Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Page 1 © Copyright 2011, All Rights Reserved.
Corporate Social Responsibility
Seminar Topic: This material provides an in-depth examination
of what corporate social responsibility is. This program discusses the benefits, framework, and defines the gap between shareholders and employees.
This material is intended to be a guide in general. As always, if you have any specific question regarding the state of the law in any particular jurisdiction, we recommend that you seek legal guidance relating to your particular fact situation.
The course materials will provide the attendee with the knowledge and tools necessary to identify the current legal trends with respect to these issues. The course materials are designed to provide the attendee with current law, impending issues and future trends that can be applied in practical situations.
Page 2 © Copyright 2011, All Rights Reserved.
Copyright © 2011 Printed in the United States of America. All rights reserved. No part of this
monograph may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, except for citation within legal documents filed with a tribunal, without permission in writing from the publisher.
Disclaimer: The views expressed herein are not a legal opinion. Every fact situation is different and the reader is encouraged to seek legal advice for their particular situation.
The Apex Jurist, www.ApexJurst.com is Published by ApexCLE, Inc.
www.ApexCLE.com
Ordering Information: Copies of this monograph may be ordered direct from the publisher for $24.95
plus $4.25 shipping and handling. Please enclose your check or money order and shipping information. For educational, government or multiple copy pricing, please contact the publisher.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
ApexCLE, Inc.
1. ApexCLE, Inc. 2. Law-United States – Guide-books. 3. Legal Guide 4. Legal Education.
119 South Emerson St., Suite 248 Mount Prospect, Illinois 60056 Toll Free 8666572004
920 South Spring Street Springfield, Illinois 62704
Toll Free 8666572004
Page 3 © Copyright 2011, All Rights Reserved.
Author’s Email Address: [email protected]
Author’s Website:
Author’s Mailing Address:
6539 N. Newgard 3N
Chicago, IL 60626
Author’s Phone Number: (773) 299-8476
About The Author
Chipo C. Nyambuya is an Independent Legal Consultant developing a
Corporate Social Responsibility practice as the principal of Aligned Value
Strategies, LLC. She began her career as a corporate counsel in the financial
sector and then transitioned to a career as an advisor for rule of law and
governance projects in international development. She promotes an
integrated approach to Corporate Social Responsibility. Her approach allows
corporations, SMEs and other organizations to establish and develop effective
and successful Corporate Social Responsibility programs while still focusing
on how to optimize their core missions and profitability.
Ms. Nyambuya currently works for the British Consulate General in
Chicago, while also working on short term rule of law and governance
projects with international development organizations. In recent years she
has consulted for startup companies on internet law and technology and for
not for profit organizations. Ms. Nyambuya serves on the boards of
Survivors’ Truths and Minority Legal Education Resources, Inc. and is a
volunteer for several organizations, including the Constitutional Rights
Foundation Chicago.
She received her J.D. from the Ohio State University College of Law,
Columbus, Ohio and her A.B. with distinction, from the University of
Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan.
Page 4 © Copyright 2011, All Rights Reserved.
Corporate Social Responsibility
Introduction
Define and be clear what Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) means for
your client.
1. Client looking to operational ways to make visible impact as global
citizens. Ultimately, they want to reflect that impact in their
communities of interest as they engage in socially responsible and
sustainable practices.
2. Clients that want to provide opportunities to attract and retain talent by
providing opportunities for employees to apply CSR/shared value
principles.
All ultimately with an eye to distinguish their brand in the
marketplace and to optimize their profit margins, ROI and developing an
edge over their competitors.
In short, you need to affirm the point that for your client's program to
be successful; their CSR program is "[CSR] sic should be the topic in every
board room in every company, large and small, around the world. It's not about
smiling children and flowers and clear ocean waters. It's about efficiency, and
longevity, and commodity prices, and profitability."
and that you are here to help your business client achieve their CSR
goals retain these talents and ultimately mature CSR as their business
Page 5 © Copyright 2011, All Rights Reserved.
practice. As it matures, accountability for performance, value and impact
on the ROI for CSR programs will be necessary to ensure value for the
efforts and investments made.
Corporate Social Responsibility isn't about giving money away and
adopting the latest cause of activists. CSR and sustainability are
approaches to business operation and execution that build employee
engagement, improve environmental performance, create positive social
impact, enable operational efficiency, reduce cost, foster innovation,
strengthen relationships with customers and consumers and ultimately . . .
create business advantage.
Dave Stangis, VP for Corporate Responsibility with Campbell Soup
Company, responding to University of Michigan Professor Aneel
Karnani's infamous editorial in The Wall Street Journal, "The Case
Against Corporate Social Responsibility."
BENEFITS
What are the benefits to you and your to take on clients in CSR
counseling. The benefits are manifold, including but not limited to:
Demonstrate an increased value to existing clients
Develop expertise in the field, resulting in you expanding your brand
and positive flow through benefits to enhance your reputation
As a large going concern, to potentially dominate the segment of
Page 6 © Copyright 2011, All Rights Reserved.
the market
Provide holistic services to clients—enabling you to cross-sell your
services to your clients.
Be a pioneer in developing a new market
Increase your resource utilization by energizing your work force as you
tap into, develop and strengthen their latent talents and skills.
DEFINE THE GAP
In current practice, CSR covers a broad range of questions and issues.
As corporations start to adopt this relatively new concept, appreciate
that many of your clients are overwhelmed by the complexities of the
questions they encounter.
Why are you and your firm particularly suited to fill this gap? You are
uniquely positioned to shepherd corporations through CSR advising because:
You have the talent and skill sets to address the issues corporations
face as they explore and integrate CSR in their internal practices.
You have the insight to counsel corporations on how they can
develop CSR and make it an integral part of their profit making model.
You are currently structured to help corporations leverage existing
resources to grow their business, help implement large scale change
management and efficient processes to do so.
You are already equipped to respond to and focus on the complex
questions and to derive the answers corporations need answered as
Page 7 © Copyright 2011, All Rights Reserved.
they navigate the waters into doing well by doing good.
As you proceed, be mindful of the goals of corporate management -
to maximize shareholder value.
Develop strategies that serve that duty in light of incorporating social
responsibility into business practices.
The first overarching challenge to overcome is the allocation of the resources
available to the corporation.
Clear definition of the CSR shared value that is then
communicated to shareholders
o Help client define goal, strategy to meet the goal in the short
medium and long term, the investment, and a matrix that
will measure the client's performance.
o Develop client's communication strategies that reflects the
total maximized value to shareholders in the short medium
and long term
Many of your clients have already come to realize CSR requires the
inclusion of communicating an ethical corporate ethos to shareholders and
employees and working to secure their buy-in to that ethos and illustrating
how their corporation reflects it in its operations.
49% of CEOs cite complexity of implementation across functions as the
most significant barrier to implementing an integrated, company-wide
approach to sustainability. Competing strategic priorities is second with
48%.
Page 8 © Copyright 2011, All Rights Reserved.
88% of CEOs believe that they should be integrating sustainability through their supply
chain. Only 54% believe that this has been achieved within their company. An almost
identical performance gap is seen for subsidiaries
FRAMEWORK/STRATEGY
CSR Advising
Specifically, CSR takes into account the positive social impacts on your client's following
business operational functions.
Initial Process Considerations
SWOT analysis of each CSR Practice Area in the Client's organization:
o Risk assessment and analysis;
o Business/economic/profit/ROI implications
o Legal implications
o Marketing implications
o Reporting mechanisms and resources to assist in how to counsel
your clients in each topical area
o How to counsel your clients on which topical areas in which to
proceed and why (i.e. how to sell your services)
Strategic partnerships
Community engagement community relations
Brand building
Donations; philanthropy; foundations
Page 9 © Copyright 2011, All Rights Reserved.
Pro-bono
Risks of green washing; blue washing,
Risk management and risk assessment
Social media and its impact – great, but means you have to be available all the
time and you have to know how to manage your audience/constituency;
have a clear strategy/message
Human Capital Management
Executive Compensation
Health insurance coverage and costs
Health insurance rules
Flex work hours
Harmonization of work policies and benefits (i.e. workforce worldwide enjoys
same benefits regardless of where situated—i.e.
McDonalds model) Working conditions
Hiring/Recruitment practices
Diversity and Inclusion (Age, gender, sexual orientation and disabled)
o What are your recruiting practices? How can you modify them to
promote and increase diversity?
o How diverse is your current workforce? Diversity retention?
Page 10 © Copyright 2011, All Rights Reserved.
o Why diversity? Why is it important?
o How can you make your workforce more diverse?
o What are the barriers to diversity? (Geographic, cultural, etc.)
Product Sourcing, Development and Distribution
Product Offerings Customers/Clients rights
Clients/Customer disclosures
Transparency
Customer Service
Environmental Sustainability — The Life Cycle Approach (Cradle
to Cradle/Cradle to Grave; recycling, up cycling); Total Cost of
Ownership/acquisition/production
Building/renovation materials
Energy/Electricity/power
Recycling programs (batteries, technology,
commodities)
Water usage
Waste management
Property management/Real Estate leasing/acquisition
policies and practices Food Services
Travel services
Change from black to white roofs or green roofs — savings of
$2trillion across the country per year at minimal cost
Ethical Sourcing
Page 11 © Copyright 2011, All Rights Reserved.
Identify environmental sourcing goals (recycled products)
Sourcing from Minority/Women Business Enterprises (M/WBE) Supplier Audits:
Ensure suppliers' ethics (manufacturing practices, retailing, labor/employment
practices, etc.) align with your CSR policies
Disposal of procured products (either in-house or via
suppliers)
Supply chain management
Fair Trade
WTO
Transparency (bid request and selection process,
confidentiality considerations)
Corporate Governance and Ethics
Corporate Reporting procedures
Corporate Lobbying Rules
Whistleblower Rules
Fiduciary Responsibilities/duties: lobby to re-define
what this means in the particular industry?
Transparency
Codes of Conduct
Guidelines for Executive Compensation
Political Action Committees (PACs)
Establishing and funding considerations
Identifying alternative lobbying mechanisms
PAC's agenda Who determines the agenda of the organization's PAC
Page 12 © Copyright 2011, All Rights Reserved.
PAC's code of conduct and rules of operation
Transparency (i.e. disclosure on what activities and policies the corporation
have in place and whether they raise long term regulatory, reputational risks to
the client's profitability)
Tax policy/taxation
Shareholder's Rights and Management Accountability
Management and Benefit Compensation Disclosures
Power to dictate when and whether the organization engages in
more CSR programs
Power to dictate Board and management composition
Stakeholder/shareholder relations and dialogue
Transparency
Key Reporting Mechanisms and Measurement Matrices
Each practice area has key matrices organizations would be interested in. To
fully advise your clients, you should assist your clients to prepare these matrices
to measure their performance against their CSR goals. You will need to evaluate
and review the following recognized protocols to advise your corporate clients
or to create the matrices which best capture the activities, policies and
procedures that mark your clients' CSR goals and objectives which clients will
use to measure their CSR performance that they will then report to stakeholders
and constituencies. Additionally, you can use these tools to clarify the benefits
you provide through your CSR services to your clients. An example is attached as
Exhibit XX.
Global Reporting Initiative (GRI)
ISO 26000 and Other ISO certifications
NCQA
Page 13 © Copyright 2011, All Rights Reserved.
Ecometrix
LEED
Xanterra's Environmentally Preferable Procurement
tracking database Carbonostics
Ceres
Carbon Disclosure Project
Another major consideration is corporate registration or changing of corporate
form. Two new forms which will begin to have increasing scope is the B
Corporation and the L3C. You should research these forms to best advise your
clients on what corporate form is best for them as they proceed into CSR and
whether their current form or the forms of their subsidiaries may best be served
by registering as a B Corporation or as an L3C—depending on where your client
is situated in the market.
RESOURCES
Stanford University Social Innovation Review The Economist
Harvard University CSR Initiative
Worldwide Ethical Alliance
-Xanterra Electronics Waste Recylcing Policy and Protocol CSR news
http://www.sustainablebusiness.com/
http://www.matternetwork.com/
www.sustainability-indexes.com
EXHIBIT X
Employee Benefits (Medical Insurance)
Page 14 © Copyright 2011, All Rights Reserved.
Review the organization's mission statement should include , e.g., "helping the
world stay world healthy" or "helping those who are in need". I am not sure if
this is there a fee for service or managed care, but there should be the following
considerations:
• how does organization determine who will be covered or
included (i.e. who are the customers, define the patient
population, what is the eligibility criteria)
• What are the products/services offered
• What is the provider network
• Use criteria (i.e. will patients be required to have a medical
home or will they be able to see anybody at any time and of
course)
• What are your fiscal issues that need to be addressed
• What is the source(s) of revenue
• how is revenue allocated?
• how will costs be managed?
• Who are your investors and how are they selected?
Rewarded?
• Are your organization's goals and objectives linked/aligned
to its mission statement, values (integrity, quality,
innovation, etc).
• Who will monitor or provide oversight for performance
(quality of care); What are the standards used to determine
quality performance or best practices?
• What health services are covered, delivered