31
THE ADIPOSE LOBE OF THE PELA'IC PIN OP THE SALMON. 703 An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of the Pelvic Fin of the Salmon. By Edward W. Sliann, B.Sc, Demonstrator and Assistant Lecturer in Zoology in the Victoria University of Manchester. With Plate 43 and 3 Text-figures. CONTENTS. PAGE I. INTKODTTCTOBY . . . . 703 II. DETAILS OF THE ANATOMY OF THE PELVIC FIN AND OF ITS ADIPOSE LOBE . . . . 706 III. THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ADIPOSE LOBE . . 718 IV. OBSERVATIONS FEOM OTHER TELEOSTEI . . 722 V. HOMOLOGY AND FUNCTION . . . . 727 I. INTRODUCTORY. DURING the past two years the Zoological Department in Manchester University has been in receipt of fresh salmon, mainly from the Wye, which have been sent for the purpose of age determination by means of scale-markings. In December last Professor Hickson called my attention to the presence of a fleshy lobe lying immediately above the pelvic fin of a large female specimen. As we did not then know whether this growth was normal, and, if normal, whether it was con- fined to female specimens, I undertook to investigate the question; the investigation has not only proved exceedingly

An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

THE ADIPOSE LOBE OF THE PELA'IC PIN OP THE SALMON. 703

An Account of the Anatomy and Homology ofthe Adipose Lobe of the Pelvic Fin of theSalmon.

By

Edward W. Sliann, B.Sc,Demonstrator and Assistant Lecturer in Zoology in the Victoria

University of Manchester.

With Plate 43 and 3 Text-figures.

CONTENTS.PAGE

I. INTKODTTCTOBY . . . . 703

II. DETAILS OF THE ANATOMY OF THE PELVIC FIN AND OF

ITS ADIPOSE LOBE . . . . 706III. THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ADIPOSE LOBE . . 718IV. OBSERVATIONS FEOM OTHER TELEOSTEI . . 722

V. HOMOLOGY AND FUNCTION . . . . 7 2 7

I. INTRODUCTORY.

DURING the past two years the Zoological Department inManchester University has been in receipt of fresh salmon,mainly from the Wye, which have been sent for the purpose ofage determination by means of scale-markings. In Decemberlast Professor Hickson called my attention to the presence ofa fleshy lobe lying immediately above the pelvic fin of alarge female specimen. As we did not then know whetherthis growth was normal, and, if normal, whether it was con-fined to female specimens, I undertook to investigate thequestion; the investigation has not only proved exceedingly

Page 2: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

704 EDWARD W\ SHANN.

interesting, but has opened up a wider scope of research thanI had anticipated.

On consulting various books on fishes I found that thelobe was invariably figured in the best drawings of thesalmon ; in Day's ' British Fishes/ for instance, it can clearlybe seen.1 At the same time no reference to the occurrence ofsuch a lobe could be found in any book which might beexpected to throw light upon a structure of this nature. Imade a dissection of the adipose lobe, and so found that itwas supported at its base by a splint of bone; the posterior,or distal, extremity of this bone was united to, but notfused with, the outermost fin-ray. This splint of bone isdepicted in a figure of the pelvic fin skeleton of the trout inParker and Haswell's ' Text-book of Zoology,'" and it isthere mentioned that " the adipose lobe of the pelvic fin issupported by a small scale-like bone." By treatment ofsections of the lobe with osmic acid and with Sudan III , Iwas able to satisfy myself that a considerable amount of fatwas present in the lobe ; I further observed from my sectionsthat the lobe was stiffened by <i plate of hyaline substancewhich ran throughout its length. I was fortunate enough toobtain a series of young salmon ranging in age from one tofive months ; from these I prepared serial sections of the pelvicregion, and was thereby enabled to observe the origin andgrowth of the adipose lobe-. From these observations I havebeen able to demonstrate that this so-called " adipose lobe "is nothing more or less than an enlarged scale which has neverpierced its connective-tissue pocket. That a scale is capableof becoming a fin-like structure is an additional support toMr. Goodrich's hypothesis, namely, that the dermal fin-rays(lepidotrichia) are modified body-scales, if his lucid argumenthas not already gaiDed general acceptance.

I further examined the condition of the pelvic fins of otherTeleosteans; and my observations from illustrations and fromactual specimens go to show that an enlarged scale in the

1 See also fig. 1 herein.2 Ed. 2, vol. ii, fig. 864.

Page 3: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

THE ADIPOSE LOBE OF THE PELVIC FIN OF THE SALMON. 705

outer angle of the pelvic fin is a character which is commonto a wide range of members of that class. This "accessoryscale/' if I may so term it, is particularly characteristic ofthe more primitive' Teleosteans, and is almost invariablyabsent in highly specialised forms; it is often well developedin actively swimming forms, and absent, or much reduced, informs which haunt the ground. Only in the genus Salmo,so far as I am aware, is the accessory scale converted intoan adipose lobe, and only in this genus, and perhaps inOoregonus , has it any skeletal connection with the fin-rays of the pelvic fin.

The nature of the function which this adipose lobe servesis obscure, but it is possible that it may. assist in facilitatingthe rapid movements for. which this fish is noted. Thesubject will be treated more fully at the conclusion of thispaper.

I wish to acknowledge my indebtedness to Miss P. C.Esdaile, M.Sc, for permission to remove the portions of thesalmon (which had been supplied by J. A. Hutton, Esq., forwork upon which she was engaged) which I required, alsofor furnishing me with various particulars as to the size, age,locality and condition of the several specimens. To ProfessorLorrain Smith I am indebted for the use of apparatus in thePathological Department, and for his ready assistance indetermining the nature of the fat in the adipose fins.Finally, I am glad of this opportunity gratefully to acknow-ledge the kindness of Professor J. W. Spengel for grantingme a table for work in his laboratory at Griessen, and for theuse of apparatus and materials; also that of Professor J.Versluys for his friendly interest and for many illuminativesuggestions.

Figs. 1 and 2 illustrating this work were prepared fromphotographs kindly undertaken respectively by Mr. J. T.Wadsvvorth, of the Zoological Department at ManchesterUniversity, and by Mr. A. W. Brown, of the Gatty MarineLaboratory at St. Andrews.

Page 4: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

706 EDWARD W. SHANK.

II. DETAILS OP THE ANATOMY OF THE PELVIC FIN AND OP ITS

ADIPOSE LOBE.

(1) A n a t o m y of t he P e l v i c F i n .

The anatomy and development of the pelvic fin of thesalmon has been described in a paper by K. Gr. Harrison,1

and, as it is desirable that the environment of the adiposelobe should first be realised, I give below Harrison's summaryof the anatomy:

" Die Lage der Bauchflosse variirt bekanntlich sehrstark bei den verschiedenen Teleostiern. Sie kann hinter,direkt unter, oder vor der Brustflosse liegen und wirddementsprechend bauch-, brust-, oder Kehlstandig genannfc.Die erste dieser Lagen ist natiirlich als die urspriinglicheanzusehen. Diese findet sich bei dem Lachs. Diese Flosseist an der ventralen Seite des Korpers gelegen, sehr nahezur Medianebene,und ganz ventral von der Rumpf muskulatur.Die Muskeln der beiden Flossen werden zum grossten Theilnur dnrch ein diinnes Lager Fettgewebe von einandergetrennt. Kopfwarts ragt zwischen sie auf eine gewisseStreche der M. r e c t u s abdomin i s hinein.

" Die Flossenstrahlen sind am Korper in einer schragenLinie befestigfc. Die Basen beider Flossen convirgiren somitcaudalwarts gegen die Mittellinie. Der grosste Theil desprimaren Skeletes der Flosse besteht vorzugsweise aus eineniKnochen, der als Basa le m e t a p t e r y g i i bezeichnet wird.Derselbe ist dreieckig und nur theilweise verknocheit. Diecaudale Seite des Dreiecks ist die Kurzeste ; an ihm articulirenvermittelst kleiner Eadien die Flossenstrahlen. Die Langedes Knochens iibertriffb seine Breite um ein bedeutendes under dehnt sich, wie auch die Muskeln, weit von der Basis derfreien Flosse nach vorn aus.

' ' Die Ebenen, in denen diese Knochen auf den beidenSeiten des Korpers liegen, convergiren dorsalwarts. Daher

1 Harrison, K.G., " Unpaar. u. Paar. Flossen. d. Teleostien,"' Arcli. furMikr. Anat.,' 1895, p. 530.

Page 5: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

THE ADIPOSE LOBE OF THE PELVIC PIN OF THE SALMON. 707

liegen die Mm. Adduc to res beinahe ganz dorsal zumKnoclien eingebettet zwischen Hartgebildeu und Muskeln desRurnpfes, wahrend die Abductoren zumgrossten Theil ventralvom Flossenskelet sich finden.

"Der M. abduc to r super f ic ia l i s entspringt von derFascie, welclie den tiefliegenden bedeckt und zielit zu derBasis eines jeden Plossenstraliles. Er ist der kleinste vonalien Flossenrnuskeln.

"Der M. abduc to r profundus entspringt von dermedianen Kante des Basale uud befestigt sicli an derInneuseite der ventralen Strahlenhalfte.

"Der M. adduc to r super f ic ia l i s ist leicht iu zweiPortionen trennbar. Ein laugfaseriger Theil eutspriugt vondem oralen Ende des Basale und inserirt an den vier antero-lateralen Sfcrahlen. Ein Kursfaseriger Theil ist mehr oderweniger deutlich in einzelne. Muskelbiiudel zerlegt, die vonder Fuscie der Korperniuskulatur entspringen und an derBasis der caudalen Strahlen inseriren. Der Verlauf derletzten caudal gelegenen Muskelbiindel ist beinahe vertical.

"Der M . adduc to r prof undus eutspringt vorzugsweisevon der medianeu Kante des Basa le und ist symmetrischzum eutsprechenden Biindel des Abductor profuudus an derInnenseite der dorsalen Strahlenhalfte befestigt. Der Muskeliibertrifft an Masse den oberflachlichen Adductor uin einBedeutendes.

" Die Nerven der Plosse bilden eineu Plexus und stammenvon sechs Riickenmarksnerven ab."

My observations bear out in every respect the aboveaccount oE the musculature of the pelvic fin of the salmon,and I will only add that, iu adult specimens, the tendonsfastened to the bases of the fin-rays are very distinct;forwards, however, the muscle sheets are quite continuous,excepting that of the adduc to r superficial is , which, asHarrison remarks, is divided longitudinally into two portions.There are normally nine fin-rays in each pelvic fin, andthough most authors quote ten as a variation from the normal,I have not yet met with this condition.

Page 6: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

708 EDWARD Ttf. SHANN.

In addition to the bony elements of the pelvic fin, namelythe Basale m e t a p t e r y g i i and the lepidotrichia (dermalfin-rays), which have been mentioned above, there are inaddition three small nodules, the distal pterygiophores (seefig. 2, Pt.). The precise positiou of these nodules varies notonly in different specimens, but in the right and left fins ofthe same specimen. The largest pterygiophore is placedinvariably, so far as my observations go, between the dorsaland ventral halves of the ninth, or innei*, fin-ray. The middlepterygiophore varies in positiou, but not infrequently occursbetween the dorsal and ventral halves of the fourth fin-ray.The outer pterygiophore occurs between the dorsal andventral halves of the third or second fin-ray. In one specimenthe middle and outer pterygiophores were bound closelytogether and occupied the space between the third andsecond fin-rays. On warming each of these pterygiophoresin turn in a weak solution oE caustic potash, the inner wasfound to remain single, but the middle and outer split fairlyreadily each into two distinct nodules. That all these severalportions are ossified is indicated by the fact that theyeffervesce when placed in dilute hydrochloric acid.

Having now in mind the position and essential points inthe anatomy of the pelvic fin of the salmon we shall proceedto locate and to describe the structure, known as the adiposelobe, with which it forms an intimate connection.

(2) Ana tomy of the Adipose Lobe.

The lobe (fig. 1) lies in the angle between the pelvic finand the body-wall in a position dorsal to and abaxial from thefirst, or outermost, fin-ray. It presents a vertical triangularsurface when the fish is viewed from the lateral aspect, theacute-angled apex of the triangle being directed posteriorly ;at the proximal end its section is approximately in the formof an equilateral triangle, whose apex is directed inwardsand is united to the body-wall of the fish; at the aboral endthe lobe is free and plano-convex in section, the convex

Page 7: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

THE ADIPOSK LOBE OF THE PELVIC FIN OF THE SALMON. 709

side is aclaxial and simply represents the result of the gradualrounding-off of the angular adaxial surface which has beennoted at the proximal end. The outer vertical surface is greyin colour and firm in texture ; the two inner surfaces, namelythe dorso-lateral which faces the body-wall, and the ventro-lateral which faces the upper surface oE the outermost fin-ray,are white in colour and soft to the touch. When at rest, thetwo inner surfaces of the lobe are closely apposed to thesurfaces of the fish which they respectively subtend; as aresult oE this the soft ventro-lateral surface is grooved in itsposterior half owing to the pressure of the fin-skeleton.

The lobe is equally well developed in specimens of bothsexes, and, as far as one can judge from the comparativelyfew specimens which I have been able to examine, it furtherappears that the size of the lobe is not altered during theseasonal movements of the fish. Specimens were examinedin the pink of condition, fresh from the sea, and others whichhad spawned and were, in some cases, iufected with fungus,but neither the regular outline of the lobe nor its consistencyappeared to differ in any degree; this is worthy of note,as itis well known that the body-scales of the salmon undergo avei-y marked disintegration at their margins, known as thespawning-mark, after the sexual products have been shed.Only in one unfortunate fish, which had long been sufferingfrom an unsightly wound,1 was the adipose lobe, on either side,reduced to a mere stump. The following measurements arefrom a male salmon weighing 22£ lb., 100 cm. in length,52 cm. in girth, taken in the Wye, and will serve to conveyan idea of the normal proportions of the adipose lobe :

Length of outer margin of pelvic fin . 10-0 cm.„ inner ,, „ . . 5'5 „

Breadth of distal „ „ 6-0 „„ proximal ,, ,, . . 3'0 „

Length of adipose lobe . . . . 4'0 ,,Breadth „ (at base) . . 0'7 „

1 A hole about an inch in diameter piercing the body-wall and entering the abdominal cavity in the anal region.

Page 8: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

710 EDWARD W. SHANN.

On removing the skin from the base of the adipose lobe andthat covering the dorsal aspect of the outermost fin-ray asplint of bone, fig. 2 (Sp.), was observed connecting the fin-ray with the base of the adipose lobe. At its adaxialextremity this splint of bone is attached by connective tissue,just as two adjacent fin-rays are connected, to the dorsal halfof the outermost fin-ray posterior to the point where the

TEST-PIG. 1.

F.r.d.

Adipose lobe from the left side to show its connection with thepelvic fin. The ligament connecting with the dorsal ramus ofthe head of the fin-ray has been severed, and the lobe deflectedoutwards through an angle of 180° (so that its inner, angularsurface is presented). Ad. Adipose lobe. F.r.d. Dorsal halfof the 1st fin-ray. Lig. Ligament. Sp. Splint of bone.

latter is joined by the ventral half; but while the two halvesare still quite distinct, the splint in this region is rectilinear,and in girth somewhat more slender than the dorsal half ofthe fin-ray. At its abaxial extremity the splint curves sharplyupwards so as to circumscribe the base of the adipose lobe(Text-fig. 1). There appear to be no muscles connected withthe splint; it simply lies in a pocket of connective tissue, tothe Trails of which it is loosely attached; nor ai-e there in theadult any muscles connected with the adipose lobe. On the

Page 9: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

THE ADIPOSE LOBE OP THE PELVIC FIN OF TEE SALMON. 711

inner aspect of the latter, however, near the proximalextremity, there are certain masses of tough ligament (lig.),which unite it with the heads of the dorsal halves of the first(outermost) and second fin-rays. Owing to this arrangementa certain amount of movement of the adipose lobe is conse-quent to the movement of the fin-rays, but there appears tobe no mechanism for independent action. Further dissectionof the lobe revealed the presence of an irregularly shapedmass of hard substance running throughout its length ; nearthe base the mass is more or less spear-shaped, so that icappears linear in cross section; as the distal extremity isapproached the section becomes triangular, but in all parts aflat surface runs parallel with, and close beneath, the verticalouter wall of the lobe.

(3) His to logy of the Adipose Lobe.

Transverse sections, taken near the base of the lobe shortlybefore it loses all connection with the body-wall, are tri-angular in outline. Fig. 3 represents such a section togetherwith the adjacent portion of the body-wall. The first featureof note is the entire absence of epidermis, not only on thesurface of the lobe, but also on the surface of the opposingbody-wall; this condition invariably obtained in the case ofall adult specimens examined by me.1 The lobe is boundedby a single strand of homogeneous material, which is slightlyrefringent and stains deeply with iron-ha3inafcoxylin; thisstrand I take to be the menibrana basale (M.b.). Belowthe membrana basale the lobe is composed of denseconnective tissue (C.t.), whose fibres run approximately

1 It should be mentioned, however, that the fish had all travelled con-siderable distances before they reached me, so that the epidermis mayhave been rubbed off during transit or may have decomposed duringthe time that elapsed before the tissues were placed in the preservingfluid. I hope later to have an opportunity to clear this doubtfulpoint by preserving carefully the adipose lobe from a salmon immediatelyit is taken from the water.

VOL. 58, PAET 4. NEW SEEIES. 4 7

Page 10: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

712 EDWARD W. SHANN.

parallel to the surface of the lobe which they subtend. Inthe centre of the lobe there is a fatty tissue (F, t.') ; theconnective tissue here is loosely and irregulai"ly arranged toallow space for the fat-globules. The latter have beendissolved by the action of alcohol in the preparation depictedin fig. 3; they will be described later when fig. 5 is examined.The accessory scale (Sc. A.), can be seen as a band ofrefringent substance running parallel to the vertical outerwall of the lobe throughout its entire height. It issurrounded by a scale pocket (Sep.). A normal body-scale(8c.) is also shown in fig. 3 ; on comparing the accessory scalewith this, it is seen that the former is very much the larger,but does not show the characteristic concentric markings.In thicker sections from this region of the lobe a few largepigment-cells were observed embedded deep in the outervertical wall.

Fig. 4 represents a transverse section taken through the baseof the adipose lobe quite close to its origin, where it is scarcelyto be distinguished externally from the body-wall. Two scales(S.c.) are seen lying in their pockets (Sep.), close beneaththe outer wall. The accessory scale (Sc. a.) is cut close to itsroot, and appears shorter and thicker than in the sectionshown in fig. 3 ; the arrangement of the tissues is similar inthe two sections. Near the inner aspect a round space isseen (Sp. h.); this is due to the removal of the bony splint(Text-fig. 1, Sp.) which supports the adipose lobe. It wasnoticed above, under the description of the dissection of thelobe, that the splint lay in a pocket of connective tissue; nowin the section, the hole (Sp. h.) is seen to be surrounded byconcentric stands of connective tissue, which give it theappearance of a scale-pocket. This resemblance will receivefurther notice in the section on homology.

Proceeding towards the middle of the length of the lobe,where it is entirely free from the body-wall, we obtain a crosssection which is still roughly triangular; such a section isshown in fig. 5. The outer vertical wall (0.), is approxi-mately straight, the dorsal angle (D.) is acute, the ventral

Page 11: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

THE ADIPOSE LOBE OF THE PELVIC KIN OJi1 THE SALMON. 713

extremity (V.) has become flattened, the dorso-lateral borderis markedly longer than the ventro-lateral, the latter isdeeply furrowed. There is no epidermis; the outer border is,as before, formed by the membraua basa l e (M.b.) Im-mediately below the surface occur several layers of closelypacked connective-tissue fibres. These vnu parallel to tliesurface which they subtend, and are very definitely defined ;they are not shown in fig. 5, which was drawn from a hand-cut section; they appear, however, in fig. 6. There is a largeaccumulation of fat-globules (Ft.) in the central area; theyappear as a band of orange running parallel with theaccessory scale iu sections stained with Sudan III. Inaddition a small clump appears in the central area on theouter side of the scale, where the latter makes a small bendaway from the outer border of the lobe.

A few pigment-cells [Pig.) occur in the outer wall. Theaccessory scale (Sc. a.) is seen as a narrow strip of hyalinesubstance, running approximately parallel to the outer borderof the lobe throughout the length of the latter. In sectionsfrom the same region of other salmon, there is sometimes aknotted swelling in that part of the accessory scale whichlies within the broad portion of the lobe; it is more usual,however, to find this swelling nearer the distal end; such acondition is realised in fig. 6.

As the distal end is approached, the outline of the lobeand the shape of the accessory scale vary considerably iudifferent salmon.1 This is not surpi'ising in an orgau of suchadventitious nature. The most constant and, moreover, themost striking feature of the distal area of the lobe is thepresence of a patch of well-defined stratified epithelium.This epithelium, which is depicted in Text-fig. 2 (1), andunder higher magnification in fig. 7 [Ep.)} corresponds withthe normal mucous epithelium of fishes; that is to say, it con-sists of round cells on the surface, passing into oval cells,and finally into palissade cells, the latter standing on a well-

1 So far as I have observed they are always similar in both the adiposelobes of the same fish.

Page 12: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

714 EDWABD W. SHANN.

defined membrana basale (M.b.). Each cell contains awell-defined nucleus (IV.). Serial sections show that thisepithelium occupies an oval area a few millimetres from thetip of the lobe, and that it is confined to the outer vertical

TEXT-FIG. 2.

Scbl. .Sc.A.

- S c . A .

Sc.A. M.b.

T. Ss. Adipose lobe of adult salmon. 1. In the region of theepidermis. 2. Slightly more than 3'5 mm. from the tip.3. Slightly more than 1 mm. from the tip. 4. At the tip.0., V. Outer, ventral aspects. Ct. Connective tissue. Ep. Epi-dermis. M. b. Membrana basale. Se. A. Accessory scale. Scbl.Scleroblastic layer.

wall of the lobe. The invariable preservation of thisepidermal tissue on a definite area, which is in no wayspecially protected, tends to suggest that the absence ofepidermis from the remainder of the lobe is quite a normal

Page 13: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

THE ADIPOSE LOBE OP THR PELVIO FIN OF THE SALMON. 715

condition. Beneath the membrane ba sa l e (31. b.) of theouter wall are numerous small pigment-cells (Pig.)'- a fewlarge isolated pigment-cells occur deep in the dorso-latenilsurface. The connective tissue (C. t.) is more open in texturethan that of the proximal region; the elongated nuclei of thecells (JV.) are clearly depicted ; towards the surface the nucleiare fewer and rounder. The accessory scale in this region istypically trimdiate in outline as appears in Text-fig. 2 (1),with a swelling where the rays meet; but it is sometiuit-scompressed into masses, which are plate-like in section andmuch vacuolated. The succeeding sections sketched iu Text-fig. 2 (2, 3) show that the scale is continued to the extremedistal end of the adipose lobe, though in the liist> No. 4, itonly consists of a. layer of scleroblasts (Scbl.), by means ofwhich growth is continued throughout life.

(4) Examina t ion of the F a t of the Adipose Lobe.

Sections from all parts of the lobe, taken from freshspecimens or from those which have been preserved in10 per cent, formalin or in Mailer's fluid, give the charac-teristic blackening on treatment with dilute osmicacid. Thistreatment is not entirely satisfactory, for while the fat-globulesturn black, the connective tissue is also affected to a certaindegree, turning brown, and the fatty matter is not sufficientlyclearly differentiated. A better result is obtained by treatinghand-sections, or frozen sections, with Sudan III accordingto the method described by Lee1; the fat-globules are thenstained a deep orange coloui', while the other tissues arescarcely affected. The distribution of the fat in a sectiouprepared in this manner is illustrated in fig. 5. Nearer thedistal extremity the fat is almost entirely confined to theinner side of the accessory scale ; towards the base it spreadsto the outer side, where it occurs in very considerable quan-tities.

The fact that a stain is readily obtained with Sudan III at1 ' Microtomist's Vade-Mecnm,' ed. vi, p. 376.

Page 14: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

716 • EDWAED W. SHANN.

the ordinary room temperature indicates that the fat is in aliquid condition, as opposed to a fluid crystalline condition ;for the staining is consequent upon the solution of the dyein the fat, and the solubility is greater in liquid fats than influid crystalline, while in crystalline fats it cannot occur(until they are melted). The fat-globules are only slightlyrefractile. These observations suggest that the fat is alliedto olein, but it is unlikely that the deposit is composed of anyone pure compound.

A further examination of the fat was made by stainingwith Kultschitzky's hsematoxylin after mordanting withbichromate of potash. The significance of this method inrelation to fats has been explained in a paper by LorrainSmith and W. Mair as follows :l

" Weigert's bichromate ha3niatoxylin method for the stainingof inyelin has become firmly established in histology. Onstudying the effect of the bichromate mordant ou fatty tissuewe were convinced that the myelin method could be extendedto apply to ordinary fats such as occur in fatty liver and fattymyocardium. This proved to be the case, and we found thatthe points on which the method depends are the length of timeduring which the bichromating is carried on, the strength of thesolution, and the temperature at which the solution is applied.We early discovered that positive results could be obtainedwith formalin sections of fatty liver and heart if these weremordanted in a bichromate solution kept saturated at 37° C.After a fortnight of this treatment sections of fatty liver orheai't yield extremely well defined and sharp blue staining ofthe fat-globules with Kultschitzky's hsematoxylin followed bydifferentiation in Weigert's borax ferricyanide solution. Oninvestigating the chemistry of this reaction Dr. Thorpe foundthat the process is due in the first place to the oxidisingaction of the bichromate. In the process of oxidation of amolecule of fat the oxide of chromium (CrO3) forms with it acompound which is practically insoluble in fat solvents. This

" Fats and Lipoids in Relation to Methods of Staining," ' Skandi-navisclien Archivfiir Physiologie,' 1911, p. 251.

Page 15: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

THE ADIPOSE LOBE OF THE PELVIC FIN OF THE SALMON. 717

compound-in virtue of the chromium oxide which it containsis able to form a lake with haematoxylin. It is necessary,however, to distinguish two kinds of fat. The fats in whichno unsaturated grouping occurs are not acted on by thebichromate solution. On the other hand, where the moleculeof fat contains such a group there occurs a slow process ofoxidation, and it is while this oxidation is going on that theinsoluble fat-chrome compound is formed. The blue sub-stance which then results from staining is a threefold bodycomposed of fat, mordant, and dye. It becomes clear, there-fore, that only the unsaturated fats can be stained by thisprocess, and that on account of the ease with which they canbe oxidised by the bichromate. We found also that themethod may be applied to the staining of lipoid bodies inwhich unsaturated groupings occur such as cholesterin andcerebrosides.

" In the next place it is interesting to find that as thebichromating goes on and the fat becomes fully oxidised andsaturated a stage is reached at which no staining takes place.It is only during the process of oxidation that the chromiumoxide combines with the unsaturated molecule in such a waythat it can lake the hsematoxylin. Olein, for example, whenoxidised by bichromate of potassium yields finally dioxystearicacid, and this fat will not stain by these methods."

A number of sections of the adipose lobe 5 mm. thick, froma ripe female fish taken in the Wye nets, were prepared on thefreezing microtome. These were then placed in a saturatedsolution of potassium bichromate and kept at a temperatureof 36° C. In order to observe the effect of oxidation inducedby this treatment, sections were removed at intervals oEtwenty-four hours, and subjected to the haematoxylin (Kult-schitzky) test as described above. For two days no colora-tion took place; on the third day two minute blue speckswere observed, showing that oxidation had begun, and oneach of the succeeding days up till the eighth very few bluespecks appeared. On the ninth day the first obvious bluecoloration was noted; the next day the specks were fewer,

Page 16: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

718 EDWARD W. SHANN.

bat darker in colour. This condition obtained till the nine-teenth day, when the blue became more scarce again, indi-cating the approach of saturation. On the twentieth day,after which the observations were discontinued, the blue hadalmost disappeared.

A parallel series of observations was made with sectionsfrom the adipose dorsal fin of the same fish. In this case adistinct blue coloration was produced on the first day ofbicliromating, showing that oxidation had began. The bluespecks increased in number and in intensity of colour till thethird day. The condition remained practically constant untilthe sixteenth day, when the colour became less intense andthe specks fewer, indicating the approach of saturation. Thefading continued until the twentieth, and last, day of theinvestigation.

While admitting that the foregoing experiments throw verylittle light, in the absence of other data, upon the chemicalaffinities of the fats under examination, they are highlyrelevant as emphasising the qualitative difference betweenthem. We see, firstly, that the deposit in the adipose dorsalfin becomes oxidised much more readily than does that in theadipose lobe of the ventral fin; secondly, that the saturationpoint is approached at a correspondingly earlier date in theformer than in the latter. We may, therefore, conclude thatthe fat in the lobe is of a more stable nature than that in theadipose dorsal fin.

III . THE DEVELOPMENT OE THE ADIPOSE LOBE.

For the purpose of examining the details of the developmentof the adipose lobe I was fortunate enough to obtain a verycomplete series of young salmon, which were all hatched onthe same day, and were removed from the water at intervalsof a few weeks. The following table will show the age, size,and external appearance of the lobe in the eleven specimenswhich are to receive notice in this section :

Page 17: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

THE ADIPOSE LOBE OP THE PELVIC FIN OF THE SALMON. 719

Condition of adipose lobe.No trace externally

No.1 .2 .

4 .5 .6 .7 .8 .9 .10 .11 .

Age.

5 weeks

6 ;,

7 .,8 „10 ,12 ,.14 ,.16 .,19 „21 „23 ..

Length.*

23'5 m m25 .,

24 ,.

24 ,.

24-5 s,26-5 „27 „29-5 ,.34-5 .,41 „43-5 ..

Very slight papillaSlight projectionDistinct lobe

* From tip of lips to fork of tail.The specimens were fixed in Zenker's fluid. Transverse

slices comprising the whole of the pelvic region were cut fromeach fish. These slices were embedded in paraffin, remainingin the oven for 1 i to 3^ hours, according to their size, andstained in liEematoxylin (Grenadier1) on the slide.

(1) Desc r ip t ion of the Sec t ions .

In the youngest fishes examined (Nos. 1, 2 and 3) the spliutmakes its appearance in the series as an ossified strand,lying just beneath the surface in the upper angle of thefin-fold, and on a level with the plane which divides the twondductor muscles. Passing over a few sections in the posteriordirection the head of the dorsal half of the first lepidotrichcomes into view at the outer end of the basa le and betweenthe two adductor muscles; the splint in the same section isseen to be travelling ventralwards and outwards. Slightlybeyond this again the spliut is seen to come into close contactwith the haft of the dorsal half of the first lepidotrich, so thatthe two together form a V-like structure of bone, lying in thedorsal region of the developing fin, with the angle of the Vpointing towards the fin's proximal extremity. In the sectionlast described the basa le is still quite entire, and there is

1 ' Practical Zoology,' Marshall and Hurst, ed. vi, p. 466.

Page 18: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

720 EDWARD W. SHANN.

not yet a trace of any of the other lepidotrichia, dorsal orventral, in the region where the splint appears. This con-stitutes a marked difference from the condition in the adultfish, in which the junction of the splint with the dorsal halfof the first lepidotrich occurs iu the free portion of thefin outside the body-wall, and on a level with otherlepidotrichia.

In No. 4 the splint is decidedly larger than in the fore-going specimens, and it is more curved. It first appears as acrescentic ossification placed nearly iu the position notedabove, but slightly higher up, for it subtends the a d d u c t o rs u p e r i o r muscle. Further back, iu addition to the portionwhich goes to meet the first lepidotrich, the upper extremityof the splint still remains in section as a disc of ossifiedtissue. No. 5 very nearly resembles No. 4, but in it theventral half of the first lepidotrich appears in several sectionsbefore the splint finally disappears, a condition which isprobably due to the greater extension of the fin (and conse-quently of the lepidotrichia) prior to sectioning, for it is notobserved in the older and presumably more advancedspecimens. In No. 5 is begun, and in Nos. 6 and 7 iscontinued, the blunting and obliteration of the primarytin-fold, which was so clearly denned in the youngerspecimens.

The body-scales are first clearly visible in No. 6. FromNo. 7 onwards there is an aggregation of connective tissuewhich forms a triangular area immediately above the fin; thebase of the triangle is foi'med by the body-wall, and its acuteapex points towards the division between the two adductormuscles. In No. 8 an abnormally large body-scale is foundembedded in this triangular area, and this eventually becomesthe accessory scale, the skeleton of the adipose lobe. InNo. 9 the accessory scale is seen deeply embedded in theconnective tissue of the body-wall at its basal anterior end ;at the distal end it has grown towards the surface, and,pushing the body-wall before it, has formed a slight projectingpapilla. The scale does not extend to the tip of the papilla.

Page 19: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

THE ADIPOSE LOBE OF THE PELVIC FIN OF THE SALMON. 721

The aggregation of connective tissue in whicli the accessoryscale is embedded does not at this period reach the splint ofbone which in the adult forms the suppoi't of the adiposelobe, which seems to indicate that the final condition issecondary. Not until No. 10 does the papilla lose connection•with the body-wall on its inner aspect and become a freelobe.

In No. 11 the adipose lobe, though still relatively small, inoutward appearance resembles the adult condition, only itsoutline is curved rather than angular. Vertical longitudinalsections of this specimen were prepared, and such a sectioncontaining the adipose lobe is depicted in fig. 8. The adiposelobe (Ad.) is seen lying in the angle between the body-walland the ventral (pelvic) fin (V. F.). The epidermis (Ep.) hasbeen very considerably damaged, but a trace of it stillremains. A number of body-scales (So.) are seen, cut invarious planes; they have not yet broken through theirscale-pockets (8c. p.) The accessory scale (8c. A.) is cutsomewhat obliquely, aud is seen deeply embedded in thetissue of the adipose lobe; at this period it is scai'celydistinguishable structurally from the normal body-scales, foril; displays the characteristic thickened ridges, though in amuch less marked degree. It is considerably longer thanany of the normal body-scales; this does not appear in thedrawing, but can easily be observed by following its coursethrough the serial sections. Its proximal extremity, too, ismuch more deeply seated than that of the normal scales.

(2) Summary of the Development and Modeof Growth .

In the course of development the formation of the bonysplint, which connects the first fin-ray with the base of theadipose lobe occurs at the same time as that of the fia-rays—i. e. long before there is any trace of the body-scales.It is plainly visible in sections from Specimen 1 onwards.The body-scales do not appear till Specimen 6 is examined.Only in Specimen 8—that is to say, sixteen weeks after

Page 20: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

722 EDWARD W. SHANN.

hatching—is there any trace of the differentiation of theaccessory scale, and the adipose lobe is not visible externallyuntil the nineteenth week.

A scale, which is developed in a thickened area of connec-tive tissue immediately above the base of the pelvic fin, isseen rapidly to increase in length, thenceforward graduallyto lose its ridged markings and to become homogeneous instructure. This process begins about sixteen weeks after thehatching of the fish. As this specialised scale elongates itpushes before it the overlying tissues. First a ridge isformed in a horizontal direction along the body-wall; whenthe posterior extremity of the ridge reaches the space betweenthe ventral fin and the body-wall, it leaves the latter andforms a slight projecting papilla. Tlie papilla is at firstconical, but, as the scale continues to grow, its outer aspecttends to become flat, the dorsal find ventral borders becomesharply angular owing to the pressure of the edges of thegrowing scale, and the tissues on the inuer aspect becomelargely adipose, in consequence of which its marginal wallsfall inwards into folds along the lines of least resistance.Thus we arrive at the triangular outline of the adipose lobewhich has been described in the adult salmon.

IV. OBSERVATIONS FROM OTHER TELEOSTEI.

(1) From the examination of other Teleostean fishes, and,where this was not practicable, from illustrations of such, itsoon becomes evident that the occurrence of an enlarged scaleat the outer angle of the base of the pelvic fin is a wide-spreadfeature of the order.

(2) The scale is constant for a given species.(3) The scale is rarely absent from the Malacopterygian

fishes, which are beyond doubt primitive Teleosteaus, and ismore constant in the less specialised forms in other groups.

(4) The scale is seldom seen in connection with ventralswhich are thoracic in position, and never, so far as I amaware, with those which have reached the jugular position.

Page 21: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

THK ADIPOSE LOBE OP THti PELVIC FIN OP THE SALMON. 723

(5) So far as present observations go, the development ofthe accessory scale into an adipose lobe, possessing a skeletalconnection with the ventral fin, is confined to the genusSalmo.

(1) Range of Fishes in which Scale has beenFigured.

The following list of fishes in which the accessory scale ispresent is by no means complete, but will serve to indicatethe wide range of its occurrence. I have not stated thegroups from which it is absent unless I have actuallyobserved this.

Sub-order—Malacopterygii.

Family Elopidaa . . Elops saurus. Ox. 387, J. & E. 178.Megalops atlanticus. .1. & E. 177,

Camb. 547.Hyodontidso . Hyodon tergisus. J. & E. 180.

H. selenops. J. & E. 181.Albulidse . . Albula conorhynchus. Camb. 54S.Gonorhynchida: Gonorhynchus. greyi. Ox. 395.Clupeidte . . None observed without.Salmonidss . . Present in all genera except Oameius,

Tlialeiclitliys, Mallotus andHypomesus, which Boulenger re-gards as together forming a naturalgroup. In Salmo is enveloped inconnective tissue and largely sur-rounded by fat.

Sub-order—Ostariophysi.Characinidse . Hydrocyon goliath. Camb. 578.Cyprinidss . . Carpiodes cypi'inus. J. & E. 71.

Cyprinus carpio. Ox. 376.Labeo falcifer. Camb. 583.

1 The references to figures are as follows. J. & E.: Jordan and Ever-mann, ' Fishes of North and Middle America/ vol. iv (plates), platenumber. Camb.: ' Cambridge Natural History—Fishes,' page number.Ox.: ' A Treatise on Zoology,' pt. 9, Oxford, page number.

Page 22: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

724 , EDWARD AV. SlfANJST.

Siluridse . . Tracli inocephalus myops. J.&E.235.

Synodus foetens. J. & E. 236.

Siib-order—Haplomi.Scopelidee . . Saurus nndosquainis. Gimtber1 42,

relatively enormous.

Sub-order—Percesoces.Atherinidse . Ather ina s t ipes . J. & E. 332, long,

thin scale.K i r t l and i a vagrans. J. & E. 336,

very small.Ather inopsis calaforniensis. J.

& E. 341, very small.Mugilidoe . . Mugil cephalus. Ox. 420, J.&E. 343.

M. curema. J. & E. 344, moremarked than in M. cephalus .

Chsetonmgil proboscideus. J. &E. 346.

Agonostomns monticola. J. & E.347.

J o t n r u s pichavdi . J. & E. 348.Polynemidse . Polynema qnadri f i l i s . Oamb.641.

Siib-order—Acanthopterygii (Division Perciformes3).Berycidee . . Beryx splendens. Camb. 655.Serranidte . . Centropomus nndecimalis. J. &

E. 476, indistinct.Hoplopagrus gun ther i . J. & E.

513.Neomeni s. J. & E., present in all the

species figured.Oxiurus chrysurus. J. & E. 520.Rhomboplites aurorubeus. J. &

E. 521.Apsilus dentatus. J. & E. 522.Verilus sordidus. J, & E. 515,

very small.Acroponiatidre . Xenocys jeisia*. J. & E. 526, very

small.' ' The Study of Fishes.'3 The accessory scale is not figured in any other division of the

Acanthopterygii.

Page 23: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

THE ADIPOSE LOBE OP THE PtiLVIC FIN OP THE SAL11OX. /2o

Xeniclithys agassizii. J. & E. 527,very small.

Pristipoinatidse Hsemulon. J. & E. 528-32, presentin all species figured.

Lythrulon opalescens. J. & E. 536.Anisotremus surinamensis. ' J. &

E. 538, very small.A. bilineatus. J. & E. 539, very

small.A. virginicus. J. & E. 540, more

marked.Orthopristis chrysopterus. J. &

E. 541, very small.Mierolepidotus inovnatus. J. &

E. 542, very small.Sparidse . • Scale present in all Sparidte figured.Mullids) . . Mullus auratus. J. & E. 360.

Mulloides rathburni. J. & E. 361.Upeneus maculatus. J. & E. 362.Pagrtis auratus. Camb. 665.

Gerridse . . Xystema cinereum. J. &E. 556.G-erres olisthostomus. J. & E.

557.Cyphosidse . . Kyphosvis sectatris. J. & E. 559.

Hermosillia azurea. J. & E. 559.Scisenidse . . Cynoscion. J. & E. 561-3. Present

in all figured, but small.Sageniohthys ancylodon. J.&. E.

564, small.Bairdiella chrysura. J. & E. 566,

very small.Umbrina sinaloss. J. & E. 571,

small.Menticirrhns americanus. J. & E.

572, small.Pomacentridse . Dacyllus aruanus. Ox. 443.

Microspatliodon chrysurus. J. &E. 593.

M. dorsalis. J. &E.594.Scaridse . . Sparisoma hoplomystax. J. ct E.

611, very small.Scarus ctizamile. J. & E. 612, very

small.

Page 24: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

726 EDWARD W. SHANN.

Pseudoscarus guacanaaia. J. &E.617.

Choetodontidse . Chsetodipterus faber. J.&E.619,small.

Chsetodon nigrirostris. J. & E.620, doubtful.

(2) Personal O b s e r v a t i o n s .

Having noted the above-mentioaed list of fishes in whichthe accessory scale is figured, I next proceeded to examinethe actual nature of such a scale in various specimens of fishin the collection at Giessen.

The scale was first examined in fishes most nearly allied tothe salmon, and the following observations were made :

(1) In all the species of Sal mo the accessory scale isencased in an adipose lobe, and is connected at its base by asplint of bone with the outermost fin-ray of the pelvic fin.

(2) In other genera of the Salmonidae1 the accessory scaleis well developed, but it is nob enclosed in connective tissue.

(3) In other Malacopterygian fishes, especially in thosewhich are adapted for active swimming, there is usually amarked accessory scale.

In Clupea h a r e n g u s this scale is very elongated, more-over it is subtended along its inner margin by a strip of skin,so that it forms a hollow conical outgrowth from the body ;there is no bony connection with the fin-rays. In Hyodonsp. (?) there is an elongated hollow scale, as in Clupea, butno trace of connective tissue.

Passing next to the Ostariophysi, various Cyprinids wereeligible for examination. A well-marked accessory scale wasfound inAbramis blicca, A. virnba, Squal ius cephalus ,Cypr inus (Leuciscus) dolula , Luciscus rut i lus , andChondros toma n a s u s ; but in Barbus vulgar is , thoughdistinct, it is very small.

1 Except in Osmerus, and probably also in Thaleichthys,Mallotus and Hyponiesus, but I have not had an opportunity toexamine actual specimens of the last-named genera.

Page 25: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

THE ADIPOSE T.OBB OF THE PELVIC PIN OP THE SALMON. 727

Some specimens of Mugi l cephalus which had lain manyyears in spirit were the next that came to hand. In these atriangular patch of skin devoid of scales was found in thenormal position of the accessory scale; there was no trace ofa lobe.

A few genera of Acanthopterygian fishes in which theaccessory scale has been figured were lastly examined. Inthese there was a small flap or thread of skin in the normalposition, but the skin was entirely devoid of stiffening matterof any sort. Among the Mullidas, Mullus b a r b a t u s andM. fu rmute tu s showed such a condition; in the former,however, the thread of skin was very slender, and the latterwas badly preserved, so that it was not possible to judge of itsnormal condition. Among the Sparidas, Sa rgus unimacu-l a tu s shows a distinct flap of skin, but the occurrenceof any projecting tissue is very doubtful in another speciesof Sargus (not identified), and the same must be said ofCharax pun tazzo . At all events there is in these formsa certain area at the outer angle of the ventral fin which iscovered by skin, but is devoid of scales.

V . HOMOLOQY AND FUNCTION.

In the foregoing pages we have examined the structureand the development of the adipose lobe of the pelvic fin ofthe salmon, and have seen from both these points of view thutit resembles a body-scale. We have further noted that thepresence of an accessory scale, or, in some instances, of a flapof skin in a corresponding topographical position, is a wide-spread feature of Teleostean fishes. That the adipose lobe ismorphologically neither more nor less than a large body-scalewhich has never broken through its surrounding pocket istoo obvious to require proof, but it would not be right to leavesuch a remarkable structure with no more than a platitude ofthis kind. The possibility of deriving the dermal fin-raysfrom body-scales, through the intermediary of a fin-like scale,such as we have in Sal mo, occurred to my mind before my

VOL. 58 , PAET 4. NEW SERIES. 48

Page 26: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

728 EDWARD W. SHANN.

attention was called to the admirable paper by Mr. G-oodrich,1

which deals with the same question from the developmentalpoint of view. The following is a summary, in his own words,of Mr. Groodrich's observations : 2

" Besides these body-scales are found scale-like exoskeletalelements set end to end in rows and forming jointed dermalfin-rays, called l ep ido t r i ch i a , supporting the web of boththe paired and the median fins. The minute structure ofthese fin-rays is almost or quite identical with that of thescales of the fish to which they belong. This is true moreespecially of the lower forms. In some, such as Amblyp te rus ,there is a perfect gradation in form and arrangement betweenthe body-scales and the fin-ray elements. But, as a rule, thetransition is more abrupt, the segments of the rays acquiringa squarish or oblong shape, and not overlapping. Both thescales and the lepidothrichia are embedded in the dense con-nective tissue, the fibres of which enter the substance of thebone. Movable joints are formed by the fibrous matrixremaining unossified between them."

In the light of these facts, what had been but a passingidea acquired a real significance. The resemblance betweena scale covered by connective tissue and a lepidotrich mighteasily be accounted for on grounds of analogy; but since weknow that fin-rays are developed from scale-like elements, itseems just to regard the fin-like scale of Salmo as a con-necting link between a body-scale and a lepidotrich.

The fin-like nature of the adipose lobe is enhanced by thefact that it is connected by a splint of bone with the ventralfin. "What, then, is the homology of this bony splint ? Wehave noted that in the course of development it appearstogether with the lepidotrichia, which it resembles in structure,at a period before there is any trace of body-scales. Itsposition in the adult fish (p. 710), see fig. 2, indicates that itrepresents the dorsal half of an additional lepidotrich. If

1 Goodrich, E. S., " On the Dermal Fin-rays of Fishes," ' Quart.Joura. Mior. Sci.' (v), vol. 47,1903.

3 ' A Treatise on Zoology,' Oxford, pt. is, p. 212.

Page 27: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

THE ADIPOSE LOBE OF THE PELVIC FIN OF THE SALMON. 729

this homology is true, it should be noted at the same timethat the ventral ramus of the head is wanting, as is also alltrace of a ventral ha.lf; moreover, while the lepidotrichia arecharacteristically jointed, the splint is composed of a singlepiece.1 These points are apparent in Text-fig. 3. It wasfurther observed that the splint lies in a pocket of connectivetissue, which in section resembles a scale pocket (see fig. 4,Sp. h.). The resemblance does not necessarily prove thehomology of the two structures; it is merely satisfactory asnot dispelling the idea. Taking the sum of these considera-tions we must suppose that we have to deal with the head

TEXT-FIG. 3.

f— Sp.

The first (outermost) lepidotrich of the pelvic fin, together withthe splint of bone which supports the adipose lobe, seen fromthe inner aspect. Sp. Bony splint (probably = dorsal half ofa tenth lepidotrich). H. d.Head of dorsal half of first lepidotrich,with its dorsal ramus d., and ventral ramus v. H. i: Head ofventral half of 1st lepidotrich.

and dorsal ramus of an additional lepidotrich which exhibitscertain scale-like properties. Whether this lepidotrich is inthe process of development or whether it is the vestige of aonce fully developed ray I cannot at present decide withcertainty, but its secondary fusion tends to show that it isvestigial. The exact homology of the adipose lobe itself ismore obscure; that it arises as a scale we have seen. It isunlikely that it ever f anctioned as a fin-ray, or part of a fin-

1 This is not necessarily a dissimilarity, for it will be noticed that theheads of the lepidotrichia are also devoid of joints, and the splint isonly equal in size to the head of a fully developed Lepidotrich. Theunjointed condition of the heads of the Lepidotrichia is, without doubt,due to secondary fusion.

Page 28: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

730 EDWAED W. SHANN.

ray, for in that case it would have reversed its course ofevolution to a quite unimaginable extent. It is equallyunlikely that it is a rudimentary fin-ray, or part of a fin-ray,since it contains but one large scale (instead of a series setend to end), and further, it lies dorsal to all parts of thefin skeleton. It is alienated from any fundamental resem-blance with the adipose dorsal fin, in the first place becauseit develops comparatively late in the life of the fish, it is anadventitious outgrowth, that is to say, not the result of thedevelopment of a pre-existing embryonic fold (as is the casewith the adipose dorsal) ; in the second place its fatty matteris of a different composition, and it is devoid of horny rays(actinotrichia). It seems probable, then, that the adiposelobe of the pelvic fin of Salmo is an organ sui gener is .This does not detract, however, from its importance assuggesting the lines by which a fin may have been derivedfrom a scaly outgrowth of the body-wall.

The function of this remarkable structure presents a puzzleto the investigator. It is almost impossible to believe thatan organ of such large dimensions and regular occurrence inthe genus Salmo serves no useful purpose in the daily roundof these fishes. It seems justifiable to dismiss summarily theidea that it is a storage organ; the relatively stable propertiesof its fatty matter, the development of a stiffening axis, andits invariability in salmon of varying physical condition allpoint iu this direction.1 Again, as it is equally developed inboth sexes, it is probably not analogous with the " claspers "of E lasmobranchs . G-unther has laid stress on the valueof the paired fins of fishes as balancing organs.2 The pectoralsand pelvics are placed where they are required to support thegreatest weight of the fish on which they occur; thus thesalmon, being thickly built in the posterior abdominal region,requires large ventrals. The adipose lobes may then act asadditional balancing organs for the pelvic region; further,situated as they are just in the outer angle of the pelvic fin

1 Except in one extreme case, see p. 709.2 ' The Study of Fishes,' p. 44.

Page 29: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

THE ADIPOSE LOBE OF THE PELVIC PIN OF THE SALMON. 7 3 1

(see fig. 1), they may act as dams to prevent the back-wash ofwater, which would be considerable in a fish with largepelvics, and so facilitate the swift motion through the waterfor which the salmon is noted.

EXPLANATION OF PLATE 43,

Illustrating1 Mr. Edward W. Shatm's paper, "An Accountof the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of thePelvic Fin of the Salmon."

LETTERING.

Ad. Adipose lobe. B. TO. Basale metapterygii. C. t. Connectivetissue. Cu. Cutis. Ep. Epidermis. F. r. d. Dorsal half of a fin-ray.F. r. v. Ventral half of a fin-ray. Ft. Fat-globules. Ft.' Patty tissuefrom which the fat has been extracted with alcohol. M. Muscle, ilf. 6.Membrana basale. N. Nuclei. Pig. Pigment-cells. Pt. Pterygiophores.8c. Body-scale. Sc. a. Accessory scale. Sc. p. Scale pocket. 8p. Splintof bone which supports the adipose lobe. Sp. h. Hole caused by theremoval of the splint of bone which supports the adipose lobe. V. f."Ventral (pelvic) fin. 0., V., V. Outer, dorsal, and ventral aspects.

Fig. 1.—A portion of the right side of a Wye salmon showing thepelvic fin; a piece of black pasteboard has been placed beneath theadipose lobe to render its outline more distinct. Photograph, by Mr.J. T. Wadsworth, Manchester. X | .

Fig. 2.—Skeleton of the right pelvic fin of a Wye salmon, seen fromthe ventral aspect; the rays are spread out and separated from theBasale metapterygi i , with which in the natural condition theyclosely articulate. The numbers refer to the lepidotrichia. Photo-graph by Mr. A. W. Brown, St. Andrews. Slightly reduced.

Fig. 3.—Transverse section of the adipose lobe, abou tone third of thelength froni the basal end, together with the adjacent body-wall. Froma Rhine salmon, whose adipose lobe measured 35 mm. by 6 mm. Thesections, of which this is one, were block-stained iron-haeinatoxylin, andcut 30 n thickness.

Fig. 4.—Transverse section of the adipose lobe at the base (the lobeis quite continuous with the body-wall). Rhine sahnon, dimensionsnot known. Method of preparation as above.

Page 30: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

732 EDWARD W. SHANN.

Fig. 5.—Transverse section of the adipose lobe in the middle region,to show the distribution of fat. $ fish from the Dovey; recentlyspawned, 18 or 19 lb., 35$ in. by 17£ in.; shape very like a "fresh" fish.Not at all emaciated; no fat on the pyloric caeca; five years old.Hand section, stained Sudan III. X 18.

Pig. 6.—Transverse section of the adipose lobe slightly distalwardsfrom the middle. § fish from the Wye, 29J in. by 15 in.; full of ripeeggs. No sign of emaciation; no fat on the pyloric cesca. Stainedhcematoxylin, cut 16 ft in thickness.

Fig. 7.—Transverse section of the outer wall of the adipose lobe nearits distal end, to show epidermal epithelium. $ fish from the Wye,35 in. by 19J in.; spring fish, unspawned. Great accumulation of faton the pyloric caeca ; nearly five years old. Prepared as above.

Fig. 8.—Vertical longitudinal section of the pelvic region of a youngsalmon. Age of fish twenty-three weeks; length, 43'5 mm. Stainedhoematoxylin, cut 12 /i in thickness.

Page 31: An Account of the Anatomy and Homology of the Adipose Lobe of

co. 1U.58MM. 13

F.r.v.