23
2016 Georgia REALTORS ® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR ® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education courses. Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing Commercial Properties #67353 Sponsored by: Georgia Association of REALTORS ® , GREC School #271 Partners in Education Program Visit the Georgia REALTORS ® website to learn about membership benefits, continuing education opportunities, networking events, and more! (www.garealtor.com ) NOTICE: The following material is copyrighted and is provided to you for one-time use only in this GAR-sponsored course. You may not reproduce or redistribute any portion of this packet without the express written permission from the GAR Professional Development Department.

Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

2016

Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and

REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education courses.

Commercial Property 101 – The Foundation to

Analyzing Commercial Properties

#67353

Sponsored by:

Georgia Association of REALTORS®, GREC School #271

Partners in Education Program

Visit the Georgia REALTORS® website to learn about

membership benefits, continuing education opportunities,

networking events, and more!

(www.garealtor.com)

NOTICE: The following material is copyrighted and is provided to you for one-time use only in this GAR-sponsored course.

You may not reproduce or redistribute any portion of this packet without the express written permission from the GAR Professional Development Department.

Page 2: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

STUDENT NOTICE

The Georgia Association of REALTORS®, Inc. is approved by the Georgia Real Estate Commission (GREC) to offer continuing education, sales postlicense, and broker prelicense courses. The GREC school code number is 271 with a renewal date of December 31, 2019. The Georgia Real Estate Commission has approved this course for three (3) hours of continuing education credit. GAR school policy defines an instructional hour as 50 minutes. To receive continuing education (CE) credit for this in-classroom course, the student must:

be on time

sign in with the course facilitator before the course begins

be present in the course during all instruction periods

return a completed evaluation to facilitator at the end of course

not have taken this course for continuing education credit within the past 366 days. There is no make-up session for this course. Cell phones and other electronic devices can be distracting. Use of communication methods such as text messaging, E-mailing, web surfing, etc. is prohibited while class is in session if it poses a distraction to other attendees and shall be grounds for dismissal. Taking pictures of PowerPoint slides requires the permission of the instructor. Entrance qualifications and standards of completion will not be based on race, color, sex, religion, national origin, familial status, handicap, sexual orientation, or gender identity. No recruiting for employment opportunities for any real estate brokerage firm is allowed during this course or on the premises while this course is in session. Any effort to recruit by anyone should be promptly reported to the Director of Professional Development; Georgia Association of REALTORS®; 770-451-1831; 6065 Barfield Road; Sandy Springs, GA 30328; or to the Georgia Real Estate Commission; 404-656-3916; International Tower; 229 Peachtree Street, NW; Suite 1000; Atlanta, GA 30303-1605. 1-20-16

Page 3: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

COMMERCIAL PROPERTY -101

(The Foundation to Analyzing Commercial Properties)

PRESENTED BY:

Debra R. Forrest

Founder and Principal Analyst

Forrest Consulting & Associates, LLC

Commercial Real Estate Analysis

“Analysis You Need…Credibility You Deserve”

Page 4: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

[ii]

Introduction:

Commercial Properties 101: The Foundation to Analyzing Commercial Properties is designed to

equip new and experienced real estate agents with knowledge and understanding of commercial

properties needed on the path to becoming professionals. The focus of this class of properties is

numbers. Therefore, this course is set to lay the foundation on which to build and establish more

accurate numbers which can result in the avoidance of closing delays, making the most of your

clients’ investments, and arming you for negotiations.

Commercial Professionals are expected to possess special knowledge to help their clients make

informed decisions when investing large sums of equity and financing into complex properties.

The author, Debra Forrest, has designed this course discussions with examples and problems to

help you understand, visualize, and practice the information you are about to learn. Fill-in the

blank exercises are provided as studies show that when you write something down, you are more

prone to remember it.

Enjoy the Course…

Copyright 2016 Forrest Consulting & Associates, LLC

Page 5: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

[iii]

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Section 1: Identifying with Commercial Property

Residential vs Commercial Property .……………………………………………….. 1

Relevant Definitions ………………………………………………………………… 2

Rights and Interests …………………………………………………………………. 2

Section 2: Understanding Commercial Properties

Land Fundamentals……………………………………………..……………………... 4

Defining Land Use- Zonings……………..……………………………………………. 6

Exercise #1, Problem …………….…………………………………………………..... 8

Commercial Buildings…………..…………………...………………………………… 8

Section 3: Understanding Market Conditions

Distinguish Cost, Price and Value……………………………………………….…… 10

Exercise #2, Discussion………….…………………………………………………..... 10

Factors of Value……………………………………………………………………… 11

Exercise #3, Discussion……..….…………………………………………….…….... 12

Markets and Marketability…………………………………………………………… 12

Forces That Impact Value….………………………………………………………… 13

Section 4: Highest and Best Use Concept

Introduction to Highest and Best Use………………………………..………………. 14

Four Tests of Highest and Best Use………………………………….………….…… 15

Exercise #4, Case Study..……….……………………………………..……………... 16

Page 6: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

1 | P a g e

SECTION 1

IDENTIFYING WITH COMMERCIAL PROPERTY

OBJECTIVES: By the end of this session you should be able to:

Differentiate Residential and Commercial Property

Interpret Relevant Definitions

Explain How Value is Inherent in Rights and Interests

Residential vs Commercial Property

There are distinct differences between the classifications of residential properties and

commercial properties. Comparing commercial real estate to residential real estate is like

comparing apples to oranges. Both are from the same genre, but that is where the similarities

end.

Residential real estate is focused on personal use. It typically involves purchasing a property for

individual use most often to provide housing for families. For the most part, residential agent's

represent the buyers or sellers of single family or primary homes.

Commercial real estate is business focused. It involves property that is sold, leased, or used to

achieve a predetermined business objective. It is typically purchased as an investment to achieve

an anticipated rate of return on the funds invested. They can be income producing, purchased

specifically to lease to business owners and generate cash flow or non-income producing,

purchased for owner-occupancy.

Unlike residential, you can invest in a wide range of commercial real estate categories, including

retail, office, industrial, apartments, investments, and ground leasing.

Page 7: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

2 | P a g e

Specialized areas or disciplines for commercial real estate agents:

Representing tenants or lessees by finding, selecting, and negotiating new space for client

businesses.

Representing building owners or lessors by working to lease out building space for the

highest possible price and with the most favorable terms. Frequently a commercial agent

represents one owner or even one building exclusively in order to ensure the building is

leased to capacity.

Representing investors who want to buy and sell commercial property by finding

opportunities that offer the lowest risk to the client, the best return on investment, and the

best capitalization rate, which is the net operating income of the property divided by the

sales price or value of the property.

Relevant Definitions

Real Estate – a parcel of land including all improvements permanently attached to it.

Real Property – the interests, benefits, and rights inherent in ownership of real estate.

Personal Property – consists of every kind of property that is not real property and is moveable

without damage to the real estate.

Lessee – tenant or one who has the right to occupy and use a property owned by another for a

period of time according to a lease agreement.

Lessor – landlord or one who conveys the rights of occupancy and use to others under a lease

agreement.

Fee Simple (Estate) – absolute ownership subject only to limitations imposed by the

government.

Leased Fee Interest – the ownership interest that the landlord (lessor) maintains in a property

under lease with rights of use and occupancy conveyed to a tenant (lessee).

Rights and Interests

Real property ownership involves not only the identification and valuation of a variety of rights

but also the analysis of the many limitations of those rights and the effect that the limitations

have on value.

The bundle of rights concepts compares real property ownership to a bundle of sticks. Each stick

in the bundle represents a separate right or interest inherent in the ownership

Page 8: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

3 | P a g e

The bundle of rights concepts compares real property ownership to a bundle of sticks. Each stick

in the bundle represents a separate right or interest inherent in the ownership.

These individual rights can be separated from the bundle by sale, lease, mortgage, donation, or

another means of transfer. The complete bundle includes the following:

the right to sell an interest

the right to lease an interest

the right to occupy an interest

the right to give an interest away

Ownership of the fee simple interest is equivalent to ownership of the complete bundle of

sticks that can be privately owned, while one or more of the sticks can represent partial

interest in a specific property. Each individual right in the bundle has some potential value. If

any or all are removed from the fee simple interest, one or more partial interests are created.

Property interests in real property can be created in several ways:

Economically – most common is when the fee simple interest is divided by a lease.

Legally – legal restriction on the use of a property and usually an easement is always

involved. Other restrictions include life estates and transferrable

development rights (TDR)

Physically – most common are created horizontally- division of real property through

subdivision and assemblage and vertical- division in real property by

subsurface rights and air rights.

Financially – impacts real estate investment practices. Here the analysis of mortgage

and equity components is of particular importance.

Though these qualities are components of both residential and commercial real estate, it is

in commercial where these rights and interests are more prominent as they are sold and

leased and subsequently, the thing that makes commercial real estate a very profitable

business for many.

Page 9: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

4 | P a g e

SECTION 2

UNDERSTANDING COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES

OBJECTIVES: By the end of this session you should be able to:

Identify Land Fundamentals

Define Commercial Land Use- Zonings

Describe Commercial Improvements

Land Fundamentals

(Note: A good commercial flyer would select and advertise the best of these features)

1. size and shape – advantages and disadvantages caused by street frontage, width and

depth

2. zoning – government regulated building codes and density of use

3. topography – land’s contour, grading, natural drainage, soil conditions, view, physical

usefulness

4. utilities – sanitary sewer, domestic water, natural gas, electricity, storm drainage,

telephone service, and cable television

5. accessibility – analyzes all forms of access to and from the property and the

neighborhood (i.e. streets, freeways, highways, railways, airports, public transportation)

6. ingress/egress – curb-cuts, dedicated turn lanes, traffic lights, and limited access (u-turns)

7. exposure – traffic volume’s impact on commercial property’s highest and best use

8. corner influence – impact of properties with frontage on two or more streets

Page 10: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

5 | P a g e

9. excess land - land that is not needed to serve or support existing improvements, has the

potential to be sold separately, and must be valued separately

10. surplus land – land is not needed to serve or support existing improvements, cannot be

sold separately, and has no independent highest and best use

11. plottage – highest and best use results from assembling two or more parcels

12. soil analysis – surface soil and subsoil conditions that can affect the cost of development

and therefore the property value

13. flood plan and wetlands analysis – check proximity to potential areas through the use of

floodplain maps prepared by local governments and FEMA

14. environmental influences – climate, water supply, air quality, lakes, conditions,

contamination, etc.

A good commercial flyer would include the following:

1. property type

2. property address

3. size – acreage, square feet

4. map - showing subject location

5. aerial map

6. site survey or tax plat –, shape, road frontage, and dimensions

7. zoning

8. visibility

9. taxes

10. traffic counts

11. area description – main corridors, demographics

12. Comment - ideal use

Page 11: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

6 | P a g e

Defining Land Use- Zoning Districts – (ex. Gwinnett County)

Residential

RA-200 Agriculture-Residence District.

R-LL Single-Family Residence-Large Lot.

R-100 Single-Family Residence District.

R-75 Single-Family Residence District.

OSC Open Space Conservation District.

R-60 Single-Family Residence District.

MH Manufactured Housing.

Multi-Family

TND Traditional Neighborhood Development District.

R-SR Senior Oriented Residence District.

R-TH Residence Townhouse District.

RM-13 Multifamily Residence District.

RM-24 Multifamily Residence District.

HRR High-Rise Residence District.

Commercial

O-R Office-Residence District.

O-I Office-Institutional District.

C-1 Neighborhood Business District.

C-2 General Business District.

C-3 Highway Business District.

Mixed-Use

MU-N Neighborhood Mixed-Use District.

MU-C Community Mixed-Use District.

MU-R Regional Mixed Use District.

Industrial

M-1 Light Industry District.

M-2 Heavy Industry District.

Example of some Setback Requirements

Zoning

District

Min. Lot

Size

Max. Net

Density/

FAR

Max

Height

Min. Lot

Width

Min.

Front

Setback

Min. Side

Setback

Min.

Rear

Setback

Min. %

Commo

n Area

C-1 None None 35 ft. None 15 ft. 10 ft. 30 ft. NA

C-2 None None 45 ft. None 15 ft. 10 ft. 30 ft. NA

C-3 None None 45 ft. None 15 ft. 10 ft. 30 ft. NA

M-1/M-2 1 acre None 45 ft. 150 ft. 50 ft. 25 ft. 50 ft. NA

Page 12: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

7 | P a g e

Zonings

O-I Office-Institutional District.

C-1 Neighborhood Business District.

C-2 General Business District.

C-3 Highway Business District.

O-I Office-Institutional District.

Purpose and Intent. This zoning district is established to provide a location for offices,

institutions and limited related retail business and service activities in buildings of high character

in attractive surroundings.

C-1 Neighborhood Business District.

Purpose and Intent. The C-1 Neighborhood Business District is intended to provide for

commercial uses of a convenience nature for nearby residential neighborhoods. These uses are

intended to be facilities serving the everyday needs of these nearby neighborhoods rather than

the larger community.

C-2 General Business District.

Purpose and Intent. The C-2 General Business District is intended to provide adequate space in

appropriate locations along major streets, thoroughfares and intersections for various types of

business use. These uses include the retailing of major goods and services, general office

facilities and public functions that would serve a community area of several neighborhoods. The

intensity of development and uses in the C-2 General Business District is greater than in the C-1

Neighborhood Business District because it is intended to serve a greater population and to offer a

wider range of goods and services.

C-3 Highway Business District.

Purpose and Intent. The C-3 Highway Business District is intended for business uses which

require locations accessible to major highways and arterials that serve significant portions of the

community. The C-3 district allows an intensity of development and uses that is greater than in

the C-2 General Business District because it is intended to serve a greater population and to offer

a wider range of goods and services.

Page 13: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

8 | P a g e

Exercise #1, Problem: Describe Commercial Land

a. Review the photo slide on the vacant land parcel. Given this visual and the discussion, write

a brief description of the subject land and market area with consideration of the

aforementioned land fundamentals:

Commercial Buildings

Classes of Buildings

Retail buildings are typically grouped into four classes: Classes A, B, C, and D. The class

rankings reflects the strength of tenants, quality of design and materials of the improvements,

and purchasing power of consumers in the market area.

Office buildings are grouped into Classes A, B, and C, which reflects the competitive ability of

each building to attract similar types of tenants. A combination of rent, building finishes, system

standards and efficiency, building amenities, location and market perceptions are measured.

Class A: highest quality finishes

architectural appeal

state of the are systems

example: brick on all four sides with good architectural design

Class B: secondary or average quality

fair to good quality finishes

adequate systems

do not compete with Class A buildings at the same price

example: brick on three sides with plain design

Class C: below average quality

lower quality and condition

often older

tenants requiring functional space at below average rents

example: stucco structure

Class D: very low quality

older (retail)

may be economically obsolete

example: metal structure

Note: Buildings may be classified by type of construction or according to local markets

classification of quality and market position.

Page 14: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

9 | P a g e

Classes are further broken down into good, average, and low cost construction

and condition.

Exterior Description

1. foundation

2. framing

3. exterior walls

4. exterior doors and windows

5. façade

6. roof and drain system

Interior Description

1. walls and partitions

2. floorplan (restrooms, kitchenette, conference room, anchor tenant, etc)

3. ceiling

4. lighting design

5. flooring

6. restrooms

Basic Property Inspection Checklist

Site Inspection Building Inspection Other Observations -location - construction finish/quality - bldg management

-ingress and egress - age and condition - leases

- traffic/exposure -floorplan and space layout - rent rolls

-parking spaces -stairways/corridors/elevators - tenant mix

-topography -HVAC systems - tenant quality

-parking lot lighting -amenities - occupancy levels

-landscaping and grading -security - CAM

-signage -warehouse clearance - financial statements

-road frontage -% office finish -highway proximity

-land-to-building ratio -loading docks -transportation

-stories -environmental

Page 15: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

10 | P a g e

SECTION 3

UNDERSTANDING MARKET CONDIIIONS

OBJECTIVES: By the end of this session you should be able to:

Distinguish Cost, Price and Value

Describe Factors of Value

Identify Markets and Marketability

Evaluate Forces That Impact Market Value

Distinguish Cost, Price and Value

Cost is a fact. It is the dollar amount required to create, produce, or obtain a property. It is

the actual construction costs or overall development cost.

Price can be the amount asked, the amount offered, as well as the amount paid for the

property. It may or may not have any value relation to the value attributed to a particular

property.

Value is not a fact but rather an opinion of worth at a specified time. It is the monetary worth

of a property, good, or service to buyers and sellers at a given time. It is also the present

worth of the future benefits projected to accrue to the real property owner.

Exercise #2, Discussion: Cost vs Price vs Value

Miranda is representing a client that recently purchased an investment property (land and

building) for $1.0 mil. Two independent appraisers have provided opinions of $1.1 mil on the

property, so in this case price and value appear to be the same. However, Miranda’s client now

wants her to list the property for a firm sale’s price of $1.4 mil.

a) Assuming seller made no changes to the property and the market is stable, would anyone

pay the higher price? Why or Why not? ______________________________________

Page 16: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

11 | P a g e

Four Factors of Value

Four independent factors create value: utility, scarcity, desire, and effective buying power.

Utility and scarcity are supply factors. Desire and effective purchasing power are demand

factors. All four factors must be present to have value.

Utility – is the ability of a product to satisfy a human want, need, or desire. All properties

must have utility to tenants, owner-investors, or owner-occupants. To compare, residential

properties generally satisfy the need for shelter, and commercial properties generate income.

Both may have design features that enhance their attractiveness. These features are called

amenities. The value of amenities is related to their desirability and utility to an owner-

occupant or tenant-occupant.

Scarcity – is the present anticipated supply or anticipated undersupply of an item relative to

the demand for it. In general, if demand is constant, the scarcity of a commodity makes it

more valuable.

Desire – is a purchaser’s wish for an item to satisfy human needs (e.g., shelter, clothing,

food, companionship) or individual wants beyond the essentials required to support life.

Effective Purchasing Power – is the ability of an individual or group to participate in a

market (i.e., to acquire goods or services with cash or its equivalent). A valid opinion of the

value of a property includes an accurate assessment of the market’s ability to pay for the

property.

Supply and Demand

The interaction of these four factors that create value is reflected in the basic economic principle

of supply and demand. The utility of a commodity, its scarcity or abundance, the intensity of the

human desire to acquire it, and the effective power to purchase it all affect the supply of the

demand for the commodity in any given situation.

4-Stages of Neighborhood’s Life Cycle

Growth – a period during which the market area demand increases, then supply.

Stability – a period of equilibrium in supply and demand

Decline – a period of diminishing demand, over supply and increased vacancies

Revitalization- a period of renewal, redevelopment, and increasing demand

Page 17: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

12 | P a g e

Exercise #3, Discussion: Supply and Demand

Given the following scenarios of a 10-yr old 50-unit apartment building, which is typical in the

market area, what might you determine in regards to supply and demand?

a) Apartment was 80% leased 2 years ago with average rent of $800 and has increased to a

current occupancy of 100% leased, no amenities, current average rent $1000/mth?

__________________________________________________________________________

b) A 10-yr old 100-unit apartment building 80% leased and occupied, no amenities, average

rent $800/mth and ¼ mile north within the same market is a new 100-unit apartment

building 100% leased and has a swimming pool and gym, average rent $1200/mth.

____________________________________________________________________

Markets and Marketability

Market Analysis – a process of identifying and studying the supply and demand of a property

type and the market area.

Marketability Analysis – a process that investigates how a particular piece of property will be

absorbed, sold, or leased under current or anticipated market conditions.

Market and Marketability analyses are to show the interaction of supply and demand affect’s on

the property’s value.

1. active market – a market characterized by growing demand, a corresponding lag in

supply, and an increase in prices.

2. depressed market – a market in which a drop in demand is accompanied by a relative

oversupply and a decline in prices.

3. buyer’s market – a market in which buyer’s have the advantage; exists when market

prices are relatively low and declining due to an oversupply of property or a reduced

number of potential buyers.

4. seller’s market- an active market in which the sellers of available properties can obtain

higher prices than those obtainable in the immediately preceding period.

5. strong market – a market that reflects either high demand and increasing price levels or

a large volume of transactions.

Page 18: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

13 | P a g e

6. soft market- a market characterized by low demand and declining price levels.

Forces That Impact Market Value

Social – focuses on demographics and

attitudes toward social trends and lifestyle

options.

demographic composition

lifestyle options

attitudes toward education

law and order

Economic – focuses on circumstances and

trends that impact current and anticipated

supply and demand of real property.

employment

wage levels

new development

occupancy rates

rental and price patterns of existing

properties

Governmental – involves regulations and

legal activities at all levels of government. local zoning and building codes

environmental laws regulating new

developments and control of

hazardous materials

legislation affecting the types of

loans, loan terms, and investment

power of institutions.

Environmental and Geographic – focuses

on the natural and man-made environmental

surroundings.

topography and soil

toxic contaminants (i.e. asbestos)

rivers, mountains, lakes, oceans

highways, airports, railroads,

waterways, immediate area

desirability

Page 19: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

14 | P a g e

SECTION 4

HIGHEST AND BEST USE CONCEPT

OBJECTIVES: By the end of this session you should be able to:

Identify with Highest and Best Use Concepts

Apply the Four Tests of Highest and Best Use

Analyze a Highest and Best Use Case Study

Introduction of Highest and Best Use (HBU)

Though this method is used by real estate appraisers, a review of the concepts of a highest and best

use analysis can particularly arm a real estate agent with powerful knowledge and understanding

on how to:

15. determine ideal uses for a parcel of vacant land, if a vacant building should be

demolished for redevelopment, or how to market an existing building for maximum

value.

16. position and market a commercial property in the best way

17. read and forecast market trends for marketability purposes

All of the above can go a long way in advising your client on how and where to create value for

their commercial property. This will be the proof in the pudding to your client that you are truly a

knowledgeable and informed expert and professional.

A highest and best use analysis identifies the most probable and profitable competitive use a

property could be used for. Since economic conditions change, a property's highest and best use

changes as well.

It is the reasonably probable and legal use of vacant land or an improved property, that

is legally permitted, physically possible, financially feasible, and that results in

maximum value.

Page 20: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

15 | P a g e

This analysis seeks to solve the highest and best use of:

Land as Though Vacant Property as Improved

Options Options

a. a.

b. b.

c.

Four Tests of Highest and Best Use

1. Legally

Permissible

The use must be legal or probable. That is, the use must conform to

existing zoning restrictions, or there must be a reasonable likelihood a

rezoning or variance may be granted.

Private deed restrictions must not be violated.

2. Physically

Possible

Physical attributes of the land that must be considered include size,

access, shape, orientation, soil conditions, potential hazards,

topography, and utilities.

Physical attributes of the building that must be analyzed include design,

size, efficiency, mechanical systems, floor plan, construction materials,

quality, and physical condition.

3. Financially

Feasible

Land may be developed with different uses. Only those uses, which

produce a positive net return over time with acceptable risk, are

deemed financially viable.

This use must not depress surrounding property values.

4. Maximum

Productivity

Of all uses that survive the first three tests, there is only one use, which

produces the greatest return with the least risk. This single use

represents the property’s Highest and Best Use.

Supply and demand are constantly fluctuating, so it is common for a

property’s highest and best use to change.

Page 21: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

16 | P a g e

Exercise #4, Problem: Case Study Applying Highest and Best Use Concepts

Assume your client wants to purchase 2.0 -acres of land to develop a 5,000 square foot

commercial building for a local restaurant use within Duluth, Gwinnett County, GA. Your client

has a budget of $550,000. Your research returns three listings of vacant tracts of land within

your client’s desired location.

Consider the data below for the three listings. Assume all comparable listings have public

utilities available, no environmental issues, outside of floodplain, and no atypical government

restrictions, answer the question that follows.

Land #1:

size: 2.50 –ac zoning: C-2 shape: rectangular

topo: leveled list price: $650,000 ($260,000/ac)

The site is located along a major 4-lane road with regional retailers and some local shops within

the surrounding. The site has good exposure to traffic and very good road frontage.

Land #2:

size: 2.50 -ac zoning: C-1 shape: very irregular

topo: rolling, 40% timber list price: $500,000 ($166,667/ac)

This site is located ½ mile north of Land #1 along the same corridor with more local shops than

regional. It has 30% less exposure to traffic but good road frontage. Timber costs $20,000 to

remove.

Land #3:

size: 2.00 –ac zoning: C-1 shape: rectangular

topo: leveled list price: $400,000 ($200,000/ac)

This site is located approximately 1-mile north of Land #1, along the same corridor. It is a

narrow lot with 40% less road frontage.

1. List at least six primary steps you would take to decide which, of the listings have an

ideal land use suitable for your client’s purpose to build a restaurant?

1.________________________ 4._______________________

2.________________________ 5._______________________

3.________________________ 6._______________________

Page 22: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

17 | P a g e

Debra R Forrest

Commercial Real Estate

Analyst/Appraiser/Agent

[email protected]

Phone: (470) 418-2324

Forrest Consulting & Associates, LLC

http://www.forrestconsultingandassociates.com

Page 23: Commercial Property 101 The Foundation to Analyzing ... · 2016 Georgia REALTORS® partners with the Local Boards and REALTOR® Firms to provide quality, affordable continuing education

© 2017 Inspironix, Inc. (916) 488­3222        InspiroScan Survey Form PIE Instructor / Course Evaluation v5        Side 1

Georgia Association REALTORS® ­ Partners in Education  Student Course / Instructor Evaluation  Course Name _____________________________

  Instructor ________________________________

   Date _____________________________________

 

PLEASE FILL IN THE BUBBLES COMPLETELY SO ANSWERS ARE SCANABLE.

Please do NOT use check marks, x's or any other type of mark.The instructor encouraged my participation through questions and answers or exercises.

Strongly DisagreeDisagreeNeutralAgreeStrongly Agree

The instructor presented ideas clearly and made the subject matter interesting.Strongly DisagreeDisagreeNeutralAgreeStrongly Agree

The use of the outline / handouts for study and / or reference was helpful.Strongly DisagreeDisagreeNeutralAgreeStrongly Agree

The topic is relevant / helpful to my real estate activities.Strongly DisagreeDisagreeNeutralAgreeStrongly Agree

I would want this instructor back.Strongly DisagreeDisagreeNeutralAgreeStrongly Agree

Additional Comments:

Thank you for your input. (Revised 5­2017)