21
1 An Exercise Progression from for Shoulder Rehabilitation based on Rehabilitation based on the available EMG Literature Ti L Uhl PhD ATC PT FNATA Tim L. Uhl PhD ATC PT FNATA Department of Rehabilitation Sciences College of Health Sciences University of Kentucky Context Therapeutic exercises are prescribed along a continuum a continuum A common goal to increase neuromuscular activity In order to stimulate neuromuscular & musculotendinous adaptations musculotendinous adaptations Thereby allowing the patient to return to “normal” physical Context Better understanding the neuromuscular activity levels of therapeutic exercise allows us to match the exercise selected to the patient’s state of healing This knowledge also allows us to titrate the exercises prescribed up or down the continuum based on the patient’s response continuum based on the patient’s response Objectives Describe Electromyography data collection and interpretation Outline an exercise progression through a phased rehabilitation process keeping physiological healing response and tissue reactivity in mind Higher EMG activity greater muscular recruitment Rehabilitation exercises are often selected based on EMG research to facilitate specific muscle activation Therapeutic exercises rarely isolate “The whole of science is nothing more than a refinement of everyday thinking.” Albert Einstein (1879 - 1955), Physics and Reality 1936

An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    6

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

1

An Exercise Progression from for Shoulder

Rehabilitation based onRehabilitation based on the available EMG

Literature

Ti L Uhl PhD ATC PT FNATATim L. Uhl PhD ATC PT FNATADepartment of Rehabilitation Sciences

College of Health SciencesUniversity of Kentucky

Context• Therapeutic exercises are prescribed along

a continuuma continuum • A common goal to increase neuromuscular

activity • In order to stimulate neuromuscular &

musculotendinous adaptationsmusculotendinous adaptations • Thereby allowing the patient to return to

“normal” physical

Context• Better understanding the neuromuscular

activity levels of therapeutic exercise allows y pus to match the exercise selected to the patient’s state of healing

• This knowledge also allows us to titrate the exercises prescribed up or down the continuum based on the patient’s responsecontinuum based on the patient’s response

Objectives• Describe Electromyography data collection and

interpretation• Outline an exercise progression through a phased

rehabilitation process keeping physiological healing response and tissue reactivity in mind– Higher EMG activity greater muscular recruitment

• Rehabilitation exercises are often selected based on EMG research to facilitate specific muscle activation– Therapeutic exercises rarely isolate

“The whole of science is nothing more than a refinement of everyday thinking.”

– Albert Einstein (1879 - 1955), Physics and Reality 1936

Page 2: An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

2

Electromyography (EMG)

• A technique to• A technique to evaluate and record electrical activity from skeletal muscle– EKG/ECG – cardiac

musclemuscle• Device is

electromyograph• Generates an

electromyogram

Electromyography

• The recording and l i f l t i lanalysis of myoelectrical

signals derived from motor unit activity

• Motor Unit– Nerve cell body in the spinal

cord– The motor nerve (axillary)– The muscle fibers that the

nerve innervates

When a Muscle Contracts

• Action potential travels d t tdown motor nerve to neuromuscular junction

• ACh causes breakdown of membrane to produce motor action potential (endplate potential)(endplate potential)

• Potential is propagated along sarcolemma

Set-up for collecting EMG data

Page 3: An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

3

Set up for Indwelling Electrodes (Fine Wire)

Action Potential Propagation• The recording

electrodes (surface orelectrodes (surface or indwelling) placed in parallel to the muscle fibers detect the relative voltage difference between the two electrodes as the action potential propagates along the muscle fibers

Utilization of EMG in Rehabilitation and Research

• Initiation of muscle activation (Onset)• How long is a muscle activated (Duration)• Amount of muscle activation (Amplitude)• Measures level of fatigue occurring in a

muscle (Frequency shifts)

Which Muscle Turned on First?

0 . 0 0 m s e c . 1 0 0 . 0 0

t o rq u e (2 0 4 8 x )

v e lo c it y (3 2 0 x )

s u p ra (0 . 5 x )

i f (0 5 )

(3 2 x )

(3 2 x )

(3 2 x )Force

Velocity

Supraspinatus

2 0 0 .0 0 m s e c .

in f ra (0 . 5 x )

p o s t d e lt (3 2 x )

(2 5 x )

(3 2 x )

Infraspinatus

Posterior Deltoid

Page 4: An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

4

Utilization of EMG in Rehabilitation and Research

• Measure of EMG AmplitudeT d t i h h l ti it– To determine how much muscular activity was recruited for a particular exercise

• EMG activity is translated from Volts to percentage of muscle activity– MVC – maximal voluntary contractiony– RVC – reference voluntary contraction (task, set

load)

Relative Amount of Muscular Activity

• Normalization of EMG signal to an event or to a specific task

• Allows for comparison between subjects, days, muscles or studies

– Soderberg & Knutson, Phys Ther 2000

Normalization• Specific positions identified for

shoulder or MMT positions• Rotator cuff• Rotator cuff

– Kelly, J Ortho Res 1996• Scapular musculature

– Michener, Phy Ther 2005• 100% isometric contraction (MVIC)

– Most commonly used– Need to perform for 3-5 sec duration with

2 3 repetition with at least 30 90 sec rest2-3 repetition with at least 30-90 sec. rest– Hagberg. Am J Phys Med 1981

• The highest amplitude obtained during time interval is considered 100% (1 or ½ second)

• EMG data is expressed as a %MVIC or %RVC

EMG Amplitude Categorization• 0 – 20% Low activity• 21 – 40% Moderate activity

• 15%MVIC= 30N force conservative estimate toy

• 41 – 60% High activity• >61% Very High activity

– DiGivone, JSES 1990

– 0 – 5% Minimal EMG activity (background noise)

– Perry, Gait Analysis 1992

conservative estimate to protect repair

– Long, JOSPT 2010

– Assumptions: fraction of MVIC, CSA, specific tension, & fiber pennation

Perry, Gait Analysis 1992

• <20% = Minimal activity• 20-50% = Moderate activity• >50% = Marked activity

– McCann, Clin Orth Rel Res 1993

– 44±15N load for 206 ±88 cycles generated 50% loss of rotator cuff repair

– Bicknell, Arthroscopy 2005

Page 5: An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

5

Limitations of EMG• Sources of interference

– Movement artifact

– External electrical noise (electrical outlets, ECG)

– Possibility of “cross-talk” from other muscles (surface)

• Reducing interference by use good equipment, small electrodes, and careful electrode placementelectrode placement

• Not a measure of force or strength– Moderate correlation in an isometric conditions

– Inman, EEG Clin Neurophysiol 1952

Rotator Cuff Tendon Rupture• Not typically traumatic• Degenerative overuse• Degenerative overuse

mechanism most common

• Combination of compression and peccentric overload

– Lin et al., J Biom 2004

Biomechanical Properties of Healing Tendon

• Human tendon maximal strength ranges from 50 –150MPa

– Gelberman et al., Injury and Repair Musculoskeletal Soft Tissues 1987

• Rat maximal tensile load =25 + 9 MPa

6wks = 8%– 6wks = 8%– 12 wks = 12%– Repaired supraspinatus post-

op does not approach intact values

– Carpenter et al., JSES 1998

Rehabilitation Implications

• Following tendon repair first 3- 6 wks loads across the tendon have to be minimal

• Animal model suggest Immobilization is beneficial over early mobilization– Increased organization– Less scar formation– Mechanically stronger– Mechanically stronger

– Thomopoulos, J Biom Eng, 2003

• Gradual introduction of stresses during the maturation process– Lower EMG activity

Page 6: An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

6

Rehabilitation Progression

Sport S ifi

FunctionalSpecific

Recovery

Strength Endurance

PowerKineticChain breakage

Kibler, Functional Rehabilitation

Acute Rest Modalities

Injection ROM

Wound care

Neuromuscular Control

Bracing

Rehabilitation 1998

Immobilization ≠ Inactivity• EMG activity is present in

immobilizer• Caution for certain activities to

protect of rotator cuff – Bimanual tasks increases Biceps (7-

16%) [SLAP]– Pulling open door activated

Supraspinatus (10-20%) [Rot Cuff Repairs]Repairs]

– Pushing open a door quicky activate Infra. (60±45%) [Rot Cuff Repairs]

– Reaching task with contralateral limb facilitate scapular musculature (20-60%) in the immobilized limb

– Smith, J Sh Elb Surg 2004

Quick Motions of ContralateralArm Increase Activity

Other Precautions in Sling

• Post-operatively to• Post-operatively to protect healing rotator cuff avoiding drinking with involved side while in sling

– Long, JOSPT 2010

Page 7: An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

7

Acute Phase Rehabilitation• For proper healing need some

period of immobilizationperiod of immobilization• Initiate ROM within physiological

healing restraints and pain tolerances

• Can we find a balance Hugh Owen Thomas Father of Immobilization

Adhesions

Communication

Respect Physiological Healing when Prescribing Exercises

80

90

100

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

% M

VIC

0

10

What level of muscle activity is associated with PROM?

• Pendulum• Pendulum• Supine Passive

elevation– w/ or without

therapist• Forward Bow• CPM

Pendulum

• Small vs large circle• Small vs large circle• Correct vs incorrect• 13 Healthy subjects• Concluded small

circles (20cm)circles (20cm) generated lowest EMG activity

– Long, JOSPT 2010

Page 8: An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

8

Passive Exercises• Surface EMG on 10

healthy subjects C f

Supra. Infra. Ant. Delt. TrapMn Sd Mn Sd Mn Sd Mn Sd

Pulleyusing MVIC for normalization– Pendulum– Pulley– Therapist assisted

PROM

Pulley18 10 9 5 25 15 15 10

Bar Rise 8 3 5 2 11 7 4 4

PROM4 2 3 2 8 4 8 3

CPM 5 6 4 2 2 2 5 5PROM

– CPM

• Pulley most activity (p<.05)

– Dockery, Orthopedics 1998

Passive Exercise• In 10 healthy subjects • What level of muscle

activity is associated• Supine Passive elevation performed by individual < 10%

• Forward Bow moving body around

activity is associated with PROM?– Not truly passive– Overall levels below

15% suggests to be a safe estimate to

stationary arm <10%– Uhl, Phy Med Rehab

2010

safe estimate to protect tissue

• No evidence in post-operative cohort

Rehabilitation Progression

Sport S ifi

Functional

• Protect weakened tissues

• Regain motion & functionSpecific

Recovery

Strength Endurance

PowerKineticChain breakage

Kibler, Functional Rehabilitation

function• Activate

inhibited/weakened muscles gradually

Acute Rest Modalities

Injection ROM

Wound care

Neuromuscular Control

Bracing

Rehabilitation 1998

Active-Assisted ROM Exercises• Critical period to avoid

abnormal movement patterns or substitution patternsor substitution patterns

• Various assistive devices (Pulley, Stick, Wall & Water) to minimize loads on healing tissue

• Facilitates muscle activation and dynamic muscular

l f h j icontrol of the joint• Caution using long lever

arms may be too much demand for recovering tissues

Page 9: An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

9

Gravity Minimized AAROM Exercises• Water provides buoyancy

– Slow elevation low demand on muscles <10%F t l ti t d– Fast elevation generated more activity

– Kelly et al. JOSPT 2000

• Wound considerations & availability to pool

Ex Supra Infra Ant. Delt

Sub. Delt.

Slow

4 + 4% 2 + 2% 2 + 2% 2 + 1%

Fast

17+15% 21+16% 17+13% 11+4%

Incremental Loading ↑ EMG activity

• Neer’s 3 phases demonstrated a progressiona progression

• Supine PROM• Upright AAROM• Upright AROM• Resistive

• RVC 2.25 (5lb) abd. to 150º• Not all AAROM are equal

Pulley Elevation w/Stick

Wall Slide

Mn Sd Mn Sd Mn SdSupra 13 17 19 18 22 23• Not all AAROM are equal

• Minimal – Moderate levels– McCann, Clin OrthoRel Res 1993

p

Infra. 20 31 27 20 9 10

Ant. Delt.

21 14 43 18 26 15

Serr. Ant.

14 14 29 20 18 14

Trap. 14 13 9 9 17 14

University of Washington Exercise Program

• Rehabilitation program which progresses patientswhich progresses patients from PROM to RROM.

• Similar to Neer’s program but emphasizes more scapular motion (protraction) and does not(protraction) and does not incorporate as much isometric and elastic resistance exercises.

– Rockwood & Matsen, The Shoulder 1998

Kinetic Chain Exercise Program

• Incorporates legs and• Incorporates legs and trunk to initiate and facilitate arm elevation

– Kibler , Med Sci Sport Ex 1998

– McMullen & Uhl JAT 2000

• Utilizes patient’s hand Ut es pat e t s a din contact with surface to unload the weight of the arm for AAROM exercises

– Wise, JSh Elb Surg 2004

Page 10: An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

10

EMG Assessment of Passive, Active-Assistive, & Active Exercises

45

50

-Uhl, Phy Med Rehab 2010

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Supraspinatus

Infraspinatus

Anterior deltoid

Upper trapezius

Serratus anterior

0

5

Supine Passive ROM

Forward Bow WC press up, hands close

WC press up, hands apart

Towel slide Scapular protraction on

ball

Supine press up

Wedge press up

Standing press-up

Passive Active-Assistive Active

Kinetic Chain Active Exercises = Static Standing Press-up

50

20

25

30

35

40

45

Supraspinatus

Infraspinatus

Anterior deltoid

Upper trapezius

Lower trapezius

Serratus anterior

0

5

10

15

Ips step up, no ball Standing press-up

Serratus anterior

Active Motion Relevance

• Passive = some Active-Assistive Exercises

• Active exercise in repaired flexor tendons is necessary to regain neuromuscular control (plasticity)– Session 1: immediately after immobilization

and PROM – Session 2: 6 weeks of active exerciseSession 2: 6 weeks of active exercise

– Coert J Hand Surg (EUR) 2009

• Deltoid progression supports the Reading protocol for massive cuff tears

– Levy, J Sh Elb Surg 2008

Subdividing Active-Assistive Elevation Exercises

50.00

10.00

15.00

20.00

25.00

30.00

35.00

40.00

45.00

Supraspinatus

Infraspinatus

Anterior Deltoid

0.00

5.00

Dusting Sidelying Elevation

Supine Forward Elevation

(Red Band)

Ball Roll Standing T-bar

Rope & Pulley Wall walk Standing T-bar w/ active

lowering

Active forward elevation

Graviity Minimized Upright Assisted Upright Active

Page 11: An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

11

Results

• AFE > Assisted Ex’s • Wall walk exercise was – Supraspinatus– Anterior Deltoid

• Anterior Deltoid activity increased at each level

most demanding of upright exercises for Supraspinatus– Reserve for later stage

in recoveryS i T B d 90– Gravity Minimized<

Upright assisted< Active

– Gaunt et al., Sports Health (2010)

• Supine T-Band 90 –150º although using resistive exercise was relative low demand on cuff musculature

Post-operative Subjects• Previous literature has used healthy subjects Is the

progression similar in post-operative subjects?progression similar in post operative subjects?

• Study Purposes:• To identify order of exercises of increasing

muscular activation amplitude in post-SLAP

Methods / Subjects• 20 subjects between 18 - 50 y/o

– healthy group vs. post-SLAP group, 4-6 wk s/p Type II repairType II repair

– No concomitant RC repair• Muscles

– Supraspinatus– Infraspinatus Healthy Group

Post-SLAP Group p

– Biceps– Serratus– Up. Trapezius– Ant. Delt.

Healthy Groupn = 10

Group n = 10

mean ± SD mean ± SDAge (years) 28 ± 6 28 ± 9Height (meters) 1.77 ± 0.1 1.81 ± 0.1Weight (kilograms) 84 ± 19 90 ± 20

• Reference Contractions- sub-maximal

EMG Normalization

maximal– Yang, APMR 1983

• Shoulder Muscles:– AFE –McCann, CORR 1993– 5lb Isometric Forward Elevation @ 45°

• Biceps and Infraspinatus:p p– 5 lb Bicep curl– 5 lb Isometric External Rotation

@ 45°

Page 12: An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

12

3 PROM Exercises

UE Rangerhttp://www.ueranger.com/

Active-Assisted (AAROM)

T-bar not illustrated

AAROM & AROM EMG - Results• No difference between groups for any

l t di dmuscle studied• EMG amplitudes

– Lowest for passive ex’s– Greatest for Active Forward elevation

• Active-Assistive – Supported Active Assistive = PROM– Wall Walk = AFE

Page 13: An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

13

EMG Levels (%RVC)

120

EMG Activation by Muscle

Upper Trapezius Serratus Anterior Anterior Deltoid Biceps Supraspinatus Infraspinatus

-20

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

EMG

(%R

VC)

Exercise

PROM AAROM AROM

Rehabilitation Progression

Sport S ifi

Functional

• Regain motion & function

• Regain strength • Develop enduranceSpecific

Recovery

Strength Endurance

PowerKineticChain breakage

Kibler, Functional Rehabilitation,

Develop endurance

Acute Rest Modalities

Injection ROM

Wound care

Neuromuscular Control

Bracing

Rehabilitation, 1998

Progression through Recovery • Re-establish

coordinated UEcoordinated UE movement before adding significant loads

• Enhance strength by increasing loadsg– Resistance – Speed– Lever arm

• Increase Endurance

Subtle Lever Arm Changes Muscular Activation Levels

• Wise, J Sh Elb Surg 2004

A. Short

, g

B LongB. Long

Page 14: An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

14

Developing Scapular Stabilization Exercises

• Low Row and Inferior GlideLow Row and Inferior Glide– Isometric exercises biasing

serratus and lower trapezius• Lawnmower & Robbery

– Dynamic exercises integrating trunk and scapular musculature

• These exercises areThese exercises are appropriate for intermediate phase scapular strengthening

– Kibler, AJSM 2008

Low to Moderate Muscular Demands (20-40%)

Up. Trap Low. Serr. Ant. Post.Up. Trap Low. Trap.

Serr.Ant

Ant. Delt.

Post. Delt.

Inferior glide

8 + 6 19 + 27 23 + 20 5 + 2 9 + 6

Low row 10 + 8 15 + 12 28 + 21 17 + 13 42 + 23

Lawnmower

22 + 16 31 + 19 26 + 21 6 + 4 16 + 11

Robbery 32 + 17 27 + 21 21 + 17 7 + 6 14 + 9

Lawnmower & Robbery

Increase activation of Lower Trapezius when contralateralhip extensor are activated. This phenomenon is suggested to occur due to tightening of thoracolumbar fascia in the direction of contralateral scapula within the kinetic chain.

Maenhout Br J Sports Med 2010

Elastic Resistance Exercises

• Rubber tubing for shoulder• Rubber tubing for shoulder exercises

• Developed for throwing athletes (on-field)

• Identified 7 exercises that moderately activated primarymoderately activated primary muscle involved in throwing– (* indicates key exercises)

– Myers JAT 2005

Page 15: An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

15

Elastic Resistance ExercisesHigh to Very High Category

Ant Mid Low Ser Sub- Supr InfraAnt. Delt

Mid. Delt

Low Trap

Ser. Ant.

Sub-scap

Supra

Infra

ER 0 6 ± 6 8 ± 7 48 ±25 18 ±19 72 ±55 20 ±13 46 ±20

ER 90* 22 ±11 50 ±21 88 ±51 66 ±39 57 ±50 50 ±21 51 ±3090IR 0 6 ± 6 40± 3 44 ±30 21 ± 4 74 ±47 10 ± 6 32 ±51

IR 90 28 ±18 41 ±21 54 ±39 54 ±32 71 ±43 41 ±30 24 ±21

Elastic Resistance Exercises

Scapular Punch

Shoulder extension

Shoulder Flexion w/ axial load

Low Row

Elastic Resistance ExercisesAnt. Delt

Mid. Delt

Low Trap

Ser. Ant

Sub-scap

Supra InfraDelt Delt Trap Ant. scap

ScapPunc* 45 ±36 36 ±24 32 ±32 67 ±45 69 ±47 46 ±31 35 ±17

Low Row* 19 ±13 34± 23 44 ±32 22 ±14 69 ±50 46 ±38 29 ±16

SSh. Flex* 60 ±41 32 ±14 49 ±35 67 ±37 99 ±37 42 ±22 47 ±34

Sh. Ext* 19 ±15 27 ±16 53 ±40 30 ±21 97 ±55 29 ±21 50 ±57

Elastic Resistance ExercisesAnt. Delt

Mid. Delt

Low Trap

Ser. Ant.

Sub-scap

Supra Infra

Throw Accel* 27±20 22 ± 12 53 ±46 55 ±35 93 ±51 36 ±32 33 ±22

Throw D l* 29±16 44 ±16 63 ±42 48 ±32 69 ±48 64 ±32 45 ±21Decel* 29±16 44 ±16 63 ±42 48 ±32 69 ±48 64 ±32 45 ±21

Page 16: An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

16

What about Weight Bearing Exercises?

• Fixed Boundary Axial Load• Fixed Boundary Axial Load– Lephart & Henry JSR 1996

• Greater joint congruency thereby decreasing shear forces

• Football & Wrestling – sport

6 + 3 BW%

g pspecific

• EMG activity highly correlated to load R2 = .95

7 Common CKC Exercises • Prayer• Quadruped

16% BW + 2%• Quadruped• Tripod• Pointer• Push-up• Push-up feet elevated• One arm push-up

33% BW + 3%One arm push up

– Uhl et al. JOSPT 2003

Push-up elevated and One Arm Push-up

40% BW + 4% 60% BW + 6%40% BW 4% 60% BW + 6%140

160

EMG Activity for Exercise Position

40

60

80

100

120

EMG

Act

ivity

(% M

VIC

)

-20

0

20

Prayer Quad Tripod Pointer Push-up Push-up elev 1 arm push-up

E

Supraspinatus Infraspinatus Ant-deltoid Post-deltoid Pec-major

Page 17: An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

17

Scapular Muscular Activation• Ipsilateral leg ext.

biases SerratusA t i (#3)Anterior (#3)

• Contralateral leg ext. biases Lower Trapezius (#2)

– Maenhout Br J Sport Med 2010

• EMG low• EMG low –moderate 15- 45%

Unstable Surface does not Increase Muscular Activation

120

40

60

80

100

120

Cuff LinkPush-up

0

20

Middle Trapezius

Lower Trapezius

Serratus Anterior

Tucker et al., JAT 2008

Injury Effects Neuromuscular System

• Serratus Anterior inhibition• Substitution of upper• Substitution of upper

trapezius & rhomboids– Scovazzo et al., AJSM 1991

• 80 ms delay in activation of Serratus anterior, indicating poor muscular control

Wadsworth & Bullock Saxton Int J– Wadsworth & Bullock-Saxton, Int J Sports Med. 1997

• Increased Upper Trap activity & decreased SerratusAnterior activity with a load

– Ludewig & Cook, PT 2000

Serratus Progression• Least to most challenging

based on average amplitude ofbased on average amplitude of MVIC

• Shoulder Extension (5+3)• Press-up (32+28)• Forward Punch (34+15)• Scaption (38+10)• Knee Push-up Plus (40+15)• Knee Push-up Plus (40+15)• Serratus anterior Punch (44+12)• Dynamic Hug (50+15)• Push-up Plus (58+17)

– Decker, AJSM 1999

Page 18: An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

18

Lower Fibers of Serratus Anterior

• Protraction focuses on• Protraction focuses on upper fibers

• Elevation above 120 deg is needed to address lower fibers of Serratus Ant.Serratus Ant.

• Diagonal Flexion / Adduction / Ext. Rot.

– Ekstrom et al., JOSPT 2003

Serratus Anterior Exercises (%MVIC)Exercise Mosely ’92 Ekstrom ‘03

Flexion 96 + 45 NTAbduction 96 + 53 NTAbduction 96 + 53 NTScaption > 120o 91 + 52 96 + 24Diag Flex/ Horiz Add/ Ext. Rot.

NT 100 + 24

Military Press 82 + 36 NTUnilateral shoulder press supine w/plus

NT 62 + 19

Push up w/plus 80 + 38 NTPush up w/ hands wide 57 + 36 NTBilateral scapular protract. NT 57 + 22

Biasing Serratus Anterior (SA) over Upper Trap (UT)

• Push-up plus is better than wall push-up tothan wall push-up to activate SA relative to UT

– Ludewig AJSM 2004

• Exercises favoring early LT & MT over UT

ti tiactivation– Prone Ext– Prone Horiz Abd– Side-lying ER

– De Mey JOSPT 2009

Rotator Cuff Core Exercises

Protect t ianterior

capsule

Page 19: An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

19

647283

7372

74

79

8080

100

Supraspinatus Subscapularis Infraspinatus Deltoid

s ctio

n

I f i t

Deltoid

72

66

60

80505662

52

80

74

70

67

64

50 0

20

40

60

EMG Activity (% MVIC)

Pron

e ER

at 9

0Sc

aptio

n ER Flex

ion

PHA

90° E

RSc

aptio

n IR

Mili

tary

pre

ssAb

duct

Supraspinatus

Subscapularis

Infraspinatus

Rehabilitation Progression

Sport S ifi

Functional

• Increase Power• Integrate specific

functional demandsSpecific

Recovery

Strength Endurance

PowerKineticChain breakage

Kibler, Functional Rehabilitation

Acute Rest Modalities

Injection ROM

Wound care

Neuromuscular Control

Bracing

Rehabilitation 1998

Baseball Throwing Tasks

175

200

75

100

125

150

%M

VIC

InfraspinatusSupraspinatusSubscapularisDeltoidSerratus AnteriorTrapezius

0

25

50

Early Cocking Late Cocking Acceleration FollowThrough

Phases of Throwing

Plyometrics• Overhead plyometric simulate and

prepare body to return throwing activities

– Cordasco et al. AJSM 1996

50

60

70

80

90

VIC

0

10

20

30

40

Infraspinatus Supraspinatus Subscapularis Upper Trap

% M

V

Page 20: An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

20

Plyometrics Posterior Shoulder

• No EMG evidence• No EMG evidence • Several studies

indicate benefit – Injury reduction

– Swanik J Sport Rehab 20022002

– Strengthening– Carter, J Strength

Cond Res. 2007– Swanik, JSES 2002

Key Points: Acute Phase & Early Recovery

• Consistently low EMG activity for PROM– 15% MVIC appears to be most safe15% MVIC appears to be most safe

• AAROM exercises can be performed in a position or with support that equals PROM and requires less activation than AFE– Establish proper movement with support or in

gravity minimized position prior to initiating unsupported upright or resistive exercises

• Neural reorganization – Upper trapezius activation increases as upright

positions

Key Points: Recovery Phase• Resistance can be advance many ways

– Lever armLever arm– Load – Speed

• Many exercises overlap muscular activations be efficient with exercise selection – Subscapularis active with several functional

exercises

Key Points: Functional Phase• EMG studies can help you select appropriate

exercise for your patient but must consider / k d dsport/work demands

– Not all tasks or exercise activation levels are known

• There are often multiple variations to activate the muscle

Think along a continuum of exercises– Think along a continuum of exercises• Design program based:

– Tissue physiology– Your clinical judgment – Available evidence

Page 21: An Exercise Progression Context from for Shoulder Rehabilitation … · 2019-07-09 · 5 Limitations of EMG • Sources of interference – Movement artifact – External electrical

21

Thanks Y’all

My Old Kentucky Home Contact: [email protected]