APPENDIX – J · Because regulatory evaluation criteria are constantly changing, concentrations of contaminants present and considered to be acceptable may, ... TOLEDO CITY OF USD

APPENDIX – J

ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENT SCREENING REPORT ANTHONY WAYNE TRAIL IMPROVEMENT PROJECT TOLEDO, OHIO

PID 95676

Prepared for: The City of Toledo Division of Engineering Services 600 Jefferson Avenue, Suite 300 Toledo, Ohio 43604

January 10, 2014

1375 Euclid Avenue Cleveland, Ohio 44115 216-622-2400 Project No. 13816761

TABLE OF CONTENTS

K:\Projects\T\Toledo\13816761\DOCs\Environmental\Environmental Site Screening\AWT Environmental Screening Assessment.doc i

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ................................................................................................................................ ES-1 SECTION 1 PROJECT SUMMARY ............................................................................................................ 1-1

1.1 Introduction .............................................................................................. 1-1 1.2 Scope of Services ..................................................................................... 1-2 1.3 Limitations and Data Gaps ....................................................................... 1-2

SECTION 2 HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW ............................................................................................ 2-1 2.1 Oil and Gas Well Maps ............................................................................ 2-1 2.2 Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps .................................................................. 2-1 2.3 Aerial Photographs ................................................................................... 2-1 2.4 Historical Records Review Summary ...................................................... 2-2

SECTION 3 REGULATORY DATABASE REVIEW ........................................................................................ 3-1 3.1 Regulatory Database Search .................................................................... 3-1 3.2 Project Area ............................................................................................. 3-3

3.2.1 RCRA Generators ........................................................................ 3-3 3.2.2 OH LUST ..................................................................................... 3-3 3.2.3 UST .............................................................................................. 3-4 3.2.4 OH SPILLS .................................................................................. 3-4 3.2.5 Other Databases ........................................................................... 3-4

3.3 Surrounding Properties ............................................................................ 3-4 3.4 Unmapped Sites ....................................................................................... 3-4 3.5 Regulatory Database Review Summary .................................................. 3-5

SECTION 4 SITE RECONNAISSANCE ...................................................................................................... 4-1 4.1 Site Reconnaissance ................................................................................. 4-1

4.1.1 Site 1, Vacant Lot and Billboard, 16 Lucas Street ....................... 4-1 4.1.2 Site 2, The Standard Lofts, 34 South Erie Street ......................... 4-1 4.1.3 Site 3, Parking Lot, 37 South Erie Street ..................................... 4-1 4.1.4 Site 4, Reflections Car Wash/Interior Dimensions/Vacant

Office & Warehouse, 34 & 44 Vance Street/41 & 43 Lucas Street ............................................................................................ 4-1

4.1.5 Site 5 Vacant Commercial Building, 116 South Erie Street ........ 4-1 4.1.6 Site 6, Vacant Lot, 615, 617, 623 & 625 Lafayette

Street/111 South Erie Street ......................................................... 4-2 4.1.7 Site 7, Fire-X Fire Equipment, 115, 127 & 131 South Erie

Street ............................................................................................ 4-2 4.1.8 Site 8, Vacant Lot, 139, 145 & 147 South Erie Street ................. 4-2 4.1.9 Site 9, Unknown Commercial Operation, 144 & 202 South

11th Street, 118 Wabash Street .................................................... 4-2 4.1.10 Site 10, Woodchucks Bar & Grill/Parking Lot, 630 South

11th Street .................................................................................... 4-2 4.1.11 Site 11, Unknown Commercial Operation, 37 & 39 Vance

Street 4-2 4.1.12 Positive Beginnings Inc., 29 Vance Street & 142 South Erie

Street 4-2

TABLE OF CONTENTS

K:\Projects\T\Toledo\13816761\DOCs\Environmental\Environmental Site Screening\AWT Environmental Screening Assessment.doc ii

4.1.13 Site 13, Erie Street Market, 237 South Erie Street ...................... 4-3 4.1.14 Site 14, Norfolk Southern Railroad ............................................. 4-3

SECTION 5 SUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATIONS ..................................................................................... 5-1

SECTION 6 REFERENCES...................................................................................................................... 6-1

TABLES Table ES-1 Recommended Phase I Sites

Table 1-1 Environmental Site Screening List

Table 3-1 Environmental Database Sources

Table 5-1 Recommended Phase I Sites

FIGURES Figure 1 General Location Map

Figure 2 County and City Road Map

Figure 3 Preliminary Project Plans and Recommended Phase I Sites

APPENDICES Appendix A Environmental Site Screening Checklist Forms

Appendix B ODNR Oil and Gas Well Maps

Appendix C Historical Information

Appendix D Regulatory Database Report

Appendix E Project Area Photographs

Executive Summary

K:\Projects\T\Toledo\13816761\DOCs\Environmental\Environmental Site Screening\AWT Environmental Screening Assessment.doc ES-1

URS Corporation (URS) conducted an Environmental Site Assessment (ESA) Screening to assess the environmental conditions for a City of Toledo project which includes the reconstruction and realignment of the Anthony Wayne Trail (AWT) in Toledo, Lucas County, Ohio (Project Area). The location of the Project Area is shown on Figure 1. The intent of the project is to improve physical access and the entry image of downtown Toledo. Major tasks include reconstruction of the existing pavement; redesign and reconstruction of entrance and exit ramps; modification of the existing Erie Street/Lafayette Street intersection; and urban design work including improved pedestrian linkages, gateway signage, landscaping, and bioswales. The Project Area is approximately 0.5 miles in length, extending from the AWT’s bridge over Swan Creek, through its convergence with Erie Street and the Erie Street/Lafayette Street intersection. The Project Area runs through areas used primarily for commercial and light industrial purposes. The City of Toledo will likely need to establish new right-of-ways and acquire possession of several parcels in order to complete this project.

This ESA Screening was conducted in accordance with Ohio Department of Transportation – Office of Environmental Services (ODOT-OES) guidance (2009). A total of 14 sites were investigated as part of the screening process. Based on owner, type of property and geographic location, several parcels were grouped together and assigned a Site Identification (ID) Number, as shown in Figures 2 and 3.

As a result of the investigation, six sites listed in the following table are recommended for additional environmental investigation in the form of a Phase I ESA.

TABLE ES-1 Recommended Phase I ESA Sites

Site ID Property Name Address Concerns

4 Reflections Car Wash, Interior Dimensions, Vacant Office/ Warehouse

34 - 44 Vance Street, 41 & 43 Lucas Street

Historical Petroleum Storage and Release, Former Junk Shop & Tannery Operations

5 Vacant Commercial Building 116 South Erie Street Historical Manufacturing

Operations

7 Fire-X Fire Equipment 115, 127, 131 South Erie Street

Historical Cleaner, Historical Petroleum and Hazardous Material Storage

10 Woodchucks Bar & Grill/City of Toledo Parking Lot

630 South 11th Street Former Filling Station, Historical Petroleum Storage

12 Positive Beginnings Inc. 29 Vance Street & 142 South Erie Street

Former Filling Station, Historical Petroleum Storage

13 Erie Street Market 201 & 237 South Erie Street

Historical Petroleum Storage and Release, Hazardous Material Storage, Spills

SECTIONONE Project Summary

K:\Projects\T\Toledo\13816761\DOCs\Environmental\Environmental Site Screening\AWT Environmental Screening Assessment.doc 1-1

1. Section 1 ONE Project Summary

1.1 INTRODUCTION

URS Corporation (URS) conducted an Environmental Site Assessment (ESA) Screening to assess the environmental conditions for a City of Toledo project which includes the reconstruction and realignment of the Anthony Wayne Trail (AWT) in Toledo, Lucas County, Ohio (Project Area). The location of the Project Area is shown on Figure 1. The intent of the project is to improve physical access and the entry image of downtown Toledo. Major tasks include reconstruction of the existing pavement; redesign and reconstruction of entrance and exit ramps; modification of the existing Erie Street/Lafayette Street intersection; and urban design work including improved pedestrian linkages, gateway signage, landscaping, and bioswales. The Project Area is approximately 0.5 miles in length, extending from the AWT’s bridge over Swan Creek, through its convergence with Erie Street and the Erie Street/Lafayette Street intersection. The Project Area runs through areas used primarily for commercial and light industrial purposes. The City of Toledo will likely need to establish new right-of-ways and acquire possession of several parcels in order to complete this project.

This ESA Screening was conducted in accordance with Ohio Department of Transportation – Office of Environmental Services (ODOT-OES) guidance (2009). The intent of the ESA Screening process is to identify all sites within a study area with a potential for contamination by environmentally-regulated substances (i.e. hazardous substances and/or petroleum products) and to provide sufficient investigation to develop a list of suspect sites that may require additional investigation in the form of a Phase I ESA. The primary focus of the ESA Screening involved gathering and reviewing present day and historic land use information as well as conducting a review of regulatory databases and performing a field inspection. Other relevant information such as significant physical characteristics of the area and historical information pertinent to potential site contamination issues was also evaluated as part of this ESA Screening.

The Project Area includes primarily commercial and industrial sites. Figure 1 is a General Location Map depicting a portion of the United States Geological Service (USGS), Toledo and Rossford, Ohio topographic maps. The Project Area boundaries and the 14 sites investigated are illustrated on the County and City Road Map (Figure 2) and the Preliminary Project Plans & Recommended Phase I Sites (Figure 3). The sites are identified by a Site Identification (ID) Number as shown in Figures 2 and 3. A Screening Checklist was completed for each site and is included in Appendix A. Contiguous groups of residential sites or similar sites were assigned to one Screening Checklist. Below is a summary of sites which were investigated:

TABLE 1-1 Environmental Site Screening List

Site ID Property Name Address

1 Vacant Lot with Billboard 16 Lucas Street

2 The Standard Lofts 34 South Erie Street



Site ID Property Name Address

3 Parking Lot 37 South Erie Street

4 Reflections Car Wash, Interior Dimensions, Vacant Office/ Warehouse 34 - 44 Vance Street, 41 & 43 Lucas Street

5 Vacant Commercial Building 116 South Erie Street

6 Vacant Lot 615, 617, 623, 625 Lafayette Street, 111 South Erie Street


8 Vacant Lot 139, 145, 147 South Erie Street

9 Unknown Commercial Operation, Residential

144 & 202 South 11th Street, 118 Wabash Street

10 Woodchucks Bar & Grill/City of Toledo Parking Lot 630 South 11th Street

11 Unknown Commercial Operation 37 & 39 Vance Street



14 Norfolk Southern Railroad NA

1.2 SCOPE OF SERVICES

The Scope of Services was performed in accordance with the Prime Agreement between the City of Toledo and URS dated May 31, 2013.

1.3 LIMITATIONS AND DATA GAPS

This report and the associated work have been provided in accordance with the principles and practices generally employed by the local environmental consulting profession. This is in lieu of all warranties, expressed or implied.

URS cannot warrant or guarantee that not finding indicators of hazardous materials means that hazardous materials do not exist on sites within the Project Area. There is no investigation thorough enough to preclude the presence of materials on a site, which presently, or in the future, may be considered hazardous. Because regulatory evaluation criteria are constantly changing, concentrations of contaminants present and considered to be acceptable may, in the future, become subject to different regulatory standards and require remediation.



URS has exercised due and customary care in the conduct of this ESA Screening, but has not independently verified information provided by others. Therefore, URS assumes no liability for any loss resulting from errors or omissions arising from the use of inaccurate/incomplete information or misrepresentations made by others.

SECTIONTWO Historical Records Review


2. Section 2 TWO Historical Records Review

URS reviewed various historical records including: Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR) Oil and Gas Well Maps; Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps, Topographic Maps, and Aerial Photographs to identify current and prior uses of the sites located within the Project Area.

2.1 OIL AND GAS WELL MAPS

URS searched the ODNR oil and gas well mapping website for oil and gas wells located within the project area. The ODNR Oil and Gas Well Map is included as Appendix B. The map did not indicate any active, abandoned, or plugged oil and gas wells within the Project Area or Project Area vicinity.

2.2 SANBORN FIRE INSURANCE MAPS

URS contracted Environmental Data Resources (EDR) to obtain Sanborn Fire Insurance (Sanborn) maps for the Project Area. Sanborn maps were available for the years 1888, 1895, 1904, 1936, 1951, and 1976. Copies of the Sanborn maps are included in Appendix C.

1888 – A majority of the Project Area is occupied by residential structures, commercial stores, and light industrial facilities, including lumber yards, mills, and various manufacturing operations. A furniture and refrigerator manufacturing company, a junk shop (also labeled as a former tannery), a boiler shop, and various residences are located on the northern portion of the Project Area. The southern portion of the Project Area is largely occupied by a lumber yard and residences. A rail line runs along the western portion of the Project Area.

1895 & 1904 – The Project Area is similar to the 1888 maps.

1936 - The Project Area is largely occupied by commercial and light industrial operations. The northern portion of the Project Area includes a grain and milling company, a motor freight depot, service and retail stores, and various warehouses. The southern portion of the Project Area includes a convention hall and exhibition building, a machine shop, and service and retail stores. Gasoline tanks were identified at Sites 1, 7, 10, and 12. Oil storage buildings were identified at Sites 4 and 10.

1951 – The Project Area is relatively similar to the 1936 maps.

1976 - The Project Area is largely occupied by warehouses, various commercial stores, and parking lots. The northern portion of the Project Area includes grocery and manufacturing parts warehouses, a motor freight depot, a commissary, a boiler shop, and a machine shop. The southern portion of the Project Area includes municipal shops and a restaurant. The AWT has been constructed and is depicted as intersecting with Lafayette Street and S. Michigan Street.

2.3 AERIAL PHOTOGRAPHS

URS obtained historical aerial photographs of the project area from The Lucas County Soil and Water Conservation District (SWCD). The aerial photographs were taken in 1957, 1969, and 1991. Copies of the aerial photographs are included in Appendix C.

SECTIONTWO Historical Records Review


1957 - The Project Area appears to be densely developed with commercial and/or industrial structures. South Erie Street is present on the central portion of the Project Area. A rail line runs along the western portion of the Project Area.

1969 - The Project Area is relatively similar to the 1957 aerial photograph. Interstate 75 and the Anthony Wayne Trail have been constructed to the northeast of the Project Area.

1991 - The Project Area appears similar to the 1969 aerial photograph.

2.4 HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW SUMMARY

Based on the information obtained during the historical research, the Project Area has been developed for commercial, residential, and light industrial uses since at least 1888. A rail line has been located on the western portion of the Project Area since at least 1888. Additional commercial and light industrial development began in the early 1900s through the 1950s. There were several sites of environmental concern identified in the Project Area during the historical records review. These sites include filling stations, railroads, and various manufacturing operations.

SECTIONTHREE Regulatory Database Review


3. Section 3 THREE Regulatory Database Review

3.1 REGULATORY DATABASE SEARCH

URS contracted EDR to conduct a search for facilities listed by regulatory agencies as potentially having environmental concerns. The ODOT-OES Environmental Site Assessment Screening Guidelines require a search distance of ¼ mile from the project area or corridor to identify environmental concerns. Facilities incorrectly mapped in the EDR report that are greater than ¼ mile from the search distance are excluded from the discussion in this section. The complete list of databases reviewed is provided in the EDR Report, included in Appendix D, and summarized in the table presented below. The Site Numbers identified in this section correspond to the Environmental Site Assessment Screening Checklist numbers identified in Figures 2 and 3.

It should be noted that this information is reported as URS received it from EDR, which in turn reports information as it is provided in various government databases. It is not possible for either URS or EDR to verify the accuracy or completeness of information contained in these databases. However, the use of and reliance on this information is a generally accepted practice in the conduct of environmental due diligence.

The following table summarizes the number of facilities in the site vicinity that were identified in the indicated agency databases within the indicated survey distances.

TABLE 3-1 Environmental Database Sources

Type of Database Description of Database/Effective Date Radius

Searched

Number of Sites

Identified Within

¼-mile of Project Area

Number of Sites

Identified Within Project

Area

NPL The National Priorities List (NPL) identifies uncontrolled or abandoned hazardous waste sites. To appear on the NPL, sites must have met or surpassed a predetermined hazard ranking system score, been chosen as a state's top priority site, pose a significant health or environmental threat, or be a site where the EPA has determined that remedial action is more cost-effective than removal action.

0.25 miles 0 0

CERCLIS The Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Information System (CERCLIS) database identifies hazardous waste sites that require investigation and possible remedial action to mitigate potential negative impacts on human health or the environment.

0.25 miles 2 0





Searched

Number of Sites

Identified Within


Number of Sites


Area

CERCLIS-NFRAP

CERCLIS sites designated “No Further Remedial Action Planned” (NFRAP) have been removed from CERCLIS. NFRAP sites may be sites where, following an initial investigation, no contamination was found, contamination was removed quickly without the need for the site to be placed on the NPL, or the contamination was not serious enough to require Federal Superfund action or NPL consideration.

0.25 miles 0 0

CORRACTS Listing of RCRA facilities that are undergoing corrective action. Corrective actions may be required beyond the facility’s boundary and can be required regardless of when the release occurred, even if it predates RCRA.

0.25 miles 0 0

RCRA TSD Resource Conservation & Recovery Act (RCRA) treatment, storage, or disposal (TSD) sites.

0.25 miles 0 0

RCRA Generators

RCRA-regulated hazardous waste generator notifiers list. This includes; Large, Small, and Conditionally Exempt Small Quantity Generators (LQG, SQG, and CESQG). Former RCRA Generators (Non-Generators) are also included in this list.

0.25 miles 36 1

ERNS EPA's Emergency Response Notification System (ERNS) list contains reported spill records of oil and hazardous substances.

0.25 miles 0 0

DERR The Ohio EPA Division of Emergency and Remedial Response (DERR) list of sites with known or suspected contamination.

0.25 miles 5 0

Brownfields Brownfields are real property, the expansion, redevelopment, or reuse of which may be complicated by the presence or potential presence of a hazardous substance, pollutant, or contaminant.

0.25 miles 2 0

SWLF State inventory of solid waste disposal and landfill sites.

0.25 miles 0 0

LUST List of information pertaining to all reported leaking underground storage tanks (LUST).

0.25 miles 15 2





Searched

Number of Sites

Identified Within


Number of Sites


Area

UST State registered underground storage tank (UST) sites listing. This listing includes archive UST sites.

0.25 miles 16 2

VAP The Voluntary Action Program (VAP) was created to give individuals a way to investigate possible environmental contamination, clean it up, if necessary, and receive a promise from the State of Ohio that no more clean-up is needed.

0.25 miles 2 0

OHSPILLS State registered emergency response to accidental releases, spills, and unauthorized discharges.

0.25 miles 28 2

Other databases searched in the EDR report, included various records maintained by federal, state and local agencies. The sites on these databases were evaluated by URS and determined not to have a significant adverse impact on the Project Area or are discussed in this section of the report. Facilities with poor or inadequate address information are listed in the Orphan Summary database. URS verified the location of the orphan facilities and included the facilities located in or within ¼ mile of the project area in the below discussion.

3.2 PROJECT AREA

3.2.1 RCRA Generators

One site located within the Project Area was identified as a RCRA Generator:

Erie Street Market Place, 237 South Erie Street – Site 13 is listed as a RCRA Non-Generator formerly generating hazardous waste. The site has no recorded regulatory violations. See Section 3.2.2 for further information regarding this site.

3.2.2 OH LUST

Two sites located within the Project Area were identified in the OH LUST database. These sites were listed under the Orphan Summary section of the EDR Report:

Former Automotive Shop, 38 Vance Street – This address is located on a portion of Site 4. The site was listed as having one 6,000-gallon gasoline UST, which was removed in November 2000. One recorded LUST incident, dated September 2006, is reported for the site. The Ohio Bureau of Underground Storage Tank Regulations (BUSTR) granted a No Further Action (NFA) status



to this site in 2006. Although the release has been issued a NFA, it is unknown if residual impacts remain.

Erie Street Market Place, 237 South Erie Street – Site 13 was listed as having one 8,200-gallon gasoline UST, which was removed in August 1992. One recorded LUST incident, dated September 1992, is reported for the site. BUSTR granted NFA status to this site in 2002. Although the release has been issued a NFA, it is unknown if residual impacts remain.

3.2.3 UST

Two sites located within the Project Area were identified in the OH UST database:

Former Automotive Shop, 38 Vance Street – See Section 3.2.2 for a discussion of Site 4.

Erie Street Market Place, 237 South Erie Street – See Section 3.2.2 for a discussion of Site 13.

3.2.4 OH SPILLS

A total of 5 spill incidents within the Project Area were identified in the OH SPILLS database. Three of these incidents occurred at various locations along the I-75/Anthony Wayne Trail roadway or exit/entrance ramps and involved diesel fuel and motor oil. Two of the incidents occurred at Site 13 in 2000 and 2013. The spill incidents were described as “dead fish” or “fish kill”. No further detail regarding the spills is provided.

3.2.5 Other Databases

Other databases searched in the EDR report, including non-ASTM databases, are various records maintained by federal, state and local agencies. Sites 10 and 12 were identified in the Historical Auto Stations database and Site 7 was identified in the Historical Cleaners database. There were over 100 other sites within ¼-mile of the Property listed in the Historical Auto Stations and Historical Cleaners databases. These types of facilities are typically of environmental concern due to their uses of petroleum products or solvents, respectively, however, no specific environmental issues were identified regarding these facilities. Although some of these facilities are not identified in the regulatory databases, they may have been in operation prior to major environmental regulations.

3.3 SURROUNDING PROPERTIES

The EDR report identified several facilities located outside the Project Area that are listed in regulatory databases. Based on distance, topographic location, or regulatory status, these sites were not identified as likely to pose an environmental concern to the Project Area.

3.4 UNMAPPED SITES

URS reviewed EDR’s Orphan Summary, which is a listing of sites that have not been geocoded based on lack of sufficient data regarding their exact location within the general area. None of the Unmapped Sites identified on the Orphan Summary appear to be located within the



designated radii of the Project Area, and therefore, URS has no reason to believe that these sites had an impact on the Property.

3.5 REGULATORY DATABASE REVIEW SUMMARY

The EDR Report identified three sites within the Project Area that are identified in regulatory databases that may pose an environmental concern to the project area. Historical activities conducted on the sites, as presented in the EDR report, may have resulted in subsurface contamination. These sites are summarized in the following table:

TABLE 3-1 Environmental Database Summary

Project Area

Site ID Property Name Address Database


34 - 44 Vance Street, 41 & 43 Lucas Street UST, LUST

7 Fire-X Fire Equipment 115, 127, 131 South Erie Street Historical Dry Cleaners

10 Woodchucks Bar & Grill/Parking Lot 630 South 11th Street Historical Auto Station


Historical Auto Station


RCRA Generator, UST, LUST, SPILLS,

SECTIONFOUR Site Reconnaissance


4. Section 4 FOUR Site Reconnaissance

On August 26, 2013, URS conducted a visual inspection of the Project Area. The Screening Checklists completed for each site are included in Appendix A. Figure 3 presents an overview of the Project Area, which is overlain on an aerial photograph.

4.1 SITE RECONNAISSANCE

The site reconnaissance is conducted for two purposes: 1) to inventory land use and 2) to note locations with an elevated potential for contamination. Photographs taken during the visual inspection are included in Appendix E. The Site Numbers listed below correspond to the Environmental Screening Checklist page associated with a particular parcel or group of similar parcels. Following is a discussion of the sites.

4.1.1 Site 1, Vacant Lot and Billboard, 16 Lucas Street

At the time of the site reconnaissance, this site consisted of a triangular-shaped grassy vacant lot with a billboard, located at the convergence of the Anthony Wayne Trail and Lafayette Street. No items of environmental concern were identified at the site.

4.1.2 Site 2, The Standard Lofts, 34 South Erie Street

At the time of the site reconnaissance, this site was occupied by a multi-story warehouse building which had been converted into residential loft apartments. The site included the apartment building as well as associated paved parking areas. No items of environmental concern were identified at the site.

4.1.3 Site 3, Parking Lot, 37 South Erie Street

At the time of the site reconnaissance, this site consisted of a paved parking lot, a small landscaped area, and an art sculpture. No items of environmental concern were identified at the site.

4.1.4 Site 4, Reflections Car Wash/Interior Dimensions/Vacant Office & Warehouse, 34 & 44 Vance Street/41 & 43 Lucas Street

At the time of the site reconnaissance, this site was occupied by a multi-tenant commercial/warehouse building, which included a car wash, furniture supply store, and several vacant spaces. The building was a one story structure, with a partial second story, and had brick exteriors. No items of environmental concern were identified at the site.

4.1.5 Site 5, Vacant Commercial Building, 116 South Erie Street

At the time of the site reconnaissance, this site consisted of a vacant commercial/warehouse building and associated paved parking and loading dock areas, as well as a vacant, grassy lot. The building was a two story structure with brick exteriors. No items of environmental concern were identified at the site.



4.1.6 Site 6, Vacant Lot, 615, 617, 623 & 625 Lafayette Street/111 South Erie Street

At the time of the site reconnaissance, this site consisted of a vacant grassy lot with no structures. No items of environmental concern were identified at the site.

4.1.7 Site 7, Fire-X Fire Equipment, 115, 127 & 131 South Erie Street

At the time of the reconnaissance, the site was occupied by Fire-X, which is a supplier of fire safety and suppression equipment. The site consisted of a one-story commercial/warehouse building with brick exteriors, as well as an associated gravel parking area and storage yard. No items of environmental concern were identified at the site.

4.1.8 Site 8, Vacant Lot, 139, 145 & 147 South Erie Street

At the time of the reconnaissance, the site consisted of a vacant lot. A majority of the site was concrete-paved, with the remainder being grass-covered. No items of environmental concern were identified at the site.

4.1.9 Site 9, Unknown Commercial Operation, 144 & 202 South 11th Street, 118 Wabash Street

At the time of the reconnaissance, the site was occupied by multi-tenant office/commercial/warehouse building. The building appeared to include at least two separate commercial operations; however, no signage was visible indicating specific tenants. The building also included vacant units and warehouse space. No items of environmental concern were identified at the site.

4.1.10 Site 10, Woodchucks Bar & Grill/Parking Lot, 630 South 11th Street

At the time of the reconnaissance, the southeastern portion of the site was occupied by Woodchucks Bar & Grill, a small, two-story brick building. The remainder of the site consisted of a municipal parking lot owned by the City of Toledo. No items of environmental concern were identified at the site.

4.1.11 Site 11, Unknown Commercial Operation, 37 & 39 Vance Street

At the time of the site reconnaissance, this site was occupied by a small, brick one-story commercial building. The site appeared to be an electronic equipment repair operation; however, no signage was present indicating a specific tenant or operation. No items of environmental concern were identified at the site.

4.1.12 Site 12, Positive Beginnings Inc., 29 Vance Street & 142 South Erie Street

At the time of the reconnaissance, the site consisted of a one-story commercial building, which was occupied by Positive Beginnings, Inc., a child care facility. No items of environmental concern were identified at the site.



4.1.13 Site 13, Erie Street Market, 237 South Erie Street

At the time of the reconnaissance, the site was occupied by the Erie Street Market, which included a large one-story warehouse building containing the Libbey Glass Factory Outlet, Superior Antique Mall, Civic Center Promenade, Pepe’s Restaurant, the Erie Street Chowder House, as well as an outdoor farmer’s market space. No items of environmental concern were identified at the site.

4.1.14 Site 14, Norfolk Southern Railroad

At the time of the reconnaissance, the site consisted of vacant grassy and vegetated land, which runs parallel to the Anthony Wayne Trail. The remnants of a former railroad right-of-way, including railroad lines as well as scattered rail ties, were visible at various points throughout the site. The following environmental concerns are typically associated with historical railroad operations: surface contamination resulting from spillage and/or mismanagement of petroleum products and other various chemicals used in maintenance operations; regulated railroad bedding material (slag, gravel, etc.); chemicals leaching from treated railroad crossties; oils, pesticides, and herbicides which may have been used in the maintenance of the rail lines.

SECTIONFIVE Summary and Recommendations


5. Section 5 FIVE Summary and Recommendations

URS conducted an ESA Screening to assess the environmental conditions for a City of Toledo project which includes the reconstruction and realignment of the Anthony Wayne Trail in Toledo, Lucas County, Ohio. This Screening was conducted in accordance with ODOT-OES guidance (2009). A total of 14 sites were investigated as part of the screening process. As a result of the investigation, the six sites presented in Table 5-1 are recommended for additional environmental investigation in the form of a Phase I ESA. The recommended Phase I ESA sites are identified on Figures 2 and 3.

TABLE 5-1 Recommended Phase I ESA Sites

Site ID Property Name Address Concerns


34 - 44 Vance Street, 41 & 43 Lucas Street

Historical Petroleum Storage and Release, Former Junk Shop & Tannery Operations

5 Vacant Commercial Building 116 South Erie Street Historical Manufacturing

Operations


Historical Cleaner, Historical Petroleum and Hazardous Material Storage

10 Woodchucks Bar & Grill/City of Toledo Parking Lot

630 South 11th Street Former Filling Station, Historical Petroleum Storage


Former Filling Station, Historical Petroleum Storage


Historical Petroleum Storage and Release, Hazardous Material Storage, Spills

SECTIONSIX References


6. Section 6 SIX References

EDR, 2013. The EDR DataMap Corridor Study, Anthony Wayne Trail, Toledo, Ohio 43604. Inquiry Number 3679472.2s. Environmental Data Resources, Inc. July 29, 2013.

EDR, 2013. Sanborn Fire Insurance Map Report, Anthony Wayne Trail, Toledo, Ohio. Inquiry Number 3679472.3. Environmental Data Resources, Inc. August 1, 2013.

ODNR, 2013. Ohio Oil and Gas Well Locator. http://www2.dnr.state.oh.us/website/dog/oilgasviewer/index.html. Ohio Department of Natural Resources, Division of Oil and Gas Resources. August 4, 2013.

SWCD, 2013. Historical Aerial Photographs for the Years 1957, 1969, and 1991, Toledo, Ohio 43604. Lucas County Soil and Water Conservation District. August 26, 2013.

ODOT-OES, 2009. Environmental Assessment Guidelines. Ohio Department of Transportation Office of Environmental Services. April 2009.

FIGURES

GENERAL LOCATION MAP

PROJECT

AREA

SITE LOCATION

(LUCAS COUNTY)

MY TOPO

USGS - TOLEDO

TOLEDO, OHIO

TOLEDO, OHIO

ANTHONY WAYNE TRAIL IMPROVEMENT PROJECT

1

COUNTY AND CITY ROAD MAP

2

LEGEND

#

TOLEDO, OHIO

ANTHONY WAYNE IMPROVEMENT PROJECT

PRELIMINARY PROJECT PLANS &

RECOMMENDED PHASE I SITES

3

LEGEND

#

TOLEDO, OHIO


APPENDIX A

Environmental Site Screening Checklist Forms

ENVIRONMENTAL SITE ASSESSMENT SCREENING CHECKLIST

NAME:

Jennifer Shepard

DATE: 8/26/2013

TITLE:

Environmental Scientist

DISTRICT:

2

COUNTY/ROUTE/

SECTION:

Lucas/Anthony Wayne Trail

PID:

95676

PROJECT DESCRIPTION:

Anthony Wayne Trail Reconstruction & Realignment Project, Toledo, Ohio

Parcel No./Owner/Address: 1217181/ Billboard Properties Limited /16 Lucas ST (Site ID �)

Project Right-of-Way (Row) Requirements From Parcel: No New ROW

Strip ROW

Minor Take

Whole Parcel Take

Not Available

X

LAND USE:

Current Land Use (For Commercial/Industrial land use, specify type and tenant):

Vacant Lot and Billboard

Past Land Use (For Commercial/Industrial land use, specify type and tenant):

Various commercial, former furniture manufacturing facility/lumber yard/motor freight depot

Environmental Records (Date queried) (Result)

National Priority List (NPL)

7/29/2013

No

Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Information System (CERCLIS)

7/29/2013

No

OEPA Master Site List (MSL)

7/29/2013

No

Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA)

7/29/2013

No

Bureau of Underground Storage Tank Regulation (BUSTR)

7/29/2013

No

Other State/Local Lists

7/29/2013

No

* Date of Last Government Update

NPL/CERCLIS/OEPA MSL in vicinity (type of facility and location in relation to project):

No

Visual Inspection

UST’s No Surface Staining No

AST’s No Sheens No

Drums No Damaged Vegetation No

Landfills No Odors No

Pond/Lagoon No Other(specify)

Phase I ESA required Yes No X -


NAME:

Jennifer Shepard

DATE: 8/26/2013

TITLE:


DISTRICT:

2

COUNTY/ROUTE/

SECTION:


PID:

95676



Parcel No./Owner/Address: 1215987,1899066/ Standard Lofts LLC, Norfolk Southern /34 S Erie St (Site ID �)


Strip ROW

Minor Take

Whole Parcel Take

Not Available

X

LAND USE:


The Standard Lofts


Office/warehouse building



7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

Yes



No

Visual Inspection






Phase I ESA required Yes No X


NAME:

Jennifer Shepard

DATE: 8/26/2013

TITLE:


DISTRICT:

2

COUNTY/ROUTE/

SECTION:


PID:

95676



Parcel No./Owner/Address: 1215704/ Robert W. Root, Trustee/37 South Erie Street (Site ID �)


Strip ROW

Minor Take

Whole Parcel Take

Not Available

X

LAND USE:


Parking Lot


Various commercial stores, residences



7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No



No

Visual Inspection

UST’s Yes (former) Surface Staining No




Pond/Lagoon No Other(specify) Monitoring well observed



NAME:

Jennifer Shepard

DATE: 8/26/2013

TITLE:


DISTRICT:

2

COUNTY/ROUTE/

SECTION:


PID:

95676



Parcel No./Owner/Address: 1217414,1217317,1217307/Vance Street Holdings LLC, Khoil Ltd./34 & 44 Vance St, 41

& 43 Lucas St (Site ID �)


Strip ROW

Minor Take

Whole Parcel Take

Not Available

X

LAND USE:


Reflections Car Wash, Interior Dimensions, Vacant Office/ Warehouse


Residences, various warehouses, former junk store and tannery



7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

Yes


7/29/2013

No



No

Visual Inspection






Phase I ESA required Yes X No


NAME:

Jennifer Shepard

DATE: 8/26/2013

TITLE:


DISTRICT:

2

COUNTY/ROUTE/

SECTION:


PID:

95676



Parcel No./Owner/Address: 1217194/ TLC Properties Inc./ 116 South Erie Street (Site ID �)


Strip ROW

Minor Take

Whole Parcel Take

Not Available

X

LAND USE:


Vacant Commercial Building


Residences, various warehouses, former furniture/refrigerator manufacturer



7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No



No

Visual Inspection






Phase I ESA required Yes X No X


NAME:

Jennifer Shepard

DATE: 8/26/2013

TITLE:


DISTRICT:

2

COUNTY/ROUTE/

SECTION:


PID:

95676



Parcel No./Owner/Address: 1224961,1224954,1224951,1224947,1224944/John C. Loos/ 615, 617, 623, 625

Lafayette St, 111 South Erie St (Site ID �)


Strip ROW

Minor Take

Whole Parcel Take

Not Available

X

LAND USE:


Vacant Lot


Residences, hotel, various commercial stores, parking lot



7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No



No

Visual Inspection








NAME:

Jennifer Shepard

DATE: 8/26/2013

TITLE:


DISTRICT:

2

COUNTY/ROUTE/

SECTION:


PID:

95676



Parcel No./Owner/Address: 1224964,1224974,1224977/ ABCO Fire Properties LLC /115, 127, 131 South Erie St

(Site ID �)


Strip ROW

Minor Take

Whole Parcel Take

Not Available

X

LAND USE:


Fire-X Fire Equipment


Residences, services garage, plumbing and heating co, unspecified commercial



7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

Yes



No

Visual Inspection





Pond/Lagoon No Other(specify) Historical UST



NAME:

Jennifer Shepard

DATE: 8/26/2013

TITLE:


DISTRICT:

2

COUNTY/ROUTE/

SECTION:


PID:

95676



Parcel No./Owner/Address: 1224981,1224987,1224991/Pamela O’Connell/139,145,147 South Erie St (Site ID �)


Strip ROW

Minor Take

Whole Parcel Take

Not Available

X

LAND USE:


Vacant Lot


Residences, boiler shop, unspecified commercial



7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No



No

Visual Inspection








NAME:

Jennifer Shepard

DATE: 8/26/2013

TITLE:


DISTRICT:

2

COUNTY/ROUTE/

SECTION:


PID:

95676



Parcel No./Owner/Address: 1218594,1218647,1218604/Nicholas Cisterino, Robert Tschirret Jr./ 144 & 202 South

11th Street, 118 Wabash Street (Site ID �)


Strip ROW

Minor Take

Whole Parcel Take

Not Available

X

LAND USE:


Unknown Commercial Operation, Residential


Residential, flour mill, soap maker, various warehouses, unspecified commercial



7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No



No

Visual Inspection



Drums Yes Damaged Vegetation No





NAME:

Jennifer Shepard

DATE: 8/26/2013

TITLE:


DISTRICT:

2

COUNTY/ROUTE/

SECTION:


PID:

95676



Parcel No./Owner/Address: 1217397/ The City of Toledo /630 South 11th Street (Site ID �!)


Strip ROW

Minor Take

Whole Parcel Take

Not Available

X

LAND USE:


Woodchucks Bar & Grill, municipal parking lot


Residential, machine shops, filling station, various manufacturing unspecified commercial



7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No



No

Visual Inspection








NAME:

Jennifer Shepard

DATE: 8/26/2013

TITLE:


DISTRICT:

2

COUNTY/ROUTE/

SECTION:


PID:

95676



Parcel No./Owner/Address: 1217327,1217334/Pamela O’Connell & Bradley Stough/37 & 39 Vance St (Site ID ��)


Strip ROW

Minor Take

Whole Parcel Take

Not Available

X

LAND USE:


Unknown Commercial Operation


Residence, paper warehouse



7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No



No

Visual Inspection








NAME:

Jennifer Shepard

DATE: 8/26/2013

TITLE:


DISTRICT:

2

COUNTY/ROUTE/

SECTION:


PID:

95676



Parcel No./Owner/Address: 1217247,1217227/Pamela O’Connell/29 Vance St & 142 South Erie St (Site ID ��)


Strip ROW

Minor Take

Whole Parcel Take

Not Available

X

LAND USE:


Positive Beginnings Inc.


Residence, bakery, filling station, machine shop



7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No



No

Visual Inspection








NAME:

Jennifer Shepard

DATE: 8/26/2013

TITLE:


DISTRICT:

2

COUNTY/ROUTE/

SECTION:


PID:

95676



Parcel No./Owner/Address: 1871812/CITY OF TOLEDO/201 & 237 South Erie Street (Site ID ��)


Strip ROW

Minor Take

Whole Parcel Take

Not Available

X

LAND USE:


Erie Street Market


Lumber yard



7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

Yes


7/29/2013

Yes


7/29/2013

Yes



No

Visual Inspection








NAME:

Jennifer Shepard

DATE: 8/26/2013

TITLE:


DISTRICT:

2

COUNTY/ROUTE/

SECTION:


PID:

95676



Parcel No./Owner/Address: 1899065,1899067,1899069,1899071/Norfolk Southern/No address (Site ID ��)


Strip ROW

Minor Take

Whole Parcel Take

Not Available

X

LAND USE:


Railroad line


Undeveloped



7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No


7/29/2013

No



No

Visual Inspection







APPENDIX B

ODNR Oil and Gas Well Maps

Anthony Wayne Trail

ESA Screening

Printed: Aug 28, 2013

APPENDIX C

Historical Information

Certified Sanborn® Map Report

Anthony Wayne Trail

Anthony Wayne Highway

Toledo, OH 43604

Inquiry Number: 3679472.3

August 01, 2013

1976 Certified Sanborn Map

B28

8-4E

69-A

766

Order Date:EDR Inquiry:

Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1976

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766

This Certified Sanborn Map combines the following sheets.Outlined areas indicate map sheets within the collection.

Volume 1, Sheet 9

Volume 1, Sheet 10

Volume 1, Sheet 20

Volume 1, Sheet 21

Volume 1, Sheet 22

Volume 1, Sheet 23

Volume 1, Sheet 40

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 29

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Callout

1

jennifer_shepard

Callout

2

jennifer_shepard

Callout

3

jennifer_shepard

Callout

4

jennifer_shepard

Callout

5

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14

jennifer_shepard

Callout

6


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1951

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 1, Sheet 21

Volume 1, Sheet 22

Volume 1, Sheet 23

Volume 1, Sheet 40

Volume 1, Sheet xxxx

Volume 1, Sheet 9

Volume 1, Sheet 10

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 30

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Callout

1

jennifer_shepard

Callout

2

jennifer_shepard

Callout

3

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14

jennifer_shepard

Callout

4

jennifer_shepard

Callout

5

jennifer_shepard

Callout

6

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1936

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 1, Sheet 9

Volume 1, Sheet 10

Volume 1, Sheet 21

Volume 1, Sheet 22

Volume 1, Sheet 23

Volume 1, Sheet 40

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 31

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14

jennifer_shepard

Callout

1

jennifer_shepard

Callout

4

jennifer_shepard

Callout

5

jennifer_shepard

Callout

2

jennifer_shepard

Callout

3

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Callout

6


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1904

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 1, Sheet 4

Volume 1, Sheet 5

Volume 1, Sheet 6

Volume 1, Sheet 9

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 33

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Callout

1

jennifer_shepard

Callout

2

jennifer_shepard

Callout

3

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14

jennifer_shepard

Callout

4

jennifer_shepard

Callout

5

jennifer_shepard

Callout

6


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1895

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 1, Sheet 3

Volume 1, Sheet 4

Volume 1, Sheet 9

Volume 1, Sheet 10

Volume 1, Sheet 11

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 34

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Callout

3

jennifer_shepard

Callout

2

jennifer_shepard

Callout

1

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14

jennifer_shepard

Callout

4

jennifer_shepard

Callout

5

jennifer_shepard

Callout

6


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1888

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 1, Sheet 3

Volume 1, Sheet 5

Volume 1, Sheet 21

Volume 1, Sheet 21

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 35

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14

jennifer_shepard

Callout

4

jennifer_shepard

Callout

1

jennifer_shepard

Callout

5

jennifer_shepard

Callout

6

jennifer_shepard

Callout

2

jennifer_shepard

Callout

3


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1976

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 1, Sheet 20

Volume 1, Sheet 21

Volume 1, Sheet 50

Volume 1, Sheet 51

Volume 1, Sheet 55

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 5

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14

jennifer_shepard

Callout

9


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1951

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 1, Sheet 20

Volume 1, Sheet 50

Volume 1, Sheet 54

Volume 1, Sheet 55

Volume 1, Sheet 21


0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 6

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Callout

9

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1936

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 1, Sheet 20

Volume 1, Sheet 21

Volume 1, Sheet 50

Volume 1, Sheet 54

Volume 1, Sheet 55

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 7

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14

jennifer_shepard

Callout

9


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1904

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 1, Sheet 2

Volume 1, Sheet 3

Volume 1, Sheet 5

Volume 1, Sheet 7

Volume 1, Sheet 8

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 8

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14

jennifer_shepard

Callout

9


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1895

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 1, Sheet 9

Volume 1, Sheet 12

Volume 1, Sheet 58

Volume 1, Sheet 63

Volume 1, Sheet 64

Volume 1, Sheet 68

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 9

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Callout

9

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1888

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 1, Sheet 21

Volume 1, Sheet 37

Volume 1, Sheet 22

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 10

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14

jennifer_shepard

Callout

9


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1976

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 1, Sheet 20

Volume 1, Sheet 22

Volume 1, Sheet 23

Volume 1, Sheet 24

Volume 1, Sheet 56

Volume 2, Sheet 104

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 53

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Line

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Line

jennifer_shepard

Line

jennifer_shepard

Callout

4

jennifer_shepard

Callout

5

jennifer_shepard

Callout

6

jennifer_shepard

Callout

7

jennifer_shepard

Callout

8

jennifer_shepard

Callout

9

jennifer_shepard

Callout

10

jennifer_shepard

Callout

11

jennifer_shepard

Callout

12

jennifer_shepard

Callout

13

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1951

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 2, Sheet 104

Volume 1, Sheet 20

Volume 1, Sheet 22

Volume 1, Sheet 23

Volume 1, Sheet 24

Volume 1, Sheet 56


0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 54

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Line

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Callout

4

jennifer_shepard

Callout

5

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14

jennifer_shepard

Callout

9

jennifer_shepard

Callout

13

jennifer_shepard

Callout

10

jennifer_shepard

Callout

11

jennifer_shepard

Callout

12

jennifer_shepard

Line

jennifer_shepard

Line

jennifer_shepard

Callout

6

jennifer_shepard

Callout

7

jennifer_shepard

Callout

8


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1936

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 2, Sheet 104

Volume 1, Sheet 20

Volume 1, Sheet 22

Volume 1, Sheet 23

Volume 1, Sheet 24

Volume 1, Sheet 56

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 55

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14

jennifer_shepard

Callout

4

jennifer_shepard

Callout

5

jennifer_shepard

Callout

9

jennifer_shepard

Callout

10

jennifer_shepard

Callout

11

jennifer_shepard

Callout

12

jennifer_shepard

Line

jennifer_shepard

Line

jennifer_shepard

Callout

6

jennifer_shepard

Callout

7

jennifer_shepard

Callout

8

jennifer_shepard

Callout

13


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1904

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 1, Sheet 5

Volume 1, Sheet 6

Volume 1, Sheet 8

Volume 1, Sheet 9

Volume 1, Sheet 49

Volume 1, Sheet 50

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 56

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Line

jennifer_shepard

Line

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14

jennifer_shepard

Callout

4

jennifer_shepard

Callout

5

jennifer_shepard

Callout

9

jennifer_shepard

Callout

10

jennifer_shepard

Callout

11

jennifer_shepard

Callout

12

jennifer_shepard

Callout

6

jennifer_shepard

Callout

7

jennifer_shepard

Callout

8

jennifer_shepard

Callout

13


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1895

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 1, Sheet 7

Volume 1, Sheet 8

Volume 1, Sheet 9

Volume 1, Sheet 10

Volume 1, Sheet 68

Volume 1, Sheet 70

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 57

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Line

jennifer_shepard

Line

jennifer_shepard

Callout

4

jennifer_shepard

Callout

5

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14

jennifer_shepard

Callout

9

jennifer_shepard

Callout

10

jennifer_shepard

Callout

11

jennifer_shepard

Callout

12

jennifer_shepard

Callout

6

jennifer_shepard

Callout

7

jennifer_shepard

Callout

8

jennifer_shepard

Callout

13


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1888

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 1, Sheet 20

Volume 1, Sheet 20

Volume 1, Sheet 21

Volume 1, Sheet 21

Volume 1, Sheet 22

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 58

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygon

jennifer_shepard

Polygonal Line

jennifer_shepard

Line

jennifer_shepard

Line

jennifer_shepard

Callout

4

jennifer_shepard

Callout

5

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14

jennifer_shepard

Callout

9

jennifer_shepard

Callout

10

jennifer_shepard

Callout

11

jennifer_shepard

Callout

12

jennifer_shepard

Callout

13

jennifer_shepard

Callout

6

jennifer_shepard

Callout

7

jennifer_shepard

Callout

8


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1976

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 1, Sheet 20

Volume 1, Sheet 51

Volume 1, Sheet 55

Volume 1, Sheet 56

Volume 2, Sheet 101

Volume 2, Sheet 103

Volume 2, Sheet 107

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 97

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1951

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 1, Sheet 20

Volume 1, Sheet 54

Volume 1, Sheet 55

Volume 1, Sheet 56

Volume 2, Sheet 101

Volume 2, Sheet 103

Volume 2, Sheet 107

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 98

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1936

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 1, Sheet 54

Volume 1, Sheet 55

Volume 1, Sheet 56

Volume 2, Sheet 101

Volume 2, Sheet 103

Volume 2, Sheet 107

Volume 1, Sheet 20

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 99

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1904

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 1, Sheet 3

Volume 1, Sheet 7

Volume 1, Sheet 8

Volume 1, Sheet 44

Volume 1, Sheet 45

Volume 1, Sheet 47

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 100

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1895

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 1, Sheet 12

Volume 1, Sheet 64

Volume 1, Sheet 67

Volume 1, Sheet 68

Volume 1, Sheet 69

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 101

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14


B28

8-4E

69-A

766


Client:

Site Name:

Address:

City, ST, ZIP:

Certification #

Copyright: 1888

8/1/2013 2:51:03 PM3679472.3

URS Corporation

Anthony Wayne Trail


Toledo OH 43604

B288-4E69-A766


Volume 1, Sheet 22

Volume 1, Sheet 22

0 Feet 165 330 660

3679472 - 3 page 102

jennifer_shepard

Callout

14

Aerial

Photographs

HISTORICAL AERIAL PHOTOGRAPHS

1957

LEGEND

#

TOLEDO, OHIO


jennifer_shepard

Rectangle

HISTORIC AERIAL PHOTOGRAPH

1969

LEGEND

#

TOLEDO, OHIO


jennifer_shepard

Rectangle

HISTORIC AERIAL PHOTOGRAPH

1991

LEGEND

#

TOLEDO, OHIO


jennifer_shepard

Rectangle

APPENDIX D Regulatory Database Report

FORM-BPF-TXV

®kcehCoeG htiw tropeR ™paM suidaR RDE ehT

440 Wheelers Farms RoadMilford, CT 06461Toll Free: 800.352.0050www.edrnet.com

Anthony Wayne TrailAnthony Wayne HighwayToledo, OH 43604

Inquiry Number: 3679472.2sJuly 29, 2013

SECTION PAGE

Executive Summary ES1

Overview Map 2

Detail Map 3

Map Findings Summary 4

Map Findings 8

Orphan Summary 212

Government Records Searched/Data Currency Tracking GR-1

GEOCHECK ADDENDUM

Physical Setting Source Addendum A-1

Physical Setting Source Summary A-2

Physical Setting SSURGO Soil Map A-5

Physical Setting Source Map A-10

Physical Setting Source Map Findings A-12

Physical Setting Source Records Searched A-22

TC3679472.2s Page 1

Thank you for your business.Please contact EDR at 1-800-352-0050

with any questions or comments.

Disclaimer - Copyright and Trademark Notice

This Report contains certain information obtained from a variety of public and other sources reasonably available to Environmental DataResources, Inc. It cannot be concluded from this Report that coverage information for the target and surrounding properties does not exist fromother sources. NO WARRANTY EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED, IS MADE WHATSOEVER IN CONNECTION WITH THIS REPORT. ENVIRONMENTALDATA RESOURCES, INC. SPECIFICALLY DISCLAIMS THE MAKING OF ANY SUCH WARRANTIES, INCLUDING WITHOUT LIMITATION,MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR USE OR PURPOSE. ALL RISK IS ASSUMED BY THE USER. IN NO EVENT SHALLENVIRONMENTAL DATA RESOURCES, INC. BE LIABLE TO ANYONE, WHETHER ARISING OUT OF ERRORS OR OMISSIONS, NEGLIGENCE,ACCIDENT OR ANY OTHER CAUSE, FOR ANY LOSS OF DAMAGE, INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION, SPECIAL, INCIDENTAL,CONSEQUENTIAL, OR EXEMPLARY DAMAGES. ANY LIABILITY ON THE PART OF ENVIRONMENTAL DATA RESOURCES, INC. IS STRICTLYLIMITED TO A REFUND OF THE AMOUNT PAID FOR THIS REPORT. Purchaser accepts this Report "AS IS". Any analyses, estimates, ratings,environmental risk levels or risk codes provided in this Report are provided for illustrative purposes only, and are not intended to provide, norshould they be interpreted as providing any facts regarding, or prediction or forecast of, any environmental risk for any property. Only a Phase IEnvironmental Site Assessment performed by an environmental professional can provide information regarding the environmental risk for anyproperty. Additionally, the information provided in this Report is not to be construed as legal advice.

Copyright 2013 by Environmental Data Resources, Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction in any media or format, in wholeor in part, of any report or map of Environmental Data Resources, Inc., or its affiliates, is prohibited without prior written permission.

EDR and its logos (including Sanborn and Sanborn Map) are trademarks of Environmental Data Resources, Inc. or its affiliates. All othertrademarks used herein are the property of their respective owners.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

TC3679472.2s EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1

A search of available environmental records was conducted by Environmental Data Resources, Inc (EDR).The report was designed to assist parties seeking to meet the search requirements of EPA’s Standardsand Practices for All Appropriate Inquiries (40 CFR Part 312), the ASTM Standard Practice forEnvironmental Site Assessments (E 1527-05) or custom requirements developed for the evaluation ofenvironmental risk associated with a parcel of real estate.

TARGET PROPERTY INFORMATION

ADDRESS

ANTHONY WAYNE HIGHWAYTOLEDO, OH 43604

COORDINATES

41.6461000 - 41˚ 38’ 45.96’’Latitude (North): 83.5471000 - 83˚ 32’ 49.56’’Longitude (West): Zone 17Universal Tranverse Mercator: 287876.4UTM X (Meters): 4613405.5UTM Y (Meters): 598 ft. above sea levelElevation:

USGS TOPOGRAPHIC MAP ASSOCIATED WITH TARGET PROPERTY

41083-F5 TOLEDO, OH MITarget Property Map:1980Most Recent Revision:

AERIAL PHOTOGRAPHY IN THIS REPORT

2011Photo Year:USDASource:

TARGET PROPERTY SEARCH RESULTS

The target property was not listed in any of the databases searched by EDR.

DATABASES WITH NO MAPPED SITES

No mapped sites were found in EDR’s search of available ("reasonably ascertainable ") governmentrecords either on the target property or within the search radius around the target property for thefollowing databases:

STANDARD ENVIRONMENTAL RECORDS

Federal NPL site list

NPL National Priority List

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY


Proposed NPL Proposed National Priority List SitesNPL LIENS Federal Superfund Liens

Federal Delisted NPL site list

Delisted NPL National Priority List Deletions

Federal CERCLIS list

FEDERAL FACILITY Federal Facility Site Information listing

Federal CERCLIS NFRAP site List

CERC-NFRAP CERCLIS No Further Remedial Action Planned

Federal RCRA CORRACTS facilities list

CORRACTS Corrective Action Report

Federal RCRA non-CORRACTS TSD facilities list

RCRA-TSDF RCRA - Treatment, Storage and Disposal

Federal RCRA generators list

RCRA-LQG RCRA - Large Quantity Generators

Federal institutional controls / engineering controls registries

US ENG CONTROLS Engineering Controls Sites ListUS INST CONTROL Sites with Institutional ControlsLUCIS Land Use Control Information System

Federal ERNS list

ERNS Emergency Response Notification System

State- and tribal - equivalent CERCLIS

OH SHWS This state does not maintain a SHWS list. See the Federal CERCLIS list and Federal NPL list.

State and tribal landfill and/or solid waste disposal site lists

OH SWF/LF Licensed Solid Waste Facilities

State and tribal leaking storage tank lists

INDIAN LUST Leaking Underground Storage Tanks on Indian Land

State and tribal registered storage tank lists

INDIAN UST Underground Storage Tanks on Indian LandFEMA UST Underground Storage Tank Listing

State and tribal institutional control / engineering control registries

OH ENG CONTROLS Sites with Engineering Controls

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY


OH INST CONTROL Sites with Institutional Engineering ControlsOH HIST INST CONTROLS Institutional Controls DatabaseOH HIST ENG CONTROLS Operation & Maintenance Agreements Database

State and tribal voluntary cleanup sites

INDIAN VCP Voluntary Cleanup Priority Listing

State and tribal Brownfields sites

OH BROWNFIELDS Ohio Brownfield Inventory

ADDITIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL RECORDS

Local Lists of Landfill / Solid Waste Disposal Sites

ODI Open Dump InventoryDEBRIS REGION 9 Torres Martinez Reservation Illegal Dump Site LocationsOH SWRCY Recycling Facility ListingOH HIST LF Old Solid Waste LandfillINDIAN ODI Report on the Status of Open Dumps on Indian Lands

Local Lists of Hazardous waste / Contaminated Sites

US CDL Clandestine Drug LabsOH CDL Clandestine Drug Lab LocationsUS HIST CDL National Clandestine Laboratory Register

Local Land Records

LIENS 2 CERCLA Lien Information

Records of Emergency Release Reports

HMIRS Hazardous Materials Information Reporting SystemOH SPILLS 90 SPILLS 90 data from FirstSearchOH SPILLS 80 SPILLS 80 data from FirstSearch

Other Ascertainable Records

DOT OPS Incident and Accident DataDOD Department of Defense SitesFUDS Formerly Used Defense SitesCONSENT Superfund (CERCLA) Consent DecreesROD Records Of DecisionUMTRA Uranium Mill Tailings SitesUS MINES Mines Master Index FileTRIS Toxic Chemical Release Inventory SystemTSCA Toxic Substances Control ActFTTS FIFRA/ TSCA Tracking System - FIFRA (Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, & Rodenticide Act)/TSCA (Toxic Substances Control Act)HIST FTTS FIFRA/TSCA Tracking System Administrative Case ListingSSTS Section 7 Tracking SystemsICIS Integrated Compliance Information System

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY


PADS PCB Activity Database SystemMLTS Material Licensing Tracking SystemRADINFO Radiation Information DatabaseRAATS RCRA Administrative Action Tracking SystemRMP Risk Management PlansOH TOWNGAS DERR Towngas DatabaseOH UIC Underground Injection Wells ListingOH NPDES NPDES General Permit ListOH AIRS Title V Permits ListingINDIAN RESERV Indian ReservationsSCRD DRYCLEANERS State Coalition for Remediation of Drycleaners ListingOH CRO Cessation of Regulated Operations Facility ListingOH COAL ASH Coal Ash Disposal Site ListingOH Financial Assurance Financial Assurance Information ListingUS FIN ASSUR Financial Assurance InformationEPA WATCH LIST EPA WATCH LISTPRP Potentially Responsible PartiesPCB TRANSFORMER PCB Transformer Registration Database2020 COR ACTION 2020 Corrective Action Program ListCOAL ASH DOE Steam-Electric Plant Operation DataCOAL ASH EPA Coal Combustion Residues Surface Impoundments ListLEAD SMELTERS Lead Smelter Sites

SURROUNDING SITES: SEARCH RESULTS

Surrounding sites were identified in the following databases.

Elevations have been determined from the USGS Digital Elevation Model and should be evaluated ona relative (not an absolute) basis. Relative elevation information between sites of close proximityshould be field verified. Sites with an elevation equal to or higher than the target property have beendifferentiated below from sites with an elevation lower than the target property.Page numbers and map identification numbers refer to the EDR Radius Map report where detaileddata on individual sites can be reviewed.

Sites listed in bold italics are in multiple databases.

Unmappable (orphan) sites are not considered in the foregoing analysis.

STANDARD ENVIRONMENTAL RECORDS

Federal CERCLIS list

CERCLIS: The Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Information Systemcontains data on potentially hazardous waste sites that have been reported to the USEPA by states,municipalities, private companies and private persons, pursuant to Section 103 of the ComprehensiveEnvironmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act (CERCLA). CERCLIS contains sites which are eitherproposed to or on the National Priorities List (NPL) and sites which are in the screening and assessment phasefor possible inclusion on the NPL.

A review of the CERCLIS list, as provided by EDR, and dated 02/04/2013 has revealed that there are 2 CERCLIS sites within approximately 0.25 miles of the target property.

PageMap IDDirection / Distance Address Equal/Higher Elevation ____________________ ________ ___________________ _____ _____

PLABELL RUBBER MANUFACTURING S 300 S SAINT CLAIR ST. SE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.212 mi.) AL240 161

PageMap IDDirection / Distance Address Lower Elevation ____________________ ________ ___________________ _____ _____

TOLEDO COAL GAS PLANT 328 SOUTH ERIE STREET SE 0 - 1/8 (0.110 mi.) M88 77

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY


Federal RCRA generators list

RCRA-SQG: RCRAInfo is EPA’s comprehensive information system, providing access to data supportingthe Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) of 1976 and the Hazardous and Solid Waste Amendments (HSWA)of 1984. The database includes selective information on sites which generate, transport, store, treat and/ordispose of hazardous waste as defined by the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA). Small quantitygenerators (SQGs) generate between 100 kg and 1,000 kg of hazardous waste per month.

A review of the RCRA-SQG list, as provided by EDR, and dated 02/12/2013 has revealed that there are 10 RCRA-SQG sites within approximately 0.25 miles of the target property.


SALVATION ARMY 131 BELMONT ST 0 - 1/8 (0.000 mi.) A1 8 ROCKYS 34 N 11TH ST NNE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.146 mi.) AA161 118 LUCAS METRO HOUSING AUTHORITY 435 NEBRASKA W 1/8 - 1/4 (0.199 mi.) AF216 152 TAYLOR BUICK INC 1211 MONROE ST NNE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.236 mi.) AS287 191 ELTRA CORP PRIVATE TRUCK FLEET 511 HAMILTON ST WSW 1/8 - 1/4 (0.250 mi.) AT313 208


ROOT OUTDOOR ADVERTISING INC 21 S ERIE 0 - 1/8 (0.000 mi.) E7 12 TIBBET INC 155 S SUPERIOR ST E 0 - 1/8 (0.070 mi.) 51 53 CITY OF TOLEDO 401 S ERIE S 1/8 - 1/4 (0.148 mi.) W163 121 LASALLE CLEANERS, INC. 922 JEFFERSON AVE. NE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.226 mi.) AO273 182 WEBB CORP 425 JEFFERSON AVE ENE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.248 mi.) 310 204

RCRA-CESQG: RCRAInfo is EPA’s comprehensive information system, providing access to data supportingthe Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) of 1976 and the Hazardous and Solid Waste Amendments (HSWA)of 1984. The database includes selective information on sites which generate, transport, store, treat and/ordispose of hazardous waste as defined by the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA). Conditionallyexempt small quantity generators (CESQGs) generate less than 100 kg of hazardous waste, or less than 1 kg ofacutely hazardous waste per month.

A review of the RCRA-CESQG list, as provided by EDR, and dated 02/12/2013 has revealed that there are 13 RCRA-CESQG sites within approximately 0.25 miles of the target property.


ST PATRICK’S HISTORIC DOWNTOWN 130 AVONDALE AVE NNE 0 - 1/8 (0.020 mi.) A31 23 XEROX CORPORATION 801 WASHINGTON ST NE 0 - 1/8 (0.038 mi.) H38 28 TOLEDO CLUTCH AND BRAKE SERVIC 200 INDIANA AVENUE N 1/8 - 1/4 (0.148 mi.) AB166 124 RIVEREAST CUSTOM CABINETS INC 221 S ST CLAIR ST SE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.168 mi.) AC183 142 STARR AUTOBODY & SERVICE 117 N ELEVENTH ST NNE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.223 mi.) AK257 173 PRESTOLITE ELECTRIC INC 511 HAMILTON ST WSW 1/8 - 1/4 (0.250 mi.) AT312 206


GILBERT MAIL SERVICE 601 MONROE ST ENE 0 - 1/8 (0.099 mi.) Q78 67 OHIO BELL TELEPHONE CO - L5310 121 HURON ST ENE 0 - 1/8 (0.123 mi.) Q99 89 QUILTER ENVIRONMENTAL CENTER 348 S ERIE ST SE 0 - 1/8 (0.125 mi.) T105 93 OHIO BELL TELEPHONE CO - L5312 130 N ERIE ST NE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.125 mi.) N107 97 WGTE TV-FM 136 HURON ST ENE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.139 mi.) Q156 115 COMMODORE PERRY APARTMENTS 505 JEFFERSON AVE ENE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.220 mi.) AM254 171 U S POSTAL SERVICE 435 S ST CLAIR ST SSE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.244 mi.) AQ301 196

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY


State- and tribal - equivalent CERCLIS

OH DERR: The DERR database is an index of sites for which Ohio EPA maintains files. It includessites with known or suspected contamination, but a site’s inclusion in the database does not mean that it isnow or has ever been contaminated.

A review of the OH DERR list, as provided by EDR, and dated 05/03/2013 has revealed that there are 5 OH DERR sites within approximately 0.25 miles of the target property.


PLABELL RUBBER CO, TOLEDO 300 S ST CLAIR ST SE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.212 mi.) AL241 162Activity: COF


LINVER KRIPKE, TOLEDO 628 S FIFTEENTH ST NNW 0 - 1/8 (0.058 mi.) I48 52Activity: SA

TOLEDO CITY OF USD PART 2 328 S ERIE ST SE 0 - 1/8 (0.110 mi.) M90 79 COLUMBIA GAS OF OHIO TOLEDO SE 333 SOUTH ERIE ST SE 0 - 1/8 (0.117 mi.) M98 88

Activity: COF, VAP

MIDDLEGROUNDS, TOLEDO WASHINGTON & OTTAWA STSE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.243 mi.) AR298 195

State and tribal leaking storage tank lists

OH LUST: The Leaking Underground Storage Tank Incident Reports contain an inventory of reportedleaking underground storage tank incidents. The data come from the Department of Commerce Division of StateFire Marshal’s List of Reported Petroleum Underground Storage Tank Release Incidents.

A review of the OH LUST list, as provided by EDR, and dated 05/20/2013 has revealed that there are 17 OH LUST sites within approximately 0.25 miles of the target property.


PAUL LORENZEN 25 N ONTARIO NE 0 - 1/8 (0.038 mi.) H44 48FR Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further ActionFacility Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further Action

SALVATION ARMY 27 MOORISH NE 0 - 1/8 (0.062 mi.) K49 52FR Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further ActionFacility Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further Action

TOLEDO CLUTCH & BRAKE 200 INDIANA AVE N 1/8 - 1/4 (0.148 mi.) AB165 123FR Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further ActionFacility Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further Action

PLABELL RUBBER CO, TOLEDO 300 S ST CLAIR ST SE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.212 mi.) AL241 162FR Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further ActionFacility Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further Action


FORMER AUTOMOTIVE SHOP 38 VANCE ST 0 - 1/8 (0.000 mi.) B13 15FR Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further ActionFacility Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further Action

UNK 237 S ERIE ST E 0 - 1/8 (0.016 mi.) G28 22FR Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further ActionFacility Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further Action

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY



AL PEAKE & SONS PRODUCE 139 S HURON ST E 0 - 1/8 (0.021 mi.) 32 24FR Status: Active FR Status: T1S: Tier 1 Source InvestigationFacility Status: Active FR Status: T1S: Tier 1 Source Investigation

SUPREME BUMPERS INC 420 S. 15TH ST. NW 0 - 1/8 (0.038 mi.) I42 33FR Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further ActionFacility Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further Action

COLUMBIA GAS OF OHIO, INC. 313 S ERIE ST ESE 0 - 1/8 (0.083 mi.) M57 56FR Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further ActionFacility Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further Action

TRUE NORTH # 518 822 MONROE ST NE 0 - 1/8 (0.104 mi.) R80 68FR Status: Inactive FR Status: DIS: a release is disprovedFacility Status: Inactive FR Status: DIS: a release is disproved

BOWSER-MORNER, INC. 122 S ST CLAIR ST E 0 - 1/8 (0.107 mi.) U86 75FR Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further ActionFacility Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further Action

CANNON PAPER CO 152 HAMILTON ST S 0 - 1/8 (0.116 mi.) W93 81FR Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further ActionFacility Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further Action

FORMER WESTERN UNION BUILDING 140 N HURON ST ENE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.142 mi.) 160 118FR Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further ActionFacility Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further Action

WATER DEPARTMENT 401 S ERIE ST S 1/8 - 1/4 (0.149 mi.) W167 131FR Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further ActionFacility Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further Action

MANAHAN BLDG 110 OTTAWA ST E 1/8 - 1/4 (0.223 mi.) AN260 176FR Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further ActionFacility Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further Action

UNITED STATES POSTAL SERVICE 435 S SAINT CLAIR ST SSE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.244 mi.) AQ302 198FR Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further ActionFacility Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further Action

PROCARE AUTOMOTIVE SERVICE SOL 1001 JEFFERSON AVE NNE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.245 mi.) AO305 202FR Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further ActionFacility Status: Inactive FR Status: NFA: No Further Action

OH UNREG LTANKS: A suspected or confirmed release of petroleum from a non-regulated UST.

A review of the OH UNREG LTANKS list, as provided by EDR, and dated 08/25/1999 has revealed that there are 2 OH UNREG LTANKS sites within approximately 0.25 miles of the target property.


FORMER CIVIC AUDITORIUM 237 S ERIE ST (N PARKIN E 0 - 1/8 (0.015 mi.) G24 19Facility Status: RPT

VACANT WAREHOUSE 11 OTTAWA ST E 1/8 - 1/4 (0.238 mi.) AR289 193Facility Status: RPT

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY


State and tribal registered storage tank lists

OH UST: The Underground Storage Tank database contains registered USTs. USTs are regulated underSubtitle I of the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA). The data come from the Department of CommerceDivision of State Fire Marshal’s Facility File.

A review of the OH UST list, as provided by EDR, and dated 05/20/2013 has revealed that there are 6 OH UST sites within approximately 0.25 miles of the target property.


OWENS CORNING WORLD HQ ONE OWENS CORNING PKWYNE 0 - 1/8 (0.037 mi.) H36 27 LUCAS METRO HOUSING 201 BELMONT AVE NNE 0 - 1/8 (0.043 mi.) F46 49


TRUE NORTH # 518 822 MONROE ST NE 0 - 1/8 (0.104 mi.) R80 68 OHIO BELL TELEPHONE CO - L5312 130 N ERIE ST NE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.125 mi.) N107 97 WATER DEPARTMENT 401 S ERIE ST S 1/8 - 1/4 (0.149 mi.) W167 131 UNITED STATES POSTAL SERVICE 435 S SAINT CLAIR ST SSE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.244 mi.) AQ302 198

State and tribal voluntary cleanup sites

OH VCP: Ohio EPA, Voluntary Action Program Sites.

A review of the OH VCP list, as provided by EDR, and dated 11/14/2012 has revealed that there are 2 OH VCP sites within approximately 0.25 miles of the target property.


TOLEDO CITY OF USD PART 2 328 S ERIE ST SE 0 - 1/8 (0.110 mi.) M90 79 COLUMBIA GAS OF OHIO TOLEDO SE 333 SOUTH ERIE ST SE 0 - 1/8 (0.117 mi.) M98 88

ADDITIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL RECORDS

Local Brownfield lists

US BROWNFIELDS: The EPA’s listing of Brownfields properties from the Cleanups in My Community program,which provides information on Brownfields properties for which information is reported back to EPA, as well asareas served by Brownfields grant programs.

A review of the US BROWNFIELDS list, as provided by EDR, and dated 12/10/2012 has revealed that there are 2 US BROWNFIELDS sites within approximately 0.25 miles of the target property.


PLABELL RUBBER 300 S. ST. CLAIR STREET SE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.212 mi.) AL243 166


PARK-LIKE PROJECT 111 OTTAWA ST. E 1/8 - 1/4 (0.225 mi.) AN270 179

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY


Local Lists of Registered Storage Tanks

OH ARCHIVE UST: Underground storage tank records that have been removed from the Underground Storage Tankdatabase.

A review of the OH ARCHIVE UST list, as provided by EDR, and dated 05/20/2013 has revealed that there are 19 OH ARCHIVE UST sites within approximately 0.25 miles of the target property.


OWENS CORNING WORLD HQ ONE OWENS CORNING PKWYNE 0 - 1/8 (0.037 mi.) H36 27 PAUL LORENZEN 25 N ONTARIO NE 0 - 1/8 (0.038 mi.) H44 48 LUCAS METRO HOUSING 201 BELMONT AVE NNE 0 - 1/8 (0.043 mi.) F46 49 VACANT FACILITY 131 INDIANA AVE NNE 0 - 1/8 (0.109 mi.) S87 76 TOLEDO CLUTCH & BRAKE 200 INDIANA AVE N 1/8 - 1/4 (0.148 mi.) AB165 123 PLABELL RUBBER CO, TOLEDO 300 S ST CLAIR ST SE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.212 mi.) AL241 162


FORMER AUTOMOTIVE SHOP 38 VANCE ST 0 - 1/8 (0.000 mi.) B13 15 UNK 237 S ERIE ST E 0 - 1/8 (0.016 mi.) G28 22 AL PEAKE & SONS PRODUCE 139 S HURON ST E 0 - 1/8 (0.021 mi.) 32 24 FORMER FORT MEIGS AUTO ELECTRI 1 NORTH HURON ENE 0 - 1/8 (0.038 mi.) J39 30 SUPREME BUMPERS INC 420 S. 15TH ST. NW 0 - 1/8 (0.038 mi.) I42 33 COLUMBIA GAS OF OHIO, INC. 313 S ERIE ST ESE 0 - 1/8 (0.083 mi.) M57 56 TRUE NORTH # 518 822 MONROE ST NE 0 - 1/8 (0.104 mi.) R80 68 BOWSER-MORNER, INC. 122 S ST CLAIR ST E 0 - 1/8 (0.107 mi.) U86 75 OHIO BELL TELEPHONE CO - L5312 130 N ERIE ST NE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.125 mi.) N107 97 FORMER WESTERN UNION BUILDING 140 N HURON ST ENE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.142 mi.) 160 118 WATER DEPARTMENT 401 S ERIE ST S 1/8 - 1/4 (0.149 mi.) W167 131 UNITED STATES POSTAL SERVICE 435 S SAINT CLAIR ST SSE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.244 mi.) AQ302 198 PROCARE AUTOMOTIVE SERVICE SOL 1001 JEFFERSON AVE NNE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.245 mi.) AO305 202

Records of Emergency Release Reports

OH SPILLS: The Spills Database comes from the Ohio EPA.

A review of the OH SPILLS list, as provided by EDR, and dated 12/31/2012 has revealed that there are 40 OH SPILLS sites within approximately 0.25 miles of the target property.


UNK 913 WASHINGTON ST REAR NE 0 - 1/8 (0.073 mi.) K52 55 UNK 340 HYATT WSW 0 - 1/8 (0.087 mi.) 63 61 SPECIAL TRANSPORT SERVICES I75 SB AT EXIT 201 NW 0 - 1/8 (0.124 mi.) 102 91 ABLE CONCRETE & BUILDERS SPENCER ST & 700 MILL S SSW 1/8 - 1/4 (0.142 mi.) 159 117 TOLEDO CLUTCH AND BRAKE CO N/A N 1/8 - 1/4 (0.153 mi.) AB170 133 UNK LOGAN & S ERIE ST S 1/8 - 1/4 (0.161 mi.) Y176 137 KACANDES INCORPORATED LOGAN ST. & ERIE ST. S 1/8 - 1/4 (0.161 mi.) Y177 138 KUHLMAN CORP ERIE & LOGAN ST S 1/8 - 1/4 (0.163 mi.) Y181 140 TOLEDO WWTP 239 INDIANA AVE N 1/8 - 1/4 (0.170 mi.) AB185 144 LUCAS COUNTY CHILD SUPPORT ENF 1000 MONROE ST NNE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.172 mi.) AG187 144 EAGLE EXPRESS LINE 435 SOUTH ST CLAIR SSE 1/8 - 1/4 (0.244 mi.) AQ304 201


UNK 175 S NORTH ANTHONY WAY 0 - 1/8 (0.000 mi.) C4 10

Documents

APPENDIX – J · Because regulatory evaluation criteria are constantly changing, concentrations of contaminants present and considered to be acceptable may, ... TOLEDO CITY OF USD