Title 公立高等学校における学校安全と危機管理に関する一考察 : アンケート調査の分析から

Author(s) 下地, 敏洋

Citation琉球大学教育学部教育実践総合センター紀要 = Bulletin ofFaculty of Education Center for Educational Research andDevelopment(24): 89-100

Issue Date 2017-03

URL http://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12000/37046

Rights

-7 :/ Jr- }-i!M1!tO)~tJTiP b­

T±ru~¥$

A Study on the School Safety and Risk Management in Public High Schools : Characteristics of Answers by Principals

Toshihiro SHilVlO]I

Abstract

Purpose of the Study: This paper is to report the result of current status and the issues on the school safety and the risk

management in public high schools in Okinawa.

Design and Methods: The questionnaires were sent to 60 public high school principals in Okinawa by mail. Questions

included in the field of the current status and the issues on the school safety, and the risk management Respondents

W=55) completed the questionnaire on the types of issues of the school safety and the risk management which schools

have faced, and seminars or lectures principals would like to give teachers.

Results: Thirty-eight principals would like to give their teachers seminars or lectures focused on how to deal with the

accidents and incidents at schools on the legal basis. Thirty-five principals also hoped the emergency measures to give to

teachers. Principals also recommended teachers take the seminars on the traffic accidents and how to deal with the victims

of crimes suffering from the Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PfSD) . As issues to give effective lectures to teachers, the

principals mentioned that securing the required the number of classes, the budget, the human resources are very

important to give seminar lectures.

Implications: The school safety and risk management are essential for principals to give students meaningful school life

to enjoy at schools. Therefore, principals and schools should pay much more attention to school safety through seminars or

lectures for teachers. To secure schools' safety, schools and communities should also cooperate each other because they

are interdependent resources for students and teachers.

Keywords: School Safety, Risk Management, Public High Schools, Seminal; Principals

:f--?- F : ·~~f:l3ttc~, 1J A 7 ""<-*:;; / r, 0:s'ri\11i~W, -UJffl~, ~-.N:

1 . lei: t:N>I= W-c:!'i, !Jt.~1:.fiEI'i'.WI~ft:~-zoft:,L., L ""C~A:6~1f!lll:%~f*~l6h6£,~il~ib6o WfR

ft:~r~ (2015) O)m-~-c:~-t ~:to 19, rwf~:tolt 6~1ff1Sibil~ft:~t,t!l\l:%f~:tov '-c~:Mff6hJ

6.::. ~, &T.J r!}t.~1:.fiE~O)ft:~0)1itf:lil:il~~ Gh6J .::. ~ il~¥~~-c::Q::b9 Gh -cv '6o .::. 0).::. ~ !'i, Wf~!'i~l!J!rO))'r,~1:.fiEO)ft:~f*~~~O)i!A~;:il~G, -{-0)1:.1frJ&T.JJitf*O)ft:~0)1itf*f~M L -c, JHE:il~ib6.::. ~ il~~6h -cv '6o !J?i:f~, ft:~O)iitf:lil:l'i, )'r.~1:.fiEil~W~1f~f*~im L -c, ~

-89-

'#tJ~:Q::~~-1±6 C: C: tl~, 1§~--c:'~ 6Ar~'~9~1*~tlf~ L, 1fi!il"< AO)JrufJ~15Jfllg·~1~1m:tl::~i±6 :: C: C', 1:.MJ6)¥0)/Jj(~fJI~fct6 C: ~;t Gh6o

~f::_, ~C'-1!f~*i!iY:~il~J61:. L -ct, ~&V~-f*1!f;6~~Jf.Jlitl~%tf.t-961§~~1*iJ~1itft~ tL -cv '6:: C: C', -{-O)~~~JI~ul,~l!l~~v 'll::~6:: C: ~~J:: '?, ~EG!i1:.fJEii~ 13 "< O)~C~m~l~'tl:'C..' L -cJ& '? *Jltr:: C: ~~-Jf,t;6~6:: C: ~~fct6 C: ~;t Gh6o ~il (2013 : 2) li, l'ft:~fctt±~~~:m

T 6:: C: li, --t-r<-cO)A"< il~1:.~ 6l:C':l&tlli*I¥JiJ~-J~15J.J;:f,t:. C: J b£r<-c:to '?, 'te~lit±

~~~~15J.J;:f,t~1tfC'iYJ 6 C:t~t~Ni L -cv '6o:. 0):. C: li, ~~1fO)~~~:tov '-c t1JiJ:71-C'lif,tlt 'ZJ~, (:'O)J:: 5 f,t:jj(~~'ti:~C'iYJ6 C: JE~C'~ 60)fC.6 5 Zl\

~il (2013 : 4) I±, 'tl:~~ 1*1* · *i'ifc&VJ».~ <1B<~) O)~mx~~ t-6:. e: O)fctv ':I*~J C'iYJ6 C: IE~ L, IJ».~~t f::_ G-9*1!f • *i!ij:O)J61:.~1li5li::T 6:: C: iJ~, 'te~~1it{lF:T 61:--c:':l&t :i=~C'iYJ6J :. C: C: I7JiJ~--1tj: • *i!iY:iJ~961:. Lf::_tie't, 1Bz~O)J61:.~:1Jt::k~lli5<'':. C: iJ~C' ~ 6:1*~J 0) 2,~iJ~'te~~~;t6J::C', :i=~C'iYJ6 C:~r<-cv '6o

J!I1¥, ±11!. • $)1$(, -6'$.1., ~cp~ffi!ct C:''O) § Mi».~il~J61:.-9 6 let e:··, ~C't!JG!il1:.fJE"O)fl:

~~~~1'Tv ', 'ft:~O):pt{lF:I~~~-cv '6o f:O)f::_~, 13 :>sn~Gill~iJ~-JI¥J1itfct·l~¥a!J3(~&V:5t tfr~V~~~Jittr~1'Tv \ ~Jt!JG!il1:.fJE"-O)}~~~PH*fctMf.t~T 6 f::_~, ?fm!1!f~r:p,c.,,l~~iJ~*Jl

MIJtC: L -c~Jru-96:. C: iJ~:I:~C: fct0-cv'6o ~~, ~ · ,1, • cp · r'i'll~~rl=l~bi", ~~EG!i1:.fJEii~~~~'itL6*1*~*i'ifcli~~1~rttH~iYJ6o

!f.J:I~, ~€l~iVJO)lf!.~iJ~G1:.fJEii~:!f':~T61Wii~~C'Ii, :!t:~a~&®~iVJO)'ft:~1it{lF:Iil!G,~C:fct

0-c1t'6o ~t=, ~~cpO)Jr.fctGi"1i5c~f~O)~t\5~cr, :!f':r~a~fct.!::', a~r~'~9~Jtm~rl=l~bi",

~rf'J:7j-O)lt 'f=6 C::. 6 C'*1!f~*i'ifc;6~J61:. L -cv '6o 17'1$1±, 1fi!il"< 0)1:_{JEO)~fi:~~~IZSI C:-96 *i!iY:, ~tJ1t~fct C:''1:.1JEri'l90) r- 7 7'';v, 1:.fJE e: ~ffi!r~'~90)1*fil~~tJ1t~, ~;m:11r1~ J:: 6~17'11~A, ±lli-~$)1$lf,t e:·· § Mf».~O)J61:_f,t C:'~t!IS(I~bf=0 -cv '6o 1t 'Th0)-7-Al~:tov '-c t, ~fjlJjO)

ill~C'I¥J1itfct·l~¥a!J3(~, M1*~M"-O)!f41Jl%Jr.t& ~Jittflil!G,~C'iYJ '? , !f.J:I~~*~r:p,c.,, C: T 6?f :@~O)f(t~?f:@fllgfJ~Jt1f:li'te~1it{lF:O)J::C'~"<:i=~f,t'bO) C: f,t0-cv '6o -{-O)f::_~, ~~O)t~

¥a!J3(~, 1:.fJE& Vf:lF:~1!f~VI~±llii!ilG1±~"-0)fl:~~~ C: ~tJfft~I~:JJo ;t, flt~?fm!~~ C: %fJ;t~ ;Wii~6 f::_~O)~ffi{1iJf1i_~0)~1iflif,t C:'', -{-O))(t);t~t~#Rfct t 0) C: f,t0 -cv '6 ~·l~iJ~iYJ6o ~~. v'C~~W-IZSIC:-96§~~§~*~*~~~x~M-f*~~IZSIC:-96*~*i'ifct~L-c

:to'?, ~C:f:lF=~1lf0)~1$fct·i~¥aO)::tt;.~~m~tJfctC:''M-f*~M~B-~t=~~il~-Jill~fct%TJ;tii~

:1<~ GtL -c1t '6o -J'i '?, *1**J'ifcO)il'J$?J:.:mC'fi~~~m~Jt&V±llii!ilGO)mif-!I:Mf*~M~C: O)Jf m~tJO):i=~·~iil~r'i'IJ < f,t0 -cv '6o

f,t;to, tl'f~0):7'o-/~Jv1t:&Vr'i'13Ji:-i~¥a1t::t±~0)~~~~1-tv\ #l¥:71-~W1,~C:T6-1 /7 ;v:r./ -if!ct c:-~~~. 7mil:il'#1:.0)7mil:)t&V~~t Ani/'#1:.0)1:.Ti§-~·I:I:O)J!fi1t '~~IZSI C:-96 t-7:1';v ~~%TT 6tf'l~&Vt~~~V~~~Jittr, #l¥:71-1iJf11$:1*1'J)IGI~:to~t 6*1!f*i!ij:O)%JJ;t~~O):)({t;, ¥~1-$,

~·l:l:~~mf Lf::_l:C'%JJ;t-96:. C: tl!G,~C'iYJ '? ,~1f~J& '? ~< ~fjtt :~ro-/~;vft: L -c~t=o -11, Y~C'I±iYJ6il~~ffi!r~'~90) ~A ::1 ~ ::1-::::..-7"-~ 3 Y~~IZSI C:-96 t-77'';vii~J61:.-96-7-

A tiYJ '?, ?fm!1!fi~J::613 "<O)~H~&Vtf'l~~VI~WJ§~tl!G,~C: f,t0-cv'6o r'i'IJ~~~~

:tov '-cl±, ~ffi!r~'~90) ~A ::1 ~ ::1-::::..-7"-~ 3 /~ t-7f;v~~IZSI e: -9 6 5 -Jmfct e:··m~f*Hilli~~IZSI C: f,t 6 C: O)wa1~)ffi:W: 'b lYJ 6o

:.O)J:: 51~, ~1JliL !f.J:I~?fm!~iJ~~'te~~~?fm!O)tJt~l~ft0-c, 1:.fJE~~ffi!~~~'te

~~$l~T6f=~~~f,t-9r<~Mr.tl±~t!IS(I~bt::_0-cv'60)iJ~:m:I*C'iYJ6o ~~il~G~'te~~

~?fm!O)tJt~l~ft'i:J, ~il'l~tJ!&®U~, ~ffi!C: O)[ID~~~iffi L -c, :l*r£tE~&"CF$1!f*i'ifc

O)*fAiliJJJ:I~~bi)6 :_ C: iJ~:i=~C'lYJ6o :. 0) J:: 5 fct:l*t£0)cp, #~~IWi'!,il'J;Wii~~~~:to~t 6~'te~V~?fm!O):m:l*~~~fE~ L,

-90-

Jlll~J::.:)(t-9 Q;p]f{~OY(£ V) 1Jli:: ~;to l-'"(, )e;t};t~li::~;tQ .::_ ~ l'i 1J A~ • '? ;:f-:/ ;/- / ~--~~ 7 ..{ :/ 7- ·-? ;:f-:/ ;J. / r (l)tJ!A~\iPG "6:1:~--z:;bQo f:(l),:_ ~ l'i, ${tj: • $i!ij:(7)~1?Jjll:&Vi¥Jitf~)(t);t

*~ t~ VJ, WC~~%(7):=JE~&V~~it{:l¥d::.*-9-TQ "6(7)~~*-Qo

;$::~;5(7) § i¥J l'i, ~~tl V~~J.!IH::.M-t Q,JiJf{~(7)~1ifiH::.~ L--c, #;f!I!!Jf!d:kJ (7) !Ji'tftr'i'D~~ ftil~Wc~t::.M L--c!f.ft::.~,~t~ ~ ~;tQ:fiJHI$r:kJ$(7)~:i*&V~li:fflW-t Q.::. ~, $14= • $~361:. ~(l)~~J~t::.:tov \-c, ~n~Mr,t-z:~ QH(l)~J't~t &v-m:IX ~~li::fflW L-, 4-f&(l):)(tr,t~t::.

-J\.t \'"(~ij\j 9'-Q .::_ ~ -z:ibQo

2. J!lff/jj1f #;f!I!J,!f!;:sL~~~ft 60 !6 t::.)(t L--c, 'itf--l-1 ~ 'itf--1- 2 (7)/ Y-7- HJlB!I::mli:tB* L-, §l~li:*

~ L- t::o ~nm:M r10, l'i, .l:JLJJX; 28 ~ 9 ftl 5 13 n ~ G 9 ftl 29 13 * -z: ~ L- t::o WFJJ~ l'i, 'itf--1- 1 (7) 4 rj § -z:, ~~tllf~~~m!~~(l)-liJff~t::.--=>v \-c, CD r~~tllf~~~m!t::.M L--c, -~(l)Wc~~ t::.~,~~~-liJffl$1:tfiiJt~ ~ }f!!,v \ * -tn~ (fi~~t.R.) J, ® r~~tl -a~~~m!~(7)-liJffl$"1i::~nm-t

Q~(l)~lifiiJt~~}f!!,v\*-tn~ (fi~~t.R.)J l:t~t.R.~~~c.Jili:, ® r:t:(7)fi:!1, .-~-z:(l)~~tl

-a~~~m!t::.M-t Q,JiJff~t::.--=>v \-c, :toYJ.---:5~ (7).::. ~ n~ib VJ '* L-t:: G, =:lett< t~~ v \J l:t~c.Jili:,

@ r~~H~(l)}~\~Jl: § 7 :r. /' ~ 1) A r J l'iO X (l)~l\tt::.J: V) §l~li::>f<IJi)f::o ~j!;Eli::*~ l-t::r'i'D~

~ 60 ~!fl55 ~(l)~ftJ: VJ §l~n~ib VJ, §lli)($1'i 91.7% -z:ib--:d::o

3. ta:!l! o~~~&~m:•••~tt0)81::?t. '"C

( 1 ) ~~~&~m:-'IJII::IJ!I"t .f,Mft1::~~81::?L '"t' <*lUm.iil'> Cal .. ftft) r~~tllf~~~m!I::.M L--c, •~(7)Wc~~~::.~,~~~-liJffl$1'ifiiJt~~,lf!!,v\'*-tn~J 1::.

M L--c, r~1::.:to1t Q${4= • $~1::.M-tQJt{£~(7)f~i¥JtlH9l1J I::.M-tQ-liJf{l$il~ 38 ftf:~~ "6~<. JJ-r rr,t~-=F~J 35ft!=, rx:~m$~J 27ft!=, r~~~,r,,(7)Q-7J 1714=, r~!!~rE(~J

14{tf:, r7J<(7)$~J 7{4=, r:t:(7)fi:!1J 4{tj:~t~-::>-cv\Qo r:t:(7)fi:!1J (l)§J~I'i, r~~~~

L- -c ~,~ ~ ,lf!!,;bnQP9$t:t~m~n -cv \QJ, rn~f9J-liJff~J, r~~§JJM;e:~. illifJ(l)~JJX:J

r :tt!Jo/.J7 v ;v:¥-t::.)e;t-9 Q)\tf,t, ${tj:(7);fE(~tf • 1JO~tf-(7),t,,(7)Q-7~ J -z:ib-::> t::o

< 2 > ~~~&~m:•••~tt0)8~~1il!i-t .f,§O)BB <*lUm.iil'> <a 2 ••> r~~tllf~~~m!~~(l)-liJff~li:~nm-t Q~(l)~Mt:tfiiJt~ ~ ,lf!!,v \'*-tn~J (fi~§l

~) 1::.ML--c, rn~rl'l,(l)itf;~u I::.M-tQ~nqlftJ:~~'b~<, JJ-r r-rJf(l)itf*J 16 ftJ:, r~ft~ffl(l)it{;~J 15 {tf:, r:t:(7)fi:!1J 2 {tj:~t~-::>-cv\Qo r:t:(7)fi:!1J (l)§J~I'i, r1:.ft(7);e:~~

J!j!!:J ~ r!f,fl::.f~lt \j -z:ib-::>f::o ( 3) ~~~&~m:-'IJII::IJ!I"t .f,~tii::?L '"t'

r f:(7){i:!1, -~--z:(l)~~tllf~~m!I::.M-tQ:fiJHI$1::.--:>It\'"(, :f-:>Yr---:5~(7).::_ ~ iJi;b VJ'*L-f::G, =:'~cit<t~~lt\J t::.)(t-tQ§l~l'i, {jz(l)~:f-:JVJ-z:ibQo

CD~~~I::.M L--c, ;ts::~l'i1:.ft(7)1±\/\ VJ 1=1 n~fi~ ( 5 n~m) ib VJ, ~1::.?2:v \-cv \Q :IX~t~(7)-z:)rl-$n~G "6/\ VJ ~Tv\ (!5c±IM~!.tv \f::IJl), imJfl~~~'J:IWJ:fJJ( L--cv \Q)

®~~tl Lf~~~m!I::.M-t Q,JiJf{l$1'i, /Ft-F$1l1Jll:)(t~(7)-~ ~ J.r-t~ L-, We~~ (7){~~ ~ ~fi11:Jl:Q:, Wl=WlFJl~MI::.M!knt~n~ G 1J 7- ~ • -y ::f-:/ ;J. / r (7)fr&Jl£li:fJ£:-tr:kJ$1::.t~-::> -cv \Qo

@~~~m!I::.M-t Q,JiJf{~l'i, fii!Jli:f* 5 ~ll&-liJf{~li:!fl,t,,l::.~tiWTQ .::_ ~ -z::l:~t~ ~ ~;tQo fii!JI::.TQ .::_ ~ -z:, ~~m!li::~~TQ .::_ ~ -z:, ~~(l);e:~(l)f'i'Dijif;:~i,)iQo

@~~ (7),jjJf{I$(7)J.;.f~ G f', ~m!tf(l);p]f{~li::lt~ L--c li L-It\

@~4, r~~~m!(l)f!IIH!J iJiJ.tiJi-::>'"(v\QJ:?I::.~CQo !f.fl::., ..{/::$7-;:fy r~-!f--1/'~

-91-

~~[!.!1H:~TQ'~'A'¥a#;f[O)f;:_6l)O)li]f{@:!i, ~.i!!R~£,§l!-c'(bQ C: ~;tQa @f[!;~~m!?::::. :::t- 7 JvO) 5!00: L-& Vfr&~o cv~~;f:~O)iWit£o

®~~f:J:£,-f'L- 'b~f;:lt 'Qa~t:Jtf;:~::_ QO)-c'f'it,t<, ~];:It 'Qa~~~-Ft:5<:a~O)PJ"fili·~'b

ib I?' -{-O)Jlll? {riD?,~""('~ Q~-~iliil~W\ L-It\ @¥-f(;:f,t l-o ( 4 ftf:) @1F:~~:fJJI;:fr!:~~m!? ::=.:::t- 7 Jv-c'Mr.t::r1it:=-NT QZl~. 1iJf{@:O)a~r~9{r1itf*T Q :=_ C: il~- L-It 'a @~@·~~0)1i}f{@:fj:~f7ErP11tO)~@:tc:£:~-~15{r@ L- -c~~-"0)1iJf{@:!;:~iJ~--=> -cv 'Qo ~[!.~

tN~f;:--::>lt '-c 'b~ff-!j-~~ J-.t /?'~~-~ffiO)~f7Et~~~-~151;:~~~il~~;IJO L--cv 'Qo 'J3. t:., J;t~-=F~~~;:--::>It '-cl:t~~~RWiil~Hil!IT:sl:~L- -c AED ~-~{rf'T--=>-cv 'Q 0

@~~m!l;:--::>tt ,-c~~~O);f:~il~+:S1-C: lilt ,;tf,tv '0)-c';f:~~!Hl::rlzh -cv ,~ t:.v \ ®~:tc:£:, fr!:~~m!~O)~fi.fs:I¥Jf,t~JII~::r~:lifli-t-Qa~r~90)1itf*il~• L-v \

@.IJZIJX: 26 ~~J: I? l~:tc:i:fi.'fs:i!JIJH*~J'Et~Ji::~J C: L--ci& I? Ulv-c':Jo I?, ~~~-c' ~TTQo tX~~J;1,~1f:O)l& I? fJl]f.il~:=_;h'J3.-c'IRJ#R!;:*-m-c:~ QZl~~- 5 il~~C: L- -c7j;Qo

®*-I~f@:-c'~Ji-9 Q1i}ffl~t,r*-I~ L--cv 'Q~~il~$1t \ ®~:tc:£:, fr!:~~m!0)1iJf{@:l:t~:±1l~f-t~-c:§tlt-cv'Qil~~~~flz:-c::£:~~§t~•-rQfi.fs:ill'J

il~~ 5 C: J: It \ @;;$:~~~j:~~ri;!;:--::>lt '-c~:Jifli l..-f:.o {i:!10)1i}f{l~ (ij~~. A ]-.VA, 36)¥~:;~, fiVj.j1i}f{@:) b

ib I?, a~r~90)1Jtf*il~::k~-c'ibQo

@±:WJ>~~~lJ:-"O)J& '? *JI.Jj.iJ~£,§l!""('(bQo @)fr!;~~m!? ::=.:::t- 7 JvO)J'i(lt L-l;:f*Qffl@;il~£,§l!C: ~;tQo ®•~1¥ · #lfJ::-c:ftb:hQ~~~~;::Jolt Q~~m!"? ::=.:::t- 7 ;vO)*H&Vwil~il~*~

:JifliO)f;:_61), ~;{_ Q C: C: b ~;:_~~ 0)1i}f{l~{rfT 5 £,§l!iJ~ i!tJ Qo @fr!;~~m!? ::=.:::t- 7 JvO)~~iE&V!l!tfil~£,§l!-c'ibQo

@~.=_~tm (q:JWJm, ~r~9Jm, imf§i!JIJ) r~90)JifJM~£,§l!-c'ibQo

o•MO)~Jit-Tz·!l? 1JA. H=-=>L'"C §1~0)9=J-c:, xtr.t-r ~ v 7 v A r- O)§J~;flf;: x I=IJO)rJi § -c:-:i=$v 't O)l:t, r~~ 15 r ~f7E

m~J::O)~r~~M!;:X;JJ;t-t-Q~f*~~O)!) A J-.il~--::>< G:h -cv'QJ 0) 14~ (25.5%) -c'ib--=>f:.o J;I,r, r~~ 11 rm;;fll:~f*~~~e:O)Ji~fi.fs:illiJt~~-c:~-c~.-,QJ 11~ (2o.o%), r~~ 14 rw~~ ~~1f. fi;fli:~f*~~ e: li~m~~~ <~ftm~:±f£) 1:t~~~~~O)~ r::1 O)m~~~ ::rtE~

L.-cv'Qj 10~ (18.2%) -c'ib--::>t:.a r~91 lfi)f:(£/fl3}t *JMO)~tJilq~~;:< <li~il~C: '?!;: < v', ~~:7!-0)~:&~f*~;:/f:tct~~ibQ1:f7EO)JE~iJ~-c:~-c~.-,QJ, r~~ 1 ~~~~~1*~~0)1::

f7E~r:J{r1:f7E:JoJ:Vf*~~~;:~Git-cv'QJ, r~9 12 l~f*~~""t§~ · im¥RTQrk1$~iJ~~ r:kJ-c:#im:f:!M~6n-cv'QJ 0)3rJi§l:t-{-:h-{'':h8~ (14.5%), r~~s I9=J~il~G0)51*-1aH'A'

¥ail~iltJJI;:~m!6:h, ~f*~~r~9-c:#;ff6:h -cv 'QJ 7 ~ (12.7%) -c'ib--=>f:.o -1J, :£:~1;:Qi=IJO)§J~O)£b--=>t:.:rJi§ l'i, r~~ 3 IJ1¥ll%~!!!!~9=Jill:{r~~IH;:~;t -cv 'Q1:f7EO)

tE~t~~-c:~ -cv 'Q J, r~~ 11 r ~ftm~J::O)r~9MI;:--::>tt '-c, 1f!4fJJMr.tO)m§l!·tiil~~~r~91;:#@m!

f4~6:h -cv 'QJ, r~~ 16 ~~~R~O)ji~i.fs:i!JIJil~:i:~~~;:mJ~6:h -cv 'QJ 0) 3 J]i§ -c'ib--=>f:.o 'J3. t:., ~531J-c']f.Q C:, @I~O)i!fJ--=> t:.W-c'---::>O)]f.X I=IJO)@l~O)i!fJ--=> t:.rJi § f'i, r~9 2 I#

~~W~MK~L-< ~-t,r:J§;t -cv'Q1:f7EO)JE~iJ~-c:~-c~.-'QJ, r~~ 10 ~~f7Em~·~'A'¥al;:

--::>v'-c, ¥a15 ·li~ • t§~O)~:Jifli~. *~i¥JI;:X;JJ;tt,rfT5~r:kJfi.fs:i!JIJiJ~1it:sl:L--cv'QJ 0)2JJi § -c'ib--=> f;:_o = --::>O).lj.X ~O)@)~O)(b.-::d;::rJi§ l'i, r~~ 8 I ~ft~f*~~O)·It!J]j.~{r§tlt 11:60 t§~fi.fs:i!JIJO)l& I? *JI.Jj.;(r;JtJ1¥ L- -cv 'Qj 0)-J]i § -c'ib--=> f:.o

-92-

ft:J:o, :£:rj§ I::O!=DO)§J~O)~Ii 17 13<: (30.9%), 16 r]{§ I::O!=DO)~Ii 17 13<: (30.9%), 15 r]{§ I::O!=DO)~Ii 7 13<: (12.7%) tb0f::_o -trr:, 6 r]{§ I: X !=DO)§J~O)~Ii, 2 13<:

(3.6%) -c'tJJ-?f::_o

4.8 ~51 (2013 : 12) li, ¥t~*:£:0))(t~~~J.JJ:JGI:: -'Jv '-c, r ~fl~M~:IJXIDiti~~f*@SifF~9liHfitlftffl5

IJJ~O)*:£:ft ~--0) W~it*~' Jl!ll%0)tP:rf~Jl!ll%~1tffaifO)*:£:~xim1JU!IJO)JE L,v 'ru~~ )l~~ft ~--0) Wxim*~· ±!!!W · t=~trwJe~J:.aifO):J:olt 0 ~'& ~ ll/J~, ±tf!~O)Il/J~rrs-tJJO)ru~ ~ fJt;fl.~i¥Jto~:~1Jo

It~·· W~JJ~~ 0)=-'JJ ~~L, -cv'0a :;t;:~t-c'li, W~M-*~ O)tJ!i~n~G, ~*tllfflt~~~

1::-'Jv '-c~~~~l7-0a .f:O)f::_lfJ, #.!Ji'ts'Lr'i'\i~~~:::J:olt 0~*tllfflt~~~. !f.fl::~fl~M~:IJXIDiti~~@aifF~9

&V'$51JJ~O) W1:.5*~ 1::%t-t0:m:tk~~Ji!!H::-'Jv '-c, 1}~il~fx:ft~q:r,c.,,l:: ~-·O)J:: 5 ft%t ~~ l, -cv '00)fpO)tJ!.~il~G~~~~li-0a

( 1) $¥1=-$'titO)glit:t:Se:li:tJ<alfti:.~L -cMt::t:;jlf;tgmfJPiJ!S&tJB!l&I:."JL'"C r~*tllfflt~~~~::oo 1__, -c, •fx:O)~Jflllt~~::~,~~t1ilff~lifi!Jt~ ~ .'l!!,v '*-tn~J 1::

~~~~:jR~'""(:'§]~~;:j(/i)f::_o

~:fJJI::, f~I:::J:olt 0l!=ft!= · *i55ci::OO-t 0Ji:f:f:~O)i~i¥J;f.Jtl¥ll;J 1::00-t 01ilff~il~ 38ft!=~ §J~il~~t?P-<, ~O)*ft!= · *i55cl::%fL, -c. f%~1!t~1:.1tn~G~O))(t~I::MT0E'~w

~IDF~~~~.W.JJl5*-.f::_)(t~iJ~~1JOL, -c~t::_=. ~il~~;tGh0a ~-i55c*fjlJ~*7'-7'A.­

;z. (lfl!JX: 281:f. 11 fl) I:::J:ov '-c t, lflPX: 181:f.l3ril~ Gltl!JX: 27£f.J3r0) 10 £FF~9~:, ~'&ft:¥Jf

$~ft~~-c'$~ft l__,f::_~f'& • ~l:-{frJiJ~ 1, 079 ft!=J61:. l, -cv '0a .f:O)i*J~Ii, f~'&-fJIJil~

4,849 ft!= (=.O)~O)~f'&~ li, #f~O)~~TO)ffi,{~&lf~~iJ~iir-?td~I::J")t-?f::_~f'&),

~L:-fJIJil~ 1,230 {t!=l:'lh0o ~L:-7-.A ~ L, -eli r,c.,,J!JiA~M~. 9=rtllt$mliA~M~. * lfiL ~iA~M~. Mtffijj-~, ~~~. !!HimtJi~. ~.~,~ (i~~~jj-), i*JJ!JtJi~. ~9=r:J1EJ ~il~

tlJ0o ~'&Q--.A ~]__,-eli f"@;f~f'&, tJ!JJ 'O~fj<J!!!IJJ~f'&, -¥:JttWJitfj-' ~[lli~f'&, J::~

Wlltff • ~flli~f~, JE:lttW!Itff • ~flli~f'&J ~-c'th0a ~flii!n~G!f.f31J:3[~~*-c'0):£:13(:fi

-c'J6~ L,, J6~~mli f~4. !f.f31Jfi_S-IJJ, ~jj-t~~. im'¥9=r, ~.SifF~9. fx:t:i*Jjj-, i.Qf~J

~'""(:'tlJ0o

?XI::, r~~-¥~J li 35 ft!=-c', tffi51b9=r&lff*fiEtHifF~9-c'O)Q-7J, ~rPfll&:JJEf~t!¥~-c lvn~

/vjt0)~1'.!i1:.fl.Er...O)JBJ!ft%t~il~::i<lh Gh -cv '0:17\N.il~ru~~:~ 0a rxim*~J li 27 A ~:, Jl!ll%ximi~O)&JE~m'&~if(l, •~0)1Jo'&1!t&lffB<'&1!t ~ 1__, -cO)M~ft c·O)~,~·t'til~

ru~~:~0o

~ G 1::, f~'& ~ ,c.,,O)Q-7 J li 17 ft!=-c', R'\"~O)±!!!)!tQ~'&I::00-9 0~1'.!i~fl.Er...O) J. / 7' ;vffiJr...O))(';j-~O)~,~·~'til~ru~~:~ 0a r~l!~rB<'&J li 14 ft!=l:, Jmi~/'-/PJT~~I:~ft

il~~~i6*h0-7- ;z. t~;t -c:J:o VJ, .f:O)f::_lfJ0)1iJff~iJ~~,~I:'lb0 =. ~ tru~~:~ 0a r * O)*~J li 714:1:, rflJll<f-tt~&\1 VJ, JilfGv '1:=\'--t /7"1::{# 5 -~It ~--*M*~I::-'Jv '-ct ~~ l, -cv '0 =. ~ il~fiij ;t 0a

r.:cO)ffhJ li4ftt:~:, §J~i*J?Gii r~lflllt~~ j__,-z~,~~.'l!!,bn01*l?i¥1im,m~:n-cv'

0 J , fijiU~1ilff~ J , r ~§!~~iff&. flliJJ 0) 1f!JX:J r Jtljo/}7 v ;v:¥-I::M-9 0 M~. *ft!=O)rB< '&1!t ·1J0'&1!fO),C.,,O)Q-7~J -c'th-?f::_o =.0)=. ~ il~G. !Jf!-~1f~~~O)fJJf:f:1!t1ilffl~ft c·~

~1ilf{~~1:.ft:Jt;~:J1!~1ilffl~ft c'01ilff~il~5<::iJ*I¥H::~fil5 l, -cv '0 =. ~ il~ru~~:~ 0a l,n~

L,ftiJ~ G, 1:.fl.EO)JltA.!jo/J~{~~jf~mft::J1E!t ~··7 v ;v:¥-& l}F~:::::. '/ ~ :J1Ef~t!¥~*ft!=O)~,B( '&1!t ~ ft-?t=1:.ftr...O))(';j-~O)f±.JJit c·~l,v '-7-.AI::M-90 !J A~ &v~ 7-1 ~;z.-y*:J

-93-

:!- / ~ O)£,~·ti~~;t '"C1t 'Q~m!i!ft 1t 'Q := ~ 75~~f"('~ Qo ( 2) ~ie~.a:cJm:~t'JfJ.I~It0)8~11f!iO)UI::-::>I. ''"C

l'¥:13ttc~V~~m!~~0)1iJf{~~~nfi!T Q~O)~f'i{ilJt.:: ~ .~,v '~TiPJ f;:fi~~

:j:Jri:iJC'@]~~:::Jt61)f.:.o

:lfHJJt;:, la~r~90)iff:lfl:J ~ 0)@]~75~ 41 ftf:b~t~v \ =¥--tv 7~J(1f-?#R~ f.t1'f$0)~nm, iJ'Jli.~§~~~~~:IELtd~~H~~iff:liH'i, ~ffl-~1;:~ 0'"C:i:~C'd0Qo ~~~j:~fj(O)

¥tJ~f:lfl:~iEi"" Q tO)--c, •~75~1iJf{~O)t.:.6bt;:.a~r~9~:w&f:lll:-T Q = ~ r:tipr~9n:!Jn;:*Ji;J;.Jb~'.t 1t 'mPJ it&: L1t 'ffl-:1*75~;bQo LiP Lf.t75~ G, lfiJ:~I'i1t '""::)56~-9 QiP7iJliJC'~ f.,tv \ ~·~~ {;$:0)~~ ~ q75~f.tlt.tHi, jjtJJf.tx-tr.tl:t!ll L 1t \ jjtJJf.tx-tr.t75~C'~ Q q ~ VC, ~·

~0)1iJff'~. w'l*~75~£,~~ f.tQJ O)C'lbQ elf¥~: 2015)0 t1zt;:., 17'JfO)iff:lfl:J 16 {tf:, ~~~ijiO)iff:lfl:J 15 {tj:O)@J~il~cb '?, r:Jl~O)itv '1iJff~~T Qt.:.

60f;:f:t~l75~cb '? ~f{ilfi0)~1t '~fii:Bifil;:ft:<Jllfii""Q£,~75~cb '?, 7'Jf ~~ftgijiO)iff:liH:t&v '1iJff~~T Qf.:.bi)O)[itijiUC'tcbQo A;f:,t/'(/:1 !J :A ~~f'Fpj(:L, ·tflf¥R~nTQ := ~ t£,~C'd0Qo

LiPLf.t75~G, 1-{-0){t!!J O)@J~f;:t(bQJ: ")(;:., l~fj(0)~~~1j!!:J 75~£,aj{C';bQ 0 if¥ ~ (2015) l'i, l'¥:txe'l'i!J _A :;I 0 "Y';f:/;1- / ~0)~~75~-:j::i:~C';bQ ~~;tQO ::¥-­

?- Fl:t~~·~O)#im~~. Y~!i!~fj(r-..O)~~{f::C'cbQJ bzl!r<-cv 'Qo ""::)~ '?, ~· ~-?~fj(O)~~Jm~~~j:~*~ ~ fiJ:~~]:!O)filijiUC' b £b Qo ~f.:., flliJIDGO)*'tifJ: ~''#R~ f.,t~IEJO)]:!~~t~*~-?JIJ:~~Jmf;:£,~C'd0Qo :_:O)_:_~r;:"":)1t''"C, if¥~ (2015) l'i, ~~JIJ:~r;:~pr,t--c~ Q$1~-?wil~r;:""::)v '-c¥:f~--c~nfi!L -c~-cv 'Q75~, *13 **!.1~-?

~Hf:if;:J: Q±:WJ;~~f.t ~--75~lbQ t.:.LJ\1;:., -{-O)flliJIDGf.t G C'f'iO)l&*Jl, -{-O)~f;:Ji-@--9 QI& *Ji, ili:~O)Mi!~ b!l!th Lt.:.l&*Jif,t: ~-75~:::lt6b G.h -c~ t.:.$~t cbQJ ~Jl!!A:'"(1t 'Qo

~t.:., ~fj(0)~~~1j!!:~{!Ei""t.:.601;: t, ~·~75~ L0iP'J 1i}f{~~i'm6b~~~[P]l:~ Q := ~ r;:J: '?, ~17Er;:&v'~•~cbt.:.;tQ = ~ t£,~t=-~~*-Qo

(3) Rfllf:t:O)~Jit7:z: •:J? I) A j-.O)f6:!lil'i;O)~Jitl::-::>l,\'"(

~~H~O)x-tr,t-T ::c. v :1 !J :A ~ @J~O)r:Jlc', @J~f!Ml--c x FnO)rJi § --c:-:m=~v 'tO)t:tr~, 15 ~~f:iE:J:~~J:O)~r~,Mr;:xtr.t-t-Q~f*~~O) !J A ~75~"":)< Gn -cv'QJ --c: 141'X (25.5%)

C'£b0 f.:.o :_: 0) ::::_ ~ fj:, ¥~~' flliJIDGO) § 7'"&~-?l!fip~, !j\ • r:Jl • ~;j:XO))l~fj: ~-75~+:51' r;:~mg L -cv 'f.tv '~75~lbQ::::. ~ 75~~;t G.hQo ~1*~~75~il~~~fl::~TQ := ~ C', ${tj: · *i!&~*~';:I$1.1::-TQ = ~ t RJ"ffigf.t:= ~ 75~~1t '~ ~*-GnQ t.:.!J6, v A ~O)f''fpj(:75~~75~n

Qo r~,17 lfitli::Mf*~M~~O)Jl~fis:fljiJ75~--c~-cv'QJ l'illtx (20.0%) -z:, 51'Xf;:11'X O)'!IJ-@---c:il~fis:ffj1J75~:w&.lz:--c~ -cv ''.tv 'o LiP Lf.t75~ G, ~17Em~~~;:.t31t '-c, ~:J}!O)~r& f2EJ~~ml~i¥J:l*i5L& V±lliJIDGO) ~75!1\t:!1tO)fE~ l'i£,~ -z: lb Q o

r~, 14 lfl~~~1f, mitll::~{,:r;~~~il~m~~~ c~f:iEm~::tf£) r:t~~~~~O)~IJ O):J:fl.~i!f~ ~te~ L -cv 'QJ 10 rx (18.2%), r~, 1 lmf:E/FilJL ~~:J}!O)mtJ75q~r;: < <it ~75~~ '? r;:< v\ ~7f-O)~ilZ~1*';:/F*75~cbQ~1:iEO):J:E~75~--c~-cv'QJ, r~, 1 ~~-?

~f*~MO)~fiE~IJ~~1:iE.t3J:Vf:lfl:~i!f~;:~Git-cv'QJ, r~, 12 IM-f*.mt~r-..;f:§~ · im¥R i""QI*J$~75~rxi*J-z-#im~~~.n-cv'QJ 0)3rJi§75~-{-.n~-.nsrx (14.5%), r~,s 1r:p ~tJ~£::>0)51*1*'tflf¥RtJ~JitJJI;:~Jm~n, ~1*~~r~9--c#~~.n -cv 'QJ 7 rx (12.7%) -z: lb0f.:.o ::::.O)J: 5 f,t:@]~O)if.Mr~tJ~G, -)i!iO)·tflf¥R!J)(~~#~ii~£,~C'cbQ ~~;tG.hQo

~rxr;:oFnO)@J~:rJi § l:t, r~, 3 l)jg\i%~]!-?r:flill~~jliJr;:~;t -cv 'Q~fiEO):J:E~75~--c:~

-cv 'QJ, r~, n 1 ~1:1Et~~J:O)r~,J£H;:"":)v '-c, !fl.AAxtr.tO):i:~·ti75~~~r~9r;:#im~~~.n

'"C1t 'QJ, F~, 16 ~~~H~O)}l~f2js:f!jlj75~~~·~~;:}jli]~ ~.h '"C1t 'QJ 0) 3 J]i§ C'lb0t.:.o -"":)O);l;.X FnO)@J~J]i§ f'i, r~, 2 1'¥:1§1-?~~7'51;:~ L < [21S]fll~:l@.;t '"C1t 'Q~f;iEO);j:E

-94-

Wil~'1:'~-o·'QJ, r~~ 10 lj::f~t~~·t~~~;:"')""·c ¥R~ ·it~· :.m~O)~:Mff~, *•i¥J~;:

Mr.t~1-T 5 ttrklf*i!J!Jil~ifft L-""Cit 'Q J 0) 2 l:JH~I '1:'iltJ·:d;:o = "')O)]j.x l=fJO)@J~lJ: § 1-J:, r~~

s r j::f~~f*~1lfO)·t~]j.~~§t~t Jt6b:t§~f!.fs:ifiiJO)J& 'J ifJI.]j.~:JtJ!g L--c~t 'Q J 0)-:IJ: § '1:iltJ -::>f;:o ~""CO)lJi§ I;:OFDO)@J~O)ilfJ-::>t;:~~~:t 17 t3t (30.9%), 16 O)lji§ I;:OFDO)~~~:t

17t3t (30.9%), 150):CJi§I;:Qi=fJO)~~~j:7t3t (12.7%) iltJ-::>f;:o -jj, 6lJ:§(;:xl=fl'"(' @J~O)ilfJ-:;> f;:~(j:, 2 t3t (3.6%) '"('ilfJ-::> f;:o

£AJ::O);:. ~ il~G, @J~O)ilfJ-::>t;: 40 ttl:t, ~~~~~~l~IH;:ML--c, qil~m-::>-c It 'Q tO)~ ~;tQ ::_ ~ ;()~'"('~ Qo

( 4) fti&lit~J.WIO)t:cY.>I=faJf.J<"t:~ .f,f.J' ~O)~I;:ML- -c, 1-Tl!&l:t~'O)J:: 5 fJ'::X!liJ~'1:~ Qtc6 5 il\ -0 § 1;:, A1;t /~/ :7 !J .A H'fJftr...O)mJJ'1:iltJ Qo ~~~;::fOit '""C, ~'1:1i5ffl'1:~ .'5

A1tl;:~-tQ·t~~~:ta~r~mkVA1tfJ': ~-!Jo/.J~af.:ltJ':mU¥-il~iltJ 'J, ]Jf!;~1f~~~~~~~~:t c 6b ~TQ~i-"%~~~r:p,L.,I;:, £,~fJ':1iJF{~rkl$1;:ii§"ffl'1:~ QAtt~*gfrTQ::. ~ '1:, ~ffl.

~'1: J:: 'J 1f:t.JJfJ':1iJFf~~il~~:M!!'1:'~ Q 0)'1:1-J:fJ':It 'fc6 5 il\ = 0 § 1;:, ffl~~O)f;:61)0)a~r"'~O)iff:*'1:iltJQo ~~il~~~~;:fJ¥:~'1:'~ Q t;:6bl;: t, :::z~

7'-1-*~?'0)WC.~I-J:£,~'1:', 1tb"""lil~)t;H.QI;:ft0::. ~ t~tRJ1t0)-0'1:'iltJQ 0 L-il~L-, !J 7 :7 :r -1 7''1~ t iltJ Q t=6b, ~liftllil~~:M!!m-ii!U~ft-c Q 1: '1:', ttrkJ51-0)~f*1lf ~ i!~Wftlm t £,~ '1:iltJ 'J, :::z~"f'·-1 -*~?' O)W2.~1:t1r5Z.JJfJ':-¥~'1:iltJQ ~ ~;t GnQo ::. 0)::. ~ 1;:01t '""CI:t, ~ < O)t5t* t£,~·ti ~~~ L--c:to 'J , 1-Tl!&froH;: t ~lm~~¥ L-, Mr.t L--c t G 1t 'f;: 1t 'a

-=0 § 1;:, T.iff*t£,~'"('iltJQo J,if!;rkJ5'i-O)~j1ifgij]~:Jl3~TQ~O)~t~?)(:JmJtfJ': ~-·-y·

iJ~£,~'1:iltJ Q0 L-il~ L-fJ':iJ~ G, ~~ c!:: lv ~-O)~(;::tQit '""C, -{-0)7-~I:I:H;:*%' L-""Cit 'Qffl. :!*iJ~iltJ Q t;:6b, 1-Tl!&fftiJO)MJ.t~WW¥ L-t;:lt \

< 5 > iift~Uc!: O)JIUI ~~~ c!:: ~~:@1-J:, ~O)]j. '"('j.tf,t'"('~ Q t O)'"('(j:fj:lt \ !J(.!lj::1JEO)t3t51-'"('O)fiSIIJ

wiH!t~il~ 'J, f*~1lf~±lh~c!:: O)i!~fj:£,~0)t0) c!:: fJ':-::>""Cit 'Qo f*~1lf~±lh~{:±B:;il~r

~-t t= 'f:JO)~~~iff*-tQ t=6bl;:mJJ'1:~ Qrkl$c!:: L--c, t.~ta! (2013 : 62-63) r:t, f!AO) 4 .~~¥1f'""(lt 'Q 0

CD~~~~;:"')I,t '""(O)lg3£fiSIIJ~:JtJ!gT Qo

~[!.~·t~~~Jj)(~ L-, @$aT .'5o ~r!.~iJ~~::. 'J ~Tit '~ffl'1:0)iliS@J c!:: r±~~~r...O)mJJ ~{t(~-9 Qo

@li=ftf: • li=~3flj::a~O)~~~fl.js:i!JIJ ~if.:s'z:-9 Qo "i. f;:, ±lh~{±B;; c!:: O)i!~O)f7iJ c!:: L- ""( t, '(j(O) 4 .~~¥1f'""(lt 'Q0 CD±!h~O) § 7~ c!:: ~ c!:: O)r"'~'1:', /F~1lr·t~~i!~!.fs:i!JIJ ~llt.:s'z:-9 Qo ®~iJZ~~i!JIJ~~~mm L-, ~~iff:*c!:: ~~~~:@(;:01t '-c~!S L--g-lt '~ t-00 ®±lh~f±.a;;l;: r -r- c!::'' t no *O)*J ~~;: mn L--c t G 50 @t5trkl&V~mJJn'1:0)~~iff*O)f;:6b, *7 /7 -171;:J:: QiliS@] c!:: 7±~0)mJJ~1~Qo

5 . -;:. J:: cY.> ~~;::fOit '""CI:t, !J(.!lj::f~il~~~fd':!!\l%'1:'~'L.' L--c¥:~::. c!:: iJ~'1:~ Q::. c!:: il~, -if:m~fd':::.

c!:: '1:'dtJQo -{-O)f;:6b, ~~~~~~:@(;:01t '""CI:t, 131:;1{0)~~.~~, jj!fjlwil~, ~~ffl1t

~t:kWJ'1:'iltJQiJ~, ~~@ljj!f-9 Q f;:(/)0) § C.t!JWfil~'"('~ Q J:: 5, ~""(O)~lffiSIIJ0)9J'"('~m&

~r'i\'16b, iJ~-0-{-0)frejJ~t-& 5::. c!:: iJ~1l~'1:iltJQ c!:: ~;t GnQo ~rk151-l;::tott Qli={tf: • li=~l:t

-95-

mm ~ a~r"',~~r-If'~1: t..- -cB v;, -t:-o:>fl~t~i!Bi~:::.:bt:. v;, xtr.ttiji£JJ[o:>t o:>t.PG:I:::kf~t o:>;t'C'~iJBi[:=:.t=~ 0"'Clt'go fll;~~:@o:>::k~ ~ ~ -t:-o:>r*J$(:=:.0v '"'C, if¥~ (2015) l:t, (i:o:> 5 .~~?¥;1f'""Clt 'go

CD~~:@I:::.xt-9g~~o:>ttr:klf;$:i!iiH:tH~n-cv'giJ\

@fll;~~:l!l!o:>l&*Jir-..o:>~¥fiffil:t~~~:::.1t:bh -cv 'g iJ'o

@fll;~~:l!l!o:>I&*JitJ~*JL~~f*o:>I&*Ji~ f~0 -cv 'giJ'o @%i!1:ft:o:>;f:lllii\o:>~$1:t~ Ghg iJ'o

@*oo;~±H!~~ o:>it~tJ~!PJJ: L- -cv 'giJ'o

~~, li=ftf: · li=~l:t~r*J)ii.o:>v 'f:. g ~ = 6 'C'~1: L-, -t:-o:>ii[ii11H:t~fi[i'C', ±11!~~001*~00 ~

o:>it~t~,~'C'ibgo 0-J::$: (2015) t, Jilllffifm'C'~1: L-t:.9=J~1:~~${tf:'C'Jtf4~'tJ~${tf:~l:::.:s'I.

i?l:lf't:. IJilllffifml:::.:t31t g 9=J~-fF.1:~A$1tf:f:::_f*g ?7 .A :7 7 ;;t-.AJ o:>W-i!fit=o:>9=J'C', $1tf:~

*1tl::.~ <'' = ~ tJ~'C'~ f~1J>0 t:.~!EI0)-0 ~ L- -c' '-¥*~. *oo;, ±!!!~. 1Ti!&o:>it~o:>:l:~·!'1(:::. 0 v '"'CJLi!""'Cv 'go -t:-o:>9=J'C', CD~tJ~·twW~:ffl:::. ~ ~-* VJ, q)ttr,ttJ~'C'~ f~tJ'0 t:. = ~, @~ 1f ~mitrl:tJ>Go:>~:X;J:~tJ~'C'~ f~tJ>0 t:.= ~, @:f11<~1!fr-..~ 0 -cv 'gfil;~~·til:=:.)llf]!mo:>::kAtJ~~..-j tJ>f~tJ'0t:.= ~, cv~ ~V~o:>F"','C'~I=ft:PfF.t:::.ooT-g·twwx:m:o:>ftlJi.ij.tJ~~0 -cv 'f~tJ,0t:.= ~, o:> 4 .~~m:flSi L- -cv 'go ~~"1fl:t, iWiJJ[t'A'W1l:~9t.i!1:ft:o:>ii5-tJ.Jfi!IHJtJ~~tJ~g 9=J'C', ~ o:>)tJJ;t[:::./Jo;t, ~)r}.(:::.:f31t g 001*~00t§lio:>it~tJ~~_q :1:~)3[~~ L- -c ~ "'Clt 'go -t:-o:> = ~ 1:::. 0v'"'CI:t, ::$:~;t;o:>~Al~ftl:::.)(t-9g 7/7- rwffiBlto:>fffi:ltHUov'-ct, ~,~·titJ~~~h "'Cv'go

L-tJ> L-f~tJ~ G, :uJH~~iffi L--co:>~Jilljlo:>~~~~:J!I!I:::.xtTg~~~~JJo:>!PJJ:, 13 _q 0)~"1ffi§-j}J ~Jm l-"'C 0) !Jr.j!j::ft:o:>~~:@(:::_)(t-9 g ;f:lllii\o:>!PJJ:tJ~;& tJ ::k~'C' ;b go -t:-o:> = ~ 0)~~ f~ < L--c, ~)1-(:::.:f31t gJt~mJJtJ~;ff~i¥JI:::.~fflg-9g J:!ffflg·til:t1E:< f~g to:> ~:Jti!{U'C'~ go Jt$f4~' (2009 fF.) r:t, $i!i)(xtJ;t~60<''g~~1iJf{l~o:>:l:~·til:=:.0v '"'C, l:l:::k$~1:::.:t3v'

-cr:t, ~o:>xtr.t~60<''0""C{lil:~1!t~~~~~~~xt:V:.1:::.~0-ct..-;t ?li=f~Jt:Pt~< f~v\ 2l::t:., $i!i)(

1&o:>~N'C', ~Jflljlo:>~lllii\/F..IE~IDII~o:>/F+7t~f~ ~--~ 2l:: ~-2l::f~r~,M.~tJ~m:f1Si~h "'Cv'gJ ~m :f1Si L- "'Cv 'go -t:- L- -c, l~$i!ij(~jW ('f:_bb(:=:.l:t, :m:if:'C'(j:~ff~jl1i}f{l~tJ~~ :bbb-c:l:~f~f!jt'Jr]~*

f;:TJ ~ Jil!A:"'Cl,t 'go ~~:l!I!T o:>fi[!I!H:t~ < , tJ >0~{Jl1Jo:>~ 5 JHf:l:t:l: < ~~ 0 -c :t3 VJ , ~jl l:::.xt-9 g :uJH~o:>;(£ VJ

77~~:1!1!1!fo:> !J -?7--~ '/ 7"tJ~::1<6bn -cv 'go

~1m:1e• 1. :«iiltJHIJW, (2016), f ?' .:::...:::z-7 Jv ...... i31:Jl:O):ljl:ii$[111J.li:Jl)J& I'HJll:f. J W ~ F .. 9~f[!ffl\Hi}f(rt~, ~JlfC~mJ~1iJf~}f.

(7) : 20-21

2. if¥~~. 2015, f~0)~1lfJO!!!UJWllt"'-*/'} / HUP7J>0-~~J Wi..l.H::i:k~=?ttl~'~lflillft~~Cl§J'~M-g-t

/:$1-1i}f~~~~. 39, 53-61

3. ? IH*a$, f~1:.Ti5K:t3~t 0*tj(I11Jli::O)jjM:i~;:J WiWi~~ · iWi~:WP~~I:.:t3~t 0:!JI:i&~JJli::O)jjM:iK~.

(IJZ.pj(; 28 if.ll ~ 17 131&11'})

http://www.jpnsport.go.jplanzen!Portals/0/anzen/kenko/jyouhou/pdVJirei/jirei23-5.pdf

4. ~!l!.ll.1ill)d:tA.I3*7-*'-'/~$t/7'-, ~:!JI:tj(:!JI:f:?rJl~*-T'-?'.r-:::-7-, (IJZJ1.l(;28if.ll ~ 17 Bl&f~)

http://www.jpnsport.go.jplanzen/Portals/0/anzen/kenko/jyouhou/pdVH28saigai/database_usersguideH281

l.pdf

5. !lJ*frt'§J, (2015), r~l"i e:··:::. ~ -c:llf-f:.:a:-11-t 00)iJ>J W ~ r .. 9?;&~1iJH~~~. ?;&W00~1iJFJ\:r.JT. (7) : 21-24

6 . iltillJE~t (2013), ~'te-3':: C: ~1lfl0!1!, :kfrt~IH6

-96-

1. X'lf!lf-!1.~', (2009), W0)~1fFJ!""?.:::..::z.7;v--T-c''t:a:-~B~iJ,G"i'0k.il6f;:-

2. i**'!Jf!<iY!lt1f~~g_,, (2015), Yt.!l1=.fiE:{\¥0)~~11f1*%T~-~1f~"' .:::..::z. 7 ;v-

3. t~ffi:lf.Hr, (2015), rwf;:~~f;::::KiiJ Gn.Q,I'?;~:r:JJ:s 7-.:r. v :7 ~A r- J ~ ~ r"'9WOillHJF1~.ll. wc~003E-liJF5Em,

(7) : 20

-97-

~r"'~ 1. ~~tlV~1fi~!IH=~L--c, jlt~O)~.ljl'&~~=~,~~~1iJH~fi{iiJt~~.~,v\~TiJ\ ~~3

T9~C.%1:.0~~:1fv\-c< t~t:i:v\ (fl~~tJfPJ)

7 x®$1!& -1 ~n~:fllt~ 7 JkO)$i!iJc .:r. J;t;%-¥3 ;;t 15<~~{-'0)-:77 7J ~l:.:t31t9$1tf: · $i!ij:I:.:M-t-9Jf1f:~O)y~J3'-J;f:B:~

=\=- -t O){ti!

~r"'~ 2. ~~tlvm:~'lff:!1!1E:Jii~0)1iJH~:a:~:lif!i:-t-9~0)~~ifiiJt~~ .~,v \~Til\

7 a~r"',0)1Jtf* -1 ~fi\:~iff0)1i'if* 7 rlf0)1Jtf* .:r. .lll'&~O);giDilt ;;t -t O){ti! (

~r"'~ 3. -t-O)fm, •~-c:O)~~tlvm:~wf:!l!l=~-t-9Wf~~=0v \-c, :tJ~--:5~0)=- ~ tJ~&J VJ

~ L-t~ t>, -::lc.tt< t~t:i: v \

-98-

[~~H#O),#:~J!l~ 7-::r. '/ 7 ~ 7- "]

~fJliJO)~;j:Jil!H-:, ~~~T 6il'J$-z" LJ;: t>OF!J, ~~~ L.J~v \J: 5 -z" 1....-t;: t> x F!J~~v \'"( < tf!.t!: v \ I -r~~'b . 'f*ft(J)~ 1 rff:f:E/F13JJ, *~O)m:tJ;a»i~~-= < < J.l~;a» ~ VJ ~-= < "\ w~O) :>e:~:OOtJf- ~-=/F*;O" lb

61:f7EO)fE:fjj;O'>-z"~ -cv \60 2 'F~~W1:~~-=:tf 1....- < IEQ~:J§;t -cv \61:f7EO)fE:fjj;O'>-z"~ -cv \60 3 ~lloM£J!~cpill~~~IH-:~;t '"Cv \61:f7EO)fE:fjj;O'>-z"~'"Cv \6o 4 ~~.J(Jm;O'>~ < 1:f7E~-= fif.; 6 %fJ;t:I*75G~.Xhtm!i33 ~fE:fjj 1....-, %fJ;t:I*75G ~0)~[,~;0'>~1£

~-=~m!t!:n -cv \60 5 cp'Ff;;a~c:, O)ij 1*-l*·tw¥a;O"~~~-=~m!t!:n, OOfJf-~~r~,-z"::lt::fr t!:n -cv \60 II ~ViM-f*ffi!J. H(J)VfftL 6 13 ,Jit~/j(J-J-: l:flt~:O):IO.:ChJ ;O'>;VJ 6 ~ ~ l'i, f~M-z"~ 6,JitJfrf~:kA ~001Jf-~OO~-=

f§~-t 6 J: 5 m~ L--cv \60 7 W~001*~000)1:f7E~ r::1 ~1:f7E:IOJ: Lff*~tf~-=~ t>-tt-cv \60 8 1:f7E~f:lil:~tfO)·t~J}.~~~~t ll:bbf§~fi.fs:ifiiJO)l& VJ *Jl]}.~Q L--cv \60 9 A*l~"1f~O)frl~*~~-=-t0~"1f;O'>, *~A;v~A~-z"~ i?!v~hbn -cv \60 10 1:f7Em~·lt¥a~-:0v\-c, ¥a'\5 • il~ · f§f~O)~nm~, *JL.I'f:H-:)ttJ;t~11"5~il'Jfi.fs:ifill

;0'>1ii.:sl: L--cv \60 11 1:f7Em~J:O)r"',~~-="")" \-c, ~%fJ;tO)m~·t1:;a»~~r~,~-=::!t:im~¥t!:n -cv \60 12 001*~00~~ · im¥ai""6il'J?§:~;O'>~il'J-z"::!t:im~¥t!:h -cv \60 13 ·tw¥a.::c 7 !vl-:)(1-t 6 .ff:l-:00-t 6 m~;O'>fT:bh -c v \ 6o III HllM · Q~~ (J)U

14 w~~~~1f. mMoof*~OO~il~m~~~ <1:~m~±~) l'i~~~OOO)~r:JO)

m~ti"~ ~fE:fjj 1....- -cv \ 6o 15 1:f7Em~J:O)~r"',~~-=%tr,t-t 6 OOtJf-~000) ~ :A ";0'>-0 < t>n -c" \ 6o 16 ~~H#O)Jl~fi.fs:ifiiJ;O»~~~~~-=)a]~ t!:n -cv \60 17 m:tli:OOfJf-~00~ ~ O)}l~fi.fs:fi]IJ;O'>'"{"~ '"Cv \6o

( I~Jil'l\!1i]ff~J 2015.7 20 ]{ J: VJ f~Jt])

-99-

~;r-t 3 7 / 'i'- ~ liJ~El!tfffi* C*:) *- 1 ~lff&~l;:&::,wt:: ~ ~*-9-liJff~l;:---:::>\.t \-c<ri~§J~)

7 xim$=i!iJc 27

4' ~!!~fl£'@: 14

? JkO)$=~ 7

.::r:. J;t~-¥~ 35

;;t ~'@: ~ ,c_,,O)'i'/ 17

j] WIUolt 9$=14 • $=~1;:%f-t Q Jf1:f:~O)?ti¥Jt.l.t00

38

::\'- -t"O)fll 3

*-2 ,jjJff~:a:--9 Q ~0)~ (fj~§]~)

~ ~ §]~~ (ftf)

7 a~r~'~, 0)1Jtf* 41

4' ~~~fll 0)1Jtf;~ 15

? 7lf0)1Jtf;~ 16

.::r:. Jll'&j!O)~ID& 14

;;t -t"O)fill 2

-100-