2

GAN TION v CA, JUDGE AGUSTIN MONTESA (CFI, Manila), ONG WAN SIENG, SHERIFF OF MANILA 21 May 1969 Ponente: Makalintal, J. DOCTRINE: Compensation possible only when two parties are each other’s creditor and debtor FACTS 1. 1961 – P filed an ejectment case against Ong Wan Sieng (OWS) 2. P contends that OWS was in default for 2 months of rent at 180/month 3. OWS contends that rent was only 160/month, and that he tried to pay P but was refused 4. CFI ruled in favor of OWS, awarding latter P500 in attorney’s fees 5. 1963 – P notified OWS that rent would increase 180/month, and demanded payment of unpaid rent amounting to 4k from 1961-1963 6. OWS able to obtain writ of execution for P500 attorney’s fees 7. P complained that P500 should be considered partial legal compensation to him for the 4k debt owed by OWS 8. CA ruled against P, stating that P500 can only be considered legal compensation if P and OWS were creditors and debtors of one another, but the P500 attorney’s fees did not belong to P but to his attorney, and therefore the attorney was the creditor, not P ISSUES 1. WON attorney’s fees can be subject of legal compensation RULING

Digest - Gan Tion v CA

Download DOCX Report

Upload
liaa-aquino
View
293
Download
8

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Digest - Gan Tion v CA

Citation preview

Page 1: Digest - Gan Tion v CA

GAN TION vCA, JUDGE AGUSTIN MONTESA (CFI, Manila), ONG WAN SIENG, SHERIFF OF MANILA21 May 1969Ponente: Makalintal, J.

DOCTRINE: Compensation possible only when two parties are each other’s creditor and debtor

FACTS

1. 1961 – P filed an ejectment case against Ong Wan Sieng (OWS)2. P contends that OWS was in default for 2 months of rent at

180/month3. OWS contends that rent was only 160/month, and that he tried to

pay P but was refused4. CFI ruled in favor of OWS, awarding latter P500 in attorney’s fees5. 1963 – P notified OWS that rent would increase 180/month, and

demanded payment of unpaid rent amounting to 4k from 1961-1963

6. OWS able to obtain writ of execution for P500 attorney’s fees7. P complained that P500 should be considered partial legal

compensation to him for the 4k debt owed by OWS8. CA ruled against P, stating that P500 can only be considered

legal compensation if P and OWS were creditors and debtors of one another, but the P500 attorney’s fees did not belong to P but to his attorney, and therefore the attorney was the creditor, not P

ISSUES

1. WON attorney’s fees can be subject of legal compensation

RULING

1. Yesa. P500 does not belong to attorney but to Pb. P is the proper creditor of the P500c. P500 may properly be the subject of legal compensation

against OWS’ debtsd. Unjust to ask P to pay P500 when OWS owes him 4k

CA decision reversed

COCO-GAN: Generation by Parts via Conditional …COCO-GAN: Generation by Parts via Conditional Coordinating by assembling a set of s00altogether with a merging func- tion ’. In practice,

COCO-GAN: Generation by Parts via Conditional …COCO-GAN: Generation by Parts via Conditional Coordinating by assembling a set of s00altogether with a merging func- tion ’. In practice,

Documents

Ferroelectricity at the Ferroelectric Crystals for …Fabrication and characteriza-tion of self-assembled ferroelectric linear and nonlinear photonic crystals: GaN and LiNbO3.- Part

Ferroelectricity at the Ferroelectric Crystals for …Fabrication and characteriza-tion of self-assembled ferroelectric linear and nonlinear photonic crystals: GaN and LiNbO3.- Part

Documents

GN001 Application Guide Design with GaN Enhancement …€¦ · GaN Systems – 1 GN001 Application Guide. Design with GaN Enhancement mode HEMT. Updated on JAN-24-2018. GaN Systems

GN001 Application Guide Design with GaN Enhancement …€¦ · GaN Systems – 1 GN001 Application Guide. Design with GaN Enhancement mode HEMT. Updated on JAN-24-2018. GaN Systems

Documents

Digest of Statistics for Museums, Libraries 2005 and … 2005 • Digest 2005 • Digest 2005 • 3 • Digest 2005 • Digest 2005 • Digest 2005 Employment People employed by the

Digest of Statistics for Museums, Libraries 2005 and … 2005 • Digest 2005 • Digest 2005 • 3 • Digest 2005 • Digest 2005 • Digest 2005 Employment People employed by the

Documents

PAPER DIGEST VOL. 50 592 1996 - Friardale Index Page Digest/1996-04-CollectorsDigest-v50-n592.pdf · PAPER DIGEST MARY CAD OGA N STORY PAPER CO LLE CTOR Founded 1941 by W .H .GAN

PAPER DIGEST VOL. 50 592 1996 - Friardale Index Page Digest/1996-04-CollectorsDigest-v50-n592.pdf · PAPER DIGEST MARY CAD OGA N STORY PAPER CO LLE CTOR Founded 1941 by W .H .GAN

Documents

Fotoalbums - Bauskatapa kalns gan skaistumam, gan atpŪtai, gan vasaras un ziemas priekiem!

Fotoalbums - Bauskatapa kalns gan skaistumam, gan atpŪtai, gan vasaras un ziemas priekiem!

Documents

Documents

Documents

Gaeaf WINTeR 2019 - Royal Welsh College of Music & Drama · Gaeaf WINTeR 2019 aRadc Ia Gan | By Tom Stoppard Cyfarwyddwr | Director Hannah Noone de NaaNc TIoN Gan | By clare Barron

Gaeaf WINTeR 2019 - Royal Welsh College of Music & Drama · Gaeaf WINTeR 2019 aRadc Ia Gan | By Tom Stoppard Cyfarwyddwr | Director Hannah Noone de NaaNc TIoN Gan | By clare Barron

Documents

SAFETY ccident nvestigation branch DIGEST - Welcome …€¦ · · 2014-11-12nvestigation branch MARINE ACCIDENT INVESTIGAis an TION BRANCH ... Cargo Securing Manual DPA – Designated

SAFETY ccident nvestigation branch DIGEST - Welcome …€¦ · · 2014-11-12nvestigation branch MARINE ACCIDENT INVESTIGAis an TION BRANCH ... Cargo Securing Manual DPA – Designated

Documents

GaN/Si LED and HEMTs - SEMI.ORGGaN/Si LED and HEMTs ... S.I. SiC GaN Bulk-GaN GaN Silicon GaN 3C SiC GaN Silicon Glass Ref.:Website of Yole Substrates for GaN Epitaxy on Si LED and... ·

GaN/Si LED and HEMTs - SEMI.ORGGaN/Si LED and HEMTs ... S.I. SiC GaN Bulk-GaN GaN Silicon GaN 3C SiC GaN Silicon Glass Ref.:Website of Yole Substrates for GaN Epitaxy on Si LED and... ·

Documents

POWER GaN Progress of GaN Transistors

POWER GaN Progress of GaN Transistors

Documents

PosIX-GAN: Generating multiple poses using GAN for Pose ...openaccess.thecvf.com/content_ECCVW_2018/papers/11131/...PosIX-GAN: Generating multiple poses using GAN for Pose-Invariant

PosIX-GAN: Generating multiple poses using GAN for Pose ...openaccess.thecvf.com/content_ECCVW_2018/papers/11131/...PosIX-GAN: Generating multiple poses using GAN for Pose-Invariant

Documents

POWER GaN GaN – Moving Quickly into Entirely New Markets

POWER GaN GaN – Moving Quickly into Entirely New Markets

Documents

STORY PAPER COLLECTORS' DIGEST Digest/2000-05-CollectorsDige… · PAPER DIGEST E dit o r: MARY CAD O GAN STO PAP E R COLLECTOR Foundin 194 1 by W .H .GANDER C O LLECTO RS ' DIGEST

STORY PAPER COLLECTORS' DIGEST Digest/2000-05-CollectorsDige… · PAPER DIGEST E dit o r: MARY CAD O GAN STO PAP E R COLLECTOR Foundin 194 1 by W .H .GANDER C O LLECTO RS ' DIGEST

Documents

Documents

GaN Transistors

GaN Transistors

Documents

AAIN DIGESTafricaain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/AAIN-Digest-1.pdf · 2018. 12. 26. · AAIN DIGEST Inside this edition Message from the CEO New Heights for incuba- tion, business

AAIN DIGESTafricaain.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/AAIN-Digest-1.pdf · 2018. 12. 26. · AAIN DIGEST Inside this edition Message from the CEO New Heights for incuba- tion, business

Documents

Analysis of Heat Dissipation in AlGaN/GaN HEMT with GaN ...Analysis of Heat Dissipation in AlGaN/GaN HEMT with GaN Micropits at GaN-SiC Interface by ... simulated using Silvaco (Atlas)

Analysis of Heat Dissipation in AlGaN/GaN HEMT with GaN ...Analysis of Heat Dissipation in AlGaN/GaN HEMT with GaN Micropits at GaN-SiC Interface by ... simulated using Silvaco (Atlas)

Documents

MedGAN CGAN b-GAN LAPGAN MPM-GAN AdaGAN Introduction … · iGAN IAN ID-CGAN IcGAN InfoGAN LAPGAN LR-GAN LS-GAN LSGAN MGAN MAGAN MAD-GAN MARTA-GAN MalGAN McGAN MedGAN MIX+GAN MPM-GAN

MedGAN CGAN b-GAN LAPGAN MPM-GAN AdaGAN Introduction … · iGAN IAN ID-CGAN IcGAN InfoGAN LAPGAN LR-GAN LS-GAN LSGAN MGAN MAGAN MAD-GAN MARTA-GAN MalGAN McGAN MedGAN MIX+GAN MPM-GAN

Documents

Aluminum Gallium Nitride (GaN)/GaN High Electron Mobility

Aluminum Gallium Nitride (GaN)/GaN High Electron Mobility

Documents

Simulation of p-GaN/ i-InGaN/n-GaN Solar Cell

Simulation of p-GaN/ i-InGaN/n-GaN Solar Cell

Engineering

Documents

Jasimuddin Rakhali gan - Fussilatbd Books/Jasimuddin/rakhali-gaan-by...Title: Jasimuddin Rakhali gan Author: Subject: Jasimuddin Rakhali gan Keywords: Jasimuddin Rakhali gan Created

Jasimuddin Rakhali gan - Fussilatbd Books/Jasimuddin/rakhali-gaan-by...Title: Jasimuddin Rakhali gan Author: Subject: Jasimuddin Rakhali gan Keywords: Jasimuddin Rakhali gan Created

Documents

GaN/Gd2O3/GaN Single Crystal Heterostructure …GaN on Gd2O3. Fig. 2 XTEM showing the structure of GaN/Gd2O3/GaN. It was unexpected that an hcp Gd2O3 single crystal would grow on GaN,

GaN/Gd2O3/GaN Single Crystal Heterostructure …GaN on Gd2O3. Fig. 2 XTEM showing the structure of GaN/Gd2O3/GaN. It was unexpected that an hcp Gd2O3 single crystal would grow on GaN,

Documents

From Bulk Gallium Nitride Material to Vertical GaN … Bulk Gallium Nitride Material to Vertical GaN Devices . Outline ... MOCVD (MBE) GaN HVPE material. GaN …

From Bulk Gallium Nitride Material to Vertical GaN … Bulk Gallium Nitride Material to Vertical GaN Devices . Outline ... MOCVD (MBE) GaN HVPE material. GaN …

Documents

Synthesis and Characterization of GaN Rods Prepared …file.scirp.org/pdf/ACES20120200012_66051043.pdfThe first step in the synthesis of GaN rods is the deposi- tion of gold clusters

Synthesis and Characterization of GaN Rods Prepared …file.scirp.org/pdf/ACES20120200012_66051043.pdfThe first step in the synthesis of GaN rods is the deposi- tion of gold clusters

Documents

Gan William Shakespeare Cyfieithiad gan Gwyn Thomas ...theatr.cymru/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/Act-II-Pecyn-Addysg-Theatr... · Gan William Shakespeare Cyfieithiad gan Gwyn Thomas

Gan William Shakespeare Cyfieithiad gan Gwyn Thomas ...theatr.cymru/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/Act-II-Pecyn-Addysg-Theatr... · Gan William Shakespeare Cyfieithiad gan Gwyn Thomas

Documents

GaN Power HEMT Tutorial: GaN Basicsiganpower.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/GaN-Power-Device-Tutorial-Part1-GaN-Basics.pdf1，Kevin J. Chen, Understanding the Dynamic Behavior in GaN-on-Si

GaN Power HEMT Tutorial: GaN Basicsiganpower.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/GaN-Power-Device-Tutorial-Part1-GaN-Basics.pdf1，Kevin J. Chen, Understanding the Dynamic Behavior in GaN-on-Si

Documents

MULTI-FOCUS ULTRASOUND IMAGING USING GENERATIVE ADVERSARIAL NETWORKShrivaz/Goudarzi_ISBI... · 2019. 11. 4. · Generative Adversarial Network (GAN) [2] to learn propaga-tion of US

MULTI-FOCUS ULTRASOUND IMAGING USING GENERATIVE ADVERSARIAL NETWORKShrivaz/Goudarzi_ISBI... · 2019. 11. 4. · Generative Adversarial Network (GAN) [2] to learn propaga-tion of US

Documents