Upload
s-balagopal-sivaprakasam
View
579
Download
48
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
CASE STUDY COCA COLA - POWERPOINT PRESENTATION
Citation preview
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 1/54
Coca-Cola in Kerala
to whom does water belong?
Photo ‘Spilt Happiness’ by Peter Davis, some rights reserved http!!"lic#r$com!photos!pediddle!%&''()(*+!
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 2/54
./0D1C.0
• &222
.he Coca-Cola Company open a bottling plant in
Plachimada, Kerala
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 3/54
./0D1C.0
• &222
.he Coca-Cola Company open a bottling plant in
Plachimada, Kerala
.hey were invited in by the state government as
part o" a regional ind3striali4ation program,and receive s3bsidies
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 4/54
Plachimada,
Kerala State
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 5/54
&22& 5677 08 P/0.6S.
979S.
C0C9-C0:99divasi ;tribal people, o3tside o" the caste system<
start sit-in in "ront o" Plachimada bottling plant
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 6/54
&22& 5677 08 P/0.6S.
979S.
C0C9-C0:99divasi ;tribal people, o3tside o" the case system<
start sit-in in "ront o" Plachimada bottling plant
.he plant is acc3sed o"
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 7/54
&22& 5677 08 P/0.6S.
979S.
C0C9-C0:99divasi ;tribal people, o3tside o" the case system<
start sit-in in "ront o" Plachimada bottling plant
.he plant is acc3sed o"• 1sing more bore wells than permitted in their
license
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 8/54
&22& 5677 08 P/0.6S.
979S.
C0C9-C0:99divasi ;tribal people, o3tside o" the case system<
start sit-in in "ront o" Plachimada bottling plant
.he plant is acc3sed o"• 1sing more bore wells than permitted in their
license the level o" gro3ndwater is said to have
dropped "rom )( to =22m below the s3r"ace
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 9/54
&22& 5677 08 P/0.6S.
979S.
C0C9-C0:99divasi ;tribal people, o3tside o" the case system<
start sit-in in "ront o" Plachimada bottling plant
.he plant is acc3sed o"• 1sing more bore wells than permitted in their
license the level o" gro3ndwater is said to have
dropped "rom )( to =22m below the s3r"ace
• Discharging poll3ted waste bac# into the waters3pply
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 10/54
&22& 5677 08 P/0.6S.
979S.
C0C9-C0:99divasi ;tribal people, o3tside o" the case system<start sit-in in "ront o" Plachimada bottling plant
.he plant is acc3sed o"
• 1sing more bore wells than permitted in theirlicense the level o" gro3ndwater is said to havedropped "rom )( to =22m below the s3r"ace
• Discharging poll3ted waste bac# into the waters3pply
• .he res3lt "or local people was bad smelling andtasting water, rashes and stomach aches
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 11/54
&22% nvestigations o" water s3pply
• District medical o""icer declares water 3n"it "or
cons3mption
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 12/54
&22% nvestigations o" water s3pply
• District medical o""icer declares water 3n"it "or
cons3mption local water s3pplies have high
concentration o" salts, "rom rapid depletion o"
s3pplies
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 13/54
&22% nvestigations o" water s3pply
• District medical o""icer declares water 3n"it "or
cons3mption local water s3pplies have high
concentration o" salts, "rom rapid depletion o"
s3pplies
• 55C investigation shows that ‘biosolids’
distrib3ted as "ertili4er contain dangero3s
levels o" cadmi3m and lead
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 14/54
&22%- &22+ :egal battle• April 2003 :ocal Panchayat ;democratically elected local government< cancel
Coca-Cola license to operate
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 15/54
&22%- &22+ :egal battle• April 2003 :ocal Panchayat ;democratically elected local government< cancel
Coca-Cola license to operate
• May 2003 the Kerala State government over-r3les the decision o" thePanchayat not to renew the Coca-Cola license
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 16/54
&22%- &22+ :egal battle• April 2003 :ocal Panchayat ;democratically elected local government< cancel
Coca-Cola license to operate
• May 2003 the Kerala State government over-r3les the decision o" thePanchayat not to renew the Coca-Cola license
• December 2003 Kerala High Co3rt r3les in "avo3r o" the Panchayat, with the
reasoning that the State has to protect the s3pply o" water "or the local people
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 17/54
&22%- &22+ :egal battle• April 2003 :ocal Panchayat ;democratically elected local government< cancel
Coca-Cola license to operate
• May 2003 the Kerala State government over-r3les the decision o" thePanchayat not to renew the Coca-Cola license
• December 2003 Kerala High Co3rt r3les in "avo3r o" the Panchayat, with the
reasoning that the State has to protect the s3pply o" water "or the local people
• April 2005 appeal by Coca-Cola res3lts permission to draw (22,222 litres o"
water a day$ Panchayat ordered to renew license
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 18/54
&22%- &22+ :egal battle• April 2003 :ocal Panchayat ;democratically elected local government< cancel
Coca-Cola license to operate
• May 2003 the Kerala State government over-r3les the decision o" thePanchayat not to renew the Coca-Cola license
• December 2003 Kerala High Co3rt r3les in "avo3r o" the Panchayat, with the
reasoning that the State has to protect the s3pply o" water "or the local people
• April 2005 appeal by Coca-Cola res3lts permission to draw (22,222 litres o"
water a day$ Panchayat ordered to renew license
• June 2005 Panchayat re"3se to renew license> Coca-Cola appeal to High Co3rt$
Panchayat renew the license "or % months
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 19/54
&22%- &22+ :egal battle• April 2003 :ocal Panchayat ;democratically elected local government< cancel
Coca-Cola license to operate
• May 2003 the Kerala State government over-r3les the decision o" thePanchayat not to renew the Coca-Cola license
• December 2003 Kerala High Co3rt r3les in "avo3r o" the Panchayat, with the
reasoning that the State has to protect the s3pply o" water "or the local people
• April 2005 appeal by Coca-Cola res3lts permission to draw (22,222 litres o"
water a day$ Panchayat ordered to renew license
• June 2005 Panchayat re"3se to renew license> Coca-Cola appeal to High Co3rt$
Panchayat renew the license "or % months
• November 2005 Coca-Cola once again approach the Kerala High Co3rt
res3lting in co3rt order to Panchayat to renew license
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 20/54
&22%- &22+ :egal battle• April 2003 :ocal Panchayat ;democratically elected local government< cancel
Coca-Cola license to operate
• May 2003 the Kerala State government over-r3les the decision o" thePanchayat not to renew the Coca-Cola license
• December 2003 Kerala High Co3rt r3les in "avo3r o" the Panchayat, with the
reasoning that the State has to protect the s3pply o" water "or the local people
• April 2005 appeal by Coca-Cola res3lts permission to draw (22,222 litres o"
water a day$ Panchayat ordered to renew license
• June 2005 Panchayat re"3se to renew license> Coca-Cola appeal to High Co3rt$
Panchayat renew the license "or % months
• November 2005 Coca-Cola once again approach the Kerala High Co3rt
res3lting in co3rt order to Panchayat to renew license
• January 2006 Panchayat renews license, imposing =% conditions, the most
notable o" which is that the bottling plant does not 3se the local gro3ndwater
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 21/54
&22%- &22+ :egal battle
• .o date the S3preme Co3rt has not passed
3dgment on the appeals lodged at each stage
o" the legal proceedings
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 22/54
&22%- &22+ :egal battle
• .o date the S3preme Co3rt has not passed
3dgment on the appeals lodged at each stage
o" the legal proceedings
• .he Plachimada bottling plant has been closed
since &22), despite Coca-Cola declaring
victory in the co3rt battle
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 23/54
./[email protected]/A 08 P:9CHB9D9
P/0.6S.
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 25/54
nvestigations into state o"
water media attention
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 26/54
nvestigations into state o"
water media attention
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 27/54
nvestigations into state o"
water media attention
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 28/54
nvestigations into state o"
water media attention
INTERNATIONAL
ATTENTION
!RE""#RE ON
$O$A%$OLA
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 29/54
nvestigations into state o"
water media attention
INTERNATIONAL
ATTENTION
!RE""#RE ON
$O$A%$OLA
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 31/54
ndependent investigation carried o3t by .he
6nergy and /eso3rces nstit3te ;ndian 70< "inds
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 32/54
ndependent investigation carried o3t by .he
6nergy and /eso3rces nstit3te ;ndian 70< "inds
• o pesticides in Coca-Cola Prod3cts
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 33/54
ndependent investigation carried o3t by .he
6nergy and /eso3rces nstit3te ;ndian 70< "inds
• o pesticides in Coca-Cola Prod3cts
• 0ver 3se o" water reso3rces in some areas$
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 34/54
ndependent investigation carried o3t by .he
6nergy and /eso3rces nstit3te ;ndian 70< "inds
• o pesticides in Coca-Cola Prod3cts
• 0ver 3se o" water reso3rces in some areas$
• /ecommends clos3re o" plant in /aasthan
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 35/54
0wnership o" water nitial Co3rt /3ling
n December &22% single 3dge bench r3les3phold right o" panchayat to "orce clos3re o"
bottling plant
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 36/54
0wnership o" water nitial Co3rt /3ling
n December &22% single 3dge bench r3les3phold right o" panchayat to "orce clos3re o"
bottling plant
.he reasoning o" the 3dgment is based on
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 37/54
0wnership o" water nitial Co3rt /3ling
n December &22% single 3dge bench r3les3phold right o" panchayat to "orce clos3re o"
bottling plant
.he reasoning o" the 3dgment is based on• P3blic .r3st Doctrine it is the responsibility o"
the state to sa"eg3ard certain reso3rces "or
the people
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 38/54
0wnership o" water nitial Co3rt /3ling
n December &22% single 3dge bench r3les3phold right o" panchayat to "orce clos3re o"
bottling plant
.he reasoning o" the 3dgment is based on• P3blic .r3st Doctrine it is the responsibility o"
the state to sa"eg3ard certain reso3rces "or
the people• 9rticle &= o" the ndian Constit3tion the right
to li"e
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 39/54
9pril &22( reversal o" initial decision
.his 3dgment, entirely based on investigation o" gro3ndwater in thearea by a co3rt appointed committee, is that Coca-Cola can draw
(22,222 litres o" water a day
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 40/54
9pril &22( reversal o" initial decision
.his 3dgment, entirely based on investigation o" gro3ndwater in thearea by a co3rt appointed committee, is that Coca-Cola can draw
(22,222 litres o" water a day
Rea&onin' i&(
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 41/54
9pril &22( reversal o" initial decision
.his 3dgment, entirely based on investigation o" gro3ndwater in thearea by a co3rt appointed committee, is that Coca-Cola can draw
(22,222 litres o" water a day
Rea&onin' i&(
•
Coca-Cola are a legal person, there"ore have right to draw water"rom their land
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 42/54
9pril &22( reversal o" initial decision
.his 3dgment, entirely based on investigation o" gro3ndwater in thearea by a co3rt appointed committee, is that Coca-Cola can draw
(22,222 litres o" water a day
Rea&onin' i&(
•
Coca-Cola are a legal person, there"ore have right to draw water"rom their land
• Panchayat not 3ali"ied or in"ormed eno3gh to ma#e proper
decision
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 43/54
9pril &22( reversal o" initial decision
.his 3dgment, entirely based on investigation o" gro3ndwater in thearea by a co3rt appointed committee, is that Coca-Cola can draw
(22,222 litres o" water a day
Rea&onin' i&(
•
Coca-Cola are a legal person, there"ore have right to draw water"rom their land
• Panchayat not 3ali"ied or in"ormed eno3gh to ma#e proper
decision
$ri)ici&m&(
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 44/54
9pril &22( reversal o" initial decision
.his 3dgment, entirely based on investigation o" gro3ndwater in thearea by a co3rt appointed committee, is that Coca-Cola can draw
(22,222 litres o" water a day
Rea&onin' i&(
•
Coca-Cola are a legal person, there"ore have right to draw water"rom their land
• Panchayat not 3ali"ied or in"ormed eno3gh to ma#e proper
decision
$ri)ici&m&(
• /eport does not address water 3ality ;i$e$ poll3tion<
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 45/54
9pril &22( reversal o" initial decision
.his 3dgment, entirely based on investigation o" gro3ndwater in thearea by a co3rt appointed committee, is that Coca-Cola can draw
(22,222 litres o" water a day
Rea&onin' i&(
•
Coca-Cola are a legal person, there"ore have right to draw water"rom their land
• Panchayat not 3ali"ied or in"ormed eno3gh to ma#e proper
decision
$ri)ici&m&(
• /eport does not address water 3ality ;i$e$ poll3tion<
• Paid "or by Coca-Cola and dra"ted by representative on committee
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 46/54
9pril &22( reversal o" initial decision
.his 3dgment, entirely based on investigation o" gro3ndwater in thearea by a co3rt appointed committee, is that Coca-Cola can draw
(22,222 litres o" water a day
Rea&onin' i&(
•
Coca-Cola are a legal person, there"ore have right to draw water"rom their land
• Panchayat not 3ali"ied or in"ormed eno3gh to ma#e proper
decision
$ri)ici&m&(
• /eport does not address water 3ality ;i$e$ poll3tion<
• Paid "or by Coca-Cola and dra"ted by representative on committee
• Possible inacc3rate estimation o" rain"all trends and water 3sage
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 47/54
E$ONOMI$"
O*
!LA$+IMADA,
" -ATER
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 48/54
E$ONOMI$"
O*
!LA$+IMADA,
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 49/54
E$ONOMI$"
O*
!LA$+IMADA,
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 50/54
Eho governs water?
ndian co3rts tend to protect economic rights o" pop3lation
e$g$
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 51/54
Eho governs water?
ndian co3rts tend to protect economic rights o" pop3lation
e$g$
• Olga Tellis & Ors vs Bombay Municipal Council (1985) 2
Supp SC 51
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 52/54
Eho governs water?
ndian co3rts tend to protect economic rights o" pop3lation
e$g$
• Olga Tellis & Ors vs Bombay Municipal Council (1985) 2
Supp SC 51
• M! C! Me"#a versus $nion o% n'ia 2(12) SCC118
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 53/54
Eho governs water?
ndian co3rts tend to protect economic rights o" pop3lation
e$g$
• Olga Tellis & Ors vs Bombay Municipal Council (1985) 2
Supp SC 51
• M! C! Me"#a versus $nion o% n'ia 2(12) SCC118
Billions in ndia still get their water "rom rivers, wells, and
comm3nal p3mps there"ore privati4ation o" water wo3ld
have dramatic e""ects on access to water$
7/17/2019 Case Study Coca Cola Ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/case-study-coca-cola-ppt 54/54
Eho governs water?
ndian co3rts tend to protect economic rights o" pop3latione$g$
• Olga Tellis & Ors vs Bombay Municipal Council (1985) 2Supp SC 51
•
M! C! Me"#a versus $nion o% n'ia 2(12) SCC118 Billions in ndia still get their water "rom rivers, wells, and
comm3nal p3mps there"ore privati4ation o" water wo3ldhave dramatic e""ects on access to water$
.#T does "inal co3rt r3ling in Plachimadashow that economic interests tr3mp localconcerns?