Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    1/55

     

    Asbestos ManagementPlan and Register for17 - 31 Dover Street,

    Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    AAQ Pty. Ltd. T/A

    Asbestos AuditsQueensland P.O. Box 3657Loganholme

    Queensland 4129A.C.N. 097 570 879Ph. /Fax: (07) 5549 2250www.asbestos-audits.com.au

    A s b e s t o sA u d i t s

    Q u e e n s l a n d

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    2/55

     

    2  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    Our Reference 011JN01

    17 February 2011

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.C/- PO Box 46

    Runaway BayQld. 4216Attn: Mr. David Mattner;

    Dear David;

    Asbestos Management Plan and Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    We are pleased to be able to supply you with the Updated Asbestos Management Plan and

    Register of our inspection of 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    The report includes a set of recommendations for the identified asbestos. Your attention is

    drawn, in particular, to these detailed in Chapter 4 of the report.

    We would be pleased to discuss any aspect of this with you so do not hesitate to contact us

    should you require any further information, or assistance with the implementation of the

    recommendations.

    Yours faithfully

    Brian SketcherBRIAN SKETCHER 

    Manager

    Asbestos Audits Queensland.

    AAQ Pty. Ltd. T/A

    ASBESTOS AUDITS

    QUEENSLAND

    P.O. BOX 3657

    LOGANHOLME

    QLD. 4129 

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    3/55

     

    3  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    Contents 

    Page Number 

    1. 

    Introduction and Scope 5 

    2. 

    Management Plan 8 

    2.1  Management Plan Including Control Measures 8 

    2.2  Policy Development Regarding Asbestos Containing Materials 9 

    2.3  Signage & Labelling 10 

    2.4 

    Register Maintenance Log 11 

    3. 

    Limitations 12 

    4. 

    Asbestos Register (Including Recommendations) 14 

    4.1  Asbestos Containing Materials For the Vacant Tenancy 17 Dover Street. 14 

    4.1.1  Centre Corridor: Electrical meter backing board 14 

    4.1.2  External: Eaves lining 14 

    4.1.3 

    External: Drain surrounds 15 

    4.1.4  Amenities Area: Showers, Toilets & Lunchroom: Tiled ceiling linings 15 

    4.1.5  Warehouse Main Corridor: Wall linings 15 

    4.1.6  Airconditioning Plant Rooms: Wall lining 16 

    4.1.7  Warehouse: Medium and Large Store Rooms: Wall lining 16 

    4.1.8  Warehouse: Small storeroom and foyer alcove to airconditioning rooms:

    Walls & ceiling linings 17 

    4.1.9  Warehouse: Internal Original Main Dividing Walls: Wall lining 17

    4.2  Asbestos Containing Materials For the Pfizer Tenancy 31 Dover Street. 18 

    4.2.1 

    External: Eaves lining 18 4.2.2  External: Drain surrounds 18 

    4.2.3  Skylights: Wall linings 18 

    4.2.4  Marketing Office & Box Cupboard: Ceiling lining 19 

    4.2.5  Lab: Mezzanine Archive Room: Walls & ceiling linings 19

    4.3  Asbestos Containing Materials (Presumed) 20 

    4.3.1  Fuse Boards: Fuse linings 20 

    4.3.2  Gaskets, Seals and Sealing Compounds 20

    4.4 

    Non Asbestos Containing Materials 21 

    5. 

    Risk Assessment Findings & Conclusions 23 

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    4/55

     

    4  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    5.1  Asbestos Risk Assessment 23 

    5.2  Summary of Register 24 

    5.3  Risk Assessment Findings 24 

    5.4 

    Removal 25 

    6.  Legislative Requirements 26 

    Appendices Appendix A Sample Locations and Sample Analysis Report 

    Appendix B Photographs 

    Appendix C Plans and Drawings

    Appendix D Limitations of an Asbestos Inspection 

    Appendix E Principles of an Asbestos Management Plan 

    Appendix F Health Risks Related to Asbestos Appendix G Glossary of Terms 

    Appendix H Register Maintenance Log 

    Appendix I Annual Review Updates 

    Appendix J References

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    5/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    5  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    1. Introduction and ScopeAsbestos Audits Queensland was engaged by J & D Contracting on behalf of

    Janalan Pty. Ltd. to conduct an audit of the property at 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    and to produce an Asbestos Management Plan and Register.

    The purpose of the audit was to locate, sample, analyse, and compile a register of

    asbestos containing materials as required by Part 13 of the Workplace Health and

    Safety Regulations 2008 and to compile an Asbestos Management Plan as set

    down in Safe Work Australia's Code of Practice for the Management and Control of

    Asbestos in Workplaces  [NOHSC: 2018 (2005)] and also the requirements laid

    down under the relevant Queensland Legislation.

    The section of the building known as 17 Dover Street was originally inspected on 6th 

    April 2005 to ascertain the nature of materials used during construction and those

    that may have subsequently been incorporated into the building. This was carried

    out under the old Queensland legislation and regulation framework.

    Under Queensland legislation these requirements apply only to those buildings thatwere given building construction approval before 1990. This is based on most

    general building products (fibre cement sheet, pipe etc) were no longer

    manufactured with asbestos after 1990.

    A total ban on the importation of asbestos however was not put in place until 2003

    therefore between 1990 and 2003 buildings could still be constructed with

    machinery containing imported asbestos components such as gaskets or seals on

    electric motors for example. To cover this area we use the presumption criteria from

    the Code of Practice“if there are inaccessible areas that are likely to contain asbestos containing

    materials the person in control should presume that there is asbestos in

    these areas.”

    We base our use of presumptive criteria on our experience of areas we have seen

    to contain asbestos on other sites given the age and design of the building along

    with what else has may have been found in the building and "areas that are likely  to

    contain asbestos".

    This re-inspection took place on 15th February 2011 as part of the asbestos

    management plan for the building and to upgrade this inspection report according to

    the codes of practice. The re- inspection involved a visual inspection of the

    previously documented asbestos material identified in the Asbestos Materials

    Report and Register to ascertain the following-

    •  If the recommendations for the management of the materials has been carried outand what still remains to be done if anything.

    •  If any deterioration of asbestos material has occurred in the previous year or sincethis was previously carried out.

    •  If the information in the register is still current (i.e. have any removals beenundertaken).

    •  Updating the register information to include what were formerly known as asbestoscontaining products if this was not included in the previous register.

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    6/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    6  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    •  Including presumed asbestos containing materials as per the Code of Practice -presumption criteria.

    •  Including where possible asbestos containing materials which may be in use by thetenants in the occupational environment.

    The risk assessment was carried out concurrently with this inspection to ascertain

    regular working hour practices around and near the building or essential plant

    asbestos containing materials.

    Explanation of the Process:

    This report represents the culmination of a process including the following-

    i. Gathering of information - plans, brief history, age, style and construction of

    building.

    ii. Inspection - onsite inspection of all available safely accessible  areas andrecording of information. Assessment and recording of condition and risk

    associated with asbestos containing material areas. Unless otherwise

    mentioned this inspection is confined to the building and essential plant

    equipment. Inspection is not carried out upon underground services or tenants

    machinery or stores also unless otherwise mentioned.

    iii. Material Analysis - samples were taken for analysis during this inspection

    and sent to a NATA (National Association of Testing Authorities) laboratory.

    Tests to determine the presence of asbestos in the samples were carried out

    by this laboratory in accordance with NATA Procedures

    iv. Collation and Register Creation - The results of 1, 2 and 3 were used to

    create the asbestos register. Where the inspector judged materials to be of

    the same or very similar composition, subsequent occurrences of that material

    were noted as “similar to” the analysed sample and assessed as having the

    same or similar asbestos content. Also as per the Federal Codes of Practice

    presumption criteria were applied to areas commonly known to contain

    asbestos but for some reason (safety or accessibility) could not be confirmed

    by sampling.

    v. Risk Assessment – Combining the four points above and analysing the

    potential risk for occupants and maintenance or repair staff of any asbestos

    containing materials located.

    vi. Management Plan & Summary - This report contains a Management Plan,

    which discusses the ongoing management, control and removal of any

    asbestos containing material found and summarises the findings from the

    register.

    The Federal Code of Practice requires a what, when, who & how approach. The

    what is what is going to be done. The who  is to be responsible for maintaining the

    register and overseeing the implementation of the plan and being responsible for

    this. The when  is a time frame for implementing these recommendations. The how  

    is how is the person in control going to comply.

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    7/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    7  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    For a small site or building such as this we have made the presumption that

    the person named at the front of the report and/or the business or company

    that has engaged our services to carry out this work will be the person or

    body responsible in these matters.  That is- they are the “person in control”

    of the site or building. Further that the recommendations will be carried out inthe plan within 12 months and be monitored in an ongoing manner at the time

    of the annual re-inspection (the what & the when). Review of this plan will

    only be carried out by appropriately qualified companies or personnel and

    additions, rewrites and modifications made to this plan as required during the

    useful life of the building(the how).

    No one section or part of a section, of this report should be taken as giving an

    overall idea of this report. Each section must be read in conjunction with the whole

    of this report, including its appendices and attachments. A Glossary of Terms used

    in this report is included in the Appendices.

    Included in this report are Recommendations. It should be noted that these

    actions are recommended only and that implementation is the responsibility

    of the person in control/building owner/manager. 

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    8/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    8  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    2. Management Plan

    2.1 Management Plan Including Control Measures

    “The ultimate goal is for all workplaces to be free of asbestos containing

    material.” - Code of Practice for the Management & Control of Asbestos 2005

    We would recommend for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion that the following steps be

    taken to manage the asbestos containing materials found –

    1) 17 Dover Street: Remove, cleanup or repair the damaged asbestos

    cement sheet in the vacant warehouse area.

    2) 17 Dover Street: Paint or seal the unpainted asbestos cement sheeting

    in the areas around the main airconditioning room.

    3) The remaining asbestos containing materials located at 17 - 31 Dover

    Street, Albion are currently found to be of a low potential risk to the building

    occupants. For the following reasons –

    •  The materials are not likely to be disturbed in day to day activities.

    •  They are all in good condition and the asbestos is in a sealed and

    well bonded form.

    •  It is unlikely to deteriorate due to weather because of itslocation/bonded condition.

    If there is a concern about exposure to asbestos containing materials due to

    unexpected or unplanned emergencies or during maintenance tasks then

    reassessment may be required.

    4) Label those items as asbestos containing as per the recommendations in

    the register section and install signs notifying anyone entering the premises

    of the existence of an Asbestos Register.

    5) As part of the site induction process all new staff or site visitors should beshown and explained the purpose of the asbestos register and made aware

    of the presence of asbestos on this site. As well as their responsibilities

    should any work being carried out impact upon the asbestos containing

    materials found or any unexpected asbestos containing material be

    encountered. Awareness training may be required for those workers or

    subcontractors prior to commencement of work on this site or to carry out

    maintenance activities.

    6) The person or persons “in control” and responsible for implementing these

    recommendations and this Management Plan are the tenants along with

    Janalan Pty. Ltd. They are responsible for decisions on Management

    Options for the medium and long term as well as those listed in this

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    9/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    9  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    Management Plan. This is applicable until the building changes ownership or

    management or until the next yearly re-audit.

    Keeping in mind the definition of "person in control" which may create

    situations where the "person in control" may change temporarily. Forexample a Tenant or Real Estate Agent may carry out works in or on the

    building such as part of maintenance or minor renovation/repairs as part of

    their respective duties in which case they also become the person in control.

    7) Safe work methods as per the Codes of Practice shall be used at all times

    when handling, working with or removing asbestos on this site. Monitoring

    shall be carried out if required under the Code of Practice or if significant

    concern is raised by staff or workers for it to be prudent to do so.

    8) Review the Management Plan and Register at least annually   to assess

    the currency of the plan and record any changes to asbestos containingmaterial. This is a requirement of the Code of Practice and Must   be

    followed.

    Control Methods

    9) Therefore removal followed by ongoing management and control of any

    maintenance activities are the required control methods.

    2.2 Policy Development Regarding Asbestos Containing

    Materials

    Policy Development

    We would recommend that that the tenants and Janalan Pty. Ltd. develop specific

    policies and document them in their WH & S Plans and Quality Systems on different

    aspects of asbestos management. We would suggest the following topics be

    included-

      Inclusion of this Asbestos Management Plan in the onsite induction process.

      Asbestos containing materials in electrical systems.

      Asbestos containing material management: Comprising care, maintenance,

    repairs & clean up of damaged areas.

      Responsibility of contractors or sub contractors regarding asbestos.

      Reference to this Asbestos Management Plan and Register.

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    10/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    10  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    2.3 Signage & Labelling

    In accordance with section 9.5 of the Code of Practice for the Management and

    Control of Asbestos in Workplaces   [NOHSC: 2018 (2005)] signs warning of

    asbestos “should be placed at all of the main entrances to the work areas whereasbestos is present”.

    Therefore in this building we would recommend installation of this sign at the main

    entrances to both tenancies and the main driveway at the south end of the building.

    So as long as the sign conforms to Australian Standard 1319 Safety Signs for the

    Occupational Environment the exact wording has been left open. The sign conforms

    to Australian Standard 1319 Safety Signs for the Occupational Environment see

    below.

    Example;

    Caution/ Warning

    An Asbestos Containing Material Report & Register exists for this building

    Consult Asbestos Register prior to commencing work.

    Also as part of measures to control exposure to asbestos safety labelling should

    warn people of the locations of the asbestos containing material.

    Queensland Government Department of Employment & Industrial Relations

    Asbestos Fact Sheets 1 & 4 provide further guidance on labelling and signage

    minimum requirements.

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    11/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    11  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    2.4 Register Maintenance Log

    Persons with control of workplaces must keep an accurate register on the premises

    along with details of any maintenance or service work on the ACM present

    including-

    i. “The company who is performing or performed the work

    ii. The Date/s the maintenance or service work was undertaken

    iii. The scope of work

    iv. Any clearance certificates”

    It is a requirement that the person with control should ensure workers are informed

    about the register of ACM. The register should be made readily available to -

    v. “Workers and their representatives

    vi. Any other employers within the premises

    vii. Any person removing ACM

    viii. Any person engaged to perform work that may disturb ACM, including

    presumed ACM

    ix. Any other person who might be exposed”

    Therefore to assist in recording any maintenance or service work on asbestos

    containing material, an Asbestos Maintenance Log is included in this document and

    may be used by the person required to maintain this register to record any

    maintenance or service work on asbestos containing material on this site.

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    12/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    12  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    3. Limitations

    As outlined in the Appendices there are limitations to any building inspection forasbestos. In many instances, asbestos may be present in inaccessible areas such

    as:

      Wall cavities;

      Beneath floors;

      Slab construction;

      Areas of landfill on the site.

      Integral parts of boilers, pumps, compressors, machinery, plant and pipe work;

      Reheat units within air conditioning ducts; and

      Fire doors.

    Confirmation of the existence of lagged pipe work in wall cavities and that which

    may be “chased” into walls is not possible with a visual inspection in a non-

    destructive survey. Should any demolition or upgrading work be undertaken, then it

    is possible that asbestos containing materials may be found in these areas. Pipe

    ‘’chasing’’ was common in older buildings to limit heat loss from hot water pipework.

    Unless otherwise mentioned the inspection is limited to the building and “essential

    plant” included in the building and does not cover tenants or occupier’s equipment,

    machinery, stock or spare parts. (Refer to the Glossary).

    With respect to the audit of 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion no demolition or

    dismantling of any of the above was undertaken. Unless otherwise mentioned, high

    voltage switchboards which were “live” at the time of the inspection were not

    accessed. This applies particularly to large mains cabinets and connection boxes

    which have a safety cut out switch which activates when access panels are opened.

    This means that samples may not have been taken of phenol based co-polymer

    products or resin based boards within these electrical areas or any fuse linings

    inside ceramic fuse holders.

    Electrical switches and switchboxes unless otherwise mentioned were also not

    dismantled or opened for inspection for safety reasons. ENERGEX substations

    were not inspected.

    Fire door cores were accessed along the top edge of the door. If the door was fully

    enclosed or the edges beaded, access was obtained where possible. However no

    locks or door mechanisms were disassembled.

    Unless otherwise mentioned, inspections were not undertaken beneath carpets for

    the presence of other floor covering.

    The following locations were not visually inspected:

      Roof or ceiling space inspection access was limited to those areas that could

    be accessed using standard ladders.  The rooftop was not accessed nor was the Energex Substation.

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    13/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    13  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

      The access door into the roof space in the Pfizer tenancy near the marketing

    office was not accessed due to the location of furniture beneath it.

      There was limited access into the ceiling space in the vacant office area in 17

    Dover Street due to the fixed acoustic tile plaster ceiling.

      Above the acoustic plaster and used throughout the rest of the building is a

    fixed ’stramit’ upper ceiling and above this could only be examined above part

    of the Pfizer Tenancy via the mezzanine Archive Room.

      Heaterbanks internal duct lining samples were obtained with the assistance of

    Hastie Services the airconditioner contractor for the site.

    Fire dampers and electrical heater banks in the ducts could not be located for

    inspection.

    Amounts, measurements and quantities mentioned in this report are approximate

    only. Materials that may contain asbestos but are not considered a significantexposure risk include paints, mastic, sealants, adhesives and similar materials.

    Unless otherwise mentioned these may not have been sampled or included or may

    be listed under the presumption criteria.

    Only areas to which safe and reasonable access is available were inspected. The

    Australian Standard AS 4349.0 - 2007 summarises thus "The inspector shall not

    enter or inspect areas where safe and reasonable access is not available. The

    extent of accessible areas, as defined by the presence of safe and reasonable

    access, shall be determined by the inspector, based on the conditions encountered

    at the time of inspection" and notes "Reasonable access does not include removing

    screws and bolts or any other fastenings or sealants to access covers.”

    Reasonable access does not include the use of destructive or invasive inspection

    methods. Nor does reasonable access include cutting or making access traps, or

    moving furniture or stored goods. This site has undergone renovations in its lifetime

    and different types of fibre cement sheet and products have been used.

    Representative samples for these products have been taken, however without

    sampling each individual sheet or area the results of the testing can only give an

    indication of the asbestos content. If unsure if a certain product contains asbestos it

    is always better to assume it does and handle it accordingly. (Refer to the

    Appendices)

    AAQ Pty. Ltd. warrant to conduct their work with the degree of skill, care anddiligence normally exercised by consultants in similar circumstances, but there is no

    guarantee, expressed or implied,  that all asbestos has been identified in this

    report/register (refer to Limitations of an Asbestos Audit or Inspection in the

    Appendices). AAQ Pty. Ltd. building inspectors carry out inspections according to

    the guidelines set out in internal document AAQ29 Workplace Health & Safety.

    This report has been prepared for the use of the client, and is not to be relied upon

    by any third party without prior consultation with AAQ Pty. Ltd for a purpose other

    than that for which it was created. (For example tendering, costing, programming

    of works, refurbishment or demolition.)

    This report should be read in conjunction with existing reports and documentation ofasbestos materials for this building. If copies are required, all relevant parts of this

    report must be reproduced in full. 

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    14/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    14  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    4. Asbestos Register (Including Recommendations) 

    All works/actions recommendations should be carried out in accordance with theCode of Practice for the Safe Removal of Asbestos  and the Code of Practice for the

    Management and Control of Asbestos in Workplaces   (See the Appendices for

    References).

    Materials or products reported as “similar to sample” are based on a visual

    inspection and comparison to a sample taken for analysis. The “Action Taken”

    sections are provided for building owner/manager to note any works carried out

    which may alter the status or condition of the products or materials listed, eg

    “sheeting removed May 2011”, “Lagging removed from boiler Feb 2012”.

    4.1 Asbestos Containing Materials For the VacantTenancy 17 Dover Street.

    4.1.1 Centre Corridor: Electrical meter backing board

    The main meter backing board contains asbestos. This material is used asthermal insulation to the electrical connections. This material is unpaintedand in good condition and is non friable and there is approximately 1.5m

    2.

    Sample number DO - 13. Refer to image 1.

    Recommendation:Avoid damage and abrasion. Remove if dismantling, structural alterations,electrical or communications upgrade or demolition is to be carried out in thisarea. Reassess at least annually. Label appropriately as per StateGovernment guidelines and the Code of Practice.Action Taken:

    4.1.2 External: Eaves lining

    The external eaves along the street frontage and to the curved arch loadingdock are lined in asbestos cement sheeting. This material is painted and ingood condition. It is non friable and there is approximately 120 m

    2. Similar to

    sample number DO - 02. Refer to image 2.

    Recommendation:Avoid damage and abrasion. Remove if dismantling, structural alterations ordemolition is to be carried out in this area. Reassess at least annually. Labelappropriately as per State Government guidelines and the Code of Practice.

    Action Taken:

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    15/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    15  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    4.1.3 External: Drain surrounds

    The drain surrounds around the outside of the building are asbestos cementsheet. This material is unpainted and in good condition and is non friable and

    there is approximately 2m2

    . Sample number DO - 02. Refer to image 3.

    Recommendation:Avoid damage and abrasion. Remove if dismantling, structural alterations ordemolition is to be carried out in this area. Reassess at least annually. Labelappropriately as per State Government guidelines and the Code of Practice.Action Taken:

    4.1.4 Amenities Area: Showers, Toilets & Lunchroom: Tiled ceilinglinings

    The ceilings throughout the staff amenities area is lined in asbestos cementsheet tiles. This material is painted and in good condition and is non friableand there is approximately 150m

    2. Sample number DO – 10.

     Refer to image

    4.

    Recommendation:Avoid damage and abrasion. Remove if dismantling, structural alterations ordemolition is to be carried out in this area. Reassess at least annually. Label

    appropriately as per State Government guidelines and the Code of Practice.Action Taken:

    4.1.5 Warehouse Main Corridor: Wall linings

    The walls of the main corridor and the infill panels to a former doorway andthe panels above the door at the end of the corridor are lined in asbestoscement sheeting. This material is painted and in generally good condition

    with some minor damage. It is non friable and there is approximately 60m

    2

    .

     

    Sample number DO – 12. Refer to image 5.

    Recommendation:Avoid further damage and abrasion. Repair, replace or removedamaged panels. Remove if dismantling, structural alterations or demolitionis to be carried out in this area. Reassess at least annually. Labelappropriately as per State Government guidelines and the Code of Practice.Action Taken:

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    16/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    16  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    4.1.6 Airconditioning Plant Rooms: Wall lining

    The walls in the airconditioning plant rooms are lined in asbestos cementsheeting. This material is unpainted and in generally good condition but with

    some minor damaged panels and is non friable and there is approximately24m

    2. Similar to sample number DO – 14. Refer to image 6.

    Recommendation:Avoid further damage and abrasion. Seal or paint unpainted panels. Remove, repair or replace damaged panels as soon as practicable dueto this area being used for the airconditioning systems. Remove if dismantling, structural alterations or demolition is to be carried outin this area. Reassess at least annually. Label appropriately as per StateGovernment guidelines and the Code of Practice.Action Taken:

    4.1.7 Warehouse: Medium and Large Store Rooms: Wall lining

    The walls of the medium and large store rooms are lined in asbestos cementsheeting. This material is painted and in generally good condition howeverthere are a number of damaged panels especially lower panels. It is nonfriable and there is approximately 200+ m

    2. Similar to sample number DO –

    14. Refer to images 7 & 8.

    Recommendation:Avoid further damage and abrasion. Repair, replace or removeddamaged panels. Remove if dismantling, structural alterations or demolitionis to be carried out in this area. Reassess at least annually. Labelappropriately as per State Government guidelines and the Code of Practice.Action Taken:

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    17/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    17  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    4.1.8 Warehouse: Small storeroom and foyer alcove toairconditioning rooms: Walls & ceiling linings

    The walls and ceilings of the small storeroom and the small foyer outside the

    airconditioning plant rooms are lined in asbestos cement sheet. This materialis unpainted and it is in generally good condition with a few damaged panelsand is non friable and there is approximately 30 m

    2. Similar to sample

    number DO - 14. Refer to image 9.

    Recommendation:Avoid further damage and abrasion. Repair, replace or removedamaged panels. Paint or seal unpainted panels. Remove if dismantling,structural alterations or demolition is to be carried out in this area. Reassessat least annually. Label appropriately as per State Government guidelinesand the Code of Practice.

    4.1.9 Warehouse: Internal Original Main Dividing Walls: Wall lining

    The walls of the warehouse dividing it from the remainder of the building arelined in asbestos cement sheeting. Including the small separate office area(refer image).This material is painted and in generally good conditionhowever there are a number of damaged panels especially lower panels. It isnon friable and there is approximately 250+ m

    2. Sample number DO – 14.

    Refer to image 10.

    Recommendation:Avoid further damage and abrasion. Repair, replace or removeddamaged panels. Remove if dismantling, structural alterations or demolitionis to be carried out in this area. Reassess at least annually. Labelappropriately as per State Government guidelines and the Code of Practice.Action Taken:

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    18/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    18  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    4.2 Asbestos Containing Materials For the Pfizer Tenancy31 Dover Street.

    4.2.1 External: Eaves lining

    The external eaves along the street frontage and to the side seating arealoading dock are lined in asbestos cement sheeting. This material is paintedand in good condition. It is non friable and there is approximately 120 m

    2.

    Similar to sample number DO - 02. Refer to image 2.

    Recommendation:Avoid damage and abrasion. Remove if dismantling, structural alterations ordemolition is to be carried out in this area. Reassess at least annually. Label

    appropriately as per State Government guidelines and the Code of Practice.Action Taken:

    4.2.2 External: Drain surrounds

    The drain surrounds around the outside of the building are asbestos cementsheet. This material is unpainted and in good condition and is non friable andthere is approximately 2m

    2. Sample number DO - 02. Refer to image 3.

    Recommendation:Avoid damage and abrasion. Remove if dismantling, structural alterations ordemolition is to be carried out in this area. Reassess at least annually. Labelappropriately as per State Government guidelines and the Code of Practice.Action Taken:

    4.2.3 Skylights: Wall linings

    The two large skylights have walls lined in asbestos cement sheeting. Thismaterial is painted and in good condition and is non friable and there isapproximately 24m

    2. Similar to sample number DO – 18. Refer to image

    Recommendation:Avoid damage and abrasion. Remove if dismantling, structural alterations ordemolition is to be carried out in this area. Reassess at least annually. Labelappropriately as per State Government guidelines and the Code of Practice.Action Taken:

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    19/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    19  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    4.2.4 Marketing Office & Box Cupboard: Ceiling lining

    The ceilings in the Marketing Office and the adjacent Box Cupboard are linedin asbestos cement sheeting. This material is painted and in good condition

    and is non friable and there is approximately 12m2

    Sample number DO – 20.Refer to image

    Recommendation:Avoid damage and abrasion. Remove if dismantling, structural alterations ordemolition is to be carried out in this area. Reassess at least annually. Labelappropriately as per State Government guidelines and the Code of Practice.Action Taken:

    4.2.5 Lab: Mezzanine Archive Room: Walls & ceiling linings

    The walls and ceilings of the mezzanine sample archive room are lined inasbestos cement sheet. This material is painted and it is in generally goodcondition. It is non friable and there is approximately 30 m

    2. Sample numbers

    DO - 18 (wall) & DO - 19 (ceiling). Refer to image 2.

    Recommendation:Avoid damage and abrasion. Remove if dismantling, structural alterations ordemolition is to be carried out in this area. Reassess at least annually. Label

    appropriately as per State Government guidelines and the Code of Practice.Action Taken:

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    20/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    20  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    4.3 Asbestos Containing Materials (Presumed)

    4.3.1 Fuse Boards: Fuse linings

    The older ceramic fuses on the fuse boards may contain woven asbestostextile insulation. This material is unpainted, medium condition, friable   andthere is approximately < 0.5m

    2.

    Older circuit breaker and fuse boards are located in this building but were notdismantled.

    Recommendation:Attach warning labels to the fuse boards or remove from use. Examine fusesfor linings and remove fuse linings if present as soon as practicable.

    Action Taken:

    4.3.2 Gaskets, Seals and Sealing Compounds

    Gaskets and seals for machinery and other components used on machineryetc. may contain asbestos. Importation of such components was not bannedin Australia until December 2003 therefore any gaskets or seals in machineryconstructed prior to this date should be treated with caution. A check with the

    manufacturer or a sample analysis is advised prior to working upon anysuspect material. Similarly sealing compounds such as mastic used as walland floor joint sealant or joint sealant on such things as ducts or pipes mayalso contain asbestos.

    Minor machinery such as roller door motors etc exist in this building.

    Recommendation:Avoid damage and abrasion. Remove and replace with a non asbestosalternative the next time any gaskets, seals or sealants are disturbed.Remove if dismantling, structural alterations or demolition is to be carried out

    in affected area. Label appropriately as per State Government guidelinesand the Code of Practice.Action Taken:

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    21/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    21  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    4.4 Non Asbestos Containing Materials

    Areas Recorded as not Containing Asbestos (Samples Taken

    for Sample Analysis that did not contain Asbestos)

    This section is included so that if at a later date there is any question about an

    unknown substance or material in the building this may offer some solution as to

    whether or not it contains asbestos. (It is also a requirement under section 9.3 of

    the Code of Practice)

    This also contains areas where a product or material was assessed by the inspector

    to be “similar to” one of the listed samples taken.

    DO – 01 External: Expansion joint sealant Sealant

    DO – 03 External: Loading dock upper wall sprayed oncoating

    Decorative coating

    DO – 04 Entranceway: Sprayed ceiling insulation Vermiculite

    DO – 05 Office: Open area orange vinyl floor covering

    beneath carpet

    Vinyl floor tile

    DO – 06 Office: Managers office white & grey vinyl floor

    covering beneath the carpet

    Vinyl floor tile

    DO – 07 Amenities Area: Green vinyl tiles used on the

    walls

    Vinyl tile

    DO – 08 Warehouse: Grey vinyl floor covering Vinyl floor tile

    DO – 09 Female Lunchroom: Wall lining adjacent to

    doorway

    Fibre cement sheet

    DO – 11 Cleaners Room: Dark green vinyl floor covering Vinyl floor tile

    DO – 15 Warehouse: White vinyl floor covering in loading

    dock area

    Vinyl floor tile

    DO - 16 Pfizer Tenancy: External: Expansion joint

    sealant

    Sealant

    DO - 17 Pfizer Tenancy: Office Area: Male Shower: Wall

    lining

    Fibre cement sheet

    DO - 21 Main Corridor: Heaterbank duct lining Insulation

    DO - 22 Pfizer Tenancy: Heaterbank duct lining Insulation

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    22/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    22  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    Areas assessed as ‘similar to’ the above sampled areas were –

    •  17 Dover (Vacant Tenancy): Office Area: Beneath the carpet throughout the office

    area are vinyl tiles. Similar to samples DO – 05 & DO – 06.

    •  17 Dover (Vacant Tenancy): Amenities Area: Green vinyl tiles are used on the wallsthroughout the staff amenities and many are pink or blue. Closer investigation

    revealed that they are similar to sample DO – 07. These have now been covered

    over or removed.

    •  17 Dover (Vacant Tenancy): Throughout the Amenities and corridors to the

    Amenities and in the Lunchroom new fibre cement sheet has been added to the wall

    linings mainly to cover over older vinyl tiles which were attached to the walls. Similar

    to sample DO - 17.

    •  17 Dover (Vacant Tenancy): Male Shower: Dark green vinyl floor tiles similar to

    sample DO – 11. (Note that DO – 11 was sampled as it is a smaller thicker tile and

    a darker shade of green than DO – 07) These have now been covered over or

    removed.

    •  17 Dover (Vacant Tenancy): Amenities Area: Grey vinyl floor tiles used throughout

    the amenities area (except cleaners room and Male shower) similar to DO – 08.

    •  17 Dover (Vacant Tenancy): Main Service Corridor between Warehouse & Office:

    Grey vinyl floor tiles similar to DO – 08.

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    23/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    23  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    5. Risk Assessment Findings &Conclusions

    5.1 Asbestos Risk Assessment

    Many factors have bearing on any risk assessment, the following table summarises

    the matrix of how we base our assessment of asbestos risk.

    Risk Factors Considered Risk Score

    Asbestos

    Form

    Bonded: Hard or difficult to break with tool (non friable) 0

    Bonded: Difficult to damage by hand (non friable) 1

    Friable: Can be dislodged crushed or broken by hand

    (friable)

    5

    Friable: Spongy, flaky or fluffy (Friable) 6

    General

    Condition

    Good 0

    Medium 2

    Poor 5

    Surface

    Coating

    Painted or Sealed 0

    Unpainted or unsealed 2

    Accessibility Generally Accessible by public or staff 5

    Accessible by Maintenance Staff or not regularly accessed 2

    Generally Inaccessible 0

    Scoring

    0-5 Avoid damage and abrasion. Remove if dismantling, structural alterations or demolition is

    to be carried out in this area. Reassess at least annually. Label appropriately as per State

    Government guidelines and the Code of Practice

    5-8 Avoid further damage and abrasion. Seal, encapsulate ,repair/remove or remove and

    replace damaged or deteriorated area. Remove remaining material if dismantling, structural

    alterations or demolition is to be carried out in this area. Reassess at least annually. Label

    appropriately as per State Government guidelines and the Code of Practice

    8-15 Restrict access to this area or material, place warning signs if necessary Remove as soon

    as practicable using a Licenced Asbestos Removalist.

    These are general principles, additional factors may also be involved onsite and used by our

    inspectors when putting together the risk assessment of each asbestos containing material found.

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    24/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    24  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    5.2 Summary of Register

    The inspection of the building and the subsequent sample analysis of materials

    suspected of containing asbestos located at 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion, identified

    the following types of asbestos containing materials:

      Damaged asbestos cement sheet in the warehouse area and debris: Requires

    cleanup and removal by licenced asbestos removalist.

    These asbestos containing materials below do not pose a risk from exposure to

    airborne fibres so long as the materials are not disturbed or have work carried out

    upon them, i.e. cut, sanded, drilled, etc. Refer to Section 5.3 and the Appendices to

    provide a summary of the health risks related to asbestos.

      Asbestos containing electrical backing boards – resin based.

      Asbestos cement products; sheeting and drain surrounds.

      Presumed asbestos containing material

    5.3 Risk Assessment Findings

    This is to summarise the findings in the register and to outline the asbestos

    management recommendations for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    A hazard is something with the potential to cause harm. Risk is the likelihood

    that the harm will occur from exposure to the hazard. The risk relates to

    illness or disease arising from exposure to airborne asbestos fibres.

    Safe Work Australia's: Code of Practice for the Management and Control of

    Asbestos in Workplaces  [NOHSC: 2018 (2005)] section 5.1 cites the following five

    points as the hierarchy of controls which are the basis of management and control

    of asbestos in the workplace

    1. Elimination/removal – Most Preferred 

    2. Isolation/enclosure/sealing;

    3. Engineering controls;

    4. Safe Work Practices (administrative controls);

    5. Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) – Least Preferred.

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    25/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    25  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    From this the asbestos containing materials at this site can be divided up as

    follows;

    Asbestos containing materials found that require removal, repair, cleanup or

    painting/sealing were -

    i. Damaged wall lining in the main warehouse and the smaller storerooms at

    the rear of the main area.

    ii. Unpainted panels in the airconditioning plant room and adjacent foyer and

    corridor areas.

    Asbestos containing materials of lesser concern are the following –

    iii. Asbestos cement sheet painted and in good condition.

    iv. Asbestos based resin board.

    v. Asbestos cement drain surrounds.

    vi. Presumed asbestos containing material.

    These items have a lower exposure risk however they are more regularly

    encountered and exposed to damage so management of the condition of these

    items is important. This is of particular concern when maintenance work or

    renovation, may lead to damage to these items.

    Control Methods

    Therefore clean up and removal followed by ongoing management and control of

    any maintenance activities are the required control methods.

    5.4 Removal

    No asbestos products or materials were found during this inspection that warranted

    immediate removal.

    However the damaged asbestos sheeting and debris must be cleaned up and

    removed prior to re-tenanting the vacant tenancy.

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    26/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    26  Janalan Pty. Ltd. 

    6. Legislative Requirements

    Safe Work Australia's: Code of Practice for the Management and Control ofAsbestos in Workplaces  [NOHSC: 2018 (2005)] requires that persons in control of

    premises have a duty of care to ‘

      Develop and implement and maintain an asbestos management plan

      Investigate the premises for the presence or possible presence of asbestos

    containing material

      Develop and maintain a register of the identified or presumed ACM including

    details on their locations, accessibility, condition, risk assessments and control

    measures

      Assess the condition of any ACM that are found and the associated asbestos

    risks  Develop measures to remove the ACM or otherwise minimise the risks and

    prevent exposure to asbestos

      Ensure the control measures are implemented as soon as possible and are

    maintained as long as the ACM remain in the workplace.”

    Any maintenance work done on, or in the vicinity of, materials which contain

    asbestos is required by legislation to be carried out in accordance with the Code of

    Practice for the Safe Removal of Asbestos .

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    27/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Appendix A 

    Sample Locations and SampleAnalysis Report

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    28/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Sample Locations 

    Sample No. Location Description

    DO – 01 External: Expansion joint sealant Sealant

    DO – 02 External: Drain surround Fibre cement

    DO – 03 External: Loading dock upper wall sprayed on coating Decorative coating

    DO – 04 Entranceway: Sprayed ceiling insulation Vermiculite

    DO – 05 Office: Open area orange vinyl floor covering beneath

    carpet

    Vinyl floor tile

    DO – 06 Office: Managers office white & grey vinyl floor covering

    beneath the carpet

    Vinyl floor tile

    DO – 07 Amenities Area: Green vinyl tiles used on the walls Vinyl tile

    DO – 08 Warehouse: Grey vinyl floor covering Vinyl floor tile

    DO – 09 Female Lunchroom: Wall lining adjacent to doorway Fibre cement sheet

    DO – 10 Amenities Area: Ceiling tiles Fibre cement sheet

    DO – 11 Cleaners Room: Dark green vinyl floor covering Vinyl floor tile

    DO – 12 Main Corridor: Infill panel to doorway Fibre cement sheet

    DO – 13 Main Meter Box: Main meter backing board Resin board

    DO – 14 Warehouse: Dividing wall lining Fibre cement sheet

    DO – 15 Warehouse: White vinyl floor covering in loading dock

    area

    Vinyl floor tile

    Additional Samples taken 2011*

    DO - 16 Pfizer Tenancy: External: Expansion joint sealant Sealant

    DO - 17 Pfizer Tenancy: Office Area: Male Shower: Wall lining Fibre cement sheet

    DO - 18 Pfizer Tenancy: Mezzanine Sample Archive: Wall lining Fibre cement sheet

    DO - 19 Pfizer Tenancy: Mezzanine Sample Archive: Ceilinglining

    Fibre cement sheet

    DO - 20 Pfizer Tenancy: Marketing Office: Ceiling lining Fibre cement sheet

    DO - 21 Main Corridor: Heaterbank duct lining Insulation

    DO - 22 Pfizer Tenancy: Heaterbank duct lining Insulation

    * Note: These sample have been analysed by low powered stereo microscopy. Complete PLM

    analysis will be carried out by a NATA accredited laboratory and the confirmatory analysis

    certificate included in the final full report.

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    29/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Extract From Previous Asbestos Analysis Report 2005

    ASBESTOS IDENTIFICATION REPORT

    CLIENT: Asbestos Audits Queensland

    ADDRESS: P.O. Box 3657 Loganholme, Qld 4129

    DATE: 28 April 2005

    REPORT NO: 5AD0545H

    LOCALITY: 17 Dover Street, Albion PAGE NO: 1 of 2

    NATA ACCREDITATION NO: 1526

    SCOPE OF ACCREDITATION: Class 7.82.31: Qualitative identification of asbestos types in bulk samples by polarized

    light microscopy. 

    RESULTS:

    Sample: DO-01 Sample size (b): 20x10x10

    Description: The sample is a black bituminous lump

    Result: No asbestos was detected by polarized light microscopy

    Sample: DO-02 Sample size (a): 20x5x5

    Description: The sample is a grey fibrous sheeting

    Result: Chrysotile and amosite asbestos were detected by polarized light microscopy

    Sample: DO-03 Sample size (c): 10x10x3

    Description: The sample is a grey mortar lump coated by a perlite-containing yellow layer

    Result: No asbestos was detected by polarized light microscopy

    Sample: DO-04 Sample size (c): 10x5x5

    Description: The sample is an off-white micaceous lump, painted whiteResult: No asbestos was detected by polarized light microscopy

    Sample: DO-05 Sample size (b): 60x30x2

    Description: The sample is an orange flooring

    Result: No asbestos was detected by polarized light microscopy, but identification may not be

    possible due to adhering resins. Confirmation by another independent analytical technique is

    advised

    Sample: DO-06 Sample size (b): 40x30x2

    Description: The sample is a white and a grey flooring

    Result: No asbestos was detected by polarized light microscopy, but identification may not bepossible due to adhering resins. Confirmation by another independent analytical technique is

    advised

    Sample: DO-07 Sample size (b): 50x30x2

    Description: The sample is a green flooring

    Result: No asbestos was detected by polarized light microscopy, but identification may not be

    possible due to adhering resins. Confirmation by another independent analytical technique is

    advised

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    30/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Sample: DO-08 Sample size (b): 40x40x2

    Description: The sample is a grey flooring

    Result: No asbestos was detected by polarized light microscopy, but identification may not be

    possible due to adhering resins. Confirmation by another independent analytical technique is

    advised

    Sample: DO-09 Sample size (b): 10x10x1

    Description: The sample is a pale grey fibrous sheeting, painted pale grey

    Result: No asbestos was detected by polarized light microscopyASBESTOS IDENTIFICATION REPORT

    CLIENT: Asbestos Audits Queensland

    ADDRESS: P.O. Box 3657 Loganholme, Qld 4129

    DATE: 28 April 2005

    REPORT NO: 5AD0545H

    LOCALITY: 17 Dover Street, Albion PAGE NO: 2 of 2

    NATA ACCREDITATION NO: 1526

    SCOPE OF ACCREDITATION: Class 7.82.31: Qualitative identification of asbestos types in bulk samples by

    polarized light microscopy. 

    RESULTS:

    Sample: DO-10 Sample size (b): 10x10x5

    Description: The sample is an off-white fibrous sheeting

    Result: Amosite and chrysotile asbestos was detected by polarized light microscopy

    Sample: DO-11 Sample size (a): 20x20x3

    Description: The sample is a dark green flooring

    Result: No asbestos was detected by polarized light microscopy, but identification may not be

    possible due to adhering resins. Confirmation by another independent analytical technique is

    advised

    Sample: DO-12 Sample size (a): 70x60x5

    Description: The sample is a pale grey fibrous sheeting, painted white

    Result: Chrysotile asbestos was detected by polarized light microscopy

    Sample: DO-13 Sample size (a): 10x5x1

    Description: The sample is a dark brown fibrous board, painted black

    Result: Chrysotile asbestos was detected by polarized light microscopy

    Sample: DO-14 Sample size (a): 20x20x1

    Description: The sample is a pale grey fibrous sheeting

    Result: Chrysotile asbestos was detected by polarized light microscopy

    Sample: DO-15 Sample size (b): 40x40x3

    Description: The sample is a white flooring with a black bituminous fibrous layer glued to the

    back

    Result: No asbestos was detected in the white flooring by polarized light microscopy, but

    identification may not be possible due to adhering resins. Confirmation by another independent

    analytical technique is advisedResult: Chrysotile asbestos was detected by polarized light microscopy in the black bituminous

    fibrous layer glued to the back 

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    31/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    ASBESTOS-FORMING MINERAL IDENTIFICATION REPORT

    CLIENT: Asbestos Audits Queensland

    ADDRESS: P.O. Box 3657 Loganholme, Qld 4129

    DATE: 28 April 2005

    REPORT NO: 5AD0545HX

    LOCALITY: 17 Dover Street, Albion PAGE NO: 1 of 1

    PROCEDURE

    The samples were analysed by X-ray diffraction, which detects crystalline substances and

    minerals (including asbestos-forming minerals). Non-crystalline substances (eg glass, most

    organic compounds) are not detectable by this technique.

    RESULTS

    Sample: DO-05

    Description: The sample is a 3mm thick orange flooring

    Result: Calcite, goethite and rutile were detected by X-ray diffraction. Asbestos-forming

    minerals were not detected.

    Sample: DO-06

    Description: The sample is a 2mm thick off-white flooring

    Result: Calcite and rutile were detected by X-ray diffraction. Asbestos-forming minerals were

    not detected

    Description: The sample is a 2mm thick grey flooring

    Result: Calcite and rutile were detected by X-ray diffraction. Asbestos-forming minerals werenot detected.

    Sample: DO-07

    Description: The sample is a 3mm thick green flooring

    Result: Calcite and rutile were detected by X-ray diffraction. Asbestos-forming minerals were

    not detected.

    Sample: DO-08

    Description: The sample is a 2mm thick grey flooring

    Result: Calcite and rutile were detected by X-ray diffraction. Asbestos-forming minerals were

    not detected.

    Sample: DO-11

    Description: The sample is a 3mm thick dark green flooring

    Result: Calcite, goethite and rutile were detected by X-ray diffraction. Asbestos-forming

    minerals were not detected.

    Sample: DO-15

    Description: The sample is a 3mm thick off-white flooring

    Result: Calcite and rutile were detected by X-ray diffraction. Asbestos-forming minerals were

    not detected.

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    32/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Appendix B 

    Photographs

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    33/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Image 1: Asbestos based resin backing board to the main electrical meters.

    Image 2: External asbestos cement sheet eaves lining.

    Image 3: External asbestos cement drain surround.

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    34/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Image 4: Asbestos cement sheet ceiling tiles used throughout the amenities area.

    Image 5: Main corridor asbestos cement sheet wall linings.

    Image 6: Unpainted asbestos cement sheet wall linings in the airconditioning room.

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    35/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Image 7: Storeroom: Damaged asbestos cement sheet wall panels.

    Image 8: Storeroom: Damaged asbestos cement sheet wall lining.

    Image 9: Small storeroom: Unpainted asbestos cement sheet wall linings.

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    36/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Image 10: Large rear dividing wall of asbestos cement sheet with many small areas of

    cracking and damage that require repair

    Image 11: Pfizer Tenancy: Asbestos cement sheet wall linings to the skylight in the roof

    space.

    Image 12: Pfizer Tenancy: Mezzanine: Archive Storeroom: Asbestos cement sheet wall

    and ceiling lining.

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    37/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Appendix C 

    Plans and Drawings

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    38/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Aerial View: 1: 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    No plans or drawings were supplied for this site.

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    39/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Appendix E 

    Limitations of an AsbestosInspection

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    40/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    LIMITATIONS OF AN ASBESTOS AUDIT OR INSPECTION

    •  There is no device or instrument at the moment which can automatically detect

    Asbestos.

    The presence of asbestos or asbestos containing materials installed in building orplant equipment can only be confirmed visually backed up by sample analysis in acertified laboratory. An appropriately qualified person will take samples of suspectedmaterials and have them analysed in a laboratory to confirm the presence ofasbestos. Therefore limiting samples taken will decrease the confidence in theAsbestos Audits findings and the Asbestos Management Plan & Register  generated from it.

      Generally it is impossible to locate all asbestos within a building in the courseof an audit.

    This is due to factors such as-.1. To avoid damage to the building- asbestos may be hidden behind walls or floors/floor

    coverings or above fixed ceilings.2. Plant or equipment within the building which contains an asbestos component

    included by the manufacturer.3. No plant or building plans available indicating hidden asbestos usage.4. Minimising the inconvenience or delay while an asbestos audit is underway.5. No access to lifts, lift shafts and rooms, air conditioning ductwork, airways and other

    internal construction elements such as plumbing or electrical risers/conduits.6. Services located below wall surfaces “chased” in insulating material

    •  Relying on an Asbestos Inspection or Audit. 

    An Asbestos Management Plan & Register can only indicate such asbestos as wasfound in the course of the inspection. For the reasons outlined above it should neverbe relied upon   solely   to indicate the presence of all or no asbestos . The findingsmust be considered together with the specific limitations and scope of inspection whichwas undertaken and all other documentation on the building. 

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    41/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Appendix F 

    Principles of an AsbestosManagement Plan

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    42/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    General Principles of an Asbestos Management PlanThis Flow Chart is based on the General Principles of an Asbestos Management Plan on page 20 of the

    Code of Practice for the Management and Control of Asbestos in Workplaces.

    Was the building given council 

    building construction approval

    prior   o 1990? 

    Review relevant building records and have an inspection carried out to identify ACM

    locations including inaccessible areas. Conduct material sampling.

    Are there any inaccessible areas with possible asbestos?

    Is there a

    health risk?

    Determine

    control method

    Periodic Review

    Presume asbestos

    is present

    Review all relevant construction records

    Is there asbestos

    containing material?

    Clearance Report

    may be required

    Enter identification and location details in

    ACM register

    Maintain ACM Register

    ACM Register Required

    Has it been

    verified that there

    is no asbestos?

    ACM Register not required

    RemovalEnclose or seal and

    label as required

    Enter details into

    ACM Register

    Enter details in

    ACM Register

    Label as required and maintain

    undisturbed

    Assessment of condition of ACM

    Determine period for

     – re- inspection

    NO

    NO

    YES

    YES

    YES

    NO

    YES

    YES

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    43/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Appendix G 

    Health Risks Related to Asbestos

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    44/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Health Risks of Asbestos 

    General Health Risk

    Asbestosis, mesothelioma, pleural plaques and lung cancer are the recognised diseases

    caused by asbestos and are all as a result of inhalation of airborne asbestos fibres.

    Hence for asbestos containing materials or products to pose a health risk airborne fibres must

    be generated either through degradation or high energy mechanical action.

    The degree of asbestos fibre release, and hence inhalation exposure, is in part dependent upon

    the matrix material binding the asbestos, general condition and product type.

    The highest health risk is associated with exposure to amphibole asbestos (amosite, crocidolite)

    with crocidolite being cited as the material of greatest concern.

    Chrysotile (a serpentine mineral) is considered to be of lesser but still significant concern.

    Asbestos types:

      Chrysotile is commonly known as white asbestos.

      Amosite is commonly known as grey or brown asbestos.

      Crocidolite is commonly known as blue asbestos.

    Asbestos Cement Products

    Asbestos cement products were commonplace building materials prior to 1986. Many building

    product manufacturers in Australia didn’t phase out the use of asbestos in their products until

    the early 1980’s and then it was a gradual process.

    Imported building products can still contain asbestos either through legislation that allows a

    certain percentage of asbestos in products in that country or no legislation at all in countries

    that still mine it.

    These products consist of asbestos fibres bound in a cement matrix and the degree of fibre

    release depends on the condition of the material.

    The main health risk with asbestos cement products is from maintenance or similar activitywhere the material is worked upon (mechanical energy applied) resulting in airborne dust.

    It can also be prone to weathering, storm damage and the cement matrix does react and break

    down in acidic or polluted atmospheric conditions (i.e. industrial areas) over a period of time. 

    Asbestos Impregnated Sealants

    Asbestos containing materials such as asbestos impregnated sealant are generally in good

    condition.

    The very nature of their composition and adhesive qualities does not easily allow for the release

    of asbestos fibres. However, similar to any asbestos containing material the use of power tools

    or application of mechanical energy may release the asbestos fibres into the environment.

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    45/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Vinyl Floor Coverings

    With vinyl floor coverings, asbestos may be present in any of the following:

      The vinyl body of the tile or sheet;

      A fibrous backing felt/insulation under the tile or sheet;

      A fibrous adhesive, putty or grout used to fix the tile.

    Asbestos contained in the vinyl body of the tile or sheet is held in a stable matrix. The very low

    rate of wear does not normally give rise to fibre release considered to pose a significant health

    risk. A health risk may arise when asbestos fibres are released due to maintenance work or

    when the flooring is friable due to age.

    Asbestos adhesive or putty is sometimes used to coat the back of vinyl tiles or sheet. This

    product does not pose a risk to exposure from airborne fibres, so long as it is not disturbed or

    worked upon.

    Asbestos backing felt/insulation or asbestos adhesive is normally not exposed and does not

    represent a significant health risk. However, when exposed due to wear or damage to the

    overlaying vinyl these materials upon further wear or abrasion may liberate fibres

    depending upon the amount of abrasion and the age and condition of the material. 

    Asbestos Containing Electrical Backing Boards

    Asbestos resin board usually black in colour (i.e. common brand names in Australia are

    “Zelemite” or “Ausbestos”); generally stay in good condition unless worked upon due to their

    hardness and surface finish.

    They are formed from asbestos added to phenol based products or resins which are in a liquid

    condition and poured into moulds to form the sheets or shapes required. They are used where

    fire, thermal or spark resistance is required along with strength and low wearing properties.

    These materials do not pose a risk to exposure from airborne fibres, so long as they are not

    disturbed or worked upon, i.e. cut, sawn, drilled or sanded. Any of these actions may release

    the asbestos fibres into the environment.

    Asbestos Containing Electrical Boxes

    Electrical boxes are often designed and constructed using asbestos containing sheeting as

    thermal insulation inside the box (metal or wood outer construction) and a front face mounting

    board containing asbestos sheet of the type mentioned above.

    The sheeting inside the box can be of a very high asbestos content and if drilled though will

    release asbestos containing dust.

    The door or cover to these boxes can also sometimes have an asbestos cement or material

    lining.

    Another source of asbestos common in electrical boxes is the woven textile white asbestos fuse

    linings used to suppress arcing and sparks in older ceramic fuse holders. These fuse linings

    however are usually contained within the fuse holder and are not a hazard unless disturbed.

    These fuses or boxes are often not inspected internally during the course of our audits as they

    are live and would require disconnection and/or dismantling to find this material.

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    46/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Woven Asbestos Rope or Textile Material

    This material does not pose a significant risk to exposure from airborne fibres, so long as the

    fibrous surface is in good condition and is not disturbed or worked upon, i.e. drilled, cut, or

    abraded. Any of these actions may release the asbestos fibres into the environment.

    Note that some uses of this material which have constant repeated impact or pressures applied

    to them (such as door seals) will increase the rate of break down of this material and possibility

    of release of fibres into the environment.

    Asbestos Fire Door Core Material

    Asbestos containing core material in the fire doors is usually sealed and undisturbed as it

    contained within the door structure.

    Fire doors can be constructed in a number of ways but the most common is a sandwich

    construction in which an outer wooden frame and covering contains sheets of asbestos cementsheet acting as an outer layer to a central core of either asbestos or compressed asbestos

    material.

    This material does not pose a risk to exposure from airborne fibres, so long as the core is not

    disturbed or worked upon, i.e. drilled, cut, or abraded. Any of these actions may release the

    asbestos fibres into the environment. This should especially be kept in mind in regard to

    changing of locking or automatic closing systems and the correct hanging of theses

    doors.

    Gaskets

    Gasket materials are composed of a wide variety of materials. Asbestos was used in many

    different types and forms of gaskets and was used up until December 2003 in imported

    gaskets.

    Where the material is in situ it does not pose a significant risk except where the materials have

    severely degraded.

    The main concern with asbestos gaskets is during maintenance activities where significant fibre

    release can result if the gaskets are worked upon (i.e. sanded to remove old gaskets).

    .

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    47/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Appendix H 

    Glossary of Terms 

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    48/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Glossary of Terms

    The following describes the terms used in this report.

    Asbestos: is the name applied to a group of six different fibrous minerals (amosite, chrysotile,

    crocidolite, and the fibrous varieties of tremolite, actinolite, and anthophyllite) that occurnaturally in the environment. Non asbestos (non fibrous) forms of tremolite, actinolite, and

    anthophyllite also are found naturally. The most common mineral type is white (chrysotile), but

    others may be blue (crocidolite), gray (anthophyllite), or brown (amosite). It differs from other

    minerals in its crystal development. The crystal formation of asbestos is in the form of long thin

    fibres. Asbestos is divided into two mineral groups- serpentine and amphibole. The division

    between the two types is based upon the crystalline structure. Serpentines have a sheet or

    layered structure where as amphiboles have a chain like structure. These minerals do not have

    any detectable odour or taste. Asbestos can be found naturally in soil and rocks in some areas.

    Asbestos fibres are resistant to heat and most chemicals and have great tensile strength.

    Because of these properties asbestos has been mined for use in a very wide range of buildingmaterials, friction products and heat resistant fabrics.

    Chrysotile: White asbestos: This is a Serpentine mineral and considered to be of lesser but

    still significant concern than brown or blue asbestos. White asbestos has “curly” fibres. This

    property allows it to be woven e.g. fire resistant suits or gloves

    Amosite: Grey or brown asbestos: This is an Amphibole mineral and has straight harsh grey

    to brown fibres and was often used in situations where additional strength was required such as

    high temperature asbestos pipe insulation as well as heat resistance such as fire rating.

    Crocidolite: Blue asbestos: This is an Amphibole mineral and has straight blue fibres and the

    fibres are very fine. Blue asbestos tends to have been used in situations where acid resistance

    was required as well as being a common material used for fire rating of steel structural beams.

    Asbestos Containing Material (ACM): Means any material, object, product or debris that

    contains asbestos. 

    Good Condition: Showing no, or very minor, signs of damage and/or deterioration of the

    material.

    Medium Condition: Showing small amounts of damage and/or deterioration of the material.

    Poor Condition: Showing a large amount of damage or deterioration or that the material is no

    longer able to carry out its intended use.

    Friable: Asbestos containing material which can be crumbled, pulverised or reduced to powder

    by hand pressure when dry.

    Non Friable: Material which contains by weight more than 1% asbestos in which the asbestos

    fibres are bonded by cement, vinyl, resin or other similar material.

    Friability: The potential for a product containing asbestos to release breathable fibres depends

    on its degree of friability. Friable means that the material can be crumbled with hand pressure

    and is therefore likely to emit or release fibres. The fibrous or fluffy sprayed on materials used

    for fireproofing, insulation, or sound proofing are considered to be friable and they readily

    release airborne fibres if disturbed. Materials such as asbestos containing vinyl floor tile or

    asbestos containing sealants are generally considered non friable and do not emit or release

    fibres unless subjected to mechanical energy operations such as sawing or sanding operations.Asbestos cement pipes or sheet can emit or release airborne fibres if the materials are cut or

    sawed or if broken up in demolition operations.

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    49/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Monitor Condition: Carry out regular general observation of the condition of the material to

    note any changes.

    Avoid damage and abrasion: As far as practicable limit activities on or adjacent to material such that

    (such as opening or closing doors with asbestos door seals or heavy wear areas for asbestos

    felt backed vinyl).Action Taken: This section is provided for the building owner/manager to record any works

    Chased:  Where pipe work (usually hot water pipes) has been fitted into channels carved

    out of brickwork or concrete walls and insulated using plaster type filler asbestos. (This is not

    common in the Northern states of Australia but is important in the Southern states where heat

    loss due to low temperatures meant that hot water piping needed to be insulated.)

    Person with Control: means in relation to premises, a person who has control of a premises

    used as a workplace. The person with control may be -

      The owner of the building

      A person who has, under any contract or lease an obligation to maintain or repair the

    premises

      A person who is occupying the premises

      A person who is able to make decisions about work undertaken at the premises or

      An employer at the premises.

    Risk: means the likelihood of a hazard causing harm to a person.

    Workplace: means any place where a person works.

    Competent Person: means a person possessing adequate qualifications, such as suitable

    training and sufficient knowledge, experience and skill for the safe performance of the specific

    work.

    Hazard: means any matter, thing, process or practice that may cause death, injury, illness ordisease.

    Dust & Debris: means visible particles, fragments or chunks of material. Large and heavy

    enough to have settled in the work area, that are likely to have originated from ACM.

    Essential plant: includes –

      Boilers; and

      Cooling towers; and

      Escalators; and

      Lifts; and Piping.

      It does not include tenants machinery or equipment or any other stored plant or equipment,

    stock or spare parts unless otherwise mentioned.

    Accredited Laboratory – a testing laboratory accredited by NATA (National

    Association of Testing Authorities), Australia.

    Air Monitoring – airborne asbestos sampling to assist in assessing exposure and theeffectiveness of control measures. This includes exposure monitoring, clearance

    monitoring and control monitoring.

    Asbestos Removalist – a person whose business or undertaking includes asbestos

    removal work or a self employed person whose work includes asbestos removal work.

    Accredited Laboratory – a testing laboratory accredited by NATA (NationalAssociation of Testing Authorities), Australia.

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    50/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Appendix I 

    Register Maintenance Log 

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    51/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Register Maintenance Log

    This log is for the purpose of recording all maintenance or service work carried out on asbestos

    containing material.

    Date Name/Company Nature and scope of Work Clearance Certificates

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    52/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Appendix J 

    Annual Review Updates 

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    53/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Asbestos Containing Materials RegisterAnnual Review Updates and Review of Management

    Plan for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion. 

    ReviewDates

    Date ofInspection

    Inspector/Company 

    2012

    2013

    2014

    2015

    2016

    2017

    2018

    2019

    2020

    2021

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    54/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    Janalan Pty. Ltd.

    Appendix K 

    References 

  • 8/16/2019 Asbestos Reporting Techniques by Gustav Rappier

    55/55

      Asbestos Materials Report & Register for 17 - 31 Dover Street, Albion.

    References

    It is recommended that the following documents be read in conjunction with this

    report. Queensland documents are available from GoPrint, 371 Vulture Street,Woolloongabba, Brisbane, the Safe Work Australia's' Codes of Practice are

    available from Safe Work Australia, Canberra or their website.

    (i) Safe Work Australia: Code of Practice for the Management and Control of

    Asbestos in Workplaces  [NOHSC: 2018 (2005)], NOHSC, Canberra, Australia.

    (ii) Safe Work Australia: Code of Practice for the Safe Removal of Asbestos

    [NOHSC: 2002 (2005)], NOHSC, Canberra, Australia.

    (iii) Queensland Government Department of Employment & Industrial Relations

    Asbestos Fact Sheets 1-5.

    (iv) Safe Work Australia: Guidance Note on the Membrane Filter Method for

    Estimating Airborne Asbestos Fibres [NOHSC: 3003 (2005)], NOHSC,

    Canberra, Australia.

    (v) Workplace Health and Safety Queensland: Workplace Health and Safety Act

    (1995)

    (vi) Workplace Health and Safety Queensland: Workplace Health and Safety

    Regulation 2008

    (vii) Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation and Other Legislation Amendment

    Regulation (No. 1) 2005

    Selected Further Information

    Web SitesQueensland Government Dept. of Workplace Health & Safety

    http://www.deir.qld.gov.au/workplace/  

    Queensland Asbestos Industry association-

    http://www.asbestosindustry.asn.au 

    Safe Work Australia

    http://www.safeworkaustralia.gov.au/Asbestos Audits Queensland

    http://www.asbestos-audits.com.au/

    U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Asbestos Home page

    http://www.epa.gov/opptintr/asbestos/  

    Or contact your local Queensland Workplace Health and Safety Office on 1300 369 915

    © AAQ Pty Ltd 2011