Countering the Opposition

8/13/2019 Countering the Opposition

1/20

CO!NERING#HE OO"I#ION

!-:765,15/;6 ;0- #-59-,1+;)*3-

& !-+


2/20

1 HE ACIC" Of NO KILL OONEN"

Requiring shelters to

give animals to rescue

groups means putting

animals into the hands

of hoarders and dogfighters.

#HE

#AC#IC"OfNO KILL

OONEN#"

We can never be

No Kill as long asthe public is

irresponsible.

!There are simpl

too man animals

and not enough

homes for them all."

No Kill causes

animal suffering.

Open admission

shelters cannot be

No Kill.


3/20

HE NO KILL Ad%OCAC( CENE!

FiF'ee" +ea% ag#, " K > =@

" K > > >>. '

,I =6 I

= >6 ===>.I " K

>@>> =@@ , > > A

> =. => =

@ =>>@= = == @

=>> @=, > 6

A AA = > >A= >.

= @

" K, @ ==> >=A>

6 >>. == A

" K @> =>> @=, A=@

>= >==>

6 = =>> >@ > 6 >, = =>, @> >

= =, > ( =)

>>> 6 @= =>==

6 @, = @> ==

= = 6 > = >

>=. >= ==> @

A= > , > @ =

6. ' > 6 = =, @

= =. '

= > = " KG=

A= = =G > 6 = @.I @J>

=@> @>A >= =

" K >, =

; @= >

= @I = >6=6. "

K > A ==E >;

" K > A @ >A =

A>. #=> , >==>

" K >, = @= >.

a> A=> =6 A= =>>

=@ @=

>=>, = >G

>= ==> >A> = >

= =E>GA=

=> > = ==

@>> >.

We cant be No Killbecause we cant adopt

out animals who mightinjure someone,especially a child.

No Kill meansanimals livingtheir entire livesin cages

We have all the No

Kill programs but itjust doesnt work.

No Kill is veryexpensive. Ourcommunity cannot

afford it.

!No Kill advocates

are radical extremists."


4/20


5/20


A= =,

A=@ > = 6

> >=> > @>@, 6 =

> =@ =

A. ? B@> > =A

= 6: =,

>=> @ = = >

, > > == > =>@ >@

@ =>> =>

>@ =@ > @= ==>.

B@ > A = >

=> = >: =, = =

= 6 =

= A= = = = >

6 >=>. ' = >

> = >; > @=

A = =6 >=

> >. %= =

>=>, = = > =

>=>, ==>, >= >, =>

= >. i = =>,

> > >

>= > =@ =>A

==> , >

@=>, = >=> 6 >

A @ >.

a@ > = >=> A=

=. C >=> > =

>? ' > > J A

. > , @ => . >, 6 = >, @=

=>. #=> = =

>. > =>@ =@>.

#=> = == >@= = >>

> = = >@=. a

6 @ >= =@

=>A = =.

@ @= 6 @>

>=>, = 6 = 6

. C > = >>? +> .

>> > >=> >@

> = @ >

= => =, = >

I 8) 8)( s8%8)7, 8)6) %6) 23

4)4) + 8 6+ % '%8

6 (+ 8 8)6 ) ))6= =)%6,

;) 86)) %%7 %6) )(

96 %87 7)8)67 98 *6 %

). )6) %6) %= 6)%77 ;=

%%7 %6) )+ )( 7)8)67.

B98 4)8 )6449%8 7 8 ) *

8). I8 74= ()7 8 )


6/20

A @ >

==>> = 6. B@ >

=@? eA A=@ = >=>

@, @=>> = @=

> => A= =

=> 2011 A= 50

=>. # > > =

>, a=> > A @=>

> = = =>. '

>> =6 = > >6

@ 6 = > > = >. eA >

= > =@ @>, @ A =>@=>

>>> > IGA

= > > >-

>.I ' => =

> =>@ >= @

A = >. ' >

=6 = = = 6>. '

=E = A==J>

G => > @, >

>= = > =,

=> > = = =>

= > = > . '

J > 6> @ > A

@ J> A> =

= A=-=> @=> @ = >>=> @> =,

>=> @ A= A=

=>. ' J > >@>>

A> @ > > > =

A A = . a, =


@= 6 = 6 . i ,

> = @>. B@ > >

A =. '= = A= 23

= =.

= = =

>= = >. == =

== = = = >@=. B@ 17

A =

= =>= >>

@ = >=GJ> 17

A = =@

= >. A 80 =

> = = >=

= >=, @ >

6.

" > =A , @ > > >@>> E> " K @>

> =@@ , @

@> 6 20 > =

6 = > = = =>

6 " +=6 C.

I#D" #HE I!!E"ON"IBLE $BLICD" fA$L#.#2

E


7/20


=, =E " K

>@>> =@@ @= > =>@

Gpeople who care deeply. C= >

; > =@.

'= = " K @> . > @> = "=,

> @. = @=, >

=@=. = @ >=>; > =

=A. = @I =

- >> > = A=

>=AA => @=G >

> => = => >.

" = , =

=@= => @, "

K >@>> =A> = >

@ A >> = >

A= @ A=

==>> .

!=A=, > @> A

6, > @ >

=: => >,

A@=>, >, >= = =

@ >@=. => 6

@ , = ,

> >G> > a=>

>= => => =

>G .. >=> @>

= ==>> J =

@ @ .

I '98)7 8%8 %)

%'))( N K 79'')77, 8)

49' ((8 '%+), 8)

7)8)67 ; 4')7 %(46')(96)7 ((.

I s H E I R J O BA% 7)8)67 %6) 79447)( 8 46() %

7%*)8= )8, 978 ) 8)6 7'% 7)6')

%+)')7 ;' ()% ;8 8) )**)'87 * 9%

66)7478=. ) (**)6)')? ) 8)67 (8

97) 49' 66)7478=@ %7 % )


8/20


#3 ID" OO E'EN"I%E.

@> =>>@=>

=>> , > =>@, @==> >=A> = @>,

=@ " K > >A >

==>>A >=

==> = => =>

>A >. + 6@,

==> > 6 >

>A A> = = >-A

@, =@> 6

>. = =A =, >

@> =>@ =@>, > >>

= = @ => =A

A@> =@>. #=>, >@ > @>

A@=>, @ @ =>@=>. =>, >@ > >, = =A@.

a, , >, >@ > @= ==

6 = >, = > >> >A

-=,

>A> => =@ =>.

i , @-> >@ @

== = @ =

= >A =>. # @

>A 90 = >, =

>A 40 = > @= > = = >

=. # @ > > 6 =>

=> A= 30 = >

>-@ >= >>> .

a= > @> => =

50 = > @ >.

!=A=, > > >= >> = ,

6 > A >

= => >>. 6>

=@ > @

6 > > 6 , >

=>> =A @>>=,

= >>->6, >>->A =

@ =@ @

A@= >@=. " >-

A ==> 6 " K

>> @J> ,

= >@=

= =E> A@=>. i F=> @= 1990>, A@=>

> A= 110,000 @=> >=

=. a>>@ -=A

@= , @ A >

A= => =A >

>=A>.

m%= * 8) 46+6%7 ()8*)(

%7 )= '4)87 * 7%+ )7

%6) 6) '78-)**)'8) 8%

49(+, ;%6)97+ %(

8) + %%7. s) 7*8'787 8 46%8) 4%864=.

O8)67 6+ 6))9). s8

8)67 %6) 74= )77 )


9/20


A 98-78%8) 789(= *9(8%8 8)6) ;%7

'66)%8 )8;)) 6%8)7

* *)7%+ %( 4)6

'%48% 74)(+

%% '86. )

(**)6)') )8;)) 87)

7)8)67 8%8 79''))()( %8

7%+ )7 %( 87)

8%8 *%)( ;%7 8 8)7>) * 8) 9(+)8, 98

8) '8)8 * 8)6

(6)'867 8 4))8+

%8)6%8)7 8 +.

d-,1+);165 M);;-9: M69- #0)5 M65-@

a , A=, A@=> =>@=>

= =A = >>> ==>>A

> >=> =>> @=. eA

> @> , =

>=> @ = A@=>

=6 A= 6. B " K >,

>= A@= => => =. i

%, "A, @ >

=> @= A@=> = 30

= 8,000 = @ > " K

A. i , @= >=

> => = @ >

2,500, >A A> >

>=. ' >=A> A@=> =A

=@ >>, =>

> >A = @,= =A@

>=.

B= %J> " K A, >=

@ = 5,000 > >

A= =. ' => = @ =

> => =>. i 2010, >

=> , @= >

@ @> @= 10,000. i > >A> =@ $200,000

>> 6, > =@

> $250,000 =A@>.

!=A=, >A

> => > >

@ @>>>> A= 12

=> @ >>. A=

> =@ 10 => = ,

=A@> @ @>>>> A=

> > @ 120

=>.

' @= > >@> = A

> > = ( = ,


10/20


* In addition to the fact that animals are under the constant threat of a death sentence in many shelters, some commercially-

sourced animals come from mills which contribute to animal cruelty.

@>>>> @ = => =

>; = =, @

= = => >). i ,

> @>>>>

@= =@ > A =,

> A> > = =A@>. a A= > = =,

> A= 10-= = @

= A= 20 =>

>> .

> >

=E A

= = >@=> 6 ==>, >

>A> = =A@> .* F=

, > >=E =

, == >=

>> 6 >= > >

>. !=A=, @

= => >> =>

=A@ >> > > >. F, >@>>@

=6 == =>@> E>

= = 6 = >=,

@ => @= A

> > >= E>

6 A@ > >=J> >A

>>, = @= =

> >.

#4 NO KILL H!EAEN" $BLIC "AfE(.

" K A> = = ==

= >= i>, >=J> ==

= , J " K @>

J @ A@> > @=

>, > .I ' =

= > .

> @ A

>, @ = >

, > =, =>. i >,

, ==>> >@> =>. B@

> >=J> ==>>A ==

6 .

a " K @ > = =

= > = 6. =@,

= = > > = >>

= @=, == >@= = >

>, =>>A = =>> ==. '> > =

> , > >=,

= 6, @>> >=> > = >

>@= =. a >=>

= A = >@>> >

@ A >= @I =>

> > => @

= => ==A A== A= ,

@> " K > >

A@> > A

= , > >> @ >.


11/20

HE NO KILL Ad%OCAC( CENE! 1

&E !IEd NO KILL. I dIdND &O!K.#5

K > . i >

=> =@> >= 6 >,@= @ @. " K > >

. i > =>

=@> >= = 6

=A>. i> >@>> > == =

== >

. a >= == > A =

" K,I @ > =

=>> 6> >=

= = 6 =, > 6

>>= A =@ =@>>,

" K > . i = =A,

G > >, >= =G

== @ > >== A=

6. 6>, >= " K

> @= => > = >

6 =>. #=

= >=> => > >

@> A , '"% >

== >A = = >. a

>= " K > = =>@ =@> >> > >

,I @ A= =>@ =@ >

6 A= = @>

. i, " K >= A >6>

> =@> @.

=@, >=> A

= " K @ =6. '>

> > A

> = ==>, @

@ = = 6. i 2004, = , Ca

1.5 @

=@ 150 = >/@= >@==> =

> @J> -

@. ' >=J> ==

> -> = >/@=

==, @ >@ 6 A >@==>

= = @= = A= ,

@= > = >=>. B

=>, = Ca, =@

@, == A= 9,000

>@==> =, 84 = = =.

s)8)6 + 7 8 %

)8%8= 47)( 8

7)8)67 = 987() *6')7.

#)8)6 %%7 )8)6+7)8)67 ) 6 () ')7

(; 8 ) 8+: 8)

'')7 %() = 8)

4)4) ; 69 8).

CHOICE


12/20


=, = = @

> = >

>= = ==. ' >= >

= ==>

>=A> " K e@ @>> A=> =

= >A =, >=@>

A> >A. a

@ >= = @

> > ==,

=, >> " K

>= > >A > >

A= .

a " K >=, >E

> ==> = =

: need. CA =

>= @>

6 = A= =A

>@> J,

=> ===

=@>> >= ===

=. @>>@ " K >=

==> " K A

> =>> = @ =@>>

(>@ > , = = =@ > =>@ = @

>) =A =A> 6

=>> = @J> A

>> = >. i >=, @=

> =@>, == @>

> > > @> 6.

' A " K >@>>, ==, >=

@> ==> >=A>

" K eA. =>@> 6 6 = >A

>, @E " K e>, = > A =

>, @ = A=

> , A= > .

HE NO KILL

EQ!AION

"98))67

R)7'9) P%68)6747

F78)6 C%6)

6%4, N)98)6, R))%7)

C46))7) A(48

P6+6%7

m)('% & B)%6

P6))8 & R)%8%8

P)8 R)8)8

P9' R)%87/C98=

I))8

P6%'8) R)()487

H+-"9), L;-C78 s4%=

%( N)98)6

C4%77%8), D)('%8)(

L)%()674

' ==> &=A> eA=

= @ HA


13/20


i F=@= 2007, > >, "A,

>= " KI > > @ > @

= >. a= ==>,

>> > = >6 > =

= >. ' > =

A 6, >

>@>6 = >

=6 =. ' >

> >=J> >= >

=>, B= D==>

> A=> ==

=@> @ ==> @

>A A> >.

> > > = @=

= @= =6 >= >>.

a= >@E @=

= >=> =6>> 6 A> =

> = =

=A>: = =>, =@---

-6 >=> >@ > > @

=>> a=. > ==, @= > >:

> >=> = =@

=@ = @ >. ' > >

>=J> " KI > ==A. i

>>, = > 6

@==> => >

=@ , > =@ =@ >@>>@

>> " K >=>.

C> > > >=G

= >>, , >@=G ==> " K

A. " K > = =

@>A =, =@>

> @> 6. i >

=E >= => > >

= = = 6 A

A =@ >=

>. ' " K A @>

=> A= >=J> >> >:

a > =@>.I " K > @ A@

>, > >A = A>

@ > A > > @=

@ = 6 >A

> > >=> , @>

" K =@>I =@

@= >= == => .

i , =@ 1,000 > > = A>

> -" K ,

BNO KILLLEAd" #O &A!EHO$"ING.C#6

) N K )%(7 8 ;%6)97+@ %6+9)8 7 % '='7

;' %7 = ) 49647): 8 7)( 87) ; *% 8

7%) )7 *6 49' '68'7 %( 49' %''98%8= =

4%8+ % 4'896) * 8) %8)6%8) %7 )) (%6)6.


14/20

> E, I > >

>. ' " K >, >

@ . ',

> A= 6, >

> >= 6> > @

= = .

a= " a C=

a>>,

D> > = = 6>, >

>, , = > =

= A > = == 6. '

> = > @>A==6 6 =6=> = A

= . C>

>= . = => >

=> @> =>, =

J> A, > = >@= =

?

' = > >6 =

> >> = > >

A = A> >, >> =

6> = > = >

= = > ?I

' @@>, A=, > = = > .I

F=>, @ = == = @= 6> = >I >=

= A A,

6 @ A. , >

> = , = > =@

" K >=>. a -=@ " K >=>,

> = @> , -

A=>, = @=@> , =A

E

A@=> 6 , =

,

= . a =

6> = > = A =>. a

>> " K >=, A=

> > >

A= = A=>= =.

a =, > 14 >, =@ >

@ > A= > = >

= 6 = > =

A.

B = A >=6 > 6 =@> @>,

= => >=> A

=@ A " K = , -=@

>@>>@, > >=> =

>=> =@ 6G

> , = @

=.

R9+= 1,000 %%7 78

8)6 )7 %8 8) %(7 * 8)

%8-N K 8)% 8%8 '%)

, ))()7 %>+, 8 )4@8) %%7 L%7 ")+%7.

N K 44)87, )4+

%%7 )%8 4988+ 8)

8 ()%8.


% , > " K A

= -: >A A> >

== @= J> =6 >=

>>, @ A ,

> > >=>

@ =J> . '

ANIMAL !E"C$E!" A!E HOA!dE!" & dOG fIGH#E!".#7


15/20

==, > A> @> A =

" K e= =

>6 >= == >. ' A

=, = A> @> = =

=>@, >A > = =

= >= >

=@ =E> @ = >

@=>.

=@, >=> = @

A@= A > =>@ =@>. i2010, > =>@ >> >

" +=6 =@

=>@ =@> >A > =

" +=6 >=> @

> =>

==>. i > =@

> >= == > = >>

@> = >>@

>=>. a !>, >

==>>A >=>

= > >J> >=

== , A > = > >= @> = @ => =

=@ > A. i =, F=,

g= >=, => =

=>@ =@> >A > >=> =

6 A @>

> =@>.

a =, A=, > =>@

>> > > >

= =E> @ A @>

A. >>> >

= @ >@=> =

=, >,

I >G

>. a @= = >

>=> = = @> @> =

. B =>,

A=I >= > 50 =

6. i > 6 !=

C@, "= C=, > = =

=: 99 = > = 6.a @> =>@ =@> =

>A > > >@ 6,

= > 100 =

@ .

' >@> @> = > =

=>@=> > 6= 6. i =

@ >A >, @> >A =

shelters @ >

rescuers. !=A=, =>>G

=>@=> >G =@> A =

= >= > >

=.


R)7'9)67 %6) %% )67,

%= * ; %) 78%68)(8)6 6+%>%87 %*8)6

98))6+ %8 8)6 '%

7)8)6 %( 6)%>+ 8%8 * 8)

7)8)6 ;%78 ++ 8 (

;%8 ;%7 )')77%6= 8 7%)

)7, they;9(.


16/20


1Shelter killing isthe leading causeof death for healthydogs and cats in

the United States.

OEN AdMI""ION "HELE!" CANNO BE NO KILL.#8

" K >=> @ = =A, =

= >, @ >> = @

>. B@ =E> =@> >- >>I

= > " K: a

-6 >= = J A

>> . i @> > 6

> @ > 6 .I

'> > >. a " K >= =

>>I = >>.I a

= = " K =

>=> @> " K @>

=A .

a >>I >= > A G

>@ G = 6

>. i , @> =

>>I = 6 >=> > >. K

>=> = closed A >.

' = closed A >

O4) %(77@ 7)8)67 can ) N K.$Es!O4) %(77@ ()7 8 )% 6) 9%)@NO! ;) 8) )( 6)798 7 +.

I 8) )(, 8 7 8

%6()67 6 (+

*+8)67 6 '69) 4)4)

; %6) 6)747) *6

8) +6)%8)78 %6 8

)*% )%8= (+7 %(

'%87 87 '986=. )

9)6 ) '%97) *

()%8 *6 8)7) %%7

7 8) '% 7)8)6.

869= 468)'8 %%7,

8) %(%8) 7 ')%6:get them out of shelters.


17/20


"HEL#E! !EfO!M EffO!#" A!E $N!EA"ONABLE.#9

N K 44)87 ;6 8

()*)%8 7)8)6 6)*6 %(

6)7'9) %'')77 %;7 = =+

%98 8)6 6)596))87.

)6 +% 7 8 %) 8)7)

468%8 %;7 ;'%(%8) 74), '

7)7) 46')(96)7 %44)%6

96)%7%) %( % 86)%8

8 8 49' 7%*)8= %( 8)

%%7 8)7))7.

= = > = @ =

> . ' = closed g

=> > @

6. ' = closed A=>

>A A> @

> >> 6. a > @= > = > ,

=@> =A >=A =

==.

i=, 6 >=> = > > =

>- =I > =

> =A >>

@=> > =@ >

=>, 6 = ==>, =

=> @=> > , 6=>A =6 >. #

=I > = @I

=>@ > >> 6.

= == > " K

e, =, >> >@ >

C= D=, @>>@ > a@>, '>, A =@

=, F=, !>, % i>,

'>, g=, " +=6 >=. #

6 > " K > @>

>@ > > @ > =


18/20


# >= == > >= ==

> F= > = >

> > @=

=>@ =@> @> = =>@

=@> 6 > = >=> =

> A . #@=>, > >@ . @

@ @>@ . B@

> > > = ,

>> ( =>), >=>G

A - >=> A >

@ = =

@> > =@>, = >,

==> > =>> >G> > =>,I A =

>==>> > >.

i > - >=: @ J

6 >>, 6

>>=. A=> =

== = >=>, >>=>G

= =@>

G = >=

=@ " K A>>

>A> = = >

=E =@>

. " K > A

>= ===

== =

>= => > A>AI >>= >@ @=

> = >=

>= >

= A.

#= > =

=> " K A>> = =

A=> , @ ,

>= >= =>

A.

'> =@>, > > >= ==> @=>=@ = @>, = => @ = >=

> =@ A= >@ =6

= @= IG

> >. > =@

A =>, A=, > @>

>> 6 >@= >

>=>, they = . ' 6

>6, ==, > @>

" K >. i >

@ >@=

> >@

>A.

!=A=, = =@ =>

A> = > @> = @

=E> = A@> =6

. ' =, => =>, @ >.

a@ A A> = @-

@ =E > who > =,

@ what> = = = A

NO KILL !EfO!ME!" A!E E'!EMI"".#10

"MEA! HE ME""ENGE!


19/20


=, ==>>

=E : Ca, @ >,

>= = => =@. i, >

@ > =>I

>G A= >=>

= =E> 6,

6 = =6 = ==

@ G> " K

A A= @ >@,

= A

> A= = > @> .

F= = >= 6,

= A > > @

A >@= = > =>. % ,

= > @ >=

= A, (=@)

> @> 6 >,

(=@) @> 6@=> @= J> >=>. '> >

6> AJ> = A>

> = 6 > =

> A >

=>. !=A=, > A>>

= > @ > =

> =@ " K

= A > >

.

', A >@ >=

6, @ > A a= @

= 6 . '=@ " K A, = @=

> 6 > =

>=>. = @=

= = => = > =

= >G

@=> >

A =>. a >>

=@ A> = -

> A= @ =

@>> >=> =>> @= ,

== = 6 6 = @ >>>: A =

>A >.

i @ > >@ ,

= > @

= =@ , >

> => =

A @ =E =@

A " K . + =

=A = =A> > -

=@ A= =@> >@

= = .

i , > =

6 = = @> > >=>,

@ = = A

>, > A

A. ' = > =

= A, > =

>6 > >>

> @ .

I8 7 8 who 7 6+8, 98

what 7 6+8 8%8 %88)67.

s8%(+ 94 8 87) ;

'% 8 ) *6)(7@ *%%7 98 6)%8=

()*)( 8)6 + %(

;6 8 8;%68 8) 6)*6

8%8 ;9( )( 8 7 8)

= ;%= 8) %%

468)'8 ))8 '%

))6 6)%' 87 *9)78

48)8%.

This guide is excerpted from Friendly Fire b

Nathan & Jennifer Winograd with the permission of

the authors. There is no affiliation with or implied

endorsement of an other content of the book. The

views expressed in the book are solel those of the

authors and not necessaril those of the No Kill

Advocac Center.


20/20

Shelterkilling is

the leadingcause ofdeath forhealthy

dogs andcats inAmerica.

Together,

we canchange that.

%('%'=')8)6.6+*%') '/%('%'=')8)6

Is #IHIN O!R REACHA N KILL NAION

Documents

Countering the Opposition