65
B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and the Physics case for the Large Hadron Electron Collider

B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

B.MelladoUniversity of the Witwatersrand

On behalf of the LHeC Study Group

HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14

Exploration of the Higgs boson and the Physics case for the

Large Hadron Electron Collider

Page 2: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

CERN Referees

Published 600 pages conceptual design report (CDR) written by 150 authors from 60 Institutes.Reviewed by ECFA, NuPECC (long range plan), Referees invited by CERN. Published June 2012.

arXiv:1206.2913

arXiv:1211.4831 and 5102

Page 3: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

About 200 Experimentalists and Theorists from 76 InstitutesSupported by CERN, ECFA, NuPECC

http://cern.ch/lhec

Present LHeC Study group and CDR authors

Page 4: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

LHeC Physics Programme

Ultra high precision (detector, e-h redundancy) - new insight Maximum luminosity and much extended range - rare, new effects Deep relation to (HL-) LHC (precision+range) - complementarity

CDR, arXiv:1211.4831 and 5102http://cern.ch/lhec

Strong coupling 0.1%; Full unfolding of PDFs; Gluon: low x: saturation?, high x: HL LHC searches…

Page 5: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

5

M.Klein

Page 6: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

LHeC Collaboration arXiv:1211:5102, see also O.Bruening and M.Klein arXiv:1305.2090

After the Higgs discovery: LHeC 1033 34 Luminosity (parameters in parenthesis) Turn the LHeC into a Higgs factory

Page 7: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

Some LHeC Context Some LHeC Context

The LHeC is not the first proposal for TeV scale DIS, but it is the first with the potential for significantly higher luminosity than HERA …

… achievable with a new electronaccelerator at the LHC …

[JINST 1 (2006) P10001]

Considering x10 increase of lumi

Page 8: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

The LHeC Detector

8

P. Kostka

Page 9: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

9

Particles of

interest

Pdfs are needed to calculate cross-sections at the LHC

Page 10: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

Physics and Range

Large xGluon

HiggsBoson

co MK

-four-momentum transfer squared

Bjorken

High PrecisionQCD &El.weakPhysics

RPV SUSY, LQSubstructure ?

Nuclear Structure

QGPlasma

High Density Matter

Page 11: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

LHeC Kinematics and the LHC

11

Extension of parton density

measurements at the LHeC very

important for upgraded LHC

Luminosity

Page 12: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

d/u at large x

Lead motivation for a LHeC: pdfs at high x for discovery physics

Page 13: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

Gluon Density Distribution

Spectacular increase in the precision of gluon density function at high x. This is important for discovery physics at the LHC

Page 14: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

14

M.Klein

Page 15: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

15

Higgs Physics at the LHeC

Page 16: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

16

On July 4th reported 5σ. With the addition of WW a 6σ effect is reached and reported in the final paper.

Habemus novum BosonPhys.Lett. B716 (2012) 1-29

Page 17: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

17

Evidence for VBF and VH production modes given in terms of ratio w.r.t. ggF+ttH modes.

Observe > 4σ evidence.

ATLAS-CONF-2014-009

Page 18: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

Higgs at LHeC

It is remarkable that VBF diagrams were calculated for lepton nucleon collisions before for pp!

Consider feasibility for the following point:

18

At LHC replacelepton lines by quark lines

Page 19: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

Higgs via VBFQualitative remarks

Unlike QCD partons that scale like 1/PT

2, here PT~sqrt(1-x)MW

19

Due to the 1/x behavior of the Weak boson the outgoing parton energy (1-x)E is large forward jets

At high PT

Contribution from longitudinally polarized Weak Bosons is suppressed in favor of transversely polarized WB at high pT

Page 20: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

20

Higgs Decay Products

Scattered fermions

Central Jet Veto

Well-defined prediction of the SM. Kinematics of scattered quarks, very sensitive to new physics

Page 21: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

Introduction

We’ll come back to HH production later

Page 22: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

LHeC, a Higgs Factory M.Klein

Page 23: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

MC Samples in Hadron-level study

23

U.Klein et al.

Page 24: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

24

U.Klein

Page 25: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

25

CDR analysis is being revisited by Tokyo/Liverpool

Page 26: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

26

Refining event selectionWork in progress

Masahiro Tanaka

Page 27: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

27

Masahiro TanakaResults being cross-checked

Work in progressNeed to add photoproduction of ttbar

Need more man power to develop more realistic detector simulation and to study other channels

Page 28: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

28

Page 29: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

29

Spin/CP Quantum numbers

At some point the study of the signal strength is not sufficient to understand presence of new physics in Higgs couplings. Scrutiny of kinematics of scattered quarks is a unique window of opportunity to establish admixtures of BSM terms in the HVV coupling

Page 30: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

30

Need to investigate physics beyond the SM within the 0+ hypothesis with high precision

Page 31: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

31

S. Biswal, R. Godbole, B.M. and a S. Raychaudhuri Phys.Rev.Lett. 109 (2012) 261801

CP Structure of HVV Couplings

Page 32: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

32

Page 33: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

33

Strong potential to exclude admixture of BSM physics in the HWW coupling

Very conservative systematics assumed

Page 34: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

34

Double Higgs Production with a 50 TeV Proton Beam

In the light of the FCC kick-off meeting, we are evaluating feasibility of double Higgs production with a 50 TeV beam. Electron-proton collisions offer the advantage of reduced QCD backgrounds and negligible pile-up with the possibility of using the 4b final state.

Page 35: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

35

Feynman rules for the interactions of the scalar boson with gauge bosons, fermions and self-interactions.

Exploring the feasibility of the HHH coupling via double-Higgs boson production

Page 36: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

HH and tHt in ep

Polarisation, max lumi, tuning cuts, bb and WW

decays may provide O(10%) precision - tentative

FCC-he unpolarisedCross section at 3.5 TeV:

total : 0.7 fbfiducial : 0.2 fbusing pt(b,j)>20 GeVΔR(j.b)>0.4η(j) <5η(b) < 3

NewTentative Studies

Require time for reliable result(detector, analysis, backgrounds..)

Bruce Mellado, Uta Klein, Masahiro Khuze et al

Page 37: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

37

Cross-sections for CC backgrounds in fb for Ee=60,120,150 GeV

Cross-sections for CC HH->4b (branching ratios included)For unpolarized electron beam

Results assume 70% b-tagging efficiency, 0.1 (0.01) fake rates for c (light) jets

Results promising at parton level, giving comparable signal and background cross-sections even before topological requirements. Looking forward to the particle-level study.

Page 38: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

This is a important discriminator to distinguish EW from QCD multi-jet production

Scattered quark is more forward in signal

Page 39: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

39

Lagrangian with generic HHH coupling. Implementing into Feynrules with MG5

M.Kumar, R.Islam

Page 40: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

40

A photon-photon collider can be associated to LHeC effort

MH=125 GeV

Strong potential to measure CP mixing and violation thanks to control over photon polarization

Page 41: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

41

M.Klein

Page 42: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

42

M.Klein

Page 43: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

Outlook and ConclusionsLHeC displays strong complementarities with the LHC/e+e- with regards to Higgs physics

Forward jet tagging secures the feasibility of the Higgs search in CC and NC in ep collisions

With the isolation of the Hbb signal at the LHeC a window of opportunity opens for the exploration of the CP properties of the HWW and HZZ vertexesThe latter is a unique feature of the ep collider absent in pp/e+e- collisions

Exploring high lumi scenarios Higgs factoryThe LHeC removes the PDF/QCD uncertainties for pp: LHeC becomes precision Higgs facility

Exploring double Higgs production in the contex of FCC. Promissing results at parton level to be evaluated at hadron level 43

Page 44: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

44

Extra Slides

Page 45: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

• Previously considered as `QCD explorer’ (also THERA)

• Main advantages: low interference with LHC, high Ee ( 150 GeV?) andlepton polarisation

• Somewhat lower luminosity at reasonable power, no previous experience exists

• First considered (as LEPxLHC)in 1984 ECFA workshop

• Main advantage: high peaklumi obtainable (~2.1033 cm-2 s-1)

• Main difficulties: building round existing LHC, e beam energy (60GeV?) and lifetimelimited by synchrotron radiation

LINAC-RING

RING-RING

How Could ep be Done using LHC?How Could ep be Done using LHC?

… whilst allowing simultaneous ep and pp running …

Preferred Option

Page 46: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

46

Page 47: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

47

Page 48: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

48

Expect 5000 H bb events at 60 GeV for 1ab-1 0.7% coupling measurement at S/B ~1.

LHeC is high precision Higgs facility

Page 49: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

49

Page 50: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

Signal Efficiency for Different Ee

First row: Cumulative efficiencySecond row: Efficiency w.r.t. previous cut

50

Page 51: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

Effect of Jet Energy Resolution

51Charge Current Analysis (results)

Nominal

Page 52: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

Effect of Range of b-tagging

52Charge Current Analysis (results)

Nominal

Page 53: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

Effect of Jet PT

53Charge Current Analysis (results)

Nominal

Page 54: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

Signal Efficiency for Different Ee

First row: Cumulative efficiencySecond row: Efficiency w.r.t. previous cut

54

Page 55: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

55

Page 56: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

56

Page 57: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

57

Need to investigate physics beyond the SM within the 0+ hypothesis with high precision

Page 58: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

58

Study in pp collisions

Page 59: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

59

Page 60: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

60

Effect of PDF uncertainties and pdf choice

Page 61: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

Circularly polarized laser

Linearly polarized laserM.Velasco

Page 62: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

Only Only with with CC

Only Only with with CC

== 0 if CP is conserved

In s-channel production of Higgs:

== +1 (-1) for CP is conserved forA CP-Even (CP-Odd) Higgs

If A1≠0, A2≠0 and/or |A3| < 1, the Higgs is a mixture of CP-Even and CP-Odd states

Possible to search for CP violation in gg H fermions without having to measure their polarization

In bb, a ≤1% asymmetry can be measure with 100 fb-1

that is, in 1/2 years arXiv:0705.1089v2

M.Velasco

Page 63: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

Kinematic Distributions (Ee = 60 GeV)

Page 64: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and
Page 65: B.Mellado University of the Witwatersrand On behalf of the LHeC Study Group HEP Seminar, Tsinghua University, 22/08/14 Exploration of the Higgs boson and

Despite large beam energy imbalance, jets are relatively central