Did Legalized Abortion Lower Crime Joyce2001

7/29/2019 Did Legalized Abortion Lower Crime Joyce2001

1/75

1%(5:25,1*3$3(56(5,(6

','/(*$/,=('$%257,21/2:(5&5,0("

7HG-R\.H

:RUNLQJ3DSHUKWWSZZZQEHURUJSDSHUVZ

1$7,21$/%85($82)(&2120,&5(6($5&+

0DVVD.KXVHWWV$YHQXH

&DPEULGJH0$

-XQH

7KHYLHZVH[SUHVVHGKHUHLQDUHWKRVHRIWKHDXWKRUDQGQRWQH.HVVDULO\WKRVHRIWKH1DWLRQDO%XUHDXRI(.RQRPL.5HVHDU.K

E\7HG-R\.H$OOULJKWVUHVHUYHG6KRUWVH.WLRQVRIWH[WQRWWRH[.HHGWZRSDUDJUDSKVPD\EH

TXRWHGZLWKRXWH[SOL.LWSHUPLVVLRQSURYLGHGWKDWIXOO.UHGLWLQ.OXGLQJQRWL.HLVJLYHQWRWKHVRXU.H


2/75

'LG/HJDOL]HG$ERUWLRQ/RZHU&ULPH"

7HG-R\.H

1%(5:RUNLQJ3DSHU1R

-XQH

-(/1R

$%#%

7KLV SDSHU H[DPLQHV WKH UHODWLRQVKLS EHWZHHQ WKHOHJDOL]DWLRQRI DERUWLRQ DQGVXEVHTXHQW

GH.UHDVHVLQ.ULPH,QD.XUUHQWVWXG\UHVHDU.KHUVHVWLPDWHWKDWWKHOHJDOL]DWLRQRIDERUWLRQH[SODLQVRYHU

KDOIRIWKHUH.HQWGH.OLQHLQQDWLRQDO.ULPHUDWHV7KHDVVR.LDWLRQLVLGHQWLILHGE\.RUUHODWLQJ.KDQJHVLQ

.ULPHZLWK.KDQJHVLQWKHDERUWLRQUDWLRZHLJKWHGE\WKHSURSRUWLRQRIWKH.ULPLQDOSRSXODWLRQH[SRVHG

WROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQ,QWKLVSDSHU,XVHDQDOWHUQDWLYHLGHQWLIL.DWLRQVWUDWHJ\,DQDO\]H.KDQJHVLQ

KRPL.LGHDQGDUUHVWUDWHVDPRQJWHHQVDQG\RXQJDGXOWVERUQEHIRUHDQGDIWHULQVWDWHVWKDWOHJDOL]HG

DERUWLRQSULRUWR5RHY:DGH,.RPSDUHWKHVH.KDQJHVZLWKYDULDWLRQLQKRPL.LGHDQGDUUHVWUDWHV

DPRQJ.RKRUWVIURPWKHVDPHSHULRGEXWZKRZHUHXQH[SRVHGWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQ,ILQGOLWWOHHYLGHQ.H

WRVXSSRUWWKH.ODLPWKDWOHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQ.DXVHGWKHUHGX.WLRQLQ.ULPH,.RQ.OXGHWKDWWKHDVVR.LDWLRQ

EHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQG.ULPHLVQRW.DXVDOEXWPRVWOLNHO\WKHUHVXOWRI.RQIRXQGLQJIURPXQPHDVXUHG

SHULRGHIIH.WVVX.KDV.KDQJHVLQ.UD.N.R.DLQHXVHDQGLWVVSLOORYHUHIIH.WV

7HG-R\.H

1DWLRQDO%XUHDXRI(.RQRPL.5HVHDU.K

)LIWK$YHQXH WK)ORRU

1HZ


3/75

,,QWURGX.WLRQ

,QDUH.HQWDQG.RQWURYHUVLDODUWL.OH'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWWSUHVHQWHYLGHQ.HWKDWWKH

OHJDOL]DWLRQRIDERUWLRQLQH[SODLQVRYHUKDOIRIWKHUH.HQWGH.OLQHLQ.ULPHD.URVVWKH86

0RUHRYHUWKH\VXJJHVWWKDWWKHIXOOLPSD.WRQ.ULPHRI5RHY:DGHZLOOQRWEHIHOWIRUDQRWKHU

\HDUV7RTXRWH2XUUHVXOWVVXJJHVWWKDWDOOHOVHHTXDOOHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQZLOOD..RXQWIRU

SHUVLVWHQWGH.OLQHVRISHU.HQWD\HDULQ.ULPHRYHUWKHQH[WWZRGH.DGHVS,IWUXH

SROL.LHVWKDWUHGX.HDERUWLRQZRXOGEHH[SH.WHGWRLQ.UHDVH.ULPHZKHUHDVSROL.LHVWKDWLQ.UHDVH

DERUWLRQVX.KDVWKHUH.HQWO\DSSURYHGDERUWLRQSLOOPLJKWKDYHWKHRSSRVLWHHIIH.W*LYHQWKH

VR.LDO.RVWVDVVR.LDWHGZLWK.ULPHDQGWKH.RQWURYHUV\VXUURXQGLQJDERUWLRQD.DXVDOOLQN

EHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQG.ULPHKDVSURIRXQGLPSOL.DWLRQVIRUVR.LDOSROL.\

7KHSXUSRVHRIWKLVSDSHULVWRDQDO\]HWKHDVVR.LDWLRQEHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQG.ULPH

'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWWSUHVHQWD.RPSHOOLQJ.DVHWKDWWKHDVVR.LDWLRQEHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQG.ULPHLV

SRWHQWLDOO\.DXVDO$..RUGLQJWRWKHDXWKRUVLQ.UHDVHVLQWKHUDWLRRIUHSRUWHGDERUWLRQVWROLYH

ELUWKVWKHDERUWLRQUDWLRDUHVWURQJO\DVVR.LDWHGZLWKORZHU.ULPHDQGDUUHVWUDWHV0RUHRYHU

WKHPDJQLWXGHRIWKHHIIH.WLVUHPDUNDEOH$SHU.HQWLQ.UHDVHLQWKHPHDQDERUWLRQUDWLRLV

DVVR.LDWHGZLWKDQSHU.HQWGH.UHDVHLQYLROHQW.ULPHDQSHU.HQWGH.UHDVHLQSURSHUW\.ULPH

DQGDSHU.HQWGH.UHDVHLQPXUGHU7KHVHHIIH.WVDUHJHQHUDOO\ODUJHUDQGPRUHSUH.LVHO\

HVWLPDWHGWKDQWKHHIIH.WVRILQ.DU.HUDWLRQDQGSROL.HPDQSRZHU7KXVWKHPDJQLWXGHRIWKH

DVVR.LDWLRQEHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQG.ULPHWKHXVHRIQRQH[SHULPHQWDOPHWKRGVDQGWKH

.RQWURYHUVLDOQDWXUHRIWKHSROL.\LPSOL.DWLRQVVXJJHVWWKDWIXUWKHUH[DPLQDWLRQLVZDUUDQWHG

0\HPSLUL.DODSSURD.KWRWKHDQDO\VLVRIDERUWLRQDQG.ULPHGLIIHUVIURPWKDWRI'RQRKXH

DQG/HYLWWDQGIROORZVSUHYLRXVHIIRUWVWRDVVR.LDWHOHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQZLWKIHUWLOLW\V.KRROLQJ

DQG.KLOGSRYHUW\/HYLQHHWDO$QJULVWDQG(YDQV*UXEHU/HYLQHDQG6WDLJHU

6SH.LIL.DOO\,HVWLPDWHDUHGX.HGIRUPHTXDWLRQLQZKL.K.KDQJHVLQDUUHVWDQGKRPL.LGH


4/75

UDWHVDPRQJ.RKRUWVH[SRVHGWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQLQWKHSHULRGSULRUWR5RHDUH.RPSDUHGZLWK

.RKRUWVXQH[SRVHG,QILYHVWDWHV$ODVND&DOLIRUQLD+DZDLL1HZ


5/75

UHSRUWLQJLPSURYHVLWPD\VWLOOEHDSRRUSUR[\IRUXQLQWHQGHGELUWKVDYHUWHG'RQRKXHDQG

/HYLWWDVVXPHWKDWGLIIHUHQ.HVLQDERUWLRQUDWLRVZLWKLQVWDWHVRYHUWLPHUHIOH.WGLIIHUHQ.HVLQ

XQLQWHQGHG.KLOGEHDULQJ)HZZRXOG.RQWHQGWKDWDERUWLRQLVDQXQDPELJXRXVPHDVXUHRI

XQZDQWHGSUHJQDQ.\%XWLWGRHVQRWIROORZWKDWGLIIHUHQ.HVLQWKHJURZWKRIDERUWLRQZLWKLQ

VWDWHVLQWKHSHULRGDIWHU5RHPHDVXUHUHODWLYH.KDQJHVLQSUHJQDQ.LHVWKDWZRXOGKDYHEH.RPH

XQLQWHQGHGELUWKV)RULQVWDQ.HEHWZHHQDQGWKH86IHUWLOLW\UDWHIHOOIURPWR

ELUWKVSHUZRPHQWRWKHUHSRUWHGOHJDODERUWLRQUDWHRYHUWKLVVDPHSHULRGURVH

IURPDERUWLRQVSHUZRPHQWRLQWRLQ+RZHYHUIURPWR

WKHIHUWLOLW\UDWHURVHWRGHVSLWHDSHU.HQWLQ.UHDVHLQWKHDERUWLRQUDWHIURPWR

RRQLQHWDO6X.KVXPPDU\VWDWLVWL.VDUHDWEHVWVXJJHVWLYH1HYHUWKHOHVVWKH\

XQGHUV.RUHWKHSRVVLELOLW\WKDWWKHOLQNEHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQGXQLQWHQGHGIHUWLOLW\LVZHDNHUWKDQ

'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWWDVVXPH

$WKLUGDGYDQWDJHRIWKHUHGX.HGIRUPZLWK.DWHJRUL.DOPHDVXUHVRIDERUWLRQOHJDOL]DWLRQ

LVWKDWSUHYLRXVVWXGLHVKDYHGHPRQVWUDWHGDPDUNHGGH.OLQHLQUHODWLYHIHUWLOLW\UDWHVLQUHSHDO

VWDWHVEHWZHHQDQG%HUNRYDQG6NODU-R\.HDQG0R.DQ/HYLQHHWDO

$QJULVWDQG(YDQV7KLVGH.OLQHLQIHUWLOLW\UDWHVUHSUHVHQWVDPRUH.UHGLEOHVRXU.H

RILGHQWLI\LQJYDULDWLRQZLWKZKL.KWRXQ.RYHUDUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQG.ULPHWKDQ

ZLWKLQVWDWH.KDQJHVLQUHSRUWHGOHJDODERUWLRQVEHWZHHQDQG

)LQDOO\DUHGX.HGIRUPDQDO\VLVRIDUUHVWVDQGKRPL.LGHVE\VLQJOH\HDURIDJHDOORZVIRU

DVLPSOHEXWGLUH.W.RPSDULVRQRI.RKRUWVH[SRVHGDQGXQH[SRVHGWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQ'LGIRU

H[DPSOHWKHDUUHVWUDWHIRUPXUGHUDPRQJ\HDUROGVIDOORULQ.UHDVHOHVVLQUHSHDOUHODWLYHWR

QRQUHSHDOVWDWHVDPRQJWKRVHERUQEHWZHHQDQG"

7KHQXPEHURIDERUWLRQVLVEDVHGRQWKH&HQWHUVIRU'LVHDVH&RQWURODQG3UHYHQWLRQ&'&VXUYH\RIVWDWHKHDOWKGHSDUWPHQWVZKL.KWHQGWREHORZHUWKDQWRWDOVUHSRUWHGE\WKH$ODQ*XWWPD.KHU,QVWLWXWH$*,,XVHWKH&'&HVWLPDWHVEH.DXVH$*,GLG

QRWUHSRUWDERUWLRQVIRU


6/75

,.RQ.OXGHWKDWWKHDVVR.LDWLRQEHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQG.ULPHLVQRW.DXVDOEXWPRVWOLNHO\

WKHUHVXOWRI.RQIRXQGLQJEHWZHHQWKHJURZWKLQDERUWLRQDQG.KDQJHVLQ.UD.N.R.DLQHDQG

KDQGJXQXVH0\.RQ.OXVLRQLVEDVHGRQWKHIROORZLQJILQGLQJV

)LUVWWKHDERUWLRQUDWHLQUHSHDOVWDWHVEHWZHHQWRLVDOPRVWGRXEOHWKDWRIQRQ

UHSHDOVWDWHV


7/75

DVVR.LDWLRQEHWZHHQIHUWLOLW\DQG.ULPH7KHVHUHJUHVVLRQVDUHSHUVXDVLYHIRUVHYHUDOUHDVRQV

WKHZHOOGR.XPHQWHGGH.OLQHLQIHUWLOLW\DVVR.LDWHGZLWKOHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQLQWKHSUH5RHSHULRG

DSSHDUV.OHDUO\UHODWHGWRWKHGH.OLQHLQXQLQWHQGHG.KLOGEHDULQJWKHD..XUD.\ZLWKZKL.K

ELUWKVDV.RPSDUHGWRDERUWLRQVDUHPHDVXUHGLQWKHVDQGHDUO\VHOLPLQDWHV

PHDVXUHPHQWHUURUDQGWKHDYDLODELOLW\RIIHUWLOLW\UDWHVE\UD.HLQ.UHDVHVWKHSRZHUWRGHWH.W

DQHIIH.WJLYHQWKHJUHDWHUGHPRJUDSKL.LPSD.WRIOHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQRQEOD.NIHUWLOLW\

)LQDOO\'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWWVSULPDU\UHJUHVVLRQVDUHVHQVLWLYHWRIXQ.WLRQDOIRUP,WLV

QRW.OHDUDSULRULZKDWWKH.RUUH.WIXQ.WLRQDOUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQ.ULPHDQGXQLQWHQGHG

.KLOGEHDULQJVKRXOGEH'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWWUHJUHVVWKHQDWXUDOORJDULWKPRI.ULPHRQWKHOHYHORI

WKHHIIH.WLYHDERUWLRQUDWLR:KHQ,UXQWKHH[D.WVDPHUHJUHVVLRQVEXWXVHWKHORJRIWKHHIIH.WLYH

DERUWLRQUDWLRWKH.RHIIL.LHQWRQDERUWLRQEH.RPHVSRVLWLYHDQGVWDWLVWL.DOO\VLJQLIL.DQWWKH

.RPSOHWHRSSRVLWHRIZKDWWKH\UHSRUW

,,(PSLUL.DO,VVXHV

7KHUHDUHWZRHPSLUL.DO.KDOOHQJHVWRHVWDEOLVKLQJDOLQNEHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQG.ULPH

)LUVWRQHPXVWGHPRQVWUDWHDUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQGXQLQWHQGHG.KLOGEHDULQJ

&OHDUO\DERUWHGSUHJQDQ.LHVDUHXQZDQWHG7KHSURSHU.RXQWHUID.WXDOKRZHYHULVXQZDQWHGRU

PLVWLPHGSUHJQDQ.LHVWKDWZRXOGKDYHEH.RPHXQLQWHQGHGELUWKVKDGDERUWLRQUDWHVEHHQORZHU

1HZ


8/75

&RUN%OXPVWHLQDQG:ROOPDQ0RUHRYHUWKHXSVXUJHLQ.ULPHZDV.RQ.HQWUDWHG

DOPRVWH[.OXVLYHO\DPRQJWKRVHXQGHU\HDUVRIDJHDQGDIIH.WHGEOD.NVPRUHWKDQZKLWHV

8QOHVVRQH.RQWUROVIRUWKHVHVRXU.HVRI.RQIRXQGLQJLWLVGLIIL.XOWWR.RQYLQ.LQJO\DWWULEXWHWKH

GH.OLQHLQ.ULPHWRWKHOHJDOL]DWLRQRIDERUWLRQ

$$ERUWLRQDQGXQLQWHQGHG.KLOGEHDULQJ

$VRXWOLQHGE\'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWWWKHUHDUHVHYHUDOZD\VLQZKL.KOHJDODERUWLRQ.DQ

DIIH.W.ULPH&RKRUWVL]HLVRQH)HZHUELUWKVPHDQIHZHU.ULPLQDOVLQVXEVHTXHQW\HDUV

/HJDODERUWLRQKRZHYHUPD\DOVRDIIH.W.ULPHUDWHVE\DOORZLQJZRPHQSUHGRPLQDQWO\SRRU

\RXQJDQGPLQRULW\WRDYRLGDQXQLQWHQGHGELUWK6LQ.H.KLOGUHQIURPGLVDGYDQWDJHG

ED.NJURXQGVDUHPRUHOLNHO\WR.RPPLW.ULPHVDVWHHQRUDGXOWVWKHUHVXOWRIWKLVVHOH.WLYH

UHGX.WLRQLQXQLQWHQGHG.KLOGEHDULQJLVDGURSLQ.ULPHUDWHVDSSUR[LPDWHO\WR\HDUVODWHU

7KHUHDUHWZR.RPSRQHQWVRIXQLQWHQGHG.KLOGEHDULQJWKURXJKZKL.KDERUWLRQPD\

RSHUDWH/HJDODERUWLRQPD\LPSURYHWKHWLPLQJRIELUWKV$VDUHVXOW.KLOGUHQDUHERUQLQWR

PRUHQXUWXULQJHQYLURQPHQWVWKDQWKH\ZRXOGKDYHEHHQKDGD..HVVWRDERUWLRQEHHQPRUH

UHVWUL.WLYH/HJDODERUWLRQPD\DOVRUHGX.HIDPLO\VL]HZKL.KPD\LQ.UHDVHUHVRXU.HVGHYRWHG

WRHD.K.KLOG(YLGHQ.H.RQVLVWHQWZLWKDUHGX.WLRQLQ.RPSOHWHGIDPLO\VL]HZRXOGEHDQ

LQYHUVHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQGIHUWLOLW\6WDWHVZLWKJUHDWHUDERUWLRQUDWHVZRXOGKDYH

ORZHUIHUWLOLW\UDWHVDOOHOVH.RQVWDQW(YLGHQ.HWKDWDERUWLRQLPSURYHVWKHWLPLQJRIELUWKV

ZRXOGEHPRUHGLIIL.XOWWRGR.XPHQW$IWHUDQLQLWLDOGH.OLQHLQIHUWLOLW\UDWHVZLWKWKHDGYHQWRI

OHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQWKHUHPD\EHOLWWOHDVVR.LDWLRQEHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQGIHUWLOLW\UDWHVDVGHOD\HG

.KLOGEHDULQJLV.RPSOHWHG+RZHYHUHYHQLIDERUWLRQRQO\LPSURYHVWKHWLPLQJRIELUWKVWKHUH

VWLOOVKRXOGEHDQLQYHUVHDVVR.LDWLRQEHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQGWHHQIHUWLOLW\7KDWLVVWDWHVZLWK


9/75


10/75


11/75


12/75


13/75


14/75


15/75


16/75


17/75


18/75

,SHUIRUPDVLPLODUGLIIHUHQ.HLQGLIIHUHQ.HDQDO\VLVRIUD.HVSH.LIL.KRPL.LGHUDWHVIRU

WHHQVWR\HDUVRIDJHDQG\RXQJDGXOWVDJHVWR$OPRVWDOOWHHQVLQUHSHDOVWDWHVWKDW

.RPHRIDJHEHWZHHQDQGZHUHERUQDIWHUDQGWKXVZHUHH[SRVHGWROHJDOL]HG

DERUWLRQLQXWHURVHH7DEOH%\.RQWUDVWLQDOO\RXQJDGXOWVDJHVWRZHUH

ERUQSULRUWRDQGZHUHXQH[SRVHGWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQ&RQVHTXHQWO\.KDQJHVLQ.ULPH

EHWZHHQDQGDPRQJ\RXQJDGXOWVLQUHSHDOVWDWHV.DSWXUHYDULDWLRQXQUHODWHGWR

OHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQDQGVHUYHDVDPHDQVRIHOLPLQDWLQJSHULRGHIIH.WVDPRQJWHHQV

2QO\KRPL.LGHGDWDDUHUD.HVSH.LIL.DQGSRSXODWLRQGDWDE\\HDUVWDWHDQGUD.HDUH

DYDLODEOHRQO\LQILYH\HDUJURXSLQJV&RQVHTXHQWO\,ORVHVRPHSUH.LVLRQLQWKHDVVLJQPHQWWR

H[SRVHGDQGXQH[SRVHGJURXSVDV.RPSDUHGZLWKWKHDQDO\VLVE\VLQJOH\HDURIDJH+RZHYHU

WKHSDWWHUQRIKRPL.LGHYDULHVVLJQLIL.DQWO\E\UD.HDQGPRVWOLNHO\UHIOH.WVGLVSDUDWHUHVSRQVHVWR

WKH.UD.NHSLGHPL.6LQ.HP\REMH.WLYHLVWRHOLPLQDWHSHULRGHIIH.WVVWUDWLIL.DWLRQE\UD.H

HQKDQ.HVWKH.UHGLELOLW\RIWKH.RPSDULVRQJURXSV$QRWKHUDGYDQWDJHRIWKHPRUHDJJUHJDWH

DJHJURXSLQJVLVWKDW,ORVHIHZHUREVHUYDWLRQVEH.DXVHRI]HURKRPL.LGHUDWHV7KHUHOHYDQW

UHJUHVVLRQPRGHO.DQEHZULWWHQDVIROORZV

5HSHDO7HHQ


19/75

EHIRUHDQGDIWHUH[SRVXUHWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQDPRQJWHHQVUHODWLYHWR\RXQJDGXOWVLQUHSHDO

UHODWLYHWRQRQUHSHDOVWDWHV,IDERUWLRQORZHUV.ULPHWKHQVKRXOGEHQHJDWLYH

,9 5HVXOWV

$ $ERUWLRQIHUWLOLW\DQGXQLQWHQGHG.KLOGEHDULQJ

7KHILUVWVHWRIUHVXOWVSHUWDLQVWRWKHUHODWLRQVKLSVDPRQJDERUWLRQIHUWLOLW\DQG

XQLQWHQGHG.KLOGEHDULQJ)LJXUHGLVSOD\VWLPHVHULHVRIIHUWLOLW\DQGUHVLGHQWDERUWLRQUDWHVIRU

UHSHDODQGQRQUHSHDOVWDWHVEHWZHHQDQG

7KHUDWHVDUHELUWKVRUDERUWLRQVSHU

ZRPHQWR\HDUVRIDJH7KHILUVWREVHUYDWLRQLVWKDWWKHGLIIHUHQ.HLQIHUWLOLW\UDWHV

EHWZHHQUHSHDODQGQRQUHSHDOVWDWHVLVVPDOODERXWELUWKVSHUZRPHQDQGUHODWLYHO\

.RQVWDQWEHWZHHQDQG7KHJDSZLGHQVDIWHUDQGLVHVVHQWLDOO\.ORVHGE\

/HYLQHHWDO+RZHYHUWKHJDSLQDERUWLRQUDWHVEHWZHHQUHSHDODQGQRQUHSHDOVWDWHVLV

PX.KODUJHUDSSUR[LPDWHO\DERUWLRQVSHUZRPHQDQGGRHVQRWGLPLQLVKDIWHU

,PSRUWDQWO\WKHGLV.UHSDQ.\LQDERUWLRQUDWHVEHWZHHQUHSHDODQGQRQUHSHDOVWDWHVLVQRW

UHIOH.WHGLQDGLIIHUHQ.HLQIHUWLOLW\UDWHVDIWHU,IWKHDERUWLRQUDWH.DSWXUHVXQLQWHQGHG

SUHJQDQ.LHVWKDWZRXOGKDYHEH.RPHXQLQWHQGHGELUWKVWKHQRQHZRXOGH[SH.WWRREVHUYHD

JUHDWHUGLIIHUHQ.HLQIHUWLOLW\UDWHVEHWZHHQWKHWZRJURXSVRIVWDWHV

2QHH[SODQDWLRQIRUWKHGLV.UHSDQ.\LVWKDWDERUWLRQLVXVHGPRUHIUHTXHQWO\DVD

VXEVWLWXWHIRU.RQWUD.HSWLRQLQUHSHDOVWDWHVEH.DXVHWKH.RVWDQGVWLJPDDVVR.LDWHGZLWKDERUWLRQ

DUHOHVV7KXVWKHUDWHRIXQLQWHQGHG.KLOGEHDULQJPD\EHVLPLODUD.URVVVWDWHVGHVSLWHGLIIHUHQW

UDWHVRIDERUWLRQ$QRWKHULQWHUSUHWDWLRQ.RQVLVWHQWZLWKWKHWLPHVHULHVSDWWHUQVLQ)LJXUHLV

WKDWDERUWLRQDIIH.WVRQO\WKHWLPLQJRIELUWKVDQGQRW.RPSOHWHGIDPLO\VL]H7KXVWKHLQLWLDO

GH.OLQHLQIHUWLOLW\UDWHVDVVR.LDWHGZLWKHDUO\OHJDOL]DWLRQUHSUHVHQWVDVKLIWLQWKHWLPLQJRIELUWKV

,XVHUHVLGHQWELUWKDQGDERUWLRQUDWHV'DWDRQUHVLGHQWDERUWLRQZHUH.RQVWUX.WHGIURPWKH&HQWHUVIRU'LVHDVH&RQWURO+HQVKDZ)RUUHVW6XOOLYDQDQG7LHW]HDQG+HQVKDZDQG9DQ9RUW


20/75

IURPDGROHV.HQ.HWRWKHHDUO\WZHQWLHVIURPWKHHDUO\WZHQWLHVWRWKHODWHUWZHQWLHVDQGVRRQ

7KLVZRXOGSUHVHUYH'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWWVDUJXPHQWWKDWVWDWHVZLWKJUHDWHULQ.UHDVHVLQDERUWLRQ

KDGIHZHUPLVWLPHGELUWKVDQGORZHUVXEVHTXHQW.ULPHUDWHV+RZHYHULI'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWW

DUH.RUUH.WZHVWLOOVKRXOGREVHUYHDQHIIH.WRIOHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQRQWHHQIHUWLOLW\UDWHVLQWKH

SHULRGDIWHU5RHVLQ.HQRDJHJURXSGHOD\V.KLOGEHDULQJLQWRDGROHV.HQ.H

$VDIXUWKHUH[DPLQDWLRQ,HVWLPDWHGDVHULHVRIUHJUHVVLRQVZLWKWRWDODQGWHHQVWDWH

IHUWLOLW\UDWHVDVWKHGHSHQGHQWYDULDEOH,QWKHILUVWPRGHO,UHJUHVVHGIHUWLOLW\UDWHVRQDVHWRI

LQGL.DWRUYDULDEOHVIRULQWHUD.WLRQVEHWZHHQUHSHDOVWDWHVDQGSHULRGVEHIRUHDQGDIWHU5RH,Q

WKHVH.RQGVHWRIPRGHOV,UHJUHVVHGIHUWLOLW\UDWHVRQWKHDERUWLRQUDWH7KHSRLQWLVWRHVWLPDWH

WKHVLPSOH.RUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQGIHUWLOLW\DGMXVWHGIRUVWDWHDQG\HDUIL[HGHIIH.WV

5HVXOWVDUHVKRZQLQ7DEOH&ROXPQVDQGODUJHO\UHSOL.DWHWKHUHVXOWVLQ/HYLQHHWDO

6LQ.HWKHGHSHQGHQWYDULDEOHLVLQORJVWKH.RHIIL.LHQWRQ5HSHDOLQGL.DWHV

WKDWWRWDOIHUWLOLW\UDWHVIHOOSHU.HQWDQGWHHQIHUWLOLW\UDWHVSHU.HQWPRUHLQUHSHDOUHODWLYHWR

QRQUHSHDOVWDWHVEHWZHHQDQG&ROXPQVDQGSUHVHQWVWKHUHVXOWVRID

UHJUHVVLRQRIORJIHUWLOLW\UDWHVRQORJDERUWLRQUDWHV7KHLQWHUD.WLRQWHUPEHWZHHQUHSHDOVWDWHV

DQGDERUWLRQUDWHVDOORZVWKHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQGIHUWLOLW\WRYDU\EHWZHHQUHSHDO

DQGQRQUHSHDOVWDWHV7KHLQWHUD.WLRQWHUPVDUHSRVLWLYHWKH\LQGL.DWHWKDWLQUHSHDOVWDWHVD

RQHSHU.HQWLQ.UHDVHLQWKHDERUWLRQUDWHLVDVVR.LDWHGZLWKSHU.HQWLQ.UHDVHLQWKHIHUWLOLW\

UDWHRIDOOZRPHQDQGDLQ.UHDVHLQIHUWLOLW\UDWHRIWHHQV

,QQRQUHSHDOVWDWHVWKH

UHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQGIHUWLOLW\LVSRVLWLYHEXWVWDWLVWL.DOO\LQVLJQLIL.DQW,I,OLPLWWKH

UHJUHVVLRQWRWKHSRVW5RHSHULRGDIWHUZKL.KDERUWLRQVZHUHPHDVXUHGPRUHD..XUDWHO\WKH

SRVLWLYH.RHIIL.LHQWVIRUUHSHDOVWDWHVEH.RPHHYHQODUJHU>[email protected]

$.WXDOO\,XVHGDWZR\HDUPRYLQJDYHUDJHRIWKHDERUWLRQUDWHWRD..RXQWIRUWKHPRQWKGLIIHUHQ.HLQWKHOHQJWKRISUHJQDQ.\EHWZHHQDQDERUWLRQDQGELUWK

7KHVHHVWLPDWHVDUHREWDLQHGE\VXPPLQJDQGIRUDOOZRPHQDQGDQGIRUWHHQV


21/75

DVVR.LDWLRQEHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQGWHHQIHUWLOLW\UDWHVLVLQ.RQVLVWHQWZLWKWKHVWRU\WKDWVWDWHVZLWK

KLJKHUDERUWLRQUDWHVKDYHORZHUUDWHVRIXQLQWHQGHG.KLOGEHDULQJ(YHQLIDERUWLRQKDGQRHIIH.W

RQ.RPSOHWHGIHUWLOLW\DQGRQO\DIIH.WHGWLPLQJZHVKRXOGVWLOOVHHDQHJDWLYH.RUUHODWLRQ

EHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQGWHHQIHUWLOLW\

'HVSLWHDSRVLWLYHRULQVLJQLIL.DQWUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQGIHUWLOLW\UDWHVRQH

PLJKWDUJXHWKDWELUWKVLQVWDWHVZLWKJUHDWHUDERUWLRQUDWHVDUHPRUHIDYRUDEO\VHOH.WHGRUPRUH

LQWHQGHG-R\.HDQG*URVVPDQ,QGHHG'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWWVDUJXPHQWLVHVVHQWLDOO\WKDW

OHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQLQ.UHDVHVWKHDJJUHJDWHLQWHQGHGQHVVRIELUWKV7KXVVWDWHVZLWK

.RPSDUDWLYHO\KLJKDERUWLRQUDWHVVKRXOGKDYHDVPDOOHUSURSRUWLRQRIELUWKVIURPSUHJQDQ.LHV

GHV.ULEHGDVXQLQWHQGHG7RSURYLGHVRPHLQVLJKWDVWRWKHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQG

ELUWKVIURPXQLQWHQGHGSUHJQDQ.LHV,UHJUHVVHGGL.KRWRPRXVLQGL.DWRUVRISUHJQDQ.\LQWHQWLRQ

RQVWDWHDERUWLRQUDWHVZLWKGDWDIURPWKH3UHJQDQ.\5LVNDQG$VVHVVPHQW0RQLWRULQJ6\VWHPRU

35$06VHH6H.WLRQ,,,$5HVXOWVDUHVKRZQLQ7DEOH,Q.ROXPQVDQGWKHGHSHQGHQW

YDULDEOHLVRQHLIDZRPDQGHV.ULEHGKHUSUHJQDQ.\DVXQLQWHQGHGPLVWLPHGRUXQZDQWHGDQG

]HURLILQWHQGHG,Q.ROXPQVDQGWKHGHSHQGHQWYDULDEOHLVRQHLIWKHSUHJQDQ.\ZDV

XQZDQWHGDQG]HURRWKHUZLVH(D.KPRGHOLQ.OXGHV.RQWUROVIRUDJHUD.HDQG\HDUDQGKDOIWKH

VSH.LIL.DWLRQVLQ.OXGHVWDWHIL[HGHIIH.WV7KHDVVR.LDWLRQEHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQGXQLQWHQGHG

SUHJQDQ.\LVSRVLWLYHDOWKRXJKVWDWLVWL.DOO\LQVLJQLIL.DQWLQWKHVSH.LIL.DWLRQZLWKVWDWHIL[HG

HIIH.WV7KHUHLVDQHJDWLYHDVVR.LDWLRQEHWZHHQWKHDERUWLRQUDWHDQGDQXQZDQWHGSUHJQDQ.\LQ

WKHPRGHOZLWKIL[HGHIIH.WVEXWLWLVPHDVXUHGLPSUH.LVHO\

7KHUHDUHWZR.DYHDWVWRWKLVH[HU.LVH)LUVW35$06LVDVXUYH\RIZRPHQWKDWJDYHELUWKDQGWKXVLVQRWWKHDSSURSULDWH

.RXQWHUID.WXDOIRUDERUWHGSUHJQDQ.LHV6H.RQGWKHGDWDSHUWDLQWRZKHUHDV'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWWXVHDERUWLRQGDWDIURP$ERUWLRQUDWHVKRZHYHUDUHKLJKO\VHULDOO\.RUUHODWHG'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWWUHSRUWWKH\HDU.RUUHODWLRQWREH0RUHRYHUXQLQWHQGHGELUWKVDYHUWHGDUHXQREVHUYHG7KXVVX.KH[HU.LVHVDUHRQHRIWKHIHZZD\VDYDLODEOHRIDVVHVVLQJZKHUH.KDQJHVLQDERUWLRQUDWHVDUH.RUUHODWHGZLWK.KDQJHVLQELUWKVGHV.ULEHGDVXQLQWHQGHG


22/75


23/75


24/75


25/75

DUUHVWUDWHVIRUYLROHQW.ULPHSURSHUW\.ULPHDQGPXUGHUEHWZHHQWKHDQGELUWK

.RKRUWVIDOORUULVHOHVVE\DQGSHU.HQWUHVSH.WLYHO\LQUHSHDOUHODWLYHWRQRQUHSHDO

VWDWHV6LPLODUGH.OLQHVDUHREVHUYHGIRUKRPL.LGHYL.WLPL]DWLRQDQGRIIHQGLQJUDWHV.ROXPQV

$QXQH[SH.WHGUHVXOWKRZHYHULVWKDWWKHDGYDQWDJHDVVR.LDWHGZLWKHDUO\OHJDOL]DWLRQLQ

UHSHDOVWDWHVRIWHQEH.RPHVJUHDWHUIRUPRUHUH.HQW.RKRUWV,QGHHGWKHUHODWLYHGH.OLQHLQ

PXUGHUDUUHVWUDWHV7DEOH.ROXPQDPRQJ.RKRUWVERUQEHWZHHQLQUHSHDOVWDWHVLV

DOPRVWILYHWLPHVJUHDWHUWKDQWKHUHODWLYHGH.OLQHH[SHULHQ.HGE\WKH.RKRUWV

7DEOHVDDQGEGLVSOD\UHVXOWVLQZKL.KWKHUHGX.HGIRUPHIIH.WVRIOHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQ

RQ.ULPHDUHDOORZHGWRYDU\E\DJHDQG.RKRUW&RHIIL.LHQWVLQHD.K.ROXPQVKRZWKHUHODWLYH

GLIIHUHQ.HLQDUUHVWDQGKRPL.LGHUDWHVE\ELUWK.RKRUWVDQGVLQJOH\HDURIDJHLQUHSHDOUHODWLYHWR

QRQUHSHDOVWDWHV%\DQGODUJHWKHHVWLPDWHVTXDQWLI\WKHSDWWHUQVREVHUYHGLQ)LJXUHV

&RQVLGHUWKH.RPSDULVRQRIWKHDQGELUWK.RKRUWVIRUWHHQV\HDUVRIDJH

2QO\RIWKH.RHIIL.LHQWVLQ7DEOHVDDQGEDUHQHJDWLYHDQGQRQHDUHVWDWLVWL.DOO\

VLJQLIL.DQWDWWKHSHU.HQWOHYHO>.ROXPQVLQ7DEOHVDDQGE@5HVXOWVDUHWKH

RSSRVLWHDPRQJ\RXQJDGXOWVDJHVWRWZHQW\VHYHQRIWKH.RHIIL.LHQWVLQWKHORZHUKDOI

RI.ROXPQVDQGDUHQHJDWLYHDQGRYHUKDOIDUHVWDWLVWL.DOO\VLJQLIL.DQW,QDGGLWLRQWKH

PDJQLWXGHRIWKHHIIH.WRIDERUWLRQOHJDOL]DWLRQRQKRPL.LGHLVRIWHQODUJHZLWKUHODWLYHGH.OLQHV

RIEHWZHHQDQGSHU.HQWDPRQJ.RKRUWVLQUHSHDOUHODWLYHWRQRQUHSHDOVWDWHV

(VWLPDWHVIRUWKH.RKRUWVEXWHVSH.LDOO\WKHELUWK.RKRUWVDUHDOVR

XQH[SH.WHG$V*UXEHU/HYLQHDQG6WDLJHUDUJXHRQHZRXOGH[SH.WWKH.RHIIL.LHQWVIRU

.RKRUWVLQUHSHDOVWDWHVERUQDIWHU5RHY:DGHWRWHQGWR]HURDVQDWLRQDOOHJDOL]DWLRQRIDERUWLRQ

OHDGVWRUHODWLYHGH.UHDVHVLQ.ULPHLQWKHQRQUHSHDOVWDWHVZKDWWKHDXWKRUVWHUPERXQ.HED.N

1RWHDOVRWKDW,VKRZKRPL.LGHYL.WLPL]DWLRQUDWHVE\VWDWHRIUHVLGHQ.H.ROXPQDQGVWDWHRIELUWK.ROXPQ7KH

VLPLODULW\RIWKH.RHIIL.LHQWVVXJJHVWVWKDWPLJUDWLRQIURPVWDWHRIELUWKWRVWDWHRIUHVLGHQ.HPD\QRWEHDQLPSRUWDQWVRXU.HRIPLV.ODVVLIL.DWLRQLQWKHH[SRVXUHPHDVXUH


26/75

,QVWHDG,ILQGWKDWWKH.RHIIL.LHQWVRQROGHUWHHQVERUQEHWZHHQLQUHSHDOVWDWHVDUH

QHJDWLYHODUJHLQPDJQLWXGHDQGVWDWLVWL.DOO\VLJQLIL.DQW

7DNHQWRJHWKHUWKHWLPHVHULHVSORWVDQGUHGX.HGIRUPUHJUHVVLRQVDUHLQ.RQVLVWHQWZLWKD

VWURQJ.RKRUWHIIH.W:K\VKRXOGWHHQVH[SRVHGWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQUHVSRQGGLIIHUHQWO\IURP

\RXQJDGXOWV":K\GRGLIIHUHQ.HVEHWZHHQUHSHDODQGQRQUHSHDOVWDWHVZLGHQDQGQRWQDUURZ

ZLWKQDWLRQDOOHJDOL]DWLRQ",WLVLPSRUWDQWWRUH.DOOWKDWWHHQVERUQEHWZHHQ.RPHRIDJH

EHWZHHQDQGDSHULRGRIUDSLGLQ.UHDVHLQYLROHQW.ULPH


27/75

VHQVLWLYLW\RIWKHLUHVWLPDWHVWRWKHSHULRGEHIRUHDQGDIWHU,UHHVWLPDWHG'RQRKXHDQG

/HYLWWVUHJUHVVLRQVRIORJDUUHVWVE\VLQJOH\HDURIDJHIRUWHHQVDQG\RXQJDGXOWV,QWKHVH

UHJUHVVLRQVWKHDXWKRUVGRQRWXVHWKHHIIH.WLYHDERUWLRQUDWLREXWLQVWHDGDVVLJQHD.KDJHWRWKH

VWDWHDERUWLRQUDWLRWKDWH[LVWHGWKH\HDUSULRUWRELUWK)RULQVWDQ.HDUUHVWVIRU\HDUROGVLQ

1HZ


28/75

WKHUHIRUHLVWRILQGRWKHUPHDQVRIVHSDUDWLQJSHULRGIURP.RKRUWHIIH.WVLQWKHDEVHQ.HRI

.RQVLVWHQWGDWDRQ.UD.NXVHE\\HDUDQGVWDWH

:LWKLQVWDWH.RPSDULVRQJURXSVE\VLQJOH\HDURIDJH

$QDOWHUQDWLYHPHDQVRIDGMXVWLQJIRUSHULRGHIIH.WVLVWRXVHDZLWKLQVWDWH.RPSDULVRQ

JURXS,QWKLVDQDO\VLV,.RPSDUH.KDQJHVLQ.ULPHE\VLQJOH\HDURIDJHEHWZHHQWKHDQG

ELUWK.RKRUWVZLWK.KDQJHVLQ.ULPHDPRQJWKHDQGELUWK.RKRUWVVHSDUDWHO\

ZLWKLQUHSHDODQGQRQUHSHDOVWDWHV,WKHQ.RQWUDVWWKHVHGLIIHUHQ.HLQGLIIHUHQ.HVEHWZHHQ

UHSHDODQGQRQUHSHDOVWDWHV2QO\WKH.RKRUWLQUHSHDOVWDWHVZDVH[SRVHGWROHJDOL]HG

DERUWLRQDQG\HWDOO.RKRUWVH[SHULHQ.HGWKHVDPHSHULRGHIIH.WV,IIRULQVWDQ.HWKHVSUHDGRI

.UD.NDQGJDQJYLROHQ.HGLIIHUHGLQWLPLQJDQGV.RSHEHWZHHQUHSHDODQGQRQUHSHDOVWDWHVWKHQ

DZLWKLQVWDWH.RPSDULVRQJURXSZLOODGMXVWIRUVX.K.RQIRXQGLQJ

7KHDGYDQWDJHRIXVLQJDQGDVWKHH[SRVXUHSHULRGLVLOOXVWUDWHGLQ7DEOH

7KHUHLVDQSHU.HQWGURSLQIHUWLOLW\UDWHVDPRQJWHHQVDQGDSHU.HQWGURSLQWKHIHUWLOLW\UDWH

RIDOOZRPHQLQUHSHDODV.RPSDUHGWRQRQUHSHDOVWDWHVEHWZHHQDQG0RUHRYHUWKH

.KDQJHEHWZHHQDQGGRPLQDWHVWKHWRWDO.KDQJHEHWZHHQDQG7KH

UHODWLYHIHUWLOLW\UDWH.KDQJHIURPWRDPRQJDOOZRPHQLQUHSHDOVWDWHVLVSHU.HQWRI

WKHWRWDO.KDQJHWKDWR..XUVEHWZHHQDQG7KLVLVSODXVLEOHVLQ.HOHJDOL]DWLRQ

R..XUUHGVXGGHQO\LQ1HZ


29/75

7KHUHVXOWVLQ7DEOHVKRZSURSRUWLRQDWH.KDQJHVLQ.ULPHIRU.RKRUWVH[SRVHGUHODWLYH

WR.RKRUWVXQH[SRVHGWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQ)RUHD.K.ULPHWKH''HVWLPDWHV.RQWUDVW.KDQJHV

LQ.ULPHEHWZHHQWKHWZRDJHJURXSVZLWKLQUHSHDOVWDWHVRQO\WKH'''HVWLPDWHV.RPSDUH

UHODWLYH.KDQJHVEHWZHHQUHSHDODQGQRQUHSHDOVWDWHV

7KHUHDUHSRWHQWLDOO\REVHUYDWLRQV

JLYHQGDWDE\DJH\HDURIELUWKDQGVWDWH+RZHYHUGXHWRPLVVLQJGDWDRU]HURKRPL.LGHV

D.WXDOVDPSOHVL]HVYDU\IURPIRUDUUHVWUDWHVIRUYLROHQWDQGSURSHUW\.ULPHWRIRU

PXUGHUDUUHVWUDWHV,QHD.K.ROXPQWKH\RXQJHUDJHJURXSLVIURPWKHDQGELUWK

.RKRUWVDQGWKHROGHUDJHJURXSLVIURPWKHDQGELUWK.RKRUW,IOHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQLV

DVVR.LDWHGZLWKORZHU.ULPHDQGDUUHVWUDWHVWKHQWKH''DQG'''HVWLPDWHVVKRXOGEHQHJDWLYH

,ILQGWKDWH[.HSWIRUKRPL.LGHDPRQJDQG\HDUROGV.ROXPQWKHUHLVOLWWOHWR

VXJJHVWWKDWWKH.KDQJHLQ.ULPHDPRQJWKRVHH[SRVHGWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQGLIIHUHGIURPWKRVH

XQH[SRVHG)RULQVWDQ.HDUUHVWUDWHVIRUYLROHQW.ULPHLQUHSHDOVWDWHVIHOORQHSHU.HQWPRUH

DPRQJUHODWLYHWR\HDUROGVEHWZHHQDQG.ROXPQ:KHQDGMXVWHGIRU

VLPLODU.KDQJHVLQQRQUHSHDOVWDWHVWKHUHODWLYHGH.OLQHDPRQJ\HDUROGVZDVSHU.HQW

1HLWKHU.KDQJHZDVVWDWLVWL.DOO\VLJQLIL.DQW,QGHHGWKHUHLVQRWRQHVWDWLVWL.DOO\VLJQLIL.DQW

.KDQJHLQDQ\DUUHVWUDWHIRUDQ\DJHJURXS$QRWKHUQRWHZRUWK\UHVXOWLVWKDW.KDQJHVLQ

KRPL.LGHDQGPXUGHUDUUHVWUDWHVDPRQJ\RXQJDGXOWVWR\HDUROGVDUHDOPRVWDOZD\V

VPDOOHUWKDQWKHWR.KDQJHVLQ7DEOHVDDQGE7KLVVXJJHVWVWKDWWKHXVHRI

.RPSDULVRQJURXSVZLWKLQUHSHDODQGQRQUHSHDOVWDWHVQHWVRXWVKDUHGSHULRGHIIH.WVPRUH

HIIH.WLYHO\WKDQDVSH.LIL.DWLRQZLWKRQO\VWDWHDQG\HDUIL[HGHIIH.WV

7KHUHDUHODUJHQHJDWLYHDQGVWDWLVWL.DOO\VLJQLIL.DQWHIIH.WVRIDERUWLRQOHJDOL]DWLRQRQ

KRPL.LGHYL.WLPL]DWLRQDQGRIIHQGLQJUDWHVDPRQJUHODWLYHWR\HDUROGV.ROXPQORZHU

PLV.ODVVLIL.DWLRQZRXOGWHQGWRELDVHVWLPDWHVGRZQZDUGV7KXV,DOVRSHUIRUPDQDO\VHVLQZKL.KWKHSUHDQGSRVWH[SRVXUH

SHULRGLVIURPWRDQGWKHDJHGLIIHUHQ.HEHWZHHQWKHWUHDWPHQWDQG.RPSDULVRQJURXSLVWZR\HDUVLQVWHDGRIRQH7KXV\HDUROGVDUH.RPSDUHGWR\HDUROGV\HDUROGVDUH.RPSDUHGWR\HDUROGVHW.


30/75

KDOI7KHVHHVWLPDWHVDUHLQ.RQVLVWHQWQRWRQO\ZLWK.KDQJHVLQKRPL.LGHDPRQJRWKHUDJH

JURXSVEXWDOVRDUHLQ.RQVLVWHQWZLWKUHVXOWVIRUDUUHVWUDWHVDPRQJUHODWLYHWR\HDUROGV

WRSKDOIRI.ROXPQ)RUD.ORVHUORRNDW.ULPHDPRQJDQG\HDUROGV,SORWWHGWKH

QDWXUDOORJDULWKPRIDUUHVWDQGKRPL.LGHUDWHVIRUDQG\HDUROGVLQ)LJXUHVDI


31/75

DQGUHPDLQUHODWLYHO\IODWLQQRQUHSHDOVWDWHV6H.RQGWUHQGVLQKRPL.LGHHVSH.LDOO\KRPL.LGH

RIIHQGLQJDPRQJ\RXQJDGXOWVDQGWHHQVZLWKLQUHSHDODQGQRQUHSHDOVWDWHVDUHTXLWHVLPLODU

%RWKWHQGWRULVHSHDNDQGIDOODWURXJKO\WKHVDPHWLPHDQGUDWH)LJXUHVDQG

,QDQDQDO\VLVRIWKH\HDUVWHHQVLQUHSHDOVWDWHVDUHWKHWUHDWPHQWJURXS

DQG\RXQJDGXOWVWKH.RPSDULVRQJURXS

$.RQWUDVWRI.ULPHUDWHVEHWZHHQDQG

UHYHUVHVWKHH[SHULPHQW6SH.LIL.DOO\E\DOOWHHQVLQUHSHDOVWDWHVKDGEHHQH[SRVHGWR

OHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQZKHUHDVRQO\DWHQWKRI\RXQJDGXOWVKDYHEHHQH[SRVHG

%\DOO

\RXQJDGXOWVLQUHSHDOVWDWHVKDGEHHQH[SRVHG7KXVWKH''IRUUHSHDOVWDWHVEHWZHHQ

DQGVXEWUD.WVWKH.KDQJHLQ.ULPHDPRQJWHHQVIURPWKH.KDQJHLQ.ULPHDPRQJ\RXQJ

DGXOWV6LQ.HWHHQVH[SHULHQ.HQR.KDQJHLQH[SRVXUHGXULQJWKLVWLPHWKH\VHUYHDVWKH

.RPSDULVRQJURXSIRU\RXQJDGXOWV,HVWLPDWHDVLPLODUVHWRI''VIRUWKHQRQUHSHDOVWDWHV

DOWKRXJKWKH.RQWUDVWLQH[SRVXUHLVQRWDVJUHDWDVLWLVLQWKHUHSHDOVWDWHV

(VWLPDWHVRIWKH''DQG'''IURPHTXDWLRQDUHSUHVHQWHGLQWKHWRSSDQHORI7DEOH

7KHDQDORJRXVHVWLPDWHVIRUWKH.RPSDULVRQRI\RXQJDGXOWVDQGWHHQVEHWZHHQDQG

DUHVKRZQLQWKHORZHUSDQHO7KHUHDUHSRWHQWLDOO\DJHVWDWH\HDUREVHUYDWLRQVIRU

HD.KUD.LDOJURXSEHWZHHQDQGDQGREVHUYDWLRQVIRUWKH.RPSDULVRQV

'XHWRPLVVLQJGDWDRUOD.NRIUHSRUWHGKRPL.LGHVDYDLODEOHREVHUYDWLRQVDUHOHVV(D.K

,QJHQHUDO.RPSDULVRQVEDVHGRQDQGDVWKHSUHDQGSRVWH[SRVXUHSHULRGDUHODUJHO\.RQVLVWHQWZLWKUHVXOWVUHSRUWHGLQ7DEOH5H.DOOWKDWDOOWHHQVLQKDGEHHQERUQEHIRUHDQGWKXVZHUHXQH[SRVHGWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQLQXWHURE\DOOWHHQVKDGEHHQERUQDIWHUDQGWKHUHIRUHKDGEHHQH[SRVHGWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQ%\.RQWUDVWQRQHRIWKH\RXQJDGXOWVDJHV

WREHWZHHQDQGKDGEHHQH[SRVHGWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQLQXWHURZKL.KPDNHVWKHPDUHOHYDQW.RPSDULVRQJURXS

5HIHUWR7DEOH2QO\\HDUROGVLQZHUHH[SRVHGWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQEHWZHHQDQG*LYHQDJHJURXSVDQGWZR\HDUVWKHUHDUHSRVVLEOH.HOOVRIH[SRVXUHWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQEHWZHHQDQG$JDLQUHIHUWR7DEOH%HWZHHQDQGRIWKHSRVVLEOHWHHQDJHJURXSVKDGEHHQH[SRVHGWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQ

5H.DOOWKDWH[SRVXUHLQQRQUHSHDOVWDWHVEHJLQVZLWKWKHELUWK.RKRUW7KXVEHWZHHQDQGWKHLQ.UHDVHLQH[SRVXUHWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQLVJUHDWHUDPRQJ\RXQJDGXOWVWKDQDPRQJWHHQVLQQRQUHSHDOVWDWHVEXWWKH.RQWUDVWLVQRWDVJUHDWDVLQUHSHDOVWDWHV(TXDWLRQ.DQHDVLO\EHPRGLILHGWRUHIOH.WWKHDQDO\VLVRIWKLVVH.RQGH[SHULPHQW


32/75

VSH.LIL.DWLRQLQ.OXGHVWKHVDPHVHWRI.RQWUROYDULDEOHVDVZHUHXVHGE\'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWW

(VWLPDWHVIURPWKHILUVWWKUHHURZVRI7DEOHDUJXHDJDLQVWDQ\UHGX.WLRQLQKRPL.LGH

IURPH[SRVXUHWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQ7KH''HVWLPDWHVLQURZVDQGLQGL.DWHWKDWKRPL.LGH

UDWHVLQ.UHDVHGUHODWLYHO\PRUHDPRQJWHHQVWKDQ\RXQJDGXOWVEHWZHHQDQG6HYHQRI

HLJKW''HVWLPDWHVDUHVWDWLVWL.DOO\VLJQLIL.DQW7KH''HVWLPDWHVLQURZDUHLQVWUX.WLYH

EH.DXVHWKH\UHIOH.WWKHILQGLQJUHSRUWHGHOVHZKHUHWKDWWKHXSVXUJHLQKRPL.LGHZDVUHODWLYHO\

JUHDWHUDPRQJWHHQVWKDQ\RXQJDGXOWV%OXPVWHLQ7KH'''HVWLPDWHVLQURZ

.RPSDUHWKHUHODWLYH.KDQJHVLQ.ULPHDPRQJWHHQVLQUHSHDODQGQRQUHSHDOVWDWHVDIWHU

HOLPLQDWLQJVWDWHVSH.LIL.UHSHDOYVQRQUHSHDOSHULRGHIIH.WV,IDERUWLRQORZHUV.ULPHWKHQ

HVWLPDWHVLQ7DEOHVKRXOGEHQHJDWLYH7KHUHLVQRHYLGHQ.HWKDW.ULPHIHOOPRUHDPRQJWHHQV

H[SRVHGDV.RPSDUHGZLWKXQH[SRVHGWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQ

5HVXOWVIRU\RXQJDGXOWVDUHGLVSOD\HGLQWKHORZHUSDQHORI7DEOH,QWKLVDQDO\VLV

WHHQVVHUYHDVWKH.RPSDULVRQJURXSVLQ.HWKHLUH[SRVXUHLQUHSHDOVWDWHVGLGQRW.KDQJH5RZ

VKRZVWKH''HVWLPDWHVIRUUHSHDOVWDWHV7KHHVWLPDWHVDUHVPDOODQGVWDWLVWL.DOO\LQVLJQLIL.DQW

IRUERWKZKLWHVDQGEOD.NV7KH''HVWLPDWHVIRUQRQUHSHDOVWDWHVDUHLQURZ7KH''

HVWLPDWHVLQURZDQGWKH'''HVWLPDWHVLQURZVKRXOGEHLQWHUSUHWHGPRUH.DXWLRXVO\7KH

H[SHULPHQWLQQRQUHSHDOVWDWHVLVOHVVVKDUSEHWZHHQDQGVLQ.HWHHQVWKH

.RPSDULVRQJURXSZHQWIURPSDUWLDOO\H[SRVHGWRIXOO\H[SRVHGWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQRYHUWKLV

SHULRGVHHIRRWQRWH7KH''HVWLPDWHVIRUZKLWHVLQURZDUHODUJHDQGVWDWLVWL.DOO\

VLJQLIL.DQWVXJJHVWLQJWKDWDERUWLRQKDGDQLPSRUWDQWGLIIHUHQWLDOLPSD.WRQKRPL.LGHDPRQJ

\RXQJZKLWHDGXOWV)RUEOD.NVWKH''HVWLPDWHVVXJJHVWOHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQKDGQRHIIH.W7KH

'''HVWLPDWHVVKRZDSRVLWLYHDQGLQVLJQLIL.DQWHIIH.WRIOHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQRQKRPL.LGHUDWHV


33/75

:KDWRYHUDOO.RQ.OXVLRQ.DQEHGUDZQIURPWKHUHGX.HGIRUPHVWLPDWHVLQ7DEOHV"

7KHUHVXOWVLQ7DEOHWKDWDVVR.LDWHH[SRVXUHWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQZLWKDUUHVWDQGKRPL.LGHUDWHV

IRUWR\HDUROGV.ROOH.WLYHO\DUHODUJHO\.RQVLVWHQWZLWK'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWWVILQGLQJV

VWDWHVWKDWUHSHDOHGDERUWLRQSULRUWR5RHY:DGHH[SHULHQ.HGHDUOLHUGH.UHDVHVLQ.ULPHWKDQ

QRQUHSHDOVWDWHV+RZHYHUWKLVLQLWLDODVVR.LDWLRQLVQRWUREXVWWRDPRUHUHILQHGDQDO\VLVE\

DJHUD.HDQGVXESHULRGV$V7DEOHVDDQGELQGL.DWHWKHUHLVQRDVVR.LDWLRQEHWZHHQ

H[SRVXUHWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQDQGDUUHVWDQGKRPL.LGHUDWHVDPRQJWHHQV0RUHRYHUWKHUHLVQR

DVVR.LDWLRQEHWZHHQOHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQDQG.ULPHDPRQJ\RXQJDGXOWVWR\HDUVRIDJH

ZKHQ,XVHZLWKLQVWDWH.RPSDULVRQJURXSV)LQDOO\,ILQGQRDVVR.LDWLRQEHWZHHQWKH

OHJDOL]DWLRQRIDERUWLRQDQG.ULPHDPRQJEOD.NWHHQVDQG\RXQJDGXOWVJURXSVIRUZKRPWKH

GHPRJUDSKL.LPSD.WRIDERUWLRQZDVJUHDWHVW7KXVP\.RQ.OXVLRQDWWKLVMXQ.WXUHLVWKDWWKH

DVVR.LDWLRQEHWZHHQOHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQDQG.ULPHDVUHSRUWHGE\'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWWLVSUREDEO\

VSXULRXVGXHWRWKHLQDELOLW\WR.RQWUROIRU.KDQJHVLQ.UD.NXVHDQGLWVVSLOORYHUHIIH.WV

&&ULPHDQGXQLQWHQGHGELUWKVDYHUWHG

7RWKLVSRLQWWKHDQDO\VLVRI.ULPHDQGDERUWLRQKDVUHOLHGRQDUHGX.HGIRUP.RPSDULVRQ

RI.ULPHDQGDUUHVWUDWHVLQUHSHDOUHODWLYHWRQRQUHSHDOVWDWHV'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWWKRZHYHU

HPSKDVL]HWKHGLUH.W.RUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQODJJHGDERUWLRQUDWLRVDQG.ULPHLQDQHIIRUWWR

PHDVXUHWKHHIIH.WRIXQLQWHQGHGELUWKVDYHUWHG


34/75

$..RUGLQJO\,XVHWKH'''IUDPHZRUNIURPDERYHDQGUHJUHVVD.RKRUWVUD.HVSH.LIL.

KRPL.LGHUDWHLQSHULRGWRQWKHUD.HVSH.LIL.IHUWLOLW\UDWHLQ\HDUWDDQGWKHLQWHUD.WLRQRIWKH

IHUWLOLW\UDWHDQGH[SRVXUHWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQLQ\HDUWDZKHUHDLVWKHDJHRIWKH.RKRUWDW

WLPHW7KHREMH.WLYHLVWRGLIIHUHQ.HRXWWKHXQGHUO\LQJUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQIHUWLOLW\DQG.ULPH

DPRQJJURXSVXQH[SRVHGLQRUGHUWR.DSWXUHWKHGLIIHUHQWLDOHIIH.WRIDIDOOLQIHUWLOLW\DPRQJ

JURXSVH[SRVHG7RLOOXVWUDWH.RQVLGHUHTXDWLRQ

DMWWWMMDWMDMWDDMWDMW H767HHQ


35/75

7KHUHVXOWVLQWKHWRSSDQHORI7DEOHVKRZWKH''DQG'''HVWLPDWHVIURPWKH

HVWLPDWLRQRIHTXDWLRQ7KHORZHUSDQHOVKRZVUHVXOWVIURPWKHVDPHH[HU.LVHEXWIRUWKH

SHULRGZKHQ\RXQJDGXOWVZHUHWKHH[SRVHGJURXSDQGWHHQVWKH.RPSDULVRQJURXS

7KHUHLVOLWWOHHYLGHQ.HRIDQ\DVVR.LDWLRQEHWZHHQXQLQWHQGHG.KLOGEHDULQJDVSUR[LHGE\

GLIIHUHQWLDO.KDQJHVLQIHUWLOLW\DQGKRPL.LGH7KH'''HVWLPDWHVLQURZDUHVPDOODQG

VWDWLVWL.DOO\LQVLJQLIL.DQW7KHUHVXOWVIRU\RXQJDGXOWVDUHHTXDOO\XQVXSSRUWLYHRIDUHODWLRQVKLS

EHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQG.ULPH

'6HQVLWLYLW\DQDO\VHV

)XQ.WLRQDOIRUP

'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWWV.RQ.OXVLRQWKDWOHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQORZHUHG.ULPHLVEDVHGSULPDULO\

RQUHJUHVVLRQVRIWKHQDWXUDOORJRIWKHWRWDO.ULPHUDWHRQWKHOHYHORIWKHHIIH.WLYHDERUWLRQUDWLR

7KHVSH.LIL.DWLRQLPSOLHVDQH[SRQHQWLDOUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQ.ULPHUDWHVDQGDERUWLRQ

+RZHYHUZHDUHUHDOO\LQWHUHVWHGLQWKHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQ.ULPHDQGXQLQWHQGHGELUWKV

DYHUWHGZKL.KLVXQREVHUYDEOH%\HQWHULQJWKHOHYHORIWKHDERUWLRQUDWLRLQDUHJUHVVLRQRIORJ

.ULPHUDWHV'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWWDVVXPHWKHUHODWLRQEHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQGXQLQWHQGHG

ELUWKVDYHUWHGLVDOVROLQHDU2WKHUIXQ.WLRQDOIRUPVDUH.OHDUO\SRVVLEOH

7RDVVHVVWKHVHQVLWLYLW\RIWKHLUHVWLPDWHVWRDQDOWHUQDWLYHVSH.LIL.DWLRQ,UHHVWLPDWHG

'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWWVUHJUHVVLRQVDVSUHVHQWHGLQ7DEOHRIWKHLUSDSHU,VXEVWLWXWHGWKHQDWXUDO

ORJDULWKPRIWKHHIIH.WLYHDERUWLRQUDWLRIRUWKHOHYHORIWKHDERUWLRQUDWLR7KHUHVXOWVDUH

GLVSOD\HGLQ7DEOH7KHILUVWURZRI.RHIIL.LHQWVUHSOL.DWHVWKHUHVXOWVLQ'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWW

/HW&EHWKH.ULPHUDWH8WKHUDWHRIXQLQWHQGHG.KLOGEHDULQJDQG$WKHDERUWLRQUDWH'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWWUXQ/Q&D8ZKHUHD!+RZHYHU8LVXQREVHUYHG&RQVLGHU8E/Q$ZKHUHE7KLVLPSOLHVGLPLQLVKLQJUHWXUQVWRDERUWLRQ

ZKL.KZRXOGEHSODXVLEOHLIVXEVWLWXWLRQRIDERUWLRQIRU.RQWUD.HSWLRQLQ.UHDVHGDVWKHUHODWLYHSUL.HRIDERUWLRQIHOO6XEVWLWXWLQJIRU8LQWKH.ULPHHTXDWLRQ\LHOGV/Q&./Q$ZKHUH.DE


36/75

7KHVH.RQGURZRI.RHIIL.LHQWVLVIRUWKHORJRIWKHHIIH.WLYHDERUWLRQUDWH7KHVH

.RHIIL.LHQWVDUHSRVLWLYHLQHYHU\.DVHDQGVWDWLVWL.DOO\VLJQLIL.DQWLQILYHRXWRIVL[UHJUHVVLRQV

$QLPSRUWDQWOLPLWDWLRQRIXVLQJWKHQDWXUDOORJDULWKPRIWKHHIIH.WLYHDERUWLRQUDWLRLV

WKDWVPDOODEVROXWHLQ.UHDVHV.DQEHYHU\ODUJHUHODWLYHLQ.UHDVHVLIWKHLQLWLDOOHYHOLVORZ7KH

WKLUGURZRI7DEOHVKRZVWKHZHLJKWHGPHDQVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQDQGWKHPLQLPXPDQG

PD[LPXPYDOXHRIWKHHIIH.WLYHDERUWLRQUDWLRLQWKHVDPSOH7KHUHLV.OHDUO\DQH[WUHPHUDQJH

RIYDOXHVIRUWKHHIIH.WLYHDERUWLRQUDWLR7ROHVVHQWKHLPSD.WRIVX.KH[WUHPHUHODWLYH.KDQJHV

,VWUDWLILHGWKHVDPSOHE\UHSHDODQGQRQUHSHDOVWDWHVDQG,UHVWUL.WHGLWWRWKH\HDUV

7KLVLQ.UHDVHGWKHPHDQVORZHUHGVWDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQVDQGWLJKWHQHGWKHUDQJHEHWZHHQWKH

PLQLPXPDQGPD[LPXP,WKHQUHHVWLPDWHGWKHUHJUHVVLRQVIRUWKHVXEVDPSOHZLWKERWKWKH

OHYHODQGWKHORJDULWKPRIWKHHIIH.WLYHDERUWLRQUDWLR7KHUHVXOWVLQWKHORZHUWZRSDQHOVRI

7DEOHPLUURUWKRVHIURPWKHIXOOVDPSOHDQHJDWLYHUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQWKHQDWXUDOORJRI

WKH.ULPHUDWHDQGWKHOHYHORIWKHHIIH.WLYHDERUWLRQUDWLREH.RPHVSRVLWLYHLQHYHU\LQVWDQ.H

ZKHQWKHQDWXUDOORJDULWKPRI.ULPHLVUHJUHVVHGRQWKHQDWXUDOORJRIWKHHIIH.WLYHDERUWLRQUDWLR

7UDYHODQGPLJUDWLRQ

(IIH.WVRIDERUWLRQOHJDOL]DWLRQRQ.ULPHZLOOEHELDVHGLIZRPHQLQQRQUHSHDOVWDWHV

WUDYHOHGWRUHSHDOVWDWHVWRREWDLQDERUWLRQ

$VDVLPSOH.KH.N,.UHDWHGD.DWHJRU\RIERUGHU

VWDWHVWKDW.RQVLVWHGRIDQ\VWDWHWKDWVKDUHGDERUGHUZLWK&DOLIRUQLD1HZ


37/75

VKRXOGDOVREHQHJDWLYHEXWVPDOOHULQDEVROXWHYDOXHWKDQWKH.RHIIL.LHQWRQ5HSHDO

7KHUHVXOWVZHUHQRW.RQVLVWHQWZLWKWKLVH[SH.WDWLRQQRWVKRZQ,QGHHGWKHUHZDVQR

.RQVLVWHQWSDWWHUQWRWKHUHVXOWV)RUIRXURXW.RPHV.RHIIL.LHQWVRQWKHERUGHUVWDWHWHUPVZHUH

SRVLWLYHDQGRIWHQVWDWLVWL.DOO\VLJQLIL.DQW)RUYLROHQW.ULPHDUUHVWUDWHVWKH.RHIIL.LHQWZDVPRUH

QHJDWLYHWKDQWKH.RHIIL.LHQWRQUHSHDOVWDWHVDQGVWDWLVWL.DOO\VLJQLIL.DQW

$QRWKHUVRXU.HRIELDVLVWKDWPRVW.ULPHVWDWLVWL.VDUHPHDVXUHGE\VWDWHRIUHVLGHQ.H

ZKHUHDVWKHLQGL.DWRUVRIDERUWLRQOHJDOL]DWLRQPHDVXUHH[SRVXUHE\VWDWHRIELUWK2QHXVHIXO

DVSH.WWKH1&+6YL.WLPL]DWLRQGDWDLVWKDWWKH\DUHDYDLODEOHE\VWDWHRIELUWKDVZHOODVVWDWHRI

UHVLGHQ.H7KHUHVXOWVLQ7DEOHVEDQGVKRZOLWWOHPHDQLQJIXOGLIIHUHQ.HEHWZHHQHVWLPDWHV

RIDERUWLRQDQGKRPL.LGHYL.WLPL]DWLRQDVPHDVXUHGE\VWDWHRIUHVLGHQ.HDQGE\VWDWHRIELUWK,

LQWHUSUHWWKLVDVVRPHHYLGHQ.HWKDWUHOR.DWLRQWRDQRWKHUVWDWHLVQRWDVLJQLIL.DQWVRXU.HRIELDV

6DPSOHVHOH.WLRQDQGVWDWH\HDUIL[HGHIIH.WV

,QDOODQDO\VHV,GURSSHGREVHUYDWLRQVLIWKHUHZHUH]HURKRPL.LGHVLQDVWDWH\HDUDJH

.HOO7RDVVHVVWKHVHQVLWLYLW\RIWKHHVWLPDWHVWRWKLVORVVRIGDWD,UHUDQWKHUHJUHVVLRQVLQ

7DEOHVDDQGIRUYLROHQW.ULPHDQGSURSHUW\.ULPHDUUHVWUDWHVIRUWKHVXEVDPSOHRIVWDWH

\HDUDJH.HOOVWKDWZHUHDYDLODEOHIRUPXUGHUDUUHVWUDWHV7KHUHZDVOLWWOHGLIIHUHQ.HEHWZHHQ

WKHVH.RHIIL.LHQWVDQGWKRVHLQ7DEOHVDDQGQRWVKRZQ7KHUHVXOWLVQRWVXUSULVLQJ

VLQ.HWKHUHJUHVVLRQVZHUHZHLJKWHGE\WKHVWDWHSRSXODWLRQDQGWKHGURSSHGREVHUYDWLRQVWHQGHG

WREH\RXQJHUDJHJURXSVIURPVPDOOVWDWHV

,XVHG.RPSDULVRQJURXSVZLWKLQUHSHDODQGQRQUHSHDOVWDWHVWRDGMXVWIRUZLWKLQVWDWH

WUHQGVLQ.ULPHWKDWPD\KDYHGLIIHUHGEHWZHHQWKHVHWZRW\SHVRIVWDWHV$OHVVUHVWUL.WLYH

DGMXVWPHQWLVWRLQ.OXGHVWDWH\HDURIELUWK7DEOHRUVWDWH\HDU7DEOHLQWHUD.WLRQV7KH

LQ.OXVLRQRIVWDWHVSH.LIL.WUHQGVKDGTXDOLWDWLYHO\OLWWOHHIIH.WRQWKHHVWLPDWHVEXWGLGLQ.UHDVH

WKHVWDQGDUGHUURUVUHVXOWVQRWVKRZQ


38/75

9&RQ.OXVLRQ

'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWWSUHVHQWDQLQWULJXLQJDVVR.LDWLRQEHWZHHQWKHJURZWKLQ

DERUWLRQDQGWKHGH.UHDVHLQ.ULPHLQWKHV7KHHYLGHQ.H,KDYHSUHVHQWHGGRHVQRWVXSSRUW

D.DXVDOLQWHUSUHWDWLRQRIWKLVDVVR.LDWLRQ7KHSULPDU\GLIIHUHQ.HEHWZHHQ'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWWV

DSSURD.KDQGPLQHLVRQHRILGHQWLIL.DWLRQ,KDYHDUJXHGWKDWWKHPRVWXVHIXOVRXU.HRI

LGHQWLI\LQJYDULDWLRQZLWKZKL.KWRXQ.RYHUDUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQWKHOHJDOL]DWLRQRIDERUWLRQ

DQG.ULPHLVD.RPSDULVRQRI.RKRUWVH[SRVHGDQGXQH[SRVHGWRWKHSUH5RHUHSHDORIDERUWLRQ

ODZVEHWZHHQDQG7KHUHLVVXEVWDQWLDOHYLGHQ.HWKDWWKHSUH5RHOHJDOL]DWLRQRI

DERUWLRQUHGX.HGIHUWLOLW\DQGE\H[WHQVLRQXQZDQWHG.KLOGEHDULQJ%\.RQWUDVW'RQRKXHDQG

/HYLWWUHO\RQWKHDGMXVWHG.RUUHODWLRQEHWZHHQDERUWLRQUDWLRVIURPWRDQG.ULPHUDWHV

IURPWR+RZHYHUDERUWLRQLVSRRUO\PHDVXUHGSULRUWR5RHPRUHRYHULWLVPRUH

GLIIL.XOWWRGHPRQVWUDWHDQDVVR.LDWLRQEHWZHHQDERUWLRQDQGXQLQWHQGHG.KLOGEHDULQJLQWKH

SHULRGDIWHU5RHZKL.KUDLVHVXQ.HUWDLQW\DVWRZKDWGLIIHUHQWLDO.KDQJHVLQDERUWLRQZLWKLQ

VWDWHVDUHPHDVXULQJ

7KHRWKHUPDMRUGLIIHUHQ.HEHWZHHQWKHLUVWXG\DQGPLQHLVWKHHIIRUWWR.RQWUROIRU

.RQIRXQGLQJIURPXQREVHUYHGSHULRGHIIH.WVVX.KDV.UD.NDQGKDQGJXQXVH,XVHGWKHUHODWLYH

.KDQJHLQ.ULPHDPRQJ.RPSDULVRQJURXSVRIVLPLODUDJHDQGUD.HZLWKLQUHSHDODQGQRQUHSHDO

VWDWHVWRPLQLPL]H.RQIRXQGLQJ7KH.RPSDULVRQJURXSVZHUHHLWKHUXQH[SRVHGWROHJDOL]HG

DERUWLRQRUH[SHULHQ.HGQR.KDQJHLQH[SRVXUHGXULQJWKHVWXG\SHULRG7KHDVVXPSWLRQZDV

WKDWYDULDWLRQLQWKH.ULPHUDWHRIWKH.RPSDULVRQJURXSZDVDUHDVRQDEOH.RXQWHUID.WXDOIRUZKDW

ZRXOGKDYHEHHQREVHUYHGDPRQJWKHWUHDWPHQWJURXSKDGWKHUHEHHQQROHJDOL]DWLRQRI

DERUWLRQSULRUWR5RH'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWWXVHG.RQWUROVIRUQDWLRQDOWUHQGVWRDGMXVWIRU


39/75

.KDQJHVGXHWRKDUGWRPHDVXUHID.WRUVWKDWDIIH.W.ULPH+RZHYHUWKHDUULYDODQGGLIIXVLRQRI

.UD.NYDULHGE\VWDWHZKL.KOLPLWVWKHXVHIXOQHVVRIQDWLRQDOWUHQGVDVD.RQWUROIRUVX.K

.RQIRXQGLQJ,QVXPHYHQLIRQHZHUHWR.KDOOHQJHP\.KRL.HRIGDWDVHOH.WLRQRI.RPSDULVRQ

JURXSVRUDUJXHIRUDSDUWL.XODUIXQ.WLRQDOIRUPWKHPDJQLWXGHRIWKHHIIH.WVUHSRUWHGE\

'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWWWKHLQDELOLW\WR.RQWUROIRUVWDWH\HDUHIIH.WVWKHIUDJLOLW\RIWKHLU

HVWLPDWHVDQGWKH.RQWURYHUVLDOSROL.\LPSOL.DWLRQVLQGL.DWHWKDWIXUWKHUPRUHUHILQHGDQDO\VHV

DUHQHHGHGEHIRUH.DXVDOLQIHUHQ.HVDUHGUDZQ


40/75

$.NQRZOHGJHPHQWV

7KLVZRUNZDVVXSSRUWHGE\DJUDQWIURPWKH2SHQ6R.LHW\,QVWLWXWH-RKQ'RQRKXH,,,DQG

6WHYHQ/HYLWWJUD.LRXVO\VKDUHGWKHLUGDWDDQGSURJUDPVZKL.KJUHDWO\ID.LOLWDWHGP\DQDO\VLV

7KH\DOVRJDYHPHKHOSIXO.RPPHQWVRQDQHDUOLHUGUDIW,PXVWDOVRWKDQN*UHJ&ROPDQIRU

UHVHDU.KDVVLVWDQ.HDQG%REDHVWQHU0L.KDHO*URVVPDQ6DQGHUVRUHQPDQ3KLOLS&RRN

:LOOLDP(YDQV3KLOOLS/HYLQH-RKQ/RWWDQGQXPHURXVVHPLQDUSDUWL.LSDQWVIRUKHOSIXO

.RPPHQWV7KHYLHZVDQGHUURUVLQWKLVPDQXV.ULSWDUHPLQHDQGQRWWKRVHRIWKH2SHQ6R.LHW\

,QVWLWXWH%DUX.K&ROOHJHRUWKH1DWLRQDO%XUHDXRI(.RQRPL.5HVHDU.K


41/75

5HIHUHQ.HV

$.NHUORI*HRUJH


42/75

$QQXDO6XPPDU\$WODQWD*HRUJLD&HQWHUVIRU'LVHDVH&RQWURO

&RRN3KLOLSDQG-RKQ+/DXE7KH8QSUH.HGHQWHG(SLGHPL.LQ&RPSXWHU)LOH@,QWHU8QLYHUVLW\&RQVRUWLXPIRU3ROLWL.DODQG6R.LDO

5HVHDU.KYHUVLRQV%RVWRQ0$1RUWKHDVWHUQ8QLYHUVLW\&ROOHJHRI&ULPLQDO-XVWL.H

>SURGX.HU@$QQ$UERU0L.KLJDQ,QWHU8QLYHUVLW\&RQVRUWLXPIRU3ROLWL.DODQG6R.LDO

5HVHDU.K>GLVWULEXWRU@

)R[-DPHV$ODQ'HPRJUDSKL.VDQG86+RPL.LGH7KH&ULPH'URSLQ$PHUL.D$OIUHG

%OXPVWHLQDQG-RHO:ROOPDQHGV1HZ


43/75

*DUURZ'DYLG/6H[XDOLW\DQG/LEHUW\WKH5LJKWWR3ULYD.\DQGWKH0DNLQJRI5RHY:DGH

%HUNHOH\&$8QLYHUVLW\RI&DOLIRUQLD3UHVV

*HURQLPRXV$UOHQHDQG6DQGHUVRUHQPDQ7KH6R.LRH.RQRPL.&RQVHTXHQ.HVRI7HHQ

&KLOGEHDULQJ5H.RQVLGHUHG7KH4XDUWHUO\-RXUQDORI(.RQRPL.V

*HURQLPRXV$UOHQHDQG6DQGHUVRUHQPDQ0DWHUQDO


44/75

+HQVKDZ6WDQOH\)RUUHVW-D.TXLOLQH'DUUR.K6XOOLYDQ(OOHQDQG&KULVWRSKHU7LHW]H

$ERUWLRQ1HHGVDQG6HUYL.HVLQWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV(D.K6WDWHDQG

0HWURSROLWDQ$UHD1HZ


45/75

XEL.ND/=0DWHM.HN+3'DYLG='\WU\.K:%0LOOHUDQG=5RWK&KLOGUHQIURP

8QZDQWHG3UHJQDQ.LHVLQ3UDJXH&]H.K5HSXEOL.5HYLVLWHGDW$JH7KLUW\$.WD

3V\.KLDWUL.D6.DQGLQDYL.D

/DGHU/DZUHQ.H$ERUWLRQ,,0DNLQJWKH5HYROXWLRQ1HZ


46/75


47/75

7DEOH

$VVR.LDWLRQ%HWZHHQWKH)HUWLOLW\5DWH$ERUWLRQ/HJDOL]DWLRQDQGWKH$ERUWLRQ5DWH

86

'HSHQGHQW9DULDEOH

/RJ)HUWLOLW\5DWH /RJ7HHQ)HUWLOLW\5DWH

5HSHDO[ 5HSHDO[

5HSHDO[

/RJDERUWLRQUDWH

/RJDERUWLRQUDWHUHSHDO

VWDWH

$GMXVWHG5

1

D$OOUHJUHVVLRQVLQ.OXGH.RQWUROVIRUVWDWHDQG\HDUHIIH.WVDQGDOODUHZHLJKWHGE\WKHUHVLGHQW

SRSXODWLRQRIZRPHQWR\HDUVRIDJHLQWKHVWDWH5HSHDOLVDGXPP\YDULDEOHWKDWLVRQH

IRUWKHVWDWHVRI$ODVND&DOLIRUQLD:DVKLQJWRQ'&+DZDLL1HZ


48/75

7DEOH

$VVR.LDWLRQEHWZHHQ3UHJQDQ.\,QWHQWLRQDQGWKH6WDWH$ERUWLRQ5DWHVEDVHGRQWKH3UHJQDQ.\5LVN$VVHVVPHQWDQG0RQLWRULQJ6\VWHP35$06

8QLQWHQGHG3UHJQDQ.\ 8QZDQWHG3UHJQDQ.\

$ERUWLRQUDWH[

6WDWHIL[HGHIIH.WV 1R


49/75

7DEOH

$UUHVWV$UUHVW5DWHV0XUGHU9L.WLPL]DWLRQ5DWHVDQG0XUGHU2IIHQGLQJ5DWHVE\%LUWK&RKR

5HSHDODQG1RQUHSHDO6WDWHV

/QYLROHQW /QSURSHUW\ /QPXUGHU /QPXUGHU /QPXUGHU /QP DUUHVWUDWHV DUUHVWUDWHV DUUHVWUDWHV 9L.WLPL]DWLRQ RIIHQGLQJ YL.WLPL]

UDWHVUHVLGHQW UDWHV UDWHVELUWK

%LUWK.RKRUWV

5HSHDO

5HSHDO

5HSHDO

1

5VTXDUHDGM

&RHIIL.LHQWVLQEROGVWDQGDUGHUURUVEHORZDUHUHODWLYH.KDQJHVLQDUUHVWDQGKRPL.LGHUDWHVIRUELUWK.R

UHODWLYHWRQRQUHSHDOVWDWHV7KHRPLWWHG.DWHJRU\LVWKHELUWK.RKRUW$OOVSH.LIL.DWLRQVLQ.OXGLQWHUD.WLRQVRIDJHDQGVWDWHDVZHOODVDJHDQG\HDURIELUWKVHHHTXDWLRQLQWH[W6WDQGDUGHUURUVKDY

IRULQWUD.ODVV.RUUHODWLRQZLWKLQVWDWHDQG\HDURIELUWK.HOOV7KHUHDUHSRVVLEOH.HOOVDJHJURX

YDULHGQXPEHURIDJH\HDU.HOOVVLQ.HWKHVDPSOHLVOLPLWHGWR.RKRUWVERUQEHWZHHQDQG7KREVHUYDWLRQVHLWKHUEH.DXVHVWDWHVGLGQRWUHSRUWLQWKRVH\HDUVRUWKHUHZHUHQRKRPL.LGHVRUDUUHVWVLQD

VWDWH\HDU.HOO$OOUHJUHVVLRQVKDYHEHHQZHLJKWHGE\WKHVWDWHSRSXODWLRQ


50/75

7DEOHD

$UUHVW5DWHVE\6LQJOH


51/75

&RHIIL.LHQWVLQEROGVWDQGDUGHUURUVEHORZDUHUHODWLYH.KDQJHVLQDJHVSH.LIL.DUUHVWUDWHVIRUELUWK.RK

UHSHDOVWDWHV7KHRPLWWHG.DWHJRU\LVWKHELUWK.RKRUW$OOVSH.LIL.DWLRQVLQ.OXGHIL[HGHIIH.WVI

VWDWHDVZHOODVDJHDQG\HDURIELUWK6WDQGDUGHUURUVKDYHEHHQDGMXVWHGIRULQWUD.ODVV.RUUHODWLRQZLWK.HOOV$OOUHJUHVVLRQVKDYHEHHQZHLJKWHGE\WKHVWDWHSRSXODWLRQ


52/75

7DEOHE

0XUGHU9L.WLPL]DWLRQDQG2IIHQGLQJ5DWHVE\$JH%LUWK&RKRUWVDQG5HSHDODQG1R 0XUGHU9L.WLPL]DWLRQ6WDWHRI

5HVLGHQ.H

0XUGHU2IIHQGLQJ5DWHV 0XUGHU

%LUWK

ELUWK.RKRUWV ELUWK.RKRUWV

$JH

$JH

$JH

$JH

$JH

$JH

$JH

$JH

$JH

$JH

5VTXDUHDGM 1

&RHIIL.LHQWVLQEROGVWDQGDUGHUURUVEHORZDUHUHODWLYH.KDQJHVLQDJHVSH.LIL.DUUHVWUDWHVIRUELUWK.RK

UHSHDOVWDWHV7KHRPLWWHG.DWHJRU\LVWKHELUWK.RKRUW$OOVSH.LIL.DWLRQVLQ.OXGHIL[HGHIIH.WVI


53/75

VWDWHDVZHOODVDJHDQG\HDURIELUWK6WDQGDUGHUURUVKDYHEHHQDGMXVWHGIRULQWUD.ODVV.RUUHODWLRQZLWK

.HOOV$OOUHJUHVVLRQVKDYHEHHQZHLJKWHGE\WKHVWDWHSRSXODWLRQ


54/75

7DEOH

'LIIHUHQ.HLQGLIIHUHQ.H(VWLPDWHVRI5HODWLYH&KDQJHVLQ)HUWLOLW\5DWHV$PRQJ7HHQV

DQG$OO:RPHQLQ5HSHDODQG1RQUHSHDO6WDWHV

&KDQJHLQ/Q)HUWLOLW\5DWHVLQ5HSHDOYV1RQUHSHDOVWDWHV

7HHQV

5HODWLYHWR

$OOZRPHQ

5HODWLYHWR

7KHGLIIHUHQ.HLQGLIIHUHQ.HVDUHDVIROORZV/Q)5MWUHSHDO/Q)5MUHSHDO/RJ)5MWQRQUHSHDO/Q

)5MQRQUHSHDOZKHUH)5MWLVWKHIHUWLOLW\UDWHRIDJHJURXSMLQ\HDUWDQG/QLVWKHQDWXUDOORJDULWKP


55/75

7DEOH

5HODWLYH&KDQJHVLQ$UUHVWDQG+RPL.LGH5DWHVDPRQJ&RKRUWV([SRVHGWR/HJDOL]HG$ERUWLRQ

EHWZHHQDV&RPSDUHGWR&RKRUWV8QH[SRVHGEHWZHHQLQ5HSHDODQG

1RQUHSHDO6WDWHV

&ULPH


56/75

6WDQGDUGHUURUVDUHLQSDUHQWKHVHV$OOVSH.LIL.DWLRQVLQ.OXGHVWDWHIL[HGHIIH.WVDQGVWDQGDUGHUURUVKDYHEHHQ

DGMXVWHGIRU.OXVWHULQJZLWKLQVWDWHDQG\HDURIELUWK,QHD.K.ROXPQ.RKRUWVIURPWKH\RXQJHUDJHJURXSZHQWIURP

XQH[SRVHGWRH[SRVHGWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQLQXWHUREHWZHHQWKHROGHUDJHJURXSLQHD.K.ROXPQLV

IURPWKHRUELUWK.RKRUWDQGZDVXQH[SRVHGWROHJDOL]HGDERUWLRQGXULQJWKLVSHULRG7KHUHDUHSRWHQWLDOO\

REVHUYDWLRQVJLYHQGDWDE\DJH\HDURIELUWKDQGVWDWH'XHWRPLVVLQJGDWDRU]HURKRPL.LGHVD.WXDOVDPSOH

VL]HVYDU\IURPIRUDUUHVWUDWHVIRUYLROHQWDQGSURSHUW\.ULPHWRIRUPXUGHUDUUHVWUDWHV9L.WLPL]DWLRQ5LV

IRUKRPL.LGHYL.WLPL]DWLRQE\VWDWHRIUHVLGHQ.HDQG9L.WLPL]DWLRQ%LVIRUKRPL.LGHYL.WLPL]DWLRQE\VWDWHRIELUWK

S


57/75


58/75

7DEOH

5HODWLYH&KDQJHVLQ+RPL.LGH5DWHVZLWK5HVSH.WWR5HODWLYH&KDQJHVLQ/DJJHG)HUWLOLW\

5DWHV$PRQJ7HHQVDQGHTXDWLRQLQWH[W@6WDQGDUGHUURUVDUHLQSDUHQWKHVHV7KHIHUWLOLW\UDWHLVODJJHG\HDUVIRUWHHQKRPL.LGHDQG\HDUVIRU\RXQJDGXOWKRPL.LGH0RGHOVLQ.OXGH.RQWUROVIRU

SULVRQHUVSROL.HLQ.RPHSRYHUW\$)'&JHQHURVLW\.RQ.HDOHGJXQODZVDQGEHHUWD[DVLQ

'RQRKXHDQG/HYLWW$OOPRGHOVLQ.OXGHVWDWHDQG\HDUIL[HGHIIH.WV5HJUHVVLRQVDUHZHLJKWHGE\WKHUD.HVSH.LIL.SRSXODWLRQWR\HDUVRIDJH


59/75


60/75

Figure 1

Fertil ity and Abortion Rates for Repeal (R) and Non-Repeal

Fertility rate NR

Fertility rate R

Abortion ra

Abortion rate R

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79

Year

BirthorAbortions/women15-44


61/75


62/75

Figure 2c

Ln Violent Crime Arrrest Rates for 20 & 21 Year Olds by Birth

Cohort and Repeal (R) and Non-Repeal States (NR)

21_NR

21_R

20_NR

20_R

1.6

1.9

2.2

2.5

2.8

68-70 71-73 74-76 77-79

Birth Cohort

LnArrestsper1000

Figure 2d

Ln Violent Crime Arrrest Rates for 22 & 23 Year Olds by Birth Cohort

and Repeal (R) and Non-Repeal States (NR)

22_NR

22_R

23_NR

23_R

0.6

1.1

1.6

2.1

2.6

3.1

68-70 71-73 74-76 77-79

Birth Cohort

LnArrestper1000


63/75

Figure 3a

Ln Property Crime Arrrest Rates for 16 & 17 Year Olds by Birth Cohort


16_NR

16_R

17_NR

17_R

3.30

3.35

3.40

3.45

3.50

3.55

3.60

3.65

3.70

68-70 71-73 74-76 77-79

Birth Cohort

LnArrestsper1000

Figure 3b

Ln Property Crime Arrest Rates for 18 & 19 Year Olds by Birth Cohort


18_NR

18_R

19_NR

19_R

2.80

2.90

3.00

3.10

3.20

3.30

3.40

3.50

3.60

68-70 71-73 74-76 77-79

Birth Cohort

Arrestsper1000


64/75

Figure 3c



21_NR

21_R

20_NR

20_R

2.60

2.70

2.80

2.90

3.00

3.10

3.20

3.30

68-70 71-73 74-76 77-79

Birth Cohort

LnArrestsper1000

Figure 3d



22_NR

22_R

23_NR

23_R

2.40

2.50

2.60

2.70

2.80

2.90

3.00

3.10

68-70 71-73 74-76 77-79

Birth Cohort

LnArrestsper1000


65/75


66/75

Figure 4c

Ln Murder Arrrest Rates for 20 & 21 Year Olds by Birth Cohort and

Repeal (R) and Non-Repeal States (NR)

21_NR

21_R

20_NR

20_R

2.80

2.90

3.00

3.10

3.20

3.30

3.40

3.50

3.603.70

3.80

3.90

68-70 71-73 74-76 77-79

Birth Cohort

Ln

Arrestsper10000

0

Figure 4d

Ln Murder Arrrest Rates for 22 & 23 Year Olds by Birth Cohort and

Repeal (R) and Non-Repeal States (NR)

22_NR

22_R

23_NR

23_R

2.90

3.00

3.10

3.20

3.30

3.40

3.50

3.60

3.70

3.80

68-70 71-73 74-76 77-79Birth Cohort

LnArrestsper100000


67/75

Figure 5a

Ln Murder Victimiation Rates by State of Residence for 16 & 17 Year

Olds by Birth Cohort and Repeal (R) and Non-Repeal States (NR)

16_NR

16_R

17_NR

17_R

0.40

0.90

1.40

1.90

2.40

2.90

3.40

3.90

68-70 71-73 74-76 77-79Birth Cohort

LnArrestsper100000

Figure 5b

Ln Murder Victimization Rates by State of Residence for 18 & 19 Year

Olds by Birth Cohort and Repeal (R) and Non-Repeal States (NR)

18_NR

18_R

19_NR

19_R

2.00

2.20

2.40

2.60

2.80

3.00

3.20

3.40

3.60

3.80

68-70 71-73 74-76 77-79

Birth Cohort

LnArrestsper100000


68/75


69/75


70/75


71/75


72/75


73/75


74/75


75/75

Documents

Did Legalized Abortion Lower Crime Joyce2001