Upload
others
View
9
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
IntroductionTheAssociationofWaterTechnologies(AWT)CoolingCommittee’sCorrosionCouponTaskGrouprevisedthecorrosioncouponguidelinesin2010andearly2011tobetteroutlineacceptablecorrosioncouponsurveypracticesandtomoreproperlydefinecorrosioncouponresults.Theinformationpresentedisspecificforopenrecirculatingcoolingsystemsandclosedchilledwaterloops(itisnotintendedasareferenceforothersystemtypes).Thismaterialwascontributedbyanumberofindividuals,therebyprovidingaconsensusofopinionfromdifferingregions,perspectivesandoperations.Thecorrosionratesandcomparativegradingareseparatedintotwogeneralcategories:industrialprocesscoolingandcomfortcooling(HVAC)applications,soastoprovideamoreaccuratereflectionofperformancerelativetooperationalchallenges.Thedocumentprovides“RecommendationsandGuidelines”forthewatertreater.Thisisnotpresented,norisitproposed,asaStandard.Itisintendedtobeusedasanaid,inconjunctionwithothersurveymethodsanddata,todeterminehowwellthemetallurgiesofasystemareprotectedagainstcorrosionandtogaugetheimpactofchangesmadetoawatertreatmentprogram.Thisisa“livingdocument”andwillbeexpandedinscope,asmoreinformationisforwardedto,andreviewedby,theCouponTaskGroup.WarningsandDisclaimers:Thisdocumentisdesignedtoprovideinformationregardingthesubjectmatterpresented.ItisproducedwiththeunderstandingthatneitherAWTnorthecontributorsarerenderinglegal,medical,engineeringorotherprofessionalservices.NeitherAWTnorthecontributorsshallbeliablefordamages,inanyevent,forincidentalorconsequentialdamagescaused,orallegedtobecaused,directlyorindirectly,bytheuseofanyinformationdisclosedinthisdocument,includingtheuseofanyrecommendations,methods,products,services,instructionsorideas.
2
AWTRecommendationsandGuidelinesforCorrosionCouponsinCoolingSystemsAcorrosioncouponsurveyshouldhaveadefinedobjectivepriortoinitiatingthestudy.Thishelpstopositiontheresultsandpursueanyneededcorrectiveaction(s).Corrosioncouponsareusefulindeterminingaveragelossratesovertheinstallationperiodandcanillustrateevidenceoflocalizedattack.Theresultsidentifytrendsthatreflectacceptablecorrosionprotection,gainsmadebychangestothetreatmentprogram,equipmentoroperationofthesystemortheneedforimprovementsthatshouldbeinvestigatedbyfurthersurveywork.Couponstudiescompriseonlyoneofanumberoftoolsthatareavailabletodeterminecorrosioncontrol.Eachresultneedstobeviewedasauniquevaluefortheoperatingconditionspresentduringthesurveyperiod.Thisvalueshouldbecomparedagainstotherresultstoidentifyimprovementsincontrolandprotection.Corrosioncouponresultsarenotanabsolutereflectionofactualsystemcorrosionrates–existingoxidesonolderwatersidesurfacestypicallyretardcorrosionmoreeffectivelythantheprotectivesurfacedevelopedonthecorrosioncouponduringthesurveyperiod.Apoorratedoesnotnecessarilyreflectasignificantproblem;however,itdoeshelptoidentifytheneedforcorrectiveaction.Thevaluesobtainedfromthegravimetricevaluationofcorrosionusingcoupons,dependsuponmanyfactors.Thesefactorsincludebutarenotlimitedto:1.Typeofindustry2.Exposuretimeinawatersystemcoupontestrack3.Couponrackdesignandcouponplacement4.Orientationofthecoupon5.Flowcharacteristicspassingoverthecoupon:watervelocity,downtime,etc.6.Temperatureofthewaterpassingthroughthecorrosionrack7.Waterchemistryandquality8.Processcontamination:organics,gases,acids,alkalis,metals,etc.9.Qualityandconcentrationofthewatertreatmentprogram1.AcceptablevaluesfromanHVACsystem(i.e.acoolingtoweroperatinginaninstitutionalorcommercialfacility)maynotbeattainableinarefinery,chemicalorotherindustrialmanufacturingplant.ThesamecanbesaidforHVACsystemsoperatingwithastressedwatersupply(i.e.make‐upwatershighintotaldissolvedsolids,sulfatesand/orchlorides,asexamples).Corrosionratesidentifiedinthesesystemsmaynotmatchthevaluesusedtoevaluateprotectioninunstressedsupplies.Itmightbemoreappropriatetoreferencetheguidelinesidentifiedforindustrialcoolingtowercircuitstogaugecorrosioncontrolwhenoperatingwiththesemoredifficultsources.
3
2.Corrosionratesmeasuredbycorrosioncouponsaretheresultoftimeaveragingthelossofmetalfromthecoupon.However,therateoflossofmetalbycorrosionofaclean,unpassivatedcouponisnotlinear.Corrosionratesaremuchhigherintheinitialfewhoursordaysofexposure.Thehigherrateofcorrosionoccursduringanduntilthemetalsurfaceacquirespassivation.Therefore,arecommendedandwidelyacceptedexposuretimeforunpassivatedcorrosioncouponsinatestrackisaminimumof90days.Short‐termdurations(30‐daysorless)usuallywillresultinhigherobservedcorrosionrates.Thehigherratesaretheresultoftheshorttimeaveragingoverthehighercorrosionratespresentduringinitialpassivation.Theshorttermandresultinghighercorrosionratesmaybejustifiedwhenchangestotreatmentprograms,ornewtreatmentprogramsarebeingevaluated.Withlongertermduration,theinitialhighmetallossfromthecouponbecomesasmallerpercentageoftheoverallweightloss.Also,asthemetalcouponcorrodes,thecorrosionproductscanactasabarrierreducingtherateoffurtherattack.3.Thecorrosioncouponrackshouldbeconstructedofmaterialswhichwillneithercontributetocorrosionnorresultincorrosioninhibition.Optimalplacementoftherackwouldbeonthereturnheadertothecoolingtower,orthereturnlinefromachillerorheatexchanger(i.e.thesiteofferingthewarmestrecirculatingwater).Theeffluentfromtherackcanflowbacktothemainwatersourceinfreeflowtoatmosphericpressurewheretheflowratecanbemanuallymeasuredorreturntothepressurizedpipingsystemwhereaflowmeterisfirstusedtomonitorandcontroldesiredwaterflowrates.Thereisawiderangeofopinionsconcerningpreferredandacceptablematerialsofconstruction(M.O.C.)usedinthemanufactureofcouponracks.Thesevaryfromthemorecommonlyappliedmildsteel,tostainlesssteel,PVC,galvanizedandcoppermetallurgies.Whilesuccessfulapplicationsofeachofthecommonoptionshavebeennotedthereremainavarietyofphilosophiesonthepositiveandnegativeaspectsofeach.Someofthesephilosophiesareshownbelow.M.O.C. Pros Cons
CarbonSteel
• Suitableforhigherpressure/hightemperature
• Ruggedconstruction• Componentsarereadily
available• Representativeofthebulkof
thepipingmetallurgy(typically)
• Thewatersidesurfaceconditionscanbeusedasaqualitativereflectionofgeneralprotection,conceivablyforyears
• Undersevereoperatingconditionsthewatersidesurfaceswillcorrode(butthat,inandofitself,wouldidentifypoorcontrol)
• Ferrouscomponentsweighmorethanplasticcomponentsandmayrequireadditionalsupport.
StainlessSteel
• Suitableforhigherpressure/hightemperature
• Ruggedconstruction• Willnotcorrodereadily
• Moreexpensivethanotheroptions
• Nottypicallyrepresentativeofthebulkofthesystem
4
• 316SSfittingsarereadilyavailable
piping• Fittingsforalloysotherthan
316maybenotbefoundeasily
PVC • Easytoconstruct• Relativelyinexpensive• Canbemanufacturedwith
transparentsegmentsallowingthecouponsurfacestobevisuallyinspectedthroughoutthesurveyperiod
• Schedule80isavailableinthreadedcomponents
• Limitedpressureapplications• Limitedtemperature
applications• Nottypicallyrepresentative
ofthebulkofthesystempiping
Galvanized • Suitableforhigherpressure/hightemperatureapplications
• Ruggedconstruction• Willcorrodeataslowerrate
thanwillcarbonsteel(althoughthismaymaskanobviouscorrosionconcern)
• Corrosionofthegalvanizedsurfacescouldindirectlyimprovethecorrosionratesofferrouscoupons
• Alkalineprogramsmayattackthegalvanizedpipe.
CopperTube
• Suitableforhigherpressure/highertemperatureapplications
• Sturdyconstruction
• Corrosionofthecouponrackcomponentscouldadverselyimpactthecorrosionresultsoflessnoblemetalcoupons(however,corrosionofthecopperrackwouldalsoimplythatcorrosionofthesystemcoppermetalwasoccurring).
Constructionmaterialscanbe¾”or1’inchdiameter,schedule40orschedule80piping.TemperaturesofthewaterandpressureinthesystemmustbeconsideredwhenselectingtheM.O.C.Allrequiredvalves,strainersandflowrestrictingdevicesshouldbemadeofsimilarmaterials.Couponrackdesignsareoftenpromotedwithhorizontalsectionsthatarenolessthantwelve(12)inchesinlengthandverticalsectionlengthsofthree(3)inches,ormore.Whenconsideringthatallflowsinexcessofone(1)gallonperminutewillbeturbulent,increasedhorizontalpipelengthsbeyondsix(6)inchesandincreasedverticalseparationsofthehorizontalsectionsareunlikelytoreduceturbulenteffects(seeTable1below).Comparativesurveysshouldalwaysbecompletedinthesamecouponrackorcouponrackdesignasthiswilllimitthevariablesassociatedtothedifferencesinlossrates.Itiscommonlyrecommendedthatcouponsshouldbeplacedintothecorrosioncouponrackfollowingthegalvanicseriesinseawater.Thisstipulatesthatthemost“active”orleast“noble”metaloralloymustbeplacedinthenumberoneposition,whichisthefirstcouponexposedtotheflowingwater.Othercouponswouldfollowthegalvanicseriesinseawater
5
withthelastcouponbeingtheleast“active”ormost“noble”metaloralloy.Theprocedurepreventsthemore“noble”orleast“active”metaloralloyfromcathodicallydepositingontheactivemetaloralloy.Inreality,ifanappropriatewatertreatmentprogramisinplace,theactualcouponorderwillmakelittleornodifferencetotheresults.Thereisanargumentforlimitingthenumberoffactorstobeconsideredwhenanalyzingresultsandifthecouponsareinstalledaccordingtothegalvanicseries,anyhighlossrateswillnotbeblamedon,orassociatedto,galvanicdifferences(regardlessofwhetherthesecould,orcouldnot,impactresults).Asnotedpreviously,workingwithastandarddesignandaminimumofvariablesmakesitfareasiertoassessthepotentialissuesneedingredress.Havingaremovablecarbonsteelspoolpieceaspartofthecouponrackisaveryusefulmeansofvisuallymonitoringpipewallconditionsoverlonger‐termperiods.Ifthesesegmentsaretobeutilized,thecouponrackshouldinstalledinalocationthatallowsthesepiecestobeeasilyinspected(orremovedforinspection)withoutinterference.(SeeexampleinFigure2.)4.Couponsshouldbeplacedinthecouponracksuchthatwaterflowsfromthecouponholdertothetipofthecoupon.Thisorientationanddirectionofflowispromotedasthebestmeansofreducingthepotentialoferosionatthetipofthecoupon.However,atnormalflowratesandwithnoabrasivesuspendedsolidspresentinthewater,erosionisunlikelytobeanissue.Severalargumentshavebeenputforwardontheidealdirectionofflowtolimitsuspendeddebrisfromcollectingononeortheotherendofthecoupon(therebycausingunderdepositcorrosion).Somesuggestthattheflowshouldbefromtheholdertothecoupontip,othersfromthecouponendtotheholder.Bothconcernscanbeaddressed,atleastinpart,byutilizinganupstreamstraineraspartoftherackdesign(thiswillhelppreventdebrisfromcollectingoneitherthemountingscreworthecoupontip).Note:whereastrainerisincorporatedtoreducetheimpactofanyforeigndebris,particularattentionshouldbepaidtotheflowrateduringthecourseofthesurvey(thetrappedmaterialwithinthestrainermayrestrictflowandthechangeinflowratemayimpactresults).Wherepractical,theinstallationofatransparentplasticstrainerwillindicatewhetherthismightbecomeanissue.(SeePartsListFigure1.)Thecouponshouldbeorientedwiththebroadfaceinaverticalposition.Thisreducestheaccumulationofdebrisontothefaceofthecoupon,whichcanacceleratecorrosion.Whenremoved,thecouponshouldbeinspectedtoensureitisstillproperlyorientedandsecuredontheholder.Ifnot,thisinformationshouldbeincludedintheanalysisreport.Thecouponholdershouldbeequippedwithamarkidentifyingtheflatedgeofthecouponsothattheorientationcanbeconfirmedduringinstallation.Couponsshouldalsobeelectricallyisolatedfromtheholderusingsuitableplasticwashers,screwsandnutswherethegalvanicdifferencebetweenthecouponandthemountinghardwareisfelttobeaconcern.
6
Couponmountingstems0.5inchesindiameterarerecommended.Non‐metallicholdersarethepreferredmaterialofconstructionbutstainlesssteelisacceptableinalkalineenvironments.TheholdermustpositionthecouponbeyondtheTeefittingthattheholderisthreadedinto.Itisgenerallyrecommendedthatthecouponholderstemlengthsarenolessthanthree(3)inchesinlength.5.Waterflowthroughacoupontestrackshouldbesettoemulatesystemequipmentflowrates.Inmanysystemsaconstantflowbetween3‐5feetpersecondisnormal.Highervelocities(i.e.8Ft./Sec.andabove)cancauseerosiononsoftalloyssuchascopper‐basedmaterials.Calculationofthewatervelocityinapiperequiresthreemeasurements,OD(OutsideDiameter),WT(WallThickness)andGPM(Gallonsperminuteflow).Thesevariablesareincorporatedintothefollowingformula:Velocity=(0.408Xgpm)/id2 whereidisinchesspecifictothepipeScheduleand
MOCLowerwatervelocitiescancauseparticulatemattertosettleontothecouponresultinginunderdepositattack;especiallyifabiofilmispresent.Aflowmeterorotherflowcontroldeviceshouldbeincorporatedtomaintainaconsistentandrepeatableflowrate.Thispracticefacilitatesaccuratecomparisonsofcouponratesfromonetimeframetoanother.Note:Flowrestrictingvalvesusuallyrequirea15psidroptooperateproperly,whileflowindicatorsrequireroughlya2psidifferential.
Table1:FlowRatesandReynoldsnumbersforSchedule80pipe
FlowGPM 3/4InFt/Sec 3/4In
Reynolds#1InFt/Sec 1InReynolds
#1 0.742 4258 .446 32982 1.484 8517 .892 65963 2.226 12776 1.338 98944 2.968 17034 1.784 131925 3.710 21293 2.230 164906 4.452 25551 2.676 197887 5.194 29810 3.122 230868 5.936 34068 3.569 263849 6.678 38327 4.015 2968210 7.420 42585 4.461 3298011 4.907 3627712 5.353 3957513 5.799 4287414 6.245 4617215 6.691 49470
Note:Inmanycoolingsystems(bothHVACandprocess),circulationmaybeinterrupted.Whereverpossible,determinethefrequencywithwhichthisoccursandincludeitinthe
7
evaluationofresults(stagnantflowconditionsinterferewithfilmformationandmaintenanceandmayresultinhighercalculatedcorrosionrates).Incorporationofacheckvalvetopreventsystemdrainagehelpsmaintainmoreconsistentresults.6.Normally,thecorrosioncouponrackisconnectedtothereturnrisertothecoolingtower,becausethewateriswarmerthanthecoldwellsupplyandpotentiallymoreaggressive.Itshouldbenotedthatcouponresultsdonotreflectcorrosionratesofheatexchangerwatersides,asthereisnoheattransferacrosscouponsurfaces.7.Waterchemistryandqualityhasastrongimpactoncorrosion.Temperature,pH,conductivity,bacteriaandbiofilm,dissolvedandsuspendedsolidswillinfluencetherateofattackonthecoupons.Uncontrolledmicrobialpopulationsand/orsuspendedsolidscontaminationcanresultinsurfaceaccumulationsthatmayharboursulfatereducingbacteria.This,inturn,cancauselocalizedmetallossresultinginfalsehighcorrosionvalues.Note:Thequalityofthewatertreatmentprogramwillimpacthowwellthesystemmetallurgiescanbeprotectedfrommostcorrosionmechanisms.Surfacepassivationandcontrolovermicrobiologicalpopulations(andcontroloversuspendedmaterialthatmightharbourSRB’s)willimpactresults.8.Processcontaminationscanaccelerateattack.Organics,gases,acids,alkalisandmetalscanimpactcorrosionrates.Sourhydrocarbonleakswillincreasecorrosionduetosulfideattackoncopperorcarbonsteel.AmmonialeakscandecreaseattackoncarbonsteelduetohigherpH.However,ammoniawillaccelerateattackoncopper.Acidcontaminationwillacceleratecorrosiononsteelandcopper.Alkalicontaminationwillaccelerateattackoncopper,brassandzincgalvanizedcomponents.9.Thewaterchemistryandqualityofchemicaltreatmentwillinfluencecorrosionratesofcoupons.Usingpre‐passivatedcouponspriortoinstallationintherackisnotrecommendedasthisprocessmayresultinafalse,lowcorrosionrate.Typically,un‐passivatedcouponsareusedinarackwithcontinuouswaterflowfora90daytestperiodwithapropermaintenancelevelofthesystem’schemicaltreatment.Usingun‐passivatedcouponsforashorttestperiodofonly30dayswillyieldahigherinitialcorrosionratecomparedtousingpassivatedcoupons.Fora90daytestperiod,un‐passivatedcouponsaresuccessfullyusedifthechemicaltreatmentisataleveltopassivatethesystem.Followingtheaboveguidelines,acceptablecorrosionratesforcarbonsteelandcopperalloysinopenrecirculatingcoolingwatersystemsarelistedinTable2.ThecorrosionratedataanddescriptionspresentedintheTable2barenotnecessarilyapplicabletoallcoolingtowersystems.Itisimportanttonotethatsomewatersupplieswillpresentadditionalchallengestothewatertreatmentprofessional.Corrosioncouponsurveysconductedinthese“stressed”waters(i.e.thosewithhighTDS,sulfatesand/orchlorides,forexample)mayneedtobeevaluatedrelativetoTable2aoragainstahybridoftheTables2aand2bvalues.Whereamake‐upwatersupplyisnotstressed,theTable2bvaluesshouldbeconsideredforHVACsystems.CorrosionratesforclosedcoolingwatersystemsarelistedinTable3.
8
Table2a:QuantitativeClassificationofCorrosionRatesforOpenRecirculating
CoolingWaterSystems–IndustrialCoolingSystemsandHVACSystemsOperatingWithHighStress/HighTDSMakeupWaters
CorrosionRates(mpy)
Description CarbonSteel CopperAlloysExcellent Lessthanorequalto1 Lessthanorequalto0.1VeryGood 1to3 0.1to0.25Good 3to5 0.25to0.35
ModeratetoFair 5to8 0.35to0.5Poor 8to10 0.5to1
VeryPoortoSevere >10 >1
Table2b:QuantitativeClassificationofCorrosionRatesforOpenRecirculatingCoolingWaterSystems–HVACforInstitutionalandCommercialFacilities.
CorrosionRates(mpy)
Description CarbonSteel CopperAlloysExcellent Less0.5 Lessthanorequalto0.1VeryGood 0.5to1 0.1to0.2Good 1to2 0.2to0.3
ModeratetoFair 2to3 0.3to0.5Poor 3to5 0.5to1
VeryPoortoSevere >5 >1
Table3:QuantitativeClassificationofCorrosionRatesforClosedRecirculating
CoolingWaterSystemsCorrosionRates(mpy)
Description CarbonSteel CopperAlloysExcellent Lessthanorequalto0.2 Lessthanorequalto0.1VeryGood 0.2to0.3 0.10to0.15Good 0.3to0.5 0.15to0.20
ModeratetoFair 0.5to0.8 0.2to0.3Poor 0.8to1 0.3to0.5
VeryPoortoSevere Greaterthanorequalto1 Greaterthanorequalto0.5
NotesforTables2and3:• Theseratesassumethatthemetallossisuniformwithnopitting,localizedattack,
gouging,etching,microbialorcreviceattackevident.Theseconditionsarenotacceptable,andifanyarenoted,thecauseshouldbeaddressed,near‐term,withfollow‐upsurveystoconfirmimprovement.
• Localizedattackatthecouponholdermaybeignoredifthetreatmentisunabletointeractwiththecouponinthisareaandnootherabnormalitiesarenoted.
9
• Laboratoryanalysisshouldexpresscouponweightstothenearest0.1mg,readingsaretypicallyreportedasmils(or1/1000ths)ofaninchperyear.
• Couponsshouldbestoredinsuitablecorrosionresistantenvelopestopreventcorrosionbothpriortoandfollowingthesurveyperiod.Topreventanyalterationtothecouponsurfacebeforeinstallation,donottouchcouponsurfacewithfingersorcontaminatesurfaces
• Uponremoval,couponsshouldbegentlyblotteddryusingonlyacleanpapertowel.• Couponsshouldbestoredinsuitablecorrosionresistantenvelopestoprevent
corrosionbothpriortoandfollowingthesurveyperiod.Figure1
PartsforCorrosionCouponRack
1InchSchedule80PVC
LetterDesignation
Description NumberRequired
SpearsNumber
A CompactBallValveSocket 2122‐010B Schedule80Nipple6"Trimmed 864‐060C SSDoleControlValve1"X10GPM 1 DOLED1 Schedule80Nipple18" 884‐180D2 Schedule80Nipple12" 4 884‐120D3 Schedule80Nipple9" 884‐090E TEEFiptxFiptxFipt 805‐010F CorrosionCouponHolder 4 MS MetalSamplesRC13QC0100663"Teflon
10
StemG Schedule80Nipple2" 884‐020H 90oELLFiptxFipt 808‐010I Schedule80Nipple18"Trimmed 1 884‐180J Schedule80PVCPipe PipeSupplyK TEESocxSocxSoc 810‐010L ReducingBushingSpigxFipt(3/8") 1 838‐129M Schedule80Nipple3/8"x1.5" 1 881‐015N LabBallValve3/8" 1 1521‐003O UnionSocXSoc 857‐010P 90oELLSocxSoc 806‐010Q SRThreadedY‐Strainer,Clear YS31S8‐
010CLSRExampleofthecomponentsusedina4positionPVCcorrosioncouponrack.Notetheuseofaflowrestrictingdevice(itemC).Figure2
Exampleofamildsteelcorrosioncouponrackshowinganupstreammountedstrainer,upwardflow,aflowindicator,flowfromthecouponholderthreadedendtowardthe
11
coupon,unionandremovablespoolpiece,dedicatedcirculationpumpandisolationvalves.Thepumpandflowindicatorareusedtomaintainrepresentativeflowconditions.NOTE:Thismildsteelpiperackinstallationutilizessomeplasticcomponents–itismountedinalocationwheretemperatureandpressurearenotaconcern.Itisequippedwitha6inchsteelpipespoolinthelowerleftcornerandisequippedwithanin‐linewaterboosterpumptoassureoperationwithadequatewaterflow.AcknowledgementsThisdocumenthasbeenproducedbytheAWTCoolingSubcommitteeCorrosionCouponMonitoringTaskGroupbythefollowingindividuals:TaskGroupChair:KenSansom,CWT–SolutechWaterManagement,Inc.‐Calgary,Alberta,CanadaTaskGroupContributors:ArthurJ.Freedman,Ph.D.–ArthurFreedmanAssociates,Inc.–Naperville,Illinois,USATimothyE.Keister,CWT‐ProChemTechInternational,Inc.–Brockway,Pennsylvania,USAK.AnthonySelby–WaterTechnologyConsultants,Inc.‐Evergreen,Colorado,USAJamesScott,CWT–SanJoaquinChemicals–Fresno,California,USAW.John(Jack)Soost,CWT–ArthurFreedmanAssociates,Inc.–Lancaster,Pennsylvania,USA