Upload
bee5834
View
220
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
1/26
CRIMINAL JUSTICE ISSUES
2013 LEGISLATURE
Keith S. Hampton
Texas Interfaith Center
for Public PolicyJanuary 29, 2013
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
2/26
CRIMINAL JUSTICE PHILOSOPHY
1980 - 1995* Largest Prison Construction in History
* Enhanced Penalties, Longer Sentences
* Easier Prosecutions
* No Public Defender Systems
* Busiest Death Row in America
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
3/26
CRIMINAL JUSTICE DEVELOPMENTS
1995-2005* Costs of prisons mount
* DNA expose flaws in system
* Federal Courts and the Texas Death Penalty (Burdine, Salazar,
Fiero, Penry)
* Innocent People Executed: Willingham, Cantu and DeLuna
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
4/26
LEGISLATIVE RESPONSE
* Creation of State Jails
* Creation of the Indigent Defense Commission
* Creation of Forensic Science Commission
* DNA statute
* Creation of Innocence Clinics
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
5/26
Foreseeable Future
* Emphasis on Treatment and Prevention
* Focus on Special PopulationsMentally Ill, Vets, Drug
Addiction
* Eventual Innocence Commission
* Child Abuse ConvictionsNew Frontier in Innocence
* Brain Science will impact criminal cases
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
6/26
DISCOVERY ISSUES
No General Right to Discovery in
Criminal Cases
Brady v. Maryland
The Morton Case
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
7/26
INTERROGATIONS
Recording Interrogations Involuntary Confessions
Science of False Confessions
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
8/26
Efforts to Improve Reliability
Forensic Science Commission
Innocence Clinics DNA statutes
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
9/26
Death Penalty
Parties legislation
Mental Retardation
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
10/26
MARIJUANA
Class C
Other States Federal - State Relations
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
11/26
FIREARMS
HB 553 (Otto): Makes it a crime for any public servant, includingpolice, to enforce or attempt to enforce any acts, laws, executive
orders, agency orders, rules or regulations of any kind whatsoever of
the United States government relating to confiscating any firearm,banning any firearm, limiting the size of a magazine for any firearm,
imposing any limit on the ammunition that may be purchased for any
firearm, taxing any firearm or ammunition therefore, or requiring the
registration of any firearm or ammunition therefore.
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
12/26
MORE FIREARMS
SB 182 (Birdwell) Permits concealed weapons atuniversities
HB 507 (Guillen) Makes it a crime for hunters or
recreational shooters to discharge a firearm and its
projectile crosses across the property line of a school
HB 508 (Guillen) Makes it a crime to wrongfully
exclude a concealed weapon license holder from
premises HB 223 (Huberty) Creates a defense to unlawful
carrying of a weapon to a school board meeting if the
person has a license to carry a concealed weapon
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
13/26
2ND AMENDMENT
A well regulated Militia, being necessary to
the security of a free State, the right of the
people to keep and bear Arms, shall notbe infringed.
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
14/26
ARTICLE I SECTION 23
OF THE TEXAS CONSTITUTION
Every citizen shall have the right to keep and bear
arms in the lawful defense of himself or the State; butthe Legislature shall have power, by law, to regulate
the wearing of arms, with a view to prevent crime.
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
15/26
LANDMARK GUN CASES
District of Columbia v. Heller, 554 U.S. 507 (2008)
McDonald v. City of Chicago, 130 S.Ct. 2030 (2010)
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
16/26
HellerMajority Opinion
[W]e hold that the Districts ban on handgun possession
in the home violates the Second Amendment, as does its
prohibition against rendering any lawful firearm in the home
operable for the purpose of immediate self-defense.
Assuming that Heller is not disqualified from the exercise of
Second Amendment rights, the District must permit him to
register his handgun and must issue him a license to carry
it in the home.
Handguns at Home
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
17/26
HellerMajority Opinion
[N]othing in our opinion should be taken to cast doubt
on longstanding prohibitions on the possession of
firearms by felons and the mentally ill, or laws forbiddingthe carrying of firearms in sensitive places such as
schools and government buildings, or laws imposing
conditions and qualifications on the commercial sale of
arms.
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
18/26
HellerDissenting Opinions
The Second Amendmentwas adopted to protect the right ofthe people of each of the several States to maintain a well-regulated militia. It was a response to concerns raised during
the ratification of the Constitution that the power of Congressto disarm the state militias and create a national standing armyposed an intolerable threat to the sovereignty of the severalStates. Neither the text of the Amendment nor the argumentsadvanced by its proponents evidenced the slightest interest in
limiting any legislatures authority to regulate private civilianuses of firearms. Specifically, there is no indication that theFramers of the Amendment intended to enshrine the common-law right of self-defense in the Constitution.
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
19/26
UNLAWFUL CARRYING OF A WEAPON
A person commits an offense if the personintentionally, knowingly, or
recklessly carries on or about his or her person a handgun, illegal knife,
or club if the person is not on the persons own premises or premises
under the persons control, or inside of or directly en route to a motorvehicle or watercraft that is owned by the person or under the persons
control.
Crime to have a handgun in plain view in the car or boat or engaged incriminal activity.
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
20/26
Exceptions
Not a crime if the person is traveling or hunting, fishing,
or other sporting activity on the immediate premises
where the activity is conducted, or is en route betweenthe premises and the actors residence, motor vehicle, or
watercraft, if the weapon is a type commonly used in the
activity or has a concealed handgun permit (chapter 411,
Govt Code)
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
21/26
PLACES WEAPONS PROHIBITED
A school or educational institution or school activity
Polling place on election day Court or offices utilized by the court
Racetrack
Airport
Prison
Concealed weapon permit no defense
Crime if person possesses or goes with a firearm, illegalknife, club, or prohibited weapon to:
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
22/26
PROHIBITED WEAPONS
Crime to possess: (1) an explosive weapon; (2) a
machine gun; (3) a short-barrel firearm; (4) a firearm
silencer; (5) a switchblade knife; (6) knuckles; (7)
armor-piercing ammunition; (8) a chemical dispensingdevice; (9) a zip gun; or (10) a tire deflation device.
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
23/26
SELF-DEFENSE AND DEADLY FORCE
A person can use deadly force when and to the degree the actor
reasonably believes the deadly force is immediately necessary to
protect himself against deadly force or prevent violent felonies.
A persons belief in the necessity of deadly force is presumptive
reasonable if he believed the person was forcibly entering his
habitation, vehicle or place of business or employment.
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
24/26
Texas Castle Doctrine
A person who has a right to be present at the location
where the deadly force is used, who has not provoked the
person against whom the deadly force is used, and who is
not engaged in criminal activity at the time the deadly force
is used is not required to retreat before using deadly force
[.]
habitation, vehicle or place of employment or business
Beyond the Castle
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
25/26
Self-DefenseActors belief that force was immediately necessary ispresumed reasonable if knew/had reason to believe
the person forcibly entered his home, business orvehicle, didnt provoke it, and wasnt otherwise engagedin criminal activity.
JURY MAYNOTCONSIDER RETREAT
7/29/2019 Criminal Justice Issues In the 83rd Legislature
26/26
Firearm Bills in Light ofHeller
States can, but dont have to, ban guns at universitiesor other sensitive areas.
Can Texas ban the possession of firearms by felons?
Can Texas deny the right to carry a concealed weaponto those behind on child support?
Do people under 21 years have the right to carry?
The List of Presumptively Lawful Regulatory Measures