CAM Technical Paper LTE.pdf

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/30/2019 CAM Technical Paper LTE.pdf

    1/17

    Introduction

    LTEtechnologypromisestobringspeedsofover100Mbpsdownlinkand50Mbpsuplinktomobileusers

    usingmobilebroadbandapplications.With196operatorsin75countriescurrentlyinvestinginthe

    technology,LTEisnowgenerallyacknowledgedtorepresentthefutureoftheindustry.

    Inturn,demandfordataisrunningatlevelsthatwereunimaginableevenacoupleofyearsago.Thisisdue

    totheemergenceofsmartphonesandotherhighenddevicesrunningmultimediaapplicationssuchas

    streamingvideoandmobileTV.By2015,itispredictedthattotaldatarateswillexceed6,300,000terabytes

    permonth.

    Giventhatsome50%oftotalmobiletrafficissaidtooriginateorterminatewithinbuildings,wepredicta

    corresponding

    massive

    increase

    in

    demand

    for

    data

    from

    our

    in

    building

    networks.

    Thepurposeofthisdocumentistopresentthefiguresrelatingtothisgrowthindatademandandtoassess

    howwemayscaleourexistinginbuildingDASnetworkstohandlethisgrowth.Weconsideroptionssuchas

    deployingsmallercellstoimprovecapacityinlocalisedareas;utilisingMIMOtechnologiestoofferhigher

    datarates;andupgrading,allorpartofourexistingDASnetworkstoLTEtechnology.Thedocumentis

    structuredasfollows:

    Firstwehighlightthefiguresbehindthehypesurroundingthiseverincreasingdemandfordata.WelookatthenumberofdevicessuchassmartphonesandtabletPCs,bothnowandintheyearstocome,

    andmultimediaservicessuchasvideo,VoIP,gamingetc.Thesefigureswillhelpusbenchmarkthe

    requirements

    of

    future

    in

    building

    network

    designers.

    Workingwiththesefiguresfordatademand,wemustconsidertheperformanceofbothexistingcellulartechnologies(HSPAandHSPA+)andemergingtechnologies(LTEandLTEAdvanced).Weneed

    toestimatehowthesetechnologieswillbeabletocopewithincreasingdemandandforhowlong.

    OneofthekeyfactorsinincreasingtheperformanceofwirelessnetworksistheintroductionMIMOtechnologies.MIMOwillplayanimportantroleinourdecisionsonfuturenetworkdesign.Asectionin

    thisdocumenthasbeendedicatedtoexplainingmultipleantennatechnologies.

    WeconsiderhowaninbuildingDASmaybedesignedtocopewiththevolumesofdatathatwillberequired

    in

    the

    coming

    months

    and

    years.

    In

    the

    case

    of

    4G

    networks,

    the

    challenge

    from

    the

    outset

    willbetoengineerthenetworkstodelivercapacity,asopposedtocoverage,whereitisneeded.

    FinallywelookatacoupleofpossiblesolutionsformigratingaDAStoLTEwith2x2MIMO,withoneoptionsimplydoublinguponexistinginfrastructureandamorenovelapproachusingCAT5/6cabling

    tocarrytheDASsignals.

    LTETechnicalChallengesforInBuildingCoverage

  • 7/30/2019 CAM Technical Paper LTE.pdf

    2/17

    LTETechnicalChallengesforInbuildingCoverage

    Copyright:CellularAssetManagementLtd2010 www.cellularasset.com Page2

    ThisdocumentisdesignedtohighlightthechallengesinvolvedindesigningaDAStosupportthemassivedatademandsgeneratedbytheproliferationofsmartphonesandthelike,togetherwith

    applicationssuchasvideostreamingandmultimediagaming.Itisnottheobjectivetoproposeany

    solutionsbuthopefullytostimulatediscussion.

    Exponentialgrowth

    in

    data

    consumption

    Overtheperiodofthelastthreeyearsto2010,thevolumeofdatabeingconsumedovermobilenetworks

    hasalmosttripledyearonyear.In2010,accordingtoCisco,totalglobalmobiledatatrafficwasinexcessof

    230petabytespermonth(1petabyte=1,000,000gigabytes).Thisisoverthreetimesgreaterthantotal

    globalinternetusageinthewholeoftheyear2000.

    Whilstthisrateofgrowthisforecasttoleveloutduring2011,Ciscohasforecastthatby2015wewillseea

    26foldincreasein2010rates,withmonthlyusageof6.3exabytespermonth(1exabyte=1,000

    petabytes).Pleaseseefigure1below.

    Moreover,AlcatelLucenthasforecasta16foldincreaseinmobiledatatrafficto2015butwarnedthatit

    couldgrowashighas40timestodayslevels[2].

    Figure1:CiscoForecasts6.3Exabytes(6,300,000Terabytes)

    perMonthofMobileDataTrafficby2015

    Thisdescription

    of

    the

    growth

    in

    data

    rate

    consumption

    includes

    some

    newterminologyusedtodescribethevastquantitiesofdataunder

    discussion.Thechartoppositeshowsthevaluesofthesenewterms,suchaspetabytesandexabytesrelative

    tothemorerecognisablefiguressuchasgigabytes.

  • 7/30/2019 CAM Technical Paper LTE.pdf

    3/17

    LTETechnicalChallengesforInbuildingCoverage

    Copyright:CellularAssetManagementLtd2010 www.cellularasset.com Page3

    Smartphones,TabletPCsandDataHungryApplications

    Thegeneralpatternofacceleratinggrowthinusageofadvanceddataservicesislinkedtoastronguptake

    intheusageofsmartphonesandotherhighenddevicessuchasTabletPCsandmobilegamingconsoles.

    Smartphones,runningapplicationssuchasstreamingvideoandinteractivegamingareextremelydata

    hungry.In

    2010,

    the

    typical

    smartphone

    generated

    24

    times

    more

    mobile

    data

    traffic

    than

    abasic

    feature

    cellphone.CiscoVNI

    Tomakemattersworse(forthenetworkdesigner)theiPhoneandtheAndroidbaseddeviceswillconsume

    5to10timesasmuchdataasaregularsmartphone.

    Typicallyahighendsmartphonewillgeneratearound79MBpermonthcomparedwith3.3MBpermonth

    forabasicfeaturesetphone.

    Thetablebelowgivesanideaofthelevelsoftrafficgeneratedbydifferentdevicetypes.

    Devicetype

    Traffic

    Generated

    cf.

    Basic

    Mobile

    Phone

    Basicmobilephone x1

    Smartphone x24

    Handheldgamingconsole x60

    TabletPC x122

    Laptop x515

    Table1:FiguresCourtesyCiscoVNI2011

    ImpactofsmartphonesfromtheMobileOperatorsperspective

    FigurescollatedandreleasedbytheGlobalMobileSuppliersAssociation(GSA)showasubstantialgrowthin

    revenuethroughout2010whichhasbeendrivenbythesuccessofthesmartphonethroughoutEurope,the

    USAandAsiaPacific.

    VodafoneUK:2010datarevenuegrowthup30%;drivenbysmartphonesuccess VodafoneItaly:2010datarevenuegrowthup22%;smartphonesales50%oftotalhandsetsales AT&TUSA:2010datarevenuegrowthup27%;7.4milliondevicesales;4.1millioniPhonesalesin2010 PCCWAsia: >80%ofnewsubscribersaresmartphoneusers;3Gdatarevenuegrewby156%inH12010Thisphenomenalgrowthinsmartphoneadoptionandtheexponentialincreaseindatausageisfurther

    borneoutbythefollowingfiguresandpredictions:

    Googlestatethat300,000Androidphonesareactivatedworldwidedaily. TheITUestimatesthattheglobalnumberofsmartphonesisexpectedtoquadruplefromtoday's(2010)

    estimateof200millionhandsetstoalmost1billionby2015.

  • 7/30/2019 CAM Technical Paper LTE.pdf

    4/17

    LTETechnicalChallengesforInbuildingCoverage

    Copyright:CellularAssetManagementLtd2010 www.cellularasset.com Page4

    Figure2:CourtesyGlobalMobileSuppliersAssociationwww.gsacom.com

    AccordingtoInformaTelecoms&Media,whilstsmartphonepenetrationcurrentlyrunsatjust13%,this

    accountsfor65%ofallmobilecellulartrafficworldwide.Thisusagefigureissettoincreaseexponentially

    overthenextfiveyearswiththeaveragetrafficpersmartphoneuserincreasingby700%by2015.

    Inadditiontothesuccessofthesmartphone,therearerangesofother,datahungrydevicesthathave

    recentlyemergedonthesceneandarebeingadoptedbytheconsumeratarate:

    WorldwidesalesofmediatabletssuchastheiPadwillreach19.5millionbytheendof2010andexceed54millionin2011.Gartner.

    Shipmentsofmobilebroadbandenabledconsumerproducts,includingebookreaders,mobiledigitalcameras,camcorders,personalmediaplayersandmobilegamingdeviceswillincrease55foldbetween

    2008and2014withtotalshipmentsreaching58millionunitsperyearin2014.ABIResearch

    GiventhatatabletPCcangenerateaboutfivetimesasmuchdataasahighendsmartphone,thepotential

    data

    usage

    of

    a

    combination

    of

    all

    these

    devices

    is

    beyond

    any

    figure

    that

    the

    original

    mobile

    networks

    weredesignedtohandle.

  • 7/30/2019 CAM Technical Paper LTE.pdf

    5/17

    LTETechnicalChallengesforInbuildingCoverage

    Copyright:CellularAssetManagementLtd2010 www.cellularasset.com Page5

    PredictionsonFutureDemandforDataonInbuildingSystems

    UsingthesefiguresasaguidelinewecanmodelthepotentialimpactonaninbuildingDASoftherapidly

    increasingdemandfordatadueto:

    Thelevelofpenetration(marketshare)ofsmartphonesincreasingfrom13%currentlyto50%andbeyond

    by

    2015

    Asevenfoldincreaseintrafficpersmartphone:CiscoVNI

    Inpredictingthedemandonaninbuildingnetworkwemakethefollowingassumptions:

    1. Inaninbuildingscenarioweassumethemajorityofthetrafficwillcomefrommobilephones.Wedonotincludelaptopsorotherdevices.(smartphonetraffic+basicphonetraffic=compositetraffic).

    2. Therewillbenosignificantincreaseinthenumberofhandsetswithinagiveninbuildingscenarioasweassumethebuildingpopulationwillnotchangesignificantlyovertime.

    3. AlthoughtheDASforeachindividualbuildingwillexperiencedifferenttrafficchangesovertime,wecanassumeapredictionforagenericscenariosuchasashoppingcentre.

    Tables2and3showthepredictedtrafficlevelsasdescribedaboveperdevice:

    Combiningthefiguresforincreaseinpenetrationofsmartphoneswiththesevenfoldincreaseindata

    demandfromthesedevices,wecanseefromthetablesabovethatinbuildingtrafficperdeviceis

    predictedtoincreasefrom13.2to278.9MBpermonthby2015,morethanadoublingofdatayearon

    year.

    Table2:Currenttrafficlevels(MBpermonth)

    TrafficperMonth Penetration% TrafficxPenetrationBasicPhone 3.3 87% 2.871

    SmartPhone 79.2 13% 10.296

    CompositeTraffic 13.167

    Table3:Predictedtrafficin2015(MBpermonth)

    TrafficperMonth Penetration% TrafficxPenetrationBasicPhone 3.3 50% 1.65

    SmartPhone 554.4 50% 277.2

    CompositeTraffic 278.85

  • 7/30/2019 CAM Technical Paper LTE.pdf

    6/17

    LTETechnicalChallengesforInbuildingCoverage

    Copyright:CellularAssetManagementLtd2010 www.cellularasset.com Page6

    Indesigninganinbuildingnetworktodeliverthesevolumesofdatathereareanumberofoptions

    availabletous:

    DeployingHSPA+andLTEtechnologywithinbuildingstoprovidehighthroughput,lowlatencynetworks.

    MIMO

    antenna

    systems

    are

    an

    integral

    part

    of

    LTE

    and

    HSPA+

    technologies

    and

    may

    be

    used

    to

    improveperformance,byimprovingthequalityoftheradiolink,and/orincreasingdatathroughput,

    undergivenconditions.

    Smallcellarchitecturescanbeusedtoincreasethecapacityofanetworkbydeliveringthedatalocallytoasmallernumberofusers.

    Theseoptionswillbediscussedinthefollowingsections.

  • 7/30/2019 CAM Technical Paper LTE.pdf

    7/17

    LTETechnicalChallengesforInbuildingCoverage

    Copyright:CellularAssetManagementLtd2010 www.cellularasset.com Page7

    ComparativePerformanceofCellularTechnologies:HSPA,HSPA+andLTE

    Asthedemandfordataincreaseswemustconsiderthetechnologiesbeingused(withintheinbuilding

    system).Althoughtherearemorecriteriathanjustdataratestoconsiderwhendecidingonacellular

    technology,itisoneofthemostimportantandwethereforepresentacomparisonofHSPA,HSPA+andLTE

    datarates.

    HSPAandHSPA+arewellestablishedtechnologies,withhundredsofnetworksdeployedglobally.LTE

    rolloutsbeganlate2010andinbuildingLTEisstillintheearlystages.LTEAdvancedisstillindevelopment.

    (Performancefiguresquotedinthissectionare,inthelargepart,peakdatarates,fromwhichwecan

    calculatethroughputratesfromonsiteexperience.Throughputfiguresarequotedwhereavailable.)

    HSPAhasbeenlaunchedbyover99%ofWCDMAoperatorsglobally:

    35%ofHSPAnetworks supportupto3.6MbpspeakDL 30%ofHSPAnetworks supportupto7.2MbpspeakDL 8%ofHSPAnetworks supportupto14.4MbpspeakDLHSPA+hasbeendeployedinstages,asthetechnologyhasevolved.

    TheevolutionofHSPA+technologiescanbeseenfromthedatabelow.

    HSPA+using64QAM, supportsupto21MbpspeakDL HSPA+using16QAMwith2x2MIMO supportsupto28Mbpspeak DL HSPA+using64QAMand2x5Mhzcarrier supportsupto42MbpspeakDL HSPA+using16QAM supportsupto11.5MbpspeakUL HSPA+usingmulticarrierontheuplink supportsupto23MbpspeakULFurtherdevelopmentofHSPAtechnologieswithinRelease9and10aimsatthefollowingdownlinkrates:

    Rel9HSPA+combinesmulticarrierandMIMOin10MHzbandwidthfor84Mbpspeakdownlink HSPA+beyondRelease9shouldleadtopeakdownlinkdataspeedsexceeding100Mbps

    LTEtechnologywasfirstrolledoutin2010.Inbuildingthroughputfiguresarescarceatthistime.

    Thenumberofcommercialnetworkslaunchedtodateisstillquitelowandactualthroughputfiguresare

    hardtocomeby.ThepeakdataratesforLTEareasfollows:

    Peakdownlinkspeeds(64QAM) supportsupto100Mbps(SISO)supportsupto172Mbps(2x2MIMO)

    supportsupto326Mbps(4x4MIMO)

    Peakuplinkspeeds supportsupto50Mbps(QPSK)supportsupto57Mbps(16QAM)

    supportsupto86Mbps(64QAM)

  • 7/30/2019 CAM Technical Paper LTE.pdf

    8/17

    LTETechnicalChallengesforInbuildingCoverage

    Copyright:CellularAssetManagementLtd2010 www.cellularasset.com Page8

    Table2:ComparisonofPeakDataRates:ThroughputFiguresShownWhereAvailable.

    DatacourtesyHSPAtoLTEAdvancedRysavyResearchwww.3gamericas.org

    MIMOtechnologyisdiscussedindetailinthenextsection.

  • 7/30/2019 CAM Technical Paper LTE.pdf

    9/17

    LTETechnicalChallengesforInbuildingCoverage

    Copyright:CellularAssetManagementLtd2010 www.cellularasset.com Page9

    MIMOTechnologies

    ThispaperisaddressesthechallengesofrollingoutinbuildingLTEnetworks.MIMOtechnologyisa

    fundamentalpartofLTE,impactingtheamountofworkandthecostsinvolvedinarolloutmorethanany

    othersingleitem.WehavethereforeprovidedadescriptionofMIMOconcepts,terminologyandmodesof

    operationas

    they

    relate

    to

    LTE.

    MIMOisconsideredessentialforLTE,tomaximizesystemcapacityandprovidehighdatarates.Both2x2

    and4x4designsarebeingconsideredalthoughonly2x2configurationsarebeingdeployedatthistime.[5]

    LTEsystemsspecifythreetypesofantennatechniques;Diversity,BeamformingandMIMO

    Fig3:TypicalConfigurationsforMultipleAntennaSystems

    AntennadiversitycanincludetransmitdiversityorMultipleInSingleOut(MISO)andreceivediversityor

    SingleInMultipleOut(SIMO)configurations:

    MISO(transmitdiversity),usestwoormoretransmitantennasandasinglereceiveantenna.Thesamedataissentfrombothtransmittingantennassimultaneously,butcodedinsuchawaythatthereceiver

    canidentifythedatafromeachtransmittingantenna.Thistechniquecanmakethesignalmore

    resistanttofadingandisusedtoimproveperformanceinpoorcoverageareas.

    Transmit Receive

    SISO

    MISO Transmitdiversity

    SIMO Receive

    diversity

    MIMO

  • 7/30/2019 CAM Technical Paper LTE.pdf

    10/17

    LTETechnicalChallengesforInbuildingCoverage

    Copyright:CellularAssetManagementLtd2010 www.cellularasset.com Page10

    SIMO(receivediversity)usesonetransmitantennaandtwoormorereceiveantennas.Onlyonedatastreamistransmittedacrossthepathandspatialdiversityatthereceiveendcanbeusedtoimprove

    SNRunderpoorchannelconditions.

    TransmitBeamformingisatechniquewherebymultipledatastreamsaretransmittedovermultiple

    transmitantennas,andwiththehelpoffeedbackfromthereceiver(ChannelQualityInformationCQI),the

    relativephaseofthetransmittedsignalscanbeadjustedsuchthattheywillcombineconstructivelyatthe

    receivertofocustheRFbeamonthatdevice.TransmitBeamformingcanbeusedtoimprovesignal

    receptionandincreasetherangetoaparticularreceivingdevice.

    MIMO(MultipleInMultipleOut)makesuseoftwoormoretransmitantennasandtwoormorereceive

    antennas.DependingonthewayMIMOisimplemented,multipleantennaconfigurationscanbeusedto

    generatehigherthroughput(spatialmultiplexing)ortoprovideamorereliablelink(diversitytechniques).

    Spatialmultiplexingisusedtoincreaselinkcapacity.Theinformationtobetransmittedisdividedintoindependent

    data

    streams

    and

    each

    stream

    is

    sent

    simultaneously

    from

    aseparate

    antenna

    (multiple

    spatialstreams).IfwehaveNtransmitantennasthenwemustalsohaveNreceiveantennas.Ifthe

    resultantdatastreamsaresufficientlyuncorrelatedtobedistinguishablefromoneanother,thenthe

    totalthroughputofthelinkwillbeNtimesthesingledatastream.

    Spatialdiversitycanbeusedtoincreasetherangeand/orreliabilityofalink.Thesamedataistransmittedsimultaneouslyovermultipleindependentfadingsignalpathsandbymakinguseofthelow

    probabilityofthesesignalpathsexperiencingdeepfadesatthesametime,theincomingsignalscanbe

    combinedtoincreaseSNR,henceimprovinglinkreliabilityandrange.Foreffectivediversity,the

    antennasattheboththetransmitterandthereceivermustbeplacedwavelengthapart.

    SingleUserMIMO(SUMIMO)iscommonlyusedinLTEsystemstoincreasethedataratetooneuserin

    goodradioconditions.ThemostcommondownlinkconfigurationforLTEis2x2SUMIMOusingspatial

    multiplexing.(seeFig4).

    MultiUserMIMO(MUMIMO).Considertwodatastreams,eachstreamoriginatingfromadifferentuser

    device(seeFig4).MUMIMOreliesonthefactthatthespatialseparationbetweentheuserdevicesis

    sufficientthattheinformationarrivingatthereceiveantennaswillhaveuncorrelatedpaths.Thismaximises

    thepotentialcapacitygainatthereceiver(theeNodeviaDASantenna).

    Oneof

    the

    design

    motivations

    of

    the

    LTE

    standard

    is

    to

    keep

    the

    terminal

    or

    mobile

    device

    cost

    low.

    Thereforeinordertominimiseactualtransmitantennasonthemobiledevice,multipleuserMIMO(MU

    MIMO)isbeingconsideredasanattractiveoption.

  • 7/30/2019 CAM Technical Paper LTE.pdf

    11/17

    LTETechnicalChallengesforInbuildingCoverage

    Copyright:CellularAssetManagementLtd2010 www.cellularasset.com Page11

    Fig4:SUMIMOandMUMIMOconfiguration

    Tosummarisetheabove,MIMOisamethodofusingmorethanoneantennaatthetransmitterand

    receiverto

    improve

    communications

    performance.

    MIMO

    has

    the

    potential

    either

    to

    increase

    the

    capacity

    ofnetworksortoenlargetheareaofagivencellwithouttheneedforadditionalspectrum.

    DASAntennas

    SingleUserMIMO

    (LTEconfiguration 2x2SUMIMOusingSpatialMultiplexing)

    MultiUserMIMO

  • 7/30/2019 CAM Technical Paper LTE.pdf

    12/17

    LTETechnicalChallengesforInbuildingCoverage

    Copyright:CellularAssetManagementLtd2010 www.cellularasset.com Page12

    CorrelationinMIMOChannels

    ForMIMOtobeeffectiveinachievingitsobjectivesofincreasedrangeandcapacity,theenvironmentin

    whichitisdeployedmustprovidesufficientmultipath(reflectedwaves).Thisisreferredtoasnonlineof

    sight(NLOS)transmissionwhichtypicallyoccursinanindoorenvironment.

    In

    this

    so

    called

    rich

    scattering

    environment,

    the

    transmitted

    signals

    bounce

    off

    objects

    such

    as

    walls,

    such

    thattheyarereceivedwithdistinctlydifferentprofilesatthereceiveantennas;i.e.thesignalsareeasily

    distinguishablefromoneanother.Inmathematicalterms,thesignalsaredecorrelatedatthereceiver.

    Conversely,inanenvironmentwithpurelylineofsightLOScharacteristics.thereisonepredominantsignal

    arrivingatthereceiver.TheadvantagesofMIMOcannotbeaseasilyrealisedasthesignalsarenolonger

    decorrelated.Furtherdescriptionisbeyondthescopeofthisdocument;howevermoredetailisavailable

    onrequestfromCAM.

    MIMOisacrucialtechnologyforimprovinginbuildingcellularcoverage.Inarichscatteringenvironment

    withahighsignaltonoiseratio,aMIMOsystemcandeliverbetween70%to100%throughputandcapacity

    gainsover

    asingle

    input

    single

    output

    (SISO)

    deployment.

    The

    rich

    scattering

    environment

    describes

    most

    inbuildingenvironmentsandinbuildingdistributedantennasystems(DASs)canprovidehighsignal

    quality.(ADCJune2010)

    AchallengeforradioplannersisleveragingthemaximumperformancefromMIMOsystems,thiswill

    requireinbuildingsystemsdesignedtoprovideasufficientlymultipathrichenvironmentwhilestill

    achievingahighsignaltonoiseratio.

  • 7/30/2019 CAM Technical Paper LTE.pdf

    13/17

    LTETechnicalChallengesforInbuildingCoverage

    Copyright:CellularAssetManagementLtd2010 www.cellularasset.com Page13

    ChallengesforInbuildingSolutions

    Thusfarinthisdocumentwehavehighlightedthesoaringincreasesindataconsumptionmainlydueto

    smartphonesusingdatahungrymultimediaapplications.Predictionsfordataconsumptiongoingforward

    show

    more

    than

    a

    doubling

    of

    traffic

    year

    on

    year

    from

    2011

    to

    2015.

    Thisraisesthequestion:howlongcantheexisting2G/3GinbuildingDASscopewiththedatademands

    uponthemandwhatwouldbeanappropriateupgradepathtothenextgenerationofnetworks?

    HowlongcananexistingDASsupporttheincreasingtraffic?

    InordertoestimatehowlonganexistingDAScansupporttheincreasingtrafficlevelswemustmakea

    coupleofassumptions:

    Forsitesthatcansplitintosmallercellsthecapacityofthesitemaybedoubledforadoublingofcells. NetworksupportforhigherHSPA+withoutMIMOwillalsoliftcapacitybyafactoroftwoAseachofthesechangesdoublescapacityofthesitewecanseethattheexistingDASwillbeableto

    supporttrafficgrowthforanothercoupleofyearswithinanyparticularbuildingbeforeMIMObecomes

    necessary.

    AddedtothisisthefactthatneitherMIMOnorSmallCelltopologieswillbeaddedasanetworkwide

    upgrade,butwillbedeployedinlocalisedareasonly.Thenetworkupgradescanbeperformedgradually

    overtime,spreadingboththecostsandtherisksaswelearnfromeachstageofanupgrade.

    WhatOptionsareAvailableforUpgradinganExistingInbuildingDAS?

    Reducingcellsizebysectorisationorusingsmallcells. Largebuildingscanbedividedintosmallercells(orsectors),reducingthenumberofuserspercell(orsector),therebyincreasingcapacity.The

    disadvantagesarethattherearephysicallimitationstohowsmallcellscanbemade;smallercellsmay

    meanmorecellswhichinturnrequiremoreNodeBs,whichrequiremorespaceandmorepower.Re

    cablingofthesystemeachtimeasmallcellisaddedcanbeexpensive.

    IncreasingdatarateswithMIMO.Thishastheadvantagethatcapacitycanbeincreasedwithoutusingmorespectrum.Thisoptioncouldproveexpensiveifcablinghadtobedoubledup;however,thereare

    optionsavailableforrunningmultipleantennasoveronecable,oroveranEthernetlink.

    DeployingLTEtospecificareaswithinthebuilding.ThisisundoubtedlythewayLTEwillbedeployedforthereasonsgivenearlieri.e.capacityisonlydeliveredwhereitisneeded.AnyupgradetoLTE

    technologywillfollowthisupgradepathforreasonsofcostandefficiency.TheadvantagesofMIMO

    arethatcapacitycanbeincreasedwithoutusingadditionalspectrum.Themaindisadvantageas

    mentionedaboveisdoublinguponcablingtothemultipleantennas.

  • 7/30/2019 CAM Technical Paper LTE.pdf

    14/17

    LTETechnicalChallengesforInbuildingCoverage

    Copyright:CellularAssetManagementLtd2010 www.cellularasset.com Page14

    WhatOptionsareAvailableforDeployingaNewInbuildingDAS?

    ItisafactthatGSM/UMTSwillcomprisetheoverwhelmingmajorityofsubscribersoverthenextfivetoten

    years,evenasnewwirelesstechnologiesareadopted.Therefore,eveninthelightoflargeincreasesindata

    demand,anewDASdeploymentwouldmostlikelystillbebasedonabuildingwide2G/3Gnetworkwith

    smallerareasofhighcapacityLTEnetworks,onlywherethedatademandisrequired.TheLTEsectionsof

    thenetwork

    would

    be

    similar

    to

    the

    upgrade

    options

    given

    in

    the

    previous

    section.

    EstimatedcostsfromCAM,foranewDASinstallationcomprisingmaterialsdescribedbelow,areasfollows:

    20antennas 700mcoaxialcable 10splitters 10couplersCosts:

    1.

    2G

    /

    3G

    /

    4G

    SISO

    System:

    22,000

    to

    design

    and

    install

    2. 2G/3G/4G2x2MIMOSystem: 32,000todesignandinstall

    3. 2G/3G/4G4x4MIMOSystem: 46,000todesignandinstall

    Figuresarebasedonthefactthatthematerialsaredoubledineachcasebutthelabourrequiredforeach

    installationdoesnotdouble.Asapercentage,a2x2systemwouldbe45%moreexpensivetoinstallanda

    4x4system109%moreexpensive.

    ThesecostshoweverwouldonlybeapplicableifweweretodeployMIMOoveranequivalentareatothe

    SISOinstallation.Aswehaveseeninthisdocument,thisrolloutscenariomaynotbethemostsuitable,or

    themost

    cost

    effective.

    Todeliverpoolsofhighcapacity,usingMIMO,onlywhereitisneededwouldprobablycostmorefromthe

    pointofviewofplanningandsitesurveysbutwillultimatelybecheaperthandeployingMIMOthroughout

    thebuilding.Thisissueisopentodiscussion.

  • 7/30/2019 CAM Technical Paper LTE.pdf

    15/17

    LTETechnicalChallengesforInbuildingCoverage

    Copyright:CellularAssetManagementLtd2010 www.cellularasset.com Page15

    ANovelApproachtoDeployingInbuildingLTECoverage:(CellularoverLAN)

    InprevioussectionswehavediscussedtheadvantagesanddisadvantagesofdeployingMIMOtechnologies

    forinbuildingnetworks.Oneofthemaindisadvantagesisthecostofrunningmultiplecablestothe

    multipleantennasinaMIMOsystem.Thereareafewoptionswherebymultipleantennascanbefedfrom

    asinglefeeder.OneoptioninvolvesfeedingtheantennasviatheexistingCAT5/6cablingwithinthe

    building.

    Thissolution,calledMobileAccessVEisdesignedtodeliverinbuildingLTEcellularservicesoveranexisting

    CAT5/6LANinfrastructure,whilemaintainingfullEthernetandwirelessLANcapabilities.Thevendor

    claimsthefollowingperformancefiguresandfacilities:

    Extendscarriergrade,5barcoveragefor2G,3G,4GserviceswithMIMO Reducesinstallationtimebyhalf,ascomparedwithconventionalsolutions transparentlycoexistsalongsidetheLANwithoutimpactingLANperformance SupportsconnectivitytoanytypeofoperatorRFcapacitysource Offersproactiveendtoendnetworkmonitoring

    Plug

    and

    play

    design

    scales

    cost

    effectively,

    allowing

    customers

    to

    choose

    where

    new

    services

    are

    activated

    ResultsfromanactualMobileAccessVEinstallationgivethroughputfiguresforanindoorLTEdeployment:

    70dBmcoveragewastestedin90%ofthebuilding,followingMobileAccessVEdeployment EachVEPodcovered10,000squarefeet. Spatialmultiplexed2x2MIMOand64QAMwasverifiedusingtheLTELGUSBdongle ThemeasureddatathroughputatMIMOconfigurationwas:

    15MbpsforUL(uplink)dataspeed

    40

    Mbps

    for

    DL

    (downlink)

    data

    speed

    SISOperformanceequivalentsofferlessthan35%ofMIMOthroughput(15MbpsUL,25MbpsDL)(http://www.mobileaccess.com)

    Thissolutionprovidesanadvantageinitsquickandeasyinstallation timesandMIMOsupportat4G,

    withoutimpactingontheexistingLANperformance.MobileAccessVEisalsothefirstcellularsolution

    validatedwiththeCiscoUnifiedWirelessNetwork.MoredetailisavailableonrequestfromCAM.

  • 7/30/2019 CAM Technical Paper LTE.pdf

    16/17

    LTETechnicalChallengesforInbuildingCoverage

    Copyright:CellularAssetManagementLtd2010 www.cellularasset.com Page16

    LTEFemtocells

    AFemtocellisasmallbasestation,designedtobedeployedwithinhomeorsmallbusinesspremisesto

    provideenhancedcoverage.Thecoverageandcapacitymadeavailablebyusingthesmallcellapproach

    withinbuildingsiswellsuitedtoLTEdeployment.

    LTEFemtocells

    are

    supported

    within

    3GPP

    as

    early

    as

    Release

    8(2008)

    and

    are

    identified

    as

    Home

    eNode

    Bs(HeNB).However,unlikethe3GFemtocell,thereiscurrentlynodefinedarchitecturalstandardinplace.

    ThelevelofinterestfromoperatorsisdrivingtheFemtocellecosystemforwardatapace.Enterprise

    Femtocellsthatcouldprovidecoverageinlargebuildingsarenowinthepipeline,supportingfemtofemto

    handovers.

    CellularAssetManagementwillbehappytodiscussthepotentialofFemtocellsuponrequest.

    Conclusions

    Thepurposeofthisdocumenthasbeentopromotediscussiononthebestwaytoservethesoaringlevels

    ofdatademandexpectedoverthenextfewyears,usinganinbuildingDASsystemandnewtechnologies

    suchasLTE.Themainpointsare:

    Smartphonedevicesareexpectedtomorethandoublethetrafficdemandedofinbuildingsystemsyearonyearfrom2010to2015.

    ToupgradeanexistinginbuildingDASfortheincreaseindatatherearetwomainoptions:reducethesizeofeachcellandincreasethedataratessupportedbytheDAS.

    TosupportthedataratesofHSPA+andLTEtheinbuildingsystemswillneedtobeupgradedforMIMOantennatechnology.

    FemtocelltechnologyforLTEcouldprovidesmallcellcapacitysolutions,althoughitisstillindevelopment.

    AlternativedistributionsystemssuchasMobileAccessVEcouldprovideaquickandsimplerupgradepathwithextracapacitybeingaddedtoareasasthetrafficincreases.

    Doweupgradenow?Inthenexttwoyears?Morelikelywewillseenetworksupgradegradually,providing

    extracapacityonlyinlocalisedareaswhereitisrequiredandleavingthe2G/3GDASinstallationstohandle

    thewiderareacoverage.

  • 7/30/2019 CAM Technical Paper LTE.pdf

    17/17

    LTETechnicalChallengesforInbuildingCoverage

    Copyright:CellularAssetManagementLtd2010 www.cellularasset.com Page17

    References

    1. CiscoVisualNetworkingIndex:GlobalMobileData:TrafficForecastUpdate,20102015.www.cisco.com2. MobileBroadbandGrowthReport:PublishedbytheGlobalmobileSuppliersAssociation(GSA)www.gsacom.comFeb20113. TheIET EngineeringandTechnologyMagazine:Article:Willmobilenetworksbereadyforthe4Gdatadeluge?

    http://eandt.theiet.org/magazine/pastissues/index.cfm

    4. Ofcom TheCommunicationsMarket2010(August)http://stakeholders.ofcom.org.uk/binaries/research/cmr/753567/CMR_2010_FINAL.pdf

    5. AgilentTechnologies.http://www.home.agilent.com/agilent/application.jspx?nid=34563.0.00&lc=eng&cc=GBLTEimplementationofMIMO

    6. HSPAtoLTEAdvanced,RysavyResearchSept2009http://www.4gamericas.org/

    7. NECShowsHowSmallCellLTEDeploymentisSmarterWaytoSustainableFuture:MobileBroadbandMobileWorldCongress

    Feb

    2011

    http://www.nec.com/