Upload
nafiz-ahmed
View
224
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/4/2019 Corruption is Not Identifiable as a Single
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corruption-is-not-identifiable-as-a-single 1/12
1
2. Introduction:
2.1 What is Corruption?
Corruption is not identifiable as a single, separate, independent entity which can be isolated
and destroyed. Corruption is a complex set of processes involving human behaviour and
many other variables, some of which are difficult to recognise or measure. Even though
corruption manifests itself as a force on its own and often generates its own momentum, it is
linked to many other factors, and it is by understanding these factors that we can hope to
understand corruption. Understanding corruption is therefore the first step in eradicating or,
at least, containing corruption. In order to understand corruption, we have to first define it.
There are several meanings of the word corruption but when we use the term, we usually
refer to a specific kind of exchange, activity or behaviour. For instance, corruption could
mean a process of physical decay or degeneration; the loss of innocence; a state of moral
impurity or moral deterioration; perversion in taste or language; and also the wrongful,
negligent or wilfully corrupt act of a public official in the discharge of his or her public
duties. Therefore, when we discuss corruption in Bangladesh, we are referring to the
exchange, activity, process or behaviour which occurs when the public domain comes into
contact with the private domain. From this definition, it is obvious that corruption carries
within it several assumptions - of a 'public' as opposed to a 'private' domain; an official codeof behaviour as opposed to an unofficial code of behaviour; the existence of a public or state
apparatus; and even the existence of a particular kind of social, economic and political
organisation (within which the public and private can operate smoothly). These assumptions,
embodied in the popular meaning of corruption, are significant because definitions aside,
when it comes to dealing with corruption - at the political, economic and certainly, at the
sociological level - it is often difficult to decide exactly what constitutes corruption.
8/4/2019 Corruption is Not Identifiable as a Single
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corruption-is-not-identifiable-as-a-single 2/12
2
2. 2 Definition of Corruption
It is very a very challenging task to define a complex phenomenon like corruption because it
is viewed differently from different aspects. Although there is rapidly growing interestsamong policy makers, NGOs ,donor agencies, academicians etc. to identify the causes and
consequences of corruption, still no consensus has been made to define corruption
comprehensively in existing literatures. Its notion varies across country, culture, society and
of course overtime. One activity may be viewed as corruption in developing countries while
it may not be in developed countries. In general, the term “corruption” is always used to label
a large set of illegal activities ranging from “bribery” to “extortion”, from “embezzlement” to
“nepotism”. In this paper I am concerned with the corruption in public sector governance and
its impact on economy of Bangladesh. That is why the scope to define corruption from
different perspective is limited here. The World Bank’s definition of corruption is “The abuse
of public office for private gain. Corruption is every transaction between actors from the
private and public sectors through collective utilities that are illegally transformed into
private gains”2. But there is no way to believe that corruption is only a problem within public
administration. Corruption is also pervasive in private sector. Klitgaard (1998) has given a
very simple definition of this multidimensional subject as: C=M+D-A-S where
C=Corruption, M= Monopoly, D= Discretion, A= Accountability and S= Public sector
salaries3. Put differently, the degree of corruption depends on the amount of monopoly power
and unrestricted supremacy that official's exercise and the extent to which they are held
responsible for their actions. The UN's Dictionary of Social Science explain as “ Corruption
in public life is the use of public power for private profit, preferment of prestige or for the
benefit of group or class, in a way that constitutes a breach of law of standards of high moral
conduct”(1978:43). According to Transparency International (TI-2009), corruption is the
misuse of entrusted political power for personal gain. In the light of the above discussion,
corruption can be defined in a broader perspective as the exploitation of public resources and
avoidance of public laws that results in unfair personal gains, lessen economic growth rate
and encourages greater inequality of income.
8/4/2019 Corruption is Not Identifiable as a Single
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corruption-is-not-identifiable-as-a-single 3/12
3
2.3 Corruption and Social Problems
This review found that few studies examine or establish a direct relationship between
corruption and Social Problems. Corruption, by itself, does not produce Social Problems.
Rather, corruption has direct consequences on economic and governance factors,
intermediaries that in turn produce Social Problems. Thus, the relationship examined by
researchers is an indirect one.
2.4 Sociological Perspective of corruption
It might be asked, what is a sociological point of view? Sociology is the study of the
development, nature and laws of human society. Society, in turn, is a term which describes a
mode of life, and includes a range of interests and activities, such as process, organisation,
structure, human behaviour, human relationships, customs, and forms. The term
'sociological', therefore, can be fairly widely applied.
To provide an understanding of corruption from a sociological perspective, it would be
necessary to examine, explore and critically analyse corruption as a process of social
formation, encompassing corruption in the real world of social structures, institutions and
modes of exchange, and at the same time, to also locate and reconcile the reality within an
analytical framework which would critically explore the discourse on corruption. This Study
aims to approach the subject of corruption in Bangladesh from the sociological perspective
by critically examining a selection of literature on the subject, and by seeking through this
examination to explore the fundamental processes of the social formation of corruption in
Bangladesh - both as a reality, as well as expressed in the literature selected on the subject.
Sociological interpretations must take into account social, political and economic forces, both
as societal conditions, as well as rhetorical and historical influences which inform the
discourse on corruption. It is also important to move beyond dichotomous, normative
conclusions and focus instead on corruption as an exchange, as well as behaviour, process
and outcome. Consequently, the challenge in exploring corruption from this perspective lies
essentially in being able to critically focus on the subject of corruption as it exists in
Bangladesh, together with the conceptual demands of the dominant discourse on the subject.
As will be discussed in some detail in this Study, many of the works under review are
informed - either implicitly or explicitly - by an ethnocentric, modernising ideology, which is
8/4/2019 Corruption is Not Identifiable as a Single
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corruption-is-not-identifiable-as-a-single 4/12
4
not necessarily applicable to the reality of conditions in developing societies like Bangladesh.
The significance of these influences is enormous because they reflect the dominant discourse
on corruption - especially as an issue of development -- in no uncertain terms.
Corruption as behaviour, process or activity, is impossible to quantify. Consequently, for
social scientists the functional argument which focuses on the 'positive' aspects of corruption
necessarily provides only a means of understanding process. Thus, while it might be argued
that corruption functions as a useful mechanism to aid social, political or economic exchange,
the relevance to social science lies in the process as activity, without reference to its
normative qualities. Consequently, while this Study adopts many 'functional' arguments, it
does so in a non-judgmental way, the aim being to further the understanding of the process by
which corruption takes place in a given situation.
8/4/2019 Corruption is Not Identifiable as a Single
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corruption-is-not-identifiable-as-a-single 5/12
5
3. Findings and Analysis:
The 2010 Corruption Perceptions Index shows that (CPI) Bangladesh is in 134th
position in
the world.
3.1 Education: Corruption: Preventing access to education
The falling standards in the education sector are also revealed by the survey: 74% of thehouseholds used extra regular method for admission of their children into school. Among the
various extra regular methods used, payment of donation was most prominent and used by
about 41% of the households, followed by the use of political influence (28%) and through
Corruption in Education: Ratio of Service Receipients Forced to Pay Bribe
54.1
21.8
35.5 32.5
for admission in school to be enlisted for
stipend in primary level
to be enlisted for
stipend in secondary
level
for actual disbursement
of the stipend
P e r c e n t a g e
8/4/2019 Corruption is Not Identifiable as a Single
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corruption-is-not-identifiable-as-a-single 6/12
6
private tutors (10%). Payment of money for admission of children into school was reported
by 3.6% of the households. When the households were asked about the ethical standard one
out of every five households believed that unethical practice existed in the admission
procedure.
3.2 Health: Corruption: Preventing access to health service
The survey revealed that approximately two-fifths (39.4%) of the households reported
payment higher than normal registration fees at the outpatient department. The households
who had patients seeking impatient treatment also reported irregularities in admission
procedure. Normal process of admission was reported by only 41% of the households.
Among the extra regular methods for admission into hospital the frequently used methods
were: consultation with the doctor at private chamber (20% of the households); payment of
extra money to the hospital staff (18% of households); through hospital staff (9%); and
through influential persons reported by 9% of the households. Measures of opinion showed
that about 70% of the households either agreed or completely agreed that there existed
unethical practices in the procedure for admission into the hospital and a higher proportion
(81%) held similar view regarding supply of medicines or treatment at the hospital.
C o r r u pt i o n i n H e a l t h : R a t i o o f S e r v i c e R e c e i p i e n t s
F or c e d t o P a y B r i b e
54.8
29.3
for outdoor treatment for operation/x-
ray/pathological test
P e r c e n t a g e
8/4/2019 Corruption is Not Identifiable as a Single
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corruption-is-not-identifiable-as-a-single 7/12
7
3.3 Municipal Service Sector: water, electricity, holding tax and business & trade license
Another sector which has a profound effect on the quality of life is the supply of public
amenities. The baseline survey revealed that only about 44% of urban dwellers in the country
had\ municipal water supply. About 23% of the households reported difficulty getting water
supply and of these about 17% of the households reported payment of extras money, 16%
reported repeated visits and 12% reported long wait and red tape in getting water line. In
relation to electricity supply approximately 4 out of every 5 urban households in the country
reported to have electricity connection. Just fewer than 30% of these households did not face
any difficulty in getting electricity connection to their house. The remaining 70% of the
households faced various difficulties: among the difficulties faced about 33% of the
Corruption in Police: Ratio of Service Receipients Forced to Pay Bribe
77.7 79.2
60.6
for FIR/GD or any other
complain
for police clearance to avoid arrest
P e r c e n t a g e
9.529
7.94
2.384
4.569
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
Low Income (< Tk.
72,000 per year)
Middle Income
(72000-140,000)
High Income
(140,000+)
Total
P e r c e n t a g e
8/4/2019 Corruption is Not Identifiable as a Single
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corruption-is-not-identifiable-as-a-single 8/12
8
4. Recommendation
4.1 Increasing Political Accountability
Political accountability refers to the constraints placed on the behavior of public officials byorganizations and constituencies with the power to apply sanctions on them. As political
accountability increases, the costs to public officials of taking decisions that benefit their
private interests at the expense deferent/disincentive to corrupt practices.
4.2 Strengthening Civil Society Participation
As stakeholders in good governance and institution mediating between the state and the
public, the organizations that comprise "civil society"- citizen groups, nongovernmental
organizations, trade unions, business associations, think tanks, academia, religious
organizations and last media- can have an important role to play in constraining corruption.
This is true at the country level as well as internationally. Civil Society Organizations (CSO),
with Transparency International spearheading the fight against corruption is the most
prominent example of what an international civil society organization can achieve in
awareness- raising, pressuring government as well as international organizations for change
and pressuring governments as well as international organizations for change and working
with various sectors to implement innovative anti-corruption reforms.
4.3 Creating a Competitive Private Sector
The degree to which powerful elite's influence decisions and policy-making of the state
(state capture) constraints the implementation of a fair, competitive, honest and transparent
private sector and thus hinders broad-based economic development. The ability of powerful
economic interest to capture the state can be constrained by:
Economic policy liberalization
Enhancing greater competition
Regulatory reform
Good corporate governance
Promoting business associations, trade unions, and concerned parties
Transnational cooperation
8/4/2019 Corruption is Not Identifiable as a Single
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corruption-is-not-identifiable-as-a-single 9/12
9
4.4 Institutional Restraints on power
The Institutional design of the state can be an important mechanism in checking corruption.
Of particular importance is the effective development of institutional restraints within the
state, which is most effectively achieved through some degree of separation of powers and
establishment of crosscutting oversight responsibilities among state institutions. Effective
constraints by state institutions on each other can diminish opportunities for the abuse of
power and penalize abuses if they occur. For ensuring institutional restraints on power the
following steps should be taken:
Independent and Effective Judiciary
Anti-corruption Legislation
Independent Prosecution and Enforcement
Audit Organizations
Legislative Oversight
4.5 Improving Public Sector Management
A fifth building block of an anti- corruption strategy consists of reforms in the internal
management of public resources and administration to reduce opportunities and incentives for
corruption. Reforming public sector management and public finance requires.
A meritoric civil service with magnetized, adequate pay
Enhancing transparency and accountability in budget management
Enhancing transparency and accountability in tax and customs
Policy reforms in sectional service delivery
Decentralization with accountability
In most cases greater public oversight can play a key role in the reform process. The practice
of political patronage in public administration continues to be an important source of
corruption in many development countries. Political patronage can be a source of
accountability to the patron, but it can undermine continuity and the development of
standards, institutional values, and memory in the public sector. This opens the way to
conflict of interest, misprocurement, and theft of public funds. The short-term and uncertain
nature of many political appointments also decreases the time horizons of public sector
workers, creating incentives for predatory behavior.
4.6 Anti-Corruption Legislation
8/4/2019 Corruption is Not Identifiable as a Single
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corruption-is-not-identifiable-as-a-single 10/12
10
While a well-functioning, competent and clean judiciary is key in upholding the rule of law
on a day-to-day basis, anti-corruption laws turn out to be an effective means prosecute of an
anti-corruption strategy. Anti-corruption laws work to deter corrupt actions, prosecute and
resurrect a sense of justice, which has become a rare commodity in endemically corrupt
countries. Legislation supporting the transition towards a corruption free society includes a
freedom of information law, whereby citizens can demand the disclosure of information
regarding government activities; a whistle-blower protection law in order to encourage the
reporting of corruption cases; conflict of interest law, procurement laws and party financing
laws. Anti-money laundering regulations also contribute towards curbing fraudulent
practices.
4.7 Transparency
Transparency via public scrutiny has proven to be one of the most powerful forms of
monitoring public officials. Such transparency can be fostered by a number of measures,
including: opening sessions of the parliament, government, and the courts to the public;
registering lobbying activities; and publishing the voting records of parliamentarians, annual
reports of government bodies, trial records, and the decisions of judges. A free and vibrant
media is another important factor in making transparency work for the general public.
4.8 The Role of the Media
A free and open media help expose levels of corruption by uncovering and shedding light on
abuses. In transition economies on Eastern on Eastern and central Europe, greater openness
felt by the media since the rail of communism has brought with it a plethora of stories of
fraud, corruption, and criminal activity, making the media perhaps the most persistent
institution in the fight against corruption. The Internet provides unprecedented opportunities
of disseminating knowledge and increasing transparency across national borders in a timely
fashion at low cost.
8/4/2019 Corruption is Not Identifiable as a Single
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corruption-is-not-identifiable-as-a-single 11/12
11
5. Conclusion
To fight corruption requires highest level political commitment for courageous action
without fear or favor. Where the political commitment is weak, and institutions are not
functioning independently and effectively – create demand: inform, communicate and
campaign for a social movement. Addressing corruption in Bangladesh will require a
comprehensive strategy because of the issues raised in this paper – the core reason being the
collusive nature of political and administrative elites and their relationships, which in turn has
maintained its debilitating hold on state institutions and process. Given the extent of the
problem and its impact on economic and political life in Bangladesh, it is unrealistic to expect
a reform agenda which will reduce the level of corruption in a few years. What the paper
proposes is a two-step reform agenda: (i) reform of the state institutions with focus on the
accountability of the executive (to prevent political corruption) and (ii) reform of the civil
service recruitment process and a review of its norms and regulations to ensure greater
accountability, transparency, efficiency and effectiveness.
8/4/2019 Corruption is Not Identifiable as a Single
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/corruption-is-not-identifiable-as-a-single 12/12
12
Bibliography:
1. www.wikipedia.com/tib
2. www.transparency.org/report_2010_bd
3. www.accbd.gov.bd