28
aLs1 sL1qAq DMDI$1OW 2HflM ThaMaTAHA 'ionujjoq YJTOD mAJq UT4A OI2IDU MOITADOJ nuh,M .51 n& OQ4 nbhoW HD51A3$1 DIMOMOD 10 UAHSIUH JA4OITAM invA fl3 d3J?M OOI 81O AM bhdmjD QQI ibmM bIer! "imono3H n3qO Iii 3jftq thinmnoiivnH :QQI qoilaktoW" io1 b1Bq5Iq w iqiq idT "irIiH IaJiqiD IinmnotivnH :qoda*roW" bifE QQI F- nu1 snino){ lo iiivinU fJ i cft nrIw bi31qmo3 asw iIfrIb ti1i 311T 2.QQI 1-EI i3dcn3iq32 ii13vinU nninsW ii b1ri 311T 2QQI b nzit briE M nhub sninno)1 lo iiviriU ri ia 1o21oIq nuiiiv £ w lorfiuE iol briE noiuth nuis1urnii v iol ith 1nbui2 iEub1n briE ihjl th An&1i lothuE bnl3 3bwiT thnoiiBrninI flu rnoiq (I 318E51 '51HflT4 lo flEq i iqq 21r1T .ii1Eiiq2of1 ii uB5wH 1EnoiiT4 rf lo oth ion briE lorthJE rii lo oth 5W bsqx noirnqo nA .jnrnJvnI .fI31E2$1 3IfflOfIO3H lo owl b3sx ol ion ixi 10 noii flor1 .bvisi irIh 11A .nw±IEM .51 rru d Q?1 © © nibuI3th iibsi3 Ilul 113th bbivoiq noiaiimq iioi1qx juothiw bioup d m rIqfnfriEq .31iJO &II 01 f1Vi ! 3iiOfl

DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

aLs1 sL1qAq DMDI$1OW 2HflM

ThaMaTAHA 'ionujjoq YJTOD mAJq UT4A

OI2IDU MOITADOJ

nuh,M .51 n&

OQ4 nbhoW

HD51A3$1 DIMOMOD 10 UAHSIUH JA4OITAM invA fl3 d3J?M OOI

81O AM bhdmjD QQI ibmM

bIer! "imono3H n3qO Iii 3jftq thinmnoiivnH :QQI qoilaktoW" io1 b1Bq5Iq w iqiq idT "irIiH IaJiqiD IinmnotivnH :qoda*roW" bifE QQI F- nu1 snino){ lo iiivinU fJ i

cft nrIw bi31qmo3 asw iIfrIb ti1i 311T 2.QQI 1-EI i3dcn3iq32 ii13vinU nninsW ii b1ri 311T 2QQI b nzit briE M nhub sninno)1 lo iiviriU ri ia 1o21oIq nuiiiv £ w lorfiuE iol briE noiuth nuis1urnii v iol ith 1nbui2 iEub1n briE ihjl th An&1i lothuE

bnl3 3bwiT thnoiiBrninI flu rnoiq (I 318E51 '51HflT4 lo flEq i iqq 21r1T .ii1Eiiq2of1 ii uB5wH 1EnoiiT4 rf lo oth ion briE lorthJE rii lo oth 5W bsqx noirnqo nA .jnrnJvnI

.fI31E2$1 3IfflOfIO3H lo

owl b3sx ol ion ixi 10 noii flor1 .bvisi irIh 11A .nw±IEM .51 rru d Q?1 © © nibuI3th iibsi3 Ilul 113th bbivoiq noiaiimq iioi1qx juothiw bioup d m rIqfnfriEq

.31iJO &II 01 f1Vi ! 3iiOfl

Page 2: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

Jq WBEIOFIJGL co 8O3OôOQflUJAL211A oi ooqoDbUWGUt O1, ECOJOUJ!C1JG W VILJ(flU

IJJLIUTJ C0212 (.1 CJ1JL f1QJ2)

wotoL2) pu wncp wqjc jpct ou bLoqnctou miq "m' tjrnu J.Q2p.cuou2 tpt jj ou

C02t TUCLC22 12 cLnc1J: L2PJCtJOU2 t1Jt IJJ OU pcq C02t2 (C WOI.G CUJCIQIJt pm.UGL2 uq

LGJJOCWOU MGU wnjtnrntiorntj 9L bLc2ur Ju rqqTpou tQ bbcL juq tjrnt tpc oi.w wjccu pA

couJbfr1JA WTLj(G1 jOLCG2 !U IJJQ P2IJCQ O1 Wfljt1UtIOIM1J2 12 2JiJJtIA ILL 1J391J tIJG !Ut1-U1.11J

UAJLOUUJGUWJ LG2tUCtIOU2 OL LGflJt1OU2 JJJG TUtQL-pLUJ LGTIOCtJOU OT bwqnctiou pA

JoJjop (5) AJnji1uftJouJ2 qo UOt WCLC2G pc bLoqnctIou-LqJocpou cvnq pA

co2tJA QUAOUUJUWJ LQ2PJCtTOU2 pflt LflWQUt2 1I!U2t JpcLJ tLqG OU JH.C Loriuq qo UOt

rpc nwut JJJQ ruqiu t: (j) jpcq jpcwjispou ruci. bLoqclcnou 2cu2JtJAItA to

bbcL qbt2 u ojiobojA moqGJe Ju iipicp wnjtiutJouj cu cuqocuon2JA to CiuiJuG

2JUJJjLJA JUCLGg2G rpc bLoqrlctlou uq JL LG2bOU2Q to co2tjA GUMLOUUJCUWJ LQ2U4CUOU2 Jp2

(4QuAaouwQuw qnujbiu1 (5) IU2tUJUt ICLJ! OU jqn to mnjtrnrtouj tJUJJ2

qw to prcp bLoqncrrou 12 iutcwnoujA LcJOctcq rn Lc2bou2c to CUATLOIJUJGIJWJ LQ2tLTCtIOIJ2

2 LTIUJUt2 flU2t rLqc uq JUAC2tUJGUI JpcLJTwOU (j)jq I!pGL9J1ipOu UJCJ.C2C2 1JJ

jpc fl-AJGx1CO gc-tLqc qptc rncjnqcq 2owG tpcOLGt!cJ 2OU2 1JJJt IACLC tJJQU (12Gq

IBaLKVCI

rocviiow DECI2IOM2COVbE1IJJAE14E22 WIlD bfV14L

COLTA bOITflJJOM VBVLEEIkL

I4BEI MOLICUJ b9bCL thO

Page 3: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

rIOii3UbOIiflI .1

10 bnuoi suinU 3di bnB rn3m1A 3b8IT 3iI nBah3mA rfhoM b3i3Iqmo3 1ifl3331 311T

3r1i bns i1oq 3bslt n33wbd noii33nno3 i £11318 v3IIoq-3iIduq 3dt ot ir1uoid TFAO 3di

.ain3mu1s noitsils13ciil-3bs1t-itna lo l3dmun £ 3bsm 21J 3dt iii quoi Isin3mnolivna .tn3mnolivn3

lo 3g6insvbs 1st ot 13b1o 111 o3ix3M oi noitubrnq iJ1nsii bluow zlf3noiisnLflum U tEdt asw 3n0

W31v 10 ithoq aidi oi in3md3sflA .bowolljl 313W 3b613 331111 o3ix3M ni abrEbn6ia fBlfl3mflolivfI3 13W01

bsiJ 3311 b3tioqqua aqiioi lsin3mnolivn3 2U in3thmolq 1613v .Iul3vinu ansm on d asw

nith nhLsan3 ot 3iuol ntn-not iad di ai o3ix3M 111 blBbnsia nivi1 gnith s tsdt niuis iiia s lo duon3 b3aus3 noiiiaoq 3bs11-itns 3111 aabdi13vT'1 .o3ix3M ni noif301olq I6tn3mnolivn3

.aiac(bsnE 131111u1 lnBrisw ot

I8in3mnolivn3 lo 2133113 311110 aia1sna 3vmaoq 8 t3ubno3 01 ai qsq zifft lo ocpuq 3dT

Isnoitsri no bn6 (in3rno1qm3 33n311) noit3IJboIq lo 3fnulov 3111 ains1q lo noiis3oI 3111 no noits1u3i

31111631111w I3bom 3111 bsd if I as b31nfl (IicI3up31l m "alsnoiisnillum" as lsIoaflI .315113w

no 131iin3 31311 auo1 111w I .amill 3vith3qmo3 1i33113qmi id znoiakb noits3ol-insIq auon3obn3

31fF .in3mnolJvn3 131163136 1 aifl3n3d 311101 as nhiupth fuorliiw noi1sLu31 d b3aoqmi 81203 3(11

3rIT .bBd to boos i1oq n3vi s im Di w 3Idsvinoa 11E iaomls ni bi13i3mB1sq 3(11163131181

isiIi lo 3mo3iuo 3Idi8aoq iaiow 3111 28 b3131q131th 3d 1nibios bluoda i1oq s lo 2133113 31S113w"

.b311831 316 21113113ff I8tn3mnolIvn3 011 113111W 111 ioq to biovs 01 85 02 83111111103 3fl13fl111P(8 dtiw I3bom 1oqoi1o bisbnsia £ qol3v3b 111w I

a3rlinIJo3 owl 315 31311T £.noiiBSilRi33qa noit3ubolq iol aiasd 36rnsvbs-3viis1sqmo3 116 "35J161111311"

tnBiano3 iIliw nkwbrnq 1o1a 3viiibqmo3 s ai'( .(Y bnfi X) aboo owl bns (ni31o1 bn6 3111011)

bns 211111131 25313fl1 1111w ni3ub01q 101332 3vIiil3qmo3 f133113qmi its al X bn6 3fs3a 01 21rI1J131

113111W 2133113 316113W 3V6f1 111w a3htaubni 118 III 2181)3 838151 d3idw 110i181U31 S 31qffl6x3 ns aA ff3112 biovs 01 daiw I .itaubth nii3qmO3-l1oqmi 11510 tlOqx3 118 21 16111 13111311w no 11rn3Ln3 bn3q3b

.2133113 lo monoxE1 b3tsi3oaaB d I bns anOilB3tlqfflO3

I

Page 4: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

4JJø C9JJ2 WJFE2221CW LOL cucLgJ cdrnppunw) i u pipct-jcic jvunvk o1 bbcq cucuij-cdnq1pqnw woqcjpun1!ou 2OJACL) 20JAc2 ?21CW2 0 U0U-UJC9t IUI9W! N!2\GE (w91pcw9pcq bLo&9ww!u

92 qqcq uio 2fl A21cw2 10 GV2 q-' (wixcq iucdnøptA uq uou-juct

12 !" fflLIJ 19LC1A qnc 10 IJJC L9CI 1P91 mfl11!1191!011012 9U2C 11 GdnpUnW MJJCU 1L9C C0212 9W LC19IACJA

O IJJC C021 UCLG92G2 U OUC COflUIIA OACL pofp COnLUcr EI7LIPCL 9U9J1Z12 1UqC91C2 1J191 111! Uqu1

o co i uo ijq p1qccq rpc obboc bbc ro PC tC cøc: wnuw911ou912 moop tpc ccq

ccouq wc I.i!ouipi 1iJtiou w9C bioqncrou uq bpwj jociou WOLC Lc2bou2uc

LojJon1u 1C wnou oj CUA0UWCU1 boj!CA oujA joMcI.2 MCIL9LC jI1LpCL

LC2I)CC1 O 11191 ! 111C !111fl1!0U o IL9qC 9U!CL2 (oL pc qccou uo o WWOAC wcw)

(Lcc9JJ 1P91 WGLC 12 UO c0Wb9L91!/C 9q111JtdC)' H0!ACL 1CLC 2110 2CCouq-pC21 9LnI11C1J1 91P

iu IJJC bLc2cucc °L IPC2C C02(2 cnc xbwqncrou lpgu onjq OIPCLMI2C occrn

CIThILOUWCIU9I boJcA-uqnccq o1 uic w x m ouc conuiLA (LoLcU) .ur1e iou.u Lqc

VLC 92 LOIIOMZ Efl21 1L9C 9U4CL2 qo u2njøic bwqcIctou pom pc ccq ot

9u8Jlsc fJJC woqcj Ur1WC14C911A fl2!U JçI11J1CL0Lq2 (J) uou-jucvi cowbjcwcupu.rA sj04ipUr3

OL LOflL U1.w jAbce) C!P1 UJ9qm& 911q 01TL A949JC2 LOL IJJC UflWPCL2 °L JJuJJ OL C9CJJ IAbC2 I 111(12

12 LcbLC2cIucq pA tj IJou-pIJc9L !ucdrIsil!c2: cipi onbn jciqe (powc uq LoLc!I1 enbb11ce LOL C9C

1112 ACLA qUJcflJ 10 OP1911 9U9,A1!C91 LC2STJI9 !' 1JJ2 wOqCf EACU 9 b91.t9J-cdn!J!punw AC12!0U

W(1U1Q !U HJ3Cp IIJC U1.UJ-2bCC!IJC cabj

COnUl4G2 911q CSIJ 2!W!I9LIA p 1°911 II' IJJC JJOWC OL L0LC1U C0flUfIA M1O91!O1 qcucq 92 IPC

911q 2U1J9LJA 1191!0U9J ULW2 !U 1PC L0tCI COIW4 N1111m9110119J UUJ.12 W911J19W bJ9u !U P0111

JJLW2 JJJCLC 9LC JJOWC COI1UILA U91!0U91 L1UJJ2 JJICp W9A OL UJØA 1101 CXbOLI 10 IPC L0LC! COrIUflA

JJJCLC 12 LL CU&k 911q CX1 !1J10 uq Oflj O L0flL LILUJ JThC2,4 1491101191 UJJ2 9W 2W1C-bJ9U1

Wflh11-b!91U CCOU0UJC2 °L 9U 9 P! L0L Wn11!U91!0U91 bLoqnclzow

1WbCLLCCI COIJJbCI!110IF jJJCLC 9LC UIW-2bCC ll 92 bJauj-2bcqljc Xcq C0242 111 )( CLC911IJ

Page 5: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

aiao3 31)811 dicI is nsd in3miavni its d b3bu13m is alsnoitsniilum 1i 1zftivM .dh1

noitluini 3f!T .32s313rn iaoo lo 13v31 n3vi s oi anoqai igisI i1idila s 3vsd 318113w bits nod3ubolq

mhi.1-131rn tacIt 3381 3111 zioni llsnoiisn13tth noit3ubolq niis3o131 is iqobs om alsnoiisnitlum tacIt

.3vianoqa3I as taut d ism aio1 ihsm 3viiii3qmo3 duoidi annil Isnoiisn gnoms anoita3olIs3l

320311 .tII3mnaIvn3 3IialIoqOiIO lo 3qi zidi cii lsi3IrI3 ai 23253l3fli 1203 lo ciriol 3111 biiiIT

bvits131 315 aiz113 318113w bits cioibubolq (1n3mqiup3 b3xfl 3vian3qx3) 21203 b3xfl no ilsi 2325313it

3IdsFIsv no hal 2328313n1 12031! .v1inuJo3 13111i3 iol 233ci31J32flO3 W31 citiw 1IX3 aiiiill 3(1102 .ionim

.iis1 d3um 318 315113w bits cioii3iJbolq no zi1b 3111 aiao3 (1sciiism)

3d1 cii lls13ci3 ai ii i1ic1a 3mi1 a aubth I tnuo3 cii 328513111 tao3 3111 n3dw c1huoI

its 3vad 11 Iinuo3 cii bisof anniI .annll Isnoilanlilum gni3slqaib acinfi Isnoiisn lo cioii1ib

11 ¶(ItnuO3 cii atcinlq nisimsm 1no I (1tnuo3 cii 1)335301 amli! 3 1iciuo3 cii ainslq 32013 01 3v11133ni

lo ann3i cii bsiuas3m ci11i1 .325313n1 3203 3111 1 331132dB 3111 cii swns oa 3ciob 3vsd bluow 3dt Ii

cii ci v1tnuo3 oil irnJoz) moil amifl lo qicIal3nwo ailida I Itnuo3 cii 325313cii iao3 3111 a13dmuci cmii

.23283 hIs cii ion tud iaom

Page 6: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

I3boM 3di lo nO!ia3fli33q

brn ñ) ahinuo3 owT .(dI) aIdsn3V bns noatthsM moil nIsi ai I3bom nbh3bnu 3dT

bnfi (iodal) J noh3ubrnq 10 aiots1 owi is 313dT .X bns'( aboo auo3n3omod owl 3oubolq (1

m Ino b3au loi3fiI 3flI33q s al $1 .3tidommi 118noiiam3ith tud ahtaubth nwt3d 3lidom al J .51

moil lodEl awsib ioia X 3di 10 noiarisqxH J3born 3dJ "u1x3vno ol Iflsq ais $1 .flaubth Y 3I1I

ann3i iii biuasm iods! 10 iao 3111 thalsi d313di 1oi3oa Y 3(11 m oiii J\$1 3(11 niaisi 1o1a Y di 3(11 bits b3xfl 3111 thod lol b3au ai iodsJ .iqsq 3111 iuof1iJoIdi 3Th313Uit as b3au 3d 111w '1 .Y lo

n33w13d ainsd 3bslt 13111010 atao3 noqansit is 313111 noi1bbs ni bits X grn3ubolq ni aiao3 3ldBflSv

.b3tI0qx3 X lo tutu tq todsl 10 atinu as b311bqa anitMuo0

s ai 1 iiinuoo ni Y lo iuqtuo 311T .(d1) z3hinuo3 3111 tonb ot b3au 3d 111w (ji) atqh3adu2

al Y tol noIt3nuI noit3ubolq 311T .SIlo in3mwobn3 a'i (iifwo3 a11$1 313(1w JIOIt3flul as1uoU-ddoO

= I — (I)

lo i3uboIq Isnigism 3ulsv 3di 01 , w sw di 1o ti1sup3 d n3vi zi io1a Y dt ni bnsm3b todsJ

iods1

k = I 1- *(\ ?) — ()

bits zunil Ifinoitfin ot nh13hi as 3ldsimv a 31snia3b ot b3au d iliw (mn) atqh3a13qu2

331UOZ31 1531 3U2fl03 isdi athu1t as b3ll3bom 3d 111w aiomsd 3bSlt tl3qaq 3111 1uofIuotrfl3 31ff .inu03 fIth0q1n 3111 iol 3Ufl3V31 jstn, rbidw a11hst as nsdi idist aiao3 noqansii as d3ua

-afnl3i) Thisi Ismiiqo d b3auInoo thd a11uai 3di 10 noisi3iql3trn 3111 biovs 01 as oa 3b81fl 51 iod3 itS 01 3ub 35s313rn tao3 noit3ubotq s b 33n353lq 3111 ni Ii 31qffl5x3 io1 .5133113 (3bsll-1o

Isin3mnolJvrI3 311101 3ub stilt al a113w avotqmi Thist llsma s isdi bnfl 3W flOIJ3flia3l !ftifl3fflflOlIVfl3 a3ob iud noiaulno3 aidi abiova ism I noiiqmuaas 31ff i33113 3bslt-10-aml3i £ 01 tO flOit3fliSOl

thu tufi .318113w I3wol 3nhI3b os aimsd bsii isdt noitqmuaoiq s al 313111 :asid 3iisoqqo 3111 316313 .I3bom thu ni llsma (I3v si 333113

Page 7: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

2nnhl m 3v1135 1o i3dmun 3di 3s3ibnl oi bo2u 3d oals 111w (1n, 1m) .bvi33qa3i annfl Isnoi)sni)Ium

ni3d ai )sdw 1x3)no3 3d) moil 1s313 3d zswIs 111w 11 111ñ3qoH .1 flu03 ni b3asd 2mlfl n bns

ui annhl Isnoi)sn lo idmun 3d) o) 213131 sw1s noi)5up3 as ui 3Idsnsv a 2B 1n b)n3z31q31

.(i v1)11u03

anhl !Bnoflsn A .i vIinhJo3 m basd nnfl Isnoisn i 10 vdnuo3 ui anisa 3d) aion3b

s(flnuo3 ni mill Isnolian 3110 d beau iodsl 3d) 02 flnuo3 asd all ni noii3ubrnq all ils asl13bfw

d n3vi 21 1

= + + + + ()

-anfi bus 3h1133q2-)fIllIq 3d) 3Th 1 baa [) bna 1203 aoi)3ubolq 1nniiam )na)ano3 3d) 21 3 313dW

3110 tloqafisi) o b3b33f1 iodsl 10 )nuoms 3d) al i .iodsl lo 2111w ui b3vJaa3m d)od 2)203 b3XlI 3i1i33q2

ion 21 -r 02 znoi)331lb d)od iii 311182 3d) 3d 0) 3U2Z5 3W d3IdW j (1lnuo3 01 1 vnuo moil X lo linu

.i(ilnuoo (d b3lqfl3adUa

d383 ui )nslq 3110 23)sl3qo ii . iinuo ui anisa asd 1 Iinuo3 th basd Isnolisnlflum A

moil 13111n3 )3m 315 23182 .v1)11U03 3asd all ni , 1 iao3 b3xfl 3fikq2 nrifl all 2iu3th iud 1)rnJo3

id novi iodsl 1 vnuoo iol bnamob aad Ianoilsni)Ium 1 vi)nuio3 a oa 3bs1) )on noi)3ubrnq 1830!

+ + ()

iodaI j 1)nuo3 iol bnsm3b asd oals Isnodsrnhlum I V1)11U03 A

+ ()

ati lo 110138301 3d) d b3ninn3l3b ai 3MM 3d) d b3zu vo1onrb3i 3d) lad) muaaa 3W laul) 33i)oM

lo alao3 3d) in3231q31 0) 10 32151 iliw 3W 2flOi)332 )X311 3d) nI .a133-lsIJpbs3d all lo ion alns1q

Page 8: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

o

inuoo m rn3ubo1q znrñl ils d 3rnod 3d ium iwx, ff .bmbnsi Isin3mnolivn3 mo nhi33m

3qi ton tud m bris m n 3qt1o annfl tTh di oa 1

Isnoiisn1 n moil bnsm3b iodsl nibbA .1 yiinuo 10 ia3mwobn3 iodsl Istol 3dt 3ton3b 1 t&I

I viiniio vI Ciinuo3 ni bsd 1snoitsthuIum bns i inuo3 ni b3asd thinoitsnitlum .m zrnifl

:flflfi3I3 t3*!Sm ioiasl

(L + + 7 + + + (ô)

+ + ( + + +

.M b3ion3b mo3ni i itiwo o tfloiq on oIsm iot X 3111 muhdiliup3 nI

= - I) + = (V)

iilitU .Y bns X lo noitqmiizno3 3111 3ioa3b j bns X bits i tnuo3 ni X lo *iq 3111 zton3b 1q

as1uoU-ddoO ai i1auo3 11353 th imuanoo 3vitain3z3lq3l 311110

+ + + - (8)

abnsm3b nivi

(2)

aIsup3 3Uit3V31 1snimm) anoitsup3 nbhq d b3niun3i3b ai iotz X 3d1 al mundiliupa

fsnigism ivo hq lo aqithsm Isnoiiioqoiq 3lon3b 3W .anoiiibno3 viin3-11 bits (12o3 Isniinm

.i t311sm nI Isnoiinniilum j itiuio s lo qithsm 3111 31qmsx3 iol (mn = !) ,

d io3

-vIsin3m3lqmo3 th f13111w) 316 1iism 11353 in amiil tsnoitnnittum bits Isnoitsn b &Ioitsup3 ni3hI

:(t±sid iii a3Idshsv b3taboas IIIIW miol 223nJ13sk

Page 9: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

cp at pcc poq ,#ip cdnajiA rpc '.!$upuq !qc boryc ajpcuiic ortbn cdn9p CLO

(18)

('u) I, -

(j) 'X —

(j) L' b'fl2llJ JJc2C c bLc!ou uj bucid cdrn,pou2 iicr cxbtcniou to onbn rn rcuu oj bucc

(14) c = =

jji (gpo nu qczirnuq cdn!ou2 ())

woqcj pc bqcc c1021!ciIA i auc (cc cdrnitiou ())LcqncpJ rpc uJJ IrnJLJcnb o 2p9Lc

UUIJ2 WLJCC 2JJLC qMqcq pA (JJC 9L2fJff1uu bL!CC cjcicA o( qcwuq lxi wqccr ju orn

iu canuxor woqcj iiqp powocucon bwqnc pc obrurnq wajcnb oujjnj ycu pA tpc

(j) b(j

(is) b'Q 5,) (,,)

(ii) b(j —) + L) (-j,)

(io) 'b'Q— i.'c' (x',)

Page 10: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

8

lo ni3ffl 3dt n3cI bn8 nnlI q atuqtuo mundilwp3 isdi iqsq 3di ifi 13181 33n313191 iol 31oi4

b3xfl no liiib ton tud1 3 aiao3 1sniism bna ahq no thn3q3b anlui3I nias13ni dtiw noil3ubcflq

3111 gnrnsd3 f1uo1dt 3n3i3ffl3 noit3ubolq tTh 1ioiibni Ino 111w aiao3 b3x11 ni nsdD .tao3

1w bns 1q 1o u1sv muhdiliup3

nrifl iuol di lo 13dmun 3111 oi nibnoqno3 znoitibno3 iflrnq-os rnoI is Isup3 3un3vo1 qzthism isdi tn3mniup31 3111 as n3i,thw 3d ns atfloiq oi (€i)-(Oi) afIoiisUp3 n3vif)

.atao3 b3xiI

(4s) (+ � + (QI)

() (+).q � + (Os)

(s) + + � + ('s)

() + ( + + 'bIs () :as b3z1qx3 3d n83 anoiiibno3 1tn3 i1 adt (8i)-(1I) thau n3di 3vitiaoq 318 aiiiqtuo II

{+?) —

+ ()

(tn) � [(N—

+ — ()

(I) ++) ()

(si) w+(+\w � (ô)

1138310 anniI lo l3dmun 3111 anmurn3i3b ru instioqini 318 aiao3 b3xfl isdI 3311313131 13i81 iol 310V1

.muridiliup3 iii (vits al) ataix 3qt-flnfl lsIu3itIsq s ton 10 13111311w bns 3qvi

Page 11: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

diiw bisi3oazs m (8I)-(t) a3iiilBup3ni irIi3 oift I3bom 3dt m ioi X di hsmrnu oT

3Th ()-() ni aitihwp3ni iuol 3d bns 1(qi mill wol iol rbl3 owi) 213v31 iuqiuo tdi3 odi

3O3flI ) d n3vi ,ia ahq zboo llsnoiiibbA .3q1 cba b &irrfl to l3dmun 3d3 dñw b3lBi3oazs

bnsm3b iodgl dliw I3d33oi (ô) noilsup3 gnns3I3 13]hBm io1sl moiI hq ioial bns (V) moil a13v31

.() iot 'I' di molt

lo i3dmun 3dt of ub kio ion b3is3ilqmo3 3liIJp ai lthom lBfnrmm idf fl3V3 ffIi 1S313 ai ii

.a3iiilsup3ni lo aml3i iii bzz3iqx3 tln3i3dth i Ii IBdI I31 3111 of 311b lud 1d6i1Bv auon3obn3

1i3rti 1111w aioiq boos !sm of flu3lflib I3v i ii bns muhdiiup3 ni bsIz 3d Iliw 3dl lo 3mo2

-IBIIIsq niau zzioiq 3Idsl3biano3 Ism 3W ((dQQi) 1dEn3V bns n3alrAlBM nI .abodf m IB3!iIBnfi

.abodi3m Is3h3nwn of niniui 3ioI3d ni1ilBup3ni no (fnlano3 bI3d 1M bns 1w) abodi3m muildiliup3

of b3r1313i 3m ai3bB3i b313inI .anoiiBIumi2 fs3h3mun of Ilziib vom iliw I iqq thf I nI

.zf3EolqqE Is3thIsns 4Iqth iii iom s io1 (dQI) 3IcIMI3V bn n3aIi1mM

Page 12: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

01

iao0 IithisM no i3sclml anoiiIu$L fsinmnrnivn3 £ a'rnill B 3aIBI 113U1W a3biloq Isffi3mnolivn3 iol afluiaoi aiiqini bna aiIt3a3lq anoiia airiT

.1803 io Ho iutlqlua-wot 3VLfl3X3 310ffl lo au odf nhiup3i as d3ua aiao3 noii3uboIq Isniism

rIB nhoni tiitu 10 moni li lo aaol 3rIi 1qmia is "aiao 318113w isdI oiasdqm3 I nisgA

.nods1u31 3dt moil i331h Istn3mnolivn3 1513113n3d

niw rinol aam1as1a 1(IBin3m3Iqmo3 th b3vloa al noiia auoiv3lq rft ni b3dhzab bbom 3dT

ni 3V113s 318 a3qii mifi wol ifs ion js13n3 nI .13i1s3 b3ion as MAO ol anoian3tx3 abioh311iu$1

ni aiaoa 1sniism ni a3asi3rn Isnoiiioqoiq lo bh a ivo alIua3l atn3a3lq I 31ui1 .mlthdiliup3

owl 3d1 I 3IdsT lo woi qol 3111 nI .(aixs lsfnothiod 3111) 21a03 3bsli bns (aixs 183i113v 3111)1 IirnJo3

s awob 3vom w as 1iao3 iom nimod I Ilnuo3 ni noii3ubolq dliw js3iin3bi 315 a3hlnuo3

di nO .11 y1inuo3 at nndi I vIinuo3 ni 13dif1 318 afaoa Isnig tam woi motiod 3(11 a! .nmuIo3

aiaO3 3a3dT .iI v11r1u03 at ataO3 Ianiism lo nothoqolq a as aiao3 3b511 318 aiinu fft aixs Ianothiod

.anoiiiib diod ni 3ni3mrna 318

31311w migi mthIdiliup3 3111 nivig noiis1umia 3111 moil aflua 3viisiilsup zin3a1q I 51IJi1

-1131) wol is aiaoa iioqanali n3dW .muhdiIiup3 m viizia 318 isdi a3q(1 nnfl 3111 as b311113b al 3ffl31

mr3i isdi bns 3v11381n bits d annil lsnoiisn 1no lo aiaianoo 3mi1 3(11 (ma1Rsib 3111 lo 3bia basil

id b3isnimob ai 3ni31 3(11 d3id (i3V 31s aiao3 rloqanali 11311W .3Z5313fli iao3 dt ol 3vifiarI3zni al

(aiaoo hoqanali 3isl3bom) noiia 3lbbim di iii ai ii .a3a8313rn lao3 lo a13v31 ifs iol alsnoifsthulum

nwob vom w as 1x113 auoivdo isom 311T .83as313th iao3 01 32flOZ31 ni aflida 3atL31 33 w isdi

s iol :3viiiuini ai aidT .zmifl d 3qii d b33s1q31 315 annfl d 3q(i isdi al (01. = r nmulo3 s inslq au 3ao13 ol 3viin33rnns 3153131 viinhJo3 m a3aa3l3ni tao3 3111 4 Iinuo3 ni b3I3risupbs3d trail

.11 iinuo3 th inslq au moil thoqx3 d 1 tinuo3 3v13a oi bits I (1inuo3 ni

a3aa3i3rn iao3 3111 3tiqa3b muhdilhJp3 ui iaix 01 3unuln03 1 iinuo ui b3i3rIaupba3d anniI

muhdiliup3-1s13n3 a ai 33n31ax3 b3urnino3 113(11 hsq a! .b3daithmib 1ia3i 318 al3dmun 113(11 hid

Page 13: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

U

0.1

0 U

0 I. 0.

1

U

oE.1

0I.1

0

0.1

U

0o1

3mr3

51

muh

diliu

p1

311i

no

ao

D

&üs

M1o

t3

sqcn

I—1

iui'1

a

a

88

88

a a

a a

a a

a a

a a

88

88

88

a 08.

OV

. 0ô

. 0.

0.

E

. O

t. .

0.

1.

01.

80.

ô0.

0.

0.

E0.

0.

10

.

3M

ii vn

uo3

b no

inoq

oi

a aa

at

o3

noqn

wiT

&lT

Ift

n n

arm

ft

,m em

lftd

m

arni

ft

m

m

Page 14: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

juIJ2 pcoqdnol.(cLcq (CLG qp wouo(ouJcoJJA o MC WOAG qoau ouA cojnwu °I JLC jOUJA (JIG q0Wc2(C WOLJCG( BI 92 !U(fi!(!0u Monjq 2I1G2( (JIG i0(0J UJIWpCL 01 bjoiuo !u conup.? IGaCc( LCqnCrn ML JO OfIfflcJGu(JA 2(LOU iJJ0( 0 AGLA 2IIIOJJ UnWJIGL 01 iThcuL utwo con GU(GL 2GLAUIJUCLG92JII urnupco 01 Thc-n' ULWO JpMoLq (JIG J)OUOW 01 (JIJO cojnwu (JItO cuGLoJ-GdnJJpu•nwu boi. qnc o pe cou Juctesoc ouq u boi.j qnc (0 cowbcp(iou IU (JIG COflu(LA-JI WOLJCG( JjLoWqou (JIG cornnu .1. = pj ocnojA JGOqO (0 0 LJJ in ML so IJJG UflWJICL 01 )bc-wt ULWO 19112 LSbIqJA:(JIJ2 JO bLCCJOGJA (G jThG 01 GUGL0J-CdfIJJJpLJflW CCCI 1I12( sJJnqGq o jpe coos JUCLG92CO WOAUin cdrnppurwz 92 (JIG C09( JUCLGSOG PGCOUJGO GX(LGUJC V qcrsjjeq JIIObGC(J0U °L (JIG LGOnJ(2 2r1G2( (JIOt

v oOwCNpsi bnjn LGOrIJ( W0MiJ qoMu c0flurn .L = 1001E!flLG J JO IJJO( (AbG-UijLW2 GX!2(

JJJG !u(IT!(!0u pCpiuq (JIJO LCOIIJ( OCCUJO (0 LflU O0WG(JJJU JJJCC (JIG 10ll04iJ' NJJQU (L9C CO2(2

coo(2 jpn (L9C cooro ocew bLo(cc( x onbni ow bLoqncpou coos UCLG9OG2 pnr nor MGIIOLG

p1JJCL (E!LC 4) HOMGAGL' LOL 0 1ACU C0O( 1IICLG92G MC9LG 12 drnic IUOGIJOIf JAG (0 (JIG JGAGJ 01 (L9G

cacci on x bi.oqnc(Jon JO wncp J0LGL MJIGU (LSG 002(2 VLG JOMGL (EnLG ) pou MJJGU (JIGA OLG

cacer 01 J0MiU bLoqnc(Jou ouq MGjJ0LC In conU(LA I snq unorn (JIOOC A9u9pJc2 in conuQ p jpc

2GAGL9J LCOflJ(2 uc sbboLGn( jLOW I.I•flLco 5-4 JJLe( (JIG COO( JUCLCUOGO qo JJOAC (JIG Ju(nJ(yc

= •0 •50 onq 0 10 EInLG2 5 3 suq 4 LGObGC(JiCJA

COflUILJGO p snq I LGObC0IJACJA jpcoc (p1Gc ntco coi.LG2boUq (oqJjjGLCU( conwu 01 nw j £

JCAGJ2 (' yP XL) MJIGLG y" suq )(L JUcJnqG oil bi.oqncpou pA °ll Uun (Abco bwqncrn u

E!1ILG 5-4 JJJfI2(LS(G (JIG Gacc(o 01 (JIG W9LJU9J COol WCLGSOGO On MCJ9LC ouq bLoqncqon

bcL bsu( in cornsp.A I (rncdnoppco ()-(j)) o oJuJIJcouqA cqnccq pA (PC WCLG92G u

b4cco sqn2( (0 (JIG JUCLGO2C n cLto JCGGb (JIG OOJfl(J0u (0 (JJJ2 OnpO)OIGW COIJO(9U( H0MGAGL OlTibfl(

(JIG UflWJICL 01 (JUl32 in cOcp CofluiLA bGL R!(P LGLCLGUCC (0 wGdnsJJ(JGO ()-() obbstnijA

qowwsrcq pA Wn(J139(JOUSJ2 (pCU WOL8JUVJ COOL IIJCLGUOGO oulA occj bJou(-JGAGJ bLoqnc(Jon suq nor

Jqcu(JcsJ pn( GOCJI 01 (Pew COUCC1UL0(G (J3GIL bwqnclJou n 4JJGJL COIIU(LA p bjouç IL bLoqnc(Jou JO

j (.. = 80) Vi °H bOiu(2 (JIGOG C0jflhJJlJ2 (JIG WIWJIGL 01 (ThG W' snq (Abe wL (JUl32 OLG

OUG IU(CLC2(!U LGOITJ( (GUIIO 01 (JUJI nnwpco OCCSTL2 in (JIG LOL LJJI(-p9uq COJflUJJJO 01 E!1

(JIG LG1ICC qcwouq 10L JOpOL in (JIG X2GC(0L

bpcuowcuow yo OOWG (JLW2 GXI( Mi(JI cool JUCLGS2G2 (JJCLG JO 9 WOqGLO(JOu JIJ (JIG M9G L0(G qnc (0

is

Page 15: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

OLI

OU

IJ

xte:

co

nupA

rn

upic

co

e•

EC

i O

UIJ

CLG

V2G

2 !U

C

0fW

U

Ut4

PIG

C

O

JjIII

LG

L!flL

o.oo

o-

o.oo

o

10•0

00•

Qo.

ooo

90•0

00

1OO

OO

OE

,

Jo.o

oo

H00

00

.100

•000

AC

E

OW

4E

(z.io

)

-V--

M-&

0•00

0

OO

oo;

—ci

——

X-t

AC

E

OW

IE

(-o3

)

0•00

0 I

I I

I t

o.oo

o

go•0

00

9000

0

Joo.

000

Jo.o

oo

FO

OO

O

1000

00

AC

E

OW

IE

(z.o

oa)

—-M

-L

-*-M

P

Page 16: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

II 1 v1111u03 in amifl n 31323mob d3 sinsvbB2ib 13V32 328313rn 3203 no 3ubolq 3111 wo1 (13 318

iiiqiuo 1o 2201 3g181 s al 31311T .11 ylinuo3 th al33ubolq d1 12o3-wol 3di 1211 B8 3131qmo3 12um orlw

318113W 3Vi83fI iliiw 133113118 l0i33Z &flh1J331-fliZfl3l3fli fl8 in nOit3ubolq lo noit811no3 3113 03 3ub

iua .31u1s101il noi3lithff1o-18h12ubth-3b811 3111 111 a3fio both2sdqmo nood asd 38113

3f18d3 118m2 (I3V 8 1no al 0131113843 3381 odl d bo3itim 5181 1inuoo ni a32aol 318113w iomuano

noiiauboiq aiao 3b813 i1id 1111W .11 1inuo3 mrnl noiii33qmo3 Iqqu2 d1 01 3ub X lo 33hq 3113 iii

iovowoH .bonoilnom iauj 333113 31832 3vi183n 311310 oonozds 3113 niy1qmi b333o3oiq 211 (13nUo3 111

cu 2l3muano3 ml 33nq iodid '(1in83flmia £ flu ath,231 noii3nia3l IBinOmnonvno 343 lo 3203 3111

.318113w Ion iud noil3ubrnq i3otolq 63203 3b613 zuilT .633n3up32r1o3 318113w ov1s3n 43kw 1 iinuoz

bluod2 z13i-n8d 3blnl 38113 133113 3113 01 InOmualfl 318113W "323(1 bno3" 8 od 03 mo ion aoob oioilT

.noiiEIuOl IsJn3mnolkvno 3111 id b33ubni 0a83-I3ni io noii3uboIq 3(11 03 noqaoi cli 1)328313111 3d

noii3ubolq n3ciw 11 viinuo3 iol rn3o noiI3ubolq luods 23111231 Ia13n3 3113 of noiiqo3xo 31ff

111 2328313111 1203 3113 3683 21113 iii .(1 31UiI) 63203 obsil dii1 is 2Isnoufsniilum d boisnimob 21

11 vu3nuo3 ni 1)338301 zrniil .11 vItnuo3 ni 3111113w bus flOuI3Ubolq 110 118 is 333110 011 ovsd 1 yu3n1Jo3

isdi 1In31sqqs :ii d hurl r1i 318 lodhi3n hud 1 1h1wO3 11132831311112033111 moil 3113n3d on 3V13331

.al3muzno3 1 11flhJo3 03 no b3228q (llLJ1 21 326313111 12o3

13qsq o43 oh noii3ubollni orIl ui bo3nsvbs noiiu2 3111 03 3ffidib313 on 3V1 4- 231uiI

32011318111 inidi I .aoasol3ni 320301 znoqaoi noil3ubolq l3glsI of bsol wod3mo2 21anoilflrnlIum isdi

3383013103 31dB ioilod 318 zlsnoiianiilum tsdt noiiiulni 3113411w nthow 318 noi1aou2 2143 rn3nsvbs

3361 2nnfl lsnoibsn 38113 ai rthLoohovo 3d 03 111336 z1ab1fIB 3231133811W .llBn0136m33rn noit3ubolq

236S313111 1203 33fl313X3 131fl101 3113 noclw 3311311 bns aloiii3qmo3 as arlnii 1611011511 riioio1

of lud jrnfl 341 nidliw Ion main8d33m 33118m oviiIioqmo3 out duoidi bsnolanwui ai noit3ubolq

328313111 1 ao3 b33ubni-noi181u31 s fuodiiw 10 rlhiw anism3l 3n3mu18 lInsi Ismiiqo 3111 321[J03 lO .1311183 belon I as

Page 17: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

aovnb-i3h8m viiit3qmo3 idi dw noai auoivdo on ai 31311T .(1if1L1o3 ioilio 3I11 fli &frlil IBnOIIBII

.2nnfl tnBlq-iJIum d noi1s3o1!ni mifl-iith naift iIaw 3d bluorI2 arrrifl Isnoitsn noms noitB3oIIB3l

ol znoqi noit3ubolq tadi w3iv lo inioq 3iiaoqqo 3di hoqquz 01 ia1 ni 1- 2311Ji1

i Ii n3dw ladi ( iu1) zlsnoilathiLum d b3ianimob al noii3ubolq n3dw 1311am2 is 232B313fli 3203

lo 331131210 orli 01 oi,b 3d ion if1im 21111 iov3woH .( 3iui1) annil Isnoilan d boianimob

21203 obsil 11311w muhdlliupo ni iaix3 zlsnoiisthihim ladi 1351 odl 01 iorf tin tud oa ioq alanoilanillum

moã fIOft3IJbOlq niis1uani ai tadi (oldaiiav uonooxo 3111) aiao obsil gni1h3bnu 3d1 zi II .dii1 oia

3thmsxo ol 13bIo a! zmifl lnalq-iilum lo 33n312ix3 (auonobn3) 3(11 nadi iodiai 328313th 12o3 odi

iol 211u251 ahoq3l I 1daT .annil Isnoiianiihim niaao1qqua fflB1o1q dt otoiwoi I iaodioqd auIi

io1 .zlanoiiathulum ninnsd moil i3sqmi iao is! orli 2318313 d3illw r lo OIJISV 3(11 S. = r 1203 obsil

llaiinoas,,ia aohinuO3 aou1av 13f1id iol baa tasiioqmi isdi ion 315 alanoilanitlum r 10 aoulsv lowo!

.noiiibqmo3 olflil oosl amifl tanoiisn tsrIt oa 1isius ni

1inuoo 111 1203 lanig tam ni 32531311 810 2133113 3111 2OVig I oldaT ni nmuIo3 iaiil 3dT

ouT .(I 31u1) m ,1m niod otnigoi muhdiliup3 3111 boi1ianoq alanoiisnuiLum dtiw ''. = Is I

iotla baa oiolod 1110(1 bonnsd eia alsrioiiathulum 113(1W a3fl8d3 3111 thOq5I I 3ldsT lo nmulo3 bnoooa

111 311152 3111 1i3sX3 318 2133113 318113W odT . a ni3d 31flig31 muhdiliupo 3(11 32S313flI 1203 orIt

.bonnsd 315 alanoiisniilum nodw iois1 ai 3aaoqaoi nOii3ubOiq 3(11 baa nmu1o3 Owl 3111

arIl 3imixsm 01 11320(13 ai i isdi 118331) 2133113 aoiiouboiq dtooma isdw3moz ob alsnoiisniiluM

3111 01 oub 1351 111 at (I 31ui1 aiiaiov £ oiuR) $33113 nii1tooma in3lsqqs odi 10 iaom lud (i33I13

I oldsT lo nmulo3 biith off .3mig31 lanolisnillum odi (111W b3tsi3oaaa oia isdi 21203 obsit did

131110 nI .328313rn 1203 odi iotls bonnsd 318 alanoiisniiliim 3111 didw 111 in3mn3qxo 115 ai3ubao3

01 bolaqmo3 21 (omigol alanoitanitlum oas313ni 1203 on) mlthdiliup3 b3tohiaolnu Isitini odi abiow

3nizzoibbs 21 inomhoqxo aidT .b3nnsd 318 alanoitanitlum baa boaa3loni ai 12033111113111w 1113110

21 iowans 3dT chow as b3nnsd 3d aurilI inslq-iilum bhjoda t)3a5313ni 318 21203 Ii :noiia3up orli

.133113 IsiolI3nod on asd aisnoitathulum ninnsd isdi iasol Ia to 3vitB33fl

Page 18: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

9U 1UU!9 2!1fl9j!OU 1ItJJ 110 C02j !UCLC uq WJ4E2 J'UILP' COPW1J C0Wb9LC2 ipc J9J1TG 0 A9USPIG2 BIJGL rIJC C02( IIJCLC92G Up 342 puucq O

92 1O W9JCG pc qCLCUCC pc1Mccu COJflWU2 I 9U 3 ! .LPI I 3 92 J9LC 92 b022!p1cA rpi i WC9U tp jpc A9JflC 0 . CJJO2CU (swou wc Lcboucq Hi JIflL 9U 3) ncp

x bi.oqncpou L -I?? -13 1W1x bLoqnqiou p -jj 18 0•Q

MCJt9LC L -WO 80fiCR9LC P 0? 00

C02 IUCLGØ2C WCLC92C

C0LC 9Uq UIJCL 9LJCL C02WJ4E2 puucq WJ4E puuq

bCLCCU19C CJJ9Uk2 (Lc9ruc o cw wcLc92c)

(L cpoeu o wnrnc fpc nnbcj o psuuui y)BIU 1Pq °t WCLG92Gq PA0!A9ICU1 0J Q J. =

LPIG 3

x bwqncuou -.V?x bLoqnciou p o'o WIMCII9LC -30 30ôMCJULC P 00 00 -if?

C02 !UCLC92C IUCLCU2C

___________ pqoLc 9CL 9IJCL C02viv jocq W34E P91111 Y&1E pVUIJCq2

bCLCCUI9k C91JG2 (LGJ9PAC 0 CL0 !UCLC92)

(L cpocu jo wxiwtc pc Iwb9cf o 9UUflJ y4J1.2) ,N9LJ1J9I °1 P1 COIIIULA L !UCL21 pA (?j ' =

iØPJG I

IQ

Page 19: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

°L E!fILQ J O 9LUAC 9 bCLCCUfdC WCLCU22 Ill tO C9JCflJ9tC EILc 8 HOJACL I P' IL5

I tJJCIJ fl2C jJJC LtIO CtMCCu tJJG2C flAO (J3Q) tO !IJU9tG tJJG bCLCCUt9C UCLGS22 011 tJJC AGLI!C9!

!UCLG oh iu iLpjc co nui wit to pc qnbciircq pA 911 !UCLC92C 111 b1nu xcq co Oh

u CCnJtC pc IIJCLC92C u bjut xcq co ucccnn) to qribcic ip succc !" JL9pJc CO2tW v'

L1Lc j pi iwbic2 9 AVJITC Oj L &QVICL tJJ9U OL 0 ij) JØJC LJJC L2flIPU tOt9J C02t !UCLCS2C

vuq 922nW1U 9 A9JITC O L 2flCJ LJ19t WIijt!IJøt!01J812 qowwstc 111 cdnll!punw (IIMIJJ LCLC11CC O

pt i pvc qouc we hOffM1J cowbntc we A9U9Ccoei C92C 1ACU 9 C02t !UCLC92G oJ

tAbc uLrjtw (2cuu p pA cxbor.z) WOLC tP9U i qoc Thc wJi.w (2cI.u p pA bLoqnctiou u p)

CCCt2 cowbcstc tpc cowbou hflLtPCL qo !"!t!1 LW V Avu•9pJc coat !UCLC !wb9ci2

cqncu ontbnt tfl2 co qo uor !uCLc w bLoboI4!ou to we co coi. QGUCL9j cdnqpunw

9CCOLqIJ to rue qecc °L tJ C02t !1JCLG92c LW2 Lc2bouq to jpc uci.ce w upc co pA

Jpc 2ccouq qgjcnjrA ' rpr rpc wnjtubjc IJCCC22SLA to cdcrnrc rpc riio i uor cou2t9ue Pf't A911C2

2 tJJG 29WC 1J flJG bLceut CS2C 92 tPC tOt9J C02t IJJbO2cq PA IJJC LcflJ9t!OU !wb9ct1u 011 A949pJc C02t

sccu cse oj pA wnIt!bAu nb tpc bcLCcut9k !IJCLC82C !11 xcq C0242 2Otpøt tPC tOt9j coat to we juu

xcq C02j2 bCIJØJ tIle hJLIJJ WJTCJJ JC22 tP9U tile 29WG bCLCCutdC !UCLC92C ID A949pC CO2W jJ112 2

cowbcq tO A949pC C02t2 u' rue C9IIPL9thOU °h tJJ WOCJ 20 tJJØt tJC 2ØWC bcLCCUt$C !IJCLGS2C ID

tO tC A9JJ1C2 O W9L1U9J C02t 111CLe92c2 ncq !U rule bLeiione ou bjiwt pccq co 9LC 2W9JJ

JJJCLC 9LC coucebtn9j q!gJcnht!e2 w bcjqu A9JfIGV O[ zcq CO1 iIJCLC922 1Pt 9LC cowbuipjc

ecouowA

eX9Wb1e °L9 xcq C02t iwbLoAcwcut tIJ9t IUI VCtfISflA IOlicL2 UJIII.UJVI co wwviwbLoAcq LuG!

bcLGq cwwbie w bLoqncrJou rccpuoJo'c put clectLou!c hue! !ur!ou u ntowopqc i 911

92 Lcdna1u exbcu2Mc cdnibwcut pn 92 110 cacct on W9L!U9I CO9t s pLq time rpujqu

J tJ312 2eCtiOU HC 92211WC tP9t IJJC CUJ9LOUWCUt9I LekJ9tioU wbc on bJ9ut xeq co ncp

E1111LO11WCUt9! JG&f1j9t!OU2 pibct OIl bJ9Ut L!X1 C0

U

Page 20: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

81

aB0I3 iiaso fIB 3181111381 oi 131)10 m -t aIuR ni as msa 3111 8- a31ui1 lo nil3ds1 3111

nwoda ai 1a03 bini odi baB O th as13th i203 311110 nolI3nIR s as 3I31 muhdllhIJp3 311T

1snoiis4 .1 ui1 bns migs1b thu nvi1d a3iihsllmia 3vifsiilsup w31 s is 31311T . 31ui1 ni

1311181 ai -r 10 a13v31 did 01 3lfn3bom is 3wtaiq 3111 iud r 3111 10 aoulsv wol is 3isnlmob znnfl

3111 (lo tn3tsviup3 i&x)-b3xfl 3111) nsdi 13is3i aasini iao3 bns i. lo abv3l dgicI IA .tn3l3Iuib

bnn m a3qi lo a13v31 3i8-I3bom iA .muhdiliup3 ni ovit arinfi d n bns d aqI lo alai 103 311U5I

.mundiliup3 ni 3V1138 318 aunfl d -inalq 13did 5rIT .3viliuini ziO ni 3asizni aslo i1ui s as in3 &mnfln-3qi isdi 1381 dT

audi bns 1 '(Iin1Jo3 th biso1 ainslq 1111w a3q1i mill ils 3sinsvbsaib I iinuo3 ni Z1a03 b3x11 3fl133qa

ni 3351q 31si 01 3unrino3 a3ob noii3ubmq mdi 1381 311T .arinfl n3qii iol 3sinsvbs ris 315313

auoviq 3111(11 b3iOn 3SW f1Uo1ffi fI1iB13qo 133113 mUflCJihuJp3-1513n3 3111 lo i1uai 3111 all inuo3

ainslq 3moa nhiiim13qw n3wol 3as313n1 iao3 311101 3ub I inuo3 111 ainslq moa lo 1x3 3111 :noiia

.3viviua 01

aiao3 3b811 did is amill d m-3qi bits aiao3 3b8ii 3iBlobom is rinfi m-3qi al ii isdi 1381 3dT

diOd r1uou1i niifn3qo 13311, muhdi1iup-1sin ,Iidua i,rlions d 01 aina I vlinuo3 flu ni3ubo1q

-unfl all 1o noiis3oI 3dm 11bom 3111 (11 lanoiisnittum s od of nio ai mill nil .a31s-i ,nw 'a3hinuo3

(ô) bits () moil isdi 31on) 3isi sw 13w01 3111 asd inuo3 113111w flO 1no abnqb Isiiqs3 3fl133qa

arfnfln-3qi1 31tnbom 318 aiao 31)811 ndW .w = dWIl 1rio 3vIiiaOq 3d diod nsm bits dm mdi

ns iol Ismiiqo ii nb1nm 1 Iinuo3 iii mdi vods 11 1inuo3 ni isi sw 3111 niais, insnimob 315

n-3qt 3i1sn3q aiao3 3blni did iv iuH .1snoilsthi1umm-qi s 3d 01 Isnoiisniilum s ai mdi mill

ii a,1sm aidT .11 Iinuo3 ni isi sw bits iodsl iol bnsmb 3111 bits aidmun 113111 ni3ub3i annfl

ioclsl muildiliup3 i1i -r did IA .11 1Jnuo3 in b3l3flsupbs3tl 3d 01 alsaoiisniilum tol Isrnflqo

01 ub bnsmb todsi b3z83i3rn 3111 diwiuo ion a,ob 11 yIinuo3 ni aiao3 3fli33q2-mull tol bbnsmb

.1 vIinhJo3 ni alao3 3fl133qz-inslq did

Page 21: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

120

I •0

I'0I

I •?

I 0F!?

rioFO.X?

I 0?

I•0?

I00

UJWtULW

uf!1uJJ

ir WF UJtULUJ

I#'WtUWJ

iP ULUUJTh

jLVIJthOI4 c0V V JLObOWOU OOfWQ P NC

01 •Q 03 09 0? 02 08 I0 1? 30 ? •0 ? tO ?0 Q0 • 80

C.)

4

I

IPflLG —jwbc 01.bJ'U Excqc0 011 qJC dmppuflw C1IJJC

Page 22: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

iio bifLe COOGI

cJC 0 bjout obcLof!ou (c onjbpnL 2cLnppc12) CLC9t!U 9 2!IflOt!OU tp9t jo OCtfI9JjA o pApuq 0 OJTLLCJCAOUCC 0 tJJJO UJOA pe J!W!rCq pj wouA c9oco tpc coot OL xcq cdnibwcut woA pe Lcjoteq to tpeto bjout coboctA 9ACL0C coot Lob coutiunonojA uuq jo ooAwbtoiic to woi.iuvj coer jpe ewbji.jcojcoot io iuqebcuqeur °L tP 2CSIC °L tile bjout OL bjoui cobocitA iuqccc 'U tpio Woqcj tJJCLC 12 110 I!UJ!t

oponjq cwbpoosc ipot tjJJO CXCLCJOC COUOJqCL? 911 IIJCLCORC pi 0 NbflLC. xcq cooç jpot jo we

WOLJCCt wccjiou ujo pA JJ0/tJIJ 9 2W9JJCL IJflWpcL OL bjouio bLoqncIu JOLgCL onjbn beL b1our

w rpc A9u9pJe coot csoe 111 we jxcq-coor Co2c w wqnonA o opje to e1JectucJA L9rJou9pc tptonp

tu rpe Jou9pJc coot cooe Ontbnt beL bjsut ju conutiA L o IJJCU PJilCL ju we xcq coot coee tpou

bjouto ju conutLA U ACt JI1 tPC JOttCL C92G rJJC towj ontbnt °L tPCOC LCL UU2 Jo P!PCL 111911

j) tPCLC JJ W"° UJ9!Ut9!1J!U bjougo iu conutLA U 111 L!flLC iJJCLC OLC jLW2 UJ9Wt9JUi1J

J9LCL ontbnro jpie JO MP9t pobbcuo JU tpjo woqc LOL cxvwbjc t tJJC JOMCL LJJJt-pa1Jq COLIJCL °L

J)G 9AoJqCq LOL rile uqneti.A 92 9 jJ0JC pA tJJC CXU 0 2OWC L!UJJ2 Mitil LCUI9!1J1U uum bLoqnc1u

111 tPC COOC °L° LCf1J9rJ0u iwboctiu 011 JJxcq C02t2 e,K,ncij COOt IUCLC9OCO C9u C2OCUr!OJIA

ewbpoojscq w tile rLoqe-Juqn2rLJ9I-oLvrn.otJou J!tCL9tflLe

ouq tIJCLC 12 tilC jon °L tile OflLbJflOOLbucc OACL IJJ9L11J9j COOt 011 tJJC loot ontbnt we ccicucX eacct

1292 MCJJ OIIJCC tile IOMCL oiitbnt etIfl LCdIULCO 9 JOLk iUbfIt °L JPOL (red LCOJ JOpOL bLoqncpJA LOII2Y

21UJUC91Jt coote cou PC oAoJqeq oujA pA bwqnciu 9 JOt JCfl ot oujA jo ontbnt occtcq pnr MCJJjOLC

JJJC JutflJtJou 12 oowetpju 111CC rIle Lo11oi!u i' we °L0 LCflJ9tjOU !wboctJu 011 AVLIOpJC coor2

bLoqncjJou ouq MCJLOLC eaecje ow wncp 0UJSJJCL ju tile xcq coot cooc tpou ju tpe A9Li9JC coot coec

pi cowbouu JfrILco -9 uuq MC 0CC politeAeL 0 dnouttoryejA qjci.cut eaecc uotp tile

bLoqncrJou pnt LOLCC couonwet.e to pnA rile cootiA qowcetJc ontbnt iuoresq °L cjicob L0Le!IJ iwboi.e

bLoqncrJou ow tpc coot JucLe9ee pnt tpeA qo uot iuonjote MCft9LC jioqe coojo bLofect qouJc2tc

E!11LC2 N0A1IJ LLOUJ E!nLC Q to Jf1LC MC 2CC tilC LCOflJt til9t tLqc W042 IU2flJ9tC

Xt ooiuet t}JC JCACJ OL tilC COOt JIJCLCS2C NC 2CC drIVH(9i!ACJA 2JUJJJSL LCOI1112 LOL rile tMO OCt2 0L

JflLC2 -8 bLeoCut rpc oowe &obpe oe E!rILco &obpju C9UC2 ouq

Page 23: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

HOUOU4I 9x12: conijp) b1iji xcq coe (2cc cxt)

EUC4 OJCLGSG2 !U C0mJ& W'U EP1 CO

g

L!flLc ,

It!ffLG Q

20000.eo.000

.10000

90.o00

80.o0o.J00.000

fl0000

150000

130000

110•000 _____bkC ECtWE (zo.i)

20000:eo.oooo.00o90000:80000

J00.000

.110•000

150•000•

J30000:

110000

bEC EOIWE (zo)

—.---x-tj-Q-Mj--M-

20000

90000

0.00o

90000

80000

0000O

I 10000

I 0•000

130000

40000 -

bEC KEGIWE (too3)

—ç--Mj---M-

Page 24: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

DO 2U

cowpwcq bo11cA o iunpu ipe cuiq1oumcuJ LCnJSiOU uuq rpcu pUUUHJ wnupoup W9C2

w x bLoqncou w conuA L u cornuLA jr OJnWU LGC oj jpjc cwbpwsc jp

cojnurn °L !uq!cc rp nbbLcnu (puuuu) WflJPuStiOUJ2 CUCLG2 oujA I!JuIA SLCL

pcp nbboI4 pc wnjuou pc cdfIfl!p4nw LcIuJc y cowbtuou o pc uq ccouq

LCUIIA pii fluJc io qo ip wnjpu9pouøp bcL 2G pn LØWCL up rpc cxircucc o pip fLSC co

!u2nJøcq WOLC LLOW rpc IUCLC92G lu xcq co MCU rpc LCJWC i qownrnrcq pA wnjmpoup

3 poiiz LG2ujf? dcwjswctA 2!WUL jo poc ot j jpc pø bLoqncpou i

33

Page 25: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

.anoiaul3noO bns vulmmue

-U no isd3b odi nhub b33nflvbi3 313W tsdi 2in3mu1B 11ri3v32 d b3isviiom ai l3qsq thIT

i3Ifino3 s zi 313r1i 11111 21W ain3mum a3d1 lo iatndi 1sin r1T .3b1ii oi1 o3ix3M-EbsnaD

3b1fl 3311 isdi 3bsm 21w noii23ua odi ll&i1i33q .iilsup Il3in3mnolivn3 bns 3bfni 3311 1133wi3d

21J 1i2o3 biovs 01 loblo ni o3ix3M oi noif3ubolq vom oi 2lsnoiisrnulum U 321J63 bluow

i3IJ2 03 21(1332 W3IV 21111' .3111113W bns adoj 81J ni aaol s niau& d313di 21o13no3 Isin3mnolivn3

moil 3111113w bnfl noii3ubolq 313&3mob 3i81112n1 iaum 213h18d 3bahi i2l11 .znoiiiaoqolq 318mq32 owl

bncx2 .21331b b3t13228 di asd II3vom3l 113111 Ii flOiiS1u31 lStn3fnnolivfl3 1t2O3 1 2333113 3111

lo 2333113 3113 gnis13gsx3 llBnoii&n3ini noii3ubo-Iq n1i1idz lo 31d8q83 lias 3111 alsnoiiBrnuIum

.zlsnoiisniilum 0(1 311 313(11 31311w noiiShJii2 11 01 3V131131 23i3110q

03 3Ub 2321313(11 3203 3(13 moil noii3ubolq 3isIu2ni b33bni ob zl3rrrnd 31)813 111th bnil 3W

31d1110v131 £ asd noii3ubolq nifl1uanI .318113w 3381112(11 ion ob 3di iud noiis1u31 Isin3mnollvn3

2811 o2111 ii iud i2o3 1Bni1Bm 13V0 33nq lo 2233X3 3111 03 3iJb I3bom afl1Ui31-fli28313fll 21113 111 133113

3111 2333113 323113 12no13s111m12 1110 nI .a33nq 13f1l11 f1UO1ff 3 213ffl112fl03 no 133113 3!dSlOVS1fIlJ nfl

1203 noii3ubolq i&fi 333113 3113 03 if13mUTh iaOd-bfl0332 0(1 21 313(11 aunT .gniibzIIo 1338x3 laomlfl

.al3rrIlld 3bwii d b3inflqmo8 3d bfuoda 2328313(11

nhi1Id2 38 tq3bB ni3d alsnoiisniilum 01 n nrBtl3q in3mu1s 3113101 rloqqua 0(1 W0f12 231112351

aninil 18(101311(1 inB1q-31rna 1no) b3nnsd 318 3di 31311w 32831 01 3v138131 118floiiBfl133fli fIOii3ubOlq

noii3ubolq Isnoiinn ni a3ansdD .3283 3d! 3d 03 21838 b32oqqo 3(13 i381 nI .(b3iiiml3q 318

(1311w (18113 alsnoiisniilum d b3isnnnob ai noii3ubrnq 11311w 1311131n2 11311m 318 3nsd3 3203 s niwollo1

isdi 3381 3111 03 3111) 131s1 zi aidi 38113 b3woda (13(13 3W i3v3woH .amiil Isnolilfi d b3iflrnmob zi ii

333113 nid3oom in3lsqqs 311310 iaoM .dinI 31181203 3bahi (13(1w mlthdiliup3 11132118 aIBnoliBnhihJm

1m bni d1 q3 113kw 2floiilJIoa 311108 rniuqmo331 d b3wods 3W 28 ai203 3b813 did ot 3ub 3381 ff1 21

3113 (II .1)3333(31 21 232fl0q231 noii3lrbolq 328313rn alsnotismilum 38113 in3mhJ1E 3di iua .baa31qqua

Page 26: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

N4(JJ JOC9J 1D b!IJ0AG12 1L0W JIG9qdflVL(C12 SC(J!4(G2

1 2OWGIIWC 9fl9CJIC (0 U9(OU9J oMUCIzpfr J( conjq 9JO G 0 2flp2(911(!91 !Wb01(911CG IJ U UJOGJ

o[ 0MI1CL2JJb) ULG U0( qLGC(JA 9GC(Gq jJJ!2 J92( LG2ITJ( UJUA JIG UJb0L(91J( W2O9L 9 GWO(!OUUJ AUJIIG

COflU(LA (0 COIIU(LA JJ GAGU (JJOf1JJ ULUJ-2bGC!LJC xcq C0Uf ((JIG J0C9(!0U OJ MJIJCJI 2 (JIG qGU(0U

!U cOnu(LA p JIUAG 911 uccuc ro 2JIfl bju u comuLA (B) J GUcL9 uim oIiuc12p1b 2JI1 p0w

qo O 9( Ufl) UM9A JL0W WI7I(!U9(!OUUI ULW (OMULq U9(!OUUJ jjiwr pi bUL(!CflJUV UUIJ pGUqcJnUL(cLcq

O (JIGIL bOJICA IUJbOL(UUCG (v) lu GUGL9r GUAILOUWGII(UJ CO2( UCLGUG2 2pTJ( (JIG LG1WG (Mpcu tJIGA

E1UUIIA (JIGLG ULG OWG GUGL9J LG2JTJ(2 UJIOfl( ULW (Thc2 Uuq 0MUGL2JJIb 9J(JI0flJ1 JUW UO( 2JILG

HI U0U (0 J9LGL bLoqncrlou GaCCW

W9L1U9J COZI2 CUIJUO( JIG UJIOLJIC CXCGb4 pA bWqflC(0U CCLG92C LG2flJP1J JU J3LGL MGflULG GGC(2

pA (JIG GXi( 0j OWC JLUJ UUq JI1JIGL Ofl(bfl(2 pA (JIG LGW9!U!U U1J gGkJU(I01J MJJCJI JwbUc( 017

IWbOL(UU( III (JIG WOqGJ j{Cf1J9pOU2 !AP!CP IUJbUC( 017 bJUu( XGq C0( ULC LGJU(IAGJA CU2UA 9poLpcq

4CX( MC U0(C (JI9( (JIG J0LUJ °L Lcrq9(0u-uqncCq C09( !UCLGU2CU M92 dnUu(I(UjIACJA AGLA

(JI9IJ qoc (JIG !1J(GLIJUJ C02( UJJIJ!W9I1OU WGCJIU1JW ! (JIG bLccucG O WflJ(JIJU(!OUUW

UJI2GUCG 0 WI1J(W9(IO1J9J2 (JIG COWbC(I(IAC WULJCC( WGCp91JIUJ JC9q2 (0 JIKJUJA JEILCL bLoqrIc(ou 2pjp

Page 27: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

93ngI,b.g

(3xi 3di m b3aauib ion *iow biBIi mo 01 no13131 a3buI3ni)

:iothA nnA .uzaI binT bhoW 10 nin1O dT Q'QI) iiurbI3BIfl blBd3iSI bns ml()1 nornbnA •221q flBI1f3IM lo ii13vinU

3iIdu1 10 Ianiuot "3bgiT IsnoiiBtn3inl bris 3iIodI IBifl3mflOlIVn3 3IiB1i2" QQt) 11032 ii5nnfl .nimo3diIo1 .z3imono33

iiziviU Isin3mnolivn3 oU :in3mnoiivn3 3di bas nsasvinh2 .M.T bas fkibst iiswscIfl .iqsq nthow 3bsiT iI iol sD 3d1 moil i3s1i3U

lIo-3bBIT s diiw bsiT bas noiisioqrn0 IsnoiisniiluM lo o3ñT 3!qmi2 A" (QQI) bsJ 2 bmthsi .l3qsq rthhow $I3flit bns TIM "noiiaiinnoD baa iimixoiq fl33Wid

3vini3qmoO li1iqmI ni noiiijlloq IoiinoC) 01 thisbnsi2 WZ13V r (IQQ1) .51 narifi bnsbqoD bii2 añmono Isin3mno1ivn baa onuoa51 naibansD odi is b3iaiq oomim :i!isM

.IQQI 13dm3iq32 (ohainO dqI3uO niiM IsunnA quoiO

baa Isnoiiacn3inI :noiis3oJ iiaubnI baa znoiishi51 Isin3mno1ivnI" (1QQ1) 1hA nozniv3J .iqsq nthow n3biv3 3iia3moU

lo iodT di oim 3ahql3in3 lsnoiisniiluM zIi nhia1oq1o3nI" QQ1) .51 amst fl32u11SM .Q81-Qô1 I? ovii3qg 3u00no33 lo Isirwot "bsiT 1snoiisminI

nedW iIoq Ia1n3mnoiivn3" Q1) i3liw310 nsT4 baa .51 biswb3 oioM $1 zmaI. fl3aIDIlSM &Mmono33 Iainmnoiivna 10 lairwot "auonobn3 ois noiisaoJ insI baa 5w131n12 ihaM

1n3manaM baa

!snotM ni noiiii3qmoD" (QQ1) 13liw310 naM baa .51 biawba ioM .2 23m5t ,n3zu)hsM monoa 3iIduq lo !&nuot "auon3obn3 ia znoiitrnl maN n3dw j3ji0q Iain3mnolivn3

xv- 1ô;

133 ijU 10 3nai1oqmI b3asi3nI 3dT" (sQ1) Idan3V .t nodinA baa .51 zmst n3au]hsM ni izdioqyH n313vnoD A :qidnthsI3S1 3mono33 3iinsliA dtioi4 ni in3mivrII

3iinaIisafIalT wM 3fIT froiibe) iIIhO ohofliV baa i3idi3 bñ!iW 1wdiisM h3aoasD .nimo3di1o1 a1d1 iizieviaU 3bndmaD :nobnol .ymono33

3bBlT w*1 3di ban nnii IanoiianflluM" ,(dQQt) aIdan3V .t nodmnA baa .51 amat n3auhsM idmun iqa nbhoW d3m51 3imono33 lo uswfl Ianoiia4 Io3dT

(1oiib3) h3d3i2 iioH m "in3mno1ivna di baa 3bslT nbior (IQQ!) I3sd3iM i3ibua2 .idoM .fl.D.t :ngniduT .noiaamiU Isnoiiarn3inJ ff :viizns32 Iain,mnrnivn3

"z3i1iaubnI niiulloq lo noiia3oj 3di baa noiia1uR Iainrnnonvn3" QQ1) bad3IM 13fI3aiJBM

.l3qaq nbhow

Page 28: DMDI$1OW aLs1 - National Bureau of Economic Research · 2HflM DMDI$1OW sL1qAq aLs1 YJTOD 'ionujjoq ThaMaTAHA UT4A mAJq MOITADOJ OI2IDU n& .51 nuh,M nbhoW OQ4 JA4OITAM UAHSIUH 10 DIMOMOD

bLoqncR uq tc cun2: 1om.uJ o pcwouvj Ecouolnicr mAcu9p1c& y i (j)) JL9qc vuq bo11c !I4i wbccc cowbcj!ou! pc cc a

CØLLLO (cqaL) jL9qc auq IJJC EU,4toUUJCU KJflMGLjbp VI92L (1oo4Y EU19IUWCUW1 haflCA bI'U rOC9LOU rnq OOACUJWCIU JLotccpau. u C

JOLJUIJ }9bCLrcsIcc Cowbc1!1!Acucv uq gpc Jwbpc9iiou2 LOL },OflCA D!U flUTGI2!1A at ojaqo

JflpcqOLq JOW2 E (io) CP0U 10qqG EIJJ!OU jçcucqou iu pc oioirnj EcouowA:

2t1P2A21C11J

jnpcqpq JpawiJ (j) qbbcq oqcpuK 4W NJ2\OE