Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION AND DESIGN OF THE STUDY
1.1. INTRODUCTION
1.3. OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
1.4. REVIEW OF LITERATURE
1.4.1. STUDIES RELATED TO INDIA
1.4.2. STUDIES RELATED TO FOREIGN COUNTRIES
1.5. SCOPE OF THE STUDY
1.6. IMPORTANCE OF THE STUDY
1.7. NULL HYPOTHESES
1.8. DEFINITION OF CONCEPTS
1.8.1. PRIVATE SECTOR
1.8.2. ORGANIZATIONAL CLIMATE
1.8.3. SELF ESTEEM
1.8.4. STRESS
1.8.5. CONTROL
1.8.6. WORKLOAD
1.8.7. ROLE AMBIGUITY
1.8.8. ROLE CONFLICT
1.8.9. DEPRESSION
1.8.10. ANXIETY
1.9. METHODOLOGY
1.9.1. COLLECTION OF DATA
1.9.2. CONSTRUCTION OF QUESTIONNAIRE
1.9.3. SAMPLING DESIGN
1.9.4. FIELD WORK
1.9.5. FRAME WORK OF ANALYSIS
1.10. LIMITATION OF THE STUDY
1.11. CHAPTER SCHEME
1
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION AND DESIGN OF THE STUDY
1.1. INTRODUCTION
Work is a dominant element with core importance for status and
development of the economy and the individual worker. Many people spend
half of their lives in work-related activities. No other activity demands
consistent physical, emotional and cognitive stress as work stress. Working in
organizations gives individuals life-sustaining income but also exerts pressure
on them. This can have negative consequences for achieving the goals of the
organization and meeting the needs of the individuals. If the work
environment is a source of social and psychological stress, it can have harmful
effects on the well-being of the employees.
Stress is frequently a disabling human phenomenon. Stress at work
has detrimental effect on the behaviour of the people, which results in personal
and organisational inefficiency. Job stress can be described as a condition
where job related factors interact with the worker to change her psychological
and physiological conditions, so that the person’s mind and/or body is forced
to deviate from its normal way of functioning.1 The phenomenon of stress is
highly individualistic in nature. Each individual under her optimum level of
stress will perform to full capacity. If the individual experiences the stress
below the optimum level, then she gets bored. Motivational level to work
1. T.A. Beehr, and J.E. Newman, “Job stress, Employee Health and Organisational Effectiveness: A Facet Analysis”, Model and Literature Review, Personnel Psychology, Volume 31, 1978, pp.665-699.
2
reaches a low point and apathy sets in, and the individual withdraws from the
work psychologically and physiologically. While too little stress in an
individual’s life is stunting, too much stress can be damaging. It is apparent
that the health consequences of stress can be numerous, when health is taken in
its broader meaning as ‘complete physical mental and social well-being and not
merely the absence of disease’2
The modern world which is said to be a world of technological
advancement is also a world of stress due to the increasing competition among
nations, regions and enterprises on a global scale. The enterprises have to
update their knowledge and skill in information technology on the one hand
and enhance flexible responses to market change on the other. The option for
the growth, survival and stay ahead in business requires swift adaption to fast
changing customer request and circumstances. As a result managers and staff
are pressurized for technological achievements, profit motives and
productivity and sometimes traditional employment practices and contracts are
replaced by temporary workers and contract laborer.
Challenge, stress and strain have thus passed on the workforce at
large. Employees now have to face and cope with poor working conditions,
increased time pressure and long working hours due to narrowing deadlines
and increased work load, at the same time being aware that jobs are no longer
stable and the work is becoming precarious. Organizational stress has far
2. WHO, Constitution of the World Health Organisation, Geneva, Volume 73(1), 1948, pp.11-19.
3
reaching effect on physical and mental health, happiness and life satisfaction.
While stress at work will remain the major challenge to occupational health, the
ability to understand and manage the challenge is improving.3 Since last two
decades a number of empirical research studies on organizational stress have
been conducted to find the casual factors, consequences and coping techniques.
Social support is one of the major coping methods in work place today. The
moderating effect of social support on job stress-well being outcomes has been
identified by many researchers.4
1.2 STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM
In India, private sector women employees’ ratio has seen an
increase. Due to the nature of work in the industry and also the variety of roles
the women have to undertake in their household activities, the level of stress
may be more when compared with that of men. In private sector organization
various personnel are involved in a hierarchy, like lower level, middle level
and upper level. In the cadre also engulfed with extreme stressors. There is a
strong reason to believe that women employees working either in any
organization at any level face a lot of problems which lead to stress. It is said
that work cause stress and depression for women employees.
In India, job stress can affect women workers especially though
women find for easier access to education of all types today than in the past
3. A. Cox, T. Griffiths, E. Rial-Gonzales, Research on work-related Stress”. Luxembourg: European Agency for Safety and Health at Work, 2000.
4. A.P. Singh, and S. Rai, “Stress, Social Support and Well-being among Dual-Career Couples”, Stress Behaviour: The Coping Strategies, Volume 2, 2004, pp.221-251.
4
and relative freedom from gender bias in the matter of recruitment and
emoluments, they live under social conditions where traditional role
expectations in family and society have not much changed. Though women in
many families may be the breadwinners and actual providers, they are
expected to be more responsible for the maintenance part of the domestic
organization. Biologically, at a certain period of her life, women is more or less
committed to child-bearing and child-rearing, and she has other biological
conditions which make it difficult for her to support such familial and
professional demands adequately. Thus, inherently women are subject to
special problems as workers in any type of organization or profession. The
peculiar job conditions of private sector organization expose their women
workers to many special problems. If the health of these individuals and
concomitantly the health of the organizations for which they work are to be
maintained at the optimum level, those problems have to be fully probed and
analysed and understood. Hence, the researcher has undertaken this study on
the women employed by the private sector in Thoothukudi district, Tamil
Nadu. Fatigue is a common result of any employment.
Job stress is a phenomenon that goes far beyond this. Job stress is
a chronic disease caused by condition in the workplace that negatively affect an
individual’s performance and overall well-being of her body and mind.One or
more of a host of physical and mental illness manifests job stress. In some cases,
job stress can be disabling. In chronic cases, a psychiatric consultation is usually
5
required to validate the reason and degree of work related stress.5 This
phenomenon threatens the well being of an emerging industry that promises
much for the business earning for the country from foreign sources, and
promises a lot of employment opportunities with relatively high emoluments.
The glamorous aspects of the prospects naturally allure many young people,
and many of them may walk into the trap innocently.
The progress of a nation is limited to its productive capacity, which
in turn depends upon the caliber of private sector women employees. The
women employees system in particular are instruments to develop the human
capital as economic assets for wealth generation and also as social assets for
improving the quality of the life of the people. Women employees should
provide scope for understanding several major socio-economic changes
affecting the society that include global economic integration, national
economic reforms, changing demographic pattern, social norms favouring
women and weaker sections, increasing environmental consciousness,
changing family finances, demands of labour market and so on.
Occupational stress is a much talked phenomenon. However there is
little consensus between different professional groups regarding how to tackle
it. Based on a review of international research, it is concluded that women
employees occupational stress is a real phenomenon. However little is known
about the effects of reducing or mediating the impact of stressors. Actually
5. N. Brindha and P. Palanivel, “Working Women and Stress”, Women’s Link, Volume 14, No.4, Oct-Dec, 2008, pp. 7-10.
6
there are a very few studies of effective interventions but none involving large
samples or long-term follow-up. For an individual any environment has a
certain degree of stress, though of varying duration. When stress is sustained
for a long period of time, the problem becomes significant. Since India is a
labour surplus economy; getting employment is a must for all not only for the
self but also for the betterment of the country. Entering into a wrong job and
hanging on to it for the obvious reason of making a living is quite common in
Indian economic scene. Such a situation only adds to the occupational stress.
The individuals entering into private sector organization field are
professionals. They enter into professions and then they professionalise
themselves and so they find themselves at loggerheads. Further, these
professions are structured in a way that a worker is simultaneously exposed to
both overload and acute time pressure. Generally people under stress express
their frustration through some common ways like excessive criticism of
government and management, and displaying inability to get along with
others. But, in the private sector such individual behaviour cannot be easily
identified as individual performance, cannot be quantitatively measured as
precisely as in teaching field. Symptoms of stress take a long time to erupt.
Once it erupts, it not only affects the concerned individual but also the co-
workers through strained interpersonal relations and ultimately affects the
people which form the very core for the success of private sector organization.
Hence occupational stress situations and their perceived impact on women
employees are taken up for the present study. The researcher has made an
7
attempt to study the occupational stress among the women employees in
Thoothukudi District.
1.3. OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
The following are the main objectives of the present study:
v To study the profile of the study area and theoretical framework of stress.
v To measure the assessment of personality related stress factors of women
employees.
v To study the level of stress management of the sample respondents and
their socio-economic factors.
v To analyse the personality related stress factors with respect to their socio-
economic factors.
v To offer suitable suggestions on the basis of the findings of the present
study.
1.4. REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Coping with work or occupational stress and the prevention of stress
related disease has increasingly becoming the focus of occupational health
specialists, organizations and industrial psychologists. Many authors for
example (Linden field & Vandenburg, 20006, Schelebusch, 20077, Sulton, 20008)
provide the important psychological and behavioural symptoms of stress
6. G.Lindenfield, and M.Vandenberg, “Positive Under Pressure: How to be Calm and Effective When the Heat is on London”, Thorsons, 2000.
7. L.Schlebusch, Mindshift: Stress Management and Your Health, Pietermaritzburg: University of Natal Press, 2000.
8. J. Sultone, Thrive on Stress. Oxford: How to Books Ltd. 2000.
8
namely: inability to laugh, feeling of loneliness, fearfulness, inability to
concentrate, suppressed anger and feelings of anxiety.
This study can be attributed to stress being truly an interdisciplinary
study. It has become part of medicine, psychology, anthropology, sociology
and the like. It has no clear cut boundaries. Consequently the problem of
review is very difficult. There are many studies. As much comparison between
different studies become very difficult. However the researcher has made an
attempt to present the major findings of the studies undertaken specially with
reference to occupational stress. A review of literature pertaining to the study
was made by the researcher. In this section some of the research finding has
reported by experts, research scholars, and professional in the field of study
have been presented.
1.4.1. STUDIES RELATED TO INDIA
Chakraborthy Krishna9 (1978), says that there is an unconscious fear
among all, including the women themselves, that to alter the traditional
arrangement, might change or even destroy the family and feminity. This is
because, the process of social change is ambiguous and offers women,
conflicting signals. Consequently, the decision, women make to seek an
occupation, is dependent upon their ability to cope with dual responsibilities,
domestic and occupational and to negotiate with their husbands and kin to
make an arrangement that satisfies the latter.
9. Chakraborthy, Krishna, The Conflicting Worlds of Working Mothers. Calcutta: Progressive Publisher, 1978.
9
Ahmad, Bharadwaj, and Narula10 (1985), assess stress levels among
30 executives from both the public and private sector, using an ORS scale to
measure the dimensions of role stress. Their study reveals significant
differences between public and private sector employees in three dimensions of
role stress—role isolation, role ambiguity, and self-role distance. The authors
also establish the insignificant effect of several background factors, such as age,
level of education, income, marital status, and work experience.
Bhandarkar, A. and Singh.P11 (1986), in their study on “managerial
stress; study in cyclical perspective” speak of the sources of stress and
manifestations between public and private sector executives. The results
established relationship between job pressures and stress. Positive relationship
between locus of control and stress also was found. Social support was found
to have very little direct influence on the perception of stress. Further the study
found that age, education and family size also were contributory factors to
stress. Between the public and private sector executives it was found that in
private sector locus of control was the strongest predictor of stress where as in
public sector it was job pressures that predicted stress.
Jha S.S12 (1988), in his study on “Job stress and employee strain in
Indian executives” explains the pattern of stress and strain in three work
10. S. Ahmad, A. Bharadwaj, and S. Narula, “A Study of Stress among Executives”, Journal of Personality and Clinical Studies, Volume 1, 1985, pp.47–50.
11. A. Bhandarkar, and P. Singh, “Managerial Stress: Study in Cyclinical Perspective”, Journal of Management, Volume16, No.1, 1986, pp.25-59.
12. S.S. Jha, “Job Stress and Employee Strain in Indian Executives”, Work and Stress, Volume 2, 1988, pp.233-237.
10
groups namely production, personnel and data processing divisions in an
organization. Results indicated that job future ambiguity had negative effect on
job satisfaction in all the three groups. The pattern of stress in the three groups
was different among different levels of management. Among different levels of
managers, the middle levels of managers had more role ambiguity than others
did.
Dhillon, P.K13(1991), in his study on “Moderators effects on the
occupational stress-job satisfaction relationship” explains the effect of
occupational stress on job satisfaction. The moderating effects of age,
education, and hierarchical level were also examined. It was found that role
overload, role ambiguity, role conflict, responsibility for persons and
unprofitability had significant negative relationship to job satisfaction. Other
factors like unreasonable group and political pressure , under participation,
powerlessness, poor peer relation, intrinsic impoverishment, low status and
strenuous working conditions did not have any relationship to job satisfaction.
Moderating effects of age, education and hierarchical levels were found
between some of the stressors and job satisfaction.
Singh, A.D and Nath, K.14 (1991), in their study on “Effects of
Organisational Climate, Role Stress and Locus of Control on Job Involvement
of Banking Personnel” explained the impact of ten job stressors on outcomes
13. P.K. Dhillon, “Moderator Effects on the Occupational Stress – Job Satisfaction Relationship”, Productivity, Volume 31, No.4, 1991, pp.584-589.
14. A.D. Singh, and K. Nath, “Effects of Organizational Climate, Role Stress and Locus of Control on Job Involvement of Banking Personnel”, Indian Journal of Industrial Relations, Volume 27, No.2, 1991, pp. 63-76.
11
like frustration, physical strain, alienation and intent to quit. Among the
stressors experience of inequity, role conflict, job requirement, capability
mismatch and role overload significantly influenced all the outcomes. Lack of
leadership support, job difficulty and inadequacy of role authority had no
influence on any of the outcomes.
Rajeshwari, T.R15 (1992), found significant negative relationship
between age and stress and also between experience and stress. This study also
found negative correlation between number of members in the family and
stress. The level of stress did not differ between different levels of workers
namely officers and clerks.
Barnes, B.L.,16 (1992), in his study on “Stress aviation personnel”
reveals that aviation personnel were tested in different indices to evaluate their
health status and adjustments to occupational stressors. It was found that work
load was related to stress. Also higher responsibility resulted in higher anxiety
levels. Further those who had greater experiences of life changes reported more
adaptation to stress. Also those with feelings of stagnation at the job, as well as
internal and departmental politics and discrimination showed greater
frustration.
15. T.R.Rajeshwari, “Employee stress: A Study with Reference to Bank Employees”, Indian Journal of Industrial Relations, Volume 27, No.4, 1992 pp.419-429.
16. B.L. Barnes, “Stress in Aviation Personnel”, Psychological Studies, Volume 37 No.1, 1992, pp.1-6.
12
J. Rama Joshi17 (1993), has studied the “Gender differences in the
determinants of job performance: The sample consisted of 48 women and 27
male workers”. The questionnaire used in the study included seven sections
viz., demographic characteristics, motivation of workers, work values,
perceptions of the company, its policies and practices, supervision and
management, expectations from work, satisfaction with aspects of the job,
commitment to the organization and performance on the job. Two kinds of
analyses were done namely ‘t’ test and multiple regression analysis. The results
indicated: some similarities well as some critical differences in the determinant
of job performance of both the sexes. Factors extrinsic to the job had impact on
job performance of both the groups but more so in the case of female workers.
The negative impact of such off-the-job problems was set off by their higher
satisfaction with the firm.
R.A. Sharma and RabinarayanSamantara18 (1995), have studied
about “conflict management in an Indian firm”. The aim of the study was to fill
the gaps and to resolve the inconsistencies in research findings and also to
examine whether the research findings obtained in the foreign settings are
valid in the Indian conditions. Two sets of variables have been examined in the
present study–conflict management strategies and organizational effectiveness.
The sample consisted of 50 managers of a computer manufacturing
17. J. Rama Joshi, “Gender Differences in Determinants of Job Performance”, Indian Journal of Industrial Relations, Volume 28, No.3, April 1993, pp.238-247.
18. R.A. Sarma, and RabinarayanSamantra, “Conflict management in an Indian firm”, Indian Journal of Industrial Relations, Volume 30, No.4 April 1995, pp.439-453.
13
organization. The instruments used in the study included conflict management
Scale (Sayeed and Mathur, 1981) and organizational effectiveness scale (Mott,
1972). Statistical calculations such as mean, standard deviation, correlation and
multiple regression analysis were made. The major findings were: the conflict
resolution behavior of the managers is characterized by a predominant use of
smoothing, accommodating, confrontation and compromising modes together
with occasional or frequent use of forcing and withdrawing. The conflict
management strategies tended to relate much more systematically with the
flexibility and productivity aspects of effectiveness than with adaptability.
Singh, A.K. and Sehgal, V.19 (1995), in their study on “Men and
women in transition: patterns of stress, strain and social relations” highlight the
patterns of stress and strain among men and women as well as single and dual
career couples. They found that male and female managers did not differ
significantly on various stress dimensions. Difference in gender was however
found in strains women were characterized by anxiety, whereas men exhibited
more symptoms of somatic problems comparing the single and dual career
couples. It was found that male managers with spouses working experience
higher work load than managers whose spouse were not working. When it
comes to strains also single career male managers had better psychological and
physiological well-being than others. Working women managers had better
19. A.K. Singh. and P. Sehgal, “Men and women in transition: Patterns of stress, strain and social relations”, Vikalpa, volume 20, No.1,1995,pp.13-22.
14
physical well-being than their working spouses but had poorer psychological
well-being.
Berhem, et al.,20 (2004), in their study on “A new model for work
stress patterns” describe that the role of ambiguity as the main source of work
stress and self-knowledge as the main coping strategy to overcome work stress.
Work stress is believed to be one of the most important factors affecting
productivity.
Avinashkumar and Srivastav21 (2006), in his study on “coping with
stress in organizational Roles” explains dominant coping strategies and back
up coping strategy in individual and organization. Measurement of coping
strategies in the organization using role projective instrument can be very
useful for the individual and his organization. The results showed that
dominant coping strategy is the most frequently used style by the individual
which is most likely to be practiced under normal circumstances and back up
coping strategy is under pressure.
1.4.2. STUDIES RELATED TO FOREIGN COUNTRIES
Lewig and Dollard22 (2001), find that public sector employees are
subject to greater work-related stress than private sector employees. Dollard
and Walsh (1999), however, report that private sector workers in Queensland,
20. Berham, Belal, MdSidin, Samsinar and Syed Kadir, “A New Model for Work Stress Patterns”, Asian Academy of Management Journal, Volume 9, No. 1, 2004, pp: 53-77.
21. Avinash Kumar and Srivastav, “Coping with Stress in Organisational Roles”, Indian Journal of
Industrial Relations, Volume 42, No. 1, 2006, pp.110-128.
22. K.A. Lewig, and M.F. Dollard, “Social Construction of Work Stress: Australian Newsprint Media Portrayal of Stress at Work”, Work and Stress, Volume 15 No.2, 2001, pp.179–190.
15
Australia, had made twice as many stress claims as public sector workers.
Macklin et al. (2006) survey 84 public and 143 private sector employees to
assess any significant difference in their stress levels. They conclude that there
is no significant difference between employees on the basis of sector, but that
there is a significant difference between genders, i.e., female employees are
subject to greater stress than males.
D’Aleo, et al.,23 (2007), examine a sample of 559 public and 105
private sector employees to assess their respective risk profiles. They find that
public sector employees face more stress than private sector employees. Malik
(2011) collects data on 200 bank employees in Quetta, Pakistan, of which 100
work in public sector banks and the remaining 100 in private sector banks. The
author finds that there is a significant difference in the level of stress to which
both groups are subject, and that public sector bank employees face a high level
of occupational stress.
According to Budden, et al.,24 (2007), many individuals intend to
exercise, but fail to link this intention to behavior. The study examined the
impact of an implementation intention intervention (i.e., instructions to form
specific if-then plans) on an exercise intention-behavior relationship among
working adults who varied in reported occupational stress levels. Results
23. N. D’Aleo, P. Stebbins, R. Lowe, D. Lees, and D. Ham, “Managing Workplace Stress: Psychosocial Hazard Risk Profiles in Public and Private Sector”, Australian Journal of Rehabilitation Counselling, Volume13 No. 2, 2007, pp.68–87.
24. S. Budden, Jill, Sagarin, J. Brad, “Implementation Intentions, Occupational Stress, and the Exercise Intention-Behavior Relationship”, Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, Volume 12, No. 4, October 2007, pp.391-401.
16
indicated that implementation intentions backfired, such that participants who
did not form an implementation intention exercised significantly more than
participants who formed an implementation intention.
According to Collins, Stewart25 (2008), many pieces of research have
been undertaken in recent years that consider stress in statutory social work.
The research has tended, inevitably, to focus on negatives in social workers'
lives, by considering dissatisfaction with the job, absences from work and other
physical, psychological and behavioral symptoms of stress. Little attention has
been given in the studies of stress and social work to expanding on the
positives of social work, the rewards involved, high job satisfaction, the
importance of how workers cope with the job, the contribution of supervision,
personal and group support at work and home, alongside the positive well-
being of many individual social workers. This article highlights the satisfaction
social workers feel about their work, considers healthy and unhealthy coping
strategies that are, and might be, used, gender differences and the importance
of various forms of support from within the work setting, especially mutual
group support, accompanied by individual differences linked to good self-
esteem, personal hardiness and resilience.
25. Collins, Stewart, “Statutory Social Workers: Stress, Job Satisfaction, Coping, Social Support and Individual Differences”, British Journal of Social Work, Volume 28, No.6, September 2008, pp.1173-1193.
17
According to Kawano26 (2008), the present study examined degrees
of job-related stress factors as well as mental and physical symptoms among
Japanese hospital nurses in various departments, and clarified associations of
departments and job-related stress factors with those symptoms. A self-
administered questionnaire was distributed to 1,882 full-time nurses at four
acute care hospitals in Japan. The survey included demographic factors, and
the Brief Job Stress Questionnaire. Among 1,599 nurses who completed all
items relevant to the study, data from 1,551 female nurses were analysed. The
results show that working in operating rooms was associated with fatigue, that
working in intensive care units (ICU) was associated with anxiety, and that
working in surgery and internal medicine was associated with anxiety and
depression independently of demographic factors and job-related stress factors.
The physical and mental health of nurses might affect their time off, quality of
nursing care and patient satisfaction in acute care hospitals. Therefore, job-
related stress factors should be minimized, to improve the physical and mental
health of nurses, considering unique departmental demands.
According to Michael, et al.,27 (2009), Studies investigating gender
differences over the past two decades have produced contradictory results,
with some to indicate no differences, and some suggesting that either men or
26. Kawano, Yuri , “Association of Job-Related Stress Factors with Psychological and Somatic Symptoms among Japanese Hospital Nurses: Effect of Departmental Environment in Acute Care Hospitals”, Journal of Occupational Health, Volume 50, No. 1, January 2008,pp.79-85.
27. Michael, Galanakis, Anastasios, Stalikas, Helen, Kallia, Catherine, Karagianni Christine, “Gender Differences in Experiencing Occupational Stress: The Role of Age, Education and Marital Status”, Stress and Health, December 2009, Volume 25, No. 5, pp.397-404.
18
women experience more psychological stress. In this study, gender differences
were examined in occupational stress, taking into consideration the role of
marital status, age and education. Results from a sample of 2775 professionals
suggest that women experience higher levels of occupational stress than men.
Nevertheless, when marital status, age and education were introduced in the
equation, no significant gender differences were identified. Implications and
future research directions are discussed.
According to Avey, et al.,28 (2009), Workplace stress is a growing
concern for human resource managers. Although considerable scholarly and
practical attention has been devoted to stress management over the years, the
time has come for new perspectives and research. Drawing from the emerging
field of positive organizational behavior, the study offers research findings
with implications for combating occupational stress. Specifically, data from a
large sample of working adults across a variety of industries suggest that
psychological capital (the positive resources of efficacy, hope, optimism, and
resilience) may be key to better understanding the variation in perceived
symptoms of stress, as well as intentions to quit and job search behaviors. The
article concludes with practical strategies aimed at leveraging and developing
employees' psychological capital to help them better cope with workplace
stress.
28. Avey, B.James, Luthans, Fred, Jensen, M. Susan, “Psychological Capital: A Positive Resource for Combating Employee Stress and Turnover”, Human Resource Management, Volume 48, No.5, September-October 2009, pp. 677-693.
19
According to Lazuras, et al.,29(2009), the study examined four
potential roles of work-related negative affectivity on the associations between
self-reported occupational stress and physical well-being among
telecommunication employees in Greece. Participants (764, predominantly
male) completed a battery of self-report measures on perceived occupational
stress, negative affectivity, and illness symptoms. In line with previous
research, negative affectivity exerted a nuisance effect, by inflating the
association between reported stressors and illness symptoms, and significantly
predicted illness symptoms, over and above the effects of stressors. In addition,
negative affectivity influenced reported illness symptom indirectly, through the
effects of stressors, and moderated the relationship between interpersonal
conflict at work and illness symptoms. The findings suggest that negative
affectivity can largely explain and influence in different ways the associations
between self-reported stress and physical strain. it is recommended that future
studies of occupational stress should control for the effects of negative
affectivity, and that health professionals should be cautious of its effects when
interpreting relationships between self-reported occupational stress and
physical well-being.
29. Lazuras, Lambros, Rodafinos, Angelos, Matsiggos, Georgios,Stamatoulakis, Alexander, “Perceived Occupational Stress, Affective, and Physical Well-being among Telecommunication Employees in Greece”, Social Science and Medicine, Volume 68, No. 6, March 2009, pp. 1075-1081.
20
According to Wu, et al.,30 (2010), the study conducted explored
factors associated with occupational stress among female hospital nurses in
China. Nursing is a highly stressful occupation, and high levels of occupational
stress are believed to affect the physical and mental health of nurses.
Occupational stress among nurses is the result of exposure to a combination of
working environment and personal factors. A cross-sectional study was
conducted in 2008. The study population consisted of 2613 female nurses from
20 hospitals in the Liaoning province of China. Occupational stress was
measured by questionnaires that included the Chinese version of Personal
Strain Questionnaire, and data were collected on respondents' demographics,
working situations, occupational roles, and personal resources. Of the nurses
solicited for enrolment in the study, 79 center dot 2percent returned the
completed questionnaire. A general linear regression model was applied to
analyze the factors associated with occupational stress. Mean Personal Strain
Questionnaire score was 86 center dots 9, and this score was correlated, in
descending order of standardized estimate, with role boundary, role
insufficiency, responsibility, social support, self-care, nurse-patient
relationship, chronic disease, role overload, rational coping and night shift.
Role boundary and role insufficiency were the factors that had the highest
association with occupational stress. Occupational health education and
30. Wu, Hui, Chi, Tie-Shuang, Chen, Li, Wang, Lie, Jin, Ya-Ping, “Occupational Stress among Hospital Nurses: Cross-Sectional Survey” , Journal of Advanced Nursing ,Volume 66, No. 3, March 2010, pp.627-634.
21
occupational training programs may be necessary to improve the knowledge
and ability of nurses to cope with job demands and reduce occupational stress.
According to Wickramasinghe, et al.,31 (2010), the paper examined
the moderating effect of coping strategies on the relationship between work-
related dimensions (i.e. work routinization, role clarity, relationships with
others and promotional opportunity) and job stress. For the study, a
convenience sample of 385 white-collar employees, full-time employed in
various types of private sector organizations, belong to different industries and
ranked at different levels within the organizations responded. The factor
analysis led to identify four broad coping strategies that individuals use,
namely, individual positive coping, workplace initiatives, workplace informal
support and individual destructive coping. It was found that both individual
positive coping and workplace initiatives moderate the relationship between
'relationships with others' and job stress. However, none of the coping
strategies have moderated the relationship between job stress and the other
three work-related dimensions.
According to Sun, et al.,32 (2011), Aviation ground crews play a very
important role in air transportation. Not only does their work pressure affect
individual health and organizational efficiency, but aviation safety. The aim of
31. Wickramasinghe, Vathsala, “Work-related Dimensions and Job Stress: The Moderating Effect of Coping Strategies”, Stress and Health, Volume 26, No.5, December 2010, pp.417-429.
32. Sun, Kuo-Shun Chiou, Hawjeng “Aviation Ground Crews: Occupational Stresses and Work Performance”, African Journal of Business Management, Volume 5, April 2011, pp. 2865 – 2873.
22
this study is to explore the relationship between various sources of
occupational stress and work performance. In this study, the connection among
a variety of occupational stress, coping strategies and work performance was
also explored, using the Structural Equation Modeling (SEM). The result of the
analysis exhibited that occupational stress had a negative impact on work
performance, and the coping strategies were the mediator survivals between
occupational stress and work performance. The findings of the study argued
that we can have a better understanding of the characteristic of aviation ground
crews and the causal relationship between occupational stress and work
performance, and the proposed model can be beneficial to improve the
practices of human resources management and the policies of relevant aviation
industries.
According to O'Neill, et al.,33 (2011), Employee stress is a significant
issue in the hospitality industry, and it is costly for employers and employees
alike. Although addressing and reducing stress is both a noble goal and is
capable of resulting in expense reductions for employers, the nature and
quantity of hospitality employee stress is not fully understood. The first aim of
this study was to identify common work stressors in a sample of 164
managerial and hourly workers employed at 65 different hotels who were each
interviewed for eight consecutive days. The two most common stressors were
interpersonal tensions at work and overloads (e.g., technology not functioning).
33. O'Neill, W.John, Davis, Kelly, “Work stress and well-being in the hotel industry”, International Journal of Hospitality Management, Volume 30, No. 2, June 2011, pp.385-390.
23
The second aim was to determine whether there were differences in the types
and frequency of work stressors by job type (i.e., managers versus non-
managers), gender, and marital status. Hotel managers reported significantly
more stressors than hourly employees. There were no significant differences by
gender or marital status. The third aim was to investigate whether the various
stressors were linked to hotel employee health and work outcomes. More
employee and coworker stressors were linked to more negative physical health
symptoms. Also, interpersonal tensions at work were linked to lower job
satisfaction and greater turnover intentions.
According To Wu, Yu-Chi,34 (2011), Prior empirical research
findings regarding the relationship between job stress and job performance are
inconsistent. It was argued in this study that one reason for these inconsistent
results may be an existing moderating effect. Stress does not always result
directly from the source of pressure itself, but rather from the perception of that
pressure. Therefore, individual difference variables (e.g., emotional
intelligence) that might relate to that perception should also be considered. The
effects of emotional intelligence on the relationship between job stress and job
performance were investigated with a sample of employees in the Taiwanese
finance sector. The results indicated that emotional intelligence had a positive
impact on job performance and moderated this relationship. In this respect,
highly emotionally intelligent employees are more likely than are low
34. Wu, Yu-Chi, “Job Stress and Job Performance among Employees on the Taiwanese Finance Sector: The Role of Emotional Intelligence”, Social Behavior and Personality, Volume 39, No. 1, 2011, pp.21-31.
24
emotional intelligence employees to be able to reduce or transform the
potential negative effects of job stress on job performance. The results of this
study clarify knowledge of stress effects and, thus, the usefulness of stress
management practices can be improved and enhanced.
From the review of literature, it is found that there are many surveys
and studies on sources of stress in a particular sector but not as a whole. There
is no separate study on stress management of women employees in private
sector. Hence, in this study, in addition to the analysis of sources of stress, an
attempt is also made to measure women employees’ stress in private sector.
1.5. SCOPE OF THE STUDY
The present study is confined to the prevalence of stress among the
women employees in private sector in Thoothukudi district only, even though
private sector is spread all over India. Further the study is mainly undertaken
from the view point of the women employees, even both men and women are
working in private sector. However data pertaining to the level of stress were
collected from the women employees of private sector concerned. The study is
limited to identify the occupational stress situation and perceived behavior
under such situations and also to assess the outcome of stress in private sector.
The study is confined to the analysis of occupational stress factors among such
women employees.
25
1.6. IMPORTANCE OF THE STUDY
This study assumes importance, because of the following reasons:
This study aims at identifying stressors in the workplace, which will
help management to remove or reduce them, thus ensuring increased efficiency
at the work place and general well-being of the individual. Secondly, the study
of individual characteristics in the stress process will necessarily throw light on
which type of individuals experience more stress. The identification of these
differences will help in training employees to modify their behavior, which will
help them to face stress in a better way. The results also will help in identifying
the type of training programs to be given to employees. Thirdly, in spite of
availability of scales to measure stress in the workplace, none take into account
the whole of the job. Some of them are too general or too myopic. Still others
are so medical or psychological in orientation that their use in organizations
may not be feasible. The scale that has been developed in this study used a
quite comprehensive topology of stress dimensions taking into account of all
the elements of the work of women employees in private sector.
1.7. NULL HYPOTHESES
The following are null hypotheses framed in the present study.
v The level of personality related stress management of private sector
women employees is independent of age.
v The level of personality related stress management of private sector
women employees is independent of education.
26
v The level of personality related stress management of private sector
women employees is independent of marital status.
v The level of personality related stress management of private sector
women employees is independent of type of family.
v The level of personality related stress management of private sector
women employees is independent of number of dependents.
v The level of personality related stress management of private sector
women employees is independent of monthly income.
v There is no significant difference among the mean scores of personality
related stress factors such as Job Culture and Climate, Health Outcomes,
Workload, Safe and Healthy Working Conditions, Family, Conditions and
Rewards, Operating Policies, Opportunity for Growth and Development,
Infrastructure, Supervision, Personal Conflict, Innovations and Changing
Development, Benefits and in total of private sector women employees
with respect to their age.
v There is no significant difference among the mean scores of personality
related stress factors such as Job Culture and Climate, Health Outcomes,
Workload, Safe and Healthy Working Conditions, Family, Conditions and
Rewards, Operating Policies, Opportunity for Growth and Development,
Infrastructure, Supervision, Personal Conflict, Innovations and Changing
Development, Benefits and in total of private sector women employees
with respect to their educational qualification.
27
v There is no significant difference between the mean scores of personality
related stress factors such as Job Culture and Climate, Health Outcomes,
Workload, Safe and Healthy Working Conditions, Family, Conditions and
Rewards, Operating Policies, Opportunity for Growth and Development,
Infrastructure, Supervision, Personal Conflict, Innovations and Changing
Development, Benefits and in total of private sector women employees
with respect to their marital status.
v There is no significant difference between the mean scores of personality
related stress factors such as Job Culture and Climate, Health Outcomes,
Workload, Safe and Healthy Working Conditions, Family, Conditions and
Rewards, Operating Policies, Opportunity for Growth and Development,
Infrastructure, Supervision, Personal Conflict, Innovations and Changing
Development, Benefits and in total of private sector women employees
with respect to their nature of family.
v There is no significant difference among the mean scores of personality
related stress factors such as Job Culture and Climate, Health Outcomes,
Workload, Safe and Healthy Working Conditions, Family, Conditions and
Rewards, Operating Policies, Opportunity for Growth and Development,
Infrastructure, Supervision, Personal Conflict, Innovations and Changing
Development, Benefits and in total of private sector women employees
with respect to number of dependents.
v There is no significant difference among the mean scores of personality
related stress factors such as Job Culture and Climate, Health Outcomes,
28
Workload, Safe and Healthy Working Conditions, Family, Conditions and
Rewards, Operating Policies, Opportunity for Growth and Development,
Infrastructure, Supervision, Personal Conflict, Innovations and Changing
Development, Benefits and in total of private sector women employees
with respect to monthly income.
1.8. DEFINITION OF CONCEPTS
1.8.1. PRIVATE SECTOR
The private sector undertakings are individuals or companies of
profit making. The private sector encompasses all for-profit businesses that are
not owned or operated by the government. Companies and corporations that
are run by government are the part of what is known as the public sector, while
charities and other nonprofit organizations are part of the voluntary sector.
Moreover the part of national economy is made up of private enterprises. It
includes private schools and colleges, hospitals, supermarket, textile
showrooms, jewellery mart, financial institutions, corporate sector, private
banking sector and private insurance sector, the personal sector (households)
and corporate sector (companies), and is responsible for allocating most of the
resources within an economy.
1.8.2. ORGANIZATIONAL CLIMATE
Properties of the business environment in a workplace observed by a
staff strongly influence their actions and job performance. For example, a
perceptive business manager might take the trouble to survey employees about
29
the organizational climate to identify and promote those aspects that are most
conducive to achieving corporate objectives.
1.8.3. SELF ESTEEM
Self-esteem is a term used in psychology to reflect a person's overall
emotional evaluation of his or her own worth. It is a judgment of oneself as
well as an attitude toward the self. Self-esteem encompasses beliefs and
emotions such as triumph, despair, pride and shame. Smith and Mackie define
it by saying "The self-concept is what we think about the self; self-esteem is the
positive or negative evaluations of the self, as in how we feel about it." Self-
esteem is also known as the evaluative dimension of the self that includes
feelings of worthiness, prides and discouragement. One's self-esteem is also
closely associated with self-consciousness.
1.8.4. STRESS
Stress is a term that is commonly used today, but has become
increasingly difficult to define. It shares, to some extent, common meanings in
both the biological and psychological sciences. Stress typically describes a
negative concept that can have an impact on one’s mental and physical well-
being, but it is unclear what exactly defines stress and whether or not stress is a
cause, an effect, or the process connecting the two. With organisms as complex
as humans, stress can take on entirely concrete or abstract meanings with
30
highly subjective qualities, satisfying definitions of both cause and effect in
ways that can be both tangible and intangible."35
1.8.4.1. Hyper Stress
This is another form of negative stress that occurs when the
individuals is unable to cope with the workload. Examples include highly
stressful jobs, which require longer working hours than the individual can
handle. If we suspect that we are suffering from hyper stress, we are likely to
have sudden emotional breakdowns over insignificant issues, the proverbial
straws that broke the cannel’s back. It is important to recognize that our body
needs a break, or we may feel end up with severe and chronic physical and
psychological reactions.
1.8.4.2. Hypo Stress
Hypo stress occurs when a person has nothing to do with his time
and feels constantly bored and unmotivated. This is due to an insufficient
amount of stress; hence some stress is inevitable and helpful to us. Companies
should avoid having workers who experience hypo stress as this will cause
productivity and mindfulness to fall. The job scope is boring and respective. It
would be a good idea to implement some form of job rotation so that there is
always something new to learn. The type of stress is named as eustress and
distress. Distress is the most commonly referred to type of stress, having
negative implications, whereas eustress is a positive form of stress usually
35. R.M.K. Keil, “Coping and stress: A conceptual analysis”, Journal of Advanced Nursing, Volume 45, No. 6, 2004, pp.659–665.
31
related to desirable events in person’s life. Both can be equally taxing on the
body, and are cumulative in nature, depending on a person’s way of adapting
to a change that has caused it.
1.8.5. CONTROL
Controlling is one of the managerial functions like planning,
organizing, staffing and directing. It is an important function because it helps
to check the errors and to take the corrective action so that deviation from
standards are minimized and stated goals of the organization are achieved in a
desired manner. According to modern concepts, control is a foreseeing action
whereas earlier concept of control was used only when errors were detected.
Control in management means setting standards, measuring actual
performance and taking corrective action.
1.8.6. WORKLOAD
Workload generally means the amount of work people have to or
are expected to complete. However workload is not just about the sheer
amount of work it may also mean: How difficult the work is – difficulty is
influenced by many factors including the skill level of staff. How much the
amount of workload varies (i.e. busy and quiet periods). The extent to which
staff have control over their workload and the way they choose to carry out
their work. The length of time for which staff have worked at an intense rate
without any breaks. Also, the nature of workload varies from job to job and it is
worth being aware of the special features of the workload experienced by those
people you manage. For example, some jobs may be repetitive, others may
32
require dealing with people, and others require staff to constantly undertake
new and unfamiliar tasks. Each of these features needs to be considered when
thinking about the kinds of steps you can take to help prevent and resolve
workload problems.36
1.8.7. ROLE AMBIGUITY
Role Ambiguity - norms for a specific position are vague, unclear
and ill-defined. Actors disagree on role expectations, not because there is role
conflict but because role expectations are unclear. Examples: job descriptions,
clinical objectives.37
1.8.8. ROLE CONFLICT
"Role conflict is a conflict among the roles corresponding to two or
more statuses." We experience role conflict when we find ourselves pulled in
various directions as we try to respond to the many statuses we hold.38
Conflict among the roles begins because of the human's desire to reach success,
and because of the pressure put on an individual by two imposing and
incompatible demands competing against each other. The effects of role
conflict, as found through case-studies and nationwide surveys, are related to
individual personality characteristics and interpersonal relations.39
36. Ronny Lardner Chiara Amati, Rob Briner, “Stress management standards for workload”, Edinburgh, pp.2
37. http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_is_role_ambiguity#ixzz1urFDYOCt
38. Macionis, Gerber, John, Linda, Sociology 7th Canadian Ed. Toronto, Ontario: Pearson Canada Inc. 2010. pp. 129.
39. R.L.Kahn, D.M.Wolfe, R.P.Quinn, J.D.Snoek, and R.A. Rosenthal "Orginizational stress: studies in role conflict and ambiguity", APA Psychnet. 2010.
33
1.8.8.1. Interpersonal Conflict
Interpersonal role conflict occurs when the source of the dilemma
stems from occupancy of more than one focal position. For example, as a
husband and a father in a social system a superintendent may think his wife
and children expect him to spend most of his evenings with them. However,
his school board, he may feel, expect him (as their school superintendent) to
spend most of his after-office hours on educational and civic activities. The
superintendent usually cannot satisfy both of these incompatible expectations.
1.8.8.2. Intra Personal Conflict
Intra-personal role conflict occurs when an individual in one role
believes that others have many different expectations for him/her in regards to
that role. "The school superintendent, for example, may feel that the teachers
expect him to be their spokesperson and leader, to take their side on such
matters as salary increases and institutional policy. However, the
superintendent may feel that the school board members expect him to
represent them, to "sell" their views to the staff because he is the executive
officer and the administrator of school board policies".40
1.8.9. DEPRESSION
Depression is the mental state of excessive sadness characterized by
persistently low mood or extensive loss of pleasure and interest. To be
considered a clinical condition, depression symptoms must have duration of at
40. B.A. Mackey, “Application of role conflict theory to the role expectations held for the dean of students by various reference groups”, Doctoral Dissertation, University of Florida, 1977.
34
least two weeks and include: decreases or sometimes increases in weight,
agitated or sluggish activity, and disturbance in sleep, appetite, and
concentration.
1.8.10. ANXIETY
Anxiety is an unpleasant state of inner turmoil and apprehension,
often accompanied by nervous behavior, such as pacing back and forth,
somatic complaints and rumination. It is the subjectively unpleasant feelings of
dread over something unlikely to happen, such as the feeling of imminent
death. Anxiety is feeling unrealistic fear, worry, and uneasiness, usually
generalized and unfocused. It is often accompanied by restlessness, fatigue,
problems in concentration, and muscular tension. Anxiety is not considered to
be a normal reaction to a perceived stressor although many feel it occasionally.
When anxiety becomes overwhelming and distressing to the sufferer, it may
fall under the psychiatric diagnosis of anxiety disorder. Anxiety is not the same
as fear. Fear is evoked by a realistic danger and is an appropriate response to a
perceived threat, while anxiety is worry or overreaction to a situation that is
only subjectively seen as menacing. Anxiety is the sense of uneasiness that is
experienced in the individual’s relationships with other people. In any situation
where the person’s vanity is undermined, fear arises. The conjunction of this
fear with the vanity creates anxiety.
Anxiety = Fear + Vanity
35
1.9. METHODOLOGY
This Section exhibits the methodology which includes the collection
of data, construction of structured questionnaire, sampling design, fieldwork
and the framework of analysis.
1.9.1. COLLECTION OF DATA
The present study is mainly based on both primary data and
secondary data. Personal interview method is used to collect the primary data
with the help of questionnaire. The secondary data have been collected from
standard books, journals, and websites.
1.9.2. CONSTRUCTION OF QUESTIONNAIRE
The instrument used for the study was a structured questionnaire. It
compresses into two sections. The first section relates to the demographic
factors and the second section consists of occupational stress scales.
Occupational stress scales were used for identifying the stress level. Altogether
thirteen factors are categorized like job culture and climate, health outcomes,
workload, safe and healthy working conditions, family, conditions and
rewards, operating policies, opportunity for growth and security,
infrastructure, supervision, personal conflicts, innovations and changing
development and benefits. The above factors are supported with ten statements
for answering by the sample respondents.
1.9.3. SAMPLING DESIGN
The researcher visited the respective office premises of the private
sector organization/institution. Permission was denied to meet the women
36
employees inside the office during working hours. The only alternative
available for the researcher was to meet the respondents when they come out of
the office. With hard difficulty the researcher could persuade 600 women
employees from different private sector organization/institution to get the
required information within the scheduled time frame. With a view to
analyzing the level of stress among women employees in private sector 600
women employees were selected as sample respondents. Adequate cares has
been taken to include the various types of women employees working in the
private sector as samples. The personal profile of the respondents shows that
the universe of study is represented by various backgrounds relating to age,
educational qualification, marital status, type of family, number of dependents,
and income of women employees. A pilot study was conducted with the help
of the questionnaire to test its contents and modifications were made on the
basis of the study. The researcher has collected primary data on the basis of the
following ways:
Table 1.1
Distribution of Sample Unit
S.No. Name of the Institution Sample size
1 Private Schools and Colleges (self-financing) 100
2 Private Hospitals 100
3 Super Market, Textiles Show Rooms and Jewellery Mart 100
4 Financial Institutions, Corporate Sectors 100
5 Private Banking Sector 100
6 Private Insurance Sector 100
Total 600
37
Now a-days private sector means not only corporate sector but also
other sectors like Educational Institutions, Hospitals, Super Markets, Textile
Show Rooms, Jewellery Marts, Financial Institutions, Companies, Banking
Sector and Insurance Sector. So stress may occur in any field, in any levels of
management and also in any circumstances. It depends upon the person as well
as the working environment. On the above basis, primary informations were
collected for analyzing the stress level of women employees. Stratified random
sampling is used. The sample respondents were randomly selected.
1.9.4. FIELD WORK
The researcher carried out the field work for this study during the
period from April 2012 to September 2012. Questionnaire was given to the
private sector women employees. Questionnaire was explained to the
respondents in detail for understanding the importance of the research.
Adequate time was given to the respondents to provide their opinions for the
questions in the questionnaire.
1.9.5. FRAME WORK OF ANALYSIS
The information collected from the sample respondents were
tabulated for analysis. Simple tables were prepared for understanding the
general profile of the respondents.
Simple Percentage Analysis
Simple percentage analysis refers to a ratio. With the help of
absolute figures it will be difficult to interpret any meaning from the collected
38
data, but when percentages are found out then it becomes easy to find the
relative difference between two or more attributes.
Percentage = sRespondent of No. Total
sRespondent of No.
The data have been analyzed by using various statistical tools like
percentage analysis, Likert’s scaling technique, chi-square test, analysis of
variance (ANOVA), weighted arithmetic mean and Garret’s ranking technique,
correlation, and the like. The collected data were analyzed with the help of
percentage analysis, to find out the conditions of descriptive statistics. The co-
efficient of variation was applied to get the extent of variations during the
study period. To measure the level of stress and the opinion of the sample
respondents the Likert’s five point scales was applied. Chi-square test was
applied to find out the relationship between demographic factors and the level
of stress. Garret’s ranking technique was used to rank the problems faced by
the sample respondents. Arithmetic mean was also used to measure the factors.
To analyse the personality stress factors with respect to their socio-economic
factor, ‘t’ test and ANOVA (‘F’ test) were applied.
Weighted Average Method
The weighted mean is a mean where there is some variation in the
relative contribution of individual data values to the mean. Each data value (Xi)
has a weight assigned to it (Wi). Data values with larger weights contribute
more to the weighted mean and data values with smaller weights contribute
less to the weighted mean. The formula of Weighted Average is
39
Weighted Average = sRespondent Total
)(Frequency x s)Respondent of (No.
S
Sor
i
ii
W
XW
S
S
There are several reasons why one might want to use a weighted
mean. Each individual data value might actually represent a value that is used
by multiple people in the sample. The weight then is the number of people
with that particular value. The sample might deliberately over represent certain
segments of the populations. To restore balance, one would place less weight
on the over represented segments of the population and more weight on the
less represented segments of the population. Some values in the data sample
might be known to be more variable (less precise) than other values. One
would place greater weight on those values known to have greater precision.
Likert Scaling
The level of attitude varies from one respondent to another. Attitude
cannot be measured directly in quantitative terms. Hence, the researcher has
used five point scale for measuring the level of attitude of the respondents in
Thoothukudi district.
Measurement of Attitude
The researcher has made an attempt to measure the extent of
attitude of the women employees towards occupational stress with the help of
an attitude scale. In the present study, 15 components have been identified to
measure the attitude of women employees towards occupational stress.
40
Level of Stress
The researcher has made use of the Likert scale to measure the
attitude of the respondents towards occupational stress. The Likert scale is one
of the most widely used attitude scaling technique. The score given to the
various degrees are as follows:
Strongly agree – 5, Agree – 4, No opinion – 3, Disagree – 2, strongly
disagree - 1
The total score of each respondent is obtained by adding scores that
has received for 15 statements. From the total score obtained by adding the
individual scores obtained by the 600 respondent’s, arithmetic mean and
standard deviation have been calculated. The different levels of attitude have
been calculated as follows:
High level attitude = Arithmetic Mean (+) Standard Deviation.
Low level attitude = Arithmetic Mean (-) Standard Deviation
Medium level attitude = scores varying between high level satisfaction and low
level satisfaction.
Relationship between Demographic Variables of the Women Employees and Level
of Stress
In this section an attempt is made to analyze the relationship
between women employees demographic background like age, education,
marital status, type of family, number of dependents, and monthly income and
their level of attitude by using chi-square test.
41
The chi-square test aims at comparing the observed data with the
expected data. The formula for the chi-square test is as follows:
c2 (r-1, c-1) = å-
-
ji ij
2
ijij
E
)EO(
where Oij – Observed value in the ijth cell
Eij – Expected value in the (ij)th cell.
R = number of rows in the contingency table.
C = number of columns in the contingency table.
On the assumption of independence of attributes,
Eij = N
)B)(A( ji
Where Ai = total of ith row
Bj = Total of jth column.
N = Total number of observations
If the calculated value is greater than the table value at a particular
confidence level (0.05 levels), the null hypothesis will be rejected. If the
calculated value is less than the table value at a particular confidence level (0.05
levels) the null hypothesis will be accepted.
Correlation
The Karl Pearson’s co-efficient of correlation is denoted by the
symbol “r”. Correlation measurement is used for describing the degree and
42
direction of the relation between two variables. The formula used for
measuring the degree of relationship between two variables is
r = ( )( )2222 )y(yN)x(xN
yxxyN
å-åå-å
åå-å
where N = Number of sample
x = Raw score for the first group
y = Raw score for the second group
The value of the coefficient of correlation always lies between -1 and
+1. When r = +1, it means that there is perfect positive correlation between the
variables. When r =-1, it means that there is perfect negative correlation
between the variables. When r = 0, it means that there is no relationship
between the two variables.
Analysis of Variance
Analysis of variance was developed by R.A.Fisher and a test so
developed by him is known as the Fisher’s test or more commonly as F- test.
Now-a day, F-test is widely used in the analysis of variance. It is mainly used to
test the hypothesis of equality between two variances. This test is also used to
test the hypothesis of equality amongst several means. This test is particularly
suitable for experimental work, as no assumption of equality of variance is
required. The analysis of variance is mainly carried on under: (i) one-way
classification.
F = samples within Variance
samplesbetween Variance
43
Generally the variance between samples is greater than the variance
within samples. Sometimes, in rare cases, the variance within samples may be
greater than the variance between samples. In such cases the two variances
should be interchanged so that the value of F is always greater than one. This
can be achieved by taking the value of the numerator always greater than that
of the denominator. The ANOVA test is used to test whether there is any
significant difference between the demographic factors and the occupational
stress. This analysis is applied when the variables are in internal scale and the
numbers of groups in the sample are more than 29. In the present study, the
“F” statistics have been computed to find out the association between mean
agreeability scores on job factor & job culture and climate, health outcomes,
workload, safe and healthy working conditions, family, conditions and
rewards, operating policies, opportunity for growth and security,
infrastructure, supervision, personal conflict, innovations and changing
developments, benefits among women employees. Whenever ‘F’ is found to be
significant, Scheffe’s test was applied to find out which of the paired means
had significant difference.
Ranking Principle
“Henry’s Garrett ranking principle” has been applied to find out the
reasons for stress. The order of merit given by the respondents for the ten
statements is converted into ranks. For each reason, the scores of individual
respondents are added together and divided by the total number of
44
respondents. The mean scores for all the reasons are arranged in the
descending order and ranks are given in the order of importance.
1.10. LIMITATION OF THE STUDY
The study had to be conducted within a given time frame. The data
were collected only among the segment taken for study in a specific area-
Thoothukudi District. The results may vary if other segments are also
considered for the study or a different area is undertaken. Only the women
employees within the Thoothukudi District limits were considered.
Unmarried women employees are outnumbered. So they are not
differentiated.
Due to mental stress and workload, the respondents could not freely
express their feelings. As the employer did not permit the employees to answer
the questionnaire in the work place. Parents also do not permit their wards to
answer questions. Hence the researcher contacted the respondents only outside
their work place. The researcher has conducted the survey with the
respondents only during the travelling time from office to their residences and
vice versa. Furthermore, the time available is not adequate to persuade the
respondents to answer all the relevant questions after impressing upon the
importance of the research and sophisticating their co-operation to participate
in the research.
45
1.11 CHAPTER SCHEME
The study entitled “A Study on Stress Management of Private Sector
Women Employees in Thoothukudi District” has been organized in six
chapters.
The first chapter “Introduction and design of the study” comprises
Introduction, Statement of the problem, Objectives, Review of literature, Scope
of the study, Importance of the study, Hypotheses of the study, Definition of
concepts, Methodology, Collection of Data, Construction of Questionnaire,
Sampling design, Fieldwork, Framework of Analysis, Limitations of the study
and chapter scheme.
The second chapter exhibits detailed profile of the study area and
theoretical frame work of stress.
The third chapter elaborately deals with assessment of personality
related stress factors of private sector women employees.
The fourth chapter consists of descriptive analysis of socio-
economic factors and also deals with the level of stress factors and socio-
economic factors.
The fifth chapter analyses the personality related stress factors of
the sample respondents with respect to their socio-economic factors.
The sixth chapter is devoted to present the summary of findings,
suggestions and conclusion.