Upload
sarah-burstein
View
217
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
1/85
P A U L
H A S T I N G S
1(202)551-1763
April 30, 2015
BY HAND DELIVERY
The Honorable
Lisa R.
Barton
Secretary
United States International Trade Commission
500
E
Street,
SW
Washington, DC 20436
CBI
IS P-^^
DOCKET
NUMBER
Office of th e
Secretary
Int'l Trade Commission
29172.00208
Re :
CERTAIN ELECTRIC SKIN
THEREFOR, AND KITS
(ITC Inv. No. 337-TA- )
CARE
DEVICES,
BRUSHES
AND
CHARGERS
CONTAINING
SAME
Dear Secretary Barton:
Enclosed for
filing
on behalf of Pacific
documents in supportof Complainant's request
pursuant to the provisions ofSection 337 of
Bioscience Laboratories, Inc. ( Complainant ) are the following
that the
Commission
commence an
investigation
Tariff Act of 1930,
as amended: J
he '
1. One original (unbound) and eight
2. One copy, on CD, of the Non
Confidential
Exhibit, to
th e
3.
One
copy, on CD, of the
materials submitted (Rules 201
(8)
copies of
the verified
Complaint
(Rulp
210.8(a)(1)(i));
Confidential
Exhibits,
including
public
versio'ns
of
the
Compaint
(Rule 210.8(a)(1)(i));
j
Confidential
Exhibit
tothe Complaint, segregated
from
other
and210.8(a)(1)(ii)); {
(c)
4.
One
physical sample of each
accused
product, as identified in the
Complaint;
5. Eighteen (18) additional paper
co;
pies
both non-confident ia l and
(Rules 210.8(a)(1)(iii) and 210.11
6. Five (5) additional paper copies
Embassies
of
Canada, China,
and
210.11(a)(1));
Certified copies
of
U.S. Patent Nbs
patent ) and D523.809 ( theD'809
the Complaint
as Exhibits 1-3 (R^ile
8. Certified copies ofthe assignments
copies
of the
assignments
are
210.12(a)(9)(H));
of the Complaint and accompanyingExhibits, on CDs,
confidential,
oneeach
for
service
upon
the
proposed Respondents
(a)(1));
J
if the non-confidential Complaint for service upon the
Isifael, Korea, and the
United
Kingdom
(Rules 210.8(a)(i)(iv)
. 7,320,691
( the
'691
patent ),
7,386,906 ( the '906
patent ). Legible copies ofthe patents are included with
210.12(a)(9)(i)); {
related to the '691, '906
and
D'809 patents. Legible
included with the Complaint as Exhibits4A-6 (Rule
Paul
Hastings
LLP I 875 15th
Street,
N.W. I Washington, DC 20005
t:
+1.202.551.1700
I www.paulhastings.com
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
2/85
P A U L
H A S T I N G S
The
Honorable Lisa R. Barton
April 30, 2015
Page
2
9. Acertified copy and three
(3)
additional
copies,
on CDs, ofthe
prosecution
histories ofthe
'691, '906 and D'809 patents along with any applicable reexamination
prosecution
histories.
Legible
copies
ofthe
prosecution histories
are
included with
the
Complaint
as
Appendices
A
B, D and F (Rule 210.12(c)(1));
10. Four (4)
copies, on
CD, ofeach technical reference mentioned
in
the
prosecution
of the '691,
'906 and
D'809. Legible copies
ofthe references are included with
the
Complaint as
Appendices C, E and G (Rule 210.12(c)(2));
11. A letter and certification concerning the confidentiality of Confidential
Exhibit
37 and
containing a request forconfidential treatmentof such document (Rules201 6(b) and
210.5(d)); and
12. Astatement ofpublic interest (Rule210.8(b)).
Thank you for your attention to this matter. Please contact me at the number
above
if you have any
questions.
If
Iam
not available, you
may
contact
Timothy
Cremen
at (202)
551-1838.
RMM:mrp
Enclosures
LEGALJJS E# 114713329.1
wigiv'wgn&aatgss
•?
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
3/85
P A U L
H A S T I N G S
1(202)551-1763
April 30,
2015
BY HAND DELIVERY
The Honorable Lisa R.
Barton
Secretary
United
States International
Trade
Commissioi)
500 E Street, SW
Washington, DC 20436
29172.00208
Re:
CERTAIN ELECTRIC SKIN
THEREFOR, AND KITS
(ITC Inv. No. 337-TA- )
CARE DEVICES,
BRUSHES
AND CHARGERS
CONTAINING
SAME
Dear Secretary
Barton:
I am
counsel
for Pacif ic
Bioscience
C.F.R. § 201.6, Complainant requests
Tariff Act, as amended, and attached to
Laboratores, Inc. (hereinafter Complainant ). In accordancewith 19
confidential treatment of Exhibit 37, filed under Section 337 of the
Complainant's
complaint. j
Confidential treatment is sought for Exhibit 37
relating to Complainant's proprietary and con
plantand equipment, laborand capital, and '
and U.S. Design Patent No. D523.809 inthe
because
it
contains
confidential
business
information
idential commercial information, including investment in
the exploitation ofU.S. Patent Nos. 7,320,691,
7,386,906
United
States.
|
in
The information
described
above qualifies
as
201.6(a)(1) in that:
1. It is not available to
the
public;
2. Unauthorized disclosure of such
position ofComplainant; and
confidential business information pursuant to Rule
information could
cause
substantial harm to the competitive
3. The disclosure of
this
information
necessary to perform its statutory
could impair the Commission's
ability
to
obtain information
functions.
Paul Hastings
LLP
I 875 15th Street,
N.W.
I Washington, DC20005
t:+1.202.551.1700 I
www.paulhast ings.com
*T^sraa*Wf)VKsS ''i&' 4>,u-*35lt
-W
^gM;m«M^Vfi'W 'v-»*'-'lJW''^ti*^''^w'''J''''T''i ': 'r
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
4/85
P A U L
H A S T I N G S
The Honorable
Lisa
R.
Barton
April 30, 2015
Page 2
Thank
you for your attention to this
matter.
Please do not hesitate
to
contact
me if
there are any
questions pertaining to this submission.
RMM:mrp
Enclosures
LEGAL_US_E # 114713462.1
^i-SPjSAgSZZfg&WFlfigsrT
Respectfully submitted,
Robert M. Masters
of
PAUL
HASTINGS
LLP
875 15th Street, NW
Washington, DC
20005
Attorney for Complainant Pacific Bioscience
Laboratories, Inc.
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
5/85
UNITED
STATES
INTERNATIONAL
TRADE
COMMISSION
WASHINGTON, D.C.
In the
Matter of:
CERTAIN ELECTRIC
SKIN CARE
DEVICES,
BRUSHES AND CHARGERS
THEREFOR,
AND
KITS
CONTAINING
SAME
Inv. No. 337-TA-
p t t r t Tr TNTEREST STATEMENT
Complainant Pacific Bioscience
Public Interest Statement concurrently
19 C.F.R. § 210.8(b).
First and foremost, the public i
rights by excluding infringing imports.
Escutcheons, andComponents Thereof,
LEXIS 494, at *18 (June 19, 2000). As
designed anddeveloped technology
andkits containing the same( Clarisonic
underthe mark Clarisonic. PBL obtained
trade dress, among other rights, to protecjt
the Clarisonic systemresulting in
intellectual property rights, including U
trade dress.
PBL
seeks, inter alia, a
g<
articles, anda ceaseanddesistorder
The
requested
relief, therefore, furthers
robustintellectual property regime.
Laboratories, Inc. ( PBL ) respectful }
submits this
wii;h
a Complaint
having
the above-caption,
pursuant
to
I:iv
se t
directed
.
n u m e r o u s
eneral
interest
favors the
protection
ofU.S.
intellectual property
(Pertain Two-Handle
Centerset Faucets
and
No.
337-TA-422, USITC Pub. 33b,
2000
ITC
I
s
forth
more fully in
the
Complaint, PBL created,
to skin
care
devices,
brushes and (chargers therefor,
f
I
' '
I
system ),
and
manufactures
and
sells such
technology
intellectual property rights in the fam ofpatents and
this technology. Respondents
have unlawfully
copied
and
ongoing
infringements of several ofPBL's
S.
Patent
Nos.
7,320,691, 7,386,906,
and
D523,809;
and
exclusion
order against
importations
of infringing
prohibiting
Respondents
from
importing
or selling the same.
;he public's
interest
in encouraging innovation
via
a
TTnrirwaj-uwM>^|ij.iM^wj^tMww«Wir;i; k%M^w
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
6/85
The public's
strong interest in protecting intellectual
property
is not outweighed
by
any
countervailing considerations. See Certain Battery-Powered Ride-On Toy Vehicles and
Components
Thereof,
Inv.
No. 337-TA-314,
Comm'n
Op. at 11 (Apr.
9,
1991) (stating that
exclusionary relief should only be denied when the adverse effect on the public interest would
be greater than
the interest in
protecting
the patent
holder ).
As discussed
below,
the
issuance
of
the requested
relief
would not
have
an adverse
effect
on public health
and
welfare, competitive
conditions in
the
United States economy, the
production of
like
or
directly competitive articles in
the United States, or United States consumers.
1) Explain how the articlespotentially subject to the orders areused in the United
States.
The infringing articles
in
this
matter
are hand-held electric skin
care
devices, generally
used
for the
cleansing
offacial skin and/or treatment of
acne, along
with brushes or brushheads,
and chargers
for
those
devices.
Auser operates such a device by activating amotorized
brushhead on the device, such
that
the brushhead moves and
when
placed
incontact with the
user's skineffects the facial skincleansing. The motionof the brushhead is intended to
cleanse
skin by
loosening the
adhesion ofsebaceous plugs inthe skin's
pores,
thereby
resolving
a root
cause
ofacne. The
brushhead
is also
effective
at cleansing
the
skin
and
removing any impurities
such as makeup.
Each
device is
battery-powered
and
is
sold with
a
complimentary charger that
plugs into a standard electrical outlet.
2)
Identify
any public health, safety, or
welfare concerns
intheUnited States relating
to
the requested remedial
orders.
The issuance of the requested relief will have
no
adverse impact upon the health, safety
or welfare
concerns
in
the
United
States.
To
the
contrary, itwill benefit public health,
safety,
or
welfare
by
removing
lesser-quality, knock-offproducts from the
marketplace.
PBL has devoted
significant sums ofits
annual revenues
to research
and development,
including
university-based
~^^ggg3gJWJffift}^a?Sfe'&*' = J) ^,V'K''M, 'Wl^'^.'^ililgll ,^j,y.»vut'iBi''
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
7/85
clinical studies, to ensurethat its Clarisonic
brushheads, andchargers are assafeand
while copying proprietary elements ofPB.
construction and design. On information
little
resources
onresearch anddevelopment
informed and believes that these accused
acne andcleansing skinthanthe proprietary
would,
therefore, further thepublic's interest
marketplace.
In addition, as discussed in more
from the United States marketplace, PBL
through its existing line ofClarisonic
market share ofits proprietary skin-cleanjsin
expanding
the
resources
that
PBL
could
effectiveproducts. In this manner,
furthers
the public interests of health,
In any event, the public willnot
health or welfare need. See Sponsion,
Cir.
2011) (noting that
theCommission
[w]ould
deprive
the public
of
products
The infringing products relate to the
each of which is a non-life-threatening
type
ofa
health issue
that outweighs
the
line of electricskin care devices, brushes and
effective as possible. Many
of
the accused products—
L's patents and trade dress—are ofinferior
and
belief,
Respondents
have
spent comparatively
of
safe
and
effective devices. Thujs, PBL is
t
Itroducts
are
less
effective
and/or
lessjsafe at treating
- -
Clarisonic
line ofproducts. The requested relief
I
in
having proven
effective and safe products inthe
Retail
below, should the
accused
products
be
excluded
can meet the demandfor electric skincaredevices
.
Moreover,
if PBLwereto enjoy its
rightful
i
[
g
systems,
revenues would
increase, thereby
devote
to
further research and development more
i
gthe public's interest in encouraging innovation
also
• . . I
and
welfare.
products
affirmin
safety
be
any important
eprived
ofproducts necessary for
•
v.
Int'l
Trade
Comm'n,
629 F.3d 1331,1360 (Fed.
las only denied an exclusion
order
when the order
necessary for
some
important health
or welfare need ).
' ' i
i.
cleansing ofskin and in
some cases
a treatment for
acne,
aW
largely cosmetic skin condition and which is not
the
[
public's interest in protecting intellectual
property
and
Inc.
•^yp^^s^^WTTTW^WP^^^^^
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
8/85
encouraging innovation. Moreover, as discussed in more detail below, the requested
relief will
not
deprive
the
public oftreatment options,
at least
because (i)
PBL
anticipates
that it can meet
the demand
for any
excluded
products; and
(ii) consumers have a
variety
of
commercial
alternatives for the treatment
of
acne. . ,
3) Identify like
ordirectly competitive
articles that
complainant,
its licensees, or third
parties
make
which
could
replace
the subject
articles
if they
were
to be
excluded.
The infringing articles constitute
unlawful
copies ofPBL's proprietary Clarisonic line of
hand-held
electric skin care
devices. Thus, the Clarisonic line ofproducts can replace the
subject
infringing
articles if
they were
tobe
excluded, raising
no
public interest concerns. See
Certain
Lens-Fitted
Film
Packages
( LFFPs ), Inv.
No.
337-TA-406, Comm'n Op., 1999 ITC LEXIS
202 at
*39-40
(June 28, 1999)(finding no
public
interest concerns
when
there
was
no
evidence
that the demand for the products
at-issue could
not be supplied by the
complainant,
and
reasoning that
[t]he fact
that
some
retailers and consumers may have to pay ahigher price for
the [products] does
not
justify a
determination
that the public interest inprotecting intellectual
property rights is in any way outweighed ).
In
addition,
the public has avariety ofalternatives
when
itcomes to
facial
cleansing and
treating
acne. These alternatives include, for
example,
manual cleansing with soap,
topical
creams and ointments, and orally-administered medications.
The
presence ofan adequate supply
ofsubstitute
products,
while not necessarily as
convenient
or
effective
as the Clarisonic
system,
is sufficient to override anypublic interestconcerns.
4)
Indicate
whether
the complainant, its
licensees,
and/or third
parties have the
capacity to replace the volume of articles subject to the requested remedialorders in
a commercially
reasonable
time in
the United States.
PBL
has the capacity to replace the volume ofinfringing articles subject to
the
requested
remedial orders
in
a commercially reasonable time in the United States.
PBL
developed the
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
9/85
market
for
the technology-at issue, and ha^
demand. PBL's manufacturing facility in
components
of the
Clarisonic system
in
PBL
believes that
with
current
replace the volume of
articles
subject to
5) State how
the
requested remedial
As
discussed above,
the
issuance
desist order in this investigation will not
be
replaced
byPBL's
Clarisonic
line
o
effective. In addition, a variety of
treatacne, suchasmanual cleansing with
administered medications. The issuance
encouraging innovation,
which
could
the resources andthe motivation to
keep
up
with
Redmond, WA has the
equipment required to produce
volume.
r e s o u r c e s
the
in a commercially reasonable time, it can
requested remedial orders.
orders
would impact
consumers.
o|f
the requested general exclusion order
and cease and
j
adversely impact consumers. Any excluded
articles
can
,
which
are
thoroughly tested
tobe
safe and
products
are available
for facial cleansing and to
soap, topical creams
and
ointments, and orally-
of
the requested
relief
furthers the public's interest
in
result in newer, better products for consumers.
f products,
' alternative
gwnfflff^TO^^^^ f^'Sft Mr™ '^ n -
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
10/85
Dated: April 30, 2015
^wmtrnmrnw?***
Respectfully submitted,
Attorneysfor Complainant
Pacific Bioscience Laboratories,
Inc.
Rober t M . Mast er s
Timothy P.
Cremen
PAUL HASTINGS LLP
875 15th St
NW
Washington, D.C. 20005
Tel: (202)551-1700
Fax:
(202)551-1705
Robert L.
Sherman
Natalie G.
Furman
PAUL HASTINGS
LLP
75
East 55t h Street
New York, NY
10022
Tel: (212)318-6000
Fax: (212)318-6847
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
11/85
UNITED STATES
INTERNATIONAL
TRADE
COMMISS ION
WASHINGTON,
D.C.
In th e
Matter
of:
CERTAIN ELECTRIC
S KIN C ARE
DEVICES, BRUSHES AND CHARGERS
THEREFOR,
AND
KITS
CONTAINING
S AME
Inv . N o . 337-
COMPLAINT
OF THE TARIFF
UNDER SECT ION
337
ACT OF 1930,
AS
AMENDED
Complainant:
PACIFIC
BIOSCIENCE
LABORATORIES,
INC.
17275 N E 67th Cour t
Redmond, WA 98052
(425)
285-1711
Counsel for Complainant:
Rober t M. Masters
Timothy P. Cremen
PAUL
HASTINGS
LLP
87 5
15th
St
NW
Washington,D.C. 20005
Tel:
(202)
551-1700
Fax: (202) 551-1705
Robert
L.
Sherman
Natalie
G.
Furman
PAUL
HASTINGS
LLP
75
East
55th Street
New
York, NY 10022
Tel: (212)318-6000
Fax: (212) 319-4090
Proposed Respondents:
OUR
FAMILYJEWELS, INC.
d/b/a Epipiir Skincare
10226
S.
Dransfeldt
Road
Parker,
CO
80134
ACCORD MEDIA, LLC
d/b/a Truth in Aging
241 West 36th Street, Apt. 16
New York, NY 10018
XNOVT
ELECTRONIC CO., LTD.
Room
915, GuanLiDa Mansion;
Qianjin 1st Road •
Zone
30 Bao'An; Shenzhen, China
MICHAEL TODD TRUE ORGANICS LP
648 SW
Port St. Lucie
Blvd.
j
Port
St.
Lucie,
FL 34953-1947 {
MTTO LLC
648 SW Port St. Lucie Blvd.
Port
St. Lucie,
FL
34953-1947
SHANGHAI
ANZIKANG
ELECTRIC
CO,
LTD .
168 JiXinRoad,
Building
3,Room 401
MinhangDistrict,Shanghai, China
NUTRA-LUXE M.D, LLC
j
6835 International Center
Blvdl
Unit
5
Fort Myers, FL 33912 i
SPIS'-w^W
way-iM'W%
vWU^'fii'/'''M ifl V
mK?5-^ajf^••^j«=w^-
k
i -w
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
12/85
v bm^@m&wv&
BEAUTYTECH, INC.
1430S.DixieHwy, Ste.321
Coral Gables, FL 33146-3175
ANEX CORPORATION
C-304 Seoul Hightech Venture Center,
647-26
Deungchon-dong,
Gangseo-ku, Seoul,
157-030,
Korea
RN VENTURES LTD.
Francis House, 10 Francis Street
London
SW1P
IDE, United Kingdom
KOREAN BEAUTY
CO,
LTD.
10F, PluszoneBldg700
Deungchon-Dong,
Gangseo-Gu
Seoul,
Korea
H2PRO BEAUTYLIFE, INC.
1043 SegoviaCir.
Placentia, CA 92870-7137
SERIOUS SKIN CARE, INC.
112 N.Curry St.
Carson
City,
NV 89703-4934
HOME
SKINOVATIONS
INC.
lOOLeekCrescent Unit 15
Richmond
Hill,
ON
L4B
3E6,
Canada
HOME SKINOVATIONS LTD.
Tavor Building, ShaarYokneam
Yokneam, 20692, Israel
WENZHOU
AI
ER
ELECTRICAL
TECHNOLOGY
CO,
LTD
d/b/a
CNAIER
1#,
XiaSong
Road, WanQuan
Town, PingYang,
Zhejiang, China
COREANA COSMETICS CO, LTD.
204-1
Jeongchon-ri,
Seonggeo-eup,
Seobuk-gu
Cheonan-si, Chungcheongnam-do, Korea
FLAGEOLI CLASSIC LIMITED
7310 Smoke Ranch Road
Las Vegas,NV 89128
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
13/85
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I .
II .
INTRODUCT ION .
TH E PARTIES .
A. The Complainant PBL
B. Proposed Respondents
1. Our FamilyJewels.
2. Accord Media
3.
Xnovi
4. MTTO LP and
MTtO
LLC .
5. Anzikang
6. NutraLuxe
7.
Beauty
Tech, Inc.
d/fb/a
5th
Avenue
Buzz.
8. ANEXCorp
9.
RN Ventures Ltd..
10. Korean Beauty
11.
H2P ro
12 . Serious Skin
Care.
13. Fkgeoli
14 . Home Skinovations.
15.
CNAIER
16.
Coreana
III.
THE
TECHNOLOGY
AND
PRODUCTS
A. Description of theTechnology
B. Background Information
1. Conventional
2. The
Innovative
on
.
Treatment
IV . THE PATENTS-IN-SUIT..
A.
B.
C.
The '691
Patent
1. Identification
o f
the
2. Non-Technical Desc
3. Foreign Counterparts
The ' 9 06 Patent
1. Identification of
th i
2. Non-Technical
Descr:
3. Foreign Counterparts
T h e D '8 0 9 P ate nt
1. Identification of
th e
2. Non-Technical DescriptL
3. Foreign Counterparts
Page
.7
.7
,7
...9
10
11
13
14
15
.16
.17
.1 7
.1 8
.19
.2 0
.2 1
.2 2
AT ISSUE 1 23
i
at
Issue '
23
the Products and
Processes at Issue ...J. 23
of Acne
> 24
Claiisonic System . 24
27
,28
Patent and PBL's Interest Therein 28
ription ofthePatented Invention t
29
29
30
Patentand
Ownership
byPBL
}...
30
iption of the Patented Invention
[. 31
P (
31
J 32
Patent
and Ownership by PBL J 32
on of
the
Patented
Invention I. 33
33
.-5^-*™^-—jT^t^jTTSETB^r^ rr-^PT^rT^^^^^^r^^T^^^Tp^^^^n
teff̂ ^ZW'^~' $J
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
14/85
TABLE
OF CONTENTS
(continued)
Page
V. THE TRADE DRESS 33
VI.
LICENSES
: ...; _ 38
VII. UNLAWFUL AND UNFAIR
ACTS
OF RESPONDENTS 39
A.
Infringement ofthe
'691
Patent
39
B.
Infringement
of the '906 Patent 42
C. Infringement
of
the D'809
Patent
44
D. Trade Dress Infringement
45
VIII. SPECIFIC INSTANCES OF SALE
AND
IMPORTATION
47
EX
RELATED
LITIGATION
50
A.
NutraLuxe Litigation (Western
District ofWashington)
50
B. Litigation inChina 59
C. Litigation inGreat Britain 53
D. Contemporaneous Litigation
in the
Western District of
Washington
53
X .
HARMONIZED TARIFF
SCHEDULE
53
XI.
DOMESTIC
INDUSTRY
53
A. Technical Prong
54
B.
Economic
Prong—Significant Investment
in
Plant,
Equipment, Labor,
and
Capital _
rr
C.
Economic Prong—Substantial Investment
in the Exploitation
of
PBL's
Patented
Technologies .
56
D. Injury
to
Domestic Industry
5g
XII. GENERAL EXCLUSION
ORDER
60
XIII.
RELIEF
:
61
-11-
-w~m,. „„»-„ ,. .„, -»», ,- .. .. ,, .„ „. , .. „ .. ., ,_„. ,„ .„ ,, ,, ..
-^,.„, ,_-...,.,„„.,—^ww«>njBWI >Wi^»WlWMIIlllMIMWW»Ml*Mi«
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
15/85
Exh ib i t No .
4A
4B
5A
5B
7A
7B
7C
7D
7E
7F
7G
7H
71
7J
DOCUMENTARY EXHIBITS
Description
Certified
copy
of
U.S.
Patent
No.
7,320,691
( the
'691
patent
Certified
copy
of
U.S.
Patent
No. 7,386,906
( the '906 patent )
Certified
copy of
U.S.
Patent
No. D523,809 ( the D'809 patent )
j
Certified copy of the ass.
inventors
to Pacific
ignment
papers for U.S.
Patent
No. 7,320,691 from
the
Laboratories, Inc. ( PBL ) |
ioscience
Certified copy of
the
assignment for U.S. Patent No. 7,320,691
from PBL to
L'Oreal S.A.
Certified copy of the
assignment
for
U.S. Patent No. 7,386,906 from
the
inventors
to P BL
Certified copy of
the
assignment for
U.S.
Patent No. 7,386,906 from PBL
to
L'Oreal
S.A.
nment for U.S. Patent No. D523,809 from the inventors
Certifiedcopyof the assigi
to P BL
Declaration of
Lilac Muller
in Supportof Complaint
Photographs,
Receipt, ^nd Physical
Exhibit
from Purchase of
Our Family
Jewels'Episonic
Photographs,
Receipt, Jmd
Physical Exhibit from Purchase ofAccord
Media's
UltraClear
Photographs, Receipt, ^nd Physical
Exhibit
from
Purchase ofXnovi's
Lemonsonic
Photographs, Receipt,
jmd Physical
Exhibit
from
Purchase
of
MTTO's
Soniclear
Photographs, Receipt,
md
Physical Exhibit
from
Purchase
of
Anzikang's Dione
Photographs, Receipt,
NutraSonic 4-Speed
and Physical
Exhibit
from Purchase
ofNutraLuxe's
Photographs,Receipt,
NutraSonic Travel
Photographs, Receipt,
Buzz's
NuSonic
Photographs, Receipt,
Photographs, Receipt,
and Physical
Exhibit
from Purchase
of
NutraLuxe's
and
Physical Exhibit from Purchase of5th
Avenue
and Physical Exhibit
from Purchase
ofANEX's Mimian
and Physical Exhibit
from
Purchase ofRN Ventures'
- l i i -
e*rmrwexa*m*s'>*>r-r*™r™r*>*™*TV
^W ' ^ ^ ggWg tWTW^
»«ei»- •*»--•- •
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
16/85
Exhib i t No .
7K
7L
7M
7N
7 0
7P
8A
8B
8C
8D
9A
9B
9C
9D
9E
10A
10B
11A
Description
Magnitone Pulsar
Photographs, Receipt, and Physical Exhibit from Purchase ofKorean
Beauty
Photographs,
Receipt, and
Physical
Exhibit
from
Purchase ofH2Pro's Eve
Photographs,
Receipt, and Physical Exhibit from Purchase ofCoreana's 4D
Mot ion .
Photographs, Receipt,
and Physical
Exhibit
from Purchase of Serious
Skin
Care's / Flageoli's Beauty Buzz
Photographs, Receipt, and Physical Exhibit from
Purchase
of
Home
Skinovations'
Silk'n
Sonic
Photographs,
Receipt,
and Physical Exhibit from Purchase of
CNAIER
Printout
of the
Episonic
Word
Mark
from
the
Trademark Electronic
Search
System (TESS) available at
http://tmsearch.uspto.gov/
(last
accessed
Jan.
13,
2015)
Prmtoutfromhltp://www.epipurskincare.com/products/episonic-facial-cleansing-
system.html
(last
accessed Jan. 9, 2015)
Printout from http://www.amazon.com/Episonic-Facial-Cleansing-Brush-
System/dp/BOOFWZRCGS/ (last
accessed July
16, 2014)
Printout from http://centralops.net/co/DomainDossier.aspx
for
epipurskincare.com (last
accessed Mar.
12,
2015)
Printout
from
https://www.tmthinaging.com/terms
(last
accessed
Dec.
2, 2014)
Printout from http://www.truthinaging.com/review/ultra-renew-clear-our-new-
power-cleansing-brush (last accessed Jan.
9,
2015)
'
Printout from
http://www.truthinaging.com/ultra-clear-replacement-brush-heads
(last
accessed
Jan. 9,2015)
Printout from http://www.amazon.com/Ultra-Clear-Facial-Cleansing-
System/dp/B00DMHKG2K/
(last
accessed
July 16, 2014)
Printout from https://www.ttutlimaging.com/about (last accessed
Mar.
13,
2015)
Printout
from http://www.amazon.com/Lemon-Sonic-Cleansing-Svstem-
White/dp/B00DCMDYK6
(last accessed
Dec.
2, 2014)
Printout from http://www.amazon.com/Lemon-Sonic-Cleansing-System-
Replacement/dp/B00I505TPI/ (last
accessed
Dec. 2, 2014)
Printout from http://www.michaeltoddusa.com/somclear-antirnicrobial-deansme-
system/soniclear.html (last
accessed Jan.
9,
2015)
- I V -
?^^5, '9^'3®£&'r S33*Kra '^^
vmw&st&w ' 9G&pa$ir?m>*
^•jtBIS^^B
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
17/85
Exh ib i t N o .
11B
11C
11D
12
13A
13B
13C
13D
14A
14B
14C
15A
15B
15C
15D
15E
16A
16B
Description
fmazon.com/Soniclear-Anti-microbial-Skin-Cleansing-
/'dast
accessed Jan. 9, 2015)
{
Printout from http://www.
System/dp/BOOMNNGRL
Printout
from
http://searcrj.sunbiz.org/
for
MTTO
LLC
(last
accessed
Mar. 13,
2015)
Printout from http://searcLsunbiz.org/
for
MichaelTodd True Organics LP
(last
accessed Mar. 13,2015)
c|enter/anzikang-electric-facial-body-brus;h-spa-deaning-
;ift-packing-pink/ (last accessed Dec.
2,12014)
Printout from http://acne.
system-electric-waterproof-:
Printout from http://www.
Printout from http://www.
Cleansing/dp/B002RZKFAQ/
nutrasonic.com/contact-us/ (lastaccessed Dec. 2, 2014)
amazon.com/Nutra-Sonic-1020-Professional-
dast accessed Dec. 2, 2014) [
amazon.com/Nutra-Sonic-0046-Compahion-
G6/ (last accessed Dec.2,2014)
Printout from http://www.
Professional/dp/B004UO
•TV'
Printout from http://search.sunbiz.org/ for Nutra-Luxe M.D,LLC (last
accessed Mar. 13,2015)
Printout from http://www.
accessed Nov. 27, 2014)
5thavenuebuzz.com/shop/devices/test]hgv.html
(last
Printout from http://www.
Avenue/dp/B00J7U9ZVE
amazon.com/SONIC-CLEANSING-SYSTEM-5th-
(last accessed Nov. 27,
2014) |
Printout
from
http://searcji.sunbiz.org/
for
Beautytech,
Inc.
(last
accessed
Mar.
13, 2015)
;clariancy.com/pdf/mimian/mimian_catalog.pdf
(last
rintout from http://www
accessed Dec. 2, 2014)
.amazon.com/Mimian-Beauty-Portable-Cleanser-
dast accessed Nov. 27, 2014) ;
Printout fromhttp://www
Facial/dp/B00JSQ5ZG6/
Printout from http://anexcorp.com/ (last accessed Apr. 24, 2015)
j
Printout
from http://anex^orp.com/eng/02_sub/02_sub.html (last
accessed
Apr.
24,2015)
Printout from http://anexcorp.com/jap/ (last accessed Apr. 27,
2015)
Printout
from https://magbitone.co.uk/shop/magnitone-pulsar/ (last accessed
Nov. 27,2014)
;.lookfantastic.com/magnitone-pulsar-daily-skin-
exfoliation-brush-for-face-and-body/10858382.html(last
Printout fromhttp://www
cleansing-toning-and
accessed Nov. 27, 2014)
g}T7-'-g»'WF*'.l't»>frft • ' '**-> »»*
ff
-*^ ' ~n »-.*•
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
18/85
Exhib i t
N o .
16C
16D
17A
17B
18A
18B
18C
19A
19B
19C
19D
19E
19F
20A
20B
20C
20D
Description
Manual from
https://magnitone.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/
MagnitonePulsarMP009Manual.pdf
(last accessed
Mar. 13, 2015)
Printout
from
https://www.magnitone.co.uk/terms-and-conditions/
(last
accessed
Mar. 13, 2015)
Printout from http://www.amazon.com/Korean-Beauty-Cleansing-Foundation-
Batteries/dp/B00HMHI3AS
(last accessed
Nov.
27, 2014)
Pr in tou t f rom
ht1p://omniko.gobizkorea.com/catalog/mc/down.jsp?f£e_path=/att/cat/omniko
/&file_nm=korean+beauty+4d+motion+cleanser.pdf
(last accessed
Mar. 13, 2015)
Printout from http://www.amazon.com/Micro-Sonic-Care-Brush-
Motion/dp/B00FAX7KXM/ (last accessed
Nov.
27,
2014)
Printout
from
http://h2probeauty]ife.com/05/?page_id=196
(last accessed
Mar.
13, 2015)
Printout from
http://h2probeautyHfe.com/5th/subpages/00aboutus/aboutus.html
(last
accessed
Mar. 13,2015)
Printout from http://www.amazon.com/Sefious-Skincare-Sonic-Clean-
System/dp/B00B91S40W7 (last
accessed
Nov. 27, 2014)
Printout
from
http://www.seriousskincare.com/product_p/150571.htm
(last
accessed Nov. 27,2014)
Printout from
http://www.seriousskincare.com/product_p/
bbnormalbrushhead2.htm
(last
accessed
Nov.
25,
2014)
Printout
from
http://wvvAv.seriousskincare.com/prdduct_p/175898.hm'i (last
accessedNov. 25,2014)
Printout
from
http://nvsos.gov/sosentitysearch/CorpDetails.aspx?lx8nvq=
)J01tjaSh0oiEKVRSRMqEA%253d%253d&nt7=0
(last
accessed Mar. 13, 2015)
Printout
from http://www.bbb.org/losangelessiliconvalley/business-reviews /not-
elsewhere-classified/serious-skin-care-in-los-angeles-ca-100027036
Oast accessed
Mar. 13, 2015)
Printout
from
https://www.silkn.com/contacts/ (last accessed Dec. 2. 2014)
Printout from https://www.silkn.com/somc-clean-prus/ (last accessed Nov
27
2014)
Printout
from
http://www.amazon.com/Silkn-SonicCleanPlus-Cleansmg-Sensitive-
Silicone/dp/B00O84208Y/ (last accessed Nov. 27, 2014)
Printout from https://www.silkn.com/about/
(last accessed
Mar.
13,
2015)
- V I -
- '^ f f^Wg^l^^i l l^WSBH
^^wj^^sts^Bis^^^ssswse^
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
19/85
Exh ib i t N o .
20E
21A
21B
21C
21D
22A
22B
23A
23B
23C
24
25
26
27
27A
27B
27C
27D
27E
27F
27G
27H
Description
Printout from
http://centralops.net/co/DomainDossier.aspx
for www.silkn.com
(last
accessed
Mar.
16,2015)
.amazon.com/Cnaier-Electric-Waterproof-Cleansing-
dast accessedJan. 9, 2015)
Printout from http://www.
Massager/dp/B00NDW20t4/
Printout fromhttp://www
beauty-mstrument/1990793J77
2014)
,dhgate.com/product/ultrasonic-deansing-instrument-
.html#sl-18-l
13711470265 (last
accessed Nov.29,
Printout
from
http://www.chinaaier.com/en/
(last accessed Mar. 13, 2015)
Printout from htto://centealops.net/co/DomainDossier.aspx for j
www.chinaaier.com (last fccessed Mar. 16,2015)
amazon.com/Coreana-Senite-Motion-C
(last accessed
Nov. 27,
2014)
Printout from http://www.
Korean/dp/B00H4HGR0Y
eanser-
coreana.com/eng/main/main.asp
(last accessed
Mar,
rintout from http://www.
13,2015)
Printout from http:
4808:vt8qa9.2.2 for The
//tmsealrch.uspto.gov/bin/showfield?f-doc&sfate-
Bsauty Buzz (last accessed Mar.
13,
2015)
.gov/sosentitysearch/CorpSearch.aspx
(last accessed
rintout from http://nvsos
Mar. 13, 2015)
Printout from http://nvso6
8NLTQnMaYsXahC9WBpQ'
.gov/sosentitysearch/CorpDetails.aspx?lx8nvq-Mkg
•%253d%253d&nt7=0# (last accessed Mar. 13, 2015)
Photographs
and Physical
Exhibit ofPBL's
Clarisonic
Plus
Photographs
and Physical
Exhibit
of
PBL's
Clarisonic
Pro
Photographs and Physical
Exhibit of
PBL's Clarisonic Aria (Mia 3)
Claim Charts
in Support
of:Complaint
Claim
Chart
Showing
Infringement
by
Episonic
ofthe
'691 Patent
Claim
Chart
Showing Iafringement by
UltraClear ofthe
'691 Patent
Claim Chart Showing
Infringement
byLemonsonic of the '691 patent
Claim
Chart
Showing
Infringement
bySonidear ofthe
'691
Patent
Claim
Chart
Showing
Infringement
byDioneof the
'691
Patent
Claim Chart Showing Infringement by NutraSonic 4-Speed
of
the '691 Patent
Claim Chart Showing Infringement
by
NutraSonic Travel
of
thfe '691 Patent
Claim Chart Showing Infringement
by
NuSonic
of
the '691
Patent
-vli-
^Z&zzs T - ^w ^T p ^n s s ^ ^ r ^PT i ^ ^ ^
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
20/85
Exhib i t
N o .
27 1
27J
27K
27L
27M
27N
2 7 0
27P
27Q
27R
27S
27T
27U
27V
27W
27X
27Y
27Z
27AA
27BB
27CC
2 7DD
27EE
27FF
27GG
28A
28B
«* Jnf
Description
Claim Chart Showing
Infringement by
Mimian
of the
'691
Patent
Claim
Chart
Showing
Infringement
byMagnitone
Pulsar
ofthe
'691 Patent
Claim Chart Showing Infringement
by
Korean Beauty of
the '691
Patent
Claim
ChartShowing Infringement byEveof the'691 Patent
Claim Chart Showing Infringement by
Beauty
Buzz ofthe '691 Patent
Claim
Chart
Showing
Infringement by
Silk'n Sonic
of the
'691
Patent
Claim
Chart Showing Infringement
by
CNAIER
of the
'691 Patent
Claim Chart Showing Infringement byCoreana 4DMotion of the '691 Patent
Claim
Chart
Showing Infringement by
Episonic
of the '906 Patent
Claim ChartShowing Infringement byUltraclear of the
'906
Patent
Claim
Chart
Showing Infringement by
Lemonsonic
of the
'906
Patent
Claim Chart Showing Infringement byDioneof the
'906
Patent
Claim ChartShowing Infringement byMimian of the '906Patent
Claim
Chart Showing Infringement
by
Coreana
4D
Motion
of the
'906 Patent
Claim
Chart
Showing Infringement byEpisonic of the
D'809
Patent
Claim Chart Showing
Infringement by
UltraClear
of the
D'809
Patent
Claim
Chart
Showing
Infringement byDioneof the
D'809
Patent
Claim
Chart
Showing
Infringement by NutraSonic 4-Speed of the
D'809
Patent
Claim ChartShowing Infringement byNuSonic of theD'809 Patent
Claim Chart
Showing
Infringement
byMagnitone Pulsar oftheD'809
Patent
Claim Chart
Showing
Infringement by
Beauty Buzz ofthe
D'809 Patent
Domestic industry claim chartfor
U.S.
PatentNo. 7,320,691
Domestic industry
claim
chart
for
U.S.
PatentNo. 7,386,906
Domestic industry
claim
chart
for
U.S.
PatentNo.
D523,809
Claim
Chart Showing Infringement
by
CNAIER
of
the'906
Patent
Technology Agreement between L'Oreal
and
L'Oreal USA,
Inc., dated
January 1, 2012
Amendment Agreement,
effective
February 15, 2012
-V111-
g y,Hi.JWHJ B ,M' •-^ ^aJi', tfLM^ggB^
HW
W ^^ - ' A - S - T iw ^ ^ a ^ ^
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
21/85
Exh ib i t
N o .
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
Description
Clarisonic Technology Agreement between
L'Oreal
and PBL, dajted
February
15, 2012 '
Case No. 2:10-cv-00230
Dkt. No. 1 - Complaint.
, Dkt. No. 65 - Amended Complaint
ase No.
2:10-cv-00230
Case No. 2:10-cv-00230
Dkt. No. 98 - Order
on
Claim Construction
Case No. 2:10-cv-00230,Dkt. No. 228—Jury's Verdict Form
Case No. 2:10-cv-0023Q:
Modifythe Stipulated
, Dkt. No. 257—OrderGrantingJoint Motionto
Permanent Injunction f
Civil
Complaints
filed
in China
Claim
Form
filed
in
the
Intellectual
Property
Enterprise
Court
J
Declaration of Robert Hennessy in Support of Complaint
- I X -
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
22/85
'l^^'SM^min^mv^
APPEND ICES
As
required
by
19 C.F.R. §210.12(c), a certified copy ofeach of the prosecution histories of the
patents-at-issue, including the references cited
therein, is
submitted
in
the
following appendices.
Appendix No.
App.
A
App.
B
App.
C
App.
D
App.
E
App.
F
App.
G
l***ne%&&*SZggm8&eXmWr
Description
Certified copyof the
file
historyof
U.S.
PatentNo. 7,320,691
Certifiedcopyof the file histories of the reexaminations of U.S.Patent No.
7,320,691
Eachdocument of recordin the file history and
reexaminations
of the '691
patent
Certified
copy
of the file history of U.S. PatentNo.
7,386,906
Eachdocument of record inthe
'906
patent
file
history
Certified
copy
of the file history of U.S. PatentNo.D523,809
Each document of
record
in the D'809 patent
file
history
-x -
WFWR^TS-^^^^1
i^y m^w^i
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
23/85
I. INTRODUCT ION
1. ComplainantPacific
violation of Section
337 of th e TariffAct of
respectfully requests that the United States
investigation andgrant reliefto remedy the
importation into theUnited States, and/or
owner,importer or consigneeof certain
and kitscontainingsame, that infringePBL
described
below.
2. L'Oreal S.A, together with L
cosmetics and beauty company and,has built
knownbrands in the personal careand
Lancome, Maybelline, Garnier,Kiehl's, Skin
amongothers. In 2011, L'Oreal acquired
portfolio.
3. Since the early2000s,PBL
soldin the United
States
(andworldwide) its
Clarisonic System ), whichis a lineof
skin
devices,brushes and related accessories, the
treatment solutions. Examples of
Clarisonic
^^FS^^^^S^^^^BS^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
;
Bioscience
Laboratories,Inc. ( PBL ) files this Complaintfor
1930,as amended, 19
U.S.C.
§ 1337 ( Section337 ) and
Ihternational Trade Commission ( ITC ) institute an
•unlawful importationinto theUnitedStates, the
sale
for
salewithin the United States after importation, by the
s
1
ic skin care devices, brushes and chargers therefor,
United States patents
and
trade dress
id the
manner
d ie
electric
. related
,'Oreal USA, Inc., ( L'Oreal ) is the world's largest
an unrivaledportfolio of someof the world's best
i
fields,
including
without
limitation, Lpreal Paris,
I
Ceuticals,La Roche-Posay, Matrix and Yves St.Laurent,
f.
further adding value and
prestige
to fhe
L'Oreal
BL
has
designed,
developed,
manufactured,
marketed,
and
innovativeClarisonicSonicSkinCleansing System(the
i
care products
that include a
number
of sonic
cleansing
I
Clarisonic Opal®
Sonic Infusion System, and
targeted
products arepictured
below:
v^ ^>^B£'2I* [ ̂ &$' S^ ^ ^i'i
LJ'Hpil'
W^i
i r y ^ ^ g ^ r ' H l n r ^ ^ y*
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
24/85
0
o
4. The Clarisonic
System
was developed by PBL over
many
years and at great expense
and effort, and
represents abreakthrough in technology consisting of
devices and
methods
for
treatment
of
early stage
acne and for the
effective cleansing
of
skin. Those devices and
methods
employ
motion
and forces
at
sonic frequencies to cleanse,
soften
and
smooth
skin. They alleviate
clogged pores
and
remove debris from the
skin more
gently
and
effectivdy
than other
alternatives,
such
as
manual
cleansing.
The innovations
embodied
in the
Clarisonic System have been recognized
in
the United States (and worldwide), and
are
protected
by
numerous United
States and foreign
intellectual
property
rights, including rights deriving
from patents, trademarks
and trade
dress.
5. As described in more
detail below,
PBLhas investedconsiderable resources in the
development ofadomestic industry with respect to the
Clarisonic System.
PBL is headquartered
in
Redmond,
WA
and designs,
develops,
manufactures, markets,
and
sells the Clarisonic
System
from
that
location.
6.
Prior
to
the introduction
ofthe
Clarisonic
System,
there were
no sonic facial
cleansing
devices on
the market.
Indeed, before development ofthe
Clarisonic
System, no market
existed for sonic skin care devices. PBL expended considerable resources to create
the
sonic skin
care market and to educate the public regarding
facial
cleansing,
as
well as tomarket and sell
its
sonic
facial
cleansing
devices.
7. Since
its introduction, the Clarisonic System
has
become widely
acclaimed by
professionals
and consumers, and has
garnered
many media awards from sources such
as
•ss> * *r^ ^ajtg^'jgr^gyf*- v^s^ss^M^aajyg^i^saa^=ai?g-s>'
v- ,.>-•
„-«,.,-.,
jf^i^m^easmi^-p -'
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
25/85
authoritative magazines in the beauty i
Winfrey Show, Best
ofSephora in 2007
and
2010. The success
of
the Clarisonic System
those
accused herein.
8. The proposed respondents i
(ii)
Accord Media,
LLC;
(iii) Xnovi Electronic
MTTO LLC;
(v)
Shanghai Anzikang Electric
Tech, Inc.; (viii)
ANEX
Corporation; (ix)
H2PRO
Beautylife,
Inc.;
(xii)
Serious Skin
Skinovations Ltd.;
(xiv)
WenzhouAi Er
CoreanaCosmetics
Co,
Ltd.; and (xvi) Flag
Respondents ).
9. The accused productsare im
therefor, and kitscontainingsame,and s
cleansing
system byOur
Family
Jewels,
Inc.
facial
cleansing system byAccord
Media,
a sonic skincleansing system byXnovi
product ); (iv) anantimicrobial sonic cleans
MTTO LLC under
the
name soniclear (
Shanghai Anzikang
Electric
Co, Ltd. undei
cleansing system
by
Nutra-Luxe
M.D,
LLC
( NutraSonic 4-Speed
product );
(vii) a fac
name nutra sonic (companion2-speed) (
byBeauty Tech,
Inc. d/b/a
5thAvenue
industijy,
Oprah's Favorite
Things
in2007 on
the
Oprah
i
2008, andQVCCustomer Choice in
2008,
2009 and
iias spurred a
large
number ofknock-off
products
-
m
this investigation are: (i)
Our
Family Jewels, Inc.;
I
i
Co,
Ltd.;
(iv)
Michael
ToddTrue
Organics
LPand
i
Co, Ltd.;
(vi)
Nutra-Luxe M.D,
LLC; (vii)
Beauty
•RN
Ventures Ltd.;
(x)
Korean
Beauty
Co,Ltd.; (xi)
,
Inc.;
(xiii)
Home
Skinovations
Inc.andHome
ideal
Technology
Co, Ltdd/b/a CNAIER; (xv)
koli
Classic
Limited (collectively
'Troposed
Care.
:
Elec
ported
electric
skin care devices,
brushes and
chargers
pecjifically indude,
but
are
not
limited to: (i)| a
facial
1
under the
name
episonic ( Episonic product );
(ii)
a
(
LtC under the nameultraclear ( UltraClear product ); (iii)
i
Electronic Co,
Ltd.
underthe
name Lemon; ( Lemonsonic
i
ing system by
Michael Todd True
Organics
LP and
Scjniclear product ); (v)
an
ultrasonic beauty instrument by
the
name
Dione ( Dione product );
(vi)
a facial
under the namenutra sonic (professional 4-speed)
j
al deansing
system by Nutra-Luxe
M.Di, LLC under
the
NutraSonic
Travel
product ); (viii) a skin jcleansing system
Buzz under the nameNuSonic
( NuSonic
product ); (ix) a
^ r jn ;
wsw* u ^?
§- v i i
•^^^BTsr^Ti^^^^^^s^
Ki1*? ^*^ ^
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
26/85
beauty sonic
skin
care deanser by ANEX Corporation under the name mimian ( Mimian product );
(x)
a
daily
skin
cleansing and toning brush by RN Ventures Ltd.
under
the name Magnitone Pulsar
( Magnitone Pulsar product ); (xi) afacial cleansing
system
by Korean
Beauty
Co, Ltd.
under
the
name
KOREANBEAUTY 4D MOTION ( Korean
Beauty
product ); (xii) afacial
cleansing
system
by H2PRO Beautylife, Inc. under the
name
EVE Micro
Sonic
Care ( Eve
product );
(xiii)
an
ultrasonic
cleansing system by Serious Skin
Care,
Inc.
/ FlageoH Classic Limited under the name the
beauty
buzz
( Beauty
Buzz
product );
(xiv)
a
facial
cleansing system
by
Home Skinovations Inc. and
Home
Skinovations Ltd. under
the name Silk'n
SonicCleanPlus
( Silk'n Sonic
product );
(xv)
a
facial
cleansing system
by
Wenzhou
Ai
Er
Electrical
Technology
Co,
Ltd
d/b/a
CNAIER under
the
name CNAIER AE-603 ( CNAIER product ); and (xvi) a facial deansing
system
by Coreana
Cosmetics
Co,
Ltd. under the name Coreana 4D
Motion
Cleanser ( Coreana 4D Motion
product )
(collectively
Accused
Products ).
10.
As addressed
herein,
Proposed
Respondents are
engaged inunlawful
and unfair
acts
ofcompetition
in violation
of
19
U.S.C. §
1337(a)(1)(B) by selling within the United States after
importation,
selling
for
importation
and/or
importing
certain
dectric
skin
care devices,
brushes
and
chargers
therefor,
and kits containing
same,
that infringe claims
of
one or more of the
following
United
States Letters Patent: (i) U.S. Patent No. 7,320,691 ( the
'691
patent );
(ii) U.S.
Patent No.
7,386,906
( the '906
patent );
and
(iii) U.S.
Design
Patent
No.
D523,809 ( the
D'809 patent ).
Collectively, these
patents
are referred
to
herein
as the Asserted Patents.
11.
An industry exists in the United
States
relating to the
artides protected
by
the
'691,
'906,
and
D'809 Patents, as
required
by 19 U.S.C. §
1337(a)(2)
and (3).
12.
In
addition,
certain
Proposed Respondents'
actions are unlawful
under
the unfair
methods
of
competition provision
of 19 U.S.C. §
1337(a)(1)(A)
because each of their
products
infringes PBL's distinctive trade dress (the Clarisonic Trade
Dress ).
-4-
v^^•^^^j^^mfv -
•^ww-* , .„-[==%;.c =.^j..t^,,^Jgiej^^ iWj(,
S^py^iyi^Li^y^iyiy^^^^.j^,
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
27/85
13. Those certain Proposed Respondents' violations of19
U.S.C.
§
1337(a)(1)(A)
have
substantiallyinjured or threaten to cause
industry in the United States,within the
14. The following table
infringed intellectual property.1
Proposed
Respondent
Our
Family
Jewels
Accord
Media
Xnov i
MTTO
Anzikang
Nut raLuxe
Nut raLuxe
Beauty
Tech d/b/a
5 t h Avenue
Buzz
Accused '
Produc t
Episonic
UltraClear
Lemonsonic
Soniclear
Dione
NutraSonic
4-Speed
NutraSonic
Travel
NuSonic
: m e a n i n
summarizes
Exh ib i t
7A
7B
7G
7D
7E
7F
7G
7H
Exhib i t
27
A,Q;
w
B,R:
X
C, 3
D
E,T.
Y
F ,Z
G
H.AA
7,320,691
Claims 1, 4-6,
12-16, 22, 31,
33,39-41,42,
44-46, 49, 51-
52
Claims 1, 4-6,
12-16,22,31,
33, 39-41, 42,
44-46, 49, 51-
52
Claims 1, 4-6,
12-16, 22,
31,
33, 39-41,42,
44-46, 49, 51-
52
Claims 31, 33
39-41
Claims 1, 4-6,
12-16,22,31,
33, 39-41, 42,'
44.46, 49, 51
52
•
Claims 31, 3
39-41
Claims 31,
3
39-41
Claims 31,
3
39-41
7,386,906'
C la im s 1 -
2, 4-5, 7-
15
Claims 1-
2, 4-5, 7-
15
Claims
2, 4-5,
15
Claims 1-
2, 4-5, 7-
4 C
- - I?
**.... -.?.-•.-„/:••
-_
substantial injury to, and/or destruction of,PBL's related
ing of 19U.S.C. § 1337(a)(1)(A)®.
the Proposed Respondents, infringing
products,
and
D523,809
V
.Trade
Dress '
/
/
'iSn-' t v
1In the table,Exhibit 7 ( Ex. 7 ) refers to
refers to photographs of the respective
the
Declaration of
Lilac
Muller and
th e
Exhibit letter
infringing product.
ThatDeclaration is discussed below.
identified patents infringed by each respective product
Asserted Patents and, in three instances, trade dress.
Exhibit 27 refers to claim charts showing
of th e identified
claims
of one
or
more of
the
d i e .
-5 -
^VWWWF^W?%~'^'*,'®°~*™** • YV- ^yMW^^Vy-^ * '~ ' ^ 5^* - -^ -^
.^T£V.. .^Vl.^ -^^ -j,-,.-
-^y.
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
28/85
Proposed
Respondent
A N E X
RN
Ventures
Korean
Beauty
H2P r o
Serious Skin
Care /
Flageoli
Home
Skinovations
CNAIER
Coreana
Accused;;
Product
Mimia
Magnitone
Pulsa r
Korean
Beauty
Eve
BeautyBuzz
Silk'n
Sonic
CNAIER
Coreana 4D
Mot i on
Exhibit?
71
7J
7K
7L
7N
70
7P
7M
Exh ib i t
Z':--27
••• •'.
I ,U
J,BB
K
L
M,CC
N
0 ,GG
P ,V
7,320,691
. Claims 1, 4-6,
12-16,22,31,
33,
39-41,42,
44-46, 49, 51-
52
Claims 31, 33,
39-41
7,386,906
Claims
2>4-5>7-
t . 'g^kfrx^.
D523,809
:
Trade
Dress
•.:, w.3-..
: -Si.- — • :
, SSC. . , u In i
.a
Claims 31, 33, &X .S^llf?'
jV
^-•-'
' '
• ^sS--^ •- • •
39-41 fcc* ;:sjg3fcM .*.-£%;>:: 'x £j£-:'
:j i
Claim;
39
s 31,33,
&:&SjjjB&t*-.\: v:^- - v^ / :.q
j-41
l-..:V
gJg*g;-r--« -
^«LL.V: \ : f
-.*_.• . •«
Claims 31,
33,
felS^IJ?
39-41 *' '
^ : j - *
iS
**-' :
J*Sl
:.>./iiSS;,:-..;'1la
Claims
39 -
31,
33, tJr.Tfei
^f^sCy^
£
^ . ^ ^X
Claims 1, 4-6
12-16, 22, 31,
33, 39-41, 42,
44-46, 49, 51-
52
Claims 1, 4-6,
12-16, 22, 31,
33, 39-41,42,
44-46,49, 51-
52
5^2ifc___l
';i___^___^
Claims 1- ^^S^m^'h'p^:^
2,4-57-9
h:j^ '^i£^pfes*??
Pk.'- .. . .?.iKs. .»>-» -.-Ji S~-- -*
=
'.Vi;.-.=
-. j-V'.'h1™
- ,v^ Vcfjv?; -^r.-?,
•-
••-
~'^
.r
it . :.
.-, - • 'J^V' -*-
••...--jj
14
15. PBL is the exclusive
United
States licensee
ofall substantial rights, including the right
to bring suit ofprotectable patent rights (including the Asserted Patents)
as
described
herein.
PBL
also is the owner
ofcertain
trade dress
rights,
asserted herein. In view
ofthe
widespread
infringement by elusive foreign entities,
Complainant
seeks a
permanent
general exclusion order to
prohibit
anyone from
importing, entering
and
selling
within the
United States
electric skin care
devices,
brushes
and
chargers
therefor, and
kits
containing
same
that infringe
these
patents
and
trade
dress.
Complainant also seeks permanent cease and desist orders to halt the marketing, sales and
distribution of
infringing
products in the
United
States by
each and
every
one
of
the Proposed
Respondents.
' kNtSTSP^^S^HT^^P
4m/k st&tw
»*»™ mmmm
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
29/85
II .
TH E PART IE S
A.
The Complainant PBL
16. PBL (PacificBioscience Lab
incorporated inJanuary
2001,
with its
Redmond, WA. PBL is in the business o
marketing, advertising, offering to
sell
and
the Clarisonic System.
17. In 2004, PBL introduced the
known as the Clarisonic Classic), the first
creating a newmarket for sonic fadal
remains enormously successful. In 2010,
Companies.
18.
In
December 2011, L'Oreal
B. Proposed Respondents
1.
Our
Family
Jewels
19. On information
and
belief,
Skincare, ( Our FamilyJewels ),is a co
with its principal placeof business at 10226
20.
On
information
and
belief,
electric skin care devices, brushes and char
products. See Exhibits 8A-8C.
The
packag:
epipurskincare.com. See Exhibit
7A2.
websiteas Our Family Jewels. See Exhibit
the owner of the Episonic trademark. S
oratories, Inc.) is a Washingtoncorporation
principal-place of business at 17275 NE 67th Court,
f researching,
designing, developing,
manufacturing,
:lling technically advanced skin care products, including
e .
Clarisonic System and began selling the
Clarisonic
(now
|
skin care device available on the market, thereby
j
g
devices.
The
Clarisonic System has been and
was named one of Inc. 500's Fastest Growing Private
sonic
.
deans
in;
PBL
acquiredPBL.
Respondent Our Family
Jewels, Inc.,
d/ti/a
Epipiir
organized
and
existing under
the
laws
of
Oregon
S.
Dransfeldt
Road, Parker,
CO
80134.
Our
Family Jewels
manufactures,
markets,
and
sells
i
ers therefor, and kits containingsameas the Episonic
I
ng for the Episonic product directs
consumers
to
domain
dossier fo r that website
lists
t ie owner of the
$D. Additionally, Our
Family Jewels
Inc. is
listed
as
i.
Exhibit 8A.
rporation
The
-7 -
r-it-v^vgn r̂-r^ti'wwsvv
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
30/85
21. On
information and
belief,
the
Episonic products are manufactured inChina and are
imported into and
sold
in the United States. For example, components
of
tiie
Episonic products
bear
the label Made
inChina.
See Paragraph
7 and
Exhibit 7A2
to the
Declaration
of
Lilac Muller
inSupport ofComplaint
( Muller
Deck ), attached
hereto as Exhibit
7.
22. On
information
and belief,
the Episonic
products are available and sold in
the
United States
through
Our
Family
Jewels' website,
htttp://www.epipurskmcare.com/products/episomc-fadal-cleansmg-system.html,
and
at
least
through
Amazon.com,
http://www.amazon.com/Episonic-Facial-Cleansing-Brush-
System/dp/BOOFWZRCGS/.
See
Exhibits 8B-8C.
23.
Accordingly,
Our
Family
Jewels
is
responsible for importing into
the United States,
selling for importation into the United States, and/or selling within the United States after
importation
the
Episonic
products.
24. As set forth
below
in Paragraphs 169,187, 196, and 203-206, Our
Family
Jewels'
Episonic
products infringe
the
'691 Patent,
the
'906 patent,
the D'809
patent, and the Clarisonic
Trade
Dress.
2. Accord
Media
25.
On information and belief,
Respondent
Accord Media,
LLC,
d/b/a Truth
in
Aging,
( Accord Media )
is
alimited liability company organized and existing under
the
laws ofNew York
with its principal
place,
ofbusiness
at
241
West 36th
Street, Apt.
16,
New York, NY
10018.
26.
On information
and belief, Accord Media manufactures, markets, and sells electric
skin
care devices, brushes and chargers
therefor,
and
kits containing same
as
the UltraClear
products.
See
Exhibits 9A-9B.
The
packaging
for the UltraClear products explains
that
it
is made
by
Truth
in
Aging.
SeeExhibit 7B2. The Terms
ofUse page
of the Truth in Aging website
lists
Accord
Media, LLC as
the
actual company. See
Exhibit 9A.
Additionally, the AboutTruth in
' J • - ' •* * ̂ *S9^^^ i^™*™^^^
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
31/85
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
32/85
Electronic Co, Ltd.
having
an
address
of Rm
915 Guanlida Mansion (Nonle Plaza), [QJianjin
the
IRoad 30Area of BaoAnShenzhen, China.
See
Exhibit
7C2.
33. On information
and belief,
the
Lemonsonic
products
are manufactured
in
China
and
are imported
into
and
sold
in
the
United States; For example,
components
of
the
Lemonsonic
product bear the label Made in China. SeeMuller Decl. (Exhibit
7),
paragraph 14 and
Exhibit
7C2.
34. Oninformation and
belief,
the
Lemonsonic
products are available and
sold
in
the
United States,
at
least
throughAmazon.com,
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00DCMDYK6/and
http://www.amazon.com/Lemon-
Sonic-Cleansing-System-Replacement/dp/B00I505TPI/.
^Exhibits
10A-10B.
35.
Accordingly, Xnovi
is responsible for
importing into the
United
States, selling
for
importation into
the
United States, and/or selling
within
the United States after importation the
Lemonsonic products.
36. As set
forth
below in Paragraphs 171 and
189,
Xnovi's Lemonsonic products
infringe the
'691
Patent
and the '906
patent.
4. MTTO LP and
MTTO
LLC
37. On
information and belief, Respondent Michael
Todd
True Organics LP ( MTTO
LP )
is
a
limited
partnership
organized
and existing under the laws ofDelaware with its principal
place
of
business
at648 SW
Port
St.
Lucie Blvd., Port
St.
Lucie,
FL
34953-1947.
38.
On information and belief, Respondent MTTO LLC
is,
a
limited
liability company
organized
and existing-under
the
laws of
Delaware
with
its principal place
of
business
at
648
SW
Port
St.
Lucie Blvd., Port St. Lude, FL 34953-1947. On information and belief, MTTO LLC is a
general partner ofMTTO LP.
-10-
^/ sssgaa^w^M^^ „ . | ..... u... .u ji
^ ™
~ J
-T—p- aT-j.j^..M-= u —
-j.WL»^»WJ1.U.MIIMJIIII
I l ll l.ll | j | . I. I ..in HI .CTIMI BUIJJJIIIIII1MIIIIIU1ILH III
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
33/85
39.
On information and
belief,
manufacture, market and sell electric skin
containing sameas the Soniclear products,
products refers to MichaelTodd true org;
consumers of the Soniclear products to mi
of the FloridaDepartment of StateDivision
with
address in
Port
St. Lucie,
FL
34953,
the Soniclear products aremanufacturedin
States. For example,components of the
Muller Ded. (Exhibit 7), paragraph18and
40.
On information and
belief,
MTTO's ownwebsite,http://www.:
system/soniclear.html, and at leastthrough
Anti-microbial-Skin-Cleansing-System,
41. As set forth belowin
Paragra1]
Patent .
MTTOLPandMTTO
LLC (collectively, f'MTTO )
t
devices, brushes and chargers
therefor*,
and kits
Exhibit 11A. The packagelabeling for the Soniclear
Port S fLucie, FL 34953 USA
and
directs
rmcHaeltoddtmeorganics.com. See Exhibit 7D2. A search
of Corporations
yields
two entities relatedto MTTO
i
,
J>
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
34/85
43. On information and belief, Anzikangmanufactures,markets, and sells electric skin
care
devices, brushes and
chargers
therefor, and kits containing same as the Dione products.
See
Muller Deck
(Exhibit 7), Exhibits 7E1-7E2.
Themanual fortheDioneproduct lists, in
Chinese:
See
Exhibit
7E2.
A
translation
of
this
Msting
as
assisted
by
Google Translate
(http://translate.google.com):
ShanghaiAnzi Kang Electric
Co,
Ltd.
Produc t ion Address :
Ningbo
Ninghai Sanmen
Bay Economic Development Zone
Sales Address :
Shanghai Minhang
Qu,Ji
Xin Road,
No.
168 Building
3,
Room 401
44. Based on thepackage labeling, theDione product is
manufactured
in China and is
imported
into and
sold
in the United
States. For
example, the
packaging
for
the
Dione product
bears a multitude of Chinese characters and a Sales and Production Address in China. See Muller
Deck (Exhibit 7),paragraph 22 andExhibit 7E2.
45.
On information and
belief,
theDioneproductis
available
and
sold
in the
United
States at least through the internet,
http://acne.center/anzikang-electric-facial-body-brush-spa-
cleaning-system-electric-waterproof-gift-packing-pink/,
and
through
Amazon.com.
See
Exhibit
12;
Muller Deck (Exhibit 7),Exhibit 7E1.
46. As set forth below inParagraphs
173, 190,
198 and 203-206, theDione product
infringes the
'691 Patent,
the '906 patent the
D'809 patent, and
theClarisonic Trade Dress. -
-12-
^^^^^^•pb^^^afei ĝsgFtft^w^ w
•••«
•«gw?ge^ gea»^wg~^'v
^T^B'gywiSgww^1^^
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
35/85
6. Nu t raLuxe
47.
On information and
bekef,
limited kability company organized and
business
at
6835
International Center Blvd.
48. On informat ion and belief,
care devices, brushes and chargers therefor,
products
and the
NutraSonic
Travel prod
NutraSonic
4-Speed product and
NutraSonib
Nutra
Luxe
MD.
See
Exhibits
7F2 and
the NutraSonic Travelproduct further lists
Unit5,FortMyers, FL
33912. See
Exhibit
Division of Corporations yields the details
FL 33912, USA. SeeExhibit 13D.
49.
On information and bekef,
4-Speed product
and
NutraSonic
Travel
and sold in the United States. For example.^
Made in China. See MullerDeck (Exhibit
50.
On information and bekef,
available and sold in the United States at le;
http: /
/www.
amazon.
com/Nutra-Sonic
http: /
/www.
amazon.com/Nutra-Sonic-
http://www.amazon.com/Nutra-Sonio
Exhibi ts 13B-13C.
Res
pondent
Nutra-Luxe M.D,
LLC ( NutraLuxe )
is a
g
under
the laws ofFlorida with its
principal place
of
tyoit 5,FortMyers, FL33912.
aLuxe manufactures, markets, and sells electric skin
t
andkits containing same as the NutraSonic 4-Speed
:
See Exhibits 13A-13C.
The package
labeHng
forthe
I
Travel product
state
thatthe
products
are offered by
. The bottom-of the back
of
the package labeling for
In address
of
6835 International Center Boulevard,
7G2.
A search of theFlorida Department ofState
for Nutra-Luxe M.D, LLC with address in Fort Myers,
at least the brushheads and chargersfor the NutraSonic
TF3W^E3*H$ ¥r*
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
36/85
51. As set forth below in
Paragraphs 174
and
199, NutraSonic
4-Speed products
infringe
the
'691
Patent
and
theD'809 patent.
52. As
set forth below in
Paragraph 175,
NutraSonic Travel products
infringe the '691
Patent .
7. Beauty
Tech,
Inc.
d/b/a
5th Avenue Buzz
53.
On information
and
bekef, Respondent Beauty Tech,
Inc.
d/b/a 5th Avenue
Buzz
( 5th
Avenue
Buzz ) is a
corporation organized
and
existing under the
laws of
Florida with its
principal place ofbusiness at
1430
S. Dixie
Hwy,
Ste. 321, Coral Gables, FL 33146-3175. On
information
and
belief,
5th Avenue
Buzz also
has
a
place
of
business at
20241
NE
16th
Place,
Miami,
FL
33179.
54.
On information and
bekef,
5th Avenue
Buzz manufactures, markets, and
sells
electric skin care
devices,
brushes and chargers therefor, and
kits
containing
same as
the NuSonic
products. See Exhibit 14A. The
base
ofthe charging station
Hsts
Bauty [sic] Tech, Inc. USA.
www.beautytec.com. See Exhibit 7H2. The bottom
of
the website for 5th Avenue
Buzz
also
identifies
Beautytech, Inc.
as
the copyright
owner.
See
Exhibit
14A.
The Florida
Department
of
State Division ofCorporations Hsts 1430 SDixie Hwy Ste 321, Coral Gables, FL 33146 as the
address for Beautytech,
Inc.
See Exhibit14C.
55.
• Qn information and bekef,
the
NuSonic products are manufactured in
China
and are
imported
into and sold in the United States. For example, components of
the
NuSonic
products
bear the labd Made in
China.
SeeMuller
Deck (Exhibit 7), paragraph 34
and Exhibit
7H2.
56. On information and bekef, the NuSonic products are
available
and
sold
in
the
United
States at least
through the
5th
Avenue
Buzz website,
htto://www.5thavenuebuzz.com/shop/devices/test-hgv.html, and through Amazon.com,
-14-
&®^^%m*tyu™%%-®
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
37/85
http://www.amazon.com/SONIC-CLEAN^ING-SYSTEM-5th-Avenue/dp/B00J7p9ZVE. J«
Exhibi ts 14A-14B.
57.
As
set
forth
below
in
Paragraphs
176 and 200, the
NuSonic
products :
'691 Patent and the D'809 patent.
8.
ANEX
Corp.
58.
On information and
bekef,
corporation organized and existing underthe
304SeoulHightechVenture Center, 647-26
On
information
and
bekef,
ANEX
also has
345
Seokcheon-ro, Ojeong-gu, BucheonCi
59. On information and bekef,
devices, brushes and chargers therefor, and
Exhibits 15A, 15D. The ANEX website (in
Park, 345 Seokcheon-ro, Ojeong-gu,
The
ANEX
website (inJapanese) ksts an
Deungchon-dong, Gangseo-ku,
Seoul, 157-1
Mimian products ksts Anex Corporation
647-26 Deungchon-dong, Gangseo-ku,
60. Based on packagelabekng,
importedinto and soldin the United
States,
th e
label
Made in Korea. See
Muller
Decl
61.
On information and
bekef,
States at leastthroughAmazon.com, http:/
Facial/dp/B00JSQ5ZG6/.
See
Exhibit
15E:
w^ T w™ ^ s ^ r w™ r ™ T T f f ^
• fww w
£J:
infringe the
RespondentANEXCorporation
( ANEX )
is a
i
laws of Koreawith its principal place of business at C-
Deungchon-dong, Gangseo-ku, Seoul,
1(57-030,
Korea,
place
of
business
at #304-705 Bucheon Techno
Park,
Gyenggi-do 421-741,Korea.
ANEX manufactures, markets, and seks dectric skin care
I
Irits
containing sameas the
Mimian
products.
See
Engksh) ksts
an
address
of#304-705 Bucheon Techno
City,
Gyenggi-do
421-741,
Korea. See
Exhibit
15C.
address
of
C-304
Seoul
Hightech Venture
Center, 647-26
I,
Korea.
i>£
Exhibit 15E. A brochure for the
with address at C-304 SeoulHightech Venture Center,
157-030, Korea.
^Exhibit
15Aat 16.
Mimian products are manufactured
iti
Korea and are
{
For example, components of theMimian products bear
I
(Exhibit 7),paragraph 38andExhibit712.
,Bucheon
-030.
Seoul,
tie.
the Mimian products are available and so
d in t h e Un i ted
/www.amazon.com/Mimian-Beauty-Portable-Cleanser
-15-
-gOTr®^1—H^TT^n^T^^sr^T •r'sr'wr
B.»P i/
' / jB i ' ^ p^wp
-
•^-•aaw'i
«£y •^'t-ijf'T^*
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
38/85
62. As set forth
below inParagraphs 177 and 191,
the Mimian
products infringe the '691
Patent and the '906patent.
9. RN Vent ur es L td .
63.
On information
and bekef,
Respondent
RN
Ventures
Ltd. ( RN
Ventures ) is a
corporation organized and
existing under
the
laws ofUnited Kingdom
with its prindpal place
of
business atFrancis House, 10 Francis Street,
London
SW1P IDE, United Kingdom.
64. On information and bekef, RN
Ventures
manufactures, markets, and seks electric
skin
care
devices, brushes and chargers
therefor,
and kits
containing same
as
the
Magnitone Pulsar
products.
See
MuUer
Deck
(Exhibit
7),
Exhibit
7J2.
On the
base
of
the
charging
station,
RN
Ventures Ltd London SW11 is
printed.
See Exhibit
7J2.
Additionauy, the brochure for the
Magnitone Pulsar
products states that
Magnitone is
a
trading brand
name
owned
by: RN
Ventures
Ltd. London, SW11. See Exhibit
16C
at 10. TheMagnitone terms
and
conditions
website
ksts
Francis House, 10 Francis St, London SW1PIDE as the address for R N Ventures Ltd. See
Exhibi t
16D.
65.
On
information
and bekef, the Magnitone Pulsar
products
are
manufactured
in
China,
distributed from United'Kingdom, and are
imported
intoand sold in the United States. For
example, components
of the
Magnitone
Pulsar
products
bear
the
label Made
in
China. See Muller
Deck (Exhibit 7), paragraph 42 and
Exhibit
7J2. '
66.
On
information
and bekef,
the Magnitone Pulsar
products are available and sold in
the
United States
at
least through
the
Magnitone website,
https://magnitone.co.uk/shop/magnitone-pulsar/, and
other
websites, such
as
http://www.lookfantastic.com/magmtone-pulsar-daky-skin-cleansing-toning-and-exfokation-brush-
for-face-and-body/10858382.html.
^Exhibits
16A-16B.
-16-
»->W«»W»»-v»»w, -*»~»^»'^^-*^« »« «-^^
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
39/85
67. As set forth belowin Paragraphs 178 and 201, the Magnitone'Pulsar products
infringe the '691 Patent and the D'809 patent,
10. Korean
Beauty
68.
On information and
bekef,
is a corporation organizedand existing under
at 10 F, Pluszone Bldg700,Deungchon
69. On information and
bekef,
skin care devices, brushes and chargers
products.
See
Exhibits 17Aand 7K2. The
Exhibi t
7K2.
A b rochu re for
the Korean
andproduct
image,
ksts the company and
Bldg700,Deungchon-Dong, Gangseo-Gu,
70. On
information and
bekef,
and are importedinto and soldin the United
Beautyproducts bear the labd Madein
Exhibit 7K2.
71.
On information and
bekef,
United States at least through Amazon.com,
Foundation-Batteries/dp/B00HMHI3AS.
72. As set forth below in Parage
Paten t .
Respondent Korean BeautyCo, Ltd. ( KoreanBeauty
the laws of Korea with its principal place
of
business
g, Gangseo-Gu, Seoul, Korea.
I^^^~qZF> 8^^
8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint
40/85
1043
Segovia
Or,
Placentia, CA
92870. On information and bekef, H2Pro
has
a place ofbusiness
also at 4319 Regency Drive, Glenview, IL 60025.
74. On information and bekef,H2Pro manufactures,markets, and sekselectric skincare
devices,
brushes and ;chargers therefor, and kits
containing same
as the Eve
products.
See
Exhibits 18A
and
7L2. The
packaging
for the
Eve
products
states
the product
is
distributed by
H2Pro
and
ksts
a
website
of
www.h2probeautykfe.com. See Exhibit 7L2. The H2Pro
Beauty
Life
website ksts
an
address
of 1043 Segovia Or,
Placentia,
CA 92870.
See
Exhibit
18B.
On a
different About us
page,
the H2Pro
Beauty Life
website ksts
a
different address,
namely, 4319
Regency Drive, Glenview, IL 60025.
See
Exhibit 18C.
75.
On information andbekef, theEve
products
are
manufactured
in
Korea,
andare
imported
into
and sold
in the United
States. For example,
components of
the
Eve products
bear
the
label
Made
in
Korea. See Muker Deck (Exhibit
7),
paragraph 50 and Exhibit 7