9
Appendix L Draft Development Plan for DEV-A19-3 and DEV-A17-2 (provided to the EA by Sam Katz Holdings Limited)

Appendix L Draft Development Plan for DEV-A19-3 and DEV ...€¦ · The table below provides a summary of impacted and retained vegetation communities, based on the approved Draft

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Appendix L Draft Development Plan for DEV-A19-3 and DEV-A17-2 (provided to the EA by

Sam Katz Holdings Limited)

MUD CREEK | Analysis of the Proposed Realignment at 323 Oxford Street West

Page 1 of 8 | June 5, 2017

1 Base InformatIon & IdentIfIcatIon of natIve vs. non-natIve communItIes

The primary source for this analysis is the Vegetation Communities Map provided in Appendix B of the July 2016 Draft Mud Creek Subwatershed Class Environmental Assessment. The preparation of the Environmental Assessment has been an ongoing process, spanning over a decade. As such, we note that the conditions as shown in this figure may no longer accurately reflect existing conditions, however they do provide a single source of data for this analysis. Furthermore, the Landowner Group and their consultants do not agree in all cases with the quantity, quality and location of identified vegetation communities in the July 2016 Draft Mud Creek Subwatershed Class Environmental Assessment.

Figure 3 - Mud Creek EA - Vegetation Communities, Appendix B - Subject Lands Status Report And Environmental Impact Study, of the July 2016 Draft Mud Creek Subwatershed Class Environmental Assessment

This figure, prepared by LGL Limited, identifies existing vegetation communities in the EA Study Area as of 2015. As shown, the following vegetation communities are located within the subject lands:

eLc code vegetation type & characteristics area (ha)FOD4B Black Locust Deciduous Forest

Located on upland valley slopes in well-drained areas.0.03

FOD4C Manitoba Maple Deciduous ForestHighly disturbed area with lots of dumping.

0.83

FOD5-7 Dry-Fresh Sugar Maple-Black Cherry Deciduous ForestHeavily disturbed area with dry to fresh soils, rapid to well drainage.

1.08

FOD7A Manitoba Maple Lowland Deciduous ForestMoist to fresh soils with well to poor drainage.

2.74

FOD7B Lowland Deciduous ForestMoist to fresh soils with well to poor drainage. Forest is dominated by Manitoba Maple, Willow and Poplar.

2.02

MAM2-5 Narrow-leaved Sedge Mineral Meadow MarshSeasonally flooded and dominated by emergent hydrophytic macrophytes.

0.48

SWT2 Mineral Thicket SwampGlossy Buckthorn, Common Buckthorn and Red-osier Dogwood. Swamp contains skunk cabbage. Seasonally flooded and dominated by hydrophytic trees and shrubs.

1.53

CUT1A Dogwood/Common Buckthorn Cultural ThicketResulting from or maintained by anthropogenic based influences.

0.84

CUT1B Common Buckthorn Cultural ThicketResulting from or maintained by anthropogenic based influences.

1.97

CUW1 Mineral Cultural WoodlandMixed Species. Resulting from or maintained by anthropogenic based influences.

1.95

Ag AgricultureResulting from or maintained by anthropogenic based influences.

9.56

The information provided above relating to vegetation community characteristics has been retrieved from Table 3: Summary of Ecological Land Classification Vegetation Communities within the Mud Creek Study Area, of Appendix B (July 2016 Draft Mud Creek Subwatershed Class Environmental Assessment). The Vegetation community areas and boundaries were provided by CH2M Hill and their consultants, LGL Limited. The lines provided were not legally surveyed and are approximate limits only, digitized from ortho imagery.

Analysis of Existing Vegetation Communities at 323 Oxford Street West

The majority of existing vegetation communities located in the portion of the Mud Creek Subwatershed that is within the subject lands (323 Oxford Street West) are identified as being of non-native and/or invasive dominant species. These areas are described as being degraded and of poor quality, often having resulted from or maintained by anthropogenic based influences. As presented in the EIS, the FOD5-7 and MAM2-5 are the only vegetation communities identified as being native-dominant and comprise 12% of the vegetation communities within the subject lands.

Approximate location of 323 Oxford Street West

Native Dominant Species

EXIST

ING SE

WER

AGE EASE

MEN

T

EXISTING SEWERAGE EASEMENT

FOD5-7

Ag

CUT1A

CUT1B

FOD4C

MAM2-5

Ag

FOD4B

FOD7A

SWT2

FOD4C

FOD7A

FOD7B

MAS2-1MAS2-1

CUW1

SWT2

M

FOD4B

FOD4A

NATIVE COMMUNITIES: 1.56 ha (12%)

NON-NATIVE/INVASIVE COMMUNITIES: 11.91 ha (88%)

PRO

UD

FOO

T LN

OXFORD ST W

BEAV

ERBR

OO

k AV

E EX

T.

MUD CREEK | Analysis of the Proposed Realignment at 323 Oxford Street West

Page 2 of 8 | June 5, 2017

Comparison of Existing Vegetation Communities and approved green network, as depicted on the Approved Draft Plan of Subdivision

As approved, the Draft Plan of Subdivision requires that only 2.45 ha of wooded area be protected. For the purposes of comparison, the adjacent table (right) analyses potential impacts of the approved Draft Plan of Subdivision on existing vegetation communities.

2 deveLopment approvaLsThe 1999 ApprOveD DrAFT pLAN & Tree preServATiON pLAN

Approved Draft Plan of Subdivision

The subject lands are tied to an approved Draft Plan of Subdivision, from January 1999. A 1998 Tree Preservation Report accompanies this approval, and identifies wooded areas to be protected within Block 4 (Multiple Family) and Block 7 (Park). A summary of the green network, as depicted on the approved plans, is listed below:

Block no. description area (ha)

6 Open Space Block (for stormwater management purposes) 1.96

7 park Block 5.67

8 park Block 0.21n/a NeT Wooded Areas to be protected 0.30

Total Wooded Areas to be Protected 2.45

Overlap with Beaverbrook Avenue - 0.22

Overlap with Block 7 - 1.93

totaL Green netWorK (including park blocks) 8.14

The table below provides a summary of impacted and retained vegetation communities, based on the approved Draft Plan of Subdivision.

eLc code vegetation community area (ha)1999 approved draft plan of subdivision

& 1998 tree preservation reportretained areas (ha) Impacted areas (ha)

native dominant speciesFOD5-7 Dry-Fresh Sugar Maple-Black Cherry Deciduous Forest 1.08 0.78 0.30

MAM2-5 Narrow-leaved Sedge Mineral Meadow Marsh 0.48 0.48

non-native and/or Invasive dominant species

FOD4B Black Locust Deciduous Forest 0.03 0.03

FOD4C Manitoba Maple Deciduous Forest 0.83 0.83

FOD7A Manitoba Maple Lowland Deciduous Forest 2.74 0.73 2.02

FOD7B Lowland Deciduous Forest 2.02 2.02

SWT2 Mineral Thicket Swamp 1.53 0.26 1.26

CUT1A Dogwood/Common Buckthorn Cultural Thicket 0.84 0.84

CUT1B Common Buckthorn Cultural Thicket 1.97 1.29 0.68

CUW1 Mineral Cultural Woodland 1.95 1.95

totaL 13.47 3.90 9.57

The table above includes retained vegetation communities located in the park block only (Block 7), as the open space block (Block 6) is intended to accommodate storm water management facilities and impacts vegetation communities located within this block are anticipated.

Map-2 Wooded Areas To Be Retained”, Prepared By Proctor & Redfern Limited (July 1998)323 Oxford Street West – 1999 Approved Draft Plan of Subdivision

RETAINED: 4.10 ha (29%)

IMPACTED: 9.37 ha (71%)

MUD CREEK | Analysis of the Proposed Realignment at 323 Oxford Street West

Page 3 of 8 | June 5, 2017

3 tHe proposed tmIG mud creeK reaLIGnment (2017)

The Municipal Infrastructure Group Ltd. (TMIG) was retained in 2016 by Sam Katz Holdings Limited to provide a solution for the uncontrolled flooding that occurs on the subject lands, at 323 Oxford Street West, with the intention that the proposed solution would be appended to the final Mud Creek Subwatershed Class Environmental Assessment. TMIG has been coordinating their modelling, calculations and proposed solution with City staff and their consultant team throughout the duration of this exercise.

TMIG Memorandum “Conceptual Design Of Mud Creek Re-Alignment On The ESAM Lands For Informing The Mud Creek Subwatershed Class Environmental Assessment”

The memorandum prepared by TMIG addresses design considerations such as the Beaverbrook Avenue Extension, potential local roadway crossings, the preferred alternative of the Mud Creek Subwatershed Class Environmental Assessment, existing culverts and storm sewers, storm event peak flows, meander belt width, and riparian storage. The proposed corridor provides opportunities for an enhanced creek and vegetation system, and comprises the following areas:

Features of the Defined Valley & creek corridor area (ha)

Low Flow Channel 0.58

valley Floor 2.21

embankment (max 3:1 side slope) 1.57

vegetated Open Space 1.66

total creek corridor 6.02

5 Metre Buffer with Multi-Use path (located outside of the valley corridor) 0.42

total creek corridor + Buffer 6.44

NOTE:

PROVIDED WITHOUT PREJUDICEFOR DISCUSSION PURPOSES ONLY

VegetatedOpen Space

VegetatedOpen Space

Naturalized Valley Corridor (60 metres)

Buffer(5m)

Valley Bottom WidthDependent on Meander Belt

Low FlowChannel

Planted Valley Floor & Slopes

Depth of LIDs Vary with Respect to Groundwater Levels

and Volume RequirementsPotential Wetland Pockets

in the Valley Floor

Potential Multi-use Pathway

Potential Multi-use Pathway

Regional Storm Flood Water Level(Matching Existing Regional Storm Riparian Storage)

Beaverbrook Ave Extension(21.5 metres)

Depth of Valley Dependent on Existing

Channel Inverts, Riparian Storage Requirements and

Other Constraints

Where possible, Site Plans for blocks adjacent to the Mud Creek valley corridor shall orient outdoor amenity space adjacent to the valley corridor.

LID

MAY 2017

Conceptual Creek Alignment and Restoration OpportunitiesWhere possible, Site Plans for blocks adjacent to the Mud Creek valley corridor shall orient outdoor amenity space adjacent to the valley corridor.

MU

D CR

EEK

| A

naly

sis o

f the

Pro

pose

d Re

alig

nmen

t at

323

Oxf

ord

Stre

et W

est

Pag

e 4

of

8

|

Jun

e 7,

201

7

4 tHe

pro

pose

d t

mIG

mu

d c

ree

K

rea

LIG

nm

ent

(201

7)

MUD CREEK | Analysis of the Proposed Realignment at 323 Oxford Street West

Page 5 of 8 | June 5, 2017

EXIST

ING SE

WER

AGE EASE

MEN

T

EXISTING SEWERAGE EASEMENT

7.596 ha

5.67 haPARK BLOCK

.21 haPARK BLOCK

MULTIPLE FAMILY

1.94 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

1.96 haOPEN SPACE

3.97 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

2.5 haSCHOOL SITE

PUBLIC ELEMENTARY

3.55 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

30m SETBACK FROM RAILWAY

WOODED AREA TO BE PROTECTED

BLOCK 7

BLOCK 8

BLOCK 1

BLOCK 6

BLOCK 2

BLOCK 4

BLOCK 3

BLOCK 5

FOD5-7

Ag

CUT1A

CUT1B

FOD4C

MAM2-5

Ag

FOD4B

FOD7A

SWT2

FOD4C

FOD7A

FOD7B

MAS2-1MAS2-1

CUW1

SWT2

M

FOD4B

FOD4A

5 Impacts on tHe exIstInG veGetatIon communItIes

FOD5-7

Ag

CUT1A

CUT1B

FOD4C

MAM2-5

Ag

FOD4B

FOD7A

SWT2

FOD4C

FOD7A

FOD7B

MAS2-1MAS2-1

CUW1

SWT2

M

FOD4B

FOD4A

EXIST

ING SE

WER

AGE EASE

MEN

T

EXISTING SEWERAGE EASEMENT

FOD5-7

Ag

CUT1A

CUT1B

FOD4C

MAM2-5

Ag

FOD4B

FOD7A

SWT2

FOD4C

FOD7A

FOD7B

MAS2-1MAS2-1

CUW1

SWT2

M

FOD4B

FOD4A

EXIST

ING SE

WER

AGE EASE

MEN

T

EXISTING SEWERAGE EASEMENT

FOD5-7

Ag

CUT1A

CUT1B

FOD4C

MAM2-5

Ag

FOD4B

FOD7A

SWT2

FOD4C

FOD7A

FOD7B

MAS2-1MAS2-1

CUW1

SWT2

M

FOD4B

FOD4A

EXIST

ING SE

WER

AGE EASE

MEN

T

EXISTING SEWERAGE EASEMENT

7.596 ha

5.67 haPARK BLOCK

.21 haPARK BLOCK

MULTIPLE FAMILY

1.94 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

1.96 haOPEN SPACE

3.97 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

2.5 haSCHOOL SITE

PUBLIC ELEMENTARY

3.55 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

30m SETBACK FROM RAILWAY

WOODED AREA TO BE PROTECTED

BLOCK 7

BLOCK 8

BLOCK 1

BLOCK 6

BLOCK 2

BLOCK 4

BLOCK 3

BLOCK 5

FOD5-7

Ag

CUT1A

CUT1B

FOD4C

MAM2-5

Ag

FOD4B

FOD7A

SWT2

FOD4C

FOD7A

FOD7B

MAS2-1MAS2-1

CUW1

SWT2

M

FOD4B

FOD4A

Summary of Impacts on the Existing Vegetation Communities

eLc code vegetation community area (ha)1

Impacted areas (ha) total Impacted area (ha)

roads (oxford st and Beaverbrook ave)

sewerage easements

proposed channel

approved draft plan of subdivision

native dominant species

FOD5-7 Dry-Fresh Sugar Maple-Black Cherry Deciduous Forest 1.08 0.24 0.39 0.63

MAM2-5 Narrow-leaved Sedge Mineral Meadow Marsh 0.48 0.06 0.24 0.19 0.48

non-native and/or Invasive dominant species

FOD4B Black Locust Deciduous Forest 0.03 0.03 0.03FOD4C Manitoba Maple Deciduous Forest 0.83 0.17 0.21 0.20 0.57

FOD7A Manitoba Maple Lowland Deciduous Forest 2.74 0.20 0.67 0.69 0.42 1.98

FOD7B Lowland Deciduous Forest 2.02 0.46 0.39 1.17 2.02SWT2 Mineral Thicket Swamp 1.53 0.02 0.06 0.01 1.17 1.26

CUT1A Dogwood/Common Buckthorn Cultural Thicket 0.84 0.00

CUT1B Common Buckthorn Cultural Thicket 1.97 0.04 0.23 0.35 0.62CUW1 Mineral Cultural Woodland 1.95 0.53 0.10 0.12 1.20 1.95totaL 13.47 1.75 1.23 1.88 4.69 9.55

1Vegetation community areas and boundaries are approximate and have not been staked.

Road Works (Oxford St W Widening & Beaverbrook Ave Extension)

Existing Easements & Sanitary Sewer Upgrades*

Approved Draft Plan of SubdivisionProposed Channel & Corridor

Native Dominant Species

Non-native / Invasive Dominant Species

Impacted Existing Vegetation

*The Mud Creek EA (July 2016) identifies an existing sanitary sewer that runs parallel to the Mud Creek channel from Oxford Street West to Wonderland Road. This sanitary sewer extends north of Oxford Street West, and is located underneath the channel.

According to the EA, “the 1050mm diameter sanitary sewer was constructed in 1965. Therefore, this sewer is unlikely to be replaced for another 40‐50 years. However, this sanitary sewer does not have a standard maintenance access road to allow for regular flushing.”

North of Oxford Street, the condition of this sanitary sewer is substandard in terms of manhole arrangement, and required upgrades are anticipated in the coming years

OXFORD ST W

BEAV

ERBR

OO

k AV

E EX

T.

MUD CREEK | Analysis of the Proposed Realignment at 323 Oxford Street West

Page 6 of 8 | June 5, 2017

7.596 ha

5.67 haPARK BLOCK

.21 haPARK BLOCK

MULTIPLE FAMILY

1.94 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

1.96 haOPEN SPACE

3.97 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

2.5 haSCHOOL SITE

PUBLIC ELEMENTARY

3.55 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

30m SETBACK FROM RAILWAY

WOODED AREA TO BE PROTECTED

BLOCK 7

BLOCK 8

BLOCK 1

BLOCK 6

BLOCK 2

BLOCK 4

BLOCK 3

BLOCK 5

FOD5-7

Ag

CUT1A

CUT1B

FOD4C

MAM2-5

Ag

FOD4B

FOD7A

SWT2

FOD4C

FOD7A

FOD7B

MAS2-1MAS2-1

CUW1

SWT2

M

FOD4B

FOD4A

7.596 ha

5.67 haPARK BLOCK

.21 haPARK BLOCK

MULTIPLE FAMILY

1.94 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

1.96 haOPEN SPACE

3.97 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

2.5 haSCHOOL SITE

PUBLIC ELEMENTARY

3.55 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

30m SETBACK FROM RAILWAY

WOODED AREA TO BE PROTECTED

BLOCK 7

BLOCK 8

BLOCK 1

BLOCK 6

BLOCK 2

BLOCK 4

BLOCK 3

BLOCK 5

FOD5-7

Ag

CUT1A

CUT1B

FOD4C

MAM2-5

Ag

FOD4B

FOD7A

SWT2

FOD4C

FOD7A

FOD7B

MAS2-1MAS2-1

CUW1

SWT2

M

FOD4B

FOD4A

7.596 ha

5.67 haPARK BLOCK

.21 haPARK BLOCK

MULTIPLE FAMILY

1.94 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

1.96 haOPEN SPACE

3.97 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

2.5 haSCHOOL SITE

PUBLIC ELEMENTARY

3.55 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

30m SETBACK FROM RAILWAY

WOODED AREA TO BE PROTECTED

BLOCK 7

BLOCK 8

BLOCK 1

BLOCK 6

BLOCK 2

BLOCK 4

BLOCK 3

BLOCK 5

FOD5-7

Ag

CUT1A

CUT1B

FOD4C

MAM2-5

Ag

FOD4B

FOD7A

SWT2

FOD4C

FOD7A

FOD7B

MAS2-1MAS2-1

CUW1

SWT2

M

FOD4B

FOD4A

7.596 ha

5.67 haPARK BLOCK

.21 haPARK BLOCK

MULTIPLE FAMILY

1.94 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

1.96 haOPEN SPACE

3.97 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

2.5 haSCHOOL SITE

PUBLIC ELEMENTARY

3.55 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

30m SETBACK FROM RAILWAY

WOODED AREA TO BE PROTECTED

BLOCK 7

BLOCK 8

BLOCK 1

BLOCK 6

BLOCK 2

BLOCK 4

BLOCK 3

BLOCK 5

FOD5-7

Ag

CUT1A

CUT1B

FOD4C

MAM2-5

Ag

FOD4B

FOD7A

SWT2

FOD4C

FOD7A

FOD7B

MAS2-1MAS2-1

CUW1

SWT2

M

FOD4B

FOD4A

OXFORD ST W

BEAV

ERBR

OO

k AV

E EX

T.

6 retaIned & enHanced veGetatIon communItIes

Summary of Retained and Enhanced Vegetation Communities

eLc code vegetation communities area (ha)1

retained vegetation areas (ha)

realigned creek (enhancement areas- ha)2

total retained & enhanced area (ha) valley floor

embankment & vegetated open

spacenative dominant species

FOD5-7 Dry-Fresh Sugar Maple-Black Cherry Deciduous Forest 1.08 0.45 3.23 3.68

MAM2-5 Narrow-leaved Sedge Mineral Meadow Marsh 0.48 2.21 2.21

non-native and/or Invasive dominant species

FOD4B Black Locust Deciduous Forest 0.03 0.00FOD4C Manitoba Maple Deciduous Forest 0.83 0.03 0.03FOD7A Manitoba Maple Lowland Deciduous Forest 2.74 0.75 0.75FOD7B Lowland Deciduous Forest 2.02 0.00SWT2 Mineral Thicket Swamp 1.53 0.26 0.26

CUT1A Dogwood/Common Buckthorn Cultural Thicket 0.84 0.84 0.84

CUT1B Common Buckthorn Cultural Thicket 1.97 1.35 1.35CUW1 Mineral Cultural Woodland 1.95 0.00totaL 13.47 3.68 2.21 3.23 9.12

1Vegetation community areas and boundaries are approximate and have not been staked.2Identifies potential opportunities for restoration. The channel’s planting plan may differ as the proposed realignment evolves. The area calculations above include only those lands within 323 Oxford Street West.

Wooded Area to be Protected

RETA

INED

VEG

ETAT

ION

ENHA

NCE

D AR

EAS

Proposed Restoration Valley Floor (Potential)

Retained Vegetation

Valley Floor (MAM2-5)

Embankment (FOD5-7)

Enhancements

Proposed Restoration Embankment & Vegetated Open Space (Potential)

MUD CREEK | Analysis of the Proposed Realignment at 323 Oxford Street West

Page 7 of 8 | June 5, 2017

7.596 ha

5.67 haPARK BLOCK

.21 haPARK BLOCK

MULTIPLE FAMILY

1.94 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

1.96 haOPEN SPACE

3.97 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

2.5 haSCHOOL SITE

PUBLIC ELEMENTARY

3.55 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

30m SETBACK FROM RAILWAY

WOODED AREA TO BE PROTECTED

BLOCK 7

BLOCK 8

BLOCK 1

BLOCK 6

BLOCK 2

BLOCK 4

BLOCK 3

BLOCK 5

Proudfoot Park - East

FOD5-7

Ag

CUT1A

CUT1B

FOD4C

MAM2-5

Ag

FOD4B

FOD7A

SWT2

FOD4C

FOD7A

FOD7B

MAS2-1MAS2-1

CUW1

SWT2

M

FOD4B

FOD4A

7 opportunItIes to enHance tHe naturaL HerItaGe system

Summary of Additional Opportunities for Enhancements

eLc code vegetation communities area (ha)1

additional retained area (ha)

additional enhanced area (ha) total area of potential additional opportunities2 (ha)

30m derailment

Zone

realignment beyond the

subject Lands2,3

potential dedication of

Land (fleetway)3

native dominant species

FOD5-7 Dry-Fresh Sugar Maple-Black Cherry Deciduous Forest 1.08 0.98 0.60 1.58

MAM2-5 Narrow-leaved Sedge Mineral Meadow Marsh 0.48 0.31 0.31

non-native and/or Invasive dominant species

FOD4A Black Walnut Deciduous Forest - 0.10 0.10FOD4B Black Locust Deciduous Forest 0.03 0.09 0.09FOD4C Manitoba Maple Deciduous Forest 0.83 0.18 0.18

FOD7A Manitoba Maple Lowland Deciduous Forest 2.74 1.36 1.36

FOD7B Lowland Deciduous Forest 2.02 0.00SWT2 Mineral Thicket Swamp 1.53 0.00

CUT1A Dogwood/Common Buckthorn Cultural Thicket 0.84 0.00

CUT1B Common Buckthorn Cultural Thicket 1.97 0.00CUW1 Mineral Cultural Woodland 1.95 0.00totaL 13.47 0.18 0.98 0.91 1.54 3.61

1Vegetation community areas and boundaries are approximate and have not been staked.2Impact on the existing vegetation communities in this location are anticipated due to the Oxford Street West widening and relocation and enlargement of the Oxford Street culvert, as proposed in the preferred alternative of the July 2016 Draft Mud Creek Subwatershed Class Environmental Assessment.

3Includes areas located outside of the subject site.

30 metre Derailment Zone

Potential Dedication of Land

Additional Retained Vegetation

Restoration Potential (30m Derailment Zone)

Adjacent Lands (OS1 Zone in Fleetway)

Potential 5m Buffer (West of Valley Corridor)

Additional Opportunities

7.596 ha

5.67 haPARK BLOCK

.21 haPARK BLOCK

MULTIPLE FAMILY

1.94 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

1.96 haOPEN SPACE

3.97 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

2.5 haSCHOOL SITE

PUBLIC ELEMENTARY

3.55 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

30m SETBACK FROM RAILWAY

WOODED AREA TO BE PROTECTED

BLOCK 7

BLOCK 8

BLOCK 1

BLOCK 6

BLOCK 2

BLOCK 4

BLOCK 3

BLOCK 5

FOD5-7

Ag

CUT1A

CUT1B

FOD4C

MAM2-5

Ag

FOD4B

FOD7A

SWT2

FOD4C

FOD7A

FOD7B

MAS2-1MAS2-1

CUW1

SWT2

M

FOD4B

FOD4A

7.596 ha

5.67 haPARK BLOCK

.21 haPARK BLOCK

MULTIPLE FAMILY

1.94 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

1.96 haOPEN SPACE

3.97 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

2.5 haSCHOOL SITE

PUBLIC ELEMENTARY

3.55 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

30m SETBACK FROM RAILWAY

WOODED AREA TO BE PROTECTED

BLOCK 7

BLOCK 8

BLOCK 1

BLOCK 6

BLOCK 2

BLOCK 4

BLOCK 3

BLOCK 5

Proudfoot Park - East

FOD5-7

Ag

CUT1A

CUT1B

FOD4C

MAM2-5

Ag

FOD4B

FOD7A

SWT2

FOD4C

FOD7A

FOD7B

MAS2-1MAS2-1

CUW1

SWT2

M

FOD4B

FOD4A

7.596 ha

5.67 haPARK BLOCK

.21 haPARK BLOCK

MULTIPLE FAMILY

1.94 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

1.96 haOPEN SPACE

3.97 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

2.5 haSCHOOL SITE

PUBLIC ELEMENTARY

3.55 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

30m SETBACK FROM RAILWAY

WOODED AREA TO BE PROTECTED

BLOCK 7

BLOCK 8

BLOCK 1

BLOCK 6

BLOCK 2

BLOCK 4

BLOCK 3

BLOCK 5

FOD5-7

Ag

CUT1A

CUT1B

FOD4C

MAM2-5

Ag

FOD4B

FOD7A

SWT2

FOD4C

FOD7A

FOD7B

MAS2-1MAS2-1

CUW1

SWT2

M

FOD4B

FOD4A

OXFORD ST W

BEAV

ERBR

OO

k AV

E EX

T.

Proposed Channel & Corridor

WIT

HIN

THE

SU

BJEC

T LA

NDS

BEYO

ND

THE

SUBJ

ECT

LAN

DS

MUD CREEK | Analysis of the Proposed Realignment at 323 Oxford Street West

Page 8 of 8 | June 5, 2017

8 summary of Impacts & BenefIts

Summary of Additional Opportunities for Enhancements

eLc code vegetation communities area1 (ha) Impacted

area (ha)retained &

enhanced area (ha)area of additional opportunities2 (ha)

net area (ha)

native dominant species

FOD5-7 Dry-Fresh Sugar Maple-Black Cherry Deciduous Forest 1.08 0.63 3.68 1.58 5.71

MAM2-5 Narrow-leaved Sedge Mineral Meadow Marsh 0.48 0.48 2.21 0.31 2.52

non-native and/or Invasive dominant species

FOD4A Black Walnut Deciduous Forest - 0.10 0.10FOD4B Black Locust Deciduous Forest 0.03 0.03 0.09 0.09FOD4C Manitoba Maple Deciduous Forest 0.83 0.57 0.03 0.18 0.46FOD7A Manitoba Maple Lowland Deciduous Forest 2.74 1.98 0.75 1.36 2.88FOD7B Lowland Deciduous Forest 2.02 2.02 0.00SWT2 Mineral Thicket Swamp 1.53 1.26 0.26 0.52CUT1A Dogwood/Common Buckthorn Cultural Thicket 0.84 0.84 1.68CUT1B Common Buckthorn Cultural Thicket 1.97 0.62 1.35 2.70CUW1 Mineral Cultural Woodland 1.95 1.95 0.00totaL 13.47 9.55 9.12 3.61 16.65

The proposed realignment of Mud Creek nearly triples the retained and enhanced Natural Heritage lands located within and adjacent to 323 Oxford Street West, post development, increasing this area from 4.10 ha to 12.73 ha.

Benefits of the Mud Creek Realignment include:

• A potential dedication of +0.38 ha of parkland to the City – part of a 1.92 ha total land dedication.

• A potential 5 m wide buffer block, including a trail +0.42 ha, in addition to the 60 m wide valley corridor.

• A restored meadow marsh, 4.6 x larger than the existing marsh.

• an increase in total native dominant vegetation communities

from 1.56 ha to 8.23 ha (more than 5 x the existing condition).

• a connected and restored channel, over 1 km in length.

• Controlled stormwater runoff.

• Traffic and infrastructure improvements, including the relocation and upgrade of sanitary sewers.

NATIVE: 1.56 ha (12%)

RETAINED: 4.10ha (29%)

RETAINED & ENHANCED:

12.73 ha (57%)

NON-NATIVE/INVASIVE:

8.42 ha (51%)

NON-NATIVE/INVASIVE:

11.91 ha (88%)IMPACTED:

9.37 ha (71%)IMPACTED:

9.55 ha (43%)

NATIVE: 8.23 ha (49%)

Existing Condition Approved Draft PlanProposed Creek Proposed Creek

1Vegetation community areas and boundaries are approximate and have not been staked.

2Includes areas located outside of the subject site.

7.596 ha

5.67 haPARK BLOCK

.21 haPARK BLOCK

MULTIPLE FAMILY

1.94 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

1.96 haOPEN SPACE

3.97 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

2.5 haSCHOOL SITE

PUBLIC ELEMENTARY

3.55 haMULTIPLE FAMILY

30m SETBACK FROM RAILWAY

WOODED AREA TO BE PROTECTED

BLOCK 7

BLOCK 8

BLOCK 1

BLOCK 6

BLOCK 2

BLOCK 4

BLOCK 3

BLOCK 5

Proudfoot Park - East

FOD5-7

Ag

CUT1A

CUT1B

FOD4C

MAM2-5

Ag

FOD4B

FOD7A

SWT2

FOD4C

FOD7A

FOD7B

MAS2-1MAS2-1

CUW1

SWT2

M

FOD4B

FOD4A

OXFORD ST W

BEAV

ERBR

OO

k AV

E EX

T.

Native Dominant Species

Planned & Potential

Non-native / Invasive Dominant Species

Impacted Existing Vegetation

Retained Vegetation

Valley Floor (MAM2-5)

Embankment (FOD5-7)and Restoration Potential of 30m Derailment Zone

Enhancements

Potential Dedication of Lands (OS1 Zone in Fleetway)

Additional Opportunities

Potential 5m Buffer (West of Valley Corridor)