Upload
ankur-rai
View
225
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
1/63
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
2/63
discrimination and overty to a "reat e7tent. @or sustainable develoment of the nation, all $ndians must oose and "ht
a"ainst any kind of discrimination
Issue
Bitter criticism of the caste system – aste system is vehemently critici8ed in modern world without understandin" and
analy8in" what caste as a system is. Aow, when and why, the system "ot derailed and how to brin" it back on rails.
#ecently #ikke Nohrlind, co!ordinator of the $nternational Dalit +olidarity Network said, - aste discrimination is a "lobal
issue, aectin" hundreds of millions of eole in many arts of the country- Therefore, an amendment in ?uality &ct 3414
has been made to outlaw aste in *= to "ive le"al rotection to 21C,C Aindus based in the *=. Till now, the &ct rohibited
race discrimination, harassment and victimi8ation in the work!lace. ) unrivile"ed sections of societyJ
• Ghat is the osition of dierent castes as it e7ists resently in "round realitiesJ
• Ghy the system is olitici8edJ
• Ghat is the dierence between caste as a system and casteismJ
Discrimination elsewhere in the world
Discrimination to some e7tent e7ists everywhere in one form or other – be it a social, olitical and economic system or
institution, be it a bi" or small institution as small as that of a family.
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
3/63
arents, oor relatives or unemloyed youth become an easy rey of discrimination. &nd in a society, oor, illiterate and
i"norant eole uite often become victims of e7loitation. @ear of bein" discriminated or e7loited srin"s from i"norance.
?uality of all e7ists in theory , but no ower on earth can ever turn it into a reality.
Intolerance reason behind discrimination
*sually, in every society, dierences in behavior, character, education, lan"ua"e, way of life, culture, social back"round
create a distance between two individuals or "rous. #esistance to tolerate, adat or areciate each other widens the
distance. +ome become so a""ressive that they oenly abuse or oress others. $n order to be one u, either they let down
others or try to control their destiny by adotin" discriminatory ractices. &nd in this rat!race, stron"er always wins and
weaker suers.
Grounds for discrimination
$n every society and a nation there e7ists numerous identities based on factors like race, class, caste, reli"ion, "ender,
lan"ua"e or re"ion. ravin" for more ower – muscle, money or olitical – of some individuals or "rous tends eole to
adot discriminatory ractices. Discriminatory ractices work on whims and fancies>likes and dislikes of stron" ersons.
ontrollin" the destiny of others satises their e"o and serves their interests.
Racism and Western World
#acism is a much more serious roblem than caste in matter of discrimination, as it is based on the color of the skin, which
can not be hidden. +ocieties in Gestern Gorld are divided sharly into four water!ti"ht comartments. )Ghites- at the to of
social hierarchy, then comes Kellows 0aanese, hinese or 'hiliines6 followed by )Browns- $ndians, 'akistanis and eole
from other +outh!?astern nations and at the bottom )Blacks-. The western world is witnessin" a rise in white suremacist
movements. East two cate"ories have always been humiliated. They have to stru""le to "et suitable jobs accordin" to their
ualications. They are forced to work for less money, accused for snatchin" jobs from )whites- and havin" slavish mentality.
Treatment to Indian students in western nations
?very year, on an avera"e H4,444 odd $ndian students "o to Gestern nations for further studies. #ecently in &ustralia,
$ndians, 'akistanis alon" with
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
4/63
Caste system and British rulers
$n the ast, British rulers in $ndia, while layin" foundation of democratic institutions of $ndia, started many discriminatory
ractices. $n order to kee balance of ower and counter Brahmins hold on $ndian society assed some discriminatory &cts
like &ct of 1M1M %into %orely #eforms6or ommunal &ward of 1M3.Till 1MH, they ket their railway comartments, waitin"
rooms, arks, clubs, hotels, laces of other entertainment and residences se"re"ated.
Two asects of caste system have ama8ed the British rulers in the ast –
• inIuence of aste system on $ndian societyO
• #eluctance of its eole to convert into other reli"ions, on the "round that all reli"ions are valid.
Dalit Activists and caste system
Dalit Activists critici8e caste system vehemently and hold it resonsible for keein" 54 million Aindus – dalits, tribals and
other backward classes – oor, )subju"ated, discriminated a"ainst and humiliated.- )Technolo"ies for human survival F. were
all develoed by lower castes-, but )uer castes took away the fruits of their labour and invention.- )$n the hearts of the
oressed castes, there is an"er and hatred.- 9+ocial!justice: demands their emanciation by endin" all kind of
discrimination.
There are two otionsP )either comlete euality to Dalit Bahujan communities or their conversion into other reli"ions.- +uch
comments of Dalit &ctivists and olitical leaders arouse emotional sentiments of oor masses, "enerate venom in their heart
and create a feelin" of 9otherness:.
&ccordin" to 'r. =ancha $laiah, an activist, comlete euality means –
• ?mbracin" all lower castes,
• ?atin" with them,
• Treatin" them as their eual, and
• &n end to the alle"ation that they are merit!decient.
$nsite of all such comments, it is the lower se"ment of society, which is stickin" stron"ly to its caste!identities.
India and ‘Caste’ as a ‘System’
aste is a very old and indi"enous system, concetuali8ed, develoed and racticed e7clusively in $ndia. $t is diLcult for the
western world to understand its role – ast or resent – in $ndian society or because of its comlete locali8ation and
unfamiliarity to see it in its totality.
Strong features of ‘caste-system
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
5/63
The stren"th of caste system has been roved by the followin" factsP
• Desite centuries of forei"n rule over 5Q of $ndian oulation remains Aindu and have stron" feelin"s for caste!system.
• Aad caste system become obsolete, it would have "iven lace to other system.
• aste system has inIuenced all other communities livin" in $ndia.
@ollowin" are the stron" features of 9caste: as a system –
• Assimilation of di!erent social grou"s without conversion– $n the ast, caste assimilated numerous social "rous –immi"rants, locals, tribal, rofessionals or others into its mainstream without any conversion. $t assi"ned each incomin"new "rou a searate caste identity and made them its inte"ral art in due course of time.
• This way, neither it disturbed its e7istin" internal social order nor revented new "rous to join the mainstream. $t did notannihilate their faith, way of l ivin", internal order, customs, culture or lan"ua"e. $nstead, it "ave them freedom to roseraccordin" to their internal rhythm.
• #aste regarded as a natural institution by $indus – $ndian society re"ards family, e7tended family, =ula, aste and reli"ionas fundamental social institutions. &n individual is a natural member of a family, which is a unit of an e7tended family,
e7tended family of =ula, =ula of a tribe
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
6/63
determines social status. Gealth is also acuired throu"h birth. There also e7ists a shar distinction between the&ristocratic>elite society and common man.
ritics claim that for centuries in the ast and even at resent, eole born in lower castes have been suressed or
oressed by eole belon"in" to uer castes. *er castes are accountable and unishable for the miseries of lower caste.
They should make rearations for the sins>historical wron" done by their ancestors.
Aow far this alle"ation and its remedy is correctJ 0ustice 9+ocial, economic and olitical: never allows unishin" somebody
else for the crimes committed by others.
• )o access to education – $t is alle"ed that uer castes has ket its monooly on education to reinforce its traditionaldominance and revented lower castes from "ettin" educated. Ghen British rulers allowed le"ally admission to allirresective of caste or creed in "overnment schools, hi"her castes oosed admission of the children belon"in" to lowerstrata.
$t is only a half truth. British rulers did not bother much about mass education. $t was not so much because of discrimination,
that backward castes were debarred or denied access to education, as for –
%odern education system was very costly and therefore, unaordable by masses. The costly nature of education tended to
make it a monooly of the richer classes and city dwellers.
• The medium of instruction was a forei"n lan"ua"e – ?n"lish.
• Eower!castes did see any immediate use of education. $t was more imortant for them to work and arran"e two suaremeals day rather than sendin" on education.
Aowever, an imoverished "rou caste Aindus in search of livelihood looked uon modern education as means to earn their
livin" resectfully and devoted their scarce resources on it.
The relentless eort of missionaries and the reformers could educate a very small number of eole from lower!castes.
• Ran*ing
$n the ast, rankin" of dierent social "rous was done on some rinciles. +elf!disciline, hy"iene, cleanliness, morality,
knowled"e, sirituality of dierent social "rous i.e. castes and usefulness of their work to the society as a whole were the
considerations, which determined the social, economic or olitical status of a "rou in society vise!a vise others. Ai"her a
caste, urer it was considered, and "reater were the self!restrictions on its behavior throu"h rituals.
• +obility
%obility of individuals from one caste to another was restricted in the ast. But uward mobility of a "rou in the social scale
was thou"h diLcult, but not imossible. &ncient $ndia had allowed uward mobility of a caste throu"h "ood deeds – by
adotin" more orthodo7 ractices, cleaner habits, self!disciline and observance of rituals or the osition of a caste could be
imroved. This way, lower!castes were encoura"ed to follow disciline in life.
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
7/63
Now dierent castes refer to be called backwards. They are racin" to "et a ta" of backward castes, so that they can avail
the benets of uota 7ed for backward castes in jobs an.
• Wealth – Doors for honor or wealth were always oen to deservin" individuals>"rous of any caste. Aistory is the roof that even the lowest rank attained even soverei"nty in $ndia such as %aratha =in"s, who fou"ht their way u!to the thronea"ainst %ohammedan and commanded resect of all $ndians. @rom fourteenth to the ei"hteenth century, soldiers came
from all strata of society includin" the lowest in the ritual term. There was no discrimination in the recruitment andtreatment of soldiers on caste basis. #ajut status was "iven to soldiers.
• ,ccu"ation
ritics of aste system alle"e that there was no freedom>choice to individuals in matter of occuation in the ast. They were
forced eole to emloy themselves in hereditary occuations. This alle"ation is not wholly truth.
$n ancient ?uroe and &sia also, occuations were not only hereditary, but also limited it to be followed by secic classes
only. $t was considered natural and convenient for a erson to do a job, which he knew, the knowled"e of which, he acuired
in a natural way.
• #hanges brought in by Industrial revolution
$t was the industrial revolution, which had chan"ed the trend. Now total aversion of modern youth from their traditional
occuation has rendered millions unemloyed or underemloyed or confused about what they want to do. They waste their
time, ener"y and eorts in search of white collared jobs rather than ursuin" jobs, which suits to their knowled"e, atitude
and ualications. There is more job!satisfaction, hainess, success or contentment in doin" a job, one knows well rather
than in stein" on someone else:s toes.
+ir 0ohn +hore, who was ;overnor ;eneral of $ndia durin" 1M!1M2, observed that there was considerable latitude in matter
of work in $ndia. &mon" many castes, it was constantly found that one brother ursuin" hereditary vocation and another
enterin" army. AT olebrooke also conrms it, )$t may be received as a "eneral ma7im that occuation aointed for each
tribe is entitled merely to a reference. ?very rofession, with few e7cetions, was oen to every descrition of ersons and
the discoura"ement arisin" from reli"ious rejudices is not "reater than what e7ists in ;reat Britain from the eects of
%unicial and ororate laws.-
• Alternative ideologies to "rovide breathing s"ace
$n the ast, whenever ri"idities and discriminatory ractices of society in the name of caste system suocated $ndian society,
there arose alternative ideolo"ies or styles of life, which "ave eole breathin" sace. #ise of Buddhism in &ncient $ndia, +u
tradition of $slam and Bhakti movement of Aindus in medieval $ndia around 14th century6, and reform movements of 1Mth
and 34th centuries tau"ht symathetic attitude towards lesser human bein"s, brotherly love for each other and fellowshi,
love and resect all human bein"s irresective of caste or creed and rejected ractice of elaborate rituals and caste
retensions.
Modern India
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
8/63
%ost of the alle"ations a"ainst caste system, which were there in the ast, can not be justied now in modern $ndia. 'rocess
of moderni8ation, industriali8ation, sread of education and "rowin" awareness amon" masses have already brou"ht to an
end slowly but steadily many of the discriminatory ractices of aste system. $t has become more liberal and less restrictive
in all walks of life. astes no lon"er enjoy le"al or reli"ious sanctions. ?7ulsion from castes means little, while earlier it
meant comlete social ostracism. (ld style of authority and ower e7ercised by caste!elders has already diminished.
#estrictions or interactions between dierent castes arisin" due to considerations for urity and ollution are fadin" away
from ublic life even from rural areas. Traditional barriers on marria"e, hereditary occuations and commonality are loosin"
its imortance.
#onstitution of India
'reamble of the $ndian onstitution romisesto secure to all its citi8ensP 0*+T$?, social, economic and oliticalO E$B?#TK of
thou"ht, e7ression, belief, faith and worshiO ?/*&E$TK of status and of oortunityO and to romote amon" them all
@#&T?#N$TK assurin" the di"nity of the individual and the unity and inte"rity of the Nation. &rticle 15 of the onstitution
rohibits any kind of discrimination on "rounds of caste, race, reli"ion, "ender or lace of birthO &rticle 1C "ives euality of
oortunity in matter of ublic emloyment, &rticle 2 creates National commission for +cheduled astes to safe"uard their
interests etc.
egislations for e&ual o""ortunities
& number of amendments in the onstitution and le"islation have been assed to remove the disabilities of backward eole.
*n!touchability has been declared a crime. Bonded labor is abolished by law. ivil #i"hts &ct, 1M55, aims to eliminate
injustice a"ainst weaker sections. &mendment to 'revention of &trocities &ct +T6 1M2M rovides for stern unishments for
oenses committed a"ainst +T by *er astes. +ecial ourts, under +T &ct, have been established for unishin"
oLcials, if found "uilty. +till, there is no resite from discriminatory ractices. GhyJ
Reasons for the miseries of downtrodden
There are many reasons, why eole do not "et resite from discriminatory ractices. There is no denial of the fact that with
the assa"e of time, and for a lon" time, livin" under alien rule, caste system had develoed many deformities. The system
became too ri"id to kee its identity continuin". +till it is not so much because of the caste!system, but because of bad
olitics and oor "overnance, that millions of eole have still to suer discrimination and e7loitation in modern $ndia. +ome
of the causes are as followin" –
• %mergence of .olitical Identities
Durin" their imerial rule, the British had divided the $ndian society into ve major "rous, "ivin" each one an indeendent
olitical identity based on the olitical ower and the amount of wealth, they hold. The water!ti"ht comartmentali8ation of
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
9/63
$ndian society had been done by ensuses durin" British rule into %inorities, +cheduled astes, now oularly known as
Dalits or +s, +cheduled Tribes +Ts6, (ther Backward castes (Bs6 and Ai"her astes.
• .olitical com"artmentali/ation of Indian society
%odern $ndian society has been olari8ed on caste and communal basis into followin" unbrid"eable sections – *er castes,
+cheduled astes, +cheduled tribes, (ther Backward lass and %inorities. +tratication of $ndian society has been done in
most insensitive manner for the urose of balancin" the ower. $t has become a bye!word for $ndian oliticians.
• .oor e0ecution of rules and regulations
$ndian society is sharly divided into two broad divisions! )haves- and )have!nots-. The most imortant factors resonsible
for disarities are resent!day!olitics, irrational and corrut ways of ursuin" the aternal olicies of the "overnment at
cetral and +tate levels and "overnment:s failure to address real issues.
• 1se of ‘#aste as the most "owerful tool to create vote-ban*s
9aste: has become for the resent!day olitical leaders as the easiest and most owerful tool to sway ublic emotionally
and to create a lar"er vote bank. $t may be called ossication of caste!system fallen into the hands of ower brokers and vote
"u88lers.
• .riority to abstract issues in order to divert "ublic attention
Day in and day out, ublic attention is bein" diverted from real issues and ublic sentiments are aroused by Ioatin" in
olitical world abstract issues like discrimination, social justice, aLrmative action>reservations, secularism. +ectional interests
are bein" romoted on caste basis. #eal issues like mass!scale illiteracy, overty, unemloyment, inIation, deteriorated law
and order situation, increasin" violence or "eneral coarsenin" of moral ber of the $ndian society are ushed into the
back"round.
• #entrali/ation of control systems
There is comlete centrali8ation of control systems in the hands of a few individuals, families and "rous irresective of
castes or creed. They have enou"h money, muscle and olitical ower lus and the suort of criminals. They are Iourishin"
day by day and control almost all the national resources. They enjoy life at cost of ta7!ayers. This very small section of
society virtually controls the destiny of millions. They have a say in almost every walk of national life.
• orrution
orrution has become a major>erennial imediment to imlement various develomental schemes. $"norance and
essimist attitude of masses makes corrut ersons bold. (nce the ublic raises its voice a"ainst arbitrary behavior>actions
of owerful lobby, all discrimination and malractices would "et automatically controlled.
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
10/63
• Aversion form human' moral or traditional values
&version of eole from human, moral or traditional values has a""ravated the roblem. The total concentration of educated
eole is on ursuit of money and materialistic leasures by hook or crook. @avoritism, in!disciline, violence, corrution, and
chase of materialism based on ruthless cometition have "iven shar rise to disarities and discrimination. $t leads to cut!
throat cometition and creates rift amon"st dierent "rous. 'olitical e7ediency and oortunism has made sectional forces
more assertive>a""ressive in attitude and vocal about their ri"hts but i"nores duties.
• Reconcile the claims of growth with the claims of e&uity
$t is one of the bi" challen"es for the "overnment to reconcile the claims of "rowth with the claims of euity. omassion,
sensitivity, euality or fraternity can not be imosed or enforced by any outside a"ency or authority. +uch a ste may rove
to be a cause of social unrest. $t has to be in!built in the social economic and olitical system of a country throu"h education
and awareness – education, which is the source of knowled"e and owerO and awareness, which comes from availability of
information.
• )arrow loyalties of caste and religion
Narrow loyalties of caste and reli"ion are encoura"ed "eneratin" sub!cultures like caste!ism, favoritism, and lure for easy
money, neotism, arochialism, communalism, re"ionalism, bi"oted sentiments and irresonsible comments, sreadin" in!
disciline in the society. The risin" asirations and demands of eole, with the sread of education and awareness, has
created added roblem for the "overnment.
• Discriminatory measures ta*en by the Government
$n $ndeendent $ndia, ;overnments at centre and the rovinces are continuously thrustin" uon the ublic many
discriminatory>lofty>oulist rules, re"ulations and olicies in the name of helin" )oor masses-. ommon men esecially
belon"in" to uer castes feel threatened, helless and suer from discriminatory olicies of the "overnment. 'rotective
olicies and laws can neither convert an iniuitous +ociety into an euitable one, nor does it hel in any way the vulnerable,
oressed and submer"ed masses.
%ost of measures taken by the ;overnmental authorities touch the roblems suercially at its erihery only. %ost of the
solutions ursued by the "overnment are totally unrelated to day to day roblems of common man in real life. $nstead of
benetin" or helin" the oor, on one hand such develomental ro"rams increase corrution, and on the other it
encoura"es lethar"y, a"itation and attitude to deend on authorities for each and everythin".
‘Reservation "olicy as means to end discrimination
+uccessive "overnments both at the centre and rovinces are tryin" to tackle roblem of discrimination and disarity by
oenly favourin" olicies of 9reverse discrimination:, which "ive more imortance to distribute ower on ro!rata basis by
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
11/63
7in" uota. The sustainable develoment of submer"ed sections can be achieved by rovidin" uality of education to
everybody and makin" eole aware of dierent oortunities available to them.
#eservation olicy can hardly be able to brin" in desired transformation in the society. $n a democratic country, discrimination
anywhere or in any form – be it ositive or ne"ative – is the most objectionable thin". The roblem of discrimination or
disarities can not be tackled by 7in" u uotas or by adotin" the ath of reverse discrimination or treatin" a few sections
of society more than euals by entitlin" them for referential treatment by the "overnmental a"encies in dierent sheres of
life.
'olitical leaders of various olitical arties desire to 7 u uotas in all "overnmental institutions for dierent sections of
society on ro!rata basis. +uch a demand is based on ne"ative e7hortations. The "overnment:s olicy of #eservation in jobs
and education has resulted in a tou"h cometition amon"st various castes to demand a lower status, so that they can also
avail more concessions and facilities.
*nder!currents of caste olitics have made the "overnment incaable to solve the burnin" national issues. $t has made to
maintain law and order diLcult. $nter!caste and intra!caste, inter!community and intra!community and inter!tribal and intra!
tribal conIicts are increasin" day by day in order to "et more sace in the corridors of ower.
+eaning of ‘)o Discrimination
9No discrimination: does not mean sharin" ower eually. %ore than thousand million eole can not be accommodated in
ower echelons. $t means a harmonious artnershi between eole belon"in" to dierent sections of society and the
authorities resonsible for "overnance. ;overnance should be done on the basis of mutual hel, mutual resect and mutual
trust. ;overnance is a continuin" rocess, throu"h which conIictin" interests and diverse needs of all the eole are looked!
after and a cooerative action is taken.
.athetic condition of u""er castes belonging to middle class
%iddle class has always been the backbone of society. Now the voice of uri"ht and honest eole belon"in" to middle
class is bein" continuously throttled mercilessly. They are bein" unished for followin" sincerely family!lannin" norms,
which has decreased their numbers. $n resent day vote!bank olitics based on "ame of numbers, it is very easy now for the
ursuers of olitical ower to sideline them.
ower castes more tenacious about their caste-identity
Today lower castes, which are more tenacious about their caste than the hi"her, could be easily swayed emotionally in the
name of caste!based reservations. #eservations 'olicy has "iven the 9backwards: an identity as a comosite and owerful
olitical ressure "rou. They have "roued to"ether and increased their numerical stren"th. $t has heled them to emer"e
as a owerful and assertive ressure "rou and unite, or"ani8e and "ht vi"orously for the seats of ower.
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
12/63
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
13/63
ublic with a sense of justice, commitment to the nation, understandin" for each other and consciousness about duties alon"
with ri"hts.
Winding u"
@ollowin" stes could to be taken to brin" to an end discrimination of any kind –
• @irst of all, "overnment should nd out root causes of discrimination and derivation,
• ;overnment should identify without bias vulnerable "rous, which are discriminated a"ainst by the resent modernsociety. $t should not be on the basis of caste.
• $dentify the secial needs or roblems of each "rou searately,
• &ccordin"ly lan about the measures to be taken to rotect the interests of vulnerable individuals.
• Gell meanin" judicious laws, which could directly imrove day today life of common men, should be carefully le"islated.
• +uch laws should not remain only on aers but have to be e7ecuted>imlemented in real life for dealin" with socialinjustice eectively.
• To "ive relief to 9Aave!nots:, the way out is to tackle eectively local crimes a"ainst common man whether in rural orurban areas and imrove law and order osition.
• The money meant for the develoment uroses should actually be sent for which it is intended i.e. the betterment of submer"ed sections of society.
• 'ower "enerally rests with hysical stren"th, wealth and knowled"e. =nowled"e brin"s in both hysical stren"th andwealth. Therefore, stress on knowled"e throu"h 9education for all: should be the to riority for the "overnment foremowerment of weaker sections, which are victims of discrimination.
• Gidesread human ri"hts violations should be stoed by unishin" the culrits.
• $t is necessary to ut honest and ri"ht ersons at crucial ositions. There are very few eole, who have theknowled"e>understandin" what to do, how to do and when to doO
& stron" olitical will and coura"e is needed to brin" to an end caste!ism and with it all kinds of discriminatory attitudes,
reressive laws and ractices. @or the roserity of the nation and tension!free>stress!free life of common man, as su""ested
by @irst Backward class ommission:s hairman =aka =alelkar in mid fties, )National solidarity in a democratic set u
demands ;overnment to reco"ni8e only two ends – the individual at one end and the nation as a whole at the other. Nothin"
should be encoura"ed to or"ani8e itself in between these two ends to the detriment of the freedom of the individual and
solidarity of the nation. &ll communal and denominational or"ani8ations and "rouin"s of lesser and narrower units have to
be watched carefully, so that they do not jeoardi8e the national solidarity and do not weaken the eorts of the nation to
serve the various elements in the body olitic with euity. %utual hel, mutual resect and mutual trust are the touchstone,
on which all communal and denominational activities will be tested.-
April 14, 201 'osted by latasinha S !eneral, "ocial an# political $alues an# systems S Equality % All S &ea$e a comment
(ri"in, Gesterni8ation, +anskriti8ation and %oderni8ation of aste +ystem
https://latasinha.wordpress.com/2016/04/14/https://latasinha.wordpress.com/2016/04/14/https://latasinha.wordpress.com/author/latasinha/https://latasinha.wordpress.com/author/latasinha/https://latasinha.wordpress.com/author/latasinha/https://latasinha.wordpress.com/category/general/https://latasinha.wordpress.com/category/general/https://latasinha.wordpress.com/category/social-and-political-values-and-systems/https://latasinha.wordpress.com/category/social-and-political-values-and-systems/https://latasinha.wordpress.com/tag/equality-fi-all/https://latasinha.wordpress.com/tag/equality-fi-all/https://latasinha.wordpress.com/2016/04/14/discrimination-and-caste-system/#respondhttps://latasinha.wordpress.com/2016/04/14/discrimination-and-caste-system/#respondhttps://latasinha.wordpress.com/2016/04/08/origin-westernization-sanskritization-and-modernization-of-caste-system-3/https://latasinha.wordpress.com/2016/04/14/https://latasinha.wordpress.com/author/latasinha/https://latasinha.wordpress.com/category/general/https://latasinha.wordpress.com/category/social-and-political-values-and-systems/https://latasinha.wordpress.com/tag/equality-fi-all/https://latasinha.wordpress.com/2016/04/14/discrimination-and-caste-system/#respondhttps://latasinha.wordpress.com/2016/04/08/origin-westernization-sanskritization-and-modernization-of-caste-system-3/
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
14/63
)$f there is honesty in $ndia today, any hositality, any charity! any aversion to evil, any love to be "ood, it is due to whatever
remains of the old faith and the old culture-. . #aj"oalachari
)aste was the system of social life, in which Ainduism was e7ressed. FF Ainduism was the ideolo"ical and emotional
buttress of casteF. aste and Ainduism succeeded in doin" in $ndia, what no state, no conueror and no economy was able
to do – the establishment of a sin"le unied system of society throu"hout the whole of $ndia accommodatin" numerous semi!
autonomous communities arisin" at many times and in many laces6, a system of society, which was able to comrise a
"reater ran"e of local dierences in a sin"le system than any society has reviously accomlished.- Throu"h caste system,
$ndia has simultaneously accommodated )it to an almost endlessly varied system of semi!autonomous community and at the
same time, it brin"s considerable unity, harmony and condition of eace.- $t )succeeded in wieldin" an enormously varied
lurality of semi!autonomous communities arisin" at many times and in many laces and adotin" themselves to many
dierent conditions into a sin"le system of societyF- Don %artindale, $ndia since 1MH, M6
$n modern understandin" of caste!system, element of 9system: is less and 9caste: is dominant.:
Introduction
Conceptualied! ori"inated and practiced e#clusively in India – $ndia resents one of the oldest, continuous and
uninterruted livin" civili8ations in the whole world known as Ainduism. (ther well advanced civili8ations of ancient world
were of ?"yt, ;reece and %esootamia6. (ne of the rominent features of $ndian civili8ation is its 9aste!system:. aste
system is a uniue way of stratifyin" the society. $t has been concetuali8ed, ori"inated and racticed e7clusively in $ndia. $t
has "iven a distin"uished identity to $ndian society.
Covers the entire social fa$ric of India – aste!system is one of the rominent features runnin" throu"h the entire social
fabric of $ndia. astes have its ethnic roots as denoted by 0ati e7tended family6, and a ritualistic and symbolic si"nicance in
its mindset. +o emer"ed the caste system. $nternali8ed caste
norms dene an individual role in the society. ommon men feel "ood and loved, when they live u to the norms set u by
their elders, and an7ious and "uilty, when he trans"ress them. $t has "reatly inIuenced the thinkin" of eole and their
culture allover $ndia.
%ne of the oldest livin" institution – aste system has maintained its continuity without interrution. $t has survived the
vicissitudes of time, saved itself by erosion from within and assault from outside only because of the adatability. $ts
absortive nature has internali8ed alien inIuences. $t has taken dierent shades and meanin" with the chan"in" times and
laces. $ts character durin" $ndus
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
15/63
Issue – aste system has always been a centre of attention for Gesterners, oliticians, intellectuals, activists or reformers
from other faiths. $t has been both defended and oosed vehemently in the olitical circles of modern $ndia. %any assaults
have been made on caste!system, esecially because of the deformities and ri"idity develoed into the system durin" a very
lon" eriod of its evolution and its bein" under alien rule. Aowever, after each assault, caste system has re!emer"ed with
"reater force.
Aow aste!system has chan"ed its comle7ion with the chan"in" times continuously, can be seen in its ori"in and rocess of
evaluation – its ori"in, and movin" throu"h the eras of moderni8ation, +anskriti8ation and olitici8ationJ
&hy so much criticism' – *sually, susicions or misunderstandin"s about any system arise, when the fundamentals and
knowled"e about the system or "round realities of the lace are not clear. Aalf cooked information, half a truth, artial or
incomlete knowled"e with a urose to let down somebody is harmful for the whole society. %any a times, such oinions
turn out to be a "reat lie.
Reality is dee"er than what is seen on the surface – #eality is much deeer than what is seen on the surface. (ne should not
form an oinion or take a decision without analy8in" rationally the whole scenario. %any misunderstandin"s about caste!
system would not sustain itself, once there is even a moderate understandin" about its ori"in and true nature of its beliefs,
systems and values and a little knowled"e about the "round realities of 31st century of $ndia. (ne should form an oinion or
take a decision after analy8in" rationally the whole scenario.
&estern &orld and (induism and caste system
$induism and its caste-system' a way of life – Ainduism and its caste!system do not mean reli"ious festivals, sacred te7ts,
and statues of deities, rituals or show o reli"iosity. $t is a way of life.
Criticism of Caste $y British rulers and why' – $n the ast, British $merial rulers and missionaries critici8ed caste!
system bitterly. Gard alle"ed )Not only is the caste contrary to every rincile of justice and olity, it is reu"nant to every
feelin" of benevolence. The social circle is almost invariably, comosed of ersons of the same caste, to the careful e7clusion
of others. $t aims one class of men a"ainst anotherO it "ives rise to "reatest de"ree of ride and aathy. $t forms a suLcient
e7cuse for not doin" an act of benevolence towards another, that he is not of the same caste, Ney, a man dyin" with thirst
will not accet a coolin" dro of water from the hands or the cu of a erson of a lower caste.- They intentionally hi"hli"hted
the weaknesses and suressed the salient feature of caste as a system.
2arl +ar0 remar*ed that British, )had a double mission in $ndia, one destructive, the other re"eneratin"O the annihilation of
the old &siatic +ociety and layin" the material foundation of Gestern +ociety in &sia.- The re"eneratin" character was
concerned with social transformation throu"h modern education, ?n"lish lan"ua"e as a medium of learnin" and oLcial
lan"ua"e, moderni8ation in economic shere, olitical unication of the country and layin" foundations for many democratic
institutions. The reactionary and destructive character was seen in the economic and social shere. The "rowth of casteism
had a close connection with these develoments. Dutt #', $ndia Today, HC6.
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
16/63
.ursuance of sectional interests ( &lon" with them, a "rou of intellectuals, activists and reformers, who were deely
inIuenced by the thinkin" of western world, condemned caste!system. $n the be"innin" of 34th century durin" British rule in
$ndia, with the introduction of electoral olitics, many olitical "rous emer"ed in the scene takin" u the interests of
articular section>sections. +uch a develoment "ave a new shae to caste system and laced ursuance of sectional
interests over the interests of the all the eole. &t resent, a lar"e number of olitical leaders> "rous>olitical arties are
vocal in critici8in" caste and ursuin" sectional interests, as it hels them to attract the illiterate masses and creates vote!
banks for them. @or them, caste has become a dero"atory word. They consider it roblematic and comlicated and wish to
create a casteless society.
&hy &estern &orld is mysti)ed'
There are some basic dierences in 9class: as the system adoted by Gest for stratication of society and 9caste: in
$ndia. Gestern world is mystied by ama8in" luralities and uniue social structure of $ndia based on caste. $t is diLcult for
the western world to understand the role of caste – ast or resent – in $ndian society. omlete locali8ation and unfamiliarity
makes it diLcult to understand caste as a system in its totality and to know the nuances, the nature, role both in the ast as
well as in resent6 and value of caste as a system. Because –
#aste not class basis of strati3cation – +tratication of a society becomes necessary for or"ani8in" human and social
behavior in tune with the objectives of a society. Ghile in Gestern world, usually anthroolo"ists, historians and sociolo"ists
identify 9class:, as universal basis of stratication within a society, $ndian society has been stratied socially on the basis of
caste!system.
.ower and social status associated with wealth – $n materialistic Gestern societies, wealth has always been associated with
ower, authority and social status. $n $ndia, its aste system has searated wealth from status, ower from authority, ursuit
and achievement in knowled"e from temtations of worldly comforts. The "reatness of a state is jud"ed on the basis of the
de"ree of ri"hteousness and justice, with which a social "rou lives or administration "overns lives of the eole, and not on
the basis of the si8e of a state or its treasury. +imilarly, in the society, status of a erson or a caste is ranked on the basis of
knowled"e, disciline and moral standards, and not on the basis of material success, or control of ower.
Stress on duties rather than rights – Ghereas, Gestern cultures have "rown around the idea of Uri"hts9, formin" the natural
foundation of human relationshi, caste system evolves around the concet of )duty, tolerance and sacrice-. ?mhasis on
duty usually makes a erson or a "rou humble and tolerant. $ts value!system hels eole to adjust themselves, without
much diLculty, to most drastic chan"es. $ndia has achieved its freedom in a eaceful manner under the leadershi of
%ahatma ;andhi. ommon men, here, are lled with a sense of duty.
)o conversion – *nlike hristianity or $slam, Ainduism has made new "rous its inte"ral art without any conversion and
brou"ht them under one umbrella without annihilatin" their own faith.
Truth' Ahimsa' "eace and non-aggression – Truth, &himsa, eace and non!a""ression have always been the art of $ndian
ethos. $ndians have till now acceted oression and e7loitation without much rotest. $ndian way of life and tolerance of its
eole has revented the masses to e7ercise coercion so far. Ghile in the ast, intolerance of eole led to bloody revolutions
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
17/63
elsewhere in the world, $ndia ket on adatin" itself to chan"in" times. Ghereas in the ast, other nations had assed
throu"h many bloody revolutions like in ancient ;reece, #ome or other ?uroean countries, and made eole to work under
the threat of a whi, tolerance in $ndia had revented eole from doin" that. $t is continuously $nternali8in" the
chan"es and has ket on adatin" itself to chan"in" times. $ndia has entered the modern era without any cultural break.
%ri"in of Caste System
Initial sta"es of Caste system
#aste-system in the ma*ing – aste!system is very old and indi"enous one, concetuali8ed, develoed and racticed
e7clusively in $ndia. &s reIected in 9#i"veda:, when eole ceased to be a wanderin" eole, started the
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
18/63
erfect "uide to art of livin". $t seaks of everythin"! on stayin" healthy, social values, imrovin" concentration and tenets of
behavior, which are relevant till today. $ts rituals are techniues for leadin" a harmonious life. &ccordin" to
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
19/63
cultural system. $t took thousands of years to evolve. $t was done cordially throu"h caste!system at dierent oints of time.
The beauty of the system was that the main society as a whole remained stable, even while oerin" a lace to new "rous
within the main!stream.
#aste as a mechanism for the merger – 9aste system: has rovided uniue mechanism for the mer"er ofnumerous discrete
tribes>social "rous and associations arisin" for olitical, sectarian or other reasons. &s more indi"enous and forei"n social
"rous desired to mer"e into its fold,
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
20/63
#aste system as a mechanism – aste system acted as a mechanism for assimilation. aste system never tried to liuidate
or absorb new "rous articially into its main stream. Throu"h it, numerous discrete tribes>social "rous – be it immi"rants,
locals, tribal, rofessionals or others have been internali8ed in the mainstream of the society. ?ach was assi"ned a searate
caste name and made them its inte"ral art in due course of time.
)o conversion – Ainduism does not believe in conversions. $t has not imosed its own beliefs, ractices and customs on
incomin" social "rous. $t concedes validity to all the reli"ions of the world and does not lay down strictures a"ainst any faith
or reject any reli"ion or its "od as false. $t has accommodated eole belon"in" to all the faiths, that is why, all the twelve
major reli"ions of the world are resent and Iourishin" in $ndia without much hindrance.
Assimilation of di!erent grou"s ( Aindus never revented new social "rous to join the mainstream of the land. (utsiders
were neither reulsed, nor allowed others to swee their own established culture o the roots. $t never tried to annihilate the
ori"inality, internal order, customs or lan"ua"e of incomin" "rous. Throu"h aste!system their beliefs, behavior atterns
rules and re"ulations and life styles were le"itimi8ed with the freedom to evolve and chan"e accordin" to their internal
rhythm. $t has neither reulsed any trend vehemently, nor allowed others to swee its own established culture o the roots.
#aste a natural institution for $indus – The units of social!olitical or"ani8ations were family, clan, villa"e, tribe and 0ana.
ommon!men re"ard them as natural and fundamental social institutions. & number of families livin" in one locality formed
"rama villa"e6. & number of such units dwellin" in a articular re"ion constituted a vis canton6. 0ana a "rou of tribes6
consisted of a number of such cantons, with a kin" as their ruler.
?very individual born in a family has a caste. @amily was the unit of society headed by father. aste is second only to the
family in widenin" a erson:s social radius and in "ettin" imortance in his>her rivate and occuational life.
%&ual status to all within a caste – &ll members of a caste enjoy eual social status with similar ri"hts and duties, similar and
similar thinkin" rocess.. & erson:s relation with members of his caste remains closer and eual than with those belon"in" to
other castes. Ais relations with other castes are usually formal. aste values, beliefs, rejudices, injunctions as well as
distortions of reality become an indivisible art of a erson:s syche and conscience. They share moments of joy and sorrow.
Why assignment of #aste by 5irth7 – (ver the time, due to economic and social reasons, caste system became a hereditary
system. &ssi"nment of dierent functions to dierent communities led to the transfer of knowled"e and e7ertise throu"h
inheritance. $t has evolved an atmoshere, where traits of a trade, intelli"ence abilities, e7eriences, values and skills were
transmitted from one "eneration to another in a natural way throu"h inheritance.
%m"loyment' dignity and honor for all – There was a close bond between individual and the society and individual and the
occuation throu"h caste. $t mana"ed a secic work for all. Doin" one:s job roerly boosted the morale of the eole and
romoted social euilibrium and solidarity.
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
21/63
S"awning bed for high level of e0cellence !The system served as a sawnin" bed for social and technical skills and led to
achieve a hi"h level of +eciali8ation and wisdom in dierent areas of activities. By its very nature, it encoura"ed the
develoment and reservation of local skills. There was a tendency to brin" in the most diversied skills to hi"h level of
e7cellence.
ocal character 8decentrali/ed9 and Interde"endence – No caste took an all $ndia character. &ll the activities of urban or rural
areas were conned within a small area, havin" very li ttle links with the outside world because of slower means of transort.
Eocal character and semi!autonomous nature of caste system made close interaction and cooeration between dierent
castes a reality. $nter!deendence in social life and self!reliance in ersonal life were the intrinsic features of caste system
makin" each local area self!suLcient and caable to fulll all the needs of its eole.
#aste' "roviding social security and stability – ?arlier, instead of "overnment, elders of each caste havin" sense of
belon"in", not a desire to e7ercise authority6 used to take care of maintainin" disciline within the caste and heled its
destitute>helless members.aste rovided to all its members social security and stability.
#ontrolled arbitrariness of strong and "owerful "ersons – There was not a sin"le "rou identiable as very stron"!dominatin"
all the others, or as an enemy to defeat. The lurality of society rovided automatic checks and balances and controlled the
arbitrariness or unbalanced "rowth of ower of any "rou.
Im"ortance to self-disci"line and *nowledge – ower was
decentrali8ed. ?ach caste was an indeendent entity, with its own hierarchy, based either on a tribal identity or an
occuational identity. There was not much disarity between dierent castes or between urban and rural eole. &s far as
castes are concerned, they rose and fell in their social order, some died out and new ones were formed from time to time.
Sharing :oys and sorrows together – $t held all sections of society to"ether. 'eole shared with their caste!fellows moments of
joys and sorrows.
Rationale behind assigning rights and duties to di!erent grou"s – The system of each caste havin" a secic osition in the
society and a secic work to do with its ri"hts and duties boosted the morale of its eole and romoted social euilibrium
and solidarity. Their relative osition in society deended on urity, morality, knowled"e, contribution of their work to the
society as a whole and siritual standards, they could maintain. onsiderations of self!disciline, hy"iene and cleanliness on
the basis of climatic conditions of the re"ion were "iven imortance.
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
22/63
+ost scienti3c system – $n its urest form, caste system may be re"arded as one of the most scientic social systems ever
evolved anywhere in the world. The "enius of the hilosohers of ancient $ndia has rovided a hilosohy, the rationality of
which is in conformity with the laws of nature. $t rovided a stron" social structure to $ndian society, which led to the all round
"rowth of its cultural herita"e and "iven $ndian society coherence, stability, continuity. $t ket its members comfortable and
satised. $t instilled in eole, self!disciline, consciousness, self!control and self!direction. $t assi"ned them duties accordin"
to their natural instincts and ualities. $t develoed in them a feelin" of belon"in", interdeendence and team!sirit. Belief in
concets like 9live and let others live: as well as 9
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
23/63
153C to 156. $nitially %uslims were interloers in the subcontinent. They established their emire from the 1th century
onwards. @or a eriod of over one thousand years, $slam had walked hand in hand with ower.
+any social evils develo"ed into the system – Gidesread misunderstandin" "ave birth to many social evils, caste!conIicts,
feudal oressions and mass overty. ontinuous loot, arson, killin"s and violence on oor and women develoed feelin" of
insecurity in Aindus, which led them to reli"ious fundamentalism in order to retain their cultural identity. Ghile livin" under an
alien olitical order, whether it was Turks, %u"hal, 'ortu"uese or British, i"norant masses blindly followed the dictates of
Aindu 'riests and all the rituals su""ested by them. To Aindus, ri"idity in observin" the rituals aeared as a shield to retain
their cultural identity. They ri"idly and blindly observed all customs and traditions, which had lost their sanctity in the li"ht of
the circumstances of that time. $t tended to develo many evil ractices in the system.
Start of discriminatory "ractices – The discriminatory "overnance of %uslim rulers reared "round for stienin" > hardenin" >
crystalli8in" social norms, ractices and rituals. %ost of the time under %uslim rule, non!%uslims, esecially in the North were
continually at the receivin" end of the discriminatory ractices of the rulers and forced conversions at the hands of %uslim
invaders. $ntolerance of rulers towards their Aindu subjects made it diLcult for Aindus to reserve their culture and continue
their indi"enous identity.
Rise of communalism ( Aindu and %uslim riests arbitrarily distorted and misinterreted tenets of their resective reli"ions.
They urosely hi"hli"hted and critici8ed the dierences on the surface like )Aindus are idol worshiers- or $slam believes
9either you are a %uslim or else a 9=ar: etc. $t tended to make eole suerstitious. $ndian society was torn by acrimony
between Aindus and %uslims. +ometimes it took an a""ressive form. Both the communities had for"otten that ;od is the
same whether you call Aim 9$shwar: or 9&llah:. &ll human!bein"s are eual in his eyes. Ae never divides man from man.
Reaction on masses– 'eole blindly followed the dictates of Aindu and %uslim riests. 'eole blindly followed the dictates of
Aindu and %uslim riests. $"norant mob concentrated more on observance of rituals ri"idly than understandin" the
substance>meanin">or reason behind them acted as a shield to rotect and reserve identity and the basic roots of Ainduism.
%mergence of evil "ractices – ontinuous loot, arson, killin"s and violence on oor and women, kidnain" of beautiful
"irls>women for se7ual leasures of those in authority led to emer"ence of many social evils and ractices like child marria"e,
+ati 'ratha, 'urdah system to save one:s honor, 'oly"amy, dowry etc. Durin" %edieval era, also started the feudalistic
attitude, e7trava"ance and lu7urious life style of %o"ul rulers and those at helm of authority. Disarity between rulers and
ruled had increased. $"norance, suerstitions and hellessness of oor masses had led to the oression of weaker sections
of the society esecially the women and oor workers>shudras.
Nature of Caste durin" Medieval ,eriod
Automatic chec*s and balances – The lurality of society rovided automatic checks and balances and controlled
arbitrariness or unbalanced "rowth of any articular caste!"rou. There was not a sin"le "rou amon"st Aindus identiable
as very stron" dominatin" all the others, or as an enemy to defeat. The e7istence of owerful easant was a reality of the
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
24/63
rural life of %edieval $ndia. They rovided leadershi of most armed bands, which were numerically redominant and
economically and olitically stron" at the villa"e level. Non!=shatriya easantry in *', Bihar and %' ket a check on
=shatriyas: arbitrariness. There was a cut!throat cometition between =ayasthas "ave a tou"h cometition to Brahmins in the
ela of learnin".
6loating "o"ulation ( @loatin" oulation of "rous like ;ujjars, Bhattis, #ajut ran"ers remained outside caste system. They
were so stron", that they terrori8ed settled a"riculturists for centuries. @orests, which cometed with arable land in si8e and
imortance, till the 12th century, "ave shelter and food to lar"e sections of society and served as havens for those in search
of escae from society.
%&ual social status to all within a caste – Throu"hout medieval eriod also, all the members within a caste enjoyed eual
social status vise!a!vise other castes. aste values, beliefs, rejudices, injunctions as well as distortions of reality became an
indivisible art of a erson:s syche and conscience. They shared moments of joy and sorrow. & erson:s relation with his own
caste!members was closer than with those belon"in" to other castes>communities.
&esterniation of caste+system
Rise of %uro"ean "owers with Renaissance +ovement – The 'rocess of Gesterni8ation started with the #enaissance durin"
late middle a"es in $taly around 1Hth century. This cultural movement has rofoundly aected ?uroean intellectual life. $t
started in $taly, and sread to the rest of ?uroe by the 1th century.
The #enaissance movement was a cultural movement that rofoundly aected ?uroean intellectual life. $ts inIuence was felt
everywhere, in literature, hilosohy, art, music, olitics, science, reli"ion, and other asects of intellectual inuiry. The
sincere knowled"e seekers of Gestern world did not care for inconveniences or challen"es for creatin" modern civili8ation.
They sacriced their time for about two centuries6, ener"ies and comforts in search of knowled"e. Then only they could
develo "reat modern scientic knowled"e, techniue and wealth.
Scienti3c and technological changes – ?uroe set out on ath of scientic and technolo"ical chan"e. #eliance on observation
and rationality had led to many inventions in the eld of science and technolo"y. The invention of rintin", bein" one of them
has heled in the dissemination of ideas from the later 15th century onwards.
#hanges due to the develo"ment of technology – $n 1HM3 the )discovery- of the )New Gorld- by hristoher olumbus
challen"ed the classical world!view. $t chan"ed the relationshi between dierent arts of the world. $t led to the rise of the
?uroean %aritime economics, the coloni8ation of the &mericans and +outh and +outheast &sia.
,rocess of &esterniation of Caste system
The rocess of Gesterni8ation of caste!system in $ndia be"an with the frantic eorts of missionaries to convert as many
$ndians as ossible into hristianity and comin" of ?ast $ndia omany in $ndia rst to trade and later on to increase its
olitical ower in $ndia. ?ast $ndia omany successfully established 9British $merial #ule: in $ndia by 1M52.
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
25/63
2arl +ar0 on the ob:ectives of 5ritish Rulers in India – =arl %ar7 had ri"htly remarked that while layin" down the foundation of
%odern democratic "overnment in $ndia, British had a double mission in $ndia, one destructive, the other re"eneratin"O the
annihilation of the old &siatic +ociety and layin" the material foundation of Gestern +ociety in &sia. The re"eneratin"
character was concerned with social transformation throu"h modern education, ?n"lish lan"ua"e as a medium of learnin"
and oLcial lan"ua"e, moderni8ation in economic shere, olitical unication of the country and layin" foundations for many
democratic institutions like 'arliament, $ndian ivil +ervices, 0udicial system etc. etc. The reactionary and destructive
character was seen in the economic and social shere.
Divide and rule "olicy of Im"erial rulers – The rulers adoted the ath of 9divide and rule:. The way British "overned $ndia,
served double urose for them. They "ot the credit for amelioration and rotection of rimitive and inward!lookin" society of
$ndians. &t the same time, they ket the natives busy in their in!"hts.
Develo"ment of modern means of trans"ort – The ositive eect of the rocess of moderni8ation and industriali8ation,
technolo"ical develoments under British rule, esecially in the areas of transort, means of communication and information
technolo"y was that it had made closer interaction ossible. +hortenin" the "eo"rahical distances had brou"ht eole livin"
in distant areas to"ether.
Ne"ative in-uence on society
The modern means of transort and communications brou"ht to an end the local character and inter!deendence of various
caste "rous. +mall local castes livin" in distant laces "rew in si8e. aste or"ani8ations and ressure "rous entered into
re"ion!wise caste alliances and emer"ed as a stron" force for the ursuance of their sectional interests in the olitics. $t led to
olari8ation of dierent caste "rous and waterti"ht comartmentali8ation of $ndian society.
%!ect of Industriali/ation – The rocess $ndustriali8ation be"an under British rule to build a modern $ndia. Ghile Britain, alon"
with other ?uroean nations, was roducin" hi"h technolo"y, hi"h roductivity, hi"h wa"e and hi"h rot commodities, $ndia
remained to roduce low technolo"y, low roductivity, low wa"e and low rot items. $t left $ndia economically far behind the
advanced nations. Durin" British rule, $ndia missed out rst few hases of $ndustrial revolution –
(ne that revolutioni8ed a"riculture and te7tile roduction.
+econd one occurrin" in the rst half of the 1Mth century, which was based on caital "oods industry. &nd
The third durin" the last uarter of the 1Mth century, when science was fused with technolo"y.
Discredited traditional occu"ations – $ndustriali8ation and emer"ence of white!collared jobs based on formal education tended
to make many traditional occuations obsolete, as they were considered less ayin", more ha8ardous or time consumin".
$ndustriali8ation had eroded the authority of caste and kinshi in matters of occuation. New occuations that emer"ed "ave
choice of occuation, but accessibility to them deended on modern education, knowled"e of ?n"lish lan"ua"e and loyalty to
British.
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
26/63
Adverse e!ect of traditional occu"ations becoming obsolete – Due to the aathy of rulers towards indi"enous skills,
knowled"e and occuations, many traditional occuations became obsolete and led to the decay of villa"e industries. $t
ushed millions backward in a very subtle manner and loosened the sanctity of caste rules and caste consciousness in
matters of occuation. $t discoura"ed local "enius, cotta"e industries and ne arts. %any castes of rural artisans, craftsman
and traditional occuations abandoned their traditional work. They had no otion but either to mi"rate to cities as industrial
labor or become a"riculture labor.
#hanged wor*-culture ( $t scattered the eorts, sense of direction and manufacturin" skills of millions of artisans, craftsman,
weavers etc. There had been casualty of workers rst, afterwards their work style, commitment, motivation and culture. They
lost their creativity, sense of achievement and ride. Gork culture has chan"ed tremendously since then. %ore, a erson
withdrew from hysical labor, more civili8ed, honored and ualied he was re"arded by modern society. $t resulted in
discreditin" many traditional occuations and in destruction of $ndian handicrafts and cotta"e industry <
1nem"loyment increased –
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
27/63
=Regenerating e!ects of modern education – $ntroduction of modern education was welcomed by all, missionaries as well as
Aumanitarians, intellectuals and nationalist leaders. The atmoshere was comletely ready. National leaders and reformists
considered modern education )the key to the treasures of scientic and democratic thou"ht of the modern Gest.- +read of
the 'rinciles of Democracy across the nation led the eole to resist imerialism and tyranny of British rule. The elite and
intellectual sections of society hoed that modern education would "ive the eole the key to oen the treasures of scientic
discoveries. Throu"h Gestern literature and hilosohy eole would understand the democratic, liberal and humanitarian
thou"hts of the modern 9Gest:.
$t was hoed that modern education would make eole aware of the real issues hamerin" the ro"ress of $ndian society,
remedy the social, olitical and economic ills of the country and imrove the life of common men by enablin" them to
conuer i"norance, hun"er, overty and disease. &s hoed modern education, ei"hteenth century onwards, led to social
awakenin", "ave imetus to social ro"ress and brou"ht many reforms. $t had inIuenced substantially the workin" style and
thinkin" of the eole. National leaders welcomed rationality and "ood features of %odern ?n"lish education. +ome of the
ositive eects of modern education on $ndian society were as follows –
,"ened u" the doors of the *nowledge ( %odern education oened u the doors of the knowled"e Iourished in ?uroe after
#enaissance movement of %iddle &"es. $t had widened the mental hori8ons of $ndian intelli"entsia.
%ducation for all – Durin" second half of the nineteenth century, British "overnment in $ndia oened the doors of education
to all the sections of $ndian society, irresective of caste or creed. +till, very few amon"st the "eneral ublic could avail the
advanta"es of formal modern education. ?ducation remained conned within a small section of society.
$ighlighted evil "ractices – %odern education had hi"hli"hted the evil ractices and weaknesses develoed into the system
like ri"idity and harshness of many social customs and ractices revalent at that time for the weaker sections of the society
i.e. un!touch!ability and inhuman treatment to women, +ati, 'oly"amy, child marria"e etc. etc. revalent at that time.
Attracted attention of social reformers – %odern education had attracted the attention of intellectuals and social reformers
towards real issues evils caused by i"norance, irrationality of mumbo!jumbo of rituals and suerstitions created by some
selsh eole to entan"le the i"norant and oor masses. They su""ested remedies for social, olitical and economic ills of
the country. They took uon themselves the resonsibility to build a modern, oen, lural, culturally rich, roserous and
owerful $ndia out of a fra"mented, overty stricken, suerstitious, weak, indierent, backward and inward lookin" society.
Reali/ation of the worth of liberty and freedom – $t euied national leaders with intellectuals tools with which they fou"ht
the oressive British #aj. $ndians reali8ed the worth of liberty and freedom. They "ot e7osure to the hilosohies of thinkers
like Eocke, %ill, #oussseau,
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
28/63
cultural and intellectual attainments-. The traditional $ndian system of education had withered away for the lack of oLcial
suort. $ts "radual disaearance had disassociated $ndian eole from their culture, classical roots, knowled"e and
traditional way of livin". &lon" with it faded $ndian values, hilosohies and traditions. +ome of the adverse eects of modern
education system on $ndian society were as followin" –
5rainwashing through education – $n educational institutions under British "overnment or %issionary schools, educated
them, reached eole and instilled in the minds so much comle7 about the rimitiveness of $ndian society, its social
structure and its values and systems that they started feelin" their social ractices as indefensible.
%any ?ducated $ndians re"arded native ractices as )discriminatory,- )iniuitous,- )e7loitative,- )oressive- )barbarous,-
)uncivili8ed- and )hi"hly stratied-. $ndian social!structure, based on caste system, was held resonsible for all evil social
ractices, feudalistic attitude, backward thinkin", belief in do"mas and suerstitions sustained by a uniue set of rituals, and
whimsical concet of urity and ollution.
A good reci"e to convert individuals into christianity ( %issionaries considered modern education a "ood recie to brainwash
$ndians and to attract $ndians towards hristianity. %odern education system had made their job easy. %issionaries: schools
were oened allover $ndia. ;overnment "ave them liberal "rants for rovidin" free education to lower strata of $ndian society
and rovidin" for them ermanent jobs. %odern education reared "round for mass conversions.
Disassociated Indian "eo"le from classical roots – %odern education has also disassociated many $ndian eole from their
traditional way of learnin", classical roots and knowled"e. Gith it faded $ndian values, hilosohies, systems and traditions. $t
made them to loose their faith in social values and systems.
Rise to unhealthy com"etition ( %oderni8ation of the attern of education and occuations makin" knowled"e of ?n"lish as
basic ualication for white collared jobs esecially in "overnment6 increased role of formal education and trainin" for
emloyment. Eimited oortunities in modern education and "overnment jobs became the bone of contention between
dierent sections of the society. Tou"h cometition between dierent sections of society to "et hold on modern occuations,
led to inter!caste rivalries, social tensions and "rou conIicts amon" $ndians.
=Start of 5rahmin vs )on-5rahmin movement ( The monooly of Brahmins in these areas cautioned the British and "enerated
an"er amon"st the non!Brahmin communities and %uslims. $n the +outhern states, there emer"ed two rival "rous –
Brahmins and Non!Brahmins and in the North – Aindu and %uslims.
‘Census operations’
Regenerative e!ect of #ensus o"erations – &fter consolidatin" its osition, the British ;overnment in $ndia made an eort to
know about the eole, whom they want to rule and chalk out strate"ies for the colonial "overnance. British anthroolo"ists
worked very hard to collect data and to catalo"ue various castes and tribes. @or the rst time, the ensus oerations drew
the attention of the rulers, intelli"entsia and ublic to the diversity of $ndian society and multilicity of castes and sub!castes
throu"hout $ndia.
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
29/63
Administrative convenience' main concern of rulers – British rulers redened the structure of $ndian society throu"h ensus
oerations accordin" to their administrative convenience.
Degenerative e!ect of #ensus (
• +o far, aste was a Ie7ible and Iuid unit of $ndian society. ensus oerations destroyed its Ie7ibility and "ave ri"idity tosocial stratication and hierarchical rankin".
• The older four .ower in numbers? – The introduction of electoral olitics, in the be"innin" of the 34th century "ave
rise to )'ower in numbers-. ;overnment of $ndia &ct of 1M4M also known as %into %orley #eforms "ranted searate %uslim
?lectorate.
Divided Indian "o"ulation into uncom"romising grou"s on caste and communal lines – $t brou"ht the idea of communal
electorate to the forefront in the minds of all the castes and communities and led to divide Aindu oulation also into two
uncomromisin" "rous, vi8. UGe- Non!Brahmins vs. UThey- Brahmins and caste Aindus. $t "ave olitical levera"e to the non!
Brahmin castes on account of their numerical stren"th.
Suggestion to e0clude 1ntouchables from $indu-fold – The su""estion of ensus ommissioner to e7clude untouchables from
Aindu fold in the comin" 1M11 census immediately increased the imortance of untouchables in olitical circle, in social
circle, and in their own eyes too. &round 1M4M, the non!Brahmin ommunity, which resented the Brahmins hold in modern
occuations, was divided into two Backwards and untouchables. @or the rst time, the lowest layer of Aindu ommunity was
concetuali8ed under the name of 9untouchabes: in the olitical circles.
#ommunal Award' .oona "act of @BC – ommunal &ward of 1M3 created a ermanent slit in Aindu +ociety and
eretuated casteism further. Dr. #ajendra 'rasad said, 9the rincile of dividin" oulation into communal "rous, which had
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
30/63
been adoted in the %into %orley reforms had been considerably e7tended, even beyond what had been done by %onta"u
helmsford #eformsF The electorate in 1M1M was broken u into 14 arts, now it is fra"mented into seventeen uneual
bitsF: Aindu community was further weakened by "ivin" searate reresentation to +cheduled castes. Division on the basis
of reli"ion, occuation and service were made. ?very ossible cross division was introduced by the British. The ommunal
&ward stren"thened the roots of casteism in olitics.
Instilled venom a"ainst caste system and (induism – The leaders of the downtrodden like %ahatma 'hule, &mbedkar
or ;oal ;anesh tau"ht the lower castes to "et united. They instilled deely in the minds of millions of unlettered Aindus,
venom a"ainst caste!system and the Brahmin community. aste system, to them, was resonsible for treatin" them as lesser
human bein"sO en"a"in" them in forced labour, unsavory jobs imosin" many restrictions on themO reventin" them from
joinin" the mainstream of the societyO and the subju"ation of lower castes with the hel of reli"ion. They vehemently
critici8ed its hierarchical structure, and re"arded untouchability as an inevitable concomitant of caste system. Dr. &mbedkar
made it abundantly clear that, it was throu"h olitical ower that untouchables were to nd their solution, not throu"h
accetance by Aindus. ?radication of caste system became the major lank of 9backward: castes and 9untouchable: castes.
Start of the practice of "ivin" 0,references1 23eservation ,olicy4
British rulers devised a novel method to distribute and balance ower on 9referential!basis:. To restrict Brahmin:s entry in
;overnment jobs and make it available to non!Brahmins communities, British rulers started ractice of )'references- by
"ivin" non!Brahmins nancial assistance and references in education and ;overnment emloyment at local and rovincial
level. $t served double urose for them – "ettin" credit for amelioration and rotection of downtrodden and keein" natives
busy in their in!"hts. Eater on, it "ave birth to the 9'olicy of #eservations:.
5rahmin-)on-5rahmin movement in South – 'ractice of "ivin" non!Brahmins nancial assistance and references in
education and ;overnment emloyment at local and rovincial level by the "overnment was stron"ly established in the +outh
at rovincial level. The atrona"e of British rulers to non!Brahmin castes had led to the emer"ence of owerful ressure
"rous and increased their demand for referential treatment in education, jobs and elections. $t ultimately "ave birth to the
uota system. 1M45 to 1MH4 was the eriod, when idea of #eservation>ositive discrimination was conceived, e7erimented
and established rmly. $t oened u various channels of confrontation.
Sans5ritiation of Caste system
%odern education, Gestern literature and hilosohy widened the mental hori8ons of visionary national leaders and
reformers. They welcomed rationality and other "ood features of and made "ood use of liberal, and humanitarian
ideas>thou"hts of %odern Gestern Gorld. But at the same time destructive nature of new olicies alarmed national leaders.
National leaders "ot alarmed at the erosion of $ndian ulture and divisible olicies of the rulers. They reali8ed the imact of
British racial discrimination and their reressive olicies on the $ndian eole. The destructive character of British imerialism
lit the re and "ave birth to national movement. ?conomic loot, olitical subju"ation, assertion of lordly sueriority over the
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
31/63
subject on the "round of race, assumtion of a hau"hty e7clusiveness, ersistent insultin" and suercilious behavior towards
all $ndians, e7clusion of $ndians from all laces of authority and resonsibility and denial of their caacity for self!"overnance
united $ndians a"ainst British rule.
National leaders and reformers tried to revive their own rich ancient culture and revent the masses from bein" swayed away
by the "lamour and materialism of alien culture. +ocial #eformers advised eole to remain rmly rooted to the $ndian
ulture.
'eformers an# intellectuals fought for 'eformation – #eformers observed that i"norance, suerstitions or irrationality
of eole was hamerin" the ro"ress of $ndian society. #eformers or"ani8ed meetin"s to make eole aware of the social
evils>real issues. They advised eole to sto treatin" low caste Aindus inhumanly. They advocated for "ivin" women their
ri"htful lace in society. $t was considered it vital because woman as a mother is the best teacher. &lso women needed to be
rotected from evil social ractices like +ati, 'oly"amy, child marria"e, infanticide, feticide etc.
The intellectual ferment was stron"est in Gest Ben"al, %aharashtra and Tamil Nadu. $n 1M32, #aja #am %ohan #oy founded
Brahma +amaj in Ben"al. Ae insired the eole of Ben"al, *', 'unjab, %adras and other rovinces, to form similar
or"ani8ations and interret reli"ion rationally. 'rarthana +amaj in %aharashtra 12C6, &rya +amaj in Northern $ndia, #ama
=rishna %ission, Theosohical +ociety of $ndia 12M6, Dev +amaj in Eahore and +ervants of $ndia +ociety took u the job to
awaken the masses. They talked about the "reatness of Aindu
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
32/63
True reli"ion does not discriminate mankind in terms of race, color, nationality, caste or "ender.
The most noble task of every individual is to work for the enli"htenment and ulift the weaker ersons.
The markin"s of $ndian culture are simlicity and solidity.
They advised eole not to be swayed away by Gestern culture. @irst they should know their own herita"e and try to revive
what is "ood in it. They made sincere eorts to make reli"ion as bedrock of the value!system. #eli"ion in its ure sense does
not lead to discrimination. $t does not teach eole to hate or divide mankind. These were the noble ideas that had inIuenced
"reatly the youn" minds of educated middle class.
Moderniation of caste system
)By indeendence, we have lost the e7cuse of blamin" the British for anythin" "oin" wron"- B# &mbedkar, uoted from T($,
'.34, 0an 3C, 34146
,ost Independent India – @rom 15th of &u"ust 1MH onwards, $ndeendent $ndia is committed to democratic, secular and
e"alitarian rinciles as enshrined in the onstitution of $ndia. 'reamble of the $ndian onstitution romises to secure to all its
citi8ensP 0*+T$?, social, economic and oliticalO E$B?#TK of thou"ht, e7ression, belief, faith and worshiO ?/*&E$TK of status
and of oortunityO and to romote amon" them all @#&T?#N$TK assurin" the di"nity of the individual and the unity and
inte"rity of the Nation. &rticle 15 of the onstitution rohibits any kind of discrimination on "rounds of caste, race, reli"ion,
"ender or lace of birthO &rticle 1C "ives euality of oortunity in matter of ublic emloyment, &rticle 2 creates National
commission for +cheduled astes to safe"uard their interests etc.
#oncern of Government for the "rotection of under"rivileged-castes – & number of amendments in the onstitution and
le"islation have been assed to remove the disabilities of backward eole. *ntouchability has been declared a crime.
Bonded labor is abolished by law. ivil #i"hts &ct, 1M55, aims to eliminate injustice a"ainst weaker sections. &mendment to
'revention of &trocities &ct +T6 1M2M rovides for stern unishments for oenses committed a"ainst +T by *er astes.
+ecial ourts, under +T &ct, have been established for unishin" oLcials, if found "uilty. +till, there is no resite from
discriminatory ractices. GhyJ $s caste system resonsible for it or roblems lie somewhere elseJ
(aste more li)eral in social sphere – $n modern $ndia, sread of literacy and "rowin" awareness amon" masses has
already brou"ht to an end slowly but steadily many of the discriminatory ractices and deformities develoed in aste
system, while livin" under alien rule. $t has become more liberal and less restrictive in social life of the eole. astes no
lon"er enjoy le"al or reli"ious sanctions.
#astes ess restrictive – ?7ulsion from castes means little, while earlier it meant comlete social ostracism. (ld style of
authority and ower e7ercised by caste!elders has already diminished e7cet for a few rural areas esecially in Aaryana and
#ajasthan. #estrictions or interactions between dierent castes arisin" due to considerations for urity and ollution are
fadin" away from ublic life even from rural areas. Traditional barriers on marria"e, hereditary occuations and commonality
are loosin" its imortance.
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
33/63
.oor governance – $n modern $ndia, millions of submer"ed eole suer from discrimination and e7loitation, it is not the
caste!system, but the bad olitics and oor "overnance, which is resonsible. %odern $ndia is sharly divided into two –
)haves- and )have!nots-. The most imortant factors resonsible for disarities are vote!bank olitics, irrational and corrut
ways of ursuin" the aternal olicies and "overnment:s failure to address real issues at central and +tate levels.
‘#aste' the most "owerful tool for creation of vote-ban*s – 9aste: has become a bye!word for $ndian oliticians. @or the
resent!day olitical leaders caste is the easiest and most owerful tool to sway ublic oinion emotionally and to create a
lar"er vote bank for them. $t may be called ossication of caste!system fallen into the hands of ower brokers and vote
"u88lers.
%mergence of "olitical identities ( @or olitical and "overnance uroses, modern $ndian society has been stratied in most
insensitive manner. @or "rabbin" the olitical ower, the modern $ndian society has been divided into the followin"
unbrid"eable "rous – *er castes, +cheduled astes, +cheduled tribes, (ther Backward lass and %inorities. +ectional
interests are bein" romoted on caste or communal basis shamelessly.
)arrow loyalties of caste and religion – Narrow loyalties of caste and reli"ion are encoura"ed in olitical arena. $t has
"enerated sub!cultures like caste!ism, favoritism, and lure for easy money, neotism, arochialism, communalism,
re"ionalism etc. Bi"oted sentiments and irresonsible comments are sreadin" in!disciline in the society. The risin"
asirations and demands of eole, with the sread of education and awareness, has created added roblem for the
"overnment.
1nder-currents of caste "olitics – *nder!currents of caste olitics have made the "overnment incaable to solve the burnin"
national issues. $t has made to maintain law and order diLcult. $nter!caste and intra!caste, inter!community and intra!
community and inter!tribal and intra!tribal conIicts are increasin" day by day in order to "et more sace in the corridors of
ower.
Real issues "ushed into the bac*ground – #eal issues like mass!scale illiteracy, overty, unemloyment, inIation,
deteriorated law and order situation, increasin" violence or "eneral coarsenin" of moral ber of the $ndian society etc. are
ushed into the back"round. the voice of uri"ht and honest eole belon"in" to middle class is bein" continuously throttled
mercilessly. They are bein" unished for followin" sincerely family!lannin" norms, which has decreased their numbers. $n
resent day vote!bank olitics based on "ame of numbers, it is very easy now for the ursuers of olitical ower to sideline
them.
The voice of uri"ht and honest citi8ens of $ndia irresective of caste or community is bein" continuously throttled
mercilessly. $n resent day vote!bank olitics based on "ame of numbers, it is very easy now for the ursuers of olitical
ower to sideline them.
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
34/63
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
35/63
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
36/63
Before formin" any oinion or reachin" to any conclusion, it would be better to understand the dierence between 9caste!
system: and 9caste!ism: and 9caste!less society: on the basis of "round realities that e7ist today.
*enom a"ainst caste+system started only in recent past – There was not so much heart!burnin" because of caste
earlier.
8/18/2019 Discrimination and Caste
37/63
• aste as system – aste is an or"anised social institution. This term is secically used to refer the social structure of Aindu $ndia. Broadly seakin", the fourfold division of society has been sanctioned in ancient scritures and said tostructure all social relations.
• aste!ism – ?ntry of caste in olitics, "overnment basin" it ulift of submer"ed sections of society on caste, ri"id attitudein observance of caste ractices without havin" re"ard for reason or rhyme or usin" it for vested interests of owerfullobbies !be it Brhmins, musclemen, olitician to "arner vote!banks lead to casteism. $t has "enerated many abnormalitiesand distortions in the system. aste is a social institution. Brin"in" it into olitics and usin" it for olitical "ains is the
bi""est disservice one can do to the nation done by the leaders of various olitical arties in recent ast.
Caste as a tool to further their followin" for the Critics of caste+system – $t is an irony that those very eole, who
critici8e caste!system vehemently, them!selves clin" to their caste identity very stron"ly. ?ntry of 9caste: into olitics led to
unchecked "rowth of caste!ism. @or oliticians, it is a recie for creatin" vote!banks. @or others it is the base to enjoy secial
rivile"es>benets of aLrmative action ro"rams initiated and imlemented by the ;overnment of $ndia. ?lite section
amon"st lower castes rotects its turf under the banner of backward castes. The interest of all lies in keein" the majority of
eole i"norant, insecure and out of mainstream. &nd here lies the cru7 of resent day:s caste!ist olitics.
3aisin" e#pectations of a"itated youth – #isin" e7ectations of eole, olitical ambitions and economic interests have
aroused the militancy amon" the discontented youths of dierent castes and communities all over the nation, which has
divided the $ndians into innumerable unbrid"eable "rous. 9'olitici8ation of caste: needs to be arrested at its earliest.
Strati)cation of a society! a natural phenomenon
$ndividuals dier from each other in natural endowments, intelli"ence, atitudes, attitudes, skills, ersonal needs and other
innate characteristics. +uch dierences are at to "ive rise to the formations of dierent social "rous and systems. $t is uite
natural that in every society, anywhere in the world emer"e dierent "rous out of functional necessity. ?ach society devises
its own rinciles for stratication, for coordinated functionin" of all arts to"ether, for keein" its whole system t and
functional as well as for takin" care of the interests of its eole as a whole. $ts basis may dier from lace to lace. $t may be
on basis of class, caste, reli"ion, re"ion, lan"ua"e or occuation.
Class’ a $asis in &estern Societies
Individualistic by nature – *sually, class stratication be"ins with individuals. Division of society alon" 9lass: lines forms
dierent "rous on the basis their economic and cultural level. Ghat determines 9class: varies from one society to another.
*sually ossession of wealth determines hierarchical distinctions between individuals or "rous within a community .
Distinction between two "rous deends on their bein" owerful and owerless. +ocial classes with more ower usually
subordinate classes with less ower, which 'ower was closely linked to ability to assert one:s status throu"h hysical
stren"th.
Ran*ing ( Dierent variables are also adoted to decide status of dierent "rous within a society, like occuation, education
and ualications, income, wealth, ownershi of land, roerty etc. Besides, there are other factors as well considered as
imortant as one:s wealth in determinin" class status, at least at hi"her levels, like costume and "roomin", manners and
cultural ren