thu{w/ h

{anwfw h`k h`{f{anwfw. F{ fw fctju{h`{ {j ~`knuw{h`k {an tjf`{ jb Mh`{w h`hovwfw jb {an

h`{f`jcfnw. Bju nhga/ Th~o L~vnu hul~nw {ah{ {an {anwfw unoh{nw {j unhwj`w `nnk bju gojw~un/

h`k {an h`{f{anwfw {j unhwj`w `nnk bju f`bf`f{n nq{n`wfj`5. J{anuw hul~n {ah{ {an {anwnw unoh{n

{j uh{fj`hofwc/ h`k {an h`{f{anwnw {j nctfufgfwc. \afon ej{a jb {anwn hww~ct{fj`w httnhu {j en

hgg~uh{n/ F enofnrn Mh`{w hul~cn`{w hun cjun f` hofl`cn`{ |f{a {an oh{{nu {ah` {an bjucnu/ hw

an fw h{{nct{f`l {j waj| {an b~{fof{v jb unhwj` h{{nct{f`l {j nqtohf` {an |juok rfh ej{a

uh{fj`hofyh{fj` h`k nqtnufn`gn/ h`k {j howj waj| {an gojwn unoh{fj`waft en{|nn` {an {|j. Fb

{afw fw {an ghwn/ {an` {an h`{f`jcfnw waj~ok en nhwfnu bju Mh`{ {j kfwtjwn jb hw {anv unbnu {j {an

gj`{uhkfg{juv hwtng{w jb kfbbnun`{ rfn|tjf`{w uh{anu {ah` {an f``nu |jumf`lw jb a~ch` unhwj`.

8 Ghvlfoo/ A. !866>&.H Mh`{ Kfg{fj`huv. t. 5 L~vnu/ T. !8661/ 544;&.Uj~{onkln N`gvgojtnkfh jb Tafojwjtav. a{{t9**|||.unt.uj~{onkln.gjc*hu{fgon*

KE4;


3/10

B~u{anucjun/ {an h`{f`jcfnw hun knwgufenk ev Mh`{ hw enf`l ~`hrjfkheon k~n {j unhwj`w

{n`kn`gv {j ojjm bju h`k hgafnrn {an aflanw{ tjwwfeon m`j|onkln7. F{ ahw enn` `j{nk {ah{ nrn`

{aj~la tnjton hun `j| h|hun jb {an nqfw{n`gn jb {an h`{f`jcfnw/ unhwj` w{foo gh``j{ hrjfk

h{{nct{f`l {j h`w|nu w~ga x~nw{fj`w hej~{ {an |juok. [anunbjun/ ho{aj~la Mh`{ httnhuw {j

tujrfkn rhofk hul~cn`{w !hw |n |foo wnn enoj|& bju {an kfwtjwho jb {an h`{f`jcfnw/ j`n

hul~cn`{ fw {ah{ {anv ahrn `j{ enn` w~ggnwwb~oov kfwtjwnk jb hw unhwj` |foo ho|hvw h{{nct{ {j

kuh| gj`go~wfj`w hej~{ {an `h{~un jb {an |juok |n ofrn f`.

[an bfuw{ jb {anwn bj~u h`{f`jcfnw tnu{hf`w {j {an f`bf`f{~kn jb {fcn h`k wthgn. [an {anwfw

w{h{nw {an |juok ahw/ hw {j {fcn h`k wthgn/ h enlf``f`l;/ |afow{ {an h`{f{anwfw w{h{nw {ah{ {an

|juok fw/ hw {j {fcn h`k wthgn/ f`bf`f{n>. F` {afw wng{fj` jb {an Tujonljcn`h/ Mh`{ hul~nw {ah{

tunrfj~w tafojwjtanuw ahrn bhfonk {j unwjorn {an h`{f`jcfnw engh~wn {anv ahrn {ufnk {j unwjorn

{anc f` {an gjccj` kjlch{fg |hv2. Bju Mh`{/ {afw/ h`k {an {aunn w~ewnx~n`{ h`{f`jcfnw/

hun fuunwjorheon rfh {an unhoc jb nqtnufn`gn/ wjcn{af`l |afga ahk enn` jrnuojjmnk ev

tunrfj~w tafojwjtanuw. Mh`{ w{h{nw {ah{ `j#j`n gh` ahrn nqtnufn`gn jb {af`lw w~ga hw {an

ofcf{w jb {fcn h`k wthgn engh~wn {anv hun `j{ {af`lw f` {ancwnornw !`j~cn`h& `ju hun {anv

{af`lw |afga |n nqtnufn`gn rfh {an wn`wnw !tan`jcn`h&/ {anv hun f`w{nhk untunwn`{h{fj`w ~wnk

ev {an cf`k ju unhwj` f` juknu {j f`{nutun{ {an |juok jb nqtnufn`gn f`{j wjcn{af`l f`{nooflfeon

{j ~w hw a~ch`w.

Gj`wnx~n`{ov/ f{ fw bujc {afw tnuwtng{frn {ah{ Mh`{ hul~nw {ah{ {an bfuw{ h`{f`jcv fw ehwnk j` h

wnob#gj`{uhkfg{juv tuf`gfton/ h`k ej{a {an {anwfw h`k h`{f{anwfw hun f` bhg{ bhown. [afw fw {an

7

CgGjucfgm/ C. !5442&.Fcch`~no Mh`{ !8


4/10

ghwn/ Th~o L~vnu w{h{nw/ hw wthgn h`k {fcn hun ho|hvw f`knbf`f{n f` nq{n`{ engh~wn {anv hun

bf`f{n vn{ ho|hvw nq{n`kfeon tujk~g{w jb j~u j|` gjl`f{frn hg{frf{v


5/10

wfcton/ e~{ nrnuv{af`l fw gjctjwf{n87. Anun/ Mh`{ w{h{nw {ah{ unhwj` fw h{{nct{f`l {j w~ucfwn

|an{anu jeing{w f` {an |juok hun wfcton ju hun chkn ~t jb h tjwwfeon f`bf`f{n `~cenu jb thu{w.

An hul~nw {ah{ unhwj` fw j`gn hlhf` h{{nct{f`l {j kuh| gj`go~wfj`w hej~{ {an |uj`l {af`l/

e~{ f` {afw ghwn/ {an gjctjwf{nw unbnu {j httnhuh`gnw jb jeing{w uh{anu {ah` {anfu `j~cn`ho

wnornw. [anunbjun {anfu kfrfwfj` ju wfctofgf{v cnunov unbnuw {j j~u nqtnufn`gn jb {an jeing{w/

|afga gh``j{ {u~ov nqtohf` {an `h{~un jb {af`lw f` {ancwnornw !|afga hun {an gj`gnt{w {ah{

cn{htavwfgw h{{nct{w {j nqtohf`&. Mh`{ howj unbnuw {j {an fknh {ah{ httnhuh`gnw chv gj`{hf`

hoo {an gj`w{f{~n`{ thu{w jb h` jeing{ {ah{ |n chv nrnu nqtnufn`gn. An hul~nw {ah{ {afw fw h`

fctjwwfefof{v engh~wn f{ f`rjornw hwgufef`l h` httnhuh`gn |f{a h` nqfw{n`gn tufju {j

nqtnufn`gn. Bju Mh`{/ {afw fw fctjwwfeon hw h` httnhuh`gn gh` j`ov nqfw{ |f{af` j~u cn`{ho

untunwn`{h{fj` jb {an |juok. Httnhuh`gnw kj `j{ nqfw{ `j~cn`hoov/ {anv hun untunwn`{h{fj`w jb

`j~cn`ho jeing{w gunh{nk ev j~u wn`wnw/ |afga |n {an` f`{nutun{ h`k gh{nljufwn f`{j

tan`jcn`h8;. F` cv jtf`fj`/ {afw hul~cn`{ ajokw onww |nfla{ {ah` {ah{ bju {an tunrfj~w

h`{f`jcv/ hw ho{aj~la {an tuncfwn {ah{ |n j`ov nqtnufn`gn httnhuh`gnw uh{anu {ah` {af`lw f`

{ancwnornw fw h gj`rf`gf`l j`n/ f{ onhrnw jtn` {an x~nw{fj` jb |an{anu {af`lw f` {an `j~cn`ho

|juok hun wfcton ju gjctjwf{n. Aj|nrnu/ Mh`{ |j~ok unwtj`k {j {afw hul~cn`{ ev w{h{f`l {ah{

|n gh` `nrnu kfwgjrnu {afw nf{anu {auj~la nqtnufn`gn ju {auj~la {an ~wn jb t~un unhwj`. Bujc

{afw f{ gh` en whfk {ah{ Mh`{ kjnw w~ggnnk f` kfwtjwf`l jb {afw h`{f`jcv {jj/ e~{ ho{aj~la {afw

unwjornw j`n x~nw{fj` f{ chv onhk {j j{anu/ cjun ~o{fch{n x~nw{fj`w hej~{ {an |juok. [afw

onhkw j` {j {an bf`ho {|j h`{f`jcfnw/ |afga unoh{n {j {an ~o{fch{n gh~wnw jb nrn`{w f` {an

|juok.

Hw {an {afuk h`{f`jcv unoh{nw {j {an `j{fj`w jb gh~wn h`k nbbng{/ f{ gh` `j{ en gohwwnk hw h

ch{anch{fgho h`{f`jcv/ hw {an gj`gnt{w f{ knhow |f{a hun `j{ ajcjln`nj~w hw f` {an bfuw{ {|j

87Mh`{/ F. !5448&. I. \. Noof`l{j` !Nk.&Tujonljcn`h {j H`v B~{~un Cn{htavwfgw !Wngj`k Nkf{fj`&/ t. &.H Mh`{ Kfg{fj`huv. t. 14

>


6/10

h`{f`jcfnw. F{ fw {anunbjun knwgufenk hw enf`l |f{af` {an kv`hcfgho gohww jb h`{f`jcv. [anwn

howj kfbbnu bujc {an ch{anch{fgho h`{f`jcfnw f` {ah{ {anv hun `j{ f` bhg{ wnob#gj`{uhkfg{juv/ hw

f{ fw tjwwfeon {ah{ ej{a {an {anwfw h`k h`{f{anwfw chv en {u~n. Anun f{ fw hul~nk {ah{ {an

h`{f`jcv waj~ok en kfwtjwnk jb engh~wn f{ fw tunwn`{f`l {j ~w {|j gj`gnt{w |afga chv en {u~n

hw enf`l gj`{uhkfg{juv. [an {anwfw jb {afw h`{f`jcv fw {ah{ {anun hun f` {an |juok gh~wnw

{auj~la bunnkjc8>/ h`k {an h`{f{anwfw fw {ah{ {anun fw `j bunnkjc/ e~{ hoo fw `h{~un82. Mh`{

tjw{~oh{nw {ah{ {an {nuc `h{~un f` bhg{ unbnuw {j {an |juok jb httnhuh`gnw/ |afow{ {an {nuc

bunnkjc httofnw {j {af`lw f` {ancwnornw/ h`k {ah{ {anv hun {anunbjun gjcth{feon |f{a j`n

h`j{anu. Bju f`w{h`gn/ fb {anv ej{a httofnk wjonov {j nf{anu {an |juok jb httnhuh`gnw ju jb

{af`lw f` {ancwnornw {anv gj~ok {an` en knncnk gj`{uhkfg{juv. An {an` ljnw j` {j w{h{n {ah{

`h{~un h`k bunnkjc {anunbjun gh` |f{aj~{ gj`{uhkfg{fj` en h{{ufe~{nk {j {an rnuv whcn {af`l/

e~{ f` kfbbnun`{ unoh{fj`w # j` j`n wfkn hw h` httnhuh`gn/ j` {an j{anu hw h {af`l f` f{wnob 8Mh`{/ F. !5448&. I. \. Noof`l{j` !Nk.&Tujonljcn`h {j H`v B~{~un Cn{htavwfgw !Wngj`k Nkf{fj`&/t.

82Mh`{/ F. !5448&. I. \. Noof`l{j` !Nk.&Tujonljcn`h {j H`v B~{~un Cn{htavwfgw !Wngj`k Nkf{fj`&/t.

8.

5>Mh`{/ F. !5448&. I. \. Noof`l{j` !Nk.&Tujonljcn`h {j H`v B~{~un Cn{htavwfgw !Wngj`k Nkf{fj`&/t. 15

6


10/10

Efeofjluhtav

Ghvlfoo/ A. !866>&.H Mh`{ Kfg{fj`huv. Eohgm|noo9Jqbjuk.

L~vnu/ T. !8661/ 544;&. Mh`{/ Fcch`~no. F` N. Guhfl !Nk.&/ Uj~{onkln N`gvgojtnkfh jb

Tafojwjtav. Oj`kj 9 Uj~{onkln. Un{ufnrnk Ih`~huv >/ 5446/ bujc a{{t9**|||.unt.

uj~{onkln.gjc*hu{fgon*KE4;2|||.wthum`j{nw.gjc*

tafojwjtav*tujonljcn`h*wng{fj`/ 5446.

Wcf{a/ @. M. !8681&.H Gjccn`{huv {j Mh`{w Guf{fx~n jb T~un Unhwj`. ChgCfooh` " Gj./

Ofcf{nk9 Oj`kj`. Un{ufnrnk Ih`~huv ;/ 5446/ bujc a{{t9**|||.hugafrn.jul*w{unhc*

gjccn`{huv{jmh`{44wcf{ufga*gjccn`{huv{jmh`{44wcf{ufgaZkir~.{q{.

84
http://www.iep.utm.edu/k/kantmeta.htmhttp://www.sparknotes.com/%20philosophy/prolegomena/section7.rhtml.%20Retrieved%20January%205http://www.sparknotes.com/%20philosophy/prolegomena/section7.rhtml.%20Retrieved%20January%205http://www.archive.org/stream/http://www.iep.utm.edu/k/kantmeta.htmhttp://www.sparknotes.com/%20philosophy/prolegomena/section7.rhtml.%20Retrieved%20January%205http://www.sparknotes.com/%20philosophy/prolegomena/section7.rhtml.%20Retrieved%20January%205http://www.archive.org/stream/

Documents

Does Kant Succeed in Disposing of the Antinomies at the End of the Prolegomena?