DEBATE TABULATION OF ESC 2013.xls

ESC FIB 2013No. Team Name VP Score M Pos VP Score M1 FORMASI UB A 1 263.00 3.00 -1 1 266.00 8.002 FORMASI UB B 1 262.00 2.00 1 1 262.00 2.003 SMAN 1 DENPASAR A 0 260.00 -3.00 1 1 261.00 5.004 UM A 0 258.00 -1.00 1 1 261.00 7.005 SMAN 1 SIDOARJO A 1 261.17 4.67 1 1 258.83 2.676 SMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG A 1 259.00 1.00 -1 0 258.00 -8.007 UNMUH A 1 258.83 4.83 1 0 260.00 -2.008 SMKN 4 MALANG B 0 258.00 -1.00 1 1 261.00 10.009 UNAIR A 1 260.00 4.00 -1 1 260.00 5.00

10 UNAIR B 1 261.00 4.00 -1 1 260.00 2.0011 SMAN 1 SIDOARJO B 0 260.00 -2.00 -1 0 259.00 -3.0012 MAN 3 MALANG A 0 256.00 -2.00 -1 1 262.00 3.0013 SMKN 4 MALANG A 1 258.00 1.00 1 0 258.00 -2.0014 SMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG B 1 256.00 1.00 -1 1 257.00 1.0015 SMAN 2 BONDOWOSO A 1 258.00 2.00 1 0 256.17 -2.6716 MAN 3 MALANG B 1 259.00 1.00 -1 0 256.00 -1.0017 SMAN 1 SIDOARJO C 1 256.00 1.00 -1 0 256.00 -5.0018 SMAN 10 MALANG A 0 257.00 -1.00 -1 1 259.00 2.0019 FIB UB A 0 256.00 -4.00 1 1 259.00 2.0020 ESP FTP UB A 1 259.00 3.00 1 0 255.00 -5.0021 UM B 0 255.00 -1.00 1 0 257.00 -2.0022 SMAN 2 MADIUN A 0 256.50 -4.67 -1 0 257.00 -2.0023 SMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG C 0 255.00 -1.00 1 0 254.00 -7.0024 SMAN 2 MOJOKERTO A 0 254.00 -4.83 -1 1 257.33 2.0025 SMAN 2 MADIUN B 0 257.00 -4.00 1 0 255.33 -2.0026 SMAN 9 MALANG A 0 256.00 -3.00 -1 0 251.00 -10.00

Organised by:A- Core: Amir Abdul Aziz (UGM), Aditya Janu Perdana (UB), Nadiyah Jubair (UM)

Tabulated by: Dinda Novitasari (FORMASI UB Tab Team)

ESC FIB 2013Pos VP Score M Pos VP Score M Pos VP_ SCORE_ MARGIN1 1 264.00 2.50 -1 1 267.00 5.00 1 4 1060.00 18.501 1 262.00 5.00 -1 0 264.00 -1.00 1 3 1050.00 8.00-1 1 261.00 1.00 1 1 265.00 1.00 -1 3 1047.00 4.001 1 261.00 2.00 -1 1 265.00 5.00 1 3 1045.00 13.001 1 261.00 1.00 -1 0 262.00 -5.00 -1 3 1043.00 3.33-1 1 261.33 4.67 1 1 264.00 3.00 -1 3 1042.33 0.67-1 1 262.00 3.00 1 1 260.00 2.00 1 3 1040.83 7.831 1 258.00 1.00 -1 1 261.00 2.00 -1 3 1038.00 12.00-1 0 261.50 -2.50 1 0 261.00 -3.00 1 2 1042.50 3.501 0 260.00 -1.00 1 0 259.00 -2.00 1 2 1040.00 3.00-1 1 257.00 1.00 1 1 259.83 4.33 1 2 1035.83 0.33-1 1 259.00 2.00 1 0 258.00 -2.00 -1 2 1035.00 1.00-1 0 260.00 -1.00 -1 1 258.00 1.00 -1 2 1034.00 -1.001 0 257.00 -5.00 1 0 260.00 -5.00 -1 2 1030.00 -8.00-1 0 259.00 -3.00 -1 1 256.50 2.00 1 2 1029.67 -1.671 0 257.00 -1.00 1 1 255.00 5.00 1 2 1027.00 4.001 0 256.67 -4.67 -1 1 257.00 1.00 -1 2 1025.67 -7.671 1 252.00 2.00 -1 0 257.00 -1.00 1 2 1025.00 2.00-1 0 259.00 -2.00 1 0 256.00 -1.00 1 1 1030.00 -5.001 0 257.00 -2.00 -1 0 254.50 -4.33 -1 1 1025.50 -8.33-1 0 256.00 -1.00 -1 1 257.00 1.50 -1 1 1025.00 -2.501 1 254.83 0.83 1 0 254.50 -2.00 -1 1 1022.83 -7.83-1 0 254.00 -0.83 -1 1 256.00 3.00 1 1 1019.00 -5.83-1 0 250.00 -2.00 1 0 255.50 -1.50 1 1 1016.83 -6.331 1 253.00 5.00 -1 0 250.00 -5.00 -1 1 1015.33 -6.00-1 0 248.00 -5.00 1 0 253.00 -3.00 -1 0 1008.00 -21.00

Organised by: ESA FIB UBA- Core: Amir Abdul Aziz (UGM), Aditya Janu Perdana (UB), Nadiyah Jubair (UM)


ESC FIB 2013POS_

02020-220020-2-2002-2020-20000-2

ESC FIB 2013PRE-ELIMINARY 1 MATCH UP

ROOM GOVERNMENT1 SMAN 2 BONDOWOSO A2 SMAN 2 MADIUN B3 UNMUH A4 ESP FTP UB A5 FORMASI UB B6 UM B7 SMKN 4 MALANG A9 UM A

10 SMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG C11 FIB UB A12 SMKN 4 MALANG B13 SMAN 1 SIDOARJO A14 SMAN 1 DENPASAR A

PRE-ELIMINARY 2 MATCH UPROOM GOVERNMENT

1 FORMASI UB A2 FORMASI UB B3 SMAN 1 SIDOARJO A4 UNAIR B5 ESP FTP UB A6 MAN 3 MALANG B7 SMAN 1 SIDOARJO C9 SMAN 1 SIDOARJO B

10 SMKN 4 MALANG B11 UM A12 SMAN 10 MALANG A13 SMAN 2 MADIUN B14 SMAN 2 MADIUN A


1 UNAIR A2 SMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG B3 UNAIR B4 SMAN 1 DENPASAR A5 MAN 3 MALANG B6 FIB UB A

7 UNMUH A9 MAN 3 MALANG A

10 SMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG A11 SMAN 2 MOJOKERTO A12 SMAN 1 SIDOARJO B13 SMAN 2 MADIUN A14 SMAN 9 MALANG A


1 UNMUH A2 UM A3 SMAN 10 MALANG A4 UNAIR A5 MAN 3 MALANG B6 FIB UB A7 SMAN 1 SIDOARJO B9 FORMASI UB B

10 UNAIR B11 SMAN 2 MOJOKERTO A12 SMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG C13 FORMASI UB A14 SMAN 2 BONDOWOSO A



ESC FIB 2013PRE-ELIMINARY 1 MATCH UP

OPPOSITIONMAN 3 MALANG AUNAIR BSMAN 2 MOJOKERTO ASMAN 9 MALANG ASMAN 1 SIDOARJO BSMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG BSMAN 10 MALANG AMAN 3 MALANG BSMAN 1 SIDOARJO CUNAIR ASMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG ASMAN 2 MADIUN AFORMASI UB A

PRE-ELIMINARY 2 MATCH UPOPPOSITION

SMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG AUNMUH ASMAN 2 BONDOWOSO ASMKN 4 MALANG AUNAIR ASMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG BSMAN 1 DENPASAR AMAN 3 MALANG ASMAN 9 MALANG ASMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG CUM BSMAN 2 MOJOKERTO AFIB UB A


FORMASI UB AFORMASI UB BSMAN 1 SIDOARJO ASMKN 4 MALANG ASMKN 4 MALANG BUM A

SMAN 2 BONDOWOSO AESP FTP UB ASMAN 1 SIDOARJO CSMAN 10 MALANG AUM BSMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG CSMAN 2 MADIUN B


MAN 3 MALANG ASMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG BSMKN 4 MALANG ASMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG ASMAN 2 MADIUN B SMAN 1 SIDOARJO CESP FTP UB ASMAN 1 DENPASAR ASMKN 4 MALANG BUM BSMAN 9 MALANG ASMAN 1 SIDOARJO ASMAN 2 MADIUN A

Organised by: ESA FIB UB, Aditya Janu Perdana (UB), Nadiyah Jubair (UM)

: Dinda Novitasari (FORMASI UB Tab Team)

ESC FIB 2013No NAME TEAM

ROUND 1C P1 P2

1 ZELLY SIDI ZAMZAMI FORMASI UB A 762 HARIS APRIYANTO FORMASI UB A 753 ALDWIN OCTAVIANUS WIJAYA SMAN 1 DENPASAR A 754 LEIDITYA NARISTI FORMASI UB A 745 MUHAMAD FAHRI AKBAR FORMASI UB B 756 RICKY KURNIAWAN UNAIR A 757 M. ABDAN SYAKURA SMAN 1 SIDOARJO A 75 76 758 UYUN NISHAR UM A 749 FRANKY YENDIANA UM A 73

10 MUHAMMAD FAJAR SHIDDIQ ADJAM FORMASI UB B 7411 RENNY FITRIA NUR AINI FORMASI UB B 7512 FELICIA EVELYN SALIM SMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG A 7413 ELIZABETH LARAS SUKMA HANAKATA SMAN 1 DENPASAR A 7414 MOCHAMAD EKY RAHMANTYO K. SMAN 1 SIDOARJO A 74 74 7415 ZAKIA NURUS SYIFA UNAIR B 7416 ENITA WARDHANA UNAIR B 7517 AHMAD ZULFIKAR ADI PRAJA NEGARA UNAIR B 7418 NURLAILATUL HIDAYAH UM A 7319 AMBIKA UNMUH A 74 73 7320 UDIN UNMUH A 75 74 7421 HASYA AFINA S. MAN 3 MALANG A 7322 GABRIELLA SMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG B 7423 BAGUS P. SANTOSA SMAN 1 SIDOARJO B 7424 AULINA KHASANAH SMKN 4 MALANG A 7425 REIKA AZIL ARYANI SMKN 4 MALANG B 7426 SRI WULAN SARI ADI SMKN 4 MALANG B 7427 RIZKI ANWAR UNAIR A 7428 RUFINA ADELIA WIDYATAMA SMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG A 7329 RICHARD FIRMAN HADI PRAYOGA UNMUH A 74 74 7330 I NYOMAN ADI WIYARNA SMAN 1 DENPASAR A 73.531 HAFIDZ AULIA S. SMAN 1 SIDOARJO A 74 74 7432 NOVIA WIDYA CHAIRANI SMAN 1 SIDOARJO B 7533 LISA RAMADHANI H. SMKN 4 MALANG A 7434 WEKA PUSPITA AKBAR UNAIR A 7435 GADIS ALIF WIDANINGRUM SMAN 1 SIDOARJO B 7436 RICHARD REINALDI G. SMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG A 74.537 LAYYIN NAFISA MAN 3 MALANG A 7338 PANDHU PRAYOGA SMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG B 7439 ANNISA MARDIANING UTAMI SMAN 10 MALANG A 7440 EKA NURCAHYANINGSIH SMKN 4 MALANG A 7341 ZAENAL ABIDIN SMKN 4 MALANG B 73

42 ALMIRA NOVA AULIA FIB UB A 7343 ANINDYA MARCHA ANGELINA DJIANTO SMAN 2 BONDOWOSO A 7444 AULIYA YUDIA YASYFIN MAN 3 MALANG B 7445 VEVINA DYAHSASI NUGRAHA SMAN 2 BONDOWOSO A 7446 ANGELINA SALVITA SMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG B 7447 DEDY ARDIAN SYAH UM B 7448 AULIA AKIFINA ANNUR UM B 7349 NUR DEBY MAULIDIA UM B 7450 SITI MAGHFIRAH FIB UB A 7351 MELATI ARIENA PUTRI RAMADHANI SMAN 2 MADIUN A 74 74 7352 FARHAN ALI FARDHANI SMAN 1 SIDOARJO C 7453 L.C.S LAELAN H.K. MAN 3 MALANG A 7354 GITA MAHARDIKA HAYATI MAN 3 MALANG B 7455 FATIMAH SMAN 2 BONDOWOSO A 7356 TIARA WIRANTI ESP FTP UB A 7457 NAJELINA RUTH Y. S. FIB UB A 7358 AMIRA ALVA SALSABELA SMAN 1 SIDOARJO C 7259 HIMAYATI SALAMAH ESP FTP UB A 7460 WIDA SEKAR ENING MAN 3 MALANG B 7461 FEBBY LEONITA KUSUMAWIJAYA SMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG C 7362 ANDY YUWONO SMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG C 7363 HABIBA NUR LAILI SMAN 10 MALANG A 7364 DAYIN WIJAYA SMAN 10 MALANG A 7365 PUTRA RONAILDO ADI NUGRAHA SMAN 1 SIDOARJO C 7366 RR ERIKA PURWA A SMAN 2 MOJOKERTO A 73 72.5 7167 GRESIANA GEDE WIRAWATI SMAN 2 MADIUN B 7468 ALDI NAZAR BASUKI WIJAYA ESP FTP UB A 7369 DEWI ITIKA BASUKI SMAN 2 MADIUN A 73 73 7370 EMIRZA RAKASAKTI SMAN 9 MALANG A 7371 SHEDY MAHARANI NARISWARI SMAN 2 MADIUN A 73.5 73 7372 MUHAMMAD NOOR ZUHDI SMAN 2 MOJOKERTO A 73 73 7273 TANIA CHRISTABELLA T. SMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG C 7274 ISTIQOMAH AINI SMAN 2 MOJOKERTO A 73 72.5 7175 QONITA PUTRI FIRDAUSA SMAN 2 MADIUN B 7376 SASTRI JENDRA AYUNINGRAT SMAN 2 MADIUN B 7377 KRISTINA AUGUSTA SMAN 9 MALANG A 7378 VIQIH ALIEFIAN SAMBORA SMAN 9 MALANG A 73

Organised by:A- Core: Amir Abdul Aziz (UGM), Aditya Janu Perdana (UB), Nadiyah Jubair (UM)


ESC FIB 2013ROUND 1 ROUND 2 ROUND 3 ROUND 4

GRAND SUMAVG C P1 P2 AVG C P1 P2 AVG C P1 P2 AVG

76.00 76 76.00 76 76.00 77 77.00 305.0075.00 76 76.00 75 75.00 76 76.00 302.0075.00 75 75.00 75 75.00 76 76.00 301.0074.00 76 76.00 75 75.00 76 76.00 301.0075.00 75 75.00 75 75.00 76 76.00 301.0075.00 75 75.00 75 75.00 75 75.00 300.0075.33 73.5 74 74 73.83 75 75.00 75 75.00 299.1774.00 74 74.00 75 75.00 76 76.00 299.0073.00 75 75.00 74 74.00 77 77.00 299.0074.00 75 75.00 75 75.00 75 75.00 299.0075.00 74 74.00 75 75.00 75 75.00 299.0074.00 74 74.00 74 74 75 74.33 76 76.00 298.3374.00 74 74.00 74 74.00 76 76.00 298.0074.00 74 74 74 74.00 75 75.00 75 75.00 298.0074.00 75 75.00 75 75.00 74 74.00 298.0075.00 75 75.00 74 74.00 74 74.00 298.0074.00 76 76.00 74 74.00 74 74.00 298.0073.00 75 75.00 75 75.00 75 75.00 298.0073.33 74 74.00 75 75.00 75 75.00 297.3374.33 74 74.00 75 75.00 74 74.00 297.3373.00 75 75.00 74 74.00 75 75.00 297.0074.00 74 74.00 74 74.00 75 75.00 297.0074.00 74 74.00 74 74.00 74 77 74 75.00 297.0074.00 75 75.00 74 74.00 74 74.00 297.0074.00 75 75.00 74 74.00 74 74.00 297.0074.00 74 74.00 74 74.00 75 75.00 297.0074.00 74 74.00 75 75.00 74 74.00 297.0073.00 74 74.00 74 74 76 74.67 75 75.00 296.6773.67 74 74.00 75 75.00 74 74.00 296.6773.50 74 74.00 74 74.00 75 75.00 296.5074.00 73.5 73 74 73.50 74 74.00 75 75.00 296.5075.00 73 73.00 74 74.00 74 75 73 74.00 296.0074.00 74 74.00 74 74.00 74 74.00 296.0074.00 74 74.00 74 74.00 74 74.00 296.0074.00 74 74.00 74 74.00 73 75 73 73.67 295.6774.50 73 73.00 73 73 73 73.00 75 75.00 295.5073.00 75 75.00 74 74.00 73 73.00 295.0074.00 73 73.00 74 74.00 74 74.00 295.0074.00 74 74.00 73 73.00 74 74.00 295.0073.00 75 75.00 74 74.00 73 73.00 295.0073.00 74 74.00 73 73.00 75 75.00 295.00

73.00 74 74.00 75 75.00 73 73.00 295.0074.00 73.5 73 73 73.17 74 74.00 73.5 73.5 73.50 294.6774.00 74 74.00 73 73.00 73 73.00 294.0074.00 73 73 73 73.00 74 74.00 73 73 73.00 294.0074.00 73 73.00 73 73.00 74 74.00 294.0074.00 73 73.00 74 74.00 73 73 73.00 294.0073.00 74 74.00 73 73.00 73 75 74.00 294.0074.00 73 73.00 74 74.00 73 73 73.00 294.0073.00 74 74.00 74 74.00 73 73.00 294.0073.67 74 74.00 72.5 73 74 73.17 73 72 72.50 293.3374.00 73 73.00 74 73 73 73.33 73 73.00 293.3373.00 74 74.00 73 73.00 73 73.00 293.0074.00 72 72.00 74 74.00 73 73.00 293.0073.00 73 73 73 73.00 74 74.00 73 73 73.00 293.0074.00 73 73.00 73 73.00 73 74 72 73.00 293.0073.00 74 74.00 73 73.00 73 73.00 293.0072.00 73 73.00 73 74 74 73.67 74 74.00 292.6774.00 73 73.00 73 73.00 72 74 72 72.67 292.6774.00 73 73.00 73 73.00 72 72.00 292.0073.00 73 73.00 72 72.00 74 74.00 292.0073.00 73 73.00 72 72.00 74 74.00 292.0073.00 74 74.00 72 72.00 73 73.00 292.0073.00 74 74.00 72 72.00 73 73.00 292.0073.00 73 73.00 73 73 73 73.00 73 73.00 292.0072.17 75 74 74 74.33 72 72.00 73 74 73.50 292.0074.00 73 73 73 73.00 73 73.00 72 72.00 292.0073.00 73 73.00 73 73.00 73 73 72 72.67 291.6773.00 73 73.00 72 72 73 72.33 72.5 73 72.75 291.0873.00 72 72.00 72 72.00 74 74.00 291.0073.17 73 73.00 72 72 73 72.33 72.5 72 72.25 290.7572.67 73 73 73 73.00 72 72.00 72 73 72.50 290.1772.00 72 72.00 72 72.00 74 74.00 290.0072.17 73 74 73 73.33 72 72.00 72 73 72.50 290.0073.00 73 73 73 73.00 73 73.00 71 71.00 290.0073.00 73 73 73 73.00 72 72.00 71 71.00 289.0073.00 71 71.00 71 71.00 73 73.00 288.0073.00 71 71.00 70 70.00 73 73.00 287.00



ESC FIB 2013AVERAGE

76.25 175.50 275.25

375.2575.2575.00 674.79 774.75

874.7574.7574.7574.5874.5074.5074.5074.5074.5074.5074.3374.3374.2574.2574.2574.2574.2574.2574.2574.1774.1774.1374.1374.0074.0074.0073.9273.8873.7573.7573.7573.7573.75

73.7573.6773.5073.5073.5073.5073.5073.5073.5073.3373.3373.2573.2573.2573.2573.2573.1773.1773.0073.0073.0073.0073.0073.0073.0073.0072.9272.7772.7572.6972.5472.5072.5072.5072.2572.0071.75

ESC FIB 2013ELIMINARY ROUND

1 SMAN 1 DENPASAR A

SMAN 1 DENPASAR A

8 SMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG B

ROOM 1

4 SMKN 4 MALANG B

SMKN 4 MALANG B

5 SMAN 1 SIDOARJO B

A- Core:Tabulated by: Dinda Novitasari (FORMASI UB Tab Team)


POS NEG

CHAMPION OF ESC FIB 2013 - HS

SMKN 4 MALANG A

SMKN 4 MALANG B SMKN 4 MALANG A

Organised by: ESA FIB UB

A- Core: Amir Abdul Aziz (UGM), Aditya Janu Perdana (UB), Nadiyah Jubair (UM)Tabulated by: Dinda Novitasari (FORMASI UB Tab Team)


SMAN 1 SIDOARJO A 2

SMKN 4 MALANG A

SMKN 4 MALANG A 7

ROOM 2

SMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG A 3

SMAK St ALBERTUS MALANG A

MAN 3 MALANG A 6

, Aditya Janu Perdana (UB), Nadiyah Jubair (UM)


POS

1 FORMASI UB A

CHAMPION OF ESC FIB 2013 - VARSITY

FORMASI UB A

ROOM 3FORMASI UB A

4 UNMUH A




NEG

FORMASI UB B 2

CHAMPION OF ESC FIB 2013 - VARSITY

FORMASI UB A

ROOM 4FORMASI UB B

UM A 3

Organised by: ESA FIB UBAmir Abdul Aziz (UGM), Aditya Janu Perdana (UB), Nadiyah Jubair (UM)

Dinda Novitasari (FORMASI UB Tab Team)

Documents

DEBATE TABULATION OF ESC 2013.xls