Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Several groups enjoyed floating the
June 6, 2019 www.thermopir.com PAGE 11
Learning the gamephoto by Mark Dykes
Parents help kids develop their throwing and catching skills during the first session of Start Smart Baseball hosted by the Hot Springs County Recreation District. Other stations were set up for the youngsters to practice hitting and running the bases.
PUBLIC NOTICES IN NEWSPAPERS.Where public information is accessible to the public.
431 Broadway • PO Box 31 • Thermopolis, WY [email protected]
307 864-2328 Fax 307 864-5711
Thermopolis Independent Record IRTherm
opolis
Public notice is your right to know about the issues that directly affect your life. And, you can easily find public notices in the Ther-mopolis Independent Record. Without public notices in the news-paper, you’re left to guess about what the government is doing in your community and how elected officials are spending your tax dollars.
The Independent Record fulfills an essential role in serving your right to know. After all, it shouldn’t be your responsibility to know how to look ... where to look ... when to look ... and even what to look for in order to be informed about public information. It is the government’s responsibility to notify you of public information, and the Independent Record is the most accessible place to find it.
PUBLICNOTICE
Without public notices in the newspaper, you’re left guessing.
by Angus M. Thuermer Jr., WyoFile.com
Via Wyoming News ExchangeTHERMOPOLIS — At emotional
hearings that drew hundreds, critics challenged regulators’ baseline assump-tions that would allow the dumping of tons of pollutants above Boysen Reser-voir while boosters heralded the jobs the 4,250-well Moneta Divide oil- and gas-field expansion would bring.
More than 300 residents of Fremont and Hot Springs Counties packed sep-arate hearings in Riverton and Ther-mopolis to tell the Wyoming Depart-ment of Environmental Quality why it should approve or reject a discharge permit for Aethon Energy Operating, LLC and Burlington Resources Oil & Gas Company, LP.
The permit would allow the dumping of 8.27 million gallons of produced wa-ter a day and up to 2,161 tons of total dissolved solids a month into Boysen tributaries. The proposed expansion of the Moneta Divide Field is also expected to generate hundreds of jobs.
The hearings were a tale of two coun-ties as Fremont County residents ap-plauded the project at a hearing in Ri-verton. But downstream in Thermopolis, where the town draws its drinking wa-ter from the Bighorn River below Boy-sen, some Hot Springs County residents were equally opposed to a development they said could threaten their health and livelihoods.
Critics questioned whether DEQ baseline pollutant measurements — first taken in 2009, 37 years after en-actment of the governing Clean Water Act — were a valid starting point from which to measure growing contamina-tion of a drinking water supply.
Project backers, meanwhile, said not only have existing discharges of “pro-duced water” not harmed the environ-ment, they’ve even aided ranchers and wildlife in the arid landscape east of Shoshoni.
Comments and counter comments, which DEQ will accept through July 5, drew regular applause at the hours-long public meetings. Held to solicit issues the state regulatory agency should con-sider, the assemblies evoked heartfelt but divergent declarations.
“We are bleeding out Wyoming men,” said project supporter Bethany Baldes, a Riverton resident whose husband left
that town for work in Cheyenne. “Let’s bring our fathers, sons, husbands home.”
In Thermopolis, John Buck wondered what might happen to residents below Boysen. “You’re going to contaminate our water,” he said. “We don’t need to sell ourselves to these corporations for jobs. They want to dump this on our com-munity and send the money to Texas.”
DEQ’s draft permit would allow Aeth-on and Burlington to discharge produced water — a byproduct of oil and gas de-velopment — into the Alkali and Bad-water creek drainages some 40 miles above the reservoir. Pollutants would be diluted in a 300- by 700-foot mixing zone there, and in the body of the reser-voir, before being released from the dam into the Wind and Bighorn rivers below.
Residents of Thermopolis, which draws its municipal water from the Big-horn about 15 miles downstream of the Boysen Dam, shouldn’t be able to detect water quality changes if the permit is approved, the DEQ says.
“We feel the standard to obtain a per-mit has been met,” DEQ Water Quality Division Administrator Kevin Frederick said about the companies’ discharge cal-culations. A modeling report, prepared by Aethon consultants and supporting the proposed permit, runs 637 pages while the permit application itself is 113 pages.
The permit would ensure “there re-ally is no change,” beyond normal back-ground variation of historic pollutants in the Class I water below Boysen, said Bill DiRienzo DEQ’s discharge program manager. Class I waters are not sup-posed to be degraded below the qual-ity that existed on the date they were designated, according to environmen-tal laws, which in the case of the Wind River was 1979.
“Previous discharges from this facility remained essentially unchanged” since 1979, DEQ’s “statement of basis” for the permit reads. With new discharges, DEQ “shouldn’t be able to measure any dif-ference from the past,” DiRienzo said.
DEQ set baseline “grandfathered” discharge figures from the Moneta field at 908 tons a month of total dis-solved solids, DiRienzo’s slide presen-tation showed. That amount of pollut-ants “isn’t a problem because that 908 was in the river when it was designated Class I,” he said.
But several commenters challenged
that baseline standard. How, one crit-ic wondered, could DEQ justify basing its “no deviation” standard using water quality measurements from between 2010-2016, not 1979?
Water quality wasn’t measured, DiRienzo said, until former Moneta Divide operator Encana spiked its dis-charge in 2008-2009. It released up to 3,000 tons a month of total dissolved solids before DEQ curtailed them back to 908 tons a month.
DEQ began measuring discharges in that 2008-2009 period. Before then, “we don’t have that data,” DiRienzo said. “That may not be a good answer but that’s the way it is.”
“This issue is about jobs — hundreds of families being able to put food on the table,” one person at the Riverton hear-ing said. Mayors of Riverton, Lander, Dubois and Shoshoni all back the project.
Moneta Divide expansion is project-ed to recover 18.16 trillion cubic feet of natural gas and 254 million barrels of oil over 65 years, the BLM wrote in an-nouncing its draft environmental impact statement for the development. Mone-ta Divide could generate $71 million a year in federal royalties, $57.6 million a year in severance taxes for Wyoming, and $70 million a year in county taxes, its statement read.
“This is a blue-collar state,” said John Vincent, former Riverton mayor, in backing the permit. “This is our in-dustry. We can fuss and worry, but it’s time to start acting.”
In Thermopolis, pipeline company owner and state Rep. Lloyd Larsen (R-Lander) told the crowd that the roomy high school auditorium where they were meeting was paid for by mineral-sever-ance taxes.
“It is about jobs, but not all about jobs,” Larsen said. Mineral taxes fund Wyoming schools to the tune of about $15,000 a student a year, he said. In 2018, the oil and gas industry paid the equivalent of $2,600 in taxes for every man, woman, and child in the state, said John Robitaille, the vice president for environment, health and safety for the Petroleum Association of Wyoming.
Oilfield worker Dustin Brost, a man-ager for Key Energy Services, said his company employs about 16 people in Riverton. “It’s very low,” he said of the workforce.
“We would like to be in that 50 range,”
he told WyoFile. “We look forward to employing many people in Fremont County.”
A moribund economy has cascading effects on wellness, said Riverton resi-dent Ruby Calvert, general manager of Wyoming PBS. Free and reduced lunches given at schools, an indicator of poverty, have risen in the last decade from 44 percent of students to 77 per-cent, she said.
“That’s horrible for [Fremont] coun-ty,” she said. “I think we have to have faith in the technology, the DEQ and Aethon and Burlington.”
DEQ measurements put average baseline pH below Boysen at eight, chlo-ride at nine milligrams per liter, sulfates at 129 mg/L and total dissolved solids at 348 mg/L. New discharges under the draft permit could increase pH to nine, chloride to 12 mg/L, sulfates to 167 mg/L and total dissolved solids to 409 mg/L.
“This is going to be the cleanest wa-ter released out of this field in 60 years, Robitaille said. An angler, he’s walked and fished the entire Wind River Can-yon below Boysen and wouldn’t back the project if he thought it would affect the fishing there, he said.
Produced water aids agriculture, Ro-bitaille said. “If that water were to dry up, a lot of ranchers would dry up.”
Rancher Rob Hendry, chairman of the Natrona County Board of Commis-sioners and a rancher with property in the Moneta Divide Field, said pro-duced water has benefited his family’s livestock since 1965. His father used to ask a previous operator to turn the wa-ter on, he said.
“The companies have always been good to the environment,” Hendry said.
Existing discharges benefit wildlife and “have not impacted the tributaries negatively,” Rep. Larsen said to large applause.
Moneta Divide operators sought to dispose of produced water — a separate byproduct from fracking fluids — by re-injecting it, DiRienzo told the Riverton Audience. But they could not find an underground reservoir with adequate space or into which the federal EPA would permit introduction of pollutants.
“They had to shut in a bunch of wells,” DiRienzo said.
Encana subsequently built the Nep-tune Water Facility, a reverse-osmosis plant that essentially uses filters to
purify produced water. That outflow is blended with untreated produced water at volumes that are not to exceed DEQ limits at the outlet of Boysen Dam.
Aethon’s modeling for the draft per-mit predicts how much salt — a key pollutant — could be added to the res-ervoir “and not reduce water quality coming out of the dam.” DiRienzo said. Those calculations form the basis for the draft permit.
The model “reasonably simulates” what could occur, accounting for vari-ous fluctuations, DEQ’s Frederick said. The model, DiRienzo said, “is like pre-dicting the weather.
“It’s not precise,” he said. “It’s as good as we can do right now.”
Operators should build more reverse-osmosis plants so all produced water dis-charged on the surface is clean of pol-lutants, some audience members said. Operators could do that if they seek to speed up development of the field, a pace that will be constrained by the DEQ permit.
Riverton Dr. Ryan Kindervater urged building treatment facilities to cleanse all the produced water. In the past, “in-sufficient examination of things,” asso-ciated with industrial development has led to health complications for workers, some of whom he has as patients, he said.
Health was a worry of other com-menters, including one who said the project “lines the pockets of out-of-state billionaires,” while fellow residents, “for the privilege of a few new jobs … trade your health, your children’s health.”
Kindervater asked “why can’t we have our cake and eat it too?” He proposed that constructing additional treatment plants “would bring more jobs.”
That’s not practical, said Key Ener-gy’s Brost. That idea would be “ungodly expensive,” he said after one meeting.
There are 138 discharge outlets in the Wind River and Bighorn River basins, DEQ said. Moneta Divide would have 16. The average oil and gas field in the basin produces 400 tons of total dissolved solids a month. Moneta Divide would be the fourth largest, at 2,161 tons a month, an amount one commenter said was the equivalent of 80 railroad coal cars.
“The norm is not to treat that much water,” Brost said. “The norm is to have discharge permits. If it’s not having an impact so that the DEQ’s not worried about it, why put in more plants?”
Boysen, Moneta plan draws sharp division between counties
