Upload
nada-ly
View
106
Download
8
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Corporate Financial Reporting
Citation preview
ACCT2542 Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009
Version 1.0.3
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis
Page 3 Accounting for Income Tax
Page 7 Consolidation Accounting
Page 10 Consolidation Accounting
Page 15 Consolidation Accounting
Page 19 Consolidation Accounting
Page 24 Consolidation Accounting
Page 26 Accounting for Asso
Page 30 Accounting for Interests in Joint Ventures
Page 33 Introduction to Corporate Financial Reporting
Page 36 Presentation of Financial Statements
Page 40 Earnings Per Share
Page 44 Principals of Disclosure
Copyright Ka Hei Yeh 2009
First Edition published October 2009.
This work
No Derivative Works 2.5 Australia Licence
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by
Commons, 171 Second Street, Suite 300, San Francisco, California, 94105, USA.
Disclaimer: The author does not guarantee the accuracy of the notes available and will not be h
any damages (including lost marks etc.
caution. Do not rely on them; these notes are not intended to serve as a replacement for your own.
g & Analysis Semester 2 2009
Contents
Accounting for Income Tax
Consolidation Accounting Principles
Consolidation Accounting Wholly Owned Subsidiaries
Consolidation Accounting Intragroup Transactions
Consolidation Accounting Minority Interests
Consolidation Accounting Indirect Ownership
Accounting for Associates The Equity Method
Accounting for Interests in Joint Ventures
Introduction to Corporate Financial Reporting
Presentation of Financial Statements
Earnings Per Share
Principals of Disclosure
published October 2009. (Revised February 2010)
work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution
No Derivative Works 2.5 Australia Licence. To view a copy of this license, visit
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/2.5/au/ or send a letter to Creative
Commons, 171 Second Street, Suite 300, San Francisco, California, 94105, USA.
The author does not guarantee the accuracy of the notes available and will not be h
etc.) as a result of the use of these notes. Use at your own discretion with
caution. Do not rely on them; these notes are not intended to serve as a replacement for your own.
2
Creative Commons Attribution-Non-Commercial-
To view a copy of this license, visit
nd/2.5/au/ or send a letter to Creative
Commons, 171 Second Street, Suite 300, San Francisco, California, 94105, USA.
The author does not guarantee the accuracy of the notes available and will not be held liable for
) as a result of the use of these notes. Use at your own discretion with
caution. Do not rely on them; these notes are not intended to serve as a replacement for your own.
Accounting for Income Tax
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 3
Accounting for Income Tax
Background
Accounting for income tax is not as easy as it seems. A businesss accounting profit is rarely
ever the same as its tax profit (or taxable income). This is because they are determined using
different rules. As such, methods must be used to find out a businesss tax profit based on its
accounting profit by using the balance sheet and other accounting information.
Finding Taxable Profit from Accounting Profit
As such, our first step is to define how we get from accounting profit to taxable profit. We
generally take the following steps:
1. Find the accounting profit
2. Add back any expenses that are not tax deductible
3. Deduct away any revenues that are not considered assessable income
4. Add any assessable incomes which are not considered revenue
5. Deduct any tax deductions that are not expenses
Following this, we should get our taxable profit. This is explained later.
Permanent and Temporary Differences
The differences between accounting and tax profit can either be permanent or temporary.
Permanent differences are differences that affect one of either of the profits and will never
affect the other. Such examples include:
Government Grants
Tax Exemptions/Deductions
Tax exemptions and deductions are permanent because both accounting and tax profit take
into account the expenditure from things that cause exemptions and deductions (such as a tax
deduction on purchases of new vehicles) but only tax profit will take into account the
exemption/deduction by further reducing the tax profit whereas it does not further reduce
accounting profit. A permanent difference can affect accounting profit more but not tax profit.
Permanent differences are not explicitly defined in the AASB 112 (Income Tax Standard) but
it does state that any that appear must be disclosed in the financial reports.
Temporary differences are those that occur in both accounting and tax profit but they occur
in different periods. They are defined in the AASB 112 as, differences between the carrying amount
of an asset or liability in the balance sheet and its tax base.
Carrying Amount is the amount at which the asset or liability is recorded on the balance
sheet. Tax Base is the amount which is attributed to the asset or liability for tax purposes. These two
may or may not be the same.
Accounting for Income Tax
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 4
Examples of temporary differences include:
Interest revenue
Instantly recognised by accounting profit, but only recognised in tax profit when actually
cashed out.
Provision for long service leave
Instantly recognised by accounting profit, but only recognised when the long service leave is
actually paid for.
Calculating the Tax Base of an Asset and Liability
The tax base of an asset is calculated by taking the carrying amount and:
Deducting future taxable amounts
Adding future deductible amounts
For a liability, we simply add future taxable amounts and deduct future deductable amounts;
which is the opposite of what is done for assets.
Example:
In our provision for long service leave (a liability), assume we put $1000 in there as our
expense for this year. We know from the above that provision for long service leave is fully tax
deductable only when it is paid out. This is a future deductible amount as it can be deducted in the
future; but not now. As such the tax base of this would be $1,000 + $0 - $1,000 = $0.
Taxable and Deductible Temporary Differences
Temporary differences can be further split into two types based on the asset or liabilitys
carrying amount and tax base.
Taxable temporary differences result in greater taxable income in the future, such as:
An assets carrying value exceeds its tax base, or,
A liabilitys carrying value is exceeded by its tax base.
Since this causes a greater taxable income in the future, this taxable temporary difference,
when multiplied by the tax rate, gives the deferred tax liability. (i.e. the amount of tax that the
business ultimately has to pay in the future because of this temporary difference.)
Examples of a taxable temporary difference include: interest revenue (this is not treated as
assessable income until the actual cash is received), accelerated depreciation (where depreciation is
accelerated for tax purposes) and capitalised costs (as opposed to being expensed).
Deductible temporary differences result in a lower taxable income in the future. This occurs
when:
An assets carrying value is exceeded by its tax base, or,
A liabilitys carrying value exceeds its tax base.
Accounting for Income Tax
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 5
These will result in a lower taxable income in the future and, when multiplied by the tax rate,
gives the deferred tax asset amount. (i.e. the business has already paid for the tax and will not
need to pay any it when the amount is recovered or settled in the future.)
Examples of a deferred tax asset include: provisions (as seen before, all provisions are tax
deductible when paid out) and allowance for doubtful debts (only deductable when it does go bad).
Components in Accounting for Income Tax
From what weve seen above, a companys total tax liability can be split into two parts:
Current Tax
This is the tax that the business has to pay now during the current period.
Deferred Tax
This is the tax that the business will be required to pay when the asset is realised or a
deduction when the liability is expensed.
The Statement of Taxable Income
The Statement of Taxable Income basically shows the tabular process of finding taxable
profit by deduction from the firms accounting profit and other information (as stated on Page 3).
A thorough illustrative example is provided from Slide 39 to Slide 50 of Week 1 lecture notes.
Another example can also be found in Picker et al, Page 189 and Page 207.
Note that in the process of finding the carrying value of items in the statement may require
you to find missing values through the reconstruction of T-Accounts. Refer to ACCT1511 notes if you
have forgotten how to do this.
After finding the current tax liability (say $11,000), we need to do the following journal entry:
Dr Income Tax Expense 11,000
Cr Current Tax Liability 11,000
The Deferred Tax Worksheet
The Deferred Tax Worksheet is simply an extension of the process we use to find taxable or
deductable temporary differences. Although the worksheet looks complex, the process is simple:
1. Take the entire firms assets and liabilities and list out their current carrying value.
2. Deduce the tax bases of all those assets and liabilities.
3. Calculate the difference between the carrying value and the tax value.
4. Based on the kind of asset or liability, place it as a taxable amount or a deductible amount.
5. Add all these taxable and/or deductible temporary differences.
6. Multiply these two figures by the tax rate to find the deferred tax asset and deferred tax
liability respectively.
7. Deduct the respective beginning balances to find the adjustment required.
Accounting for Income Tax
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 6
A thorough illustrative example is provided from Slide 51 to Slide 59 of Week 1 lecture notes.
Another example can also be found in Picker et al, Page 200.
After finding the adjustment values for both Deferred Tax Asset and Deferred Tax Liability,
we will need the following journal entry:
Dr/Cr Deferred Tax Asset [Debit if the adjustment is positive; Credit if negative.]
Dr/Cr Deferred Tax Liability [Credit if the adjustment is positive; Debit if negative.]
Dr/Cr Income Tax Expense [This balances the journal out so it depends on the above two.]
Tax Losses
Sometimes, a business may have more deductions than assessable income (although very
rarely). In this case, the tax office will not reimburse the firm with cash. Instead, they will defer the
deduction until a period where there is no tax loss and the company can then realise the deferred
tax asset.
Asset Revaluation and Tax
Previously, we have learnt that if we revalue an asset, such as a land, we would do the
following:
Dr Land 10,000
Cr Asset Revaluation Reserve 10,000
This is technically correct when there is no tax. However, when we have tax, we also need to
tax the Asset Revaluation Reserve at the current tax rate (30% in Australia). We would need to also
include the following journal entry:
Dr Asset Revaluation Reserve 3,000
Cr Deferred Tax Liability 3,000
We can shorten the above two into a single journal entry to save time.
Dr Land 10,000
Cr Income Tax Expense 7,000
Cr Deferred Tax Liability 3,000
We will also need to reflect this in our deferred tax journal entry by also adding:
Dr Asset Revaluation Reserve 3,000
Consolidation Accounting - Principles
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 7
Consolidation Accounting Principles
Background
Consolidation accounting is accounting for business combinations (i.e. more than one entity).
This means things such as creating a balance sheet, income statement etc. for the entire business
group as one whole. Naturally this is similar to normal accounting but there are differences we need
to understand.
Business Combinations
To have a business combination, there must be control. Control is defined as, the power to
govern the financial and operating policies of an entity or business so as to obtain benefits from its
activities. To gain this control, an entity usually needs to have the majority of voting rights in the
entity in question.
It does not matter if a business does not exercise its power over another entity as long as it
holds power.
Example:
Company A has 49% of shares in Company B. Company C has 51% of shares in Company B.
Therefore, Company C has control over Company B.
If Company A has 49%, but the other 51% was owned by many other individuals, then
Company A has control of company B.
In the above example, Company A is the, parent and Company B is the, subsidiary. When
lots of companies are holding shares in each other, it is very hard to determine who has control. As
such, many entities use this as a way to avoid consolidation but still be considered a group.
There are many ways of achieving control over another company. These can be:
Script acquisitions: Company A buys shares in Company B in exchange for shares in
Company A. This means that people who have shares in Company B end up with shares in
Company A.
Purchase method: Directly buying shares in another company to gain control.
At the moment, we will only look at parent-subsidiary relationships where one company
controls another. We will look at other relationships such as joint-ventures later.
Determining the Cost of Acquisition
When a parent acquires control over a subsidiary, it measures the cost of combination as
the fair values of assets, liabilities and equity acquired at the date of exchange. We must note that
this can be different to the carrying amount of the asset on the subsidiarys balance sheet.
Any costs directly associated with the acquisition must also be attributed as a cost of
acquisition.
Consolidation Accounting - Principles
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 8
The acquirer shall only recognise assets and liabilities that can have their fair values
measured reliably; including intangible assets and contingent liabilities.
Recall that fair values can be determined through various methods including:
The current market value of the asset/liability
An estimated value based on comparison with something that has equal or almost equal
features.
The present value of the asset/liability
The net selling value of the asset/liability
The depreciated replacement cost of the asset
Goodwill
Goodwill is the excess that is paid to acquire a business based on its fair value. i.e. If the fair
value of a firms assets and liabilities equals $45,000 but the acquirer paid $50,000 to acquire the
business, then $5,000 can be attributable as goodwill.
Goodwill can only be recognised by the firm being acquired and only purchased goodwill can
be recognised. That is, only an entity which has been purchased before can have goodwill.
Excess
The opposite of goodwill is excess. This is when the acquirer pays less than the fair value of
the assets and liabilities of the entity being acquired. Unlike goodwill, excess is immediately
recognised as a profit or loss.
An excess rarely occurs and if you end up with an excess, you should double check to make
sure you did not make any mistakes. Even the AASB 3 assumes that excesses result from
mathematical calculation errors as this is very rare. If, after recalculation and double checking, an
excess still results, you can then recognise it.
The journal entry to immediately recognise excess as a gain is:
Dr Excess XXXXX
Cr Gain on Acquisition of Subsidiary XXXXX
The Consolidation Method
There are three stages to the consolidation method. These are:
1. Line-by-line aggregation
This is simply adding up the same accounts in the parent and the subsidiary together, such
as adding both entities accounts receivables together etc.
2. Elimination and adjustments for intra-group activities
This is the process of removing any internal activities between the parent and subsidiary. If
the parent sold something to the subsidiary, in terms of the company, nothing has changed,
so we need to eliminate this activity.
Consolidation Accounting - Principles
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 9
A simple example will help clear this up:
Put $4 into your left pocket. Call your left pocket Company A and your right pocket
Company B. Now, take $4 and move it to your right pocket. You have just simulated an inter-group
transaction between Company A and B. But look at yourself, as a person (the entity), you still have $4.
All you did was move the money around. This is exactly what we are trying to eliminate.
3. Allocation to minority interest
This is the allocation that is required when the parent does not own 100% of the subsidiary
and must allocate a portion of the equity to the minority interest.
The Consolidation Worksheet
The Consolidation Worksheet is used to tabulate the above process. It looks like as below:
Parent Ltd Subsidiary Ltd Elimination Entries Consolidated
Balance Dr Cr
Capital
Ret. Earnings
Liabilities
Assets
-Goodwill
-Investment
-Others
Here, we simply add across, taking into account any elimination entries. Elimination entries
are those journal entries that we take the remove intra-group activities such as mention before.
Note that the two Debit and Credit columns must equal each other.
We use the consolidated balance to prepare the consolidated financial statements.
We must also note that these journal entries and the consolidation worksheets are all
temporary; we only use them for one time. The next time we need to do the statements again, we
must go through the entire process again from scratch to produce the consolidated statements.
Consolidation Accounting Wholly Owned Subsidiaries
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 10
Consolidation Accounting
Wholly Owned Subsidiaries
Background
Wholly owned subsidiaries are those where a parent has 100% of the shares in the
subsidiary, meaning that they have full control.
Adjustments for Fair Value
When adjusting assets to their fair value, we use the following journal entry:
Dr Asset
Cr Business Combination Valuation Reserve
However, remember that when we increase the value of any asset, there is a tax
consequence that we must also take into account. In this case:
Dr Business Combination Valuation Reserve
Cr Deferred Tax Liability
It must be noted that this is the consolidation entry that is required when an assets fair
value is higher than its carrying amount at the date of acquisition. The same entries can also be used
for recognising an intangible asset at fair value, except here we use the full amount instead of the
difference between fair value and carrying amount.
For recognising contingent liabilities, we use the following:
Dr Business Combination Valuation Reserve
Cr Liability
Dr Deferred Tax Asset
Cr Business Combination Valuation Reserve
Acquisition Analysis
Acquisition analysis is used primarily to find goodwill or excess. We conduct it by:
1. Finding the net fair value of identifiable assets and liabilities. This is the same as taking
equity.
2. Deducting the cost of combination.
Example:
The Parent paid $2 per share for 100,000 of shares in Subsidiary for complete ownership. At
the date of acquisition, the Subsidiary had $120,000 in share capital and $60,000 in retained
earnings.
Consolidation Accounting Wholly Owned Subsidiaries
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 11
Additionally, the fair value of land and equipment are $250,000 and $100,000 respectively.
Their carrying amounts are $240,000 and $95,000 respectively.
The acquisition analysis would thus be:
Equity = $120,000 + $60,000
+ ($250,000 - $240,000) x 0.7 [BCVR Land]
+ ($100,000 - $95,000) x 0.7 [BCVR Equipment]
= $190,500
Cost of Combination = 100,000 x $2
= $200,000
Goodwill =$9,500
The journal entries would be:
Dr Retained Earnings 60,000
Dr Share Capital 120,000
Dr Business Combination Valuation Reserve 10,500
Dr Goodwill 9,500
Cr Shares in Subsidiary 200,000
Note that in the example, we have BCVR as a debit figure of $10,500. When we do the
individual journal entries later, we eliminate our equity acquired against this debit figure when we
account for the increase in tax liability due to increase in carrying amount.
Example:
Dr Land 10,000
Cr Business Combination Valuation Reserve 7,000
Cr Deferred Tax Liability 3,000
Dr Equipment 5,000
Cr Business Combination Valuation Reserve 3,500
Cr Deferred Tax Liability 1,500
Notice how we have now eliminated $10,500 from BCVR after the adjustments (the Credits
equal the Debits so it is eliminated) which is exactly the amount we need to eliminate from above.
Dealing with Differences in Depreciation
When assets that depreciate are revalued, their level of depreciation will be different to
what is required for the group as a whole.
Example:
Following on from the previous example if the equipments carrying value in the Subsidiary is
$95,000 and it is depreciated at 20% per year, the subsidiary would record a depreciation expense of
$19,000 per year.
Consolidation Accounting Wholly Owned Subsidiaries
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 12
For the group, this equipment is worth $100,000 so the depreciation expense per year should
be $20,000. This is a $1,000 increase over what is actually recorded so we must record the extra
depreciation in the consolidation entries as follows:
Dr Depreciation Expense 1,000
Cr Accumulated Depreciation 1,000
Dr Deferred Tax Asset 300
Cr Income Tax Expense 300
Note that in the example, such an entry can only be made in the year of acquisition because
it directly affects the firms expense accounts. Recall that expense accounts are closed at the end of
each year to retained profits. Thus for the following year, the journal will need to be as follows:
Dr Depreciation Expense1 1,000
Dr Retained Earnings (Opening)2 1,000
Cr Accumulated Depreciation3 2,000
Dr Deferred Tax Asset4 600
Cr Income Tax Expense5 300
Cr Retained Earnings (Opening)6 300
1. This years additional depreciation expense.
2. Last years additional depreciation expense. We cannot directly debit from depreciation
expense from last year as the account has been closed to retained earnings so we debit from
that instead.
3. Total accumulated depreciation. Not an expense account that is closed so we can change it.
4. Deferred Tax Asset results from increase in expense meaning less tax to be paid.
5. This years tax expense should decrease from more expenses. (30% tax rate)
6. Last years tax expense should also be less from more expenses, but cannot be directly
debited from as it has been closed. Credit retained earnings instead. (30% tax rate)
Sale of Assets after Acquisition Date
The Subsidiary owns land of $240,000 in our example previously. If this was sold in the
following year at $275,000 to an external party, the subsidiary would have recorded the following:
Dr Cash 275,000
Cr Land 240,000
Cr Gain on Sale of Land 35,000
However, when we consolidate, we value the land at $250,000 and not $240,000. This
means the gain on sale of the land must be reduced by $10,000. Thus, we would need to adjust it as
follows:
Dr Gain on Sale of Land 10,000
Cr Income Tax Expense 3,000
Cr Transfer from BCVR 7,000
Dr Transfer from BCVR 7,000
Cr BCVR 7,000
Consolidation Accounting Wholly Owned Subsidiaries
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 13
Note that if this was not in the period where acquisition took place, we would debit
Retained profits (opening) instead of Transfer from BCVR. We would also include this directly in
the pre-acquisition entries.
Recall that the pre-acquisition entries were:
Dr Retained Earnings 60,000
Dr Share Capital 120,000
Dr Business Combination Valuation Reserve 10,500
Dr Goodwill 9,500
Cr Shares in Subsidiary 200,000
Add the following journal in:
Dr Retained Earnings (Opening) 7,000
Cr Business Combination Valuation Reserve 7,000
Results in:
Dr Retained Earnings 67,000
Dr Share Capital 120,000
Dr Business Combination Valuation Reserve 3,500
Dr Goodwill 9,500
Cr Shares in Subsidiary 200,000
Goodwill Impairment
When goodwill is recorded after acquisition, it is usually amortized/impaired. Goodwill is
only recorded on the consolidation journals.
Example:
Following from our example, our acquisition resulted in $9,500 of recognised goodwill. If
$1,900 was impaired this year, our journal entry would be as follows:
Dr Impairment Loss 1,900
Cr Accumulated Impairment Losses 1,900
In the next year, we would need to put the expense into retained profits since the impairment
loss expense account has been closed to it. That is:
Dr Impairment Loss 1,900
Dr Retained profits (opening) 1,900
Cr Accumulated Impairment Losses 3,800
These two entries in the example are sometimes placed into the pre-acquisition entry.
Consolidation Accounting Wholly Owned Subsidiaries
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 14
Excess
Excess is immediately recorded as income in the period of acquisition by crediting the excess
account. In any other period, we put it into the retained profits account.
Dividends
When the subsidiary issues dividends, the parent will be the only entity getting those
dividends as it holds all the shares in that subsidiary. A dividend payout is, as such, treated as a
reduction in the cost of acquiring the subsidiary.
Example:
The subsidiary declared a dividend of $10,000 and the parent bought those shares cum-
dividend, the parent has a right to that dividend. Thus, to the parent, this represents a return of
$10,000 on their investment in the subsidiary. As such, the entry in the parents books would be:
Dr Investment in Subsidiary 190,000
Dr Dividend Receivable 10,000
Cr Cash 200,000
However, when we do consolidation, we need to eliminate the dividend payable from the
subsidiary and the dividend receivable from the parents book. This entry is:
Dr Dividend Payable 10,000
Cr Dividend Receivable 10,000
If a dividend is declared and paid, we use the following:
Dr Investment in Subsidiary 10,000
Cr Dividend Paid 10,000 [If current year]
Cr Retained Profits (opening) 10,000 [If previous year(s)]
If the dividend has been declared, but has not been paid yet, we use the following:
Dr Investment in Subsidiary 10,000
Cr Dividend Declared 10,000
Dr Dividend Payable 10,000
Cr Dividend Receivable 10,000
Consolidation Accounting Intragroup Transactions
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 15
Consolidation Accounting Intragroup Transactions
Background
A large part of doing consolidation is removing transactions between the entities that are
part of the consolidation.
Simple Eliminations
Most elimination entries (journal entries to eliminate intragroup activities) are based very
much on common sense. That means, simply reversing what was done before.
Example:
The parent company provided $10,000 worth of management services to subsidiary. The
subsidiary paid the entire sum in the period it was accrued.
In this case, the parent would have recorded $10,000 of management fee revenue while the
subsidiary would have recorded $10,000 of management fee expense. In this case, we simply reverse
that. i.e.:
Dr Management Fee Revenue $10,000
Cr Management Fee Expense $10,000
If the subsidiary had only paid a fraction (i.e. not the entire sum) we also remove that
because an entity having a payable to and a receivable from itself means it does not owe anything.
Dr Accounts Payable XXXXX
Cr Accounts Receivable XXXXX
This same logic can be applied to many other things such as dividends and borrowings.
Transfer of Inventory
For inventory we only need to eliminate it if inventory has been sold in between the entities.
In these cases, the entity will see the cost of the inventory as the price at which it was originally paid
for when it first entered the entity. The entity will see the sale of the inventory as the revenue
gained when it left the entity.
Example:
The parent bought 200 boxes of apples at $8 per box from a supplier. During the same year,
the parent sold all 200 boxes of apples to the subsidiary at $10 per box. The subsidiary then sold
these boxes to consumers at $12 a box in the same year.
In this case, the parent would have recorded $1,600 in Cost of Goods Sold and $2,000 in Sales
Revenue. Likewise, the subsidiary would have recorded $2,000 in Cost of Goods Sold and $2,400 in
Sales Revenue.
Consolidation Accounting Intragroup Transactions
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 16
If we add these together, it would mean the entity as a whole had $3,600 in Cost of Goods
Sold and $4,400 in Sales Revenue. As we can see, this is not the case! Thus, we must eliminate the
entry made between the two as it is an intragroup transaction.
Dr Sales Revenue 2,000
Cr Cost of Goods Sold 2,000
The above example only applies when the goods have been bought, transferred and then
sold in the same period. In the case of when inventory has not been entirely sold at the end of the
year but it has been transferred, we must also revalue inventory depending on if it was transferred
at a profit or loss.
Example:
If, in the previous example, only 150 boxes of apples were sold at the end of the year and 50
remained, the journals that the parent and subsidiary have would be as follows:
Parent:
Dr Cost of Goods Sold 1,600
Cr Sales Revenue 2,000
Subsidiary:
Dr Cost of Goods Sold 1,500
Dr Inventory 500
Cr Sales Revenue 1,800
In this case, the remaining inventory is not worth $500 to the entity because it was bought by
the parent for $400 previously. This means we need to eliminate inventory by $100. The true Cost of
Goods Sold is 150x$8=$1,200 meaning we must also eliminate the extra. Sales Revenue must be
written down by $2,000 as well.
Dr Sales Revenue 2,000
Cr Cost of Goods Sold 1900
Cr Inventory 100
Remember! When we change the carrying amount of an asset, we must also include the tax
consequence. In this case it is (assuming a tax rate of 30%):
Dr Deferred Tax Asset 30
Cr Income Tax Expense 30
Transfer of Plant
When plant and is sold by the parent to the subsidiary or vice versa, we need to eliminate
the gain or loss on sale of that plant. We would also need to adjust depreciation because the two
companies would depreciate it at different rates. The consolidated entity as a whole must
depreciate it at the same rate as the company which first bought it does.
Consolidation Accounting Intragroup Transactions
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 17
Example:
A parent company sells plant to the subsidiary for $90,000 on the 1st January 2009. This plant
was bought on the 1st January 2008 by the subsidiary for $100,000. It is depreciated at 20% over 5
years. The subsidiary
Here we would note that the depreciation should be $20,000 per year and that one year has
already past so the carrying amount would be $80,000. This means the plant was sold at a gain of
$10,000 to the subsidiary.
Also to note that since the subsidiary carries the asset at $90,000 and assuming it will also
depreciate it at the same rate, it will only depreciate $18,000 per year (90,000/5) and not the
$20,000 at which it was previously. Consolidating requires that this be the latter figure.
In this case, we must:
Eliminate the extra $10,000 carrying amount.
Eliminate the extra sale of the plant at $80,000. This is recorded in the parents books.
Add back the extra $2,000 of depreciation.
Eliminate the proceeds of $90,000 for the sold plant recorded on the subsidiarys books.
As such, we use the following journal entry:
Dr Proceeds from plant transfer 90,000
Dr Plant at cost 10,000
Cr Carrying amount of plant sold 80,000
Cr Accumulated Depreciation 20,000
Dr Income Tax Expense 3,000
Cr Deferred Tax Liability 3,000
Note that if the above happened two years later, we would also need to separate each
years depreciation adjustment as depreciation expense is closed off to retained profits at the end of
each year. The proceeds from plant transfer and carrying amount of plant sold account is also
closed off and would need to be referenced to retained profits. For 1st January 2010, the entry would
be:
Dr Opening Retained Earnings 10,000
Dr Plant at Cost 10,000
Cr Accumulated Depreciation 20,000
Dr Opening Retained Earnings 3,000
Cr Deferred Tax Liability 3,000
Dr Opening Retained Earnings 2,000 [For 1st Year Depreciation]
Dr Depreciation Expense 2,000 [For 2nd Year Depreciation]
Cr Accumulated Depreciation 4,000
Dr Deferred Tax Asset 1,200
Cr Income Tax Expense 600
Cr Opening Retained Earnings 600
Consolidation Accounting Intragroup Transactions
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 18
Transfer of Land
Unlike plant, land does not depreciate. Thus, we only have to deal with the elimination of
the movement of land around the company.
Example:
The parent bought land on the 1st January 2009 for $100,000. It then sold this land to its
subsidiary for $120,000 one year later. The subsidiary then sold this land for $150,000 to an external
party another two years later.
At the date of sale, the entry required would be:
Dr Proceeds from transfer of land 120,000
Cr Carrying amount of land sold 100,000
Cr Land at cost 20,000
Dr Deferred Tax Asset 6,000
Cr Income Tax Expense 6,000
In the next year, the land is not sold so there is unrealised profit:
Dr Opening retained earnings 20,000
Cr Land at cost 20,000
Dr Deferred Tax Asset 6,000
Cr Opening retained earnings 6,000
In the year after when the land is sold, we can finally recognise the profit with:
Dr Opening retained earnings 20,000
Cr Carrying amount of land sold 20,000
Dr Deferred Tax Asset 6,000
Cr Opening retained earnings 6,000
Deagan Chapter 29 provides many more worked examples on intragroup transactions.
Consolidation Accounting Minority Interest
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 19
Consolidation Accounting Minority Interest
Background
Parents do not always necessarily own 100% of their subsidiaries to have control over them.
They may have control, but have less than complete ownership. The other owners of the subsidiary
are called the minority interest. It is also sometimes known as outside equity interest.
Minority interest is defined as, that portion of profit or loss and net assets of a subsidiary
attributable to equity interests that are not owned, directly or indirectly through subsidiaries, by the
parent.
Whats Different?
We still use the same techniques and methods that we used for wholly owned subsidiaries.
That is, we:
Do line-by-line aggregation at 100%.
Eliminate intragroup activities at 100%.
By 100%, we mean that we add the full amounts to each other. Even if the parent (100%)
owns 70% of a subsidiary, we do not add 100% of the parent and 70% of the subsidiaries accounts
together. We add 100% of both the companys accounts together.
There is, however, one intragroup activity that we do not add 100% of and that is dividends.
This is because dividends are paid out according to how much of the subsidiary the parent holds. So
if the parent only holds, say 80% of the company, it is only entitled to 80% of the dividends of which
is intragroup. The remaining 20% is to an external party (the Minority Interest) and thus, is not
intragroup so it does not need to be eliminated.
Methodology in Attributing to Minority Interest
To find who holds what and how much of equity, we first find how much is attributable to
the minority interest. Once we have found this, we know that the residual amount is what is
attributable to the parent company.
We should find minority interest by splitting the whole process into three distinct time
periods.
1. Minority Interest in Pre-Acquisition Equity
2. Minority Interest in Post-Acquisition changes to Equity
3. Minority Interest in Current Period Profit/Loss
Minority Interest in Pre-Acquisition Equity
We need to adjust our pre-acquisition entry to take into account that the parent has only
taken a percentage and not the entire ownership of the subsidiary. We only take a percentage (the
percentage the parent owns) of the net fair value acquired in the subsidiary.
Consolidation Accounting Minority Interest
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 20
Example:
A parent company has paid $70,000 to obtain 75% of the shares in a subsidiary. At that date,
everything in the subsidiarys books was recorded at fair value except for plant which has a fair value
of $2,000 higher than its carrying amount. The subsidiary had retained earnings of $20,000 and
share capital of $70,000.
Thus, our acquisition entry would be:
Equity = $70,000 + $20,000
+ $2,000 x 0.7 [BCVR Plant]
= $91,400
Net fair value acquired = $91,400 x 75% 1
= $68,550
Cost of Combination = $70,000
Goodwill =$1,450
The journal entries would be:
Dr Retained Earnings 15,000 1
Dr Share Capital 52,500 1
Dr Business Combination Valuation Reserve 1,050 1
Dr Goodwill 1,450 1
Cr Shares in Subsidiary 70,000
1 Note here that we have only acquired 75% ownership.
In the example, the rest of the equity is directly attributable to the minority interest as they
are the holders of that equity. The journal entry is essentially the same except that there is no
goodwill and we credit the minority interest instead.
Example:
Following on from the previous example, 25% of equity is attributable to minority interest:
Dr Retained Earnings 5,000
Dr Share Capital 17,500
Dr Business Combination Valuation Reserve 350
Cr Minority Interest 22,850
Minority Interest in Post-Acquisition changes to Equity
When there are changes to equity such as retained earnings, reserve accounts and the
business combination valuation reserve, part of it is attributable to the minority interest.
The most important is recognising retained earnings. We usually do the entry for retained
earnings after all journal entries requiring the use of the retained earnings account are completed.
This is because these accounts all impact on the opening retained earnings account which will affect
Consolidation Accounting Minority Interest
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 21
how much is attributable to the minority interest. This means you should eliminate intragroup
activities before allocating minority interest here.
Example:
A parent owns 75% of a subsidiary which had $10,000 of retained earnings at acquisition
date. Three years later, that subsidiary now has $60,000 in retained earnings.
Previously, the parent sold plant that that had a carrying amount of $50,000 to the
subsidiary at a profit of $5,000. Both companies depreciate in straight-line over 5 years.
First, we need to adjust for the plant:
Dr Opening Retained Earnings 5,000
Dr Plant at Cost 5,000
Cr Accumulated Depreciation 10,000
Dr Opening Retained Earnings 1,500
Cr Deferred Tax Liability 1,500
Dr Opening Retained Earnings 1,000
Dr Depreciation Expense 1,000
Cr Accumulated Depreciation 2,000
Dr Deferred Tax Asset 600
Cr Income Tax Expense 300
Cr Opening Retained Earnings 300
Notice how there are references to Opening Retained Earnings here.
Aggregating this would give us a debit figure of $7,200 for Opening Retained Earnings.
Moving on to adjusting retained earnings, we note that there is an increase of $50,000 in
retained earnings. This needs to be adjusted lower by $7,200 as seen from above. Thus, the change in
retained profits would be $42,800. We need to attribute 25% of this to minority interest as follows:
Dr Retained Earnings 10,700
Cr Minority Interest 10,700
Basically put, the minority interest is only interested in the profits contributed to the entity
after all adjustments have been made. If there is movement between equity accounts, the minority
interest also has interest in those movements. Thus, a certain percentage (how much is attributable
to the minority) must be allocated to them.
Example:
If $1,000 was moved from retained earnings to the general reserve. (75% ownership)
Dr General Reserve 250
Cr Minority Interest 250
Consolidation Accounting Minority Interest
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 22
Changes in the Business Combination Valuation Reserve and Minority Interest
During pre-acquisition, we may have assets which have a fair value higher than their carrying
amounts, we have end up with a journal entry as follows:
Dr Inventory 10,000
Cr Deferred Tax Liability 3,000
Cr Business Combination Valuation Reserve 7,000
(Assuming we had Inventory with a fair value $10,000 higher than its carry amount)
When this inventory is sold in the next period (remember we assume that all opening
inventory is sold in the year), we need to reduce Minority Interest because this would have already
been reflected in retained earnings. Not doing this would mean double-counting and getting a
wrong figure. Thus:
Dr Minority Interest 1,750*
Cr Business Combination Valuation Reserve 1,750*
* The firm holds 75% ownership so only 25% of BCVR needs to be eliminated.
Minority Interest in the Current Period
After adjusting for changes in previous periods, we move to the current period. In this period
of time, we are most concerned with:
Dividends
Transfers between equity accounts
Profit or Loss for the period
If $1,000 of dividends were declared in the current period by the subsidiary of which 75% is
owned by the parent, then we would need the following journal entry:
Dr Dividend Payable 750
Cr Dividend Declared 750
Dr Dividend Revenue 750
Cr Dividend Receivable 750
(To eliminate the intragroup dividend of 75%)
Dr Minority Interest 250
Cr Dividend Declared 250
(To attribute 25% of the dividend to the Minority Interest)
If the dividend was paid out in the same period, we simply change a few journals so it
becomes:
Dr Dividend Revenue 750
Cr Dividend Paid 750
Consolidation Accounting Minority Interest
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 23
Dr Minority Interest 250
Cr Dividend Paid 250
If there were transfers between reserves (such as one in the general reserve), the minority
interest has interest in the movement from these reserves. As such, a $5,000 movement from
general reserve to retained earnings with 75% ownership would take the following form:
Dr Transfer from General Reserve 1,250
Cr General Reserve 1,250
Profit for the Period
If the closing retained earnings are not given in the year, we can figure this out by taking our
adjusted opening balance figure, taking away all expenses and adding revenues. Otherwise, we can
find out profit for the period by taking the retained earnings at the end of the period, adding back
any distributions and deducting the last periods retained earnings away. A portion of this would be
allocated to the minority interest:
Dr Minority Interest Share of Profit XXXXX
Cr Minority Interest XXXXX
Unrealised profits in Upstream Transactions
Upstream transactions are those which are from the subsidiary to the parent. These have an
impact on unrealised profits for the subsidiary which in turn, impacts on minority interest. Since
these profits are unrealised, we need to reverse a portion of these allocations to minority interest
since they have already been put into retained earnings.
Example:
A subsidiary sells $18,000 worth of inventory to the parent at $2,000 profit during the year.
At the end of the year, the parent has not sold any of the inventory in question. The parent holds 75%
of the subsidiary.
Here, we simply take the profit generated ($2,000) which is unrealised in terms of the group.
We then need to tax this since it has not been taxed and then allocate 25% of it to the minority
interest. That is 2000x0.3x0.7 meaning the following:
Dr Minority Interest 350
Cr Minority Interest Share of Profit 350
Note that when this is realised, we will reverse this transaction so that we credit minority
interest and debit its share of the profit instead.
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis
Consolidation Accounting
Background
Prior to this stage, we have only considered the situations where the subsidiary itself does
not control any other company. However, if the subsidiary has control over another business
it is the parent of a parent-child relationship)
that. We call these parent-child-
The Parent-Child-Grandchild Relationship
In this course, we will only
over a subsidiary that also controls a subsidiary of its own.
many other types of relationships which lead to indirect ownership.
Direct Minority Interest
that has that minority interest. Indirect Minority Interest
interest in another company though the subsi
DMI is actually the minority interest we were dealing with in the previous
notice in this diagram that the 20% DMI in the Child also has an interest in the Grandchild since they
own the Child. Likewise, the Parent has an interest in the Grandchild through the Child.
their interests by multiplying their percentages along the
respective subsidiary.
Example:
In the previous diagram, the parent has 80% of the Child whom has 60% of the Grandchild.
Thus, the Parent has 80% x 60% = 48
20% control of the Child whom has 60% interest in the Grandchild. Thus, there is
12% in the Grandchild.
For the entity as a whole, the 12% IMI and the 40% DMI in the Grandchild totals to 52% that
must be attributable to MI in any of the Grandchilds profits
Parent
Parent80% 60%
Consolidation Accounting
g & Analysis Semester 2 2009
Consolidation Accounting Indirect Ownership
Prior to this stage, we have only considered the situations where the subsidiary itself does
not control any other company. However, if the subsidiary has control over another business
child relationship), then the owners of the parent would have interest in
-grandchild relationships.
Grandchild Relationship
only consider the relationship where a parent company has control
over a subsidiary that also controls a subsidiary of its own. However, note that in reality, there are
many other types of relationships which lead to indirect ownership. Graphically this relati
Direct Minority Interest (DMI) is the minority interest that is directly linked to the subsidiary
Indirect Minority Interest (IMI) is the minority interest that has
interest in another company though the subsidiary. Graphically, DMI is shown as
DMI is actually the minority interest we were dealing with in the previous
notice in this diagram that the 20% DMI in the Child also has an interest in the Grandchild since they
own the Child. Likewise, the Parent has an interest in the Grandchild through the Child.
eir percentages along the route taken to get from DMI to the
In the previous diagram, the parent has 80% of the Child whom has 60% of the Grandchild.
80% x 60% = 48% indirect ownership of the grandchild. The DMI of the child has
20% control of the Child whom has 60% interest in the Grandchild. Thus, there is
For the entity as a whole, the 12% IMI and the 40% DMI in the Grandchild totals to 52% that
in any of the Grandchilds profits.
Child Grandchild
Child Grandchild80% 60%
DMI: 20%
Consolidation Accounting Indirect Ownership
24
Indirect Ownership
Prior to this stage, we have only considered the situations where the subsidiary itself does
not control any other company. However, if the subsidiary has control over another business (that is,
ners of the parent would have interest in
consider the relationship where a parent company has control
However, note that in reality, there are
this relationship is:
is the minority interest that is directly linked to the subsidiary
is the minority interest that has
, DMI is shown as:
DMI is actually the minority interest we were dealing with in the previous section. However,
notice in this diagram that the 20% DMI in the Child also has an interest in the Grandchild since they
own the Child. Likewise, the Parent has an interest in the Grandchild through the Child. We calculate
taken to get from DMI to the
In the previous diagram, the parent has 80% of the Child whom has 60% of the Grandchild.
ild. The DMI of the child has
20% control of the Child whom has 60% interest in the Grandchild. Thus, there is IMI of 20% x 60% =
For the entity as a whole, the 12% IMI and the 40% DMI in the Grandchild totals to 52% that
Grandchild
Grandchild
: 20% DMI: 40%
Consolidation Accounting Indirect Ownership
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 25
Rules for Allocating to Indirect Minority Interest and Direct Minority Interest
DMI is interested in both pre and post acquisition equity of the subsidiary but however, IMI
is only interested in post acquisition equity. Thus, our pre-acquisition entry does not need to take
into account any IMI.
Basically, we follow the same process we outlined to find MI in the previous section. Recall:
1. MI Share of Pre-Acquisition Equity
2. MI Share of Changes in Equity from Acquisition Date to the Beginning of Current Period
3. MI Share of Changes in Equity in the Current Period.
Note that we have already established that IMI does not need to be taken into account in
the pre-acquisition equity, thus, IMI applies to steps 2 and 3 while DMI applies to all steps.
Intragroup Transactions, Indirect Minority Interest and Direct Minority Interest
The required elimination entries for intragroup transactions are generally the same as with
just minority interest. However, we simply need to know which type of minority interest is impacted.
To find this, we simply note which company within the group recorded the profit of the transaction.
The Parent recorded it: No effect on any Minority Interest
The Child recorded it: Impact on Direct Minority Interest only.
The Grandchild recorded it: Impact on both Direct Minority Interest and Indirect Minority
Interest.
Dividends, Indirect Minority Interest and Direct Minority Interest
As a rule of thumb, only Direct Minority Interests gain dividends and Indirect Minority
Interests do not gain any. This is because companies only pay dividends to those who directly hold
their shares. This means that only people who are direct owners (the parent company and the direct
minority interest) gain any dividends. This means that Indirect Minority Interests do not.
However, we must adjust Minority Interests share of profit for the increase in profit as a
result of a grandchild paying dividends to the child company. This is because the Indirect Minority
Interest of the grandchild is the Direct Minority Interest of the child company and thus, has a right to
the increase in profits resulting from a dividend payment. This should be allocated accordingly to
how much Indirect Minority Interest exists.
Accounting for Associates The Equity Method
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 26
Accounting for Associates The Equity Method
Background
In Consolidation Accounting, we looked at the case where the parent had control over the
subsidiary. In this part, we look at the case where the company has significant influence, but does
not have control. This means the company has around 20% to 49% of voting rights in the company.
This is where we use the equity method.
Significant Influence
Significant Influence is broadly defined as having 20% to 49% of the voting rights of a
company. However, note that this is a quick guide and a company may have significant influence
even if their level of voting rights is below 20% or exceeds 49%. However in this course, for
simplicitys sake, we consider 20% to 49% of voting rights as having significant influence.
We must also note that the equity method does not apply to:
Venture Capital Organisations
Immaterial Investments
Accounting for Investments
We account for investments at cost at the acquisition date of the investment in question. As
with consolidation, dividends from pre-acquisition profits are seen as a return of investment.
However, as of May 2008, the ASB is now trialling an international standard where all dividends are
realised as just revenue and not a return on investment. For this course however, we will still treat
them as a return on investment.
Dividends from post-acquisition profits are return on investment and are recorded by the
investor as dividend revenue.
Where do we apply the Equity Method?
The Equity Method is applied depending on the situation of the investor. If the investor
already prepares consolidated financial statements, then the equity method is applied in the
consolidated worksheet. The cost method is first applied in the financial statements of the parent
entity before the equity method is applied during consolidation.
Although you do not need to know the exact journals and details of the cost method (since
we are only interested in the equity method), you should have a brief idea of what the cost method
does so that you can
If the investor does not prepare consolidated financial statements, then the equity method
is applied in the accounting records of the investor.
Accounting for Associates The Equity Method
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 27
Applying the Equity Method
The investment in an associate is usually recognised at cost at acquisition date with the
carrying amount being varied at later periods to reflect the investees post-acquisition profits. Any
distributions such as dividends from the investee will also reduce the investments carrying amount.
The investors share of the profits or losses in the investee must also be reflected in the
investors profit or loss for the period. We also need to adjust the carrying amount of the investment
for any changes in equity that are not reflected in the profit or loss of the investor. These include
land, plant and equipment revaluations.
Remember, as always, we must not forget the income tax implications of these changes.
Like with consolidation, shares in a company can be acquired with goodwill or at a discount.
We find these in much the same way as we do for normal consolidation; through an acquisition
analysis.
We must also adjust depreciation in the investees profit/loss if the fair value of the asset
differs from the recorded value at acquisition date (We did the same thing with consolidation).
Example:
A Ltd has acquired 25% of B Ltd for $150,000. At acquisition date, all assets of B Ltd in their
books were recorded at their fair values. B Ltd had $300,000 of share capital and retained earnings of
$200,000 at acquisition date. Prepare the acquisition analysis and required journals at the date of
acquisition.
Equity: $300,000 + $200,000 = $500,000
Net fair value acquired: 25% x $500,000 = $125,000
Cost of Combination: $150,000
Goodwill: $25,000
If we assume the investor is a parent:
Dr Investment in B Ltd 150,000
Cr Cash1 150,000
Recording an Associates Profit or Loss and any Dividend Payments
There are slight differences that we need to take into account when recording down an
associates profit/loss and any dividend payments for that period depending on whether the investor
is a parent or not.
The following table on the next page outlines the basic differences between the two in
terms of recording the investors share of profits, losses and dividend payments.
1 Note that this can also be Accounts Payable. It depends on how A Ltd has acquired B Ltd. We assume this to
be cash if it is not mentioned how.
Accounting for Associates The Equity Method
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 28
If the Investor is a Parent
All records in the Consolidation Worksheet
If the Investor is not a Parent
All records in the Investors Accounts
Year 1
Acquisition Journal Entry
DR Investment in B Ltd
CR Cash
DR Investment in B Ltd
CR Cash
Recording share of associates profit or loss for the period
DR Investment in B Ltd
DR Share of Income Tax Expense*
CR Share of associates profit or loss*
Note: Flip this journal around to record a loss.
DR Investment in B Ltd
DR Share of Income Tax Expense*
CR Share of associates profit or loss*
Note: Flip this journal around to record a loss.
Recording dividends in the current period
DR Dividend Revenue
CR Investment in B Ltd
Note: This is an elimination journal entry that is
required to eliminate the revenue recognised under
the cost method.
DR Dividend Receivable
CR Investment in B Ltd
Note: Dividend Receivable can also be Cash depending
on whether the dividend has been received yet. If
cash, then a journal is needed later to record receipt.
Year 2
Recording share of associates profit or loss for the period and prior periods
To record profits this period.
DR Investment in B Ltd
CR Opening Retained Earnings2
To record profits from last period.
DR Investment in B Ltd
DR Share of Income Tax Expense*
CR Share of associates profit or loss*
Note: Flip each journal around to record a loss in the
respective period a loss is incurred.
DR Investment in B Ltd
DR Share of Income Tax Expense*
CR Share of associates profit or loss*
Note: The investor has already recorded last years
share of profit/loss and does not need to record it
again since it is still in the investors books. For a
consolidated entity, the consolidation worksheets are
compiled again at the end of each period. This is not
the case here.
Note: Flip this journal around to record a loss.
Note that in the above table, we assume that the associate was acquired with all assets
recorded at fair value at acquisition date. If this was not the case, we simply adjust the share of the
associates profit or loss that the investor has. To find out how much we need to adjust by we do a
simple calculation.
Example:
2 Note here that this entry includes Share of Income Tax Expense and Share of associates profit or loss.
The amount we credit to Opening Retained Earnings is the difference between the two. Any dividends can also
be eliminated against here. Example: If the dividend paid in the last period was $5,000, we would reduce both
sides of this journal by $5,000.
*Note that if you are not given the amount of income tax expense, but are given the level of net profit. Then
you may omit Share of Income Tax Expense and simply change the next entry from Share of associates
profit or loss to Share of associates after tax profit or loss.
Accounting for Associates The Equity Method
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 29
When A Ltd acquired 25% of B Ltd, B Ltd had recorded a plant at $300,000. However, its fair
value was $350,000. The plant has a useful life of 10 years. Thus, the additional depreciation we need
to recognise each period (assuming one year) is:
[ ($350,000 - $300,000) / 10 ] x 25% = $1,250
However, we need to take into account the tax effect of this. Assuming that the corporate tax
rate is 30% the after tax effect would be: $1,250 x 0.7 = $825. This is the extra amount that we need
to deduct from the amount that is attributable to the investor.
If B Ltd had made a $100,000 profit for the year, of which 25% ($25,000) is attributable to
the investor, we would need to deduct $825 from that so that the investors share of the associates
profit is now $24,175.
Treating Losses that Exceed the Carrying Amount of the Investment
If an associate occurs so many losses that it causes the carrying amount of the investment to
drop below zero, the use of the equity method is to be suspended. The carrying amount of the
investment will never go below zero, and any extra losses from that period and any period later will
be unrecognised. This loss will only be recognised when the associate makes profits that are equal to
the unrecognised losses and at this point, the equity method is to be used again.
Accounting for Interests in Joint Ventures
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 30
Accounting for Interests in Joint Ventures
Background
Joint Ventures are where two or more companies decide to form a new entity under shared
control. This means that all the assets, liabilities and equity of the new entity are shared between
the controlling companies. This also means that one single company cannot have control over the
entity. All decisions must be made by all the owners of the joint venture.
All Joint Ventures are contractually bound. They cannot be formed without one.
Joint Ventures
Joint Ventures can be split into three different types:
Jointly Controlled Operation (JCO)
Such as manufacturing aircraft where the different components (wings, avionics, tail, interior
etc.) may be constructed by different companies and brought together to make a complete
aircraft. All these companies share risk and return.
Jointly Controlled Asset (JCA)
Such as an oil pipeline, electrical power grid etc. Companies will share in the maintenance
and usage of the asset.
Jointly Controlled Entity (JCE)
A joint venture where a new entity is created and profits are shared.
Methods to Account for Joint Ventures
The AASB 131 currently allows two methods to account for joint ventures:
The One-Line Method
This method is where the venturer simply makes a simple entry into their accounts to note
the investment in the joint venture and the assets given up to do so. This method can only
be used by JCEs but is not preferred.
The Line-by-Line Method (also known as Proportional Consolidation)
This method is where the venturer records its proportionate ownership of the assets,
liabilities, revenues and expenses in its accounts. The AASB 131 requires this method for
JCOs and JCAs. It prefers companies use this method over the one-line method for JCEs.
All the One-Line Method does is recognise the investment in the joint venture with the
following journal:
DR Investment in Joint Venture
CR Cash
Under the Proportional Consolidation method, this is similar for the current period.
DR Cash in Joint Venture
CR Cash
Accounting for Interests in Joint Ventures
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 31
However, in the next period when the venturer knows what the cash has been used on in
the joint venture, it must then reverse the above and allocate the cash to appropriate accounts such
as:
DR Cash
DR Plant
DR Land
Cr Cash in Joint Venture
We take the figures for these from the books of the joint venture. However, we only take
the required percentage. I.e. If we only own 50% of the venture, we will only recognise 50% in this
journal.
Jointly Controlled Operations
In JCOs, each individual venturer:
Recognises assets, liabilities, expenses and revenues in the operation in its own financial
statements.
Uses their own property, plant and equipment. This means that each venturer can use their
own depreciation method and time frame.
Carries their own inventory in the operation.
Capitalises costs in the operation in a work-in-progress account.
JCOs are preferred over JCEs most of the time because they are not considered a separate
economic entity as a JCE is. This means there is no equity, no tax, less regulation and less liability.
Also mentioned is that JCOs allow each venturer to use their own depreciation method, which can
allow for more tax savings.
Jointly Controlled Assets
JCAs are similar to JCOs in how they are recognised. Any jointed held assets are recorded in
the venturers own financial statements. Any liabilities and expenses that are incurred from it are
also split and recorded in their own financial statements.
Jointly Controlled Entities
JCEs are entirely separate economic entities from the venturers. The JCE itself controls all
the ventures assets, liabilities, expenses and revenues. In short, the JCE itself is like any other
business entity in that it prepares its own financial statements and controls itself. The venturers
simply provide cash or any other necessary resources to the JCE for it to function.
JCEs are popular because it allows established firms to undertake higher risk projects. If the
project fails, the liability is only limited to the JCE and not the venturers companies. It also allows
the bypassing of some restrictions such as limitations on foreign ownership. If one company is local
and another international, the international company can bypass this by creating a JCE with the local
company.
Accounting for Interests in Joint Ventures
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 32
Transactions between the Joint Venture and the Venturer
There are a few rules that apply when a venturer purchases or sells an asset to the joint
venture. When the venturer sells an asset to the joint venture, it can only recognise the gain or loss
on the sale of the asset which is attributable to other venturers. Such that if the venturer has a 25%
stake in the joint venture, it can only recognise 75% of the gain or loss.
If a venturer buys an asset from the joint venture, the share of profits from the sale can only
be recognised when the venturer then sells the asset out to another entity other than the joint
venture.
Losses when buying or selling are recognised immediately.
Transferring Assets to a Joint Venture
When transferring assets to a joint venture, we usually use the following entry:
Dr Cash 150,000
Cr Equipment 150,000
Here we are assuming that we put up $300,000 worth of equipment to transfer to the joint
venture. Since we have 50% interest in the joint venture, we only need to credit 50% of the
equipments value since we still own the other 50%. Likewise, we now have 50% of the cash the
other venturer put in ($300,000).
If the fair value of the equipment was different to its carrying amount, then we need to
adjust this. Assuming the carrying amount of the equipment was $200,000 and the fair value of it is
$300,000, the journal entry would be instead be:
Dr Cash 150,000
Cr Equipment 100,000
Cr Profit on Sale of Equipment 50,000
However for the other venturer, the journal entry would be the same either way:
Dr Equipment 150,000
Cr Cash 150,000
In short, we see other venturers contributions as the fair value and not the carrying amount
as recorded by the venturer that contributed the asset.
Introduction to Corporate Financial Reporting
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 33
Introduction to Corporate Financial Reporting
Background
Financial Accounting is the process of collecting and processing financial information for
users both internal and external to the organisation in question. The objective of financial reporting
is to provide a true, fair (this is disputable), relevant and reliable view of the corporation to its users
to help them make informed decisions.
Types of Reports
Reports can either be general purpose or special purpose. General purpose reports are
those that:
Comply with the AASB Framework
Are tailored to meet needs common to all users
These are usually the regularly yearly financial statements that the corporation is required to
produce. Special purpose reports are those that are designed to meet a specific need required from
a specific group, such as a bank requiring a report on liquidity etc.
Regulation of Financial Reporting
In Australia, five main bodies create or enforce accounting frameworks from the AASB.
These are:
The Financial Reporting Council (FRC)
This body has oversight of the AASB and auditing standards. It monitors the effectiveness of
auditing.
The Australian Accounting Standards Board (AASB)
The neutral standards setter for accounting standards. Currently, however, it relies on the
International Financial Reporting Standards (IRFS) as Australia has adopted these. The AASB
may sometimes change a few things and introduce an Australian version of the equivalent
IFRS.
The Australian Securities and Investment Commission (ASIC)
This body is the corporate watchdog. It monitors corporations in Australia, inspects
auditors and also reviews compliances.
The Financial Reporting Panel
This panel resolves disputes between the ASIC and corporations about treatments of specific
line items in financial reports. This removes the need for court proceedings which can be
costly to the corporation and also removes the need for detailed accounting laws to go
through courts that usually do not understand them enough to make a well informed
decision.
Introduction to Corporate Financial Reporting
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 34
The Australian Stock Exchange (ASX)
The ASX operates the market for financial securities and ensures that they comply with
listing rules and also have continuous disclosure of any information that, in general, will
influence the share price.
Note that Accounting Standards are laws.
Who is Required to Report?
Companies that meet any two of the following three criteria do not have to prepare
accounts, apply standards or be audited.
Consolidated Gross Operating Revenue less than $25 million.
Consolidated Gross Assets less than $12.5 million.
Less than 50 employees.
However, it will have to prepare accounts, apply standards and be audited if it is requested
by ASIC or any shareholder that owns more than 5% of voting rights.
Disclosing Entities
Entities who must report are known as disclosing entities. These companies are required to
file biannual reports. Disclosing entities are those that:
Have securities quoted on the ASX
Have securities issued with a prospectus
Have securities issued during a takeover
Have securities issued with an compromise agreement
Are corporations that take loans
The Annual Report
The annual report is comprised of:
Balance Sheet (also known as the Statement of Financial Position)
Income Statement (also known as the Statement of Financial Performance)
Statement of Cash Flows
Statement of Changes in Equity
Notes to Financial Statements
Directors Declaration
This is a declaration by the director that the accounts are a true and fair view of the business
and that they comply with all accounting standards. It should also state any significant
events after balance date and also state if they believe the firm will be able to pay all
outstanding debts on time. A director can only declare this after a CEO or CFO has declared it.
Directors Report
This report is from the directors of the company. They briefly state what the business has
done during the year, any significant changes in the past or upcoming, significant post-
Introduction to Corporate Financial Reporting
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 35
balance date events and compliances. Most importantly, the report includes a statement of
corporate governance.
Auditors Report
This is the report by the auditors who confirm that the financial statements are a true and
fair representation of the company in question.
Materiality
Materiality is whether the information has the ability to influence decisions or
accountability of managers. For example, a $1 pen in a multi-billion dollar firm would be immaterial
seeing as the purchase of a single $1 pen will not influence decision making. However, the purchase
of company cars is material as it would considerably change the firms accounting figures which
could lead to different decisions being made.
Materiality is normally determined using professional judgement on behalf of management.
Management may also use the AASB 1301 to find arbitrary guidelines to determine materiality.
These guidelines are:
5% - Immaterial
>5% and
Presentation of Financial Statements
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 36
Presentation of Financial Statements
Background
The presentation of financial statements is covered by the AASB 101 which is the equivalent
to the IAS 1 with a few minor changes. Financial statements are structured representations of the
financial position and performance of the company.
The AASB 101
Within the AASB 101 are eight different considerations that we must take into account when
applying the standard to financial statements. These are:
1. Fair presentation and compliance with IFRSs
This means fairly representing the effects of all transactions and absolute compliance with
the AASB. Management may state, in the notes, why they believe compliance will be
misleading but they must still apply the standard.
2. Going-concern
Financial statements should be prepared on the grounds that the firm is a going concern
unless management actually intends to liquidate or cease trading. Any uncertainty must be
disclosed.
3. Accrual basis of accounting
Except for the Statement of Cash Flows, all other statements must be prepared on an
accrual basis.
4. Consistency
Financial statements should be in the same format and also consistency between periods for
easy comparison. It is only allowed to change if the firms operations changes significantly or
a newly modified AASB standard requires a different presentation.
5. Materiality and Aggregation
As mentioned previously, all dissimilar material items must be presented individually. They
must not be aggregated.
6. Offsetting
Items in the financial statements should not offset unless it accurately reflects the substance
of transactions or events.
7. Frequency of Reporting
Complete set (Balance Sheet, Income Statement, Statement of Changes in Equity, Statement
of Cash Flows and notes to the financial statements) of financial statements required
annually. Reasons for changing the reporting period must be disclosed.
8. Comparative Information
The financial statements must disclose at least 2 years of data in each statement. If there
has been a change in accounting policy, 3 years is required.
The AASB 101 only applies to general purpose financial statements. That means that
companies which do not have to prepare these or companies that are preparing special purpose
statements do not have to abide by the standard.
Presentation of Financial Statements
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 37
The Statement of Financial Position
The Statement of Financial Position (Balance Sheet) measures a businesss assets, liabilities
and equity. Its main use is to provide information on the companys financial position including
capital structure, liquidity, solvency and flexibility. Note that the AASB101 allows you to use either
name for this statement.
This statement is very limited in terms of its usage and interpretability. As such, it is best to
use with the notes to the financial statements. It is also limited by the fact that assets can be
measured at a variety of costs, intangibles are not recognised and the fact that off-balance sheet
items exist.
All assets and liabilities must be classified as current or non-current and they must meet the
criteria to be labelled an asset or liability. Recall the definition of an asset and liability. Line items
should also be listed from the most liquid to the least liquid form.
The standard requires, at a minimum:
Property, Plant and Equipment
Investment Property
Intangible Assets
Financial Assets
Investment accounted for under equity method
Biological assets
Inventories
Trade and other receivables
Cash and cash equivalents
Held for sale assets
Trade and other payables
Provisions
Financial liabilities
Current taxes
Deferred taxes
Non-controlling interested presented within equity
Issued capital and reserves attributable to the owners of the parent
The Statement of Comprehensive Income
The Statement of Comprehensive Income is also known as the Statement of Financial
Performance or more popularly as the Income Statement. Note that the AASB101 allows you to use
either name for this statement. It presents the entire firms revenues and expenses incurred in the
period.
This statement can either be done in one whole statement or split into two statements. One
shows just the components of profit and loss and the other shows components of other
comprehensive income.
Presentation of Financial Statements
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 38
The AASB 101 requires all items of revenue and expenses to be listed in the statement and
as such, is a prime source for performance information and also performance prediction. It is limited
by the fact that managers may make biased judgements on the handling of some expenses and/or
revenues which can skew results.
The standard requires, at a minimum:
Revenue
Finance cost
Share of profit and loss of associates/JVs accounted for using the equity method
Tax expense
After-tax profit(loss) of discontinuing operations/assets
Profit or loss
Profit/Loss attributed to non-controlling interests
Profit/Loss attributed to owners of the parent
This is the splitting point if we want to use the two-statement approach. The remaining
points go on the other statement. If we want a one statement approach, combine both
together.
Each component of other comprehensive income classified by nature
Share of other comprehensive income of associates/JVs accounted for using the equity
method
Total comprehensive income
Total comprehensive income attributed to non-controlling interests
Total comprehensive income attributed to owners of the parent
In addition to the above minimum line items, the AASB 101 requires separate disclosures of
certain things to enhance understandability. These include:
Inventory & Property, Plant and Equipment Write-Downs
Restructuring costs
Losses/Gains on Disposals
Profits/Losses on discontinued operations
Litigation settlements
Reversal of provisions
Nature and Function of an Expense
The statement of comprehensive income requires that line items be classified by either their
nature or function. Generally, a function of expense can be broken down into many smaller natures
of expense. If an expenses by function method is used, the breakdown of the nature of expenses
must be disclosed.
For example, cost of sales is a function of expense. However, purchases of materials and
employee costs are the nature of the expense. Both of these are considered part of the cost of sales.
Presentation of Financial Statements
Corporate Financial Reporting & Analysis Semester 2 2009 39
The Statement of Changes in Equity
This statement shows the changes in each component of equity throughout the period. It
puts the opening balances out first, shows all adjustments during the year and then the closing
balance for the period.
The Cash Flow Statement
This statement was studied in depth in ACCT1511: Accounting and Financial Management 1B.
Recall that this is the only statement that does not require the use of accrual basis of accounting.
This statement has already been covered and is not covered in this course.
The Notes to the Financial Statements
These are made to enhance understandability of the financial statements. Typically, the first
note is a summary of all accounting policies the firm uses. This section should also disclose all
contingent liabilities, unrecognised contractual commitments, risk management objectives and
policie