Page 1
NEATPAGEINFO:id=4E448945-E9A5-40AC-949C-E2861CCA5401
Julia Belluz
Julia Belluz
Note: Documents are in reverse chronological order.
Page 2
NEATPAGEINFO:id=5F0B2586-1BFC-4D40-9707-B29621A7D6DE
Page 3
NEATPAGEINFO:id=4DEBAF9F-B018-4DA9-BA50-A0F28882159C
Page 4
NEATPAGEINFO:id=1A4DD7D9-ABD6-46A5-B27A-F2000924D2D2
Page 5
NEATPAGEINFO:id=46A949EC-A779-4E64-B9EF-F5B74F149030
Page 6
NEATPAGEINFO:id=E608223F-5773-42A9-9BB7-0E7D20C978BC
Page 7
NEATPAGEINFO:id=2AF05C40-80B6-4244-9628-B847A1A67F7F
Page 8
NEATPAGEINFO:id=86C2FD0E-A8B7-4423-B5A8-D6D778486431
Page 9
NEATPAGEINFO:id=19A94824-CE9C-4804-ADB5-88C5B9C77BC3
Page 10
NEATPAGEINFO:id=94047195-EEEF-4825-BEC6-DAB7D957DB26
Page 11
NEATPAGEINFO:id=25FD26BA-48B8-403A-9663-6DA79486F12B
Page 12
NEATPAGEINFO:id=A3CBB771-BB50-4298-B361-06EBDD74F99C
Page 13
NEATPAGEINFO:id=4F3F6D26-A763-44D3-862C-A969397703F2
Page 14
NEATPAGEINFO:id=AD974089-81BD-42A3-B0BB-81C59F548AFB
Page 15
NEATPAGEINFO:id=13689085-B12D-401F-84B1-250587BEE74D
Page 16
NEATPAGEINFO:id=1E687976-F877-4F26-A12B-26AE56243A78
NEATPAGEINFO:id=1DED206C-E8DC-4990-B4B9-28F16F279A69
Page 17
NEATPAGEINFO:id=B400C991-7D3C-47DE-8899-263B22FC67BA
NEATPAGEINFO:id=E7312C59-2E3A-476E-A77B-D3DB83C0B3B4
Page 18
NEATPAGEINFO:id=16C20534-696C-425B-9EA9-0BFD5872C52A
NEATPAGEINFO:id=4DF1B408-52EF-465A-AE07-18AB946F21B7
Page 19
NEATPAGEINFO:id=8FAA3022-5F4A-4D18-A256-AA2CB78BD2CF
NEATPAGEINFO:id=49862239-05DD-4DA2-A4FA-D9A15C8CDBE7
Page 20
NEATPAGEINFO:id=F2BEB595-1270-4051-B933-52D63EECB1DB
NEATPAGEINFO:id=EEAB47F3-F741-4D73-89A1-F7E26C4CF8F9
Page 21
NEATPAGEINFO:id=23196801-F947-48D1-AB52-43E19A3ABE69
NEATPAGEINFO:id=1EA995CD-C62C-4348-9055-A1F51CEEFFF4
Page 22
NEATPAGEINFO:id=FDE2FACE-943E-4E70-AD4A-6963BD4E0966
NEATPAGEINFO:id=E3855857-0250-4258-AEB8-DABA8D9C935C
Page 23
NEATPAGEINFO:id=83C25508-6B78-4668-BCCA-850173B2B65A
NEATPAGEINFO:id=824F9EC4-7AE2-4816-B13A-2FCEDEDFC25C
Julia Belluz
PHAC monitoring the journalist's Twitter feed.
Julia Belluz
These notes refer to redacted text.
Page 24
NEATPAGEINFO:id=B7256CCD-B0AC-448C-B251-1931B68AA3F6
NEATPAGEINFO:id=29F4E5D9-0D59-4771-B9A1-30B33CA9C442
Page 25
NEATPAGEINFO:id=FF5B58EB-8F74-4325-B1AD-B51D1D5DAC00
NEATPAGEINFO:id=2367831D-AC93-447B-BF94-F9616DB9B625
Julia Belluz
Interesting comment here. "PT MOHs" stands for provincial-territorial ministers of health.
Page 26
NEATPAGEINFO:id=D9DBDE86-6CBF-4ACD-81E8-39E93A8D207E
NEATPAGEINFO:id=958F47E9-4973-4C20-8108-ACFDC4482686
Page 27
NEATPAGEINFO:id=A6779F3E-B909-494B-95FE-7604C9BFDB3A
NEATPAGEINFO:id=04217B2B-C772-4D8F-AF62-88BB2A34C405
Page 28
NEATPAGEINFO:id=AB1FDDB9-0903-4E72-9036-9ABACA3635D9
NEATPAGEINFO:id=7D1AA7CC-F6F9-43E9-BF1C-E9688E7BC4AE
Page 29
NEATPAGEINFO:id=F688D0F4-F186-4870-B0F1-6E24B5F127B2
NEATPAGEINFO:id=F9E83B88-14CA-4FF4-B5DB-DA8F6E01EB4A
Page 30
NEATPAGEINFO:id=B08096DC-C0C4-4729-A8B8-7E149164E14E
NEATPAGEINFO:id=4BD604F1-C054-40F8-B610-6FF268FC1A14
Julia Belluz
The suggestion that PHAC not want to engage with media who might "negatively" view them
Page 31
NEATPAGEINFO:id=A91AF7F8-FC5F-405C-9CB9-5BCF3E203A19
NEATPAGEINFO:id=2C5F214E-22E9-4D9A-B534-3E022C4B83D1
Julia Belluz
Julia Belluz
Page 32
NEATPAGEINFO:id=73B43388-1E0E-49B6-8E68-5AC4EED70E7E
NEATPAGEINFO:id=BF52D991-18EF-499A-BAF2-B85E71A9638E
Julia Belluz
"MO" = Minister's Office. Lines for media interview—which was deemed "medium impact"—were sent up to the Federal Health Minister's Office for approval.
Page 33
NEATPAGEINFO:id=955782B2-22B7-4D18-81DD-FB3F884DE94D
NEATPAGEINFO:id=A0FBB8A4-D873-489B-BB83-D8D9FBF5F5F4
Page 34
NEATPAGEINFO:id=5C6D7CB4-2772-4EF8-B0FD-5F2F0340AFC4
NEATPAGEINFO:id=B2D7976A-C722-4522-931B-60243E26DE3E
Julia Belluz
In an interview, PHAC officials cited this review article as one of the core pieces of evidence to support their decision to stockpile Tamiflu. Here, media officials within PHAC express concern about the conclusions of the review.
Page 35
NEATPAGEINFO:id=6512CA62-DF3E-4BF8-B93F-247230160A74
NEATPAGEINFO:id=F4FEE35E-6AA0-4376-A211-EC08DF8797B3
Page 36
NEATPAGEINFO:id=36B2C35E-ECDD-4A40-8E05-DAC21B31FAC8
NEATPAGEINFO:id=3960FDFE-BEA0-46E0-96A2-7FBEBFDDE9CD
Julia Belluz
Another meeting to discuss this media request.
Page 37
NEATPAGEINFO:id=0529036F-CB42-46D0-9C95-CA5DB78287D9
NEATPAGEINFO:id=3A57102C-BC90-4F44-993E-274984EEA3BA
Page 38
NEATPAGEINFO:id=177A7811-11CF-419A-8723-EC913D529E7A
NEATPAGEINFO:id=13F839D9-2142-45DA-A58A-0387D774672B
Julia Belluz
Page 39
NEATPAGEINFO:id=02AC52C0-BA3D-4337-B790-0C677622BEDF
NEATPAGEINFO:id=6C8B071B-F4BE-4D12-BAE9-304E0C024E8E
Page 40
NEATPAGEINFO:id=47202EF0-947A-448F-993D-D1427685368D
NEATPAGEINFO:id=DC100E1A-01EB-4043-944E-ACE52241F8C6
Page 41
NEATPAGEINFO:id=93208C1B-0A66-4333-8E67-E1241A0BA809
NEATPAGEINFO:id=EA9C3A50-2D49-441B-A297-EA17A6D86C89
Page 42
NEATPAGEINFO:id=C6484E06-030D-4364-A9FD-8F6CC8D7D77C
NEATPAGEINFO:id=97235490-9D82-4C36-8E87-19319B421EAE
Page 43
NEATPAGEINFO:id=7C315A69-3B06-4B27-80FC-613873FD2F9B
NEATPAGEINFO:id=29E56F00-D89B-42ED-8254-F84FBBEEA047
Page 44
NEATPAGEINFO:id=69BD7DE7-5C35-4A75-88AB-238D9FF5A5AA
NEATPAGEINFO:id=DED12F67-BADE-49E8-9441-C1CB62DDDAF9
Page 45
NEATPAGEINFO:id=C759B231-982C-411D-88A1-98566CA302D3
NEATPAGEINFO:id=1F66D5BE-E34A-494E-8C26-BA99908D9FCC
Page 46
NEATPAGEINFO:id=41E748B2-F2A2-488E-B70F-B745E25D5F6C
NEATPAGEINFO:id=39A17A86-AE26-4B3B-BF3A-5C586DEC0777
Page 47
NEATPAGEINFO:id=3CED0CA5-3C6D-4698-92F6-8D226ED00CFF
NEATPAGEINFO:id=0BD04D03-F7FE-4B3D-A338-5544E5E1E8C3
Page 48
NEATPAGEINFO:id=BB91DC32-CCED-48B8-936F-FCB3064B4213
NEATPAGEINFO:id=405026A6-ABC0-4FEA-B137-E478D1B80FDB
Page 49
NEATPAGEINFO:id=10B00D83-BE0D-40C1-BA56-22859971FB2A
NEATPAGEINFO:id=C859EACA-133E-4995-B75A-13238E544FCF
Page 50
NEATPAGEINFO:id=943B31B1-8742-4B51-A7BD-A8CE1545BC76
NEATPAGEINFO:id=3E4E6EEA-5477-4A42-A997-7B197247996B
Page 51
NEATPAGEINFO:id=E0603A90-939E-4800-9C8C-B0C1DCC98F8E
NEATPAGEINFO:id=067E1B9F-DFDD-410E-A0BA-6FAA832E0EBB
Page 52
NEATPAGEINFO:id=2AFACC34-7328-47D6-B429-4576A48F8DCC
NEATPAGEINFO:id=A0B7FE86-951A-498B-9732-7870DF1B67F7
Page 53
NEATPAGEINFO:id=34309009-CB81-471A-9E49-11268ED00492
NEATPAGEINFO:id=F850FF40-C999-43B8-BD26-99D602B60AD3
Page 54
NEATPAGEINFO:id=F249DBDB-3CBB-4FFB-86E8-CAEC8303DB8E
NEATPAGEINFO:id=5B1F5C06-BBBF-4564-8F3F-399DE703991B
Page 55
NEATPAGEINFO:id=8BC30D02-7C5A-45D0-9A9B-2AA6DABE7887
NEATPAGEINFO:id=BC61C03F-8B7D-4276-B3A2-0F8F6E5764CA
Julia Belluz
The final media lines here, after several rounds of editing and input from various PHAC departments.
Page 56
NEATPAGEINFO:id=069C8BB8-EF41-4749-8EA2-B417AC151A5F
NEATPAGEINFO:id=68EAF355-BEA5-465C-AD9B-BD9E4E166956
Page 57
NEATPAGEINFO:id=742907B1-A6C0-4FB8-97DA-418C02A1111D
NEATPAGEINFO:id=976F98CD-3146-4409-9E24-8F6FCA607522
Page 58
NEATPAGEINFO:id=45229F0D-5944-4167-A390-54C574509789
NEATPAGEINFO:id=83A30412-E0FF-4B28-8751-2834C34FA54E
Page 59
NEATPAGEINFO:id=C9637F28-7EE4-4C32-89B2-33A1990BF493
NEATPAGEINFO:id=B2E65DEE-5224-4BC9-A7D6-B36064CE7987
Page 60
NEATPAGEINFO:id=D129C44E-251C-414F-BD41-1D640A0D1E6B
NEATPAGEINFO:id=6B2C0D31-39A0-4539-B9F5-66589F382212
Page 61
NEATPAGEINFO:id=4D8ED8F0-0BEF-4820-826C-2B5E4D948B85
NEATPAGEINFO:id=CBBB7C0B-B5CB-437E-8B11-2E7F68373DA5
Page 62
NEATPAGEINFO:id=3185A521-AD45-4DBF-8C15-3EE218DD7869
NEATPAGEINFO:id=AF22ADE0-4518-4BEF-8CD0-D32290A98400
Julia Belluz
A de-brief after the Maclean's/Medical Post interview with PHAC.
Page 63
NEATPAGEINFO:id=2A447C9F-6D64-4E29-A2A6-36DEC9B67F47
NEATPAGEINFO:id=38200AC4-5D87-43D4-9765-E88F5B3DD216
Page 64
NEATPAGEINFO:id=9F182B74-715F-49FB-B526-63E2FB0543FD
NEATPAGEINFO:id=E42466A0-FB48-4F1F-B8B3-A5E13BC7CCC9
Julia Belluz
PHAC cites this study by Hsu in the Annals of Internal Medicine as key piece of evidence. Here's the study link: http://annals.org/article.aspx?articleid=1103757 Its conclusion: "Therapy with oral oseltamivir and inhaled zanamivir may provide a net benefit over no treatment of influenza. However, as with the randomized trials, the confidence in the estimates of the effects for decision making is low to very low."
Page 65
NEATPAGEINFO:id=5D914928-4F02-4AD9-85BE-D3A57F711794
NEATPAGEINFO:id=C27D433A-E058-460C-83FA-E526396810DF
Page 66
NEATPAGEINFO:id=21869726-1354-4A03-8B75-3A2B4EAF6723
NEATPAGEINFO:id=B6B442C5-8B6B-43A6-AE8D-2C3E75CCBD36
Julia Belluz
There is concern about the fact that they quoted a meta-analysis to support their decision to stockpile Tamiflu which has a conclusion that "is not very reassuring."
Page 67
NEATPAGEINFO:id=2DEDC5CF-9A2F-4CF5-A4F1-120688E871B0
NEATPAGEINFO:id=823EE2ED-9432-4CA1-9798-C5EF06F0F9F2
Page 68
NEATPAGEINFO:id=7FFD8A3D-E63F-4713-845B-C204662C18A8
NEATPAGEINFO:id=40F6AB2D-FE1A-4256-B4F6-96CB3685F417
Page 69
NEATPAGEINFO:id=C55242F8-C314-4622-8BC1-26FEDE136089
NEATPAGEINFO:id=DB00EC47-2ADF-45A6-8582-FEF09D36E21B
Page 70
NEATPAGEINFO:id=2A3B0F2C-F318-46B6-8B84-7E502DAC0D36
NEATPAGEINFO:id=2C19AFD1-1836-48BD-A9B3-4C2EEA21657E
Page 71
NEATPAGEINFO:id=60774CA8-FE15-43B4-B664-B4C02ACCDD12
NEATPAGEINFO:id=CF58FB49-EAE1-4F88-A976-2E94CEAA8764
Page 72
NEATPAGEINFO:id=2770B57A-1EB8-4658-994E-C9211DB17F30
NEATPAGEINFO:id=314659B2-BE0B-4EE0-8222-BEC4F90D15C2
Page 73
NEATPAGEINFO:id=706DDF26-EE9E-457B-9D7F-67A22E76A6FD
NEATPAGEINFO:id=9038AABE-0927-4164-A4B7-5C2E58BED932
Page 74
NEATPAGEINFO:id=2AB0483B-3074-4634-8665-9BA4438FE5C7
NEATPAGEINFO:id=577584E3-8F1F-4021-BE7E-E65CAB9E7ECC
Page 75
NEATPAGEINFO:id=72E10E16-DC2A-406F-BD2A-12C70D734CA5
NEATPAGEINFO:id=6DC2371B-A602-4C38-BF6C-CBACE48664CF
Page 76
NEATPAGEINFO:id=A7107043-F2E8-4BD5-9928-F58F0025A825
NEATPAGEINFO:id=89ECE274-2475-4BC8-8C67-C77F695BCDC9
Julia Belluz
Again, the Minister's Office approving media lines.
Page 77
NEATPAGEINFO:id=5C4DD5CB-E03C-46AE-BEC9-4B4306D0CA9A
NEATPAGEINFO:id=C2D40D39-E60E-4F69-B91D-0260FA5F2FB5
Page 78
NEATPAGEINFO:id=2134856A-878A-4F92-BE25-228B6D16F8E5
NEATPAGEINFO:id=28D42416-745C-4836-80EE-82C1C1D50AB5
Page 79
NEATPAGEINFO:id=9C61B296-8D57-4C7D-A0D8-A0B26E29201A
NEATPAGEINFO:id=9FE78A75-A2CB-4A52-9889-5ADA325C8A7B
Julia Belluz
PHAC can't grant media interview until the Minister's Office sends approval.
Page 80
NEATPAGEINFO:id=A8CA9968-8A25-4E5D-AD41-170D26598E3E
NEATPAGEINFO:id=23379CA8-6011-42C3-A96D-484452A1B37C
Page 81
NEATPAGEINFO:id=886D4085-F28D-4AC8-9E39-3ED434E41CBB
NEATPAGEINFO:id=DDFFD150-899D-4C32-B89E-D3649166D81F
Page 82
NEATPAGEINFO:id=C77818F3-E324-466E-8DD2-5A9144F23DF5
NEATPAGEINFO:id=51043D66-42DD-4D42-A0E2-FFD0A22B5C07
Page 83
NEATPAGEINFO:id=A9EC608A-838A-48C6-8242-9779F6D81DB7
NEATPAGEINFO:id=B9FE70DB-F2D8-4F73-9B7D-55CF80C2CAFE
Page 84
NEATPAGEINFO:id=D4168844-E2CD-4882-93C3-065CAE4CA56E
NEATPAGEINFO:id=2B0C13D7-033C-4239-9333-CAF228302B97
Page 85
NEATPAGEINFO:id=8380FED8-88E6-4792-BB48-541A238FBC67
NEATPAGEINFO:id=B09C5465-962B-41C2-81E9-D4F57DFF4D65
Julia Belluz
A discussion of the journalist's credentials.
Julia Belluz
More rounds on the media lines.
Page 86
NEATPAGEINFO:id=9959D0E7-A349-4B2E-97A5-698AF96BAFD4
NEATPAGEINFO:id=FE0A12C4-BBDD-496C-83EE-9178493A0163
Page 87
NEATPAGEINFO:id=D462DF06-2063-4795-A053-D75B8E67043C
NEATPAGEINFO:id=77E3613B-4EE2-4CF4-8481-B0272EA0C9A9
Julia Belluz
More rounds on the media lines.
Page 88
NEATPAGEINFO:id=7597757B-B68B-4990-8D9A-BB138AFDA046
NEATPAGEINFO:id=492407FB-B612-4591-AE8E-2CBA9EF027E2
Page 89
NEATPAGEINFO:id=DD4ACBDE-D69A-425B-B347-1E4B9A866D7F
NEATPAGEINFO:id=14C7777C-897B-45B6-BD2E-302E4138ECFC
Julia Belluz
Draft media lines
Page 90
NEATPAGEINFO:id=DEC1CA7D-C3F3-4B4A-BC2E-E75681262BD7
NEATPAGEINFO:id=6169FDF9-2A77-4D1A-BAF6-ADF14ACB401D
Page 91
NEATPAGEINFO:id=524CF8DA-238C-4155-904E-BE199EE45652
NEATPAGEINFO:id=67C493FB-D438-41A2-8948-AEE18E67A009
Page 92
NEATPAGEINFO:id=4A13DD11-F731-4662-B439-8B5E28EC47BE
NEATPAGEINFO:id=17C4A3B0-C57E-47A4-A3EF-1857E4F2A141
Page 93
NEATPAGEINFO:id=860294B6-0231-4E49-B0D4-E906ABF8B0DC
NEATPAGEINFO:id=77C5257F-6DA1-475A-8496-528AFC5EFEFE
Page 94
NEATPAGEINFO:id=07E77C66-5BB6-474D-AF06-6E5B2D751031
NEATPAGEINFO:id=B01AD5DF-772E-44C1-9359-70B1076DB80F
Page 95
NEATPAGEINFO:id=0D2C213A-8D52-4C5B-8B2A-8FFD66603C18
NEATPAGEINFO:id=3B73D21B-7650-4BB1-BF13-022DF4C200B7
Page 96
NEATPAGEINFO:id=1D54EC88-02D1-4A9F-91B4-C3B356F07D2D
NEATPAGEINFO:id=799E19E5-36D8-4EEB-9449-DA71CEE7811B
Page 97
NEATPAGEINFO:id=2193F36E-55D8-4825-8A3B-EC532BA15ABF
NEATPAGEINFO:id=E7B37A7A-F011-445A-B605-E8CD29FDB4E3
Julia Belluz
More discussion about the key messages.
Page 98
NEATPAGEINFO:id=4A74E557-0EA0-4BE2-B94D-D753961DA2B6
NEATPAGEINFO:id=A37D6172-6EED-4725-BF30-8888E63FA341
Julia Belluz
More comments on the media lines.
Page 99
NEATPAGEINFO:id=4BEA8F27-1C96-4A18-A177-CACC156D43E4
NEATPAGEINFO:id=2280314A-F723-46F1-B43B-4E9004C25377
Page 100
NEATPAGEINFO:id=091D4454-3006-493C-AD87-34FE8C860509
NEATPAGEINFO:id=0C26AE1F-E969-4596-8537-373BF6B4BD53
Page 101
NEATPAGEINFO:id=3B79870B-3BC3-448C-8F44-BE16AA51603B
NEATPAGEINFO:id=F665467F-1F09-4DF7-B18B-C2476C1C4628
Julia Belluz
There were at least a half dozen people at PHAC working on this media request.
Page 102
NEATPAGEINFO:id=E4E32CC7-EFD1-4885-B925-AD43D9D58FA2
NEATPAGEINFO:id=6349EC64-FDA1-46F0-BE0E-27E027CC1EA1
Page 103
NEATPAGEINFO:id=8C587D63-4C50-4039-91CE-525B84C4C3FF
NEATPAGEINFO:id=2D892ECD-4854-49F9-B2EB-00AA410CC848
Page 104
NEATPAGEINFO:id=FD57C411-20A7-492A-A034-AD5705F62986
NEATPAGEINFO:id=B58288D0-E694-4742-947B-394417A3D6FD
Page 105
NEATPAGEINFO:id=C79A8912-F57D-478E-8A5F-C4F386EF2516
NEATPAGEINFO:id=28E39FA3-C6E9-45B3-95E1-C31DFD2BB72A
Julia Belluz
Barbara Raymond, Director of the Pandemic Preparedness Division at PHAC, weighs in with proposed questions about what journalist might ask in the interview.
Page 106
NEATPAGEINFO:id=2EE5B16C-7169-4804-A0A7-65E40850B2BC
NEATPAGEINFO:id=C1C69062-7DCE-4FEA-A800-F5E04174E4EE
Page 107
NEATPAGEINFO:id=DD516367-767D-4440-B10B-518A9B9C6223
NEATPAGEINFO:id=19A414ED-3CFA-42B2-9AAF-D95FD9109C04
Page 108
NEATPAGEINFO:id=7621AC75-AAA4-471B-BA10-084D49E36211
NEATPAGEINFO:id=40E58C70-8EE1-43E5-BEE7-2B3D8B1B997A
Page 109
NEATPAGEINFO:id=83E57635-F55E-4AD1-814F-8F2B91FC12F8
NEATPAGEINFO:id=F732B921-FFBC-4118-BB32-82A884EEC9BC
Page 110
NEATPAGEINFO:id=89AD374A-EAB0-4C08-B07C-B5F10F47B380
NEATPAGEINFO:id=D27882E6-1715-4FDA-9B7A-94A0B717A16E
Page 111
NEATPAGEINFO:id=1415A927-8D7F-4F8D-AA23-6EBC59620006
NEATPAGEINFO:id=CA922615-48C6-4BE1-9F4B-0E7BE1BFA855
Page 112
NEATPAGEINFO:id=B560D348-EF88-40E9-B72B-B519BC978DB7
NEATPAGEINFO:id=590C00EC-27AC-4064-BCD7-9554FCAD7D1D
Page 113
NEATPAGEINFO:id=480D5EE4-4E26-4757-9836-7B01E6830633
NEATPAGEINFO:id=1FEE242A-56C4-467B-AFBF-298969219D0F
Page 114
NEATPAGEINFO:id=17F84508-1A04-4E86-8A5E-CA68F3BF5FCA
NEATPAGEINFO:id=BC40F201-8936-49A8-9C69-C751CEE0B565
Page 115
NEATPAGEINFO:id=7E58A2F2-79F3-4806-8DD4-9F8074C557AC
NEATPAGEINFO:id=B76C37AD-A4E4-499A-B71A-4D8EA51227C7
Page 116
NEATPAGEINFO:id=40515940-073A-4547-849A-E8A914D18A97
NEATPAGEINFO:id=3A35B074-A14A-4FB4-9AB0-5FF9FB2DB57E
Page 117
NEATPAGEINFO:id=F48FC05A-4B31-47EB-B9ED-A7CAE476B93C
NEATPAGEINFO:id=0F72CDF3-DA09-4344-B7DA-04DA0BA6BAD8
Page 118
NEATPAGEINFO:id=C8A7811A-6B8A-40B5-BF1D-A286FD66A392
NEATPAGEINFO:id=46419499-21B9-4594-BC9D-CBE79EFF35AE
Page 119
NEATPAGEINFO:id=559D2551-6FDA-4B6B-B974-7D2007337DC3
NEATPAGEINFO:id=5E561DD1-E24E-4EED-883D-47A2A8A1BE86
Julia Belluz
PHAC on the uncertainties in the evidence base.
Page 120
NEATPAGEINFO:id=FE516289-E7A6-44E0-BF70-3A9155D7DA19
NEATPAGEINFO:id=7E8506C0-1B3D-49E4-ABDD-873FDAD417F1
Julia Belluz
Redacted lines.
Julia Belluz
Redacted lines
Page 121
NEATPAGEINFO:id=DD625711-2407-4714-8BFB-14ED5602EB47
NEATPAGEINFO:id=DC5AD7F0-F3D1-4781-9DF2-C42EABD6FBDE
Julia Belluz
More redactions.
Page 122
NEATPAGEINFO:id=34CF6504-5379-4668-AA3F-C4DE83541237
NEATPAGEINFO:id=602086E3-22F7-448F-AEED-04F13DA07C62
Page 123
NEATPAGEINFO:id=954716EB-A3CC-41D3-8908-6EDDD1B0F0CA
NEATPAGEINFO:id=E11EB5E1-ADD6-4BE9-BC1C-2DA0479741FE
Page 124
NEATPAGEINFO:id=CDDBAC74-6C72-4D9F-B457-B1C0774FE756
NEATPAGEINFO:id=2AB28259-6BCA-48E3-A03F-E68814F3217F
Page 125
NEATPAGEINFO:id=4924653C-A0BE-4A7A-956D-B9FDECE0F5ED
NEATPAGEINFO:id=92DCACE0-B83A-4776-966A-C2036EF78F15
Page 126
NEATPAGEINFO:id=F6C5797E-8D48-442C-B1B2-E519DDD5F9B5
NEATPAGEINFO:id=12C1E4C5-676D-4141-B4E7-ECCB8908AC67
Page 127
NEATPAGEINFO:id=F8661664-418F-4EFB-8D13-84909AACF87E
NEATPAGEINFO:id=79A1C0D3-200E-43DC-92A7-27234385E815
Page 128
NEATPAGEINFO:id=EFD601B7-4EC2-498B-959E-C3EBD86C2A13
NEATPAGEINFO:id=E1CD0805-AB2A-46C4-BB44-DCD9D89222D3
Page 129
NEATPAGEINFO:id=D70A2032-790A-4236-BB5A-23661557177F
NEATPAGEINFO:id=5898843B-BD74-4A39-9BEF-9C553363F09B
Page 130
NEATPAGEINFO:id=E054C692-45C0-41D7-A2CC-6787FC841C6B
NEATPAGEINFO:id=FFC56625-A065-4C3D-A9FC-94CCF8CF1A86
Julia Belluz
More internal discussion to "clarify our position" before speaking to the media.
Page 131
NEATPAGEINFO:id=F8C0BFD7-405B-4E47-B55A-17C704285814
NEATPAGEINFO:id=A525E9BD-B04D-4A92-A7B0-48EA2D631E6F
Page 132
NEATPAGEINFO:id=5804439A-3426-4429-93A7-4AB470366518
NEATPAGEINFO:id=151CA3C2-29DE-4077-B180-9507500F9309
Page 133
NEATPAGEINFO:id=7A996557-28C7-4CE9-99FD-1B5308909ECC
NEATPAGEINFO:id=BA371CB4-AE43-4B96-9E24-B12C7CD8834B
Page 134
NEATPAGEINFO:id=42395097-83CB-46A2-B9D0-5CE39B88AF04
NEATPAGEINFO:id=0A9DBC39-F23F-4787-B270-8738DB249602
Julia Belluz
Written responses were recommended instead of granting an interview.
Julia Belluz
Page 135
NEATPAGEINFO:id=08C29E6F-F57E-48A3-9113-A5EA44EABA28
NEATPAGEINFO:id=326CF78D-B5B5-4138-BACF-9B3ECA7F25E4
Julia Belluz
Page 136
NEATPAGEINFO:id=E6B86C92-ADA8-4A1C-A287-1530A6A69EAB
NEATPAGEINFO:id=576E6AA6-6D2F-4628-AA66-93F691610865
Page 137
NEATPAGEINFO:id=580BFCBE-432B-4B46-9E96-9D5198954A3E
NEATPAGEINFO:id=5436D58A-ED55-4250-A39D-872B9AF4E759
Julia Belluz
An urgent conversation.
Page 138
NEATPAGEINFO:id=6ED642B3-DCD6-46F6-B98A-37C99AD35A38
NEATPAGEINFO:id=F6C5F98B-179F-4C9C-9DA9-3B562D29331B
Julia Belluz
Several drafts to come to a final version of a request for approval, to be sent up to the Minister's Office.
Page 139
NEATPAGEINFO:id=AFBF7057-A787-40BC-B16E-99DAA53E1C11
NEATPAGEINFO:id=1B8EAC95-2353-4D7E-86BA-1F21B2FC5D30
Page 140
NEATPAGEINFO:id=EE306176-59D2-496B-AA61-4149C8D1F849
NEATPAGEINFO:id=C8987F25-2D4F-4932-AA26-C3B47DE47721
Page 141
NEATPAGEINFO:id=1A552935-6470-494A-94D9-C33C6F2BC752
NEATPAGEINFO:id=3671F2E5-64A6-4A3C-B00C-965BD51BA819
Page 142
NEATPAGEINFO:id=9EE33553-22BD-4707-B4A0-21DBB33DF35A
NEATPAGEINFO:id=1443D905-FC1B-45AB-92F1-905601476413
Page 143
NEATPAGEINFO:id=413F5599-2476-43DC-A570-12E6C6316512
NEATPAGEINFO:id=E29212AF-E91C-4B65-BF1A-3274A710A290
Page 144
NEATPAGEINFO:id=40FE5572-65F6-4D23-92E6-9307A5BDE551
NEATPAGEINFO:id=A8E1A1DD-10E7-40FD-8EDF-0698E3264534
Page 145
NEATPAGEINFO:id=F926F732-2520-4331-8113-8CF3E8EDA80D
NEATPAGEINFO:id=CD20B532-60FF-4123-96E3-AB818AD28A68
Page 146
NEATPAGEINFO:id=CE5D904A-BE22-4991-843F-35DF8BA9DD19
NEATPAGEINFO:id=EF05171E-33E7-415D-AEFE-0C5BDC2B4A4B
Page 147
NEATPAGEINFO:id=3BF38283-DE20-437F-AD25-E509C54F91EB
NEATPAGEINFO:id=351BCEFB-3C85-4AF3-8789-D1F5718FB0EA
Page 148
NEATPAGEINFO:id=19F11105-D7BB-4BD9-A5B0-3F515DC1B123
NEATPAGEINFO:id=2391E1F3-5E90-453A-AA46-D858A48A417D
Page 149
NEATPAGEINFO:id=E39C3E90-54DA-422E-BD29-C094C52AB2AE
NEATPAGEINFO:id=598492D4-33EE-4EF6-BE06-5DCE8979F9FB
Page 150
NEATPAGEINFO:id=9FC617CD-AADF-4B1C-B352-1F7D9E60115C
NEATPAGEINFO:id=5C7CFF95-04DC-48A0-880E-F87112444209
Page 151
NEATPAGEINFO:id=A88B866F-C080-43E5-A5D6-5431495D9736
NEATPAGEINFO:id=BBBE4668-37F8-419A-A786-5CD986EAADA7
Page 152
NEATPAGEINFO:id=2090F8FD-E4FE-4A53-AB95-7FE82FF19CAF
NEATPAGEINFO:id=4F79BA0A-2A32-4746-9D31-E8AB4ADF14BF
Page 153
NEATPAGEINFO:id=D2B43B46-51DE-492E-BDAF-3C3710C61C78
NEATPAGEINFO:id=9B6040C2-6F4B-4969-8303-6F5DC2F5DA98
Page 154
NEATPAGEINFO:id=A4E82199-AB76-4785-B395-8350C325CB10
NEATPAGEINFO:id=E3F95F02-B930-436C-8FE3-6817C56EC85E
Page 155
NEATPAGEINFO:id=89FD337D-D630-44A4-9535-1CD6694442D9
NEATPAGEINFO:id=A6696C49-7F3F-4E6A-A721-07F3D777FB66
Julia Belluz
Media lines were sent to the Minister's Office for approval.
Page 156
NEATPAGEINFO:id=401675A1-EEF1-4601-9902-95163567CF7F
NEATPAGEINFO:id=6CBF6762-13AC-4147-A262-95E8D41B70DF
Page 157
NEATPAGEINFO:id=80658D56-08FA-48B2-9F28-88B5055C165D
NEATPAGEINFO:id=B72EDF9C-787C-4A23-A4E8-6F3FFB689E93
Page 158
NEATPAGEINFO:id=8CE06E1D-AB00-49ED-B9BB-F5E25C4F6497
NEATPAGEINFO:id=27CA936D-918B-4A04-883F-B55E9DAE7EF5
Page 159
NEATPAGEINFO:id=6AD75D4C-9C9A-4EA1-81B4-F8C1B2D8A424
NEATPAGEINFO:id=DDDCB7E1-1D25-41D4-B883-19404EBA1286
Page 160
NEATPAGEINFO:id=BFB02552-66F5-4F26-B08A-6E491EA1D0E3
NEATPAGEINFO:id=A773E5F7-D164-46F7-AC3C-1D45EE0E9AE9
Page 161
NEATPAGEINFO:id=37AF58FE-376E-4734-9317-EF47EF72708A
NEATPAGEINFO:id=B0E3CD0F-687A-4D42-8FBE-E94DDB9CE44C
Julia Belluz
This telling line is omitted.
Page 162
NEATPAGEINFO:id=62004BCF-C999-4114-8E30-F6917C8570D2
NEATPAGEINFO:id=F75B738C-934F-4251-9D7E-ABCFAB8F49E4
Page 163
NEATPAGEINFO:id=0E6045E6-1DE0-4CC8-BF58-E259D6D9FF91
NEATPAGEINFO:id=1AA9E711-F277-46AE-840D-76D3E4457431
Page 164
NEATPAGEINFO:id=1D981396-D5E2-4217-B1D8-CB65D7C590FF
NEATPAGEINFO:id=F758A3D8-0C3E-4A1E-B617-37675631A665
Page 165
NEATPAGEINFO:id=22E65668-71BF-476B-A6F6-D97A4555B32C
NEATPAGEINFO:id=F043C899-F6F0-4BFE-9F68-79D1C28EC975
Page 166
NEATPAGEINFO:id=EC9600C1-9FD7-4487-9226-1B4F91EC845C
NEATPAGEINFO:id=74C83EBC-5365-49CD-9669-61F41F32211F
Page 167
NEATPAGEINFO:id=B5216184-0A14-49B9-A03D-74C143692EB1
NEATPAGEINFO:id=2466E2CB-AE89-4CC9-BF6E-AB8BDEEC9B0B
Page 168
NEATPAGEINFO:id=9E131D4A-8B9D-4CA3-A5F3-53620E8F6D51
NEATPAGEINFO:id=BA6ED79A-8D71-4111-A3B3-19F071738521
Page 169
NEATPAGEINFO:id=EB9EB9F6-2045-474D-BCD3-4741150D22EB
NEATPAGEINFO:id=FBD8A682-A0DA-4898-99F7-EA6641B87A49
Page 170
NEATPAGEINFO:id=6739C5E3-B093-4598-8446-73BC1CA45A2D
NEATPAGEINFO:id=CE4C587F-8A26-47A7-A7F0-6248D4C36932
Page 171
NEATPAGEINFO:id=3AF9079D-CAB2-4C95-82D5-E7AA58A86183
NEATPAGEINFO:id=DF720091-4DB6-45B3-9212-E2E72EA5CFD3
Page 172
NEATPAGEINFO:id=28B5565C-9C7F-44D3-BDD2-D9D3B49DAB90
NEATPAGEINFO:id=A2281AF7-B545-45ED-AEF6-3AC82474F954
Page 173
NEATPAGEINFO:id=5269E85F-CFB0-4FE8-8198-F9908A4F432F
NEATPAGEINFO:id=E05A86FC-9C56-493E-BF59-693E1E75F0E8
Page 174
NEATPAGEINFO:id=A382B74D-6EE3-4486-AAAA-B490B991C41E
NEATPAGEINFO:id=72D37319-10B0-460A-9E2B-E8D9521274D1
Page 175
NEATPAGEINFO:id=A60BB387-922F-4FC0-A622-4DEFFD811280
NEATPAGEINFO:id=AD674D2B-E0CB-4B4D-8978-09C45D00933D
Page 176
NEATPAGEINFO:id=D0BFAB07-C86B-4DB8-8CEF-1F646427FBA8
NEATPAGEINFO:id=1F511F57-4D02-4003-995A-88DC350CFE63
Page 177
NEATPAGEINFO:id=8EF306BC-180F-4855-A11D-8643CC753AFB
NEATPAGEINFO:id=157740D4-23A3-4177-A8CF-905F1E52FA49
Page 178
NEATPAGEINFO:id=AB94AD31-1412-4B17-8076-A923D8BDA93D
NEATPAGEINFO:id=15068590-24E5-426B-B347-0CECBE66950B
Page 179
NEATPAGEINFO:id=FDBB03D9-B6B2-4210-84E4-B7DC65053CE9
NEATPAGEINFO:id=A2944C3F-2C6A-4A56-B8C6-CA30A0EC541C
Page 180
NEATPAGEINFO:id=D9858D9B-FB57-449F-99E7-770FC0511C7B
NEATPAGEINFO:id=4ACF3594-8C54-44AF-B126-745BAA98310A
Page 181
NEATPAGEINFO:id=97236BA6-F9DA-4C66-80F7-E14C99E0DF0D
NEATPAGEINFO:id=37A45169-E623-4A2A-B523-973D9D4DE4AE
Page 182
NEATPAGEINFO:id=2D0A5D54-23CD-4042-B5AE-12D8F977E014
NEATPAGEINFO:id=9AC2F975-47BF-4FE2-9A6F-24DC0B750D0B
Page 183
NEATPAGEINFO:id=25469D6B-6076-4623-875F-5B1543B25A93
NEATPAGEINFO:id=04EBED5D-3AF9-4326-B181-C5ECDE157890
Page 184
NEATPAGEINFO:id=7F5FFABE-EC6A-4C10-9F13-610F44A8DCCC
NEATPAGEINFO:id=1EFE593B-F2BD-48A7-AE91-C358B380A19A
Page 185
NEATPAGEINFO:id=4DFCEE29-4C00-4D4F-96C7-9CCC92D3EBF0
NEATPAGEINFO:id=DAC39B66-9B87-42DF-9341-F77A3B0B5A6A
Page 186
NEATPAGEINFO:id=01C6A22A-EE19-4235-BC85-11C255ACCCB8
NEATPAGEINFO:id=DD77AB60-DDAF-41BA-9AAE-DE24EDF88D04
Page 187
NEATPAGEINFO:id=10621391-05D8-4160-9191-E8E49BABA517
NEATPAGEINFO:id=27A3FACB-CC95-4A23-9C58-3565D8331BA3
Page 188
NEATPAGEINFO:id=C8CD862B-7CB8-4897-B790-CA7293C69293
NEATPAGEINFO:id=3B872833-FF9E-4E83-A0E4-B33E6E21B823
Page 189
NEATPAGEINFO:id=210B36C7-B9AD-4F2C-842F-1B9E012291AD
NEATPAGEINFO:id=9A6B821A-3C17-4C65-82DC-E0EEACC6CEF7
Page 190
NEATPAGEINFO:id=E17BA96C-5D13-462A-B14C-81597AFE8ECE
NEATPAGEINFO:id=44729152-946E-4DCF-99A1-58527612DA23
Page 191
NEATPAGEINFO:id=D650EAA1-BFF0-497C-98F8-FDD9ABD9B6C7
NEATPAGEINFO:id=4F1911FC-28CF-41D7-84A9-7D81380CE4D9
Page 192
NEATPAGEINFO:id=B5C32E90-4268-4625-AE0C-B44131E68A3C
NEATPAGEINFO:id=9E45B616-EA5E-4851-884A-5FA6E646CC4D
Page 193
NEATPAGEINFO:id=19C4DAB1-E02D-4660-8C7E-FEA6631801EA
NEATPAGEINFO:id=D11FCB64-7FE9-48EC-A477-932BA687E36C
Page 194
NEATPAGEINFO:id=09795E4D-044B-4FC2-937B-3A0CF4ABE8DE
NEATPAGEINFO:id=92621911-5F24-444F-BEA3-60F02320D7E5
Page 195
NEATPAGEINFO:id=3B0267AE-9A3E-420E-B253-80EA27006734
NEATPAGEINFO:id=B3A90E43-3F4F-4F09-AFED-0EA8DD1DBC88
