Upload
cheryl
View
52
Download
5
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Description of weakly bound nuclei with PTG/HFB and Gamow/HFB approaches. Nicolas Michel ( ESNT/ SPhN /CEA ) Kenichi Matsuyanagi (Kyoto University) Mario Stoitsov (ORNL – University of Tennessee). Plan. Scientific motivation: drip-line nuclei - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Citation preview
Nicolas MichelNicolas MichelCross-fertilization between shell model and Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsenergy density functional methods
Description of weakly Description of weakly bound nuclei with bound nuclei with
PTG/HFB and Gamow/HFB PTG/HFB and Gamow/HFB approachesapproaches
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel (ESNT/SPhN/CEA)(ESNT/SPhN/CEA)
Kenichi MatsuyanagiKenichi Matsuyanagi (Kyoto University) (Kyoto University)
Mario StoitsovMario Stoitsov (ORNL – University of Tennessee) (ORNL – University of Tennessee)
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 22
Plan Plan
• Scientific motivation: drip-line nucleiScientific motivation: drip-line nuclei
• Gamow states, Berggren completeness relation, Gamow Shell ModelGamow states, Berggren completeness relation, Gamow Shell Model
• Gamow quasi-particle states and HFB densitiesGamow quasi-particle states and HFB densities
• Applications: Nickel chain (spherical)Applications: Nickel chain (spherical)
• PPööschl-Teller-Ginocchio (PTG) basis for loosely bound systemsschl-Teller-Ginocchio (PTG) basis for loosely bound systems
• Resonant structure with PTG basisResonant structure with PTG basis
• Applications: Nickel chain (spherical)Applications: Nickel chain (spherical)
Zirconium and Magnesium (deformed)Zirconium and Magnesium (deformed)
• Conclusion and perspectivesConclusion and perspectives
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 33
Scientific motivation Scientific motivation
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 44
Gamow statesGamow states
• Georg GamowGeorg Gamow : : decay decay
G.A. Gamow, Zs f. Phys. G.A. Gamow, Zs f. Phys. 5151 (1928) 204; (1928) 204; 5252 (1928) 510 (1928) 510
• DefinitionDefinition : :
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 55
Complex scaling methodComplex scaling method
• Radial integral calculationRadial integral calculation : : complex scalingcomplex scaling
• Analytic continuationAnalytic continuation : integral : integral independentindependent of R and of R and θθ
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 66
Gamow states locationGamow states location
Choice of contourChoice of contour
arbitraryarbitrary
narrownarrow
broadbroad
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 77
Completeness relations with Completeness relations with Gamow states Gamow states
• Berggren completeness relationBerggren completeness relation (l,j) : (l,j) :
T. Berggren, Nucl. Phys. A T. Berggren, Nucl. Phys. A 109109, (1967) 205, (1967) 205
• Continuum discretizationContinuum discretization : :
• N-body discretized completeness relationN-body discretized completeness relation (all l,j) : (all l,j) :
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 88
Application : He, Li and O chainsApplication : He, Li and O chains
• He, Li chainsHe, Li chains : valence particles above : valence particles above 44HeHe core : core : H = WS (H = WS (55He) + SGIHe) + SGI
0p0p3/23/2, 0p, 0p1/21/2 (resonant), p (resonant), p3/23/2 and p and p1/21/2 scattering continuums scattering continuums
SGI : Surface Gaussian Interaction :SGI : Surface Gaussian Interaction :
• Dependence on number of nucleons for T=0Dependence on number of nucleons for T=0
• Spherical Gamow Hartree-Fock basisSpherical Gamow Hartree-Fock basis from H = WS + SGI from H = WS + SGI
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 99
N. Michel et al.,N. Michel et al., Phys. Rev C, Phys. Rev C, 6767 054311 (2003) 054311 (2003)Rev. Mex. Fis., Rev. Mex. Fis., 50 S250 S2 74 (2004) 74 (2004)
Bound from Bound from unbound basis unbound basis
Helium anomaly Helium anomaly
reproducedreproduced
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 1010
Halo densityHalo density
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 1111
E (
MeV
)E
(M
eV)
S-components S-components
missingmissing
SatisfactorySatisfactory
resultsresults
(schematic model) (schematic model)
N. Michel et al., Phys. Rev. C N. Michel et al., Phys. Rev. C 7070, 064313 (2004), 064313 (2004)
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 1212
Gamow HFB spaceGamow HFB space
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 1313
Densities with Gamow HFBDensities with Gamow HFB• HFB equations:HFB equations:
• Complex particle and pairing densities:Complex particle and pairing densities:
• HF associated bound and narrow resonant states in HF associated bound and narrow resonant states in discrete sumdiscrete sum
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 1414
Quasi-particle pole statesQuasi-particle pole states• Bound, resonant states:Bound, resonant states:
S matrix poles => outgoing wave function behavior S matrix poles => outgoing wave function behavior
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 1515
Quasi-particle scattering statesQuasi-particle scattering states• Scattering states:Scattering states:
u(r):u(r): incoming and outgoing componentsincoming and outgoing components v(r):v(r): outgoingoutgoing wave function behavior wave function behavior
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 1616
Gamow Gamow quasi-particle states normquasi-particle states norm
• Normalization:Normalization:
S-matrix polesS-matrix poles:: complex scaling complex scaling
Scattering statesScattering states:: Dirac delta normalization Dirac delta normalization
Continuum discretizationContinuum discretization::
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 1717
Gamow Hartree-Fock Gamow Hartree-Fock diagonalization methoddiagonalization method
• Two-basis methodTwo-basis method
BasisBasis generated bygenerated by ph part ph part of HFB hamiltonian: of HFB hamiltonian:
B. Gall et al., Z. Phys. B. Gall et al., Z. Phys. A348A348 183 (1994) 183 (1994)
• HFB matrix structure:HFB matrix structure:
• Diagonalization of HFB matrix in Gamow HF basisDiagonalization of HFB matrix in Gamow HF basis
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 1818
Description of Nickel calculationsDescription of Nickel calculations
• Considered nuclei:Considered nuclei: 8484Ni, Ni, 8686Ni, Ni, 8888Ni, Ni, 9090NiNi
• Interaction and space:Interaction and space:
Skyrme interaction:Skyrme interaction: Sly4, E Sly4, Ecutcut = 60 MeV, l: 0 = 60 MeV, l: 0 →→ 10 10
RRcutcut = 20 fm, k = 20 fm, kmaxmax = 4 fm = 4 fm-1-1, N, Nscatscat (l,j) = 100 for GHF basis. (l,j) = 100 for GHF basis.
• Interest:Interest: Resonant structure Resonant structure directlydirectly put in HFB basis put in HFB basis
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 1919
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 2020
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 2121
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 2222
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 2323
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 2424
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 2525
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 2626
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 2727
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 2828
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 2929
PTG basis for HFB calculationsPTG basis for HFB calculations
• Gamow HF(B) basis:Gamow HF(B) basis: Advantages:Advantages: good asymptoticsgood asymptotics, , smoothly varying continuumssmoothly varying continuums Inconvenients:Inconvenients: complex arithmetic, complex arithmetic, long calculationslong calculations
• Weakly bound systems:Weakly bound systems: realreal continuouscontinuous bases bases sufficientsufficient• Real Gamow HF basis:Real Gamow HF basis: problematicproblematic due to due to resonant structureresonant structure in in continuumcontinuum
• PTG basis:PTG basis: resonancesresonances replaced by replaced by bound statesbound states No resonant stateNo resonant state in (l,j) partial wave: in (l,j) partial wave: Hankel/Coulomb functionsHankel/Coulomb functions Smooth continuumsSmooth continuums for all partial waves for all partial waves Weakly bound systems asymptotics Weakly bound systems asymptotics well describedwell described
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 3030
Accepted in Phys. Rev. CAccepted in Phys. Rev. C
HF/PTG potentials HF/PTG potentials
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 3131
HF/PTG wave functionsHF/PTG wave functions
r (fm)r (fm) Accepted in Phys. Rev. CAccepted in Phys. Rev. C
---- : PTG---- : PTG : HF: HF
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 3232
r (fm)r (fm) r (fm)r (fm) Accepted in Phys. Rev. CAccepted in Phys. Rev. C
---- : PTG p---- : PTG p---- : PTG n---- : PTG n
: Box p: Box p : Box n: Box n
.… .… : HO: HO
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 3333
Accepted in Phys. Rev. CAccepted in Phys. Rev. C
----- : prot.----- : prot. : neut.: neut.
… … : THO: THO
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 3434
Accepted in Phys. Rev. CAccepted in Phys. Rev. C
----- : prot.----- : prot. : neut.: neut.
April 7-10, 2008April 7-10, 2008ESNT/SPhN/CEAESNT/SPhN/CEA
Cross-fertilization between shell model Cross-fertilization between shell model and energy density functional methodsand energy density functional methods
Nicolas MichelNicolas Michel 3535
Conclusion and perspectivesConclusion and perspectives• Gamow Shell Model:Gamow Shell Model: Hybrid methodHybrid method: Gamow Hartree-Fock basis necessary: Gamow Hartree-Fock basis necessary He, Li chains with He, Li chains with schematic Hamiltoniansschematic Hamiltonians Next stepNext step : : realisticrealistic interactions, interactions, effectiveeffective interactions with continuum interactions with continuum
• HFB expansions with Gamow and PTG basesHFB expansions with Gamow and PTG bases Precise tool to study dripline heavy nucleiPrecise tool to study dripline heavy nuclei PTG basis near-optimal for weakly bound systemsPTG basis near-optimal for weakly bound systems Nickel chain, Nickel chain, 4040Mg and Mg and 110110Zn : spherical and deformed ground statesZn : spherical and deformed ground states • Conclusions and perspectivesConclusions and perspectives Weakly bound nuclei : Weakly bound nuclei : fast and stable method with PTG basisfast and stable method with PTG basis Future Future QRPAQRPA calculationscalculations with with quasi-particle basis quasi-particle basis fromfrom HFB/PTG HFB/PTG Gamow-HFBGamow-HFB :: problems remain for unbound nuclei problems remain for unbound nuclei