Constitutional Compromises

Pleasantville High SchoolUS History 11RMr. Brunelli

Virginia Plan

New Jersey Plan

Great Compromise

Asma: Vanilla > Chocolate > StrawberryBrandon: Strawberry > Vanilla > ChocolateChristopher: Chocolate > Strawberry > Vanilla

VANILLA vs. CHOCOLATE

VANILLA vs. STRAWBERRY

STRAWBERRY

VANILLA vs. STRAWBERRY

STRAWBERRY vs. CHOCOLATE

CHOCOLATE

STRAWBERRY vs. CHOCOLATE

CHOCOLATE vs. VANILLA

VANILLA

Arrow’s Impossibility Theorem

JACK : JILL GOES > BOTH GO > NEITHER GOES > JACK GOES

JILL : BOTH GO > NEITHER GOES > JILL GOES > JACK GOES

JOINT : NEITHER GOES > JILL GOES > BOTH GO > JACK GOES

CANNOT HAVE PERFECT LIBERTY & MAXIMIZE UTILITY AT THE SAME TIME

JACK GOES JACK DOESN’T

JILL GOES (BOTH GO)

4 + 3 (7)

(JILL GOES)2 + 4

(6)

JILL DOES

N’T(JACK GOES)

1 + 1(2)

(NEITHER GOES)3 + 2

(5)

The Liberal Paradox