Climate Change and Peel Region.Adaptation to WHAT?

Shuttle Mission Topography/Elevation data

Neil Comer, Simon Eng, Heather Auld, Erik Sparling

TRCA logo???CC-RAI logo???

Weather: Conditions today and over the next few days; “operate day-to-day based on weather” Climate: Weather over time: Its Extremes, Trends, Changes; “plan on longer term based on climate”

Climate consists of:

• Average weather – now with new averages and trends

• Celebrity high impact storms, the “unusual”

January 12, 2013: High of 14.8C broke records from 1938-2012

Peel Region Climate and Weather Events

October 29, 2012: Remnants of Hurricane Sandy… “In Mississauga, 2,000 customers reported being without power.”

March 22, 2012: Toronto Pearson high temperature reaches 26.0 C; warmest March on record for many stations (Toronto Pearson & City)

Winter 2009-2010: warmest in Canada since nationwide records began in 1948 - 4.0°C above normal; Lake Ontario temperatures peak at 24C

July 21, 2011: Toronto Pearson Humidex exceeds 48; extreme at 50.3 in July, 1995

Peel Region Climate and Weather Events

October 29, 2012: Remnants of Hurricane Sandy… “In Mississauga, 2,000 customers reported being without power.”

March 22, 2012: Toronto Pearson high temperature reaches 26.0 C; warmest March on record for many stations (Toronto Pearson & City)

Winter 2009-2010: warmest in Canada since nationwide records began in 1948 - 4.0°C above normal; Lake Ontario temperatures peak at 24C

August 4, 2009: One hour rainfall from a Mississauga gauge exceeded 1 in 100 year event; flooding damages private properties, municipal and Peel Region infrastructureTornadoes in Peel Region: June 10 1979 & May 31, 1980, Brampton; July 7, 1985 Meadowvale; June 1923, Hornby to Long Branch; etc.

2007: Toronto Pearson experienced driest summer in nearly 50 years with 95 consecutive days without significant rainfall.Lake Ontario water levels down 0.25 metre from long-term average

Peel Region Climate and Weather Events

2009: tornado outbreaks; > 18 tornadoes; Vaughan tornado > $10M in damages; largest single-day tornado outbreak in Canadian history

2005: southern Ontario tornado outbreak Kitchener-Oshawa; Finch Ave washout; ~100mm/hour; highest insured loss in Ontario’s history

Winter, 2007-08: Pearson snow total 194 cm; 13 cm shy of record… Summer 2008: wettest June, July and August on record (396 mm).

January, 1999: Snowiest two-week period since 1846

Winter, 2001: 104 day stretch with snow on the ground; longest snowcover period in record (dating to 1840)Summer, 2001: Driest summer in 54 years of records (Pearson)

Peel Region Climate and Weather Events

2005: southern Ontario tornado outbreak Kitchener-Oshawa; Finch Ave washout; ~100mm/hour; highest insured loss in Ontario’s history

Climate variability and extremes…

May 12, 2000: Severe t-storms; “extensive damage” Port Credit Yacht Club, power outages Brampton and Mississauga

Tornadoes in Peel Region: June 10 1979 & May 31, 1980, Brampton; July 7, 1985 Meadowvale; June 1923, Hornby to Long Branch; etc.

7.37.7

8.8

Updated Climate Normals (Averages) indicate that Toronto Pearson Airport has warmed significantly …

YYZ Annual Mean Temperatures (Normals)1961-1990 7.3 C1971-2000 7.7 C1981-2010 8.8 C

Toronto’s Climate has been changing in many ways…

U.S. study: >75%of natural disasters are triggered directly or indirectly by weather and climate

Need to protect critical municipal assets & services – water, transportation, telecomm, buildings and shelters, electricity, energy

Why the concern over weather, climate and its changes?

hurricane

flood

heat

cold

windice storm

tornadolightning/thunderstorm

drought

Weather Hazards from the “Top 10” List: HIRA’s web-based and survey (226 municipalities)

blizzard/snowstorm

fog

41% of Ontario municipalities named power failures in their top 10 hazards63% municipalities in this region named power failure in the top 10 hazards

hail

Top 3 risks in Ontario municipalities

0102030405060708090

100%

mun

icpa

litie

s Weather

Non-weather Weather related

STRUCTURES Ice Storms and Wet Snow

Rainfall Intensity & Accum.

Extreme Winds

Summer Storms & Tornadoes

Extreme Snow

Power Lines & Transmission Structures

FAILURE ice + wind ADDITIVE FAILURE FAILURE SOME

Communication FAILUREice + wind ADDITIVE FAILURE FAILURE SOME

Buildings WET SNOW DRAINAGE & FAILURE FAILURE FAILURE FAILURE

Roads, Bridges OPERATION RISKS

DRAINAGE & EROSION

OPERATION& RISKS

FAILURE RISK OPERATION

Stormwater & Wastewater

POWER FAILURES

TOTAL FAILURE

POWER FAILURES FAILURE RISKS

Water Supply & Distribution

POWER FAILURES DROUGHT POWER

FAILUREPOWER FAILURE RISKS

Risks to Various Infrastructure Types from Increasing Climate/Weather Extremes (Frequencies/Intensities)

Structures Expected Lifecycle

Houses/Buildings Retrofit/alterations 15-20 yrsDemolition 50-100 yrs

Sewer Major upgrade 50 yr

Dams/Water Supply Refurbishment 20-30 yrsReconstruction 50 yrs

Bridges Maintenance annuallyResurface concrete 20-25 yrsReconstruction 50-100 yrs

Flexible adaptation options: Work with Infrastructure Lifecycles

“Tornado proofing”: Building Code &“tornado prone” regions

Confirmed and Probable Tornadoes by Fujita Scale – Revised and Updated Database (to 2009)

1960

1965

1970

1975

1980

1985

1990

1995

2000

2005

2010

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

South - Max/Mean/Min Temperature Trend

Southern Peel Region Temperature Trends

Average Highs

Average Lows

Daily Averages

Many implications for a changing climate…. Requiring adaptation

Climate Change and Peel Region.Adaptation to WHAT?

Shuttle Mission Topography/Elevation data

Neil Comer, Simon Eng, Heather Auld, Erik Sparling

Environment Canada Stations

Data Length

EC Intensity-Duration-Frequency Stations in the Area (extreme rainfall)

Environment Canada

Lightning Detection Network

(Proxy for extreme events?)

EC – Long Term Historical Climate Indices

- Other climate indices have also been calculated using this dataset

Temperature Stations

Precipitation Stations

19181922

19261930

19341938

19421946

19501954

19581962

19661970

19741978

19821986

19901994

19982002

20062010

73.5

74

74.5

75

75.5

76

Historical Lake Ontario Level (m) (IGLD 1985 Datum)

Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec74

74.2

74.4

74.6

74.8

75

75.2

75.4

75.6

Lake Ontario Monthly Average Level 1918-2011 (m)

Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec0.24

0.26

0.28

0.3

0.32

0.34

Lake Ontario Monthly Standard Dev (m)

Wave and Wind Statistics

- Also ice coverage, freezeup/breakup (erosion protection)- Also 2 buoys in western Lake Ontario (seasonal) (45139, 45159)

Historical Wind Frequency and Strength – Pearson A, Toronto Island A

For projections…• There have been a few local projects already:• 1.PRECIS – U Regina report for MOE• 2.Statistical downscaling (95 locations) for MOE• 3.WRF Regional Climate Model – (U of T) for MOE• 4.SENES Future Weather and climate driver Report for City of

TorontoGlobal models: 24 models in the last assessment (2007), but in the new assessment (2013) there are about 40 models available from which we can calculate an ensemble

Additional variables/indices can be calculated from model output (next slide)

27 PROJECTED Climate Change Core Indices (useful for this study?) :

1. FD, Number of frost days: Annual count of days when TN (daily minimum temperature) < 0oC2. SU, Number of summer days: Annual count of days when TX (daily maximum temperature) > 25oC.3. ID, Number of icing days: Annual count of days when TX (daily maximum temperature) < 0oC.4. TR, Number of tropical nights: Annual count of days when TN (daily minimum temperature) > 20oC.5. GSL, Growing season length: Annual (1st Jan to 31st Dec in Northern Hemisphere count between first span of at least 6 days with daily mean temperature TG>5oC and first span after July 1st of 6 days with TG<5oC. 6. TXx, Monthly maximum value of daily maximum temperature: 7. TNx, Monthly maximum value of daily minimum temperature: 8. TXn, Monthly minimum value of daily maximum temperature: 9. TNn, Monthly minimum value of daily minimum temperature: 10. TN10p, Percentage of days when TN < 10th percentile: 11. TX10p, Percentage of days when TX < 10th percentile: 12. TN90p, Percentage of days when TN > 90th percentile: 13. TX90p, Percentage of days when TX > 90th percentile: 14. WSDI, Warm spell duration index: Annual count of days with at least 6 consecutive days when TX > 90th percentile

15. CSDI, Cold spell duration index: Annual count of days with at least 6 consecutive days when TN < 10th percentile16. DTR, Daily temperature range: Monthly mean difference between TX and TN17. Rx1day, Monthly maximum 1-day precipitation:18. Rx5day, Monthly maximum consecutive 5-day precipitation:19. SDII Simple precipitation intensity index: the daily precipitation amount on wet days, (RR ≥ 1mm), divided by number of wet days.20. R10mm Annual count of days when PRCP≥ 10mm21. R20mm Annual count of days when PRCP≥ 20mm: 22. User defined PRCP threshold.23. CDD. Maximum length of dry spell, maximum number of consecutive days with RR < 1mm24. CWD. Maximum length of wet spell, maximum number of consecutive days with RR ≥ 1mm25. R95pTOT. Annual total PRCP when RR > 95p. 26. R99pTOT. Annual total PRCP when RR > 99p.27. PRCPTOT. Annual total precipitation

Example of Canadian Regional Model output variables (CANRCM4) from Env. Canada