Case 1:18-cv-01771-TSC Document 22-5 Filed 05/08/19 Page … Decl copy 1.pdfCase 1:18-cv-01771-TSC Document 22-5 Filed 05/08/19 Page 14 of 16 Case 1:18-cv-01771-TSC Document 22-5 Filed

Case 1:18-cv-01771-TSC Document 22-5 Filed 05/08/19 Page 1 of 16











�� 'EH#8>Q @(QH7'Q '=#8;GQ2EM#E&Q #Q &E#4Q ;'HI'EQ E'6#E&8>6Q H7'Q��Q �'>GKGQ #>&Q H7'

%8H8P'>G78BQCK'GH8@>Q#>&QE'CK'GHQE'L8'MQ#>&Q#&L8%'Q3@=QH7'Q��Q 7'Q&E#4Q;'HH'EQ8GQ%8E%K;#H'&Q

M8H78>QH7'Q�'B#EI='>HQ2EQ#&&8H8@>#<QE'L8'MQ#>&Q8>BKH�Q#>&QH7'OQ%@>H#8>QCK'GH8@>GQH@Q';8%8HQE';'L#>HQ

8>+AE=#H8@>�Q %@=='>HQ $K$$;'G�Q #>&Q '&8HG�Q �K;H8B;'QL'EG8@>GQ @(QH7'Q &E#4Q ;'HJ'EGQ #E'Q2EM#E&'&Q

$'HM''>Q�EI7KEQ�#EOQ#>&Q�@7>Q�@E'Q2EQ5EI7'EQE'L8'M�Q%@=='>HG�Q#>&QCK'GH8@>G�Q 7'G'Q'=#8;GQ

&8G%KGGQH7'Q&E#4QE'GB@>G'�Q 8>%;K&'Q%@=='>HGQ#>&Q#&&8H8@>#;Q'&8HG�Q'N%7#>6'Q5EH7'EQE'L8G8@>GQ@(Q

H7'Q&E#4Q;'HH'E�Q%@>H#8>QCK'GH8@>GQ2EQ%;#E8.%#H8@>�Q#>&Q2E=K;#H8@>Q@(Q#&&8H8@>#;QCK'GH8@>GQH@Q';8%8HQ

E';'L#>HQ8>2E=#H8@>�Q !7'Q'=#8;GQ#E'QBE'&'%8G8@>#;Q$'%#KG'QH7'OQM'E'Q&E#4'&Q$'+AE'Q&'H'E=8>8>6Q

H7'Q .>#;Q %@>H'>HGQ @(QH7'Q ;'HJ'EQ �@EH8@>GQ @(QH7'Q '=#8;GQ #E'Q &';8$'E#H8L'Q $'%#KG'Q H7'OQ %@>H#8>Q

@B8>8@>G�QGK66'GH'&Q'&8HG�Q#>&QE'%@=='>&#H8@>G�Q

�� KEH7'E�Q @H7'EQ 8>H'F#;Q �'B#EI='>H#;Q %@==K>8%#H8@>GQ #>&Q B@G8H8@>GQ #E'

GK==#E8P'&Q 8>Q G@='Q@(QH7'G'Q'=#8;Q'N%7#>6'GQ $'HM''>Q�EH7KEQ�#EOQ #>&Q�@7>Q�@E'�Q 8>%;K&8>6Q

%@==K>8%#H8@>GQ#>&QB@G8H8@>GQE';#H8>6QH@QH7'Q#&&8H8@>Q@(Q#Q%8H8P'>G78BQCK'GH8@>QH@QH7'Q��Q%'>GKG�Q

7'G'Q'=#8;GQ#E'QBE'&'%8G8@>#;Q$'%#KG'QH7'OQM'E'Q&E#4'&Q$'2E'Q#Q/>#;Q&'%8G8@>Q7#&Q$''>Q=#&'Q

%@>%'F8>6QH7'Q%@>H'>HGQ@(QH7'Q;'HH'EQB'EH#8>8>6QH@QH7'Q#&&8H8@>Q@(Q#Q%8H8P'>G78BQCK'GH8@>QH@QH7'Q��Q

%'>GKGQ 7'Q&@%K='>HGQ%@>H#8>Q%#>&8&�Q3#>:Q&8G%KGG8@>Q@(QL8H#;Q'>2E%'='>HQ8>H'E'GHG�QM78%7�Q8(Q

E';'#G'&�Q M@K;&Q 7#E=Q H7'Q�8L8G8@>�GQ %#B#%8HOQ H@Q %@>&K%HQ 5HKE'Q 'N%7#>6'GQM8H7@KHQ %78;;8>6Q H7'Q

GH#,G�Q 'N%7#>6'Q#>&QBE'G'>H#H8@>Q@(QL8'MG�Q

�� @='QE'%@E&GQ%@>G9GH'&Q@(Q'=#8;Q'N%7#>6'GQ$'HM''>Q�@7?Q�@E'Q#>&Q�@$'EHQ E@'GH'E�

�-%'Q@(QH7'Q�'BKHOQ�HH@F'OQ�'>'E#;�Q @EQ�#%7';Q K%:'E�QD)0%'Q@(QH7'Q�HH@F'OQ�'>'E#;�Q"��Q

�'B#EH='>HQ@(Q�KGH8%' Q �'EI#8>Q@(QH7'Q'=#8;GQ2EM#E&Q#Q&E#4Q;'HH'EQE'6#E&8>6QH7'Q��Q�'>GKGQ#>&Q

H7'Q%8H8P'>G78BQ CK'GH8@>Q #>&QE'CK'GHQE'L8'MQ#>&Q#&L8%'Q#=@>6QH7'Q ;'#&'EG78BQ@*1%'G�Q 7'Q&E#4Q

��Q


?.OO.JY <NY +<J+R@)O.,Y U<O:<EY O:.Y �.H)JOC.EOY 4JY ),,<O<FE)@Y J.T<.UY )E,Y <EHRO�Y )E,Y O:.WY +FEO)<EY

IR.NO<FENYOFY.@<+<OYJ.?.T)EOY<E4JC)O<FE�Y+FCC.EOY*R**?.N�Y)E-Y.,<ON�Y !R?O<H?.YT.JN<FENYF/YO:.Y,J)6Y

?.OO.JNY)J.Y1GJU)J,.,Y)CFE9Y$F*.KQY'JF.NO.J�Y$)+:.?Y'R+>.J�Y�JOY�)JWY)E,Y F:EY�FJ.Y4JY8KP:.JY

J.T<.U�Y+FCC.EON�Y)E,YIR.NO<FEN�Y ':.N.Y.C)<@NY,<N+RNNYO:.Y,J)6YJ.NHFEN.�Y<E+?R,.Y+FCC.EONY)E,Y

),,<O<FE)?Y.,<ON�Y .V+:)E9.Y0RKP:.JYJ.T<N<FENYF/YO:.Y,J)7Y?.OQ.J�Y+FEO)<EYIR.NO<FENY4JY+?)J<3+)O<FE�Y

)E,Y4JCRA)O<FEYF/Y),,<O<FE)BYIR.NO<FENYOFY.B<+<[email protected])EOY<E4JD)O<FE�Y ':.Y.C)<?NY)J.YHJ.,.+<N<FE)?Y

*.+)RN.YO:.WYU.J.Y,J)6.,Y*.4J.Y,.O.JC<E<E9YO:.Y3E)?Y+FEO.EONYF/YO:.Y?.OO.J�Y #FJO<FENYF/YO:.Y.C)<?NY

)J.Y ,.B<*.J)O<T.Y *.+)RN.Y O:.WY +FEO)<EY FH<E<FEN�Y NR99.NO.,Y .,<ON�Y )E,Y J.+FCC.E,)O<FENY ':.N.Y

,<N+RNN<FENYHJ.,)O.YO:.Y3E)@Y�)JWY�.ENRNY?.OO.J�Y

�� ':.Y�<T<?Y$<9:ONY�<T<N<FEY<NYU<O::F@,<E9Y�YH)9.NY<EY8??YRE,.JY�V.CHO<FEY�YHRJNR)EO

OFYO:.Y,.@<*.J)O<T.YHJF+.NNYHJ<T<?.9.Y %H.+<3+)??W�Y O:.Y�<T<?Y$<9:ONY�<T<N<FEY<NYU<O:;F?,<E9YOUFY

+FT.JYC.CFJ)E,)Y5FCY��Y5FCYO:.Y�<T<?Y$<9:ONY�<T<N<FEYOFYO:.Y RNO<+.Y!)E)9.C.EOY�<T<N<FEY

+FEO)<E<E9YJ.+FCC.E,)O<FENYHRKNR)EOYOFY)[email protected])@Y)RO:FJ<OWYJ.T<.UY4JY�C.J<+)EY�FCCRE<OWY&RJT.WY

IR.NO<FENY)E,YE.UY+.ENRNYIR.NO<FEN�Y ':.YNHJ.),N:..ONY+FEO)<E<E9Y O:.YJ.T<.UYF/Y?.9)?Y)RO:FJ<OWY

:)T.Y*..EYJ.?.)N.,Y<EY8??�Y "E.YF/YO:.YC.CFJ)E,)Y<NY<EY)Y,J)6Y4JCYU:<B.YO:.YN.+FE,YC.CFJ)E,RCY

<NY1=E)?<X.,�Y ':.N.YOUFYC.CFJ)E,)Y)J.YHJ.,.+<N<FE)?Y*.+)RN.YO:.WYU.J.Y,J)/O.,Y*.1GJ.Y !�YC),.Y

)EWY,.+<N<FENY+FE+.L<E9YU:.O:.JYOFYNR99.NOYE.UYIR.NO<FENYOFYO:.Y(�%�Y�.ENRNY�RJ.)R�Y ':.WY)J.Y

,.@<*.J)O<T.Y *.+)RN.Y O:.WY +FEO)<EY J.+FCC.E,)O<FENY )E,Y +)E,<,�Y 5)E>Y ,<N+RNN<FEY F/Y T<O)@Y

.E4J+.C.EOY<EO.J.NON�Y �/YJ.?.)N.,�YO:<NY<E4JC)O<FEYUFR@,Y:)JCYO:.Y�<T<N<FE�NY+)H)+<OWYOFY+FE,R+OY

8ORJ.Y.V+:)E9.NYU<O:FROY+:<B?<E9YO:.YNO)2N�Y.V+:)E9.Y)E,YHJ.N.EO)O<FEYF/YT<.UN Y

�� ,,<O<FE)??W�Y+.JO)<EY,F+RC.EONY)J.YU<O::.?,YHRJNR)EOYOFYO:.Y)OOFM.W�+?<.EOYHFKP<FE

F/Y�V.CHO<FEY�Y )NY�+O<E9Y��Y�FJ.�NYB.9)@Y),T<+.YU)NYNFS9:OYJ.9)J,<E9Y)Y+FCCFEY.EO.JHJ<N.Y

��Y


O;J:S!FS'J:?-;-FS+BA+-H;A9SJ:-S��S+-AILIS �LFJ:-F�SJ:-S:)A,SOF;JJ-ASABJ-S6B?S!FS'J:?-;-FS

)A,S J:-S ?-?BF)A,L?S )F-S IL*<-+JS JBS J:-S )JJBH-QS OBF=�DFB,L+JS ,B+JF;A-S )IS ;JS +BAJ);AIS !FS

'J:?-;-F�IS?-AJ)>S;?DF-II;BAIS;AS)AJ;+;D)J;BASB/S>;J;9)J;BA�S

�� "A-S ,B+L?-AJS ;IS O;J::->,S ;AS 8>>S DLFIL)AJS �� J:-S DF-I;,-AJ;)>S +B??LA;+)J;BAI

DF;N;>-9-SLA,-FS�P-?DJ;BAS� S &:;ISDF;N;>-9-SDFBJ-+JIS+B??LA;+)J;BAIS)?BA9SJ:-S#F-I;,-AJSBFS:;IS

(:;J-S�BLI-S),N;IBFI�S&:-F-S;ISBA-S-?);>S+:);AS*-JO--AS�-D)FJ@-AJSB/S LIJ;+-S)JJBH-QIS)A,S)AS

;A,;N;,L)>S;ASJ:-S(:;J-S�BLI-S"03+-SI--=;A9S),N;+-S)A,SF-+B??-A,)J;BAIS6B?SJ:-S(:;J-S�BLI-S

)ISJBS+BA9F-II;BA)>SABJ;4+)J;BASB/SJ:-S�-D)FJ?-AJ�ISF-EL-IJS1CFS)S+;J;R-AI:;DSEL-IJ;BA�S

�� &:-S�;N;>S$;9:JIS�;N;I;BAS;IS)>IBSO;J::B>,;A9S��SD)9-IS;AS1M>>SLA,-FS�P-?DJ;BAS�

DLFIL)AJSJBSJ:-S,->;*-F)J;N-SDFB+-IISDF;N;>-9-�S %D-+;4+)>>Q�SJ:-S�;N;>S$;9:JIS�;N;I;BASO;J::->,S��S

,F)7ISB/SJ:-S>-JJ-FS1GB?S�FJ:LFS�)FQSJBS�F�S$BAS )F?;A�S�+J;A9S�;F-+JBFSB/SJ:-S'%�S�-AILIS�LF-)LS

F-9)F,;A9S J:-S��S+-AILIS)A,S J:-S+;J;R-AI:;DSEL-IJ;BA�S &:.S,F)7ISO-F-S)JK)+:-,SJBSJ:-S-?);>IS

,-I+F;*-,S)*BN-�SO:;+:SJ:-S�;N;>S$;9:JIS�;N;I;BASD)FJ;)>>QS F->-)I-,�S &:-S,F)7ISO-F-S+;F+L>)J-,S

O;J:;AS J:-S�-D)FK?-AJS5FS ),,;J;BA)>S F-N;-OS )A,S ;ADLJ�S )A,S J:-QS )F-S ,->;*-F)J;N-S *-+)LI-S J:-QS

+BAJ);ASEL-IJ;BAISJBS->;+;JSF->-N)AJS;A5F?)J;BA�S+B??-AJS*L**>-I�S)A,S-,;JIS &:-S,B+L?-AJIS)F-S

DF-,-+;I;BA)>S*-+)LI-SJ:-QSO-F-S,F)7-,S*-5F-S,-J-F?;A;A9S J:-S4A)>S+BAJ-AJISB/SJ:-S>-JJ-FS &:-S

,B+L?-AJIS +BAJ);AS +)A,;,�S 6)A=S ,;I+LII;BAS B/SN;J)>S -A5F+-?-AJS ;AJ-F-IJI�S O:;+:�S ;/SF->-)I-,�S

OBL>,S :)F?S J:-S �;N;I;BA�IS +)D)+;JQS JBS +BA,L+JS 8JLF-S -P+:)A9-IS O;J:BLJS +:;>>;A9S J:-S IJ)2I�S

-P+:)A9-S)A,SDF-I-AJ)J;BASB/SN;-OIS&:-I-S,F)7S>-JJ-FISDF-,)J-SJ:-S4A)>S�)FQS�-AILIS>-JJ-FS

�� &:-S �;N;>S $;9:JIS �;N;I;BAS +)F-8>>QS F-N;-O-,S J:-S F-+BF,IS ,;I+LII-,S )*BN-S )A,

O;J::->,S 6B?S F->-)I-SDLFIL)AJS JBS J:-S ,->;*-F)J;N-S DFB+-IIS DF;N;>-9-S B/S�P-?DJ;BAS �S BA>QS J:)JS

;A5F?)J;BASO:;+:SOBL>,S F-N-)>S J:-S �-D)FK?-AJ�IS ,-+;I;BA?)=;A9SDFB+-IIS &:-S�;N;>S$;9:JIS

��S













Documents

Case 1:18-cv-01771-TSC Document 22-5 Filed 05/08/19 Page … Decl copy 1.pdfCase 1:18-cv-01771-TSC Document 22-5 Filed 05/08/19 Page 14 of 16 Case 1:18-cv-01771-TSC Document 22-5 Filed