Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    1/36

    !

    !"#$%&'( *+ ,-" .-'&'##'/"0

    !"#$%&% ()"$*

    12/'&2

    34 5647

    +,$, -., /012342 )56.789 :3; IDJHK

    ?ILGM69N;8"0#*/="/,92##"&&""-'0 '0 2 #",','*/ %8*$?-, *8'?'/2&&@ %"+*8" ,-" 7*$8, *+ A'80, B/0,2/(" *+ 12/'&2

    +*8 ,-" '00$2/(" *+ 2 C8', *+ D2/=2,*8@ '/E$/(,'*/ 2?2'/0, ,-" 8"0#*/="/,:

    F,2/,*/ G*$/?%"8?: 20 H'8"(,*8 *+ ,-" 5$8"2$ *+ 6/'D2& B/=$0,8@: 8"I$'8'/? -'D

    ,* '00$" 2 #"8D', +*8 ,-" &2/='/? *+ ,"/ &28?" (2,,&" 'D#*8,"= %@ ,-" #",','*/"8

    2/= +*8 ,-" 0&2$?-,"8 ,-"8"*+< >-" #",','*/"8 2,,2(J"= ,-" (*/0,',$,'*/2&',@ *+

    6(, 4*< KLMM: C-'(- 2, #8"0"/, #8*-'%',0 ,-" 'D#*8,2,'*/ *+ (2,,&" +8*D +*8"'?/

    (*$/,8'"0 '/,* ,-" .-'&'##'/" B0&2/=0-" ="D$88"8 C20 %20"= */ ,C*

    8"20*/0: /2D"&@: YLZ ,-2, '+ 6(, 4*< KLMM C"8" ="(&28"= $/(*/0,',$,'*/2& 2/=

    ;*'=: ,-" #",','*/"8 C*$&= /*, %" "/,',&"= ,* ,-" 8"&'"+ ="D2/="= %"(2$0" 6(,

    4*< K[MQ C*$&= 2$,*D2,'(2&&@ %"(*D" "++"(,';" 2/= C*$&= #8*-'%', ,-"

    8"0#*/="/, +8*D ?';'/? ,-" #"8D', #82@"= +*8\ 2/= YQZ ,-2, 6(, 4*< KLMM C20

    (*/0,',$,'*/2& 2/=: ,-"8"+*8": ;2&'=-" (*$8, 0$0,2'/"= ,-" ="D$88"8 2/= ,-" (*D#&2'/, C20 ='0D'00"= %@ 8"20*/*+ ,-" +2'&$8" *+ ,-" #",','*/"8 ,* +'&" 2/*,-"8 (*D#&2'/,< A8*D ,-2, *8="8 *+

    ='0D'002&: ,-" #",','*/"8 2##"2&"= ,* ,-'0 (*$8,-" 2##"&&"" (*/,"/=0 ,-2, ";"/ '+ 6(, 4*< KLMM %" ="(&28"= $/(*/0,',$,'*/2& %

    ,-" +2(, 2&&"?"= %@ ,-" #",','*/"8 '/ -'0 (*D#&2'/,: 0,'&& ,-" #",','*/"8 (2/ /*, %"

    2&&*C"= ,* 'D#*8, (2,,&" +8*D 6$0,82&'2 +*8 ,-" 8"20*/ ,-2,: C-'&" 6(, 4*< KLMM

    C"8" ="(&28"= $/(*/0,',$,'*/2&: 6(, 4*< K[MQ C*$&= 2$,*D2,'(2&&@ %"(*D"

    "++"(,';"< 6(, 4*< K[MQ 8"2=0 20 +*&&*C0S

    F37>BT4 L< F"(,'*/ 0";"/,""/ -$/=8"= 2/= 0'P,@9,C* *+ 6(, 4$D%"8"=

    >C"/,@90";"/ -$/=8"= 2/= "&";"/: J/*C/ 20 ,-" 6=D'/'0,82,';" 7*=":

    '0 -"8"%@ 2D"/="= ,* 8"2= 20 +*&&*C0S

    NF37< L]^Q< >*1-?1-? ") +-1@+(# 1@,"*.$; )*"@ )"*$1?- 2"'-.*1$

    1-." .3$ 931(1,,1-$ A#(+-;#< _ B, 0-2&& %" $/&2C+$& +*8 2/@

    #"80*/ *8 (*8#*82,'*/ ,* 'D#*8,: %8'/? *8 '/,8*=$(" &';" (2,,&"

    '/,* ,-" .-'&'##'/" B0&2/=0 +8*D 2/@ +*8"'?/ (*$/,8@< >-"

    H'8"(,*8 *+ 6?8'($&,$8" D2@: C',- ,-" 2##8*;2& *+ ,-" -"2= *+

    ,-" ="#28,D"/, +'80, -2=: 2$,-*8'`" ,-" 'D#*8,2,'*/: %8'/?'/?

    *8 '/,8*=$(,'*/ *+ ;28'*$0 (&200"0 *+ ,-*8*$?-%8"= (2,,&" +8*D

    +*8"'?/ (*$/,8'"0 +*8 %8""='/? ,-" 02D" ,* ,-" /2,';" (2,,&" *+

    ,-"0" B0&2/=0: 2/= 0$(- 20 D2@ %" /"("0028@ +*8 ,-"

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    2/36

    !

    !"#$%&'( *+ ,-" .-'&'##'/"0

    !"#$%&% ()"$*

    12/'&2

    34 5647

    +,$, -., /01233 456578 19: ;-+/4!4-: =5A6B .C ?DE78 >F78GFHB .C &GFDIG: GFA =)!% #,

    J%-+K)-: ?D7HGI .C (D8L .C &GFDIG:8"0#*/) 4-+%/%!: ?D7HGI .C (D8L .C &GFDIG:8"0#*/) $)@$>+"%K: !E,: Q.E 7D L H.R. #EB7DABF8B ABI #GE8DA.

    -GHD.FGID78G: 8"($88"/,"9

    :0;

    %/ *%!)$%$) @% ?>/>#>-4!:8"($88'>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>=

    +,$, -., /0P2NN 456578 19: ;->!*$4*)$: !"+4$

    T")*4 )??>(%: @%#4$*&%-* )? ()&&%$(% 4-@

    >-@"!*$U:8"0#*/*)$ +%-%$4/ GFA *S%

    >-!"/4$ *$%4!"$%$ )? *S% #S>/>##>-%!:8"0#*/1

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    3/36

    !

    !"#$%&$ ($%)* +%,-"*. !"/0 12 3-"". 1*&4& 52 60,,*,0. +%,-74* 82 9*,%0%:$. ;0$? 3$%$,-$ ($@"0:$,. 1,2 0%: +6 ?6 @&6 AB

    HNHO6P "#% 4%(/(/&-) *#+..%-1% (#% :+./0/(5 &' %Q%*2(/:% &$0%$) &' (#% R$%)/0%-(

    +:&,%0.5 /))2%0 /- :/$(2% &' M&33&-,%+.(# K*( @&6 GIO6 7-:&.:%0 /- *+)%) @&)6

    ABHDFF +-0 ABHIEG /) SQ%*2(/:% T$0%$ @&6 GH9 ,#/*# $%12.+(%) $%-(+.) '&$

    #&2)%) +-0 .&() '&$ $%)/0%-(/+. ;2/.0/-1)6 "#% 4%(/(/&-%$9 U6 K-(&-/& K$+-%(+9 /)

    2-0%$ 4$&)%*2(/&- /- (#% M&2$( &' =/$)( 7-)(+-*% &' V+-/.+ '&$ :/&.+(/&- &' (#%

    4$&:/)/&-) &' (#/) SQ%*2(/:% T$0%$9 +-0 4$+5) '&$ (#% /))2+-*% &' (#% ,$/( &'

    4$/;/(/&- (& (#% 2%$$%$& )%%X) + ,$/( &' &:%$-3%-( &' (#%

    ?%42;./* &' (#% R#/./44/-%) 02$/-1 (#% 4%$/&0 '$&3 U2.5 O9 OWFW (& U2-% CD9 OWED9

    +-0 '&$ &(#%$ 42$4&)%)6 "#% 4%(/(/&-%$ S2.&1/& ?&0$/12%\9 Y$69 +) + (+QB4+5%$9 +-

    %.%*(&$9 +-0 4$%)/0%-( &' (#% @+*/&-+./)(+ R+$(59 +44./%) '&$ + ,$/( &' 4$/;/(/&-

    (& $%)($+/- (#% "$%+)2$%$ &' (#% R#/./44/-%) '$&3 0/);2$)/-1 (#/) SQ%*2(/:%

    T$0%$6 K''%*(%0 /- *+)% @&6 ABCDEG /) SQ%*2(/:% T$0%$ @&6 HHG9 ,#/*#

    +44$&4$/+(%) RG9DDD9DDD (& 0%'$+5 (#% %Q4%-)%) /- *&--%*(/&- ,/(#9 +-0

    /-*/0%-(+. (&9 (#% #&.0 .21 &' (#% -+(/&-+. %.%*(/&-) (& ;% #%.0 /- @&:%3;%$9

    OWFW6 "#% 4%(/(/&-%$9 K-(&-/& [+$$%0&9 +) + */(/\%-9 (+QB4+5%$ +-0 :&(%$9 +)X)

    (#/) M&2$( (& 4$%:%-( ](#% $%)4&-0%-() '$&3 0/);2$)/-19 )4%-0/-1 &$ &(#%$,/)%

    0/)4&)/-1 &' (#+( +3&2-( &$ +-5 4+$( &' /(6]

    @&(,/(#)(+-0/-1 +..%1+(/&-) /- (#% 4%(/(/&-) +))+/./-1 (#% *&-)(/(2(/&-+..5 &' K*

    @&6 GIO9 (#% 4%(/(/&-%$) 0& -&( 4$%)) (#% 4&/-( /- (#%/$ &$+. +$123%-( +-0

    3%3&$+-0236 "#%5 $%)( (#%/$ *+)% *#/%'.5 &- (#% 4$&4&)/(/&- (#+( (#%

    S3%$1%-*5 R&,%$) K*( LM&33&-,%+.(# K*( @&6 GIOP #+) *%+)%0 (& #+:% +-5

    '&$*% +-0 %''%*(6 "#/) /) (#% ;+)/* 82%)(/&- ,% #+:% $%'%$$%0 (&9 +-0 /( /) (& (#/)

    82%)(/&- (#+( ,% ,/.. 4$%)%-(.5 +00$%)) &2$)%.:%) +-0 0%:&(% 1$%+(%$ +((%-(/&-6

    =&$ (#% 42$4&)% &' (#/) 0%*/)/&-9 &-.59 (#% *&-)(/(2(/&-+./(5 &' K*( @&6 GIO ,/.. ;

    (+X%- '&$ 1$+-(%09 +-0 +-5 0/*(23 &$ )(+(%3%-( #%$%/- ,#/*# 3+5 +44%+$

    *&-($+$5 (& (#+( #54&(#%)/) )#&2.0 ;% 2-0%$)(&&0 +) #+:/-1 ;%%- 3+0% 3%$%.5/- '2$(#%$+-*% &' (#% 3+/- (#%)/)6

    K*( @&6 GIO /- '2.. /) +) '&..&,)^

    K@ KM" _SMAK?7@> K Y"K"S T= "T"KA SVS?>S@M` KY K ?SYaA" T

    bK? 7@cTAc7@> "dS Rd7A7RR7@SY K@_ Ka"dT?7e7@> "dS

    R?SY7_S@" "T R?TVaA>K"S ?aASY K@_ ?S>aAK"7T@Y "T VSS"

    YaMd SVS?>S@M`6

    [% /( %-+*(%0 ;5 (#% @+(/&-+. K))%3;.5 &' (#% R#/./44/-%)^

    YSM"7T@ O6 "#% %Q/)(%-*% &' ,+$ ;%(,%%- (#% a-/(%0 Y(+(%) +-0 &(#%$

    *&2-($/%) &' S2$&4% +-0 K)/+9 ,#/*# /-:&.:%) (#% R#/./44/-%)9 3+X%) /(

    -%*%))+$5 (& /-:%)( (#% R$%)/0%-( ,/(# %Q($+&$0/-+$5 4&,%$) /- &$0%$ (

    3%%( (#% $%)2.(/-1 %3%$1%-*56

    ]YSM6 H6 R2$)2+-( (& (#% 4$&:/)/&-) &' K$(/*.% c79 )%*(/&- HG9 &' (#%

    M&-)(/(2(/&-9 (#% R$%)/0%-( /) #%$%;5 +2(#&$/\%09 02$/-1 (#% %Q/)(%-*% &

    (#% %3%$1%-*59 (& 4$&32.1+(% )2*# $2.%) +-0 $%12.+(/&-) +) #% 3+5

    0%%3 -%*%))+$5 (& *+$$5 &2( (#% -+(/&-+. 4&./*5 0%*.+$%0 /- )%*(/&- O

    #%$%&'6 K**&$0/-1.59 #% /)9 +3&-1 &(#%$ (#/-1)9 %34&,%$%0 L0P (&

    ($+-)'%$ (#% )%+( &' (#% >&:%$-3%-( &$ +-5 &' /() )2;0/:/)/&-)9 ;$+-*#%

    0%4+$(3%-()9 &''/*%)9 +1%-*/%) &$ /-)($23%-(+./(/%)f L@P (& $%&$1+-/\%(#% >&:%$-3%-( &' (#% M&33&-,%+.(# /-*.20/-1 (#% 0%(%$3/-+(/&- &'

    (#% &$0%$ &' 4$%*%0%-*% &' (#% #%+0) &' (#% SQ%*2(/:% _%4+$(3%-(f L)P

    (& *$%+(% -%, )2;0/:/)/&-)9 ;$+-*#%)9 0%4+$(3%-()9 +1%-*/%) &$

    /-)($23%-(+./(/%) &' 1&:%$-3%-( +-0 (& +;&./)# +-5 &' (#&)% +.$%+05

    %Q/)(/-1f L:P (& *&-(/-2% /- '&$*% .+,) +-0 +44$&4$/+(/&-) ,#/*# ,&2.0

    .+4)% &$ &(#%$,/)% ;%*&3% /-&4%$+(/:%9 +-0 (& 3&0/'5 &$ )2)4%-0 (#%

    &4%$+(/&- &$ +44./*+(/&- &' (#&)% &' +- +03/-/)($+(/:% *#+$+*(%$f L*P (&

    /34&)% -%, (+Q%) &$ (& /-*$%+)%9 $%02*%9 )2)4%-0 &$ +;&./)# (#&)% /-

    %Q/)(%-*%f L#P (& $+/)% '2-0) (#$&21# (#% /))2+-*% &' ;&-0) &$ &(#%$,/)

    +-0 (& +2(#&$/\% (#% %Q4%-0/(2$% &' (#% 4$&*%%0) (#%$%&'f L>P (&

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    4/36

    !

    !"#$%&'() #$) +!#'%+!,- .&%/'+0'!,- 0'#1 %& 2"+'0'.!, 3%/)&+2)+#4 #%

    '+0"& '+ %/)&5&!6#4 6%& ."&.%4)4 #$!# $) 2!1 !..&%/)7 8!9 #% 5)0,!&) #$)

    4"4.)+4'%+ %6 #$) 0%,,)0#'%+ %6 0&)5'#4 %& #$) .!12)+# %6 5):#47 !+5 8 "9

    #% );)&0'4) 4"0$ %#$)& .%

    ?@A> E> C$'4 F0# 4$!,, #!G) )66)0# ".%+ '#4 !..&%/!, !+5 #$) &",)4 !+5

    &)3",!#'%+4 .&%2",3!#)5 $)&)"+5)& 4$!,, :) '+ 6%&0) !+5 )66)0# "+#', #$)

    A%+3&)44 %6 #$) D$','..'+)4 4$!,, %#$)&

    ?)0#'%+ HI %6 F'0,) JK %6 #$) A%+4#'#"#'%+ .&%/'5)4L

    K+ #'2) %6

    A%22%+ IOP 5%)4 +%# '+ #)&2 6'; #$) 5"&!#'%+ %6 '#4

    )66)0#'/)+)44> C$) '+#)+#'%+ %6 #$) F0# $!4 #% :) 4%"3$# 6%& '+ '#4 +!#"&)- #$)

    %:M)0# #% :) !00%2.,'4$- #$) ."&.%4) #% :) 4":4)&/)5- !+5 '#4 &),!#'%+ #% #$)

    A%+4#'#"#'%+> C$) 0%+4)Q")+0)4 %6 #$) /!&'%"4 0%+4#&"0#'%+4 %66)&)5 R) #)4# ! &",) :1 '#4 &)4",#4>

    F'0,) JK %6 #$) A%+4#'#"#'%+ .&%/'5)4 #$!# !+1 ,!< .!44)5 :1 /'") #$)&)%6

    4$%",5 :) S6%& ! ,'2'#)5 .)&'%5>S ST'2'#)5S $!4 :))+ 5)6'+)5 #% 2)!+ S&)4#&'0#)57

    :%"+5)57 .&)40&':)57 0%+6'+)5 - IIV7 W,!0GX4 T!- PPHY>9 C$) S 8Z'&4# C&"4# [%'+# ?#%0G

    T!+5 W!+G %6 A$'0!3% #$%F5%,.$ D> F&.- )# !,>- PHY F> T> \>- VBO- VB]>9>

    K# '4 #% :) .&)4"2)5 #$!# A%22%+ IOP

    ,'2'#!#'%+ '+ /') C$) %..%4'#) #$)%&1

    #$) A%+3&)44 2'3$# +%# :) !:,) #% %/)&&'5) #$) /)#%> Z"$)&2%&)- #$'4

    .%

    #)&2'+!#'%+ '+ #$) 4!2)

    '+0'5)+#4 %6 #$) 5),)3!#'%+> C$)&) &)2!'+ '+ 6%&0)- 4'+0)- '+ #$!# 0!4)- #$) D&)4'5)+# 0%",5 +%# %+,1 2!G) +)< &",)

    !+5 &)3",!#'%+4 :"# $) 0%",5 &)4#%&) #$) %+)4 !,&)!51 !++",,)5 :1 #$)

    ,)3'4,!#"&)>

    d%&) !+%2!,%"4 #$!+ #$) );)&0'4) %6 ,)3'4,!#'/) 6"+0#'%+ :1 #$) @;)0"#'/)

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    5/36

    !

    !"#$%&'' )*' +# '&''+"# *#, -& %&.+.&, */0&% &*12 *,3"4%#5 02& *#"5*78

    )"47, #"0 -& 7+5+0&,9 !"#$%&'' -8 * 0)":02+%, ."0& 1"47, %&;&*7 &2+' +' #"0 * /*#0*'0+1 *;;%&2'+"#? +# 0)" +#'0*#1&'

    +0 5*0&%+*7+@&,9 A# +%& $"", /*+026 *#, +#';+%&, "#78 -8 02& -&'0 +#0&%&'0' "/

    02& 1"4#0%8 *' 02&8 '*) 02&56 * /"%5&% =%&'+, ;%"547$*0&, *# &2&

    '&10+"# ,+, #"0 '*8 &*12 5&&0+#$6 )2+12 +0 1"47, .&%8 )&77 2*.& '*+, +/ 02*0 2*,

    -& 02& +#0+"#9 A/ 02& E*0+"#*7 D''&5-78 ,+, #"0 02+#M 02*0 02& %&;"%0 +#

    '&10+"# K )*' 0" -& 02& /+%'0 *#, 7*'0 !"#$%&'' D10 E"9 FGH )"47, 7*;'&,6 )2*0

    %&*'"# 1"47, 02&%& -& /"% +0' /*+74%& 0" ;%".+,& +# *;;%";%+*0& *#, 17&*% 0&%5'

    /"% 02& /+7+#$ "/ '4-'&N4 %&;"%0'O J412 %&;"%0'6 +/ 02& =%&'+, )*' &"$&02&% 02&8 ,"0& 02*0 * #&) 7&$+'7*0+"# )*' #&1&''*%8 0"

    M&&; *7+.& U#"0 0" %&;&*7V 02& 7*) */0&% 02& &

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    6/36

    !

    !" $%&$'% ()*'*+ )* !" ,-!*+ .!// "&, 0' 1'"!'1 ,-' (&2%,* )* ,-'!% (&"*,!,2,!&")/

    $%'%&3),!4' )"1 12,56 7" *& 8)% )* !, !* !"*!"2),'1 ,-), ,-' 9-!'8 :;'(2,!4' -)* ,-'

    ';(/2*!4' )2,-&%!,5 ,& *)5 ,-), .)% "&, '"1'1+ )"1

    S'%' "&, ,-!* ,-' ()*'+ ,-'%' .&2/1 )%!*' ,-' (2%!&2* *$'(,)(/'+ )/%')15 $)!",'1+

    )"1 ')*!/5 8&%'*''"+ &8 ,-' Q'3!*/),2%' )

    /'3!*/),!4' 0%)"(- &8 '")(,!"3 /).* 0''" *2%%'"1'%'1 ,& )"&,-'% 1'$)%,%'*!1'", *-&2/1 %',)!" -!* ';,%)&%1!")%5 $&.'%* )* /&"3 )*,2%-!/!$$!"'*6

    W$&" ,-' 8&%'3&!"3 (&"*!1'%),!&"*+ ,-' $',!,!&"* .!// 0' 3%)",'16 7" &%1'% ,&

    )4&!1 )"5 $&**!0/' 1!*%2$,!&" )"1 !",'%%2$,!&" !" ,-' "&%

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    7/36

    !

    !"#$%$&" (#)*)+*,

    -(./01 !" $"% "#$"%&&'$()

    * +(&,, -'./ ./, #0'$'#$ 0&,0+&,1 23 4&5 6%7.'", 8%+7#$9 ,:",0. #$ ./, 0#'$.7

    /,&,%$1,& 1'7"%77,15

    * 2,;', ./, M##& ./, H+.'#$+; G77,=2;3 .# +".5 8/'7 -+7 ./, #$;3 &,+7#$ +$1

    N%7.'>'"+.'#$ >#& ./, .#.+; &,;'$K%'7/=,$. #> ;,('7;+.' O:,"%.'#&,9 ./, '$+2';'.3 #> D#$(&,77 .# +". -+7 ./, 7#%; #> ./, ;+-9 +$1 ./,

    =#=,$. 7%"/ '$+2';'.3 ",+7,19 ./, .#.+; ,=,&(,$"3 +;7# ",+7,1 +$1 ./, ;+-

    ;'Q,-'7, ",+7,1 .# ./, ?/';'00'$,7

    "#$'"+.'#$ #> ./,7, ,:,"%.'3'$( ./,=9 #./,& '=0#&.+$. "'&"%=7.+$",7

    7/#%;1 2, '$K%'&,1 '$.#9 +7 >#& '$7.+$",9 -/,./,& #& $#. ./,3 /+>'",&7X +".7 +$1 "#$.&+7. #> 0+&.',7 +".'$( '$

    (##1 >+'./X ,."5 *. '7 =3 #0'$'#$ ./+. ,+"/ ,:,"%.' $,",77+&3 +$1 0#77'2;,9 2,>#&,

    $%;;'>3'$( '.9 0&,"+%.'#$+&3 =,+7%&,7 7/#%;1 2, .+Q,$ .# +#&,(#'$( 0#7'.'#$ #> '$1''"

    "+7,79 7/+;; (# '$.# + 2&',> 1'7"%77'#$ #> ./, ,:,"%.' +$#./,& ,=,&(,$"3 -/'"/

    -#%;1 2, '$,9 23 &,+7#$ #> ;+"Q #> +00&'+.'#$9 (# 0&,7,& + D#$7.'.%.'#$5 *$ 7%"/ ,:.&,=, "+7,79 +7 "+$ "#=,

    >= ./, 0&,7,$. 7'.%+.'#$9 '. -#%;1 2, ./, /,'(/. #> N%1'"'+; '=0&,"'7'#$ .#

    0&,7,&= #> ./, "#$7.'.%.'#$9 +$1 +. ./, 7+=, .'=, 0,&='. ./,

    1'7&%0.'#$ +$1 ",77+.'#$ #> ./, (#'&=;3 ,7.+2;'7/,15 8/%79 '$ ./, &,=,13 #> +$ ,#%$1,1 %0#$ >,+&9 >,+

    ./+. D#$(&,77 -';; +(+'$ >+'; .# +". #$ ./, =+..,& #> +00&'+.'#$9 +$1 '. =+3 2,

    +77,&.,1 ./+. ./, =,=2,&7 #> ./, D#$(&,77 +&, 0&,7%=,1 .# 2, +7 0+.&'#.'" +7

    ./, =,=2,&7 #> ./'7 D#%&.9 '> $#. =#&,9 +$1 ./+.9 ./,&,>#&,9 -, =+3 &,7. +77%&,

    ./+. ./,3 -';; $#. >+'; .# >%;>';; ./,'& 1%.35 * +1='. ./'7 .# 2, .&%,9 +$1 +""#&1'$(;3

    * +7Q -/+. '7 ./,$ ./, /%&&3 +$1 $,",77'.3 >#& $%;;'>3'$( ./, ,:,"%.''$1 $# &,+7#$

    +(+'$7. ./'7 7%((,7.'#$ ,:",0.9 0,&/+079 + 1,7'&, .# +77,&. N%1'"'+; 7%0&,=+"3 '$

    + "+7, -/,&, N%1'"'+; 7.+.,=+$7/'0 '7 =#&, $,",77+&35

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    8/36

    !

    !" $% &'%( ")*+ ",&" ",+ -(%%$.$'$"/ ",&" 0(12)+%% 3$'' &2&$1 4&$' "( -)(5$6+ 4*16%

    4() ",+ (-+)&"$(1 (4 ",+ 2(5+)17+1" $% & )+7("+ -(%%$.$'$"/8 9*" ",+)+ $% 1( ,&)7

    $1 -)(5$6$12 4() &'' ",+ -(%%$.$'$"$+%: .(", 1+&) &16 )+7("+8 !4 ",&" )+7("+

    -(%%$.$'$"/ 1+5+) ;(7+%: 3+'' &16 2((6: 1(",$12 $% '(%" &16 ",+ %$"*&"$(1 $% %&5+68

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    9/36

    !

    !"#$%#& () *#$*+,$- .$"%/*$,*0/.1 !-#$"-) 2#$,/,3 %0$% *4!0 #2#"3#,!/#* ,+%

    +,-) $"# ,+% %+%$- (4% $"# ,+% %0# "#*4-% +5 6$"7

    85 %0# #2#"3#,!) /*1 $* $&2/%%#& () %0# 9+,3"#**1 ,+% %+%$- $,&1 $* $&2/%%#& ()

    %0# :"#*/,%1 ,+% %0# "#*4-% +5 %0# 6$"1 9+22+,6#$-%0 ;!% ? 0$* -+*% /%*

    ($*/* $,& !$,,+% -#3$--) 3/@# "/*# %+ %0# #A#!4%/@# +""* 0#"#/, /,@+-@#&7

    8,#&1 /% /* ,+% ."#%#,& %0$% *$/& +""* $"# /,%#,& %+ 2##% $,) #2#"3#,!)

    3"+6/,3 +4% +5 %0# -$*% 6$"7 B$!C +5 $ (4&3#%1 $, $.."+."/$%/+, 5+" %0# #-#!%/+,*1

    +" $, /2.+"% !+,%"+- -$61 0$* (##, ("+430% $(+4% () %0# /,$!%/+, +5 %0#9+,3"#** 4,$55#!%#& () %0# -$*% 6$"1 $,& *4!0 #2#"3#,!)1 /5 /% 2$) (# !$--#& *+1

    /* ,+% +5 %0# C/,& !+,%#2.-$%#& /, 9+22+,6#$-%0 ;!% ?7

    D0# 3+@#",2#,% 0$* 5+" 5+4" )#$"* */,!# -/(#"$%/+, (##, ,+"2$--) 54,!%/+,/,3E

    #-#!%/+, 0$& (##, "#34-$"-) 0#-&E $ ,$%/+,$- !#,*4* 0$& (##, %$C#,E 9+,3"#**

    0$& 0#-& "#34-$" $,& *.#!/$- *#**/+,E F.#+.-# %"$@#- 5"##-) 2+*% #@#")60#"# $,&

    2+"# G4/!C-)1 () -$,&1 *#$ $,& $/"1 %+ $, #A%#,% %0$% 6$* ,+% 0/%0#"%+ #,H+)#&1F

    $,& F(4*/,#** /* 2+"# ("/*C %0$, #@#"1 3++&* $"# .-#,%/54-1 +4" .#+.-# #@#, /,

    %0# "#2+%#*% !+224,/%/#* $,& ($""/+* +5 %0# !+4,%") $"# (#%%#" &"#**#&1 %0#/"

    &/#% 0$* (##, /22#,*#-) /2."+@#&1 $,& %0#) -++C 2+"# 0#$-%0) %0$, %0#) #@#"

    &/&F I:"#*/,%J* 5/5%0 2+,%0-) "$&/+ !0$%1 K$"!0 ?L1 ?MNMOE $,& %0# *.+"$&/!

    ."#&$%/+,* +5 %0# +4%-$6* /, /*+-$%#& $"#$* +5 %0# !+4,%") $"# (4% %0# -$*%.$"+A)*2* +5 $ &)/,3 2+@#2#,% I:"#*/,%J* P%$%#Q+5Q%0#Q1 ?MN_7O

    I"O %+ "#+"3$,/U# %0# [+@#",2#,% +5 %0# 9+22+,6#$-%0 /,!-4&/,3 %0#

    %#"2/,$%/+, +5 %0# +"" +5 ."#!#,!# +5 %0# 0#$&* +5 %0# `A#!4%/@#

    a#.$"%2#,%*W

    ]#.4(-/! ;!%

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    10/36

    !

    !"#$%&' )$#*%+$ "! ,-$ .$/012%+ "! ,-$ 3-%2%//%'$)4 56//#"*$78 902: ;8

    ?4@

    5!@ ," +"',%'0$ %' !"#+$ 2AB) A'7 A//#"/#%A,%"') B-%+- B"027 2A/)$ "#

    ",-$#B%)$ 1$+"C$ %'"/$#A,%*$8 A'7 ," C"7%!: "# )0)/$'7 ,-$ "/$#A,%"' "#

    A//2%+A,%"' "! ,-")$ "! A' A7C%'%),#A,%*$ +-A#A+,$#D

    E"CC"'B$A2,- 6+, F"4 GH= I

    6' 6+, A//#"/#%A,%'& ,-$ )0C "! !%*$ C%22%"' /$)") ," $'A12$ ,-$

    'A,%"'A2 -"0)%'& +"CC%))%"' ," #$)0C$ %,) !0'+,%"')J 56//#"*$78

    F"*$C1$# M8 A//#"*$78 902: M?8 S4

    5&@ ," $L$#+%)$ )0+- ",-$# /"B$#) A) -$ CA: 7$$C '$+$))A#: ," $'A12$ ,-$

    \"*$#'C$', ," !02!%22 %,) #$)/"')%1%2%,%$) A'7 ," CA%',A%' A'7 $'!"#+$ %,)

    A0,-"#%,:4

    ]-$ /"B$#) %'+207$7 %' ,-%) )017%*%)%"' 5%@ A#$ "! +"0#)$ +"*$#$7 1: -0'7#$7)

    "! ",-$# A+,) A//#"*$7 1: ,-$ E"'$)) B-%+-8 %, +A''", 1$ 7$'%$78 A22 ,$'7 ,"

    J$'A12$ ,-$ \"*$#'C$', ," !02!%22 %,) #$)/"')%1%2%,%$) A'7 ," CA%',A%' A'7

    $'!"#+$ %,) A0,-"#%,:4J ^"#$"*$#8 ,-$ B%,-7#ABA2 "! ,-$ $A,$# A'7 C"#$

    %C/"#,A', /"B$#) CA: 1$ /#$)0C$7 ," -A*$ +A##%$7 ,-$ A++$))"#: A'7 2$))

    %C/"#,A', /"B$#)4

    ]-$#$ %) '" C$#%, %' ,-$ +"',$',%"' ,-A, E"CC"'B$A2,- 6+, F"4 ?G< BA)

    $'A+,$7 1: *%#,0$ "! ,-$ BA# /"B$#) "! ,-$ E"'$))4 6) ,-$ 6+, %,)$2! $L/#$))2:

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    11/36

    !"

    !"#"$!% '"! (#!'! '! !$)"'*+ ,- *. /0"')1$ 23 *. "4$ 5*+!"'"6"'*+ 74')4 8$0$19

    #6"4*0':$! ;$1$*7$0@ 3" 86!" ($ (*0+$ '+ 8'+; "4#" !#'; !$)"'*+

    ,- '! >$)61'#0 "* *60 5*+!"'"6"'*+% 7'"4 "4$ 0$!61" "4#" "4$ ;$)'!'*+! *. "4$

    D6>0$8$ 5*60" *. "4$ E+'"$; D"#"$! )'"$; *+ ($4#1. *. "4$ 0$!>*+;$+"!%

    $C>*6+;'+< "4$ "4$*09 "4#" "4$ $C$0)'!$ (9 "4$ ?0$!';$+" *. 4'! 7#0 >*7$0!'+'*+ *. "4$ E+'"$; D"#"$! D6>0$8$ 5*60" 7#! 70'""$+ (9 K0@

    L6!"')$ M0#+N.60"$0% )#++*" #>>19% .*0 "4$ .60"4$0 0$#!*+ "4#" '" 8$0$19 '+=*1=$;

    "4$ >*7$0 *. ;$>*0"#"'*+ 74')4% $=$+ '+ *60 O60'!;')"'*+% '! 0$)**7$0 *. "4$ ?0$!';$+" '! !$>#0#"$19

    )*=$0$; (9 !$)"'*+ HQ% >#0#4 R,S% *. /0"')1$ 233% #+; "4#" *. "4$ 5*+#!!#0'+)'>1$! *. 1#7 '+=*1=$;% #+; "4$ .#)" "4#" +*"

    *+19 "4$ .*0)$ #+; "4$ $..$)" *. # 1#7 R5*88*+7$#1"4 /)" U*@ -VHS (6" #1!* "4$

    1$>*0" *. "4$ !#8$@

    A4$0$ '! # )1#'8 8#;$ #(*6" 1#)N *. >$0!*+#1'"9 *. !*8$ *. "4$ >#0"'$!^

    >$"'"'*+$0! >#0"')61#019% "4$ >$"'"'*+$0! '+ ]@ _@ U*!@ G^JQTY #+; G^JQT-@ K6)4

    )*61; ($ !#'; .*0 #+; #*0"#+" `6$!"'*+ *. "4$ 1$0*861#1 74')4 8#;$ "4$ ;$1$6(1') /)

    U*@ --% #+; \*6!$ a'11 U*@ FVI *+ *+$ !';$ #+; PC$)6"'=$ X0;$0 U*@ -, *+ "4$

    *"4$0@ A4#" 7#! "4$ 0$#!*+ 749 ?0$!';$+" _*C#! =$"*$; \*6!$ a'11 U*@ FVI%

    ($1'$='+< '+ 1#'+$; (9 4'8 '+ 4'! )*886+')#"'*+ "* "4$ \*6!$ *.

    _$>0$!$+"#"'=$! *. L6+$ ,H% HFYV% !$""'+< .*0"4 4'! ='$7! *+ "4$ ('11@ A4$

    ?0$!';$+" 8#9 +*" #+; )*61; +*" !6(!"'"6"$ 4'! *>'+'*+ 4*7$=$0 $C)$11$+" *0

    !6>$0'*0 .*0 "4#" *. "4$ 1$0$!!$; '"! *>'+'*+ #+; ;$!'0$ *+ "4$ 8#""$0@

    b'"4 0$!>$)" "* PC$)6"'=$ X0;$0 U*@ HF,% '" 7'11 ($ 0$8$8($0$; "4#" 5*+#!!$; 5*88*+7$#1"4 /)" U*@ V,I% #>>0*=$; *+ L619 ,% HFY-% #6"4*0':'+< "4$

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    12/36

    !!

    !"#$%'( (* "#+,-.(#/ 0,"(.%-/ 0*'("*-/ .'& 1"*2%3%( (2# #41*"(.(%*' *5 0#"(.%'

    1"*&,0($/ 6#"02.'&%$# .'& 6.(#"%.-$7 8'" $.%& .,(2*"%(9 (2# !"#$%'( %$$,#&

    :4#0,(%;# &.(#& ?,-9 @A/ @BCD/ -.(#" .6#'&%'+ $#0(%*' E *5 $.%&

    :4#0,(%;#

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    13/36

    !"

    !" !$% &'$(!)*"+ ! ,%!%' -. %-%!( '/')+'"$0 !, ! )',1(% -.

    2!) *"3-(3*"+ %4' 54*(*55*"', !"& !1%4-)*6*"+ %4'

    5)',*&'"% %- 5)-/1(+!%' )1(', !"& )'+1(!%*-", %- /''%

    ,1$4 '/')+'"$07

    !" $% "&'(%") *+ %," -'%$.&'/ 011"2*/+ .3 %," 4,$/$55$&"16

    ,'$%*-" 87 %9: :;:?@: AB CDE F:>C::? >9: 1?:G ,>D>:= D?G A>9:E

    @AH?>E >A >9: IEAKH>9: 5E:= 9AE=V T(U >A @E:D>: ?:C =HFG D?G >A DFAL9A=: DLE:DGO :;

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    14/36

    !"

    !"#$ &' (')$ *+&, &,$ )-'"#$./ "-'01,& !"'0& "2 !34 !-+/+31 5-'. &,$

    $.$-1$3(26 )-'"#$./ *,+(, -$70+-$ 0-1$3& !34 +..$4+!&$ !(&+'38 9$-&!+3#26

    '3$ .!3 (!3 !(& .'-$ 70+(:#2 !34 $;)$4+&+'0/#2 &,!3 !"'0& '3$ ,034-$4

    .$."$-/ '5 &,$

    4$&$-.+3$4 "2 ,+. !34 &' )-$/(-+"$ !34 )-'.0#1!&$ -$10#!&+'3/ ,$

    .!2 4$$. $//$3&+!# &' (!--2 '0& &,$ )0-)'/$/ '5 &,$ F(&G

    X#Y 9'..'3*$!#&, F(& O'8 LK[ 4$(#!-+31 ! /&!&$ '5 3!&+'3!# $.$-1$3(

    40$ &' ! /&!&$ '5 *!- !.'31 /$=$-!# 3!&+'3/ !34 !/ ! .$!/0-$ &'

    )-$=$3& /(!-(+&26 .'3')'#+B!&+'36 ,'!-4+316 +3@0-+'0/ /)$(0#!&+'3/6

    )-'5+&$$-+316 $&(8 !55$(&+31 &,$ /0))#26 4+/&-+"0&+'3 .'=$.$3& '5 5''4/6

    (#'&,+316 50$#6 "0+#4+31 .!&$-+!#/6 !1-+(0#&0-!# $70+)&.$3&/ $&(8

    !0&,'-+B$4 &,$ I-$/+4$3& &' )0-(,!/$ !32 '5 &,$ !-&+(#$/ '- ('..'4+&+$

    !=!+#!"#$ 5'- /&'-!1$6 5'- -$A/!#$ '- 4+/&-+"0&+'36 &' 5+; &,$ .!;+.0.

    /$##+31 )-+($ '5 /!+4 !-&+(#$/ '- ('..'4+&+$/ !34 &' )-'.0#1!&$4 /0(,

    -0#$/ !34 -$10#!&+'3/ !/ ,$ .!2 4$$. 3$($//!-2G !34

    X$Y 9'..'3*$!#&, F(& O'8 MNN !0&,'-+B+31 &,$ I-$/+4$3& +3 =+$* '5 &,$;+/&$3($ '5 ! /&!&$ '5 3!&+'3!# $.$-1$3(2 &' -$40($ &,$ $;)$34+&0-$/ '

    &,$ $;$(0&+=$ 4$)!-&.$3&/ '5 &,$ Z'=$-3.$3& "2 &,$ /0/)$3/+'3 '-

    !"!34'3.$3& '5 /$-=+($6 !(&+=+&+$/6 '- ')$-!&+'3/ '5 3' +..$4+!&$

    +.)'-&!3($8

    F& &,$ &+.$6 ?$)&$."$-6 JKUK &,$ /$('34 *'-#4 *!- *!/ '3#2 +3 H0-')$6 70+&$

    5!- 5-'. &,$ I,+#+))+3$/ !34 ,!4 @0/& "$1038 >,$-$ *!/ &,$3 3' #+:$#+,''4 '5 &,

    I,+#+))+3$/ "$+31 +3='#=$4 +3 &,$ *!- 03&+# .'-$ &,!3 &*' 2$!-/ #!&$-6 +3

    V$($."$-6 JKLJ8 >,$ O!&+'3!# F//$."#2 *!/ &,$3 5-$$ &' .$$& $+&,$- +3 -$10#!

    '- /)$(+!# /$//+'3 &' $3!(& #$1+/#!&+'3 &' .$$& &,$ $.$-1$3(28 T3 5!(&6 +& .$& +3

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    15/36

    !"

    !"#$%&! ("(()*+ )+ ,&+$&!-. /01/ %&(2)+# /33 4&-( &+4 )+ ,&+$&!-. /01/ 5*!

    &+*26"! !"#$%&! ("(()*+ *5 /33 4&-(. "78%$4)+# 26" ("9"!&% (:"8)&% ("(()*+ 6"%4

    4$!)+# 26*(" 2;* -"&!(< =+4 -"2 26" =((">?%- 4"%"#&2"4 %"#)(%&2)9" :*;"!( 2*

    26" @!"()4"+2 $+4"! ("82)*+ AB. =!2)8%" CC *5 26" D*+(2)2$2)*+< E6)( )( 8%"&! :!**5

    26&2. 8*+2!&!- 2* 26" 26"*!- *5 26" >&F*!)2- *:)+)*+. 26" G"#)(%&2$!" 4"%"#&2"4

    %"#)(%&2)9" :*;"!( 2* 26" @!"()4"+2 "9"+ ;6"+ )2 8*$%4 >""2 &+4 )2 &82$&%%- >"2

    ("9"!&% 2)>"("+2)*+"4 4"%"#&2)+# %"#)(%&2)9" :*;"!( 2* 26"@!"()4"+2. 26" =((">?%- )+ )2( 5*$!26%- (:"8)&% ("(()*+ *+ =$#$(2 /0. /013

    !":"&2"4 &+4 !")2"!&2"4 26)( :!&82)8" &+4 :*%)8- ?- :&(()+# D*>>*+;"&%26 =82

    H*< B33 4"%"#&2)+# &44)2)*+&% &+4 >*!" "72"+()9" :*;"!( 2* 26" @!"()4"+2 )+

    (:)2" *5 26" 5&82 26&2 26" ;&! ;&( (2)%% 5&! &;&- )+ I$!*:" &+4 26"!" ;&( +*

    4&+#"! *! :!*(:"82 *5 )+9*%9)+# 26" @6)%)::)+"(. &+4 26" G"#)(%&2$!" ;&( (2)%%

    5!"" 2* >""2 &( )+ 5&82 )2 >"2 &)+ )+ !"#$%&! ("(()*+ )+ ,&+$&!-. /01/< J$!)+# )2(

    !"#$%&! ("(()*+ ?"#$+ 26&2 >*+26 &+4 -"&!. )+(2"&4 *5 (2*::)+# *! "+4)+# 26"

    %"#)(%&2)9" :*;"!( 4"%"#&2"4 2* 26" @!"()4"+2. ?"8&$(" &88*!4)+# 2* 26" 26"*!-

    *5 26" >&F*!)2- *:)+)*+. 26" G"#)(%&2$!" ;&( &?%" 2* >""2. 26" =((">?%- &%%*;"4

    26"> 2* 8*+2)+$" ?- :&(()+# D*>>*+;"&%26 =82 H*< BA3 ;6)86 >"!"%-

    &>"+4"4 ("82)*+ / *5 D*>>*+;"&%26 =82 H*< B33< C !":"&2 26&2 &%% 26)(. 5&! 5!*>

    ($::*!2)+# 26" 9)"; *5 26" >&F*!)2- 26&2 26" G"#)(%&2$!" 4"%"#&2"4 %"#)(%&2)9":*;"!( 2* 26" @!"()4"+2 *+%- ?"8&$(" )2 8*$%4 +*2 >""2. 5&)!%- &+4 (K$&!"%-

    !"5$2"( (&)4 9)";". "&86 +$%%)5-)+# 26" &82( *5 26" *26"!< C 5&)% 2* ("" 26" ($##"(2"4

    &+*>&%-< C+ 5&82. $+4"! 26" 9)"; &+4 )+2"!:!"2&2)*+ #)9"+ ?- 26" >&F*!)2- *5 26"

    4"%"#&2)*+ *5 8*+2">:%&2"4 26" ()>$%2&+"*$( 5$+82)*+)+# *5 26" G"#)(%&2$!" &+4

    26" @!"()4"+2. ?*26 "7"!8)()+# %"#)(%&2)9" :*;"!(< =+4 )2 )( & 5&82 26&2 26"!" ;"!"

    ("9"!&% )+(2&+8"( *5 26" %"#)(%&2$!" &+4 26" @!"()4"+2 ?*26 9&%)4%- &+4

    ()>$%2&+"*$(%- "7"!8)()+# %"#)(%&2)9" :*;"!(>*+;"&%26 =82 H*< 10B &%!"&4- !"5"!!"4 2*. &::!*9"4 *+

    M":2">?"! N3. /0N0. 26""#$%& '%(%)*+%' 2* 26" @!"()4"+2 2* :!"(8!)?" !$%"( &+4

    !"#$%&2)*+( 6" >&- 4""> "(("+2)&% 2* 8&!!- *$2 26" :$!:*("( *5 26" =82. +&>"%-.

    26" 2&O)+# *9"! *5 &+4 *:"!&2)*+ ?- 26" P*9"!+>"+2 *5 &+- :$?%)8 ("!9)8" *!

    "+2"!:!)(" &+4 2* :&- 5*! 26" (&>". ;&( 2* %&(2 $+2)% 26" 4&2" *5

    26" *',#-&./%.+ *5 26" +"72 !"#$%&! ("(()*+ *5 26" H&2)*+&% =((">?%-< E6)(

    >"&+( 26&2. 4$!)+# 26" !"#$%&! ("(()*+ *5 26" =((">?%- ;6)86 ?"#$+ )+ ,&+$&!-.

    /013 &+4 %&(2"4 /33 4&-(. 26" @!"()4"+2 8*$%4 "7"!8)(" 26" ">"!#"+8- :*;"!(

    4"%"#&2"4 2* 6)>< =#&)+. $+4"! D*>>*+;"&%26 =82( H*(< B33 &+4 BA3 26"

    @!"()4"+2 8*$%4 &+4 )+4""4 6" "7"!8)("4 6)( ">"!#"+8- :*;"!( 4$!)+# 26"

    !"#$%&! ("(()*+ *5 26" =((">?%- ;6)86 ?"#&+ )+ ,&+$&!-. /01/. ;6"+ @!"()4"+2

    Q$"R*+ )(($"4 &2 %"&(2 +)+" I7"8$2)9" S!4"!( +$>?"!"4 NA/. NNN. NNT. NNU.

    NN0. N13. N1A. N11 &+4 N1T )+

    D*>>*+;"&%26 =82 H*< BU/ "+4"4 *+%- *+ V&- AT. /01B. 26"+ 26" "72"+()9"

    %"#)(%&2)9" :*;"!( 4"%"#&2"4 2* 26" @!"()4"+2 $+4"! 26&2 =82 8*$%4 ?" "7"!8)("4

    &+4 )+ 5&82 26"- ;"!" "7"!8)("4 4$!)+# 26" 5)9" (:"8)&% ("(()*+ *5 D*+#!"(( )+ 26-"&! /01T. ;6)86 %&(2"4 & 2*2&% *5 W1 4&-(< J$!)+# 26*(" (:"8)&% ("(()*+ *5 /01T.

    @!"()4"+2 S(>"X& )(($"4 ("9"!&% I7"8$2)9" S!4"!( )+ 26" "7"!8)(" *5 6)(

    ">"!#"+8- :*;"!($%2&+"*$(%-. )( >*!" 5&+8)"4 26&+ !"&%Y E6" ()2$&2)*+ ;&(

    8*+2">:%&2"4 &+4 "7:!"((%- )+2"+4"4 ?- 26" G"#)(%&2$!" )2("%5. "9)4"+2%-

    ?"%)"9)+# 26&2 (&)4 8*+4)2)*+ *! (2&2" *5 &55&)!( ;&( +")26"! &+*>&%*$( +*!

    )>:!*:"!< E6"!" )( 2* >- >)+4 !"&%%- +* )+8*>:&2)?)%)2-< =2 ($86 & 2)>" &+4

    4$!)+# 26" :"!)*4 *5 26")! ()>$%2&+"*$( 5$+82)*+)+#. 26" G"#)(%&2$!" >&-

    :"!5*!> )2( *!4)+&!- %"#)(%&2)9" 4$2)"( 2&O)+# )2( 2)>" 2* (2$4-. 8*+()4"!. &>"+4&+4 :&(( ?)%%(. !"("!9)+# 2* 26" @!"()4"+2 >&22"!( !"K$)!)+# &+4 4">&+4)+#

    )>>"4)&2" &82)*+" 26&2 )2 )( )+ ("(()*+< C2 >&-

    9&%)4%- &+4 :!*:"!%- (2):$%&2" )+ )2( #!&+2 *5 ">"!#"+8- :*;"!( 26&2 26"- ?"

    "7"!8)("4 ;6"+ 26" G"#)(%&2$!" )( +*2 )+ ("(()*+< C+ 5&82. )+ *+" )+(2&+8". )+

    D*>>*+;"&%26 =82 H*< T33. ("82)*+ A. 26" H*2)*+&% =((">?%- "7:!"((%-

    :!*9)4"4 Z26&2 26" &$26*!)2- 6"!")+ #)9"+ (6&%% ?" "7"!8)("4 *+%- ;6"+ 26"

    H&2)*+&% =((">?%- )( +*2 )+ ("(()*+:%&2"( @!"()4"+2)&% "7"!8)(" *5 %"#)(%&2)9" :*;"!(

    ()>$%2&+"*$(%- ;)26 26" G"#)(%&2$!". )2 )( 2* ?" :!"($>"4 26&2 26" G"#)(%&2$!"

    )+2"+4"4 )2 &+4 (&; +*26)+# )>:!*:"! *! &+*>&%*$( )+ )2. &+4 )2 )( +*2 5*! 26"

    D*$!2 2* :&(( $:*+ 26" ($::*("4 )>:!*:!)"2- *! &+*>&%-*2". )5 +*2 )>:*(()?%"< =( &%!"&4-

    (2&2"4 &2 26" ?"#)++)+# *5 26)( *:)+)*+. 26" D6)"5 I7"8$2)9" &82)+# &( &+ "+2 *5

    26" G"#)(%&2)9" $+4"! 6)( ">"!#"+8- :*;"!(. >&- +*2 #* &)+(2 26" ;)(6"( &+4

    :*%)8)"( *5 6)( :!)+8):&%< \" 8&+ *+%- 8&!!- *$2 )2( ;)(6"( &+4 :*%)8)"(. &+4 ;6"!

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    16/36

    !"

    !"# %&'# %() *+),+# +-( &*-(',+ '* '!*#, *. '!, /,0"#1%'-+,2 *+ *3,+%', *( % .",1)

    %1+,%)4 5"'!)+%5( 6,&%-#, '!, /,0"#1%'-+, !%) %1+,%)4 %&',) '!,+,"(2 !"# %&'#

    *+ 78,&-'"9, :+),+# ;-#' 0"9, 5%4 %() 5"11 6, ),&1%+,) 9*") %() *. (* ,..,&'2 64

    '!,

    5,1.%+, *. '!, 3,*31, %() "( %&&*+)%(&, 5"'! '!,

    *. !"# 3+"(&"3%12 '!, 1,0"#1%'-+,2 5*-1) 6+%B,(14 +,3-)"%', !"# 3+"(&"3%1 %() ,9,

    &!%11,(0, "'# %-'!*+"'42 %() '!%' '!,

    ,;,+0,(&4 3*5,+# '!%' !, 5*-1) 3,+3,'-%', '!,; 64 0*"(0 %# .%+ %# 9,'*"(0 %(

    %&' *.

    U-"+"(*2 '!%' (* %&&-#"(0 ."(0,+ !%# ,9,+ 6,,( 3*"(',) %' '!,;2 %&&-#"(0 *+ ,9,

    "(#"(-%'"(0 '!%' '!,4 !%9, %6-#,) '!,"+ ,;,+0,(&4 3*5,+# *+ ,8,+&"#,) '!,;

    .*+ %(4 3-+3*#, *'!,+ '!%( '!, 5,1.%+, *. '!, &*-('+42 *+ '!%' '!,4 !%)

    ;%1"&"*-#14 %&',) &*('+%+4 '* '!, 5"#!,# *. '!, /,0"#1%'-+,#= 79,( %.',+

    1"6,+%'"*( '!,+, !%# 6,,( (* &1%"; (*' ,9,( .+*; '!, /,0"#1%'-+,# "'#,1.2 '* '!,

    P(*51,)0, *. '!"#

    H!,+, "# (* &!%+0, *+ "(#"(-%'"*( '!%' %(4 *. '!, 78,&-'"9, :+),+# 5!"&! 5, %+

    (*5 !*1)"(0 '* 6, "(9%1") 5,+, "##-,) .+*; '!, -1',+"*+ ;*'"9,# *+ '* .-+'!,+%() .%9*+ '!, 3*1"'"&%1 "(',+,#' *. '!, @+,#"),(' "##-"(0 '!,;= A' "# %);"'',) "(

    '!, ;%?*+"'4 *3"("*( '!%' 78,&-'"9, :+),+ Q*= DR2 #,,P"(0 '* +,0-1%', !*-#, %(

    1*' +,('%1# 5%# "##-,) "( 0**) .%"'! 64 @+,#"),(' W*8%#= 78,&-'"9, :+),+ Q*= FN

    5%# "##-,) '* +,0-1%', ,83*+'#2 @+,#"),(' U-"+"(* 3+,#-;%614 6,1",9"(0 '!%'

    ,83*+'# %' '!"# '";, #'"11 (,,),) +,0-1%'"*( %() &*('+*1 %# 5%# .*+;,+14

    3+*9"),) 64

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    17/36

    !"

    !""!#$%&!'!(( $* +', -+.! %$ #*!/$!'(%&! 0%$1 $1! ,23+$%*' *" $1! !-!34!'#5

    3!(26$%'4 "3*- $1! 0+3 +', $1+$ "23$1!3-*3!7 $1+$ ,23+$%*' %( + 6%-%$!, 8!3%*,

    0%$1%' $1! -!+'%'4 +', #*'$!-86+$%*' *" $1! 9*'($%$2$%*': ;23!65 $1!

    !-!34!'#5 3!(26$%'4 "3*- $1! 0+3 #*'$!-86+$!, #$ =*: ?@A %( '*$ 8!3-+'!'$ *3 %',!"%'%$!: B$ %( *" 6%-%$!,

    ,23+$%*': B$ -+5

    !',: D3!(2-+

    '*$ + "!07 %' "+#$ -!3%#+' 3!%'"*3#!-!'$( 0*26, #*-! +$ $1!

    +0+5: E1! 0%(,*- *3 6+#. *" 0%(,*- *" $1! =+$%*'+6 >((!-#$ =*: ?@A

    #*!/$!'(%&! 0%$1 $1! 3!(26$%'4 !-!34!'#57 &%!0!, %' $1! 6%41$ *" 01+$ 1+,

    +#$2+665 1+88!'!,7 #+''*$

    $1! !-!34!'#5 3!(26$%'4 "3*- $1! K+3 #*'$%'2!(7 9*--*'0!+6$1 >#$ =*: ?@A

    (2

    9*'43!(( #*26, -!!$ 3!(2-! %$( 6!4%(6+$%&!( "2'#$%*'(: =+$23+6657 $1%( &%!0 %(

    +', !/!3#%(! %$( "2'#$%*'(: B

    *" 6!4%(6+$%&! 8*0!3( %( '*$ %'+

    6!4%(6+$%&! "2'#$%*'(

    +', ,!6!4+$%*' #$

    %( $1+$ $1! ,!6!4+$!, 8*0!3(

    +3! #*'(8%#2*2(65 (%6!'$ *' $1%( 8*%'$: E1! *'65 #*'#62(%*' %( $1+$ '!%$1!3 $1!

    "3+-!3( *" $1! 9*'($%$2$%*' '*3 $1! -!-

    >#$ ?@A 01%#1 3!+,( +( "*66*0(R

    ;L9: P: E1! D3!(%,!'$ *" $1! D1%6%88%'!( (1+66 +( (**' +( 83+#$%#+#$( =*(: ?WW7?JW +', ?@A 01!3! (+%, 6+0( #*'$!-86+$!, -+'5 ,%""!3!'$ +#$(7 326!( +',

    3!426+$%*'( *" &+3%!, #+$!4*3%!( +', *

    1%- 28 $* $1+$ $%-!C

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    18/36

    !"

    !"#$ &$' !"#(#) *+,-' .! $+! /# 0+(# -+1.2&- &$' (#&3+$&/-# !+ /#-.#4# !"&!

    .$&30,2" &3 !"# 1(&$! &$' !"# #5#(2.3# +6 ".3 #0#(1#$27 8+9#(3 9#(#

    0+!.4&!#' /7 &$' /&3#' ,8+$ !"# #5.3!#$2# +6 !"# #0#(1#$27 &$' 3.$2# !"#

    #0#(1#$27 2+$!.$,#' ".3 9+(: &$' (#38+$3./.-.!7 9#(# $+! #$'#' &$' !"&! ".3

    8&(!.&- (#8+(! 2+,-' $+! 8+33./-7 &66#2! !"# 2+$!.$,&$2# +6 ".3 #0#(1#$27

    8+9#(3)

    ;#2!.+$ < +6 =+00+$9#&-!" >2! ?+@ ABC 8(+4.'#3 6+( !"# 6.-.$1 +6 & (#8+(! 9.!"

    =+$1(#33 /7 !"# D(#3.'#$! &3 3++$ &3 !"&! /+'7 2+$4#$#'@ >22+('.$1 !+ !"#0&E+(.!7 +8.$.+$ +$ !"&! '&!# !"# 9"+-# >2! ?+@ ABC 2#&3#' !+ "&4# 6+(2# &$'

    #66#2!@ F$'#( !"&! !"#+(7G &3 3++$ &3 !"# =+$1(#33 2+$4#$#' .$ H,$#G CIJKG &$' .!

    .3 !+ /# 8(#3,0#' !"&! D(#3.'#$! L30#M&G 2+08-7.$1 9.!" ".3 ',!7G 0,3! "&4#

    0&'# ".3 (#8+(! +6 &-- !"# $,0#(+,3 N5#2,!.4# L('#(3 "# "&' .33,#' 3+ 6&(G

    8#("&83 .$2-,'.$1 !"+3# .33,#' /7 ".3 8(#'#2#33+( D(#3.'#$! O,#P+$ 9"+

    /#2&,3# +6 ".3 8(#0&!,(# '#&!" 9&3 ,$&/-# !+ (#8+(! ".3 &2!3 !+ =+$1(#33G !"#

    D(#3.'#$! &,!+0&!.2&--7 -+3! ".3 #0#(1#$27 8+9#(3@ Q,! !"# 0&E+(.!7 +8.$.+$

    R,&-.6.#3 !".3 2+$4#$.$1 +6 !"# =+$1(#33G 6+( .! 3&73 !"&! .! 0,3! /# & (#1,-&(

    3#33.+$ &$' $+! & 38#2.&- 3#33.+$G !"#(#/7 #5!#$'.$1 !"# -.6# +6 =+00+$9#&-!"

    &2! ?+@ ABC +$# 7#&( -+$1#(G !+ S&7G CIJA 9"#$ =+$1(#33 "#-' .!3 6.(3! (#1,-&(

    3#33.+$ &6!#( -./#(&!.+$@ T '+ $+! R,.!# 3## !"# $#2#33.!7 +( !"# (#&3+$ 6+( !"#

    '.3!.$2!.+$ 0&'# /#!9##$ !"# 38#2.&- &$' (#1,-&( 3#33.+$G 6+( &! /+!" 3#33.+$3=+$1(#33 2+,-' 9#-- (#2#.4# !"# (#8+(! +6 !"# D(#3.'#$!@ U"# (#&3+$ 1.4#$ .3 !"&!

    V.$ & 38#2.&- 3#33.+$ =+$1(#33 0&7 2+$3.'#( 1#$#(&- -#1.3-&!.+$ +( +$-7 3,2"

    3,/E#2!3 &3 "# WD(#3.'#$!X 0&7 '#3.1$&!#@V Q,! &3 & 0&!!#( +6 6&2!G !"# 6.(3! !9+

    38#2.&- 3#33.+$3 2&--#' /7 D(#3.'#$! L30#M& .$ CIJKG &6!#( -./#(&!.+$G #&2" 6+( &

    8#(.+' +6 !".(!7 '&73 9#(# /+!" !+ 2+$3.'#( !"#"$%& &"!()&%*(+#@ ;+G &2!,&--7 !"#(#

    .3 $+ (#&3+$ 6+( !"# '.3!.$2!.+$@

    Y,(!"#(0+(#G .6 .! 9#(# !"# .$!#$!.+$ +6 !"# Z#1.3-&!,(# !+ 6.5 !"# !.0# &! 9".2"

    =+00+$9#&-!" >2! ?+@ ABC 9+,-' 2#&3# .$ .!3 +8#(&!.+$ &3 +6 !"# '&!# 9"#$ !"#

    D(#3.'#$! 2+,-' 6.-# ".3 (#8+(! /#6+(# =+$1(#33 9"#$ .! 6.(3! 2+$4#$#' $+!

    .$ ),"-(%& )"))(+# /,! .$ $"!.&%$ )"))(+#G .! 9+,-' "&4# #58(#33-7 &$'

    ,$#R,.4+2&--7 3&.' 3+@ T$ .!3 +!"#( &2!3 +6 '#-#1&!.+$ +6 8+9#(3 9"#$ !"#-#1.3-&!,(# 9&$!#' !+ "&4# !"# (#8+(! +6 !"# D(#3.'#$! &! .!3 $"!.&%$ )"))(+#G .!

    #58(#33-7 &$' #58-.2.!-7 3&.' 3+@ T$ 3#2!.+$ < +6 =+00+$9#&-!" >2! JIJG .$

    3#2!.+$ K +6 =+00+$9#&-!" >2! JIAG .$ 3#2!.+$ A +6 =+00+$9#&-!" >2! JI[G .$

    3#2!.+$ < +6 =+00+$9#&-!" >2! K\\ &$' .$ 3#2!.+$ J +6 =+00+$9#&-!" >2! A\\G

    !"# ?&!.+$&- >33#0/-7 8(+4.'#' !"&! !"# D(#3.'#$! 3"&-- (#8+(! !+ !"# ?&!.+$&-

    >33#0/-7 9.!".$ !#$ '&73 &6!#( !"# +8#$.$1 +6 !"# $#5! $"!.&%$ )"))(+# +6 !"#

    3&.' >33#0/-7 +6 9"&!#4#( &2!3 "&4# /##$ !&:#$ /7 ".0 ,$'#( !"# &,!"+(.!7 +6

    !"+3# >2!3@ U"# >33#0/-7 -#6! $+!".$1 6+( .$!#(8(#!&!.+$ +( 38#2,-&!.+$@ T$

    3#2!.+$ < +6 =+00+$9#&-!" >2! ABCG "+9#4#(G !"# 3&0# >33#0/-7 "&3 $+!

    38#2.6.#' !"# :.$' +6 3#33.+$ /#6+(# 9".2" !"# D(#3.'#$! 3"+,-' 0&:# ".3 (#8+(!@

    T! 0#(#-7 3&.' !"&! ,8+$ !"# 2+$4#$.$1 +6 !"# =+$1(#33 !"# D(#3.'#$! 3"&--

    (#8+(! !"#(#!+ &-- !"# (,-#3 &$' (#1,-&!.+$3 8(+0,-1&!#' /7 ".0@ *# 3"+,-'

    0&:# $+ '.3!.$2!.+$ 9"#(# !"# -&9 0&:#3 +( 2&--3 6+( $+$#@ ]#(# &1&.$G !+

    3,88+(! !"# 0&E+(.!7 +8.$.+$ 9+,-' (#R,.(# (#&'.$1 .$!+ !"# -&9G 3#2!.+$ < +6

    >2! ABCG 3+0#!".$1 !"&! .3 $+! !"#(#@

    T$ 2&3# -.:# !"# 8(#3#$! 9"#(# !"#(# .3 (++0 6+( '+,/! &3 !+ 9"#!"#( +( $+!

    =+00+$9#&-!" >2! ?+@ ABC "&3 2#&3#' !+ +8#(&!#G +$# 4.#9 W+6 !"# 0&E+(.!7X

    /#.$1 !"&! .! &,!+0&!.2&--7 2#&3#' !+ "&4# &$7 6+(2# &$' #66#2! +$ S&7 ^KG CIJAG!"# +!"#( 4.#9 /#.$1 !"&! !"# -&9 +8#(&!#' &3 -+$1 &3 !"# #0#(1#$27 (#3,-!.$1

    6(+0 !"# 9&( #5.3!#'G !"# +8.$.+$ +6 &$' !"# +/4.+,3 .$!#(8(#!&!.+$ 1.4#$ /7 !"

    -#1.3-&!,(# 9".2" #$&2!#' !"# -&9 &$' 0&'# !"# '#-#1&!.+$ +6 8+9#(3 &$' !"#

    D(#3.'#$! !+ 9"+0 !"# '#-#1&!.+$ 9&3 0&'# &$' 9"+ #5#(2.3#' 3&.' 8+9#(3G

    3"+,-' "&4# 0,2" .6 $+! '#2.3.4# 9#.1"!@ *# 0,3! /#&( .$ 0.$' !"&! 9# &(# $+!

    8&33.$1 ,8+$ !"# 4&-.'.!7 +( 2+$3!.!,!.+$&-.!7 +6 & -&9 #$&2!#' /7 !"#

    Z#1.3-&!,(#G .$ 9".2" 2&3#G !"# =+,(! 0&7 6.$' !"# &2! .$4&-.' &$'

    ,$2+$3!.!,!.+$&- .6 .! .3 .$ 4.+-&!.+$ +6 !"# /&3.2 -&9G (#1&('-#33 +6 !"# +8.$.+$ +(

    .$!#(8(#!&!.+$ 1.4#$ /7 !"# Z#1.3-&!,(# !"&! 8&33#' .! +( +6 !"# N5#2,!.4#

    _#8&(!0#$! 9".2" 0&7 /# !(7.$1 !+ #$6+(2# .!@ *# &33,0# !"&! >2! ?+@ ABC .3

    4&-.' &$' 2+$3!.!,!.+$&-@ ]#(#G 9# &(# 0#(#-7 !(7.$1 !+ &32#(!&.$ !"# .$!#$!.+$ +

    !"# ?&!.+$&- >33#0/-7 &3 !+ !"# -.6# &$' 8#(.+' +6 #66#2!.4#$#33 +6=+00+$9#&-!" >2! ?+@ ABC@

    _+ !"# 3!,'7 &$' &$&-73.3 +6 +!"#( &2!3 +6 !"# Z#1.3-&!,(# 3.0.-&( !+

    =+00+$9#&-!" >2! ABCG 6&4+( !"# 4.#9 +6 !"# 0&E+(.!7) U"# &$39#( .$ 07

    +8.$.+$ .3 2-#&(-7 &$' '#2.'#'-7 .$ !"# $#1&!.4#@ U"# 0&E+(.!7 2.!#3 !"#

    =+00+$9#&-!" >2!3 ?+3@ A\\ &$' A^\ !+ 3,88+(! !"# !"#+(7 !"&!

    =+00+$9#&-!" >2! ABC &,!+0&!.2&--7 2#&3#' !+ +8#(&!# =+$1(#33 0#! &! .!3

    $#5! (#1,-&( 3#33.+$@ Q,! !"# -+1.2&- .$6#(#$2# +( 2+$2-,3.+$ !+ /# '(&9$ 6(+0

    !"#3# !9+ &2!3 .3G .$ 07 +8.$.+$G E,3! !"# (#4#(3#@ T! .3 #4#$ 6&!&- !+ !"# 4.#9 +6

    !"# 0&E+(.!7 &3 T 3"&-- &!!#08! !+ 3"+9@ Z#! ,3 2+$3.'#( =+00+$9#&-!" >2! A\\

    '#-#1&!.$1 #5!#$3.4# -#1.3-&!.4# 8+9#(3 !+ !"# D(#3.'#$!G &88(+4#' +$ >,1,3!

    CIG CIJ\G 9".2" -.:# >2! ABC .3 3.-#$! &3 !+ &$7 #58(#33 8(+4.3.+$ (#1&('.$1 .!3-.6# +( 8#(.+' +6 #66#2!.4#$#33G &$' &3 !+ "+9 -+$1 !"# #0#(1#$27 8+9#(3

    1(&$!#' !"# D(#3.'#$! /7 .! 9.-- -&3!@ ;#2!.+$ J +6 3&.' =+00+$9#&-!" >2! ?+@

    A\\ -.:# 3#2!.+$ < +6 >2! ABC 8(+4.'#3 !"&! V!"# D(#3.'#$! 3"&-- 9.!".$ !"# 6.(3!

    !#$ '&73 6(+0 !"# '&!# +6 !"# +8#$.$1 +6 !"# >33#0/-7`3 $#5! (#1,-&( 3#33.+$

    (#8+(! !+ 3&.' >33#0/-7 9"&!#4#( &2!.+$ "# "&' !&:#$ ,$'#( !"# &,!"+(.!7

    !"#(#.$ 1(&$!#'@V ;&.' 3#2!.+$ J +6 >2! A\\ .3 2-#&(-7 &$' 0+(# 38#2.6.2 !"&$

    3#2!.+$ < +6 >2! ABC .$ !"&! .! 2-#&(-7 38#2.6.#3 !"# $#5! $"!.&%$ )"))(+# 9"#(#&3

    !"# -&!!#( (#6#(3 0#(#-7 !+ !"# 2+$4#$.$1 +6 =+$1(#33@ Q,! -#! ,3

    &33,0# %$!."#/+ &3 2+$!#$'#' /7 !"# 0&E+(.!7 !"&! V!"# 2+$4#$.$1 +6 !"#

    =+$1(#33V 0#$!.+$#' .$ 3#2!.+$ < +6 =+00+$9#&-!" >2! ABCG (#6#((#' !+

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    19/36

    !"

    !"#$%&! ("(()*+, -..*!/)+# 0* 01" 2&3*!)04 *5)+)*+6 $+/"! (".0)*+ 7 *8 01"

    9*22*+:"&%01 -.0 ;*, !"()/"+0 :&( (0)%% !"M$)!"/ 0* !"5*!0 0* ;&0)*+&% -(("2?%4 :)01)+

    01" 8)!(0 C= /&4( 8!*2 01" /&0" *8 01" *5"+)+# *8 )0( +"A0 !"#$%&! ("(()*+ :1).1

    (1*$%/ 1&E" ?"#$+ )+ B&+$&!46 CD7G6 /"(5)0" 01" 8&.0 01&0 1" 1&/ &%!"&/4 2&/" &

    !"5*!0 0* 01" N"#)(%&0$!" )+ B&+$&!46 CD7C, I+.)/"+0&%%46 01)( &+(:"! &+/ !"8$0"(

    01" .*+0"+0)*+ *8 01" 2&3*!)04 01&0 01" %&: *8 /"%"#&0)*+ *8 5*:"!(

    .*+0"25%&0"/ *+%4 *+" 2""0)+# *8 01" 9*+#!"(( &0 :1).1 01" >!"()/"+0 :&( 0*

    !"5*!0 1)( &.0( *8 "2"!#"+.46 &+/ 01&0 (&)/ !"5*!0 :&( 0* ?" 01" 8)!(0 &+/ 01"

    %&(0,

    ;*:6 :1&0 )+8"!"+." 2&4 ?" /!&:+ 8!*2 01)( &2"+/)+# *8 (".0)*+ C *+%4 *89*22*+:"&%01 -.0 ;*, !"()/"+0 &( (0)%% )+ 8*!." &+/ "88".0 /"(5)0"

    01" !"5*!0 8)%"/ :)01 01" -(("2?%4 ?4 01" >!"()/"+0 &0 01" ?"#)++)+# *8 )0(

    !"#$%&! ("(()*+ )+ B&+$&!46 CD7C, Q1"+ 01" N"#)(%&0$!" 2"!"%4 &2"+/( & (".0)*+

    *8 & %&:6 %"&E)+# 01" !"(0 *8 (&)/ %&: )+0&.0 &+/ $+.1&+#"/6 01" %*#).&% )+8"!"+."

    &+/ .*+.%$()*+ )( 01&0 01" &2"+/"/ %&: :&( (0)%% )+ 8*!." ?".&$(" 4*$ .&++*0

    &2"+/ & %&: :1).1 )( +* %*+#"! )+ 8*!.", P1" *+%4 01)+# 01&0 .*$%/ ?" /*+" :)01

    & %&: 01&0 1&( ."&("/ 0* *5"!&0" )( 0* !""+&.0 )0, F$0 )+ 5&(()+# 9*22*+:"&%01

    -.0 !"()/"+0 8)%"/ 1)( !"5*!0 *+ 01" "A"!.)("

    *8 1)( "2"!#"+.4 5*:"!( :)01 01" N"#)(%&0$!"6 01" -.0 2&R)+# 01" /"%"#&0)*+

    ."&("/ 0* *5"!&0" &+/ 01" >!"()/"+0 %*(0 1)( "2"!#"+.4 5*:"!(,

    -( I 1&E" &%!"&/4 (0&0"/ )+ 01" .*$!(" *8 01)( *5)+)*+6 )+ .*++".0)*+ :)01

    &+*01"! 51!&(" *8 01)( .&(" 8!*2 B&+$&!4 0* B$+"6 CD7C6 >!"()/"+0 S$"T*+ 1&/

    )(($"/ &0 %"&(0 ")#10 HA".$0)E" U!/"!( )+ 01" "A"!.)(" *8 1)( "2"!#"+.4 5*:"!(6

    ?4 &$01*!)04 *8 9*22*+:"&%01 -.0 !"()/"+0,

    ;*01)+# .*+.!"0" )+ 01" 8*!2 *8 %"#)(%&0)*+ *! !"(*%$0)*+ :&( /*+"6 8*! )8 :" &!"

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    20/36

    !"

    !" $%%&'! (&)*'$'&+ +&'"+!* $(, %"--&(!. !/& -&-0&+* "1 2"(3+&** "+ $! 4&$*!

    $ -$5"+6!7 "1 !/&- )&+& )6446(3 $(, *$!6*16&, !" /$8& !/& 2/6&1 9:&%;!68&

    %"(!6(;& 6( !/& &:&+%6*& "1 /6* &-&+3&(%7 '")&+* ;(!64 !/& &(, "1 =? @44 !/6*

    4&$,* !" (" "!/&+ %"(%4;*6"( 0;! !/$! 2"(3+&** 0&46&8&, $44 $4"(3 !/$!

    2"--"()&$4!/ @%! A"? BC< 6* *!644 6( 1"+%& $(, &11&%!?

    D1 2"--"()&$4!/ @%! A"? BC< 6* *!644 6( 1"+%& $(, &11&%! !/& E;&*!6"( $+6*&*F /")

    4"(3 $(, 1"+ )/$! '&+6", )644 *$6, @%! %"(!6(;& !" "'&+$!&G @* D /$8& $4+&$,7

    *!$!&,. D 0&46&8& !/$! !/& ,&4&3$!6"( "1 &-&+3&(%7 '")&+* )$* -$,& %"&:!&(*68&)6!/ !/& &-&+3&(%7 +&*;4!6(3 1+"- !/& )$+. $* 4"(3 $* !/$! &-&+3&(%7 %"(!6(;&*

    $(, ;(4&** !/& H&36*4$!;+& '+"86,&* "!/&+)6*&. @%! BC< )644 %"(!6(;& !" "'&+$!&

    $(, !/& I+&*6,&(! -$7 %"(!6(;& &:&+%6*6(3 /6* &-&+3&(%7 '")&+*?

    J/& 4$*! $(, 4"36%$4 E;&*!6"( !/$! "(& )644 ($!;+$447 $*K 6*F /$* !/& &-&+3&(%7

    +&*;4!6(3 1+"- !/& )$+ '$**&, "+ ,"&* 6! *!644 &:6*!G J/6* 6* $ 1$6+ $(, ,&%6*68&

    E;&*!6"( 6($*-;%/ $* !/& &:6*!&(%& "1 !/& &-&+3&(%7 6*. -7 "'6(6"(. !/& !&*!

    $(, !/& "(47 0$*6* "1 !/& "'&+$!6"( "+ %&**$!6"( "1 @%! BC

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    21/36

    !"

    !"# %!& '&()&%")* +, -.)/(01%0)& "23 4"%0)"1 5+0)( "23 !/# 6&2 %+ "37/#&

    !/6 "# %+ %!& ".)/(01%0)"1 2&&3# "23 %!& ,++3 #0881* +, %!& (+02%)*9 :& !"# %!&

    '&()&%")* +, ;/2"2(& "23 "11 %!& +,,/(/"1# 023&) !/6 %+ /2,+)6 !/6 +, %!& ,/2"2(

    +, %!&

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    22/36

    !"

    !" $%&'(')* +,-',./ 0%! !1, *)!,2! +%*'34 "5 !1, 63'!,& 7!)!,2 7%8+,9, :"%+! "3

    !1, 8"'3! )(("+&2 .'!1 5'+2! -',. )3& &,(*)+,2 !1)! ;!1,2, )+, 9)!!,+2 "5 8"*'!'()*

    $%&49,3! 5"+ .1'(1 $%&4,2 1)-, 3,'!1,+ !,(13'()* ("98,!,3(, 3"+ "55'(')*

    +,28"32'?%&,(@, !"#A)!@'32B CD ?/ ,&/B EFFG/H

    I3 )3= ,-,3! !1, ,J'2!,3(, "+ 3"3K,J'2!,3(, "5 )3 ,9,+4,3(= '2 ) L%,2!'"3 "5

    5)(!2 .1'(1 9)= 3"! )*.)=2

    )** 8)+!2 "5 !1, S+(1'8,*)4"B !" &,(*)+, !1)! !1, N+,2'&,3! (*,)+*= )

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    23/36

    !!

    !" $%& '( "(()* +,( %'-.( /0-.1"1-) 2-(" )-+ "%& +,%+ +,( 30("12()+ ,%" +-

    0(/-0+ -)4& -)5(* +,%+ 1"* +,( 610"+ +1$( 7-)80("" 1" 5-).()(2* %)2 )(.(0 %8%1)9

    :;+ +,( $%).-?1)8 +,( 0;4( -6 5-)+($/-0%0& 5-)"+0;5+1-)* +,( $%

    "%& +,%+ 16 +,( ($(08()5& 0(";4+1)8 60-$ +,( =%0 %" 5-)+($/4%+(2 1)

    7-$$-)=(%4+, !5+ G-9 HIJ "+144 (M1"+"* %" +,( 30("12()+ '(41(.(" 1+ (M1"+" -0 ,(

    =-;42 )-+ ,%.( 1"";(2 +,( (M(5;+1.( -02(0" 1) L;("+1-) Y%)2 1+ 1" )-+ 6-0 +,(

    7-;0+ +- 5,%)8( +,%+ '(41(6 1) +,( %'"()5( -6 /0--6 +,%+ +,( 30("12()+ =%" 54(%04&

    =0-)8Z =-;42 1+ )-+ '( % 2(0(415+1-) -6 2;+& -) ,1" /%0+ +- 6%44 +- /0-.12(* 2;01)8

    +,( ($(08()5&* 6-0 +,( 5-)+1);%)5( -6 +,( 6;)5+1-)" -6 8-.(0)$()+* =,15, 1"

    -)4& /-""1'4( =1+, %) %//0-/01%+1-) 4%=[ T,%+ =-;42 '( 8%1)(2 '& 1"";1)8 0;4(

    %)2 0(8;4%+1-)" +- $((+ +,( ($(08()5& 16 +,(0( 1" )- E-.(0)$()+ +- ()6-05( %)

    5%00& +,($ -;+[ D,( $(0( 5%441)8 -6 % "/(51%4 1" )- 8;%0%)+& +,%+ %)

    %//0-/01%+1-) 4%= =144 '( /%""(2 -0 +,%+ -)( =144 '( /%""(2 '(6-0( +,(

    +,-;"%)2" -6 -66151%4" %)2 ($/4-&((" =,- =-0? 6-0 +,( E-.(0)$()+ ,%.(

    "+%0.(29 >+ 1"* /0-'%'4&* '(5%;"( -6 +,("( 5-)"12(0%+1-)" +,%+ +,( G%+1-)%4

    !""($'4&* 1) %//0-.1)8 7-$$-)=(%4+, !5+ G-9 HIJ* "/(51615%44& ($/-=(0(2

    +,( 30("12()+* 2;01)8 +,( (M1"+()5( -6 +,( ($(08()5&* C+- 5-)+1);( 1) 6-05( 4%="

    %)2 %//0-/01%+1-)" =,15, =-;42 4%/"( -0 -+,(0=1"( '(5-$( 1)-/(0%+1.(9C !)2

    +,%+ !5+ ,%" %;+,-01A(2 +,( 30("12()+ 2;01)8 +,( (M1"+()5( -6 +,( "%$(

    ($(08()5& C+- (M(051"( ";5, -+,(0 /-=(0" %" ,( $%& 2(($ )(5(""%0& +- ()%'4(

    +,( 8-.(0)$()+ +- 6;46144 1+" 0("/-)"1'141+1(" %)2 +- $%1)+%1) 1) 6-05( +,1"

    %;+,-01+&9C \)2(0 +,1" "/(51615 /0-.1"1-)* +,( %//0-/01%+1-) 6-0 +,( (M/()"(" -6

    +,( 5-$1)8 (4(5+1-)" =-;42* )%+;0%44&* 5-$(* 6-0* =1+,-;+ 2-;'+* 1+ 1" % $(%";0(

    +- ()%'4( +,( E-.(0)$()+ C+- 6;46144 1+" 0("/-)"1'141+1("9C

    7-)"1"+()+4& =1+, +,( .1(=" %'-.( (M/0(""* > %$ -6 +,( -/1)1-) +,%+ ]M(5;+1.(

    ^02(0 G-9 PPQ* %//0-/01%+1)8 6;)2" 6-0 +,( -/(0%+1-) -6 +,( E-.(0)$()+ -6 +,(

    N(/;'415 6-0 +,( 61"5%4 &(%0 JRSRKQX* %)2 ]M(5;+1.( ^02(0 G-9 PPH*

    %//0-/01%+1)8 6;)2" 6-0 +,( (M/()"(" -6 +,( 5-$1)8 )%+1-)%4 (4(5+1-)" 1)

    G-.($'(0* JRSR* %0( .%412 "- +,%+ +,( /(+1+1-) 1) E9N9 G-9 _KWXQS* !"#$%&$($)*&%"+,- .*/ 01/ 2*+31"*+* $4 56+ 76&88&9+1 * %)2 +,( /(+1+1-) 1) E9N9 G-9 _K

    WXQH*:95$9&$ ;3**+)$- +5>&11&$9+* $9 !#+

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    24/36

    !"

    ! #$%& %& '(%) $*%&%$& $+ ,-. /0)'%12 3242). ! 5%)( '$ 677 '(6' ! 68-22 5%'( ,-.

    /0)'%12 92&8:$& '(6' *2'%'%$&2-) %& ;. 3. ?@AB 6&7 =>?@AC (6D2 &$

    *2-)$&6E%'4 '$ %&)'%'0'2 '(2 *-$1227%&8).

    !"#$%'!"# 7%))2&'%&8F

    G(2 H6#$-%'4 +22E) '(6' %' (6) '$ 721%72 '(2 I02)'%$& 5(2'(2- '(2 J-2)%72&' )'%EE

    (6) 2H2-82&14 *$52-)K L0' 0&6LE2 '$ 72'2-H%&2 %& 5(%1( $+ '(2 6L$D2 16)2) '(2

    %))02 H64 *-$*2-E4 L2 721%727M %' 8-$0*27 '(2H '$82'(2-. N(2& '(2 242 $- '(2

    (6&7 %) 0&)0-2M %' %) L2)' '$ )($$' 6' +%D2 L%-7) %& 6 8-$0*F +%-%&8 6' $&2 6+'2-

    6&$'(2- H64 H26& 6) H6&4 H%))2).

    !' 7$2) &$' H6''2- '(6' '(2 +%-)' '5$ 16)2) (67 L22& )0LH%''27 6&7 D$'27 L2+$-2

    '(2 )0LH%))%$& $+ '(2 E6)' '(-22.

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    25/36

    !"

    !"#$%'(#&) $%& +,-$ $%,$ ."/$0-& 1,2033,) 4%03& 5&-#&$,#6 (+ ."/$0-&) %,2 ,270/&2

    $%& 1#&/02&8$ (8 $%& 9"&/$0(8 (+ &':&8-6 ;(4/) 2(&/ 8($ 20/9",30+6 %0' $(

    ,-$ 08 $%&/& -,/&/) +(# %& -,88($ %& 1#&/02&8$ 0/ 8($ %& , ;,#$6=

    ?33 $%& '&'ECS G=!"#$%&' )*+ ,-. /-0% 1-2/= T ?33 ',$$/ /"%& 4(#2

    Y,2U"20-,$0(8Y '&,8/ 2&-0/0(8= ? -,/& -,8 (##&/ 0/

    8($

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    26/36

    !"

    !" $%&"'()*%$ !+% *%&)()"', -'* +% (!).. /-0 *" (" 1)!+)' !+% 2%$)"* 2$"3)*%* 40

    !+% $5.%(, +% )( '"! 4"5'* !" 6".."1 !+% "2)')"' "6 +)( 2$%*%&%(("$, 1+)&+ +% /-0

    (%! -()*% -&&"$*)'7 !" 1+-! +% /-0 4%.)%3% !" 4% 6"$ !+% 4%(! )'!%$%(!( "6 85(!)&%9

    :% -$% "6 !+% "2)')"', !+%$%6"$%, !+-! !+% /"!)"' !" )'&.5*% !+% 3"!% -'* "2)')"'

    "6 !+% .-!% ;5(!)&%

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    27/36

    !"

    !"# %&'(!)!*!)&'+ ,")( !"#&-. )( /01# !& -#(! &' !"# 2-&*'1 !"0! (0)1 #3#4*!)5#

    &-1#-( /*(! 6# 4&'()1#-#1 0( 708(9 !"#. "05)'2 6##' )((*#1 6. !"# %")#:

    ;3#4*!)5# )' !"# #3#-4)(# &: !"# 7#2)(70!)5# *)-#1 :&- !"#)- '*77):)40!)&' !"# 5&!# &: !8& !")-1( &: 077 &: !"#/#/6#-( &: !"# %&*-!+ J*! F#3#4*!)5# &-1#-F 0'1 F-#2*70!)&'(F 8#-# 70!#-

    1#7#!#1 :-&/ !"# :)'07 1-0:! KA-*#2&9 ,"# L-0/)'2 &: !"# E")7)*07):. Q-+ G*(!)4#

    E01)7709 0'1 !"# /&!)&' !& )'47*1# !"# 5&!# &: !"# 70!# Q-+ G*(!)4# E#-:#4!& )' !"#

    1#4)()&' &: !"#(# 40(#(+ A'1 )! )( !"# ?*12/#'! &: !")( %&*-! !& 1#470-# ;3#4*!)5#

    R-1#-( S&(+ CCO 0'1 CCD9 '*77 0'1 5&)19 8)!" !"# 1)((#'! &: Q-+ G*(!)4# J#'2T&'9

    Q-+ G*(!)4# E01)770 0'1 Q-+ G*(!)4# U#.#(9 *

    !"#$%#& (#)#*& +$,-".,& (#/011#& 23#*.,& 4.,%$5#6.)& 7$6$* #,/ 2.))$*&

    889&4&'4*-+

    !"#$%&!"# 4&'4*--)'2X

    ,"# -#(*)()!# (!0'1)'2

    !& 0!!04W !"# 4&'(!)!*!)&'07)!. &: 0 (!0!*!#9 !"# 2#'#-07 -*7# )( !"0! '&! &'7.

    *#(!)&' !"# 4&'(!)!*!)&'07)!. &: (!0!*!#( -#>*)-)'2 #3

    8")4" 80( 60(#1 &' 0 1&4!-)'# 01"#-#1 !& &'7. )' :#8 ?*-)(1)4!)&' )' !"# @')!#1

    \!0!#(_ 6#40*(# ): 0 !03*)-)'2 !"# #3*#(!)&' !"# 507)1)!. &: (*4" 708( &- #3#4*!)5# &-1#-(+

    A:!#- 70.)'2 1&8' !"# :*'10/#'!07

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    28/36

    !"

    !"##$%& $( &)* +$,&%-%. #%$#$!/&/$, &)-& !-/0 1$22$,3*-4&) 5+& 6$7 89: /! !&/44

    /, ($%+* -,0; &)*%*($%*; &)* /!4-&/?* #$3*%!

    &)*%*/, 0*4*>-&*0 &$ )/27

    -&*0 &)* >$?*%,2*,&

    -"&)$%/&. &$ &)%** 0/((*%*,& -,0 !*#-%-&* J*#-%&2*,&!K B*>/!4-&/?*; A=*+"&/?*;

    -,0 L"0/+/-47 C, !*+&/$, :; 5%&/+4* MC; &)* 4*>/!4-&/?* #$3*% &$ 2-N* 4-3! /!

    +$,(*%%*0 "#$, 1$,>%*!!O &)* *=*+"&/?* #$3*% &$ (-/&)("44. *=*+"&*0 &)* 4-3! /!

    ?*!&*0 G. !*+&/$,! : -,0 :P $( 5%&/+4* MCC; /, &)* $?*%,2*,& &$ &)*

    B*>/!4-&/?*; A=*+"&/?*; -,0 L"0/+/-4 J*#-%&2*,&! $#*%-&*!; G. /2#4/+-&/$,; -! -,/,)/G/&/$, ->-/,!& &)* *=*%+/!* G. $,* 0*#-%&2*,& $( &)* #$3*%! 3)/+) G*4$,>

    &$ -,$&)*%; -,0 /2#$!*! "#$, *-+) $( &)* &)%** 0*#-%&2*,&! &)* 0"&. $(

    *=*%+/!/,> /&! $3, #*+"4/-% #$3*%! G. /&!*4(; -,0 #%$)/G/&! &)* 0*4*>-&/$, $( -,.

    $( &)$!* #$3*%! *=+*#& /, +-!*! *=#%*!!4. #*%2/&&*0 G. &)* 1$,!&/&"&/$,7 F)*

    #%/,+/#4* $( &)* !*#-%-&/$, $( &)* #$3*%! $( >$?*%,2*,& /! (",0-2*,&-4 &$ &)*

    ?*%. *=/!&*,+* $( - +$,!&/&"&/$,-4 >$?*%,2*,& -! *!&-G4/!)*0 /, &)* $?*%,2*,&-4 #$3*%! /,&$ 4*>/!4-&/?*; *=*+"&/?*; -,0 Q"0/+/-4 %*#%*!*,&! &)*

    2$!& /2#$%&-,& #%/,+/#4* $( >$?*%,2*,& &)-& >"-%-,&**! &)* 4/G*%&/*! $( &)*

    #*$#4*; ($% /& #%*?*,&! - +$,+*,&%-&/$, $( #$3*%! /, &)* )-,0! $( $,* #*%!$, $%

    +4-!! $( #*%!$,!7

    S,0*% &)* 0$+&%/,* $( !*#-%-&/$, $( &)* #$3*%! $( >$?*%,2*,&; &)* 4-3T2-N/,>

    (",+&/$,! /! -!!/>,*0 *=+4"!/?*4. &$ &)* 4*>/!4-&/?*; -,0 &)* 4*>/!4-&/?* G%-,+)

    +-,,$& 0*4*>-&* &)* #$3*% &$ 2-N* 4-3! &$ -,. $&)*% -"&)$%/&.7 U"& /& 2"!& G*

    G$%,* /, 2/,0 &)-& 3)-& +-,,$& G* 0*4*>-&*0 /! &)-& 3)/+) /! #"%*4. 4*>/!4-&/?*

    /, ,-&"%*; ,$& -02/,/!&%-&/?*7 F)*%* -%* #$3*%! !$ (-% 4*>/!4-&/?* &)-& 2-.

    #%$#*%4. G* *=*%+/!*0 G. &)* 4*>/!4-&"%*; G"& 3)/+) 2-. ,*?*%&)*4*!! G*

    0*4*>-&*0 G*+-"!* &)*. 2-. G* -0?-,&->*$"!4. *=*%+/!*0 /, #%$#*% +-!*! G.

    #*%!$,! G*4$,>/,> &$ &)* $&)*% 0*#-%&2*,&! $( &)* >$?*%,2*,&; !"+) -! &)*

    -"&)$%/&. &$ 2-N* %"4*! -,0 %*>"4-&/$,! $( -02/,/!&%-&/?* +)-%-+&*% &$ +-%%. $"&

    -, 4*>/!4-&/?* #"%#$!*! $% &$ *((*+& &)* $#*%-&/$, -,0 *,($%+*2*,& $( - 4-37 5!

    /44"!&%-&/$,! $( &)* #%$#*% *=*%+/!* $( &)* #$3*% $( 1$,>%*!! &$ 0*4*>-&* &)*

    -"&)$%/&. &$ #%$2"4>-&* %"4*! -,0 %*>"4-&/$,! 3/&) &)* ,*+*!!-%. 0*&-/4! &$

    +-%%. /,&$ *((*+& - 4-3; -%* 5+& 6$7 V:WW *2#$3*%/,> &)* X$?*%,$% X*,*%-4 &)*

    ,$3 &)* G*%>; W8 "4-&*

    &)$!* *,>->*0 /, ?-%/$"! $++"#-&/$,! $% G"!/,*!! -((*+&*0 3/&) - #"G4/+ /,&*%*!

    -,0 &$ #%*!+%/G* 3)-& &)* +)-%>*! !)-44 G* ($% !*%?/+*! %*,0*%*0 /, &)* +$,0"+&

    $( !"+) G"!/,*!! Y1*G" 5"&$G"! 1$7!"#J* L*!"!; W8 &)* "4-&/$,! &

    +-%%. $"& &)* *2*%>*,+. 2*-!"%* *,-+&*0 G. 1$,>%*!!; &)$">) - #-%& &)*%*$(

    3-! 0*+4-%*0 ",+$,!&/&"&/$,-4 ($% #%$0"+/,> - 0*4*>-&/$, $( 4*>/!4-&/?* -"&)$%/&

    3)/+) /! ",+$,(/,*0; I-,0 ,$& +-,-4/Z*0 3/&)/, G-,N! &$ N**# /& (%$2 *?*%

    (4$3/,>7I

    5&)$">); /, #%/,+/#4*; &)* #$3*% $( &)* B*>/!4-&"%* &$ 2-N* 4-3! $% #*%($%2 -+&

    #"%*4. 4*>/!4-&/?* /, ,-&"%* 2-. $,4. G* 0*4*>-&*0 G. 1$,>%*!! &$ -,$&)*%

    -"&)$%/&. $% $((/+*%! $( */&)*% &)* *=*+"&/?* $% Q"0/+/-4 0*#-%&2*,& 3)*,

    *=#%*!!4. #*%2/&&*0 G. &)* 1$,!&/&"&/$,; ,$ !"+) 0*4*>-&/$, /! -"&)$%/Z*0 G. &)R&-&* +$,!&/&"&/$, $% H*0*%-4 1$,!&/&"&/$, $( &)* S,&/*0 R&-&*!7 C& /! - (-+&

    -02/&&*0 G. &)* -&&$%,*.! -,0 -2/+/ +"%/-* ($% &)* #*&/&/$,*%! -,0 %*!#$,0*,&!

    /, &)*!* +-!* &)-& !*+&/$, [8; 5%&/+4* MC; $"% 1$,!&/&"&/$, /! ",/^"* -,0 )-! ,$

    +$",&*%#-%& /, !-/0 +$,!&/&"&/$,!; -,0 ($% &)-& %*-!$, ,$& - !/,>4* +-!* /,?$4?/,

    - ^"*!&/$, !/2/4-% &$ &)* $,* )*%*/, /,?$4?*0 )-! ,*?*% G**, !"G2/&&*0 &$ -,0

    #-!!*0 "#$, G. &)* +$"%&! $( 4-!& %*!$%& /, &)* S,/&*0 R&-&*!7 F)* #%$?/!/$, $(

    $"% 1$,!&/&"&/$, %*-0! -! ($44$3!K

    RA17 [87 C, &/2*! $( 3-% $% $&)*% ,-&/$,-4 *2*%>*,+.; &)* 1$,>%*!! 2-

    G. 4-3 -"&)$%/Z* &)* "4-&/$,! &$

    +-%%. $"& - 0*+4-%*0 ,-&/$,-4 #$4/+.7

    C& /! /2#$%&-,& &$ $G!*%?* &)-& 3)-& &)* -G$?*T^"$&*0 +$,!&/&"&/$,-4 #%$?/!/$,

    *2#$3*%! 1$,>%*!! &$ 0*4*>-&* &$ &)* "4-&/$,! $( -02/,/!&%-&/?* ,-&"%*; ($% &)/! 2-. -4!$ G*

    0*4*>-&*0 -& -,. &/2* 3/&)$"& ,*+*!!/&. $( -, *=#%*!! -"&)$%/&. G. &)*

    1$,!&/&"&/$,; G"& &)* #$3*% &$ #%$2"4>-&* %"4*! -,0 %*>"4-&/$,! #"%*4.

    4*>/!4-&/?* /, ,-&"%*; 4*-?/,> &$ &)* 0/!+%*&/$, $( &)* %*!! &$ 2-N* !"+) 0*4*>-&/$,7

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    29/36

    !"

    !"#$%&'()'*$%

    ',- ./01232423/0 5-67321 ./086-11 2/ 942,/63:- 2,- ;6-1335530-1

    2/ 56/74>892- 64>-1 90< 6-84>923/01 /= >-831>923?- 09246- /0>@ ABC 30 237-1 /= D96

    /6 AEC /2,-6 0923/09> -7-68-0F@G 14F, 91 6-H->>3/0G =>//-0F-G

    -F/0/73F 96 -7-68-0F@ 90< 2/ 942,/63:-2,- ;6-13892- 64>-1 90< 6-84>923/01 2/ F/5- D32, 32K ',-6-=/6-G 3=

    ./086-11 96-1 2,92 2,-6- -L312 9 D96 91 9 0923/09> -7-68-0F@ 90< -75/D-61

    2,- ;6-13892- 64>-1 90< 6-84>923/01 2/ 23922-6 F/4>< 0/2G H-F941- ,- H->3-?-1 2,92 2,-6- 31 90 -F/0/73F -7-68-0F@ /6

    =G -L-6F31- 2,- >-831>923?-

    5/D-6 -892-< 2/ 7--2 14F, -F/0/73F /6 /2,-6 -7-68-0F@K

    ',- ./01232423/0 6-I436-1 9>1/ 2,92 2,- -8923/0 H- =/6 9 >3732-< 5-63/< /6

    /2,-6 942,/632@ 1/ -892-< 1,9>> F-91-"#$% &'()% 92 2,- -L536923/0 /= 2,-

    5-63/-831>923/0 2/ 6-5-> /6 2-673092- 2,-

    -892-< >-831>923?- 942,/632@ /= 2,- ;6-13 1-596923/0 /= 5/D-61 30 /42 < H- /?-663@ 2 2/ 6-5-9> 32 30 14H1-6?3-02

    ./086-11 - V*G 1-F23/0 BPG /=

    2,- ./01232423/0G 2,- ;6-13923/01 91 ,- 79@ 3F@ 96-< 30 1-F23/0 B ,-6-/=K )FF/6@ ,- 31G 97/08

    /2,-6 2,3081G -75/D-6-< A'C 2/ 26901=-6 2,- 1-92 /= 2,-

    [/?-607-02 /6 90@ /= 321 14H2, 30F>4=3>> 321

    6-15/013H3>323-1 90< 2/ 79302930 90< -0=/6F- 321 942,/632@K

    &".K `K ',- ;6-1335530-1 1,9>> 91 1//0 91

    569F23F9H>- 45/0 2,- F/0?-0308 /= 2,- ./086-11 /= 2,-

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    30/36

    !"

    !"#$#%%#&'( *'%+*, ,"'*',+ -$$ ,"' *.$'( -&/ *'0.$-,#+&(

    %*+1.$0-,'/ 23 "#1 .&/'* ,"' %+4'*( "'*'#& 0*-&,'/5

    6785 95 :"#( ;-(#+& +@ ,"'

    !"#$#%%#&'( 23 ,"' '&'13? 4"#'*3? ,*-&(@'* +@ >'(('$( +4&'/ #& 4"+$' +* #& %-*,

    23 - -$ +@ ,"' !*'(#/'&, +@ ,"'

    !"#$#%%#&'(Z -&/ 8+11+&4'-$," ;#-$ +& 6'%,'12'* ^N? BD^D? - ("+*, ,#1' -@,'* ,"'

    #&>-(#+& +@ !+$-&/ 23 \'*1-&35

    A.*#&0 ,"' @+.*," (%'#(' -#,#'(? 23 %*'>'&,#&0

    +* *'$#'>#&0 .&'1%$+31'&,? 23 #&(.*#&0 ,+ ,"' %'+%$' -/'Y.-,' ("'$,'* -&/

    ' ,"' @+*' -.,"+*#,3 +@ ,"' !*'(#/'&, .&,#$ ,"' /-,' +@

    ,"' -/Q+.*&1'&, +@ ,"' &'I, *'0.$-* ('((#+& +@ ,"' 8+&0*'(( +@ ,"' !"#$#%%#&'(?

    #&(,'-/ +@ ,"' J-,#+&-$ ;(('12$3? ,"' 8+&(,#,.,#+& "->#&0 2''& -1'&/'/ 23

    (.2(,#,.,#&0 ,"' 8+&0*'(( +@ ,"' !"#$#%%#&'( @+* ,"' J-,#+&-$ ;(('12$355

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    31/36

    !"

    !"#$%&'$ )%**%+,-."#$ !/# 0%1 2334 .5 .*-+6-6 78 )%**%+,-."#$ !/# 0%1

    2934 :;%#$- ?;-5=6-+# =5 .$%;=@-6 #% :;%*&"'.#- ;&"-5 .+6

    ;-'&".#=%+5 ,$=/$ 5$."" $. N# =5 %7#%#." -*-;'-+/8> ,.5 #$- =+

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    32/36

    !"

    !"#$%!&'$(" *&'+," -. /0110*2"&!'3 45'% 60%7 898: 89;: 89>: ;>> &*?

    ;@> 2&% '0 '",1$*&'" &' '3" ?&'" 0A '3" &?B0+,*1"*' 0A '3" *"C' ,"#+!&, %"%%$0*

    0A '3" /0*#,"%% 0A '3" D3$!$EE$*"% $* F98;: -+' '30%" #,&*'"? '0 '3" D,"%$?"*' -.

    /0110*2"&!'3 45' 607 ;GF +*?", '3" %&1" 2&, "1",#"*5. %30+!? 50*'$*+" '0

    "C$%' $*?"A$*$'"!. "("* &A'", '3" /0*#,"%% 0A '3" D3$!$EE$*"% 3&? ,"#+!&,!.

    50*("*"?: &5'"?: &*? &?B0+,*"? $* '3" ."&, F98; &*? %+-%"H+"*' ."&,%7 I"%$?"%

    '0 #$(" %+53 50*%',+5'$0* '0 45' 607 ;GF 20+!? 1&J" $' ($0!&'$(" 0A '3" "CE,"%%

    E,0($%$0* 0A %"5'$0* @;: 4,'$5!" KLLL: 0A '3" /0*%'$'+'$0*: +*?", 23$53 %&$?

    /0110*2"&!'3 45' 607 ;GF 2&% "*&5'"?: &% "CE,"%%!. %'&'"? $* %&$? 45': &*?

    23$53 E",1$'% '3" /0*#,"%% '0 &+'30,$M" '3" D,"%$?"*': 0*!. A0, & !$1$'"? E",$0?

    ?+,$*# & 2&, "1",#"*5.: '0 E,01+!#&'" ,+!"% &*? ,"#+!&'$0*% '0 5&,,. $*'0 "AA"5'

    & ?"5!&,"? *&'$0*&! E0!$5.7

    I. '3" %E"5$&! %"%%$0* 0A '3" A$,%' /0*#,"%% 0A '3" D3$!$EE$*"% 5011"*5$*# 0*

    '3" 9'3 ?&. 0A N+*": F98=: 5&!!"? -. '3" D,"%$?"*' A0, '3" E+,E0%" 0A 50*%$?",$*#

    #"*",&! !"#$%!&'$0*: /0110*2"&!'3 45' 607 ;GF ?$? *0' 5"&%" '0 0E",&'"7 4% 2"

    3&(" &!,"&?. %&$?: '3" "1",#"*5. 23$53 E,01E'"? '3" %"50*? 6&'$0*&!

    4%%"1-!. '0 "*&5' /0110*2"&!'3 45' 607 ;GF ?"!"#&'$*# !"#$%!&'$(" E02",% '0

    '3" D,"%$?"*': 2&% '3" $*&-$!$'. 0A /0*#,"%% '0 50*("*" $* ,"#+!&, %"%%$0* $*

    N&*+&,. 0A "(",. ?+,$*# '3" $*(&%$0* 0A '3" D3$!$EE$*"% -. '3" N&E&*"%" L1E",$&!

    A0,5"%7 O3" 6&'$0*&! 4%%"1-!. 50+!? *0' 3&(" $* 1$*? &*. %E"5$&! %"%%$0* 23$531$#3' 3&(" -""* 5&!!"? -. '3" D,"%$?"*' $11"?$&'"!. &A'", !$-",&'$0*: -"5&+%"

    '3" 5&!!$*# 0A & %E"5$&! %"%%$0* &% 2"!! &% '3" 1&''",% 23$53 1&. -" %+-1$''"? -.

    '3" D,"%$?"*' '0 /0*#,"%% A0, 50*%$?",&'$0* $% & 50*'$*#"*' "("*' 23$53 ?"E"*?

    +E0* '3" E0%%$-$!$'. 0A 50*("*$*# $' &*? '3" ?$%5,"'$0* 0A '3" D,"%$?"*' '0 5&!! $':

    &*? '3" 1&''",% 3" 2$!! %+-1$' '0 $' A0, 50*%$?",&'$0*P -"5&+%" $' $% '0 -"

    E,"%+1"?: $* 0,?", '0 501E!. 2$'3 '3" E,0($%$0* 0A %"5'$0* @;: 4,'$5!" KL 0A '3"

    /0*%'$'+'$0*: '3&' $' 2&% '3" $*'"*'$0* 0A '3" 6&'$0*&! 4%%"1-!. '0 A$C & !$1$'"?

    E",$0?: $*?"E"*?"*' 0A '3" D,"%$?"*'Q% 2$!!: ?+,$*# 23$53 3" $% &+'30,$M"? '0

    "C",5$%" 3$% ?"!"#&'"? !"#$%!&'$(" E02",7

    O3" 0-B"5' 0A %"5'$0* R 0A 45' 607 ;GF $* ,"H+$,$*# '3" D,"%$?"*' '0 ,"E0,' S&%

    %00* &% E,&5'$5&-!" +E0* '3" 50*("*$*# 0A '3" /0*#,"%% 0A '3" D3$!$EE$*"% &!!,+!"% &*? ,"#+!&'$0*% E,01+!#&'"? -. 3$1 +*?", '3" E02",% '3","$* #,&*'"?S $%

    '0 $*A0,1 '3" /0*#,"%% 0A '3" 50*'"*'% 0A %&$? ,+!"% &*? ,"#+!&'$0*% %0 '3&' '3"

    !&''", 1&. 10?$A. 0, ,"E"&! '3"1 $A $' %""% A$' '0 ?0 %0: $*&%1+53 &%: &550,?$*# '0

    %"5'$0* 8 0A '3" %&1" 45': S'3" ,+!"% &*? ,"#+!&'$0*% E,01+!#&'"? 3","+*?",

    %3&!! -" $* A0,5" &*? "AA"5' +*'$! '3" /0*#,"%% %3&!! 0'3",2$%" E,0($?"7S 4*?

    &!'30+#3 %&$? %"5'$0* R ?0"% *0' %E"5$A. 23"'3", $* ,"#+!&, 0, %E"5$&! %"%%$0*: $'

    $% "($?"*' '3&' $' ,"A",% '0 '3" *"C' ,"#+!&, &*? *0' '0 '3" %E"5$&! %"%%$0* 0A '3"

    /0*#,"%%: -"5&+%" &% & ,+!" & %E"5$&! %"%%$0* $% 5&!!"? '0 50*%$?", 0*!. %E"5$A$5

    1&''",% %+-1$''"? -. '3" D,"%$?"*' '0 /0*#,"%% A0, 50*%$?",&'$0*: &*? $' 20+!?

    -" +%"!"%% '0 %+-1$' %+53 ,"E0,' '0 '3" /0*#,"%% $* %E"5$&! %"%%$0* $A '3" !&''",

    5&* *0' "$'3", 10?$A. 0, ,"E"&! %+53 ,+!"% &*? ,"#+!&'$0*%P &*? -"%$?"%: $' $% '0

    -" E,"%+1"? '3&' $' 2&% '3" $*'"*'$0* 0A '3" 6&'$0*&! 4%%"1-!. $* "*&5'$*#

    %"5'$0* R 0A /0110*2"&!'3 45' 607 ;GF '0 ,"H+$," '3" %+-1$%%$0* 0A & ,"E0,' '

    '3" *"C' ,"#+!&, %"%%$0* 0A '3" 4%%"1-!. 0, /0*#,"%%: &% E,0($?"? $* %"5'$0* 8

    /0110*2"&!'3 45' 607 ;>>: &% &1"*?"? -. /0110*2"&!'3 45' 607 ;@>: 23$5

    ,"H+$,"? & %$1$!&, ,"E0,': A0, '3"," 2&% &-%0!+'"!. *0 E!&+%$-!" ,"&%0* '0

    E,0($?" 0'3",2$%"7

    T+, 50*5!+%$0* $% 50,,0-0,&'"? -. '3" A&5' '3&' %"5'$0* R 0A 45' 607 ;GF 0*!.

    ,"H+$,"% '3" D,"%$?"*' '0 %+-1$' '3" ,"E0,': S&% %00* &% E,&5'$5&-!" +E0* '3"

    50*("*$*# 0A '3" /0*#,"%%S &*? *0' '0 %+-1$' & ,"E0,' '0 '3" /0*#,"%% "(",.

    '$1" $' 50*("*"%: $* 0,?", '0 $*A0,1 '3" /0*#,"%% '3","0A %0 '3&' '3" !&''", 1&.

    10?$A. 0, ,"E"&! &*. 0, &!! 0A '3"1: A0, +*?", %"5'$0* 8 0A '3" %&1" 45' S%+53

    ,+!"% &*? ,"#+!&'$0*% %3&!! 50*'$*+" $* A0,5" &*? "AA"5' +*'$! '3" /0*#,"%% %3&!!

    0'3",2$%" E,0($?"7S L' $% 0-($0+% '3&' '3" 50*("*$*# 0A '3" /0*#,"%% ,"A",,"? '0

    $* %&$? %"5'$0* R $% '3" *"C' ,"#+!&, %"%%$0* 0A '3" /0*#,"%% &A'", '3" E&%%" 0A

    45' 607 ;GF: &*? *0' &*. 0'3", %+-%"H+"*' %"%%$0*P -"5&+%": 0'3",2$%": $' 20+!

    *0' 3&(" ,"H+$,"? '3&' $' %3&!! -" %+-1$''"? '0 '3" /0*#,"%% &% %00* &%

    E,&5'$5&-!" &*? '3" E+,E0%" 0A '3" !&2 &!,"&?. %'&'"? $* ,"H+$,$*# '3"

    %+-1$%%$0* 0A '3" ,"E0,' 20+!? -" ?"A"&'"?P &*? $A $' 2"," '3" $*'"*'$0* 0A %&$?

    /0110*2"&!'3 45' 607 ;GF '0 &+'30,$M" '3" D,"%$?"*' '0 50*'$*+"E,01+!#&'$*# ,+!"% &*? ,"#+!&'$0*% &A'", '3" *"C' ,"#+!&, %"%%$0* 0A '3"

    /0*#,"%%: $' 20+!? 3&(" ,"H+$,"? '3" D,"%$?"*' '0 %+-1$' '0 '3" /0*#,"%% "&53

    &*? "(",. '$1" $' 50*("*"% & ,"E0,' 0A '3" ,+!"% &*? ,"#+!&'$0*% E,01+!#&'"?

    &A'", 3$% E,"($0+% ,"E0,'% 3&? -""* %+-1$''"?7

    U+,'3",10,": 0+, 50*5!+%$0* $% 50*A$,1"? -. '3" !"#$%!&'$(" $*'",E,"'&'$0* #$("

    '0 /0110*2"&!'3 45' 607 ;GF -. '3" %&1" /0*#,"%% $* "*&5'$*#

    /0110*2"&!'3 45' 607 G@< 23$53 '00J "AA"5' 0* N+!. @: F98;: &+'30,$M$*# '3"

    D,"%$?"*' '0 ,"#+!&'": 50*',0!: 5+,'&$!: &*? E,03$-$' '3" "CE!0,&'$0* 0A

    ,$5+!'+,&! 0, $*?+%',$&! E,0?+5'%: 1",53&*?$%": &,'$5!"%: 1&'",$&!% &*? %+EE!$"

    2$'30+' '3" E",1$' 0A '3" D,"%$?"*' +*'$! V"5"1-", RF: F98< &% "CE,"%%!.

    E,0($?"? $* %"5'$0* 8 '3","0A: -"5&+%" $' 20+!? *0' 3&(" -""* *"5"%%&,. A0, '3"/0*#,"%% '0 E,01+!#&'" %&$? 45' 607 G@< $A '3" D,"%$?"*' 3&? &+'30,$'. '0

    E,01+!#&'" WC"5+'$(" T,?", 607 ;@ $* H+"%'$0* 0* N&*+&,. F: F989: +*?",

    /0110*2"&!'3 45' 607 ;GF &% 50*'"*?"? -. '3" ,"%E0*?"*'%P &*? X"E+-!$5 45

    607 =F: &EE,0("? 0* T5'0-", 8: F98;: &+'30,$M$*# 2$'3$* 0*" ."&, '3" ?$AA","*'

    "C"5+'$(" ?"E&,'1"*'%: -+%$*"%%: 0AA$5"%: "*5$"% &*? 0'3", $*%',+1"*'&!$'$"% 0

    '3" #0(",*1"*': $*5!+?$*# 50,E0,&'$0*% 50*',0!!"? -. $': 20+!? *0' 3&(" -""*

    E&%%"? -. '3" /0*#,"%% $A /0110*2"&!'3 45' 607 ;GF +*?", 50*%$?",&'$0* 2&%

    '3"* %'$!! $* A0,5": A0, %"5'$0* @ Y-Z &*? Y5Z 0A %&$? 45' 607 ;GF &+'30,$M"% '3"

    D,"%$?"*' '0 ,"0,#&*$M" '3" [0(",*1"*' &*? '0 5,"&'" *"2 %+-?$($%$0*%:

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    33/36

    !"

    !"#$%&'() +',#"-.'$- /001%'() #2'$%1'( /" 1$(-"3.'$-#41-1'( /0 2/5'"$.'$-) #$+

    -/ #!/41(& #$6 /0 -&/(' #4"'#+6 '71(-1$28

    9:;=?@A

    =&'"' 1( $/ 0/"%' 1$ -&' #"23.'$- -- -&' '7'%3-15' /"+'"( 1$ B3'(-1/$ #"' $/-

    5#41+) $/- !'%#3(' -&' ,"/.342#-1/$ /0 -&' #%-( #!/5' .'$-1/$'+ #$+ /0

    C/../$D'#4-& >%- A/8 EFG #( #.'$+'+ !6 -&' 9',3!41% >%- A/8 EE /$ "'$-#4()

    -&' #,,"/,"1#-1/$ #%-( /" 9',3!41% >%- A/(8 H) HIE) #$+ JKL 0/" -&' 6'#"( HGMENMO) HGMONMF #$+ HGMFNMG) #$+ /0 -&' 9',3!41% >%-( A/(8 OJ) HMO) #$+ KJI

    #,,"/,"1#-1$2 ,3!41% 01$+( -/ +'0"#6 -&' '7,'$('( 0/" -&' '4'%-1/$( &'4+ 1$ HGMO

    #$+ HGMF) (&/D( -- -&' '.'"2'$%6 ,/D'"( 2"#$-'+ !6 C/../$D'#4-& >%- A/8

    EOH + #4"'#+6 %'#('+ -/ '71(-) !3- !'%#3(' C/$2"'(( P( (&/D$ !6 -&'1"

    '$#%-.'$- 1-( "'#+1$'(( #$+ #!141-6 -/ 4'21(4#-' /$ -&/(' .#--'"() #$+ +

    D1-&+"#D$ 1- 0"/. -&' "'#4. /0 ,"'(1+'$-1#4 4'21(4#-1/$ /" "'234#-1/$( 3$+'" -&'

    ,/D'"( +'4'2#-'+ !6 C/../$D'#4-& >%- A/8 EOH8P ?0 -&' C/$2"'(( D#( "'#+6

    #$+ #!4' -/ 4'21(4#-' /$ -&/(' .#--'"( (1$%' HGME #$+ 0/" -- "'#(/$ -&'

    '7'%3-15' /"+'"( &'"'1$ 1$5/45'+ #"' $344 #$+ 5/1+) -&'"' 1( $/ 5#41+ "'#(/$ 0/"

    $/- %/$%43+1$2 -- -&' '.'"2'$%6 ,/D'"( /0 -&' ;"'(1+'$- ( %'#('+ -/ '71(- 1-

    +1+ $/-) 4'21(4#-' /$ #44 .#--'"( /$ D&1%& -&' ;"'(1+'$- D#( 2"#$-'+ #$+

    +'4'2#-'+ ,/D'" -/ 4'21(4#-' !6 -&' C/../$D'#4-& >%- A/8 EOH8 >$+ 10C/../$D'#4-& >%- A/8 EOH %/$-1$3'( -/ !' 1$ 0/"%' #$+ '00'%- 1$ (/ 0#" #( 1-

    2"#$-( +'4'2#-'+ 4'21(4#-15' ,/D'"( -/ -&' ;"'(1+'$- #$+ +'%4#"'( -&' $#-1/$#4

    ,/41%6 -/ !' %#""1'+ /3- !6 -&' "34'( #$+ "'234#-1/$( -&' ;"'(1+'$- 1( #3-&/"1Q'

    -/ ,"/.342#-') -&' .'"' ,"/.342#-1/$ /0 -&' #%-( #!/5' +'(%"1!'+ %#$ $/- !'

    %/$(1+'"'+ #( #$ 1.,41'+ "','#4 /" D1-&+"#D#4 /0 -&' #3-&/"1-6 /0 -&' ;"'(1+'$-

    -/ ,"/.342#-'( "34'( #$+ "'234#-1/$( /$46 /$ -&/(' .#--'"() #$+ -&' #+/,-1/$ /0

    # %/$-"#"6 ,/41%6 !6 -&' C/$2"'(() !'%#3(' 1.,41'+ "','#4 1( $/- 0#5/"'+ 1$

    (-#-3-/"6 %/$(-"3%-1/$) #$+ -&' $#-1/$#4 ,/41%6 "'0'""'+ -/ 1$ ('%-1/$ KE) >"-1%4'

    R??? /0 -&' C/$(-1-3-1/$ 1( -/ !' +'%4#"'+ !6 -&' C/$2"'(( 1$ +'4'2#-1$2 -&'

    4'21(4#-15' ,/D'"( -/ -&' ;"'(1+'$-) 1$ /"+'" -/ '(-#!41(& -&' (-#$+#"+ -/ !'

    %#""1'+ /3- !6 &1. 1$ '7'"%1(1$2 &1( +'4'2#-'+ 03$%-1/$() #$+ $/- 1$ "','#41$2

    (#1+ ,/D'"(8

    >( D' ' #4"'#+6 (#1+) ('%-1/$ KE) >"-1%4' R? /0 -&' C/$(-1-3-1/$ '7,"'((46

    '.,/D'"( C/$2"'(() 1$ -1.'( /0 D#" #$+ /-&'" $#-1/$#4 '.'"2'$%6) -/ #3-&/"1Q'

    -&' ;"'(1+'$- -/ ,"/.342#-' "34'( #$+ "'234#-1/$( -/ %#""6 /3- # +'%4#"'+

    $#-1/$#4 ,/41%6) #$+ -&'"'0/"' 1- 1( 0/" -&' A#-1/$#4 >(('.!46 -/ +'-'".1$' -&'

    '71(-'$%' /0 # ,#"-1%34#" '.'"2'$%6 +'%4#"' -&' $#-1/$#4 ,/41%6) #$+ #3-&/"1Q'

    -&' ;"'(1+'$- -/ ,"/.342#-' "34'( #$+ "'234#-1/$( /0 4'21(4#-15' $#-3"' -/ %#""6

    /3- -- ,/41%68 >( -&' C/../$D'#4-& >%- A/8 EOH -- -&' !"#$%!&'! )*

    +,-!'-D''$ -&' $- 1- 1( '51+'$-) #$+ -&'"'0/"' $/ '51+'$%' 1( "'B31"'( -/ ,"/5') -- -&'

    '71(-'$%' /0 -&' D#" D&1%& 1$5/45'+ -&' ;&141,,1$'( + #4"'#+6 %'#('+ !'0/"'

    -&' ,"/.342#-1/$ /0 -&' '7'%3-15' /"+'"( 1$ B3'(-1/$) /" #- 4'#(-) 10 -&' 4#(- D#"

    ( $/- 6'- -'%&$1%#446 -'".1$#-'+ 1$ (/ 0#" #( -&' %- A/8 EOH (&/34+

    !' %/$(-"3'+ -/ .'#$ #$6 '.'"2'$%6 "'(34-1$2 0"/. /" -- 1( -&' '00'%- /0 -&'

    4#(- D#") #$+ $/- -&' D#" '.'"2'$%6 1-('40) #$+ -- -&'"'0/"' 1- 1( 0/" -&';"'(1+'$- -/ +'-'".1$' D&'-&'" #- -&' -1.' /0 -&' ,"/.342#-1/$ /0 -&' '7'%3-15

    /"+'"( 3$+'" %/$(1+'"#-1/$ (3%& '.'"2'$%6 (-144 '71(-'+) !'%#3(' (3%&

    %/$-'$-1/$ D/34+ .#V' >%- A/8 EOH 3$%/$(-1-3-1/$#4 /" 51/4#-15' /0 -&'

    ,"/51(1/$( /0 ('%-1/$ KE) >"-1%4' R? /0 -&' C/$(-1-3-1/$8 =&1( %/$(-1-3-1/$#4

    ,"'%',- +1(-1$231(&'( +,- !.!-/!&'00"/. #$6 /-&'" $#-1/$#4 '.'"2'$%6) (3%&

    #( #$ '%/$/.1% +',"'((1/$ #$+ /-&'"( D&1%& .#6 !' -&' '00'%- /0 # D#") #$+

    '.,/D'"( -&' C/$2"'(( 1$ -1.'( /0 D#" #$+ /-&'" $#-1/$#4 '.'"2'$%6) -/ !'

    +'-'".1$'+ !6 C/$2"'(( 1-('40 #( D' ' #4"'#+6 (#1+ #$+ (&/D$) -/ #3-&/"1Q'

    -&' ;"'(1+'$-) 0/" # 1#.#%!2 3!-#)2-- .#6 (&/"- /" /0 -&' (#.' +3"#-1/$ !3- $/

    4/$2'" -$ -- /0 -&' '.'"2'$%6) -/ ,"/.342#-' "34'( #$+ "'234#-1/$( -/ %#""6

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    34/36

    !!

    !"# #%& '!()*+ ,&*(-.&, /+ #%& 0!12.&33 )1 !.,&. #! 4& #%& &4&.2&1*+5 6!

    *!13#."& 0!44!17&-(#% 8*# 9!5 :;< -3 *!1#&1,&, 7!"(, /& #! (&-=& #%&

    ,&.4)1-#)!1 !> #%& &?)3#&1*& !> #%& &4&.2&1*+ #! #%& ,)3*.)!1 !> #%&

    @.&3),&1#A /&*-"3& #%& &>>&*#3 !> #%& 7-. 3"*% -3 #%!3& &1"4&.-#&, /+ #%&

    .&3'!1,&1#3 -.& 1!# ,&.4)1&, !. 3#-#&, )1 3-), 8*# -1, *!"(, 1!# %-=& /&&1

    >!.&3&&1 /+ #%& 833&4/(+ )1 &1-*#)12 3-), 8*#B -1, /&*-"3& )# 7!"(, 4-C& #%&

    ,&(&2-#)!1 !> '!7&.3 >!. -1 )1 ,&>)1)#& '&.)!,A 3)1*& 3"*% -1 &4&.2&1*+ 4-+ !.

    4-+ 1!# /&*!4& ,&'.&33)!1A &>>&*# !> #%& >).3# 7!.(, 7-.A #!!C '(-*& )1 #%& +&-.

    -)(".& !> #%&

    0!12.&33 #! -''.!'.)-#& >"1,3 >!. #%& !'&.-#)!1 !> #%& F!=&.14&1# ,".)12 #%&

    '&.)!, >.!4 G"(+

    9!=&4/&.A )1-(

    -"#%!.)#+ #! ,&.4)1& 7%%&. -1 &4&.2&1*+ )1 >-*# &?)3#35 O84&.)*-1

    G".)3'.",&1*&A P!(5 QLA '-2& DRJ5S5

    9! *-3& ,&*),&, /+ #%& *!".#3 !> (-3# .&3!.# )1 #%& T1)#&, N#-#&3 4-+ /& *)#&, )1

    3"''!.# !> #%& '.!'!3)#)!1 #%-# )# )3 >!. #%& @.&3),&1# #! ,&.4)1& 7%%&.

    #%&.& &?)3# -1 &4&.2&1*+ )1 !.,&. #! &?&.*)3& %)3 &4&.2&1*+ '!7&.3A -1, U)# )3

    1!# >!. #%& V",)*)-.+ #! .&=)&7 #%& >)1,)12 !> #%& W?&*"#)=& )1 #%)3 .&2-.,5U 6%&.&

    )3 1!1& -1, #%&.& *-11!# /& -1+5 X&*-"3&A -3 7& %-=& -(.&-,+ 3#-#&, -# #%&

    /&2)11)12 !> #%)3 !')1)!1A -1, 7& -.& 3"''!.#&, /+ #%& -/!=& M"!#-#)!1 >.!4

    84&.)*-1 G".)3'.",&1*&A #%& '!7&. #! '-33 &4&.2&1*+ '!()*& (&2)3(-#)!1 )1 #%&

    T1)#&, N#-#&3 4-+ /& &?&.*)3&, !1(+ /+ #%& (&2)3(-#".& )1 #%& &?&.*)3& !> #%&

    '!()*& '!7&. !> #%& N#-#&A -1, )# *-1 1!# /& ,&(&2-#&, #! #%& W?&*"#)=& /&*-"3&

    #%&.& )3 1! '.!=)3)!1 )1 #%& N#-#& -1, Y&,&.-( *!13#)#"#)!13 -"#%!.)Z)12 3"*%

    ,&(&2-#)!1 -3 7& %-=& )1 3&*#)!1 E:A 8.#)*(& PLA !> !". 0!13#)#"#)!15 83 7& %-=&-(.&-,+ 3-), /&>!.&A #%& !1(+ (&2)3(-#)=& '!7&. 7%)*% 4-+ /& ,&(&2-#&, #! #%&

    W?&*"#)=& -1, !#%&. -,4)1)3#.-#)=& /!,)&3 !. !>>)*&.3 )1 #%& T1)#&, N#-#&3 )3 #%&

    '!7&. #! '.!4"(2-#& ."(&3 -1, .&2"(-#)!13 !> -,4)1)3#.-#)=& 1-#".&A 7%)*% ,!&3

    1!# )1*(",& #%& &?&.*)3& !> #%& '!()*& '!7&. !> #%& N#-#&5

    6%& ."()12 (-), ,!71 /+ #%& T1)#&, N#-#&3 N"'.&4& 0!".# )1 #%& *-3& !> !"#$%&$

    ()* +,-&./)A DE [-7 &,5A #%& '.!'!3)#)!1 #%-# U!1(+ )1 *-3& !> - 4-1)>&3# -/"3& !> #%& &?&.*)3&

    !> '!7&.3 /+ - '!()#)*-( /.-1*% !> #%& 2!=&.14&1# )3 V",)*)-( )1#&.>&.&1*&

    -((!7-/(& )1 !.,&. #! 4-)1#-)1 #%& 3"'.&4-*+ !> #%& 0!13#)#"#)!1AU %-3 1!

    -''()*-#)!1 #! #%& '.&3&1# *-3&B /&*-"3& #%& M"&3#)!1 )1=!(=&, )1 #%& '.&3&1#

    *-3& )3 1!# - '!()#)*-( /"# - V"3#)*)-/(& M"&3#)!1A 7%)(& #%& M"&3#)!1 )1 )33"& )1

    3-), [",&*C& *-3& 7-3 #%& '!7&. !> #%& *!".# #! .&=)&7 U#%& ,&.4)1-#)!1 !>

    #%& @.&3),&1# )1 #%& '!3#7-. '&.)!, #%-# -1 -()&1 &1&4+ 3%!"(, /& ,&'!.#&,A

    &=&1 #%!"2% -*#)=& %!3#)()#)&3 %-=& *&-3&,AU -1, )# 7-3 %&(, #%-# )# 7-3 - '!()#)*

    M"&3#)!1 -1,A #%&.&>!.&A 7-3 1!# 3"/V&*# #! V",)*)-( .&=)&75

    0\90[TNL\9

    L1 =)&7 !> -(( #%& >!.&2!)12A 7& %-=& #! *!1*(",& -1, ,&*(-.& #%-# #%& &?&*"#)=&

    !.,&.3 '.!4"(2-#&, /+ #%& @.&3),&1# "1,&. 0!44!17&-(#% 8*# :;< /&>!.& #%&

    ,-#& !> #%& -,V!".14&1# !> #%& .&2"(-. 3&33)!1 !> #%& 0!12.&33 !1 #%&

    @%)()'')1&3 )1 #&. #%& 3-), ,-#& -.& 1"(( -1,

    =!),A /&*-"3& 0!44!17&-(#% 8*# 9!5 :;< %-, -(.&-,+ *&-3&, #! /& )1 >!.*& )1

    3! >-. -3 #%& ,&(&2-#)!1 !> '!7&.3 7-3 *!1*&.1&,5 6%&.&>!.&A -.& 1"(( -1, =!),

    #%& W?&*"#)=& \.,&. 9!5 .!4 #%& @%)()'')1&3B #%& W?&*"#)=& \.,&. 9!5 EEK ,-#&, G"1& #%& F!=&.14&1# !> #%& ^&'"/()*

    !> #%& @%)()'')1&3 ,".)12 #%& '&.)!, >.!4 G"(+

    9!=&4/&.A

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    35/36

    #

    'D#8*;"D"/, *+ ,-" %8""=: /*, ,* "P(""= +';" -$/=8"= -"2= #"8

    2//$DS 9*":1;$;< 3"=$:$*: >-2, ,-" H'8"(,*8 *+ 6?8'($&,$8"

    0-2&& '/ 2&& (20"0 #"8D', ,-" 'D#*8,2,'*/: %8'/?'/? *8

    '/,8*=$(,'*/ *+ =82+, (2,,&" 2/= %*;'/" (2,,&" +*8 ,-"

    D2/$+2(,$8" *+ 0"8$DS 9*":1;$;< )'*.3$*: >-2, 2&& &';" (2,,&"

    +8*D +*8"'?/ (*$/,8'"0 ,-" 'D#*8,2,'*/: %8'/?'/? *8

    '/,8*=$(,'*/ *+ C-'(- '/,* ,-" B0&2/=0 '0 2$,-*8'`"= %@ ,-'0 6(,:

    0-2&& %" 0$%D',,"= ,* 8"?$&2,'*/0 '00$"= %@ ,-" H'8"(,*8 *+

    6?8'($&,$8": C',- ,-" 2##8*;2& *+ ,-" -"2= *+ ,-" ="#28,D"/,:

    #8'*8 ,* 2$,-*8'`'/? ',0 ,82/0+"8 ,* *,-"8 #8*;'/("028'++ O2C< B, '0 /*, 2 ,28'++ D"20$8" %$, 2 I$282/,'/" D"20$8

    2 0,2,$," 2=*#,"= $/="8 ,-" #*&'(" #*C"8 *+ ,-" .-'&'##'/" U*;"8/D"/,< B, '0 2,

  • 8/10/2019 Cruz vs Youngberg, 56 Phil 234

    36/36

    $

    D*0, 2 f0$##&"D"/,g *8 2/ f2==','*/g ,* ,-" >28'++ O2C< YF"" 12(O"28@ :#