How to read citation:Case name, SP/CR/CV No., date of promulgation, volume O.G. pageCOURT OF APPEALS CASESJanuary-December 2!27T Se!urit" # $nvestigation Servi!e$n!. vs. National %a&or RelationsCommission, SP No. '()()7,*anuar" +,, +('(, '(, O.G. --..A/&ad01ersola vs. 2e, SP No.'(37'+, *ul" ), +('(, '(, O.G..+4'/&on vs. /&on, CV No. .,434, 5a"+3, +('(, '(, O.G. +7-3/6inomoto P7ilippines Corp. vs.National %a&or RelationsCommission, SP No, ''44'',O!to&er +7, +('(, '(, O.G. '+7-/lisasisvs.8ulalia,CV No. ,,)4(,2e&ruar" +7, +((,, '(, O.G. '.-./9uil vs. /sen!io, SP No. ),++',2e&ruar" +7, +((,, '(, O.G. '.3'/raneta vs. /talpa:o, SP No.)3+'3, 5ar!7 ,, +((7/r&uesvs. /r&ues, CRNo. )++7',Novem&er ',, +('(, '(, O.G. ''3)/renas0Gon;ales vs. %o!al CivilRegistrar of Calasiao, Pangasinan,CV No. ,-33+, 8e!em&er '+, +((7,'(, O.G. 4)-4/rnold vs. Torio, SP No. ,-3)(,O!to&er +7, +('(, '(, O.G. 47),/rsenio vs. %o!al Civil Registrar1auang, %aspilo"vs. Repi;o, CVNo. 7-33(,5a" +3, +('(, '(, O.G. '47->strella vs. 5esa, CVNo. )4.74,5ar!7 7, +('', '(, O.G. 3(.+>strera vs. 5agtango&, CV No.,3(-3, O!to&er ++, +('(, '(, O.G.4.7,>usta9uio08imaguila vs. Repu&li!of t7eP7ilippines, CVNo. 7)-3+,Novem&er +), +((7, '(, O.G. 4+-)>Calta!ion vs. 2a6ardo, SP No.''+,'-, 2e&ruar" ), +('', '(,O.G. -).'F2ilDe& S"stem Te!7nolog" vsNational %a&or RelationsCommission, SP No. '''.-',O!to&er +,, +('(, '(, O.G. 4,(-2ran!o vs. 5a!alino, CV No. )'.43,Septem&er '3, +('(, '(, O.G.'4,42ung vs. 8evanadera, SP No.'''+,), /ugust +., +('(, '(, O.G.4-('$Page 2 of 2#Geneti! 2arm, $n!. vs. National%a&or Relations Commission, SPNo. '()+)', 5a" +,, +('(, '(,O.G. +)))Gon;ales vs. Penta Capital 2inan!eCorporation, CV No. 7(3..,O!to&er ++, +('(, '(, O.G. 4.,'Guerra vs. Pasia, SP No. )3))-,Septem&er '+, +((,, '(, O.G.',,+Guiao vs. 2e, CV No. 7'.-4, 5ar!74(, +('(, '(, O.G. .'+)%$leto vs. Ri;al Commer!ial 1an=ingCorporation, CV No. ,..4-, *anuar"4', +((,, '(, O.G. '-,. J*enia %and Ventures vs. Register of8eeds of 1aguio Cit", CV No..-77+, /ugust '7, +('(, '(, O.G.'+7(L%a6ar!avs. /n!7or Savings 1an=,CVNo. )4-7,,5a"+-,+('','(,O.G. 3+('%aplana vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. ,3()-, O!to&er+), +('(, '(, O.G. .33(%omotan vs. 5iranda, CV No.,,'77, 2e&ruar" '+, +('(, '(,O.G. --74%on;anida vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. ,74(.,Novem&er '3, +('(, '(, O.G.4)4,, '(, O.G. -+)'&5a&anglo0Villeta vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CVNo. )477+, 5ar!7+,, +('', '(, O.G. 3(.,5a!E5ar S7elis TaCi vs. National%a&or Relations Commission, SPNo. '(.(+-, *ul" +), +('(, '(,O.G. '(.+5agsipo! vs. National %a&orRelations Comission, SPNo.''(+3(, 5a" '+, +('(, '(, O.G.')5alu&a" vs. National %a&orRelations Commission, SP No.'()()., *ul" '4, +('(, '(, O.G.3+-5ana7an vs. 1elmonte, SP No.'(,-3., /ugust '7, +('(, '(, O.G.434)5ani9ui; vs. 8uma"as, SP No.'((.-7, *anuar" +7, +('(, '(,O.G. 37)+5endo;a vs Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. )()4-, *ul" 4(,+('(, '(, O.G. 44)-5endo;a vs. People of t7eP7ilippines, CR No. 4+-.4, 5a" +,,+('(, '(, O.G. 4((3Page ' of 2#5enesesvs. Cru;, CVNo. 7.'3',*anuar" '3, +('(, '(, O.G. 3.7(5etropolitan 1an= and TrustCompan" vs. /rnaldo, CV No.)43.', Novem&er '3, +('(, '(,O.G. 4)4+, '(, O.G. -+,-5etropolitan 1an= and TrustCompan" vs. CafF 5ei, $n!., CV No.,.'+4, O!to&er ++, +('(, '(, O.G..3-+5ontes vs. Civil Servi!eCommission, SPNo. '(').(, 5a"+7, +('(, '(, O.G. +'.-PPait vs. 8enso, SP No. '(4-,,,5ar!7 '+, +('(, '(, O.G. .(',Paneda vs. *avarata, CV No. ,73)7,*anuar" 4', +((,, '(, O.G. '-,+Parallag vs. Civil Registrar ofCaua"an, $sa&ela, CVNo. ,-7.',Septem&er +(, +('(, '(, O.G..-33People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Tugano, CRNo. +3).-, Novem&er4(, +((.,Peopleoft7eP7ilippinesvs. Celis,CR No. 4+.7', *une +', +('', '(,O.G. 3474People of t7e P7ilippines vs. de*esus, CR No. (-4.3, *une '-, +('','(, O.G. 34.4People of t7e P7ilippines vs. 8elRosario, CR No. 4+'73, Septem&er'7, +('(, '(, O.G. ,+)Peopleof t7eP7ilippinesvs. 8elaCru;,CR No. +.)7- Septem&er '7,+('(, '(, O.G. 74)Peopleof t7eP7ilippinesvs. delaCru;, CR0.C. No. (4,(7, *ul"'3,+('(, '(, O.G. '(-3People of t7e P7ilippines vs.>sogon, CV No. 4++(,, *une +),+('(, '(, O.G. -7)(Peopleof t7eP7ilippines vs. 2iger,CR No. 4+'-4, /pril +., +('(, '(,O.G. -.,(People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Gavino, CR No. 4+.,., *une +4,+('(, '(, O.G. 4,' People of t7e P7ilippines vs.%a&utap, CR No. 4'4.4, *anuar" ',,+('(, '(, O.G. 3.73People of t7e P7ilippines vs.%iDanag, CR0CNo. (4+3(, 5ar!7++, +('(, '(, O.G. +-37People of t7e P7ilippines vs.5analang, CR0.C. No. (4.--,8e!em&er ,, +('(, '(, O.G. -'++People of t7e P7ilippines vs.5araorao, CR No. 4+.77,Septem&er '7, +('(, '(, O.G.''3+Peopleof t7eP7ilippinesvs. Pa6e,CRNo. 4'73(, /ugust +7, +('(,'(, O.G. 43-3People of t7e P7ilippines vs. Pla;a,CR No. 4'3.,, *une +7, +('', '(,O.G. 3-)+Page ( of 2#People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Po&lete, Sr., CR No. 4(7++,2e&ruar" +., +('(, '(, O.G. .('(People of t7e P7ilippines vs. Ro&les,CRCNo. (4)33, *une+7, +('','(, O.G. 33(-People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Santiago, CRCNo. (47'', *une'', +('', '(, O.G. 3+(.Peopleoft7eP7ilippinesvs. Sosa,CR No. 4'+.,, *une +), +('(, '(,O.G. 44,)Pe:aredondo vs. National %a&orRelations Commission, SP No.''+)4(, /ugust '', +('(, '(, O.G.'+.-Petral&a vs. People of t7eP7ilippines, CR No. 4+''7,Novem&er '7, +('(, '(, O.G. '+,4P7ilippine National 1an= vs. deCastro, SP No. '(7777, *ul" +4,+('(, '(, O.G. 434-Pilar 8evelopment Corporationvs.Gura", SP No. '(4(,., *une '.,+('(, '(, O.G. 4'43Pimentel vs. Tiu, SP No. ))73',/pril 4(, +('(, '(, O.G. .'4.)Gui!= NH eart" vs. National %a&orRelations Commission, SP No.'(3,44, /ugust +7, +('(, '(, O.G..+4.Guingvs.Capatan,CV No. ,3(..,Novem&er +), +((7, '(, O.G. 4+37RRamire; vs. 8a"ag, SP No. ''+737,Septem&er '3, +('(, '(, O.G. 74+Ramos vs. 5anoto! Realt", $n!., CVNo. ,,'-', 5ar!7'+, +('(, '(,O.G. +4'.Ramos vs. OI!e of t7eCler= ofCourt, RTC, CV No. 744(., 5a" '4,+('(, '(, O.G. '-3Ramos vs. Soriano, SP No. '''.(.,8e!em&er +), +('(, '(, O.G. '-).Ri;al Commer!ial 1an=ingCorporation vs. JDong, SP No.'(7+7(, /ugust 4, +('(, '(, O.G.'(7+SSa&ado vs People of t7eP7ilippines, SP No. '()).4, *une'7, +('(, '(, O.G. -.((San /dres vs. SupremeTransportation %iner, $n!., CVNo.)4((3, *anuar" +7, +('', '(, O.G.-)3-Santos vs. Santos, SP No. ''+.,.,Novem&er +., +('(, '(, O.G. '-)(Sapulno vs. People of t7eP7ilippines, SP No. )))-,,Septem&er ), +('(, '(, O.G. .4-(Se!urit" and Safet" Corporation oft7eP7ilippinesvs. 5upas, SPNo.'(7.3,, 8e!em&er +(, +('(, '(,O.G. -'+7Page * of 2#Si!at vs. Provin!e of Tarla!, CV No.,3)3', O!to&er '', +('(, '(, O.G..-.(Sinad vs. Natividad, CV No. ,3(4(,2e&ruar" +-, +('(, '(, O.G. +'33Solid&an= Corporation vs. 8ara!an,CVNo. 7,7,4, 2e&ruar"3, +('(,'(, O.G. 3)'+TTa7anlangit vs. /r&oleda, SP No.'(.'+,, 5ar!7 '(, +('(, '(, O.G.+'3)Tallanovs. Rementilla0Gongon, CVNo. ,4,(4, Septem&er '7, +('(,'(, O.G. .4-,To="o 5arine 5ala"an $nsuran!eCo., $n!. vs. Geologisti!s, %td., SPNo. '(-)44, Novem&er 4(, +('(,'(, O.G. -''.Tumaneng $$ vs. Nar!iso, SP No.'(7(((, 5ar!7 '+, +('(, '(, O.G.+4'(T" vs. Corporal, CV No. 7,+(3, *ul"+7, +('(, '(, O.G. 7''Uverlast $nternational Pla!ement,$n!., vs. National %a&or RelationsComission, SP No. )43-,, 2e&ruar"+,, +((7, '(7 O.G. ++37F2ernande; vs. Carungi, CV No.,37',, /ugust '7, +((., '(7 O.G.4-.(2ilipinas /gri05illing Corporation vs.RTC, 1ran!7.+, Guma!a, Gue;on,SPNo. ,7)-4, *anuar" 4', +((,,'(7 O.G. 4.4+2ian;avs. /&an!e, CVNo. ,('3),O!to&er '', +((7, '(7 O.G. 3-(32lores vs. People of t7e P7ilippines,CR No. 4(((+, Septem&er 7, +((.,'(7 O.G. 44..2ontillas vs. /&rigo, CV No. ,-)(',5ar!7 '4, +((7, '(7 O.G. +7.-2umar vs. Commission on /udit, SPNo. )','-, 5ar!7+4, +((7, '(7O.G. +4.-$Gar!ia vs. National %a&or RelationsCommission, SP No. )()34,2e&ruar" +,, +((7, '(7 O.G. ,74Gar!iavs. Gar!ia, CVNo. 73+(3,5ar!7 ), +((7, '(7 O.G. -L%aSalleCollege$nternational vs.National %a&or RelationsCommission, SP No. '''-'3,*anuar" +), +('(, '(7 O.G. .+3,%a&aro vs. National %a&or RelationsCommission, SP No. )4,)+,Septem&er ,, +((., '(7 O.G. 4-.,%and 1an= of t7e P7ilippines vs. delRosario, SPNo. )333), 5ar!7+),+((7, '(7 O.G. ''()%i&as vs. Candelaria, CV No. ,+)--,/pril +., +((7, '(7 O.G. '-3,%u!erovs. 5ar!elo, SPNo. ,34)(,/ugust +-, +((7, '(7 O.G. 3+4)&5a!atanga" vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. ,447', O!to&er'3, +((7, '(7 O.G. ',Page . of 2#5anu&a" vs. National %a&orRelations Commission, SP No.),4.), Septem&er '4, +((7, '(7O.G. .(()Pere;05artine; vs. /r&orvitae Plains5ontessori, $n!., CV No. )((4.,*anuar" +), +('(, '(7 O.G. ..(-5endo;a vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CVNo. ,.3(-, 5ar!7'-, +((7, '(7 O.G. )3)5i6ares vs. Gana, SP No. ,.,3,,*une +3, +((,, '(7 O.G. -,-+/Naigan vs. 1autista, SP No. )3)44,2e&ruar" +,, +((7, '(7 O.G. ++3+NeD&orn 2ood Produ!ts, $n!. vs.National %a&or RelationsCommission, SP No. '(++.(,O!to&er +,, +((,, '(7 O.G. 3()'OOng=ing vs. /velino, CV No. ,-773,/ugust +-, +((7, '(7 O.G. 3+44O"od vs. Civil Registrar, Cordon,$sa&ela,CVNo.,7'44,Septem&er++, +((,, '(7 O.G. 3(,-O;aeta vs. Ca&anos, SP No. )4..4,/pril +,, +((,,'(.O.G. )4-, '(7OG +,73 PPa!iK! Plans >mplo"ees /sso!iationvs. Pa!iK! Plans, $n!., SP No. )','(,/pril +), +((,, '(7 O.G. -4,3Pader vs. 5allilin, CRNo. +)-(3,*anuar" '7,+((7, '(7 O.G. '7,-People of t7e P7ilippines vs. 2a&ros,CR.C. No. (()33, *ul"'', +((.,'(7 O.G. 4(++People of t7e P7ilippines vs. u, CRNo. +)-)4, /ugust ,, +((., '(7O.G. 4(4'People of t7e P7ilippines vs./ltuveros, CR .C. No. (',+,,5ar!7 +', +((7, '(7 O.G. +.4-People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Gon;ales, CRNo. +),,', *une+),+((7, '(7 O.G. +7.7People of t7e P7ilippines vs.>s!ano, CR No. +)43-, 2e&ruar"'+, +((7, '(7 O.G. ++-7People of t7e P7ilippines vs./l!ara;, CR0.C. No. ('+,,,2e&ruar" +', +((7, '(7 O.G. +()(People of t7e P7ilippines vs. Pi:on,CR0.C. No. (',-,, *anuar" 4',+((7, '(7 O.G. +(,4People of t7e P7ilippines vs. Gener,CR0C No. (+7,(, *anuar" +),+('(, '(7 O.G. .-3.People of t7e P7ilippines vs. >&role,CR No. 4',3., 5ar!7 4(, +('(, '(7O.G. .-.4People of t7e P7ilippines vs. 5u:o;,CR No. +)'73, 5ar!7 '), +((7, '(7O.G. +-4)Page # of 2#People of t7e P7ilippines vs. $!a"an,CR0.C. No. (+4+4, 2e&ruar" ),+((7, '(7O.G. '77.People of t7e P7ilippines vs./g!aoili, CR0.C. No. (+3'-,*anuar" 4', +((,, '(7 O.G. 47+'People of t7e P7ilippines vs. 8ivina,CR0.C.No. ((.)., *une ., +((7,'(7 O.G. +-3+People of t7e P7ilippines vs. Valino,CR No. 4(3+), /pril +), +((,, '(7O.G. -474People of t7e P7ilippines vs. 1ianes,CR No. 4(.'', /pril 4(, +((,, '(7O.G. -3+4People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Samson, CRNo. +)).-, *une'),+((7, '(7 O.G. +33( People of t7e P7ilippines vs.5anangan, CRNo. +,..-, *anuar"'7, +((7, '(7 O.G. '.'.People of t7e P7ilippines vs./nguluan, CR.0C No. (++,',Novem&er +., +((7, '(7 O.G. 33.+People of t7e P7ilippines vs.1a!illano, CR0C No. (+'7-,Novem&er +., +((7, '(7 O.G. .'(People of t7e P7ilippines vs.%atonio, CRNo. 4(+,., 8e!em&er+(, +((7, '(7 O.G. 37+-People of t7e P7ilippines vs.1autista, CR0C No. ('++(,8e!em&er '), +((7, '(7 O.G. .''7People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Soliveres, *r., CRNo. +))4+, 5a"4', +((7, '(7 O.G. ''4People of t7e P7ilippines vs.5iram&il, CR0 .C. No. ('3-',Novem&er '), +((7, '(7 O.G. +-.People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Gimena0Ca!7o, CV No. ,.,(4,5ar!7 '-, +((7, '(7 O.G. ).7P7ilippine Clearing ouseCorporation vs. Cit" Treasurer of5anila, C.V. No. 74-4), Septem&er+(, +((., '(7 O.G. 4+.Pineda, Sr. vs. Gon;ales, SP No.)-'3,, 2e&ruar" '', +((,, '(7O.G. 474-Plan 8ot Com, $n!., vs. National%a&or Relations Commission, SPNo. )+,47, /pril 7, +((., '(7 O.G.+,..Provident $nsuran!e Corp. vs. 5!5ai Ce&uTrading, CVNo. .)4'+,5ar!7 +), +((7, '(7 O.G. '--)RRa"mundo vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. )'3+), /pril,+('(, '(7 O.G. .73+Residen!e$nnCorporationvs. Pe,CVNo. ,--'3, *anuar"+-, +((,,'(7 O.G. 447.Re"esvs. 5onto6o, CVNo. )''4',2e&ruar" '(, +('(, '(7 O.G. ..()Re"es, *r. vs. 2arrales, SP No.),7.7, 5ar!74', +((,, '(7O.G.-')-Page ! of 2#Rosales vs. Sa&roso, CV No. 7),+3,5ar!7 +7, +((,, '(7 O.G. -(47Rui; vs. 2eli!en, SP No. )+.,', /pril7, +((., '(7 O.G. +73,Rural 1an=of Po;orru&io, $n!. vs./!osta, SP No. )..3., /pril 4(,+((,, '(7 O.G. -3+,Rural 1an= of Tag=aDa"an, $n!. vs.5ali&iran, CV No. ,'47+, 5ar!7 4',+((,, '(7 O.G. -')'SSalongavs. 1ernal, SPNo. )').+,*ul" '., +((,, '(7 O.G. -,3'Santos05olina vs. 5olina, Sr., CVNo. ..+,(, *une 7, +((7, '(7 O.G.+3-3Sa"vs. 1uena, *r., SPNo. )3,33,Novem&er 7, +((7, '(7 O.G. '+4Se!urit" and Safet" Corp. of t7eP7ilippines $n!., ?SSCP@ vs. National%a&orRelationsComission, SPNo.)--7-, 5ar!7+', +((7, '(7O.G.+437Se!urit"1an=Corporationvs. Ta!0an, SPNo. )3'(), 5a"+., +((,,'(7 O.G. -.3.Si!at vs. /!u:a, SP No. )4('3,5ar!7 +4, +((7, '(7 O.G. +4.(S=ippers iseltin vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. 77,4-,Novem&er +4, +((., '(. OG -+4(>stiller vs. Oria, CV No. ,'-4',O!to&er ++, +((7, '(. OG +)4(>spiritu vs. Sera *ose, SP No.,3('., 5a" 4(, +((., '(. OG .++ F2ilinvest %and $n!. vs. Pastor, SP No.,4'73, /ugust +-, +((7, '(. O.G..)'+2loresvs. %lam;on, SPNo. )+-(',*une '), +((., '(. O.G. -,4 2ood Terminal, $n!orporated vs.National %a&or RelationsCommission, SP No. )(,(',2e&ruar" '3, +((., '(. O.G. -+')$Galderma vs. Pineda, SP No. )-+,.,8e!em&er +', +((7, '(. O.G. 3-3,Gali!iavs. 1an=of San*uan, $n!.,CV No. ,-)'4, /pril (7, +((., '(.O.G. +-)'Galve; vs. Vi&andor, SP No. )(.7-,5ar!7 '), +((7, '(. O.G. .)('Gamma oldings Corporation vs.Saulog, CV No. .34-4, /ugust 4',+((7, '(. O.G. +77+Guer;o vs. Veli!aria, CV No. .7(..,/pril '), +((7, '(. O.G. -)' %$gna!io vs. 8atumanong, SP No.7)7-4, /pril -, +((., '(. O.G.'3.4In re/n!7eta vs. Palparan, SP No.)3.3., *une '), +((7, '(. O.G.+7.3In re/ng 1an Ting vs. Repu&li! oft7e P7ilippines, CV No. ,734-,Septem&er '(, +((7, '(. O.G. 4,In rePadua vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. .7,7,,Novem&er +), +((7, '(. O.G. '(37InreRa:esesvs. Repu&li!of t7eP7ilippines, CVNo. ,-.(7, *une.,+((., '(. O.G. '(3', '(7 O.G.4('.$ndo P7il. TeCtile 5ills, $n!. Oor=ers"e Se!urit" $n!orporated vs.National %a&or RelationCommission, SP No. )'(((, *anuar"4', +((., '(. O.G. -''75etropolitan 1an= and TrustCompan"vs. >ugenio, *r., SPNo.)3(3', 2e&ruar" +., +((7, '(.O.G. ..375inguita vs. National %a&orRelations Commission, SP No.)3'+), O!to&er +., +((7, '(. O.G.7)-5iCRi!7Trading, $n!. vs. National%a&or Relations Commission, SPNo. ,.3-4, Septem&er ++, +((.,'(. O.G. '7++5u7la!7vs. Cru;, CVNo. .77)+,5ar!7 '+, +((7, '(. O.G. 7(+)/Na"ve vs. People of t7e P7ilippines,CRNo. +.3,3, 2e&ruar"'7, +((.,'(. O.G. 4+'7Ni!er vs. 2ernande;, CV No. .,344,*anuar" +4, +((7, '(. O.G. ...+OOriental /ssuran!e Corp. vs.1asilla, SP No. ,7'(+, /pril 7, +((.,'(. O.G. '). PPagsasama sa $isang /d7i=ain, $n!.?P$/@ vs. %ope;, CV No. ,7(,+, *une+), +((7, '(. O.G. +)+-People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Camana, CRNo. +.)-3, *une'3,+((7, '(. O.G. .'-'Page !( of 2#People of t7e P7ilippines vs. 8avid,CR No. +3,'7, *une ++, +((7, '(.O.G. .'4(People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Cantu&a, CR0.C. No. ('437, 5ar!74', +((., '(. O.G. 44-3People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Salvador 1atta, CR No. +..+(, *ul"4(, +((7, '(. O.G. .'-.Peopleof t7eP7ilippines vs. San5iguel, CRNo. ('3+4, 8e!em&er'-, +((7, '(. O.G. .'3+ People of t7e P7ilippines vs.8uldulad, CR No.+)73), O!to&er4(,+((7, '(. O.G. .'4.People of t7e P7ilippines vs. %u!as,CR No. +)-3-, *une 4(, +((., '(.O.G. -'+3People of t7e P7ilippines vs.1ang=iling, CR No. +,4,4,Septem&er +7, +((., '(. O.G.47)( People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Caindo", CR No. +)44', 8e!em&er+), +((., '(. O.G. 3--.People of t7e P7ilippines vs.8e9uito, CR0C. No. ('+,7, 5a"+,, +((7, '(. O.G. 3((,People of t7e P7ilippines vs.O!7otorena, CR No. +,3+-,2e&ruar" ++, +((., '(. O.G. +(.'People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Tolentino, CR0C No. ('++),Novem&er +), +((., '(. O.G. +(.7People of t7e P7ilippines vs. %a;aro,CRNo.+747+,5a" 4(,+((7,'(.O.G. 7(4.People of t7e P7ilippines vs.%a!7i!a, CR0.C. No. ('-)', *une'4, +((7, '(. O.G. 7')7People of t7e P7ilippines vs.$llustre, *r., CR No. +)(4',8e!em&er '), +((7, '(. O.G. 7+(-People of t7e P7ilippines vs. >vora.CR No. +)',', /pril 4(, +((7, '(.O.G. 74(-People of t7e P7ilippines vs.5a&&orang, CR No. +3,(-, /ugust4(, +((7, '(. O.G. .+4.People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Corpu;, CRNo. +),)-, Septem&er'-, +((7, '(. O.G. .+--People of t7e P7ilippines vs.1atimana, CR0.C. No. ((+'(,2e&ruar" '), +((7, '(. O.G. .4)4People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Saguin, CRNo. +()3-, Septem&er+., +((7, '(. O.G. .4),People of t7e P7ilippines vs. 1o!eo,CR No. +)73,, Novem&er '., +((7,'(. O.G. .3+4People of t7e P7ilippines vs.%umna, CR No. +)3(4, *anuar" '7,+((7, '(. O.G. ..3+People of t7e P7ilippines vs. O&i:a,CR No. +..)), /pril ',, +((7, '(.O.G. ...7Page !* of 2#People of t7e P7ilippines vs,Ramire;, CR No. +)-)), 5ar!7 '),+((7, '(. O.G. 3.',People of t7e P7ilippines vs. %evoit,CR No. +)+)7, /pril +4, +((7, '(.O.G. 3.+4People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Guidatu, CRNo. +)3,), /pril +.,+((7, '(. O.G. 37)7People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Ramos, CR No. +3)'4, 5a" '7,+((7, '(. O.G. 3,(3People of t7e P7ilippines vs. 1arad,CRNo.+.-,+,5a" ',,+((7,'(.O.G. 3).,People of t7e P7ilippines vs. Rivera,CRNo.+3,'(,5a" ++,+((7,'(.O.G. 3)74People of t7e P7ilippines vs. *unas,CR .C. No. ('.7), *anuar" ',,+((7, '(. O.G. -7(,People of t7e P7ilippines vs. 2lores,CR No. +)')3, Novem&er +), +((7,'(. O.G. 3,'(People of t7e P7ilippines vs.1orromeo, CR No. +7.'-,8e!em&er '-, +((7, '(. O.G. 3)7,People of t7e P7ilippines vs. Torres,CR C No. (+-'', 5ar!7 +4, +((7,'(. O.G. -,-,People of t7e P7ilippines vs. /rasa,CR No. +)747, /pril '(, +((7, '(.O.G. -,3)People of t7e P7ilippines vs./ltuveros, CR .C. No. (',+,,5ar!7 +', +((., '(. O.G. 777People of t7e P7ilippines vs. >s!oto,CR No. +,7.., 5ar!7 +), +((., '(.O.G. 477People of t7e P7ilippines vs. 2a&ros,CR.C. No. (()33, *ul"'', +((.,'(. O.G. ''7+People of t7e P7ilippines vs. u, CRNo. +)-)4, /ugust ,, +((., '(.O.G. '+)+People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Villanueva, CR No. +)-4-,Novem&er ), +((., '(. O.G. '7'4Peopleof t7eP7ilippines vs. deGu;man, *r., CR. C No. ((7+-,/ugust +,, +((., '(. O.G. 4-.,Penafran!ia 1road!astingCorporation vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. 7)4)4,Novem&er ., +((., '(. O.G. -++. Pere;vs. National %a&orRelationsCommission, SP No. )+))+,Septem&er +., +((7, '(. O.G.74'(Perr"man vs. 1i!ol air >CportCorporation, SP No. )'-,3, O!to&er4(, +((., '(. O.G. 4-Prudential Guarantee#/ssuran!e$n!. vs. /8RS7ippingServi!eand%i&ert" S7ipping Corporation, CVNo. .43'-, O!to&er +3, +((., '(.O.G. 4.43RPage !, of 2#Ramosvs. 1a"&a", SPNo. 7-,33,/pril +(, +((., '(. O.G. -,.Ra"mundo vs. 8e Te6u!o, SP No.)',((, /pril +4, +((7, '(. O.G..4( Repu&li! of t7e P7ilippines vs.Re"es, CV No. ,.,.-, 8e!em&er'), +((7, '(. O.G. 344+Rosales vs. >9uidata P7ilippines, SPNo. 7+++3, 5ar!7+-, +((., '(.O.G. ')'(SSing7 vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. ,',(', 5a" +.,+((., '(. O.G. 47-Song!u"avs. %im, SPNo. 37437,/ugust 4', +((., '(. O.G. 3'3,TTan vs. National %a&or RelationsCommission, SPNo. )3+,+, 5ar!7'-, +((7, '(. O.G. 7')(Tan vs. Repu&li! of t7e P7ilippines,CVNo. 7,''+, *anuar"'), +((7,'(. O.G. 4,'Tangonanvs. %o!al Civil Registrarof Solana, Caga"an, CV No. 7,7)',*ul" 4', +((., '(. O.G. 4-33Tinerovs. Sa!lolo, SPNo. )7-)3,Novem&er '-, +((7, '(. O.G. +)))Toreda vs. Gueru&in, SP No. )+343,*une 4(, +((., '(. O.G.+.(, Tro6an 5ar=eting vs. National %a&orRelations Commission, SP No.),(+3, *une +), +((7, '(. O.G.3'.4January-December 2#A/!a!io vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. ,7'(', *une '),+((7, '(3 O.G. .47./!es Produ!tions, $n!. vs T7eCastaDa" Corp., CV No. .)34-,*une +(, +((3, '(3 O.G. '')7/!ong ardDare vs. National %a&orRelations Commission, SP No.).(7), *une +3, +((7, '(3 O.G.73'(/!tive Realt" # 8evelopmentCorporation vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. ,4(.+, *une '),+((., '(3 O.G. -))(/le6andrino vs. Re"es, SP No.,+))-, /pril '(, +((., '(3 O.G.+-,+/liDalas vs. Ga&riel, CV No. ..-3,,5a" +3, +((3, '(3 O.G. '7(/log vs. /lda", CV No. 743.(, *ul"4', +((., '(3 O.G. +,4+/rmigos vs. 8e 1a!ena, CV No.4)--., /ugust ',, +((., '(3 O.G.34)/viles vs. /viles, CV No. 77+4-,*anuar" '(, +((., '(3 O.G. '3()"Page !- of 2#1alisi vs. %i&ert" $nsuran!eCorporation, CV No. 74-4+,Septem&er ', +((., '(3 O.G. 4-,'1an=of t7eP7ilippine$slandsvs./sian Constru!tion # 8evelopment,CV No. 7,)+(, Septem&er '3,+((3, '(3 O.G. +'-31atangas %aguna Ta"a&as 1usCompan" $n!. vs. 1ar;a, SP No.77)74, 5a" '7, +((., '(3 O.G.--)71attadvs. Coronel0Paolelli, CVNo..4).+, 5a" '), +((3, '(3 O.G. 4-1ellis vs. Guilala, SP No. )'7+4,*anuar" '4, +((., '(3 O.G. ..'41enedi!to vs. JingsvilleConstru!tion # 8evelopmentCoporation, SP No. ..(-', 5ar!74', +((., '(3 O.G. -434 1ermundo vs. Ca&rera, CV No.,3.+4, *ul" 4', +((., '(3 O.G.73(31ona S!entio Corporation vs.1lossomer Plasti! Corporation, CVNo. 7,+-4, 2e&ruar" +-, +((., '(3O.G. 7.-+1ondo!vs. Ro9ue, CVNo. 777'3,Novem&er 4(, +((3, '(3 O.G. '4371riones0Ta=enos7ita vs. Ca"anan,CVNo. .34'(,5a"4',+((.,'(3O.G. +-,)CCaoile vs. Caoile, CVNo. 3.(),,*ul" +,, +((3, '(3 O.G. '(4(Canutovs. /dina, CVNo. ..44-,Novem&er +), +((., '(3 O.G. +)7,Carpio, *r. vs. Carpio, CV No. ,4)+4,*anuar" 3, +((., '(3 O.G. 4.7(Cervantes vs. Sa&io, /.C. No. 7,+,,/ugust '', +((,, '(3 O.G. 4)3-C7an vs. %o!al Civil Registrar ofCandon, $lo!os Sur, CV No. ..3)7,O!to&er +4, +((., '(3 O.G. -437Classi! >verDood ProKles Pt".%imitedvs. 5etropolitan1an=andTrustCo., CVNo. ,'.)+, 2e&ruar"+,, +((., '(3 O.G. +4+7ConKado vs. Civil Servi!eCommission, SP No. .'3)3, *anuar"',, +((., '(3 O.G. -')-Consolidated Orient %easing #2inan!ing Corporation vs.Pangani&an, CV No. .'3)3, /pril+7, +((3, '(3 O.G. '')+CliL7anger Oat!7man/gen!"vs.%a"am,SPNo.)(+43,*anuar" +-,+((., '(3 O.G. 4444D8e >sta!io vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. 7),77, 5ar!7 -,+((3, '(3 O.G. '.-8e *esus vs. Navarro, CV No.7'+)3, 5ar!7+4, +((7, '(3O.G..'4+de Rama0ill vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. .3+-',Novem&er 4(, +((., '(3 O.G. +,4)Page !. of 2#8el Rosario vs. Cardona, CV No..,4(), 2e&ruar" '4, +((7, '(3O.G. 3+7,8ela Rosa vs. Conrado, Sr., CV No.7-3(', Septem&er +,, +((., '(3O.G. 3-38evelopment 1an= of t7eP7ilippines vs. Rea!7 5ulti0PurposeCooperative $n!., CV No. .)4-4,O!to&er '4, +((3, '(3 O.G. '(438irige vs. 8evelopment 1an= of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. 77.+7,8e!em&er '3, +((3, '(3 O.G. ',--8reuvs. SangguniangPanlungsodof 5a=ati, SPNo. .7-.., O!to&er4', +((., '(3 O.G. -+('8" vs. 5ara7a6, CV No. ,.--(,5ar!7 +), +((7, '(3 O.G. .3(3E>mpire >ast %and oldings, $n!. vs.Pi;arro, SP No. 733-', *une +.,+((., '(3 O.G. -,.7F2lorendo vs. Simon, CV No. 7.)33,5a" 4, +((., '(3 O.G. +'-,2uenta&ella vs. 2ama, CV No.37(.., *une +', +((3, '(3 O.G.,3+2urio vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CVNo. .')-', /ugust+,, +((., '(3 O.G. 4.77$Gallovs. a!7ero, CVNo. ,(4.-,5ar!7 4(, +((7, '(3 O.G. .+-,Gar!iavs. 5esina, CVNo. 7).-.,*anuar" ., +((3, '(3 O.G. 344G8SJ 8evelopment Corporation vs.Repu&li! of t7e P7ilippines, CV No.774(,, 5a" +7, +((3, '(3 O.G.'(+.Great Pa!iK! Savings 1an= vs.1uenaventura, CV No. .,-4-,Septem&er +7, +((., '(3 O.G.-'),Guevarra vs. Pia, CVNo. 3,'+4,/ugust '(, +((3, '(3 O.G. '.)+%In re8ealer 2inan!e Corporationvs.5analo, CVNo. 7)((-, 5a"+,+((., '(3 O.G. ')77$nvestors 2inan!ial Servi!esCorporation vs. Mga:a, SP No.7--'-, O!to&er 4(, +((., '(3 O.G.4,4+1Jeppel 5onte 1an= vs. 5antilla, CVNo. .,3'-, *ul" 4', +((., '(3 O.G.'4.-JolpingSo!iet"of t7eP7ilippines,$n!. vs. Ca:eso, SP No. ,7(43, *ul"+,, +((., '(3 O.G. .,,.L%alosin, *r. vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. 77')', *ul" +),+((3, '(3 O.G. ..-Page !# of 2#%and 1an= of t7e P7ilippines vs.Tan, SP No. ,,,.7, *anuar" '),+((7, '(3 O.G. .(((%imos vs. Vi!tor" %iner, $n!., CV No..3.+4, *anuar" +7, +((3, '(3 O.G.+)(%umanlan vs. Tirona, CV No. ,4+'(,Septem&er ++, +((., '(3 O.G.-4.(&5a!asa9uit vs. Viola, SP No. ,'.33,5ar!7 4(, +((., '(3 O.G. 7'4,5agno vs. %iDanagan, CV No.,()77, *anuar" 4', +((3, '(3 O.G.-'-5a!airog vs. National %a&orRelations Commission, SP No.)'.-., 5ar!7+,, +((7, '(3O.G..((35a"o vs. /glipa", SP No. ,73(',*anuar" +', +((3, '(3 O.G. -(7(5endo;avs. Viola, SPNo. ,77,+,*anuar" '(, +((., '(3 O.G. .47+5etro 5anila 8evelopment/ut7orit" vs. Tra!=Dor=s RailTransit /dvertising Vending andPromotions $n!., CV No. +)+++,2e&ruar" +-, +((3, '(3 O.G. 4-775etropolitan 1an= and TrustCompan" vs. O!7avillo, CV No.7,)'), Septem&er ., +((., '(3O.G. 7.-75orales vs. O&ispo, CV No. ,4((.,O!to&er 4(, +((., '(3 O.G. 333'5orning Star Travel and Tours, $n!.vs. National %a&or RelationsCommission, SPNo. .'4)4, 5ar!7+), +((7, '(3 O.G. .+--5uni!ipal Government of 5ari=inavs. %u;ong, CV No. .','+, 2e&ruar"+7, +((., '(3 O.G. 4.7-5uni!ipalit" of %ima" vs.8ima!ulangan, SP No. 777)-,2e&ruar" +,, +((7, '(3 O.G. .'+,/Na=pil vs. %ope;, CVNo. 7,,,4,2e&ruar" '-, +((., '(3 O.G. +4')Nagsama0Purefoods0ormel0Pulovs. National %a&or RelationsCommission, SP No. )+-'.,O!to&er 4', +((., '(3 O.G. 3..+Navarrovs. P7ilippineRa&&it 1us%ines, $n!., CP No. ,(33', O!to&er+3, +((., '(3 O.G. 4'-7Neri vs. Villanueva, SPNo. ,4+)(,5ar!7 +4, +((7, '(3 O.G. -))7OO!ampo vs. 1illones, CV No. 7.-,,,Novem&er ++, +((3, '(3 O.G. ..7OI!e of t7e Court /dministratorvs. Pangani&an, /.5. No. P0(-0')'., /ugust '', +((,, '(3O.G.4)-)Or&eta vs. %ava, SP No. )77)7,/ugust ), +((7, '(3 O.G. 7.3(Page 2 of 2#Orti; vs. Valde;, CVNo. 7.),',O!to&er 4', +((., '(3 O.G. '),-PPeople of t7e P7ilippines vs.Gon;ales, CRNo. +74)3, *une4(,+((., '(3 O.G. 7444People of t7e P7ilippines vs. 8eang,CRNo.4((+-,5a" 4',+((7,'(3O.G. 3-')People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Villavi!en!io, CV No. +),3+,*anuar" 4', +((7, People of t7e P7ilippines vs.>spinosa, CR No. +.,-4,Noveme&er 4(, +((., '(3 O.G.3,4+People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Peru!7o, CR No. +,(47, *anuar" 4',+((., '(3 O.G. -,.4People of t7e P7ilippines vs. /&ion,CR No. +74,7, *une 4(, +((., '(3O.G. 3'-3Peopleof t7eP7ilippinesvs. 1ori,CR No. ++3,3, 5ar!7 +', +((., '(3O.G. --,)People of t7e P7ilippines vs.5anarpies, CR. No. +)-,',8e!em&er +), +((., '(3 O.G. 44-4People of t7e P7ilippines vs./vesilla, CRNo. (('3(, *anuar"-,+((3, '(3 O.G. 4,++People of t7e P7ilippines vs. Crisol,CR No. +)+47, /pril '), +((., '(3O.G. 4,+,People of t7e P7ilippines vs.2ortale;a, CR0C No. ((3(-,2e&ruar" +', +((., '(3 O.G. +7-'People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Casimiro, CR No. +)443,Septem&er +7, +((., '(3 O.G.+)74People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Paa"ong0/"ong, CR No. +,43.,*une 4(, +((3, '(3 O.G. '7-People of t7e P7ilippines vs. %aron,CVNo. +,(4+, 2e&ruar"'7, +((3,'(3 O.G. ,--People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Tunda", CRNo. ((+470C, *une.,+((3, '(3 O.G. '3(+People of t7e P7ilippines vs.5a"!a!a"an, CR No. +,-4(, /ugust4', +((., '(3 O.G. '.).P7ilippine Commer!ial and$nternational 1an= vs. Soriao, SPNo. ).3-., 5ar!7'., +((7, '(3O.G. 3,+,Plaridel Suret" and $nsuran!eCompan" vs. Ro6as, S.P. No. )3--),*une +3, +((7, '(3 O.G. 744,Pua vs. 1autista, CV No. 774',,/ugust '', +((., '(3 O.G. +7-7)Guiro; vs. 2eli!iano, CV No. 7)7-3,*une +., +((., '(3 O.G. 3-'- RRamire; vs. Gu;man, SP No. ,+)7),*anuar" '(, +((., '(3 O.G. .)),Page 2! of 2#Ra;ovs. Pangani&an, /.5. No. P0(30+('+, /ugust '', +((,, '(3O.G. 4)-)RC%TradingC$>, N.V. vs GeelodeP7ilippines, $n!., CV No. ,+.--,/ugust 4', +((3, '(3 O.G.+))SSan 5iguel Corporation vs.Presiding *udge, RTC of Guma!a,Gue;on, 1ran!7 .+, SP No. .-(+(,5ar!7 +,, +((., '(3 O.G. -(7.Santiago vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. .+7'-,8e!em&er +(, +((., '(3 O.G. 4'3+Santos vs. General 5illingCorporation, CV No. .-)-+,8e!em&er +7, +((., '(3 O.G. 444)Sapitan vs. People of t7eP7ilippines, CR No. +).(+, *une '),+((7, '(3 O.G. 7'-+S5O8evelopmentCorporationvs.5olina, CV No. ..'3,, 2e&ruar" +4,+((3, '(3 O.G. -+-TTampol vs. Mao, CV No. 33++4, *ul"+,, +((., '(3 O.G. .74-Tan, $$ vs. Presiding*udge, RTCof5anila, 1ran!7+', SPNo. )7+)',5a" +), +((7, '(3 O.G. ..'7Tangonanvs. %o!al Civil Registrarof Santiago Cit", CV No. ,47(4,8e!em&er +), +((3, '(3 O.G. .7'Tarro9uin vs. Sa&eron, CV No..(,(,, *une +4, +((3, '(3 O.G. +)ToDer Corporation vs. Rodrigue;,SP No. ()4(7,, *ul" '), +((., '(3O.G. -7+.Tria vs. Pital&o, CV No. ,3.(3,*anuar" 4', +((7, '(3 O.G. 3.7(Trinidadvs. Cru;, CVNo. .+')+,5ar!7 4', +((3, '(3 O.G. +)-Tua;on vs. National %a&or RelationsCommission, SP No. 3+4+,, *anuar"+(, +((., '(3 O.G. -7+'U /utomative 5fg. $n!. vs.5etropolitan1an=#TrustCo., CVNo. ,+.47, Septem&er +7, +((.,'(3 O.G. 7(('meris, CV No. 7,3).,5a" +., +((-, '(- O.G. ,)CCastillo vs. Sopranes, CV No.3-++,, *une 4(, +((3, '(- O.G.,-4(Ca"a&an vs. 1rodet7, CV No.3477-,*une ', +((3, '(- O.G. 3''(C7uvs. 5arasigan,CVNo. 3'3..,*anuar" +., +((-, '(- O.G. ,,,C7ua vs. dela Pe:a, CV No. 774-3,/ugust ++, +((3, '(- O.G. 34.7Colas vs. Registr" of 8eeds of1enguet Provin!e, CVNo. 7,(3+,/ugust ), +((-, '(- O.G. ++7(Cres!ini vs. 1agalaDis, CV No..-4+), Novem&er 3, +((-, '(-O.G. -.,+Cuen!a vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. ,-''',Septem&er +), +((3, '(- O.G.,+)+Cu:a vs. Cu:a, CV No. .''74, *ul"'3, +((3, '(- O.G. 3.'-DPage 2' of 2#8ampor, Sr. vs. >spella, CV No.3).3), /pril +), +((-, '(- O.G.'+748argo vs. Pilipinas 1an=, CVNo.-)747, /pril +), +((3, '(- O.G.73478ario vs. P7ilippine 1an= ofCommuni!ations, CV No. 3'')),*ul" +,, +((3, '(- O.G. ,7338a"ang7irang vs. 1ri;, CV No.7,.47, Novem&er ), +((-, '(-O.G. +(748e Gu;man vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. ,(,44, *une '-,+((3, '(- O.G. +7-.de *esus0>dasaDa vs. delos Re"es,CV No. .')(', O!to&er -, +((-,'(- O.G. -')78e %eon vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CVNo. 73))+, /ugust4(, +((-, '(- O.G. 4.')8e %eon vs. 1alinag, CV No. .)'43,5a" 4', +((3, '(- O.G. -),(8e Pa; vs. R. Transport Corporation,CVNo. 7)447, /ugust +(, +((-,'(- O.G. ',(+8el Rosariovs. P7ilippine/irlines,CVNo. 33.+', /ugust +', +((-,'(- O.G. -4))8e!7ave; vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. .++(,,Septem&er 4(, +((3, '(- O.G.+)-48egisi!a vs. Godine;, CV No.3+,)-, 2e&ruar" +-, +((-, '(-O.G. 4()-8iente vs. P7ilippine Commer!ial$nternational 1an=, CVNo. 7.'.',*anuar" '+, +((-, '(- O.G. '-4)8omingo vs. Calaoagan0Costales,CVNo. 337,', *ul"4(, +((-, '(-O.G. 4,4.8umpit vs. Rivera, CVNo. ,(3.+,5ar!7 ',, +((3, '(- O.G. ..+(E>nri9ue; vs. Cuevas, CV No..77,., 2e&ruar" +', +((3, '(-O.G. ++7->9uita&le1an=ingCorporationvs.Ong, CV No. .'-4+, 5ar!7 '.,+((3, '(- O.G. ,+,'F2ar >ast 1an= andTrust, Co. vs.5ontilla, SPNo. 7-33., Novem&er'', +((-, '(- O.G. -(((2eli;ardo vs. 8e *esus, CV No.37.,', 2e&ruar" '), +((-, '(-O.G. 4(,)2ilinvest omes omeoDners/sso!iation vs. Tivoli Ro"aleSu&division, CVNo. 3.7-+, 5ar!74(, +((3, '(- O.G. .'.72ilomeno vs. S7oemart, $n!., CV No.773)7, Septem&er +, +((-, '(-O.G. +(.(2S 5anagement # 8evelopmentCorporation vs. 5%$ >nterprises, CVPage 2( of 2#No. 3---', 5ar!74(, +((-, '(-O.G. 4-+($Ga!ula vs. %oren;ana, CV No.3.3'), /ugust '., +((-, '(- O.G.'.+3Ga"oso vs. Gro"on0Canillas, CV No.,(4(,, Septem&er '+, +((3, '(-O.G. ,7.,Gon;ales vs. 5uni!ipalit" ofCala&anga, Camarines Sur, CV No.77,4+, *ul" '3, +((-, '(- O.G.'.'7%In re1ulaag vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CVNo. 77.,', 5ar!7'3, +((3, '(- O.G. +337In re Capistrano vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. 3,,47, 5a" +-,+((3, '(- O.G. ..+)Inre215Constru!tionand/gro0$ndustrial Corporationvs. Repu&li!of t7eP7ilippines, CVNo. .,+-.,Septem&er '., +((3, '(- O.G.3,.(Inreem&ravs. Repu&li!of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. ,4.3.,Septem&er 4(, +((3, '(- O.G.+7-)J*avier vs. Navarrette, CV No.3+)'-, Septem&er '-, +((3, '(-O.G. 743,*.C. %ee Constru!tion vs. T"!o8evelopment Corporation, CVNo..)474, /pril +), +((3, '(- O.G.-,-'*upiter S"stem, $n!. vs. Semorlan, CV No. 73,,), 2e&ruar" '7, +((-, '(- O.G. 7''1Jat7l"n vs. 2ilipino 5er!7ants$nsuran!e Co.,$n!.,CV No.--).3,Septem&er +), +((3, '(- O.G..('7Jo7 vs. Register of 8eeds ofPampanga, CV No. ,'.74, 5a" +(,+((3, '(- O.G. 743-L%adaD vs. Sim&ulan, CV No. 377,),/ugust 4', +((3, '(- O.G. 7+'%and 1an= of t7e P7ilippines vs,Nort7 Negros 5ar=eting, CV No..'--', *ul" '3, +((3, '(- O.G.7733%antionvs. Re"es, CVNo. .()3),*anuar" '+, +((-, '(- O.G. 4)).%egastovs. Pere;, CVNo. 3)44),/pril +), +((3, '(- O.G. -,4,%im vs. Repu&li! of t7e P7ilippines,CV No. 7-''., *une '(, +((-, '(-O.G. 4-+)%oreto vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. .3.3(,Novem&er '', +((-, '(- O.G. -3+7Page 2* of 2#%ori!o vs. %ori!o, CV No. 3),,7,/ugust -, +((3, '(- O.G. ,73)&5agallon vs. Rodelas, CV No.3)-(3, *ul" +), +((-, '(- O.G.4'((5aliDat0/teng!o vs. Repu&li! of t7eP7ilippines, CV No. 7.'4+, /pril '4,+((3, '(- O.G. +)-(5analoto vs. CivilRegistrar of San2ernandoCit", Pampanga, CVNo.777)-, /pril +', +((-, '(- O.G.'.''5endo;a vs. Castro, CV No. ,'+7,,*une 4(, +((3, '(- O.G. ,(),5u:o; vs. Cornels, CV No. 3,,.-',*une +, +((3, '(- O.G. 3+4(/Nama!on Constru!tion and8evelopment Corporation vs./renas, CV No. 7)+'), /pril ++,+((3, '(- O.G. ,()-NeD San /gustin Oil5anufa!turing, $n!. vs. /llied1an=ing Corporation, CV No.,-43(, Novem&er '7, +((3, '(-O.G. 7334Nort7ern5otor, $n!. vs. 2ilDritersGuarant" and /ssuran!eCorporation, CV No. 3'+.+,Septem&er '-, +((3, '(- O.G.3''7OOdulio vs. Caguim&al, CV No.3+'44, *une ), +((3, '(- O.G.7((4PPangilinan vs. Santos, CV No.37734, *ul" ',, +((3, '(- O.G.,+,7People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Tolentino, CR No. ('4'30.C.,O!to&er '4 +((3, '(- O.G. 77.(People of t7e P7ilippines vs.1riguel,CR No.('(.3,/ugust 4',+((3, '(- O.G. 7)(3People of t7e P7ilippines vs./&ar!a, CRNo. +7).(, 5ar!74',+((3, '(- O.G. .77,People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Villanueva, CRNo. +''(+, 5ar!74', +((3, '(- O.G. .7,4People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Villareal, CRNo. +7+3., 5a" 4(,+((3, '(- O.G. .)(- People of t7e P7ilippines vs.>li;alde, CR No. +,.,3, /ugust 4',+((3, '(- O.G. .)(,People of t7e P7ilippines vs.5alolos, CRNo. (((,7, 5ar!74(,+((3, '(- O.G. ..+3People of t7e P7ilippines vs./l!ore;a, CR No. +7-),, *anuar"+7, +((3, '(- O.G. 3,3.People of t7e P7ilippines vs. Sa!dal,CRNo. +,4+-, *ul"'), +((3, '(-O.G. 3+4-Page 2, of 2#People of t7e P7ilippines vs.1autista, CRNo. +,(7., *une++,+((3, '(- O.G. 33'7People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Gani&an, CR No. ++.)3, Septem&er+,, +((3, '(- O.G. 3.73People of t7e P7ilippines vs.Panto6a, CR No. +-.43, 5a" 4',+((3, '(- O.G. -),7People of t7e P7ilippines vs. Go, CRNo. +7-33, Novem&er +4, +((-,'(- O.G. -((-People of t7e P7ilippines vs. Regio,CRNo. +4+34, O!to&er '4, +((-,'(- O.G. -4'(People of t7e P7ilippines vs.%i&re6a, CRNo. +3('), Septem&er4(, +((-, '(- O.G. -3+(People of t7e P7ilippines vs. Torino,CR No. +4+)4, Septem&er 4(,+((-, '(- O.G. 4.-7People of t7e P7ilippines vs. O&a:a,CRNo.+7')7,5a" 4',+((3,'(-O.G. +7-+People of t7e P7ilippines vs./langui, CR No. +.(74, *anuar" +(,+((3, '(- O.G. +)43People of t7e P7ilippines vs.olande;, CVNo. +.'3', 5a"+3,+((-, '(- O.G. ,)+Pene"ra vs. P7ilippine National1an=, CV No. 7,'((, Septem&er'., +((-, '(- O.G. +(.,Pere;, *r. vs. Ni!olas, *r., CV No.3,344, /ugust 4(, +((3, '(- O.G..7,)Pun;alan vs. Pu;on, *r., CV No.7++'', Novem&er +-, +((3, '(-O.G. 4.+,RRans=a vs. de *esus, CV No. 77.7.,/pril +', +((-, '(- O.G. '7)3Rivamonte vs. Vas9ue;, CV No.,(3+3, *une +), +((3, '(- O.G..((3Ruaro vs. Private 8evelopmentCorporationof t7eP7ilippines, CVNo. 47)(7, /ugust 4', +((-, '(-O.G. '-3+SSales vs. $nternational Corporate1an=, CV No. 34-3(, /pril +',+((-, '(- O.G. 43(4Sante0*ulio vs. Gorospe, CV No. .,3(., 5ar!7 +., +((-, '(- O.G. -4(-Santiago0Guelas vs. Cru;, CVNo.7,4(-, /ugust '+, +((3, '(- O.G.3.7'Santos vs. Cit" Trust 2inan!e Corp.,CV No. 7334), Septem&er '.,+((3, '(- O.G. 3'+'Servi!eDide Spe!ialists,$n!orporatedvs. Gregorio, CVNo.3,3.-, *ul" '', +((3, '(- O.G.7('4Page 2- of 2#S7arief vs. San 8iego, CV No.3+,'+, O!to&er '3, +((-, '(- O.G.--(3S7ellDood $ndustries P7ils., $n!. vs.Repu&li! of t7e P7ilippines, CV No..,,43, 2e&ruar" ,, +((3, '(- O.G.7')(Silva vs. Silva, CV No. 77,73,Septem&er '., +((3, '(- O.G.33+3SiC Stars Realt" 8evelopmentCorporation vs. /ldana, CV No.3.,.(, /pril ', +((-, '(- O.G.4-+3Soriano vs. 8omingo, CV No.,4)(,, Septem&er '+, +((3, '(-O.G. 7+(3Star /sia Realt", $n!. vs. O7oleasia8evelopment # Constru!tion Corp.,CVNo. 7(.+(, *ul"'4, +((-, '(-O.G. -4)4S" vs.