1
Two Real-Time PCR assays were selected for further analysis to investigate efficiency, sensitivity and specificity. Both assays demonstrated: Efficiency close to 100% and Sensitivity 1-10 genomic copies 100 % specificity (Figure 5C) Conclusion is investigation has confirmed that C.sakazakii is genetically diverse and requires accurate identification. We developed highly specific, sensitive Real-Time PCR assays to detect Cronobacter sakazakii. e assays were validated using a set of ATCC C.sakazakii target strains and carefully selected set of closely related species – anti-targets. e assays were also validated in different laboratories. Good correlation of C.sakazakii detection by Real-Time PCR and standard methods was demonstrated. Acknowledgements e authors would like to acknowledge Drs. Elena Bolchakova and James Bruce for scientific support Legal Statements: For Research Use Only. Not for use in diagnostic procedures. © Copyright 2008.Applied Biosystems. All rights reserved. AB (Design) and Applied Biosystems are registered trademarks of Applied Biosystems or its subsidiaries in the U.S. and/or certain other countries. TaqMan is a registered trademark of Roche Molecular Systems, Inc. e specific C.sakazakii genomic fragment –potential identification signature - was identified using whole genome comparison analysis A set of Real-time PCR assays were designed to probe the identified signature fragment for specific detection of the target C.sakazakii DNA. Twenty assays were designed and tested. Eight assays detect three target C.sakazakii strains (assays #2, 10, 11, 14, 15, 16, 19, 20) . One assay (#1) detected all four target strains. One out of four C.sakazakii strains demonstrated significantly different response when the strains were tested with Real-Time PCR assays e strain ATCC 51329 was further investigated using sequencing based MicoSeq system and phylogenetic analysis We compared all four C.sakazakii sequences and several closely related organisms (Figure 4A and 4B). ATCC 51329 strain was identified as Enterobacter hormaechei (Enterobacter hormaechei was first identified as a unique species in 1989) Cronobacter sakazakii Real-Time PCR Detection: Sample Characterization, Assay Design and Validation A. H. Wong, L. Wong, P. Brzoska, T. Schild, M. R. Furtado and O. Petrauskene. Applied Biosystems, Foster City CA 94404 Abstract Background: Cronobacter sakazakii is a gram-negative bacterium within the family Enterobacteriaceae. It is found throughout the environment. Powdered milk-based infant formulas have been associated with C.sakazakii-related outbreaks in premature or other immunocompromised infants. e case-fatality rate varies from 40-80 % among newborns diagnosed with this type of infection. e conventional method approved by the FDA requires 5 days for detection. Methods: Quantitative real-time PCR is used in a wide variety of molecular applications, e.g. gene expression analysis and accurate detection of pathogen levels. To improve sensitivity and shorten detection time we designed a TaqMan® Pathogen Detection assay for C.sakazakii. Having extremely limited sequence information for C.sakazakii we decided to sequence and analyze a number of genomic fragments as potential targets for TaqMan assay designs. ese targets included the RNaseP gene and several regions selected by our Bioinfomatics algorithms. Results: Using the new sequence information we designed two Real-Time PCR assays to detect C.sakazakii. e assays were tested with four ATCC C.sakazakii strains which were characterized by 16S ribosomal DNA sequencing using Applied Biosystems’ MicroSeq system. Specificity of the assays was confirmed using a wide panel of non-C.sakazakii strains including Salmonella, Shigella, E.Coli, Citrobacter and Listeria species, as well as Enterobacter species: E.nimipressuralis, E.dissolvens, E.cloacae and E.aerogenes. Here we demonstrate that the assays have near 100% PCR amplification efficiency and a high degree of specificity for the selective amplification of targeted genes in the presence of closely related targets. Next step: Customer validation –we performed in collaboration with different laboratories. Real- Time PCR results were compared with ISO Method. Overall good correlation between standard methods and real-time PCR results was demonstrated. Conclusions: is investigation has confirmed that C.sakazakii is genetically diverse and requires accurate identification. Enhanced detection assays were designed to enable specific and highly sensitive screening of Cronobacter sakazakii. Introduction Real-time PCR detection of microorganisms in food and environment has become an important part of biothreat monitoring and epidemiological studies. Traditional culture based methods are laborious, time consuming and oſten hampered by slow growth of many organisms. We designed and tested Real-time PCR specific detection assays for detection of Cronobacter sakazakii in screening environment or food samples. Study Design We designed and tested Real-time PCR specific assays for detection of Cronobacter sakazakii based on specific C.sakazakii genomic fragment Target organisms were selected from the ATCC panel: ATCC 12868, ATCC 29004, ATCC 29544 and ATCC 51329 To demonstrate specificity of the designed assays closely related organisms were selected based on two criteria: close proximity on the phylogenetic tree and potential presence in the same location Assay #11 – target DNA Assay #16 – target DNA Assay #11 – target DNA Assay #11 – target DNA Assay #16 – target DNA Anti-target Panel Sample Name Copy no. Avg. Stdev Avg. Stdev FAM Ct VIC Ct Assay11_citrobacter 2000000 45 0 29.25 0.25 Assay11_E.aero 2000000 45 0 29.21 0.13 Assay11_E.cloacae 2000000 45 0 29.19 0.02 Assay11_E.ColiK12 2000000 45 0 29.20 0.21 Assay11_E.diss 2000000 45 0 29.02 0.03 Assay11_E.nimi 2000000 45 0 29.21 0.08 Assay11_Listeria 2000000 45 0 29.10 0.01 Assay11_NTC1 2000000 45 0 29.05 0.07 Assay11_NTC2 2000000 45 0 29.16 0.10 Assay11_NTC3 2000000 45 0 28.97 0.11 Assay11_NTC4 2000000 45 0 29.03 0.13 Assay11_Salmonella 2000000 45 0 29.09 0.08 Assay11_Salmonella anatum 2000000 45 0 29.13 0.18 Assay11_Salmonella dublin 2000000 45 0 29.16 0.04 Assay11_Salmonella entr 2000000 45 0 29.36 0.10 Assay11_Salmonella typh 2000000 45 0 29.03 0.05 Assay11_Shingella 2000000 45 0 29.19 0.21 Assay16_citrobacter 2000000 45 0 28.78 0.26 Assay16_E.aero 2000000 45 0 29.03 0.12 Assay16_E.cloacae 2000000 45 0 29.05 0.08 Assay16_E.ColiK12 2000000 45 0 29.17 0.03 Assay16_E.diss 2000000 45 0 29.00 0.11 Assay16_E.nimi 2000000 45 0 29.08 0.11 Assay16_Listeria 2000000 45 0 29.18 0.10 Assay16_NTC1 2000000 45 0 29.08 0.20 Assay16_NTC2 2000000 45 0 29.02 0.13 Assay16_NTC3 2000000 45 0 28.97 0.06 Assay16_NTC4 2000000 45 0 29.09 0.15 Assay16_Salmonella 2000000 45 0 29.18 0.01 Assay16_Salmonella anatum 2000000 45 0 29.10 0.11 Assay16_Salmonella dublin 2000000 45 0 29.22 0.01 Assay16_Salmonella entr 2000000 45 0 29.20 0.18 Assay16_Salmonella typh 2000000 45 0 29.23 0.09 Assay16_Shingella 2000000 45 0 29.25 0.21 Cronobacter sakazakii assays target test with 4 ATCC DNA strains 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Assay ID Ct 12868 29004 29544 51329 Figure 2 Validation panel 16S Phylogenetic tree Figure 4A Figure 4B Figure 3 Figure 5A Figure 5B Figure 5C 100 % match to C. sakazakii ~100 % match to E. Hormachei ATCC 29544 C. sakazakii ATCC 51329 Figure 1

Cronobacter sakazakii Real-Time PCR Detection: … · ATCC 51329 strain was identified as Enterobacter hormaechei (Enterobacter hormaechei was first identified as a unique species

  • Upload
    hatram

  • View
    220

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Cronobacter sakazakii Real-Time PCR Detection: … · ATCC 51329 strain was identified as Enterobacter hormaechei (Enterobacter hormaechei was first identified as a unique species

•Two Real-Time PCR assays were selected for further analysis to investigate efficiency, sensitivity and specificity.

•Both assays demonstrated: ➢ Efficiency close to 100% and Sensitivity 1-10 genomic copies ➢ 100 % specificity (Figure 5C)

ConclusionThisinvestigationhasconfirmedthat C.sakazakiiisgeneticallydiverseandrequiresaccurateidentification.Wedevelopedhighlyspecific,sensitiveReal-TimePCRassaystodetectCronobactersakazakii.TheassayswerevalidatedusingasetofATCCC.sakazakiitargetstrainsandcarefullyselectedsetofcloselyrelatedspecies–anti-targets.Theassayswerealsovalidatedindifferentlaboratories.GoodcorrelationofC.sakazakiidetectionbyReal-TimePCRandstandardmethodswasdemonstrated.

Acknowledgements TheauthorswouldliketoacknowledgeDrs.ElenaBolchakovaandJamesBrucefor

scientificsupport

Legal Statements:For Research Use Only. Not for use in diagnostic procedures. ©Copyright 2008.Applied Biosystems. All rights reserved. AB (Design) and Applied Biosystems are registered trademarks of Applied Biosystems or its subsidiaries in the U.S. and/or certain other countries. TaqMan is a registered trademark of Roche Molecular Systems, Inc.

•The specific C.sakazakii genomic fragment –potential identification signature - was identified using whole genome comparison analysis

•A set of Real-time PCR assays were designed to probe the identified signature fragment for specific detection of the target C.sakazakii DNA. Twenty assays were designed and tested. Eight assays detect three target C.sakazakii strains (assays #2, 10, 11, 14, 15, 16, 19, 20) . One assay (#1) detected all four target strains.

•One out of four C.sakazakii strains demonstrated significantly different response when the strains were tested with Real-Time PCR assays

•The strain ATCC 51329 was further investigated using sequencing based MicoSeq system and phylogenetic analysis

•We compared all four C.sakazakii sequences and several closely related organisms (Figure 4A and 4B). ATCC 51329 strain was identified as Enterobacter hormaechei (Enterobacter hormaechei wasfirstidentifiedasauniquespeciesin1989)

Cronobacter sakazakii Real-Time PCR Detection: Sample Characterization, Assay Design and ValidationA. H. Wong, L. Wong, P. Brzoska, T. Schild, M. R. Furtado and O. Petrauskene. Applied Biosystems, Foster City CA 94404

Abstract

Background: Cronobacter sakazakiiisagram-negativebacteriumwithinthefamilyEnterobacteriaceae.Itisfoundthroughouttheenvironment.Powderedmilk-basedinfantformulashavebeenassociatedwithC.sakazakii-relatedoutbreaksinprematureorotherimmunocompromisedinfants.Thecase-fatalityratevariesfrom40-80%amongnewbornsdiagnosedwiththistypeofinfection.TheconventionalmethodapprovedbytheFDArequires5daysfordetection.Methods: Quantitativereal-timePCRisusedinawidevarietyofmolecularapplications,e.g.geneexpressionanalysisandaccuratedetectionofpathogenlevels.ToimprovesensitivityandshortendetectiontimewedesignedaTaqMan®PathogenDetectionassayforC.sakazakii.HavingextremelylimitedsequenceinformationforC.sakazakiiwedecidedtosequenceandanalyzeanumberofgenomicfragmentsaspotentialtargetsforTaqManassaydesigns.ThesetargetsincludedtheRNasePgeneandseveralregionsselectedbyourBioinfomaticsalgorithms.Results: UsingthenewsequenceinformationwedesignedtwoReal-TimePCRassaystodetectC.sakazakii.TheassaysweretestedwithfourATCCC.sakazakii strainswhichwerecharacterizedby16SribosomalDNAsequencingusingAppliedBiosystems’MicroSeqsystem.Specificityoftheassayswasconfirmedusingawidepanelofnon-C.sakazakiistrainsincludingSalmonella, Shigella, E.Coli, Citrobacter and Listeria species, aswellas Enterobacter species: E.nimipressuralis, E.dissolvens, E.cloacae and E.aerogenes.Herewedemonstratethattheassayshavenear100%PCRamplificationefficiencyandahighdegreeofspecificityfortheselectiveamplificationoftargetedgenesinthepresenceofcloselyrelatedtargets.Next step: Customervalidation–weperformedincollaborationwithdifferentlaboratories.Real-TimePCRresultswerecomparedwithISOMethod.Overallgoodcorrelationbetweenstandardmethodsandreal-timePCRresultswasdemonstrated.Conclusions: ThisinvestigationhasconfirmedthatC.sakazakiiisgeneticallydiverseandrequiresaccurateidentification.EnhanceddetectionassaysweredesignedtoenablespecificandhighlysensitivescreeningofCronobacter sakazakii.

IntroductionReal-timePCRdetectionofmicroorganismsinfoodandenvironmenthasbecomeanimportantpartofbiothreatmonitoringandepidemiologicalstudies.Traditionalculturebasedmethodsarelaborious,timeconsumingandoftenhamperedbyslowgrowthofmanyorganisms.WedesignedandtestedReal-timePCRspecificdetectionassaysfordetectionofCronobacter sakazakiiinscreeningenvironmentorfoodsamples.

Study Design ➢ WedesignedandtestedReal-timePCRspecificassaysfordetectionofCronobacter sakazakiibasedonspecificC.sakazakiigenomicfragment➢ TargetorganismswereselectedfromtheATCCpanel:ATCC12868,ATCC29004, ATCC29544andATCC51329➢ Todemonstratespecificityofthedesignedassayscloselyrelatedorganismswere selectedbasedontwocriteria:closeproximityonthephylogenetictreeandpotential presenceinthesamelocation

Assay #11 – target DNA

Assay #16 – target DNA

Assay #11 – target DNAAssay #11 – target DNA

Assay #16 – target DNA

Anti-target Panel Sample Name Copy no. Avg. Stdev Avg. Stdev FAM Ct VIC CtAssay11_citrobacter 2000000 45 0 29.25 0.25Assay11_E.aero 2000000 45 0 29.21 0.13Assay11_E.cloacae 2000000 45 0 29.19 0.02Assay11_E.ColiK12 2000000 45 0 29.20 0.21Assay11_E.diss 2000000 45 0 29.02 0.03Assay11_E.nimi 2000000 45 0 29.21 0.08Assay11_Listeria 2000000 45 0 29.10 0.01Assay11_NTC1 2000000 45 0 29.05 0.07Assay11_NTC2 2000000 45 0 29.16 0.10Assay11_NTC3 2000000 45 0 28.97 0.11Assay11_NTC4 2000000 45 0 29.03 0.13Assay11_Salmonella 2000000 45 0 29.09 0.08Assay11_Salmonella anatum 2000000 45 0 29.13 0.18Assay11_Salmonella dublin 2000000 45 0 29.16 0.04Assay11_Salmonella entr 2000000 45 0 29.36 0.10Assay11_Salmonella typh 2000000 45 0 29.03 0.05Assay11_Shingella 2000000 45 0 29.19 0.21Assay16_citrobacter 2000000 45 0 28.78 0.26Assay16_E.aero 2000000 45 0 29.03 0.12Assay16_E.cloacae 2000000 45 0 29.05 0.08Assay16_E.ColiK12 2000000 45 0 29.17 0.03Assay16_E.diss 2000000 45 0 29.00 0.11Assay16_E.nimi 2000000 45 0 29.08 0.11Assay16_Listeria 2000000 45 0 29.18 0.10Assay16_NTC1 2000000 45 0 29.08 0.20Assay16_NTC2 2000000 45 0 29.02 0.13Assay16_NTC3 2000000 45 0 28.97 0.06Assay16_NTC4 2000000 45 0 29.09 0.15Assay16_Salmonella 2000000 45 0 29.18 0.01Assay16_Salmonella anatum 2000000 45 0 29.10 0.11Assay16_Salmonella dublin 2000000 45 0 29.22 0.01Assay16_Salmonella entr 2000000 45 0 29.20 0.18Assay16_Salmonella typh 2000000 45 0 29.23 0.09Assay16_Shingella 2000000 45 0 29.25 0.21

Cronobacter sakazakii assays target test with 4 ATCC DNA strains

05

1015202530354045

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

Assay ID

Ct

12868290042954451329

Figure 2Validation panel16S Phylogenetic tree

Figure 4A

Figure 4B

Figure 3

Figure 5A

Figure 5B

Figure 5C

100 % match to C. sakazakii

~100 % match to E. Hormachei

ATCC 29544 C. sakazakii

ATCC 51329

Figure 1