Cocaine and Instability in Africa: Lessons from Latin America and the Caribbean

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/7/2019 Cocaine and Instability in Africa: Lessons from Latin America and the Caribbean

    1/81

    In November 2009, on a dry lakebed in the

    desert o northern Mali, United Nations (UN) in-

    vestigators ound traces o cocaine amid a Boeing

    727s charred and stripped uselage. Its owners had

    apparently torched the plane ater it had been dam-

    aged, probably to destroy evidence o their identity

    and cargo. With a payload capacity o 10 tons ococaine etching a wholesale value o $580 million,

    West Aricas emerging cocaine trackers could a-

    ord the loss.

    The fight path o this 727 may have included

    layovers in Gambia, Senegal, Guinea, and Guinea

    Bissau, but it assuredly originated rom South Amer-

    ica. Its cargo added to the mounting cocaine trac

    rom Latin America that transships West Arica on

    AFRICA SECURITY BRIEF

    Cocaine and Instability in Arica: Lessonsrom Latin America and the CaribbeanBy Davin ORegan

    A P U B L I C A T I O N O F T H E A F R I C A C E N T E R F O R S T R A T E G I C S T U D I E S

    The dollar value o cocaine traicked through West Arica has risen rapidly and surpassed all otherillicit commodities smuggled in the subregion.

    Experience rom Latin America and the Caribbean demonstrates that cocaine trac contributes to dra-matically higher levels o violence and instability.

    Co-opting key government ocials is the preerred modus operandi o Latin American cocaine tra-ckers. Arican governments need to act urgently to protect the integrity o their counternarcoticsinstitutions to prevent this threat rom developing deeper roots on the continent.

    H I G H L I G H T S

    N O . 5 / J U L Y 2 0 1 0

    its way to European consumers. Estimates o annual

    cocaine transshipments through West Arica range

    between 60 and 250 tons, yielding wholesale rev-

    enues o $3 billion to $14 billion.

    Beginning in 2006, several West Arican coun-

    tries seized extremely large volumes o cocaine

    measured in the hundreds and thousands o kilo-gramsin single hauls. These seizures were oten

    accidental, indicating that actual trac was likely

    much higher. Cocaine departs Venezuela, Colom-

    bia, and elsewhere in South America in shipping

    containers, on yachts, and by small planes and jets.

    South American organized criminal and militant

    groups commonly deliver bulk shipments to West

    Arican trackers in Ghana, Nigeria, Guinea, and

  • 8/7/2019 Cocaine and Instability in Africa: Lessons from Latin America and the Caribbean

    2/8

    2

    Guinea Bissau, countries that the UN Oice on

    Drugs and Crime (UNODC) requently character-

    izes as the subregions cocaine hubs. The cocaine

    is then repackaged and moved to neighboring coun-

    tries beore being transerred to syndicates in Eu-

    rope, oten composed o Arican expatriates, who

    handle wholesale and retail sales. Seizures in West

    Arica have resulted in the arrests o Arican, South

    American, European, and other nationals.

    While West Arica is the current locus o this

    activity, the continent as a whole is an ideal trans-

    shipment centerpoor, with limited oversight and

    weak policingmaking or a low-cost and low-risk

    environment. Since Arica is not a producer or major

    consumer o cocaine, some assume that its domes-

    tic eects will be minor. Yet evidence o cocaines

    destabilizing impact is already emerging. The assas-

    sinations o Guinea Bissaus president and the head o

    the army in early 2009 were likely linked to cocaine

    transshipment. In January 2010, a senior ocer o

    Guinea Bissaus Presidential Security Service was ar-

    rested in a narcotics sting, prompting senior military

    ocials to publicly lament the regular involvement

    o security personnel in cocaine transshipment. In

    late 2009, Ghana extradited three Malians who

    claimed links to al Qaeda in the Islamic Maghreb

    to the United States on cocaine tracking charges.

    The sheer value o the trade poses not only a threat

    to security but also real risks o distorting the regions

    economy, investment fows, development, and steps

    toward democracy.

    Cocaine transshipment in Arica is new, but Lat-

    in American and Caribbean countries have over 30years o experience dealing with narcotics tracking

    and its destabilizing eects. Hard-earned lessons rom

    Latin Americas experience, then, hold potentially

    invaluable insights or Arica as it engages this new,

    pernicious enemy.

    NO ORDINARY ILL IC IT COMMODITY

    Tracking in illicit goods is common in West A-

    rica. Arms, countereit medicine, cigarettes, and crude

    oil all move illegally to and through West Arica. Tra-

    ckers in the subregion also have a history o smug-

    gling heroin around the world. The mule method o

    hiring travelers to swallow narcotics in small parcels

    and travel by air is probably a Nigerian innovation.

    But cocaine is an order o magnitude more se-

    ductive than other goods already smuggled across

    the subregion. Kilogram or kilogram, it is immensely

    more valuable. According to a UNODC assessment

    o tracking in West Arica, the estimated value o

    cocaine transshipments in 2008 rivaled crude oil or

    the most valuable smuggled commodity. Yet the vol-

    ume o cocaine trac was comparatively minuscule

    compared to the 55 million barrels o oil that were

    stolen and transported or the same return.

    The yields rom cocaine transshipment also

    dwar the subregions ocial resources. During one

    incident in January 2008, Malian security ocials

    seized 750 kilograms o cocaine ollowing a shoot-

    out. This one haul represented 36 percent o Malis

    entire 2007 military expenditures. Similarly, the 350

    kilograms o cocaine seized on one occasion in Au-

    gust 2007 in Benin represented the annual per capita

    income o 31,000 Beninois.

    Cocaine trac may prove to be a xture in West

    Arica. Transshipment has emerged in part because

    demand is growing in Europe. According to the UN

    International Narcotics Control Bureau, cocaine use

    has doubled and tripled in some parts o Western Eu-

    rope since 2000. Trackers, it would seem, are not

    shiting trac to service preexisting demand but es-

    tablishing a new route or a growing market.

    Market dynamics also explain why heroin trac

    through West Arica has not been nearly as destabi-lizing. West Arica plays a small role in global heroin

    trac because consumer markets in North America

    and Europe are supplied through the Balkans, Middle

    East, and South Asia. Only 167 kilograms o heroin

    was recovered in West and Central Arica in 2007, or

    less than one-thirtieth the amount o cocaine seized

    in just West Arica or the same year. There are grow-

    ing concerns, however, that instability in East Arica

    Davin ORegan is a Research Associate in the Arica Cen-

    ter or Strategic Studies at the National Deense University.

    cocaine is an order o magnitudemore seductive than other goodssmuggled across the subregion

  • 8/7/2019 Cocaine and Instability in Africa: Lessons from Latin America and the Caribbean

    3/8

    3

    is attracting heroin trac (contributing to an esti-

    mated 200,000 heroin addicts in Kenya), which may

    merge with West Arican cocaine routes.

    COCAINE, GOVERNANCE,

    AND CORRUPTION

    Over the last decade West Arica has emerged

    rom widespread instability and beneted rom a pe-

    riod o declining violence and growing democracy.

    Sierra Leone, Liberia, and Cte dIvoire are emerging

    rom civil wars. Mali, Ghana, and Benin continue to

    consolidate democratic gains. Cocaine trac poses adirect threat to these advances.

    Traickers abhor attention. Any state re-

    sponsewhether parliamentarians passing laws to

    enhance border security or investigators prosecuting

    smugglersraises transaction costs and lowers pro-

    its. Consequently, trackers will attempt through

    co-optation, bribery, and corruption to prevent and

    deter a states response in order to protect their pro-

    its. Rather than guard cocaine cargoes with heavily

    armed security and gunghts, trackers would rather

    pay politicians, judges, and police ocers to ignore

    their trade altogether. The strategy is to make these

    ocials beneciaries early to ensure low costs over

    the long term.

    In the Caribbean, narcotics traic has been a

    major actor in expanding and deepening corruption.

    Jamaica has struggled or years against endemic corrup-

    tion, clientelist politics, and a lack o checks and bal-

    ances within governmenta amiliar combination in

    West Arica. Beginning in the late 1990s, however, itsstrategic location between the United States and drug-

    producing countries in Latin America attracted rising

    cocaine transshipment. By 2003, Jamaica had become

    a leading transit country or cocaine destined or the

    United States. The quality o governance on the island

    soon worsened. Jamaicas ranking on Transparency In-

    ternationals Corruption Perceptions Index ell rom

    45th in 2002 to 99th in 2009. The sharp drop in public

    Cocaine Trafc and Seizures in Kilograms, 20052009

  • 8/7/2019 Cocaine and Instability in Africa: Lessons from Latin America and the Caribbean

    4/8

    4

    integrity coincides with regular eorts by transnational

    and Jamaican criminal groups to corrupt unctionaries

    in critical state agenciesparticularly the police and

    customspolitical party unctionaries and grass roots,

    community organizations.1

    Narcotics traicking has penetrated govern-

    ment and undermined governance elsewhere in

    Latin America and the Caribbean. In 2009, Leonel

    Fernndez, president o the Dominican Republic, dis-

    missed 700 police and 535 military ocers, including

    31 senior leaders, citing links to cocaine trac. In

    Mexico, the Zetas, a criminal group renowned or as-

    sassinations on behal o drug trackers, was ormed

    by ocers who deserted the military. In Brazil, So

    Paulos narcotics trackers train their members to

    pass Brazils civil service exam, thereby gaining infu-

    ence within the government bureaucracy.

    As cocaine transshipment grows, West Ari-

    cas ragile governance institutions may be urther

    weakened. Arican media reports and independent

    research already suggest that narcotics transship-

    ment proceeds may be nancing political parties and

    campaigns in Ghana.2 A Nigerian politician arrest-

    ed beore boarding a plane rom Lagos to Germany

    with more than 4 pounds o cocaine in his stomach

    explained that he needed the unds to inance his

    upcoming election campaign. Authorities believe

    he may be part o a wider network o smugglers.3 In

    Sierra Leone, the minister o transport and aviation

    was dismissed ater trial proceedings revealed that

    he allegedly provided landing clearance to a planecarrying 700 kilograms o cocaine.4 There are similar

    reports o senior level police ocers involved in co-

    caine tracking rom Benin, Nigeria, and Ghana.5

    C O C A I N E , C R I M E , A N D V I O L E N C E

    Narcotics tracking is not intrinsically violent.

    Violence within the international trade in cannabis

    and Ecstasy, a popular hallucinogen/amphetamine, is

    comparatively low. But the overwhelming evidence

    rom Latin America and the Caribbean indicates that

    where cocaine trac moves, so too do homicide rates

    and confict.

    I eorts o co-optation and bribery prove unsuc-

    cessul, trackers may resort to violence to deter or re-

    sist attempts by government authorities to curtail drug

    fows and arrest trackers. Tracking groups also use

    violence to maintain loyalty and discipline as well as

    target other trackers to resolve disputes, enorce agree-

    ments or contracts, and protect or acquire market share.

    In such environments, violence can spiral. Stud-

    ies have shown that when violence within one crimi-

    nal activity rises, all crimes can become more violent,

    gangs prolierate, and rustrated citizens may resort to

    mob justice including lynching suspected criminals.6

    Oten, the average age o violent criminals alls and

    the prevalence o violent youth behavior grows. In

    short, a culture o violence emerges.

    Evidence rom Latin America bears this out. The

    homicide rate there, the highest in the world, is more

    than three times the global average. Guatemalas ho-

    micide rate rose 50 percent between 2004 and 2008,

    an increase that paralleled cocaine trac. According

    to a World Bank report on crime in the Caribbean, the

    strongest explanation or the relatively high rates o

    crime and violence in the regionand their apparent

    rise in recent yearsis narcotics tracking.7

    Jamaica has one o the highest homicide rates in

    the world, and an estimated 40 percent o all murders

    are related to narcotics disputes. Indeed, there are

    268 local and transnational gangs in Jamaica alone,

    comprising tens o thousands o members. Police

    shootings have correspondingly risen sharply while

    relations with civilians have suered. Within the last

    10 years, almost 2,000 Jamaicans have been killed by

    the policeslayings oten ollowed up by the most

    cursory o internal investigations.Such conditions can contribute to severe bursts

    o violence in Jamaica. In May 2010, authorities at-

    tempted to arrest and extradite to the United States a

    powerul Jamaican gang leader and reputed drug tra-

    cker, Christopher Dudus Coke. Over the course

    o 3 days, Jamaican army and police units swept a

    subsection o the nations capital in search o the sus-

    pect. Their increased presence was met with hostility

    the overwhelming evidence romLatin America and the Caribbean

    indicates that where cocainetrac moves, so too do homicide

    rates and confict

  • 8/7/2019 Cocaine and Instability in Africa: Lessons from Latin America and the Caribbean

    5/8

    5

    by gang-controlled neighborhoods. Over 70 people

    were killed in clashes and gun battles.

    Tracking-associated violence can reach even

    more dangerous levels. In Mexico, traickers re-

    quently battle one another and the state to protect

    and expand their business. Government ocials esti-

    mated 9,000 drug-related deaths in 2008, a dramatic

    upsurge rom recent years that claimed the lives o

    many bystanders. Mexico has surpassed the 1,000

    deaths-per-year benchmark used to designate a state

    o civil war every year since 1995. This high toll has

    occurred despite government expenditures o $2.5

    billion per year to reduce drug-related violence and

    und the deployment o 45,000 troops.

    The upsurge in cocaine-related violence in Mexi-

    co ollows a prolonged period in which cocaine trac

    was largely ignored by the state, likely due to successul

    eorts by trackers to co-opt ocials. Trackers ac-

    cumulated much power and infuence, and some be-

    came de acto authorities in several regions, eectively

    creating ungoverned spaces. When the government

    eventually conronted trackers, the groups responded

    ercely, revealing that the state no longer held its pre-

    sumed monopoly on violence and security.

    Cocaine trac has provided a vital nancial re-

    source to insurgency groups as well. Recent reports

    rom Peru indicate that the military is encounter-

    ing resurgent elements o the Shining Path, which

    apparently has been able to reconstitute itsel with

    proceeds rom cocaine tracking. The 40-year-old

    Revolutionary Armed Forces o Colombia (FARC)

    rebel group grew substantially during the 1990s when

    it began to trac cocaine. Recently, the FARC di-

    versied its cocaine trade rom the United States to

    Europe by way o West Arica, a presence that could

    encourage insurgencies in West Arica and acilitate

    trade in strategies and tactics. According to indepen-

    dent reports, terrorist and armed groups in West A-ricas Sahel region are entering the drug trade.8 The

    same is true in the Niger Delta, where militias have

    accepted in-kind cocaine as payment rom track-

    ers.9 This permits a move into the wholesale market

    and sharply increases revenues.

    West Arica today sustains many o the con-

    ditions that enabled and anned narcotics-related

    violence and conlict in Latin America and the

    Caribbean. The subregion hosts many insurgencies

    and terrorist groups who may view cocaine trac as

    a prime opportunity to access nancial resources.

    Likewise, West Aricas already capable trackers

    in small arms, cigarettes, and humans may diver-

    siy into cocaine. In Latin America, these problems

    quickly metastasized into national security chal-

    lenges, oten beore the state was able to implement

    eective responses.

    O B S T R U C T I N G T R A F F I C , P R O T E C T I N G

    I N S T I T U T I O N S

    In 2009, indications o small-scale cocaine pro-

    cessing emerged in Guinea and processing labs were

    thought to be active in Ghana. This represents a dan-

    gerous evolution beyond cocaine transshipment and

    is urther evidence that quick and robust responses

    are necessary. Lessons drawn rom Latin Americas

    experience oer critical insight into West Aricas

    emerging counternarcotics playbook.

    Address the Problem Vigorously Now. The

    threats posed by cocaine traicking in West A-

    rica are daunting, but they will be much harder to

    reverse i let unchecked. According to the World

    Bank, the Caribbeans rising homicide and crime

    rates have exhibited strong inertia eects. This

    means that once crime rates are high, it may be

    dicult to reduce them. At the same time, crime-

    reduction eorts in the short term are likely to have

    huge long-term gains.10 Since cocaine traic in

    West Arica is still maturing, there is an opportunity

    to prevent its expansion. Deterring cocaine trac

    is much cheaper, too. I West Arica can prevent

    urther expansion o trac, it can avoid the atten-

    dant spikes in crime and violence, fight o oreign

    investment, prolieration o gangs, overcrowded

    prisons, overburdened courts, and the rising deense

    and police expenditures seen in Latin America and

    the Caribbean.

    West Arica today bears many othe conditions that enabled and

    anned narcotics-related violenceand confict in Latin America and

    the Caribbean

  • 8/7/2019 Cocaine and Instability in Africa: Lessons from Latin America and the Caribbean

    6/8

    6

    Thus, West Arican political and civic leaders

    should strenuously press responsible government

    agencies to accelerate their counternarcotics e-

    orts. Unortunately, current indications suggest

    that recently devised strategies remain unused and

    poorly distributed. In October 2008, the Economic

    Community o West Arican States developed a

    regional action plan to counter drug traicking

    based on ve themes: data collection, law enorce-

    ment, legal rameworks, drug abuse prevention,

    and political and budgetary support. The action

    plan explores speciic challenges and identiies

    aims, strategies, lead agencies, and potential part-

    ners or addressing them. However, assessments o

    country capabilities and needs by the UN Oce

    in West Arica did not commence until November

    2009 and only in Liberia and Sierra Leone. The

    assessments ound that many national agencies in

    Liberia were not even aware that the regional ac-

    tion plan existed.11 That said, the Liberian govern-

    ments collaborative work with U.S. authorities

    led to the extradition o several West Arican and

    South American nationals attempting to bribe

    Liberian ocials to acilitate large-scale cocaine

    transshipments in June 2010.

    Safeguard the Integrity of Counternarcotics

    Institutions. The eectiveness o a governments

    ability to marshal resources to prevent and deter

    threats is, at bottom, a unction o public integrity.

    Advanced training, new military equipment, and

    other capacity enhancements will have limited eecti institutions and public ocials remain corruptible.

    Institutional integrity at even the highest levels

    o government in Latin America has been compro-

    mised by the proceeds o narcotics tracking. Per-

    ceptions o a political-narcotracking nexus remain

    strong among citizens there, according to studies by

    the Organization o American States. Recognizing

    this, West Aricas leaders should vigorously imple-

    ment their regional action plans recommendation

    to target corruption among law enorcement and

    judicial personnel as a priority impediment to eec-

    tive counternarcotics eorts and strengthen oversight

    bodies, prosecute oending ocials, and train state

    institutions and civil society organizations to monitor

    and report corruption.

    Credible politicians and elections are also vital

    to public integrity. Accordingly, West Arican states

    should devise systems to properly restrict, audit, and,

    when appropriate, sanction political parties, politi-

    cians, and donors who engage in infuence peddling.

    A critical component o implementing such a system is

    developing the capacity, both within government and

    among watchdog groups, or orensic accounting so au-

    thorities can trace the intricate money trail involved.

    An immediate and simple reorm Arican states can

    take is to expand requirements or disclosure o politi-

    cal parties and candidates nancial inormation such

    as balance sheets and cash fow statements, measures

    that have gained widespread support among Latin

    Americas citizen groups and business community. This

    disclosure inormation should be updated regularly and

    made easily accessible so as to help expose suspicious

    accumulation o wealth to voters.

    Latin Americas experience also underscores

    the critical importance o protecting judicial insti-

    tutions. Until recently, Guatemalan criminal groups

    had extensive infuence within government agencies,

    which they exploited to protect their activities. Mur-

    ders o uncooperative law enorcement ocials were

    not uncommon. In response, Guatemalas legislature

    created an independent International Commission

    Against Impunity in Guatemala (CICIG), which in

    2007 was expanded through a partnership with the

    United Nations. The independent commission de-

    tailed jurists rom developed and developing countries

    to work with Guatemalan counterparts to devise legalreorms and protect jurists and judicial integrity. Sub-

    sequent reorms to the tax secretariat and penal code

    helped dismantle illegal groups and identiy sources

    o obstruction to good governance. As a result, 130

    individuals have been convicted and 2,000 police o-

    cers, an attorney general, and three supreme court

    justices have been dismissed. One ormer president

    has been indicted and another exonerated. Attitudes

    advanced training, new militaryequipment, and other capacity

    enhancements will have limitedeect i institutions and public

    ocials remain corruptible

  • 8/7/2019 Cocaine and Instability in Africa: Lessons from Latin America and the Caribbean

    7/8

    7

    have since changed and judges, prosecutors, and po-

    lice ocers in Guatemalas cities and countryside are

    now more able to do their jobs. The CICIG serves as

    a possible model in West Arica, whose legislatures

    should move to create and adequately empower simi-

    lar commissions partnered with international organi-

    zations such as the UN Oce on Drugs and Crime

    or the Inter-Governmental Action Group against

    Money Laundering in West Arica.

    Raise Transaction Costs. Tracking cocaine

    through West Arica is comparatively cheap. Make

    it expensive. Counternarcotics strategies need to o-

    cus on raising transaction costs. Arresting track-

    ers, prosecuting cases, tracking smuggling routes, and

    undertaking other counternarcotics operations are

    vital to stemming cocaine trac. Moreover, eorts

    that merely hinder the business o moving cocaine

    through West Arica make it more arduous, expen-

    sive, and unappealing to trackers. The more expen-

    sive it is, the less inclined cocaine trackers will be

    to use West Arica as a transit route.

    Operations that amount to no more than harass-

    ment have produced impressive results in the Carib-

    bean. From very low levels in 2000, annual cocaine

    seizures in the Netherlands Antilles reached 9 tons by

    2004. To counter rising trac, Antillean and Dutch

    airport security ocers stepped up searches o arriving

    and departing passengers. But, rather than arresting

    oenders (the low-level mules), police oered them

    the opportunity to cooperate. I mules were carrying

    less than 3 kilograms o drugs, they were not arrested

    but were returned to their point o origin and given

    receipts explaining the drug seizures so they would

    not ace retribution rom their employers. This tactic

    raised the cost o transporting drugs through the An-

    tilles. Meanwhile, the number o mules transiting the

    Netherlands Antilles dropped 96 percent.12

    Eorts to raise costs do not solely entail inter-diction. Nicaragua has had great success reducing

    the labor supply or cocaine tracking through its

    youth engagement strategy, which oers occupa-

    tional alternatives, specialized corrections programs,

    and rehabilitation or ormer gang members. The

    National Police also work with partners in govern-

    ment, the media, the private sector, and civil soci-

    ety to implement a Prevention o Juvenile Violence

    program. This initiative has stymied the expansion

    o Central Americas large transnational gangs,

    which play critical roles in transshipment. While

    gang members in Honduras, El Salvador, and Gua-

    temala number in the tens o thousands, Nicara-

    guas tally dropped rom 8,500 in 1999 to 4,500 by

    2008. Nicaraguas success comes despite its lower per

    capita income relative to its neighbors. Drug tra-

    cking is still a problem or Nicaragua, but a country

    with limited resources can apply novel approaches

    to hamper narcotics tracking.

    The corrosive inluence o narcotics traicking

    across Arica threatens to become institutionally en-

    trenched and poses severe and persistent security chal-

    lenges. Such has been the case in many parts o Latin

    America and the Caribbean, even where narcotics pro-

    duction and abuse have remained low. Applying these

    lessons will help Arica minimize the debilitating eects

    o this trade and the risks it poses to the continents

    recent governance, economic, and stability gains.

    N O T E S

    1 Alan Doig and Stephanie McIvor, National Integrity

    Systems Country Study Report: Jamaica 2003, Transparency In-

    ternational, 51.

    2 Im Not a Cocaine Baron, Daily Guide, April 21, 2010;

    Stephen Ellis, West Aricas International Drug Trade, African

    Affairs (2009), 192.

    3 Cocaine Smuggling Nigerian Politician Held in Lagos,

    BBC, May 17, 2010.

    4 Tanu Jalloh, Kemoh Sesay Sacked or Police to Arrest,

    Concord Times, August 5, 2008.

    5 For reports rom Benin, Ghana, and Nigeria, respectively:

    Screening Out Morally Unt Crime Fighters, UN Integrated

    Regional Information Network, October 29, 2008; Emmanuel Akli,

    MV Resurrected Benjamin Cocaine Aair, Ghanaian Chronicle,

    April 21, 2010; Idowu Sowunmi, Funding, Operational Problems

    Cripple NDLEA, This Day, November 28, 2009.

    6 William C. Prillaman, Crime, Democracy, and Develop-

    ment in Latin America, Center or Strategic and International

    Studies, June 2003, 15.

    tracking cocaine through WestArica is comparatively cheap

    make it expensive

  • 8/7/2019 Cocaine and Instability in Africa: Lessons from Latin America and the Caribbean

    8/8

    8

    7 World Bank, Crime, Violence, and Development: Trends, Costs, and Policy Options in the Caribbean, March 2007, i.

    8 UN Oce on Drugs and Crime, Security Council Debates Devastating Impact o Drug Tracking, December 9, 2009.

    9 Mike McGovern, Conronting Drug Tracking in West Arica, testimony beore the Subcommittee on Arican Aairs, U.S.

    Senate Committee on Foreign Relations, June 23, 2009. See also Ellis.

    10 World Bank, 33.

    11 Report o the Secretary General on the United Nations Oce or West Arica, UN Security Council, December 31, 2009, 11.

    12 World Bank, 98.

    The Africa Security Briefs series presents research and analysis

    by ACSS experts and outside scholars with the aim of advancingunderstanding of African security issues. The opinions, conclusions,

    and recommendations expressed or implied within are those of

    the contributors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the

    U.S. Department of Defense or any other agency of the Federal

    Government. For more information on ACSS, visit the Web site at

    http://www.africacenter.org.

    The Africa Center for Strategic Studies (ACSS) supports the

    development of U.S. strategic policy toward Africa by providing high-quality academic programs, undertaking policy-relevant research and

    analysis, and fostering awareness of and open dialogue on U.S. strategic

    priorities and African security issues. Toward these aims, the ACSS

    is committed to building networks of African, American, European,

    and international military and civilian leaders and articulating African

    perspectives to U.S. policymakers.

    AFRICA CENTER FOR STRATEGIC STUDIES

    AFRICAC

    ENTE

    RFORSTRATEGIC

    STUD

    IES

    CENTRED

    ETUDESSTRATEGIQU

    ESD

    ELAFRIQUE

    http://www.africacenter.org

    AFRICA CENTER FOR

    STRATEGIC STUDIES

    Director: Ambassador William

    M. Bellamy (Ret.)

    National Deense University

    300 Fith Avenue, Building 21Fort Lesley J. McNair

    Washington, DC 20319-5066

    Phone: + 1 202-685-7300

    Web site: www.aricacenter.org

    AFRICA CENTER

    REGIONAL OFFICE

    IN DAKAR

    Regional Manager:

    Elisabeth Feleke

    Phone: 221 33 869 61 00

    Email: [email protected]

    AFRICA CENTER

    REGIONAL OFFICE

    IN ADDIS ABABARegional Manager:

    Brad Anderson

    Phone: 251 11 517 4000

    Email: [email protected]

    AFRICA SECURITY BRIEFS

    Editor: Joseph Siegle, Ph.D.

    Phone: + 1 202-685-6808

    Email: [email protected]

    Arica Center or Strategic Studies

    Forthcoming titles

    Enhancing Civilian Protectionin Peace Operations: Insights

    from AfricaPaul D. WilliamsACSS Research Paper

    Democracy and the Chain ofCommandDominique DjindjrAfrica Security Brief

    African Infosystems: A Path toImproved Security and StabilitySteven LivingstonACSS Research Paper

    Recent titles

    Misinterpreting EthnicConicts in Africa

    Clement Mweyang AapengnuoAfrica Security Brief 4, April 2010

    Lessons Learned from PeaceOperations in AfricaPaul D. WilliamsAfrica Security Brief 3, April 2010

    Navies vs. Coast Guards:Dening the Roles of AfricanMaritime Security ForcesAugustus VogelAfrica Security Brief 2, December 2009