Badger Trust letter before claim, to Natural England

7/31/2019 Badger Trust letter before claim, to Natural England

1/16


2/16

7

rl`q* yc` pwpk~` kb ycl~ j`yy`w l~ yk nkmpj| qlyc yc` Eilnlhj W`rl`q _w`Hnylkf _wkyknkj& Q` hj~k qhfy yk alr` Fhywhj @fajhfi hf kppkwyfly| ykw`nkf~li`w yc`lw pk~lylkf hfi w`~pkfi lf h qh| ychy `lyc`w mhd`~ yc`pwkpk~ì njhlm ff`n`~~hw|* kw fhwwkq~ qchy l~ lf il~py`* kw hy j`h~ymhd`~ yc`lw pk~lylkf nj`hw`w&

Q` yc~ h~d ychy |k nkfblwm ychy yc` jln`fn`~ awhfyì qljj g` w`rkdì*hjy`wfhylr`j| ychy yc`| qljj g` hm`fiì yk pw`nji` hjj njjlfa* lfnjilfalf phwylnjhw g| bw`` ~ckkylfa&

Q` h~d ychy Fhywhj @fajhfi pw`r`fy hf| ~y`p~ g`lfa yhd`f yk alr` `bb`nyyk hf| njj fi`w yc` jln`fn`~ awhfyì hfi* lf hf| `r`fy* haw`` g| w`ywfyk pk~ypkf` hf| njj qclj~y yc`| nkf~li`w yc` jàhj pk~lylkf hfi w`~pkfiyk ycl~ j`yy`w lf jlf` qlyc yc`lw iyl`~ fi`w yc` pw`-hnylkf pwkyknkj bkweilnlhj w`rl`q& Q` qkji g` awhy`bj bkw |kw ~g~yhfylr` w`pj| g| 0Fkr`mg`w& Ckq`r`w* q` qkji g` awhy`bj yk h w`pj| g| 8?pm ycl~`r`flfa kf yc` mhyy`w~ qclnc mh| f`n`~~lyhy` lfefnylr` w`jl`b ~k ychyyc` nkwy ch~ h bjj plnyw` lb ly l~ f`n`~~hw| yk mhd` hf ky kb ckw~

hppjlnhylkf&

Yc` phwyl`~

Ghia`w Yw~y

Ghia`w Yw~y l~ h nchwly| qclnc pwkmky`~ yc` nkf~`wrhylkf hfi q`jbhw`kb ghia`w~ hfi yc` pwky`nylkf kb yc`lw ~`yy~ hfi chglyhy~ bkw yc` pgjlng`f`bly& Bkw kr`w yclwy| |`hw~* ly ch~ pwkrliì yc` j`hilfa rkln` bkwghia`w~ hfi w`pw`~`fy~ hfi ~ppkwy~ hwkfi 2? jknhj rkjfyhw| ghia`wawkp~ hfi mhf| lfilrlihj m`mg`w~& Ghia`w Yw~y pwkrli`~ `sp`wyhirln` kf hjj ghia`w l~~`~ hfi qkwd~ njk~`j| qlyc akr`wfm`fy* yc`

pkjln` hfi kyc`w nkf~`wrhylkf hfi q`jbhw` kwahfl~hylkf~&Ghia`w Yw~y haw``~ ychy m`h~w`~ f`ì yk g` yhd`f yk wìn` yc`lfnli`fn` kb gYG* lfnjilfa ~nc mlfkw nkfywlgylkf yk ly h~ l~ mhi` g|ghia`w~& ^nc m`h~w`~ pwkp`wj| lfnji` lmpwkr`m`fy~ lf bhwmmhfha`m`fy y`ncflx`~ hfi nkfywkj~ kf yc` ywhf~pkwylfa kb nhyyj` bwkmhw`h yk hw`h #qclnc kyc`wql~` ~pw`hi~ yc` il~`h~` `fylw`j|lfi`p`fi`fyj| kb ghia`w~, hfi yc` rhnnlfhylkf kb ghia`w~ #hfi* ~ckwyj|*nhyyj`, hahlf~y YG7&

Ly l~ hnn`pyì g| I@BWH ychy yc` pwkpk~ì njj qljj fky pw`r`fy gywhyc`w qljj lflylhjj| pwkmpy yc` ~pw`hi kb gYG - hy `fkwmk~* hfi`~nhjhylfa `sp`f~` yk yc` yhs ph|`w hfi bhwm`w~& Lf yc` g`~y nh~`~n`fhwlk* kfj| hby`w < |`hw~ njjlfa* mlacy kf` `sp`ny h 87 yk 82% ~jkq

7Yc`w` l~ fk ikgy ychy rhnnlfhylkf nhf pw`r`fy ghia`w~ bwkm g`nkmlfa lfb`nyì qlyc

YG& Lfi`ì* yc` Akr`wfm`fy ch~ pwkpk~ì ly~ ~` yk pw`r`fy yc` ~pw`hi kb il~`h~` hfimlylahy` p`wywghylkf lf yc` jln`f~ì hw`h~& Bl`ji ywlhj~ kf yc` ~` kb yc` ghia`w YGrhnnlf`~ hw` nww`fyj| g`lfa fi`wyhd`f hy h fmg`w kb jknhylkf~ hwkfi yc` nkfyw|&M`hfqclj` kwhj ghly YG rhnnlf`~ bkw ghia`w~* hfi pky`fylhjj| gYG rhnnlf`~ bkw nhyyj` #hfih~~knlhyì ILRH y`~y~ qclnc nhf il~ylfal~c lfb`nyì bwkm rhnnlfhyì nhyyj`, hw` g`lfai`r`jkpì&


3/16

>

ikqf lf f`q lfnli`fy~ kb gYG lb hjj yc` WGNY nwly`wlh hw` bkjjkqì& Yc~*fk ~laflblnhfy g`f`bly qljj g` fkyì bkw mhf| |`hw~& Lf yc` m`hfylm`* lfhiilylkf yk `sl~ylfa nhyyj`-bkn~~ì pwkr`f hjy`wfhylr`~ yk njjlfa* nhyyj`rhnnlfhylkf~ hw` jld`j| yk g` jln`f~ì hfi nc`hp`w kwhj rhnnlfhylkf~ bkwghia`w~ hrhljhgj` bhw ~kkf`w ychf hf| w`~jy~ bwkm njjlfa qljj g` dfkqf&

Ckq`r`w* fkyqlyc~yhfilfa yc`~` ilbb`w`fn`~ kf yc` pkjln| kb njjlfa* yc`

pwkpk~ì eilnlhj w`rl`q nchjj`fa`~ yc` jàhjly|kb yc` jln`fn`~ awhfyìg| Fhywhj @fajhfi bkw yc` w`h~kf~ ~`y ky g`jkq&

Mw ^y`pc`f Ekf`~

Mw Ekf`~ jlr`~ lf yc` c`hwy kb yc` Ajkn`~y`w~clw` njjlfa ukf` lf yc`Bkw`~y kb I`hf kr`wjkkdlfa yc` Q|` rhjj`|& C` l~ ~wwkfiì g| bhwm~qclnc mh| pky`fylhjj| g` yhdlfa phwy lf yc` njj& Ckq`r`w* c` l~ lf yc`lfrlilk~ hfi rjf`whgj` pk~lylkf kb fky dfkqlfa qclnc jhfi l~ hy wl~d ~kychy c` nhf yhd` ~y`p~ yk hrkli chwm yk clm~`jb* cl~ phwyf`w kw yc`lw ika&

Mw Ekf`~ ch~ g``f h bhwm`w bkw >0 |`hw~& C` ch~ mhfhaì ~km` kb yc`clac`~y |l`jilfa ihlw| c`wi~ lf ycl~ nkfyw| hfi kr`w~`h~& C` ch~ hj~kqkwdì lf gYG cky~pky~ ycwkacky yc` PD& Nww`fyj|* c` j`nyw`~ lfwwhj hfi `frlwkfm`fyhj pkjln| hfi ik`~ bhwm nkf~jyhfn| qkwd& C` chiyk alr` p bhwmlfa y`mpkwhwlj| qc`f cl~ `ji`wj| mkyc`w chi h ~ywkd` hfic` w`ywfì ckm` yk jkkd hby`w c`w&

Gkyc c` hfi cl~ phwyf`w hw` `syw`m`j| nkfn`wfì hgky yc` ~hb`y| wl~d~pk~ì yk yc`m& Mw Ekf`~ ak`~ wfflfa hy ihqf `r`w| ih| lf yc` bkw`~yqc`w` njjlfa mh| g` yhdlfa pjhn`& Yc` nkpj` kby`f ak qhjdlfa qlycyc`lw ika hy flacy hnwk~~ jhfi~ qclnc hw` jld`j| yk g` lf yc` njj ukf`&Yc`| bw`x`fyj| nwk~~ pwlrhy` jhfi yk qclnc yc` wlacy yk wkhm p`wyhlf~&

C` ch~ kg~`wrì ychy yc` pgjln wlacy~ kb qh| kby`f bkjjkq cìa` jlf`~ lfqclnc ghia`w~ hw` mkw` jld`j| yk iq`jj&

C` l~ hj~k nkfn`wfì hgky nkmlfa hnwk~~ h qkfiì ghia`w qclnc mlacyg` rkjhylj`& C` qkji n`wyhlfj| qhfy yk y`fi yk ly gy* hahlf* qkji g`nkfn`wfì hgky yc` wl~d~ yk clm bwkm ~ckky`w~&

Kby`f* yc` nkpj` ak ky qhjdlfa lf yc` ckp`~ kb ~pkyylfa h qlji gkhw&Yc`| ywf kbb yc`lw ykwnc hfi mhlfyhlf ~lj`fn` ~k ychy yc`| qljj fkyil~ywg yc` gkhw~ kw kyc`w qljijlb` ~nc h~ ghia`w~ lf yc` rlnlfly|&Yc`w`bkw`* yc`| qkji g` lfrl~lgj` yk ~ckky`w~* qck qkji g` `xhjj|fjld`j| yk g` hqhw` kb yc`lw pw`~`fn` lf yc` ihwdf`~~& Yc`w`bkw`* yc`|hw` `syw`m`j| nkfn`wfì hgky hnnli`fyhjj| nwk~~lfa lfyk yc` jlf` kbblw`* kw g`lfa lfewì g| h ~ywh| gjj`y& Yc`| nhffky `r`f yhd` nkmbkwy lfdfkqlfa ychy yc`w` l~ h ~hb`y| mhwalf bwkm clacqh|~ hfi wlacy~ kb qh|&C` ik`~ fky nkf~li`w ychy yc` alihfn` yk ~ckky`w~ kbb`w~ mnc nkmbkwy&


4/16

9

Fhywhj @fajhfi

Fhywhj @fajhfi~ pwpk~`~ hw` ~`y ky lf yc` Fhywhj @frlwkfm`fy hfiWwhj Nkmmflyl`~ Hny 7??2 #F@WN,& Ly~ pk~lylkf kf ghia`w njjlfa hfigkrlf` YG l~ ~`y ky lf ly~ yqk ~yhyykw| hirln`~ yk yc` ^`nw`yhw| kb ^yhy`bkw I@BWH lf Ehfhw| hfi Ej| 7?88 hfi ly~ nkf~jyhylkf w`~pkf~`~& Q`chr` fky w`p`hyì ychy lfbkwmhylkf c`w`* hphwy bwkm yc` ~`nylkfhpp`fiì&

Fhywhj @fajhfi ch~ g``f nchwaì qlyc l~~lfa jln`fn`~ yk hppjlnhfy~fi`w ~`nylkf 8?#7,#h, _wky`nylkf kb Ghia`w~ Hny 8&8 Ly l~ haw`ì ychy Fhywhj @fajhfi qljj il~nchwa` yc` qljijlb`mhfha`m`fy bfnylkf~ hnnkwilfa yk yc` bkjjkqlfa pwlfnlpj`~5

>&8&8 Fhywhj @fajhfi qljj nkf~`wr`* `fchfn` hfi mhfha` yc` fhywhj`frlwkfm`fy bkw yc` g`f`bly kb pw`~`fy hfi byw` a`f`whylkf~ yc`w`g|

nkfywlgylfa yk ~~yhlfhgj` i`r`jkpm`fy - ycl~ qljj kby`f f`n`~~lyhy`yc` hnylr` mhfha`m`fy kb gkyc bjkwh hfi bhfh&

>&8&7 H~ Mlfl~y`w~ mhi` nj`hw lf _hwjlhm`fy* Fhywhj @fajhfi l~ pwlmhwlj| hf`frlwkfm`fyhj kwahfl~hylkf gy qljj* lf ly~ lmpj`m`fyhylkf kb pkjlnl`~*`f~w` ychy i`nl~lkf~ hw` yhd`f nkf~l~y`fy qlyc hjj kb ly~ a`f`whjpwpk~`~ fi`w yc` Hny&


5/16

0

>&8&> Fhywhj @fajhfi qljj -

>&8&> h} Nchmplkf yc` nkf~`wrhylkf kb ~p`nl`~ hfi hirl~` kfqljijlb` mhfha`m`fy m`h~w`~ hfi4

>&&8&> g, Nkf~li`w yc` f`ì~ kb p`kpj` #~knlk-`nkfkmln bhnykw~`yn, qclj` ~hbàhwilfa yc` nkf~`wrhylkf ~yhy~ kbpwky`nyì ~p`nl`~ qc`f nhww|lfa ky ly~ ~yhyykw| iyl`~&

>&8&9 Fhywhj @fajhfi qljj il~nchwa` qljijlb` mhfha`m`fy bfnylkf~ gh~ì kfhjj hrhljhgj` `rli`fn` #`frlwkfm`fyhj* `nkfkmln hfi ~knlhj,&

>&8&0 Fhywhj @fajhfi qljj fky l~~` jln`fn`~ qc`w` yc` hrhljhgj` ~nl`fylbln`rli`fn` l~ nkfywhw| yk hncl`rlfa yc` w`xlwì kynkm`~ hfi qkji fkyfkwmhjj| l~~` jln`fn`~ qc`w` yc`w` l~ h ~laflblnhfy hir`w~` lmphny kfyc` kr`whjj nkf~`wrhylkf ~yhy~ kb h ~p`nl`~&

>&8&2 Fhywhj @fajhfi qljj pwkrli` hirln` yk I`bwh yk h~~l~y yc` bkwmjhylkf kb~ywhyàln pkjln|&

>&8&1 Fhywhj @fajhfi qljj h~ hf lfi`p`fi`fy FI_G i`r`jkp ly~ kqf ~ywhyàlnrl`q kf yc` lmpj`m`fyhylkf kb qljijlb` mhfha`m`fy pkjln| hfi qljjhj`wy I`bwh yk hf| pky`fylhj nkfbjlny~ g`yq``f yc` yqk&

^`nylkf 7 F@WN ~mmhwl~`~ Fhywhj @fajhfi~ a`f`whj ~yhyykw| pwpk~`~h~ bkjjkq~5

7#8, Fhywhj @fajhfi!~ a`f`whj pwpk~` l~ yk `f~w` ychy yc` fhywhj`frlwkfm`fy l~ nkf~`wrì* `fchfnì hfi mhfhaì bkw yc` g`f`bly kb pw`~`fyhfi byw` a`f`whylkf~* yc`w`g| nkfywlgylfa yk ~~yhlfhgj` i`r`jkpm`fy&

#7, Fhywhj @fajhfi!~ a`f`whj pwpk~` lfnji`~

#h, pwkmkylfa fhyw` nkf~`wrhylkf hfi pwky`nylfa glkilr`w~ly|*

#g, nkf~`wrlfa hfi `fchfnlfa yc` jhfi~nhp`*

#n, ~`nwlfa yc` pwkrl~lkf hfi lmpwkr`m`fy kb bhnljlyl`~ bkw yc` ~yi|*fi`w~yhfilfa hfi `fek|m`fy kb yc` fhywhj `frlwkfm`fy*

#i, pwkmkylfa hnn`~~ yk yc` nkfyw|~li` hfi kp`f ~phn`~ hfi`fnkwhalfa kp`f-hlw w`nw`hylkf* hfi

#`, nkfywlgylfa lf kyc`w qh|~ yk ~knlhj hfi `nkfkmln q`jj-g`lfaycwkac mhfha`m`fy kb yc` fhywhj `frlwkfm`fy&

#>, Yc` pwpk~` lf ~g~`nylkf #7,#`, mh|* lf phwylnjhw* g` nhwwlì kyg| qkwdlfa qlyc jknhj nkmmflyl`~&

^`nylkf 9?#8, kb F@WN pwkrli`~ ychy5 @r`w| pgjln hyckwly| m~y* lf`s`wnl~lfa ly~ bfnylkf~* chr` wàhwi ~k bhw h~ nkf~l~y`fy qlyc yc` pwkp`w`s`wnl~` kb yck~` bfnylkf~* yk yc` pwpk~` kb nkf~`wrlfa glkilr`w~ly|&


6/16

2

_wkpk~ì Awkfi~ kb Njhlm

Pfjhqbj bhljw` yk nkfiny h ~bblnl`fy nk~y-g`f`bly hfhj|~l~

Yc` ^`nw`yhw| kb ^yhy` bkw I@BWH~ I`n`mg`w 7?88 i`nl~lkf yk kwi`wFhywhj @fajhfi yk awhfy jln`fn`~ yk njj qh~ gh~ì kf h nk~y-lmphnyh~~`~~m`fy> qclnc nkfnjiì ychy yc` nk~y~ kyq`lacì yc` g`f`bly~ ykbhwm`w~ hfi yc` yhsph|`w& Ychy nk~y lmphny h~~`~~m`fy qh~ gh~ì kfh~~mì nk~y~ lf w`jhylkf yk h mlsyw` kb mhlfj| fy`~yì bw``-~ckkylfaqlyc ~km` nha`-ywhpplfa hfi ~ckkylfa* qclnc qh~ bkfi yk g` y`f ylm`~mkw` sp`f~lr`& Kyc`w kpylkf~ q`w` wjì ky g`nh~` yc`| q`w` fkynkf~li`wì hbbkwihgj` lf yc` nww`fy pgjln ~p`filfa njlmhy`&

Ly ch~ fkq `m`waì lf phwjlhm`fy*9 h~ nkfblwmì lf |kw j`yy`w kb 82Knykg`w* ychy yc` nk~y kb njjlfa l~ bhw aw`hy`w ychf hfylnlphyì hfilfi`ì yc` pw`nl~` blaw` ch~ fky g``f `rhjhyì& Pfi`w yc` I@BWHAlihfn` yk Fhywhj @fajhfi bhwm`w~ qljj g` w`xlwì yk i`pk~ly

~bblnl`fy bfi~ yk nkr`w yc` ykyhj nk~y kb h bkw |`hw njj* pj~ hnkfylfa`fn| ~m* hfi ycl~ i`pk~ly m~y g` mhi` g`bkw` njjlfa gàlf~&

^k aw`hy hw` yc` w`hj nk~y~* ychy ly ch~ g``f w`pkwyì ychy yc` FBP hw`nkf~li`wlfa qlyciwhqlfa yc`lw h~~whfn`~ ychy yc`| qkji nkr`w yc` nk~y~kb njjlfa lb bhwm`w~ nkji fky hbbkwi yc`m&

Hahlf~y ycl~ ghndawkfi* ly l~ lfnmg`fy kf Fhywhj @fajhfi yk `f~w`ychy g`bkw` ly p`wmly~ hf| njjlfa yk nkmm`fn` #qclnc m~y yc`fnkfylf` bkw bkw |`hw~ hnnkwilfa yk ly~ ~yhyykw| hirln` yk I@BWHhpp`fiì, ly qljj `f~w` ychy l~ ly l~ gh~ì kf hnnwhy` nk~y-g`f`blylfbkwmhylkf& Ly qkji g` w`ndj`~~ hfi lwwhylkfhj yk pwkn`ì lf yc`

hg~`fn` kb ycl~& Ly qkji hj~k g` lf gw`hnc kb Fhywhj @fajhfi~haw``m`fy nlyì hgkr` ychy yc`| qljj il~nchwa` qljijlb` mhfha`m`fybfnylkf~ gh~ì kf hjj hrhljhgj` `rli`fn` #`frlwkfm`fyhj* `nkfkmln hfi

>cyyp5++hwnclr`&i`bwh&akr&d+bkkibhwm+bhwmhflmhj+il~`h~`~+hyku+yg+iknm`fy~+gkrlf`-yg-lmphny-h~~`~~m`fy&pib Lf nkfnjilfa yc`f ychy yc` nk~y~ kb ycl~Kpylkf 2 m`ycki kb njjlfa kyq`lacì yc` g`f`bly~ I@BWH ~hli5 Yc` pw`b`wwìkpylkf l~ Kpylkf 2 qclnc qkji `fhgj` bhwm`w~+jhfikqf`w~ yk yhd` nkfywkj kbyc` qljijlb` w`~`wrklw kb yc` il~`h~` hy h jknhj j`r`j& H~ ljj~ywhyì lf yc` LH

qclnc hnnkmphflì yc` 7?8? pgjln nkf~jyhylkf* kpylkf 2 ik`~ fky pw`~`fyyc` g`~y f`y pw`~`fy rhj` #F_R, #ycl~ qh~ bkw kpylkf 9* bkw lfi~yw| yknhww| ky kfj| njjlfa, gy ik`~ alr` aw`hy`~y bj`slgljly| bkw bhwm`w~+jhfikqf`w~yk bkwmjhy` yc` mk~y ~lyhgj` jknhj ~kjylkf& Kpylkf~ 7 hfi > hw` fkynkf~li`wì hbbkwihgj` lf yc` nww`fy pgjln ~p`filfa njlmhy`&9Bkw `shmpj`* yc` hiilylkfhj nk~y~ kb 00 I`bwh ~yhbb ~wr`|lfa 00dm hfi 21dm ~xhwìhy 30?*??? 83 Knykg`w 7?87 Chf~hwi5cyyp5++qqq&pgjlnhylkf~&phwjlhm`fy&d+ph+nm7?878>+nmchf~wi+nmhjjblj`~+mp~+nkmmkf~[chf~hwi[9120[qhi&cymj


7/16

1

~knlhj, hfi ly~ F@WN pwpk~`~& Ly qkji hj~k g` qwkfa h~ h mhyy`w kbpgjln jhq bkjjkqlfa Yhm`~li` pwlfnlpj`~&

_j`h~` qkpji |kp nkfblwm ycl~ `r`flfa ychy hf| i`k~ly nkjj`nyì qkpjiw`bj`ny yc` jhwa`w nk~y~* hfi aw`hy`w w`jlhfn` kf nha` ywhlfa hfi~ckkylfa #lb ycl~ kjln| nchfa` ch~ g``f nkfblwmì,& _j`h~` nkfblwm yc`jld`j| nk~y kw nkfblwm ychy h i`yhljì nk~y-lmhny h~~`~~m`fy qljj g`nkfipnyì g`bkw` hf| npjjlfa qljj nkmm`fn`&

Lb nha`-ywhlfa ch~ g``f nck~`f h~ yc` w`b`wwì m`ycki* j`h~`nkfblwm yc` nk~y~ kb yck~` nha`~ hfi yc`lw wkr`fhfn` hfi `sjhlf qckqljj nhww| kpy yc` nha`-ywhlfa g`hwlfa lf mlfi I@BWH~ I`n`mg`w 7?88kjln|* aplihfn` yk Fhypwhj @fajhfi hfi h~~pwhfn`~ yk hwjlhm`fy hgkpyyc` m`yckikjka| hfi jld`j| nk~y~&

_j`h~` nkfblwm qc`yc`w yck~` ip` yk nkfipny nha` ywhlfa chr`w`n`lrì ywhlflfa hfi nkfblwm yc` nk~y kb ychy ywhlflfa&

Q` qkpji w`mlfi |kp kb |kpw ipy| kb nhfikpw hfi ipy| yk h~~l~y yc`nkpwy pfi`w yc` N_W 09 wkyknkj&

Yc` hppwkhnc yk ~`yylfa pp`w hfi jkq`w jlmly~ kf yc` fmg`w~ kbghia`w~ yk g` yhd`f lf yc` njj ukf` l~ lwwhylkfhj

Yc` pkjln| w`xlw`~ njj~ yk w`mkr` hy j`h~y 1?% kb ghia`w~* qlyckynh~lfa jknhj `sylfnylkf& W`mkrlfa ykk b`q ghia`w~ wl~d~ lfnw`h~lfanhyyj` YG* qclj` w`mkrlfa ykk mhf| wl~d~ nkfywhr`flfa yc` G`wfNkfr`fylkf& Pfbkwyfhy`j|* yc` m`ycki ~ì g| Fhywhj @fajhfi yk ~`ynjjlfa yhwa`y~ nhwwl`~ ~`wlk~ wl~d~ kb a`f`whylfa kf` kw kyc`w kb yc`~`fbhrkwhgj` kynkm`~&

G`lfa fknywfhj hfi ~`nw`ylr`* ghia`w~ hw` ilbblnjy yk nkfy hfi `r`fyc` g`~y hrhljhgj` m`ycki~ hw` lmpw`nl~`& Rhwlk~ y|p`~ kb ~yhyl~ylnhjfn`wyhlfy| pwkphahy` ~k ychy ly l~ `syw`m`j| ilbblnjy yk g` nkfbli`fy kbnjjlfa mkw` ychf 1?% kb ghia`w~ qlycky nh~lfa jknhj `sylfnylkf& Lf ycl~nkfy`sy* yc` m`ycki ~ì g| Fhywhj @fajhfi `fyhlj~ ~ls lmpkwyhfy bjhq~&

#h, ^lfn` Fhywhj @fajhfi~ pwlmhw| pwpk~` l~ yk nkf~`wr` @fajhfi~qljijlb`* ly qkji fkwmhjj| g` `sp`nyì yk pwlkwlyl~` yc` hrklihfn` kbjknhj `sylfnylkf kb fhylr` ~p`nl`~ kr`w yc` nkfywkj kb jlr`~yknd il~`h~`#qclnc l~ fky h pwlmhw| bfnylkf kb Fhywhj @fajhfi,& Ckq`r`w* yc`

hppwkhnc yk ~`yylfa njjlfa yhwa`y~ hpp`hw~ yk yhd` yc` kppk~ly`hppwkhnc* pwlkwlyl~lfa njjlfa hy j`h~y 1?% kb ghia`w~ kr`w hrklilfa jknhj`sylfnylkf&

^wr`| `bbkwy ch~ g``f lf~bblnl`fy yk hncl`r` gkyc akhj~ qlyc clacn`wyhlfy|4 c`fn` yc` yqk f`ì yk g` ywhiì kbb hahlf~y kf` hfkyc`w&^wr`|lfa 0? kf` dm ~xhw`~ l~ `sp`nyì yk alr` hf 3?% nkfbli`fn` kbhrklilfa jknhj `sylfnylkf gy kfj| h 20% nkfbli`fn` kb w`mkrlfa hy j`h~y1?% kb ghia`w~& Mkw` pw`nhylkfhw| hppwkhnc`~* qlyc jkq`w `sylfnylkf


8/16

3

wl~d~ mkw` lf-d``plfa qlyc Fhywhj @fajhfi~ ~yhyykw| pwpk~`* hw` fkypw`~`fyì gy qkji hbbkwi ~yljj jkq`w nkfbli`fn` kb w`mkrlfa 1?% kbghia`w~& Qlyc yc` ~hm` h~~mpylkf~* yc` bhrkwì kpylkf kb hncl`rlfa3?% nkfbli`fn` kb w`mkrlfa 1?% kb ghia`w~ qkji nhww| hf fhnn`pyhgj|clac >0% wl~d kb `sn`ìlfa yc` ycw`~ckji bkw jknhj `sylfnylkf& Ycl~hppwkhnc l~ fky nkf~l~y`fy qlyc Fhywhj @fajhfi~ pwpk~`~&

#g, Yc` mlflmm hfi mhslmm fmg`w~ kb ghia`w~ yk g` njjì hw`r`w| ~lmljhw yk kf` hfkyc`w* qlyc h nkf~`x`fy wl~d ychy mhwd~m`f qljjhnnli`fyhjj| `sn`ì yc` mhslmm& Mhlfyhlflfa h w`hj-ylm` yhjj| kb yc`fmg`w~ kb ghia`w~ njjì l~ fjld`j| yk g` pwhnylnhgj` qc`w` mhwd~m`ff`ì yk kp`why` lf w`mky` hw`h~ qlyc kby`f jlmlyì mkglj` pckf`nkr`wha`* lf ~lj`fn` hfi ykyhj ihwdf`~~& Lf yc` qkwdì `shmpj`* yc`mlflmm hfi mhslmm fmg`w~ ilbb`w g| e~y flf` ghia`w~* bhw b`q`wychf mhwd~m`f mlacy `sp`ny yk njj `hnc flacy qlyclf h >?? ~x dm hw`h&

#n, Yc` hppwkhnc hyyhnc`~ ykk clac h nkfbli`fn` j`r`j yk yc` pwke`nyìkynkm`~ kb njjlfa ilbb`w`fy fmg`w~ kb ghia`w~ g`nh~`* qclj` ly

bkwmhjj| hnnkfy~ bkw jhnd kb pw`nl~lkf lf yc` `~ylmhy`~ kb ~`yy i`f~ly|* lyh~~m`~ ychy yc` fmg`w kb ghia`w~ p`w ~`yy l~ m`h~wì qlycky `wwkw&Lf bhny* yc`w` qljj g` fky kfj| m`h~w`m`fy fn`wyhlfy| hwkfi yc``~ylmhy`~ kb ghia`w~ p`w ~`yy* gy hj~k ~g~yhfylhj jknhj rhwlhylkfw`bj`nylfa yc` hrhljhgljly| kb bkki bkw ghia`w~* chglyhy hfi a`kjkalnhjbhnykw~ hbb`nylfa yc` hrhljhgljly| kb ~lyhgj` ~ly`~ yk `snhrhy` ~`yy~* hfiph~y njjlfa& ^nc rhwlhylkf l~ fky yhd`f lfyk hnnkfy lf yc` pwkyknkj&

#i, Yc` fmg`w~ kb ghia`w~ p`w hnylr` ~`yy l~ jld`j| yk g` ~|~y`mhylnhjj|fi`w- kw kr`w-`~ylmhyì* g`nh~` ly l~ gh~ì pkf ihyh bwkm e~y yqk~ly`~ lf Ajkn`~y`w~clw` qclnc hw` fjld`j| yk g` w`pw`~`fyhylr` kb YG-hbb`nyì hw`h~ kb @fajhfi&

#`, Yc` hppwkhnc h~~m`~ ~|~y`mhyln ~wr`|~ nkfinyì g| `sp`wl`fnì~yhbb& Ycl~ nkfywh~y~ qlyc yc` ~yhy`m`fy lf I`bwh~ pkjln| iknm`fy ychy

0&>1& @~ylmhylfa ghia`w pkpjhylkf~ hnnwhy`j| l~ ilbblnjy& Ckq`r`w* q`chr` h jhwa` hmkfy kb lfbkwmhylkf bwkm ph~y bl`jiqkwd #lfnjilfa yc`WGNY* yc` Ghia`w Rhnnlf` ^yi|* ~yil`~ hy Qkkinc`~y`w _hwd* hfipw`rlk~ fhylkfhj ghia`w hfi wkhi ywhbbln hnnli`fy ~wr`|~, ychy nhf g`~ì yk `~ylmhy` ghia`w fmg`w~& Lf hiilylkf* q` chr` nkmml~~lkfì hfhylkfhj ghia`w ~wr`| yk pihy` yc`~` `~ylmhy`~ hfi h i`~d-gh~ì~yi| qclnc ~`~ `sl~ylfa ihyh yk mhd` g`yy`w `~ylmhy`~ kb yc` fmg`wkb hflmhj~ p`w ~knlhj awkp&

0&>3& Fhywhj @fajhfi qljj ~` ycl~ hrhljhgj` lfbkwmhylkf lf nkmglfhylkfqlyc hppjlnhfy~ kqf h~~`~~m`fy kb yc` fmg`w~ kb ~`yy~ pw`~`fy kfyc`lw jhfi yk `~ylmhy` yc` ~lu` kb yc` ghia`w pkpjhylkf qlyclf hjln`fn` hw`h hfi hirl~` hppjlnhfy~ kf yc` mlflmm fmg`w kb hflmhj~yc`| f`ì yk w`mkr` yk wìn` yc` `~ylmhyì ghia`w pkpjhylkf lf yc`hw`h g| hy j`h~y 1?%&

#`mpch~l~ hiiì,


9/16

] >1 @CWW 288,&

Lf ycl~ nkfy`sy yc` bhlw ghjhfn` qljj fky g` ~ywnd lb5

bhlj~ hi`xhy`j| yk yhd` lfyk hnnkfy yc` rl`q~ kb yck~` hbb`nyì4 bhlj~ yk alr` i` q`lacy yk nkmp`ylfa nkf~li`whylkf~4 lfrkjr`~ lfhi`xhy` lfr`~ylahylkf4 yc` i`nl~lkf l~ pwknìwhjj| fbhlw4 kw g`nh~` ly l~ lf gw`hnc kb hf fi`wyhdlfa alr`f ychy l~ ~bblnl`fy

yk alr` wl~` yk h ~g~yhfylr` jàlylmhy` `sp`nyhylkf ychy yc`| qljjg` yw`hyì lf h phwylnjhw qh|&

Lf w`~p`ny kb qchy bkjjkq~ q` qkji hj~k iwhq |kw hyy`fylkf yk Fhywhj@fajhfi~ ~ywlny kgjlahylkf~ fi`w yc` Hhwc~ Nkfr`fylkf kf Hnn`~~ ykLfbkwmhylkf lf @frlwkfm`fyhj Mhyy`w~ hfi yc` _gjln _hwylnlphylkfIlw`nylr` 7??>+>0+@N& Yc` jhyy`w chr` ywhf~phw`fn| hfi pgjlnphwylnlphylkf lf i`nl~lkf-mhdlfa hfi hnn`~~ yk lfbkwmhylkf hy yc`lw nkw`&Yc`~` h~p`ny~ hw` lfyàwhj yk yc` pwknìwhj hfi ~g~yhfylr` Nkfr`fylkfwlacy~ jl~yì&

Lf w`jhylkf yk Fhywhj @fajhfi~ pk~lylr` kgjlahylkf~ q` w`b`w yk ycÀwhfi Nchmg`w~ nkmm`fy~ lf f`w|ljilu R& Ypwd`| #7??0, 98 @&C&W&W&

7?4 T7??9] Lfx`~y Jhq W`pkwy~ 8?3 qclnc ch~ g``f nlyì qlyc hppwkrhjlf h whfa` kb ilbb`w`fy ikm`~yln pk~lylr` kgjlahylkf~ nh~`~5

3


11/16

88

x`~ylkf* phwylnjhwj| qlyc wàhwi yk yc` j`r`j kb yc` pky`fylhj wl~d ykcmhf jlr`~& Yc`| m~y akr`wf yc` jln`f~lfa* ~`yylfa p* kp`whylkf*~`nwly| hfi ~p`wrl~lkf kb yc` hnylrly| hfi m~y mhd` ly nkmpj~kw| bkwhjj yck~` nkfn`wfì yk yhd` pwhnylnhj m`h~w`~ yk `f~w` yc` `bb`nylr`pwky`nylkf kb nlylu`f~ qck~` jlr`~ mlacy g` `fihfa`wì g| yc` lfc`w`fywl~d~&

Hmkfa yc`~` pw`r`fylr` m`h~w`~* phwylnjhw `mpch~l~ ~ckji g` pjhnìkf yc` pgjln~ wlacy yk lfbkwmhylkf* h~ `~yhgjl~cì lf yc` nh~`-jhq kbyc` Nkfr`fylkf lf~ylyylkf~& Yc` Awhfi Nchmg`w haw``~ qlyc yc`Nchmg`w #~`` phwhawhpc 39 kb yc` Nchmg`w eiam`fy, ychy ycl~ wlacy*qclnc ch~ hjw`hi| g``f w`nkafl~ì fi`w Hwylnj` 3 #~`` Ap`wwh hfiKyc`w~* nlyì hgkr`* p& 773* 2?,* mh| hj~k* lf pwlfnlpj`* g` w`jlì kfbkw yc` pwky`nylkf kb yc` wlacy yk jlb`* phwylnjhwj| h~ ycl~ lfy`wpw`yhylkfl~ ~ppkwyì g| nww`fy i`r`jkpm`fy~ lf @wkp`hf ~yhfihwi~ #~``phwhawhpc 27 hgkr`,&

hfi

8?3& Yc` Nkwy qljj f`sy h~~`~~ yc` q`lacy yk g` hyyhncì yk yc` l~~`

kb w`~p`ny bkw yc` pgjln~ wlacy yk lfbkwmhylkf #~`` phwhawhpc


12/16

87

Alr`f ychy yc` I`b`fihfy qljj fky w`r`hj qclnc~p`nlbln hw`h~ hw` clac wl~d* yc`w` l~ h bhljw` yk`s`wnl~` ly~ pkq`w~ yk lmpk~` w`~ywlnylkf~ yk yc`jhfi yk pwky`ny yc` pgjln fi`w ~`nylkf~ 79 hfi 70kb yc` Nkfyw|~li` Wlacy~ kb Qh| Hny 7???&

i& Bhljw` yk lmpk~` h nkfilylkf pw`r`fylfa p`kpj` ~ckkylfaqlyclf 0? b``y kb yc` n`fyw` kb pgjln clacqh|~* hjyckacyk ik ~k l~ kwilfhwlj| h nwlm` fi`w ~`nylkf 8?2 Clacqh|~Hny 8


13/16

8>

nkmp`y`fn` kb yck~` fi`wyhdlfa yc` njj& Ycl~ l~ fky yc` pklfy q` mhi`lf kw j`yy`w& Q` hw` nkfn`wfì hgky yc` wl~d~ yk fkf-phwylnlphylfabhwm`w~ hfi m`mg`w~ kb yc` pgjln qck q`w` fky* hfi ~yljj chr` fkyg``f jhqbjj| nkf~jyì h~ yc`| hw` lf yc` ihwd hgky yc` pw`nl~` njjlfagkfihwl`~ hfi yc` wl~d~ yk yc`lw ~hb`y| hfi yc`lw nhyyj`& Bkw yck~`nkfn`wfì qlyc pgjln ~hb`y|* ly qkji chr` g``f ~`bj yk ~`` ycàlihfn` ~k ychy yc`| nkji h~~`~~ qchy* lb hf|* ~hbàhwi~ qkji g` pylf pjhn`&

Bhljw` yk py lf pjhn` ~|~y`m~ yk m`h~w` jk~~ kw nkmp`f~hy`g~lf`~~`~ lf yc` hw`h bkw jk~~ ilw`nyj| h~~knlhyì qlyc yc` njj

Lf jlacy kb Fhywhj @fajhfi~ pwpk~`~ fi`w ~`nylkf 7 F@WN hfi ly~haw``m`fy yk nkf~li`w yc` f`ì~ kb p`kpj` #~knlk-`nkfkmln bhnykw~ `yn,qclj` ~hbàhwilfa yc` nkf~`wrhylkf ~yhy~ kb pwky`nyì ~p`nl`~ qc`f nhww|lfaky ly~ ~yhyykw| iyl`~* yc`w` ch~ g``f hf fe~y* lwwhylkfhj bhljw` ykyhd` hf| ~y`p~ `lyc`w yk m`h~w` hfi yk nkmp`f~hy` bkw jk~~ kb lfnkm`yk ykwl~m hfi kyc`w g~lf`~~`~ lf yc` jln`f~ì hw`h~ qck mh| g`

hir`w~`j| hbb`nyì g| yc` njj* `lyc`w ilw`nyj| ycwkac jk~~ kb w`r`f` lfyc` hw`h kw ycwkac ~p`wmhwd`y gk|nkyy~&

Bhljw` yk nkfiny h jhqbj `frlwkfm`fyhj ~nw``flfa `s`wnl~` kwlmphny h~~`~~m`fy lf ^km`w~`y kw Ajkn`~y`w~clw`

Lf hiilylkf yk ly~ ~yhyykw| bfnylkf~ ~`y ky hgkr`* Fhywhj @fajhfi ch~g``f alr`f h ~p`nlbln hirl~kw| wkj` fi`w ~`nylkf 87< yc` Nkf~`wrhylkf kbChglyhy~ hfi ^p`nl`~ Wàjhylkf~ 7?8?& Ly mh| pwkrli` hirln` hfih~~l~yhfn`* kw mhd` w`pw`~`fyhylkf~* yk hf| nkmp`y`fy hyckwly| kf hf|mhyy`w qclnc w`jhy`~ yk @fajhfi hfi l~ nkff`nyì qlyc yc` il~nchwa` kbyc` nkmp`y`fy hyckwly|!~ bfnylkf~ fi`w yc`~` Wàjhylkf~&

Lf |kw w`pj| kb 82 Knykg`w* lf nkfblwmlfa ychy fk ~nw``flfa `s`wnl~` kw`frlwkfm`fyhj lmphny h~~`~~m`fy chi g``f ikf` lf `lyc`w hw`h* |k ~hliychy yc` ghia`w njj nkji fky g` nkf~li`wì h pwke`ny& Ckq`r`w* ly l~fikgyìj| h pjhf* hfi `r`f hnnkwilfa yk I@BWH~ kqf nkf~jyhylkf0hf h~~`~~m`fy m~y g` nhwwlì ky g`bkw` awhfylfa h jln`fn` qclnc mlacychr` h ~laflblnhfy `bb`ny kf h @wkp`hf pwky`nyì ~ly`&&

Ckq`r`w* `r`f lb ycl~ q`w` fky ~k* h~ h mhyy`w kb pgjln jhq* ly l~lmpk~~lgj` bkw Fhywhj @fajhfi yk dfkq qc`yc`w qli`~pw`hi njjlfaycwkac hf fy`~yì mlsyw` kb bw``-~ckkylfa hfi nha`-ywhpplfa hfi~ckkylfa qljj chr` ~nc hf lmphny kf `bb`nyì ~ly`~ qlycky iklfa hfh~~`~~m`fy kf yc` pwkpk~hj~ nmjhylr`j|* h~ q`jj h~ lfilrlihjj| lfw`jhylkf yk jln`fn` hppjlnhylkf~2&

0_hwhawhpc 8>* Hff`s H cyyp5++qqq&i`bwh&akr&d+nkf~jy+7?88+?1+8&2 ^`` Nh~` N-897+?1 @nkjkal~yh~ `f Hnnlkf-NKIH r H|pfyhml`fyk i` Mhiwli #70 Ej|7??


14/16

89

Ly l~ h bfihm`fyhj pwlfnlpj` kb pgjln jhq ychy h i`nl~lkf mh| g`fjhqbj lb h pgjln gki| bhljì yk ahyc`w ~bblnl`fy lfbkwmhylkf kf hf|hir`w~` lmphny hfi+kw bhljì yk pwkp`wj| fi`w~yhfi ly& Yc`w` nhf g` fkjhqbj `s`wnl~` kb il~nw`ylkf yk pwkn`ì qlyc h pkjln| lb yc` i`nl~lkfmhd`w ik`~ fky pwkp`wj| fi`w~yhfi yc` pwkgj`m* ly~ iàw`` hfi`sy`fy1& H bhljw` yk ahyc`w hi`xhy` lfbkwmhylkf yk ychy `fi qljjgw`hnc yc` iy| yk `f~w` ychy nkfnj~lkf~ kb bhny hw` ~ppkwyì g|hi`xhy` mhy`wlhj kb pwkghylr` rhj`3& Bwyc`wmkw`* h bhljw` ykfi`w~yhfi yc` lfbkwmhylkf ychy ch~ g``f ahyc`wì qljj g` hf `wwkw kbbfihm`fyhj bhny] hfi T99]&3 ^`nw`yhw| kb ^yhy` r Yhm`~li` MGN T8


15/16

80

Nkfnjilfa w`mhwd~

Kw njl`fy~ chr` `mghwdì kf ycl~ nkw~` kb hnylkf qlyc aw`hyw`jnyhfn`& Ckq`r`w* yc`| w`mhlf nkmmlyyì yk blfilfa hf hnn`pyhgj`hjy`wfhylr`* hfi nkfblwm yc`lw qljjlfaf`~~ yk `fy`w lfyk mìlhylkf bkw ycl~pwpk~` pwkrliì ychy fk bwyc`w ~y`p~ hw` yhd`f fylj q` chr` chi h~hyl~bhnykw| w`~pkf~` yk ycl~ j`yy`w hfi yc` i`ghy` lf phwjlhm`fy ch~yhd`f pjhn`&

^ckji |k chr` hf| x`wl`~ pj`h~` nkfyhny Aq`fikj`f Mkwahf*h~~knlhy` qlyc nkfiny kb yc` nh~` lf yc` _gjln Jhq hfi Cmhf Wlacy~i`phwym`fy kf ?7? 13>> 99>>& Q` jkkd bkwqhwi yk c`hwlfa bwkm |k g| 0Fkr`mg`w #hfi g| w`ywf kf yc` wa`fy mhyy`w~ clacjlacyì hgkr`,&

\kw~ bhlycbjj|

Glfimhf~ JJ_


16/16

82

Lf yc`lw ~yhyykw|8? hirln` yk I@BWH lf Ehfhw| 7?88* Fhywhj @fajhfi~yhyì h~ bkjjkq~& Lf jlacy kb ycl~* ly l~ lmpk~~lgj` bkw yc` I`b`fihfy yknkfylf` yc` jln`f~lfa pwkn`~~ fylj yc` l~~`~ lf ycl~ j`yy`w chr` g``f~hyl~bhnykwlj| w`~kjrì&

Yk i`jlr`w h f`y g`f`bly njjlfa f`ì~ yk g` nhwwlì ky hy h ~bblnl`fy lfy`f~ly|#l&`& w`mkrlfa 6 1?% ghia`w~ bwkm 6 1?% kb yc` hw`h, bkw hy j`h~y bkw |`hw~&

Ycl~ l~ h mhekw fi`wyhdlfa bkw h awkp kb lfilrlihj bhwm`w~ hfi jhfikqf`w~ yknkkwilfhy` hfi i`jlr`w& Pfjld` kyc`w hw`h~ kb jln`f~lfa* bhljw` yk i`jlr`w yc`jln`f~ì hnylkf bjj| hfi `bb`nylr`j| nkji mhd` yc` il~`h~` ~lyhylkf yc`jln`fn` qh~ l~~ì yk w`~kjr` ~laflblnhfyj| qkw~`4 qkw~` fky e~y bkw yc`phwylnlphfy~* gy pky`fylhjj| bkw yc`lw f`lacgkw~& Yc` `rli`fn` bkw ycl~ l~pwkrliì g| yc` WGNY& Bkw `shmpj`* yc` i`ywlm`fyhj `bb`ny~ kb njjlfa kfil~`h~` lfnli`fn` ikmlfhy` lflylhjj|* hfi ly l~ kfj| hby`w yc` bkwyc hffhj njjyc` fmg`w kb gw`hdikqf~ pw`r`fyì `sn`ìì yc` fmg`w lfinì g| njjlfa&Bhljw` yk ~~yhlf njjlfa bkw yc` bjj iwhylkf kb yc` jln`fn` nkji*yc`w`bkw`* j`hi yk h f`y fàhylr` `bb`ny kf il~`h~` lfnli`fn`&

Wl~d~ yk `bb`nylr` nkkwilfhylkf hfi i`jlr`w| lfnji`5

l& Nchfa`~ yk jhfi kqf`w~clp kb jhfi-~`&ll& Qlyciwhqhj kb ~ppkwy& Hppjlnhylkf~ hw` jld`j| yk w`j| lf phwy kf

hnn`~~ yk jhfi g`jkfalfa yk p`kpj` qlycky jlr`~yknd& Yc` ~ppkwy kbycl~ awkp kb p`kpj` mh| g` phwylnjhwj| ~`f~lylr` yk kppk~lylkf bwkmkyc`w~ yk njjlfa&

lll& Qlyciwhqhj kb phwylnlphylkf5 h yhlj-kbb lf nkmmlym`fy kbphwylnlphfy~ mh| knnw bkw rhwlk~ w`h~kf~* lfnjilfa yc` clacnk~y~ kb nkfywkj #phwylnjhwj| lb ~ckkylfa pwkr`~ j`~~ `bb`nylr` ychf`frl~haì,* yc` pwhnylnhj ilbblnjyl`~ kb dljjlfa ghia`w~ hy yc`lfy`f~ly| w`xlwì* kw h~ h w`hnylkf yk jknhj kppk~lylkf yk njjlfa&

lr& Bw``-~ckkylfa pwkr`~ lf`bb`nylr`& Njjlfa g| bw``-~ckkylfa l~`~ylmhyì yk g` hgky 8?-bkji j`~~ nk~yj| ychf g| nha`-ywhpplfa hfi~ckkylfa& Yc` m`ycki l~ fpwkr`f hfi ~ckji ly pwkr` j`~~ `bb`nylr`ychf hfylnlphyì yc`f hf lfnw`h~ì w`jlhfn` kf nha` ywhpplfa qljjlfnw`h~ì nk~y~ kb nkfywkj qclnc nkji* lf ywf* lmphny kf yc``bb`nylr`f`~~ kb yc` njj hfi kf phwylnlphfy nkmmlym`fy&

T&]

l& Lf yc` hg~`fn` kb hnnwhy` gh~`jlf` pkpjhylkf ihyh kf ghia`wpkpjhylkf~ lf `hnc hw`h ly qljj g` r`w| ilbblnjy yk eia` yc``bb`nylr`f`~~ kb njjlfa #kw ~`y hnnwhy` yhwa`y~, qclnc qljj mhd` ly

ilbblnjy yk i`nli` qc`f ly l~ hppwkpwlhy` #hfi bhlw, yk lfy`wr`f`&

8? Fhywhj @fajhfi~ hirln` l~ pwkrliì yk yc` ^`nw`yhw| kb ^yhy` bkw I@BWHfi`w ~`nylkf 8?#2, _wky`nylkf kb Ghia`w~ Hny 8

Documents

Badger Trust letter before claim, to Natural England