Upload
others
View
6
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
COMPUTERIZED FLUID DYNAMICS (CFD)CAPABILITIES OF
RBSANCHEZ PME CONSULTANTS
& ASSOCIATES, INC.
3/6/2020www.rbs-engineers.com
PRESENTED BY:
ENGR. ROSEN B. SANCHEZU.P. BSME 1980, PME, ASEAN, ACPE PSME ENGR
CFD is not yet COMMONLY USED in the Philippines.
But it is already a common,useful and PROVEN technologyabroad.
i.e. RBS CFD on BURJ KHALIFA TOWER
2
PHILIPPINE SITUATIONER
Actual CFD Simulations
by
RBSANCHEZ PME CONSULTANTS & ASSOCIATES, INC.
RBSanchez PME Consultants and Associates Inc.36th Flr. Makati Executive Tower 2 Cor. Dela Rosa St. Makati. Website: www.rbs-engineers.com
CFD Simulation and Analysis of
Sedimentation Basin Channels 1
and 2 of Balara Treatment Plant 1
Preliminary Report Discussion
January 29, 2020
CFD Simulation and Analysis of Sedimentation Basin Channels 1 and
2 of Balara Treatment Plant 1
BACKGROUND
CFD CASE SETUP - SIMULATION
Solids Fraction
Run until 14400 seconds*
CFD CASE SETUP – 3D FULL SCALE SIMULATION
Sludge concentration (solids fraction)
An operational issue is observed as accumulation takes place along the
entire basin.
- A concentration and compression gradient will form as the sludge bed
develops.
- The earlier settled sludge would increase and compress becoming
more rigid as the sludge bed progresses along the basin floor.
If sludge removal is operated after a considerable settling time, similar
results of stagnation from rigid sludge bed would be expected making the
removal system more difficult.
CFD CASE SETUP - SIMULATION
Solids Fraction
Run until 7200 seconds*
Sludge removal started after
7200s accumulation time
Solids Fraction
Similar problems are observed
even at reduced slopes and
shortened distance from sump
pit. Although steeper slopes
have been observed to cause
sludge transport to improve,
the problem of sludge
stagnation remains.
(3D full scale simulation to
verify)
*to avoid sludge increased
rigidity
Actual CFD Simulations performed to date
FESTIVAL EXPANSION
SUPERMALLAlabang, Muntinlupa
A 5,400 CTonCOOLING TOWER
NEW FESTIVAL SUPER MALL
FESTIVAL EXPANSION
SUPERMALL
5,400 TON COOLING TOWERS OPTION 1 – SINGLE LINE TOWERS
ORIENTATION – 90 deg against the WIND
WIND DIRECTON
5,400 TON COOLING TOWERS OPTION 2 – SEPARATED TOWERS
ORIENTATION – 90 deg against the WIND
WIND DIRECTON
5,400 TON COOLING TOWERS OPTION 3 – SEPARATED TOWERS
ORIENTATION – 0 deg to the WIND
WIND DIRECTON
5,400 TON COOLING TOWERS OPTION 1 – SEPARATED TOWERS
ORIENTATION – 90 deg with the WIND
FESTIVAL EXPANSION
SUPERMALL
“AS DESIGNED” CFD RUN ON COOLING TOWERS
NEW FESTIVAL SUPER MALL
Presentation of Results SEPARATED TOWERS
NEW FESTIVAL SUPER MALL
Presentation of Results SEPARATED TOWERS
NEW FESTIVAL SUPER MALL
Presentation of Results SEPARATED TOWERS
NEW FESTIVAL SUPER MALL
Presentation of Results COMBINED / SINGLE FILE TOWERS
NEW FESTIVAL SUPER MALL
Presentation of Results SEPARATED TOWERS
NEW FESTIVAL SUPER MALL
RESULTS: OPTION 3 IS THE BEST!
WIND DIRECTON
Presentation of Resul
Design and consultancy services for the redesign of all eleven (11) MSSC offices occupied at RCBC Plaza.
DESIGN AND CONSULTANCY FOR CHEVRON MSSC HVAC UPGRADE & REHABILITATION
RCBC Plaza, Makati, Manila
System rectifications and rebalancing to attain comfortable space conditions. Redesign of all floors include the improvement in operations and utilization of current resources.
Resolve the hot and cold spots over the floors, temperature gradient.
Computerized Fluid Dynamics(CFD) Studies Of Zama Precision
Die-casting Lines
by
RBSANCHEZ PME CONSULTANTS & ASSOCIATES, INC.
06/03/202024RBSanchez PME Consultants
CFD SIMULATION
CFD PRESENTATION OF CFD PRESENTATION OF
06/03/202025RBSanchez PME Consultants
ADDITIONAL UPPER VENTSENLARGE LOWER VENTSTO FOLLOWNATURAL BOUYANCY LAWS
CFD PRESENTATION OF CFD PRESENTATION OF
PROPOSED
SETUP
06/03/202026RBSanchez PME Consultants
TAKE ADVANTAGE OF NATURAL WIND DRIVEN CROSS VENTILATION
06/03/202027RBSanchez PME Consultants
We recommend “CROSS FLOW AIR VENTILATION” at the faciltyto take advantage of natural wind power
06/03/202028RBSanchez PME Consultants
2.0 NO “CROSS FLOW AIR VENTILATION” AT THE NORTHERN SIDE OF THE FACILITY. Current velocity measurements show that the air is ony recirculating“plan-wise” (and not exhausting) across the building in the northern side of the building near the furnaces.
All lower intake louvers including doors also have air inflows only and NEVER cross-ventilates.
06/03/202029RBSanchez PME Consultants
READINGS OF LOCAL VENTILATION PM2.5 PARTICLE CONCENTRATIONS
NO “CROSS FLOW AIR VENTILATION”
06/03/202030RBSanchez PME Consultants
Current “FORCED FLOW AIR VENTILATION” at the facilityuses Mechanical power to exhaust only 103,000 cfm
06/03/202031RBSanchez PME Consultants
We recommend “CROSS FLOW AIR VENTILATION” at the faciltyto take advantage of natural wind power @ 322,900 cfm.
06/03/202032RBSanchez PME Consultants
3.0 PARTICLE ACCUMULATION ALSO OCCURS AT GROUND LEVEL OUTSIDE THE BUILDING AT THE NORTHEASTERN SIDE.Outside the building, the gaseous particles on the rooftop tends to fall due to layout of the fans relative to the roof and the gooseneck exhaust design. Exhaust and particles must be vented to the atmosphere and thrown at high levels for proper dispersion. Particle readings show higher levels of PM2.5 matter in this area(705 ug/m3) in the ground level especially when exhaust of furnaces are working compared to other surrounding areas.
06/03/202033RBSanchez PME Consultants
06/03/202034RBSanchez PME Consultants
LOCAL EXHAUSTS VENTILATION SCHEMES w/ CFD RUNS
PUSH-PULL
LOCAL
OPTION
06/03/202035RBSanchez PME Consultants
LOCAL EXHAUSTS VENTILATION SCHEMES w/ CFD RUNS
PUSH-PULL
LOCAL
OPTION
06/03/202036RBSanchez PME Consultants
5.0 COMMENT ON THE PROPOSAL TO COMPLETELY INSULATE THE FACILITY TO REDUCE INTERNAL TEMPERATURES. We were told to comment on the proposed insulation of the facility. We don’t recommend these altogether if it is for forlowering of the internal temperatures. It will only cost money, time, and space and increase the internal temperatures.
We don’t recommend using 150mm thermal insulation to reduce internal working temperatures.
We recommend high “solar reflectance” radiant barriers coupled with “air/ insulation” technologies.
OTHER CASE STUDIES:
❖ Naturally Ventilated Building
❖ A kitchen Comfort and Hood Exhaust Design (Jollibee Samples)
❖ CarPark Natural Ventilation
CASE STUDIES and CFD to be shown:
❖ An Underground Road Tunnel design for oxygen, CAR fire scenario, and CO and CO2 levels.
TAGAYTAY HIGHLANDSSAMPLE FOR “GREEN”NATURAL VENTILATION
TAGAYTAY HIGHLANDS
TAGAYTAY HIGHLANDSCFD FOR NATURAL VENTILATION
TAGAYTAY HIGHLANDSMETROPOLIS MALL
CFD FOR NATURAL VENTILATION
TAGAYTAY HIGHLANDSNATURAL VENTILATION
UNDER ROOF SOLAR SHIELD
13MM HOT AIR GAP
HUGE SOLAR CAP COVER
CROSS FLOW OF AIR
HIGH RIDGE VENTS
SUPERMALL – UNDERGROUNDCARPARK TUNNEL
THESE CASES WE SHALL SHOW and PERFORM on actual software:
❖ Naturally Ventilated Building
❖ A kitchen Comfort and Hood Exhaust Design
❖ CarPark Natural Ventilation
Presentation of Results
CFD is a tool to even a better design!
ADDITIONAL CASE:A CFD Simulation
STARMALL ALABANGAlabang, Muntinlupa
A Special Request by our Chairman Mon Aguilos:
STARMALL ALABANG
A 3,600 Ton MallAlabang, Muntinlupa
METROPOLIS CFD APPROACH: PRINCIPLES OF
NATURAL VENTILATION
The Opening up on the Glass facade of Building to accommodate and act as a wind catcher intake.
A 3,600 Ton METROPOLIS MALL
AIR CAVERN CATCHERCFD FOR NATURAL VENTILATION
ACTUAL MAPCFD FOR NATURAL VENTILATION
PRINCIPLES OFNATURAL VENTILATION
A 3,600 Ton METROPOLIS MALL
CFD FOR NATURAL VENTILATION
The use of spent cool air from the three lower floors to be released upward to assist in cooling the natural ventilation of the 4th and 5th floors.
METROPOLIS MALLCFD FOR NATURAL VENTILATION
SPENT AIR
PRINCIPLES OFNATURAL VENTILATION
The use of the now shuttered / open up the main hallways and corridors to serve as exit and entry of wind driven air.
CFD FOR NATURAL VENTILATION
The design and provision (for occasional use during humid months:) of swimming pool fountain as a chilled water curtain AIR DEHUMIDIFIER during hot and humid days to dry incoming air of Building in the
wind catcher intake.
CFD FOR NATURAL VENTILATION
Estiamnted in Two (2) to 3 Months (3) of a year, the wind will be too hot and humid, and we need cooling assistance from chilled water.
CFD FOR NATURAL VENTILATION
PRINCIPLES OFNATURAL VENTILATION
The design of the Roof Apex or topmost Roof Ridge as Wind-driven cross ventilation , where natural wind will push and suck out the roof level hot air.
CFD FOR NATURAL VENTILATION
PRINCIPLES OFNATURAL VENTILATION
The Design of the side ridge vents on both sides of roof as cool air intake and air exhaust from wind driven air and natural forces to cool the roof.
CFD FOR NATURAL VENTILATION
CFD FOR NATURAL VENTILATION
The use and application of a thin film specially specified for 99% solar reflection from the roof.
To minimize heat energy as it was observed by our engineers that radiant heat from underside of roofs is very high.
CFD FOR NATURAL VENTILATION
The strategic design and use of Spent Air and/or transfer air from cinemas to assist in cooling the natural ventilation of the 4th and 5th floors.
CFD FOR NATURAL VENTILATION
TO USE the very hot south front wall as a SOLAR CHIMNEY as the MAIN EXHAUST of hot air from the building
NATURAL VENTILATION is GREEN and SUSAINABLE!
The above approaches were discussed in the meetings held.
All these components were to work SYNERGISTICALLY as a NATURAL VENTILATION SYSTEM to give a cooler building WITHOUT USING ANY AIRCON EQUIPMENT
NATURAL VENTILATION is GREEN and SUSAINABLE!
TO PROVE THIS SYSTEM, YOU HAVE TO RUN THE CFDS FOR THE WIND-DRIVEN DESIGN.
HAVE TO GET SITE WIND DATA, AND FINALLY VERIFY THE CFD MODEL BY TAKING MEASUREMENTS.
A 3,600 Ton METROPOLIS MALL
CFD FOR NATURAL VENTILATION
DEMO OF CFD WIND DRIVEN MODEL
A 3,600 Ton METROPOLIS MALL
CFD FOR NATURAL VENTILATION
A 3,600 Ton METROPOLIS MALL
CFD FOR NATURAL VENTILATION
Actual CFD Simulations
CFD FOR FLUE GAS MODELLING
OF
SHELL REFINERY IN TABANGAO, BATANGAS
Done by RBS ASSOCIATE
ENGR FRANCISCO AMARRA
CFD FOR REFINERY GAS EMISSIONS
SO2 & NOx Ground LevelConcentrations from Stack Emissions
In Shell Tabangao Refinery
Objectives of Study:
1. Determine ground level concentrations at Shell
Tabangao Refinery from September 2001 to
August 2002.
2. Study availability and quality of raw data
3. Develop methodology to be able to apply
AERMOD using local data
4. Assess applicability of AERMOD for the
Philippines using available data
Importance of Study:
• EMB – appreciation of the benefits that can be derived
at from AERMOD
• PAGASA – adapt and make available the surface and
upper air climate data format required for the successful
application of AERMOD
• NAMRIA – make available terrain data in USGS-DEM
format
• Model Users – awareness in the benefits and pitfalls in
the application of AERMOD for the Philippines
• Other readers – appreciation on the benefits of air
dispersion modeling, in general, and how this can help in
the proper management of our environment
Review of Literature:
• Philippine Clean Air Act
• Pollutants from Stack Emissions
o Effects of SO2
o Effects of NOx
• Meteorological Effects on Air Dispersion
• Terrain Effects on Air Dispersion
• AERMOD Program
o Meteorological Pre-processor
o Terrain Pre-processor
• Other recommended models
Study Area:
• Shell Tabangao Refinery
• Location
• Background history
• Process Description
• Emission Sources
• Combustion Fuels
Downloaded DOS version
program.
Studied the AERMOD
Program together with
AERMET
Deciphered the data
formats used in AERMET
Sourced surface
climatological data
from PAGASA
Reformatted
climatological data
from PAGASA
Tested validity of format by
running AERMET pre-
processor
Sourced upper air
data from PAGASA
Sourced terrain data from
UP-NIGS
Converted terrain data to
USGS-DEM format.
Run AERMAP to validate
terrain data
Run AERMOD with inputs
from AERMET and
AERMAP.
Applied to both SO2 and
NOx pollutants
Overlaid aerial map to show
contours of pollution spread
in large scale perspective
Overlaid aerial map to show
contours of pollution spread
in small scale perspective.
Deciphered the data
formats used in AERMAP
Methodology:
Input Data Required for AERMOD:
• Control Pathway
–Averaging Time, Pollutant type
• Source Pathway
–Point Sources ID and Location (x, y, z)
–Dimensions: stack height, diameter
• Emission Data
–Emission rate, stack gas temperature, gas velocity
• Receptor
–Large scale and small scale networks (locations)
Input Data Required for AERMOD:
•Meteorological Pathways–Site data for surface climate & upper air stations–Study site data
•Surface Parameters–Albedo, Bowen ratio, surface roughness
•AERMAP–Terrain files converted to USGS-DEM format
•AERMET–Raw data: Surface Climate Surface File–Raw data: Upper Air Profile File
Results: SO2 Concentrations
Se
p-0
1
No
v-0
1
De
c-0
1
Ja
n-0
2
Fe
b-0
2
Ma
r-0
2
Ap
r-0
2
Ma
y-0
2
Ju
n-0
2
Ju
l-0
2
Au
g-0
2
Ye
ar
Ave
.
Re
g. L
imit
Monthly
24-hour
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
ug
/NC
M
Emission
Sources:
Gas Turbines
CDU/STAR
Platformer
Months
Results: NOx Concentrations
Sep-0
1
Nov-0
1
Dec-0
1
Jan-0
2
Feb-0
2
Mar-
02
Apr-
02
May-0
2
Jun-0
2
Jul-02
Aug-0
2
Year
Ave.
Reg. Lim
it
Monthly
24-hour
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
ug
/NC
M
Emission
Sources:
Gas Turbines
CDU/STAR
Platformer
Months
Conclusion:
1. Shell Tabangao Refinery emission
concentrations were below the regulatory
limits for the period September 2001 to
August 2002.
2. Problems were encountered during acquisition of
raw data
– Surface climate data not in the required format
– Upper air climate data not always available
due to budget limitations
– Terrain data is not readily available and
expensive to produce
CONCLUSION
3. Conversion of raw data was successful.
AERMOD Program is applicable in the
Philippines and it was successfully
applied using Shell Tabangao Refinery
data
Recommendations:
• Air Dispersion Models – EMB should focus on
encouraging industries to make use of air modeling
programs;
• Surface and Upper Air Climatological Data – bring up-
to-date all encoding requirements for surface data and
convert to CD-144 format; include encoding of upper air
data into the CLICOM system and convert to TD-6201
format;
• Terrain Data – NAMRIA should develop digitized maps
in USGS-DEM format.
PollutantsShort Terma Long Termb
μg/NCM ppmAveraging Time
μg/NCM ppmAveraging Time
Suspended particulate Matterc –
TSPPM-10
230d
150f
24 hours24 hours
9060
1 yeare
1 yeare
Sulfur Dioxidec 180 0.0724
hours80 0.03 1 year
Nitrogen Dioxide 150 0.0824
hours
Photochemical Oxidants as Ozone
14060
0.070.03
1 hour8 hours
Carbon Monoxide35 mg/NCM10 mg/NCM
309
1 hour8 hours
Leadg 1.53
monthsg 1.0 1 year
Sea Breeze
WARM AIR
COOL AIR
DAYTIME
CONDITIONS
Land Breeze
COOLER AIR
WARMER AIR
NIGHTTIME
CONDITIONS
(Land cools faster)
Surface
Climate
Data
AERMAP
PreprocessorDEM File
Profile
File
AERMOD
Surface
File
AERMET
Preprocessor
On-Site
Upper Air
Data
Data
Output
From US-
NWS
From US-
NWS
From
USGS
Column Element
1-5 Surface Station Number
6-7 Year
8-9 Month
10-11 Day
12-13 Hour
14-16 Ceiling Height (Hundreds of Feet)
17-18 Wind Direction (Tens of Degrees)
19-21 Wind Speed (Knots)
22-24 Dry Bulb Temperature (Degrees Centigrade)
25-26 Total Cloud Cover
27-28 Opaque Cloud Cover
SurfaceDataFormatDescription
Column Element
1-8 Station Identification
9-12 Latitude
13 Latitude Code N/S
14-18 Longitude
19 Longitude Code E/W
20-29 Date and Time (Yr/Mo/Dy/Hr)
30-32 Number of Data Portion Groups thatFollow
33 Level Quality Indicator
34-37 Time (elapsed time since release)
38-42 Pressure
43-48 Height
49-52 Temperature
53-55 Relative Humidity
56-58 Wind Direction
59-61 Wind Speed
62-67 Flag Field (Quality Flags)
68 Type of Level
Upper AirFile FormatDescription
GAS &
LIQUID
TREATING
MIDDLE
DISTILLATE
HYDRODE-
SULPHURIZER
SULPHUR
RECOVERY
UNIT
THERMAL
CRACKER
CAT
REFORMER
LPG PLANTNAPTHA
HYDRO-
TREATER
CRUDE
DISTILLER
NAPHTHA
GASOLINE
COMPONENT
DIESEL
AVTUR/KEROSENE
FUEL OIL
SULPHUR
LPG
FUEL OIL
Daily Synopsis
(compiled monthly)
Climatological &
Agrometeorological
Branch (CAB)
Quality Control of
Data Input
Approved DataAverage Daily and
Monthly Report
Computer/CLICOM
Available for public
reference
Parameter From CAB Required by AERMOD/SCRAM
Conversion
Hour 3-hourly reading 1-hourly reading Copy missing hour data from the first hour
Ceiling Height Meters Hundred feet M x 3.28/100
Wind Direction Degrees Tens of Degrees Degrees/10
Wind Speed Meters/second Knots M/s x ___
Dry Bulb Temp. ºC ºC Not Applicable
Total Cloud Cover1 Okta % (x 10) Okta to %8 = “-“7 = “8”6 = “7”5 = “6”4 = “5”3 = “4”2 = “3”1 = “2”0 = “1”
Opaque Cloud Cover1 Okta % (x 10) Readings shall be less or equal to Total Cloud Cover depending on specific type(s) of clouds present.
Note: 1Total Cloud Cover = Opaque + Transparent [35].
SurfaceDataConversionGuidelines
120ºE 126ºE
UTM Coordinates: Zone 51N291300m East, 151700m North
Zone 51
ShellTabangaoRefinery
BatangasCity
CFD IN ACTION
3/6/2020WWW.RBS-ENGINEERS.COM 104
OPEN FORUM
QUESTION & ANSWER
Why USE CApplication of CFD in ACCUS
AIR COOLED CONDENSER STUDIES
RBSanchez PME Consultants and Associates Inc.36th Flr. Makati Executive Tower 2 Cor. Dela Rosa St. Makati. Website: www.rbs-engineers.com
RBS RESOURCES for
CFD Simulation
Personnel
Equipment
Servers
Instruments and tools
DREXLER G. DELA TORRE, ME
Bachelor of Science in Mechanical Engineering, BSME
St. Louis University, Baguio (2018)
Graduated “CUM LAUDE”
“3rd PLACER” - PRC Mechanical Board Exams 2018
MECHANICAL ENGINEER
NICK JOHNSONN B. FERNANDEZ, ME
Bachelor of Science in Mechanical Engineering, President Ramon Magsaysay State University – Iba Campus (2018)
PRC Mechanical Board Exams 2018
“12th PLACE”
MECHANICAL ENGINEER
JOSEPH RENE C. OMANDAC, ME
Bachelor of Science in Mechanical Engineering, Mapua University-
Cum Laude and Gold Medalist
PRC Mechanical Board Exams 2019
“6th PLACER” (August 2019)
MECHANICAL ENGINEER
RESOURCE/OFFICES:
With complete Personnel Support and resources for:
1. AutoCAD Drafting and Large format Plotting
2. Complete Engineering softwares (with license): Elite
Duct Size 3.0, PsychartHD 7.4, Flite FluidFlow Pipe and
Duct Ver 3.0., ASHRAE Fundamentals 2013, Trace 700
Cooling Load, CHVAC Heat Load, PipeSizer, AutoCAD
Suite 2013, Cloud computing, OpenFOAM, FDS,
COMSOL, ANSYS Fluent
3. Dedicated FTP site for large file transfer
SUPERCOMPUTERSHEWLETT PACKARD PROLIANT DL 380 SERVERS2 UNITS w/ XEON DOUBLE PROCESSORS32 CORES 3MHZ XEON
RBS EQUIPMENT USED: SAMPLE TESTING AND MEASUREMENT PRECISION INSTRUMENTS
THANK YOU!
3/6/2020WWW.RBS-ENGINEERS.COM 114
REFERENCES
3/6/2020WWW.RBS-ENGINEERS.COM 115