35
CALCULATION COVER SHEET Element: Trunnion Girder and Pier Anchorage Labor Code: 2686C1 Calculation Title: Trunnion Girder and Pier Anchorage Total Number of Pages (including cover sheet): Prepared by: Ira Dorsett Date: 2/22/15 Checked by: Chong Johnny Walker (Ongoing) Date: Design Basis/References/Assumptions: - ACI 318-14 -EM 110-2-2000 Standard Practice for Concrete for Civil Works -EM 1110-2-2104 Strength Design for reinforced concrete hydraulic structures -EM 1110-2-2702 Design of Spillway Tainter Gates -Post Tensioning Manual 6 th Edition AASHTO LRFD Design Specifications 2012 Rev. No. Description of Revision: Prepared by: Date: Checked by: Date: Sheet Index: F1.1-F1.43 F2.1-F2.556 F3.1-F3.2 F4.1-F4.499 F5.1-F5.665 F6.1 F7.1 Load cases and loads applied to foundation slab #3 STAAD input and output HP 14x73 Compression and tension capacities graph Foundation piling design Foundation reinforcement and concrete design Bill of reinforcement End of Calculations 1

CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

CALCULATION COVER SHEET

Element: Trunnion Girder and Pier Anchorage Labor Code: 2686C1

Calculation Title: Trunnion Girder and Pier Anchorage

Total Number of Pages (including cover sheet):

Prepared by: Ira Dorsett Date: 2/22/15

Checked by: Chong Johnny Walker (Ongoing) Date:

Design Basis/References/Assumptions: - ACI 318-14 -EM 110-2-2000 Standard Practice for Concrete for Civil Works -EM 1110-2-2104 Strength Design for reinforced concrete hydraulic structures -EM 1110-2-2702 Design of Spillway Tainter Gates -Post Tensioning Manual 6th Edition AASHTO LRFD Design Specifications 2012

Rev. No.

Description of Revision:

Prepared by:

Date:

Checked by:

Date:

Sheet Index:

F1.1-F1.43

F2.1-F2.556

F3.1-F3.2

F4.1-F4.499

F5.1-F5.665

F6.1

F7.1

Load cases and loads applied to foundation slab #3

STAAD input and output

HP 14x73 Compression and tension capacities graph

Foundation piling design

Foundation reinforcement and concrete design

Bill of reinforcement

End of Calculations

1

Page 2: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

2

Page 3: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

Check Box 1 or 2

1.

Checker's Signature:  Date:

OR

2. Checker's comments have been provided on:  Calculations 

Other 

Attached

If box 2 is checked above, the section below to be completed after backcheck of any comments.

Check Box 3, OR go on to Box 4 AND  Box 5

3.

OR

4.

AND

5.

Checker's Signature:  Date:

QA Signature:  Date:

Designer/Checker Inform

ation

Title of Calculations to be checked: 

Section Chief or Designee

QA Sign‐Off

The Design/Calculation Check is complete and all comments have been resolved and closed out.    

Checker's comments have been adequately addressed by Designer/Originator and all issues have been resolved 

between Checker and Designer. The checker has backchecked all comments and reviewed all revised calculations to 

assure incorporation into final document.

All items have been checked in accordance with District QMP and found to be correct.  Checker has no comments.

There are unresolved comments, and these have been submitted to the Section Chief or designee for resolution.

Design

 Check Documentation

File Location:

District/Customer: North Dakota

Bonnie Greenleaf

Project Location:

Project Manager:

2/29/2016

Comments have been resolved by Section Chief or designee.  The checker has backchecked comments and reviewed 

all revised calculations to assure that resolved comments have been incorporated into final document.

MVP ‐ Design Branch

Calculation Cover Sheet and Design Check DocumentationSection: (Structural/MECS/Civil)

Number of pages Including Cover 

Sheet

Trunnion Girder and Longitudinal Anchorage

Assigned Checker:

Additional Information:

Ira W. Dorsett

Project Name:

Designer/Originator(of calculations):

FMM Inlet Diversion Structure Date:

3

Page 4: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Design of Trunnion Girder and Pier Anchorage Check By:

Date:

General

Trunnion Girder

Gate Anchorage Zone

STAAD PRO 3D Structural Analysis and Design Software

Materials

Trunnion Girders  concrete shall be 7000 psi .

Anchorage zone concrete shall be  5000 psi .

Trunnion girder transverse anchorage shall be 2‐1/2" diameter grouted prestress bars.

Coated Bars and and fasteners shall conform to ASTM A‐775 or ASTM 934.  Expoxy Coating thickness shall be 12 mil

Ducts will be submitted to Contracting Officer Representative for approval

Bearing plates shall be A572 gr 50 galvanized according to ASTM A 123

The trunnion girder will be held in place by a unbonded anchorage system that extends into the concrete pier.  Longitudinal 

anchorage bars will be 2‐1/2" "expoxy coated bars placed inside 5" diameter O.D tube  for corrosion protection and 

Abutment Girder Dimensions

6' x 6' x 9.5'

Intermediate Girder Dimensions

6' x 6' x 17'

Longitudianl pier anchorage will be 2‐1/2 dia. Fusion bonded epoxy coated partially threaded bars

Element Dimensions

ACI 318‐14 Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete

American Institute of Steel Construction, 13 Edition

Computer Programs

SAPP 2000 Integrated Structural Analysis and Design Software

Ira W. Dorsett

Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure 9/29/2015

TRUNNION GIRDER DESIGN SUMMARY

The structural design is in accordance with Corps engineering Guidance and applicable industry standards.  The trunnion girder 

will be cast in place post tensioned construction.  The concrete trunnion girder shall be designed based on the working stress 

design method.  Behavior under service loads shall be considered at all load stages that may be critical during the life of the 

project from the time post tensioning is first applied.  

References

EM 1110‐2‐2000, Standard Practice for Concrete for Civil Works

EM 1110‐2‐2104 Strength Design for Reinforced Concrete Hyadralic Structures

EM 1110‐2‐2702 Design of Spillway Tainter Gates

Post Tensioning Manual 6th Edition

AASHTO LRFD Design Specifications 2012

4

Page 5: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Check By:

Date:

Figure 1‐A

R �tv Reaction Load Vertical 

RTH Reaction Load Horizontal

Mfrict Trunnion Pin Friction Torque

R Resultant Reaction

Thrust Thrust Force, Perpendicular Pier

α Resultant Angle

Descriptions

Ira W. Dorsett

2/22/2016Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure

Loading Conditions

Design of Trunnion Girder and Pier Anchorage

5

Page 6: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Check By:

Date:

Ira W. Dorsett

2/22/2016Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure

Loading Conditions

Factors

Hydraulic Factor 1.30 Per EM 1110‐2‐2104

Single Load Factor 1.70 Per EM 1110‐2‐2104

Per 1110‐2‐2702 1.20

L Case Ptv PTH Mfrict R Thrust α Rtv Rth

LC 1 (LS) ‐167.8 361.55 2.156 398.59 ‐161.28 ‐65.10 ‐257.002 ‐304.67

LC2b Ice ‐206.03 ‐525.09 2.09 564.06 ‐226.36 68.58 484.1985 ‐289.34

LC5(LS) ‐273.09 ‐545.28 ‐31.09 609.84 ‐234.45 63.40 514.9487 326.71

LC5 (b ice ‐182.55 ‐350.73 ‐26.16 395.39 157.21 62.50 374.29 ‐127.45

LC6 US LS ‐6.72 14.80 ‐5.09 16.25 6.73 ‐65.58 ‐15.0084 ‐6.24

LC 6 DS LS 44.75 ‐34.30 1.16 56.38 ‐20.83 ‐37.47 54.90278 12.84

L Case Ptv PTH Mfrict R Thrust α Rtv Rtv

LC 1 (LS) ‐370.84 799.03 4.76 880.89 ‐356.43 62.50 ‐567.975 ‐673.33

LC2b Ice ‐455.33 ‐1160.45 4.63 1246.58 ‐500.26 ‐65.58 1070.079 ‐639.45

LC5(LS) ‐603.53 ‐1205.07 ‐68.71 1347.76 ‐518.13 ‐37.47 1138.037 722.03

LC5 (b ice ‐403.44 ‐775.11 ‐57.81 873.82 347.43 0.00 827.181 ‐281.66

LC6 US LS ‐14.85 32.71 ‐11.25 35.92 14.87 0.00 ‐33.1686 ‐13.79

LC 6 DS LS 98.90 ‐75.80 2.57 124.61 ‐46.03 0.00 121.34 28.37

Per EM 1110‐2‐2702

Unfactored Trunion Load Values

Factored Trunion Load Values

Load Case 5 Governs. Examine unbalanced loading condition one gate just opening with adjacent gate fully open

6

Page 7: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Check By:

Date:

Ira W. Dorsett

2/22/2016Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure

Loading Conditions

One Gate Loaded Condition with give maximum anchorage force

1347.76 0

2.5 5 2.5

1.31 1.31

F1 2375.42

F1 2375.42

Assume Williams 2‐ 1/2  150 ksi Epoxy Coated All‐Thread Bar

CenterlineofPier

F1 F2

R1 R2

7

Page 8: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Check By:

Date:

Ira W. Dorsett

2/22/2016Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure

Loading Conditions

F1 required prestress after losses 2850.51

Bar Diameter 2‐1/2"

fts prestressing force 389.25

N # of bars 7 each side of pier

Calculate Prestress Losses

Calculate Prestess Losses per AASHTO Standard Specifications for Highway and Bridges

The loss due to elastic shortening in pretensioned members shall be taken as

Pier Face

LongitudinalAnchorage

8

Page 9: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Job: Check By:

Date:

Trunnion Dead Load (Self‐Weight) Computation

Assume trunnion girder is 6x6 in cross section and 17' long.  

Pier width = 10' therefore girder will overhang 3.5' on each side.

Girder Dimensions 1.00

H 6.00

W 6.00

ɣc 0.15 k/ft3

2.66 1.77

Weight 5.40 k/ft

α 0.51 29.47 W 5.40

4.70

Calculate loading on N‐Plane 

3.00 0.75 3.50

3.75

Prestress wPS 950.17 k/ft

Girder selfweight wTG 5.40 k/ft

Bearing stress Wbs 772.37 k/ft

Resultant Force 486.55 k/ft

Trunnion girder analyzed in STAAD as a cantilevered beam to calculate max moments and shears

Ira W. Dorsett

Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure 9//30/15

Trunnion Girder and Anchorage

1.25

2.77

WN

k/ft

WT

A

B

C

D 1

1.77

Centerlineof Pier

Symmetrical aboutCenterline

girder self weight

bearing stress

prestress force

face ofpier

9

Page 10: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Job: Check By:

Date:

Ira W. Dorsett

Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure 9//30/15

Trunnion Girder and Anchorage

Load Diagram

10

Page 11: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Job: Check By:

Date:

Ira W. Dorsett

Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure 9//30/15

Trunnion Girder and Anchorage

Max Moment 67537.00 k/in 5628.08 k/ft Centerline of Pier

Max Shear ‐1444.00 k

Max Moment ‐16256.00 k/in ‐1354.67 Face of Pier

Max Shear ‐983.00 k

Max Tensile Stress ‐1085.66 psi

Max Comp Stress 1085.66 psi

11

Page 12: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Job: Check By:

Date:

Trunnion Dead Load (Self‐Weight) Computation

Assume trunnion girder is 6x6 in cross section and 17' long.  

Pier width = 10' therefore girder will overhang 4' on each side.

Girder Dimensions 1.00

H 6.00

W 6.00

ɣc 0.15 k/ft3

2.66 1.77

Weight 5.40 k/ft

α 0.51 29.47 W 5.40

4.70

Calculate loading on T‐Plane 

1.25 3.00 0.75 3.50

Girder selfweight wTG 5.40 k/ft

Bearing stress Wbs 12.24 k/ft

Trunnion girder analyzed in STAAD as a cantilevered beam to calculate max moments and shears

Ira W. Dorsett

3/24/2015Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure

Trunnion Girder and Anchorage

WN

k/ft

WT

A

B

C

D 1

1.77

Centerlineof Pier

Symmetrical aboutCenterline

girder self weight

bearing stress

face ofpier

12

Page 13: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Job: Check By:

Date:

Ira W. Dorsett

3/24/2015Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure

Trunnion Girder and Anchorage

Load Diagram

13

Page 14: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Job: Check By:

Date:

Ira W. Dorsett

3/24/2015Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure

Trunnion Girder and Anchorage

Max Moment 7473.60 k/in 622.80 k/ft Centerline of Pier

Max Shear 108.00 k

Max Moment 710.23 k/in 59.19 Face of Pier

Max Shear ‐91.10 k

Max Tensile Stress ‐120.14 psi

Max Comp Stress 120.14 psi

14

Page 15: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Job: Check By:

Date:

N‐ Plane

Max Moment 67537.00 in‐kip 5628.08 ft‐kip Centerline of Pier

Max Shear ‐1444.00 k

Max Moment ‐16256.00 in‐kip ‐1354.67 Face of Pier

Max Shear ‐983.00 k

T‐Plane

Max Moment 7473.60 in‐kip 622.80 ft‐kip Centerline of Pier

Max Shear 108.00 k

Max Moment 710.23 k/in 59.19 Face of Pier

Max Shear ‐91.10 k

Calculate Section Modulus

S 62208 in3

Area 5184 in2

fb, bending stress due to Mn 1085.66 psi

fb, bending stress due to Mt 120.14 psi

Torsion from friction moment and gate weight

‐68.71 ft‐k

Gate wt 110 kips

Distance from centerline of pier to centerline of trunnion assembly 6.5 ft

Max Torsion ‐783.71 ft‐k

*Moments are conservatively assumed to act in same direction

Determine stresses at points A, B, C, and D on Trunnion Girder

Assume tension is positve for stress computaions

fa 1205.80 psi

fb ‐965.53 psi

fc ‐1205.80 psi

fd 965.53

Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure

Trunnion Girder and Anchorage

Ira W. Dorsett

10/5/2015

Calculate maximum flexural stresses in the Trunnion Girder

A

B

D

C

N

T

15

Page 16: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

Design of Trunnion Girder Prestress

15 2.5" @50% of Ultimate = 389 k/Bar

Calculate eccentricity by summing about centerline of girder

e 3

Maximum Tenion at point A 

1205.8 psi

Therfore prestress 1205 psi + 100 psi

1305 psi

Solve for final prestresss force

P/A +Pe/S = 1305 psi

P=  5,412,096.00

P= 5412 k

Number of Bars 13.90 appox 50% of Ultimate

Use 15 2‐1/2" bars 5835.00 kips

Final Stresses due to Prestress

‐P/A +/‐ Pe/S

‐844.18403 psi

‐1406.9734 psi

Calculate stresses in trunnion girder due to load and prestress

fa ‐201.17 psi

fb ‐1809.71 psi

fc ‐2049.99 psi

fd ‐441.45 psi

A

D

C

B

A

B

D

C

N

S

Pe

A

P

S

Pe

A

P

16

Page 17: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

Calculate initial stresses (jacking load) to prestress (65% initial prestress assumed)

Prestress force = 7585.50 kips

‐P/A +/‐ Pe/S

‐1097.44 psi

‐1829.07 psi

fa ‐623.26 psi

fb ‐2062.96 psi

fc ‐2303.24 psi

fd ‐863.54 psi

OK Since greater than 100 psi Compression

Calculation of Principle Tensile Stresses

Investigate Stresses @ Face of Pier ‐ Final Prestress & Design Load (Critical Case)

Vn‐plane ‐983.00 kips

Vt‐Plane ‐91.10 kips

MN‐Plane ‐16,256.00 in‐kip

MT‐Plane 710.23 in‐kip

Tmax ‐9404.51 in‐kip

S

Pe

A

P

17

Page 18: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

Using Bach's formula, torsional shear stress is

‐113.38 psi

Stresses in the N‐Plane

Shear stress N‐Plane

‐189.62 psi

Bending Stress (N‐Plane)

‐261.32 psi

Stresses in the T‐Plane

Shear stress T‐Plane

‐17.57 psi

Bending Stress (T‐Plane)

11.42 psi

Calculate stresses at intermediate points  E & G

Normal Stresses

10.29 psi

‐12.54 psi

Shear and Torsional Stresses

‐171.05 psi

A

B

D

C

22

9

bd

M t

bd

vV n

n

S

Mf n

n

bd

Vv t

S

Mf n

t

te fA

Pf

tg fA

Pf

max2

3 ne vv

18

Page 19: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

Shear and Torsional Stresses cont'd

‐397.82 psi

Principal Tensile Stresses

176.27 psi

403.00 psi

ftg is larger = 5.20   Limiting Value is 3

The principal stress at point E governs and is above the conservative limiting value.  However ultimate strength in shear

must be checked for total steel requirements

Calculate stresses at intermediate points  F & H

Normal Stresses

‐262.44 psi

260.19 psi

Shear and Torsional Stresses

‐397.82 psi

‐171.05 psi

max2

3 ng vv

22)2

(2 xy

yxyxtef

22)2

(2 xy

yxyxtgf

cf ' cf '

tF fA

Pf

tH fA

Pf

max2

3 nf vv

max2

3 tg vv

19

Page 20: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

Principal Tensile Stresses

287.68 psi

345.68 psi governs

Stress Definitions

22)2

(2 xy

yxyx

Hft

22)2

(2 xy

yxyxfft

20

Page 21: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By: Ira W. Dorsett

Project: Date:

Job: Check By:

Date:

ACI 318‐14

controls 387.2983 psi

737.34 psi

0.42 in2/in governs use 8# 7 @ 9"

0.06 in/in is less than 0.42 O.K.

Spalling reinforcement for trunnion girder

Peff =4% 233.4 n DDR 4% conservative assumption ACI calls our 2%

As 11.67 in2 therefore use 15 # 8's equals a As 14.77 in2

Calculate bursting stress in trunnion girder

Bursting stress = 18% of p/a 202.60 psi

36.47 0.24 psi less than 

Intermediate Pier

Longitudinal Prestrss

Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure

Trunnion Girder and Anchorage

Design of Shear Reinforcement

0.1&'5700'6.0 Mu

Vudfc

Mu

Vudfcvc

'5 fcVc

db

Vv

w

uu

fy

bwsvcvuAvreq

)(

fy

bwsAv

50min

60000

12'*6*203 psiAs

cf '2

21

Page 22: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

Check Girder to Pier Bearing

horizontal bearing distance 3.75 ft

Girder width 6 ft

Prestress Force assumed 65% ultimate for both sides 4203.9 kips

f'c 7000 psi

Bearing Stress  1297.5 psi < 0.25 f'c OK

Check stresses in pier

Pier width  10 ft

Pier stress 973.13 psi

Bursting Stress 175.16 psi equals 2.26

Area of steel req 0.21 in2/in 2.52 in2/ft use 7 #6 @ 12" for 10 feet

Spalling Reinf.

Trunnion Girder Bearing Against Pier Face

F= 4% of Prestress Force

As 16.816 in2 28.02667 use 4 rows of 7 # 7 bars @ spaced evenly

Longitudinal Reinforement

Trunnion girder to pier bearing 355.5556 psi <.25 f'c OK f'c = 6 ksi

Stresses in pier 888.89 psi 6.5 ft

Bursting stress 160 psi

As 0.384

cf '

60000

12'*6*175 psiAs

20

04.*2*4204sA

22

Page 23: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Job: Check By:

Date:

Calculate Anchorage Depth

Radius 27 ft

.90R 24.3 ft

Ira W. Dorsett

Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure 10/5/2015

Trunnion Girder and Anchorage

23

Page 24: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Check By:

Date:

General

Trunnion Girder

Gate Anchorage Zone

STAAD PRO 3D Structural Analysis and Design Software

Materials

Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi 

 Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi 

Trunnion girder transverse anchorage shall be 2‐1/2" diameter grouted prestress bars.

Coated Bars and and fasteners shall conform to ASTM A‐775 or ASTM 934.  Expoxy Coating thickness shall be 12 mil

Ducts will be rigid ferrous metal

Beaing plates shall be A572 gr 50 galvanized according to ASTM A 123

Ira W. Dorsett

Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure 2/22/2016

TRUNNION GIRDER DESIGN SUMMARY

The structural design is in accordance with Corps engineering Guidance and applicable industry standards.  The trunnion girder will 

be cast in place post tensioned construction.  The concrete trunnion girder shall be designed based on the working stress design 

method.  Behavior under service loads shall be considered at all load stages that may be critical during the life of the project from 

the time post tensioning is first applied.  

References

EM 1110‐2‐2000, Standard Practice for Concrete for Civil Works

EM 1110‐2‐2104 Strength Design for Reinforced Concrete Hyadralic Structures

EM 1110‐2‐2702 Design of Spillway Tainter Gates

Post Tensioning Manual 6th Edition

AASHTO LRFD Design Specifications 2012

Design of Abutment Pier Trunnion Girder and Pier Anchorage

The trunnion girder will be held in place by a unbonded anchorage system that extends into the concrete pier.  Longitudinal 

anchorage bars will be 2‐1/2" "expoxy coated bars placed inside a rigid metal duct and encased in grease for corrosion protection 

Abutment Girder Dimensions

6' x 6' x 9.5'

Intermediate Girder Dimensions

6' x 6' x 17'

Longitudianl pier anchorage will be 2‐1/2 dia. Fusion bonded epoxy coated partially threaded bars

Element Dimensions

ACI 318‐14 Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete

American Institute of Steel Construction, 13 Edition

Computer Programs

SAPP 2000 Integrated Structural Analysis and Design Software

24

Page 25: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Check By:

Date:

Figure 1‐A

R �tv Reaction Load Vertical 

RTH Reaction Load Horizontal

Mfrict Trunnion Pin Friction Torque

R Resultant Reaction

Thrust Thrust Force, Perpendicular Pier

α Resultant Angle

Ira W. Dorsett

2/22/2016Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure

Design of Trunnion Girder and Pier Anchorage

Abutment Loading Conditions

Descriptions

25

Page 26: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Check By:

Date:

Ira W. Dorsett

2/22/2016Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure

Abutment Loading Conditions

Factors

Hydraulic Factor 1.30 Per EM 1110‐2‐2104

Single Load Factor 1.70 Per EM 1110‐2‐2104

Per 1110‐2‐2702 1.20

L Case Ptv PTH Mfrict R Thrust α Rtv Rth

LC 1 (LS) ‐167.8 361.55 2.156 398.59 ‐161.28 ‐65.10 ‐257.002 ‐304.67

LC2b Ice ‐206.03 ‐525.09 2.09 564.06 ‐226.36 68.58 484.1985 ‐289.34

LC5(LS) ‐273.09 ‐545.28 ‐31.09 609.84 ‐234.45 63.40 514.9487 326.71

LC5 (b ice ‐182.55 ‐350.73 ‐26.16 395.39 157.21 62.50 374.29 ‐127.45

LC6 US LS ‐6.72 14.80 ‐5.09 16.25 6.73 ‐65.58 ‐15.0084 ‐6.24

LC 6 DS LS 44.75 ‐34.30 1.16 56.38 ‐20.83 ‐37.47 54.90278 12.84

L Case Ptv PTH Mfrict R Thrust α Rtv Rtv

LC 1 (LS) ‐370.84 799.03 4.76 880.89 ‐356.43 62.50 ‐567.975 ‐673.33

LC2b Ice ‐455.33 ‐1160.45 4.63 1246.58 ‐500.26 ‐65.58 1070.079 ‐639.45

LC5(LS) ‐603.53 ‐1205.07 ‐68.71 1347.76 ‐518.13 ‐37.47 1138.037 722.03

LC5 (b ice ‐403.44 ‐775.11 ‐57.81 873.82 347.43 0.00 827.181 ‐281.66

LC6 US LS ‐14.85 32.71 ‐11.25 35.92 14.87 0.00 ‐33.1686 ‐13.79

LC 6 DS LS 98.90 ‐75.80 2.57 124.61 ‐46.03 0.00 121.34 28.37

Per EM 1110‐2‐2702

Unfactored Trunion Load Values

Factored Trunion Load Values

Load Case 5 Governs. Examine unbalanced loading condition one gate just opening with adjacent gate fully open

26

Page 27: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Check By:

Date:

Ira W. Dorsett

2/22/2016Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure

Abutment Loading Conditions

One Gate Loaded Condition with give maximum anchorage force

1347.76

1.5 2.41 1.58

1.31

F1 2920.61

F1 2920.61

Assume Williams 2‐ 1/2  150 ksi Expoxy Coated All‐Thread Bar

CenterlineofPier

F1 F2

R1

27

Page 28: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Check By:

Date:

Ira W. Dorsett

2/22/2016Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure

Abutment Loading Conditions

F1 required prestress after losses 3504.73

Bar Diameter 2‐1/2"

fts prestressing force 389.25

N # of bars 9 each side of pier

Therefore

F2 F1‐R1 2156.97

F1 required prestress after losses 2157

Bar Diameter 2‐1/2"

fts prestressing force 389.25

N # of bars 6

f1 ***tension positve

‐91 ksf 631 psi

f2

‐157.26937 ksf 1090 psi

Calculate Prestress Losses

Check pier stresses with F1 =3505 kips, no gate load and no prestress force at F2

Compute fiber stresses in f2 inactive side

I

Pec

A

P

I

Pec

A

P

28

Page 29: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Check By:

Date:

Ira W. Dorsett

2/22/2016Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure

Abutment Loading Conditions

`

Calculate Prestess Losses per AASHTO Standard Specifications for Highway and Bridges

29

Page 30: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Job: Check By:

Date:

Trunnion Dead Load (Self‐Weight) Computation

Assume trunnion girder is 6x6 in cross section and 17' long.  

Pier width = 10' therefore girder will overhang 3.5' on each side.

Girder Dimensions 1.00

H 6.00

W 6.00

ɣc 0.15 k/ft3

2.66 1.77

Weight 5.40 k/ft

α 0.51 29.47 W 5.40

4.70

Calculate loading on N‐Plane 

3.75

Prestress wPS #DIV/0! k/ft

Girder selfweight wTG 5.40 k/ft

Bearing stress Wbs 934.59 k/ft

Resultant Force 486.55 k/ft

Trunnion girder analyzed in STAAD as a cantilevered beam to calculate max moments and shears

Ira W. Dorsett

Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure 9//30/15

Trunnion Girder and Anchorage

2.77

WN

k/ft

WT

A

B

C

D 1

1.77

Centerlineof Pier

girder self weight

bearing stress

prestress force

face ofpier

9"

1'‐8"

4"

4"

2'‐6"

30

Page 31: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Job: Check By:

Date:

Ira W. Dorsett

Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure 9//30/15

Trunnion Girder and Anchorage

Load Diagram

31

Page 32: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Job: Check By:

Date:

Ira W. Dorsett

Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure 9//30/15

Trunnion Girder and Anchorage

Max Moment 67537.00 k/in 5628.08 k/ft Centerline of Pier

Max Shear ‐1444.00 k

Max Moment ‐16256.00 k/in ‐1354.67 Face of Pier

Max Shear ‐983.00 k

Max Tensile Stress ‐1085.66 psi

Max Comp Stress 1085.66 psi

32

Page 33: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Job: Check By:

Date:

Trunnion Dead Load (Self‐Weight) Computation

Assume trunnion girder is 6x6 in cross section and 17' long.  

Pier width = 10' therefore girder will overhang 4' on each side.

Girder Dimensions 1.00

H 6.00

W 6.00

ɣc 0.15 k/ft3

2.66 1.77

Weight 5.40 k/ft

α 0.51 29.47 W 5.40

4.70

Calculate loading on T‐Plane 

Girder selfweight wTG 5.40 k/ft

Bearing stress Wbs 899.00 k/ft

Bearing stress Wbs 895.00

Prestress Inactive 12.69

Prestress Active 1168.00

Trunnion girder analyzed in STAAD as a cantilevered beam to calculate max moments and shears

Ira W. Dorsett

3/24/2015Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure

Trunnion Girder and Anchorage

WN

k/ft

WT

A

B

C

D 1

1.77

girder self weight

bearing stress

9"1'‐8"4"2'‐6"9"PrestressInactive Side

3'‐3" 2'‐5"

33

Page 34: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Job: Check By:

Date:

Ira W. Dorsett

3/24/2015Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure

Trunnion Girder and Anchorage

Load Diagram

34

Page 35: CALCULATION COVER SHEET - s3.us-east … · Trunnion Girders concrete shall be 7000 psi . Anchorage zone concrete shall be 5000 psi . Trunnion ... will be cast in place post tensioned

USACE‐ New Orleans District Calcs By:

Project: Date:

Job: Check By:

Date:

Ira W. Dorsett

3/24/2015Fargout Inlet Diversion Structure

Trunnion Girder and Anchorage

Max Moment 48700.00 k/in 4058.33 k/ft Centerline of Pier

Max Shear 7473.60

Max Tensile Stress 782.00 psi

Max Comp Stress 782.00 psi

35