23
Dennis McBride, Ph.D. The Washington Institute (253) 756-2335 [email protected] Goal Driven Logic Models

Dennis McBride, Ph.D. The Washington Institute (253) 756-2335 [email protected] Goal Driven Logic Models

  • View
    213

  • Download
    1

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Dennis McBride, Ph.D. The Washington Institute

(253) [email protected]

Goal Driven Logic Models

Systems and Heaps

A System• Interconnecting parts

function as a whole• Changed or damaged if

you add or remove pieces• Arrangement is crucial• Parts are connected and

only work together• Behavior depends on total

structure. Change the structure and behavior changes.

A Heap• A collection of parts

• Essential properties unchanged if you add or remove pieces

• Arrangement is irrelevant

• Parts are not connected and can function separately

• Behavior (if any) depends on size, or number of pieces

Adapted from CDC

What is a Program Logic Model?

A co nceptual m ap o f yo ur pro gram

A picture o f the linkages between a pro gram 's key co m po nents

P laces the pro cess o f co nducting a pro gram and the expected results f ro m that pro cess into a linked m o del

Purpose of a Logic Model

• Describes the elements of a program

• Describes the chain of plausible linkages between those elements

• Show the sequence between program activities and expected outcomes

Logic ModelA graphic representation that shows logical relationships between inputs, outputs and outcomes relative to a situation

SITUATION

INPUTS OUTCOMESOUTPUTS

Adapted from UW ExtensionAdapted from UW Extension

Logic Model

INPUTS

Programmatic investments

What we invest

OUTPUTS

Activities Participation

What we do

Who we reach

OUTCOMES

Short Medium Long

term

What results

Adapted from UW Extension

Participation

OUTPUTS

Activities

OUTCOMES

Short Medium Long

term

INPUTS

Programmatic investments

EVALUATION

PLANNING

Adapted from UW Extension

STAFFMONEY

TIMEVOLUNTEERS

PARTNERSEQUIPMENT

INPUTS

Adapted from UW Extension

PARTICIPATION Participants Clients Customers UsersConsumers

ACTIVITIES Service DeliveryWorkshops Counseling Facilitation Curriculum design TrainingsConferences

OUTPUTS What we do Who we reach

Adapted from UW Extension

LONG-TERMConditions

Human Economic Civic Environment

MEDIUMAction

Behavior Practice Decisions Policies Social action

SHORTLearning

Awareness Knowledge Attitudes Skills Opinion Aspirations Motivation

OUTCOMESWhat results for individuals, businesses, communities..…

Adapted from UW Extension

M O DEL LINKAG ES

G o al O b je ctiv e s In te rv e n tio n O u tco me s

Sh o rt Te rm

Lo n g Te rm(imp acts)

Ev alu atio n Stag e s

Pro ce ss O u tco meProblem/IssueProblem/Issue

Definitions

• Problem /Issue A condition that requires action (e.g., social or health).

• Goal A statement of an ideal or hoped for state or

condition. It is usually general and abstract.

• Objectives Statements of specific, achievable, and measurable desired accomplishments of a program that are derived from the goal.

Definitions: Objectives

• Outcome Objectives Statements that specify the desirable results of an intervention.  

• Process Objectives Statements that identify the steps to be taken (activities/interventions) toward accomplishing a desired end (outcome). Examples are service delivery, recruitment, instruction, referral.

 

Specific

Measurable

Achievable

Related to the goal

Time Limited

Definitions: Process• Inputs are resources a program uses to achieve

program objectives.

• Activities are what a program does with its inputs-the services it provides-to fulfill its mission.

  • Outputs are the products of program activities

and are measured in terms of what was done, how it was done, and who received it.

Definitions: Outcomes• Outcomes Benefits or changes for individual or

populations during or after participation in program activities. They are influenced by a program’s outputs.

• Short-term Example: an increase in intention to use condoms due to a sex education intervention.

• Intermediate Outcomes Example: an increase in condom use due to a sex education intervention.

 • Long-term Outcomes Example: a decrease in

STD rates due to a sex education intervention.

OUTCOME LINKAGE EXAMPLE

Teen Parenting Program1

CoordinatedCase

Management

Increased Services

(Output)

Decrease in

Repeat

Pregnancies(Intermediate)

Increased Financial

Independence

(LongTerm)

OUTCOME LINKAGE EXAMPLEPregnancy/STD Prevention Program2

Small group sessions /advocacy /referral

(Process)

Increase knowledge/ decrease sexual activity intent, increase intent to use contraceptives(Short Term Outcome)

Decrease in Sexual

Activity and/or Increase

in Effective

Contraceptive Use

Decrease in Pregnancy

Rates/STDs

(Long Term Outcome)(Intermediate Outcome)

Developing a Logic Model

• Identify the problem or issue that the program will address• Identify the ultimate goal of the program in addressing the

problem• The objectives lead to the conduct of a variety of activities

(intervention, training, service delivery)• Each activity is assumed to result in short-term outcomes• The short-term outcomes lead to intermediate outcomes• The intermediate outcomes lead to long-term outcomes• Long-term outcomes should have an impact on the ultimate

program goal

Problem/Issue

The adolescent pregnancy rate and STI/STD rate in Washington State is increasing. A needs assessment points to pockets of “high risk” youth 13-16 years of age that are especially vulnerable and are accounting for a disproportionate share of these rates. The Department of Health wants to address this issue by funding “client focused” prevention interventions targeting these populations in the state. A RFP is sent out and your team will respond. Develop a simple logic model that “maps” your response.

Goal Outcome Objectives

Intervention(Process)

Short-term Outcomes

Intermediate Outcomes

Long-term Outcomes

A statement of an ideal or hoped for state or condition. It is usually general and abstract.

Statements that specify the desirable results of an intervention that are derived from the goal.

Statements that identify the steps to be taken toward accomplishing a desired end (outcome).

•Inputs•Activities•Interventions

Outputs

Outputs are the products of program activities and are measured in terms of what was done, how it was done, and who received it.

Short term benefits or changes for participants that are influenced by a program’s outputs. (e.g., Knowledge, Attitudes, Intention)

Intermediate benefits or changes for participants that are influenced by a program’s outputs and follow short term outcomes.(e.g., Behavior).

Long term benefits or changes for participants that are influenced by a program’s outputs, follow intermediate outcomes and impact the target population.

Logic Model: Client Centered Program

Exercise

Identify:

1. Goal2. Outcome Objectives 3. Inputs/Activities/Intervention 4. Outputs5. Short Term Outcomes6. Intermediate Term Outcomes7. Long term Term Outcomes

Goal

To improve the social and health well being of teens by delaying sexual intercourse and/or reducing risks for early pregnancy/STDs