Developing Asia’s Pension Systems: Overview and Reform Directions (ADB RETA No.7357)

8/9/2019 Developing Asia’s Pension Systems: Overview and Reform Directions (ADB RETA No.7357)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/developing-asias-pension-systems-overview-and-reform-directions-adb-reta 1/31

@mvmha~gic E{ge‗{ ^mi{gai [w{pmd{<Avmzvgms ei` Zmoazd @gzmkpgai{

"E@J ZMPE Ia)3;=3'

@z) @aicbw}i ÊZF( E{gei @mvmha~dmip Jeif "`~ezfNe`j)azc'

Zmcgaieh Kaiomzmikm ai [akgeh ^zapmkpgai

:5$:: E~zgh :>5>( E@J BU( Deighe

@g{khegdmz< Pbm vgms{ mr~zm{{m` gi pbg{ ~e~mz!~zm{mipepgai ezm pbm vgms{ ao pbm e}pbaz ei` à iap imkm{{ezghw zmohmkp pbm vgms{ az ~ahgkgm{ ao pbm E{gei @mvmha~dmip Jeif "E@J'( az gp{ Jaez` ao Cavmziaz{( az pbm

cavmzidmip{ pbmw zm~zm{mip) E@J àm{ iap c}ezeipmm pbm ekk}zekw ao pbm èpe gikh}`m` gi pbg{ ~e~mz ei` ekkm~p{ ia zm{~ai{gjghgpw oaz eiw kai{mu}mikm ao pbmgz }{m) Pmzdgiahacw }{m` dew iap imkm{{ezghw jm

kai{g{pmip sgpb E@J aoogkgeh pmzd{)



:

5 Gipza`}kpgai

Ah`$ecm gikadm {}~~azp sghh jm aim ao `mvmha~gic E{ge‗{ jgccm{p {akgeh ei` mkaiadgk kbehhmicm{ gi pbm:5{p kmip}zw)

Pbg{ g{ hezcmhw `}m pa e {mg{dgk `mdacze~bgk

pzei{gpgai ‛ g)m) ~a~}hepgai ecmgic) Gi kaipze{p pa AMK@ ka}ipzgm{( E{ge àm{ iap wmp

bevm dep}zm( smhh$o}ikpgaigic ~mi{gai {w{pmd{)

â~}hepgai ecmgic g{ ei E{ge$sg`m ~bmiadmiai( j}ppbmzm ezm delaz `goomzmikm{ ekza{{ {}j$zmcgai{) Dazm e`veikm` gi Me{p E{ge ei` [a}pbme{p E{ge pbei gi

[a}pb E{ge



;

5 Gipza`}kpgai

A}z ~zalmkp oak}{m{ ai ^ZK( Giàim{ge( Fazme(Dehew{ge( ^bghg~~gim{( [gice~azm( Pbeghei` ei` _gmpied)

â~}hepgai ecmgic g{ da{p e`veikm` gi Fazme ei`[gice~azm( ei` hme{p e`veikm` gi Giàim{ge(^bghg~~gim{ ei` _gmpied)

Pbm `mdacze~bgk pzmi`{ zm{a}i`gichw kaiogzd pbmkaivmipgaieh sg{àd ao e ze~g`hw ecmgic E{ge)

E kai{pmhhepgai ao mkaiadgk ei` {akgeh oekpaz{ g{gi`}kgic E{gei{ pa bevm omsmz kbgh`zmi ei` miejhgic

pbmd pa hgvm haicmz)



0

Ogc}zm 5Zepga ao â~}hepgai Ecm` ≭?= pa â~}hepgai Ecm` 5=$?0( 57=>$:>=>

>

5>

:>

;>

0>

=>

?>

3>

57=> 57?> 573> 572> 577> :>>> :>5> :>:> :>;> :>0> :>=>

-

^ZK Giàim{ge Dehew{ge ^bghg~~gim{

[gice~azm Fazme( Zm~) ao Pbeghei` _gmp Ied



=

Ogc}zm :

Zepga ao â~}hepgai Ecm` ≭?= pa Papeh â~}hepgai( 57=>‛:>=>

>

=

5>

5=

:>

:=

;>

;=

0>

57=> 57?> 573> 572> 577> :>>> :>5> :>:> :>;> :>0> :>=>

-





?

Ogc}zm ;

Omzpghgpw Zepm "I}djmz ao Kbgh`zmi ^mz Sadei'( 57=>$:>=>

>

5

:

;

0

=

?

3

2

57=>$57== 57?=$573> 572>$572= 577=$:>>> :>5>$:>5= :>:=$:>;> :>0>$:>0=





3

Ogc}zm 0Hgom Mr~mkpeikw ep Jgzpb "Wmez{'( 57=>$:>=>

;>

0>

=>

?>

3>

2>

7>

57=>$57== 57?=$573> 572>$572= 577=$:>>> :>5>$:>5= :>:=$:>;> :>0>$:>0=





2

Pejhm 5@mdacze~bgk Gi`gkepaz{ ao [mhmkpm` E{gei Ka}ipzgm{

05)?:0)75)2:)5>):55);:5:>)>23)0_gmp Ied

00);;:)?5)25)2">):3'>)???3)0?;)7Pbeghei`

=;)3;3)=5)?5):">);2'5)57=)>0)0[gice~azm

;?);:5)25)2;):>)=>5)7>50>)=23)7^bghg~~gim{

;7);:0)35)2:)?>)055)?7;7)?:?)?Dehew{ge

=0)7;=)>5)=5):">)27'>);;0:);02):Fazme( Zm~) ao05)5:?)=5)2:):>)5>5)5?:7?)7:;5)?Giàim{ge

0=)>;:)=5)25)3">);:'>)=250>2)25;:2)?^ZK

;2)5:2)>:)>:)?>);?5)537575);??35):Sazh`

:>=>:>>=:>0=‛ :>=>

:>>=‛ :>5>

:>0=‛:>=>:>>=‛ :>5>

:>=>:>>3

Dm`gei EcmPapeh Omzpghgpw Zepm"POZ'

Evmzecm eii}eh zepmao kbeicm ao~a~}hepgai

Papeh â~}hepgai"dghhgai{'

Ka}ipzw





5>

5 Gipza`}kpgai

E i}djmz ao apbmz oekpaz{ eh{a ~agip pa ei }zcmipimm` pa {pzmicpbmi ah` ecm {}~~azp gi E{ge)

Gi ~ezpgk}hez( pbm smefmigic ao gioazdeh oedghw$je{m` ah` ecm {}~~azp dmkbeig{d{

Hezcm mrpmi`m` oedghgm{ ezm cgvgic sew pa {dehhmzi}khmez oedghgm{ sbgkb ezm hm{{ kai`}kgvm pa gipze$oedghw {}~~azp)



55

Ogc}zm =]zjei â~}hepgai e{ [bezm ao Papeh â~}hepgai( 57=>$:>;>

>

5>

:>

;>

0>

=>

?>

3>

2>

7>

5>>

57=> 57?> 573> 572> 577> :>>> :>5> :>:> :>;>

-


Fazme( Zm~) ao Pbeghei` _gmp Ied Sazh`



5:

Ogc}zm ?

Eczgk}hp}zm e{ [bezm ao C@^( 57?>$:>>?

>

5>

:>

;>

0>

=>

?>

57?> 57?= 573> 573= 572> 572= 577> 577= :>>> :>>=

-

^ZK Giàim{ge Fazme( Zm~) Dehew{ge

^bghg~~gim{ Pbeghei` _gmp Ied [gice~azm



5;

5 Gipza`}kpgai

O}zpbmz gd~mp}{ oaz ~mi{gai zmoazd kadm{ozad chajehg|epgai ei` chajehg|epgai$zmhepm`hejaz dezfmp `mvmha~dmip{)

E{ge g{ iap gdd}im ozad pbm {pz}kp}zeh`g{hakepgai{ `}m pa chajehg|epgai)

Ha{{ ao laj {mk}zgpw g{ o}zpbmz e``gic pa pbm {akgehei` mkaiadgk {mi{m ao gi{mk}zgpw)

Gi E{ge( hezcm i}djmz{ ao gioazdeh${mkpazsazfmz{ kad~a}i` pbm ha{{ ao laj {mk}zgpw)

Smhh$o}ikpgaigic {akgeh ~zapmkpgai {w{pmd{(

gikh}`gic ~mi{gai {w{pmd( kei me{m gi{mk}zgpw)



50

Ogc}zm 3Papeh Pze`m e{ [bezm ao C@^( Me{p E{ge / êkgogk ei` Sazh`

>

5>

:>

;>

0>

=>

?>

3>

2>

7>

572: 5720 572? 5722 577> 577: 5770 577? 5772 :>>> :>>: :>>0 :>>?

-

Me{p E{ge / ekgogk Sazh`



5=

Ogc}zm 2[bezm ao Gioazdeh [mkpaz Md~hawdmip gi ]zjei Md~hawdmip(

_ezga}{ Wmez{

>

5>

:>

;>

0>

=>

?>

3>

2>

7>

I m ~ e

h

K e d

j a ` g e

J e i c h e

m { b

G i ` g e

e f g {

p e i

G i a i m

{ g e

[ z g H e

i f e

b g h g ~

~ g i m {

P b e g h e

i `

F a z m

e ( Z m ~

) a o

P e ~ m g ( K b

g i e

[ g i c e ~

a z m



5?

: Avmzvgms ao E{gei^mi{gai [w{pmd{

Sm ias mredgim pbm jzae` eiepadw ao pbm ~mi{gai {w{pmd{ ao pbm 2 ka}ipzgm{)

Pbm je{gk {pz}kp}zm ao ~mi{gai {w{pmd{ g{

`gvmz{m ei` zmohmkp{ mekb ka}ipzw‗{kai{pzegip{ ei` ~zmomzmikm{)

Pbmzm g{ kai{g`mzejhm bmpmzacmimgpw gipmzd{ ao fmw ~mi{gai ~ezedmpmz{ {}kb e{~mi{gai ecm ei` kaipzgj}pgai zepm)



53

Pejhm :^mi{gai Ecm ei` Je{gk [pz}kp}zm ao ^mi{gai [w{pmd{( :>>3

Ia@mogim` Jmimogp:5):5:);?> "=='_gmpied

Ia@mogim` Jmimogp:>55)===Pbeghei`

Ia@mogim` Kaipzgj}pgai57)75??:[gice~azm

Wm{@mogim` Jmimogp2)70)=?=^bghg~~gim{

Ia@mogim` Kaipzgj}pgai:5)353==Dehew{ge

Wm{@mogim` Jmimogp53):5>?=Fazme

Ia@mogim` Kaipzgj}pgai53)35;)3==Giàim{ge

Wm{

@mogim` Jmimogp(

@mogim` Kaipzgj}pgai( ei`

Iapgaieh @mogim`Kaipzgj}pgai

57)255);?> "=='Kbgie

OmdehmDehm

Mhmdmip ao

Gikadm

Zm`g{pzgj}pgai

@mogim` Jmimogp

az

@mogim` Kaipzgj}pgai

@goomzmikm JmpsmmiHgom Mr~mkpeikw ei`^mi{gai Ecm "Wmez{'^mi{gai Ecm

"Wmez{'Ka}ipzw



52


Pbm ~mi{gai ecm zeicm{ ozad == pa ?=) Hgom mr~mkpeikw$~mi{gai ecm ce~ zeicm{

ozad 0)= wmez{ pa 5;)3 wmez{ oaz dmi( ei`

2)7 wmez{ pa :5)3 wmez{ oaz sadmi)

Pbm ~mi{gai {w{pmd{ ao ehh mgcbp ka}ipzgm{

ezm z}i jw pbm cavmzidmip) Basmvmz( pbm je{gk {pz}kp}zm ao pbm

~mi{gai {w{pmd{ g{ oez ozad }igoazd)



57


^mi{gai {w{pmd{ ao Giàim{ge( Dehew{ge ei`[gice~azm ezm `mogim` kaipzgj}pgai)

^mi{gai {w{pmd{ ao Fazme( ^bghg~~gim{( Pbeghei`

ei` _gmpied ezm `mogim` jmimogp) ^ZK‗{ ~mi{gai {w{pmd kadjgim{ e `mogim`

jmimogp ~ghhez ei` e `mogim` kaipzgj}pgai! iapgaieh

`mogim` kaipzgj}pgai ~ghhez) Pbm ~mi{gai {w{pmd{ ao ^ZK( Fazme ei`

^bghg~~gim{ be{ ei mr~hgkgphw zm`g{pzgj}pgvm

mhmdmip)



:>

; @gecia{g{ ao E{gei^mi{gai [w{pmd{

Pbm jgccm{p oegh}zm ao E{gei ~mi{gai{w{pmd{ g{ gie`mu}epm kavmzecm $ pbmwkavmz aihw e hgdgpm` ~ezp ao ~a~}hepgai )

Pbm {bezm ao pbm hejaz oazkm sbgkb g{kavmzm` jw ~mi{gai {w{pmd{ zeicm{ ozad5;):- pa =2-)

Pbm kavmzecm zepm oaz sazfgic$ecm~a~}hepgai zeicm{ ozad 5>)2- pa 0>-)



:5


Gi `mvmha~m` ka}ipzgm{( ~mi{gai {w{pmd{pw~gkehhw kavmz eza}i` 7>- ao pbm hejazoazkm ei` jmpsmmi ?>- ei` 3=- ao pbm

sazfgic$ecm ~a~}hepgai) Mvmi gi bgcb$gikadm E{gei ka}ipzgm{ {}kb

e{ Fazme( kavmzecm oehh{ smhh {bazp ao `mvmha~m`$ka}ipzw hmvmh{)



::

Ogc}zm 7[bezm ao Hejaz Oazkm Kavmzm` jw ^mi{gai [w{pmd{ ei`

[bezm ao â~}hepgai Ecm` 5=$?0 Kavmzm` jw ^mi{gai [w{pmd{( :>>3

>

5>

:>

;>

0>

=>

?>

^ZK Giàim{ge Fazme(

Zm~) ao

Dehew{ge^bghg~~gim{[gice~azm Pbeghei _gmp Ied

Hejaz Oazkm Sazfgic$Ecm â~}hepgai



:;


E{gei ka}ipzgm{ eh{a ~mzoazd ~aazhw sgpbzm{~mkp pa pbm zm~hekmdmip zepm( az pbmzepga ao zmpgzmdmip gikadm pa ~zm$

zmpgzmdmip gikadm) Zm~hekmdmip zepm g{ e sg`mhw }{m` dme{}zm ao

pbm e`mu}ekw ao ~mi{gai jmimogp e{ e {a}zkmao ~a{p$zmpgzmdmip gikadm)

^mi{gai mr~mzp{ cmimzehhw zmkaddmi` ezm~hekmdmip zepm ao jmpsmmi ?? pa 3=-(e`l}{pm` oaz japb haicmvgpw ei` giohepgai zg{f{)



:0


Psa ~mi{gai da`mhgic {p}`gm{ kad~hmpm`gi :>>2 ‛ jw AMK@!Sazh` Jeif ei` E@J $kad~}pm pbm zm~hekmdmip zepm oaz E{gei

~mi{gai {w{pmd{) Japb {p}`gm{ gi`gkepm pbep zm~hekmdmip zepm{

ezm bgcbmz gi ^ZK( Fazme( ^bghg~~gim{ ei` _gmpIed pbei gi Giàim{ge( Dehew{ge( [gice~azmei` Pbeghei`)

Jw ei` hezcm( E{gei ~mi{gai {w{pmd{ ezm iap~zavg`gic ei e`mu}epm zmpgzmdmip gikadm)



:=

Ogc}zm 5> ‛ E@J ":>>2'Zm~hekmdmip Zepm‐Zepga ao Zmpgzmdmip Gikadm pa ^zm$Zmpgzmdmip Gikadm( :>>3

>

5>

:>

;>

0>

=>?>

3>

2>

7>

Z K

G i a

i m { g e

F a z m

e ( Z m

~ ) a o

D e h e

w { g e

b g h g ~ ~

g i m {

[ g i c e ~ a z m

P b e g h e i `

_ g m p

I e d



:?

Ogc}zm 55 $ AMK@$Sazh` Jeif ":>>2'Zm~hekmdmip Zepm ‛ Zepga ao Zmpgzmdmip Gikadm pa

^zm$Zmpgzmdmip Gikadm( :>>3

>

5>

:>

;>

0>

=>?>

3>

2>

7>

Z K

G i a

i m { g e

F a z m

e ( Z m

~ ) a o

D e h e

w { g e

b g h g ~ ~

g i m {

[ g i c e ~ a z m

P b e g h e i `

_ g m p

I e d



:3


Jm{g`m{ kavmzecm ei` zm~hekmdmip zepm(pbmzm ezm e i}djmz ao apbmz smefim{{m{)

]i{}{pegiejghgpw ‛ m)c) Sazh` Jeif ogi`{ pbep

gd~hgkgp ~mi{gai `mjp mrkmm`{ ~}jhgk `mjp gi^ZK( Fazme ei` ^bghg~~gim{)

Zaj}{pim{{ ecegi{p e`vmz{m mrpmzieh {bakf{

Gie`mu}epm {eompw imp{ oaz pbm mh`mzhw ~aaz



:2

0 Sew Oazsez` oaz E{gei^mi{gai [w{pmd{

Pbm `gecia{g{ ao pbm k}zzmip {pepm ao E{gei~mi{gai {w{pmd{ defm{ gp ej}ièiphw khmezpbep pbmzm g{ ei }zcmip ke{m oaz ~mi{gai

zmoazd pbza}cba}p pbm zmcgai) Sgpba}p jgc zmoazd( pbm zmcgai‗{ ~mi{gai

{w{pmd{ ezm ghh$~zm~ezm` pa ka~m sgpb ah`$ecm gikadm {}~~azp gi oekm ao ~a~}hepgaiecgic ei` apbmz {pz}kp}zeh {bgop{)



:7


Fmw ezme{ ao zmoazd gikh}`m< gi{pgp}pgaieh ei` e`dgig{pzepgvm ke~ekgpw

cavmzieikm ei` zmc}hepgai

mr~ei`gic kavmzecm gd~zavm pbm zmp}zi{ ozad ~mi{gai e{{mp{

mibeikgic ogieikgeh {}{pegiejghgpw

~zapmkp pbm mh`mzhw ~aaz

pbgif a}p{g`m pbm jar oaz giiavepgvm {ah}pgai{



;>


Eopmz `mke`m{ ao czaspb$azgmipm` ~ahgkgm{ ei`ze~g` mkaiadgk czaspb( E{ge g{ ogiehhw ~ewgic dazmeppmipgai pa {akgeh ~zapmkpgai)

Gi hgcbp ao E{ge‗{ ze~g` ~a~}hepgai ecmgic( eim{~mkgehhw gd~azpeip kad~aimip ao {akgeh~zapmkpgai g{ ah`$ecm gikadm {}~~azp)

bm ke{m oaz }zcmip ~mi{gai zmoazd gi E{ge g{ e{d}kb mkaiadgk e{ {akgeh)

A}z ZMPE sghh kaipzgj}pm pa g`mipgowgic {~mkgogk ei`

kaikzmpm `gzmkpgai{ oaz ~mi{gai zmoazd gi E{ge)



;5


‘Ecmgic E{ge‗{ Haadgic ^mi{gai Kzg{g{— g{pbm jekfcza}i` ~e~mz oaz ZMPE 3;=3)

Pbm ~e~mz kei jm oa}i` ep sss)e`j)azc ⇚Mkaiadgk{ ei` [pepg{pgk{ "pa~' ⇚ E@JMkaiadgk{ Sazfgic ê~mz [mzgm{ "zgcbp' ⇚

Ia)5?=

Documents

Developing Asia’s Pension Systems: Overview and Reform Directions (ADB RETA No.7357)