Appendices

Appendix-1 Member List of the Study Team (1) Field Survey

1. Dr. Yoshiko TSUYUKI Team Leader/ Technical Advisor

Technical Official, Experts Service Division, Bureau of International Cooperation International Medical Center of Japan, Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare

2. Mr. Hideo EGUCHI Security Control Planner

Deputy Resident Representative, United Kingdom Office (JICA)

3. Mr. Yoshimasa TAKEMURA Project Coordinator Staff, Second Management Division, Grant Aid Management Department (JICA)

4. Mr. Yoshiharu HIGUCHI Project Manager CRC Overseas Cooperation Inc. 5. Dr. Tomoyuki KURODA Health Sector Surveyor CRC Overseas Cooperation Inc. 6. Mr. Hiroshi MORII Equipment Planner CRC Overseas Cooperation Inc. 7. Mr. Haruo ITO Equipment Planner /

Cost and Procurement Planner

CRC Overseas Cooperation Inc.

8. Ms. Rusudan PIRVELI Interpreter CRC Overseas Cooperation Inc. (2) Explanation of Draft Report

1. Dr. Yoshiko TSUYUKI Team Leader/ Technical Advisor

Technical Official, Experts Service Division, Bureau of International Cooperation International Medical Center of Japan, Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare

2. Mr. Yoshimasa TAKEMURA Project Coordinator Staff, Second Management Division, Grant Aid Management Department (JICA)

3. Mr. Yoshiharu HIGUCHI Project Manager CRC Overseas Cooperation Inc. 4. Mr. Hiroshi MORII Equipment Planner CRC Overseas Cooperation Inc. 5. Ms. Rusudan PIRVELI Interpreter CRC Overseas Cooperation Inc.

A-1

Appendix-2 Study Schedule

(1) Field Survey No. Date Movement Activities Accommodation 1 Apr. 5 (Sat) Narita→Frankfurt

(A) (B) (D) Frankfurt

(A) (C) (D) 2 Apr. 6 (Sun) Frankfurt→Baku

(A) (C) (D) Baku (A) (C) (D)

3 Apr. 7 (Mon) Baku→A) (C) (D) London→(B) Narita→Vienna→ (F) (G)

Visit the Embassy of Japan in Baku (A) (C) (D)

Train (A) (C) (D) Flight (B) (F) (G)

4 Apr. 8 (Tue) →Tbilisi (A) (B) (C) (D) (F) (G)

Ministry of Labor, Health and Social Affairs, Explanation of Inception Report (A) (B) (C) (D) (F) (G) (H)

Tbilisi (A) (B) (C) (D) (F) (G) (H)

5 Apr. 9 (Wed) Ministry of Labor, Health and Social Affairs, Explanation of Inception Report, Site survey (A) (B) (C) (D) (F) (G) (H)

Tbilisi (A) (B) (C) (D) (F) (G) (H)

6 Apr. 10 (Thu) Site survey (A) (B) (C) (D) (F) (G) (H)

Tbilisi (A) (B) (C) (D) (F) (G) (H)

7 Apr. 11 (Fri) Narita→Vienna→ (E)

Study with Fund, World Bank, Ministry of Labor, Health and Social Affairs (A) (B) (C) (D) (F) (G) (H)

Tbilisi (A) (B) (C) (D) (F) (G) (H)

8 Apr. 12 (Sat) Tbilisi→London (B) →Tbilisi (E)

Site survey (A) (B) (C) (D) (E) (F) (G) (H)

Tbilisi (A) (C) (D) (E) (F) (G) (H)

9 Apr. 13 (Sun) Meeting (A) (C) (D) (E) (F) (G) (H) Tbilisi (A) (C) (D) (E) (F) (G) (H)

10 Apr. 14 (Mon) Discussion of Minutes of Discussion (A) (C) (D) (H) Site survey (E) (F) (G)

Tbilisi (A) (C) (D) (E) (F) (G) (H)

11 Apr. 15 (Tue) Tbilisi→ (A) (C) Signing of Minutes of Discussion Visit the Central Children’s Hospital and Cardio Center (A) (C) (D) (E) (F) (G) (H) Site Survey (D) (E) (F) (G) (H)

Tbilisi (D) (E) (F) (G) (H) Train (A) (C)

12 Apr. 16 (Wed) →Baku (A) (C) Visit the Embassy of Japan in Baku (A) (C) Site survey (D) (E) (F) (G) (H)

Baku (A) (C) Tbilisi (E) (F) Kutaisi (D) (G) (H)

13 Apr. 17 (Thu) Baku→London→ (A) (C)

Site survey (D) (E) (F) (G) (H) Tbilisi (E) (F) Kutaisi (D) (G) (H) Flight (A) (C)

14 Apr. 18 (Fri) →Narita (A) (C)

Site survey (D) (E) (F) (G) (H) Tbilisi (E) (F) Kutaisi (D) (G) (H)

15 Apr. 19 (Sat) Site survey (D) (E) (F) (G) (H) Tbilisi (E) (F) Kutaisi (D) (G) (H)

16 Apr. 20 (Sun) Site survey (D) (E) (F) (G) (H) Tbilisi (E) (F) Kutaisi (D) (G) (H)

17 Apr. 21 (Mon) Site survey (D) (E) (F) (G) (H) Tbilisi (E) (F) Kutaisi (D) (G) (H)

18 Apr. 22 (Tue) Site survey (D) (E) (F) (G) (H) Tbilisi (E) (F) Batumi (D) (G) (H)

A-2

19 Apr. 23 (Wed) Site survey (D) (E) (F) (G) (H) Tbilisi (E) (F) Batumi (D) (G) (H)

20 Apr. 24 (Thu) Site survey (D) (E) (F) (G) (H) Tbilisi (E) (F) Batumi (D) (G) (H)

21 Apr. 25 (Fri) Site survey (D) (E) (F) (G) (H) Tbilisi (E) (F) Ozurgeti (D) (G) (H)

22 Apr. 26 (Sat) Site survey (D) (E) (F) (G) (H) Tbilisi (E) (F) Kutaisi (D) (G) (H)

23 Apr. 27 (Sun) Site survey (D) (E) (F) (G) (H) Tbilisi (D) (E) (F) (G) (H)

24 Apr. 28 (Mon) Site survey (D) (E) (F) (G) (H) Tbilisi (D) (E) (F) (G) (H)

25 Apr. 29 (Tue) Site survey (D) (E) (F) (G) (H) Tbilisi (D) (E) (F) (G) (H)

26 Apr. 30 (Wed) Site survey (D) (E) (F) (G) (H) Akhartsikhe (D) (H) Tbilisi (E) (F) (G)

27 May 1 (Thu) Tbilisi→Vienna→ (E)

Site survey (D) (F) (G) (H)

Akhartsikhe (D) (H) Tbilisi (F) (G) Flight (E)

28 May 2 (Fri) →Kansai→Haneda (E)

Site survey (D) (F) (G) (H) Tbilisi (D) (F) (G) (H)

29 May 3 (Sat) Site survey (D) (F) (G) (H) Tbilisi (D) (F) (G) (H) 30 May 4 (Sun) Survey for internal transportation

(D) (F) (G) (H) Tbilisi (D) (F) (G) (H)

31 May 5 (Mon) Site survey (D) (F) (D) (G) (H) Tbilisi (D) (F) (G) (H) 32 May 6 (Tue) Site survey (D) (G) (H) (F) Tbilisi (D) (F) (G) (H) 33 May 7 (Wed) Ministry of Labor, Health and Social

Affairs, report of site survey (D) (H) Site survey (F) (G)

Tbilisi (D) (F) (G) (H)

34 May 8 (Thu) Tbilisi→Baku (D) Tbilisi→Vienna→ (F)

Survey for procurement (G) (H) Baku (D) Flight (F) Tbilisi (G) (H)

35 May 9 (Fri) →Kansai→Haneda (F)

Survey for procurement (D) (G) (H) Visit the Embassy of Japan in Baku (D)

Baku (D) Tbilisi (G) (H)

36 May 10 (Sat) Baku→Istanbul→ (D) Tbilisi→Vienna→ (G)

Flight (D) (G)

37 May 11 (Sun) →Narita (D) (G) (A) Team Leader/Technical Advisor, (B) Security Control Planner, (C) Project Coordinator, (D) Project Manager, (E) Health Sector Surveyor, (F) Equipment Planner, (G) Equipment Planner / Cost and Procurement Planner, (H) Interpreter

A-3

(2) Explanation of Draft Report No. Date Movement Activities Accommodation 1 Jun. 27 (Fri) Narita→Vienna→

(C) (D) Flight (C) (D)

2 Jun. 28 (Sat) →Tbilisi (C) (D)

Ministry of Labor, Health and Social Affairs, Explanation of Draft Report (C) (D) (E)

Tbilisi (C) (D) (E)

3 Jun. 29 (Sun) Site survey (C) (D) Tbilisi (C) (D) 4 Jun. 30 (Mon) Ministry of Labor, Health and Social

Affairs, Explanation of Draft Report (C) (D) (E)

Tbilisi (C) (D) (E)

5 Jul. 1 (Tue) Ministry of Labor, Health and Social Affairs, Explanation of Draft Report (C) (D) (E)

Tbilisi (C) (D) (E)

6 Jul. 2 (Wed) World Bank, Discussion of the Project (C) (E) Additional survey (C) (D) (E)

Tbilisi (C) (D) (E)

7 Jul. 3 (Thu)

CDC Explanation of the Project (C) (D) (E) Additional survey (C) (D) (E)

Tbilisi (C) (D) (E)

8 Jul. 4 (Fri) Ministry of Labor, Health and Social Affairs, Explanation of Draft Report (C) (D) (E) Additional survey (C) (D) (E)

Tbilisi (C) (D) (E)

9 Jul. 5 (Sat) Ministry of Labor, Health and Social Affairs, Discussion on internal transportation (C) (D) (E) Additional survey (C) (D) (E)

Tbilisi (C) (D) (E)

10 Jul. 6 (Sun) Survey for internal transportation (C) (D) (E)

Tbilisi (C) (D) (E)

11 Jul. 7 (Mon) Narita→Vienna→ (A) (B)

Survey for installation (C) (D) (E) Tbilisi (C) (D) (E) Flight (A) (B)

12 Jul. 8 Tue) →Tbilisi (A) (B) Ministry of Labor, Health and Social Affairs, Discussion on the Project (A) (B) (C) (D) (E)

Tbilisi (A) (B) (C) (D) (E)

13 Jul. 9 Wed) Discussion of Minutes of Discussion (A) (B) (C) (D) (E)

Tbilisi (A) (B) (C) (D) (E)

14 Jul. 10 Thu)

Signing of Minutes of Discussion (A) (B) (C) (D) (E)

Tbilisi (A) (B) (C) (D) (E)

15 Jul. 11 (Fri) Tbilisi→Moscow→ (D)

Visit Gudushauli Hospital (A) (B) (C)

Tbilisi (A) (B) (C) (E) Flight (D)

16 Jul. 12 (Sat) Tbilisi→ (A) (B) (C) →Narita (D)

Train (A) (B) (C)

17 Jul. 13 (Sun) →Baku (A) (B) (C) Baku (A) (B) (C) 18 Jul. 14 (Mon) Visit the Embassy of Japan in Baku (A) (B)

(C) Baku (A) (B) (C)

19 Jul. 15 (Tue) Baku→London→ (A) (B) (C)

Flight (A) (B) (C)

20 Jul. 16 (Wed) →Narita (A) (B) (C) (A) Team Leader/Technical Advisor, (B) Project Coordinator, (C) Project Manager, (D) Equipment Planner, (E) Interpreter

A-4

Appendix-3 List of Parties Concerned in the Recipient Country Position & Specification Name

Ministry of Foreign Affairs Director of department of Foreign Aid Coordination Mr. Kakha Kalmakhelidze Ministry of Labour, Health and Social Affairs Minister Dr. Amiran Gamkrelidze Deputy Minister Dr. Marina Gudushauri Deputy Minister Dr. Vasil Cheishvili Department of Public Health Head Dr. Ramaz Urushadze Department of Health Policy Director Dr. Lira Topuridze Department of Technics and Technologies Chairman Dr. Dimitri Makhatadze Chairman (former) Dr. Levan Lazarashvili Deputy of Chairman Dr. Vano Potskhverashvili National Center for Disease Control Director Dr. Paata Imnadze Deputy Director Dr. Levan Baidoshvili National Medical Center Head of the Promotion and Foreign Relations Department Dr. George Baliashvili Chief of the Bio-chemical Engineering Service Department Mr. Mamuka Loladze State Medical Insurance Company (SMIC) Director Dr. Nata Kazakhashvili Centre for Medical Statistics and Information Director Mr. Manana Tsintsadze Poti Municipality Vice - Mayor Dr. Nugzar Kacharava Regional and district Health Care Bureau Director of Mtskheta Regional Health Care Department Ms. Ketevan Loria Director of Mtskheta District Public Health Department Ms. Marina Zourabichvili Director of Imereti District Public Health Department Dr. Konstantin Gvetadze Director of Khoni District Public Health Department Dr. Levan Vacharadze Director of Bagdati District Public Health Department Dr. Irakli Amaglobeli Deputy Director of Bagdati District Public Health Department Dr. Nato Mchedlidze Immunization Program Director of Imereti District Public Health Department

Dr. Dali Kobuladze

Director of Poti Regional Health Care Department Dr. Nukri Kurdgelia Director of the Bolnisi District Department Dr. Lali Cixelashvili Director of Samtredia District Public Health Department Dr. Jemal Papava Immunization Coordinator of Samtredia District Public Health Department

Dr. Marina Tevzadze

Director of Vani District Public Health Department Dr. Giga Buadze Director of Samegrelo Regional Health Care Department Dr. Lira Arachemia Epidemiologist of Tetritskaro District Public Health Department Dr. Nana Kakhelashvili Director of Regional IDP Health Care Department Dr. Omar Sichinava Director of Chokhatauri District Public Health Centre Dr. Gogi Kutubidze Deputy Director of Ozurgeti District Public Health Centre Dr. Maya Kutidze Director of Tskhinvali Regional Health Care Department Dr. Zurab Jalabadze

A-5

Medical Facilities Director of Tbilisi, MCH Treatment / Prophylactic center Dr. Gudjabidze Laly Director of Tbilisi D.Coridze maternity home Dr. Dali Gabidzashvili Director of Tbilisi Treatment / Diagnostic center & family medicine Dr. Omiadze Magda Director of Tbilisi, Maternity home #5 Dr. Alexander Labartkava Women’s Consultation Clinic Director of Tbilisi, Maternity home #5 Dr. Ketevan Injia Director of Tbilisi, Primary Health Care Center Dr. Ivane Tskhomelidze Director of Kharagauli District Polyclinic Dr. Tinatin Mchedlidze Women’s Consultation Clinic Director of Kharagauli District Polyclinic Dr. Valida Arevadze Director of Zestafoni Maternity Home Dr. Tsiala Abashidze Women’s Consultation Clinic Director of Zestafoni Maternity Home Dr. Zhiuli Peradze Director of Tskaltubo Polyclinic Dr. Vladimir Tsagareishvili Director of Tskaltubo Maternity Home Dr. Teimuraz Lortkpanidze Director of Gvishtibi Ambulatory Dr. Mikheil Bochorishvili Director of Khoni Polyclinic Dr. Romeo Chargeishvili Women’s Consultation Clinic Director of Bagdati Medical Center Dr. Nunu Sulaberidze Director of Vani District Polyclinic Dr. Valeri Khonelidze Director of Kutaisi Women’s Consultation Dr. Ketevan Iobidze Director of Imereti Regional Hospital, Kutaisi Dr. Teimuraz Chechelashvili Director of Kutaisi Regional MCH Care Centre Dr. Teimuraz Nadiradze Maternity Home Director of Kutaisi Regional MCH Care Centre Dr. Oleg Sinauridze Director of Kutaisi Regional MCH Care Centre Dr. Taisa Grdzelidze Director of Women’s Wellness Centre Dr. Lali Gvetadze Director of Samtredia MCH Health Care Centre Dr. Tengiz Gabichvadze Women’s Consultation Clinic Director of Samtredia MCH Health Care Centre

Dr. Elene Iremadze

Women’s Consultation Clinic director of Poti Medical Centre Dr. Marina Khoperia Deputy Director of Kobuleti Maternity Home Dr. Tsira Verulashvili Women’s Consultation Clinic director of Kobuleti Maternity Home Dr. Sopio Rukhadze Director of Batumi Maternity Home Dr. Nanuli Kikava Director of Batumi MCH Centre Dr. Zurab Zhgenti Obstetric-Gynecologic Department of Batumi MCH Centre Dr. Jumber Ungiadze Director of Khelvachauri Polyclinic Ambulatory Unit Dr. Ilia Beridze Director of Keda District Polyclinic Ambulatory Unit Dr. Amiran Tsintsadze Director of Shuakhevi District Polyclinic Ambulatory Unit Dr. Otar Surmanidze Director of Khulo MCH Regional Centre Dr. Temur Gabaidze Vaccination Doctor of Legava Ambulatory Dr. Nana Bolkvadze Director of Chokhatauri District Polyclinic Ambulatory Unit Dr. Anton Khundadze Obstetric-Gynecologic Dept. director of Chokhatauri District Polyclinic Ambulatory Unit

Dr. Vazha Tsirikidze

Director of Ozurgeti Maternity Home Dr. Davit Mdinaradze Women’s Consultation Clinic director of Ozurgeti Maternity Home Dr. Irina Koplatadze Deputy Director of Ambulatory Polyclinic Department director of Lanchkhuti Medical Centre

Dr. Maya Chkhaidze

Diagnostic Department director of Lanchkhuti Medical Centre Dr. Evgeni Chichua Director of Zugdidi Women’s Consultation Dr. Nanuli Chichinadze Director of Zugdidi Polyclinic for IDP Dr. Zina Gamakharia Director of Khobi Polyclinic for IDP Dr. Svetlana Gvatua Director of Martvili Maternity Home Dr. Tsatsuna Gegechkori Director of Khobi MCH Centre Dr. Mimoza Gadua Director of Djvari Urban Polyclinic (Tsalenjikha) Dr. Jemal Gogokhia Director of Tsalenjikha Medical Centre Dr. Zurab Morgoshia Director of Chkhorotsku Maternity Home Dr. Alexandre Mikaia Director of Senaki Polyclinic for IDP Dr. Luara Dgebuadze Director of Senaki Maternity Home Dr. Aliko Gogia Deputy Director of Abasha Polyclinic/Ambulatory Unit Dr. Jilda Zhordania Director of Lentekhi District Polyclinic Dr. Badri Liparteliani Director of Tsageri Hospital (not in project) Dr. Murman Totadze

A-6

Director of Tsageri District Polyclinic “Mkurnali” Dr. Kote Khvadagiani Deputy Director of Ambrolauri District Polyclinic Dr. Eteri Shengelia Director of Oni District Polyclinic Dr. Marina Goshadze Director of Kareli District Hospital “Zaza Panascerteli” Dr. Marina Kipiani Director of Khashuri Maternity Home Dr. Zurab Kacheishvili Director of Kaspi District Hospital Dr. Nugzar Gogibedashvili Director of Gori Maternity Home Dr. Jumber Gogiashvili Director of Tianeti Medical Centre Dr. Guliko Berberashvili Director of Dusheti District Hospital Dr. Gia Burduli Director of Akhalgori District Hospital Dr. Onise Gatenashvili Director of Tbilisi, Women’s Consultation for IDP from Abkhazia Dr. Nazi Meshveliani Director of Tbilisi, Hospital/Policlinic Unit ＃5 Dr. Tamaz Sharashidze Director of Women’s Consultation N8 Dr. Amiran Dzamashvili Director of Borjomi Maternity Home Dr. Zhenari Grigalashvili Director of Adigeni Maternity Home Dr. Manana Kambarashuili Director of Akhaltsikhe Regional Multyprofile Hospital Dr. Zaza Mosashvili Director of of Gynecology/Obst. Dept. of Akhaltsikhe Regional Multyprofile Hospital

Dr. Zurab Lazarashvili

Director of Aspindza Hospital/Policlinic Unit Dr. Manana Tsinadze Director of Akhalkalaki Hospital/Policlinic Unit Dr. Alexander Toroyan Director of Ninotsminda Hospital/Policlinic Unit Dr. Alexander Pogosyan Director of Tetritskaro Maternity Home Dr. Gulnara Gigauri Director of Signagi Medical Centre Dr. Lili Archvadze Director of Telavi Maternity Home Dr. Avtandil Kamburashvili Director of Akhmeta Medical Centre Dr. Tamaz Kaadze Director of Dedoplistskaro Hospital/Policlinic Unit Dr. Ivane Natroshvili Director of Sagarejo Maternity Home Dr. Tamaz Tskhvareishvili Deputy director of Kvareli MCH Centre Dr. Gela Noniashvili Director of Kakheti Health Care Department Dr. Gia Gozalishvili Director of Kazbegi District Hospital/Policlinic Unit Dr. Vazha Gudushauri Director of Treatment Profilactic Center #1 Dr. Manana Turdzeladze Women’s Consultation Clinic Director director of Treatment /Diagnostic Center & Family Medicine

Dr. Magda omiadze

Director of MCH Treatment/Profilactic Center Dr. Lali Gujabidze Director of Women’s Consultation Clinic of Rustavi Maternity Home Dr. Marika Menabde Director of Maternity Home of Gardabani District Hospital Dr. Irakli Chxikvishvili Director of Marneuli Maternity Home Dr. Marina Pataridze Director of Dmanisi District Policlinic Dr. Liza Kacitadze Director of Maternity Home #5 Dr. Alexandre Labartkava Director of Treatment/Profilactic Center #2 Dr. Shota Maglakelidze Women’s Consultation Clinic director of Treatment/Profilactic Center#3 Dr. Liunga Kacitadze Director of D. Koridze Maternity Home Dr. Dali Gujabidze Director of Mtskheta Regional Multyprofile Hospital Dr. Ivane Cxomellidze World Bank Office Executive Director Dr.George Nickolaishvili UNICEF Office Representative Mr. Ismail Ould Cheikh Ahmed Project Officer Social Policy Dr. Andro Shilakadze WHO Office Liaison Officer in Georgia Representative Dr. Rusudan Klimiashvili Embassy of Japan, Baku Ambassador Mr. Toshiyuki Fujiwara Second secretary Mr. Toshikazu Muto

A-7

Appendix-4 Minutes of Discussion

A-8

Appendix-5 Cost Estimation Borne by the Recipient Country

The removal the existing cold room of NCDC in Tbilisi and the distribution of procured equipment to the final domestic destination shall be borne by the Georgian side. The necessary cost can be estimated as follows.

The Expenses Borne by the Recipient Country

Contents Expenses

Cost of removal (Cold room) US$ 95

Cost of internal distribution US$ 28,000

Total US$ 28,095

A-27

Appendix-6 References

Name Publisher Year 1 Georgian National Health Policy (Tbilisi

1999) Ministry of Labour, Health and Social Affairs of Georgia

1999

2 Immunization Injection Safety Policy & Plan 2002-2006

Ministry of Labour, Health and Social Affairs of Georgia

2001

3 Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey, 1999 State Department of Statistics National Center for Disease Control UNICEF

2000

4 Medical Statistic of Georgia Center of Medical Statistics and Information 2001 5 Statistical Year Book of the Republic of

Macedonia 2001 Republic of Macedonia State Statistical Office

2001

6 Strategic Health Plan for Georgia 2000-2009

Ministry of Labour, Health and Social Affairs of Georgia

1999

A-28