42
Community Capital A Sustainable Approach to Community Development Mark Roseland SFU Centre for Sustainable Community Development – www.sfu.ca/cscd “Remaking the Economy” Forum March 7, 2009

Community Capital A Sustainable Approach to Community Development

  • Upload
    tamera

  • View
    53

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Community Capital A Sustainable Approach to Community Development. Mark Roseland SFU Centre for Sustainable Community Development – www.sfu.ca/cscd “Remaking the Economy” Forum March 7, 2009. SFU Centre for Sustainable Community Development. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Citation preview

  • Community Capital

    A Sustainable Approach to Community DevelopmentMark RoselandSFU Centre for Sustainable Community Development www.sfu.ca/cscd

    Remaking the Economy ForumMarch 7, 2009

  • SFU Centre for Sustainable Community DevelopmentMission: to enable the sustainable development of communities in BC, Canada, and around the worldResearch, education, and community mobilizationAcademic, professional, and outreach programs

  • A Big TitleSmaller PointSmaller Point 2Smaller Point 3

  • Local Sustainability ExamplesOslo, Norway - transit pass for downtown driversVancouver - climate action planMinneapolis - restrictions on packagingCalifornia - water retrofit requirementsSan Luis Obispo - stream daylightingZutphen, Holland - disassembly line

  • Peak Oil

  • A Model Sustainable Community

  • Sustainability Framework, Victoria, BC

  • Some Big QuestionsCan the paradigms (thinking), systems, and the institutions that created these problems also be expected to solve them?

    Can we remake our economy to provide the good things we need from economic development (jobs, income, wealth, security) without destroying our communities and the life-support systems upon which we depend?

    Where can we look for models and examples that help demonstrate a sustainable economy?

  • The Development Significance of Sustainable Development

    SD represents a historic compromise between the ideology of capitalism and its environmental critique

    SD is coming of age

  • Sustainable Development does NOT simply mean

    Environmental protection

    Economic growth (presumably to pay for, among other things, environmental protection)

  • Three Core Elements of Sustainable Development

    Environmental considerations must be entrenched in economic decisions and policy-making.

    An inescapable commitment to social equity.

    Development does not simply equal growth.

  • Sustainable Development means

    doing development differently

  • Four Key IdeasSustainable development becomes tangible when understood in terms of natural capital and natural income

    Natural capital and social equity demand that the worlds wealthier people (e.g. most North Americans) find ways of living more lightly on the planet

  • Reducing materials and energy consumption can enhance quality of life and the public domain, e.g., multiply social capital

    Critical resources for multiplying social capital are not (only) money, but trust, imagination, courage, commitment, relationships, and time

  • What is Sustainable Community Development?

    SCD is sustainable development applied at the local level.SCD means thinking globally and acting locally: its glocal.SCD aims to integrate economic, social and environmental objectives in community development.

  • SCD considers economic factors and other community elements such as housing, education, the natural environment, health, accessibility and the arts

    emerging as a compelling alternative; a participatory, holistic and inclusive process

  • SCD leads to positive, concrete changes in communities by creating employment, reducing poverty, restoring the health of the natural environment, stabilizing local economies, and increasing community control

  • Community CapitalStrengthening community capital for sustainable community development means focusing attention on six forms of capital

  • Community Capital A Framework for Sustainable Community Development

  • Natural CapitalMinimizing the consumption of essential natural capital, e.g.:living within ecological limits, resource conservation and enhancement, cleaner production, less waste

  • Physical CapitalImproving physical capital, e.g.: community assets such as facilities, water, transportation, housing, infrastructure, telecommunications

  • Economic CapitalStrengthening economic capital, e.g.:Making more with less, maximizing use of existing resources, circulating the money, making something new, trading fairly, community financial institutions

  • Human CapitalIncreasing Human Capital, e.g.:health, education, nutrition, literacy, and family and community cohesion

  • Social CapitalMultiplying Social Capital, e.g.:local governance, strong organizations, capacity-building, participatory planning, access to information, collaboration and partnerships

  • Cultural CapitalEnhancing Cultural Capital, e.g.:traditions and values, heritage and place, the arts, diversity, and social history

  • A Framework for Sustainable Community DevelopmentSustainable development requires mobilizing citizens and their governments to strengthen all forms of community capital. Community mobilization is necessary to coordinate, balance and catalyse community capital.

  • Community Capital A Framework for Sustainable Community DevelopmentSustainable community development seeks to mobilize community to strengthen all these forms of community capital.

  • Back to those Big QuestionsCan the paradigms (thinking), systems, and the institutions that created these problems also be expected to solve them?

    Can we remake our economy to provide the good things we need from economic development (jobs, income, wealth, security) without destroying our communities and the life-support systems upon which we depend?

    Where can we look for models and examples that help demonstrate a sustainable economy?

  • ***Ad lib**Lets get oriented*Blue Marble image of the Western Hemisphere that includes cloud cover, oceans, phytoplankton activity, topography, and city lights in the nightime part of the hemisphere. Credit: Reto Stckli, NASA

    NASA Releases New Views of EarthBy Andrea Thompson, LiveScience Staff Writerposted: 10 October 2007 12:42 pm ET

    http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://www.crystalinks.com/earth1007.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.crystalinks.com/earth.html&h=300&w=300&sz=43&hl=en&start=58&um=1&tbnid=G-hCdfli4AxB8M:&tbnh=116&tbnw=116&prev=/images%3Fq%3DEarth%2Bimages%26start%3D40%26ndsp%3D20%26um%3D1%26hl%3Den%26client%3Dsafari%26rls%3Den%26sa%3DN

    *CLIMATE CHANGE is one of the most critical global challenges of our time. Recent events have emphatically demonstrated our growing vulnerability to climate change. Climate change impacts will range from affecting agriculture- further endangering food security-, sea-level rise and the accelerated erosion of coastal zones, increasing intensity of natural disasters, species extinction and the spread of vector-borne diseases.

    Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC): RisksSea level, biodiversity impacts, sea weather events, coral bleaching, droughts, heat waves, floods, food security, etc.exacerbating issues like poverty, unequal access to resources, conflict and disease.Rewardscombating climate change does not have to damage or derail economies.

    UNEP and WMO Panel Puts Final Full Stop Behind Risks and Rewards of Combating Climate Change: Pocket Guide for Policy Makers Agreed by IPCC in Run Up to Bali Conference Valencia, 17 November 2007

    the IPCC is a panel jointly established by the UN Environment Programme (UNEP) and the World Meteorological Organisation (WMO).

    *Extreme Weather Events

    Almost three years after Hurricane Katrina, nearly 40,000 families still are living in vulnerable mobile homes and trailers across the U.S. Gulf Coast with another hurricane season just two months away.Reuters, April 2, 2008*Sometime during the year 2008, humanity will probably pass the point where it collectively consumes 1,000 barrels of crude oil every second of every day. More than half of it and the share continues to rise is dedicated to the movement of goods, services, and peoplee are, without a doubt, entering the twilight of the Oil Age. Canwest News Service, April 2, 2008

    Gary Kendall, Plugged In: The End of the Oil Age, released April 1, 2008 to Canwest News Service. Kendall, a former Exxon insider for 9 years, is now an analyst with World Wildlife Fund in Brussels.

    Reported in Vancouver Sun, April 2, 2008, p.A4*The forces driving the global food crisis:1) swelling population, 2) soaring energy prices, 3) middle-class hunger for meat, 4) competition from biofuels, and 5) hot money in commodities.Globe and Mail, April 12, 2008, p.1, Why Costs are Climbing

    http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://media.mcclatchydc.com/smedia/2007/08/13/17/85-20070813-FOODPRICES.large.prod_affiliate.91.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.mcclatchydc.com/economics/story/18902.html&h=727&w=920&sz=131&hl=en&start=1&um=1&tbnid=qd-lL-FVAG7syM:&tbnh=116&tbnw=147&prev=/images%3Fq%3Drising%2Bfood%2Bprices%26um%3D1%26hl%3Den%26client%3Dsafari%26rls%3Den%26sa%3DG

    Rice shortages in exporting countries push up the wholesale cost, force local supermarkets to raise theirs.Reuters Thursday, April 03, 2008

    Joanne Lee-Young, Vancouver Sun; with files from Reuters Published:Thursday, April 03, 2008 Food-price inflation is about to hit one of the main staples for local shoppers at Asian supermarkets: rice.

    Most countries that export rice face supply shortages, the Food and Agriculture Organization said Wednesday.

    Rising populations and higher incomes across Asia are leading to increased consumption of rice*The headlines in this Tuesdays (March 3, 2009) Business section of the Vancouver Sun read as follows:

    Trouble with the Economy

    Canadian Economy Shrinks, Stock Market Tumbles

    Hard Times Are Here, Canada

    *The headlines in this Tuesdays (March 3, 2009) Business section of the Vancouver Sun read as follows:

    Trouble with the Economy

    Canadian Economy Shrinks, Stock Market Tumbles

    Hard Times Are Here, Canada

    * leaving impressions like this one seared in collective consciousness *This map represents the perspective of one European Union organization; if they are correct, North America can expect profound economic and social crisis lasting over the next 5-10 years. *Climate change has been called the worlds biggest regressive tax: the poorest pay for the behaviour of the rich.

    Kirk Smith, UC Berkeley professor, cited in The Economist, Vol. 388, Number 8597, Sept. 13, 2008, p. 67*Environmental Problems of Dispersed Land Use PatternsHigh per capita energy useHigh per capita auto emissions(both smog and greenhouse gases are directly related to the amount of gasoline used)High per capita water useHigh land requirements in both the block size and the road system required to service it (road provision is seven times greater in low density areas than in medium density areas)High stormwater pollution from the extra urbanized land (low density areas have double the stormwater pollution of medium density areas)High domestic heating energy due to the lack of a shared insulating effect when buildings are grouped (50% differences are found) Poor recycling rates due to the large cost involved in collection compared to a compact housing system (European cities have four to six times the recycling rates of North America)High physical infrastructure costs (pipes, poles. roads, etc.)High social infrastructure costs (cars are required for participation in social life; juvenile crime is often based on stealing cars; the poor are increasingly pushed into outer suburbs)

    Robert Yaro, president of the NY Regional Plan Association, predicts the US population will grow by 140 million by mid-century. He told the NY Times recently: If we accommodate the next 140 million Americans the way we accommodated the last 20 or 30 million, we would urbanize three times as much land as we have over the last 200 years.

    * Yaro interviewed in Jon Gertner, Chasing Ground, NY Times Magazine, Oct. 16., 2005, pp. 46-82.**Here in Victoria you probably are familiar with Dockside Green, which uses an integrated triple-bottom-line approach throughout focusing on ecology, economics, and equity.

    The University of Victoria has an Office of Campus Planning and Sustainability, a few enlightened academics, and some very dynamic students who have created Common Energy to advocate going beyond-carbon-neutral at U Vic and now elsewhere.

    The City of Victoria is establishing a Sustainability Framework and hiring a Director of Sustainability.

    HOWEVER, to understand these kinds of initiatives and to be able to create them we need to see them as part of a bigger picture.

    As Julie Andrews says in The Sound of Music, Lets start from the very beginning

    *What is a Sustainability Framework?

    A sustainability framework is a high level policy that provides strategic guidance to both corporate and community policy, program and service areas, including the renewal of key City policies, such as the Official Community Plan, the Transportation Master Plan, and the Corporate Strategic Plan. Other communities, throughout the world, are undertaking similar processes as we all realize we must take action now to ensure our resources and quality of life are protected for future generations. The chart shown indicates how the Victoria Sustainability Framework will affect all aspects of the City's business.

    On February 5, 2009 City Council reviewed public input received on the draft Victoria Sustainability Framework, and a restatement of the sustainability commitment and goals reflecting feedback received. The draft framework was further revised to reflect Council input.* *The current debate over the Kyoto Accord on climate change illustrates that the mainstream view of the environment today is sharply different from what it was twenty-five years ago, when environmental problems were almost universally regarded as minor, technical, soluble, and politically uncontentious. They were considered by-products of economic growth and social progress which further applications of growth and progress would duly solve, as increasing wealth created the resources, and improved technology the means, to solve them.Throughout the industrialized world, governments and parties of both left and right now acknowledge that environmental problems are indeed very serious, requiring solutions which are not merely technical, and which may not be available at all without significant social and economic change. The vehicle for this shift has been the concept of sustainable development, which has succeeded in overcoming the conflict between environmental protection and economic growth that characterized the environmental debate of the 1970s and early 1980s. It accepts that protecting the environment requires fundamental change in the direction of economic progress and the institutions of government policy. But it argues that this is compatible with continued economic growth in a (regulated) global capitalist system. In this sense, sustainable development represents a historic compromise between the ideology of capitalism and its environmental critique, and which has enabled a single environmental discourse to develop, used by all manner of governments, businesses, and environmental organizations (Jacobs 1997). One might believe today that sustainable development has finally come of age. Born publicly, at least in the 1987 report of the UNs (Brundtland) World Commission on Environment and Development, a child of the global agenda at the Rio Earth Summit in 1992, stumbling awkwardly toward maturity with the Johannesburg World Summit on Sustainable Development (ICLEI 2002, Otto-Zimmerman 2002) and the 2005 Kyoto Accord on climate change, sustainable development seems to have survived even the shift to a post-September 11 world.

    Certainly in the last couple of years, with the IPCC and Al Gore taking the Nobel Peace Prize, and here in BC the Provincial Government taking the continental lead with respect to carbon taxes and GHG reduction targets, it is clear that sustainability is not just a fad it represents a new way of thinking and acting in the world.

    *Ad lib*Ad lib*Ad lib*Ad lib*Ad lib*Ad lib*Ad lib*Ad lib*There are myriad ways to understand and conceptualize community. In terms of sustainable community development, we are discovering that it is useful to think of community in terms of assets, or capital.

    *Sustainable Community Development =Planning for the long-term success and well-being of your community

    Sustainable community development requires mobilizing citizens and their governments to strengthen all forms of community capital. Community mobilization is necessary to coordinate, balance and catalyze community capital

    SCD is like a gyroscope it needs to be somewhat evenly balanced or it wont stay up.

    COMMUNITY MOBILIZATION requires building individual and community capacity for sustainability leadership through EDUCATION.

    *Minimizing the consumption of essential natural capital means living within ecological limits, conserving and enhancing natural resources, sustainable resource management (soil, air, water, energy, agriculture, etc.), cleaner production, and minimizing waste (solid, liquid, air pollution, etc.).

    *Improving physical capital includes focusing on community assets such as public facilities (e.g., hospitals and schools), water and sanitation, efficient transportation, safe, quality housing, adequate infrastructure, and telecommunications.

    http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://web.mit.edu/civenv/idr/images/Infrastructure_Collage.jpg&imgrefurl=http://web.mit.edu/civenv/idr/&usg=__Yo8YO7dzjT9bFgh9fmx7T0WrY8Q=&h=493&w=509&sz=75&hl=en&start=2&um=1&tbnid=i0Fn3_O8xLjamM:&tbnh=127&tbnw=131&prev=/images%3Fq%3Dinfrastructure%26um%3D1%26hl%3Den%26client%3Dsafari%26rls%3Den%26sa%3DG

    *Strengthening economic capital means focusing on: making more with less maximizing use of existing resources (eg. using waste as a resource); making the money-go-round circulating dollars within a community; making things ourselves - import replacement; making something new creating a new product; trading fairly with others; and developing community financial institutions.

    *Increasing human capital requires a focus on areas such as health, education, nutrition, literacy, and family and community cohesion; basic determinants of health such as peace and safety, food, shelter, education, income and employment are necessary prerequisites.

    http://www1.worldbank.org/devoutreach/winter01/images6/photo_human_6.gif*Multiplying social capital requires attention to effective and representative local governance, strong organizations, capacity-building, participatory planning, access to information, and collaboration and partnerships.

    http://www.getrichslowly.org/images/wonderfullife.jpg*Enhancing cultural capital implies attention to traditions and values, heritage and place, the arts, diversity, and social history.

    http://www.billtjones.org/breaking_ground/DSC04858.jpg*Strengthening these six forms of community capital is the foundation for sustainable community development.*Sustainable community development requires mobilizing citizens and their governments to strengthen all forms of community capital.

    COMMUNITY MOBILIZATION is necessary to coordinate, balance and catalyze community capital

    SCD is like a gyroscope it needs to be somewhat evenly balanced or it wont stay up.

    *1) For the most part, no, but for now we need to work with and through them while we develop the new paradigms, systems and institutions we need for tomorrow.

    2) If we think in ecosystem terms, the economic crisis is giving the planet a chance to breath. Now we can try to either stimulate our conventional industries and economy back into high gear by continuing to deplete resources and pollute at unprecedented rates, or we can see this moment as an opportunity to redesign our economy so as to improve all six forms of community capital. There is no doubt that this is technically possible to achieve; it is a matter of vision, will, strategy, and organizational capacity, courage, and cleverness..

    3) For answers, we need to look HERE, toward the social economy, co-operatives, community land trusts and social enterprises. Imagine if the stimulus packages around the world were aimed at the social economy rather than the unsustainable economy! These are the organizations and institutions that are demonstrating an economy which serves all, which is fair and trades fairly, which is community-based, and which is founded on respect for all people and respect for living systems. Citizens and their governments in over 6,000 communities around the world have conducted LA21 processes through ICLEI, and thousands others are, like the City of Victoria, proceeding with related sustainable development plans and programs. These communities are laboratories for social innovation and are developing the policies and programs that eventually become the models for national and international initiatives, and for a more sustainable economy.

    What motivates you?*The Chinese recognized centuries ago that crisis and opportunity go hand in hand.

    Sure, weve got a crisis, but we also now perhaps the most important opportunity in generations, to try not just to prop up our current economy, but to create a BETTER, more sustainable economy.

    The stakes are indeed high, both now and for the future. We need to get on with creating a better, more sustainable economy.

    Let me leave you with a more hopeful image of that more sustainable economy*