18
RemoteSensing Laboratory (RSLab) Radiation Laboratory (RadLab) 1/26 BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS AND INDOOR EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS AND INDOOR EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS Sergi Duque*, Paco López-Dekker*, Jordi J. Mallorquí*, Adib Y. Nashashibi** and Amit M. Patel** [email protected] * Remote Sensing Lab (RSLab) - Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (UPC) **Radiation Laboratory (RadLab) - University of Michigan (UofM)

BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS AND ...earth.esa.int/fringe09/participants/606/pres_606_Duque.pdfMUSIC order 1 and MUSIC order 3 and Non Least Squares (NLS). They use a priori

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS AND ...earth.esa.int/fringe09/participants/606/pres_606_Duque.pdfMUSIC order 1 and MUSIC order 3 and Non Least Squares (NLS). They use a priori

RemoteSensing Laboratory (RSLab) Radiation Laboratory (RadLab)1/26

BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS AND INDOOR EXPERIMENTAL RESULTSAND INDOOR EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS

Sergi Duque*, Paco López-Dekker*, Jordi J. Mallorquí*, Adib Y. Nashashibi** and Amit M. Patel**

[email protected]

* Remote Sensing Lab (RSLab) - Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (UPC)

**Radiation Laboratory (RadLab) - University of Michigan (UofM)

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Hi, my name is Sergio Duque and Im gonna present this work wich has been carried out in collaboration with the university of michigan
Page 2: BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS AND ...earth.esa.int/fringe09/participants/606/pres_606_Duque.pdfMUSIC order 1 and MUSIC order 3 and Non Least Squares (NLS). They use a priori

RemoteSensing Laboratory (RSLab) Radiation Laboratory (RadLab)2/26

Introduction

Geometry and Acquisition system description

Tomographic

processing techniques

Results

Regular baseline set

Irregular baseline set

Differential Tomographic

results.

Conclusions

OutlineOutline

Presenter
Presentation Notes
This is the outline of the presentation I ll start giving an introduction about mb and its impact on a bistatic configuration Ill continue descrigin the geometry and the system employed After that ill discuss the different tomographic processing techniques used in this work It will b followed by some results. Which will be obtained using regular and irregular baseline set And the results will also include a dif tomo res I ll end up with some conclusiong
Page 3: BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS AND ...earth.esa.int/fringe09/participants/606/pres_606_Duque.pdfMUSIC order 1 and MUSIC order 3 and Non Least Squares (NLS). They use a priori

RemoteSensing Laboratory (RSLab) Radiation Laboratory (RadLab)3/26

IntroductionIntroduction

Multibaseline

(MB) SAR techniques have appeared as evolution of InSAR.

Their objective is to distinguish

between different

scatters

in the same resolution cell

and to retrieve their height.

The MB techniques have been applied using monostatic

geometries.

Drawbacks

of monostatic

MB techniques:

Temporal decorrelation

due to the time between the passes.

Irregular baseline sampling.

Presenter
Presentation Notes
MB has appeared as an evolution of InSAR Their obj is to distinguish betwn dif scatterers in the same res cell and to retrieve their height Until now, this tecniques have been aplied using monostatic geom. They can have some drawbacks such as temporal decorrelation because the time between the pases and irregular sampling
Page 4: BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS AND ...earth.esa.int/fringe09/participants/606/pres_606_Duque.pdfMUSIC order 1 and MUSIC order 3 and Non Least Squares (NLS). They use a priori

RemoteSensing Laboratory (RSLab) Radiation Laboratory (RadLab)4/26

IntroductionIntroduction

Our Goal

Overcome

monostatic

multibaseline

drawbacks.

How to? Using a bistatic

geometry

with fixed receiver.

Only one pass

is needed no temporal decorrelation.

Freedom placing the receivers baseline sampling as desired.

Different algorithms will be tested.

Results

over a real controlled scenario

will be presented.

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Which is our goal? It is try to overcome the monostatic mb drawbacks How? Using a bistatic geo with a fixed receiver. With this kind of configuration only one pass is needed which means no temporal decorrelation. Besides, we will have some freedom placing the receivers. Here we will test different algorith and results over a controlled real scenario will b presented
Page 5: BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS AND ...earth.esa.int/fringe09/participants/606/pres_606_Duque.pdfMUSIC order 1 and MUSIC order 3 and Non Least Squares (NLS). They use a priori

RemoteSensing Laboratory (RSLab) Radiation Laboratory (RadLab)

GeomettryGeomettry and Acquisition System Description (and Acquisition System Description (RadLabRadLab))

R

7 m

Bv

= 1 m

θ

= 50 º

X

Y

Z

Tx

Rx1

RxN

Bv

R

ΔBv

zi

Sources

Resolution Cell

f0

= 34.93 GHz (λ

8.6 mm

)

Bw=2.5GHz

Positioning precision better than 0.1 mm

θ

Presenter
Presentation Notes
The acquisition system is presented on this pic on the right It has a carrier of about 35Ghz and bandwith of 2.5GHz Tx and Rx The sinthtic aperture is performed moving a robotic arm in a horizontal path and the differents baselines are done by the moving the other robotic arm in the vertical direction The geom parameters are the following R 7 m, total baseline vertical baseline 1m Incidence angle about 50º Inc and rang change along the scene Aplicar patrons Treure dades irrellevants Resaltar antenes enfront dades Afegir longitud d’ona
Page 6: BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS AND ...earth.esa.int/fringe09/participants/606/pres_606_Duque.pdfMUSIC order 1 and MUSIC order 3 and Non Least Squares (NLS). They use a priori

RemoteSensing Laboratory (RSLab) Radiation Laboratory (RadLab)6/26

TomographicTomographic processingprocessing techniquestechniquesRaw data

Back Projection

Corregistration

Preparation for APES

processing

APES Processing

High resolutionSLC image

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Firstm we adquire the raw data, we perform a BP over it and we corregister all the images acquired from the different receiver positions. We wanna do an APES processing over the slc image obtained by BP. Thus, we have to prepare the data for it, equalizing the usefull spectra
Page 7: BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS AND ...earth.esa.int/fringe09/participants/606/pres_606_Duque.pdfMUSIC order 1 and MUSIC order 3 and Non Least Squares (NLS). They use a priori

RemoteSensing Laboratory (RSLab) Radiation Laboratory (RadLab)

TomographicTomographic processingprocessing techniquestechniques

Parametric

Used in this work: MUSIC order 1

and MUSIC order 3 and

Non Least Squares (NLS).

They use a priori assumptions.

Born approximation.

MUSIC supposes the number of sources

is known.

NLS

assumes the maximum

number of sources

is known.

Expected behaviour:

MUSIC will have a good resolution if the number of sources is correct.

NLS will be timing consuming but it should present high resolution for regular and irregular baseline dataset.

7/26

3D (XYZ)Complex image

“Flat Earth”correction

Set of High resolutionSLC images

Tomographicprocessing

Geocodification

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Once we have all the images at a good resolution from all the receiver postiions, we proceed to the tomograpohic processing itself. The flat eart term is removed and then we can apply the tomographic processing. Fer la mida de les fórmules coherent amb el texte Falta decir los resultados esperados de los diferentes mètodos
Page 8: BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS AND ...earth.esa.int/fringe09/participants/606/pres_606_Duque.pdfMUSIC order 1 and MUSIC order 3 and Non Least Squares (NLS). They use a priori

RemoteSensing Laboratory (RSLab) Radiation Laboratory (RadLab)

TomographicTomographic processingprocessing techniquestechniques

Non – parametric

Used: Beamforming

(BF), CAPON

(CP)

and CAPON with subapertures

(CPs).

They only use Born approximation.

Expected behaviour:

BF will show low resolution. It presents high sidelobes

when an irregular baseline set is used.

CP is a good espectral

estimator able to retrieve the heights in a regular and irregular set of baselines.

CPs

is similar to CAPON but uses the Baseline dimension to calculate the covariance matrix. Because of this it cannot be applied to irregular set of baselines.

8/26

3D (XYZ)Complex image

“Flat Earth”correction

Set of High resolutionSLC images

Tomographicprocessing

Geocodification

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Fer la mida de les fórmules coherent amb el texte Falta decir los resultados esperados de los diferentes mètodos
Page 9: BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS AND ...earth.esa.int/fringe09/participants/606/pres_606_Duque.pdfMUSIC order 1 and MUSIC order 3 and Non Least Squares (NLS). They use a priori

RemoteSensing Laboratory (RSLab) Radiation Laboratory (RadLab)

ResultsResults. . ScaleScale modelmodel..

9/26

Presenter
Presentation Notes
The RSLab is a bistatic configuration with a fixed receiver. We are using a fixed receiver bistatic conf A C-band receiver that uses ERS2 and ENVISAT as a transmitters of opportunity has been developed (SABRINA)‏ The purpouse of SABRINA is to do differential interferometric applications Extraction of the 3D deformation component using a set of receivers with different looking angle. As u know the sar polarimetry and interferometry and differential interferometry are techniques that has been used in SAR for many years and they are mature techniques. However bistatic and multistatic systems are emerging as a new research field allowing more geometries and more configurations. And also the previous techniques mentioned before can be applied to bistatic config As u have seen in previous presentations, dfferent bistatic experiments such as airbone ones and some missions as tandem X are being carried out to try to explore the full potential of this kind of configurations At our university, in the RSLab, we have developed a Cband receiver that uses the ESA’s ERS2 and ENVISAT satellites as transmitters of opportunity, this receiver has been named SABRINA, SAR bistatic Receiver for Interferometric Applications, also we are working in a new version in X band which will be baptized as SABRINA-X
Page 10: BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS AND ...earth.esa.int/fringe09/participants/606/pres_606_Duque.pdfMUSIC order 1 and MUSIC order 3 and Non Least Squares (NLS). They use a priori

RemoteSensing Laboratory (RSLab) Radiation Laboratory (RadLab)10/26

ResultsResults. Regular . Regular baselinebaseline setset

Beam Forming (BF): Ground cut

Trees

Building

Bv

= 1mΔb=0.1 mNom hres

= 4.7cmHambiguity

=46.7 cm

Corners

Presenter
Presentation Notes
The RSLab is a bistatic configuration with a fixed receiver. We are using a fixed receiver bistatic conf A C-band receiver that uses ERS2 and ENVISAT as a transmitters of opportunity has been developed (SABRINA)‏ The purpouse of SABRINA is to do differential interferometric applications Extraction of the 3D deformation component using a set of receivers with different looking angle. As u know the sar polarimetry and interferometry and differential interferometry are techniques that has been used in SAR for many years and they are mature techniques. However bistatic and multistatic systems are emerging as a new research field allowing more geometries and more configurations. And also the previous techniques mentioned before can be applied to bistatic config As u have seen in previous presentations, dfferent bistatic experiments such as airbone ones and some missions as tandem X are being carried out to try to explore the full potential of this kind of configurations At our university, in the RSLab, we have developed a Cband receiver that uses the ESA’s ERS2 and ENVISAT satellites as transmitters of opportunity, this receiver has been named SABRINA, SAR bistatic Receiver for Interferometric Applications, also we are working in a new version in X band which will be baptized as SABRINA-X
Page 11: BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS AND ...earth.esa.int/fringe09/participants/606/pres_606_Duque.pdfMUSIC order 1 and MUSIC order 3 and Non Least Squares (NLS). They use a priori

RemoteSensing Laboratory (RSLab) Radiation Laboratory (RadLab)11/26

ResultsResults. Regular . Regular baselinebaseline setset. .

BF

CP

CPs

Presenter
Presentation Notes
The RSLab is a bistatic configuration with a fixed receiver. We are using a fixed receiver bistatic conf A C-band receiver that uses ERS2 and ENVISAT as a transmitters of opportunity has been developed (SABRINA)‏ The purpouse of SABRINA is to do differential interferometric applications Extraction of the 3D deformation component using a set of receivers with different looking angle. As u know the sar polarimetry and interferometry and differential interferometry are techniques that has been used in SAR for many years and they are mature techniques. However bistatic and multistatic systems are emerging as a new research field allowing more geometries and more configurations. And also the previous techniques mentioned before can be applied to bistatic config As u have seen in previous presentations, dfferent bistatic experiments such as airbone ones and some missions as tandem X are being carried out to try to explore the full potential of this kind of configurations At our university, in the RSLab, we have developed a Cband receiver that uses the ESA’s ERS2 and ENVISAT satellites as transmitters of opportunity, this receiver has been named SABRINA, SAR bistatic Receiver for Interferometric Applications, also we are working in a new version in X band which will be baptized as SABRINA-X
Page 12: BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS AND ...earth.esa.int/fringe09/participants/606/pres_606_Duque.pdfMUSIC order 1 and MUSIC order 3 and Non Least Squares (NLS). They use a priori

RemoteSensing Laboratory (RSLab) Radiation Laboratory (RadLab)12/26

ResultsResults. Regular . Regular baselinebaseline setset. .

MUSIC

Ns=1

MUSIC

Ns=3

NLS

Presenter
Presentation Notes
The RSLab is a bistatic configuration with a fixed receiver. We are using a fixed receiver bistatic conf A C-band receiver that uses ERS2 and ENVISAT as a transmitters of opportunity has been developed (SABRINA)‏ The purpouse of SABRINA is to do differential interferometric applications Extraction of the 3D deformation component using a set of receivers with different looking angle. As u know the sar polarimetry and interferometry and differential interferometry are techniques that has been used in SAR for many years and they are mature techniques. However bistatic and multistatic systems are emerging as a new research field allowing more geometries and more configurations. And also the previous techniques mentioned before can be applied to bistatic config As u have seen in previous presentations, dfferent bistatic experiments such as airbone ones and some missions as tandem X are being carried out to try to explore the full potential of this kind of configurations At our university, in the RSLab, we have developed a Cband receiver that uses the ESA’s ERS2 and ENVISAT satellites as transmitters of opportunity, this receiver has been named SABRINA, SAR bistatic Receiver for Interferometric Applications, also we are working in a new version in X band which will be baptized as SABRINA-X
Page 13: BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS AND ...earth.esa.int/fringe09/participants/606/pres_606_Duque.pdfMUSIC order 1 and MUSIC order 3 and Non Least Squares (NLS). They use a priori

RemoteSensing Laboratory (RSLab) Radiation Laboratory (RadLab)13/26

ResultsResults. Irregular . Irregular baselinebaseline setset

CP. Ground cut

Trees

Building

Bv

= 1mE{Δb}=16.7 cmNom hres

= 4.7cmHambiguity

=28.1 cm

Corners

Presenter
Presentation Notes
The RSLab is a bistatic configuration with a fixed receiver. We are using a fixed receiver bistatic conf A C-band receiver that uses ERS2 and ENVISAT as a transmitters of opportunity has been developed (SABRINA)‏ The purpouse of SABRINA is to do differential interferometric applications Extraction of the 3D deformation component using a set of receivers with different looking angle. As u know the sar polarimetry and interferometry and differential interferometry are techniques that has been used in SAR for many years and they are mature techniques. However bistatic and multistatic systems are emerging as a new research field allowing more geometries and more configurations. And also the previous techniques mentioned before can be applied to bistatic config As u have seen in previous presentations, dfferent bistatic experiments such as airbone ones and some missions as tandem X are being carried out to try to explore the full potential of this kind of configurations At our university, in the RSLab, we have developed a Cband receiver that uses the ESA’s ERS2 and ENVISAT satellites as transmitters of opportunity, this receiver has been named SABRINA, SAR bistatic Receiver for Interferometric Applications, also we are working in a new version in X band which will be baptized as SABRINA-X
Page 14: BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS AND ...earth.esa.int/fringe09/participants/606/pres_606_Duque.pdfMUSIC order 1 and MUSIC order 3 and Non Least Squares (NLS). They use a priori

RemoteSensing Laboratory (RSLab) Radiation Laboratory (RadLab)14/26

Height

of

ambiguity

ResultsResults. Irregular . Irregular baselinebaseline setset. .

BF

CP

Presenter
Presentation Notes
The RSLab is a bistatic configuration with a fixed receiver. We are using a fixed receiver bistatic conf A C-band receiver that uses ERS2 and ENVISAT as a transmitters of opportunity has been developed (SABRINA)‏ The purpouse of SABRINA is to do differential interferometric applications Extraction of the 3D deformation component using a set of receivers with different looking angle. As u know the sar polarimetry and interferometry and differential interferometry are techniques that has been used in SAR for many years and they are mature techniques. However bistatic and multistatic systems are emerging as a new research field allowing more geometries and more configurations. And also the previous techniques mentioned before can be applied to bistatic config As u have seen in previous presentations, dfferent bistatic experiments such as airbone ones and some missions as tandem X are being carried out to try to explore the full potential of this kind of configurations At our university, in the RSLab, we have developed a Cband receiver that uses the ESA’s ERS2 and ENVISAT satellites as transmitters of opportunity, this receiver has been named SABRINA, SAR bistatic Receiver for Interferometric Applications, also we are working in a new version in X band which will be baptized as SABRINA-X
Page 15: BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS AND ...earth.esa.int/fringe09/participants/606/pres_606_Duque.pdfMUSIC order 1 and MUSIC order 3 and Non Least Squares (NLS). They use a priori

RemoteSensing Laboratory (RSLab) Radiation Laboratory (RadLab)15/18

Results. Differential Tomography.

Experiment Description

Three set of experiments

were done moving the building

between each acquisition set.

The expected displacement is a ramp from 5 to 0 mm.

Scheme:

Presenter
Presentation Notes
The RSLab is a bistatic configuration with a fixed receiver. We are using a fixed receiver bistatic conf A C-band receiver that uses ERS2 and ENVISAT as a transmitters of opportunity has been developed (SABRINA)‏ The purpouse of SABRINA is to do differential interferometric applications Extraction of the 3D deformation component using a set of receivers with different looking angle. As u know the sar polarimetry and interferometry and differential interferometry are techniques that has been used in SAR for many years and they are mature techniques. However bistatic and multistatic systems are emerging as a new research field allowing more geometries and more configurations. And also the previous techniques mentioned before can be applied to bistatic config As u have seen in previous presentations, dfferent bistatic experiments such as airbone ones and some missions as tandem X are being carried out to try to explore the full potential of this kind of configurations At our university, in the RSLab, we have developed a Cband receiver that uses the ESA’s ERS2 and ENVISAT satellites as transmitters of opportunity, this receiver has been named SABRINA, SAR bistatic Receiver for Interferometric Applications, also we are working in a new version in X band which will be baptized as SABRINA-X
Page 16: BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS AND ...earth.esa.int/fringe09/participants/606/pres_606_Duque.pdfMUSIC order 1 and MUSIC order 3 and Non Least Squares (NLS). They use a priori

RemoteSensing Laboratory (RSLab) Radiation Laboratory (RadLab)16/18

Results. Differential Tomography.

Displacement horizontal cut @ 12 cm

5 mm ramp displacement

Uncontrolled tree movement

Presenter
Presentation Notes
The RSLab is a bistatic configuration with a fixed receiver. We are using a fixed receiver bistatic conf A C-band receiver that uses ERS2 and ENVISAT as a transmitters of opportunity has been developed (SABRINA)‏ The purpouse of SABRINA is to do differential interferometric applications Extraction of the 3D deformation component using a set of receivers with different looking angle. As u know the sar polarimetry and interferometry and differential interferometry are techniques that has been used in SAR for many years and they are mature techniques. However bistatic and multistatic systems are emerging as a new research field allowing more geometries and more configurations. And also the previous techniques mentioned before can be applied to bistatic config As u have seen in previous presentations, dfferent bistatic experiments such as airbone ones and some missions as tandem X are being carried out to try to explore the full potential of this kind of configurations At our university, in the RSLab, we have developed a Cband receiver that uses the ESA’s ERS2 and ENVISAT satellites as transmitters of opportunity, this receiver has been named SABRINA, SAR bistatic Receiver for Interferometric Applications, also we are working in a new version in X band which will be baptized as SABRINA-X
Page 17: BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS AND ...earth.esa.int/fringe09/participants/606/pres_606_Duque.pdfMUSIC order 1 and MUSIC order 3 and Non Least Squares (NLS). They use a priori

RemoteSensing Laboratory (RSLab) Radiation Laboratory (RadLab)17/18

Results. Differential Tomography.

Displacement vertical cut

Aliasing from the ground

5 mm ramp displacement

Uncontrolled tree displacement

Stable ground.

Presenter
Presentation Notes
The RSLab is a bistatic configuration with a fixed receiver. We are using a fixed receiver bistatic conf A C-band receiver that uses ERS2 and ENVISAT as a transmitters of opportunity has been developed (SABRINA)‏ The purpouse of SABRINA is to do differential interferometric applications Extraction of the 3D deformation component using a set of receivers with different looking angle. As u know the sar polarimetry and interferometry and differential interferometry are techniques that has been used in SAR for many years and they are mature techniques. However bistatic and multistatic systems are emerging as a new research field allowing more geometries and more configurations. And also the previous techniques mentioned before can be applied to bistatic config As u have seen in previous presentations, dfferent bistatic experiments such as airbone ones and some missions as tandem X are being carried out to try to explore the full potential of this kind of configurations At our university, in the RSLab, we have developed a Cband receiver that uses the ESA’s ERS2 and ENVISAT satellites as transmitters of opportunity, this receiver has been named SABRINA, SAR bistatic Receiver for Interferometric Applications, also we are working in a new version in X band which will be baptized as SABRINA-X
Page 18: BISTATIC SAR TOMOGRAPHY: METHOD ANALYSIS AND ...earth.esa.int/fringe09/participants/606/pres_606_Duque.pdfMUSIC order 1 and MUSIC order 3 and Non Least Squares (NLS). They use a priori

RemoteSensing Laboratory (RSLab) Radiation Laboratory (RadLab)18/26

ConclusionsConclusions

Bistatic

tomographic

results

have been presented over real data

obtained with an

indoor experimental setup.

Different algorithms have been used.

MUSIC: Works OK if the number of sources is the expected one.

Creates artefacts when the number of sources is incorrect.

It does not preserves the phase It is not suitable for differential application.

NLS: Good results if the maximum number of sources can characterize the cell scattering.

It presents some problems in non regular baseline sets. ?

BF: Works fine for regular baselines but with poor resolution.

High sidelobes

for a non regular baseline set.

CP: Shows pretty good results in a regular and irregular baseline set.

CPs: Works fine in a regular set but it is not applicable to an irregular set of data.

Differential Tomography

is useful for retrieving the deformation in a 3D volume.

The next step is to apply the algorithms to real data obtained with SABRINA.

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Resaltar en blau