8/10/2019 cases 36-10

1/59

G.R. No. 96566 January 6, 1992

ATLAS LITHOGRAPHIC SERVICES, INC., pe!!oner,

"#.

$N%ERSECRETAR& 'IENVENI%O E. LAG$ES(A )%epar*en o+ Laor an-

E*poy*en/ an- ATLAS LITHOGRAPHIC SERVICES, INC. S$PERVISOR&,

A%(INISTRATIVE, PERSONNEL, PRO%$CTION, ACCO$NTING AN%

CON0I%ENTIAL E(PLO&EES ASSOCIATIONAISAHAN NG (ANGGA3ANG

PILIPINO )A(PILATIP$NAN/, re#pon-en#.

Ro*ero, La4*an, Va-eano# Arre7a La8 Oe# +or pe!!oner.

E#ean (. (en-o7a +or pr!"ae re#pon-en.

G$TIERRE:, JR., J.;p

T

*o-!>a!on o+ -en!a

E*poyee# A##o!a!on or ALSISAPPACEAA(PIL !n #

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

2/59

e- on ea!on ee!on a*on4 -en!a e*poyee#

per+or*!n4 #uper"!#ory +un!on# o+ Aa# L!

Ar!er# or-er.

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

3/59

Te- a *o!on +or reon#!-era!on u T

a!ae 8!< a na!ona +e-era!on o+ aor or4an!7a!on# o+ ran=an->e

e*poyee# an- 8

T

pr!"ae re#pon-en a##er# e e*poyee#. Super"!#or#, 8

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

4/59

3!< e e*poyee#.

Ne!

a8 o

un! )'E$/, o*po#e- o+ e e*poyee# o+

%eree No. ??2,

A re"!#!on o+ )2/ #uper"!#or#F an- )/ e e*poyee#. $n-er

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

5/59

Tran=an->e e*poyee# on re 8

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

6/59

3e a4ree 8!< r!4

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

7/59

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

8/59

Te oa

un!on. T

e*poyee# 8

r!n4 aou eMu!y, u#!e, an-

proe

e*poyee# )Ar. 2?5, Laor Co-e/ or e e*poyee#

=nu=e- un-er o

erroneou# ru!n4 an- po!y o+

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

9/59

)%OLE/ o re*a!n on e- +ro* a!a!n4 8!< a na!ona +e-era!on o+ aor or4an!7a!on#

8e e*poyee#.

SO OR%ERE%.

0e!!ano, '!-!n, %a"!-e, Jr. an- Ro*ero, JJ., onur.

SECON% %IVISION

KG.R. No. 1@2@D?. Au4u# 12, 199D

%E LA SALLE $NIVERSIT& (E%ICAL CENTER AN% COLLEGE O0 (E%ICINE,

pe!!oner, "#. HON. 'IENVENI%O E. LAG$ES(A, $n-er#ereary o+ Laor an-

E*poy*enF ROLAN%O S. %E LA CR$:, (e-Ar!er Re4!ona Oe No. IV,

%E LA SALLE $NIVERSIT& (E%ICAL CENTER AN% COLLEGE O0 (E%ICINES$PERVISOR& $NION0E%ERATION O0 0REE 3ORERS, re#pon-en#.

%ECISION

(EN%O:A, J.;

Pe!!oner %e La Sae $n!"er#!y (e-!a Cener an- Coe4e o+ (e-!!ne

)%LS$(CC(/ !# a

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

10/59

%LS$(CC(S$C reo4n!7!n4 ! a# a oa e e*poyee# !n

propery oer#, a#

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

11/59

3or=er# )003/ anno eBen- a ae o

8!

or4an!7a!on o+ e e*poyee# u *ay o!n, a##!# or +or*

#eparae aor or4an!7a!on# o+

u o or-er !+ a pe!!on !# >e- y a e4!!*ae aor or4an!7a!on !n"o"!n4 an

unor4an!7e- e#a!#

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

12/59

re#ou!on, -ae- Au4u# @, 1991, re#pon-en $n-er#ereary o+ Laor an-

E*poy*en '!en"en!-o E. La4ue#*a +oun- e e*poyee# o+ a o*pany *ay e4ay a!ae8!< n-

o!ne- a!on ee!on are

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

13/59

AR'ITRAR& AN% 3HI(SICAL EERCISE O0 PO3ER ERRE% AN% CO((ITTE%

GRAVE A'$SE O0 %ISCRETION A(O$NTING TO ACTING 3ITHO$T OR IN

ECESS O0 J$RIS%ICTION 3HEN HE %ENIE% THE PETITIONERQS APPEAL AN%

OR%ERE% THE HOL%ING O0 A CERTI0ICATION ELECTION A(ONG THE

(E('ERS O0 THE S$PERVISOR& $NION E(PLO&E% IN PETITIONERQS

CO(PAN& %ESPITE THE 0ACT THAT SAI% S$PERVISOR& $NION 3ASA00ILIATE% 3ITH THE 0E%ERATION O0 0REE 3ORERS TO 3HICH THE RAN

AN%0ILE E(PLO&EES O0 THE SA(E CO(PAN& ARE LIE3ISE A00ILIATE%,

CONTRAR& TO THE EPRESS PROVISIONS O0 ARTICLE 2?5 O0 THE LA'OR

CO%E, AS A(EN%E%.K6

TAr. III, U D o+

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

14/59

3e are a+ra!- In #u*, Leru*Q# propo#a o a*en- Ar. III, U D o+

or4an!7a!on o+ e e*poyee# u *ay o!n, a##!# or +or*

#eparae aor or4an!7a!on# o+ e- 8!<

>e e*poyee# !n

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

15/59

Con#eMueny,

La4ue#*aK11

T

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

16/59

upon e

e*poyee# o+ pe!!oner %LS$(CC( 8

3e >n- 8!e e*poyee# 8!< one aor or4an!7a!onF

o*po#!n4

La4ue#*a,K2@ !n 8

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

17/59

er!>a!on ee!on e- y

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

18/59

NATIONAL ASSOCIATION O0 TRA%E $NIONS )NAT$/REP$'LIC PLANTERS

'AN S$PERVISORS CHAPTER #ee=# nu!>a!on o+

or-er o+ (e-Ar!er (ana#e# T. Cru7 -ae- 1 Au4u# 19D9 a# 8e a#

On 1 (ar< 19D9, NAT$ >e- a pe!!on +or er!>a!on ee!on o -eer*!ne

-en!a e*poyee#

Re#pon-en 'an= appeae-

'an=!n4 A an-

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

19/59

On 2 (ar< 199@, pu! re#pon-en !##ue- a -e!#!on par!ay 4ran!n4 3HERE0ORE, . . .

Conroer# o+ re#pon-en 'an= are *ana4er!a an-Wor on>-en!a e*poyee#

upa!!y !n a#e o+ error. T

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

20/59

*ea#ure# pre#r!e- y

re#pon#!!!!e# o+ #ue e*poyee#.

T

%epar*en (ana4er# an- A##!#an (ana4er# are onerne-,

8!

!n#ea-,

po##e##e- o+

po8er# nee##ary o run oe!"e#, u a#o 8!<

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

21/59

T

Conroer#,

!# e e*poyee# ran#+er, #u#pen-, ayo, rea, -!#

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

22/59

!n-epen-en u-4*en. A e*poyee# no +a!n4 8!n!!on# an- a#e- on

A, o< #pe!a a8# . . . .

A# po!ne- ou y n-# e4a a#!# !n Se!on 2 o+

#uper"!#!on o"er ran< opera!on e!n4 on

To+

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

23/59

#!4n!>ane, 8!or +un!on.

T

aounae +or*#, oaera#, -ou*en# o+ !e, -epo#!, e-4er# an-

o

an- *ar=e!n4 o+

apparen. Ar. 212, par. )*/, o+

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

24/59

an- eBeue *ana4e*en po!!e#, or o

rea, -!#n-!n4 o+ pu!

re#pon-en

y

par!!pae !n po!y*a=!n4 u are 4!"en appro"e- an- e#a!#

(oreo"er,

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

25/59

Conroer# +or*uae an- !*pe*en

%epar*en o+ re#pon-en 'an=, !n

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

26/59

or o

'y 8ay o+ !u#ra!on, on Au4u# 2?, 19D9, (r. Renao A. Tuae#,

'ran< (ana4er#WOIC#;

)a/ (e*oran-u* +ro*

T

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

27/59

re#pon-en o on#!-er an una##!4ne- !##ue

e+ore u#, no8 !# 3e anay7e-

on-!n4

2?

C

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

28/59

ona!n a #u< pro"!#!on# a# *ay e nee##ary o eeuae !# oe an-

purpo#e, or o *a=e ee!"e r!4

*ana4er!a e*poyee# 8ou- eon4 o or e a!ae- 8!< a $n!on,

proe!on !+ a!on o+

on>-en!a e*poyee# 8ere 8r!en !n -en!a e*poyee# +or

on>-en!a e*poyee# #u< a# aoun!n4 per#onne, ra-!o an- ee4rap-en!a e*poyee#;

T-en!a e*poyee# #u< a# aoun!n4

per#onne, ra-!o an- ee4rap< operaor#, 8

onro, u#o-y an-W or ae## o on>-en!a *aer#, e.4.,

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

49/59

a#< po#!!on, #ae*en# o+ >nan!a on-!!on, "au o*!na!on, a#-en!a e*poyee# are ran= an- >e e*poyee# an-

o ae or !nuene e!-en!a e*poyee# anno e a##!>e- a# ran= an- >e. A#

pre"!ou#y -!#u##e-, -en!a e*poyee# !#

Mu!e -!#!n +ro* e, -en!a e*poyee# +ro* e ar4a!n!n4 un!,

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

52/59

KG.R. No. 11@99. Au4u# 15, 199

SAN (IG$EL CORPORATION S$PERVISORS AN% EE(PT $NION AN% ERNESTO

L. PONCE, Pre#!-en, pe!!oner#, "#. HONARA'LE 'IENVENI%O E. LAG$ES(A

IN HIS CAPACIT& AS $N%ERSECRETAR& O0 LA'OR AN% E(PLO&(ENT,

HONORA'LE %ANILO L. RE&NANTE IN HIS CAPACIT& AS (E%AR'ITER AN%

SAN (IG$EL CORPORATION, re#pon-en#.

% E C I S I O N

RO(ERO, J.;

T

Inun!on #ee=!n4 o re"er#e an- #e a#!-e

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

53/59

Appea 8!< (e*oran-u* on Appea, po!n!n4 ou, a*on4 o

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

54/59

un-er #uper"!#ory e"e# an- ? )S an- S?/ an-

e*poyee#, are no "e#e- 8!<

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

55/59

u*ua!"e, an- o< *u# e *e !+ an e*poyee !# o e on#!-ere- a

on>-en!a e*poyee e8een

o onra ne4o!a!on#,

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

56/59

I !#

8-en!a

aor !n+or*a!on 8!< re#pe o

o e re4ar-e- a on>-en!a e*poyee, an- =no8e-4e o+ aor rea!on#

!n+or*a!on pera!n!n4 o nan!a !n+or*a!onK1D or e-en!a e*poyee.K19

Here!n !#e- are

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

57/59

?. To e -!rey re#pon#!e +or

e*poyee# o+ -en!a ype,

Cour rue#

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

58/59

In

Corpora!on (a4no!a Poury Pro-u# Pan# o+ Cauyao, San 0ernan-o, an-

O!# on#!ue a #!n4e ar4a!n!n4 un! nee-# o e

r!4

!*porany, #

aor 4r!e"ane !n one ar4a!n!n4 un! 8!, !n a proa!!y, no reae *u

8/10/2019 cases 36-10

59/59

!*pa on #!ua!on 8! eary +ru#rae

ran= an- >e e*poyee# o+

!=ey o !*pe-e