Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
Dearomatization of transition metal-coordinated N-heterocyclic
ligands and related chemistry
Rebeca Arévalo, Maialen Espinal-Viguri, Miguel A. Huertos, Julio Pérez* and Lucía
Riera*
Departamento de Química Orgánica e Inorgánica. Julián Clavería, 8. Universidad de Oviedo.
33006 Oviedo (Spain). *Corresponding author e-mail address: [email protected]
Centro de Investigación en Nanomateriales y Nanotecnología (CINN). CSIC-Universidad de
Oviedo-Principado de Asturias. Avenida de la Vega, 4-6. 33940 El Entrego (Spain).
*Corresponding author e-mail address: [email protected].
Contents
1. Introduction
2. Addition of Main Group Organometallic Reagents to Pyridines and Related Heteroaromatics
3. Reaction of Pyridines with Early Transition Metal Complexes
4. The Elusive Nucleophilic Attack on Transition Metal-Coordinated 2,2’-Bipyridine and 1,10-
Phenanthroline
5. Reactivity of Carbonyl rhenium and Molybdenum Complexes
5.1 Reactions of the Phosphido Complex [Re(PPh2)(CO)3(phen)] with Activated
Acetylenes and Olefins
5.2 Dearomatization by Deprotonation of Complexes with N-alkylimidazole Ligands
5.3 Couplings and Dearomatization Initiated by Deprotonation of C(sp3)-H Bonds
5.4 Couplings Between Two Monodentate Hetericyclic Ligands
5.5 Ring Opening of Imidazole Rings
5.6 Couplings Between N-Alkylimidazoles and Imine Ligands
5.7 Coupling Between N-Alkylimidazoles and Nitriles or Isonitriles
2
5.8 Deprotonation of N-Alkylimidazole Ligands in Phosphane-Carbonyl Complexes
6 Metal-Mediated tautomerization of N-Heterocycles to NHC Complexes
6.1 Tautomerization of Pyridines
6.2 Tautomerization of Imidazoles
6.3 Tautomerization of Other Azoles
7 Metal-Ligand Cooperation Based on Aromatization/Dearomatization Processes
8 Conclusions and Outlook
Acknowledgements
References
Abstract
This review focuses on chemistry published by the authors during the last decade, and relevant
chemistry from other areas is included to provide an appropriate context. 2,2’-bipyridine (bipy)
and 1,10-phenanthroline (phen), employed for a long time in all areas of coordination chemistry,
are archetypical auxiliary ligands that stabilize metal fragments but are not themselves the site
of the reactivity. Several examples of dearomatization of one of the pyridine rings of coordinated
bipy and phen are discussed, including one example of ring opening. The highly reactive species
resulting from deprotonation of coordinated N-alkylimidazoles can result, besides of the
mentioned dearomatization, in other intramolecular C-C coupling reactions involving
monodentate pyridines, other N-alkylimidazoles, imine, nitrile, isonitrile and carbonyl ligands. In
some examples, the products of these couplings, and of those between two pyridines, can be
oxidatively rearomatized, affording pyridylimidazoles and bipyridines. Similar deprotonations
leading to C-C couplings have been demonstrated for deprotonation of dimethylsulfide and
methylphosphane ligands. In some instances, the deprotonation of coordinated N-
alkylimidazoles produces complexes with rare N-alkylimidazol-2-yl ligands. The protonation or
alkylation of the non-substituted nitrogen of the later affords coordinated N-heterocyclic
carbenes.
3
1. Introduction.
This article aims to review the recent work by our group in new aspects of transition metal-based
reactivity of pyridine and imidazole ligands, many of which involve dearomatization of those
heteroaromatic rings. Six member pyridines (1, Figure 1) and five member imidazoles (2, Figure
1) are some of the most important N-heterocycles.1 There are several reasons for this relevance.
One is the prevalence of pyridine and imidazole rings in natural systems and in non-natural
molecules with physiological activity. Imidazole groups of histidine residues are some of the
main donor groups toward metals in metalloproteins, including enzymes. This has been perhaps
the main reason why imidazoles or imidazole-containing ligands have been the subject of many
studies in coordination chemistry.2 Despite this wealth of work, few studies dealt with the
reactivity of coordinated imidazoles beyond substitution reactions and proton transfer reaction
(including hydrogen bond formation) to and from a non-coordinated imidazole nitrogen atom. N-
alkylimidazolium salts (3, Figure 1) have been thoroughly studied materials;; for instance, as ionic
liquids.3 One of the ways to access such salts is by alkylation of free N-alkylimidazoles. The
deprotonation at C2 of N-alkylimidazolium cations is one of the most general ways to prepare
N-heterocyclic carbenes (NHC, 4 in Figure 1), a type of ligands that are having a huge impact in
contemporary chemistry.4 In particular, NHCs are employed as ligands in many catalytic
processes, where their strong donor character, high steric profile, strong affinity for metal
centers, leading to the high thermal stability of their complexes, and tunability, make them useful
auxiliaries. Applications of NHC metal complexes outside the realm of catalysis are currently
being found as a result of intense research in this area.5 Despite the close relationship between
N-alkylimidazoles and NHC ligands, few transformations linking the two types of compounds
were known. Recent contributions by our group are discussed in this paper, along with
appropriate mentions of previous and subsequent work by others.
Pyridines, being both good σ-donor and π-acceptor, are excellent ligands for all kinds of metal
fragments. The ability of pyridines to accept electron density in their low-lying π-symmetric empty
orbitals make them redox-active ligands, and is also the basis of the rich photophysic behavior
of many metal complexes containing pyridine-based ligands, in particular rhenium carbonyl
4
complexes. These properties have been particularly exploited for metal complexes of the
strongly chelating 2,2-bipyridine (bipy, 5 in Figure 1) and 1,10-phenanthroline (phen, 6 in Figure
1) and their derivatives, which have been employed as ligands for a long time.6,7 The complexes
of monodentate pyridines are often rather labile, a fact that considerably restricts their
applications and the study of the reactivity of the coordinated pyridines beyond their substitution.
In contrast, several types of pyridine-based polydentate ligands, including the relatively simple
bipy and phen, form robust metal complexes that are very stable against substitution. Pyridyl-
based ligands are typically resistant toward oxidation8 and very rarely have been found to
undergo chemical modification of the pyridyl ring. However, it must be noted that this is not the
result of an inert nature of pyridines. Pyridines are electron-poor aromatic heterocycles in which
one of the CH groups of benzene has been replaced by the more electronegative nitrogen atom.1
Therefore, pyridines react with nucleophiles, which attack mainly the ortho and para positions,
those with a higher positive charge. The product of such nucleophilic additions is a non-aromatic
amide with a high tendency to recover aromaticity, typically by a subsequent elimination step,
so that the overall addition-elimination reaction is formally a substitution. Indeed, the tendency
to give substitution, as opposed to addition, products, is typical of aromatic substrates. If the
pyridine does not contain a good leaving group, such as a halide, the second step involves a
formal elimination of hydride, and the overall transformation is called an aromatic hydrogen
substitution.9 Alternatively, aromaticity can be regained by oxidation, formally a hydride
abstraction, often in fact a combination of electron transfer and proton abstraction steps.10 While
those reactions are well known of free pyridines, including bipy and phen, there was virtually no
precedent of nucleophilic attack to transition metal coordinated pyridines. For monodentate
pyridines, this can be attributed to their lability;; however, this cannot explain the lack of examples
of nucleophilic attack on coordinated bipy or phen ligands, especially given the vast number of
their transition metal complexes and how extensively they have been employed in every phase
of coordination chemistry. Neither can it be attributed to lack of interest;; in fact, there has been
a considerable interest in demonstrating nucleophilic attacks to transition metal-coordinated bipy
and phen ligands following Gillard’s controversial suggestions that such attacks take place to
5
the bipy and phen ligands of some cationic metal complexes in basic aqueous solution, as it will
be discussed below.
Figure 1. Main types of N-heterocyclic species dealt with in this work.
Metal-mediated transformations of pyridines are thus mainly the realm of main group highly
electron-rich compounds such as alkyl derivatives of lithium, magnesium and zinc, aluminum
hydrides, etc. This chemistry will be very succinctly covered with an emphasis on recent
developments, as it will the related alkyl migration to pyridines which have been found in a
number of f-block derivatives, a topic which has been recently reviewed. In particular, rollover
cyclometalations, which are important processes that can be operative in bipy complexes, will
not be mentioned, and the interested reader is referred to a recent account of this chemistry.11
Most of this article will focus on our own chemistry, including several examples of
dearomatization of pyridyl rings of coordinated bipy and phen. Common features of all these
reactions are the very mild conditions under which they have been carried out, and their
intramolecular nature. In one instance, the reaction is initiated by the nucleophilic attack of a
terminal phosphanido ligand on electron-poor alkenes and alkynes. In all the other examples, it
is the result of the deprotonation of one of the CH groups of a ligand. Metal-coordinated N-
alkylimidazoles, dimethylsulfide, trimethylphosphane and monodentate pyridines have been
demonstrated to generate, on deprotonation, internal nucleophiles, which then carry out the C-
C coupling with proximal metal-coordinated heteroaromatic rings. Deprotonated N-
alkylimidazoles have been coupled also with nonaromatic ligands such as imines, nitriles,
N
R
1
NN R NNR'
+R NNR' R
2 3 4
N N N N
5 6
6
isonitriles and CO. Deprotonated monodentate pyridines have been coupled with other pyridine
ligands, affording 2,2’-bipyridine chelates within the metal template. A key feature in designing
such coupling reactions is that the deprotonated ligand must be cis to the electrophilic ligand to
which the attack is planned to occur, so that the nucleophile resulting from the deprotonation
and its electrophilic counterpart are close in the space and can couple without leaving the metal
coordination sphere. Many dearomatized products have been characterized in solution;; in
several examples, in addition, they have been isolated as crystalline solids and structurally
characterized by single-crystal X-ray diffraction. A noteworthy feature of the C-C coupling events
mentioned above is that they occur between partners that do not require functionalization other
than coordination to the metal, therefore constituting a modular, metal-templated approach to
the direct synthesis of metal complexes containing elaborate polydentate ligands from
complexes of the monodentate ligands that serve as building blocks.
2. Addition of main group organometallic reagents to pyridines and related
heteroaromatics.
The addition of main group-based organometallic or hydride reagents to pyridines and similar
systems takes place through coordination of the heterocyclic molecule to the Lewis acid metal
center followed by formation of dearomatized species, for which there is a small but growing
body of structural information.
The addition of nucleophiles to pyridines, pyridinium cations and other electron-poor
heteroaromatic substrates has been known for a long time.12-14 An example is the Chichibabin
amination, in which typically sodium amide adds to the 2 position of a pyridine.15-17 Reactions of
this kind are thought to proceed through an initial step in which the pyridine coordinates the main
group metal cationic center, followed by the addition of the nucleophile (an alkyl or hydride) to
the 2-position of the pyridine to afford a nonaromatic intermediate, the Meisenheimer adduct.
From this species, rearomatization to the 2-substituted pyridine takes place through formal
hydride elimination, as showed in Scheme 1. This kind of mechanism is generally operative in
the chemistry of electron-poor arenes.18 Note however, that the Chichibabin reaction has been
7
carried out in a variety of conditions, including homogeneous and heterogeneous media, so
different mechanisms can reasonably be expected. An elegant and synthetically useful
fluorination of pyridines and diazines, inspired by the Chichibabin reaction, has been recently
reported by Fier and Hartwig.19 Interestingly, in the (to our knowledge) only theoretical study of
the mechanism of the Chichibabin reaction, Dransfield and co-workers found that the most
favorable mechanism involves the elimination of dihydrogen, rather than sodium hydride as it is
usually assumed.20
Scheme 1. Proposed mechanism of the Chichibabin reaction.
Alternative mechanisms involve heteroarynes or ring opening-ring closure sequences.21,22 Main
group alkyl and, in some cases, hydride reagents, add to pyridines (the reaction is sometimes
called carbometalation, or pyridine insertion into the M-C bond) affording either the dearomatized
N-metalo-1,2-dihydropyridines or their 1,4-isomers. Usually the 1,2-isomers are produced under
kinetic control and the 1,4-isomers, under thermodynamic control. Often mixtures of both
isomers are obtained, although regioselectivity has been achieved under certain conditions.
These main group complexes of dihydropyridines have been found to be the intermediates in
the reactions between pyridines and organometallic reagents to afford alkylpyridines. In some
instances, di- and tri-alkylpyridines have been prepared employing an excess of the
organometallic reagent.23
Note that the classical syntheses of dihydropyridines (e.g. Hantzsch syntesis) employ de novo
construction of the rings by multicomponent reactions rather than starting from pyridines, and
that some of the pyridine reduction processes are actually reductions of pyridinium cations (e.
g. Fowler’s sodium borohydride reduction of the N-acylpyridinium salts produced in situ by the
reaction of pyridines with chloroformate esters).
N
Na NH2
N
Na
NH2
H- NaH
N NH2
8
Neutral N-H or N-R dihydropyridines are employed both by nature (the NADH and NADPH
dinucleotide coenzymes) and by synthetic chemists as selective reducing agents in
transformations driven in large part by the tendency of dihydropyridines to achieve
rearomatization. In the field of transition metal organometallic chemistry, dihydropyridines have
been either formed on the coordination sphere of a metal to which they are bound through the
C=C double bonds, or used as substrates. Ishitani studied the formation of intermediate
complexes containing 1,4-dihydropyridines η2-coordinated to ruthenium fragments in the
reaction of pyridinium cations with ruthenium hydride complexes,24 Myers employed complexes
of a strongly π-basic metal fragment with η2-coordinated pyridinium cations to access metal-
complexed dihydropyridines,25 Rudler found dihydropyridines to be useful reagents in the
chemistry of Fischer carbenes,26 and Liebeskind employed dihydropyridine π-complexes as
intermediated in the synthesis of more reduced heterocycles, such as piperidines.27
The reaction of pyridines with organolithium reagents afforded mainly 2-substituted pyridines
through alkyl addition to generate a dearomatized lithium complex of dihydropyridine. From this
species, it has been though that elimination of highly insoluble lithium hydride would yield the
final 2-alkylpyridine product. Reaction mixtures usually contain some amount of the 4-alkylated
isomer. Snaith and coworkers found that rather than undergoing an actual elimination of lithium
hydride, N-lithium dihydropyridines hydrolize (e. g., with traces of moisture) to N-H
dihydropyridines, which subsequently oxidize (e. g. on atmospheric exposure) to 2-
alkylpyridines.28
Mulvey and co-workers reported evidence pointing to intramolecular hydride transfer from a
dihydropyridide ligand to a pyridine ligand within a lithium complex (Scheme 2), and the crucial
role of the stoichiometry in the reactions between pyridines and organolithium reagents.29 These
results indicate the necessity of considering the entire coordination compound and to gain as
much knowledge as possible of its structure both to understand and to synthetically exploit the
reactivity of main group organometallics. Mulvey, Robertson and co-workers recently isolated
and structurally characterized several N-lithio-2-alkyl-dihydropyridines.30
9
Scheme 2. Proposed hydride transfer between ligands in a lithium complex.
Methods consisting of nucleophilic addition followed by oxidative rearomatization are some of
the simpler and more expedient methods for pyridine functionalization. However, preactivation
of the pyridine by its transformation to a pyridine N-oxide or an N-alkyl- or N-acyl pyridinium
cation is often required. In 2013 and 2014 Knochel and co-workers reported nucleophilic
additions to pyridines mediated by BF3.31,32 They found that the formation of pyridine-BF3 adducts
has a dramatic effect on the reaction course. Indeed, some reactions do not occur without the
presence of BF3 and, in other instances, the regioselectivity towards the product of addition to
the 4-position is attributed to BF3 complexation. A similar effect of pyridine activation by its
complexation has been found by Urabe and co-workers in the additions of benzyl Grignard
reagents.33
In the reactions between pyridines, in particular bipy and phen, and other electron-poor N-
heterocycles, and main group organometallic or hydride reagents, the formation of strongly
colored solutions have been noted a long time ago, and bipy and phen have been used as visual
indicators in the titrations of organolithium and Grignard reagents.34 However, attempts to isolate
stable metal complexes from these reactions failed. Kaim and others showed that, instead of the
previously assumed polar mechanism (carbanion transfer from the metal to the heterocycle),
many reactions between the metal reagent (alkyllithium, organomagnesium, organozinc,
aluminum hydride, etc.) and the heterocyclic substrate take place through a radical
mechanism.35-37 Thus the initially formed adduct between the metal reagent and the heterocycle
(a charge transfer adduct) undergoes an intramolecular single electron transfer to form a radical
anion of the heterocyclic substrate and the radical cation of the metal reagent. One of the
possible pathways from that system leads to the diamagnetic product of alkyl or hydride transfer
NNLi
H HN nBu
LiN
HnBu
pypy
+py
py
10
to the heterocycle. Trapping of radicals and ESR spectroscopy provided evidence in support of
such a radical pathway. Note, however, that most studies of the reactivity of main group alkyl or
hydride reagents with electron-poor heteroaromatics do not include the probing of the possible
intermediacy of radicals. Radical-based reactions of electron-poor heteroarenes can be
synthetically useful.38 Note also that radicals can display a considerable nucleophilic character
so that, for instance, radical addition to pyridines can be mainly directed to the 2 and 4 positions.
Maron, Okuda and co-workers reported in 2010 that bis(η3-allyl)calcium reacts with pyridine to
regioselectively afford a species with two anionic, dearomatized 1,4-dihydropyridide ligands,
each resulting from the addition of an allyl group to a coordinated pyridine.39 In excess pyridine,
an octahedral complex could be isolated and structurally characterized by X-ray diffraction,
which contains four intact pyridine ligands, and the two anionic ligands in trans positions. Its
reaction with E-Cl electrophiles generates the neutral N-protected 1,4-dihydropyridines and
calcium chloride.
The mechanism of the dearomatization was studied by NMR and by computational methods. An
adduct between the diallylcalcium moiety and pyridine initially forms, followed by allyl migration
from calcium to the ortho position of two of the coordinated pyridines to afford the product of
double 1,2-insertion. Next, the final double 1,4-insertion product is formed by a rate determining
Cope rearrangement step.
The Lansbury reagent, formed as the product of the reaction between pyridines with lithium
tetrahydroaluminate (lithium alanate), has been employed as a useful reducing agent in organic
chemistry for a long time. Hensen and co-workers demonstrated that Lansbury reagent has the
[Li(pyridine)4][Al(1,4-dihydropyridide)4] composition and structurally determined its structure and
those of similar derivatives.40
Budzelaar et al. studied the reactions of a pyridylbis(imine) pincer ligand with aluminum alkyls.
Along with other species, they found products of alkyl addition to the pyridine ring. Radical and
ionic mechanisms were considered. Regarding the later, the authors found the best results in
their computational modeling for the alkyl transfer from an anionic R3AlCl- species to the pyridine
ring of the pincer ligand coordinated to the cationic RAlCl+ fragment.41
11
In 2011 Okuda and coworkers reported a study of the reactivity of tris(η1-allyl)aluminum
complexes toward pyridines. In some cases, they found formation of dearomatized products of
the allyl addition to the ortho position of pyridine.42 Previous studies by other groups found either
no reaction or just formation of stable pyridine adducts in the reaction between pyridines and
other trialkylaluminum reagents. Okuda proposed a Claisen rearrangement in the case of allyl
addition to explain the especial behavior of this alkyl group. They encountered a dramatic solvent
effect in the reaction. Thus [Al(η1-allyl)3(py)], quantitatively formed as the product of the reaction
between [Al(η1-allyl)3(THF)] and pyridine, was found to be stable in pentane for weeks;; in
contrast, in THF solvent, the dearomatized product of allyl attack to the pyridine ortho position
was formed. Allyl attack is prevented by the presence of methyl groups not only at the ortho
(steric blocking), but also on the meta or para positions of the pyridine ring, indicating that
electron-rich pyridines are not electrophilic enough for undergoing the nucleophilic attack of the
allyl group. Accordingly, 4-dimethylaminopyridine does not react, whereas 4-
trifluoromethylpyridine affords mainly the product of ortho-allyl addition.
Addition of diorganozinc reagents, which are relatively mild nucleophiles, to pyridines have been
typically carried out employing transition metal catalysis. In 2015 Hevia and co-workers reported
the regioselective addition of lithium arylzincate reagents [LiZnPh3] and [Li2ZnPh4] (prepared by
co-complexation of the appropriate amounts of to LiPh and ZnPh2) to the 9-position of acridine
under microwave irradiation.43 They found a much better performance of the heterometallic
reagents compared to simple diarylzinc reagents, which has been attributed to a combination of
the anionic activation of the organozinc reagent (by forming ZnPh3- or ZnPh42- species) and an
enhancement of the electrophilicity of the heterocycle by its coordination to the lithium centers.
Note the relation with the Budzelaar’s aluminum system mentioned above. Indeed, the authors
structurally characterized the dearomatized product of the addition to the 9-position, in which the
nitrogen atom is coordinated to Li(THF)3+, as shown in Scheme 3.
12
Scheme 3. Dearomatization of acridine by reaction with lithium triphenyl zincate.
3. Reaction of pyridines with early transition metal complexes.
Early transition metal chemistry, including that of the f-block elements, shares some features
with that of the main group metals due to a high polarity of the element-metal bonds. Early
transition metal hydride and alkyl complexes, endowed with strongly electrophilic metal centers,
often react with the CH groups in the α position of N-heterocyclic ligands. For pyridines, such
reaction produces κ2-(C,N)-pyridyl complex, depicted in Figure 2 (structure 7). Note that the
pyridyl ring of this type of complex maintains the aromaticity. These pyridyl complexes display a
rich reactivity such as insertions of unsaturated organic molecules (e.g., olefins) in the M-C bond,
eventually initiating catalytic cycles. Alternatively, if a second molecule of an N-heterocycle binds
the same metal center, interligand C-C coupling can take place. For instance, the reaction of an
unsaturated alkyl complex with two equivalents of pyridine can generate a bipy ligand on the
metal coordination sphere. This chemistry has been excellently reviewed.44,45
Some early transition metal fragments are capable of binding pyridines in the very rare κ2-(C,N)
mode. In contrast with the κ2-(C,N)-pyridyl complexes mentioned above, pyridine (as opposed
to pyridyl) ligands coordinated in the κ2-(C,N) mode are dearomatized, and are considered to
possess metaloaziridine character (see structure 8 in Figure 2).
Figure 2. κ2-(C,N)-pyridyl (7) and κ2-(C,N) pyridine (8) ligands.
N
NPhH
Li
THF
THFTHFLiZnPh3
7 8
NM
NM
H
13
Pyridine and its analogs are some of the main contaminants present in petroleum crudes, and
they should be removed to avoid the emission to the atmosphere of nitrogen oxides from fuel
combustion. To this end, large-scale hydrodenitrogenation (HDN) of petroleum crudes is carried
out along with hydrodesulfurization (HDS) and hydrodeoxygenation (HDO) processes. These
hydrotreating processes employ sulfidized transition metal oxides as heterogeneous catalysts.
Since the sulfur-containing organic pollutants would poison the catalysts of subsequent
processes to which the petroleum will be subjected, these processes operate under conditions
that have been optimized for HDS. Under these conditions, the HDN process, which is of obvious
economic and environmental relevance, is not very efficient. The mechanism of HDN is
incompletely understood and it has been hoped that homogeneous models could shed some
light on its nature and eventually lead to improvements in the efficiency of the process. Hence,
particular attention has been devoted to those few transition metal-based homogeneous
systems that have been found to be able to mediate the ring opening of pyridines.46,47
In 1988, Wolczanski and co-workers reported the first example of a metal complex containing a
pyridine ligand bonded in the κ2-(C,N) mode.48 The key to obtain this previously unknown
coordination mode was the employment of the extremely reactive Ta(silox)3 (silox= OSitBu3)
complex, which was prepared by reduction of the previously known, stable complex TaCl2(silox)3
with excess sodium amalgam. Ta(silox)3 is a tricoordinated, highly reducing complex in which
the axial coordination of normal two electron donors is discouraged by the presence of a metal-
centered, two-electron filled molecular orbital perpendicular to the molecular plane. This feature
is of particular relevance for the reaction with pyridine, which is a potential two-electron σ-donor
when coordinated in the most common κ1-(N) mode. The extraordinary reactivity of Ta(silox)3 is
illustrated by the result of its reaction with the equimolar amount of CO, reported in 1986 by the
same group: one could expect simply binding of carbon monoxide to afford a carbonyl complex,
since many carbonyl complexes effectively stabilize low oxidation state metal fragments as a
result of a significant back bonding. Instead, the reaction, an extreme form of an oxidative
addition, breaks down the very strong carbon-oxygen bond of carbon monoxide, affording a
mixture of O=Ta(silox)3 and (silox)3Ta=C=C=Ta(silox)3, both Ta(V) species with
14
pseudotetrahedral geometries around the metal atoms.49 The presence of strong metal-carbon
or metal-nitrogen double bonds in the products must be a significant contribution to the driving
force of the reaction. The product of the reaction of Ta(silox)3 with pyridine is a metallaaziridine
complex in which the metal-bonded C and N atoms display geometries consistent with sp3
hybridizations. The bond between these C and N atoms is a single bond;; therefore, the pyridine
has been potentially activated towards the subsequent C-N bond breaking. In 1997, Wolczanski
and co-workers reported that the thermolysis of a niobium complex analogous to the tantalum
species discussed above resulted in the ring-opening of the κ2-(C,N)-coordinated pyridine,
affording products containing Nb-nitrene and Nb-alkylidene bonds, as shown in Scheme 4.50
Scheme 4. Pyridine ring-opening mediated by a niobium complex reported by Wolczanski et
al.
In 1987, one year before the first κ2-(C,N)-coordinated pyridine was reported, Cordone and
Taube reported the first example of an η2-(C,C)-coordinated arene: 2,6-lutidine.51 In this case,
the metal fragment was Os(NH3)5, with which Taube, Harman and co-workers conducted an
extensive dearomatization chemistry.52 The pentaammineosmium fragment is strongly reducing;;
however, η2-coordination of pyridines through a carbon-carbon double bond is only observed
when the nitrogen is sterically blocked, as in 2,6-lutidine, or quaternized (pyridinium cations).53
In general, when the aromatic substrate possesses functions capable of acting as two-electron
donors, these are the ones that coordinate osmium, a fact attributed to the avoidance of the
(destabilizing) disruption of the aromatic system. Wigley and co-workers reported the
preparation of a κ2-(C,N)-coordinated pyridine complex and its subsequent ring-opening by
nucleophilic attack.54-56 (Scheme 5). The complex does not result from the reaction of a metal
precursor with a free pyridine, but from the reaction of a nitrile with a tantallacyclopentadiene,
which in turn is formed as the product of the reduction of a Ta(V) precursor with sodium amalgam
2 (silox)3NbCl24 Na/Hg Δ, C6H6N
2 (silox)3Nb
H
py - py
HH
(silox)3Nb
H
H
N
HNb(silox)3
15
in the presence of two equivalents of a terminal acetylene. It must be noted, however, that the
same authors obtained related complexes featuring κ2-(C,N)-coordinated quinoline and 6-
methylquinoline ligands. The compound containing the κ2-(C,N)-coordinated pyridine reacts with
nucleophiles such a hydride (its source being superhydride, LiBHEt3), Grignard, or organolithium
reagents. The attack of these nucleophiles occurs initially at the metal, where they replace a
chloride ligand, but subsequently, the hydride or alkyl group migrates to the metal-bonded
carbon atom of the κ2-(C,N)-coordinated pyridine, affording a metallacyclic product in which the
ring opening of the ligated pyridine has taken place. In this product the pyridine nitrogen has
been incorporated into a metal-bonded nitrene group (see Scheme 5);; as in the pyridine ring-
opening reported by Wolczanski (see above) surely the formation of the strong Ta=N bond is a
significant contribution to the driving force of the reaction.
Scheme 5. Synthesis of a κ2-(C,N)-coordinated pyridine complex and its ring-opening by
nucleophilic attack (Wigley et al.).
Mindiola and co-workers, on the other hand, reported a completely different type of pyridine ring-
opening reaction.57,58 The reaction of an unsaturated titanium alkylidine intermediate, generated
by alkane elimination from an (alkyl)alkylidene complex, with pyridines results in ring-opening
TaCl(OAr)2
R
Ta(OEt2)(OAr)2Cl3 2 Na/Hg
Ar=2,6-diisopropylphenyl
CHtBuCexcess Δ
TaCl(OAr)2
R
R R
TaCl(OAr)2
R
R
NRCN
C
R
Δ
N
TaR
R
R
Cl OArOAr
LiX- LiCl
N
TaR
R
R
X OArOAr
X= Me, Et, nPr, nBu, H
NTa
RR
RX
ArOArO
16
metathesis of one of the pyridine C=N bonds across the Ti-C triple bond, yielding the
metallaazabicyclic products depicted in Scheme 6.
Scheme 6. Titanium-mediated pyridine ring-opening developed by Mindiola et al.
The above discussed examples have been taken as a suggestion that the metal-mediated ring
opening of pyridines under homogeneous mild conditions would require a complex with a κ2-
(C,N)-coordinated pyridine as precursor and, therefore, a very particular type of metal fragments.
The vast majority of metal complexes feature pyridines coordinated in the κ1-(N) mode, in which
the pyridine ligand remains aromatic;; it was though that such species would not be able to
mediate pyridine ring opening.46
4. The elusive nucleophilic attack on transition metal-coordinated 2,2’-bipyridine
and 1,10-phenanthroline.
Bipy and phen are some of the most prominent ligands in all areas of coordination chemistry.
Because of their combination of good σ-donor and π-acceptor properties, and their tendency to
form robust five-member chelate rings, these aromatic diimines form stable complexes with all
metals in every oxidation state. In them, with very few exceptions, bipy and phen act as spectator
ligands, stabilizing the complex without being themselves the center of the reactivity. Some forty
years ago, while investigating the behavior of cationic bipy and phen transition metal complexes
in basic aqueous solution, Gillard and Lyons interpreted certain spectral features as due to
species (termed covalent hydrates) formed by hydroxide anion (or water) addition to the diimine
ligands.59 Gillard proposed that coordination to positively charged, Lewis-acidic metal centers
activated the pyridine groups towards nucleophilic attack, and likened these complexes to the
pyridinium cations produced by nitrogen quaternization.60,61 This proposal sparked a long-
py, 25 ºC12hrs.
- CH3tBuTi
HN
tBu
P
N
P
Ti
P
N
PCHtBu
CH2tBuTi
HN
tBu
P
N
P
17
standing controversy, and work by other groups satisfactorily explained the evidence presented
by Gillard in terms of hydroxide attack on the metal rather than on the bipy or phen ligands, thus
discrediting Gillard’s hypotesis.62-66
In particular, Lay pointed out that, unlike alkyl cations, a transition metal fragment such as the
ones Gillard was considering (which were from mid to late transition metals with relatively high
electron counts) would be able to, besides withdrawing electron density via σ, release electron
density into the empty π orbitals of the heterocycle,67 and Blackman and co-workers showed that
formation of pentacoordinated complexes by hydroxide attack to [Pt(bipy)2]2+ complexes
explained the early observations that prompted Gillard to propose attack to bipy.68 In 2002,
Zhang et al. demonstrated the hydroxide attack on bipy and phen in the presence of cupric ions,
suggesting that chemistry like that proposed by Gillard can be operative in certain systems.69
However, the fact that these reactions have needed to be carried out under hydrothermal
conditions can be taken as an indication of the difficulty of functionalizing the metal-bonded
pyridine rings, a transformation that involves their dearomatization. The subsequent isolation of
an intermediate in these hydrothermal reactions containing both phen and OH ligands
coordinated to the same metal atom, led Latham et al. to suggest initial attack by OH- to the
metal, followed by a metal to phen migration.70 A perusal of the literature indicated that not only
the attack of the hydroxide anion, the one of the original Gillard’s proposal, to transition metal-
bonded pyridines, but in fact any nucleophilic attack to these ligands, is extremely rare. A review
of the chemistry carried out by Gillard and co-workers as well as by others following Gillard’s
seminal suggestions have been recently published by one of the major players in the field.71
5. Reactivity of carbonyl rhenium and molybdenum complexes.
5.1. Reactions of the phosphido complex [Re(PPh2)(CO)3(phen)] with activated
acetylenes and olefins.
In the past, our group has been concerned with the study of the reactivity towards electrophiles
of complexes containing basic ligands such as alkoxo,72,73 hydroxo,74-76 amido,77-81
alkylidenamido,82,83 etc. Alkoxo complexes [Re(OR)(CO)3(bipy)] reacted with
18
dimethylacetylendicarboxylate (DMAD) to afford the product of formal insertion of DMAD into
the Re-O bond, presumably through nucleophilic attack of the coordinated alkoxo to one of the
acetylenic carbons.72 This would develop a negative charge at the other acetylenic carbon, which
then would attack the metal, from which the oxygen would be displaced, as shown in Scheme
7a. This displacement would be aided by the positive charge developed on the metal-bonded
oxygen, which would make it a good leaving group. For the reactions of DMAD with hydroxo or
arylamido complexes, the target of the intramolecular nucleophilic attack is not the metal, but
one of the proximal CO ligands.76,80 H migration from the hydroxo or arylamido group to the
oxygen of the same carbonyl group helps to preserve the Re-O or Re-N bonds and to transform
the CO into a hydroxycarbene group, which is incorporated into a five-member metallacycle, as
shown in Scheme 7b.
Scheme 7. Reactions of DMAD with alkoxo (a) or hydroxo (b) complexes.
We have synthesized the phosphido (phosphanido) complex [Re(PPh2)(CO)3(phen)] and carried
out preliminary studies of its reactivity.77 In contrast with the reactions of alkoxo, hydroxo or
arylamido complexes discussed above, the reactions of the phosphido complex with either
methyl propiolate or methyl acrylate afford products consistent with conjugated addition of the
phosphido ligand to the acetylene or olefin to afford a zwitterionic adduct84 (reminiscent of those
involved in several types of phosphane-catalyzed coupling reactions),85 followed by
CC CO2MeMeO2C[M] CO
YR
[M] CO
YR C
C
CO2Me
CO2Me+-
[M] CO
CMeO2C C
YR
CO2Me
Y= OR= alkyl
Y
[M] C
C
CCO2Me
CO2Me
OR
Y= O, NArR= H
(a)
(b)
19
intramolecular attack of the other carbon to one of the ortho carbons of the phen ligand (Scheme
8).
Scheme 8. Reaction of [Re(PPh2)(CO)3(phen)] with methyl propiolate.
Evidence of attack to the phen ligand is found both in solution, where the NMR indicates a non-
symmetric phen, and in the solid state. The structure of the product, determined by X-ray
diffraction, confirms the formation of a carbon-carbon bond and the non-planarity of the phen
moiety. The comparison of the bonding distances N(1)-C(11)= 1.452(11), C(11)-C(12)=
1.540(14) and C(12)-C(13)= 1.307(10) Å in the product with those in the phosphido precursor
(1.329 (11), 1.387(15) and 1.354(17) Å respectively) indicates the dearomatization of the
pyridine ring as a result of the intramolecular nucleophilic attack.
The reaction of the phosphido complex with DMAD proceeds similarly, affording complex 9.86
However, whereas the product of the reaction with methyl propiolate has been found to be
indefinitely stable in solution, the product of the analogous reaction with DMAD slowly evolves
to its tautomer 10 as shown in Scheme 9. Compounds 9 and 10 have been characterized by IR,
NMR and X-ray diffraction. The transformation of 9 into 10 is at least partly driven by an increase
in the conjugation. The reaction of 9 with nBuLi (which, monitored by IR, showed the formation
of a species with low νCO bands, consistent with deprotonation to form an anionic complex)
followed by treatment with HOTf, instantaneously affords 10, suggesting that the hydrogen
migrates as a proton, rather than as a hydrogen atom or as a hydride.
N
NRe
OCOC
CO
N
NReOCOC
CO
HPPh2
H C C CO2Me
N
NRe
OCOC
CO
P
H
C C
CO2Me
PhPh
P
HC C
CO2Me
PhPh
1
11 1213
20
Scheme 9. Transformation of complex 9 into its tautomer 10.
The most striking feature of the reactions of the phosphido complex with the activated olefin and
acetylenes is the rapid dearomatization of the phen ligand under very mild conditions. It seems
likely that the reaction is somewhat facilitated by its intramolecular nature. Also noteworthy is
the stability of the dearomatized products, which have made possible to discover the
tautomerization discussed above and to crystallize the products by solvent slow diffusion.
Compared with the alkaline salts resulting from the addition of, for instance, RLi reagents to
pyridines, the dearomatized products of the reactions of the phosphido complex discussed
above are neutral complexes, without the possibility of eliminating an alkaline hydride (which,
having a large lattice energy, must contribute considerably to the driving force of the reaction).
Additionally, the presence of the metallacycle hampers the regaining of planarity that would be
required for rearomatization. It must be noted that the product of the attack to phen is the only
product of the reaction, and no product of attack to one of the two proximal CO ligands was
detected. This stands in contrast with the previously reported reactions of terminal phosphido
complexes with DMAD, where formation of five-member metallacycles resulted from the
coupling of the phosphido ligand, DMAD and one CO ligand.87-89 Note that our results in the
reactions of the hydroxo and amido complexes with DMAD discussed above indicate that the
proximal carbonyl ligands are susceptible to similar coupling reactions to form five-member
metallacycles in pseudooctahedral rhenium tricarbonyl bipy complexes. Therefore, the
unprecedented observed coupling involving the coordinated phenanthroline is not only viable
under very mild conditions, but also preferred over the coupling involving one of the CO ligands.
N
NReOCOC
CO
HP
MeO2CC C
CO2Me
PhPh
N
NReOCOC
CO
P
HMeO2C CO2MePhPh
9 10
21
5.2. Dearomatization by deprotonation of complexes with N-alkylimidazole ligands.
In 2008 we reported that the reaction of [Re(N-MesIm)(CO)3(bipy)]OTf (11) (N-MesIm= N-
mesitylimidazole;; mesityl= 2,4,6-trimethylphenyl) with the strong base KN(SiMe3)2 affords a
product consistent with deprotonation of the imidazole C2-H group, followed by attack of that
carbon to the ortho (C6) carbon of the bipyridine ligand (complex 12, Scheme 10a).90 This
reaction stands in contrast with the transformation of an N-alkylimidazole (N-RIm) into an
anionic, C-bonded imidazolyl ligand (trapped by protonation to afford a stable cationic NH,NHC
complex) by deprotonation of a [Mn(N-RIm)(CO)3(bipy)]+ complex reported by Ruiz and
Perandones in 2007 (Scheme 10b).91 Note that imidazoles have been widely employed as
ligands in transition metal chemistry,2 and that metallation of free N-alkylimidazoles at C2 was a
known reaction.92,93 However, the deprotonation of metal-coordinated N-alkylimidazoles has
been virtually unexplored before.
Scheme 10. Imidazole-bipy C-C coupling (a) or transformation of N-RIm to NH-NHC
complexes (b).
As in the reactions of the phosphido complex discussed above, the C-C coupling reaction
resulting from the deprotonation of [Re(N-MesIm)(CO)3(bipy)]OTf affords a product in which one
N
NRe
OCOC
CO
N
N
Mes
OTf
N
NRe
OCOC
CO
N
NMes
H
KN(SiMe3)2
[Mn] N NR (i) KOtBu
R= Me, Ph
(ii) NH4PF6
+
[Mn]
+
N
N
R
H
[Mn]= Mn(CO)3(bipy)
(a)
(b)
11 12
22
of the pyridine rings of the bipyridine ligands is dearomatized, and it takes place under very mild
conditions.
Reactions similar to the deprotonation of [Re(N-MesIm)(CO)3(bipy)]OTf were carried out with its
N-methylimidazole (N-MeIm) analog as well as with the two similar compounds containing phen
instead of bipy. The stability of the products varied greatly. The neutral product of [Re(N-
MesIm)(CO)3(bipy)]OTf deprotonation was sufficiently stable to permit isolation and full
characterization, including X-ray crystallography. In solution the dearomatization of the attacked
ring is indicated by the upfield shift of several of the signals corresponding to its CH groups. The
solid-state structure of this species confirms the formation of the new C-C bond between the
central carbon (C2) of the imidazole ring and the C6 carbon atom of the bipyridine ligand, and
the dearomatization of the attacked pyridine ring, geometrically shown by its loss of planarity
(see Figure 3). Unlike in the C-C coupling reactions of the phosphido complex discussed above,
where six-member metalacycles were formed, now the product of the imidazole-bipy coupling
features a five-member ring. As a result of the C-C forming reaction, the aromatic imine
functionality in the reactant is transformed into an amido group in the product.
Figure 3. Molecular structure of complex 12.
The combination of amido ligands, with a high tendency to act as π-donors, with high oxidation
state metal fragments possessing empty orbitals of appropriate symmetry, usually leads to very
23
stable complexes.94 Although in principle, for an octahedral d6 complex, with the π-symmetric t2g
orbitals completely filled, π-donation from the amido ligand should not be possible, the electron
density from the amido lone pair can be donated to the strongly π-acceptor CO ligands via the
π-symmetric metal orbitals.95 Such donation, which would stabilize the complex, would lead to a
planar amido group. A planar at nitrogen geometry, characterized by a sum of the angles about
the nitrogen atom being 360°, has been encountered in most structurally characterized amido
complexes, including in arylamido rhenium tricarbonyl complexes, in which structural evidence
supports the delocalization of the amido lone pair through the aryl substituents.77 In contrast,
complex 12, the product of the deprotonation of [Re(N-MesIm)(CO)3(bipy)]OTf, which is a rare
example of a stable amido complex of a low valent metal without aryl substituents at the amido
nitrogen, features a pyramidal amido group, the sum of the angles around the amido nitrogen
being 335°. This feature can be attributed to the constrained geometry resulting from the amido
group being part of a rigid tridentate ligand.
Besides of the structural evidence -the geometries about both the carbon and the nitrogen are
consistent with sp3 hybridization in the product-, this amido character is reflected in the reactivity.
Thus, the neutral products resulting from the deprotonation of the [Re(N-RIm)(CO)3(N-N)]OTf
(R= Me, Mes;; N-N= bipy, phen) compounds react with MeOTf. For three of the compounds, the
reactions afford stable, cationic complexes featuring amino groups resulting from methylation at
nitrogen (Scheme 11). One of these derivatives (N-MesIm, phen) was fully characterized,
including X-ray diffraction. Comparing the two series of compounds, namely, the neutral amido
products with the cationic complexes that result from the methylation of the amido compounds,
the later have been found to be significantly more stable. This is attributed to the high
nucleophilic character of the amido ligand, a fact that has been previously noted in monodentate
amido rhenium tricarbonyl complexes.77,78,80
24
Scheme 11. Methylation of the amido group of the dearomatized, C-C coupled products,
affording stable amino complexes or a ring-opening product (13).
In the cationic amino complexes resulting from at-nitrogen methylation of the amido complexes,
both NMR and X-ray data indicate the presence of a dearomatized pyridyl ring as in the amido
precursor. The neutral species formed in the deprotonation of [Re(N-MeIm)(CO)3(bipy)]OTf
reacts with excess methyl triflate under very mild conditions (15 minutes stirring at room
temperature) affording compound 13 (see Scheme 11 and Figure 4), which was characterized
spectroscopically and by X-ray diffraction. The most interesting feature in the structure of 13 is
that it reveals, besides the double methylation of its nitrogen atom, that nitrogen extrusion
occurred in the pyridine ring to which the nucleophile attack took place. The product features a
tridentate ligand with pyridine, imidazole and dimethylamino donor groups, and a
cyclopentadienyl bridgehead group formed as the product of the mentioned nitrogen extrusion
from the attacked pyridine ring. The treatment of the neutral product of the initial deprotonation
with the stoichiometric amount of MeOTf failed to yield a monomethylated product akin to the
one resulting from methylation of 12;; however, taken collectively, the results outlined above
N
NRe
OCOC
CO
N
NR
H
MeOTfOTf
N
NRe
OCOC
CO
N
NR
H
Me
R= Mes; bipy, phenR= Me; phen
MeOTf (excess)R= Me; bipy
NReOC
OC
CO
N
N
N
Me
OTf
13
25
suggest that ring opening occurs via a second methylation of such a product. The fact that the
monomethylated phen complex does not react with excess MeOTf suggest that the additional
aromatic ring in the phen ligand somewhat hinders the rearrangement leading to nitrogen
extrusion.
Figure 4. Molecular structure of the cation of compound 13.
The overall transformation that starts with the deprotonation of the cationic N-methylimidazole
bipyridine complex and ends in the pyridine ring opening shows that pyridine ring opening under
mild conditions can be achieved starting from a very stable metal complex in which the bipy
ligand, usually very inert, is coordinated in its normal mode, i.e., both pyridyl rings bind the metal
only through their nitrogen atoms, in contrast with previous examples of homogeneous metal-
mediated pyridine ring-opening, which necessitated highly reactive early transition metal
fragments capable of binding pyridines in the κ2-(C,N) mode.
5.3. Couplings and dearomatization initiated by deprotonation of C(sp3)-H bonds.
The C-C coupling reactions discussed above have been initiated by the deprotonation of the
C(sp2)-H bond of an N-alkylimidazole ligand. We have found that similar C-C couplings can be
carried out through the deprotonation of aliphatic CH groups such as those of coordinated
26
dimethylsulfide96 or trimethylphosphane,97 which triggers the C-C coupling between the resulting
methylene group and one of the pyridyl groups of bipy and phen co-ligands.
The product of the reaction of [Re(CO)3(bipy)(S(CH3)2)]OTf with a slight excess of KN(SiMe3)2
showed insufficient thermal stability to allow crystallization and thus was fully characterized only
in solution by means of NMR. To aid in this characterization the labeled analog
[Re(CO)3(bipy)(S(13CH3)2)]OTf was similarly synthesized and deprotonated. The results of the
NMR studies indicated that the methylene group resulting from the deprotonation of one of the
methyl groups of S(CH3)2 attacked the C2 position of bipy, in contrast with the attack at C6 found
in the C-C coupling resulting from N-alkylimidazole deprotonation.90 The product has been found
to be the mixture of the diasteromers showed in Scheme 12. The reaction of the mixture of
diasteromers with the equimolar amount of trimethylphosphane afforded a single compound,
resulting from the displacement (from the rhenium coordination sphere) of the sulfide donor
group group by the phosphane (Scheme 12). In an analogous fashion, the diasteromeric
mixtures reacted with bis(dimethylphosphino)methane (dmpm), affording a single product in
which the sulfide group has been replaced by a monodentate dmpm. No product containing a
bidentate dmpm ligand could be detected, despite the high nucleophilicity of this diphosphane,
showing that the low stability of the diasteromeric mixture resulting from the deprotonation and
C-C coupling does not arise from lability of the ligands (e.g., decarbonylation).
Scheme 12. C-C coupling and pyridine dearomatization initiated by the deprotonation of a
dimethylsulfide ligand.
N
NRe
OCOC
CO
+S
CH3H3C
N
NRe
OCOC
CO
H2CPMe3
S
H3C
KN(SiMe3)2
N
NRe
OCOC
CO
S
H3C H H
+
N
NRe
OCOC
CO
S
H3C H H
PMe3
27
This low stability was thus attributed to the dearomatization of one of the pyridyl rings, and thus
a similar C-C coupling was sought which would involve a nonaromatic diimine in the hope that it
would afford a more stable product. Thus compound [Re(CO)3(2,6-iPr-BIAN)(S(CH3)2)]BAr’4
(2,6-iPr-BIAN= 1,2-bis[(2,6-diisopropylphenyl)imino]acenaphthene) was prepared and
characterized both spectroscopically and by X-ray diffraction, and it was allowed to react with
KN(SiMe3)2. Indeed, the stable, single product of the reaction was found to be the neutral
complex resulting from the coupling between the methylene group of an H3CSCH2 fragment,
produced in the deprotonation of the coordinated dimethylsulfide, and one of the imine carbons
of the diimine chelate. A factor that can make the BIAN-derived amido complexes more stable
compared with their bipy counterparts is the steric protection lent by the bulky aryl group in the
former.
The deprotonation of [Re(CO)3(bipy)(P(CH3)3)]OTf with KN(SiMe3)2 afforded a mixture of two
products (Scheme 13). One of them was the neutral cyano complex
[Re(CO)2(CN)(bipy)(P(CH3)3)], formed from attack of the amide on one of the CO ligands, a
known reaction that involves the elimination of hexamethyldisiloxane, O(SiMe3)2.98 The second,
minor product, was the expected result of the deprotonation of one of the phosphane methyl
groups and subsequent intramolecular attack on the bipy C6 position. Note the difference with
the similar reaction of the dimethylsulfide complex discussed above, in which the attack was to
the bipy C2 position instead.96
Scheme 13. Formation of cyano and dearomatized C-C coupled products initiated by
deprotonation of a trimethylphosphane ligand.
N
NRe
OCOC
OTfCO
KN(SiMe3)2+
PH3C CH3
H3C
PH3C
H H
N
NRe
OCOC
CO
H
H3C
N
NRe
OCOC
CO
CN
28
As in the reaction of the sulfide complex just described, the product of C-C coupling was found
to be too unstable for isolation, but could be characterized by NMR at low temperature. Stable
2,6-iPr-BIAN analogs were isolated and characterized, including by X-ray diffraction, for P(CH3)3,
P(CH3)2Ph and P(CH3)Ph2 complexes (see Figure 5 for the P(CH3)3 derivative). The
deprotonation has been found to take place exclusively at the methyl -not at the phenyl-
substituents. The amido groups in the C-C coupling products were found to be planar at nitrogen,
pointing to amido lone pair delocalization. At first sight such delocalization could be expected to
occur onto the aryl amido substituents. However, coplanarity would be the optimal orientation of
the aryl group with respect to the amido ligand in order to maximize the overlap between
π orbitals and allow the electronic delocalization onto the aryl group, and actually the amido
group was found to be very far from coplanar with the aryl substituent (the dihedral angle
between amido and aryl planes has been found to be 79° for the trimethylphosphane derivative).
Presumably this large deviation from coplanarity is due to the steric hindrance imposed by the
bulky isopropyl groups, as it is typical of BIAN complexes. Therefore, the planarity at the amido
nitrogen in the sulfide and phosphane derivatives results at least in part from π−donation from
the amido group to the strongly π−acceptors CO ligands via the metal π orbitals.95
Figure 5. Molecular structure of the BIAN C-C coupled product obtained by deprotonation of a
trimethylphosphane ligand.
29
5.4. Coupling between two monodentate heterocyclic ligands.
Most small molecules, and certainly most metal-complexing ligands, are constituted by a few
building blocks;; therefore, a modular synthesis employing cross-coupling reactions between
appropriate precursors could serve as a general synthetic approach.99 However, those
appropriate precursors must be reactive enough, so conventional cross coupling procedures
require first the preparation of functionalized versions of the individual building blocks. For
instance, in Pd-catalyzed C-C coupling schemes, one of the partners must be an electron rich
compound, such as a main group organometallic, organoborane, etc., while the other must be
an electrophile possessing a good leaving group, such a triflate or iodide (Scheme 14).
Scheme 14. General scheme of most late-metal catalyzed C-C coupling reactions.
That adds further complication to the whole synthesis and generates unwanted byproducts.
Some subunits, notably the 2-pyridyl group, are particularly problematic.99 Pyridyl groups are
prevalent motifs in several types on natural and unnatural products, and in particular in
polydentate ligands. Several families of coordination compounds, and in particular rhenium
tricarbonyl complexes, which have been the focus of most of our work, are potentially useful due
to their catalytic, luminescent or anticancer properties.100,101 The several examples of inter-ligand
C-C coupling within the metal coordination sphere discussed above suggested to us the
possibility of employing similar schemes to assemble monodentate ligands, including pyridines,
without the need of any previous functionalization other than metal coordination. The synthesis
of polydentate ligands, especially non-symmetric ones, is often a challenging task. In currently
employed methodologies, the free ligand is first synthesized and purified employing conventional
organic synthesis procedures, which are frequently tedious, multistep methodologies affording
a low overall yield and require separation of byproducts. Then, the ligand is reacted with an
appropriate metal source to afford the targeted metal complex. We envisaged an alternative
scheme in which small, non-functionalized building blocks, like pyridines, imidazoles, etc., are
first coordinated to a metal center by simple substitution reactions. Preassembly of those
HetAr1 M + X HetAr2 HetAr1 HetAr2
30
subunits would be taken care of by the geometric preferences of the metal fragment. For
instance, the strong preference for a fac disposition of the three CO ligands in octahedral metal
complexes ensures that any two of the remaining coordination sites are mutually cis and thus
optimally placed for a C-C coupling. Additional advantages of the metal coordination are an
enhanced acidity of the CH groups to be deprotonated and an enhanced reactivity of the
electrophilic counterpart, both leading to more reactive systems and thus to milder conditions,
which in turn would provide more selective reactions.
Rhenium tricarbonyl complexes containing two N-alkyimidazole ligands and one pyridine were
synthesized by the reaction of [Re(CO)3(N-RIm)2(OTf)] (which in turn is easily prepared from the
reaction of [Re(CO)5(OTf)] and N-alkylimidazoles) with either pyridine or 4-picoline and the
equimolar amount of NaBAr’4.102,103 The new precursors [Re(CO)3(N-RIm)2(py)]BAr’4 (R= Me,
Mes) are readily prepared in a half-gram scale, are relatively stable and can be kept for several
weeks in Schlenk flasks under a nitrogen atmosphere. A key for the success of the reactions
discussed below is that in solution, [Re(CO)3(N-RIm)2(py)]+ complexes -and, in general,
rhenium(I) tricarbonyl octahedral complexes- do not undergo ligand scrambling. Their reactions
with KN(SiMe3)2 in THF at -78°C immediately afford solutions with νCO bands at lower
wavenumber values, consistent with deprotonation. The addition of silver triflate afforded
cationic products (Scheme 15).
Scheme 15. Imidazole-pyridine cross-coupling at a rhenium center.
The solid state structures of two of these products were crystallographically determined,
confirming the presence of a fac-Re(CO)3 fragment bonded to an intact N-alkylimidazole ligand
NN
N
R
R'
ReOCOC
CO
N
N
R
BAr'4
ReOCOC
CO
N N
N
R
R'
BAr'4
(ii) AgOTf
(i) KN(SiMe3)2N N R
R= Me, MesR' H, Me
31
and to a bidentate ligand formed by the coupling between the C2 positions of an N-alkylimidazole
ligand and the C2 carbon of pyridine (Figure 6). This is consistent with the deprotonation of the
C2-H group of the N-alkylimidazole, followed by the intramolecular nucleophilic attack of the
deprotonated group on the C2 carbon (the most electrophilic position) of the monodentate
pyridine. The resulting bidentate ligand initially formed as the product of the C-C coupling would
feature a dearomatized pyridyl ring, like those formed in the nucleophilic attacks to the pyridine
rings of the bidentate bipy or phen ligands discussed above. Subsequently, that ring would be
rearomatized by reaction with the one electron oxidant silver triflate. Such rearomatizations could
not be carried out with the products of coupling between a deprotonated N-alkylimidazole and a
bidentate bipy or phen ligand discussed above, the likely reason being that the rigid fac-
tridentate ligand formed as the product of the C-C coupling cannot become planar, as it would
be required for rearomatization.
Figure 6. Molecular structure of a pyridylimidazole complex obtained by C-C coupling of
imidazole and pyridine ligands.
The fact that two equivalents of silver triflate are needed suggest the participation of two one-
electron oxidation events, in agreement with formal hydride removal. In the absence of
mechanistic studies, it is proposed that the neutral, dearomatized product of C-C coupling is
oxidized by one equivalent of silver triflate to afford a radical cation, a species that would be
deprotonated to afford a neutral radical;; this would then be oxidized by the second equivalent of
32
AgOTf yielding the observed cationic complex. Since only one equivalent of KN(SiMe3)2 was
employed, the putative radical cation would be deprotonated by hexamethyldisilazane,
HN(SiMe3)2, which would have been formed as the product of the initial deprotonation by
KN(SiMe3)2.
The course of the reaction has been found to be the same for the N-methylimidazole and N-
mesitylimidazole ligands. No other organometallic compounds could be detected as reaction
products. Note that free pyridylimidazoles, which are often employed as ligands, are usually
prepared by de novo construction of the pyrazole ring. Compounds containing [Re(CO)3(N-
RIm)(dmap)2]BAr’4 (R= Me, Mes, dmap= 4-dimethylaminopyridine) cationic complexes were
subjected to the same deprotonation/oxidation sequence, affording single products from
coupling between the C2 positions of the N-alkylimidazole and the pyridine (Figure 7). These
reactions selectively afford the products of cross-coupling between one imidazole and one
pyridine, without homocoupling (complexes containing biimidazole or bipyridine ligands)
products, regardless of the particular composition of the cationic precursors: two imidazoles and
one pyridine, or two pyridines and one imidazole. This is attributed to the higher acidity of the
C2-H group of the N-alkylimidazole ligand and the higher electrophilic character of the pyridine
ligand. Note that even the relatively electron-rich dmap ligand is electrophilic enough to undergo
the C-C coupling reaction.
Figure 7. Solid-state structure of the complex obtained by the cross coupling of dmap and N-
MesIm starting from [Re(CO)3(N-MesIm)(dmap)2]BAr’4.
33
The presence of an intact N-alkylimidazole ligand in the cationic complexes formed in the
reactions of pyridine-imidazole coupling and rearomatization suggested to us the possibility of
its deprotonation. The internal nucleophile presumably resulting from deprotonation of the C2
position of the monodentate N-RIm ligand could attack either the pyridine or the imidazole ring
of the non-symmetric bidentate ligand. Thus, the reaction of tricarbonyl rhenium
(imidazole)(pyridylimidazole) compounds with KN(SiMe3)2 afforded neutral (IR) products too
unstable for isolation and even for NMR characterization. These species were in situ protonated
with HOTf, affording stable products, which could be fully characterized (Scheme 16).
Scheme 16. C-C coupling between a monodentate N-RIm ligand and the pyridine ring of a
pyridylimidazole chelate.
The determination of its solid-state structure by X-ray diffraction established the protonation at
the nitrogen of the dearomatized ring, and the presence of a fac-capping tridentate ligand
resulting from the coupling between the C2 position of the N-RIm ligand and the ortho position
of the pyridyl ring of the bidentate ligand. The metrical data of the pyridyl ring indicate its
dearomatization, in agreement with the NMR solution data. When an analogous reaction was
conducted starting with the precursor containing an N-MesIm monodentate ligand, the product
of its deprotonation was not stable enough for isolation, but could be characterized in solution,
and its spectroscopic data suggested deprotonation of the monodentate N-RIm ligand and attack
to the 2-pyridyl ring, leading to its dearomatization. The reaction of this neutral species with triflic
acid afforded a stable product (which was also crystallized and fully characterized) resulting from
protonation at nitrogen similar to the one previously discussed. These results indicate that the
NN
N
RRe
OCOC
CO
N
N
R'
+
NReOC
OC
CO
N
NR'
H
NN R
NReOC
OC
CO
N
NR'
H
NN RH
+
KN(SiMe3)2 HOTf
34
intramolecular attack by the deprotonated N-alkylimidazole takes place selectively on the
pyridine ring, as no product of attack to the imidazole ring could be detected. Note that the full
sequence of reactions leading to these products with a tridentate ligand from the starting
complexes containing three monodentate N-heteroaromatic ligands (two N-alkylimidazoles and
one pyridine) involve two consecutive C-C coupling events between the C2 carbons of the two
N-alkylimidazoles and the two ortho positions of the pyridine ring.
The C-C coupling methodology outlined above was extended (in spite of the lower acidity of
pyridines compared with N-alkylimidazoles) to the coupling between two pyridine ligands to
afford complexes containing a 2,2’-bipyridine ligand. Thus, when [Re(CO)3(dmap)3]OTf (which
was readily prepared from [Re(OTf)(CO)5] and dmap) was treated with KN(SiMe3)2 and then with
AgOTf, the single organometallic product was found to be [Re(CO)3(2,2’-bipy-4,4’-
NMe2)(dmap)]OTf, which was fully characterized, including X-ray diffraction. Compounds
[Re(CO)3(py-R)3]OTf (py-R= pyridine or 4-methoxypyridine), prepared by the reaction of the
appropriate pyridine with the labile [Re(CO)3(DMSO)3]OTf compound, afforded [Re(CO)3(bipy-
R)(OTf)] products resulting from the coupling of two of the coordinated pyridines to afford a bipy
ligand when treated first with KN(SiMe3)2 and then with HOTf (which has been found to be a
cleaner oxidant in this case than AgOTf). The product containing the parent 2,2’-bipyridine
ligand, a known complex, was identified by comparison (IR and NMR) with a authentic sample,
and the product of C-C coupling between two 4-methoxypyridine ligands was fully characterized,
including X-ray diffraction.
These results demonstrated that deprotonation of a pyridine ligand coordinated in the by far
most commonly encountered κ1-(N) mode is feasible. This methodology for inter-pyridine
coupling could be successfully extended to two different pyridine ligands, affording complexes
with non-symmetric bipy ligands. Thus [Re(CO)3(dmap)2(py)]BAr’4 and [Re(CO)3(dmap)2(py-4-
OMe)]BAr’4 were prepared from addition of either pyridine or 4-methoxypyridine to
[Re(CO)3(dmap)2(OTf)] in the presence of the equimolar amount of NaBAr’4. The deprotonation
of these mixed pyridine compounds with KN(SiMe3)2 followed by oxidation with AgOTf afforded
[Re(CO)3(dmap)(N-N’)]BAr’4 compound featuring non-symmetric 2,2’-bipyridines resulting from
35
cross-coupling between different pyridine ligands (Scheme 17). As in the formation of
compounds with pyridylimidazole complexes (see above), no formation of symmetric,
homocoupled (from coupling of two equal pyridines) could be spectroscopically detected.
Scheme 17. Synthesis of a non-symmetric bipy ligand by C-C coupling followed by oxidation.
The formation of bipyridines by C-C coupling between two pyridyl groups on the coordination
sphere of group III complexes has been reported by Diaconescu et al.104,105 A difference with our
system is that whereas Diaonescu starts with the metallation of one pyridine to afford a κ2(C,N)
pyridyl ligand (see Scheme 18), we coordinated two neutral pyridine ligands in the κ1(N) normal
coordination mode and then reacted the resulting stable cationic complex with an external base.
Scheme 18. Coupling between two pyridine ligands on a scandium complex by Diaconescu et
al.
5.5. Ring-opening of imidazole rings.
The study of the deprotonation of coordinated N-akylimidazoles was extended to cationic fac-
Re(CO)3 complexes containing three such ligands.106,107 This reaction produces neutral
(ii) AgOTf
(i) KN(SiMe3)2
R= H, OMe
ReOCOC
CO
ReOCOC
CO
N
N
N R
N
N
BAr'4
N
NR
BAr'4
NN
N
THF
Ar
LScN
Ph
THF
LSc
N
Ph
NLSc
N
N
Ph
H
L= fc[NSitBuMe2]2, fc= ferrocene 1,1'-diamideAr= 3,5-dimethylphenyl
36
imidazolyl complexes as it will be discussed in Section 6.2 for [Re(CO)3(N-MeIm)3]OTf. In
contrast, if at least one of the imidazole ligands is an N-arylimidazole, neutral complexes
resulting from intramolecular attack of the deprotonated N-RIm ligand to the C2 carbon of one
of the other N-RIm ligands, which as a consequence undergoes ring opening, are produced (see
Scheme 19). In the products, the 1,3-diaza fragment resulting from imidazole ring opening
display a cisoid geometry as a result of an intramolecular hydrogen bond, shown in dashed line
in Scheme 19. Protonation or methylation of these products occurs at the non coordinated
nitrogen of the ring opened moiety, affording transoid products.
Scheme 19. Imidazole C-C coupling and ring-opening at Re(I) complexes.
Carver and Diaconescu have reported the ring opening of N-methylimidazole upon reaction of
scandium or yttrium benzyl complexes with three equivalents of MeIm for 5 hours at 70° C
(Scheme 20).108 The authors propose that the reaction occurs via C-H activation of one of the
imidazoles (to afford an imidazole-imidazolyl intermediate which could be characterized for an
yttrium analogue).
+
NN
HN
N
RRe
OCOC
CO
N
N
R
ReOCOC
CO
N
NR´
N
N
R
ReOC
OC
CO
N
N
R
NN
N
N´´R
+
R
KN(SiMe3)2
R= R'= MesR= Mes; R'= Me
HOTf or MeOTf
R''= H, Me
N N
37
Scheme 20. Proposed mechanism for scandium-mediated imidazole coupling and ring-
opening by Diaconescu et al.
Electrophilic addition at the imine-type nitrogen to generate an imidazolium cation, followed by
the attack of a nucleophile (usually hydroxide anion) at C2 has been proposed as the mechanism
for a number of imidazole cleavage processes, from the venerable Bamberger reaction109 to the
recent tandem ring opening of imidazoles with electron-deficient acetylenes and water.110 Of
these reactions, particularly mild conditions (45-60° C) have been reported for the later. N-
alkylimidazoles metalated (e.g., lithiated) at C2 have been found to display considerable stability
towards ring opening in comparison with other metalated N-heterocyles, allowing their
employment in reactions with organic electrophiles.93 Is somewhat surprising that, although N-
THF
Ar N N
C6D672 ˚C, 5h
N
N
N
LSc N
3
N N2
LSc
N
N
N
NAr
1Sc-(imidazole)2
N N
2Sc-imidazole-mesitylene
LSc
N
N
N
N
N
N
LSc
N
N
N
N
N
N
3Sc-imidazolex
x = 0, 1
N N- x
4Sc1Sc-THF
LSc
L= fc[NSitBuMe2]2, fc= ferrocene 1,1'-diamideAr= 3,5-dimethylphenyl
38
alkylimidazoles have been widely employed as ligands, deprotonation of metal-coordinated N-
alkylimidazoles and the reaction of metalated N-alkylimidazoles with transition metal complexes
remain very little explored.111
5.6. Couplings between N-alkylimidazoles and imine ligands.
In contrast with the reactivity displayed by the rhenium complexes discussed above, the
deprotonation of [Mo(η3-methallyl)(CO)2(bipy)(N-RIm)]+ complexes yielded the neutral
imidazolyl complexes, discussed on Section 6.2, and no product of C-C coupling could be
detected. DFT calculations, however, indicated that the energy differences between the pathway
leading to the observed imidazolyl product and that leading to attack on bipy is only 3.5
kcal/mol.112 That led us to synthesize several compounds of the type [Mo(η3-
methallyl)(CO)2(pyridylimino)(MeIm)]OTf and study their deprotonation with KN(SiMe3)2,
expecting that the nonaromatic imine function would be more reactive than bipy and hence could
be the target of the deprotonated imidazole.113 Indeed, attack by the deprotonated imidazole C2
carbon to the nonaromatic imine carbon, as shown in Scheme 21 has been found to be the sole
product.
Scheme 21. Imidazole-imine C-C coupling and protonation of the resulting amido group to
afford cationic amino complexes.
DFT calculations showed that the products of C-C coupling were the favored ones both
kinetically (they were formed in a process without computable barrier) and thermodynamically.
KN(SiMe3)2
Ar= C6H5, C6H4-4-Me, C6H3-3,5-Me2
HOTf
N
NMo
OCOC
N
N
OTf
Ar
N
N
OCOC Mo
OTf
NN
H
HR
N
N
OCOC Mo
NN
HAr
39
Some of the neutral C-C products were found to be stable enough to permit isolations;; for those
too unstable, protonation at the nitrogen originating from the nonaromatic imine with HOTf
yielded stable cationic complexes that were isolated as triflate salts and could be fully
characterized. Since allylmolbdenum dicarbonyl complexes are not as substitutionally inert as
the Re(I) complexes discussed above, possible intermolecular pathways involving the transfer
of the monodentate imidazole (or deprotonated imidazole) ligands between metal centers were
considered as a possibility (note that imidazolate bridges have been found by Braunstein,
Danopoulos and co-workers).111 They, however, were ruled out by a crossover experiment in
which a mixture of two compounds having different pyridylimine and N-alkylimidazole ligands
was treated with KN(SiMe3)2 afforded only the products of intramolecular C-C coupling (Scheme
22).
Scheme 22. Crossover experiment showing the intramolecular nature of the N-RIm-imine
coupling reactions.
5.7. Coupling between N-alkylimidazoles and nitriles or isonitriles.
Nucleophilic attacks on the sp-hybridized carbon atom of nitrile and isonitrile ligands are well
known, so in principle the coupling between these unsaturated ligands and C2-deprotonated N-
alkylimidazole co-ligands could offer a potential pathway to access new anisobidentate chelates
Ar= C6H4-4-MeR= iPr
N
NMo
OCOC
N
N
Me
OTf
+
(i) KN(SiMe3)2(ii) HOTf
N
N
OCOC Mo
OTf
NN
H
H
+
Not observed:
Ar
Me
Ar
N
NMo
OCOC
N
N
Et
OTf
R
N
N
OCOC Mo
OTf
NN
H
H
Et
RN
N
OCOC Mo
OTf
NN
H
H
Me
R
N
N
OCOC Mo
OTf
NN
H
H
Et
Ar
40
within the coordination sphere of a metal.114 Two possible difficulties were considered, one for
each type of monodentate unsaturated ligand: nitriles are labile;; therefore, attack to the metal
by either the base or the deprotonated N-RIm ligand could compete with attack at the
coordinated nitrile;; as for isonitriles, the planned attack at the metal-bonded carbon atom would
afford a four member ring, perhaps of limited stability;; note that such a product would be
comparable (carbonyl and isonitrile ligands are isoelectronic) to the computationally
encountered (but not stable enough for spectroscopic detection) intermediate in the reaction
leading to imidazolyl complexes, which is formed via C-C coupling between a CO and the C2-
deprotonated N-RIm ligand.
Nitrile and isonitrile compounds were prepared by the reaction of complexes [Re(CO)3(N-
RIm)2(OTf)] with pivalonitrile or tert-butylisocyanide and the salt NaBAr’4 in dichloromethane.115
Employing the later as a triflate abstractor is based on the low solubility of sodium triflate in
dichloromethane, and is needed to achieve the displacement of triflate from the cationic complex
by the poor donor nitrile, or by the low-nucleophilic isonitrile.
The [Re(CO)3(N-RIm)2(tBuCN)]BAr’4 and [Re(CO)3(N-RIm)2(tBuNC)]BAr’4 compounds, which
could be isolated and characterized, instantaneously reacted with KN(SiMe3)2 in THF at low
temperature to afford, as indicated by the change in the color and the IR spectrum of the solution.
For the nitrile complexes, the limited stability of the neutral (as judged by their νCO IR bands)
products precluded their isolation and even in situ NMR characterization. Reaction of these
neutral species with MeOTf or HOTf afforded cationic complexes, which were isolated and fully
characterized (see Scheme 23). Their NMR data are in agreement with the initial deprotonation
of the N-alkylimidazole ligand at its C2-H position and subsequent attack of the “internal
nucleophile” to the α carbon of the nitrile. The result of the C-C coupling reaction would be the
formation a five-member chelate ring featuring an alkylideneamido (N-metaloimine,82
ketimide116) donor group. A rhenium tricarbonyl complex has been found to be one of the very
few highly reactive -yet isolable- alkylideneamido complexes,82 in contrast with the chemical
inertness displayed by these ligands when coordinated to most other fragments.116 A similar high
reactivity may be the origin of the instability of the products of the deprotonation of [Re(CO)3(N-
41
RIm)2(tBuCN)]BAr’4 (Scheme 23). Methylation of the alkylideneamido nitrogen would produce
stable, cationic imino complexes. Treatment of the solutions containing the neutral unstable
intermediate with triflic acid afforded similar products, resulting from protonation at nitrogen. The
structure of one these protonated derivatives, solved by X-ray diffraction (see Figure 8), helped
to establish the reactivity pattern sketched above.
Scheme 23. Rhenium-mediated couplings between imidazole and nitrile (top) or isonitrile
(bottom) ligands.
ReOCOC
CO
N
N
N
R
C
tBu
BAr´4
ReOCOC
CO
N
N
N
R
C
tBu
R'
KN(SiMe3)2R'OTf
BAr´4
ReOCOC
CO
LN
N
R
ReOCOC
CO
CN
NN
NR
RN
tBu
ReOCOC
CO
CN
NN
NR
RN
tBu
HOTf
H
OTf
KN(SiMe3)2
L= tBuCN
L= tBuNC
L= tBuCN, tBuNCR= Me, Mes
N N R
N N R N N R
R'= H, Me
42
Figure 8. Molecular structure of the protonated final C-C coupling product between N-MesIm
and tBuCN.
The products of the deprotonation of the isonitrile complexes were found to be stable both in
solution and in the solid state and could be completely characterized, including the X-ray
structural determination of one of the derivatives (Figure 9). They result from the coupling
between C2(imidazole) and the isonitrile carbon, resulting in the formation of four member
chelates, consisting of an imidazole and a κ1(N)-iminoacyl donor groups (Scheme 23). Note that
complexes with κ1(N)-iminoacyl ligands are relatively rare, as most iminoacyls are κ2(N,C)-
coordinated to early transition metals. Reaction of these complexes occurred at the iminoacyl
nitrogen, resulting in the formation of cationic aminocarbenes (see Scheme 23). It is interesting
to note that the conceptually simple synthesis of non-heterocyclic carbenes by successive
additions of a nucleophile and an electrophile to isonitriles remains little explored. The discussed
results show that the intramolecular C-C coupling initiated by C2-deprotonation of N-
alkylimidazole ligands can lead to the formation of four member rings and to the attack on usually
labile nitriles. In addition, the reactions are selective, affording the described products, and not
the foreseeable products of attack on CO ligands or N-alkylimidazole co-ligands.
43
Figure 9. Molecular structure of the C-C coupling product resulting of the deprotonation of the
isocyanide compound [Re(CO)3(N-MesIm)2(tBuNC)]BAr’4.
5.8. Deprotonationof N-alkylimidazole ligands in phosphane-carbonyl complexes
In view of the previously discussed results, which show that even notoriously inert co-ligands
such as bipy and phen can be the target of deprotonated N-alkylimidazole ligands, we set out to
explore the deprotonation of N-alkylimidazole ligands in carbonyl complexes containing only
phosphane co-ligands.117 Since the later cannot be the site of nucleophilic attack, we anticipated
the possibility of obtaining products of attack on the CO ligands. As mentioned above, such an
attack has been computationally found to yield intermediates in the formation of imidazolyl
complexes, but stable products of the intramolecular attack of deprotonated N-RIm ligands on
carbonyl co-ligands were not observed previously.
The deprotonation of a coordinated N-methylimidazole ligand in cationic Re(I) tricarbonyl
phosphane complexes [Re(CO)3(MeIm)2(PR3)]BAr’4 employing the amide KN(SiMe3)2 showed a
dramatic dependence on the nature of the phosphane. Thus, whereas for trimethyphosphane
complexes, imidazolyl products were obtained, when the phosphane is either
triphenylphosphane or methyldiphenylphosphane, the deprotonation followed by methylation
with excess MeOTf reaction afforded the mixture of products shown in Scheme 24.
44
Scheme 24. Reactivity of [Re(CO)3(MeIm)2(PR3)]BAr’4 with the strong base KN(SiMe3)2.
Compound 15, which is the major product of the reaction, contains a binuclear cationic complex
resulting from a double activation of a N-methylimidazole ligand. Its structure (Figure 10 shows
the X-ray structure of the cation of the triphenylphosphane derivative) suggests that the C2
carbon of the deprotonated imidazole attacks one of the cis CO ligands, forming a four-member
metallacycle. Methylation of the oxygen of the involved carbonyl generates a methoxycarbene
moiety. The same imidazolate ring binds the second rhenium fragment as an abnormal nitrogen-
heterocyclic carbene through its C5 position, indicating a double imidazole deprotonation. This
second rhenium center completes its coordination sphere with one phosphane, two carbonyls
and an N, N’-bidentate ligand that results from the formal coupling of a molecule of CO (from the
carbonyl ligand missing at this rhenium center), one imidazole and one imidazolyl ligand. The
oxygen atom of the CO molecule involved in this coupling has been methylated, so the carbon
atom originating from CO is now sp3-hybridized. The minor product (16 in Scheme 24) contains
a cationic complex with two cis carbonyls, two trans phosphanes and a chelate bis(C-
imidazolyl)ketone ligand similar to the one just described for the binuclear complex, but without
methylation at oxygen.
BAr´4
ReOCOC
CO
N N
NPRPh2
MeN
Me
(i) KN(SiMe3)2
(ii) MeOTf N
NN
N
Re
PRPh2
OC
OC
PRPh2
C O
Me
Me
Ph2RPRe
CO
C
CO
N
NN
N
Re
PRPh2
OC
OC CH
Me
OMeMe
N
N Me
OMeNNMe
+
BAr´4
BAr´4
R= Me, Ph14 15 16
45
Figure 10. Molecular structure of the cation present in compound 15.
When compound 14 was deprotonated using n-butylllithium instead of KN(SiMe3)2, the product
was a neutral imidazolyl complex which turned out to be too unstable for isolation. Its reaction
with triflic acid afforded a stable, cationic complex featuring an NH-NHC ligand (Scheme 25),
which could be crystallized as its triflate salt and characterized in the solid state by single-crystal
X-ray diffraction, and in solution by IR and NMR. This difference in reaction outcome as a
function of the base employed suggests a relative stabilization of the deprotonated N-
methylimidazole as a result of the interaction of its C2 carbon atom with lithium, a smaller, more
polarizing cation than potassium.
Scheme 25. Transformation of a N-MeIm ligand in a NH-NHC by a deprotonation/protonation
sequence.
+
ReOCOC
CO
N N
NPPh3
MeN
Me
ReOCOC
CO
N
NPPh3
MeN NMe
+
ReOCOC
CO
N
NPh3
MeN NMe H
BuLi HOTf
46
The formation of the products 15 and 16 obviously involved complex, multistep reactions, and
proposing a meaningful mechanistic sequence would require additional work. Nevertheless, the
outlined results demonstrate several points, including the deprotonation of N-alkylimidazole at
C5 and subsequent formation of “abnormal” nitrogen-heterocyclic carbenes, the formation of
alkoxycarbenes via intramolecular attack of a C2-deprotonated N-alkylimidazole ligand to a CO
co-ligand, the CO activation by the attack of two C2-deprotonated N-alkylimidazole ligands, and
the dramatic effect of the employed strong base on the nature of the products.
6. Metal-mediated tautomerization of N-heterocycles to NHC complexes.
As we have mentioned above, the coordination of organic molecules to transition metals can be
used as a pathway to activate them. In certain instances, a dramatic modification of its nature is
found to be the consequence of such coordination. A well established example of this concept
is the metal-induced acetylene to vinylidene tautomerization (Figure 11). This process has been
studied, both theoretically and experimentally, and an activation barrier of 76 kcal·mol-1 has been
found, the vinylidene species being 44 kcal·mol-1 less stable than the acetylene isomer. 118 In the
presence of a number of metal fragments the process becomes thermodynamically favored and
kinetically available, affording the corresponding vinylidene metal complexes, the relative energy
of the two tautomers being inverted. 119
Figure 11. (a) Acetylene-vinylidene isomerization. (b) Metal-induced acetylene to vinylidene
tautomerization.
CC RH C CH
R
C
C
R
H
C CH
RLnM LnM
(a)
(b)
47
6.1. Tautomerization of pyridines.
The possible isomerization of pyridine to its 2-carbene tautomer120 was first proposed by
Hammick as early as in 1937,121 but it took over 60 years to prove its existence. This type of
tautomerization is frequently the key step in important biological processes, where the
energetically less stable tautomer is often responsible for the biological activity.122 The extremely
unstable pyridyl-2-ylidene was generated in the gas phase by Schwarz et al, and characterized
by means of mass spectroscopy. 123 Pyridin-2-ylidines are more than 40 kcal·mol-1 less stable
than pyridines, but coordination to transition metal fragments can strongly stabilize them. In 1987
Taube published the first pyridine carbene complex synthesized in solution, a 2,6-lutidinium ylide
coordinated to Os(II) through the para carbon (Figure 12).51 In the last 10 years the number of
pyridylene complexes has increased considerably, probably due to the use of different strategies
to provide an additional stability to the carbenic species.
Figure 12. First metal-pyridylene complex synthesized by Taube et al.
In 2006 Carmona, Poveda et al. achieved the tautomerization of 2-substituted pyridines into the
carbene tautomers mediated by the [TpMe2Ir(C6H5)2N2](TpMe2= hydrotris(3,5-
dimethylpyrazolyl)borate) fragment (Scheme 26).124 The steric hindrance provided by the
substituents at the 2-position precluded the formation of the (κ1,N)-coordinated pyridine
complexes while the formation of the N-heterocyclic carbenes was not affected by this issue, as
the substituent in the 2-position is away from the coordinated carbon atom.
Scheme 26. Formation of Ir(III) pyridylene complexes from 2-substituted pyridines.
N[Os] H
[Os]= Os(NH3)4(NCMe)2+
[Ir]Ph
Ph N2+
N R [Ir]Ph
Ph N R
H
C6H6
[Ir]= TpMe2Ir R= Me, Ph, tBu, NMe2
60-90 ºC
48
Concurrently, in the research group of Esteruelas stable carbene tautomers of quinoline and 8-
methylquinoline were synthesized by coordination to osmium- and ruthenium-chloro
complexes.125 It is interesting to note that an increased stability of the resulting NHC complexes
is provided by an intramolecular NH···Cl interaction between the NH group and a chloride ligand
coordinated to the same metal atom (see Figure 13a). The bulkiness of the substituent and the
co-ligands, along with an intramolecular hydrogen bond are also crucial in the formation of a
carbene tautomer of 2-ethylpyridine bonded to a hydride osmium(II) complex (Figure 13b).126
Figure 13. Stabilization of N-heterocyclic carbene complexes by intramolecular hydrogen
bonds.
There is just one example of a non-substituted pyridylidene complex obtained as a 1:1 mixture
together with the N-adduct (Scheme 27).127 This outstanding transformation was mediated by
an iridium complex featuring two Ir-CH2 bonds that resulted from the metallation of two methyl
groups of mesityl substituents of the trispyrazolylborate ligand (TpMs= hydrotris(5-
mesitylpyrazolyl)borate). The presence of an Ir-CH2 bond within a chelate is essential for the
tautomerization process.
+
N
M= Ru, Os
(a)
[MH2Cl2(iPr3P)2]
R
N
[M]
R
HCl
(b)BF4
N
Os
HH
NCMe
MeCN
PiPr3
Pr3iP
49
Scheme 27. Tautomerization of non-substittuted pyridine achieved by Carmona et al.
In contrast, there are some examples in which parent pyridylidenes have been implicated in the
functionalization of pyridines.128-132 In this context Bergman, Ellman and coworkers found that
the formation of the Rh-NHC complex 18 via C-H bond activation of the heterocycle 17 (see
Scheme 28) was the key step in the Rh-catalyzed coupling of N-heterocycles and olefins.129 The
1,2-hydrogen shift involved in this process was studied in detail, using experimental and
computational methods, and an intramolecular hydrogen transfer pathway through Rh-H
intermediates was found to be the more plausible mechanism.
Scheme 28. C-H activation of N-heterocycle 17 by a Rh(I) complex.
Tautomerization of 2-substituted pyridines to NH-N-heterocyclic carbenes induced by
TpMe2Ir(III) fragments (mentioned above) has been extended to the broadly used 2,2’-bipyridine
and 1,10-phenanthroline ligands.133 A new and unexpected coordination mode was found as
monohapto N-heterocyclic carbenes, in which an intramolecular hydrogen bonding between the
NH unit of the coordinated ring and the imine-type N atom of the other ring adds stability to these
species (Figure 14, complexes 19 and 20). A similar thermal activation was published for
terpyridine which is able to act as a mono- or bidentante NHC towards one or two metal atoms.134
A couple of examples have been published where chelation is the driving force to successfully
achieve the tautomerization of a pyridine moiety.135,136 An example of this strategy is shown in
TpMs''Ir(N2) +
NC6H6
TpMs''= dimetalated TpMs
60 ºC NTpMs''Ir
N
TpMs''Ir
H
+
TpMs= hydrotris(5-mesitylpyrazoly)lborate
+0.5 [RhCl(coe)2]2N
N
CH3
17
THF
75 ºC2 PCy3+
N
N
CH3
18
Rh
PCy3
PCy3 ClH
50
Figure 14 (complex 21) in which an Ir(I) fragment allows the formation of a stable metalacycle
upon α-CH activation of 1,9-phenanthroline.
Figure 14. Pyridylene tautomers of 2,2’-bipyridine (complexes 19 and 20). Tautomerization of
1,9-phenanthroline aided by the chelation effect (structure 21).
6.2. Tautomerization of imidazoles.
In spite of the higher stability of imidazole-2-ylidenes and their metal complexes, tautomerization
of imidazoles to the corresponding NHCs are also scarce processes. The relative stability of
imidazole N- or C-metal bound isomers was computationally studied by Crabtree and Einsentein,
who found a strong dependence on the nature of the metal fragment. 137 Sundberg et al.
published in 1974 the first example of N- to C- tautomerization of an imidazole ligand mediated
by a Ru(II) complex (Scheme 29), but an acidic media was needed and very low yields were
obtained.138
Scheme 29. First example of a metal-mediated imidazole to NH-NHC tautomerization.
The only other example of tautomerization of a non-chelated imidazole ligand to its NHC form
was proposed by Bergman and Ellman in their studies of Rh(I) catalyzed C-C coupling between
alkenes and benzimidazole.139 The NHC is formed in situ via C-H activation of the heterocycle
[Ir]
PhPh
N
N
H
[Ir]
N
N
H
N
N
[Ir]
H
[Ir]= TpMes2Ir [Ir]= Ir(COD)(PPh3)
19 20 21
NN H
R1 R2
[Ru] 2+
H+N
N
[Ru]
H
H
2+
R2
R1
[Ru]= Ru(NH3)5
51
(Scheme 30) being one of the first examples in which a NHC plays a non ancillary role in a
catalytic transformation.
Scheme 30. Isomerization of a benzimidazole derivative to its NHC isomer promoted by Rh(I).
The additional stability gained because of the formation of a bidentate chelate ligand has been
used to achieve imidazole to NHC tautomerization for a N-phosphane-functionalised imidazole
in the presence of iridium140 and ruthenium141 metal fragments (structure 22 in Figure 15). An
analogous activation occurred when 2-pyridylbenzimidazole is refluxed in THF with [RuCp*Cl]4
to afford the 5-membered chelate complex 23 depicted in Figure 15,142 or in the reaction of an
N-arylimine-functionalized imidazole with [Ir(cod)(µ-Cl)]2 aided by a halogen abstractor to afford
complex 24 (Figure 15).143 The reverse tautomerization, i. e. from NH-NHC to imidazole ligands
mediated by these two metals (Ir and Ru) have also been reported by Whittlesey144 and Li145.
Figure 15. Examples of tautomerization of N-alkylimidazol derivatives to NH-NHCs assisted by
chelation.
The groups of Siebert146 and Erker147 studied the reactivity towards a strong base of imidazole-
borane adducts, showing that for the BH3 moiety the anionic 3-boraneimidazol-2-ylidene could
be isolated (structure 25 in Scheme 31), whereas migration of BR3 (R=Et, C6F5) groups to the
PCy3
N
N
+ [RhCl(COE)2]2THF, 75 ºC
N
N
Rh PCy3
ClH
PPh2
Mn+
LCl
N
NH
tBu
22
M= Ru; L=Cp; n=0M= Ir; L= Cp*; n=1
Ru
Cl
Cp*
N
N
N
H
23
N N H
N [Ir]Ar
24
[Ir]= Ir(COD)Ar= 2,6-iPr2(C6H5)
+
52
carbene carbon atom was observed for trialkyl- or triarylborane reagents (complex 26 in Scheme
31).
Scheme 31. Reactivity of imidazole-borane adducts studied by Siebert and Erker.
As we have mentioned above, in the last years our research interest has been focused on the
deprotonation of N-alkylimidazole ligands coordinated to organometallic fragments. A cationic
metal complex bearing a N-RIm ligand can be regarded as a N-metallated imidazolium salt
(Figure 16), and therefore the deprotonation of the central imidazole CH group would afford a
NHC in an analogous manner to the most general method used to prepare imidazol-2-ylidenes
from imidazolium salts. Our results show that the species resulting from such deprotonation
reaction are very reactive, mainly because of their high nucleophilic behavior, and their evolution
strongly depends on the nature of the metal fragment and its coligands, as well as on the
substituent of the imidazole.
Figure 16. Analogy between an imidazolium salt (A) and a cationic imidazole metal complex
(B).
The reaction of [Re(CO)3(N-MeIm)3]OTf (27) with the equimolar amount of KN(SiMe3) afforded
a neutral imidazol-2-yl product, 28 (Scheme 32).106,107 The formation of 28 implies, once the
deprotonation has occurred, the isomerization of the heterocyclic ligand from the N- to the C-
rhenium bonded species. Examples of this type of complexes, which feature a C-bonded
BuLi
R'
R'
N
N
BR3
R'
R'
N
N
BR3
Li
R'
R'
N
NR= Et, C6F5
BR3
R= H
25 26
N NR R'
+
N NR [M]
+
A B
53
imidazol-2-yl ligand with a non-substituted nitrogen, are very rare.116,140-142,146-148 In addition,
these species tend to be elusive and have been previously proposed for the tautomerization of
N-alkylimidazole to NHC ligands.91 Compound 28 reacts smoothly with electrophiles, such as
HOTf, to afford the product of protonation on the non-coordinated nitrogen, compound 29
(Scheme 32). The overall transformation from compound 27 to 29 can be seen as a
tautomerization of an imidazole to a NH-NHC ligand promoted by a strong base, complex 28
being a stable intermediate. This reaction sequence is reminiscent of the mechanism proposed
by Ruiz for the transformation of an imidazole into an NHC ligand at a Mn(I) center,91 although
in that case the authors could not isolate the neutral complex (analog to 28), probably due to its
lower stability.
Scheme 32. Tautomerization of a N-methylimidazole ligand promoted by a
deprotonation/protonation sequence.
In compound 28 the heterocyclic ligand is an imidazol-2-yl, but its structural and spectroscopic
properties are very close to those of the rhenium N-heterocyclic carbene compound 29 (see
Figure 17). Thus the Re-C1 distances are undistinguishable (2.190(7) Å in 28, and 2.191(5) Å
in 29) and the 13C NMR chemical shifts for the Re-bonded carbon are182.4 (28) and 178.7 ppm
(29). The rest of the metrical data for the N-heterocyclic ligand show a high electronic
delocalization for both complexes. Also noteworthy is the similarly high trans influence, reflecting
the high donor ability of both C-bonded N-heterocyclic ligands as judged from the Re-C11 bond
distances (1.958(7) Å for 28 and 1.945(6) Å for 29), compared with the other Re-Ccarbonyl bond
distances (1.901(5) Å for 28, and 1.916(6) Å for 29). The presence of a hydrogen atom on N2 in
28 is the only difference between the metallic complexes present in 28and 29, and it was
OTf
ReOCOC
CO
N
N
N
NN
NRe
OCOC
CO
N
NN
N
N N
28
KN(SiMe3)2 ReOCOC
CO
N
NN
N
OTf
29
N N
27
H
HOTf
54
confirmed by a topological analysis of the Laplacian of the electron density (∇2ρ). This study
indicated the presence of an in-plane lone pair at N2 in complex 28 and of an N-H bond in 29,
as well as the electron delocalization mentioned above.
Figure 17. NMR and structural similarities between imidazole-2-yl and NH-NHC ligands
coordinated to Re(CO)3(N-MeIm)2 fragment.
In contrast, complexes [Re(CO)3(N-MeIm)x(N-MesIm)3-x]+ (x= 1, 2), with at least one N-
arylimidazole ligand, led, after deprotonation reaction, to the C-C coupling and ring-opening
products,106 as it has been mentioned in Section 1.3.
On the other hand, the related neutral complex [Re(OTf)(CO)3(N-MeIm)2] (30) reacted
instantaneously with KN(SiMe3)3 to yield compound 31 (see Scheme 33).149
Scheme 33. Tautomerization of two N-MeIm ligands promoted by a single equivalent of base.
The new complex contained a fac-Re(CO)3 fragment bonded to one N-MeIm ligand, one
imidazol-2-yl-ligand and one NH-NHC ligand, the last two resulting from N- to C-coordination
change of two N-MeIm ligands. The N-H group of the NH-NHC ligand acts as hydrogen bond
ReOCOC
CO
OTf N
NN
N NN
H
NN
ReOCOC
CO
N
N
KN(SiMe3)2N-MeIm
HOTfN
NHRe
OCOC
CO
N
N
N
HN
OTf
30 31 32
55
donor towards the non-coordinated nitrogen of the imidazol-2-yl ligand, contributing to the
coplanarity of the two heterocyclic ligands (as shown in Figure 18 for the analogous mesityl
derivative). A molecular mirror plane is evident from the NMR spectra of 31, indicating the fast
(even at low temperature) H+ transfer between the two nitrogens, i.e., the complex can be
described as featuring two imidazol-2-yl ligands that share a proton. The Re-bonded carbon of
these ligands occurs at 180.7 ppm in the 13C NMR spectrum, and the two Re-C bond distances
are undistinguishable (Re-C2 2.214(10) and Re-C22 2.207(9) Å), showing the close similarity
between imidazol-2-yl and NH-NHC ligands. The yield of 31 notably increased when its
preparation was conducted in the presence of the equimolar amount of N-methylimidazole (N-
MeIm), as expected since, in its absence, part of the bis(imidazole) precursor 30 must have
acted as a sacrificial source of N-MeIm.
Figure 18. Molecular structure of the mesityl derivative analogous to compound 31.
Density functional theory (DFT) calculations about the reaction mechanism showed that the most
favorable one is that shown in Scheme 34. The Gibbs free energy in THF solution (in
parentheses) is referred to that of the deprotonated species [Re(OTf)(CO)3(N-MeIm)2]- (structure
I, Scheme 34) and N-MeIm. The reaction starts with loss of triflate from I to give intermediate IIa
in which the Re atom is simultaneously interacting with the non-coordinated N atom and the C-
2 atom of the imidazolyl ligand. Intermediate IIa undergoes a rotation of the imidazole ring
56
around the N-Re bond through TS-IIa/IIIa to give the intermediate IIIa. TS-IIIa/IVa connects IIIa
with intermediate IVa wherein the two heterocyclic ligands are C-bound to the Re atom. Finally,
addition of N-MeIm to IVa leads to the formation of a rhenium imidazol-2-yl(carbene) complex
Va without any transition state. The formation of the rhenium imidazolyl-carbene complex would
imply a Gibbs energy barrier in solution of 21.5 kcal/mol, consistent with the fast formation of the
product experimentally observed. A key feature of the proposed mechanism is the intermediacy
of η2-N,C-imidazolyl complexes, which make possible ligand dissociation without going through
high-energy five-coordinate species. Stable η2-N,C-imidazolyl complexes have been disclosed
by Diaconescu et. al.in scandium and uranium chemistry.150
Scheme 34. Proposed (based on DFT computations) mechanism for the formation of
imidazolyl-NHC complex 32 from the neutral bis(imidazole) derivative 30.
The reaction of 31 with trifluoromethanesulfonic acid (HOTf) afforded 32, the triflate salt of the
bis(NH-NHC) complex resulting from protonation at nitrogen (Scheme 33). The overall formation
of 32 from 30 involves, besides the substitution of OTf by the entering imidazole, the formation
of two new Re-C bonds at the expense of the two Re-N bonds. As we have discussed above,
deprotonation of a coordinated N-MeIm ligand in [Re(CO)3(N-MeIm)3]OTf followed by
protonation of the resulting imidazol-2-yl ligand affords a NHC complex (see Scheme 32). The
ReOCOC
CO
OTf N
N
I (0.0)
NN
- OTf
-
N
N
ReOCOC
CO
NN
TS-IIa/IIIa(-16.6)
N
N
ReOCOC
CO
NN
H
TS-IIIa/IVa(3.8)
N N
NN
H
ReOCOC
CON
NH
NN
ReOCOC
CO
N
N
N-MeIm
IIa (-17.2) IIIa (-17.7)
IVa (-10.5)Va (-21.8)
57
formation of the bis(carbene) complex from the bis(imidazole) precursor is not just twice that
process, because the addition of only one equivalent of base triggers the Re-N to Re-C
rearrangement of two imidazole ligands. It is also noteworthy that in the deprotonation reactions
of a) the tris(N-MesIm) compound, or b) the triflato complex 30 in the presence of free N-MesIm,
the components of the reactant mixture are the same, whereas different isomers are obtained
as products. The formation of the ring-opening product in the former case or the imidazolyl-
carbene in the later shows again the extreme sensitivity of the reaction course to the exact nature
and number of the ligands.
The wide variety of products obtained from the reactivity of the rhenium compounds prompted
us to extend our studies of deprotonation of N-alkylimidazole ligands to molybdenum
organometallic species.112 The chosen cationic compounds of formula [Mo(η3-
C4H7)(bipy)(CO)2(N-RIm)]OTf feature, like those of rhenium, pseudooctahedral structures in
which the imidazole and each ring of the bipy ligand are in cis positions. The addition of a strong
base to [Mo(η3-C4H7)(bipy)(CO)2(N-RIm)]+ complexes, followed by protonation or alkylation of
the resulting neutral product, leads to the formation of Mo-NHC compounds (Scheme 35). This
reactivity constitutes another example in which the addition of a strong base, followed by an acid
promotes the tautomerization of an N-alkylimidazole ligand to NH-NHC.
Scheme 35. Synthesis of imidazol-2-yl and NHC complexes from N-alkylimidazole ligands
coordinated to Mo(η3-C4H7)(bipy)(CO)2 fragment.
In agreement with the experimental results, a DFT study showed that the most favorable reaction
mechanism for the Mo(II) complexes consisted in an initial attack of the imidazole deprotonated
N
N
OCOC
OTf
Mo
N
N
R
THF, -78 ºC
KN(SiMe3)2
N
N
OCOC Mo
N NR
CH2Cl2
R'OTf
N
N
OCOC Mo
N NRR'
OTf
N = 2,2'-bipyridineNR= Me, MesR'= H, Me; Et
58
carbon atom onto a cis-CO ligand, to afford in a second step imidazol-2-yl species (Figure 19).
This mechanism is reminiscent of the one found for [Mn(bipy)(CO)3(N-RIm)]OTf compounds,151
suggesting that this new and unexpected ‘carbonyl mechanism’ can be quite general for related
transformations. As it is shown in Figure 19, pathway A, that led to the C-C coupling product, is
favored over pathway B, which affords formation of the imidazole-2-yl complex, by only 3.5 kcal
mol-‐1. In addition to this, the formation of Mo-IIb (-7.0 kcal mol-1) implies a Gibbs energy barrier
of only 4.8 kcal mol-1, which is clearly lower than the one required for obtaining Mo-IIa (8.3 kcal
mol-1). The better kinetic accessibility of Mo-IIb in conjunction with the fact that its evolution to
Mo-IIIb shows a Gibbs energy barrier in solution (11.8 kcal mol-1) ) clearly lower than that for the
reversion to Mo-IIa (15.3 kcal mol-1) via Mo-I, and that the Mo-IIIb product is considerably stable
(13.4 kcal mol-1), make B the most favorable pathway, affording the formation of imidazol-2-yl
products instead of the C-C coupling species, as it is encountered experimentally.
Figure 19. Schematic view of the reaction mechanisms found for the deprotonation reaction of
[Mo(η3-C4H7)(bipy)(CO)2(N-MesIm)]+ at the B3LYP/6-31G(d) (LANL2DZ for Mo) level of theory.
59
In 2013 Darensbourg evidenced the occurrence of a base-promoted conversion of a N-
alkylimidazole ligand to the corresponding NH-NHC mediated by a dinitrosyl iron complex.152
6.3. Tautomerization of other azoles.
Compared with imidazol-2-ylidenes less attention has been paid to N,X-heterocyclic carbenes
(X= O, S), mainly due to the instability of the free ligands which easily undergo dimerization
processes.153 A probably better alternative would be to force the tautomerization of the
coordinated azole ligand upon a deprotonation/protonation (or alkylation) sequence as that
described above for N-alkyilimidazole ligands. This method is illustrated in Scheme 36 for
Mn(azole)(CO)3(bipy)+ (azole= oxazole, thiazole) complexes to afford the corresponding
heterocyclic carbenes.154 Prior to this work, deprotonation of 4-methylthiazole155 or
benzothiazole156 ligands coordinated to Cr(CO)5 followed by methylation had led to the
formation of the carbene complexes, but lack of selectivity had been observed as the
dimethylated azole complexes were also obtained.
Scheme 36. Tautomerization of oxazole and thiazole to the corresponding carbene derivatives
at a Mn(I) fragment.
7. Metal-ligand cooperation based on aromatization/dearomatization processes.
The chemical behavior of transition metal complexes is dramatically dependent on the steric and
electronic properties of the ligands coordinated to the metal center. Modification of the ligands
properties has been used as a tool to improve the desired properties of metal complexes
depending on the particular processes, i. e. increasing its electrophilic/nucleophilic, basic/acid
KOtBu
X
N
[Mn]
X
N
X
NNH4PF6
[Mn][Mn]
+H
+
[Mn]= Mn(CO)3(bipy)
X= O, S
60
character, etc. A particular area in which this concept has been broadly used is in homogeneous
catalysis. In the vast majority of reactions catalyzed by metal complexes, the catalytic activity is
primarily based on the metal while the ligands are considered as spectators, as they do not
participate in the chemical transformations directly. In the last decade the development of
bifunctional catalysts has gained interest showing that the metal center and its coordinated
ligands can jointly cooperate in the catalytic cycle.157 A particular case of this type of metal-ligand
cooperation (MLC), studied by Milstein et al., is based on dearomatization/aromatization
processes on the ligand. These studies have been comprehensively covered in several recent
reviews,158-160 but due to their relevance and fundamental importance they have been, although
briefly, also included herein. These authors found that pyridine-based PNP and PNN (structures
33 and 34, Figure 20), and bipyridine-based (structure 35, Figure 20) pincer ligands can stabilize
coordinatively unsaturated complexes.
Figure 20. PNP and PNN pincer ligands studied by Milstein et al.
The facile deprotonation of the pincer backbone at one of the methylene spacer groups affords
the dearomatization of the pyridine ring, which must be stabilized by being part of the pincer
ligand. The dearomatized complexes can activate various chemical bonds including H-H, C-H,
O-H and N-H bonds. These activations are carried out by cooperation between the metal and
the ligand, regaining aromatization of the ligand by protonation of the benzylic carbon atom
(Scheme 37).
N
NEt2
PR2
N
PR2
PR2
R= tBu, iPr
N
PR2
N
R= tBu, iPr, Ph
33 34 35
61
Scheme 37. Activation of H-Y chemical bonds by cooperation of the metal and the ligand
through a dearomatization/rearomatization process.
Several pincer complexes of this type, mainly based on Ru158 and Fe,159 which are able of
participate in MLC processes, have been described showing their ability as versatile catalysts
for hydrogenation, dehydrogenation and related reactions. It has to be highlighted that the first
application of dearomatization-reprotonation was the employment of complex 36 for the
dehydrogenation of alcohols, wherein the combined metal and dearomatized ligand act in
cooperative manner to convert, for example, primary alcohols to esters or secondary alcohols to
ketones, with concomitant extrusion of H2 (Scheme 38).161
Scheme 38. Dehydrogenation of alcohols to esters or ketones with a dearomatized pincer
complex.
N
L2
L1
MLn- H+
baseN
L2
L1
MLn N
L2
L1
MLn
H-Y
N
L2
L1
MLm
H
Y
Y= H, OH, OR, NH2, NR2
N
NEt2
PtBu2
Ru COH
36OH
R1R2
H R1 R2
O
+ H2
62
Milstein and co-workers reported that, in a similar manner to aliphatic alcohols, water could also
be activated using complex 36 with the dearomatized PNN backbone (Scheme 39).162 Upon
reaction with water at room temperature, aromatization takes place to quantitatively form the
trans-hydrido-hydroxo complex 37. Thermal activation of a second molecule of water releases
molecular hydrogen and leads to the formation of cis-hydroxo complex 38. DFT studies indicate
that this process involves H2 liberation from 37 by coupling of the hydride ligand with a proton
from the side arm, followed by addition of H2O to the generated dearomatized intermediate.
Significantly, irradiation of complex 38 led to the regeneration of compound 37 concomitant with
evolution of O2. This sequence would involve a photochemically induced reductive elimination
of H2O2 from dihydroxo complex 38, thereby generating a Ru(0) intermediate (39, not observed)
that undergoes intramolecular proton transfer to regenerate the starting compound. Therefore,
this is a new approach toward a complete cycle for the generation of dihydrogen and dioxygen
from water promoted by a soluble metal complex.
Scheme 39. Proposed reaction mechanism for the generation of O2 and H2 from H2O
mediated by a Ru(PNN) complex.
N
NEt2
PtBu2
Ru CO
36
37
H
N
NEt2
PtBu2
Ru COH
OH
38
N
NEt2
PtBu2
Ru OHOC
OH
39
N
NEt2
PtBu2
Ru CO
H2O H2
H2O + 0.5 O2 H2O2cat
hν
63
8. Conclusions and outlook.
Pyridines react with several types of main group organometallic compounds to give metal-
pyridine adducts, proposed on the basis of computational studies or by extrapolation of the
behavior encountered in non-reactive systems. They evolve to metal complexes of anionic
dihydropyridines, which have been isolated only in a few cases, and which finally yield
substituted pyridines. Only in the last few years some groups have started to employ N-
coordination of the pyridine to an external Lewis acid (e.g., BF3) combined with nucleophilic
addition of an organometallic reagent, or the reaction of the pyridine with a bimetalic reagent
containing different Lewis acid and nucleophilic metal sites (e.g., lithiun aryl zincates), obtaining
selective, synthetically useful methodologies. In contrast, the pyridine rings in transition metal
complexes containing pyridyl-based ligands -which are among the most useful and widely
studied within coordination chemistry- are typically very inert. In the seventies this notion was
challenged by Gillard, who proposed that apparent anomalies in the behavior of cationic bipy
and phen transition metal complexes in basic aqueous media could be the result of hydroxide
attack to one of the pyridine carbon atoms. However, subsequent studies casted doubt on this
proposal. Our group demonstrated several instances of C-C coupling via intramolecular
nucleophilic attack to the pyridyl rings on Re-coordinated bipy and phen ligands under very mild
conditions, most of them initiated by deprotonation of C-H groups of several types of commonly
employed monodentate ligands. The products of such reactions feature metal-bonded,
dearomatized dihydropyridyl groups. The products of coupling between two monodentate N-
alkylimidazole or pyridine ligands could be rearomatized by oxidation to afford pyridylimidazole
or bipyridine ligands, including non-symmetric chelates. The reaction of one of the dearomatized
products of the bipy-N-alkylimidazole coupling with excess MeOTf led to pyridine ring opening,
a transformation previously limited to three examples of very reactive early transition metals. C-
C coupling schemes were extended to ligands other than pyridines, allowing the modular
construction of non-symmetric polydentate ligands on the metal coordination sphere.
In some cases the deprotonation of coordinated N-alkylimidazoles afforded very rare imidazole-
2-yl ligands. Their reaction with electrophiles afford NHC ligands;; in particular, their reaction with
64
acids yield NH,NHC ligands. This kind of reaction can serve to directly access metal complexes
of NHC ligands directly from stable, easily accessible N-alkylimidazole complexes.
Computational studies proved to be very useful in shedding light on the kinetics and
thermodynamics of the competing pathways that lead in some systems to C-C coupling and in
others to imidazolyl formation. Most of these reactions have been carried out employing highly
stable, easily available rhenium tricarbonyl complexes, whose chemistry has been previously
almost exclusively dominated by substitution reactions.
A growing number of types of transition metal compounds are finding applications as catalysts,
materials, and drugs. Therefore, the synthesis of transition metal complexes is becoming a
proper goal beyond their classical employment as auxiliaries towards the synthesis of metal-free
organic molecules. The traditional synthetic approach is based on the separate synthesis of the
ligands employing conventional organic procedures, which in the case of non-symmetric,
polydentate ligands can be far from straightforward, followed by their binding to the metal
through substitution reactions. In some cases, this scheme could be advantageously replaced
by the modular synthesis of the polydentate ligands from easily available monodentate ligands,
which would be first coordinated to the metal and then coupled, taking advantage of the ligand
activation and geometric preorganization by their metal coordination.
9. References.
1. Balaban AT, Oniciu DC, Katritzky AR. Aromaticity as a cornerstone of heterocyclic chemistry.
Chem Rev. 2004;;104:2777-2812.
2. Sundberg RJ, Martin RB. Interactions of histidine and other imidazole derivatives with
transition metal ions in chemical and biological systems. Chem Rev. 1974;;74:471-517.
3. Welton T. Room-temperature ionic liquids. Solvents for synthesis and catalysis. Chem Rev.
1999;;99:2071-2083.
4. Hopkinson MN, Richter C, Schedler M, Glorius F. An overview of N-heterocyclic carbenes.
Nature. 2014;;510:485-496.
65
5. Zhao G, Lin H. Metal complexes with aromatic N-containing ligands as potential agents in
cancer treatment. Curr Med Chem Anticancer Agents. 2005;;5:137-147.
6. Kaes C, Katz A, Hosseini MW. Bipyridine: the most widely used ligand. A review of molecules
comprising at least two 2,2’-bipyridine units. Chem Rev. 2000;;100:3553-3590.
7. Sammes PG, Yahioglu G. 1,10-Phenanthroline: A versatile ligand. Chem Soc Rev.
1994;;23:327-334.
8. Shopov DY, Rudshteyn B, Campos J, Batista VS, Crabtree RH, Brudvig GW. Stable
iridium(IV) complexes of an oxidation-resistant pyridine-alkoxide ligand: highly divergent redox
properties depending on the isomeric form adopted. J Am Chem Soc. 2015;;137:7243-7250.
9. Chupakhin ON, Charushin VN, van der Plas HC. Nucleophilic aromatic substitution of
hydrogen. 1st ed. California, United States: Academic Press Inc;; 1994.
10. Shaw AP, Ryland BL, Franklin MJ, Norton JR, Chen JY-C, Hall ML. Using a two-step hydride
transfer to achieve 1,4-reduction in the catalytic hydrogenation of an acyl pyridinium cation. J
Org Chem. 2008;;73:9668-9674.
11. Butschke B, Schwarz H. “Rollover” cyclometalation-early history, recent developments,
mechanistic insights and application aspects. Chem Sci. 2012;;3:308-326.
12. Mertel HE, Mizzoni RH, Shaw EN, Tenenbaum LE, Yale HL. Pyridine and its derivatives.
In: Weissberger A, Klingsberg E, eds. The chemistry of heterocyclic compounds. New York,
NY: Interscience Publishers Inc;; 1961.
13. Bull JA, Mousseau JJ, Pelletier G, Charette AB. Synthesis of pyridine and dihydropyridine
derivatives by regio- and stereoselective addition to N-activated pyridines. Chem Rev.
2012;;112:2642-2713.
14. Donohoe TJ, Connolly MJ, Walton L. Regioselective nucleophilic addition to pyridinium salts:
A new route to substituted dihydropyridones. Org Lett. 2009;;11:5562-5565.
15. McGill CK, Rappa A. Advances in the Chichibabin reaction. Adv Heterocycl Chem.
1988;;44:1-79.
66
16. Ma Y, Breslin S, Keresztes I, Lobkovsky E, Collum D. Synthesis of a 7-Azaindole by
Chichibabin cyclization: Reversible base-mediated dimerization of 3-picolines. J Org Chem.
2008;;73:9610-9618.
17. Mastalir M, Pittenauer E, Allmaier G, Kirchner K. 2,6-Diamination of substituted pyridines via
heterogeneous Chichibabin reaction. Tetrahedron Lett. 2016;;57:333-336.
18. Terrier F. Modern nucleophilic aromatic substitution. 1st ed. Weinheim, Germany: Wiley-
VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.;; 2013.
19. Fier PS, Hartwig JF. Selective C-H fluorination of pyridines and diazines inspired by a classic
amination reaction. Science 2013;;342:956-960.
20. Rudnitskaya A, Török B, Dransfield T. A B3LYP/6-31+G(d) study of the reaction pathways
and conformational preference in a model Chichibabin reaction. Comput Theor Chem.
2011;;963:191-199.
21. Van der Plas HC. The SN(ANRORC) mechanism: A new mechanism for nucleophilic
substitution. Acc Chem Res. 1978;;11:462-468.
22. Breuker K, Van der Plas HC. Occurrence of an SN(ANRORC) mechanism in the Chichibabin
amination of 4-Phenylpyrimidine. J Org Chem. 1979;;44:4677-4680.
23. Francis RF, Davis W, Wisener JT. Reaction intermediates in the alkylation of pyridine with
tert-butyllithium. J Org Chem. 1974;;39:59-62.
24. Matsubara Y, Kosaka T, Koga K, Nagasawa A, Kobayashi A, Konno H, Creutz C, Sakamoto,
Ishitani O. Formation of η2‑coordinated dihydropyridine−ruthenium(II) complexes by hydride
transfer from ruthenium(II) to pyridinium cations. Organometallics 2013;;32:6162−6165.
25. Harrison DP, Zottig VE, Kosturko GW, Welch KD, Sabat M, Myers WH, Harman WD. Stereo-
and regioselective nucleophilic addition to dihapto-coordinated
pyridine complexes. Organometallics 2009;;28: 5682–5690.
26. Rudler H, Martín-Vaca B, Nicolas M, Audouin M, Vaissermann J. Formation and selective
trapping of 2,5-dihydropyridine and its isopropylidene derivative by tungsten(0) alkylidene
complexes. X-ray structure of the 5-isopropylidene-2,5-dihydropyridine adduct. Organometallics
1998;;17:361-366.
67
27. Moretto AF, Liebeskind LS. Stereo- and regiocontrolled construction of trisubstituted
piperidines using a TpMo(CO)2(Dihydropyridine) scaffold (Tp= hydridotrispyrazolylborate). J.
Org. Chem. 2000;;65:7445-7455.
28. Barr D, Snaith R, Mulvey, RE, Reed, D. Characterization of the bis(pyridine) complex of the
butylllithium-pyridine adduct, 2-Bun(C5H5N)Li·(C5H5N)2;; its decomposition to 2-butylpyridine via
a dihydropyridine. Polyhedron 1988;;7:665-668.
29. Clegg W, Dunbar L, Horsburgh L, Mulvey RE. Stoichiometric dependence of the long-
established reaction of butyllithium with pyridine: A hidden secondary reaction that produces a
pyridine adduct of a lithiodihydropyridine. Angew Chem Int Ed Engl. 1996;;35:753-755.
30. Armstrong DR, Harris CMM, Kennedy AR, Liggat JJ, McLellan R, Mulvey RE, Urquhart MDT,
Robertson SD. Developing Lithium Chemistry of 1,2-dihydropyridines: from kinetic intermediates
to isolable characterized compounds. Chem Eur J. 2015;; 21:14410-14420.
31. Chen Q, du Jourdin M, Knochel P. Transition-metal-free BF3‑mediated regioselective direct
alkylation and arylation of functionalized pyridines using Grignard or organozinc reagents. J Am
Chem Soc. 2013;;135:4958-4961.
32. Chen Q, León T, Knochel P. Transition-metal-free BF3-Mediated oxidative and non-oxidative
cross-coupling of pyridines. Angew Chem Int Ed. 2014;;53:8746-8750.
33. Mizumori T, Hata T, Urabe H. Alkylation of pyridines at their 4-positions with styrenes plus
yttrium reagent or benzyl Grignard reagents. Chem Eur J. 2015;;21:422-426.
34. Watson SC, Eastham JF. Colored indicators for simple direct titration of magnesium and
lithium reagents. J Organomet Chem. 1967;;9: 165-168.
35. Kaim W. Radical-forming electron-transfer reactions involving main-group organometallics.
Acc Chem Res. 1985;;18:160-166.
36. Kaim W. Electron Transfer to Complex Ligands. Radical anions and organomagnesium
radical complexes of 2,2’-bipyridines and 1,10-phenanthrolines. J Am Chem Soc.
1982;;104:3833-3837.
68
37. Ashby EC, Goel AB. Evidence for a single electron transfer mechanism in the reduction of
aromatic nitrogen heterocycles with main group metal hydrides and dihydropyridyl metal
complexes. Tetrahedron Lett. 1981;;22:4783-4786.
38. O’Hara F, Blackmond DG, Baran PS. Radical-based regioselective C−H functionalization of
electron-deficient heteroarenes: Scope, tunability, and predictability. J Am Chem Soc.
2013;;135:12122-12134.
39. Lichtenberg C, Spaniol TP, Okuda J. Reactivity of tris(allyl)aluminum toward pyridine:
coordination versus carbometalation. Organometallics. 2011;;30:4409-4417.
40. Hensen K, Lemke A, Stumpf T. Synthesis and structural characterization of (1,4-
dihydropyrid-1-yl)aluminum complexes. Inorg Chem. 1999;;38:4700-4704.
41. Knijnenburg Q, Smits JMM, Budzelaar PHM. Reaction of the diimine pyridine ligand with
aluminum alkyls: An unexpectedly complex reaction. Organometallics. 2006;;25:1036-1046.
42. Jochmann P, Dols TS, Spaniol TP, Perrin L, Maron L, Okuda J. Insertion of pyridine into the
calcium allyl bond: regioselective 1,4-dihydropyridine formation and C-H bond activation. Angew
Chem Int Ed. 2010;;49:7795-7798.
43. Hernán-Gómez A, Herd E, Uzelac M, Cadenbach T, Kennedy AR, Borilovic I, Aromí G, Hevia
E. Zincate-mediated arylation reactions of acridine: pre- and postarylation structural insights.
Organometallics. 2015;;34:2614-2623.
44. Diaconescu PL. Reactions of early transition metal-carbon bonds with N-heterocycles Curr
Org Chem. 2008;;12:1388-1405.
45. Johnson KRD, Hayes PG. Cyclometalative C–H bond activation in rare earth and actinide
metal complexes. Chem Soc Rev. 2013;;42:1947-1960.
46. Bianchini C, Meli A, Vizza F. Modelling the hydrodenitrogenation of aromatic N-heterocycles
in the homogeneous phase. Eur J Inorg Chem. 2001;;43-68.
47. Angelici RJ. An overview of modeling studies in HDS, HDN and HDO catalysis. Polyhedron.
1997;;16:3073-3088.
69
48. Neithamer DR. Párkányi L, Mitchell JF, Wolczanski PT. η2-(N,C)-pyridine and µ-η2(1,2):
η2(4,5)-benzene complexes of (silox)3Ta (silox = t-Bu3SiO-). J Am Chem Soc. 1998;;110:4421-
4423.
49. LaPointe RE, Wolczanski PT, Mitchell JF. Carbon monoxide cleavage by (silox)3Ta (silox =
t-Bu3SiO-). J Am Chem Soc. 1986;;108:6382-6384.
50. Kleckley TS, Bennett JL, Wolczanski PT, Lobkovsky EB. Pyridine C=N bond cleavage
mediated by (silox)3Nb (silox = t-Bu3SiO). J Am Chem Soc. 1997;;119:247-248.
51. Cordone R, Taube H. Pentaammineosmium(II)-η2-2,6-lutidine: An intermediate for C-H
activation. J Am Chem Soc. 1987;;109:8101-8102.
52. Harman WD. The activation of aromatic molecules with pentaammineosmium(II). Chem
Rev. 1997;;97:1953-1978.
53. Cordone R, Harman WD, Taube H. Carbon-hydrogen bond activation in novel η2-bound
cationic heterocycle complexes of pentaammineosmium(II). J Am Chem Soc. 1989;;111:2896-
2900.
54. Gray SD, Smith DP, Bruck MA, Wigley DE. Regioselective C-N bond cleavage in an η2(N,C)-
coordinated pyridine and an η1(N) → η2(N,C) bonding rearrangement in coordinated quinoline:
models for hydrodenitrogenation catalysis. J Am Chem Soc. 1992;;114:5462-5463.
55. Gray SD, Weller KJ, Bruck MA, Briggs PM, Wigley DE. Carbon-nitrogen bond cleavage in
an η2(N,C)-pyridine complex induced by intramolecular metal-to-ligand alkyl migration: models
for hydrodenitrogenation catalysis. J Am Chem Soc. 1995;;117:10678-10693.
56. Weller KJ, Filippov I, Briggs PM, Wigley DE. Pyridine degradation intermediates as models
for hydrodenitrogenation catalysis: Preparation and properties of a metallapyridine complex.
Organometallics. 1998;;17:322-329.
57. Bailey BC, Fan H, Huffman JC, Baik M-H, Mindiola DJ. Room temperature ring-opening
metathesis of pyridines by a transient Ti≡C linkage. J Am Chem Soc. 2006;;128:6798-6799.
58. Fout AR, Bailey BC, Tomaszewski J, Mindiola DJ. Cyclic denitrogenation of N-heterocycles
applying a homogeneous titanium reagent. J Am Chem Soc. 2007;;129:12640-12641.
70
59. Gillard RD, Lyons JR. Equilibria in complexes of heterocyclic ligands. J Chem Soc Chem
Commun. 1973;;585-586.
60. Gillard RD. An explanation for anomalies among complexes of N-heterocyclic ligands. Inorg
Chim Acta. 1974;;11:121-122.
61. Gillard RD. Equilibria in complexes of N-heterocyclic molecules. Part III (1, 2). An explanation
for classical anomalies among complexes of 1, 10-phenanthrolines and 2, 2‘-bipyridyls. Coord
Chem Rev. 1975;;16:67-94.
62. Nord G. The base hydrolysis of bis(2,2’-bipyridyl)platinum(II) perchlorate. Acta Chem Scand
A. 1975;;29:270-272.
63. Nord G. Some properties of 2,2′-bipyridine, 1,10-phenanthroline and their metal complexes.
Comments Inorg Chem. 1985;;4:193-212.
64. Constable EC. Nucleophilic attack upon coordinated heterocycles;; definitive evidence for the
enhanced electrophilicity of coordinated pyridines. Inorg Chim Acta. 1984;;82:53-57.
65. Constable EC, Housecroft CE. Ligand reactivity in coordination compounds;; A molecular
orbital investigation of the quaternisation-coordination analogy. Transition Met Chem.
1988;;13:19-21.
66. Tzalis D, Tor Y. The organic chemistry of coordination compounds: unprecedented
substitution reactions of functionalized polypyridine complexes. Angew Chem Int Ed Engl.
1997;;36:2666-2668.
67. Lay PA. Does coordination activate heterocycles toward nucleophilic attack? The importance
of π interactions between metal ion and ligand. Inorg Chem. 1984;;23:4775-4777.
68. McInnes CS, Clare BR, Redmond WR, Clark CR, Blackman AG. The nature of the
[Pt(bipy)2]2+ ion in aqueous alkaline solution a new look at an old problem. Dalton Trans.
2003;;2215-2218.
69. Zhang X-M, Tong M-L, Chen X-M. Hydroxylation of N-heterocycle ligands observed in two
unusual mixed-valence CuI/CuII complexes. Angew Chem Int Ed. 2002;;41:1029-1031.
70. Szpakolski KB, Latham K, Rix CJ, White JM, Moubaraki B, Murray KS. Synthetic and
structural studies on copper 1H-[1,10]-phenanthrolin-2-one coordination complexes: Isolation of
71
a novel intermediate during 1,10-phenanthroline hydroxylation. Chem Eur J. 2010;;16:1691-
1696.
71. Constable EC. Forty years on -Covalent hydration of transition metal complexes revisited.
Polyhedron. 2016;;103:295-306.
72. Hevia E, Pérez J, Riera L, Riera V. Reactive alkoxide complexes of groups 6 and 7 metals.
Organometallics. 2002;;21:1750-1752.
73. Hevia E, Pérez J, Riera L, Riera V, del Río I, García-Granda S, Miguel D. Insertion of
unsaturated organic electrophiles intyo molybdenum-akoxide and rhenium-alkoxide bonds of
neutral, stable carbonyl complexes. Chem. Eur. J. 2002;;8:4510-4521.
74. Morales D, Navarro Clemente ME, Pérez J, Riera L, Riera V, Miguel D. The combination of
organometallic Mo(η3-allyl)(CO)2(phen) fragments and aquo and hydroxo ligands: controlled
synthesis and structural characterization. Organometallics. 2002;; 21:4934-4938.
75. Gerbino DC, Hevia E, Morales D, Navarro Clemente ME, Pérez J, Riera L, Riera V, Miguel
D. A new reactivity pattern of low-valent transition metal hydroxo complexes: straightforward
synthesis of hydrosulfido complexes via reaction with carbon disulfide. Chem. Commun.
2003:328-329.
76. Cuesta L, Gerbino DC, Hevia E, Morales D, Navarro Clemente ME, Pérez J, Riera L, Riera
V, Miguel D, del Río, García-Granda S. Reactivity of molybdenum and rhenium hydroxo-
carbonyl complexes toward organic electrophiles. Chem. Eur. J. 2004;;10:1765-1777.
77. Hevia E, Pérez J, Riera V, Miguel D. New octahedral Re(I) tricarbonyl amido complexes.
Organometallics. 2002;;21:1966-1974.
78. Hevia E, Pérez J, Riera V, Miguel D. Different sites of insertion in the reaction of isocyanates
with [Re(N(R)Ar)(CO)3(bipy)] (R= H or Me): N-H vs. Re-N. Chem. Commun. 2002:1814-1815.
79. Morales D, Pérez J, Riera L, Riera V, Miguel D. Formation of a 1-Azaallenylidene ligand by
reaction of an amido complex with tetracyanoethylene. Inorg. Chem. 2002;;41:4111-4113.
80. Hevia E, Pérez J, Riera V, Miguel D. Reactivity of the amido complex
[Re(NHpTol)(CO)3(bipy)] toward neutral organic electrophiles. Organometallics. 2003;;22:257-
263.
72
81. Morales D, Pérez J, Riera L, Riera V, Miguel D, Mosquera MEG, García-Granda S.
Molybdenum amido complexes with single Mo-N bonds: synthesis, structure and reactivity.
Chem. Eur. J. 2003;;9:4132-4143.
82. Hevia E, Pérez J, Riera V, Miguel D. Insertion and cycloaddition reactivity of a transition-
metal N-metalloimine. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2002;;41:3858-3860.
83. Hevia E, Pérez J, Riera V, Miguel D, Campomanes, P, Menéndez MI, Sordo TL, García-
Granda S. Synthesis of β−lactams from a N-rhenaimine: effect of the transition metal on the
energetic profile of the Staudinger reaction. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2003;;125:3706-3707.
84. Cuesta L, Hevia E, Morales D, Pérez J, Riera V, Rodríguez E, Miguel D. Activation of a 1,10-
phenanthroline ligand on a rhenium tricarbonyl complex. Chem. Commun. 2005:116-117.
85. Methot JL, Roush WR. Nucleophilic phosphine organocatalysis. Adv Synth Catal.
2004;;346:1035-1050.
86. Cuesta L, Hevia E, Morales D, Pérez J, Riera V, Seitz M, Miguel D. Activation of ancillary
ligands in the reactions of DMAD with phosphide and alkylidenamido rhenium complexes.
Organometallics 2005;;24:1772-1775.
87. Adams H, Bailey NA, Blenkiron P, Morris MJ. Metallacycle formation through the linking of
an alkyne with phosphide and acetyl groups at an iron centre: X-ray structure of
[CpFe(CO)Ph2PCH(CO2Me)C(CO2Me)=C(Me)O] (Cp= η-C5H5). J Organomet Chem.
1993;;460:73-81.
88. Ashby MT, Enemark JH, Cycloaddition of alkenes and alkynes to CpFe(CO)2PR2 to give
(R)2PFeC(=O)C=C heterometallacycles. Organometallics. 1986;;6:1323-1327.
89. Serrano AL, Casado MA, Ciriano MA, de Bruin B, López JA, Tejel C. Nucleophilicity and
P−C bond formation reactions of a terminal phosphanido iridium complex. Inorg Chem.
2016;;55:828-839.
90. Huertos MA, Pérez J, Riera L. Pyridine ring opening at room temperature at a rhenium
tricarbonyl bipyridine complex. J Am Chem Soc. 2008;;130:5662-5663.
73
91. Ruiz J, Perandones BF. Base-promoted tautomerization of imidazole ligands to N-
heterocyclic carbenes and subsequent transmetalation reaction. J Am Chem Soc.
2007;;129:9298-9299.
92. Hilf C, Bosold F, Harms K, Lohrenz JCW, Marsch M, Schimeczek M, Boche G. Carbene
structure of stable acyl (formyl) anion equivalents. Chem Ber/Recueil 1996;;130:1201-1212.
93. Hilf C, Bosold F, Harms K, Marsch M, Boche G. The equilibrium between 2-lithium-
oxazole(thiazole, -imidazole) derivatives and their acyclic isomers -a structural investigation.
Chem Ber/Recueil 1996;;130:1213-1221.
94. Gade LH. Transition metal complexes with polydentate amido ligands: novel structural
building blocks and chemical reagents. J Organomet Chem. 2002;;661: 85-94.
95. Caulton KH. The influence of π-stabilized unsaturation and filled/filled repulsions in transition
metal chemistry. New J Chem. 1994;;18:225-241.
96. Arévalo R, Pérez J, Riera L. Intramolecular nucleophilic addition to the 2 position of
coordinated 2,2’-bipyridine by a deprotonated dimethyl sulfide ligand. Inorg Chem.
2013;;52:6785-6787.
97. Arévalo R, Pérez J, Riera L. Deprotonation of coordinated phosphanes in a rhenium
complex: C-C coupling with diimine coligands. Chem Eur J. 2015;;21:3546-3549.
98. Fehlhammer WP, Fritz M. Emergence of a CHN and cyano complex based organometallic
chemistry. Chem Rev. 1993;;93:1243-1280.
99. Dick GR, Woerly EM, Burke MD. A General Solution for the 2-Pyridyl Problem. Angew Chem
Int Ed. 2012;;51:2667 –2672
100. Sato S, Ishitani O. Photochemical reactions of fac-rhenium(I) tricarbonyl complexes and
their application for synthesis. Coord Chem Rev. 2015;;282-283:50-59 and references therein.
101. Gasser G, Leonidova A. Undersestimated potential of organometallic rhenium complexes
as anticancer agents. ACS Chem Biol. 2014;;9:2180-2193.
102. Espinal Viguri M, Huertos MA, Pérez J, Riera L, Ara I. Re-mediated C-C coupling of
pyridines and imidazoles. J Am Chem Soc. 2012;;134:20326-20329.
74
103. Espinal Viguri M, Pérez J, Riera L. C-C coupling of N-heterocycles at the fac-Re(CO)3
fragment: synthesis of pyridylimidazole and bipyridine ligands. Chem Eur J. 2014;;20:5732-5740.
104. Miller KL, Williams BN, Benitez D, Carver CT, Ogilby KR, Tkatchouk E, Goddard III WA,
Diaconescu PL. Dearomatization reactions of N-heterocycles mediated by group 3 complexes.
J Am Chem Soc. 2010;;132:342-355.
105 Carver CT, Benitez D, Miller KL, Williams BN, Tkatchouk E, Goddard III WA, Diaconescu
PL. Reactions of group III biheterocycyclic complexes. J Am Chem Soc. 2009;;131:10269-10278.
106. Huertos MA, Pérez J, Riera L, Menéndez-Velázquez A. From N-alkylimidazole ligands at a
rhenium center: ring opening or formation of NHC complexes. J Am Chem Soc. 2008;;130:13530-
13531.
107. Huertos MA, Pérez J, Riera L, Díaz J, López R. Effect of the nature of the substituent in N-
alkylimidazole ligands on the outcome of deprotonation: ring opening versus the formation of N-
heterocyclic carbene complexes. Chem Eur J. 2010;;16:8495-8507.
108. Carver CT, Diaconescu PL. Ring-opening reactions of aromatic N-heterocycles by
scandium and yttrium alkyl complexes. J Am Chem Soc. 2008;;130:7558-7559.
109. Grace ME, Loosemore MJ, Semmel ML, Pratt RF. Kinetics and mechanism of the
Bamberger cleavage of imidazole and of histidine derivatives by diethyl pyrocarbonate in
aqueous solution. J Am Chem Soc. 1980;;102:6784-6789.
110. Trofimov BA, Andriyankova LV, Nikitina LP, Belyaeva KV, Mal’kina AG, Sobenina LN,
Afonin AV, Ushakov IA. Stereoselective tandem ring opening of imidazoles with electron-
deficient acetylenes and water: Synthesis of functionalized (Z,Z)-1,4-diaza-2,5-dienes. Org Lett.
2013;;15:2322-2324.
111. He F, Ruhlmann L, Gisselbrech J-P, Choua S, Orio M, Wesolek M, Danopoulos AA,
Braunstein P. Dinuclear iridium and rhodium complexes with bridging arylimidazolide-N3,C2
ligands: synthetic, structural, reactivity, electrochemical and spectroscopic studies. Dalton
Trans. 2015;;44:17030-17044.
75
112. Brill M, Díaz J, Huertos MA, López R, Pérez J, Riera L. Imidazole to NHC rearrangements
at molybdenum centers: an experimental and theoretical study. Chem Eur J. 2011;;17:8584-
8595.
113. Cebollada A, Espinal Viguri M, Pérez J, Díaz J, López R, Riera L. Influence of the N-N
coligand: C-C coupling instead of formation of imidazole-2-yl complexes at Mo(η3-allyl)(CO)2
fragments. Theoretical and experimental studies. Inorg Chem. 2015;;54:2580-2590.
114. Espinal Viguri M, Huertos MA, Pérez J, Riera L. Imidazole-nitrile or imidazole-isonitrile C-
C coupling on rhenium tricarbonyl complexes. Chem Eur J. 2013;;19:12975-12977.
115. Hevia E, Pérez J, Riera V, Miguel D, Kassel S, Rheingold A. New synthetic routes to
cationic rhenium tricarbonyl bipyridine complexes with labile ligands. Inorg Chem.
2002;;41:4673-4679.
116. Lu E, Lewis W, Blake AJ, Liddle ST. The ketimide ligand is not just an inert spectator:
Heteroallene insertion reactivity of an actinide–ketimide linkage in a thorium carbene amide
ketimide complex. Angew Chem Int Ed. 2014;;53:9356-9359.
117. Huertos MA, Pérez J, Riera L. Double activation of an N-alkylimidazole. Chem Eur J.
2012;;18:9530-9533.
118. Gallo MM, Hamilton TP, Schaefer III HF. Vinylidene: the final chapter? J Am Chem Soc.
1990;;112:8714-8719.
119. Bruce MI. Organometallic chemistry of vinylidene and related unsaturated carbenes. Chem
Rev. 1991;;91:197-257.
120. Kunz D. Synthetic routes to N-heterocyclic carbene complexes: pyridine-carbene
tautomerizations. Angew Chem Int Ed. 2007;;46:3405-3408.
121. Dyson P, Hammick PLl. Experiments on the mechanism of decarboxylation. Part I.
Decomposition of quinaldinic and isoquinaldinic acids in the presence of compounds containing
carbonyl groups. J Chem Soc. 1937;;1724-1725.
122. Raczyńska ED, Kosińska W, Ośmialowski B, Gawinecki R. Tautomeric equilibria in relation
to pi-electron delocalization. Chem Rev. 2005;;105:3561-3612.
76
123. Lavorato D, Terlouw JK, Dargel TK, Koch W, McGibbon GA, Schwarz H. Observation of
the Hammick intermediate: reduction of the pyridine-2-ylid ion in the gas phase. J Am Chem
Soc. 1996;;118:11898-11904.
124. Alvarez E, Conejero S, Paneque M., Petronilho A, Poveda ML, Serrano O, Carmona E.
Iridium(III)-induced isomerization of 2-substituted pyridines to N-heterocyclic carbenes. J Am
Chem Soc. 2006;;128:13060-13061.
125. Esteruelas MA, Fernández-Álvarez FJ, Oñate E. Stabilization of NH tautomers of
quinolones by osmium and ruthenium. J Am Chem Soc. 2006;;128:13044-13045.
126. Buil ML, Esteruelas MA, Garcés K, Oliván M, Oñate, E. Understanding the formation of N-
H tautomers from a-substituted pyridines: tautomerization of 2-ethylpyridine promoted by
osmium. J Am Chem Soc. 2007;;129:10998-10999.
127. Álvarez E, Conejero S, Lara P, López JA, Paneque M, Petronilho A, Poveda ML, del Río
D, Serrano O, Carmona E. Rearrangement of pyridine to its 2-carbene tautomer mediated by
iridium. J Am Chem Soc. 2007;;129:14130-14131.
128. Hayton TW, Boncella JM, Scott BL, Abboud, KA, Mills, RC. Coupling of an aldehyde or
ketone to pyridine mediated by a tungsten imido complex. Inorg Chem. 2005;;44:9506-9517.
129. Wiedemann SH, Lewis JC, Ellman JA, Bergman RG. Experimental and computational
studies on the mechanism of N-heterocycle C-H activation by Rh(I). J Am Chem Soc.
2006;;128:2452-2462.
130. Lewis JC, Bergman RG, Ellman JA. Rh(I)-catalyzed alkylation of quinolones and pyridines
via C-H bond activation. J Am Chem Soc. 2007;;129:5332-5333.
131. Berman AM, Lewis JC, Bergman RG, Ellman JA. Rh(I)-catalyzed direct arylation of
pyridines and quinolones. J Am Chem Soc. 2008;;130:14926-14927.
132. Johnson DG, Lynam JM, Mistry NS, Slattery JM, Thatcher RJ, Whitwood AC. Ruthenium-
mediated C-H functionalization of pyridine: the role of vinylidene and pyridylidene ligands. J Am
Chem Soc. 2013;;135:2222-2234.
77
133. Conejero S, Lara P, Paneque M, Petronilho A, Poveda ML, Serrano O, Vattier F, Álvarez
E, Maya C, Salazar V, Carmona E. Monodentate, N-heterocyclic carbene-type coordination of
2,2’-bipyridine and 1,10-phenanthroline to iridium. Angew Chem Int Ed. 2008;;47:4380-4383.
134. Paneque M, Poveda ML, Vattier F, Álvarez E, Carmona E. Synthesis and structural
characterization of a binuclear iridium complex with bridging, bidentate N-heterocyclic carbene
coordination of 2,2’:6’,2’’-terpyridine. Chem Commun. 2009;;5561-5563.
135. Song G, Li Y, Chen S, Li X. Hydrogen bonding-assisted tautomerization of pyridine moieties
in the coordination sphere of an Ir(I) complex. Chem Commun. 2008;;3558-3560.
136. Song G, Su Y, Periana RA, Crabtree RH, Han K, Zhang H, Li X. Anion-exchange-triggered
1,3-shift of an NH proton to iridium in protic N-heterocyclic carbenes: hydrogen-bonding and ion-
pairing effects. Angew Chem Int Ed. 2010;;49:912-917.
137. Sini G, Eisenstein O, Crabtree H. Preferential C-binding versus N-binding in imidazole
depends on the metal fragment involved. Inorg Chem. 2002;;41:602-604.
138. Sundberg RJ, Bryan RF, Taylor Jr IF, Taube H. Nitrogen-bound and carbon-bound
imidazole complexes of ruthenium ammines. J Am Chem Soc. 1974;;96:381-392.
139. Tan KL, Bergman RG, Ellman JA. Intermediacy of an N-heterocyclic carbene complex in
the catalytic C-H activation of a substituted benzimidazole. J Am Chem Soc. 2002;;124:3202-
3203.
140. Miranda-Soto V, Grotjahn DB, DiPasquale AG, Rheingold AL. Imidazol-2-yl complexes of
Cp*Ir as bifunctional ambident reactants. J Am Chem Soc. 2008;;130:13200-13201.
141. Miranda-Soto V, Grotjahn DB, Cooksy AL, Golen JA, Moore CE, Rheingold AL. A labile
and catalytically active imidazole-2-yl fragment system. Angew Chem Int Ed. 2011;;50:631-635.
142. Araki K, Kuwata S, Ikariya T. Isolation and Intercoversion of protic N-heterocyclic carbene
and imidazolyl complexes: application to catalytic dehydrative condensation of N-(2-
pyridyl)benzimidazole and allyl alcohol. Organometallics 2008;;27:2176-2178.
143. He F, Braunstein P, Wesolek M, Danopoulos AA, Imine-functionalised protic NHC
complexes of Ir: direct formation by C-H activation. Chem Commun. 2015;;51:2814-2817.
78
144. Burling S, Mahon MF, Powell RE, Whittlesey MK, Williams JMJ. Ruthenium induced C-N
bond activation of an N-heterocyclic carbene: isolation of C- and N-bound tautomers. J Am
Chem Soc. 2006;;128:13702-13703.
145. Wang X, Chen H, Li X. Ir(III)-induced C-bound to N-bound tautomerization of a N-
heterocyclic carbene. Organometallics 2007;;26:4684-4687.
146. Wacker A, Pritzkow H, Siebert W. Borane-substituted imidazole-2-ylidenes: syntheses,
structures and reactivity. Eur J Inorg Chem. 1998:843-849.
147. Vagedes D, Kehr G, König D, Wedeking K, Fröhlich R, Erker G, Mück-Lichtenfeld C,
Grimme S. Formation of isomeric BAr3 adducts of 2-lithio-N-methylimidazole. Eur J Inorg Chem.
2002:2015-2021.
148. Kösterke T, Kösters J, Würthwein E-U, Mück-Lichtenfeld C, Schulte to Brinke C, Lahoz F,
Hahn FE. Synthesis of complexes containing an anionic NHC ligand with an unsubstituted ring
nitrogen atom. Chem Eur J. 2012;;18:14594-14598.
149. Huertos MA, Pérez J, Riera L, Díaz J, López R. From bis(N-alkylimidazole) to bis(NH-NHC)
in rhenium carbonyl complexes. Angew Chem Int Ed. 2010;;49:6409-6412.
150. Diaconescu PL. Reactions of aromatic N-heterocycles with d0Fn-metal alkyl complexes
supported by chelating diamide ligands. Acc Chem Res. 2010;;43:1352-1363.
151. Ruiz J, Perandones BF, Van der Maelen JF, García-Granda S. On the existence of an N-
metalated N-heterocyclic carbene: a theoretical study. Organometallics 2010;;29:4639-4642.
152. Hsieh C-H, Pulukkody R, Darensbourg MY. Dinitrosyl iron complex as a platform for metal-
bound imidazole to N-heterocyclic carbene conversion. Chem Commun. 2013;;49:9326-9328.
153. Chien SW, Yen SK, Hor TSA. N,S-Heterocyclic carbene complexes. Aust J Chem.
2010;;63:727-741.
154. Ruiz J, Perandones BF. Metal-induced tautomerization of oxazole and thiazole molecules
to heterocyclic carbenes. Chem Commun. 2009;;2741-2743.
155. Raubenheimer HG, Stander Y, Marais EK, Thompson C, Kruger GJ, Cronje S, Deetlefs M.
Group 6 carbene complexes derived form lithiated azoles and the crystal structure of a
molybdenum thiazolinylidene complex. J Organomet Chem.1999;;590:158-168.
79
156. Raubenheimer HG, Kruger GJ, Lombard AA, Linford L, Vijoen JC. Sulfur-containing metal
complexes. 12. Reactions of α-thio carbanions with carbene complexes of the type
[M(CO)5O(alkyl)Ar] and with the carbyne [(η5-MeC5H4)Mn(CO)2(CPh)][BCl4]. Organometallics
1985;;4:275-284.
157. Ikariya T, Masakatsu S. Topics in Organometallic Chemistry, Bifunctional Catalysis.
Springer: Berlin, Heidelberg 2011;; Vol.37.
158. Gunanathan C, Milstein D. Bond activation and catalysis by ruthenium pincer complexes.
Chem Rev. 2014;;114:12024-12087.
159. Zell T, Milstein D. Hydrogenation and dehydrogenation iron pincer catalysts capable of
metal-ligand cooperation by aromatization/dearomatization. Acc Chem Res. 2015;;48:1979-
1994.
160. van der Vlugt, JI, Reek JNH. Neutral tridentate PNP ligands and their hybrid analogues:
versatile non-innocent scaffolds for homogeneous catalysis. Angew Chem Int Ed. 2009;;48:8832-
8846.
161. Zhang J, Leitus G, Ben-David Y, Milstein D. Facile conversion of alcohols into esters and
dihydrogen catalyzed by new ruthenium complexes. J Am Chem Soc. 2005;;127:10840-10841.
162. Kohl SW, Weiner L, Schwartsburd L, Konstantinovski L, Shimon LJW, Ben-David Y, Iron
MA, Milstein D. Consecutive thermal H2 and light-induced O2 evolution from water promoted by
a metal complex. Science 2009;;324:74-77.
Keywords: dearomatization, C-C coupling, imidazole-2-yl ligand, nitrogen-heterocyclic
carbene, modular synthesis, nucleophilic attack to pyridine, dihydropyridine ligands, reactivity of
coordinated bipy and phen
Acknowledgements
Computational studies carried out by Dr. Ramón López (Universidad de Oviedo) and Dr. Jesús
Díaz (Universidad de Extremadura) have been instrumental to our incipient understanding of the
challenging mechanistic issues.
80
The authors gratefully acknowledge funding from Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad and
FEDER (grants CTQ2012-37379-C02-01 and CTQ2012-37379-C02-02, and FPI graduate
studentships to M.E.V. and M.A.H.) and Principado de Asturias (grant FC-15-GRUPIN14-103,
administered by FICYT) and Ministerio de Educación Cultura y Deporte (FPU graduate
studentship to R.A.).