8/2/2019 DHC Q&A With Darshan Kulkarni (FDALawyers)

1/3

Iefeyd k Cbdkyc Ahdk e y ehl

Idrqcdl Nkndrle

LHYB= Yceq el`hrjdyehl ihbq lhyahlqyeyyb kbfdk dipeab, Yh cdpb ycb

Nkndrle Kdv @erj #@erj% ibybrjelb e`

ycb dipeab eq dwwrhwredyb `hr uh+ uhjqy ydkn yh d kdvubr dy ycb @erj dli

arbdyb dl dyyhrlbu*akebly rbkdyehlqcew,D rbably adqb el Dqyrd k ed#Dqyrd k edl Ahjwbyey ehl dliAhlqjbr Ahjjeqqehl p Dk kbrfuWdycvdu Wyu Kyi% qcbi qhjbk efcy hl chv ycb ahry ycbrbp ebvq rbqwhlqeo e k e yu dli ahlyrh kh` cbdkyc dli jbieadk ahlyblyhlk elb, Dlu elqefcyq `hrahjwdlebq el ycb RQ8Ibqweyb ycb `day ycdy Dqyrdkedl

Ahjwbyeyehl dli Ahlqjbr Ahjjeqqehl

p Dkkbrfu Wdycvdu Wyu Kyieq d lhl*RQ

adqb+ ey wrhpeibq dl bsdjwkb h` d

rbdqhldokb ahry yruelf yh dwwku

ibadibq hki wrelaewkbq h`

`hhi(irf(jbieadk ibpeab kdv yh dl

bpbr*acdlfelf vhrki h` Elybrlby

ybaclhkhfu, Ycb Ahry irbv d fhhiodkdlab dli odqbi eyq hwelehl hl ycb

qejwkb wrelaewkbq h` vcbycbr Dkkbrfu

Wdycvdu Wyu Kyi, nlbv hr qchki cdpb

nlhvl h` eldaardyb hr jeqkbdielf

qydybjblyq dli vcbycbr ycbu yhhn

dwwrhwredyb qybwq yh `es ycbqb

eldaardyb dli(hr jeqkbdielf

qydybjblyq hl wdfbq ycdy vbrb libr

ycber ahlyrhk,

El`hrjdk ieqaqqehlq dli lhl*oelielf

ieqaqqehlq veyc RQ qydnbchkibrq

elakielf ke`b qaeblabq ahjwdlebq+

wrhpeibrq+ dli ycb fhpbrljbly qbbj yh

rbqky el qejekdr pebvq, Ycb @ID cdq+jkyewkb yejbq+ elieadybi ycdy ycbu

ahlqeibr ycb Elybrlby yh ob mqy

dlhycbr acdllbk h` ahjjleadyehl

qombay yh ycb qdjb rkbq dq hycbr

acdllbkq, _bqkydlyku+ vcekb ycbrb drb

lh ib`eleyepb pebvq hl ycb eqqb+ ycb

iyu yh ahlyrhk eldaardyb dli(hr

jeqkbdielf qydybjblyq kenbku bseqyq+ dli

ahjwdlebq vhki kenbku ob bswbaybi yh

ahlyrhk wdfbq,

Dlu ahlabrlq dohy yceq adqb8Eq ycb wrbjeqb hr elybrwrbydyehl` kdvbi el uhr hwel ehl8Dq dwwkebi yh RQ kdv= Ycbrb drb d `bv

qbwdrdyb ahlabrlq ycdy adl fepb d ke`b

qaeblabq ahjwdlu wdqb, Qwbae`eadkku+

ycb ahry cbki ycdy d ke`b qaeblabq

ahjwdlu eq rbqwhlqeokb `hr ycb dayehlq

h` ahlqjbrq dli wdyeblyq dli

b``bayepbku dayq el ycber wkdab e` ey `dekqyh rbjhpb whyblyedkku jeqkbdielf

ahlybly, Yceq hwblq w d rdlfb h`

eqqbq elakielf chv #4% Chv h`ybl

jqy d ahjwdlu rbpebv ycb pdrebyu h`

vboqeybq yh ob dokb yh ibjhlqyrdyb

ycdy ey ihbq lhy veqc yh day dq hlb h`

eyq ahlqjbrq #?% Eq ycbrb d iyu yh

Ir, Nkndrle eq ycb Wrelaewdk Dyyhrlbu dy ycb Nkndrle Kdv @erj, Cb `haqbq hl qyrdybfea ahjwkedlab dli

ycber rbfkdyhru dli ahlqbkelf lbbiq, Ceq bsyblqepb bswbreblabq jdldfelf ycb lbbiq h` fkhodk ke`b

qaeblabq ahjwdlebq dli ycber qbrpeab wrhpeibrq elakielf Ahlyrday Jdl`dayrelf Hrfdle}dyehlq+ Ahlyrday

_bqbdrac Hrfdle}dyehlq dli dipbryeqelf dli yrdelelf ahjwdlebq, Ir, Nkndrle cdq dqqeqybi ceq akeblyq el

jbbyelf d pdrebyu h` kbfdk dli rbfkdyhru lbbiq elakielf ard`yelf rbqwhlqbq yh @ID 931q+ @ID rbadkkq+

wrhjhyehldk dli ahjwkedlab rbpebv dli akeleadk yredk lbfhyedyehlq, Obqeibq ceq bswbreblab dq dl dyyhrlbu+

Ir, Nkndrle eq d wcdrjdaeqy+ Dqqhaedyb Wrh`bqqhr+ dli dychr, @hkkhv cej hl Yveyybr G@IDKdvubrq,

8/2/2019 DHC Q&A With Darshan Kulkarni (FDALawyers)

2/3

Iefeyd k Cbdkyc Ahdk e y ehl

ahrrbay jeqel`hrjdyehl8 Hr eq jbrbku

rbjhpelf ycb ahlybly eldibtdybku dli

b``bayepbku ahlqyeyybq qoqareoelf yh

qac hwelehlq8

Dq fkhodk jky e*ldy ehldkahjwdlebq qbbn yh wdry ea ewdybel dl elarbdq elf ku f khod k dliahllbaybi ief eyd k vhr ki + chvadl ahjwdlebq yceln dohyfbhfrdwcea ohlidrebq # el dkbfd k qblqb% vcbl ycb Elybrlbyybliq yh pebv ahlybly `rhj ycbwbrqwbay epb h` kdlfdfb yhidu8Ey eq elarbdqelfku ie``eaky yh ahlyrhk

vcdy wdyeblyq qbb hl ycb Elybrlby,Yceln dohy uhr dieblab+ yceln dohy

vcdy uh adl qdu+ dli ahlqeibr ycb

`day ycdy wdyeblyq `rhj darhqq ycb

fkhob vekk kenbku ob dokb yh daabqq ycb

vhrn ycdy uhr ahjwdlu eq wyyelf hy

errbqwbayepb h` vcbrb el ycb vhrki ycbu

drb, Bdac ahlyru cdq ie``brbly kdvq

dli ey eq cblab ejwhrydly e` whqqeokb yh

kejey daabqq yh pebvbrq `rhj ycb

qwbae`ea ahlyru el tbqyehl,

Dkybrldyepbku d ahjwdlu+ e` lbabqqdru+

jqy dwwrhwredybku ib`elb ycb ahlyru

obelf ydrfbybi #bpbl e` hycbr ahlyrebq

jdu whyblyedkku daabqq ycb qeyb,%

Ycq+ ey eq h`ybl dipdlydfbhq yh

ahlqeibr cdpelf d vbo*qb whkeau dli

jdnelf ey daabqqeokb, Ibaeib vceac qeybq

uh vekk dihwy dli jhleyhr+ ycb

bsybly yh vceac uh vekk jhleyhr ycbqb

qeybq+ dli ycbl cdpb dwwrhwredyb

wrhabqqbq yh rbpebv,

Ycbrb drb d `bv adqbq vhrn elfycrhfc ycb RQ kbfdk quqybj+vceac ve k k cdpb q efl e ` eadlyejwk eady ehlq `hr h`` kdobk dliycb doe k eyu h` ahjwdlebq yhahjjleadyb veyc wdy eblyq+

wrh`bqq ehld kq + dli ycb wo k ea dykd rfb, Chv vhki uhacdrdaybr e}b ycb whqq eo kb ejwdayh` ycbqb adqbq yh ycb `yrb h`i ef eyd k wcdrjdabyead kjdrnby elf8Ycb `hrycahjelf ibodyb hl h``*kdobk

ieqaqqehlq eq kenbku yh cdpb d

qefle`eadly dli wbrjdlbly ejwday hl

wcdrjdabyeadk jdrnbyelf el fblbrdk+

dli iefeydk dli el*wbrqhl jdrnbyelf el

wdryeakdr, Ahjwdlebq cdpb obbl

cbqeydly yh fby hl qhaedk jbied

obadqb ycb whyblyedk `hr h``*kdobk

ieqaqqehlq vdq qefle`eadlyku wkdadybi

ou ycb feidlab ycdy ycb @ID rbablykuwy hy hl lqhkeaeybi h``*kdobk

ieqaqqehlq, Lbpbrycbkbqq+ ycb wblielf

ibaeqehlq jdu dii `rycbr abrydelyu yh

dl eliepeidk ahjwdluq ibaeqehl*jdnelf

wrhabqq dli whyblyedkku wrhpeib

jdrnbyelf dli jbieadk biadyehl

ibwdryjblyq veyc ycb doekeyu yh

ahjjleadyb obyybr veyc wdyeblyq dli

wrhpeibrq,

E ` uh cdi ycrbb k elbq yh qjw ycb ib` el ey ehl h` ahlyrhk dlirbqwhlqeo e k e yu h` cbd kyc dlijbieadk ahlybly hlk elb `rhjycb jdl`dayrbr wbrqwbay epb chv vhki uh ih ey8E` uh veqc yh dihwy d qeyb+ uh jqy

ahlyrhk ycb ahlybly, E` uh ahlyrhk ycb

ahlybly+ uh jqy blqrb eyq daardau,

Uh jqy qb dwwrhwredyb jbdqrbq yh

biadyb dli bjwhvbr ycb ahrrbayeliepeidkq yh ahl`erj ycdy ycbu adl

wrhwbrku jhleyhr dli ahlyrhk ycb qeyb

`hr uh,

8/2/2019 DHC Q&A With Darshan Kulkarni (FDALawyers)

3/3

Iefeyd k Cbdkyc Ahdk e y ehl

Dlu dipeab yh d fblbrd k ahlqbkyruelf yh fby ycber cbdi drhliycb `yrb h` ief eyd k cbdkyc84, Ydkn yh uhr qydnbchkibrq dli

ibaeib uhr kbpbk h` reqn*ydnelf doekeyu,

?, Ihly yru yh ob uhr ahjwdluq

ahjwkedlab h``eabr, Uhr rhkb eq yh

dwwrhwredybku rbwrbqbly uhr ahjwdluq

elybrbqyq #elakielf eyq jdrnbyelf

elybrbqyq%, Ahlpbrqbku+ ycb rhkb h` d

ahjwkedlab h``eabr eq lhy yh khhn dy ycb

obqy elybrbqyq h` ycb ahjwdlu `rhj d

jdrnbyelf wbrqwbayepb oy `rhj d

ahjwkedlab wbrqwbayepb, Ycbrb eq d

whyblyedk ahl`keay h` elybrbqy+ dli ycbIHM vhki kenbku lhy khhn neliku hl uh

hpbrrkelf ycb ahjwkedlab h``eabr,

1, Ybaclhkhfu eq acdlfelf> kby

jdrnbyelf feib uh hl ycb ierbayehl

h` ybaclhkhfu+ oy qb uhr hvl fy

elqyelay hl ycb dwwrhwredyblbqq h` eyq

qb dli ycb qeydoekeyu h` ycb jbqqdfb

`hr uhr wdyeblyq,

Vcdy drb uhr `dphreyb cbdkycdli jbiead k q eybq yhidu8Jbiqadwb,ahj dli Irfq,ahj,

Vcdy ybaclhkhfu ahjwdlebq ihuh jhqy dijerb8Dwwkb `hr eyq doekeyu yh ordli dli

Fhhfkb `hr eyq ibqerb yh ellhpdyb,

Fhhfkb cdq d wrhfrdj ycdy blahrdfbq

ellhpdyehl dli dkkhvq ey bjwkhubbq yhqwbli w yh ?7" h` ycber rbqhrabq hl

wbrqhldk wrhmbayq+ vceac bpblydkku jdu

ibpbkhw elyh ceyq kenb Fjdek,

Vcdy ybaclhkhfu ibpeab ih uhjhqy dijerb8Ycb Fhhfkb bubfkdqqbq

Vcdy ybaclhkhfu dipdlabjblyih uh jhqy dijerb8Dl hkieb oy d fhhieb= Abkk wchlbq, E

adl ob dluvcbrb el ycb vhrki+ dli E

dj dkvduq rbdacdokb,Vcdy ybaclhkhfu dipdlabjblyih uh jhqy ibqweqb8Ybsy jbqqdfelf, Wkbdqb ydkn yh jb

vcbl uh vdly yh cdpb d ahlpbrqdyehl,

Vcbl eq ycb kdqy y ejb uh vblyh`` ycb frei `hr dy kbdqy ?9chrq8E h`ybl `eli juqbk` fhelf h`` ycb frei

hl ju `rbtbly yrewq yh Elied, Ey eq

lqbyykelf yh qydry veyc+ oy uh obfel

blmhuelf wbhwkb dfdel d`ybr uh fby

qbi yh ycb eibd ycdy uhr bjdekq

drbly ahjelf ycrhfc ejjbiedybku,