Upload
maddyvicky
View
217
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
1/66
A Project Report
On
Credit appraisal
Of
Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
Submitted by
M Laxmana Swamy (DM-72)
BIMTECH (2011-2013)
At
Andhra Bank, Head Office, Hyderabad
In partial fulfilment for the award
Of
POST GRADUATE DIPLOMA IN MANAGEMENT (2011-13)
Under the guidance of
Industry Mentor:
R.V.Raju
Senior Manager,
Mid Corporate Department
Andhra Bank-Head Office
Hyderabad.
Faculty Mentor:
Prof. Kamal Kalra
BIMTECH
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
2/66
Contents
Contents...............................................................................................................1List of tables........................................................................................................... i
Summer Project Certificate.................................................................................. iii
Andhra Bank Certificate....................................................................................... iv
Acknowledgement.................................................................................................v
Executive Summary............................................................................................ vii
Letter of Transmittal............................................................................................ ix
Letter of Authorization..........................................................................................x
About the company...............................................................................................1
Literature review...................................................................................................3
Statement of the problem.....................................................................................5
Methodology and Process Description..................................................................6
Data and Process Analysis....................................................................................9
Credit Facilities..................................................................................................9
About the borrower firm and their proposal.......................................................9
Step 1: Calculating credit exposures to individual/group borrower:................11Step 2: Calculating Term loan eligibility: ........................................................12
Step 3: Primary and collateral security:...........................................................13
Step 4: Credit Risk rating and pricing..............................................................15
Credit risk rating model:...............................................................................16
CRISIL Rating and Industry analysis:............................................................22
Step 5: Calculating applicable interest rate and tenure:..................................26
Step 6: Working capital assessment................................................................26
Step 7: Credit investigation, due diligence & verification of defaulters list:.....29
Step 8 Financial analysis and compliance:.......................................................31
Step 9 Term and conditions:............................................................................35
Results................................................................................................................ 39
Credit risk rating results..................................................................................39
DSCR results:................................................................................................... 39
Sensitivity analysis results:..............................................................................40
Working capital Results:..................................................................................41
Compliance to policy........................................................................................41
1
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
3/66
Conclusions.........................................................................................................42
Limitations.......................................................................................................... 44
Recommendations.............................................................................................. 45
References..........................................................................................................46
Appendix I...........................................................................................................47
Appendix II..........................................................................................................49
Appendix-III.........................................................................................................50
Glossary of abbreviations....................................................................................52
2
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
4/66
3
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
5/66
List of tables
Table 1 Term loan I.............................................................................................10Table 2 Term loan II............................................................................................10
Table 3 Working capital limits.............................................................................11
Table 4 Exposure ceilings...................................................................................11
Table 5 Exposures to Individual and group.........................................................12
Table 6 Margin money calculation...................................................................... 12
Table 7 Collateral available.................................................................................15
Table 8 Collateral required..................................................................................15
Table 9 Net worth of individuals.........................................................................15
Table 10 CRRM rating and their meaning...........................................................17
Table 11 Factors considered under Industry risk................................................17
Table 12 Factors considered under Business risk...............................................18
Table 13 Factors considered under financial risk................................................18
Table 14 Factors considered under Management risk.........................................19
Table 15 Factors considered under facility risk...................................................20
Table 16 Factors considered under project risk..................................................20Table 17 weight associated with each risk parameter........................................20
Table 18 Parameters considered under CRAS model and their weights..............21
Table 19 Parameters under CRS model..............................................................21
Table 20 Credit rating and their meaning in CRS model.....................................22
Table 21 Factors considered by CRISIL for industry score...................................23
Table 22 Operating margins for commercial real estate.....................................25
Table 23 Applicable spread.................................................................................26
Table 24 Turn over method calculations.............................................................27
Table 25 II method calculations..........................................................................28
Table 26 Cash deficit method of the borrower....................................................29
Table 27 Defaulters list.......................................................................................30
Table 28 conduct of the borrower.......................................................................31
Table 29 key financial indicators.........................................................................31
Table 30 Remarks on key financial indicators.....................................................32
Table 31 sales receipts.......................................................................................33
Table 32 Auditors comments.............................................................................. 35
i
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
6/66
Table 33 Rating given to the borrower................................................................39
Table 34 Other ratings........................................................................................ 39
Table 35 DSCR estimations.................................................................................40
Table 36 Sensitivity Results................................................................................40
Table 37 Working capital build up.......................................................................41
Table 38 Compliance to loan policy guidelines...................................................42
ii
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
7/66
Summer Project Certificate
This is to certify that Mr. M Laxmana Swamy, Roll
No. 72, a student of PGDM (Finance) has worked
on a summer project titled Credit appraisal of
Term loans and Working Capital limits at Andhra
Bank after Trimester-III in partial fulfilment of the
requirement for the Post Graduate Diploma in
Management programme. This is his original
work to the best of my knowledge.
Date: ____________ Signature
_______
(_____________________) Prof
Kamal Kalra
BIMTECH SEAL
Faculty mentor
iii
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
8/66
Andhra Bank CertificateDate: June, 09, 2012
TO WHOMSOEVER IT MAY CONCERN
Sub: Training Certificate
We hereby certify that Mr M Laxmana Swamy a Full Time
Student of Post Graduate Diploma In Management Course,
2011-2013, of Birla Institute of Management Technology
(BIMTECH) has undergone his Summer Internship as mandated
for the completion of his above course from BIMTECH, for a
period of 8 weeks starting from April, 16,2012
The title and scope of his project was Credit Appraisal of Term
Loans and Working Capital Limits. The project was carried out
under the guidance of Mr. R V Raju, Senior Manager.
We found him to be a dedicated and diligent student. We take
this opportunity to wish him success in his future endeavours.
iv
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
9/66
Sincerely,
Mr. R V Raju
Senior Manager
Andhra Bank- Head Ofiice,
Hyderabad.
Acknowledgement
I would like to gratefully acknowledge the contribution of all the people who took active part
and provided valuable support to me during the course of this project. To begin with, I would
like to offer my sincere thanks to R.V Raju, Senior Manager, for all his support at Andhra
Bank. Without his guidance and valuable suggestions during the research, the project would
not have been accomplished.
My heartfelt gratitude also goes to S T Sridhar, Chief Manager at Andhra bank for his
valuable assistance.
I also sincerely thankProf Kamal Kalra, my faculty mentor at BIMTECH, who provided
valuable suggestions, shared his rich corporate experience, and helped me script the exact
requisites.
v
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
10/66
vi
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
11/66
Executive SummaryTerm loans and working capital limits are the major source of funding for the corporates. For
availing either term loans or working capital limits from a bank, the borrower has to satisfy
certain conditions and follow the process prescribed by the bank. Andhra Bank has got its
own loan policy method for evaluating the Credit proposals.
Mid Corporate Department at Head Office deals with Credit proposals ranging from Rs. 25-
60 crores. Branches/Zonal Offices of Andhra Bank after initial scrutiny of the proposals,
they forward the proposals with their recommendations for sanction to the Head Office. The
objective of my project work at Andhra Bank is to appraise one loan proposal received by
the Mid-corporate department at Head Office.The scope of this project is to study the credit
approval process followed by Andhra Bank.
The credit approval process at Andhra Bank starts with checking the exposure limits as per
the bank guidelines. The next step is credit rating of the borrower and decide the applicable
interest rate. Andhra bank follows its own internally developed method called Credit Risk
rating method (CRRM) for the purpose of credit rating of the borrower. Andhra bank also
avails CRISIL rating for the purpose of industry analysis and industry score.
The financials of the borrower are checked and various ratios are calculated for the purpose
of checking the financial compliance of the borrower as per bank guidelines. Working
capital assessment also needs to be done. For the purpose of assessing the working capital,
methods such as turnover method, II method and cash budget method have been prescribed.
Out these methods, cash budget method has been used for the borrower as he belongs to
Commercial Real estate.
For purpose of availing term loans, the eligibility is calculated based on margins as stipulated
by the banks policy guidelines. Margin means a fixed amount of money that must be
brought in by the borrower. As security for availing term loan the borrower has to provide
collateral security along with primary security. Collateral security is taken for the purpose of
recovering the funds given by the bank in case the borrower defaults.
vii
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
12/66
Results such as risk rating, interest applicable, EMI payable and working capital limits
approved would be mentioned. The conclusion of the project report includes comments on
methodology followed. Recommendations would also be provided.
The borrower in the case study is a privately held construction company. The borrower has
asked for term loan of 15 crores and Working capital limits of 7 crores for the purpose of
construction of a Mall in Chennai.
viii
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
13/66
Letter of TransmittalDate: June, 09, 2012
Mr. R V Raju,
Senior Manager,
Mid corporate department, Head Office.
Hyderabad.
Dear Sir,
Re: Summer Project Report
Attached herewith is a copy of my summer-project report Credit Appraisal of Term loans
and Working Capital limits which I am submitting in order to mark the completion of an
8 week summer project at you organization. This report was prepared by me using the best of
practices and summarizes the work performed on the project and is being submitted in partial
fulfilment of the requirements for award of diploma.
I would like to mention that the overall experience with the organization was very good, and
helped me to know how work is carried out in real practice with the help of your esteemed
organization. I feel honoured that I got an opportunity to work with Andhra bank, a company
of great repute.
I hope I did justice to the project and added some value to the organization.
Suggestions/comments would be appreciated.
Yours truly,
M Laxmana Swamy
ix
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
14/66
Letter of Authorization
I, M Laxmana Swamy, a student of Birla Institute of Management Technology (BIMTECH),
hereby declare that I have worked on a project titled Credit Appraisal of Term loans and
Working Capital limits during my summer internship at Andhra Bank, in partial
fulfilment of the requirement for the Post Graduate Diploma in Management program.
I guarantee/underwrite my research work to be authentic and original to the best of my
knowledge in all respects of the process carried out during the project tenure.
My learning experience at Andhra Bank, under the guidance of Industry Mentor R V Raju,
Senior Manager, and Faculty guide Prof. kamal Kalra has been truly enriching.
Date: June, 09, 2012
M Laxmana Swamy
x
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
15/66
About the company
Andhra Bank is one of the leading banks in the country among the mid size public sectorbanks. Andhra Bank has been founded by Late Mr Dr Bhogaraju pattabhi Sitaramayya in
1923 in Machilipatnam, with a paid up capital of 1 lakh rupees and authorised capital of 10
lakhs rupees. In April 1980 the bank was converted to wholly owned government bank.
Government of India holds up to 51.55 % and Life Insurance Corporation owns nearly 10 %
of the shares. The bank has its head quarters situated in Saifabad, Hyderabad.
Since 2002 Shri B A Prabhakar is chairman and Managing director of the bank. Andhra
bank has a global presence with over 1729 branches globally including developed nations
such as USA and UAE. The bank also started a joint venture with Bank of Baroda and L&G
a foreign partner to form the India first Life insurance Company limited. Andhra Bank has
got around 14,000 employees working with it.
The Head office of Andhra Bank located at Hyderabad is divided into various departments
namely SME sector, Mid and Large Corporate department, Retail department, Legal
department, and Integrated Risk department.
Vision of the bank:
Envisions being a Trustworthy, Efficient and Strong Bank committed to increase market
share by generating innovative Customer-Centric services and products igniting the
Passion and Creative talents in Human resource leveraging Technology to expand the
clientele & deliver Quality and Value Leading to Customer Delight.
Mission of the bank:
Amplify the front line capabilities to Serve Customers develop Processes leveraging
Technology dynamically locate & empower People fast-cycle knowledge into
innovative Products create Possibilities to reach the business goals & position the Bank as
a rising star in the Financial Horizon.
Key financials:
1. Total deposits by March 2012 stood at Rs 105851 crore as compared to Rs 92156
crore by the end of March 2011.
1
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
16/66
2. Advances showed a year on year growth of 17% till March 2012 reaching a level of
Rs. 84684 crores as compared to Rs. 72154 crore by the end of March 2011.
3. CASA deposits increased to Rs. 27947 crore in March 2012 compared to Rs 26779
by the end of March 2011.
4. CASA share in total deposits stood at 26.4% in March 2012.
5. Total income during Q4 FY11-12 rose by 21.3% to Rs 3220 crore.
6. Total income during the FY 11-12 rose by 32% and stood at value of Rs. 12,199
crore.
7. Net interest income during the Q4 FY 11-12 improved to Rs. 914 crore recording a
growth of 6.2 % compared to Q4 FY10-11.
8. NII for the FY11-12 improved by 16.7 % and rose to Rs. 3759 crore.
9. Operating profit for the 12 month of FY11-12 grew 16.7% and stood at Rs. 2815
crore compared to Rs 2413 crore in FY10-11.
10. Net profit for the 12 month ended March 2012 stood at Rs 1345 crore with a growth
of 6.1% from previous month.
11. Gross NPA ratio stood at 2.12% as at March 2012 compared to NPA of 0.91% by the
end of March 2011.
12. Net interest margin stood at 3.34 % for the quarter ended March 2012 and 3.67 % for
12 months ended March 2012.
13. CRAR of the bank stood at 13.18% under BASEL-II (Tier I capital: 9.02% and Tier-
II capital: 4.16%)14. Priority Sector Advances improved to Rs.27027 Crore as on 31.03.2012 from
Rs.23,082 Crore as on 31.03.2011, recording a growth of 17.1%.
15. Advances to Agriculture have gone up to Rs.12, 459 Crore as on 31.03.12 from
Rs.10, 369 Crore as on 31.03.11, recording a growth of 20.1%.
16. MSME Advances registered a growth of 18.3% and stood at Rs.13132 Crore as at the
end of March 2012 as against Rs.11,105 Crore in March 2011.
17. Retail Credit Portfolio of the Bank increased to Rs.11, 301 Crore as on 31.03.2012
compared to Rs.10, 479 Crore as on 31.03.2011, registering a Y-o-Y growth of 7.8%.
2
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
17/66
Literature review
Risk management has become one of the most important aspects for any corporate entity.
Financial institutions must be more prudent as far risk management is concerned. In Master
circular prudential norms on capital adequacy-Basel I Frame work RBI has defined credit
risk in the following way: Credit risk is most simply defined as the potential that a banks
borrower or counterparty may fail to meet its obligations in accordance with agreed terms.
It is the possibility of losses associated with diminution in the credit quality of borrowers or
counterparties. The importance of credit risk management has emphasised in the same
document. Maximising the banks risk adjusted rate of credit would be the goal of credit risk
management. Maintaining the exposures within acceptable level would also come under
credit risk management. Banks apart from managing credit risk at portfolio level, Credit risk
should also be managed at individual transaction level. A proper credit management system
would also be a part of credit risk management.
Report of the Committee on Comprehensive Regulation for Credit Rating Agencies (2009)
highlighted the importance of Credit rating agencys. Credit rating agencies and the ratingsgiven by them help allocate capital efficiently across all sectors of the economy by pricing
risk appropriately. Though not compulsory, banks get their loan portfolio rated by external
agencies due to the fact that increased risk weight must be assigned to unrated loans.
According to theBasel II guidelines (Credit requirement directive-CRD)banks are required
to implement either standardised or internal rating based approach. Since RBI has not come
out with final guidelines regarding Internal Based Approach, all banks in India are required
to follow Standardised approach where the risk weights are given by RBI. RBI had however
issued guidelines asking banks to put in place systems to measure credit risk, market risk and
operational risk to ensure capital adequacy. Pending the issue of final guidelines, RBI has
asked to parallel run both systems (standardised approach and internal rating based
approach) and furnish CRAR (Capital to Risk weighted assets). Hence Andhra Bank is doing
a parallel run of both systems.
Basel II norms state that for internal based approach parameters such as probability at default
(PD), exposures at default, maturity are required. The basic requirement for calculating
3
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
18/66
probability at default (PD) is a robust rating model. Hence, Andhra Bank with the help of
NIBM, Pune has developed CRRM model.
Prior to Tandon committee report recommendations (1974) banks followed securitized
method for working capital lending. Tandon committee report for the first time came up with
the concept of maximum permissible bank finance. Tandon committee report clearly
mentioned that banks should only finance a part of working capital need. The rest of funds
must be brought in by the borrower using long term sources.
Tandon committee report recommended three methods of lending which are discussed in the
report. Tandon committee also emphasised that the corporates should maintain less in current
assets. The committee also suggested holding norms for different classes of current assets.
Of three methods suggested by the Tandon committee, only the first and second methods of
lending are broadly used. However the third method of lending is not widely used due to the
complexities involved in the method.
Chore committee report which later came up in 1979 worked within the framework of
Tandon committee. Chore committee emphasised the importance of bill discounting in
working capital of the company. The committee also came up with many recommendations
regarding such as quarterly submission of current assets details by the company; maintain
current ratio of 1.33:1, peak and non peak limits and etc.
Marathe committee which came up later had come up with various factors effecting working
capital management. The committee report emphasised that borrowers must reduce the
dependence on bank funds for working capital requirement. Borrowers must try to reduce the
working capital requirements from 1.33:1 to 1:1.
4
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
19/66
Statement of the problem
Andhra Banks offer various credit facilities to corporate for their requirements. Term loan is
one such facility offered to the corporates. A term loan can be either short term or medium or
long term. For the purpose of sanctioning term loan, there is prescribed procedure to be
followed in order to ensure the credibility of the project and the borrower.
The process of credit approval includes risk rating the borrower. Risk rating is done using
CRRM under internal risk approach as per RBI guidelines. Applicable interest rate isdecided based on the rating obtained. The borrower however can ask for finer rates of
interest if he satisfies certain stipulated conditions. Security requirements needs to be
calculated based on the bank guidelines. Required primary and collateral security needs to be
calculated.
The working capital limits that can be availed by the borrower will also be calculated. For
this purpose suitable method must be selected first. Apart from all the above steps it also
very important to check the credit worthiness of borrower. RBI stipulates every bank to go
through various defaulters such as RBI caution list, RBI defaulter list, RBI wilful defaulters
list, SAL wilful defaulters list.
The scope of the project work at Andhra bank would be to appraise one credit proposal and
study all the above mentioned steps.
5
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
20/66
Methodology and Process Description
Andhra Bank provides Credit services both fund based and non fund based. The Credit
facilities includes term loan, demand loan, Overdraft, cash Credits, WCDL, advances
against bills, letter of Credit, guarantees, etc. To receive sanctioned advices from Head
Office, a proper appraisal system is required. Andhra Bank has got its own loan policy
method for evaluating the Credit proposals. The Credit appraisal to be done has following
stages mentioned below:
I. The process starts with checking the overall fund and non fund based limits that
can be given. Limits applicable to the unit, group and the industry segment on
whole are checked as per Banks loan policy guide lines/RBI guidelines.
II. Verifying the technical and market feasibility of the project/proposal and
undertaking SWOTanalysis of the borrower.
III. Risk Rating the borrower (e.g. A+++, A++, A+, A, B, C, D) based on the CRRM
(Credit Rating Risk Model) model followed by the Bank. For various parameters
such as management risk factors, financial risk factors, industry risk factor are
rated. Then based on the Credit rating the applicable interest rates and repayment
period is decided.
IV. The past, present and projected financials of the borrower are verified:
a. Balance sheet.
b. Profit and loss account.
c. Fund flow statements.
d. Cash flow statements
V. Calculations of the ratios such as
a. Debt service coverage ratio(DSCR)
b. Capital gearing ratio
6
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
21/66
c. Current ratio
d. Debt equity ratio
e. TOL/TNW ratio
VI. Calculating required primary and collateral security required.
VII. Performing sensitivity analysis on Debt service coverage ratio(DSCR) by
a. Increasing and decreasing cost of raw material
b. Increasing and decreasing the projected sales
c. Increasing and decreasing the applicable interest rates
VIII. Calculating of the drawing power of the borrower.
IX. Assessment of working capital limits or requirement based on turnover method or
II method or cash budget method whichever is applicable.
Sources of data:
Data regarding the borrower would be collected from the borrower itself. The
borrower has to submit various financial statements to the bank when he wants to
avail certain credit facilities from the bank. Various RBI documents are also referred
for understanding various policies.
7
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
22/66
8
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
23/66
Data and Process Analysis
Credit Facilities
Andhra bank provides various credit facilities to individuals and corporate entities. These
facilities can be fund and non fund based. Some of fund based facilities are mentioned below
Term loans: Term loans include short, medium and long term loans. Long term loans are
loans with maturity greater than 8 years while loans with maturity 1 to 8 years are called
medium term loans. Term loans are taken generally for capital requirement. The interest
applicable for a term loan depends upon the risk involved in the project and varies from case
to case.
For the purpose of short term requirements either bridge loans or short term loans are given.
These loans have a maturity less than 1 year. Generally the short term loans carry higher
interest rate compared to long term loan. Bridge loans are generally obtained as an
intermediary source of fund before getting funds from a new and large source of funds. The
money from new source of fund is used to repay the bridge loan.
Working capital limits: For the purpose of meeting the working capital requirements various
facilities are offered by the banks. These facilities include various Open cash Credit limit
(OCC) and Overdraft facilities. Over draft facilities can be clean overdraft and secured
overdraft.
Non fund based facilities: Non fund based facilities include various facilities like letter of
credit (LC), letter of comfort (LOC) and bank guarantees (BG).
About the borrower firm and their proposal
M/S ABC builders, engineers and contractors is a registered partnership firm dealing with
Andhra Bank since 2003. The firm in engaged in the development of residential and
commercial flats in Chennai and Bangalore. Mr XXX is the main promoter and managing
director of the firm. He is a qualified civil engineer and from 1995 he is in civil construction
line and having vast experience. This company has been doing construction work almost
since a decade.
9
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
24/66
Proposal: ABC builders and engineers and constructors have approached Andhra Bank for
the purpose of availing term loan as well as working capital limit renewal. The proposal
under consideration comes under Commercial real estate (CRE).The details are given below:
1. Recommendation for renewal cum enhancement of Secured Over Draft(SOD) from
Rs 4.50 crores to Rs 7 crores
2. Sanction of term loan I (project funding) for Rs 8.00 crores and term loan II for 7.00
crores.
Table 1 Term loan I
1 Facility Term loan I(project funding)
Limit Rs 8 crore
purpose
To construct commercial spaces In two basement and
ground and first floor
Margin 50%
repayment period
Repayable in Three years, Interest to be serviced as and
when debited. The loan is to be repaid as and when the
shops are registered in favour of the buyer.
interest/Commission BR+4%+0.25 % i.e. 15% p.a. presently
Table 2 Term loan II
2 Facility Term loan II
Limit 7 crore
purpose
to construct and lease out commercial space for halls in
second to fifth floor
Margin 50%
Repayment period
Repayable in 60 EMI of Rs 16.66 lakhs each with a period
of 24 months
Interest/ Commission BR+4 %+0.25% i.e. 15% p.a. presently
10
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
25/66
Table 3 Working capital limits
3 Facility SOD(Against Real estate)
Limit Rs. 7 crore
purpose Working capital
Margin 50%
Repayment period One year
Interest/ Commission BR+7.25 % i.e.18 % presently
Table 1, table 2, table 3 show the credit facilities requested by the borrower. It can be seen
that total term loan has been divided into 2 different loans. It is the different purpose and
different amortization schedules of the loan that made the company to differentiate the loan
into 2 types. Term loan I has been for the purpose of construction of 2 basements, ground
and first floor. The term loan II has been for the purpose of construction of second to fifth
floor where the proposed cinema theatres are planned to be constructed. For the purpose of
credit appraisal there is a step by step procedure to be followed as explained below.
Step 1: Calculating credit exposures to individual/group borrower:
RBI guidelines very clearly indicate the banks to maintain certain fixed amount of exposure
per borrower and to the group. Apart from exposure limits to individuals and groups, there
are exposure limits set for industry/segment.
The exposure ceiling limits would be 15% of the capital funds (of Andhra Bank) in case of a
single case borrower and 40% of the capital funds in the case of a borrower group. The
capital funds for the purpose will comprise of Tier I and Tier II capital. However there are
various norms that allow deviations depending upon the sector. For example infrastructurecompanies may be allowed a deviation of 5 % and 10% to individual and group borrower
respectively. The industry wise credit exposure limit to commercial real estate has been fixed
at 7% of total fund based advances of previous quarter.
Table 4 Exposure ceilingsParticulars Fund Non fund
11
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
26/66
based based
Exposure ceiling as
30.09.2011 5217.42 480.72
Exposure as on 03.12.2011 3517.73 157.15Add present proposal 17.5 -
Total 3535.23 157.15
Table 5 Exposures to Individual and group
Ceiling as per RBI
norm
Constitution wise
ceiling as per
bank policy Banks exposure
existing proposedTo the unit 1479.17 30 4.5 22
To the
group 3944.47 40 4.5 22
Ceiling applicable to partnership firm are Rs 30 crores to the unit and 40 crores to the group
or 6 times the net worth which is 6.25*6=37.50 crores. Table 4 and table 5 shows the total
loan amount given to commercial real estate and to the proposed borrower. The proposed
exposure is within the ceiling norms.
Step 2: Calculating Term loan eligibility:
The bank calculates term loan eligibility based on margins as stipulated in term loan policy
of the bank. Margin basically means the percentage of contribution that must be made by the
borrower. Table 6 shows the margins and margin money that must be brought in by the
borrower.
Table 6 Margin money calculation
Particulars cost Margin (%) term loan
Additional money paid to the land owners 0.75 50 0.38
Ground+ 5 floors 18.01 50 9.01
basement and others 7.49 50 3.74
other charges inclusive of upfront fee and 3.14 50 1.57
12
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
27/66
other charges/fees like CMDA plans approval
charges, TNEB charges deposits and TL
interest during construction period
contingencies 0.6 50 0.30
Total 29.99 15
As can be seen from above table, the total cost of the project is 30 crores. Out of the total
cost 15 crores is bought in by the borrower, the rest in proposed to be brought in as term
loan.
Step 3: Primary and collateral security:
Repayment capacity of the borrower and economic viability of the project will be the prime
consideration while evaluating the proposal. Security and guarantee offered by the borrower
shall be considered as secondary source of payment.
In order to obtain either a fund based or non fund based facility from the bank, security must
be given. In case the borrower defaults in paying back the borrowed funds, then banks will
have the right to liquidate the security and recover the funds given by them to the borrower.
Security offered by the borrower to the banks is divided into primary and collateral security.
The assets acquired out of the bank finance shall be taken as primary security for the
exposure. Anything offered/pledged apart from primary security is taken as collateral
security. Collateral security can be anything such as land, building, etc. Collateral security
can even be from members who are not stake holders in the deal/company. While extending
finance for acquisition of fixed assets or working capital finance against current assets,
prescribed margins shall be ensured in tune with norms prescribed by the bank.
Security can also be given in the form guarantees. In cases where collateral securities are
given by third parties guarantees or co-obligations are taken from the borrower. In case when
real estate is given as collateral security, sometimes the promoters may be required to give
guarantee to the extent of land value. In case of public companies guarantees are taken from
the directors. Taking personal guarantee makes borrower more accountable and responsible.
In proposed project, the details of primary and secondary security offered are given below:
Primary security:
13
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
28/66
For term loan I and II: 50% of undivided share of land situated in Mahabalipuram
Road and 50 % share in the super structure to be built there upon.
For Secured Over Draft (SOD) security: Real estate valuing 19.23 crores (Which is
also extended to term loans)
Collateral Security-Proposed:
Vacant land of about 7392 sft located at poonamalle high road, Nerkundram, Chennai-
600107 with Market value is 5.54 crores.
Further to the discussion where in Zonal office had highlighted the positive factors about the
proposal, requested the promoter to offer additional security and the borrower has agreed to
give the following additional securities:
1. Land to an extent of 2697 sq. ft with the building at Venkatesm Street , T Nagar,
Chennai belonging to father-in-law and mother-in-law of Mr AAA worth Rs 4 crores.
2. Vacant land to an extent of 8100 sft at site no 11, sarjapur belonging to Mr AAA
worth 4 crore.
Thus the total value of collateral security offered is valued at 13.54 crores (5.54 +4+ 4).Table
7 and table 8 shows the amount collateral available and total amount of collateral required.
As can be seen the collateral available is greater than collateral required.
14
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
29/66
Table 7 Collateral available
SI. No Particulars
Amount
(crores)
1 Value of existing security 19.23
2 Total value of new security proposed to be given ( Rs 5.5 + Rs 4+ Rs 4) 13.54
3 Total security offered 32.77
Table 8 Collateral required
SI.No Particulars Amount(crores)
1 Collateral security required at 200 % of SOD limit of 4.5 crore 9
2 200 % for short term loan of 8 crores 163 100 % for term loan of 7 crores 7
4 Total term loan requested 32
5 Security coverage 102%
Guarantors- Joint and several liabilities of partners: Since the firm is partnership firm, all
partners have their liability status is unlimited. The net worth of the all the partners has been
given below in table 9.
Table 9 Net worth of individuals
Name Net worth( in crores)
AAA 16
BBB 2.17
CCC 5.85
DDD 1.5
Step 4: Credit Risk rating and pricing
Bank has its own policy for risk rating of the borrower. Andhra follows different models
depending on the credit limit. For all advances with credit limit between 5 crores and 50
lakhs CRAS (Credit Risk Assessment System) model is followed. CRS (Credit rating
system) model is followed and when the limits are between 5 lakhs to 50 lakhs. For all credit
limits above 5 crores, CRRM (Credit rating risk management) model is used for credit
rating. For credit limits less than 5 lakhs various other systems are used for risk rating.
15
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
30/66
Initially CRAS model was used even for credit limits greater than 5 crores. But based on RBI
guidelines to implement the BESEL-II guidelines, CRRM model has been implemented. For
the purpose of rating a borrower, past financials are made use of. In case the borrower is
implementing a new project, then projected financial are made use for the purpose of risk
rating a borrower.
In case the borrower is new to the bank, it is mandatory that he must secure an overall
minimum score of 40% with a minimum of 40% score in each of the parameter. For
considering finer rates of interests the borrower should be rated B and above under
CRS/CRAS and should be rated above B++ under CRRM.
Credit risk rating model:
Andhra Bank with help of NIBM, Pune has developed an Internal rating system called as
CRRM based on the RBI guidelines. For development of the model risk parameters such as
Probability of default (PD), Loss given default (LGD), exposure at default and exposure at
maturity are used. This new model is software driven and BASEL compliant model capable
of providing rating migration statistics, PD calculations apart from several useful reports for
management information.
Under the New Capital Adequacy framework [ Based on BASEL II document], the concept
of Credit Risk, Market Risk and Operational Risk is introduced with guidelines on
classification of assets, methodologies for measuring these risks and the approaches
available to banks are furnished.
As mentioned earlier CRRM model is used for rating when credit limits are greater than 5
crores. CRRM model is used for both fund based and non fund bases. CRRM model is a very
comprehensive model. CRRM model is a software based model. All sanctioning authorities
and Zonal offices have this software loaded into their systems.
In CRRM model various types of risks are indentified. Under each risk, several parameters
are selected and under each parameter, several risk factors are taken up for evaluation and
rating on a 1 to 6 scale, with 6 being the highest score and 1 the least. Weights are attached
to Parameters/ Factor. Final ratings are assigned based on the weighted average scores. Table
10 shows various grades that can be obtained and their meaning under CRRM.
The internal and external risks are evaluated under the following heads:
16
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
31/66
a) Financial Risk Evaluation
b) Industry Risk Evaluation [External Risk]
c) Business Risk Evaluation
d) Management Evaluation
e) Security/Conduct of account
f) Project Risk Evaluation (in respect of Term Loan accounts)
Table 10 CRRM rating and their meaning
Score Rating Description
6.0-5.4 A++
An exceptionally high position of strength. Very high
degree of sustainability
5.39-4.9 A+
A high degree of strength on factors among peer groups.
High degree of sustainability
4.89-4.2 A A moderate degree of strength with positive outlook
4.19-3.6 B++ A moderate degree of strength with stable outlook
3.59-3.0 B+
A moderate degree of strength with stable and marginally
negative outlook
2.99-2.4 B
Weakness on a parameter in comparison with peers.
Unstable outlook
2.39-1.0 C
A fundamental weakness with regard to the factor.
Unlikely to improve under normal conditions.
0 D Defaulter
Industry Risk Evaluation: The Industry risk section evaluates the outlook for the industry
over the medium term. Three Distinct risk parameters have been identified and a number of
risk factors within each risk parameter have been identified. Under industry risk the
following factors are considered under which further properties are considered. Table 11
gives the factors that are considered under industry risk evaluation. There a total of 3 factors
with each factor having many sub factors considered.
Table 11 Factors considered under Industry risk
SI.NO Name of factor Number of parameters
1 Industry
Characteristics
4 parameters
2 Competitive forces 8 parameters
3 Industry Financials 3 parameters
17
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
32/66
The department handling the Credit Risk Rating at the Head Office will rate the Industry
Parameters either using Internal Industry Intelligence or using External Industry Database
and communicate the data on the Industry parameters to the credit rating officers at the 9
Branches or Zones. The Industry Ratings will be reviewed periodically to keep them in tune
with the changes in the environment.
The Branches and Zones do not have the facility to change the Industry ratings once it is pre-
determined by the Head Office. The rating officers at Zones or Branches have to select the
appropriate Industry for the Company/Borrower under consideration and the corresponding
Industry data will be automatically retrieved from the Industry database and Industry rating
will be generated automatically.
Andhra Bank has subscribed to CRISINFACs Industry Risk Scores, who provides the inputs
to the Industry scores. According to CRSINFAC, the industry score is 2.3 on a scale of 6,
which indicates unfavourable. However as per the background of the promoter and
feasibility of the project, ZO has recommended for the credit limits.
Business risk: Business risk is measured through parameters that determine the companys
business position within the industry and its sustainability. Table 12 gives factors considered.
Table 12 Factors considered under Business risk
SI. No Factor Number of parameters
1 Market position 5
2 operating efficiency 3
3 Growth 4
Financial risk: By measuring the financial risk the overall risk involved in the financialsystem of the company is measured. The following factors are taken into account while
measuring the financial risk. The factors considered under financial risk are given in table
13.
Table 13 Factors considered under financial risk
SI. No Factor Number of parameters
1 Quality of financial statements 3
2 past financial performance 5
3 financial flexibility 2
4 Cash flow adequacy projections 5
18
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
33/66
Management risk: This risk parameter tries to access the management quality and the risk
that can arise due to management. Factors considered under management risk are given in
table 14.
Table 14 Factors considered under Management risk
SI. No. Factors
1 Number of years of experience in industry
2 quality of management personnel
3 Percentage of actual sales achieved to projection made last year
4 Percentage of net profit achieved to projections made last year
5 Percentage of actual net working capital to projections made last year
6 Payment record to bankers/Institutions
7 group support
8 management succession
9 Corporate governance
10 credibility
Facility risk/ Security risk: This risk parameter tries to access the possible risk that can arise
due to securities such as guarantees and collateral security that are given the borrower.
Factors considered under facility risk are given in table 15.
19
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
34/66
Table 15 Factors considered under facility risk
SI. No. Factor
1 Collateral security
2 Personal or corporate guarantee
3 Past payment record
4 compliance with terms of sanction
5 Operations in account
Project risk: This risk parameter tries to estimate the risk involved in the project for which
the borrower is borrowing funds. Factors considered under project risk are given in table 16.
Table 16 Factors considered under project risk
SI. No. Factor
1 Average debt service coverage ratio for the project
2 Repayment period for the project including moratorium
3 Asset coverage ratio for the project
Table 17 gives the weights given to each parameter under CRRM model. Based in these
weight final score is computed.
Table 17 weight associated with each risk parameter
Category weight
Financial risk 5
Business risk 2
Industrial risk 1
Management risk 1.5
facility risk 0.5
Project risk 1
Credit Risk Assessment System (CRAS) Model:
20
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
35/66
As mentioned earlier CRAS model is used for the credit limits between 50 lakhs to 5 crores.
In CRAS model the following parameters are considered are given in table 18.
Table 18 Parameters considered under CRAS model and their weightsParameter Weight of each
(A) Management Risk Factors 20
(B) Industry & Unit Risk Factors 10
(C) Financial Risk Factors 50
(D) Operational Experience 20
Total 100
Credit Rating System (CRS) Model:
CRS model is a very simple model. CRS model is considered for credit limits between 5 to
50lakhs. Table 19 gives the parameters are considered CRS. Table 20 shows the ratings that
can be obtained and their meaning.
Table 19 Parameters under CRS model
SI.NO Parameter
1 Total Debt equity Ratio
2 DPG/TL/LC/BG/ interest commitments
3 Compliance with terms & conditions of sanction
4 Total Sales
5 Inventory + Sundry debtors
6 Submission of MSOD/Stock statements/Renewal Data
7 Achievement of projected sales
8 Supported by collateral security including II nd charge on Fixed Assets
9 Operational Experience in cash credit
10 Financial Risks not transparent
11 Unhedged Forex Risks
21
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
36/66
Table 20 Credit rating and their meaning in CRS model
Marks
secured
Credit
Rating
Grade
Acceptable Credit Rating:
Above
95%
A+++ Prime
>90 to
95%
A++ Excellent
>80 to
90%
A+ Very good
>70 to80%
A Good
>60 to
70%
B Satisfactory
>40 to
60%
C Average
Unacceptable Credit Ratings:
40% &
Below
D Poor
CRISIL Rating and Industry analysis:
Andhra bank has also subscribed to CRISIL for the purpose of risk rating the borrower. Even
though Andhra Bank has its own method for rating the borrower, CRISIL ratings are used
for cross checking the rating obtained using its own rating system.
Industry: commercial Real estate (Commercial real estate has been defined as the
construction of office and retail spaces (including malls and multiplexes).
The main players in this industry are real estate developers. Small regional players continue
to dominate the commercial real estate market, while large players have been trying to
expand beyond cities in which they have traditionally operated. The industry is predominant
unorganised, but less as compared to residential housing industry. However, the unorganised
nature of the industry has resulted in high finance costs, which have further raised its risk
profile. Table 21 gives the factors considered by CRISIL and the weights given to them.
22
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
37/66
Table 21 Factors considered by CRISIL for industry score
Factor Weight Score
Industry characteristics 85
Demand supply gap 35-Fluctuation in demand supply gap
- Growth potential
-Cyclicality
Government policy 20
-Importance to economy
-Sensitivity of government policies
Input related risk 30
Extent of competition 15
-Threat of imports/Substitutes/Unorganised sector
- Barriers to entry
-Technology risk
-International competitiveness
-Bargaining power of buyer industries
-Bargaining power of supplier industries
Total Score 2.4
For purpose of evaluating Industry risk score, the factors mentioned in the above table are
considered. The industry risk score obtained for commercial real estate is 2.4.
Demand and supply scenario:
Demand for commercial space has shown signs of revival with improvement in economy and
absorption levels have improved slightly. Many large occupiers in IT/Ites sector are
evaluating tier i/ii cities for setting up new offices but are adopting a cautious approach
before selecting a location or property. An improvement in demand has led to many of the
projects that were postponed witnessing fresh interest. However, the supply in office spaceand retail space exists and hence lease rentals for both commercial office space and retail
space are expected to remain more or less stable across the tem major cities that CRISIL
tracks in 2011.
Key drivers:
1. The demand for office space is mainly driven by IT/ITES sector, BPO and call
centres.
23
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
38/66
2. Increasing disposable incomes, faster growth in urban population and rising
demand for branded products are the man drivers for growth of malls and
multiplexes in India.
Output/capacity:
The commercial real estate industry is relatively more organised as compared to the
residential segment. This is primarily because, unlike residential segments where in the
project is partly sponsored by the customer advance, commercial projects have to be funded
largely by the way of promoter contribution and debt.
More over the asset starts generating revenue only after it is leased. Both funding difficulty
and the underlying risk with regard to leasing the property have been discouraging
developers to enter this segment. As a result, only established players with strong brand
images have ventured into commercial properties.
The industries organised nature improves its overall rating. Track record and reputation acts
as important differentials among players. Thus while developers with a brand image are able
to sell their office, small players face intense competition. Falling demand and excess supply
has increased competition. There by putting considerable pressure on the margins and
rentals.
Outlook:
1. Rentals for commercial spaces are likely to remain more or less stable in 2011.
2. Demand for commercial sector would remain muted over next one year. Increase in
prices of major inputs like steel and cement are expected to increase construction
cost. The proposed levy of 18.5 % minimum alternate tax on developers of special
economic zones will impact the profitability of developers.
3. The oversupply position is expected to increase competition; hence the medium term
outlook for the sector continues to be unfavourable.
Price realization:
The average value of operating profit that is generally available for commercial real estate is
given in table 22.
24
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
39/66
Table 22 Operating margins for commercial real estate
Year 2004-5 2005-6 2006-7 2007-8 2008-9 2009-10
Operating profit margin (%) 36.81 34.75 59.79 58.44 54.5 51
Return on capital employed (%) 12.8 19.17 13.86 16.91 9.48 10.4
1. Land is the major component of costs accounting for nearly 30-50 % of the total
project costs, with construction accounting for the rest. In the residential real
estate segment, the developer benefit from customer advances as a source of
finance.
2. On the other hand, developers in the commercial real estate segment first have to
construct and then lease or sell the property. Hence they have to bear the risk
themselves. Increased volatility in commodity prices and problems in land
acquisition have increased input related risks for developer.
3. The prices of major inputs namely cement and steel are expected to increase apart
from the increase in the excise duty.
Government policy:
1. With the importance of the sector in aiding gross fixed capital formation and
employment generation, the government had recently relaxed norms for FDI in real
estate.
2. Funding by banks for commercial real estate used to be assigned a risk weight of 150
per cent which has a major deterrent in the financing of commercial projects.
However the reserve bank of India has relaxed the risk weight from 150 per cent to
100 percent for loans given to real estate companies by the bank. This change in riskweight is expected to boost fund availability for commercial developers in long term.
3. While the urban land ceiling and regulation act(ULCRA) and rent control act(RCA)
have created scarcity of land in urban markets, other regulations such as coastal
regulatory zone (CRZ), mill land regulation and property taxes and stamp duties have
further affected growth in real estate.
Fiscal policy:
25
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
40/66
1. In union budget 2009-10, the tax holiday for software companies in software
technology parks was extended by one year. Foreign direct investment norms have
been relaxed for this sector.
2. But in the union budget 2011-12 a levy of 18.5 % minimum alternate tax on
developers of special economic zones has been proposed which will negatively
impact the sector. Also the tax holiday for software companies are major drivers of
demand for office space in urban areas.
Risk factors:
1. Impact on profitability on account of cost and time overturns due to the volatility in
land prices, disputes in title, eviction of tenants.
2. High finance cost
3. Adverse economic conditions
Step 5: Calculating applicable interest rate and tenure:
The applicable rate of interest in decided based on credit rating secured by the borrower.
Table 22 shows the applicable spread that can be applied under various rating obtained.
Table 23 Applicable spread
Credit rating under CRRM Applicable spread for commercial real estate
A++ 6.5%-7%
A+ 7.25%-7.5%
A 7.5%
B++ 7.5%
B+ 7.5%
B 7.5%C 7.5%
Step 6: Working capital assessment
Working capitals limits are asked in order carry out day to day operations of the bank. There
are 3 methods used by the bank for the purpose of assessment of working capital
requirements.
The working capital gap can also be funded using bank facility like overdraft or open cash
credit. Each type of financing has its own pros and cons. It is up to the management team of
26
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
41/66
the company to decide which type of funds they would want to avail. For the purpose of
availing working capital facilities assessment needs to be done. This assessment of Working
capital assessment would be done as prescribed by RBI depending upon the applicability.
Turn over method or I method: The bank is following Turnover method for assessment of
credit limits for all sectors (manufacturing & trading) with fund based working capital limits
up to Rs. 6 crore from the banking system. Under this method three months of turnover is
financed as working capital irrespective of level of inventories, maintained by the
constituent.
Banks finance can be availed up to 75% of the working capital gap. The rest 25 % should be
brought out from long term sources of funds. Under this method working capital eligibilityhas to be arrived based on 25% of turnover projected less 5% of turnover or actual NWC
available whichever is more. If actual NWC is less than required NWC, the borrower has to
bring in the shortfall and sanctioning Authority has to ensure the same. Actual NWC means
NWC available as per latest audited balance sheet. The assessment of working capital limits
should be done both as per Turnover Method and Inventory Method and higher of the two is
to be sanctioned depending upon the need. Table 24 shows the methodology followed under
Turn over method.
Table 24 Turn over method calculations
II method of working
capital assessment:
Under this method
the borrower should
provide for at least
25% of the current
assets from long term sources of funds (equity and long term loan). This also means that total
of current assets including banks borrowings should not exceed 75% of the current assets.
Under this system current assets and current liabilities are calculated. The gap between
current assets and current liabilities is called as working capital gap. Then the procedure
explained in the table below is followed by the bank in calculating the working capital
requirement or Maximum bank permissible funds (MPBF). Table 25 gives the methodology
followed under second method.
27
Turn Over Method
A. Turnover
B. 25% of (A)
C. Margin Required at 5% of (A)
D. Margin (NWC)
E. (B - C)
F. (B-D)
G. MPBF ( E or F whichever is lower)
H. Excess borrowing
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
42/66
Table 25 II method calculations
A) Current Assets( without bank funds)
B) Current liabilities(Without bank
funds)C) Working Capital Gap ( A-B)
D) Minimum stipulated. NWC (25% of
CA excl. Export receivables)
E) Actual/Projected NWC
F) Item C Minus Item D
G) Item C Minus Item E
H) Eligible Credit (Item F or G
whichever is lower)
Cash budget method: This method is used in calculating cash deficit that exists throughout
the year. This method is also used in seasonal sectors such as agro-based like sugar, food,
tea, tobacco, fertilizers and etc. This method is also applicable to seasonal industries such as
air conditioning, cotton textiles. This method is also applicable for construction industries.
For the before mentioned industries other method of working capital assessment or II method
are not applicable as the fluctuation levels of current assets and current liabilities in high.
Under Cash budget method maximum gap between total receipts and total payment is
covered by the banks finance. Disbursement are allowed based on monthly cash budgets
The borrower is a builder and contractor and the working capital assessment is worked out
based on the cash budget method.
28
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
43/66
Table 26 Cash deficit method of the borrower
Month Surplus/Deficit
Apr-11 -700.93
May-
11 -700.63
Jun-11 -700.31
Jul-11 -700.14
Aug-11 -700.24
Sep-11 -700.57
Oct-11 -700.16
Nov-11 -700.12
Dec-11 -700.15
Jan-12 -700.27
Feb-12 -700.49
Mar-12 -700.86
The maximum deficit is 7.01 crores in noticed during the months as can be seen from table
26. The borrower is eligible for SOD limit of Rs 7 crore.
The firm requested for sanction of SOD limit of 7 crores at finer rates of 7 crore as they are
executing projects of 23.3 crores apart from the proposed OMR project cost of Rs 29.99
crore
The firm working capital limits are renewed by Head Office, where in the enhancement of
SOD limit from 4.5 crores to7 crores was not considered in view of the NIL sales booked in
the year 2010-11. Branch/Zonal office recommends for enhancement of SOD limit from 4.5
crores to 7 crores keeping in view the various projects on hand.
Step 7: Credit investigation, due diligence & verification of defaulters list:
Whenever credit limits are requests are to be considered, it is necessary to conduct a credit
investigation before taking up such proposals for evaluation. This process of preliminary
study needs to be undertaken invariably before detailed evaluation.
a) Areas of credit investigation:
29
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
44/66
Integrity of the borrower has no substitute. Before entering into any agreement with the
borrower it is very imperative that the bank understands the borrower and his propose
properly. Banks generally carry out interviews with the borrower and enquire about his past
record, details of associates, sister concerns and etc. Apart from quantitative aspect like past
financials, qualitative aspects such as market reputation are also checked. Know your
customer principle is equally important in the case of borrower. If the bank comes to know
about the unethical practices and illegal activities with which a firm or borrower is linked
then the bank tries to distance itself from the borrower. Pre sanction and post sanction of unit
are also a part of credit investigation.
b) Defaulters list:
It is mandatory for the bank to cross the names of borrowers with that of the names in the
previous wilful defaulters list. Table 27 gives the list of defaulters list to be checked.
Table 27 Defaulters list
Name of the list Yes/No
RBI defaulters list dated March 2011(Rs 1 crore and above) no
Caution list dated June 2011 no
Wilful defaulters list dated June 2011,(Rs 25 crore and
above) no
ECGC SAL list dated 12.12.2011 no
CIBIL suit filed Rs 1 core and above 30.06.11 no
CIBIL suit filed (wilful) Rs 25 lakhs and above 30.06.2011 no
Areas of strengths and weakness of the borrower
Strengths: The managing director Mr AAA is in this line of activity for more than a decade.
He is also a qualified civil engineer. The overall conduct obtained by borrower in table 28.
Weakness:
1. All partners are from single family
2. Normal business competition which can be, however be overcome by maintaining
quality in the works better customer care and the reputation it has built up for itself
all over the years.
30
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
45/66
3. Heavy competition, government policies, natural calamities will influence the
industry and the damages if any costs heavily
Table 28 conduct of the borrowerABILITY CONDUCT REPUTATION CONDITION
capable prudent shrewd sound
experienced steady honest progressive
incapable conservative tricky stagnant
inexperienced overtrade dishonest declining
speculative
Step 8 Financial analysis and compliance:
Key financial Indicators: Table 29 shows various key financials obtained.
Table 29 key financial indicators
Audited Audited Projection Audited provisional
Financial indicators 31-03-2009 31-03-2010 31-03-2011 31-03-2011 31-09-2011
Net sales 1.33 7.34 0 0 3.03
Other income 0 0.04 0.11 0.14 0.08
Profit before tax 0.14 0.25 0.97 0.39 0.92Profit after tax 0.12 0.24 0.97 0.39 0.92
Depreciation 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.06 0.03
Cash generation 0.16 0.29 1.03 0.45 0.95
paid up capital 1.65 2.43 6.15 6.25 7.07
Tangible net worth 1.65 2.43 6.15 6.25 7.07
Adjusted TNW 4.07
Gross Fixed assets 0.32 0.51 0.45 0.48 0.42
Net fixed assets 0.28 0.46 0.39 0.42 0.39
Term liabilities 2.93 1.27 2 1.99 2.51
Banks 0.25 0.21 1.9 1.9 1.18
Friends and relatives 2.68 1.06 0.09 0.09 1.33
Investments 0 0 0 2.18 0
Current assets 8.1 10.03 22.18 20.99 26.87
Current liabilities 5.98 8.97 16.61 15.35 19.91
Net working capital 2.12 1.06 5.57 5.64 6.96
Current ratio 1.35 1.12 1.34 1.37 1.35
TOL/TNW 5.4 4.21 3.02 2.77 3.17
Adjusted TOL/TNW 4.26
Debt equity ratio 1.78 0.52 0.32 0.32 0.35Interest coverage ratio 1.43 1.6 3.31 2.05 3.06
31
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
46/66
Net profit / net sales 9.02 3.27 3.29
(Table 29 contd.)
As can be seen from the above table, the key financials are presented. Table 30 gives
remarks on key financials.
Table 30 Remarks on key financial indicators
Remarks on retained profits The firm retained 100% of the profit earned
during the year 2009-10 in the business. The
firm has introduced additional capital of Rs
3.50 crore during 2010-11
Remarks on tangible net worth TNW of the firm increased from Rs 2.43
crores as on 31.3.10 to Rs 6.25 crores as on31.3.2011 due to retention of profits and
infusion of capital of Rs 3.50 crores
Remarks on Net working capital The NWC has increased from Rs 1.06 crores
as at 31.3.2010 to Rs 5.57 crores by
31.3.2011. The increase in the NWC is due to
retention of profits of Rs 3.50 crores and
increase in tem liability.
Remarks on Current ratio The current ratio of the firm as at 31.3.2011
is 1.37 and satisfactory which is above the
minimum required level of 1.33
Remarks on Total outside liabilities to TNW TOL/TNW as at 31.3.2010 is 4.21 and as at
31.3.2011 is 2.77. The decrease in the ratio
is on account of increase in TNW due to
infusion of additional capital into the firm
Remarks on debt/equity ratio Debt equity ratio marginally improved from
0.52 as on 31.3.10 to 0.32 as on 31.3.2011 on
account of increase in TNW
Remarks on interest coverage ratio Interest coverage stood at 2.05 as per ABS
31.3.2011 and is satisfactory
Remarks on Investment/advances to associate
concerns
The firm owns a property at Gandhi bazaar,
Bengaluru and is shown as investment,
amounting to Rs 2.18 crores
Remarks on diversion of funds There is no diversion of funds from short
term sources to long term uses in the FY
32
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
47/66
2011
Remarks on borrowings from friends and
relatives
Unsecured loans reduced from Rs1.06 crores
as on 31.3.10 to Rs 0.09 as on 31.3.11
Remarks on overdue statutory liabilities NilRemarks on contingent liabilities not
provided for
Nil
Remark on EPS and share value Not applicable
Does the account show sign of incipient
sickness
No
(Table 30 contd.)
Achievability of estimated/Projected production sales
Table 31 sales receipts
Year
Actual/estimate
s Receipts
2008-2009 Actual 1.33
2009-2010 Actual 7.34
2010-2011 Actual 0
30.09.201
1 Provisional 3.03
2011-2012 Estimates 21.32
2012-2013 Projection 21.75
Table 31 provides the details of sales achieved and projected. The firm has estimated sales of
Rs 21.32 crores for the year ending 31.3.2012 and projected Rs 21.75 crores for the year
ending 31/3/2013.
33
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
48/66
The recessionary trend is slowly reversing and the projections can be achieved as they are
having sufficient projects on hand and new OMR projects.
During the year 2010-11, the sales booked are Nil. The profit after tax is 0.39 crores. The
firm has three ongoing projects at Old Mahabalipuram road, Chennai. The firm has
recognised 10% profit on the total cost incurred on the above projects after deducting
administrative and other expenses.
Auditors comments: Auditors comments are submitted by the auditors after going through
the financials of the company. Table 32 gives the details of the auditors comments
submitted by the borrower. Auditors comment on the companys balance sheet:
34
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
49/66
Table 32 Auditors comments
1 On revaluation of fixed
assets
Nil
2 On change of method of
depreciation
Nil
3 On loans and advances given
to the concerns within the
group
Nil
4 On position of unserviceable
stores/obsolete stock
Nil
5 On position of overdue /
irrevocable debtors
Nil
6 On disputed liabilities not
provided for
Nil
7 On valuation of inventory Nil
8 Others Nil
Step 9 Term and conditions:
Special terms and conditions:
1. Disbursement of term loan shall be based on the work completion certificate by our
approved engineer and CA certificate for the amount spent on the project. The release
of term loan shall be in the ratio 1:1:2 i.e. capital: booking money: term loan.
2. Branch has to maintain ESCROW account to credit the proposed sale proceeds of the
shops for term loan I and a separate ESCOW account for lease rentals for repayment
of term loan II.
3. As and when the sale of the commercial establishment takes place and advance
amount is received, the company shall remit the same into ESCROW account and
any amount received in excess of rupees 7.49 crore shall be utilised for repayment of
the loan. Our bank will have a charge on the ESCROW account and withdrawal from
35
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
50/66
escrow account will first be for the payment of interest on the term loans and towards
repayment of the term loans availed.
4. The binding letter of intent is duly modified by extending the due date of handing
over the possession to the cinipolis by the applicant builder as there might be delay in
handing over the project.
5. Branch may be permitted to issue NOC after repayment of Rs 5000 per sft and to
release the proportionate mortgaged land/undivided share along with shops to be
registered in favour of the customers duly ensuring availability of sufficient security
coverage to the loan amount outstanding at the time of each realization
Pre disbursement conditions:
Before seeking the disbursement of term loan or SOD, the firm has to comply the
following:
1. The owners Mr zzz and his wife shall execute a sale deed alienating their 50% share
of undivided land in favour of M/S builders, and the firm should offer the said
property as security.
2. The firm to submit a notarised letter of undertaking to the bank to the effect that the
firm/builder should not alienate or encumber any part or parts of the 50% share of the
property sold to them without written consent from the bank.
3. The owners of land to give a notarised letter to the bank to the effect that the GPAs
dated 17.10.2007 and 09.07.2008 are valid and subsisting and they will not becancelled till the completion of project.
4. The lessee to the firm M/S kkk India PVT limited who had executed binding letter of
agreement on 7.10.2010 shall inform the bank by the way of letter of
acknowledgement that the Binding letter of agreement (BLA) dated 7.10.2010 has
been approved by their Board and the same is subsisting and agreed to execute
agreement to lease as per terms of BLA.
Issues raised by the HO:
36
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
51/66
1. The personal guarantee of all persons giving their property as security against loans
to the firm to be obtained.
2. The party to agree for applicable rate of interest, no logic of concession for
commercial property as risk is high.
3. Promoters to bring more equity and the loan to be reduced proportionately. No
deviation in margin money is desirable.
4. Nothing is mentioned about clear and marketable title, how the firm will mortgage 50
% share of the land when they have not paid for it upfront. Land owners should join
as co-borrowers.
Reply by the Zonal office Chennai:
1. The personal guarantee of all the persons giving their property as security against the
loan to the firm will be given and the land owners will give guarantee limited to the
value of property being mortgaged by tem. As and when sale of office space is
affected the guarantee of the owners is to be reduced proportionately.
2. The firm is agreeable to rate of interest levied by the bank.
3. The form agreed to bring in margin of Rs 149895 lakhs and also bring additional
margin as decided by us.
4. The total extent of land where the office space and multiples is proposed is 45306 sft
out of this, 16954 sft being the undivided share of land pertaining to multiplex will be
transferred to the applicant firm by the way of sale deed and the same deposited by
the firm. An extent of 7248 sft being the proportionate undivided share of landpertaining to the office space will be mortgaged by the present owner of the land to
the extent of sales made; the bank is requested to issue NOC for building and
corresponding undivided share of land.
5. ZO recommends for sanction of term loan for Rs 7.32 Cr (reduced from 8 crores) and
TL II for 7 crores.
37
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
52/66
38
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
53/66
Results
Credit risk rating results
The borrower is rated as B as per CRRM. The applicable rate of interest for the term loan is
BR+7.50+TP. Borrower is requesting rate of interest for term loan at BR+4+0.25
i.e.10.75+4+0.25=15%. TP here stands for Term premium. The value of TP is 0.25 is a fixed
value and is applicable only when the tenure of credit facility is greater than 3 years. Table
33 and and table 34 show the ratings obtained by the borrower.
The borrower is rated B under CRRM as per ABS. The credit rating rationale is furnished
below:
Table 33 Rating given to the borrower
Parameter Score Rating
A)Financial risk evaluation 3.04 B+
B)Business risk evaluation 1.46 C
C)Industry risk evaluation assessment 3.1 B+
D)Management evaluation 3.35 B+
E)Security/conduct of accounts 5.25 A+Overall rating including facility 2.89 B
Projected risk evaluation 2.33 C
Overall rating including facility &
project 2.84 B
Apart from the above ratings as per CRRM, the ratings mentioned below are also obtained.
Table 34 Other ratings
Internal company rating: 2.72 B
Company rating(w/o size criteria) 2.76 B
Company rating(with size criteria) 2.76 B
DSCR results:
39
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
54/66
DSCR ratio has been calculated for the using the past and projected data. DSCR results
obtained have been shown in table 35.
Table 35 DSCR estimations
YEAR DSCR ratio
Mar-11 provisional 1.77
Mar-12 estimates 2.03
Mar-13 estimates 1.6
Mar-14 estimates 1.51
Mar-15 estimates 1.41
Mar-16 estimates 1.42
Mar-17 estimates 1.73
Mar-18 estimates 2.13
Mar-19 estimates 2.56
Average DSCR=1.8. This means that the company will be able to service its debt effectively.
Sensitivity analysis results:
Sensitivity analysis results are given below. In sensitivity analysis the variations in DSCR
are found out by varying the input parameters such as cost of production, sales and interest
rate. The table below gives the sensitivity details. Results obtained in sensitivity analysis
have been shown in table 36.
Table 36 Sensitivity Results
Sensitivity analysis DSCR
Parameter Average Min Max
Normal 1.77 1.41 2.56
5 % increase in cost of production 1.36 1 2
15% decrease in receipts/sales
realization 1.76 1.37 2.45
Increase on TL & WC increase by 2.5% 1.67 1.33 2.42
1. According to the policy, DSCR ratio should be given 1.5 to 2.
2. It is observed that the activity in insensitive to the extent for the given situation for
the above level of variations and the firm will be stable to service the interest
40
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
55/66
/instalment of the term loan and working capital. Normal weighted average DSCR is
1.71 which is comfortable and complied with policy guidelines.
Working capital Results:
Build up net working capital: For financing working capital long term sources such as equity
and term loans are made use of. Table 37 gives the working build up, which has been done
by adding funds from long term sources and deducting funds to long term used.
Table 37 Working capital build up
Audited Audited Estimates
31.03.10 31.03.11 31.03.12
Actual NWC at beginning of the year 2.12 1.06 5.64
ADD: Retained Profit for the year 0.24 0.39 1.67
(Net Profit after tax and dividend)
Depreciation 0.05 0.06 0.06
Additional Long Term Funds:
Increase in Capital/Share Application
Money
0.78 3.38. 1.03
Increase in Deposits
Increase in Term Loans 0.00 0.72 6.17
Others 0.00 0.00 0.00SUB TOTAL 2.91 5.61 14.57
LESS: Long Term Uses:
Reduction in Deposits
Reduction in Term Liabilities 1.66 0.00 0.00
Increase in Fixed Assets 0.19 -0.03 0.05
Others 0.00 0.00 0.00
SUB TOTAL 1.85 -0.03 0.05
NWC as at the end of the Year 1.06 5.64 14.52
1. Net working capital at the end of the year is arrived by adding long term sources of
fund and subtracting long term uses of funds. As can the Net working capital at the
end of financial 2009-10 year is 1.06 crores which increased to 5.64 by end of
financial year 2010-11. The value of projected estimates by the end of financial year
2011-12 is estimated to be around 14.52 crores.
Compliance to policy
41
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
56/66
The borrower needs to comply with various policy guidelines. Table 38 shows various
parameters and required level of each parameter.
Table 38 Compliance to loan policy guidelines
As per policy
(in crores)
present
proposal
compliance
Yes or No
Exposure applicable to
category(borrower wise) 30 4.5 yes
Group wise exposure N.A
current ratio 1.33 1.37 yes
TOL/TNW 6 2.77 yes
capital gearing ratio 10 - N.A
Pre sanction unit inspection yes
credit rating B Yes
Conclusions1. The methodology followed at Andhra bank is a very comprehensive and is in
accordance to guidelines issued by RBI.
2. The bank follows Tandon committees recommendations for working capital
assessment.
3. The risk evaluation process currently followed at Andhra Bank is compliant with the
Basel III guidelines.
42
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
57/66
4. The interest rate charged to borrower is completely justified in accordance to the risk.
5. The pre disbursement and post disbursement conditions are completely justified and
are as per the loan policy of the bank.
43
7/29/2019 Credit Appraisal of Term Loans and Working Capital Limits
58/66
Limitations
1. The data used is mostly secondary data and is submitted by the borrower. All
calculations and estimations are done based on the data provided by the borrower.
2. Projected financial statements are used. However there might be deviations in future
which again put financial strain on the borrower.
3. Dependence on third party for the purpose of estimating the industry risk.
4. No direct contact with the borrower. All the communication with the borrower has