Characteristics of ELLs

Diverse population

• 70% are Spanish Speakers, remaining students have many language backgrounds

• Most enter in elementary, but many in middle and high school

Different ability levels in native language and English

• Varying literacy skills

• Varying oral language

ELLs should not be considered one group

English Language Learners

A hot topic in education

Increasing number of English Language Learners (ELLs) across the U.S.

No Child Left Behind makes schools accountable for progress of all students

• ELLs are subject to the same requirements as other students

Modify techniques for ELLs

Explicitly teach vocabulary• Critical to reading comprehension• Often neglected component of instruction for ELLs

Scaffold reading by asking frequent questions• Critical to mastery

More research needed

• Relatively small number of studies in ELL language acquisition focus on component skills of literacy (phonological awareness, word reading, fluency, vocabulary and comprehension)

Implementing Techniques

Professional development• Important to understand theory as well as strategyAssessment• Pay attention to individual needs in your classroom• Progress monitoring is essential to see what works;

‘research-based’ doesn’t necessarily mean it will work for

all students Repertoire of strategies• One size does not fit all; tailor instruction to individual needs

Remember: students can be at basic literacy level in

any grade!

Reading in a second language

Reading is a similar task across languages

• Similar cognitive and language processes• Components of first language are a foundation for

second language• Universal processes must be taught and recalled to

transfer understanding

Consider cultural and linguistic barriers

Role of the native language in learning a second language

Support and resources are needed to learn English

Strong understanding in native language helps second language development

• Students with little language basis will have difficultylearning a new language

Transitional program to second language is critical

• Provide support throughout the process

Language of instruction matters for skills to transfer

• Develop skills in native language then transition to the second language

• Phonological skills transfer regardless of language of instruction• Word reading and background knowledge require instruction in primary language first

Correcting mistakes

Technical mistakes should be corrected (vocabulary,

spelling, text organization)

• Uncorrected mistakes can cause later troubles

Over-correction causes frustration

• Carefully choose when to correct

ELLs and learning disabilities

Distinguish between poor instruction and LDs

• Avoid labeling

• Provide direct instruction and opportunities for practice

• Use assessment and careful monitoring

Not all disabilities are accommodated in the same way—not all part of one group

ELLs and learning disabilities

Use the same kind of program with ELLs as regular students

• Provide extra instruction, not less

• Offer attention, individualized instruction

• Allow extra practice time

Importance of proper diagnosis

• Decide what is needed and provide necessary services

VideoTeaching Kindergarten ELLs

Mark Hopkins School, Sacramento CA

Teaching Kindergarten ELLs

• Phonological awarenessknowledge of the individual sounds within a word

• Phonemic awarenessknowledge of what letters create what sounds

• Print concepts

• Assessment

• Early reading intervention

Teacher preparation

Staff development

• Extensive practice, examples and support• Understanding of research – theory and practice

Assessment

• Continuously adapt instruction to improve outcomes

All educators must take on new roles

• ESL teachers must have reading knowledge• Classroom teachers must know about ELLs

Finding the best strategies

Learning communities

• Groupings across a school district to reflect and share strategies

No longer just a concern for teachers

• Everyone is accountable for student learning

• All administrators should be involved in finding best practices

Rural schools

Educating ELLs in a regular

classroomComprehensive reading program

• Provides a basis for learning

Strategies for ESL can benefit general population

• Hands-on learning

• Explicit instruction

Spanish ESL

Introduce cognatesWords that have similar look and meaning in Spanish and English

• 1/3 of English words are cognates

• cognates are often high level English words, but common in Spanish, giving Spanish speakers an advantage

Provide deliberate explicit instruction

Transfer language skills to English

• Good readers in both languages use same skills

• Poor readers do not see the connection between languages

Background knowledge helps with reading comprehension

Environmental factors forSpanish speakers

Mastery of first language makes transfer of skills to second language easy

• Transition is difficult if base skills are not present in native language

• Provide content in native language to make sense of second

Well-rounded curriculum bridges gapQuick and effective transition to into general classroom

• Provide rich content

• Provide systematic instruction in English

• Offer support in native language

Video

University of British Columbia Vancouver, British Columbia

• Phonemes — smallest unit of sound

• 150 phonemes can be produced by humans

• 40 are used in English

• Infants can distinguish between all human sounds

• By 12 months, children lose this ability and specialize in the sounds of their native language

• Speaking with child helps develop language skills

Working with non-English speakers

Reading can be basis for oral language development

• Basic literacy can be taught without oral proficiency • Phonological and phonemic awareness

• Vocabulary development • Names of letters

• Practice with words and sounds lays foundation for overall literacy

• As the student progresses, add the complex

Teaching ELLs

Start small, do not overwhelm the student

Include background of contextualized reading

and writing

• Becomes increasingly important to keep students engaged

• Providing background knowledge gives basis for understanding

Many things occur at once in the classroom

• Requires trained professionals

Acquiring a second language

Natural for kids to pick up a second language

Informal interactions with peers

• “Playground talk”

Exposure to teachers and advanced speakers for further development

• Learn more about the complex aspects of the language

• Transition from social proficiency to academic proficiency

Effects of second language learning

Informal learning before attending school is helpful

• Gives basic knowledge of the language

• Leads to social proficiency

• Provides background knowledge for furtherlanguage development

Formal instruction is still necessary

• Leads to academic proficiency

• Mastery of abstract concepts

Reaching Proficiency

Oral proficiency happens gradually

• Highly communicative after two years, but reliant on non-verbal cues

Academic proficiency

• Evidence suggests 5-7 years

Misconceptions about ELLs

Myth: ELL programs teach basic phonics.

• Fact: Good ELL programs provide comprehensive learning experiences.

Myth: Students cannot learn to read in two languages at once.

• Fact: Reading in two languages proves to be an effective learning method.

The Canadian immersion model

English to French

• Students already speak language of majority

• Come from literate families

(In U.S., English to Spanish immersion worked)

Spanish to English

• Going from language minority to majority is very different

• Language skills are needed for survival

Good practices in English acquisition

Don’t wait to teach content!

Help students toward basic proficiency

• Students with basic proficiency can better take advantage of instruction and ‘bootstrap’

language skills

Engage students in content areas

• Students acquire language most effectively when they are NOT focused on language learning

• Content knowledge facilitates language acquisition

Motivating second language learners

Provide high interest activities in all content areas

• Science and social studies use new concepts, rich vocabulary, lots of cognates• Focus less on technicalities of language and more on content

Offer family literacy programs• Provides motivation for student to continue learning• Encourages entire family to master the language

Scaffold to provide support and knowledge• Ask lots of questions to check for understanding, clarify misunderstandings• Repeat what child says (correctly) and elaborate

Video

Reading Rockets: Launching Young

ReadersELL student, Maricely, Hartford CT

• Spanish spoken at home and community

• Spelling and phonics cause confusion

• Varied spelling (|ph| sounds like |f|)

• Interventions

• Individualized attention

• Reading practice

• Older siblings provide tutoring and encouragement

Motivating parents to become involved

Reach out to parents

• Ask for input

• Offer multiple options for participation (before/after school, evenings, weekends)

Provide practice for teachers in welcoming parents

Use parents strengths to find ways for them to help(example: parents who were former farmers built garden used for science lessons)

• Parents can share their own skills and be involved in their child’s education

Involving all stakeholders

ELL initiatives could use more focus on involving wider

community

• Principals, administrators, school board, families,parents, and teachers

Professional organizations becoming more engaged in instruction and raising awareness

Encouraging peer acceptance

Use paired activities that raise status of ELLs

• Pair ELLs with native English speakers

• Teach a skill to ELLs and have them teach it to English speakers

Two-way immersion programs

• Both groups are learning the other language

• Provides an equal experience for all learners

Informal teaching sessions for older students

• English speakers learn Spanish from Spanish speakers, and vice versa

Recommendations for newcomers in middle and high school

Develop newcomer programs

• Intensive intervention in language and literacy• If possible, continue content instruction in native language

Sheltered instruction / scaffolding

• Provide support and generate prior knowledge to makeinformation comprehensible

Training for teachers with ELLs in general education

classrooms

• Extensive professional development

ESL when English is not the language of majority

Different situations: Additive bilingual (French speakers in Quebec)

• Students can add second language without threat to identity or first language

• English is not needed when it is not widely spoken

Subtractive bilingual (Spanish speakers in the U.S.)

• Develop strong skills in both languages

• Teach new language without losing the first

Bilingual reading programs

Team teaching

• Equal time spent in each language

• One teacher for each language

• Separate for language instruction so students do not become confused

• Keep different content associated with single language

• Integrate language across content areas gradually

Basics for older students

Assess basic skills in native language

• May informally know many component skills

Draw on culture of adolescence

• Popular music for phonemic awareness

Spend less time on basic skills than you would with

younger learners

Final thoughts

Dr. Genesee

Language is important to education, but not the only

aspect of education; do not sacrifice social development,

content knowledge

Dr. Calderón

Professional development is important!

Dr. August

Do not undervalue strengths and enthusiasm of students;

validate their experiences and offer support

Thank you for watching!

For more information, activities, and advice to help teach English language learners to read and succeed, please visit: www.ColorinColorado.org