Upload
doantu
View
224
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
BLACK & VEATCH
b' 40310920
Superfund
6601 College Boulevard
Overland Park, Kansas 66211 USA
Tel: (913) 458-2900
USEPA Region VII Omaha Lead Site Remedial Design
United States Environmental Protection Agency 901 North 5"̂ Street Kansas City, Kansas 66101 Attn: Robert Feild
Black & Veatch Special Projects Corp.
BVSPC Project 044759 BVSPC File C.3
July 21, 2008
RECEWEO
supERfuuD m »
Subject: Quality Control Assessment of Data Collected in 2007
Dear Mr. Feild:
BVSPC performed a quality control assessment of the soil data obtained from the Omaha Lead site in 2007 and we are transmitting the results to you in this letter. The soil data addressed by our assessment includes the results of the confirmation soil samples and the soil samples that were screened with both a 60 mesh sieve and a 10 mesh sieve.
Confirmation soil samples are analyzed for lead in BVSPC's field office using an XRF instrument. The same soil sample analyzed using the XRF is subsequently sent to the EPA laboratory and is analyzed for lead and other metals. Confirmation samples are collected at a rate of 5 percent (one confirmation sample per 20 XRF samples). The lead concentrations from confirmation samples analyzed by the XRF and the EPA laboratory data are compared to determine if the data satisfy the quality control goals specified in our February 1, 2007 Quality Assurance Project Plan (QAPP).
The XRF data and the EPA laboratory data fi-om the confirmation samples are used to calculate the Relative Percent Difference (RPD) between the two sets of data. The RPD was compared to the goal of 80 percent RPD for confirmation samples specified in our February 1, 2007 QAPP. During the 2007 sampling season, we analyzed 160 confirmafion samples. The RPD between the confirmation samples exceeded 80 percent goal in 3.8 percent of the samples (Table 1). For comparison, we also determined the RPD between the confirmation samples collected from 2001 through 2007. The RPD between the samples analyzed with the XRF and the laboratory in this set of samples exceeded the 80 percent goal in 5.7 percent of the samples.
We also determined the coefficient of determination (r^) of the data from the confirmation samples collected during the 2007 sampling season. For the field XRF analyses to have value, the correlation between the offsite analyses and the field analyses must be acceptable. For quality control/quality assurance purposes, r'̂ should be at least
building a WO f i d <>' difference™
Page 2
USEPA BVSPC Project 44759 Bob Feild July 18,2008
0.49. This is the coefficient of determination value that was identified in the Sverdrup QAPP as being acceptable.
As shown in the enclosed Figures 1 and 2, we determined the coefficient of determination for the XRF and laboratory data collected during the 2007 sampling season and for all of the XRF and laboratory data from 2001 through 2007. The coefficient of determinafion for the data collected in 2007 is 0.7673, indicating a very strong correlation. The coefficient of determination for all of the data collected from 2001 through 2007 is 0.5242, which is above the goal specified in the Sverdrup QAPP.
In addition to comparing the XRF data with the laboratory data from the confirmation samples, we also compared the XRF data generated by sieving the soil samples with a 10 mesh sieve and a 60 mesh sieve. On days when soil samples are analyzed in the field office, one sample per day is sieved using both a 10 mesh and a 60 mesh sieve and the soil in both samples is analyzed with an XRF instrument. The data was compared for the 2007 (Table 2) sampling season. As indicated by the enclosed Figure 3, the coefficient of determination for 2007 is 0.9545, indicating that there is a very strong correlation between the results fi-om the two sieve sizes. There were no goals established in the QAPP for the coefficient of determinafion for this data. However, a coefficient of determinafion of 0.49 or higher is generally considered acceptable.
We also determined the RPD of the samples analyzed using a 60 mesh sieve and a 10 mesh sieve for 2007 and compared the results to a RPD of 80 percent. In 2007 there were no sampling results above 80 percent (Table 2).
Based on our analysis, we believe the quality of the data in 2007 was acceptable. If you have any questions, please contact me at (913) 458-6605.
L PROJECTS CORP.
David Sanders Project Manager
Enclosure[s]
Q L i .
6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
Figure 1
Comparison of XRF Data vs. Lab Data
2007 Data
0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9,000 10,000
Lab Data
Figure 2 Comparison of XRF Date vs. Lab Data
2001 - 2007
• 4 - 1
(0
Q Q: X
30,000
25,000
20,000
15,000
10,000
5,000
^^^^P^^^^^^^^ l •
R̂ = 0.5242
^ ^ ^ ^
^ ^ ^ ^
•
li i > » * • — ^ • • "
^ ^
•
•
• • • J
10,000 20,000 30,000
Lab Data
40,000 50,000 60,000
Figure 3 lOIVIesh vs. eOiVlesh Calendar Year 2007 Omaha Lead Site
1,200
y = 0.7394X + 34.447
0.9545
1,000
800
S 600
400
200
200 400 600 800
60 Mesh
1,000 1,200 1,400 1.600
Table 1 Relative Percent Difference
2007 Data Omaha Lead Site
SAID
34595
36747
49354
92431
27264
25553
17700
24989
24396
38269
90857
63239
63007
88004
21005
79306
93345
93003
31283
74154
32996
15611
47163
35042
91234
10046
36679
34560
81398
11343
33372
93342
37756
26084
93419
34985
12457
35517
29795
51960
28423
33744
14449
66791
93434
31823
17461
20922
76891
91335
74047
87941
51011
48923
23742
35384
47293
79703
XRF_DATE
12-Oct-07
20-Sep-07
30-Oct-07
30-Oct-07
11-Oct-07
4-Jan-07
17-Oct-07
10-Dec-07
26-Oct-07
6-Sep-07
28-Sep-07
25-Sep-07
31-Oct-07
18-Sep-07
4-Jan-07
18-Sep-07
23-Oct-07
20-Sep-07
8-Jan-07
4-Jan-07
7-Sep-07
6-Sep-07
13-NOV-07
8-Aug-07
29-Oct-07
25-Oct-07
19-Sep-07
18-Oct-07
11-Sep-07
26-Oct-07
7-Aug-07
23-Oct-07
6-Sep-07
17-Oct-07
24-Oct-07
2-Oct-07
19-Sep-07
28-Sep-07
4-Jan-07
5-Sep-07
18-Sep-07
14-Dec-07
7-Sep-07
2-NOV-07
11-Dec-07
8-Aug-07
18-Dec-07
5-Sep-07
3-Oct-07
11-Oct-07
19-Sep-07
8-NOV-07
20-Sep-07
18-Dec-07
5-Oct-07
25-Sep-07
19-Dec-07
12-Oct-07
XRF_SAMPLE_ID
RYDSCPXA-34595
RD2SCPXA-36747
RYBSCPXA-49354
RYBSCPXA-92431
RYDSCPXA-27264
RDZSCPXA-25553
RYDSCPXA-17700
RDZSCPXA-24989
RYBSCPXA-24396
RYBSCPXA-38269
RDZSCPXA-90857
RYBSCPXA-63239
RYCSCPXA-63007
RYASCPXA-88004
RYDSCPXA-21005
RYCSCPXA-79306
RYBSCPXA-93345
RYBSCPXA-93003
P20SCPXA-31283
RYASCPXA-74154
RYASCPXA-32996
RYASCPXA-15611
RYASCPXA-47163
RYBSCPXA-35042
RYASCPXA-91234
RYDSCPXA-10046
RYBSCPXA-36679
RYBSCPXA-34560
RYDSCPXA-81398
RYDSCPXA-11343
RYCSCPXA-33372
RYDSCPXA-93342
RYASCPXA-37756
RYCSCPXA-26084
RYBSCPXA-93419
RYCSCPXA-34985
RYASCPXA-12457
RYBSCPXA-35517
RYDSCPXA-29795
RYASCPXA-51960
RYASCPXA-28423
RDZSCPXA-33744
RYDSCPXA-14449
RYASCPXA-66791
RYBSCPXA-93434
RYDSCPXA-31823
RYASCPXA-17461
RYBSCPXA-20922
RYCSCPXA-76891
RYCSCPXA-91335
RPZSCPXA-74047
RDZSCPXA-87941
RYCSCPXA-51011
RDZSCPXA-48923
RYASCPXA-23742
RYASCPXA-35384
RYCSCPXA-47293
RYASCPXA-79703
XRF_ND XRF_PB
157
123
31
195
283
49.01
378
3592
352
80
5523
69
318
326
37.17
239
84
257
50.74
253.71
124
145
179
37
115
195
77
172
44
189
502
174
69
433
114
198
117
138
348.23
338
46
651
221
424
79
84
714
551
282
96
239
34
883
64
481
84
54
253
ASR_NUM8eR
3609
3608
3609
3609
3609
3336
3609
3611
3609
3608
3608
3608
3609
3608
3336
3608
3609
3608
3336
3336
3608
3608
3610
3606
3609
3609
3608
3609
3608
3609
3606
3609
3608
3609
3609
3609
3608
3608
3336
3608
3608
3612
3608
3610
3611
3606
3612
3608
3609
3609
3608
3610
3608
3612
3609
3608
3612
3609
LAB_DATE
12-Oct-07
20-Sep-07
30-Oct-07
30-Oct-07
11-Oct-07
4-Jan-07
17-Oct-07
10-Dec-07
26-Oct-07
6-Sep-07
28-Sep-07
25-Sep-07
31-Oct-07
18-Sep-07
4-Jan-07
18-Sep-07
23-Oct-07
20-Sep-07
8-Jan-07
4-Jan-07
7-Sep-07
6-Sep-07
13-NOV-07
8-Aug-07
29-Oct-07
25-Oct-07
19-Sep-07
18-Oct-07
11-Sep-07
26-Oct-07
7-Aug-07
23-Oct-07
6-Sep-07
17-Oct-07
24-Oct-07
2-Oct-07
19-Sep-07
28-Sep-07
4-Jan-07
5-Sep-07
18-Sep-07
13-Dec-07
7-Sep-07
2-NOV-07
11-Dec-07
8-Aug-07
18-Dec-07
5-Sep-07
3-Oct-07
11-Oct-07
19-Sep-07
8-NOV-07
20-Sep-07
18-Dec-07
5-Oct-07
25-Sep-07
19-Dec-07
12-Oct-07
U \B_SAMPLEJD
RYDSCPLA-34595
RDZSCPLA-36747
RYBSCPLA-49354
RYBSCPLA-92431
RYDSCPLA-27264
RDZSCPLA-25553
RYDSCPLA-17700
RDZSCPU\-24989
RYBSCPI7^-24396
RYBSCPI7i,-38269
RDZSCPU\-90857
RYBSCPLA-63239
RYCSCPLA-63007
RYASCPU\-88004
RYDSCPLA-21005
RYCSCPLA-79306
RYBSCPU\-93345
RYBSCPU\-93003
P20SCPLA-31283
RYASCPUii-74154
RYASCPLA-32996
RYASCPLA-15611
RYASCPLA^7163
RYBSCPLA-35042
RYASCPLA-91234
R Y D S C P L J ^ - 1 0 0 4 6
RYBSCPLA-36679
RYBSCPLA-34560
RYDSCPLA-81398
RYDSCPLA-11343
RYCSCPlA-33372
RYDSCPLA-93342
RYASCPU\-37756
RYCSCPU\-26084
RYBSCPLA-93419
RYCSCPLA-34985
RYASCPU\-12457
RYBSCPLA-35517
RYDSCPLA-29795
RYASCPLA-51960
RYASCPLA-28423
RDZSCPLA-33744
RYDSCPU\-14449
RYASCPLA-66791
RYBSCPU\-93434
RYDSCPLA-31823
RYASCPLA-17461
RYBSCPLA-20922
RYCSCPLA-76891
RYCSCPLA-91335
RPZSCPLA-74047
RDZSCPLA-87941
RYCSCPLA-51011
RDZSCPLA-48923
RYASCPLA-23742
RYASCPLA,-35384
RYCSCPLA-47293
RYASCPLA-79703
L^B_PB DETECTION.
5570
2170
277
884
702
20.9
848
6530
638
143
9390
115
522
533
23.5
375
126
385
33.9
171
180
210
257
52.6
162
268
105
232
58.6
247
656
227
89.2
558
146
253
149
175
275
423
57.4
811
178
526
97.9
104
579
451
344
117
291
28.1
1060
53.6
573
100
45.5
300
J
J
J
J
J
J
JC RPD
1.8903440
1.7854339
1.5974026
1.2771084
0.8507614
0.8041768
0.7667210
0.5805177
0.5777778
0.5650224
0.5186079
0.5000000
0.4857143
0.4819558
0.4506346
0.4429967
0.4000000
0.3987539
0.3979206
0.3894893
0.3684211
0.3661972
0.3577982
0.3482143
0.3393502
0.3153348
0.3076923
0.2970297
0.2846004
0.2660550
0.2659758
0.2643392
0.2553729
0.2522704
0.2461538
0.2439024
0.2406015
0.2364217
0.2350015
0.2233903
0.2205029
0.2188782
0.2155388
0.2147368
0.2136800
0.2127660
0.2088167
0.1996008
0.1980831
0.1971831
0.1962264
0.1900161
0.1821925
0.1768707
0.1745731
0.1739130
0.1708543
0.1699819
1 of 3
Table 1 Relative Percent Difference
2007 Data Omaha Lead Site
SAID
90427
35637
77146
55636
27402
34377
32049
29155
17374
25918
74664
87763
11982
49319
27446
93364
74149
47681
46673
2355
91195
33468
33043
35964
33477
89377
30422
16006
93381
27461
92501
93358
21815
88031
37031
78989
32092
90107
27756
93120
29844
19988
93337
34396
30995
34219
89893
68667
93474
90601
87989
17417
29942
32914
17418
38007
93114
32284
XRF_DATE
17-Oct-07
l-Nov-07
25-Sep-07
27-Sep-07
25-Sep-07
15-Aug-07
17-Sep-07
15-Aug-07
19-Sep-07
26-Sep-07
25-Sep-07
10-Sep-07
21-Sep-07
1-Oct-07
14-Aug-07
27-NOV-07
23-Oct-07
17-Sep-07
5-Sep-07
29-NOV-07
14-NOV-07
1-Aug-07
15-Oct-07
1-Aug-07
30-Oct-07
9-NOV-07
7-Sep-07
29-Aug-07
5-NOV-07
15-NOV-07
23-Oct-07
18-Dec-07
17-Dec-07
21-Sep-07
9-Aug-07
28-Sep-07
9-Aug-07
25-Sep-07
13-Dec-07
17-Dec-07
1-Aug-07
20-NOV-07
18-Oct-07
2-Oct-07
27-Sep-07
27-Sep-07
26-Oct-07
20-Sep-07
20-NOV-07
12-NOV-07
6-NOV-07
12-Dec-07
10-Oct-07
14-Aug-07
5-Sep-07
15-Aug-07
20-Sep-07
10-Oct-07
XRF_SAMPLE_ID
RPZSCPXA-90427
RYDSCPXA-35637
RYDSCPXA-77146
RYBSCPXA-55636
RYASCPXA-27402
RYCSCPXA-34377
RYBSCPXA-32049
RYDSCPXA-29155
RYBSCPXA-17374
RYDSCPXA-25918
RYBSCPXA-74664
RYCSCPXA-87763
RYBSCPXA-11982
RYDSCPXA-49319
RYASCPXA-27446
RYDSCPXA-93364
RYDSCPXA-74149
RYCSCPXA-47681
RYCSCPXA-46673
RYBSCPXA-2355
RYASCPXA-91195
RYDSCPXA-33468
RYBSCPXA-33043
RYASCPXA-35964
RYASCPXA-33477
RYASCPXA-89377
RYBSCPXA-30422
RYCSCPXA-16006
RYBSCPXA-93381
RYDSCPXA-27461
RYASCPXA-92501
RYASCPXA-93358
RYDSCPXA-21815
RYASCPXA-88031
RYASCPXA-37031
RYDSCPXA-78989
RYBSCPXA-32092
RYASCPXA-90107
RYBSCPXA-27756
RYDSCPXA-93120
RYCSCPXA-29844
RYASCPXA-19988
RYBSCPXA-93337
RYBSCPXA-34396
RYBSCPXA-30995
RYDSCPXA-34219
RYBSCPXA-89893
RYBSCPXA-68667
RDZSCPXA-93474
RYCSCPXA-90601
RYDSCPXA-87989
RYCSCPXA-17417
RYDSCPXA-29942
RYDSCPXA-32914
RYCSCPXA-17418
RYASCPXA-38007
RYASCPXA-93114
RYCSCPXA-32284
XRF_ND XRF_PB
93
104
230
146 68
144
100 107
266 46
226
73
142 404
364
48
328 264
76
262
49 97
54
123
100
52
458
180
53
107
83
39
676 303
72
75
428
76
283
62 197
958
95
111
66
69
140
38
546
76
949
466
377
120
268
78
560
291
ASR_NUMBER
3609
3609
3608
3608
3608
3607
3608
3607
3608
3608
3608
3608
3608
3608
3607
3611
3609
3608
3608
3611
3610
3606
3609
3606
3609
3610
3608
3607
3610
3610
3609
"3612
3612
3608
3606
3608
3606
3609
3611
3612
3606
3611
3609
3609
3608
3608
3609
3608
3611
3610
3610
3611
3609
3607
3608
3607
3608
3609
U\B_DATE
17-Oct-07
l-Nov-07
25-Sep-07
27-Sep-07
25-Sep-07
15-Aug-07
17-Sep-07
15-Aug-07
19-Sep-07
26-Sep-07
25-Sep-07
10-Sep-07
21-Sep-07
1-Oct-07
14-Aug-07
27-NOV-07
23-Oct-07
17-Sep-07
5-Sep-07
29-NOV-07
14-NOV-07
1-Aug-07
15-Oct-07
1-Aug-07
30-Oct-07
9-NOV-07
7-Sep-07
29-Aug-07
5-NOV-07
15-NOV-07
23-Oct-07
18-Dec-07
17-Dec-07
21-Sep-07
9-Aug-07
28-Sep-07
9-Aug-07
25-Sep-07
13-Dec-07
17-Dec-07
1-Aug-07
20-NOV-07
18-Oct-07
2-Oct-07
27-Sep-07
27-Sep-07
26-Oct-07
20-Sep-07
20-NOV-07
12-NOV-07
6-NOV-07
12-Dec-07
10-Oct-07
14-Aug-07
5-Sep-07
15-Aug-07
20-Sep-07
10-Oct-07
LAB_SAMPLE_ID
RPZSCPLA-90427
RYDSCPLA-35637
RYDSCPLA-77146
RYBSCPLA-55636
RYASCPLA-27402
RYCSCPLA-34377
RYBSCPLA-32049
RYDSCPLA-29155
RYBSCPLA-17374
RYDSCPLA-25918
RYBSCPLA-74664
RYCSCPLA-87763
RYBSCPLA-11982
RYDSCPLA-49319
RYASCPLA-27446
RYDSCPI-A-93364
RYDSCPI-A-74149
RYCSCPLA-47681
RYCSCPLA-46673
RYBSCPLA-2355
RYASCPLA-91195
RYDSCPLA-33468
RYBSCPLA-33043
RYASCPLA-35964
RYASCPLA-33477
RYASCPLA-89377
RYBSCPLA-30422
RYCSCPU\-16006
RYBSCPLA-93381
RYDSCPLA-27461
RYASCPLA-92501
RYASCPLA-93358
RYDSCPLA-21815
RYASCPLA-88031
RYASCPLA-37031
RYDSCPLA-78989
RYBSCPLA-32092
RYASCPLA-90107
RYBSCPLA-27756
RYDSCPLA-93120
RYCSCPLA-29844
RYASCPLA-19988
RYBSCPLA-93337
RYBSCPLA-34396
RYBSCPLA-30995
RYDSCPLA-34219
RYBSCPlA-89893
RYBSCPLA-68667
RDZSCPLA-93474
RYCSCPLA-90601
RYDSCPLA-87989
RYCSCPLA-17417
RYDSCPLA-29942
RYDSCPLA-32914
RYCSCPLA-17418
RYASCPLA-38007
RYASCPLA-93114
RYCSCPLA-32284
LAB_PB DETECTION.
110
123
271
172
79.7
123
117
91.6
310
53.1
260
83.9
163
353
416
54.8
373
300
86
232
43.4
109
60.6
138
112
58.2
410
201
59
119
74.7
35.1
750
336
79.8
82.8
472 J
83.7
257
56.4
216
875
104
121
71.8
75
129
41.2
591 J
82.2
880
502
406
129
288
72.8
597
310 J
ID RPD
0.1674877
0.1674009
0.1636727
0.1635220
0.1584292
0.1573034
0.1566820
0.1550856
0.1527778
0.1432896
0.1399177
0.1389420
0.1377049
0.1347424
0.1333333
0.1322957
0.1283880
0.1276596
0.1234568
0.1214575
0.1212121
0.1165049
0.1151832
0.1149425
0.1132075
0.1125227
0.1105991
0.1102362
0.1071429
0.1061947
0.1052632
0.1052632
0.1037868
0.1032864
0.1027668
0.0988593
0.0977778
0.0964308
0.0962963
0.0945946
0.0920097
0.0905619
0.0904523
0.0862069
0.0841800
0.0833333
0.0817844
0.0808081
0.0791557
0.0783818
0.0754511
0.0743802
0.0740741
0.0722892
0.0719424
0.0689655
0.0639585
0.0632280
2 of 3
Table 1 Relative Percent Difference
2007 Data Omaha Lead Site
SAID
30189
89842
93344
89408
25780
27315
31283
18718
38142
81400
87991
34224
28157
29165
93338
90908
30939
21730
27269
91239
73077
90101
91926
30978
93354
63751
79377
93413
29274
44636
29753
37226
43843
91449
73862
23433
37036
92675
27038
68686
89514
29063
36574
37434
XRF_DATE
4-Oct-07
9-NOV-07
18-Oct-07
l -Nov-07
7-Sep-07
9-Aug-07
8-Jan-07
7-Sep-07
1-Aug-07
3-Oct-07
18-Oct-07
16-NOV-07
14-Aug-07
8-Aug-07
25-Oct-07
6-NOV-07
26-Sep-07
19-Dec-07
8-Aug-07
27-NOV-07
15-Oct-07
13-Dec-07
29-Oct-07
10-0ct-07
11-Dec-07
14-NOV-07
4-Oct-07
24-Oct-07
30-Oct-07
29-Aug-07
5-Sep-07
26-Sep-07
20-Dec-07
6-NOV-07
12-Oct-07
1-Oct-07
6-Sep-07
5-Oct-07
14-Aug-07
3-Oct-07
5-NOV-07
6-Sep-07
18-Sep-07
31-Jul-07
XRF_SAMPLE_ID
RYCSCPXA-30189
RYBSCPXA-89842
RYASCPXA-93344
RYCSCPXA-89408
RYBSCPXA-25780
RYCSCPXA-27315
P40SCPXA-31283
RYASCPXA-18718
RDZSCPXA-38142
RYCSCPXA-81400
RYCSCPXA-87991
RYASCPXA-34224
RYDSCPXA-28157
RYASCPXA-29165
RYCSCPXA-93338
RYBSCPXA-90908
RYDSCPXA-30939
RYBSCPXA-21730
RYDSCPXA-27269
RYASCPXA-91239
RYBSCPXA-73077
RYBSCPXA-90101
RYASCPXA-91926
RYBSCPXA-30978
RYASCPXA-93354
RYDSCPXA-63751
RYBSCPXA-79377
RYCSCPXA-93413
RYCSCPXA-29274
RYCSCPXA-44636
RYBSCPXA-29753
RYASCPXA-37226
RYASCPXA-43843
RYCSCPXA-91449
RYCSCPXA-73862
RYCSCPXA-23433
RYCSCPXA-37036
RYDSCPXA-92675
RYCSCPXA-27038
RYASCPXA-68686
RYASCPXA-89514
RYBSCPXA-29063
RYDSCPXA-36574
RYDSCPXA-37434
XRF_ND XRF_PB
232
421
71
136
127
849
90.94
167
484
43
76
356
42
153
84
447
18
120
729
55
62
54
35
27
46
60
186
47
71
196
254
246
76
293
55
247
69
43
317
83
189
420
44
299
ASR_NUMBER
3609
3610
3609
3609
3608
3606
3336
3608
3606
3609
3609
3611
3607
3606
3609
3610
3608
3612
3606
3611
3609
3611
3609
3609
3611
3610
3609
3609
3609
3607
3608
3608
3613
3610
3609
3608
3608
3609
3607
3609
3610
3608
3608
3606
LAB_DATE
4-Oct-07
9-NOV-07
18-Oct-07
l-Nov-07
7-Sep-07
9-Aug-07
8-Jan-07
7-Sep-07
1-Aug-07
3-Oct-07
18-Oct-07
26-NOV-07
14-Aug-07
8-Aug-07
25-Oct-07
6-NOV-07
26-Sep-07
19-Dec-07
8-Aug-07
27-NOV-07
15-Oct-07
13-Dec-07
29-Oct-07
10-Oct-07
11-Det>07
14-NOV-07
4-Oct-07
24-Oct-07
30-Oct-07
29-Aug-07
5-Sep-07
26-Sep-07
20-Dec-07
6-NOV-07
12-Oct-07
10-0ct-07
6-Sep-07
5-Oct-07
14-Aug-07
3-Oct-07
5-NOV-07
6-Sep-07
18-Sep-07
31-Jul-07
LAB_SAMPLE_ID
RYCSCPLA-30189
RYBSCPLA-89842
RYASCPLA-93344
RYCSCPLA-89408
RYBSCPLA-25780
RYCSCPLA-27315
P40SCPLA-31283
RYASCPLA-18718
RDZSCPLA-38142
RYCSCPLA-81400
RYCSCPLA-87991
RYASCPLA-34224
RYDSCPLA-28157
RYASCPLA.-29165
RYCSCPLA-93338
RYBSCPLA-90908
RYDSCPLA-30939
RYBSCPLA-21730
RYDSCPLA-27269
RYASCPLA-91239
RYBSCPLA-73077
RYBSCPLA-90101
RYASCPLA-91926
RYBSCPLj^-30978
RYASCPLA-93354
RYDSCPLA-63751
RYBSCPLA-79377
RYCSCPLA-93413
RYCSCPLA-29274
RYCSCPLA-44636
RYBSCPLA-29753
RYASCPLA-37226
RYASCPLA-43843
RYCSCPLA-91449
RYCSCPLA-73862
RYCSCPLA-23433
RYCSCPLA-37036
RYDSCPLA-92675
RYCSCPLA-27038
RYASCPLA-68686
RYASCPLA-89514
RYBSCPLA-29063
RYDSCPLA-36574
RYDSCPLA-37434
LAB_PB DETECTION.
247
448
66.8
144
120
803
96 J
176
461
45.1
79.5
372
40.2
159
87
432
17.4
116
754
53.4
60.2
55.6
36
26.3
47.1
58.7
182
48
72.5
192
249
242
77.1
289
55.7
249
68.5
42.7
319
83.5
188
422 J
44.2
298
1C RPD
0.0626305
0.0621404
0.0609579
0.0571429
0.0566802
0.0556901
0.0541350
0.0524781
0.0486772
0.0476731
0.0450161
0.0439560
0.0437956
0.0384615
0.0350877
0.0341297
0.0338983
0.0338983
0.0337154
0.0295203
0.0294599
0.0291971
0.0281690
0.0262664
0.0236305
0.0219040
0.0217391
0.0210526
0.0209059
0.0206186
0.0198807
0:0163934
0.0143697
0.0137457
0.0126468
0.0080645
0.0072727
0.0070012
0.0062893
0.0060060
0.0053050
0.0047506
0.0045351
0.0033501
3 of 3
Table 2 Comparison of 60 Mesh vs 10 Mesh Sieve
2007 Data Onnaha Lead Site
SAID
32650
91239
66791
90599
91158
30293
19869
52385
87462
87989
38186
83038
22871
90316
90373
73891
93381
90601
89408
46747
93358
87941
35517
29155
2355
93435
26226
29848
34651
35365
36416
48854
20926
30139
22070
64027
30186
15046
32388
26159
21005
47365
63751
21854
SAMPLE_DATE_60
25-Sep-07
27-NOV-07
2-NOV-07
20-NOV-07
29-OC1-07
18-Oct-07
19-Sep-07
26-Oct-07
17-Oct-07
6-NOV-07
1-Aug-07
3-Oct-07
17-Sep-07
13-NOV-07
16-NOV-07
27-Sep-07
5-NOV-07
12-NOV-07
l-Nov-07
14-Dec-07
18-Dec-07
8-NOV-07
28-Sep-07
15-Aug-07
29-NOV-07
11-Dec-07
13-Dec-07
23-Oct-07
20-Sep-07
5-Sep-07
8-Aug-07
9-NOV-07
17-Jan-07
15-NOV-07
19-Dec-07
31-Oct-07
4-Oct-07
25-Oct-07
9-Aug-07
11-Oct-07
4-Jan-07
7-Sep-07
14-NOV-07
20-Dec-07
SAIVIPLE_ID_60
RYBSCMXA-32650
RYDSCMXA-91239
RYDSCMXA-66791
RYDSCMXA-90599
RYBSCMXA-91158
RYBSCMXA-30293
RYCSCMXA-19869
RYCSCMXA-52385
RYDSCMXA-87462
RYCSCMXA-87989
RYCSCMXA-38186
RYCSCMXA-83038
RYCSCMXA-22871
RYASCMXA-90316
RYDSCMXA-90373
RYASCMXA-73891
RYBSCMXA-93381
RYASCMXA-90601
RYBSCMXA-89408
RYDSCMXA-46747
RYASCMXA-93358
RYASCMXA-87941
RYDSCMXA-35517
RYDSCMXA-29155
RYBSCMXA-2355
RYBSCMXA-93435
RYASCMXA-26226
RYASCMXA-29848
RYASCMXA-34651
RYCSCMXA-35365
RYASCMXA-36416
RYASCMXA-48854
RYASCMXA-20926
RYASCMXA-30139
RYASCMXA-22070
RYBSCMXA-64027
RYCSCMXA-30186
RYASCMXA-15046
RYDSCMXA-32388
RYBSCMXA-26159
RDZSCMXA-21005
RYCSCMXA-47365
RYASCMXA-63751
RYBSCMXA-21854
PB_60
1479
205
169
173
212
67
167
147
42
454
101
243
40
81
59
217
61
67
60
264
44
56
618
97
288
79
352
78
99
171
203
91
389.04
118
182
56
640
262
48
176
67.38
272
105
100
SAMPLE_DATE_10
25-Sep-07
27-NOV-07
2-NOV-07
20-NOV-07
29-Oct-07
18-Oct-07
19-Sep-07
26-Oct-07
17-Oct-07
6-NOV-07
1-Aug-07
3-Oct-07
17-Sep-07
13-NOV-07
16-NOV-07
27-Sep-07
5-NOV-07
12-NOV-07
l-Nov-07
14-Dec-07
18-Dec-07
8-NOV-07
28-Sep-07
15-Aug-07
29-NOV-07
11-Dec-07
13-Dec-07
23-Oct-07
20-Sep-07
5-Sep-07
8-Aug-07
9-NOV-07
17-Jan-07
15-NOV-07
19-Dec-07
31-Oct-07
4-Oct-07
25-Oct-07
9-Aug-07
11-Oct-07
4-Jan-07
7-Sep-07
14-NOV-07
20-Dec-07
SAMPLE_ID_10
RYBSCPXA-32650
RYDSCPXA-91239
RYDSCPXA-66791
RYDSCPXA-90599
RYBSCPXA-91158
RYBSCPXA-30293
RYCSCPXA-19869
RYCSCPXA-52385
RYDSCPXA-87462
RYCSCPXA-87989
RYCSCPXA-38186
RYCSCPXA-83038
RYCSCPXA-22871 .
RYASCPXA-90316
RYDSCPXA-90373
RYASCPXA-73891
RYBSCPXA-93381
RYASCPXA-90601
RYBSCPXA-89408
RYDSCPXA-46747
RYASCPXA-93358
RYASCPXA-87941
RYDSCPXA-35517
RYDSCPXA-29155
RYBSCPXA-2355
RYBSCPXA-93435
RYASCPXA-26226
RYASCPXA-29848
RYASCPXA-34651
RYCSCPXA-35365
RYASCPXA-36416
RYASCPXA-48854
RYASCPXA-20926
RYASCPXA-30139
RYASCPXA-22070
RYBSCPXA-64027
RYCSCPXA-30186
RYASCPXA-15046
RYDSCPXA-32388
RYBSCPXA-26159
RDZSCPXA-21005
RYCSCPXA-47365
RYASCPXA-63751
RYBSCPXA-21854
PB_10
1012
142
125
133
163
87
129
183
34
369
122
204
34
70
51
250
53
77
68
299
39
50
554
107
262
72
323
85
92
184
218
85
415.55
125
172
53
609
274
50
183
64.97
265
107
101
RPD
0.3749498
0.3631124
0.2993197
0.2614379
0.2613333
0.2597403
0.2567568
0.2181818
0.2105263
0.2065614
0.1883408
0.1744966
0.1621622
0.1456954
0.1454545
0.1413276
0.1403509
0.1388889
0.1250000
0.1243339
0.1204819
0.1132075
0.1092150
0.0980392
0.0945455
0.0927152
0.0859259
0.0858896
0.0732984
0.0732394
0.0712589
0.0681818
0.0658969
0.0576132
0.0564972
0.0550459
0.0496397
0.0447761
0.0408163
0.0389972
0.0364186
0.0260708
0.0188679
0.0099502
1 of 1