Upload
malcolm-newman
View
216
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Doc
umen
t num
ber
DNV KEMA KERMIT OverviewERCOT Joint Regional Planning Group / Long Term Study Task ForceAustin, TXJuly 13, 2012
1
Agenda
Introduction to DNV KEMA
Overview of Moment to Moment Balancing
Introduction to KERMIT
Review of ERCOT KERMIT Project
Details of KERMIT and Demo
Discussion
2
Agenda
Introduction to DNV KEMA
Overview of Moment to Moment Balancing
Introduction to KERMIT
Review of ERCOT KERMIT Project
Details of KERMIT and Demo
Discussion
3
The DNV Group
4
10,400employees
300offices
100countries
DNV KEMA Energy & Sustainability offers innovative solutions to customers across the energy value chain, ensuring reliable, efficient and sustainable energy supply, now and in the future.
2,300+ experts across all continents
KEMA and DNV combined: a heritage of nearly 150 years
Headquartered in Arnhem, the Netherlands
Offices and agents in over 30 countries around the globe
DNV KEMA Energy & Sustainability
5
One company serving the needs of the energy market place
6
Business and technical consultancy, expert advice, operational services
Testing, inspections, certification, verification
Risk, performance, and quality management
Research & innovation
Markets and RegulationRenewables Services and integration AnalysisCarbon ServicesWholesale Energy Market DesignRetail Energy Market Services and Competitive DesignRegulatory and Energy Policy ManagementStrategic and Analytical Services
Operational ExcellenceTrading, Retail and Market ProcessesMeter-to-Bill-Operations Organizational ConsultingIT Advisory
Power Systems and OperationsControl System Operations System expertise in SCADA, EMS, DMS, OMSPower Delivery Operations AnalysisOperations benchmarking, best practices, Control Room design
Operational TelecommunicationsUtility Network DevelopmentCommunication Network Architecture and Design Communication Protocol testingCommunication Protocol test softwareIntegrated Network Management Systems DevelopmentSystems Security Planning, Architecture, & TestingMarket Entry and Evaluation
Smart Technology Deployment (Smart Grid)Utility AMI DevelopmentHome Area Networks Consumer DevelopmentInteroperability Testing of Systems Security Planning Architecture
Service OfferingsProviding unique insight leveraging cross regional experience
Markets 3.0
Operations 3.0
Smart Grid 3.0
• Provide thought leadership in wholesale and retail convergence, and micro-grid modeling
•Lead in future design of energy planning and delivery with DR/DG multi-d. power flow
•Identify business improvement and process optimization across utility business lines
•Lead in SG Technology optimization, business case and interoperability (2.0-3.0)
Networks 3.0
•Lead in network design and cyber security services to drive OT within a smart grid
Excellence3.0
7
DNV KEMA Markets and Regulation Consulting- Renewables Services
- Market opportunities in growing solar market (DG and utility scale solar PV and CST)
- Financial and technical due diligence capabilities- Wholesale Energy Markets
- ISO/RTO Services around Markets 3.0- Focus on Renewables Integration studies leveraging KEMA’s
KERMIT model - Strategic and Analytical Services capabilities in US- Modeling tools and capabilities, i.e. PLEXOS
- Retail Energy Markets- REM strategic services- Multi – Client projects - Forum - Provides executives a knowledge sharing forum- Customized analytically and benchmarking services- Business Strategy Consulting
- Regulatory Services- Regulatory Strategy Development- Compliance Services, Legislative Policy Analysis- Financial Modeling & Business Case Preparation- Testimony Support, Expert Testimony, Position Papers- Evaluation of RPS Requirements / Renewables Strategy- Feed-In-Tariff Designs- Federal Information Collection Requests (ICRs)
8
Agenda
Introduction to DNV KEMA
Overview of Moment to Moment Balancing
Introduction to KERMIT
Review of ERCOT KERMIT Project
Details of KERMIT and Demo
Discussion
9
Introduction to Moment to Moment Balancing For any period of time, the amount of electricity produced must be the same as the electricity
consumed- Necessary to keep the frequency at 60 Hz- If more power is generated than is being consumed, then frequency increases above 60 Hz- If less power is generated, the system frequency decreases below 60 Hz
Loads are not constant- System operators can not control when a homeowner will turn lights on or off- As a result, system operators vary the output of generators to “balance” a system
Generation is not constant, either –- Variable energy resources (wind, solar) fluctuate- Plants can have outages or variations
Generation providing regulation and balancing services must account for the difference- System operators use generators to compensate for variability in their system- Governors provide automatic “primary” response, regulation provides controlled “secondary” response
10
Systems use generators to compensate for variability in a system to keep it stable
What is AGC?
Regulation is provided by Automatic Generation Control (AGC)- AGC makes use of Reg Up and Reg Down services to control system frequency
AGC is designed to control system frequency within operational limits- Signals are sent every 4 seconds to generators based on ACE- AGC measures a system deviations from:
- System frequency (60 Hz)- In a control area that is interconnected as in a control area within WECC, interchange schedules are
also part of Area Control Error - ERCOT controls frequency (only)
The goal is to minimize frequency error to be within a given deadband
Ideally regulation up / down is a net zero energy product. The Real-time Market is used to reset the regulation market every 5 minutes.
In ERCOT, regulation is provided on a capacity bases and regulation providers are paid to reserve capacity on their Resources to provide this service
11
Regulation Up/Down Service
Regulation helps ERCOT deal with second-to-second demand changes
12
Shaded portion is what must be met
by Regulation
Agenda
Introduction to DNV KEMA
Overview of Moment to Moment Balancing
Introduction to KERMIT
Review of ERCOT KERMIT Project
Details of KERMIT and Demo
Discussion
13
Overview of KERMIT
Developed using two software platforms:- Matlab / Simulink for performing simulations- Microsoft Excel for entering data and post processing / analysis of results
What is KERMIT?- KEMA’s Renewable Market Integration Tool- Originally developed to study how integrating large penetrations of renewable power affects
sub-hourly operations
KERMIT has expanded in scope and is now a tool for systems to examine operational strategies for handling variability in their system
This includes:- Renewable integration studies- Automatic generation control design and development- Evaluating the benefits of increased storage deployment- Analysis support for federal and ISO/RTO policy development
14
KERMIT Time Scales of Focus
15
1 msecond 1 day 1 month 1 year1 hour10 minutes1 minute1 second1 cycle
HarmonicsProtection
Stability
Frequency responseRegulation
Balancing
Capacity
Economics
Transient and harmonics analysisShort circuit analysis
· PSS/E· DigSILENT
AGC and balancing· KERMIT
Production costingMarket simulationSystem planning
· ProMod· GE MAPS
Overview of KERMIT Architecture
16
Inputs:LoadPlant SchedulesGeneration PortfolioGrid ParametersMarket/Balancing
Outputs:Power Plant MW OutputsArea InterchangeFrequency Deviation
Scenarios:Increasing Wind Adding ReservesStorage ParametersTest AGC ParametersTrip Events
KERMIT 24h Simulation
Generation•Conventional•Renewable
Inter-connection
FrequencyResponse
Real Time Market
Generator trip
Load rejection
Wind power forecast versus actual
Volatility in renewable resources
Key Elements of KERMIT Detailed IEEE standard dynamic models of a variety of generation types including:
- Steam (coal or gas fired)- Combined cycle gas turbine- Combustion turbine- Wind,- Storage- Hydro, and - General distributed generation resources.
Representation of generator governors, combustion and turbine controls – especially for primary frequency response and response to dispatch/regulation controls
Models of generation company portfolio dispatch and scheduling
Models of ISO real-time dispatch and AGC systems. It is also possible (and has been done) to precisely represent specific ISO AGC algorithms.
Representation of the dynamic frequency response of system load and second by second load and variable energy resource volatility.
17
Key Elements of KERMIT (2) Power system inertial response to generation-load imbalance including load dynamic response
and generator primary frequency response
Simulation of system frequency
Models of the interconnected control areas (when such exist) including a DC change to AC losses and models of inter-area regions with transmission constraints- Load flow and swing angle simulation- The load flow dynamically simulates transmission path flows among control areas as the relative phase
angles of the interconnected control areas respond to local and system generation–load imbalance caused by load variations, wind/solar variation, outages, etc.
- KERMIT has also been used successfully in island systems that do not have synchronous interconnections.
Representation of day-ahead hourly interchange and generation scheduling, load forecasting, and forecast errors. Hourly ramping behavior is also captured.
And many more modules…
18
Our goal was to include and model all sources of variability and uncertainty in a system
Agenda
Introduction to DNV KEMA
Overview of Moment to Moment Balancing
Introduction to KERMIT
Review of ERCOT KERMIT Project
Details of KERMIT and Demo
Discussion
19
Overview of Project Requirements Deliver a tool to ERCOT capable of analyzing ERCOT’s system resources to:
- Ensure adequate grid reliability; - Maintain system frequency within current NERC standards; - Provide for timely replacement of lost resources due to unit outages or unit variability; - Adequate control for risks due to unforeseen future occurrences in the real-time operations time-frame- Study future scenarios of renewable and conventional generation portfolio development and assess the
ability of the market and system to manage inherent variability in renewables- Study hypothetical changes in scheduling and market time frames, for example
DNV KEMA will develop:- A calibrated version of KERMIT for ERCOT’s system, market configuration, - Two future scenarios that ERCOT can use for the Long Term Study- New demand response modules for KERMIT to reflect potential future market participants
In addition, DNV KEMA will help support ERCOT in their KERMIT analyses to help ensure the objectives of ERCOT’s Long Term Study are met
DNV KEMA will train ERCOT staff and provide knowledge transfer to enable ERCOT to utilize KERMIT independently if desired, or to enable ERCOT own development of enhanced models, control algorithms, etc.
20
Study Benefits of Utilizing KERMIT
The primary benefit will be to support the long term resource planning/assessment process especially around adequacy of reserves and regulation capacity.
This includes:- The ability to examine and verify adequate ancillary service requirements- Ensuring real time dispatch solutions and use of regulation products are feasible and reliable- Testing future alternative market products or policy requirements for their effect on
transmission flows
The results of KERMIT analyses help ensure that future resource portfolios will provide sufficient flexibility for system dispatch and operations, including reserves and regulation, especially wrt managing renewable variability.
21
Project Team
Principal in Charge – Ralph Masiello / Jeff Bladen
Project Manager / Technical Expert – Dr. Warren Katzenstein
KERMIT Technical Expert – Dr. Khoi Vu
System Modeling Expert – Alan Roark
System Modelers / KERMIT Experts- James Hansell- Sudipta Lahiri- Andrew Stryker
22
Agenda
Introduction to DNV KEMA
Overview of Moment to Moment Balancing
Introduction to KERMIT
Review of ERCOT KERMIT Project
Details of KERMIT and Demo
Discussion
23
Agenda
Introduction to DNV KEMA
Overview of Moment to Moment Balancing
Introduction to KERMIT
Review of ERCOT KERMIT Project
Details of KERMIT
Demo
Discussion
24
Global presence DNV KEMA
25
HEAD OFFICEArnhem, The Netherlands